Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E068: The Millennial Monetary Migration with Bram Kanstein
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness 1974198792972. 1000 and
- 0:18whatever. We want to call this.
- 0:19It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell.
- 0:26Hey, OK. I say when we sell.
- 0:33Everyone welcome back to the last trade.
- 0:34This week we have Brom Constine, Bitcoin for Millennials podcast,
- 0:39among many other things and always joined by my Co host
- 0:42Jesse Myers and Michael Tanguma. Brom, thanks for joining us.
- 0:45How are you today? Yeah, I'm good guys.
- 0:48I'm excited to to chat with you. I think we've had several
- 0:52individual conversations, but this four way is something new.
- 0:55So I'm, I'm, I'm excited to see where this goes.
- 0:59Yeah, well, thanks for making the time.
- 1:00And I know we were just chatting beforehand.
- 1:03We first got connected maybe over a year ago.
- 1:05So it's been a lot of fun just to follow the growth that you've
- 1:08had and the success you've had with your podcast.
- 1:10And I appreciate you carving out an hour to speak with us today,
- 1:13especially since you're feeling under, under the weather.
- 1:15So we'll be mindful of your time.
- 1:17And you know, thanks again, Brahm.
- 1:18Let's we can get into it then. Yeah.
- 1:21So maybe the best place to start just generally for those who
- 1:25don't know you would love to just to hear a little bit more
- 1:28about your professional background.
- 1:30It's quite fascinating. It's very impressive on the
- 1:32growth and marketing side. And then ultimately, what led
- 1:35you into Bitcoin and starting your podcast?
- 1:39Yeah, So I was always just this geeky Internet kid, I think, you
- 1:44know, like as a, as a millennial, like I, I grew up
- 1:48without the Internet and then with the Internet, of course.
- 1:51So I was always like online and my mother would shout upstairs,
- 1:55like, you know, can you get off the Internet?
- 1:57I need to call, you know, like, like that.
- 1:59And later in life, I, I realized what I actually like to do and,
- 2:05and what I still like to do is to just try out new stuff.
- 2:07Like I'm just fascinated by kind of like the power of the
- 2:10Internet and that when you create things on there, there's,
- 2:14there's so many ways that it can travel to so many different
- 2:18people. But of course, I wasn't super
- 2:21aware of that when I was younger.
- 2:22But for example, like I was always trying out like Limewire
- 2:27or Kazaa or, you know, any of these file download like
- 2:30peer-to-peer the products. And then, you know, I would burn
- 2:35CDs, sell them in school. And then we would host like
- 2:38parties from the revenue where people could also buy the CDs.
- 2:41And I had a friend who who would then play the songs and stuff
- 2:43like that. So I was kind of always into
- 2:45this. Yeah, just into, I always say
- 2:47computer ring, like I like to computer and just do that.
- 2:52And later also combine that with with business.
- 2:55And I think at one point when I was like, I don't know, 22 or
- 2:59something, I actually at only at that point discovered like what
- 3:03startups were like Internet startups.
- 3:05And, you know, of course, my first understanding was, OK, you
- 3:08have an idea, someone gives you money, you launch and then, you
- 3:11know, magic and then you're rich.
- 3:13You know, like, like, like the meme.
- 3:15But it was also at that moment that I realized because I was
- 3:17like, really down there, like, what's his name again?
- 3:20Sean Parker Rabbit hole and I saw that like Napster at his at
- 3:25its peak had like 15,000,000 users.
- 3:27And I was like, oh, I was this geeky kid from the Netherlands
- 3:30in this little town. I was one of these 15,000,000
- 3:32million people. And that made me realize that
- 3:37I'd like to be early, like I like to try out new stuff that's
- 3:40launched on the Internet, right? Like, and just know and, and try
- 3:43to understand what, why are people spending their precious
- 3:46time on, you know, this idea or this thing that they're, that
- 3:49they're building. So always been into trying out
- 3:52new things. And eventually that also led me
- 3:55to, to the discovery of Bitcoin. And like my professional career
- 3:58has all yeah, for the last 12 years, I'd say has really
- 4:02revolved around these, you know, new digital business ideas
- 4:05basically. And I've seen it from several
- 4:08angles. So my first job was at a big
- 4:12tech publication in Next Web. I worked for an investor, had my
- 4:16own marketing agency and just also tried a lot of my own
- 4:19ideas, failed at a lot, sold a few.
- 4:22But yeah, over time really specialized in, yeah, the zero
- 4:28to one phase. Like, OK, you have this idea.
- 4:30What's that worth? Why should you pay attention or
- 4:33spend more time, money and energy on this idea, right?
- 4:35Like that is the most important, I'd say, challenge or assignment
- 4:40that you have when you have a business idea, because I
- 4:42believe, you know, the, the business ideas just float around
- 4:44in the universe, right? And from time to time you get
- 4:47struck with inspiration. But you see a lot of people that
- 4:50make like big plans and they, they lock themselves in for two
- 4:53years, they build something and then they're like, you know, now
- 4:55I'm here. And then there's all these
- 4:57crickets because they didn't really talk to customers.
- 4:59They didn't challenge their assumptions like all these
- 5:01things. And yeah, I, I just really
- 5:04focused on that and, and worked with a lot of companies on that.
- 5:07So from traditional finance companies spent four years in
- 5:10banking to like startups and, and scale ups and yeah, just
- 5:14through these Internet journeys and, and, and this computering
- 5:17hobby, I, I also discovered Bitcoin in, in 2014.
- 5:23Yeah, I always say like I bought at 400.
- 5:25I sold everything at 4000. I now have less than than
- 5:28before, But you know, that's kind of the flow and the journey
- 5:31that, that everyone goes through.
- 5:34It is a pity though. If I look back at my old tweets
- 5:36from 2013, I did that a few months ago.
- 5:39I, I tweet something like Bitcoin, it's a synthesized
- 5:42digital commodity and I'm like, damn, I got it, but I didn't get
- 5:45it, you know, so that's kind of how it went.
- 5:48And I think maybe to add to that, a fun thing is like one of
- 5:50the first Bitcoin that I bought was true Second Life actually.
- 5:54So, you know, I'm in the Netherlands, we have a really
- 5:56good payment infrastructure. But I was a student, I had a
- 6:00credit card with, I don't know, probably like $700.00 type, you
- 6:04know, limit. And I wanted to buy Bitcoin, but
- 6:07it was, it was really hard. But one, at one point I realized
- 6:12that Second Life had a currency, I don't know if you know that,
- 6:15but that was called the Linden Dollar, which was a currency
- 6:18that was used in the game. So if you would go in the game
- 6:22and walk to an ATM, you could use your credit card to get
- 6:25these Linden dollars and then use them in the game.
- 6:28And why I wanted to get the Linden dollars is because I
- 6:30found out that you could trade them for another token or, or
- 6:34crypto coin at that time. And I could transfer that crypto
- 6:38token to another exchange BTCE. I don't know if you remember
- 6:41that one's like a Chinese one or eventually went bust.
- 6:44And then I could transform it into or, or, or, you know, turn
- 6:47it into Bitcoin. I don't know how much I bought,
- 6:50but I think if I bought for like $100, I ended up with like
- 6:52$50.00 in Bitcoin with all the fees and all and all the stuff.
- 6:56But yeah, I think it's a fun example of just, you know,
- 6:59trying stuff out. I remember looking at the at
- 7:02the, you know, transaction pages, you know, and just having
- 7:05no clue what's what I was reading or, you know, what was
- 7:09going on. But yeah, that's kind of how it
- 7:11started. At Onramp, we believe that
- 7:14Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 7:18The hard part is securing it right.
- 7:20There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 7:23exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 7:26arrangement. Onramp solves for these
- 7:28concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 7:31solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 7:35ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 7:37possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 7:41your family is protected as well.
- 7:43On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 7:46whether for your whole stack or for part of it as a compliment
- 7:49to your existing self custody setup.
- 7:52For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 7:56Yeah, that's, that's fascinating.
- 7:57I mean, there's so many different threads to pull on.
- 7:59I know Michael has something to say, maybe business building
- 8:03related. One thing, Brahm, that you stuck
- 8:05out to me was just the idea of the digital commodity and how
- 8:08you're able to come to that a decade ago like that.
- 8:11I think that's almost, that's extremely early, not only to be
- 8:15early to Bitcoin, which I think we would still agree that we are
- 8:18today. But the ability to take this
- 8:21information and this obscure Internet money a decade ago and
- 8:25be able to create or to pull those pieces together and
- 8:29actually come to that conclusion, I think is very
- 8:31remarkable. And you must have gotten a lot
- 8:34further than other people. I know it wasn't the you didn't
- 8:38fully piece it together at that point, but you're able to pull
- 8:41it together enough to be early enough a decade ago, which I
- 8:45think is crazy. And then also just the idea of
- 8:47all these exchanges that have come and gone over the years.
- 8:50I was not familiar with BTCE, but it's not surprising just how
- 8:54those inefficiencies existed in terms of tapping into the market
- 8:57and all the fees and whether those are fees on exchange, but
- 9:01then also FX fees and the fact that they're not around today.
- 9:05I think just as an anecdote that we hear time and time again over
- 9:08those past 10 years or 15 years total, there's no shortage of
- 9:12those stories. So it's really remarkable just
- 9:14to hear over the course of a decade how these different
- 9:17interactions you've had both Bitcoin, crypto directly, but
- 9:20then also just the early, early years.
- 9:21Being kind of an Internet pioneer in some sense as it
- 9:25relates to your personal interest and professional
- 9:26interest is very interesting. But I'd love to add to that full
- 9:30transparency, right? So I, I got it, but I didn't get
- 9:33it right. And, and I also, of course, sold
- 9:35at at a certain point where I was like, OK, that's great.
- 9:38Actually, you know, I really looked at it from, from this
- 9:41kind of like technology angle. I think Jack Dorsey has talked
- 9:45about this a lot, right? Like, OK, the, the Internet
- 9:47needs a currency. That's kind of how I looked at
- 9:49it from the beginning. So I really looked at it from a,
- 9:52yeah, kind of like technological angle.
- 9:54So when I found Litecoin, I thought this is the better
- 9:58Bitcoin. I actually did a presentation at
- 10:02the bank that I later would work at where I did a Litecoin
- 10:07presentation and presented why Litecoin was the better Bitcoin.
- 10:10I have no clue what my arguments were at that time, but I think
- 10:15that that does show, you know, using one dimension to look at
- 10:20Bitcoin is not, it's not the right approach, you know, and I
- 10:24think that is actually what is this?
- 10:26What represents this flow of understanding and study and
- 10:31challenging yourself or asking you big questions?
- 10:33I think, I think Jesse talks about that a lot from like his
- 10:37his perspective, right? Like, how far do you have to
- 10:39zoom, zoom out, right, to understand why this thing should
- 10:43exist or why it's better than any alternative.
- 10:46And yeah, I think it's also nice to share, right?
- 10:50Like, like I am, I, I, like, I got it.
- 10:52I didn't get it. I was not a maxi from the start,
- 10:56you know? I did all the ICO stuff and all
- 10:58the NFT stuff to eventually get to the point, you know?
- 11:03And that's what the altcoins just like rely on or, or they're
- 11:05based around is, is technologists being sort of
- 11:09hoodwinked into like, oh, there's, there's better
- 11:11technology, you know, and rather than and, and I think for you,
- 11:16Brahma and for me, like the, the thing that we both needed to do
- 11:19eventually, because I had my altcoin phase two was to zoom
- 11:24out enough to understand Bitcoin in this like much bigger context
- 11:28rather than like looking at the little details of transactions
- 11:31per second on chain, you know, yadda, yadda.
- 11:34But you're always going to lose that battle.
- 11:35If, you know, if you get into the, into the, into the mud with
- 11:40pigs, you, you know, the pigs love it and you get dirty,
- 11:44right? Like like that's, that's what
- 11:45altcoins are kind of banking on you doing.
- 11:48Yeah, yeah. And also it's when I went down
- 11:51the more like finance and economic like dimensions of
- 11:57Bitcoin. That's where you find the reason
- 12:00for existence, right. Like I think the technological
- 12:02aspect is more about like when you find the reason of
- 12:06existence, then you will ask why questions afterwards, OK, but
- 12:09why is this better? Why is this superior money?
- 12:12Why are there 21 million? You know, why is the supply
- 12:15capped? Why is that enforced?
- 12:17You know, you know, that's when you get to that part, because
- 12:21then you can explain why the technical well, the technologies
- 12:27that are combined are combined in a good way.
- 12:32I want to say in a perfect way to solve the problem that is the
- 12:37reason of existence, right? And I've only seen that the last
- 12:42three years that I really understand that part right?
- 12:46So, well, you. Know, yeah, and.
- 12:48That ties into our relationship with with you Brahm and your
- 12:52podcast and working on it. I think I'd love to hear how
- 12:56that started. I think one thing that you
- 12:59mentioned that I think doesn't get talked about enough is it
- 13:01it's almost like a blessing that we didn't and majority of people
- 13:05do not find Bitcoin early. Because when you really think
- 13:08about it, it's almost like winning the lottery.
- 13:10And when people win the lottery, it's surely not a good thing
- 13:13because the money came too fast. And you don't really understand
- 13:16what you said a the use case, why it exists and then also the
- 13:20learning. So people know generally whether
- 13:22somebody wins a lottery or gets inheritance of capital, it
- 13:24usually comes in as quick as it goes out because it's not a
- 13:28natural. And we've kind of seen this in
- 13:29Bitcoin historically. There's not a lot of like people
- 13:32that got it in 2010 eleven and have built big businesses
- 13:36anywhere that we know about that also haven't like kind of gone a
- 13:38little bit crazy, if not very crazy.
- 13:41And so there's, there's this notion of I think there's a
- 13:45sweet spot and, and obviously bias, but I feel like 17 to 25,
- 13:51maybe 17 to 20272030, wherever it comes into is the
- 13:55monetization and how big this actually is.
- 13:58You needed that time for the market to catch up and the
- 14:00realization of where does it fit in from an order of operations
- 14:03and an adoption to start to build things that can impact the
- 14:07world. And also like, you know, make
- 14:09material difference in an individual's growth trajectory.
- 14:13The, the revenue, like all those things tying in and that like we
- 14:15haven't, we didn't see it. So imagine coming in at 2012,
- 14:18buying 5000 Bitcoin, like you'd be in a very different spot.
- 14:23And so it's just an interesting dynamic where coming back around
- 14:26now you have that frame of reference of 10 years and you're
- 14:28a different person. But it allows you to do kind of
- 14:30maybe a lot more be a lot more impactful to to what's happening
- 14:34in this space. Your your podcast, you know,
- 14:36obviously has a lot of viewers and listeners that are probably,
- 14:38you know, helping see this. So anyway, it's just a
- 14:41realization. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 14:42Kind of paradoxical. I mean, that's why I sold that
- 14:454000, right? Like, I mean, that's the for me,
- 14:48that was a was was a good point. And but when you look back, you
- 14:52know, that's that's the instant realization I had.
- 14:54I had a similar realization before I sold because then I was
- 14:56trading and I suck at trading. I'm way too emotional to trade
- 15:01now I'm more rational, but but then I was poor emotional, I'd
- 15:03say, you know, so I had, I had a certain amount, then I had less
- 15:07because it was a shit trader. And then, you know, I sold, I
- 15:09was happy. And when I finally wanted to get
- 15:11back in, I had less than than than what I had when I sold at
- 15:164000. And I think, yeah, you have to
- 15:18do that to realize what the impact is of this, of this
- 15:21absolute digital scarcity, right?
- 15:23Like like now if you sell now, I think we are all confused
- 15:26looking at the charts, like who's selling?
- 15:28I saw a nice huddle chart, by the way, like in the past few
- 15:31months, I think only 20% of all Bitcoin moved, right?
- 15:36So it's just a very, it's a it's a low supply that's actually
- 15:40been traded probably mostly by by professional people.
- 15:44But like, yeah, if you get in over your head when you think
- 15:48you get it, you know, you will get burned If you get in with
- 15:51not enough while, you know, while you did do get it at that
- 15:56time, you know, you will also get burned in some way because
- 15:59you didn't trust yourself enough, right.
- 16:01So it's just, I love this part of of I don't know if it's the
- 16:06Bitcoin journey. I think it's a journey of
- 16:07adopting something new, right? Like in, in the time of when the
- 16:11Internet came up or mobile phones, etcetera.
- 16:13I mean, it's the same thing like the first mobile phone, you
- 16:16know, that you carried around like a, like a briefcase.
- 16:18There was also like 5000 or $10,000, right?
- 16:20Like some people just tried that and then it broke or something,
- 16:25you know, and then like, so it's, it's always, and I think
- 16:29it's fun to tie that back to, to my introduction.
- 16:31It's, you have to try it to, to, to have an opinion, right?
- 16:36And that is, that has never been truer than with Bitcoin, I would
- 16:41say, because you are fighting against this crazy
- 16:45indoctrination and, and programming about money or the
- 16:48lack of programming, you know, the lack of information about
- 16:50money. So, so this is a really, really,
- 16:53really big personal challenge for people, this adoption of
- 16:56Bitcoin and then the studying. And I feel like that's probably
- 16:59I would. I would guess it's probably the
- 17:01most common shared experience that people who got in in like
- 17:072017 or or earlier and went through altcoins, if you then if
- 17:13you got to Bitcoin maximalism, that journey probably involved
- 17:19ending up with a lot less Bitcoin than you had or could
- 17:22have had. And that painful realization is
- 17:27part of understanding how precious Bitcoin is and that
- 17:30like, and you're not going to trade it anymore.
- 17:32You're not going to hot potato anything anymore.
- 17:35You're going to put it in cold storage and you're going to hold
- 17:37on because now you understand, you learned the hard way.
- 17:41I, I would guess that's the majority of people who were
- 17:44altcoiners in 2017 who are now Bitcoin maximalists have that
- 17:47kind of 10X loss that you know, and, and it hurts every time you
- 17:52think about it, but but it helped you get to Bitcoin
- 17:56maximalism. Yeah, Yeah, I think that's true.
- 18:00Yeah. And maybe to answer also my
- 18:02quote, you just said that that about the podcast, right?
- 18:04Like eventually you get invited by yourself, I think to do
- 18:09something to contribute to this thing, right?
- 18:11Like you guys, you are building this company.
- 18:14I think that also starts at a certain time, right?
- 18:17Like, like The Pioneers from really the early days, there's a
- 18:21few left, but you know, if you look at technology, there's
- 18:23always this, it's, it's like a wave, right?
- 18:26And, and if you see it, but you're too early, then, you
- 18:30know, you, you, the, the wave will basically move away from
- 18:35you. Like it will go faster than than
- 18:37how fast you can build your company, right.
- 18:39And some people are right on the tip of the wave, you know, and
- 18:42then the waves, you know, slams and some companies die, but you
- 18:45want to be, if you want to jump on a technology wave, you have
- 18:49to, you know, kind of like do it at the right time.
- 18:51And it's really hard to to think like where that is.
- 18:54But what I like with Bitcoin is that, yeah, just invite you,
- 18:58right? Like if, if I don't think
- 19:00there's any Bitcoiners or like people that really got it and
- 19:02then went back to their old life or back to the old money, right?
- 19:06Like you see that people are moving their attention to this
- 19:10thing. I started a podcast.
- 19:12You guys are building this company, right?
- 19:14And I think that's all part of it.
- 19:16I think it's a signal that shows that, yeah, this is a serious
- 19:20thing. It's not the two thing, It's not
- 19:22the Ponzi thing. Like it's people are moving
- 19:26their energy and and and intention and and time towards
- 19:30this thing. And that's, I think, a big
- 19:31signal. Did you guys see Hosh of his
- 19:37name's escaping me from bull Bitcoin Francis's tweet last
- 19:41night? This is so good.
- 19:43I don't know if you saw Jesse or Brand.
- 19:45There was a vice president's vice presidential debate from
- 19:48last night and yeah, this guy JD Vance, and they showed a picture
- 19:54of him four years ago and he's like pudgy and kind of like, and
- 19:58then like the next picture is like last night look really
- 20:01good. You know, like buttoned up hair
- 20:04in good shape, probably like 30 lbs lighter.
- 20:06And Francis was like, I know a Bitcoiner when I see her, some
- 20:10of that's gone through realization.
- 20:11It's like 4 years ago. He read the Bitcoin Standard and
- 20:14like just. Completely.
- 20:15Yeah, it's, it's, it just ties into what you said, like you
- 20:18can't go backwards in this. Once you see it, you can't Unsee
- 20:22it. And then it kind of impacts how
- 20:23you, you know, think professionally and personally,
- 20:26but. Have you guys ever had that with
- 20:28anything in your life like like this?
- 20:32Never anything on this scale, that's for sure.
- 20:37You know, like and because, because what does it mean to be
- 20:39like a technology adopter for anything else?
- 20:41It, it's, it's a, a shadow of what it means to adopt Bitcoin.
- 20:47You know, adopting Bitcoin means making it your savings, a
- 20:50savings pillar of your financial planning and adopting, I don't
- 20:56know, adopting a Walkman player means going to the store,
- 21:03dropping $50.00 and walking out with a little device, You know,
- 21:06like any, any other technology is amounts to consumption, some
- 21:10sort of device or thing that you're trying out.
- 21:15And it doesn't really matter. It's if it doesn't work, if you
- 21:18don't like it, if you get rid of it, you're going to give it a
- 21:21shot because it's, it's not central to your life.
- 21:24So it's easy to try. And then Bitcoin is this totally
- 21:27other thing where it, it is a radical, it's, it's hot swapping
- 21:32out the foundation of your existence from a financial
- 21:36perspective while you're, you know, while the plane is in
- 21:39flight. I would argue it's not only this
- 21:42financial, it starts with the financial part, right, But I
- 21:45think this is exactly why Bitcoin is it's a technology,
- 21:50yes, but when you adopt it, it becomes your life philosophy,
- 21:54right? Like it's not like, and I think
- 21:56it's fun, but like, you know this MKBHD guy, like I'm the
- 22:00gadget guy, right? Like I like to try out new
- 22:02gadgets or new cars like that's, that's fun, but it's you know,
- 22:07that's why I liked your article, Jesse so much, right?
- 22:11Like why, why doesn't the yuppie elite understand Bitcoin?
- 22:14It's there's so many super smart, analytical people that
- 22:18like to tinker around and do real research, you know, with
- 22:21Excel sheets and all that stuff like this is the best TV or this
- 22:24is the best phone or this is the best whatever.
- 22:27But from what I've seen, a lot of these types of people, they
- 22:32don't like Bitcoin where so, so kind of my conclusion from that
- 22:36is like they are intelligent enough, but they, they don't
- 22:42challenge their faults, right, or their, their beliefs.
- 22:45So I, I, you need to be somewhat intelligent to understand
- 22:48Bitcoin, but it's not an IQ test.
- 22:50It is eventually some sort of ego test.
- 22:53It's just common. Yeah, it's just common sense,
- 22:56but I think like to go back because if somebody you've
- 22:58stumbled into what we're talking about right now, it would be
- 23:01like, man, these guys sound nuts like this sounds like a cult
- 23:03like. So I think it's worth re
- 23:05anchoring to like 2 fundamental things that exist.
- 23:09One is the reason why people don't get Bitcoin is because
- 23:12they're our brains are. It's the same reason why like
- 23:14there's only a small cohort of venture capitalists that are
- 23:17really good at venture capital or seeing the future is that our
- 23:20brains are preconditioned to look at more of what exactly
- 23:23will be close to what exists today than the future.
- 23:25So when you take a radical thing like changing the money, just,
- 23:30you know, you're just predisposed to seeing it.
- 23:33That's why we love this business because everybody's taking a
- 23:35grafting of like self custody and saying that's the end all be
- 23:38all. It's like, well, no, you have
- 23:39you're just taking what you initially have heard.
- 23:41You're not thinking from a first principle perspective like,
- 23:43well, how does this go? The second part, though, is
- 23:46which you referenced about this change, like past a Fiat system.
- 23:51And I've been talking about this book, like Henry Ford's book.
- 23:53It's like if you go back 100 years, everything we're talking
- 23:55about is pretty straightforward. They'll think about everybody
- 23:57else's nuts. Yes, right.
- 23:59So it's just like everything we're talking was actually like
- 24:01baked in. If you just get out of the
- 24:02water, that is kind of like the Fiat muck.
- 24:05And it's because built into like businesses and it's built in.
- 24:08How do we save and spend in consumerism?
- 24:11But if you go backwards, you're like, Oh yeah, that makes
- 24:13complete sense that you just want a unit.
- 24:15That money doesn't grow on trees.
- 24:16So anyway, it's just just trying to re anchor it.
- 24:19So like. I love that.
- 24:19Yeah, yeah, yeah. So.
- 24:20So if we take that brother, right, like true Bitcoin or true
- 24:25getting Bitcoin, I realized that I'm not this emotional guy that,
- 24:29you know, I just said I was, I'm very fucking rational.
- 24:32Sorry, can I swear like I'm a very rational guy, You know,
- 24:37like I, I, I just ended up with this conclusion about Bitcoin
- 24:42because of a rational approach, you know, and you just mentioned
- 24:45the word cult. I think it's fun.
- 24:46Like I'm gonna have an episode of the podcast in two weeks with
- 24:51a guy who emailed me because I talked about is Bitcoin a cult
- 24:54on the podcast. And he said, I survived five
- 24:56years in a, in a, in a, in a cult.
- 25:00And I can tell you Bitcoin is the anti thesis of a cult.
- 25:04And I, I tweeted that and then people replied like, oh, you
- 25:06need to talk to this guy. So I I talked to him, but it's
- 25:09so funny. And Thomas Trolley told me the
- 25:11same. This is a cult where everyone
- 25:13says, please think for yourself and don't listen to me.
- 25:16Yeah, so and, and, and so I wanted to address that.
- 25:20But also what you said, yes, Bitcoin sounds too good to be
- 25:23true because exactly what Michael just said, it's such a
- 25:27rational, simplistic thing. And that's why it sounds so
- 25:31ridiculous in the world that we live in now.
- 25:34That's the only reason. Right.
- 25:35It's the world's crazy around us.
- 25:36It's typing. That's what people in the cult
- 25:39would say, right? But, but I, I really think it's
- 25:43that, right? Because the, the Fiat money is
- 25:45so it's so obfuscated, abstracted, you know, I mean, I
- 25:51talked to a guy in a podcast, Leon Vancombe.
- 25:53I, I maybe you know him like he's really into real estate and
- 25:55Bitcoin. He's a masters of economics, OK.
- 25:58And he told me I never learned what money is in my entire
- 26:01study. So how should a normal person
- 26:05understand what money is, right? Like it's just that is the
- 26:09paradigm that we grew up in and that's why Bitcoin just sounds
- 26:13too good to be true. Yeah, it really is such a big
- 26:17idea and I forget who made the point earlier, but most people
- 26:22don't even understand a, a 10th or 100th of how big of an idea
- 26:26Bitcoin is, right? Most people are stuck where we
- 26:29where you were Brahm in 2014 or where I was in 20/17/18 and even
- 26:34a little bit maybe 2019. Just trying to figure out what
- 26:37actually is important here. And I think it does tie into a
- 26:40how big of an idea it is. And Jesse's done great work in
- 26:44terms of looking at Bitcoins pulpit full potential valuation
- 26:48and the idea that Bitcoin is not an investment, right?
- 26:51It's it's a savings technology. And if you're looking at it as
- 26:55an investment, then naturally you're just looking for a return
- 26:58on your capital. You're not actually looking for
- 27:01a better way to preserve your wealth or a better form of money
- 27:04that can let you transact globally and freely.
- 27:07You're merely looking for something where you could park
- 27:09euros in or dollars in and you can get a return on that
- 27:12capital, you know, a year or five, ten years from now.
- 27:14But it realistically, when people think about crypto,
- 27:16they're thinking about very short term grades, maybe
- 27:19algorithmic trading. So it is just the idea that
- 27:22we're talking about a better form of money that is
- 27:25fundamentally a savings technology.
- 27:27And we're all using that. And I think it does tie into
- 27:29BRAHM, what you're working on with the podcast Bitcoin for
- 27:32Millennials, right? Because I'm really curious,
- 27:35maybe it's obvious and it's because you are a millennial,
- 27:37but why did you choose to focus on the millennial cohort?
- 27:41And really what is what are you trying to drive at?
- 27:45What is your mission of the podcast?
- 27:46And does it tie into this idea of Bitcoin being a savings
- 27:50technology that we, you know, we all have easily accessible to
- 27:52us? Yeah, I'll, I'll create a bridge
- 27:56to get there because I wanted to share, you know, like I only
- 28:01found these other dimensions of Bitcoin like this, this the, the
- 28:05economical part and the financial part.
- 28:09I really got that three years ago.
- 28:11But in, in 2017, I worked at a big bank.
- 28:13I was 30, I had a mortgage. I was already in the Bitcoin.
- 28:16I was walking around in this big bank.
- 28:18You know, I always felt undercover with my little
- 28:20Bitcoin pin on my, on my, on my, on my backpack.
- 28:23And then I talked to a colleague and at one point he told me, I
- 28:26don't know how we can, how it came about.
- 28:28But he said, like, did you know that the money in the bank is
- 28:30not yours? And I was like, what?
- 28:33Like, OK, how, how, how does that work?
- 28:35And then we had lunch for an hour and he told me, you know,
- 28:37fractional reserve banking. And I, I remember walking away
- 28:40from that conversation being like, I'm an idiot.
- 28:42Like I work at a bank, you know, I have a mortgage, I'm
- 28:45participating in this system, I'm looking into this other
- 28:48system, but I don't even see this bigger picture.
- 28:51Like, how do they compare? Like, why, why do I participate
- 28:56in something that I don't understand?
- 28:57Right. Like, remember, as, as I said
- 28:59before, like I like to tinker with stuff to understand how it
- 29:01works. And, and this was really just
- 29:03one conversation where I was, I don't want to say shattered, but
- 29:07really confronted with my own, yeah, inability basically,
- 29:11right. And so I was participating in
- 29:15something in, in not such a conscious way.
- 29:17Well, eventually, you know, I found this financial and
- 29:20economical angle more and more and I started studying it.
- 29:23But I wanted to, I want to share a tweet that I, I, I shared
- 29:26yesterday was from a screenshot from like a forum where someone
- 29:31said, you know, I lost interest, etcetera.
- 29:33And so I said, if you look at Bitcoin from just one
- 29:35perspective, as we talked about, right, like only tech or
- 29:38networks or money or economics, like you will not fully grasp it
- 29:41and eventually you lose interest.
- 29:43And that's why you really need to study, right?
- 29:46And someone replied, he said, you know, I spent countless
- 29:49hours at the Internet intersection of economics, tech,
- 29:51etcetera. But then someone replied and
- 29:53said, monetary, spiritual, health, wealth, religious time,
- 29:56psychological sovereignty, freedom, free speech, like
- 29:59energy, abundance, investment, accounting.
- 30:01And I'm like, you had all these topics relate to Bitcoin and
- 30:06that is, you know, eventually it's very simplistic.
- 30:09But you need to study these things to to grasp why the
- 30:12simplicity is so beautiful and to get them to your question.
- 30:17I think that that's the bridge. Like when you are young and
- 30:21especially, you know, as millennials in a Western
- 30:24country, I think we grew up in the best time to ever grow up of
- 30:28anyone whoever lived, OK, you know, housing, food, schooling,
- 30:34protection, all these things were all there.
- 30:37And when you would go to a store or you wanted like an ice cream
- 30:40or a lollipop, whatever, you got some coins or, or a bill, right?
- 30:43You went there, you just gave this thing, you got the ice
- 30:46cream bag, OK. You know, apparently this is how
- 30:48it works in in my country. It's very techno technology
- 30:54forward, so very early Internet. We have one of the best payment
- 30:57infrastructures in the world, right?
- 30:58Like everyone thinks it just works and it does work, but that
- 31:03is why you never question it. And the people for who it really
- 31:09worked, like our parents or the boomer generation, like they
- 31:13sold us not in a malicious way, right?
- 31:15But they sold us their story of how they built Wells, how they
- 31:19built their life, when they got married, when they got children,
- 31:22you know, how they went through school and got a job and like
- 31:24just the, the, the, the, the classic picture, right?
- 31:28But the reality shows us that that is not attainable for most
- 31:33millennials. And the millennials are now in
- 31:36ages, right? For millennials, I think that
- 31:38started like 7778 till like 9094.
- 31:44You know, we are in this age range of either starting
- 31:47families or having a young family, you know, people are
- 31:50certain, you know, amount of years into their careers,
- 31:54etcetera. Like you're thinking about how
- 31:55do I build out my life. And yeah, in reality, it's just
- 32:00not possible in the way that was told to you.
- 32:04And for me, yeah, that was just a really big reason to, you
- 32:09know, tell people about Bitcoin because I think Bitcoin, I had
- 32:11Keith Laska on and he said to me, Bitcoin is the S&P 500 for
- 32:15millennials. And I thought, you know, that's
- 32:16a that's a good idea, a good a good term.
- 32:19And I also had AI had an event where we had dinner and I said
- 32:23across from a guy who said, I love your podcast.
- 32:25And you know what I think is brilliant?
- 32:26The name like it shouldn't exist.
- 32:29Bitcoin for millennials. I shouldn't be explaining
- 32:32Bitcoin to millennials. It shouldn't be necessary.
- 32:35And when he said that, I was like, damn, that's a good.
- 32:37I never thought about it like that, but it's that we really
- 32:40need it. But it's a real life raft for
- 32:43millennials. That's kind of how I see it.
- 32:44I. Mean it's really noble that you
- 32:48you're working on this and explaining it because we're all
- 32:51millennials and it's like you said, you kind of got sold a
- 32:54bill of goods and then we all know no matter where you're at,
- 32:57specifically Western countries like lack of marriage, lack of
- 33:00birth rates, home ownership, and you get all the tech like you
- 33:04reference. But we the bill of goods we were
- 33:07sold is like the meaning of life or happiness comes from like
- 33:12things that are value, not from like the, the fastness of
- 33:16trading or the the bank job where like you know you have the
- 33:19debt from school and then you go get the big house and the car.
- 33:22And so there's a there's a proxy of Bitcoin saving from a capital
- 33:26perspective and like you're not on the hamster wheel so you can
- 33:29have freedom to to think and move, but then there's the other
- 33:33side of it. It's just like, think from a
- 33:35first principle perspective, like what gives?
- 33:36Because once you have enough money, then you're like, wait,
- 33:38that's not the thing that actually provides.
- 33:40Exactly. And that's what, so you got
- 33:42robbed on both sides before you don't have money.
- 33:45You think money is the only thing that makes you happy.
- 33:46And so you can't have kids and family then once you get money,
- 33:49if it's not the real money, then you're you're still unhappy
- 33:52because you're chasing some like things that are fleeting always.
- 33:56And so on both sides, people are just very unhappy.
- 33:59And we kind of see it in society.
- 34:01But I think just this topic is so interesting.
- 34:03Our grandparents probably got married at 20 or 21, and they
- 34:06got their first kid, right? Just think about how that is
- 34:10now. Like who?
- 34:11Now we think that's a mistake, right?
- 34:13If people do that, right, just just see how that changed.
- 34:18Yeah. In three generations.
- 34:20Totally. And, and, and I think that comes
- 34:22back to like what you could afford on like a entry level
- 34:25salary. You know, in the 50s, sixties,
- 34:30you could, you could start of a family and on one salary and buy
- 34:36a house. And, you know, that was that was
- 34:39totally viable and that allowed for family formation to happen
- 34:43in early 20s. Whereas now it's like you just
- 34:46don't as a millennial, you just don't feel financially secure
- 34:49even now. Like if it wasn't for Bitcoin, I
- 34:53wouldn't feel like I had my feet under me.
- 34:55Yeah, you know. But how bad is that?
- 35:00It's insane, right? That is crazy.
- 35:02We are immensely privileged and lucky that we got here already.
- 35:09Yeah, the I saw a stat just earlier before we started
- 35:12recording that the income required to Ford the average
- 35:16house in the United States in 2020 was about 50,000.
- 35:20It was $53,000 and in 2020 $421,000.
- 35:26So just to the point you're all making, I, I don't know me
- 35:30personally how, where I would be right now in terms of my hopes
- 35:34and aspirations for the future if it wasn't for Bitcoin.
- 35:37Because look at that $75,000 increase in the price of homes
- 35:42in a matter of four years. Very, very small percentage of
- 35:46people are making, you know, maybe even 10% more than they
- 35:50made in 2020. So Bitcoin truly is it's many
- 35:54things, but it does allow for us to level the playing field in
- 35:59some senses. And Bram, I agree with the
- 36:00sentiment that you had growing up in the 90s was was awesome
- 36:04kind of living both in the analog and digital worlds.
- 36:08But unfortunately now with central banks and governments
- 36:12and they're just the centralization around the money,
- 36:15there's this continued incentive to really not allow for, I
- 36:20guess, a reset of the financial system, right?
- 36:23There's the incentive to continue to kick the can down
- 36:25the road. And what that means for anyone
- 36:28who's around our age and 30s and 40s is there needs to be another
- 36:33way to grow your wealth. And I don't think I really don't
- 36:37think unless you're phenomenal at finding, you know, the best
- 36:40demographics to purchase real estate or you're a fantastic
- 36:44equity researcher can find companies that are far
- 36:47undervalued in public markets or private markets, whatever it may
- 36:50be. Most people are going to
- 36:52continue to see their quality of life decrease year over year.
- 36:56And it's really just a sad thing.
- 36:57And I think that's a used Michaels word.
- 36:59It is a noble effort that you're on Braun, just in terms of
- 37:02education and ultimately you might have not even been been
- 37:05here, right? If you in 2014 into 2017, you
- 37:09thought you figured it all out with altcoins and maybe you
- 37:12contributed your expertise and knowledge to build out other
- 37:16businesses or other podcasts that weren't focused on such a
- 37:20great idea and kind of a monetary revolution that is
- 37:23Bitcoin, right? So I guess it's all to say that
- 37:26this culmination, this journey that we've all been on has LED
- 37:29us to this point now. And we're able to hopefully
- 37:32distill and share our learnings with with the folks who listen
- 37:35today so that they can get a little bit further ahead and at
- 37:38a faster rate than we were able to.
- 37:40Does your Bitcoin custody setup keep you up at night?
- 37:43Maybe you still have coins sitting on an exchange worried
- 37:45about hackers. Or maybe you've set up your own
- 37:47self custody, but don't feel safe with your Bitcoin savings
- 37:50stashed on a little plastic device in your desk drawer.
- 37:54Gain Peace of Mind with Onramp and our Multi Institution
- 37:57custody solution. Here's how it works.
- 38:00Onramp creates a dedicated multi sig vault just for you. 3
- 38:04separate institutions each hold a key, Onramp bit go and coin
- 38:08cover, but none can move funds unilaterally.
- 38:11Instead, only you have control over your coins with Onramp's
- 38:16multi institution custody. You'll sleep better at night
- 38:18knowing your Bitcoin is stored with best in class security on
- 38:22chain with fault tolerant multi sig.
- 38:25If you believe your Bitcoin is going to be worth a lot someday,
- 38:28don't jeopardize that future by exposing your coins to hackers
- 38:31on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks in the real world, or perhaps
- 38:35most importantly, the risk that you might screw something up
- 38:38with a highly technical self custody setup.
- 38:41Onramp's Multi institution custody eliminates single points
- 38:44of failure, reduces your personal attack surface and
- 38:47technical burden, and provides access to financial services
- 38:51that allow you to confidently secure your Bitcoin, including
- 38:54inheritance planning, insurance backed warranties for all
- 38:57balances and transactions, low cost trading and more.
- 39:01Bitcoin is a once in a species asset, secure it right.
- 39:05Learn more at onrampbitcoin.com. It's not positive or happy
- 39:10statement about to make, but I came to conclusion, I think it's
- 39:13directionally right that like pre 2020 you could get really
- 39:16ahead by holding back coin like you could.
- 39:18It was the fastest horse. All the things we know about it.
- 39:21I think post 2020 with the amount of money that's flowed
- 39:24into the system, it just keeps pace with inflation.
- 39:27Like the real price, maybe you get some like large moves, but
- 39:31you obviously like it kind of smooths out when you start to
- 39:33look at, you know, year over year.
- 39:36Specifically things that you want when it comes to like real
- 39:39estate or anything that you want to buy from a sizeable.
- 39:42Imagine buying 60, you know, $65,000 Bitcoin a day and three
- 39:46years from now where that price kind of like Nets out at and
- 39:49what's inflation? And we kind of see it today,
- 39:50right? Everybody's excited about all
- 39:51time highs, but like inflation adjusted, I think we're still
- 39:55underneath where we were in 2021.
- 39:59So that just kind of puts the focus, even if it's not exact,
- 40:01it's directional of like we're moving so far backwards.
- 40:04And unless we adopt Bitcoin, you're basically just like out
- 40:06of the game when it comes to being able to stay alive.
- 40:10The other thing that's like really fascinating, it's kind of
- 40:13like a meta concept of like if Braun doesn't exist, Bitcoin
- 40:16doesn't exist. And what I mean by that is this
- 40:20sense of like, it's obvious that Bitcoin can't exist without the
- 40:23Internet, but let's pretend there was no like actual podcast
- 40:26videos or content that existed on the Internet.
- 40:29So you have just telecommunications protocol
- 40:31where you can send the Bitcoin. It's like we don't get to this
- 40:33point. Maybe we get to 100 bucks,
- 40:36whatever number, but it doesn't get to where it is.
- 40:39And it gets to where we're at in the same way that, like
- 40:41everything on the news now is very questionable, where you see
- 40:43stuff on Twitter and you're like, wait, is this real?
- 40:45And then now most people probably on this Potter in their
- 40:48fringes, a conspiracy theorist for their family.
- 40:52And I and I believe that's to be true.
- 40:53It's because the Internet now just like allows you to get in
- 40:56the information that wasn't, that didn't exist before.
- 40:59So these concepts about money and banking and all that, they
- 41:01just didn't exist. And now you like, it's all
- 41:03there. And so you have podcasts and
- 41:06you're synthesizing all of this information in the form of an
- 41:08hour and it lets you get up to speed.
- 41:10That would have taken you 30 years to read a book that like
- 41:13Henry Ford had to figure out. Now you can come to it.
- 41:16So it's just, it's a fascinating idea that like the more the
- 41:19content gets better and more distilled build, the faster this
- 41:21all happens. And even though you could have a
- 41:24landline to send Bitcoin through or whatever, you couldn't really
- 41:27get here until the Internet was available in the concentration
- 41:31of the content like Jesse's writings and and you know,
- 41:34Michael Saylor's and all these things had to happen.
- 41:37And then we've seen it's gotten tighter over time because like
- 41:3910 years ago is nowhere near now.
- 41:40It's like, it's excellent. You can give somebody probably a
- 41:42couple hours and they you probably at least give him a
- 41:45string to pull on to be interested.
- 41:47I think this is the explainer of why Bitcoin is an idea whose
- 41:51time has come, right? We, we talked about the reason
- 41:53of existence. That is why this is, this is
- 41:57manifesting at this moment, right?
- 41:58Like people are more open to talking about money or
- 42:05questioning the money because it's really bad, right?
- 42:08And once you go into it, and I don't think you have to get into
- 42:10it that deeply, you know, some people can explain it in a very
- 42:15rational way as you guys just shared, like they have to kick
- 42:19the can down the road. Debasement is a mathematical
- 42:22fact, right? It is going to happen.
- 42:25It's not going to change. And I think the bigger team is
- 42:30kind of like centralization and decentralization, right?
- 42:33I think AI is going to do a lot there, but it it's yeah.
- 42:39And this is how I also, I don't know if you want to go this way
- 42:42guys, but like more the spiritual or like the even
- 42:45higher level part, right? Like if the the pendulum swings
- 42:48one way to towards this centralization, you know, of
- 42:52control and power and we are moving in this other way and
- 42:56people feel that right? I, I do think we are guided by
- 42:59something that is bigger than us, not necessarily in like, OK,
- 43:03you have to do this And, and, and you know, Obama does this
- 43:05and Jesse does this, etcetera. But it's the awareness of what
- 43:11is going on, how our lives are captured in a certain way.
- 43:14How you know, back to that millennial topic, how your
- 43:17future is basically stolen from you, right?
- 43:20One, one of my biggest inflection points was when I
- 43:23heard save Dean say save Dean a moose from the Bitcoin standard,
- 43:27say like everyone discounts the future, right?
- 43:30Because you don't know how much time you have.
- 43:32And then I thought, OK, that's true.
- 43:34But what if I do something now that gives me a certain monetary
- 43:38reward and I want to save that towards the future to spend it
- 43:41on something else, whatever that is, whether it's in a month or a
- 43:45year or three years. And I think that was right
- 43:47around the time when I saw the startup.
- 43:49So I, I, I got some money and I was like, yeah, this, this is,
- 43:53this is really it. Because if I, if I'm not able
- 43:57to, to take what I have now towards the future, then it, it
- 44:03kind of discounts the future even more because I have this
- 44:06opportunity to move towards the future, build towards the
- 44:10future. But if I know that the energy
- 44:12that I gathered right now, at this moment will be worth less
- 44:16in that future, then yeah, why would I even do that?
- 44:18Because I already discount the future and you know, then I, I
- 44:24am lucky that I found Bitcoin, but there's, and so, so I'm
- 44:26protected in that way, but many people do not have that.
- 44:30And you know, I think the saddest thing is, is I, I had a
- 44:34real life conversation. So I, I know people talk about,
- 44:38you know, not having kids and all, all these things, but I had
- 44:41AI had AI, had a real life conversation with someone who
- 44:43shared that he didn't want to have kids like my age.
- 44:46And I asked him like, OK, but what is like, why, why?
- 44:51And then just, he shared, you know, he's pretty nihilistic
- 44:53about the world and, and you know, about the future,
- 44:55etcetera. And it really hit me.
- 44:58And I also asked him like, OK, but like, this is a with all due
- 45:01respect, but like, did you give up or like, what?
- 45:04Like how, how do you get to this, right.
- 45:07And I, I understand that it's annoying when someone with kids
- 45:10talks to someone without kids, right?
- 45:12Because you don't understand etcetera.
- 45:13But I really just wanted to know.
- 45:15And then he said, yeah, I do. Like it's just, that's why I
- 45:18don't want to have that have them, you know, I just take care
- 45:20of my girlfriend and, and my parents and I work and blah,
- 45:23blah, blah. And I really walked away from
- 45:24this conversation. I don't know, a bit shocked,
- 45:28right, Because I know as a parent that, you know, this is
- 45:31the only thing why we're here. And and it does not revolve
- 45:34around money, right? Like you can raise a kid with
- 45:36all the love in the world with some money or a lot of money,
- 45:40you know, like it's not about that.
- 45:42And I feel that once you kind of get touched in that thing that
- 45:48like biological urge that everyone has that we all share,
- 45:51if that gets corrupted, man, then we are very far away from
- 45:56what we are, you know, supposed to be doing, right?
- 45:59And perfectly said corrupted there.
- 46:01And I feel like it's it at the heart of of human psychology is
- 46:08the belief that we can make a better future for our our
- 46:10children, right. And and that like drives
- 46:13everything in about how we operate, what we do everything
- 46:19and Fiat money is inherently this philosophy of, of the
- 46:24future will be worse than today. And that's so incompatible.
- 46:28So fucking stupid, yeah. And so it's so.
- 46:31Irrational. It doesn't make sense.
- 46:33It doesn't make sense forced into this world where you like,
- 46:35you live within those constraints and then you end up
- 46:37with nihilism and people don't want to have kids or start
- 46:39families. But and then Bitcoin presents
- 46:41this opportunity to just like switch back into a philosophy of
- 46:44the future will be better than today.
- 46:45Yes, exactly. Also for me and then for my
- 46:48children. Yeah, right.
- 46:49Like it's. It Brent, something you you nail
- 46:52or you hit on that I haven't talked about is like we know the
- 46:55demographic changes and you know, lack of children or few
- 46:59less children in marriage. But the thing that I I was
- 47:04interesting, just like not particularly religious into
- 47:07anyone particular religion, but just went back randomly.
- 47:09I don't know why, but started reading all these religious
- 47:11texts and you see all this everybody knows like sacrifices
- 47:15and that they sacrifice children, all this crazy stuff.
- 47:17And at the you read it, you're like, this is this is insane.
- 47:20That makes zero sense. But at the time, if you think
- 47:22about it, it made complete sense.
- 47:25They had their reasons in the same way, like we'll look back
- 47:27at here and there'll be different things that are that
- 47:30won't make any sense in a future state if this all plays out the
- 47:33way we believe that Bitcoin is sound money.
- 47:35Where I'm going with that is effectively what is described or
- 47:39your friend described as like the sacrificing of children,
- 47:42like it's sacrificing himself or not having a child.
- 47:44And like we see these things play out and manifest and we
- 47:47don't know necessarily why at the time, but that's effectively
- 47:50what what's happening is that we're sacrificing children for
- 47:54money. That's a that's.
- 47:56A good point. That's basically what's
- 47:57happening is saying, because I remember going to the dentist
- 48:01and having a very like wealthy or somewhat in from western side
- 48:05wealthiness. And this is what I think really
- 48:06hit me was the dentist was telling she had two or three
- 48:08kids and she's like, Oh, I'm done.
- 48:10And she's like, we love more. And he's just like, well, what
- 48:13do you what do you mean you're done?
- 48:14And it's like, well, because we can't afford it.
- 48:16And So what do you mean you can't afford it?
- 48:17And it's just like, they're so literally, like, again, it's not
- 48:20maybe it's not literally sacrificing control, but they
- 48:21are sacrificing bringing in another human into, into this
- 48:24world because they do, they believe that they won't get the
- 48:27extra DoorDash, the extra vacation, the extra retirement.
- 48:30And so again, it's not apples apples, but it's directionally
- 48:33what would probably have been thought of there is like, This
- 48:35is why I'm doing it that way. So yeah, it's, it's, it's really
- 48:40messed up when we're how we've gotten that far that it's just,
- 48:44to your point, just built in our DNA to reproduce.
- 48:47And now it's like, oh, it's OK, I'll just get the dog.
- 48:49I'll, I'll be all right. It's so crazy.
- 48:51Yeah. I mean, perhaps this is a nice
- 48:53bridge to, you know, another inflection point for me when I
- 48:57don't know if it was on Breedlove or Knutes Funholm.
- 49:00Like they were talking about like Austrian Keynesian
- 49:02economics when someone said, you know, economics is not a
- 49:05science, it's a social study, right?
- 49:08It's how people communicate and interact with each other, how
- 49:12they defined value, etcetera. Like on top of that, yes, you
- 49:16can calculate about like all these things, but but in essence
- 49:19it it's like a social study and the Keynesians, they create all
- 49:25these rules that eventually they are manipulating all the time
- 49:30because fundamentally it's all flawed, right?
- 49:33So to keep it alive ego wise, they have to manipulate all the
- 49:36time. But by manipulating the rules of
- 49:38this, what would occur as natural marketplace of ideas,
- 49:43right? Ideas that people eventually
- 49:45spend their time on and, you know, build things or, or have a
- 49:48job. That's that, that natural
- 49:52occurrence basically that, that organic behaviour is influenced
- 49:56by rules that are set by just a, a few, you know, a centralized
- 50:00group of people basically. And people are following that.
- 50:03And so they are trying with rules on paper, they're trying
- 50:05to change this. I don't want to say biological
- 50:08behaviour, but let's call it organic behaviour, right?
- 50:11And because it's such a bad idea, this permeates into
- 50:15everything, literally what we just talked about, right?
- 50:18The result of having such a bad money is that you're influencing
- 50:25the natural choices that everyone before you, before your
- 50:29life made. So you are here, right?
- 50:31And then you say because your money sucks.
- 50:34Well, this was it. You know it insane.
- 50:38Really insane. That that does cross my mind
- 50:41with people who, who aren't going to have kids, especially
- 50:43for like the sort of political reasons of like, you know,
- 50:47global warming or whatever, the world's going to be a bad place.
- 50:49And so I don't want to bring kids into that world.
- 50:51And I can't help but think about the millions of generations
- 50:55going back that they, you know, they are their family tree goes
- 50:59back for millions of generations, you know, into
- 51:02chimpanzees. And they are breaking that
- 51:05continuity because they've been hoodwinked by the politics of
- 51:09our era. Yes.
- 51:10Like what a what a colossal tragedy that is for their for
- 51:14their family line. Imagine I think about this a
- 51:18lot. Like I'm really into like
- 51:19ancient civilizations and stuff like that.
- 51:21I think about this a lot, right? Let's say we are hunter
- 51:24gatherers and every day we are busy getting food and not trying
- 51:28to get the women killed by the animals, right?
- 51:31We are constantly aware of not dying, either food or
- 51:35protection, right? At one point.
- 51:39So these people are living, you know, the sun comes up, the sun
- 51:41goes down, the moon and the stars come.
- 51:43They look at the sky like, what the hell is going on here,
- 51:46right? And at one point it stops.
- 51:48The sun stops shining, you know, it rains, the snow comes, the
- 51:52children die. And they're like, huh, OK, well,
- 51:56next year or they just continue. They don't know about years or
- 52:00time or whatever. OK, we'll try again.
- 52:02And then it happens again, right?
- 52:03And then the sun comes up and goes down.
- 52:05And I feel like this is the biggest thing that we need to
- 52:12understand, you know, or what I think we all eventually want to
- 52:16understand. That's what I hope I think
- 52:18somewhere within us that is there, right?
- 52:20Like if you look at the sky and you zoom out, like Jessie can
- 52:23zoom out really well and just think about where we are in this
- 52:26tiny speck in Infinity and you know, this, this what is going
- 52:32on? These extensional big, big
- 52:35questions. I, I kind of lost my train of
- 52:37thought, but I I'll try to finish.
- 52:41This is, I feel what we should be talking about, right?
- 52:43But instead there's all these distractions that go against all
- 52:48these again, like organically organic questions or quests or
- 52:54challenges that would come up for any human that we all share,
- 52:58right? And it's because the the rules
- 53:02of a technology that we are using to said Bunny told me this
- 53:07express our express what we find important with each other,
- 53:13right? So what you buy shows what it's
- 53:15you kind of express something, right?
- 53:19Because these rules of this technology change all the time.
- 53:22It gets us further and further and further and further away
- 53:25from this natural, yeah, questioning of or or attempts of
- 53:31trying to understand what the hell is is going on here, right.
- 53:35I see what you're getting at. It's like like humans want to be
- 53:38and should be spending their time on self actualization.
- 53:41Like at the top of Maslow's pyramid and, and because of Fiat
- 53:45and, and how it it makes it harder to, you know, save and
- 53:50build financial security. It forces people to spend their
- 53:53time surviving in the middle of Maslow's pyramid and not being
- 53:57able to spend time self actualizing at the top.
- 54:00And that like to tie it in eloquently, it appeared Peter
- 54:02Till's quote is we were promised flying cars and spaceships or
- 54:06whatever, and all we got was 240 characters because that's
- 54:08effectively what we were supposed to continue to be
- 54:10progressing. And we've just kind of like
- 54:13stopped and we're just kind of hanging out and it's kind of
- 54:17like going back to the cult positioning is everybody feels
- 54:21it here. It's like you kind of have a,
- 54:23you know, or, and the matrix deal.
- 54:25It's like you kind of see through stuff after you get.
- 54:27This because everything else. Is like, it's like I, I, I can
- 54:30like I can see what things for what they are and it just lets
- 54:32you put you in an advantage. Maybe not with it's like the
- 54:36whole dinner conversation. Maybe it's not a great dinner or
- 54:40not great dinner conversations, depending who you are.
- 54:42Maybe just speaking for myself, but when you get to a group like
- 54:45this, you can just speak freely and you can actually talk about
- 54:47the ideas that will ultimately matter once we kind of are done
- 54:51trying to survive. Yeah, but that's also the fun
- 54:54thing of the of the podcast is I talked to so many people and I
- 54:56hear these ideas, right? Like so I talked with Seb Bunny
- 54:59who said we are consumers because the value of our money
- 55:04is the highest in the present moment.
- 55:07One minute from now, it's already worth less, right?
- 55:09So in the present moment, what I just gathered, the economic
- 55:13energy that I have is worth the most.
- 55:15That's why I'm a consumer. That's why we are stuck in this
- 55:19physical consumerist world. We are not thinking about these
- 55:23higher planes, right? And I think, Michael, you know
- 55:26the matrix or I think the Fiat money is the matrix.
- 55:29We are in this constructed paradigm.
- 55:32That's also why Bitcoin is too good to be true, because it's an
- 55:35it's not in this paradigm. It's another thing, right?
- 55:38And and people, you know, this is Jeff Booth talk, right?
- 55:40He, he says you cannot look at the new paradigm from the
- 55:43existing paradigm. You cannot see that you are
- 55:46captured in this thing because you are looking from the thing
- 55:50you know. And what's, what's crazy like to
- 55:52make that one really tangible is, you know, there's there's no
- 55:54shortage of really bad stuff happening right now, like with
- 55:57the floods in the, the southeast of the US and then Lebanon right
- 56:02now there's like invasions. We have a colleague that his
- 56:04family's based there. And the, the longer end of it is
- 56:08that it's like, why don't they leave?
- 56:10And it's like you were to your point about going backwards,
- 56:13like you don't leave your home because it's where all your
- 56:15value is. It's where everything so the
- 56:17looters will come for. It's like you just hold it and
- 56:19where all your wealth is stored. But it's this out of the out of
- 56:23the center in a different plane or paradigm.
- 56:26If you can just leave and you're not anchored to it, you always
- 56:28know that like that is your home, but you're not leaving
- 56:31everything your your home is constructed of like your family
- 56:34and like your wealth and being able to take it and propagate
- 56:36into the future and knowing that you can do that kind of changes
- 56:39the dynamic. We've never had that before.
- 56:41At best, you can trust another bank to do it.
- 56:43And then you're hopefully you know, they'll fulfill the
- 56:45obligations. But I think that's like a key
- 56:47thing that most people haven't woken up to yet is that you're
- 56:50not tied to a geographic location.
- 56:52If things get bad, you can leave with all your money and you're
- 56:55not leaving everything behind. Yeah, that's so true.
- 57:00I mean, even even for things that exist digitally native,
- 57:04like when we look at the numbers on our screen at a our bank
- 57:07account, like Michael you'd shared at some point the I think
- 57:10it's Bank of America outages today, right?
- 57:12So even if you have money that in theory you should be able to
- 57:16access digitally, or if I fly over to Europe, I should be able
- 57:19to use my credit card and purchase things there, But it's
- 57:23still a permission based system. And it's a system, Brahm, as you
- 57:26pointed out that every day that I'm holding these dollars or EUR
- 57:29or whatever I have is a day that I have less of that that
- 57:33tomorrow, right? It is, it's a little hyperbolic
- 57:35to say that because it doesn't necessarily happen in the
- 57:38Western world the next day, but it does happen in other places
- 57:42within a matter of days or weeks.
- 57:44And fortunately, we're not quite there yet.
- 57:45I don't know if we will get there.
- 57:48In Lebanon there were there were people that robbed banks to get
- 57:51their own money. Yeah.
- 57:54And they, they have the same monetary system as we have,
- 57:57right? It's the same field money
- 57:58system. So there is no difference.
- 58:00It's we are just lucky that we are in these Western countries.
- 58:04You even more than me, right, having the world reserve
- 58:09currency. But maybe one more example, like
- 58:12you, you talked about the matrix, then you talked about
- 58:14the number in your banking app, right?
- 58:16Like that's also such an interesting realization that I
- 58:19had that the number in your banking app is just a number in
- 58:22the database. And I've been to the data center
- 58:25of the bank that I worked at, and they have like a twin data
- 58:29center like 2 miles away or five miles away, and they are
- 58:33connected with a wire. So the 1 is a copy of the other.
- 58:37That's basically where all the money is.
- 58:39It's just numbers in the database.
- 58:40There's nothing physical. There's nothing real.
- 58:42There's no save like Scrooge Mcduck, right?
- 58:45There's nothing and literally nothing.
- 58:46And you bet that the Russians or all the adversaries know where
- 58:50all these data centers are, right?
- 58:52So if you sabotage one data center, the money that is not
- 58:56existing is really gone, right? It's for me that is this matrix
- 59:01thing. Like you look at this at this
- 59:04banking app and you see this number.
- 59:06It's literally computer code that shows you here's the value.
- 59:08This is what you, you know, yeah, value in your life.
- 59:12This is why you make certain decisions in your real physical,
- 59:16biological life. This computer thingy right here.
- 59:20And yeah, I just find that so fascinating, so fascinating.
- 59:23It's an. Impressive veil and system
- 59:25that's been constructed because if you think about it, you work
- 59:28your whole life and you create physical value, you put it in
- 59:30the digital database, then you hope when you retire it's going
- 59:33to be there. I think if like again, a
- 59:36brother-in-law, it's like enough dinner conversations and she
- 59:39became a spike coiner because she's like, I can't like if I
- 59:42retired and this all gets wiped away, at least I have like he
- 59:45was maybe a little right. It's just a hedge, which is at
- 59:47least something. But it's a, that's just
- 59:51basically what people believe. It's that's they work their
- 59:54whole lives. They're going to put it in the
- 59:55database and it's going to always be there when they need
- 59:57it and it's going to retain its purchasing power, which is like
- 1:00:00the first part we already know is fleeting.
- 1:00:01The second part is for how long. Yeah, but that's why I say
- 1:00:06Scrooge Mcduck, right? Like people think it's, it's a
- 1:00:08bank. Like Scrooge Mcduck has, you
- 1:00:10know, the coins in his, in his vault, They're like that.
- 1:00:13Yeah. It's just that's not what it is,
- 1:00:15you know? Yeah, That could even be applied
- 1:00:19to equities or other securities held within a brokerage account
- 1:00:22as well. I mean, we kind of assume that
- 1:00:25we can sell those securities and we can get Fiat money out of the
- 1:00:28account fairly seamlessly. But there could be a world where
- 1:00:32there could be some sort of bail insurance, right?
- 1:00:34Or that the tax laws could change in the US as it relates
- 1:00:37to retirement accounts and how you can access your funds.
- 1:00:39And then to Michael's point, physical land as well.
- 1:00:42Jurisdictions change their laws all the time.
- 1:00:45Tax rates could change. So there really is nothing like
- 1:00:49Bitcoin in the sense that you can truly you can own it in a
- 1:00:52self sovereign way and it actually is a global form of
- 1:00:56property that doesn't rely on you to ask permission.
- 1:01:00And that that is true in the sense of self custody.
- 1:01:02It's also true in the sense of what we do with multi
- 1:01:05institution custody and just, I guess building solutions.
- 1:01:09It ties back into the beginning of the conversation, just
- 1:01:12building solutions with the knowledge that we have and
- 1:01:15knowing that this is a technology that's only 15 years,
- 1:01:18you know, 15 years into it's existence.
- 1:01:20I know there's decades of cryptography and computer
- 1:01:23science to that predates that, but we're only 15 years into
- 1:01:28this. So we're still figuring it out
- 1:01:29as we go. And we need to apply that same
- 1:01:32level of, I think curiosity and open mindedness that we have as
- 1:01:36it related to getting into Bitcoin, as it relates to
- 1:01:38building out solutions as well. And as it relates to education
- 1:01:41and bringing guests on your show Brahm and exploring maybe topics
- 1:01:44that are considered more at the cusp of, I guess the Overton
- 1:01:50window or whatever it may be, right?
- 1:01:51So I think that just for me personally, and it sounds like
- 1:01:55for you guys as well, that Bitcoin opened up a curiosity
- 1:01:57that maybe was suppressed for a long time.
- 1:02:00And now you can use that to explore whatever it may be,
- 1:02:03whether it's with, you know, within Bitcoin money economics
- 1:02:06directly or it's technology philosophy, a lot of the themes
- 1:02:09that we touched on today. So I think that's just such a
- 1:02:11fascinating thing about what, you know, why we're all here
- 1:02:14today. Well, Bitcoin makes me feel
- 1:02:17again like that 13 year old kid that liked computering and was
- 1:02:21just on the Internet all day in this endless journey of
- 1:02:25information. Like, it is that feeling for me,
- 1:02:30yeah. Yeah.
- 1:02:32Well, Brahm, I know we're already over on time.
- 1:02:36So maybe just in the interest of you already being generous with
- 1:02:40it, is there anything top of mind that we didn't touch on
- 1:02:45today that maybe you just want to share with the folks, like
- 1:02:47anything related to the work you're doing with the podcast or
- 1:02:52anything else? And if not, we could always just
- 1:02:54do a hand off to where folks can find you.
- 1:02:57Appreciate your time either way. That's a good question.
- 1:03:02I think I like that you guys also started this.
- 1:03:07I think, I think the the one thing as a take away for us, but
- 1:03:11also for people listening who are getting into Bitcoin or or
- 1:03:15who are already into Bitcoin, we should not stop talking about
- 1:03:17Bitcoin. I mean, we touched the
- 1:03:19philosophical part a little bit, but I really feel like by doing
- 1:03:24this, we are manifesting this idea, right?
- 1:03:27Like, as I said in the beginning, I really believe
- 1:03:29that, you know, all information is already out there.
- 1:03:31All the ideas already float in the universe.
- 1:03:33And you know, sometimes you get this idea for, let's say, a
- 1:03:37business and, and, and it's something you want to pursue,
- 1:03:39right? I feel that Bitcoin and this,
- 1:03:43this absolute digital scarcity, it's, it's an invention and a
- 1:03:46discovery, right? But everything that's created
- 1:03:49like I just got this. I like the idea of this thing
- 1:03:53started as an idea in someone's head, right?
- 1:03:55It started as a metaphysical thing and now it now it now it's
- 1:03:57here. And I feel the same way about
- 1:04:00Bitcoin and I feel the same way about education talking about
- 1:04:03it, trying to I don't want to say Orange Bill people, but
- 1:04:07challenge people on their thinking right?
- 1:04:09Like why do you do what you do? Why do you think This is Money
- 1:04:12or whatever the questions are right?
- 1:04:14We are doing like collective manifestation all together.
- 1:04:18Everyone who thinks Bitcoin should exist, yes, it exists,
- 1:04:23but you know, in, in a way that we think would be meaningful for
- 1:04:27everyone in the world. And yeah, that, that I think is,
- 1:04:32is the core of what I'm trying to say is we should just never
- 1:04:34stop talking about Bitcoin. So I, I think it's really cool
- 1:04:36that you guys are building a company and building the, you
- 1:04:39know, out of content, etcetera. Like you never know who you're
- 1:04:43going to touch. That's something I really
- 1:04:45learned from the from the podcast and yeah, I think that's
- 1:04:49just great. So I applaud that.
- 1:04:52Yeah, this is that's very well said.
- 1:04:53Excited to go on. I know Jesse, he's been on
- 1:04:55that's coming out soon with you. And and also to that sentiment
- 1:04:59of recently you've gotten most excited of like there's a lot of
- 1:05:03Bitcoin stuff that it will be built needs to be built.
- 1:05:06But to your point, what happens when the best experts or
- 1:05:10professionals in their own right learn about Bitcoin and then
- 1:05:12start iterating and growing on their own thing?
- 1:05:15Like, it's just such a fascinating idea and concept to
- 1:05:19think about. So the more individuals that
- 1:05:21come in, I used to joke around and say, like, the best
- 1:05:23companies haven't even been built in Bitcoin because the
- 1:05:26best founders don't even know about Bitcoin yet.
- 1:05:28Like, they haven't even heard about it.
- 1:05:30They may have heard about it, but they don't understand what
- 1:05:32we're talking about. And So what happens when they
- 1:05:34come in the Bezoses and the Zuckerbergs of the world?
- 1:05:36Like we're really going to just see amazing things.
- 1:05:40So Brandon, this was a good kind of preview where I have a lot of
- 1:05:43things I'd love to chat with you and.
- 1:05:45Let's let's do that. I'll add one thing to that
- 1:05:47because this you know, you are also all Internet kids, right?
- 1:05:53I feel Bitcoin is a true Internet thing, right?
- 1:05:57And we are acting the meme. The most entertaining outcome is
- 1:06:03the most likely, right? I mean, we are all tweeting at
- 1:06:05Michael Dell. Like just show us your Bitcoin
- 1:06:08holding, right? You're teasing, you're doing.
- 1:06:10I had a tweet that went viral that said like, if Michael Dell,
- 1:06:15if Michael Dell buys Bitcoin, I will buy an old Dell computer.
- 1:06:18I'll make it a note. All these people piled in,
- 1:06:23right? And, or, and then other people
- 1:06:25had an idea like, oh, you should refurbish your old Dell stuff,
- 1:06:28Michael. And then, you know, just start
- 1:06:30making Dell notes, like stuff like that.
- 1:06:33I, for me, it's part of this manifestation.
- 1:06:35Like it's gonna happen. I had another tweet that did
- 1:06:38really well where I said, you know, Mark Zuckerberg buying
- 1:06:40Bitcoin will be the top of this cycle.
- 1:06:42Like stuff like that. It, this is an Internet thing.
- 1:06:46It and and and I feel that we can really make this happen
- 1:06:51there's nothing like this Internet culture you know so I.
- 1:06:55Here's again, on that note, here's this.
- 1:06:58I was a orange man turned into orange coin.
- 1:07:01Like, you know, like Trump adopting or embracing Bitcoin is
- 1:07:04like part of what you just described is just and it's such
- 1:07:07an insane like proposition. If you would have thought about
- 1:07:10years two years ago. Yeah, and he doesn't even have
- 1:07:13to understand it, right. Like he's, he's launching this,
- 1:07:15you know, stupid coin. You know that that is all noise.
- 1:07:19You know, if he signs, if if you know and and and shout out to
- 1:07:23David Bailey, by the way, like he they are in his ear.
- 1:07:26They are in Trump's ear in in a in a correct way, you know, and
- 1:07:30he's doing his own shit confidence.
- 1:07:32Fine, But let's say this there did this strategic reserve bill.
- 1:07:39I think the first attempt will probably fail, but it draws out
- 1:07:43people, right? It draws out people that have to
- 1:07:45create this opinion. And as we know, there are no
- 1:07:47informed critiques. So why are you against Bitcoin?
- 1:07:49Show me, you know, give me your arguments.
- 1:07:52It's going to be, you know, fireworks.
- 1:07:54I think maybe second, third attempt, let's say that really
- 1:07:57becomes a bill. Fascinating.
- 1:08:00Ultimate entertainment, don't you think?
- 1:08:03Like, then we manifested this 15 or then maybe 17 year old idea
- 1:08:07from an obscure Internet forum into a law.
- 1:08:10OK, Yeah. That's a funny thought.
- 1:08:13Is a funny thought that most of the world will learn about
- 1:08:16Bitcoin by people trying to say why this bill is a bad idea and
- 1:08:22people trying to figure out why to oppose a bill sounds crazy.
- 1:08:26That'll bring in a huge new cohort of people to
- 1:08:29understanding Bitcoin. I have I have people on Twitter
- 1:08:31yesterday I had a discussion with a guy who was like super
- 1:08:34pro EU blah blah. Like I'm, I'm pro EU trade, but
- 1:08:37not like how the European Union is now.
- 1:08:38And then he said, oh, you have Bitcoin in your bio or you're a
- 1:08:41soccer. And then I just quote tweeted a
- 1:08:43post from me where I calculated, you know, €1.00 in 2000 is now
- 1:08:4830 cents. OK.
- 1:08:50And the euro crashed 99.999% against Bitcoin.
- 1:08:54I said good luck and then there was just silence, you know.
- 1:08:59And so this will, yeah, it will draw people out.
- 1:09:02It will draw people's arguments out and, and we will get the
- 1:09:05opportunity to counter these arguments.
- 1:09:07And I think that is the opportunity that we are
- 1:09:11eventually looking for. That's a great place to stop the
- 1:09:16show. Brom, thank you so much for
- 1:09:18coming on. I know we plugged Bitcoin for
- 1:09:21millennials, but is there anywhere else that you want to
- 1:09:24send people? Yeah, you people can just find
- 1:09:27Bitcoin for millennials on YouTube, Spotify, Apple Fountain
- 1:09:32and they can find me on X Twitter at BR AM K Brom K.
- 1:09:38Awesome. Thanks, Brom.
- 1:09:39Thanks guys, enjoyed it. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:09:42week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:09:45valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:09:47rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:09:49All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:09:51notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:09:54reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:09:56entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:09:59investment or legal advice, regardless of where you are on
- 1:10:03your Bitcoin journey. We'd love to hear from you.
- 1:10:05Visit onrampbitcoin.com Contact. To schedule a consultation with
- 1:10:09one of our private client advisors.