Latest / Becker’s Healthcare Podcast / Dr. Kapil Dhingra on Leadership, AI, and Value-Based Care at The Permanente Medical Group
Transcript
- 0:01Every year, Becker's annual meeting brings health care
- 0:04leaders together to unpack the most pressing issues
- 0:06facing the industry.
- 0:08And every year, those conversations shift in profound
- 0:10and unexpected ways.
- 0:12This April, more than 3,500
- 0:14healthcare executives will return to Chicago for Becker's
- 0:17sixteenth annual meeting. Seven ninety five elite speakers
- 0:21will offer new lessons, new case studies, and
- 0:24predictions about what comes next.
- 0:26Join us April 13 through the sixteenth.
- 0:29For the agenda and event details, visit beckershospitalreview.com
- 0:33and click on the events tab in the
- 0:35upper right.
- 0:38This is Scott Becker with the Becker's Health
- 0:40Care podcast.
- 0:41I am thrilled today to be joined by
- 0:43a brilliant physician leader. We're joined today by
- 0:46doctor Kapil Dhingra,
- 0:47and doctor Dhingra is the physician in chief
- 0:50and health care executive at the Permanente Medical
- 0:53Group. He he serves specifically as the chief
- 0:55physician executive at the Kaiser Permanente San Leandro
- 0:59Medical Center.
- 1:00He also is the chief of staff at
- 1:02at the at that center.
- 1:04Doctor Dhingra,
- 1:05thank you for taking the time to join
- 1:07us today. I've been incredibly impressed by the
- 1:09Kaiser Permanente growth over the last thirty, forty
- 1:11years, particularly the quality that that that Kaiser
- 1:15Permanente has come to represent in the Permanente
- 1:17Medical Group. Can you take a moment to
- 1:19introduce yourself and and tell us a bit
- 1:21about yourself and your career?
- 1:23Great. Thank you, Scott, and I appreciate being
- 1:25on this podcast. I'm a big fan of
- 1:27Becker's and
- 1:28how you connect health care leaders from different
- 1:31areas together to improve health across our communities.
- 1:35So my name is Kapal Dhingra. I'm clinically
- 1:37trained as an emergency physician, and I'm the
- 1:40physician in chief and chief of staff at
- 1:42Kaiser Permanente
- 1:43San Leandro Medical Center, which is a city
- 1:46just South of Oakland.
- 1:47And we have multispecialty
- 1:49clinics and hospitals that care for a little
- 1:51over 375,000
- 1:53patients.
- 1:54As you may know, Kaiser Permanente is an
- 1:56integrated health care system.
- 1:58We're fortunate to take care of, just over
- 2:014,600,000
- 2:02patients
- 2:03across Northern California,
- 2:05a very diverse area.
- 2:07What's special about the territory that I have
- 2:09a privilege of leading within is
- 2:12that we are an incredibly
- 2:14diverse
- 2:15territory or service area,
- 2:17and the diversity spans a lot of different
- 2:20ways that makes me excited as not only
- 2:22a practice position, but also to lead in
- 2:24this space.
- 2:25We have incredible socio ethnic diversity, socioeconomic
- 2:30diversity.
- 2:31We're on the tip of Silicon Valley, some
- 2:33areas, and in some areas,
- 2:35many of our patients are just above the
- 2:37federal poverty line.
- 2:39Another unique fact is that we speak over
- 2:4288
- 2:43different languages in the GSA. Please don't ask
- 2:45me to name all of them for you,
- 2:47but it it is truly a privilege to
- 2:49to care for such a diverse population.
- 2:51Thank you so much. And and and take
- 2:53a moment, doctor Dingra. You've been a lifelong
- 2:56learner.
- 2:57You're you're a physician.
- 2:58You've also gone back and done an MBA.
- 3:02Talk about the commitment to lifelong learning and
- 3:04and why you've committed to it.
- 3:07Thanks, Scott. I you know, lifelong learning for
- 3:09me really came from my my father. I
- 3:12I learned a lot from my father. He's
- 3:14a first generation
- 3:15immigrant from India, and, he's a retired electrical
- 3:18engineer.
- 3:20Got some training in India. I went to
- 3:21Columbia.
- 3:23And, he was always learning. He was always
- 3:25reading. He was
- 3:26always educating and teaching, me things even when
- 3:29I maybe
- 3:30wasn't interested. But you kinda picked up on,
- 3:33the power of of of so not only
- 3:36improving oneself,
- 3:37but doing it for something that you really
- 3:38believe in.
- 3:40And so I've always been super passionate about
- 3:42health care and been interested in not only
- 3:45delivery of of care, but the systems that
- 3:48make that easier for physicians, for nurses, for
- 3:50staff to do the work.
- 3:52And,
- 3:53it's it's a challenge because health care, in
- 3:56particular, when you think about just even medicine,
- 3:58we're always learning. There's new therapeutics. There's new
- 4:01ways to deliver care. And now with health
- 4:03care systems that are rapidly evolving with technology,
- 4:06say artificial intelligence,
- 4:08you really have to be alert. You have
- 4:10to be willing to also be humbled because
- 4:13things are changing so quickly and question our
- 4:15status quo so that we can do better
- 4:17for our patients.
- 4:19Thank you, Nolan. I love that. I'm a
- 4:20huge fan and and can't tell you enough
- 4:22how much I'm a fan of people that
- 4:24are lifelong learners.
- 4:26And and your dad was an immigrant from
- 4:29India, electrical engineer.
- 4:32In in the household I grew up in,
- 4:33you were allowed to be a and this
- 4:34goes back a generation,
- 4:36a doctor or lawyer or or an accountant.
- 4:38Those were the three choices.
- 4:40You ended up being a doctor. Did you
- 4:41have multiple choices, or were your parents open
- 4:44to you doing anything? I came from a
- 4:46generation where my parents were not open to
- 4:47me doing anything, so I ended up having
- 4:49to do what they told me to do.
- 4:50Tell me about that with yourself.
- 4:53Yeah. Thanks, Scott. You know, my parents were
- 4:55very supportive. They definitely,
- 4:57first, they they preach the importance
- 4:59of getting a better education. You know, I
- 5:01have I have three kids, and my wife
- 5:02and I always think about
- 5:04our role is to love our children and
- 5:07provide a supportive environment where they could be
- 5:09their best selves, and I think I learned
- 5:10that from my parents.
- 5:12My my exposure to health care first off,
- 5:14I'm the first physician in our family,
- 5:16first in health care.
- 5:18And the thing that got me into health
- 5:20care was when my mother was diagnosed with
- 5:22breast cancer, now a little over twenty five
- 5:24years ago.
- 5:25And I remember being in college, hearing about
- 5:27the diagnosis. At the time, I was an
- 5:29economics major and not quite sure where I
- 5:31was headed. And
- 5:34what ended up happening for me is is
- 5:35I
- 5:36saw the compassion
- 5:38that she was treated by the nurses, by
- 5:40the physicians, and the staff
- 5:42when she had, you know, double mastectomy,
- 5:45complications,
- 5:46chemotherapy,
- 5:47really a long road. As As we know,
- 5:49breast cancer treatment has really evolved.
- 5:52But what that did for me is it
- 5:53exposed,
- 5:54the potential to care for others,
- 5:56and
- 5:58that really made it easy to to want
- 6:00to go into medicine.
- 6:01The decision to pursue an MBA really came
- 6:04from
- 6:05wanting to help systems
- 6:07improve. As an emergency physician, we're often at
- 6:09the nexus
- 6:11of everything that's happening in a hospital, in
- 6:13a system. You see patients that maybe are
- 6:16not receiving the most optimal care
- 6:18or coming to you because you're their last
- 6:20resort or patients who have very complex needs
- 6:22are already getting tertiary care services,
- 6:25and you're able to really see how systems
- 6:27come together
- 6:28across multiple pairs.
- 6:30That always fascinated me, and that really led
- 6:33me wanting to pursue an MBA and to
- 6:35to lead and support others,
- 6:37to make the work better for our patients.
- 6:40That's fantastic. And and what a beautiful story,
- 6:43what led you to medicine. I I I
- 6:45thank you so much.
- 6:47Fantastic.
- 6:49Talk for a second about,
- 6:51doctor Dhingra, what are you most focused on
- 6:54and excited about
- 6:55this year?
- 6:57Well, there's a lot happening in health care.
- 6:59You know, I I recently had an opportunity
- 7:00to attend the JPMorgan Healthcare Conference, and, you
- 7:03know, there's there's a lot of focus
- 7:05certainly on the cost of health care. And,
- 7:07you know, whether that's looking at
- 7:10you know, the the CMS is looking at
- 7:11how to eliminate fraud, waste, and abuse such
- 7:13that it improves the the cost of care,
- 7:16the total total spend in our on our
- 7:17GP.
- 7:19Obviously, GLP ones are still continuing to be
- 7:22an area of focus given the cost of
- 7:24pharmaceuticals,
- 7:25but the great potential that they have is,
- 7:27improving chronic disease.
- 7:29And then this other piece that I think
- 7:31all of us are talking about in any
- 7:33industry, including my own kids all the time
- 7:35is artificial intelligence
- 7:37and how is that gonna show up. And
- 7:38I recently
- 7:39read a read a book that described artificial
- 7:42intelligence,
- 7:43as almost like electricity.
- 7:46We didn't quite know what it was
- 7:48when when it came out, but then soon
- 7:50it became something that
- 7:52all of us relied on all the time.
- 7:54And so there's so much that health care
- 7:56is learning with this evolution of of AI.
- 7:58What I'm excited about
- 8:00is that
- 8:01I think our practice is gonna look different
- 8:04in just a few years. And I think
- 8:05that patients are gonna receive better care because
- 8:08we're gonna have richer
- 8:10information,
- 8:11more nuance that is gonna be supported because
- 8:14it's hard to be a clinician.
- 8:16You have so many pressures on you,
- 8:18and,
- 8:19technology has such an amazing potential to to
- 8:22help us. An area that I'm I'm very
- 8:24proud of is, the in the Permanente Medical
- 8:26Group, our CEO, doctor Maria Ansari,
- 8:29she had the prescience to unleash
- 8:31ambient listening technology
- 8:33to all 10,000 of our physicians in Northern
- 8:36California,
- 8:37and the uptake has been amazing.
- 8:39We're able to now
- 8:41chart more effectively,
- 8:43more quickly,
- 8:44and accurately in a way that allows us
- 8:46to spend more time with our patients.
- 8:48So that's an example of an application. Many
- 8:50of you have heard of these these technologies,
- 8:52and more are coming. And that's what excites
- 8:54me is to make it easier to do
- 8:56the right thing.
- 8:58Talk for a second about
- 9:00technology,
- 9:01doctors.
- 9:02You started a few minutes ago
- 9:04with some of the challenges in oncology,
- 9:07or or your your your mom's
- 9:10breast cancer.
- 9:11Talk for a second about, if if you
- 9:13don't mind, about oncology and information overload and
- 9:16AI,
- 9:17because it seems like oncologists in our country
- 9:18with the aging population are just overwhelmed.
- 9:21They have information overload.
- 9:23At what point will that turn a corner
- 9:26to where AI is really helpful to oncologist
- 9:29versus just right now, people sort of feeling
- 9:31like oncologist, particularly specialist, oncologist just overwhelmed.
- 9:35Any thoughts there? And I know it's
- 9:37a not planned question and a little bit
- 9:39off base, but I'm curious to your thoughts
- 9:41on this AI versus oncology. And AI in
- 9:42some specials where you see this evolution.
- 9:46You know, our our oncologists,
- 9:48are doing heroic work. They are constantly
- 9:51reacting to changes in data,
- 9:54changes in the science, the the new peer
- 9:55reviewed articles that come out almost all on
- 9:57a daily basis.
- 9:59Or, you know, another way is to think
- 10:01about off label
- 10:03therapeutics that can really improve,
- 10:05cancer care.
- 10:07And they need to sift through this information
- 10:09on a daily basis. When I speak to
- 10:11my oncology department and my chief,
- 10:13you know, he is talking about how there's
- 10:16there is this information overload.
- 10:18Yet
- 10:19there are systems that are out there that
- 10:21can really look at multiple nodes of care.
- 10:23So whether it's care here in Northern California
- 10:26or or care across the country about where
- 10:29those best practices live,
- 10:31how we can pull all that information together,
- 10:33and put it at the fingertips of an
- 10:35oncologist so she can make quick and rapid
- 10:37decision for our patients.
- 10:39At Kaiser Permanente, you know, we have one
- 10:41of the largest oncology groups in the country.
- 10:43And, one thing that we're very proud of
- 10:45is that we bring in multidisciplinary
- 10:48teams, whether it's oncologists or surgeons or radiologists,
- 10:52and
- 10:53look to make the most effective decision
- 10:55that's personalized.
- 10:57And that's the potential that we have with
- 10:58artificial intelligence as well is we can personalize
- 11:02care much like we're doing with many of
- 11:04the precision medicine to have the right treatment
- 11:07that that you may need,
- 11:09but also do it in a much quicker
- 11:11way. Reducing that cycle time
- 11:14from diagnosis to treatment
- 11:17to recovery
- 11:18is critical, especially in cancer care. And what
- 11:20that will do for us is it'll improve
- 11:22health span for for our patients.
- 11:25Thank you very, very much. And and and
- 11:27and take a moment, sort of trends you're
- 11:30watching right now, when talked about technology some,
- 11:34you you talked about the, you know, your
- 11:36most multicultural
- 11:37area,
- 11:39obviously, shortages of doctors.
- 11:41What are some of the trends that you're
- 11:42watching currently that you're most focused on, doctor
- 11:45Dhingra? So, Scott, I'm thinking about our workforce
- 11:48all of the time. And, you know, I
- 11:50think one of the benefits of of being
- 11:52a clinical leader is
- 11:54you get to
- 11:55see and experience
- 11:57what our people are experiencing
- 12:00twenty four hours a day
- 12:01and then have the privilege of understanding those
- 12:04issues and putting in systems that that make
- 12:06you successful.
- 12:07And so I I think about our 800
- 12:09physicians.
- 12:10I think about our over 3,000 staff here
- 12:13and the work that they do. And
- 12:16I I think about you know, we talked
- 12:18about the complexity of of being a clinician
- 12:20in this day and age and the requirements,
- 12:23and the potential of the technology.
- 12:25And so what I what I think a
- 12:26lot about is this is how do we
- 12:28make that work more seamless, more easy? How
- 12:30do we reduce waste
- 12:32that doesn't add value to the patient's journey?
- 12:35And I and I think there's a lot
- 12:36of potential certainly in artificial intelligence, but I
- 12:38also think there's a there's a human component
- 12:40that I wanted to spend a little bit
- 12:42of time on, which is the power of
- 12:44listening.
- 12:45Ultimately,
- 12:45you know, as as health care leaders, we
- 12:47have lots of great ideas, we have experience,
- 12:50But truly, to get to the most effective
- 12:52solution, you have to listen.
- 12:53You have to constantly be listening to to
- 12:55your people,
- 12:56what their ideas are,
- 12:58and and really, they're gonna provide the breakthrough
- 13:01performance for us to be successful. I always
- 13:03say our people point us in the direction
- 13:04we need to go. Our job is to
- 13:06make the pathway smoother.
- 13:08Thank you. And and and doctor Dingle, let
- 13:10me ask you this question. You had mentioned
- 13:12the first name is Capelle, like like David
- 13:14Chappell, but Capelle
- 13:16and and so I guess the question for
- 13:18you is,
- 13:20is he funnier than you, or do you
- 13:22win that that that award?
- 13:24So I I would say that it depends
- 13:27on who you ask. If you ask my
- 13:28kids, they would say Dave Chappelle's a lot
- 13:30funnier because my dad jokes to hold the
- 13:32candles.
- 13:33But, yes, it's, my name does rhyme with
- 13:36Dave Chappelle.
- 13:37You're so fantastic.
- 13:39And and and talk a little bit about
- 13:41you've had this great career, emergency physician by
- 13:44background,
- 13:45and then physician in chief, leadership career. What
- 13:48was the transition like from straight practice to
- 13:51to transitioning to leadership and practice? Talk about
- 13:54that for a moment.
- 13:56So, Scott, you know, in the Permanente Medical
- 13:59Group, we are a physician led and physician
- 14:01owned medical group. Our CEO
- 14:03is is a physician. We have a a
- 14:05board of directors
- 14:07that are physician led that partners closely with
- 14:09our our Kaiser Foundation Hospital and Health Plan.
- 14:13And one thing that is in that attracted
- 14:15me to this this opportunity because, you know,
- 14:17you you come out of residency and there's
- 14:19so many choices. You could be in an
- 14:21academic practice. You could be in a in
- 14:23a large integrated health care system like ours.
- 14:26You could go into a smaller private practice.
- 14:28But But one of the things that attracted
- 14:30me to the permanent medical group was mentorship.
- 14:33I really appreciated the ability
- 14:36to be around,
- 14:37physician leaders that were passionate,
- 14:39supported by administrative leaders who saw the mission
- 14:43of what value based care is that, you
- 14:45know, we were real our incentives are truly
- 14:47aligned around improving outcomes because everything else falls
- 14:51the derivative from that, including finance.
- 14:53And so when I when I think about
- 14:55that in my journey,
- 14:57you know, one thing that I still feel
- 14:59strongly about is maintaining my clinical practice. Now
- 15:01it is smaller than when I first started
- 15:03as a new emergency physician,
- 15:05yet what it what it again does is
- 15:07it it strengthens your leadership. And the transition
- 15:10initially was challenging in that, you know, you're
- 15:12trying to balance, really two full time jobs.
- 15:15But over time, you realize that your clinical
- 15:18role really supports your leadership practice.
- 15:20And,
- 15:21I still enjoy seeing patients. It it brings
- 15:23me a lot of joy, and a lot
- 15:25of times I get less text messages than
- 15:26I might get when I'm seeing my seeing
- 15:29patients.
- 15:30But it but it really is a joy
- 15:31and really what drew me into medicine in
- 15:33the first place.
- 15:35Thank you very, very much. No. I I
- 15:37absolutely love that.
- 15:40Thank you. Any advice to emerging leaders wanting
- 15:42to have impactful careers?
- 15:45Yeah. I would say there's probably two things
- 15:47that that I think of.
- 15:49The first thing is is is
- 15:51surround yourself with mentors
- 15:53and start asking the question of who are
- 15:55my mentors
- 15:56because,
- 15:57whether those are people that you work shoulder
- 16:00to shoulder with or maybe those are outside
- 16:03of your practice or your discipline is is
- 16:05really having that feedback loop and circle. Because
- 16:08as you ascend in leadership, it can sometimes
- 16:10feel lonely. And you may not always get
- 16:12that feedback that's important for you to be
- 16:14a better person, be a better leader. But
- 16:16when you when you create that mentorship
- 16:18circle and you get to know people across
- 16:20health care,
- 16:21you really get the feedback that helps you
- 16:23be, frankly, a better person too.
- 16:25The other advice I give,
- 16:27emergent leaders is
- 16:29the power of yes. Consider saying yes,
- 16:32and particularly say yes when you're not sure
- 16:35of yourself.
- 16:36Oftentimes, when I approach an emerging leader and
- 16:38I I have a project or an idea
- 16:40or a need,
- 16:42and they they you know, we've all been
- 16:44there. I've been there before experiencing that sense
- 16:46of imposter syndrome. Am I good enough to
- 16:48do this this big audacious task I was
- 16:50asked?
- 16:51Well, oftentimes,
- 16:52you are because that's why someone asked. And
- 16:55it's taking that leap of faith and learning
- 16:57and understanding that it may not go as
- 16:59well as you planned. You might fail at
- 17:01it, but, ultimately, you're gonna grow through that.
- 17:03And so my my two piece of advice
- 17:05to get mentors,
- 17:06just say yes.
- 17:08No. I I I love that. And there's
- 17:10this great concept, particularly as you're evolving your
- 17:12career,
- 17:13to constantly say yes to new experiences, new
- 17:15opportunities, and not be secured to. I mean,
- 17:17you almost have to stretch yourself to grow
- 17:19and figure out what you're gonna be great
- 17:20at, what you're gonna love. And then at
- 17:22some point in your career, you have to
- 17:23learn to say no too. But I think
- 17:25this concept, you know, it's it's probably not
- 17:27till you're 50 that you start to say
- 17:28no all the time and much or that
- 17:30that's the right timing or date. But but
- 17:31I think saying yes to opportunities,
- 17:33not being scared of them, and you're as
- 17:35good as anybody else, do it and try
- 17:37it and go for it. You know? And
- 17:39and if it doesn't go great, you move
- 17:41on to the next thing that you love.
- 17:42But I think that advice
- 17:44is such important advice, and it gets so
- 17:46mixed in the busy world today where people
- 17:48are taught so much. Oh, you gotta say
- 17:50no. You gotta protect your time. You gotta
- 17:51do this. You gotta do that. And I
- 17:52think that's saying yes. Most of us got
- 17:54to where we got to prevent success. And
- 17:56being an emergency physician, being a physician in
- 17:58chief,
- 17:59you teach at Berkeley. By ultimately saying yes
- 18:02to opportunities,
- 18:03and not viewing yourself as so closed off
- 18:05that you can't take on those opportunities,
- 18:07and I think it's great, great advice. Doctor
- 18:09Dhingra, thank you so much.
- 18:11Thanks, Scott. And I I appreciate the opportunity
- 18:13to to to be with Becker's. And,
- 18:16really, I I do think this is such
- 18:18an amazing forum that you all have created
- 18:20because you get to hear from health care
- 18:21leaders across the country
- 18:23that offer such amazing perspectives and grow the
- 18:26grow the health of this entire community.
- 18:29Well well well, thank you. It's amazing to
- 18:30me to watch over the thirty four years
- 18:33I've been doing this, the evolution
- 18:35of Kaiser Permanente into the quality that Kaiser
- 18:38brings to the health care to the health
- 18:40care world. Just literally amazing culture that's been
- 18:42developed there. So, thank you for taking the
- 18:44time to join us, and share your experiences
- 18:47and share your experience with Kaiser. I think
- 18:48you've been at Kaiser for fifteen, twenty years
- 18:49now. Right?
- 18:50That's correct. That's correct. Actually, my, little little
- 18:53story on that is,
- 18:54as a my professional career as an attending
- 18:56physician and physician leader is is just over
- 18:59sixteen years.
- 19:00I actually trained at a joint Kaiser Permanente
- 19:03and academic program at UC Davis.
- 19:06And when I was a college student at
- 19:08UC Berkeley,
- 19:10my first part time job was working at
- 19:12the Permanente Medical Group where I supported
- 19:14access and service assessment in the econometrics department.
- 19:18And so I've been
- 19:20fortunate, like you said, to be part of
- 19:22an organization that has a rich history
- 19:24over over seventy five years of mission driven
- 19:27value based care.
- 19:28And, you know, we've had our ups and
- 19:30our downs, but what's been consistent, what keeps
- 19:33me here,
- 19:34why my own family and friends get care
- 19:36at Kaiser Permanente is our mission. We truly
- 19:39care about our patients and the communities we
- 19:41serve.
- 19:42Thank you so much. And and, doctor Dhingra,
- 19:44what a pleasure to visit with you and
- 19:46and tell the kids you're funnier than Dave
- 19:48Chappelle. I don't I don't take it. I
- 19:49don't I don't believe it. Thank you so
- 19:51much. Thanks, Scott.