Latest / Automotive State of The Union / A Little Less Electric, Triple Incentives, The End of Free Shipping
Transcript
- 0:00[funky music] All right. Tuesday, February 20th. It feels like it's almost March.
- 0:05Today, we have Steve Greenfield, uh, on with us today talking about the government being a little less electric, triple incentives, and the end of free shipping maybe. Here I go.
- 0:14The people really know- I don't think it'll be the end... who I is and who I be. They stop and stare- Steve, good morning. Thanks for joining us today... there's no need to repeat. Paul, always nice to be here.
- 0:21Thanks for having me. Oh, it's great. Hey, I just wanna let everybody know before we get into the show that, um, tomorrow we are hosting, um, our next ASOTU Edge webinar. It is a quick shot webinar.
- 0:32That's how we do them, 25 minutes-ish. Uh, it feels a lot more like a conversation. We're gonna be with our friends at Upstart Auto Retail.
- 0:39They're gonna be sharing the results of a 100-dealer survey that they recently did.
- 0:44So, uh, Keishan Betts, head of customer success, is gonna take us through the insights and, um, we're gonna answer some questions, have a little bit of fun.
- 0:50So, you can go to asotu.com, just scroll up a little bit and you'll see that you can sign up for that webinar for free. Have you in and out, and, uh, learn a little something along the way.
- 0:59So, uh, that's where we're gonna go. But, um, Steve, you have places to be today, and, uh, [laughs] so we're just gonna try to get right into the news.
- 1:06Um, but I wanna ask you first, it's been a while, actually, we haven't seen... Did we see each other at NADA? I can't even remember. I don't even think I saw you guys there. I don't think so ei- [laughs] Yeah.
- 1:16I'm just realizing. [laughs] It was a blur. It was a blur. Yeah. [laughs] I, I told everybody I feel like I missed the show. Right. Yeah. Yeah. I missed the show 'cause we were running around so much.
- 1:25But, but what, what was your highlight takeaway from NADA? Um, it was great. I mean, I think, I think dealers are still of- very optimistic. I mean, it's still gonna be a really good year.
- 1:33Probably not quite as much from, from a profitability standpoint. Mm-hmm. But I think dealers are very optimistic and very positive.
- 1:39And, you know, I think the amazing thing, Paul, you know, you know I've talked about this, is like, you know, th- I felt like during COVID the franchise dealer model was under attack, right? Mm-hmm. From various angles.
- 1:49And I think if anything, it's just amazing, uh, after 25 years in this industry to, to just c- continue to see how durable and defensible the franchise dealer model is.
- 1:58And then, you know, now we're seeing VinFast and Fisker and others saying, "Uh, we were gonna sell directly, but we've reconsidered." Yeah. "We're gonna actually resell cars through dealers."
- 2:06And, uh, it's a testament, like this, this, this model works. It's been proven to work for 100 years or more. Mm-hmm. And it w- will continue to work.
- 2:14So, we never wanna rest on our laurel, laurels and stick our head under the sand, right? Right. To mix my metaphors. But at the same time, it's amazing.
- 2:21If, if e- ever there was going to be an attack on the franchise model, it was through OEMs and direct selling during COVID.
- 2:27And, you know, I think the dealers, rightfully so, feel pretty confident now that they have the right model. Uh, it's very profitable, durable, defensible model. Yeah.
- 2:35I mean, that, that's, I think that's good news for everybody, but I think it's, it's, uh, insightful and true.
- 2:40I just imagine, like, every time the ball gets hit over the net, the dealership model just w- you know, smacks it back across. And I- Right. Right...
- 2:48I think, I think of some of the, the challenges that a lot of companies had keeping, uh, like, employees in the building, keeping employees engaged, hiring the right people, and we didn't have that issue at all in automotive.
- 2:59Right. Like, at all. Yeah. Ve- very true. Very, very true. Yeah. I- if, if anything, uh, the opposite, right? Everything before COVID was all around turnover and retention- Right... et cetera. Right.
- 3:08And, uh, you know, at this point, I think partially thanks to what you guys are doing, you know, brick by brick you're laying the foundation to, to ensure that, you know, a future generation of employee knows that this, this is actually a really good industry to get your, your teeth cut in.
- 3:21Mm-hmm. And there are all kinds of upside opportunities in this industry. I think it's a place, too, that I'm, I'm reading a book right now called Full Time by an economist named David Bunson.
- 3:30And, um, he talks about the declining participation rate in the workforce, and he ties that directly to people feeling a sense of purpose and meaning in work.
- 3:39And, um, I think in automotive, like, again, what we're trying to do with More Than Cars is to, to, like, just provide people a pathway to find more meaning in what they do.
- 3:48And I think the automotive industry is just such a clear place that you can bring meaning and value into people's lives that work at dealerships and in the products and services you offer and sell.
- 3:57So, uh, I'm excited about it. Yeah. I, I mean, it's easy to just dismiss the industry and say, "All we're doing is selling cars" It's true... right? Or, "All we're doing is ser- servicing cars."
- 4:06But you think about people need transportation to go to work to feed their families. Mm-hmm. And, you know, th- this is why this business model is so essential to the US economy.
- 4:17But also, it's just so, so defensible because people need transportation to live, and we're providing that as an industry. So it's, it's very important.
- 4:25And if people realize that, they can align with that and feel a great sense of purpose in their day-to-day work. Full agree. Full agree.
- 4:31Well, let's talk about, um, how, how we're gonna deliver that transportation, what it even looks like.
- 4:36It's looking like 2030 might not be as electric as the government once said as the Biden administration is planning to relax its ambitious EV transition goals. Um, and here's why the pace is slowing down.
- 4:48So, the EPA is going to reduce the speed of proposed yearly emissions requirements through 2030, making EVs now, uh, having to require less or occupy less than 60% of total production as opposed to their initial higher target, um, which was a little later, 67% by 2032.
- 5:05So, it's not really an apples to apples, according to the article.
- 5:08Um, automakers, dealers even, get this, were partnering up now with the UAW to argue that EV technology costs and infrastructure development, uh, need some more time, prompting the reevaluation.
- 5:20John Bozzella of the Alliance for Automotive Innovation is emphasizing the importance of allowing the market, supply chains, and public charging infrastructure to develop to support the EV shift.
- 5:30And, and they propose 40 to 50% by 2030 might be even, like, more realistic according to demand. And infrastructure, uh, we have to mention that current production sits at about 8%.
- 5:41So, there, there's a long way to go between 8% and 60%.
- 5:45Uh, what is, what is your feeling on this and just generally the sentiment in market dynamics?Well, look, I mean, it's tough being a politician, and say that in an election year is a, is a lot.
- 5:54[laughs] But, uh, trying to anticipate what consumer demand is actually gonna be- Mm-hmm... with what's, what's, what is right for the environment, because there's a lot of debate around that.
- 6:02Then you've got, you know, the, the, the Chinese element with, you know, most of the minerals are coming out of, uh, out of China for the foreseeable future overall, and you're trying to navigate all of this.
- 6:11And, you know, it'd be great to ma- wave a magic wand and say, "We're gonna go a 100% to electric," and everyone will be happy. The consumer will be happy. We'll have independence from China.
- 6:20You know, both political parties will be happy, et cetera. But, you know, as dealers have written to, to Biden, the demand just isn't there. As you said, we're s- we're hovering around 8%, and it's not growing too much.
- 6:32The, the, the pace of acceleration of growth is slowing down.
- 6:36And, you know, the, the US government, I think, is looking at this and saying, "Okay, well, while, while it might be nice to flip over from ice vehicles to EV, um, it's just like, it's not, not that easy a path."
- 6:46So they're backing off, and we- we'll see how much they back off this year. The big unknown is, you know, it being, uh, an election year, what ha- what happens right after November- Right...
- 6:56uh, depending on who, who's in the White House, and does the IRA actually withstand that, or does it start to get dismantled?
- 7:02And without, you know, consumer-facing tax credits, I do wonder what natural demand is for EVs.
- 7:07You know, there's, uh, in your weekly, um, insights report, if you don't, if you don't get it, go to automotiveventures.com, and you should be on this email list.
- 7:15It's a great, uh, just digest of all the things going on, um, in the industry. You, you posted two articles in there. One is about E- EV incentives, new EV incentives tripling, um, in some cases.
- 7:26So is this just an indicator that, like, consumers don't, don't really want the EVs, and so manufacturers are just trying to s- respond in kind? Well, it's funny you, you, you mentioned that.
- 7:36I w- I was sitting at an AD at a dinner with a BMW store out near San Francisco and, um, you know, h- he sells 40% of new BMW at his store are EVs. Mm. Yet he said, um, "I can't make any front-end gross on, on them."
- 7:51I was like, "That's kind of interesting, so let me reconcile that. So for you, you have demand for EVs in your local market?" He said, "Yes." "But you can't make any profit on them?"
- 7:58He said, "No, I can't make any front-end gross already on EVs despite the demand." And I think that's only gonna get worse, right? So we- we're, we're, what we're seeing is just an oversupply situation.
- 8:08There will be more EVs. There already are. You look at day supply, there are more EVs on the lot than demand.
- 8:13That's gonna get worse, because a lot of these legacy automakers are building new, new models of EVs, and they've already pre-committed to those volumes.
- 8:21So we're gonna see a, a, a oversupply situation that grows over the course of the year, and th- those incentives, which now, yeah, they've tripled, are just gonna get higher.
- 8:29It's gonna be a really good time to buy an EV if you're a consumer. Mm-hmm.
- 8:33But I, I think it's gonna be really challenging for dealers, because they're gonna start looking for OEM support to say, "Look, what are you doing?"
- 8:39We see already that, you know, there's a 60%, um, um, lease penetration o- on EVs. So 60% of all EVs that are non-Teslas are being leased right now because of the loophole in the IRA. Mm-hmm.
- 8:52Um, so, so can a- a- all of those cars get the $7,500 tax incentive, but I think it's gonna be tough to sell despite that, because we're gonna continue to be oversupplied this year. It's interesting.
- 9:02Uh, you also posted another article, um, in that insights report that talks about even California's EV sales dropped substantially in Q4.
- 9:11That's the first time EV sales have dropped in California in a decade, or probably since the, the modern EV era. Um, is that, that just seems like a further indication that, like, everything's slowing down.
- 9:22Interesting that the BMW dealer, 40% of their new car sales are EVs. That's really surprising to me. I didn't expect it. I mean, I guess BMW, um, you know, a, a smaller brand that's been able to lean in heavier.
- 9:33Um, but, but even so, that's very surprising. 40%. Yeah.
- 9:37It's very, very surprising, and if you talk to, like, you know, Mercedes-Benz and BMW dealers, even in softer EV markets, they're still getting forced to take EV inventory- Mm-hmm... uh, even if there isn't demand.
- 9:48So it's g- it's gonna be an interesting year. I'm not gonna say ugly yet. I might say ugly by halfway through the year. Right. But it's gonna be an interesting year, because inventories will mount. We know that.
- 9:57The, the dealers are gonna say, like, "Give me some relief," and the OEMs are gonna have to come in over the top with increasing incentives, and we're gonna see, like, significant incentives for some of these EV models.
- 10:07It's unbelievable to me how difficult it is to find news in the auto industry, 'cause, you know, you and I- [laughs]... every morning, we scour the news. We look at a bunch of different sources.
- 10:17Not just auto stuff, but all the other stuff, and it is near impossible to find one in 10 articles that isn't about EV. Yeah.
- 10:25And- Well, it's amazing, you know, that the articles that I clip every, every week, I'm amazed at how often now these, these dynamics, both EVs and also the, the threat of Chinese- Yes...
- 10:34these are, like, big, big newspapers outside of auto, like New York Times- Absolutely... Washington Post- Reuters. Yeah... LA, LA Times, Reuters, Bloomberg.
- 10:41I mean, they're all covering this stuff now because, yeah, you, you, you can't get away from it.
- 10:45The, the average person on the street is, is reading this because no matter where they consume their news, they're, they're, they're getting this news, and they're reading about EVs and the Chinese threat and all, all, all these dynamics- Mm-hmm...
- 10:56that typically we would be pretty insulated reading ourselves.
- 10:59But, you know, the, the person on the street now, you, you, you get into an Uber and ask the Uber driver, and they have an opinion because they've been reading the same news that we're reading.
- 11:07It's funny that, that, like, the, the conversation about, you know, Chinese EVs and this international trade and, like, the big threat, the, the crazy part about it is, is, like, but it's a product that nobody wants right now.Right?
- 11:20And so it's like this massive hype machine and this, like, impending doom over something that consumers are like, "We don't wanna buy those."
- 11:28So, I mean, it'll be interesting to see how this plays out this year, but yes, it is definitely a part of, uh, pop culture and kind of, like, everyday life for people who just read the, the news.
- 11:37Well, Paul, the, the, the, the, the one caveat I would say is it, uh, there, there isn't that much demand at the price point that we've seen, right?
- 11:43If we can get a sub $20,000 EV, I think what we're gonna see, actually, you're gonna unlock a whole different- Yep... type of buyer.
- 11:50And, you know, i- imagine those cars when they come back used and you can have a good quality used V- used EV at 10 grand. I mean, we, we, we, we, we have yet to unlock that segment, and it's, it's uncertain.
- 12:00N- nobody knows how big that segment's gonna be, but- Right... I think we're about to see what the sort of $20,000 EV buyer demand is. And it'll be, you know, the infrastructure challenge is still...
- 12:11I mean, it'll just exacerbate if all of a sudden there's a sub $20,000 EV and people start saying, "Hey, this makes economically viable sense for me to buy this car," but overall cost of ownership or convenience of ownership isn't realized until after the purchase.
- 12:26Um, I think we could, we could be in for a, a real, a real awakening if we get to the sub 20,000, see what the market is, and then see what the infrastructure can actually sustain.
- 12:35Well, the other, the other big news last week was, you know, Stellantis was the last OEM to embrace the Tesla standard- Yep... for EVs.
- 12:41And, and while they don't really have any EVs yet, they're, they're going to have EVs. And, um, you know, what we're gonna see is we're gonna see these Tesla Supercharger stations overwhelmed with non-Tesla vehicles.
- 12:51And what's, what's that gonna do to the Tesla buyer's experience? They're gonna be like- Ab- it's gonna crush it... well. Yeah, so w- is Tesla gonna start charging more for non-Tesla vehicles? Probably. Mm-hmm.
- 13:01Could they thr- could they throttle the speed of charging for non-Tesla buyers? I wouldn't put it past, past Elon. I mean, but I, I still don't- Yeah... I still don't think that that's gonna help the Tesla experience.
- 13:10If all of a sudden- No, I agree. I agree... that person's gotta park there for an hour, [laughs] just kidding. Yeah. [laughs] It'd be- Yeah...
- 13:15I, I rented, um, I rented, uh, an EV when I was in Orlando last week, and I... It was the cheapest car to rent via Avis, $45 a day, and they ended up putting me in a Ford Mach-E, which I really enjoyed driving.
- 13:27I refuse to call it a Mustang because it's not. Um- Right... but, but I was, I was at a Wawa convenience store, and they have Tesla Superchargers out back.
- 13:35And I didn't need to charge it, but I, I was like, "You know what? Maybe I'll just charge it to, like, get the experience." And then I was like, "I'm not doing that. I don't have a Tesla.
- 13:42I'm not gonna face the shame [laughs] of going to the Tesla-" Yeah, right. [laughs] It's like walking into the Apple Store with an Android phone and [laughs] asking for something. Right, right. Yeah.
- 13:48So I just decided not to do it instead. [laughs] Yeah. Can you imagine the dirty looks you'd get? Oh, it would've been terrible. [laughs] Especially as I was figuring out, like, "How do I pay for this?"
- 13:56'Cause in a Tesla, it's just integrated with the app. You just pull up, plug it in, and you go. I have no idea how you charge a Ford at a Tesla station. Agreed, agreed. Yeah. Oh. Well, thanks for being with us today.
- 14:06You have, uh, places to go. We have things to do. Um, we're gonna see you back on Thursday. Thanks for joining us again.
- 14:11But, um, until then, get out there, serve some customers, love some people more than you love cars, and we'll see you here right tomorrow morning. [upbeat music] Keep it rolling. Keep it coming. Keep it coming.
- 14:22It means a lot. Keep it coming. Keep it coming. Keep it coming. It means a lot.