Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Supreme Court Orders Trial Courts To Use Electronic Recording When No Court Reporter Is Available
Transcript
- 0:03Hello. Welcome to Supreme Court Orders, Trial
- 0:07Courts to Use, Electronic Recording when No Court
- 0:10Reporter is Available. I'm Lori Krip -Martin,
- 0:13Certified Family Law Specialist and former Vice
- 0:15Chair. of the BHBA's litigation section. I'm
- 0:19delighted to introduce our speakers, judges Lawrence
- 0:22P. Riff and Ferdows F. Doherty, as well as Alphonse
- 0:26Provenziano. Judge Lawrence P. Riff, supervising
- 0:30judge of civil Los Angeles Superior Court. Judge
- 0:34Riff was appointed to the Los Angeles Superior
- 0:36Court in 2015. His civil assignments have included
- 0:40complex civil, individual courts and dedicated
- 0:44trial court. He's also served in the Family Law
- 0:47Division as supervising judge, a dedicated trial
- 0:50court and a home court. Before judicial service,
- 0:54Judge Riff was a partner of the international
- 0:56law firm Steptoe and Johnson LLP, where he served
- 1:00as the firm's managing partner for its LA office
- 1:03for 17 years and practice group leader for the
- 1:06firm's U .S. Toxic Tort and Environmental Litigation
- 1:11Practice Group. Judge Ferdows F. Doherty is a
- 1:15former trial chief of the Federal Public Defender
- 1:18for the Central District of California. FPD -CDCA,
- 1:24and he was appointed to the Los Angeles Superior
- 1:26Court bench by Governor Edmund G. Brown Jr. in
- 1:31December 2016. Judge Doherty was sworn in by
- 1:35his former federal public defender, Maria Stranton,
- 1:40in January 2017. Judge Doherty spent 14 years
- 1:45with the federal public defender's office, starting
- 1:49as a deputy federal public defender and ending
- 1:51his career as a chief of the Los Angeles office
- 1:55trial unit. Alphonse Provenziano is a board member
- 1:58of the Los Angeles County Family Law Executive
- 2:03Committee. He is also the founder of Provinciano
- 2:06and Associates, which focuses on all aspects
- 2:09of family law, including divorce and child custody
- 2:12disputes, domestic violence and restraining orders,
- 2:15grandparents' rights, prenuptial agreements,
- 2:17and family manners involving celebrities and
- 2:20other high net worth individuals. A longtime
- 2:23Los Angeles -based family law attorney, Mr. Provinciano,
- 2:26is sought after for his years of experience navigating
- 2:29high stick stakes, divorces, as well as comprehensive
- 2:33knowledge of nuanced and complex financial matters.
- 2:37And now let's get started with today's program.
- 2:41Thanks a lot, Lori. And it's such a pleasure
- 2:43to be here with Judge Doherty and Judge Riff.
- 2:46Thank you so much for your time and being here
- 2:48and talking about the new world that we're about
- 2:53to enter into with Family Violence Appellate
- 2:55Project versus Superior Court. I thought What
- 2:59would be nice as the panelists and the moderator
- 3:03is if Judge Riff, if you could talk to us a little
- 3:07bit first about how we got here originally with
- 3:10the LA Superior Court general orders and a little
- 3:14bit of the background and history into making
- 3:17that. I'd be happy to. And Al, thank you for
- 3:21inviting us. Beverly Hills Barr, nice to see
- 3:24you all again. So. We need to turn back the hands
- 3:29of time a little bit several years to a time
- 3:33when our presiding judge Judge Eric Taylor at
- 3:38the time Reached the very unhappy conclusion
- 3:44that we did not have enough court -employed CSRs
- 3:48to continue to keep court reporters in family
- 3:55law and in probate. They had long ago been removed
- 3:59from civil. A consequence of that, apparent to
- 4:04everybody at the time, was that there would be
- 4:09no verbatim record of what was occurring in these
- 4:14hearings, tens of thousands of them, hundreds
- 4:17of thousands of them. It was also apparent to
- 4:24anybody who had been around the courthouse for
- 4:27very long, that there was an available technology
- 4:30that could address this problem, and that is
- 4:33electronic recording. Electronic recording had
- 4:36for a very long time been permitted under law
- 4:41in many of our courtrooms in limited civil, so
- 4:48small claims, unlawful detainers. and in misdemeanors.
- 4:55But on account of a government code section,
- 4:5869557. Did I have that right, Judge Doherty,
- 5:0269557? Yes. Yes. Thank you. Which we will be
- 5:08talking about in a moment. We could not use electronic
- 5:12recording in unlimited civil, in family, or probate.
- 5:21That was a real problem. The court under the
- 5:25leadership of then supervising, I'm sorry, presiding
- 5:28judge Samantha Jessner and our CEO, David Slayton,
- 5:34we looked at all kinds of options. What could
- 5:37we do? And the thing that we wanted to do that
- 5:40seemed the wisest. and most efficient would be
- 5:46to get the legislature to amend 69957 to permit
- 5:51electronic recording in at least some circumstances,
- 5:54if not all. And we, working with the bar people,
- 6:00probably listening to this very webinar, participated
- 6:05in a lobbying effort. And the long and the short
- 6:09of it is even though a bill was drafted and considered,
- 6:15it died in committee, and the legislature adjourned
- 6:20with this terrible problem still existing. Now
- 6:25at that point, Judge Jessner made a very courageous
- 6:29decision. And if I can be permitted the editorial,
- 6:33Al, it was maybe the most courageous decision
- 6:35I've seen. in a very long time by any judge because
- 6:44I second that editorial. What Judge Jeffries
- 6:48decided was that it was intolerable that we would
- 6:53have tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands
- 6:56of hearings with no verbatim record and accordingly,
- 7:00essentially no right of review. In matters including
- 7:05in family law, we're very substantial. issues
- 7:10were being decided, people's lives were being
- 7:13affected, and we judges are very good at what
- 7:16we do. But I must tell you, even if we get it
- 7:19wrong, half a percent of the time, even if we're
- 7:22batting 99 .5, when you have hundreds of thousands
- 7:25of hearings, that's still a meaningful error
- 7:29rate. And there's a reason the Court of Appeal
- 7:31exists. So Judge Jessner put together a group
- 7:37and I was a principal member of that group to
- 7:40see what we could come up with. And we came up
- 7:43with a legal theory where we concluded that based
- 7:49on essentially the 14th Amendment to the U .S.
- 7:53Constitution and like provisions in the California
- 7:57Constitution, there was a constitutional denial
- 8:02of equal protection and or due process occurring,
- 8:06at least in circumstances where liberty interests
- 8:11and fundamental rights were involved. We came
- 8:18up with a general order which operated as follows.
- 8:24The general order signed by the presiding judge
- 8:28directed the CEO, the clerk of court, the clerk
- 8:31of court, David Slayton, he wears two hats, CEO
- 8:35and clerk of court. directed Mr. Slayton to direct
- 8:40the judicial assistants in the courtrooms to
- 8:44turn on the electronic recording equipment when
- 8:49the judge said to do so. And then in that general
- 8:55order, we set out some parameters under which
- 9:00a judge could decide for himself or herself.
- 9:06that the electronic recording should be turned
- 9:09on on account of a constitutional interest needing
- 9:17to be protected. The upshot was that for certain
- 9:25kinds of hearings, principally in family law,
- 9:28much more so than in civil, but also in probate
- 9:32involving conservatorships, judges now had the
- 9:37liberty, as it were, to order the electronic
- 9:40recording turned on. And the government code
- 9:45statute was abrogated to that extent, sort of
- 9:51pro tanto. And that was the state of the world
- 9:54until the Family Violence Appellate Project sued
- 9:58us. And I'll turn that back over to you at this
- 10:02point. Thank you, Judge Riff. It always starts
- 10:07good for a lawyer when we start with a lawsuit.
- 10:11So just to kind of take us where we're at. And
- 10:16so now we have. a really, I think, a great case.
- 10:21And I know that the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 10:23in the past had actually endorsed legislative
- 10:26change, suggesting that government code section
- 10:3069957 should be changed to allow electronic recording
- 10:35in family law and other disputes due to this
- 10:39huge shortage. Now, Family Violence Appellate
- 10:43Project versus Superior Court is an interesting
- 10:45case. It's a 35 -page case. I think everybody
- 10:49should take the time to really read through it,
- 10:51because it really walks through a lot of really
- 10:55substantive issues that are quite fascinating.
- 10:58But for the practitioner, what is the sort of
- 11:02key takeaway from Family Violence Appellate Project,
- 11:05or FVAP, as I think it's going to start to be
- 11:08very much uniformly called to save us all a lot
- 11:12of time when we're in court. This is a writ of
- 11:15mandate case from August 10th of 2026. And the
- 11:21major issue that FVAP takes on is essentially
- 11:25it deals with Can a court imply an indigency
- 11:31exception to a statute that facially bars recording
- 11:36in family law cases, probate, unlimited civil
- 11:40cases? And that statute that it's talking about
- 11:42is government code 69957A. So you can, in fact,
- 11:48record. in limited civil misdemeanor and infraction
- 11:52cases, and based on the general order of LA Superior
- 11:56Court, and I've done this in my practice even,
- 11:59you can ask if a substantial right is going to
- 12:03be adjudicated to have the recordings turned
- 12:07on, but it's not blanket. to go through a very
- 12:12long history, procedural history that the Supreme
- 12:18Court goes through, it basically looks at a case
- 12:20called Jameson. And back in 2018, Jameson basically
- 12:27held that if you're going to allow private reporters
- 12:32in a case, the court then has to have a fee waiver
- 12:36exception that ensures that a court reporter
- 12:39can be available for a verbatim record. Well,
- 12:44what the court notes, and it goes through an
- 12:46extensive amount of statistics and history, is
- 12:49it notes that really, unfortunately, that's just
- 12:52not happening in the superior courts that it
- 12:54was analyzing. So someone submits the fee waiver
- 12:58request for the court reporter, asks to have
- 13:00a court reporter scheduled, and then unfortunately,
- 13:06no court reporter is able to fulfill that role.
- 13:11So effectively, the court is not able to... effectively
- 13:18deliver a court reporter when an exception has
- 13:21happened. But here's really the interesting thing.
- 13:25It goes through an analysis of what it means
- 13:27to come to court in form of papyrus and what
- 13:30an indigent person is. And I think the real magic,
- 13:36if you will, of FFAP is in footnote three. And
- 13:40I think everybody from law school knows when
- 13:42you're reading a Supreme Court case, read the
- 13:45footnotes. And so footnote three is really where
- 13:49I think we're going to see a lot of discussion
- 13:53in courts going forward in the future. And so
- 13:56everybody should really save that passage in
- 14:00your practice and how you're going to use it.
- 14:02But basically, The first sentence is really important.
- 14:08Although our discussion primarily refers to indigent
- 14:11litigants, we do not suggest some absolute standard
- 14:15of indigency. What FVAP does is it says, if you
- 14:23tried to get a court reporter or if you've been
- 14:26unable to get a court reporter because the barrier
- 14:29is so high for a court reporter, that we're going
- 14:33to imply that you're indigent and that you have
- 14:39an informal papyrus right. to a court reporter.
- 14:44And that's kind of really where the advocacy
- 14:46comes into play, because it's not an automatic.
- 14:50The government code is still the law of the land.
- 14:53But if you essentially have a litigant that doesn't
- 14:57have the ability to get a court reporter there,
- 14:58even if they're someone that has means, the FVAP
- 15:04case basically overrides the government code,
- 15:07and it has an implied standard of informal policy.
- 15:11that's expanded to basically all litigants, not
- 15:14just family law litigants, but probate litigants,
- 15:17civil litigants, that will then allow for the
- 15:21court to make potentially certain findings that
- 15:24then would trigger the court to turn on the electronic
- 15:29recording information and to be able to create
- 15:34a transcript. And it goes into why they're doing
- 15:36this, that a settled statement is really not
- 15:38something that can really be suitable and help
- 15:42a party that the issues are too complex. As Judge
- 15:46Riff mentioned, the hundreds of thousands of
- 15:49litigants that are out there without a record,
- 15:52the court is not essentially able to administratively
- 15:56ensure that it's exercising its duty to the litigants
- 16:01to create a record. What we wanted to do is talk
- 16:06a little bit about first and very lucky to have
- 16:10Judge Doherty here, who's our assistant supervising
- 16:14judge for family law. And we were kind of wanting
- 16:19to understand, I think, as many of the practitioners
- 16:21on sitting in. And I think we have a substantial
- 16:27number of participants today. What should we
- 16:30expect in in family court, Judge Doherty, is
- 16:34this an automatic or is it more nuanced than
- 16:40that? Good afternoon, everyone. Thank you for
- 16:43having me. Can I just touch on two things, Mr.
- 16:48Provenziano, before we jump into that question?
- 16:51Yes, of course. That would be really important.
- 16:54One, that you mentioned that this was a writ
- 16:56of mandate. So I just want to kind of bring in
- 17:01what that means. So under the California constitution,
- 17:05in article six, section 10, the court notes that
- 17:08it can exercise jurisdiction in cases in which
- 17:12the issues presented are of such great public
- 17:16importance and must be resolved promptly. So
- 17:19this is an original jurisdiction case in the
- 17:23California Supreme Court. We don't see too many
- 17:25of those. So I thought its procedural posture
- 17:28is important to note. And the other was the issue
- 17:32that Judge Riff mentioned with respect to under
- 17:36the general order when we could turn on the recording
- 17:39equipment after making certain findings. It was
- 17:43an as applied challenge to the statute in terms
- 17:47of its constitutionality. That brings me back
- 17:51to the issue of FVAP, which at its core is a
- 17:56separation of powers. decision, because it discusses
- 17:59the issue of what the court's central function
- 18:03is and how the Constitution of California divides
- 18:07power between the branches. And when one branch
- 18:11does something to usurp the power of the other
- 18:14branch, it's important to make sure that that
- 18:17power is adjusted as per the Constitution. And
- 18:23that's really what FVAP is doing. So now with
- 18:26that kind of backdrop going into your question,
- 18:29what does this mean? Does it automatic or is
- 18:33it not? Well, the decision tells us that where
- 18:38someone would seem to want, we have a ministerial
- 18:43duty and obligation to ensure that there is a
- 18:47verbatim record. So I have I can't speak for
- 18:51the all bench officers, but the understanding
- 18:54of the decision should be that to fulfill that
- 18:57function, there should be a questioning of whether
- 19:01or not someone in a proceeding in any proceeding
- 19:04under the general order, the specifics of the
- 19:07proceeding. were ones that implicated certain
- 19:11fundamental rights. But now, after the decision,
- 19:15in any proceeding, someone is entitled to have
- 19:18a verbatim record. If they are indigent in the
- 19:22broad sense of footnote three, meaning they can't
- 19:26afford to have a court reporter, then the court
- 19:29has a obligation under FVAP to if a electronic
- 19:36or alternative means of providing a verbatim
- 19:39record is available to do so. And so to the extent
- 19:43that most of the courtrooms, I think I believe
- 19:46all of the courtrooms in the family law division
- 19:48are equipped with electronic recording. If you
- 19:51were appearing in a family law proceeding and
- 19:55there was no court reporter, whether the bench
- 19:58officer asks you or you for your client wish
- 20:01to have a verbatim record, I strongly urge all
- 20:05advocates to ask for one because without it you
- 20:09may not have a verbatim record of the proceeding
- 20:11and I've really never encountered a situation
- 20:14where someone goes no no we prefer not to have
- 20:17a verbatim record in case the bench officer makes
- 20:20a mistake or in case opposing counsel says something
- 20:23that should be preserved. So it's pretty automatic,
- 20:28in my experience, that most people want to have
- 20:31a verbatim record. And the question then becomes,
- 20:34is the broader definition of the indigency that's
- 20:41described in footnote three. And it's just as
- 20:45sort of a practice, kind of a pointer for attorneys.
- 20:50Is it Is it something that my thought may be
- 20:54a best practice for people in family law might
- 20:57be to put something in their declarations that
- 21:00they're submitting for their RFOs or a pleading
- 21:02saying, you know, my client is requesting an
- 21:07electronic recording and create the record. Is
- 21:12it something in terms of the rollout in family
- 21:15law? Is this something that every practitioner
- 21:17has to be aware of? present at the beginning
- 21:20of the hearing if a court reporter isn't present?
- 21:25I think it couldn't hurt to include it. But let's
- 21:28assume for a second that you included it in your
- 21:31brief. And it's a busy calendar, and the bench
- 21:34officer calls your case fourth, and there's four
- 21:37cases after yours. And for some reason, it hasn't
- 21:42been turned on in the first three. And then all
- 21:46of a sudden, you've included this. Maybe they've
- 21:48even made a note for themselves, but they fail
- 21:51to turn it on. I think it's incumbent if that
- 21:54situation arises for counsel to again ensure
- 21:59before their proceeding starts that they would
- 22:01want a verbatim record. Hopefully one, two and
- 22:04three would have done so too, but in case that
- 22:07did happen, to allow to make sure, maybe one,
- 22:11two and three were asking for continuances and
- 22:13they didn't really care to raise the issue, but
- 22:17four has something, even if it's a trial setting
- 22:20conference or something of that nature, that
- 22:22may not be entirely fully substantive to then
- 22:26ensure that there is a verbatim record. So I
- 22:30think it's good to do it if you want in writing,
- 22:32but also to make sure that as your proceeding
- 22:35is being called, that there is a record being
- 22:38made of it. Al, can I add something? Yes, of
- 22:43course. I want to make sure that we haven't buried
- 22:45the lead here. if people are hearing all this
- 22:49for the first time. Judge Doherty said it, but
- 22:53let's just reinforce it. The rule of law of FEAP
- 22:58is that the court now has a ministerial duty
- 23:01to ensure, I think is the word, that under the
- 23:08right conditions, a verbatim record is created,
- 23:12which record may be made by electronic recording.
- 23:17Now, what are the conditions to be satisfied?
- 23:21If you read the four corners of the opinion,
- 23:25one condition is upon request, and the second
- 23:31one is a—how do I put this? Well, the requesting
- 23:40person needs to qualify under the doctrine of
- 23:46Informa Pauperis, IFP, okay? Informa Pauperis.
- 23:50Now this was your point, Al, about footnote three.
- 23:54When lawyers and judges hear words like Informa
- 23:58Pauperis, our minds immediately go to things
- 24:01like fee waivers and indigency and that sort
- 24:06of thing. I mean, people that are really quite
- 24:08impoverished. But I think you are right, Al,
- 24:12that the Supreme Court in footnote three cautioned
- 24:15against such a limited view of what informapauperous
- 24:22means. What it says in footnote three is that
- 24:26the requesting party cannot reasonably afford
- 24:30a court reporter. And I think people could easily
- 24:37form the opinion that people well in the middle
- 24:42class who drive Lexis and have kids in college
- 24:46cannot reasonably afford for this hearing $2
- 24:53,000, $3 ,000, $4 ,000 for a court reporter.
- 24:57So the only other thing I want to say is we were
- 25:01talking about the general order. And I'll just
- 25:05ask Judge Doherty what he thinks. After FEAP,
- 25:10is there anything left of our general order?
- 25:12Does our general order offer anything that FVAP
- 25:17does not offer, in your view? I do, slightly.
- 25:22Because remember, FVAP is not proceeding specific.
- 25:27It almost, in no uncertain terms, says our general
- 25:31order didn't go far enough. So where do I think
- 25:36the general order could still be an issue? Let's
- 25:39assume for a second that you have a situation
- 25:42where parties have been appearing and there has
- 25:45been a court reporter in the courtroom each time
- 25:49and you know on Tuesdays and they always appear
- 25:52on Tuesdays and now they appear again and the
- 25:55parties did not make arrangements to have a private
- 26:00reporter because they reasonably understood that
- 26:03there would be a reporter in the courtroom and
- 26:06it's an urgent proceeding that cannot wait. In
- 26:10that sense, the cons and they can afford a private
- 26:13one. In that sense, the court is put back in
- 26:17the position of having to make a decision based
- 26:21on the constitutionality as applied to the situation
- 26:25to determine whether or not, you know, a electronic
- 26:30recording should be turned on under those circumstances.
- 26:33But like I said, That's a lot of things happening
- 26:37for that to happen. But the court didn't reach
- 26:41the constitutional question because it didn't
- 26:45potentially have to under the facts that came
- 26:48before it. It didn't disturb the constitutional
- 26:51issue otherwise either. So at the same time,
- 26:55I think the constitutional questions remain.
- 26:59And when those arise in the appropriate context,
- 27:02they still could be addressed. Going back to
- 27:04my separation of powers argument, that is the
- 27:07essence of the holding. And it is sort of true,
- 27:10because it's really looking at it more from a
- 27:12ministerial point of view of what the court's
- 27:16duty is. And I guess Judge Geordi and Judge Riff,
- 27:19something that seems nebulous, but for practitioners
- 27:23to understand, and we've kind of talked this
- 27:26out a little bit, but just to discuss it in a
- 27:28little bit more detail, what do you see in terms
- 27:34of a litigation on determining who cannot afford
- 27:38a reporter? For example, are you going to have
- 27:40to file a fee waiver? Or it seems to me that
- 27:44the FVAP holding kind of stretches it to simply
- 27:47say, Basically, it's understandable at almost
- 27:50every level of society if you can't afford a
- 27:53reporter. I know, for example, I had a trial
- 27:55recently that was a five -day trial, and the
- 27:57court reporter cost $25 ,000 for a party. Within
- 28:07the limits that you can discuss it, what can
- 28:09we expect in terms of arguments or how that would
- 28:12be decided at the onset of a hearing? The court's
- 28:15specific to say, you know, there's no absolute
- 28:18standard of indigency that's being put forward.
- 28:22The court goes on to say what Judge Riff just
- 28:25did in terms of the reasonably necessary costs
- 28:27of access to judicial process. And then, you
- 28:31know, in the final sentence, final two sentences
- 28:34of footnote three says, because the costs involved.
- 28:38of hiring a court reporter can be significant.
- 28:41The population of litigants who cannot afford
- 28:44to hire a private court reporter, but who can
- 28:46afford to pay routine fees, costs, may be large,
- 28:50and the court should be flexible in assessing
- 28:52this. So if it is required that a fee waiver
- 28:57be submitted, it would be in violation of what
- 29:00the court has already said, unanimously. the
- 29:08certain diversity of practices among judicial
- 29:11officers, both on the informal paupers piece,
- 29:20the means to afford, and also the request side.
- 29:25Remember, the two conditions in theory, upon
- 29:28request and IFP. I'll just tell you my practice,
- 29:33because I'm in a Civil court, I have hearings
- 29:39all day long. When people show up and there's
- 29:42no reporter, I now say, oh, I see there's no
- 29:47reporter. Would anybody like to have a verbatim
- 29:53record created for the possibility of appellate
- 29:55review? And just like Judge Doherty said, very
- 29:59few people say, no, I insist that there be no
- 30:03record. But what people say is, yeah, sure, great.
- 30:08And then I ask the next question. Well, can your
- 30:12client reasonably afford a core reporter for
- 30:15today's hearing? And I will accept a representation
- 30:20from counsel on that because I think reasonably
- 30:24afford is a very flexible concept and not to
- 30:29overdo this. But look, somebody could be middle
- 30:33class or maybe even upper middle class. And they
- 30:36could be thinking, look, I'm going to have a
- 30:38trial. I'm going to have my dissolution case
- 30:40or my civil jury trial. And I'm going to want
- 30:44a court reporter for that. So I've budgeted $100
- 30:48,000 for that. But for this hearing, this discovery
- 30:53matter, I really can't afford a reporter for
- 30:56that because I'm saving my money for later on.
- 31:01So I think that is a exercise of reason. And
- 31:04if somebody were to explain that to me, that
- 31:08would be good enough for me. And I would go even
- 31:11one step further than what Judge Riff said, because
- 31:14in the family courts, about 70 % of our litigants
- 31:17are self -represented. And when I talk about
- 31:20a verbatim record, transcript, they think they
- 31:24have to buy one. They think that there's a financial
- 31:26obligation. We really have to make it so simple.
- 31:30But I go back to what the Supreme Court said.
- 31:33is we have a ministerial function to protect
- 31:36and preserve and have a verbatim record. And
- 31:40that means that it gives us the opportunity to
- 31:46ensure that the person's rights are safeguarded.
- 31:51And most indigent defendants or petitioners or
- 31:55respondents in this context aren't aware of what
- 31:59the standard of review is when you don't have
- 32:02a record. They're not thinking about what we've
- 32:06been trained to do in this context. And they
- 32:10need protection in terms of their rights with
- 32:14respect to ensuring that if the court makes a
- 32:18mistake or if something happens, that their rights
- 32:21are going to be safeguarded. The court has an
- 32:23obligation to safeguard those. That's what I
- 32:26hear in the decision. And in terms of unrepresented
- 32:31litigants, pro se litigants, and pro pro litigants
- 32:34in family court and civil court, Judge Riff has
- 32:42said, look, I opened my courtroom potentially
- 32:45with, does anyone want a verbatim record? But
- 32:48is there anything, obviously, attorneys and practitioners
- 32:51are aware of FVAP, but it's just one case of
- 32:54many. Is there anything? court -wide that you
- 32:58see happening to make sure that unrepresented
- 33:02parties are at least aware of this or that there's
- 33:04some safeguards for them so that they know, for
- 33:08example, that they can get access to an electronic
- 33:12record. Well, we're all independently elected
- 33:16or appointed constitutional officers. And I think
- 33:20there might be, as Judge Riff suggested, a little
- 33:26bit of diversity of opinion in terms of the literal
- 33:32and the spirit of FVAP in this context. And I
- 33:39think that to the extent that there is, I think
- 33:42you heard both Judge Riff and I suggest that
- 33:45it is illogical not to want a verbatim record.
- 33:50So waiting for a request in that context sometimes
- 33:54may, you know, for someone that may not fully
- 33:58understand it, and to take 20 minutes to try
- 34:01to explain it so that they would then say, of
- 34:03course I want one, makes sense to ask upfront
- 34:07if the obligation is to protect their right to
- 34:10begin with, to protect the rights of all sides
- 34:13in that setting. Picking up on Judge Doherty's
- 34:18point, I know this will shock the listeners out
- 34:21there, but you know the presiding judge of our
- 34:25court is nobody's boss when it comes to how a
- 34:31judicial officer runs his or her courtroom and
- 34:33the supervising judge of civil and the supervising
- 34:37judge of family, we are nobody's boss either.
- 34:41Now we can and do both at the presiding judge
- 34:45level and the supervising judge level, we give
- 34:48some guidance as to what we think are best practices.
- 34:52And our PJ has given some informal guidance to
- 34:58the judicial offices of our court and is very
- 35:01much along the lines of what Judge Doherty has
- 35:05articulated. And I have done the same in the
- 35:09Civil Division. I will tell you, I think as time
- 35:13goes on, and maybe sooner than later, there may
- 35:16be some judicial officers who just decide, you
- 35:21know what, I'm turning it on at the beginning
- 35:22of the day, and I'll turn it off at the end of
- 35:25the day, because I don't have enough time to
- 35:29explain to self -represented litigants why they
- 35:33may want a verbatim record and the difference
- 35:35between a record and a transcript and all that
- 35:37sort of thing. That's a very aggressive reading
- 35:42of FEAP, in my opinion. But I think some judges
- 35:45may be going in that direction. Others, maybe
- 35:49at the other end of the spectrum, will read the
- 35:52opinion. It says, well, upon request. So I think
- 35:56I should wait for somebody to ask. And then there
- 36:00is this broad area in the middle. And so we can't
- 36:05really expect at least Sort of like the general
- 36:08order obviously was issued by the court broadly.
- 36:12At least at this juncture, there's not going
- 36:15to be any policy or forms or anything from the
- 36:20superior court. It's an issue mainly of advocacy
- 36:23on behalf of the litigants and their attorneys
- 36:25in implementing FFAL. I think that's correct
- 36:29in part because as Judge Reff just said, it may
- 36:33be different from courtroom to courtroom at times.
- 36:37So an advocate that is conscious of that and
- 36:42is making sure. that their surroundings ensure
- 36:47for that to happen. Now, the practice has changed
- 36:50dramatically post -COVID. Half the time, most
- 36:54of you may not even be appearing in person, depending
- 36:56on the proceeding. And most of you may not be
- 37:00conscious or care fully, because you're not thinking
- 37:05of the appellate consequences of every single
- 37:08proceeding as opposed to major substantive ones,
- 37:11and may not request it. but I think it makes
- 37:14sense to create in your practice an automatic
- 37:20uh asking and ensuring whether you're when you're
- 37:23in person you'll see it because you know the
- 37:25ftr machines that we have in our courtroom are
- 37:28big digital clocks that are ticking away you
- 37:30might be wondering what that is why you know
- 37:33is the judge timing my argument do we need a
- 37:36big clock of that you know do the clocks on the
- 37:39wall not work um but if you're um you know if
- 37:42you see that you know it's on um and it's and
- 37:45it's going on but if you're appearing remotely
- 37:47it's good to ask upfront and to make sure that
- 37:50that's happening so that there's no ambiguity
- 37:53about that at all. So I do think that this is
- 37:56obviously going to have a huge impact on how
- 37:59judges conduct, you know, their courtrooms, but
- 38:02it's also going to have an equal impact on counsel
- 38:06ensuring because if you are in front of a bench
- 38:09officer, that is going to not have a, that has
- 38:14a very literal, you know, step -by -step analysis
- 38:18of FVAP, then if there's no request, theoretically,
- 38:23there's no reason to turn it on. And so that
- 38:26will then put the onus on council to do so. And
- 38:30Judge Riff, in terms of the civil division, is
- 38:35Do you foresee differences in the implementation?
- 38:38For example, are all the courtrooms set up for
- 38:42electronic recording? And is there differences
- 38:45across the various aspects of the court operations
- 38:50in implementing FVAT? Every courtroom of the
- 38:56Superior Court of Los Angeles County is now equipped
- 38:59with FTR electronic recording equipment, and
- 39:04has been. FTR, by the way, in case somebody's
- 39:07wondering what that is, I think the former name
- 39:10of that company was For the Record. FTR, For
- 39:14the Record. And the reason that the court had
- 39:19that equipment installed in all these courtrooms
- 39:23actually was to assist us relative to our obligations
- 39:30of supervising subordinate judicial officers.
- 39:34There are rules on that. And we're specifically
- 39:37permitted to use electronic recording when so
- 39:43-called subordinate judicial officers are conducting
- 39:46proceedings. And we need the flexibility. We
- 39:50needed the flexibility to be able to move our
- 39:53commissioners and referees anywhere in the system.
- 39:57So that's why we had FTR equipment installed
- 40:02everywhere anyway. So there is no variance in
- 40:09the implementation of FVAP across any of the
- 40:13divisions. And just to kind of show this to our
- 40:21listeners, because I think this is a question
- 40:23that a lot of people have, is, well, how do I
- 40:27How do I even find this on the Superior Court
- 40:32website, or where is it? There's various tabs
- 40:37on the Superior Court website for the record.
- 40:41So there's a specific one that's electronic recordings
- 40:44for appeal that you can seek a request for electronic
- 40:51recordings separately. One simply for a transcript
- 40:55request and you can complete the ordering information
- 41:00at transcripts for reporting and electronic recording.
- 41:06And we've included at the end hyperlinks. And
- 41:09these are all in the materials that are circulated
- 41:11to everybody. And big thanks to Judge Doherty,
- 41:15who put this together. Because I had said to
- 41:17Judge Doherty myself, I've had a few electronically
- 41:19recorded cases. And then I've had a hard time.
- 41:24retrieving the transcript. And I think one question
- 41:27that Daniel Danzinger had, which I think kind
- 41:30of goes to the heart of this, his question, and
- 41:32I already know the answer to that. But I kind
- 41:34of I think a lot of people are thinking about
- 41:35this is, you know, what effect is FFAP on the
- 41:39use of AI capabilities to transcribe? But I think
- 41:42more broadly, Judge Doherty or Judge Riff, can
- 41:45you tell us who's authorized to do the official
- 41:50transcript from the electronic recordings? Well,
- 41:58okay, so let's make sure everybody is using language
- 42:02correctly here because I think it's very easy
- 42:05to make a mistake. Everything we've been talking
- 42:08about and that the Supreme Court is talking about
- 42:10is a verbatim record, okay? Something from which
- 42:16a transcript can be created. Court reporters,
- 42:20you know, take... make a verbatim record in their
- 42:23court reporting machines. FTR, pardon me, makes
- 42:29a verbatim record by electronic recording. Neither
- 42:32of those things automatically become transcripts.
- 42:36To get a transcript is another step. It needs
- 42:39to be requested. And nothing in FVAP, or Jameson
- 42:44for that matter, or our court's general order
- 42:47requires that the court provide a transcript
- 42:55to indigent, informapauperous people. So if you
- 43:02want a transcript, including from FTR, you still
- 43:05have to order it and buy it. Now that said, I
- 43:09do want to say that I believe there is money
- 43:13available for truly indigent fee waiver. folks
- 43:18to obtain a transcript, but that is a separate
- 43:24concept from this ministerial duty to create
- 43:28a verbatim record. Now, there are the people
- 43:34that create a transcript from an FTR verbatim
- 43:39record are, quote, certified transcriptionists.
- 43:44And they're certified, as I appreciate it, by
- 43:47an industry group that has certification standards
- 43:54that are acceptable to the California Court of
- 43:57Appeal and Supreme Court. So those people who
- 44:01create those transcripts will certify it as a
- 44:06certified transcript. So, Al, if you're thinking,
- 44:09well, can anybody just get the, you know, get
- 44:14the recording and, you know, turn on their iPhone
- 44:17and have Siri create a record? Probably not.
- 44:22I don't think the Court of Appeals is going to
- 44:23accept that as a record, as a transcript. Right.
- 44:28I think the thing that practitioners need to
- 44:31know is that the recordings are available as
- 44:33a verbatim record, but it's still going to cost
- 44:36to get a court reporter to do the transcript.
- 44:40Do either of you, in your legal opinion, see
- 44:44a expansive viewpoint of FVAP to say that it
- 44:49includes getting a transcript, or is it something
- 44:51more limited to simply creating the verbatim
- 44:55record? I mean, it expands the informal papyrus
- 45:01doctrine. The extent of its expansion, you know,
- 45:05will be future cases to make that determination.
- 45:09But again, this is where advocacy comes in, and
- 45:13this is where advocates can make their positions
- 45:18known, the courts will make decisions and the
- 45:22courts of appeal and the Supreme Court will make
- 45:24their decisions specific to what happens there.
- 45:28Clearly, the level of expansion of the doctrine
- 45:33in footnote three is eye -catching. Stephanie
- 45:41Bennett had a question that was, in family law
- 45:44matters, would court -appointed minors counsel
- 45:47have standing to request a verbatim request if
- 45:50the self -represented litigants don't or won't?
- 45:56Absolutely. I agree, 100%. And I think that's
- 46:00the idea is more minors counsel is an advocate,
- 46:03obviously, and is not in the format it was before.
- 46:07It was reporting to the court. and maybe acting
- 46:11in a more substantive way as sort of an expert.
- 46:13They're there to advocate for the minor. So in
- 46:17a sense, they're almost a litigant that can then
- 46:20trigger it. And I would imagine if a child asked
- 46:23for a verbatim transcript, that almost every
- 46:26child's going to fall into that verbatim, that
- 46:29informapoparous statute unless they're someone
- 46:31who's very extremely wealthy, trust -fund child.
- 46:35So to me, I think that that would be something
- 46:40that would be a little bit more easy to do as
- 46:44a minors council. So I think the point that you're
- 46:48raising is a perfect example. Assume in family
- 46:51law, and I know many of you may not be family
- 46:52law practitioners, but assume in family law that
- 46:55you have a child that wants to give a preference
- 47:00with respect to custody under family code section
- 47:033042, and they're not represented. is the court
- 47:08going to wait for an upon request in the context
- 47:12of ensuring that that expression be on a verbatim
- 47:18record? Again, some might say, well, that won't
- 47:23even be transcribed, whether it'll be sealed,
- 47:26all of that, but assume that that was going to
- 47:28be transcribed and sealed if it was upon request.
- 47:34Are you going to take time to express to a 14
- 47:38-year -old what a verbatim record is? How much
- 47:40time before they would make that request in that
- 47:44context for being able to express their position?
- 47:48Technically, not a party. So again, these are
- 47:52the things where the ministerial function and
- 47:55how you see it becomes really important. And
- 47:58it would almost be for PPAs, child interviews,
- 48:02almost in that ministerial aspect of FFAP that
- 48:06the court would potentially possibly need to
- 48:08consider making sure that there is a verbatim
- 48:11record, it would seem like. Before you go on,
- 48:17let me return to your transcript versus record
- 48:24point, OK? and where the law is going and all
- 48:28that. So I don't have an opinion on that, but
- 48:31I have an opinion on this. Both in the Jameson
- 48:34case, California Supreme Court, and FVAP, the
- 48:40court did not get anywhere near the proposition
- 48:45of there being a ministerial duty to provide
- 48:48a transcript. It was all about a verbatim record.
- 48:53And here is a fun fact. to know, you know, our
- 48:57court has an appellate division, the appellate
- 49:00division of the Superior Court, which hears appeals
- 49:04from limited civil and certain criminal matters.
- 49:09The judges who hear those cases listen to, they
- 49:16listen to the recording. They don't get a transcript.
- 49:23And I guess there's nothing stopping the Court
- 49:26of Appeal from listening to it as well. And that's
- 49:30a good point. I mean, in a civil case when there's
- 49:32a jury trial at Judge Riff and you have an electronic
- 49:35recording, will the jury, if they ask for a playback
- 49:39and there was no reporter, would they then get
- 49:41a playback from the recording? We have a separate
- 49:46program. protocol i should say for that the answer
- 49:51is yes it's exceedingly awkward but it can be
- 49:57done it's not done in the courtroom it's done
- 50:01elsewhere in the courthouse or in not even necessarily
- 50:06in the courthouse but there is a possibility
- 50:08of a readback from an electronic record just
- 50:15take I would imagine. And Eden Bautista had a
- 50:21question, which was, how long are the verbatim
- 50:24recordings available? And are they deleted after
- 50:27a period of time? I actually don't know the answer
- 50:30to that. Do you, Judge Geordi? I think they are.
- 50:34Again, I don't know if there's a policy specific
- 50:37to that. I just know from what I've heard is
- 50:42that because they're digitally stored, I don't
- 50:45know if they're deleted over time or not. I think
- 50:49that as we're doing more and more electronic
- 50:51recordings, that might change. But again, I presume
- 50:57that the time for an appeal or the time for the
- 51:01relief that's being sought will long run before
- 51:04in that context, then they would be deleted,
- 51:08even if they're kept for a year or longer with
- 51:12respect to the time in which to do so. And I
- 51:15know colloquially a lot of court reporters will
- 51:18say, well, there's a policy that we maintain
- 51:20our records for seven years. And a lot of court
- 51:23reporters will retain them over the long term.
- 51:27They'll keep them indefinitely. A scenario might
- 51:32arise. It happens already, for example, when
- 51:36there's the public court reporter and the private
- 51:39court reporter. They often ask the public court
- 51:42employed. or reporter to stay, and they dismiss
- 51:46the private reporter. I'm just kind of curious
- 51:50to the extent that you can comment on it. If
- 51:52one party did, in fact, hire a private reporter,
- 51:56but another party is an indigent, for some reason
- 51:58they would ask for an electronic recording, is
- 52:01there any policy or considerations in that situation
- 52:06that would limit an electronic recording to run
- 52:08in parallel? Probably. because FVAP indicates
- 52:14that the court's ministerial function is to ensure
- 52:17a verbatim record. I don't think FVAP gives the
- 52:20court the ability to have multiple alternatives
- 52:23happening simultaneously. So the court's ministerial
- 52:27function is satisfied in that context when there
- 52:31is a verbatim record. So if you have a court
- 52:34reporter, in fact, I mean, that actually probably
- 52:37supports the position of the government code
- 52:39in saying, 69957, why would you then have a second
- 52:46basis when a court reporter is available to turn
- 52:49on the verbatim record? Because as Judge Riff
- 52:52already told us, that the verbatim record is
- 52:55not a transcript and neither is the court reporter's
- 52:59transcription at the time until a transcript
- 53:03is sought and prepared. And Al, as I know you
- 53:08know and probably everybody knows, court reporters
- 53:11under their licensing, they're obligated to offer
- 53:14to all parties the opportunity to obtain a transcript.
- 53:20And it turns out the cost of obtaining that transcript
- 53:25from a CSR's notes versus the FDR, it's not really
- 53:29that different. I'm kind of curious, Judge, obviously
- 53:35we talked a lot about individual entities, and
- 53:39that's what we deal with almost exclusively in
- 53:42family law, except if there's a third party that's
- 53:44joined to the case, like a pension plan or something
- 53:46like that. But in terms of civil cases, is there
- 53:51any differing factors that practitioners should
- 53:55be aware of? For example, if they're on plaintiff's
- 53:58side personal injury or if one of the parties
- 54:01is a large institution to the civil litigation?
- 54:06Well, It's unlikely that I'm going to ask Exxon
- 54:10Mobil Corporation if it can afford a court reporter
- 54:14for the hearing, because I think I know the answer
- 54:17to that. Well, Al, in civil what happens is well
- 54:27-heeled plaintiff's firms, even though their
- 54:31client may be a very modest means. The firm has
- 54:35resources. And if they want a reporter, they're
- 54:38going to bring a reporter. And very often, the
- 54:40defense has plenty of resources, and they bring
- 54:43a reporter. So way more than in family law. I
- 54:51think people show up with reporters. But there's
- 54:56a huge group of cases. where people are of relatively
- 55:01modest means, the amount of controversy is relatively
- 55:05modest, where that will not be the case. So I
- 55:09think judges in civil departments are just looking
- 55:14out to see who's showing up in front of them.
- 55:17What's this case about? And did anybody bring
- 55:20a reporter? And just, I mean, I think that this
- 55:26has obviously a great ability to open up the
- 55:31courts and ensure access to justice and that
- 55:34there's a verbatim record. Judge Doherty, Judge
- 55:38Riff, in terms of the FVAP case and the general
- 55:43order as a trend in this area, how do you view
- 55:47this as a trend within access to justice and
- 55:51ensuring that people have verbatim records? How
- 55:54is that going to affect the future for individual
- 55:57litigants and to the extent that you can talk
- 56:00about it? Well, I think it's a huge victory for
- 56:03justice overall and a huge victory for access
- 56:07to justice for everyone as well in that, you
- 56:11know, the functioning of the courts of appeals
- 56:14in terms of being able to review the trial court
- 56:16generally happens within the four corners of
- 56:19a transcript and a record and here ensuring that
- 56:23that exists, at least in terms of the record,
- 56:27allows for a transcript to be made for meaningful
- 56:30review of what's happening in the trial courts.
- 56:34That protects judges, it protects litigants,
- 56:38it protects lawyers, and it is, I mean, you know,
- 56:44it's consonant with our understanding of justice
- 56:47and jurisprudence in America in terms of going
- 56:50from one level to the next. You know, so for
- 56:54the time that we didn't have, it was concerning
- 56:59for all, and for judges especially, because we
- 57:04are, you know, focused on ensuring the rights
- 57:09of the people that come before us. And when the
- 57:13government code restricts that, it affects our
- 57:17ability to do what our central function is under
- 57:23the Constitution, as I indicated before, with
- 57:25respect to the core functions of each branch.
- 57:29And I agree with that, 100%. So Al, I'm looking
- 57:34at the clock, and I know we're running out of
- 57:36time. But can I address one point that we have
- 57:40not yet touched upon, which is the concern that
- 57:44some people might have that FVAP and our general
- 57:49order is really a design by the powers that be
- 57:54to put court reporters out of business, to eliminate
- 57:58them as employees of our court. And I really
- 58:02want to speak to that. And I think I can speak
- 58:04authoritatively. That is not what's going on
- 58:07here. We are still, this court is still engaged
- 58:11in a huge effort to hire court reporters. We
- 58:17want more of them. We do not want less of them.
- 58:20And I just want to give you a couple of facts
- 58:22and figures if I might. You know, we have roughly
- 58:27520 or so operating courtrooms. This data is
- 58:33from August. But we have 331 court reporters
- 58:38employed by our court out of 522 courtrooms.
- 58:44Of those, 273 are, honest to God, stenographers,
- 58:50CSRs. 58 of them are voice writers, which is
- 58:55a new thing for our court, an old thing in that
- 58:59world. So look. We have tried so hard to hire.
- 59:06So between the third quarter of 2025 and the
- 59:10second quarter of 2026, in that year, we added
- 59:1333 court reporters of whom 26 were voice writers.
- 59:19That's great. During that same period, we lost
- 59:2348 because they retired. So not withstanding
- 59:29everything we're doing, we are still at a deficit
- 59:32and the number of reporters is declining. We
- 59:37are offering a $15 ,000 finders fee. to any court
- 59:42employee who brings us a court reporter. We're
- 59:45offering a $25 ,000 signing bonus to any court
- 59:49reporter we hire. We're offering a $12 ,000 retention
- 59:54bonus for people who will stay with us and not
- 59:57retire. We're offering an additional $10 ,000
- 1:00:01retention bonus for anybody with us more than
- 1:00:0425 years. We're paying up to, we're giving $15
- 1:00:09,000 towards student loans and equipment reimbursement,
- 1:00:14and I could go on. There are other things where
- 1:00:16you're doing to try to hire court reporters.
- 1:00:19So nobody should take from this that our court
- 1:00:22is trying to get out of the court reporter business.
- 1:00:25We are not. It's so amazing too. And I would
- 1:00:29say, I think also for the court to have the central
- 1:00:32hub where we can have court reporters in a remote
- 1:00:35location to decrease the burden on the court
- 1:00:38reporters yet call in and do court reporting,
- 1:00:41I think was a great innovation. And I think that
- 1:00:44may open it up to more people. And it's actually
- 1:00:46very interesting because doing cases elsewhere
- 1:00:49throughout the state, I've seen it in practice
- 1:00:53where you can't actually get a court reporter
- 1:00:56to that location. And basically, it's an unwritten
- 1:00:58rule that if you want a court reporter, that
- 1:01:01you can just have one remotely by stipulation
- 1:01:05and court order, simply because there's just
- 1:01:08no other way to get your verbatim record. Maybe
- 1:01:10FVAP for those kind of remote counties in California
- 1:01:13will open that up. But I think in terms of the
- 1:01:16key takeaways for all the practitioners is, obviously,
- 1:01:20the government code is still the law of the land,
- 1:01:24but you need to thoroughly review the FVAP and
- 1:01:27the general order, and there's times in which
- 1:01:29the general order and FVAP may overlap. but that
- 1:01:33it's an issue of advocacy for everybody in family
- 1:01:37law, probate, civil, for your clients. You've
- 1:01:39got an obligation as an attorney to raise this
- 1:01:42issue for your clients to have a verbatim record.
- 1:01:45And that FTR through our materials is the source
- 1:01:49for you to obtain the verbatim record to then
- 1:01:52get a transcript. I really want to thank Judge
- 1:01:55Doherty and Judge Riff. I know you guys are both
- 1:01:57so busy. Thank you for your preparation, your
- 1:02:00collaboration. and just helping make the bar
- 1:02:03a better and more enlivened place. I think that
- 1:02:06this class will answer so many questions and
- 1:02:08be a resource for practitioners throughout the
- 1:02:12state. Thank you so much for your time. Thank
- 1:02:15you. It was a pleasure. A pleasure as well. See
- 1:02:19you soon. Bye, everybody. Bye.