Latest / For the Missing: Missing Persons, Families & the Search for Answers / The Boston Strangler: Truth, Confession & The DNA Doubt | For the Missing
Transcript
- Imagine living in a city where you could lock your door three times and still feel unsafe. Imagine the silence of an apartment that was never supposed to be a crime scene. Let’s go back to June of 1962. The air in Boston is thick with humidity, but it’s not just the weather that feels heavy. It’s fear. A palpable, creeping dread that settles into the bones of every woman living in Greater Boston. For months, there have been whispers. Then, headlines. By July, the Sunday Herald runs a story that stops hearts: "Mad Strangler Kills Four Women in Boston." Four women. Gone. Not taken by accident, not lost in the chaos of war or disease, but systematically removed from this world. At first, the police believe they are chasing one man. One shadow. They call him the Mad Strangler of Boston, then the Phantom Fiend, then the Phantom Strangler. Why? Because he has a terrifying ability to get inside. There are no signs of forced entry on any of the doors. No broken windows, no kicked-in frames. These women, ranging in age from nineteen to eighty-five, let him in. Or they thought they knew him. Or they believed he was a service provider coming to fix something in their homes. This detail alone changes everything about how we view safety. It suggests that the danger wasn’t lurking in the alleyways; it was standing at the threshold, wearing a face that demanded trust. As the bodies mount up, the city reacts. People buy tear gas. They install new locks, deadbolts, security chains. Some women simply pack their bags and move out of the area entirely, fleeing their own neighborhoods because home no longer feels like home. The attacks continue despite the publicity. Despite the fear. The pattern is chillingly consistent. Sexual assault. Strangulation. Ligatures—often nylon stockings or bathrobe ties—wrapped tight around necks. Thirteen women. Thirteen lives extinguished between June 1962 and January 1964. Let’s remember who they were. Not just statistics in a police report, but daughters, sisters, mothers, friends. Each one a heartbeat waiting to be heard again. With thirteen murders across several different cities in Massachusetts, jurisdiction becomes a nightmare. Who is responsible? Boston Police? State Police? The local precincts? It’s a bureaucratic tangle that slows down the investigation, but the real confusion isn’t administrative—it’s psychological. The public wants closure. They want a name. They want a single face to blame so they can understand how this happened. Enter Massachusetts Attorney General Edward W. Brooke. He tries to coordinate the various police forces, desperate for answers. In a move that would later become controversial, he permits a parapsychologist named Peter Hurkos to use his alleged extrasensory perception to analyze the cases. Hurkos claims he can see through his mind’s eye. And what does he see? He claims, with absolute certainty, that a single person is responsible. He provides a minutely detailed description of the killer. But here is the tragedy of that moment: Hurkos describes the wrong person. The press ridicules Brooke. The public is confused. The police are not convinced that all the murders were the actions of one person, even though much of the public believes so. Meanwhile, investigators notice apparent connections between a majority of the victims and hospitals. Nurses, aides, staff. Was it a professional access issue? A pattern of opportunity? The details swirl, but no clear picture emerges. Just a fog of grief and unanswered questions. Hold that thought with me. That uncertainty—that gap between what we think we know and what is actually true—is where the mystery deepens. We need to talk about Mary Sullivan. She was nineteen years old. On January 4, 1964, she was raped and strangled in her Boston apartment. This was the thirteenth victim, the final act in a long, terrible series. The details of her death are harrowing. Three ligatures were wrapped around her neck. A broom handle was lodged in her vagina—a detail that speaks to a level of brutality and desecration that defies easy explanation. But amidst that horror, there was something else. Something chillingly mundane. Leaning against her left foot, the killer left a card. It read: "Happy New Year." Think about the audacity of that. To take a life, to violate a space, and then leave a greeting card as if signing off on a social obligation. It’s grotesque. It’s dehumanizing. Mary Sullivan became the face of the end of the spree, but also the beginning of a new kind of scrutiny. Her death sparked renewed energy in the investigation, but also deepened the sorrow. We don’t know Mary’s favorite color. We don’t know if she loved jazz or classical music. We don’t know if she had plans for the weekend. All we have is the fact of her existence and the violence that ended it. But we hold her memory. We witness her loss. And we refuse to let her be just another number in a cold case file. Fast forward to October 27, 1964. The case is still unsolved, but a new crime brings the spotlight to a man named Albert DeSalvo. A stranger enters a young woman’s home in Boston. He poses as a detective. He tells her he needs to investigate something. The woman, perhaps recognizing the authority of the uniform or the badge, lets him in. He ties her to her bed. He sexually assaults her. And then, suddenly, he leaves. As he walks out the door, he says, "I’m sorry." That apology haunts the victim. But more importantly, it leads police to DeSalvo. When his photo is published in the papers, a wave of recognition sweeps through the city. Many women identify him as the man who had assaulted them in similar ways. Earlier that same day, DeSalvo had posed as a motorist with car trouble, trying to enter a home in Bridgewater, Massachusetts. The homeowner, a future Brockton police chief named Richard Sproules, became suspicious. He fired a shotgun at DeSalvo. DeSalvo fled. He wasn’t caught red-handed in the strangling murders, but the net was closing. He was charged with rape. And in custody, he began to speak. Albert DeSalvo gives a detailed confession of his activities as the Boston Strangler. Initially, he confesses to a fellow inmate, George Nassar. Nassar reports this to his attorney, F. Lee Bailey, who eventually takes on DeSalvo’s defense. The police are impressed. DeSalvo describes crime scenes with accuracy that shocks them. He cites details that had been withheld from the public—secrets only the killer and the investigators would know. There is one moment that stands out, a tiny thread of truth in a tangled web. DeSalvo describes a blue chair in one victim’s living room. The victim stated it was brown. It seemed like a minor discrepancy, a memory lapse. But photographic evidence proved DeSalvo was correct. The chair was blue. How did he know? The police assume it confirms his guilt. He gets the details right. He knows the layout of the apartments. He knows the methods. He admits to being the Green Man and the Measuring Man, crimes he committed before the stranglings. He seems to fit the profile. He seems to be the monster they’ve been hunting. But as we will see, fitting the profile is not the same as being proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Despite the confession, there is a problem. No physical evidence substantiates his confession. There are no fingerprints matching him at the scenes of the stranglings. No blood type matches. Nothing concrete. Because of that, he is tried on charges for earlier, unrelated crimes of robbery and sexual offenses. His lawyer, F. Lee Bailey, brings up the Boston Strangler confession during the trial, hoping to paint DeSalvo as mentally unstable to gain a "not guilty by reason of insanity" verdict for those specific charges. But the judge rules the confession inadmissible for that purpose. DeSalvo is convicted and sentenced to life in prison. He dies in his cell at Walpole State Prison on November 25, 1973, stabbed multiple times with a shiv, shortly before he planned to reveal details about the true identity of the killer. For decades, the case rests. The name "Boston Strangler" sticks. But in 2013, forensic scientists exhume the remains of Mary Sullivan, the last victim. They analyze DNA found on her underwear and pubic hair. The results are devastating to the established narrative. The DNA does not match Albert DeSalvo. It does not match the victim. It belongs to someone else. Someone unknown. This casts serious doubt on his confession to all thirteen murders. Legal scholars suggest the variations in the modus operandi might indicate more than one perpetrator. The Silk Stocking Murders may have been the work of many hands, not one. The search doesn’t end until they’re home. And for Mary Sullivan, and the other twelve women, the full truth may still be out there, hidden in the gaps of history. We leave you with the silence of those apartments. With the weight of the unanswered questions. The Boston Strangler case reminds us that justice is not always immediate, and truth is not always simple. It asks us to look closer, to listen harder, and to honor the dignity of every life lost. Thank you for spending this time with me. I’m Kimberley Callahan. This story is drawn from public records and widely reported accounts. Our thoughts are with everyone affected.