Latest / Surrounded / Jillian Michaels vs 20 Body Positivity Activists
Transcript
- 0:00Would you say that it should be against the law
- 0:02to discriminate against people based on their body size?
- 0:04Unquestionably.
- 0:05So why don't we see more fitness and wellness advocates asking for that?
- 0:09I'm happy to ask for it.
- 0:10Ask for it right now.
- 0:11I didn't know that you thought I wasn't for it.
- 0:13I wasn't allowed to have
- 0:14a ding dong when I came home and I said,
- 0:16I want ding dongs in my lunch.
- 0:18You know what my mom bought me?
- 0:19Low fat ding dongs.
- 0:20Maybe there's more to life than
- 0:23trying to lose weight.
- 0:24That's what body positivity.
- 0:26Has given me.
- 0:27You have to like love yourself.
- 0:29You have to invite love into the space.
- 0:31How?
- 0:32By looking at yourself in the mirror and telling yourself I'm beautiful.
- 0:35It's not gonna work,
- 0:36kid.
- 0:36It does.
- 0:37It's an SNL skit.
- 0:39Are Americans fat phobic and obsessed with unrealistic beauty standards,
- 0:43or has the body positivity movement
- 0:45normalized unhealthy habits and lifestyles?
- 0:48I'm John Regalado,
- 0:49and today we're gonna have a debate about what it means to be healthy.
- 0:53Jillian,
- 0:53how are you feeling?
- 0:54I feel good.
- 0:55Debaters,
- 0:55are you ready to come at Jillian with your best arguments?
- 0:59All right,
- 0:59let's get into it.
- 1:00Hi,
- 1:00I'm Jillian Michaels.
- 1:01I'm a fitness expert and a health advocate,
- 1:03and today I am surrounded by 20 body positivity activists.
- 1:11All right,
- 1:11my first rounded claim is that obesity is not
- 1:14healthy and pretending it is puts lives at risk.
- 1:21If you want to be the first debater,
- 1:22get to the chair in 321.
- 1:28Hi.
- 1:29Hi,
- 1:29I'm Edie.
- 1:30Nice to meet you.
- 1:30I'm an eating disorder therapist.
- 1:32I'm gonna do my best to not use the O word because I find it,
- 1:36um,
- 1:37pretty offensive,
- 1:38uh,
- 1:38so I'm gonna use fat-bodied,
- 1:40um,
- 1:41as we talk.
- 1:42Um,
- 1:43do you understand why people find it harmful and triggering?
- 1:47It overweight and obese is literally just having
- 1:51too much body fat.
- 1:52It has nothing to do with the quality of the person.
- 1:55Yeah,
- 1:55I agree with you on that.
- 1:57Are,
- 1:58are we gonna debate the claim?
- 1:59Yeah,
- 1:59I just wanted to,
- 2:01yeah,
- 2:01I wanted to clarify though,
- 2:03are we gonna pretend like I'm a 3 and you're my mommy
- 2:05telling me how to talk?
- 2:07Wow,
- 2:07OK,
- 2:08OK.
- 2:10So the claim that you're saying is that it
- 2:13is inherently unhealthy to live in a fat body.
- 2:17It's inherently unhealthy to have excess body fat.
- 2:21Yes,
- 2:21OK.
- 2:22Where are you getting that information from?
- 2:24OK.
- 2:25There are dozens
- 2:27of MRT trials
- 2:28that show having excess body fat.
- 2:31Dozens
- 2:32is causal,
- 2:33not correlated.
- 2:34No,
- 2:34that's not true.
- 2:35There is no disease that just
- 2:37fat-bodied people get.
- 2:39I didn't say that.
- 2:40I didn't say that.
- 2:42But obesity lends itself to all-cause mortality across the board.
- 2:46Have you heard of something called
- 2:48adiposopathy?
- 2:49Mhm.
- 2:50OK,
- 2:50so you know it means
- 2:52literally sick fat.
- 2:54And you understand how it works.
- 2:56OK,
- 2:56tell me how it works.
- 2:57So it's,
- 2:59uh,
- 3:00additional layer of fat in the stomach area.
- 3:03No,
- 3:04that's not what it is.
- 3:05It works
- 3:06as follows.
- 3:07When we eat too much food
- 3:08that has energy
- 3:10that we're not utilizing,
- 3:11the body needs to put that energy somewhere,
- 3:13right?
- 3:13So it puts it in fat cells.
- 3:15So it puts it in initially subcutaneous fat cells,
- 3:18a little bit of visceral fat,
- 3:19which is fat around the organs.
- 3:21And at first you have hyperplasia,
- 3:23which means we're recruiting new little fat cells,
- 3:27which
- 3:27isn't necessarily a bad thing up to a point.
- 3:31Now the issue is that once you can no longer recruit more fat cells,
- 3:34right,
- 3:35you get hypertrophy.
- 3:37So the fat cells start to expand.
- 3:39And this is exceptionally dangerous,
- 3:42because what ends up happening is the blood vessels
- 3:44get outpaced.
- 3:46So the fat cells can't get oxygen,
- 3:48and they start screaming,
- 3:50literally.
- 3:51And when they do,
- 3:51they release
- 3:53cytokines,
- 3:54inflammatory proteins,
- 3:55right?
- 3:57I wanna of course you do want to pause
- 3:59because
- 4:00it,
- 4:00it's irrefutable.
- 4:01You don't even know what I'm talking about.
- 4:03So Gillian,
- 4:04OK,
- 4:05first of all,
- 4:05I don't appreciate the way that you're speaking to me right now.
- 4:07You,
- 4:08you called me out for just trying to understand the languaging
- 4:10and saying I was talking to like a 3 year old.
- 4:12I felt like I was talking to you very respectfully.
- 4:14You're talking to me very disrespectfully right now.
- 4:16Here's the thing,
- 4:17and I,
- 4:17I want,
- 4:18because you're telling me you understand it,
- 4:19but you don't understand it.
- 4:20You fundamentally
- 4:21didn't describe it accurately.
- 4:24But what I understand is that
- 4:25what's lipotoxicity?
- 4:27I don't want to talk about,
- 4:28I am not,
- 4:29OK,
- 4:29here,
- 4:29I'm going to say this straight.
- 4:30I am not a medical doctor,
- 4:32OK,
- 4:32so I'm not going to talk to you
- 4:34about medical diagnosis because that's outside my scope,
- 4:36and I'm fully willing,
- 4:37hey,
- 4:37hey,
- 4:38I'm fully willing to be wrong.
- 4:39What I am here to talk to you about
- 4:41is the fact that
- 4:42people in fat bodies
- 4:44are irrevocably harmed
- 4:46going into the medical system every single day because of the term,
- 4:50the O word.
- 4:51So that's what you want to litigate?
- 4:53Yeah,
- 4:54OK,
- 4:54that's not the claim though.
- 4:55The idea that.
- 4:58Fat-bodied people are inherently unhealthy is,
- 5:00I believe,
- 5:01incorrect.
- 5:02No,
- 5:02I'm not wrong amount of data.
- 5:07I'm not wrong.
- 5:07OK,
- 5:08so let me can't,
- 5:08you can't look at,
- 5:09let me finish,
- 5:10let me finish my thought first,
- 5:11please.
- 5:12You can't look at a person's body and tell whether or not their,
- 5:15what,
- 5:16tell their health status.
- 5:17So fat is an endocrine organ.
- 5:19When it overgrows,
- 5:21it does wreak havoc in the body.
- 5:24I didn't finish telling you what happens.
- 5:26So when the oxygen can't get to those fat cells,
- 5:30they'll die
- 5:31and they'll rupture,
- 5:32and then the immune system starts dumping macrophages in to try to clean it up.
- 5:35But do you know what's even more unhealthy is weight cycling.
- 5:38And as we talked about earlier,
- 5:40only except for your,
- 5:41your,
- 5:42your people who have.
- 5:44If you want to talk about that claim,
- 5:46we can.
- 5:46The claim is,
- 5:48so then what are you supposed to do though?
- 5:50So let's say this person is in a fat body and they are inherently unhealthy,
- 5:54right?
- 5:54We're telling they're,
- 5:55they're unhealthy because they're in this fat body.
- 5:57What are they supposed to do?
- 5:58We will be more significantly more prone to all-cause mortality.
- 6:03For me,
- 6:03intentional weight loss fails 95 to 98% of the time.
- 6:07So what is the why though you would probably know this better than me
- 6:11because weight is not
- 6:12an individualistic.
- 6:14Pursuit,
- 6:15you narrow it down to this idea that it's causal,
- 6:18like that they're just not trying hard enough,
- 6:20but that is,
- 6:21it's multifactorial.
- 6:23Unquestionably.
- 6:25A lot of people lose weight.
- 6:27The problem,
- 6:27right,
- 6:27is that they put it back on.
- 6:28Are we in agreement?
- 6:29Yes,
- 6:30OK,
- 6:30great.
- 6:31Why do you think?
- 6:31OK,
- 6:32we gotta pause there.
- 6:33God damn it.
- 6:34All right,
- 6:35I'm sorry,
- 6:35John.
- 6:37I'm getting somewhere.
- 6:38Yeah,
- 6:39voted out by the majority.
- 6:40Please return to your seat.
- 6:42OK.
- 6:46Hello.
- 6:47Hi.
- 6:48I have lived in a fat body for like
- 6:50as long as I can remember.
- 6:52And I've known very many fat people,
- 6:55and I don't think any of us,
- 6:56the people that I know,
- 6:57I can only speak to
- 6:59the people that I know,
- 7:00I don't think any of us are pretending
- 7:02that
- 7:04we're OK with it.
- 7:06What I wanna say here is I,
- 7:08I live with autoimmune disorders.
- 7:10I live with chronic illness,
- 7:11and I'm also neurodivergent.
- 7:13Um,
- 7:14and this is
- 7:15the body positivity movement has made it so that
- 7:18I can
- 7:19tolerate
- 7:20this life.
- 7:22I can find ways to thrive,
- 7:24even still.
- 7:26Um,
- 7:27but I'm not pretending
- 7:28that
- 7:29this doesn't
- 7:30bother me.
- 7:31And by bother,
- 7:32I mean
- 7:33that it doesn't hurt to carry my weight.
- 7:35I'm willing to concede with you
- 7:37that
- 7:38uh carrying around extra weight is harder.
- 7:40It is.
- 7:42But I,
- 7:42it must be done.
- 7:44I don't know that I agree with you.
- 7:45OK,
- 7:47tell me more,
- 7:47please.
- 7:48Well,
- 7:48tell me why you think it must be done,
- 7:49because I've worked really hard
- 7:51to not have,
- 7:53have this.
- 7:53What does that mean?
- 7:55Like you feel like you beat yourself up in the gym or something.
- 7:58No,
- 7:58I don't.
- 7:58That's not fun.
- 7:59No,
- 8:00I,
- 8:00I'm not.
- 8:01I'm just trying to understand what you,
- 8:02what you mean.
- 8:03What I mean is that,
- 8:04um,
- 8:05I grew up with a,
- 8:06with a number of undiagnosed conditions
- 8:09and even I can think back to like middle school
- 8:12and I couldn't keep up when the PE teacher would make us like run
- 8:15laps and I'm like this is physically aching me and I didn't understand why.
- 8:20And I didn't understand why because I grew up with a single parent,
- 8:23undocumented single parent.
- 8:25We were
- 8:26bound.
- 8:28To the medical system
- 8:30that we had access to.
- 8:32I've done what I needed to do
- 8:35a number of times to try to lose weight,
- 8:38but did you try?
- 8:39Tell me.
- 8:40I've done,
- 8:41done,
- 8:42I've worked at,
- 8:43I've worked out at the gym.
- 8:44I've tried to do Pilates.
- 8:45I even yoga,
- 8:47even yoga hurts me.
- 8:48OK,
- 8:49so the exercise causes you pain.
- 8:52The exercise condition.
- 8:52OK,
- 8:52no problem.
- 8:53I'm,
- 8:53I'm with you.
- 8:53Uh-huh,
- 8:53uh-huh.
- 8:54Dieting,
- 8:55for example,
- 8:55OK,
- 8:56that doesn't make any sense to me.
- 8:58I don't think that food makes very much sense.
- 9:00To me in my neurodivergent brain.
- 9:02This is where mechanistic eating actually helps people who are neurodivergent,
- 9:05and the research supports that,
- 9:07because it doesn't have to make sense to you.
- 9:09OK.
- 9:09In other words,
- 9:10it's like you eat on these schedules and you eat these foods and you eat this much,
- 9:13hence the concept,
- 9:14right,
- 9:14of mechanistic.
- 9:15I don't like that.
- 9:16I understand that you don't like it,
- 9:17but you'll have to decide what you don't like more,
- 9:19carrying the weight
- 9:21or the mechanistic eating,
- 9:22because it actually could be helpful.
- 9:24There are other ways forward,
- 9:25but you told me you tried them.
- 9:27I tried,
- 9:27I tried a whole lot.
- 9:28There's a lot of other things to be concerned about.
- 9:31I'm also a social worker.
- 9:32I work with youth.
- 9:33There are a lot of,
- 9:34let's go back to
- 9:35you.
- 9:36Uh-huh,
- 9:36yes,
- 9:37I'm,
- 9:37I'm saying for me,
- 9:38right,
- 9:39there are many things that I'm more concerned about
- 9:41than my weight.
- 9:42My,
- 9:43my body is not the most interesting thing about me brought up your weight and said,
- 9:46I don't see a way out of this.
- 9:48I've tried everything and I just,
- 9:50I'm telling you care of it in the ways that I can and I've found works for me,
- 9:55but,
- 9:55but you just told me it didn't.
- 9:57Work for you,
- 9:57but it works to an extent.
- 10:00You just told me it didn't work for you.
- 10:02It works to an extent.
- 10:04Then this isn't a relevant conversation if you're happy with it.
- 10:07I stand on 10 toes,
- 10:0910 toes down,
- 10:10that we are not pretending
- 10:12that there's healthy at any size.
- 10:14There are absolutely
- 10:16elements and aspects of the movement that do put that messaging.
- 10:20Into the universe.
- 10:21I've had those debates.
- 10:23You've said I've had numerous debates with people who
- 10:26are body positivity activists that try to tell me
- 10:29that they can be healthy at any size,
- 10:31and it's just
- 10:32not the case,
- 10:34and I disagree with that.
- 10:35And I can shame.
- 10:37You've used shame as a vehicle.
- 10:39I,
- 10:39I'm sorry we have to pause.
- 10:40You've been voted out by the majority.
- 10:41Can you
- 10:42please return to your seat.
- 10:43Got it OK.
- 10:49What I'm curious about is if you care about people's health
- 10:53and you have people in front of you and I'm sure you have people
- 10:56online who are telling you that the body positivity movement
- 10:59or I prefer the body liberation,
- 11:00body justice,
- 11:01body acceptance,
- 11:02body blah,
- 11:03all the,
- 11:04all the good shit that we like
- 11:06actually increases their health.
- 11:09Then I don't understand your debate.
- 11:12Like,
- 11:12what are you debating if the fat people are telling you it makes their life better?
- 11:16I'm debating their physical health and I'm debating the
- 11:18people who claim that you can be physically healthy
- 11:21at any size.
- 11:22OK.
- 11:23Do you think you can be physically healthy and mentally unhealthy at the same time?
- 11:26Of course,
- 11:27but that's not the claim.
- 11:28OK,
- 11:29sure.
- 11:30Um.
- 11:31I think
- 11:32the part where I get stuck,
- 11:33I am a mental health professional.
- 11:36Um,
- 11:36I work with people from a body liberation standpoint.
- 11:39I work with people in all shapes of bodies.
- 11:41What I know to be true from my experience is that body positivity,
- 11:45body liberation helps people take care of themselves.
- 11:48It's very difficult
- 11:50to understand
- 11:51why you think somebody is going to take better care of a body they hate,
- 11:55like why body positivity would not.
- 11:57Inspire people to take better care of their bodies my argument.
- 12:01I never said you should hate your body.
- 12:02In fact,
- 12:03you,
- 12:03you should.
- 12:05OK,
- 12:05so I don't think that.
- 12:07What I think is that there are people in
- 12:08the movement who have co-opted healthy at any size,
- 12:12and it went from access to healthcare to quite literally meaning for them
- 12:16that you can be healthy at any size,
- 12:18and that's not true.
- 12:20OK,
- 12:21I mean,
- 12:21I,
- 12:21there,
- 12:22the studies show that if you're very,
- 12:23very,
- 12:23very,
- 12:24very thin,
- 12:25or your body is very,
- 12:25very,
- 12:26very,
- 12:26very big,
- 12:27it is more difficult to be healthy.
- 12:28That is absolutely true.
- 12:29But can you agree with me on this point.
- 12:31I don't,
- 12:32because I,
- 12:32I don't think body positivity is the dangerous thing.
- 12:35I think I think hatred of fat bodies and people hating themselves and people
- 12:40living in self-loathing because they've been taught
- 12:42that their body is the wrong shape.
- 12:44That's the danger.
- 12:45Both can be true at once.
- 12:47So,
- 12:47let's look at this,
- 12:48right?
- 12:48So the first thing we would want to do,
- 12:50obviously,
- 12:51is incentivize somebody.
- 12:52So,
- 12:53it's like,
- 12:53OK,
- 12:54what's the why
- 12:56that's going to allow you to tolerate the how?
- 12:58But hold on,
- 12:59hold on.
- 13:00That's the positive.
- 13:01That's the inspiration piece.
- 13:03OK.
- 13:03Now,
- 13:04here's the issue.
- 13:05If that piece,
- 13:06of all the things that they get out of it.
- 13:09Don't serve them
- 13:10as much as the things that are getting out of being overweight,
- 13:14and it does provide quite a lot.
- 13:16I can give you an example.
- 13:17Wait,
- 13:17then they're not going unconsciously.
- 13:19They will sabotage the change.
- 13:21Can I give you an example so you'll understand it?
- 13:23OK.
- 13:24There was a kid that I worked with,
- 13:25OK,
- 13:26on Biggest Loser.
- 13:26He's 18 years old.
- 13:28He shows up with his dad,
- 13:29Ken.
- 13:30They both lose like 100 pounds.
- 13:32They go home
- 13:34and they're visiting their family.
- 13:35It's the holidays,
- 13:36doors fly open.
- 13:38And there's mom,
- 13:40and mom starts crying,
- 13:41and she's not crying tears of joy.
- 13:44She feels like they're gonna abandon her,
- 13:46like they broke the contract,
- 13:48like they've outgrown her,
- 13:50and she becomes sad and she withdraws.
- 13:52So what does the 18 year old do?
- 13:54He starts eating with mom again.
- 13:56What does the food provide him?
- 13:58A connection with his mom.
- 14:00I had something similar
- 14:01with my dad.
- 14:01It was one of the ways that we connected.
- 14:04Food provides a lot of people with a lot of different things.
- 14:06Yes,
- 14:07you cannot eat and not have your parasympathetic
- 14:09nervous system turned on at the same time.
- 14:11There's no such thing as not emotional eating.
- 14:12It's fine.
- 14:13It's good.
- 14:13It's great.
- 14:14Food is great.
- 14:15But what I'm trying to show you
- 14:17is that
- 14:18if
- 14:18in some cases.
- 14:21The pain associated with continuing that defense mechanism.
- 14:25Is greater
- 14:27than the pain associated with change.
- 14:30It helps people change in some cases.
- 14:33Not in the long term and I lost there.
- 14:36I'm sorry you've been voted out by the majority.
- 14:39Please return to your seat.
- 14:45So
- 14:46we earlier you were speaking about how
- 14:48these,
- 14:49there's randomized control trials that show M and
- 14:51randomized control trials that have now shown us
- 14:54that obesity is causal to all cause mortality.
- 14:57OK,
- 14:57so I,
- 14:58I disagree with that.
- 14:58I think there's going to be a problem with dozens.
- 15:00Yeah.
- 15:01So but here's,
- 15:02here's why I disagree,
- 15:03because you can disagree.
- 15:04No,
- 15:04but let me please,
- 15:05please let me hear me out.
- 15:06OK.
- 15:07OK.
- 15:07So the reason why is because
- 15:09registered dietitian school for 6 years studying nutrition,
- 15:12weight.
- 15:12All the all the stuff
- 15:14and we can't keep toxicity is
- 15:16it doesn't come off my curriculum because it's
- 15:18bullshit because it's a TikTok thing that's like,
- 15:21you know,
- 15:21cortisol face or whatever,
- 15:23but please just back to me.
- 15:24It is not bullshit.
- 15:26It's ectopic fat.
- 15:28But can we just say because you keep
- 15:29sidestepping and then we never get anywherestepping.
- 15:31This is the claim.
- 15:32OK.
- 15:33OK.
- 15:33The claim
- 15:34is that obesity is unhealthy,
- 15:36lipotoxicity is not bullshit,
- 15:39but it is the definition.
- 15:40of ectopic fat.
- 15:42It's funny it never came up in 6 years of a professional accredited.
- 15:46What's fatty liver disease?
- 15:47I know a fatty liver.
- 15:47I was a clinical dietitian.
- 15:49That's lipotoxicity.
- 15:50OK.
- 15:51OK.
- 15:52When fat is in the liver,
- 15:53when fat is in the heart,
- 15:54when fat gets deposited in the brain.
- 15:57Yeah,
- 15:57that is lipotoxicity,
- 15:59and it happens
- 16:00when the body has no place to put the excess energy anymore.
- 16:04OK.
- 16:04It is irrefutable
- 16:06that that is bad.
- 16:08For your health,
- 16:08can we just go back to the correlation as an equal causation?
- 16:10So you're saying there's causal studies,
- 16:12right?
- 16:12Yes,
- 16:12MRT the acronym is great.
- 16:15OK,
- 16:15so I think is
- 16:17the reason why we cannot show
- 16:19that
- 16:20that
- 16:20the fat in and of itself leads to the negative health
- 16:23outcomes is because we cannot keep a human in a lab
- 16:26and control every factor but have the only thing
- 16:28that's different Mendelian randomized control can you just listen?
- 16:32So a person that inherently
- 16:34eliminates.
- 16:35Any conflating factors because they're based on
- 16:39genetic predispositions coupled with lifestyle a person in a larger body
- 16:44has experienced things that we can't
- 16:47undo
- 16:48from the fat.
- 16:49So for example,
- 16:50they might have negative health outcomes because every time they go to a doctor,
- 16:54instead of being given an evidence-based treatment,
- 16:56like I have unearthed and privilege,
- 16:58I go to a doctor,
- 16:59I say,
- 16:59you know,
- 16:59my stomach hurts.
- 17:00I get a full workup saying the earth is flat.
- 17:03Are you trying to tell me that having fat in your liver,
- 17:06I just wanna talk about fat in your heart,
- 17:09having fat deposited in your brain is healthy.
- 17:11No,
- 17:12I just wanna talk about,
- 17:13so no,
- 17:13you're not trying to say that it's healthy.
- 17:15No,
- 17:15I'm not trying to tell you that is what I said.
- 17:16I,
- 17:16I was never talking about the health of it.
- 17:18I'm trying to say
- 17:20everything you're saying is hinging on this idea,
- 17:21and it's,
- 17:21it's a problem that we disagree on it,
- 17:24that it's the weight in and of itself that leads to the negative health outcomes.
- 17:27You're saying this MRT totally
- 17:29is,
- 17:30that is an endocrine organ.
- 17:31I know,
- 17:32but,
- 17:32but can you it destroys your hormone balance.
- 17:36It creates insulin sensitivity.
- 17:39What when the body has too much fat,
- 17:42it releases insane amounts of.
- 17:44Different.
- 17:45I just wonder,
- 17:46have you heard of social determinants of health?
- 17:48Tell me about it.
- 17:49OK,
- 17:49social determinants of health,
- 17:50a group of factors that impact someone's health outcomes
- 17:53that are things like your,
- 17:55uh,
- 17:56your,
- 17:56your health care access and quality,
- 17:57neighborhood and built environment,
- 17:59things like your stress levels and socioeconomic status.
- 18:02And here's the thing,
- 18:04a person who's fat or lives in a larger body,
- 18:06they,
- 18:07we can't take away that that person has probably experienced higher
- 18:10stress levels their whole life from
- 18:12experiencing marginalization in every corner.
- 18:14From shows like The Biggest Loser to the doctor's office.
- 18:16We can't take away that they
- 18:18haven't been given evidence-based health options because
- 18:21when they go to a doctor,
- 18:22they're told to go lose weight.
- 18:24Fat gets deposited in your brain not answering what I'm How does,
- 18:27how does,
- 18:29I'm confused.
- 18:29Are you suggesting these are the reasons people become overweight?
- 18:32No,
- 18:32I'm suggesting that
- 18:34I,
- 18:35a person could be in a larger body and be perfectly healthy on a on based on their labs,
- 18:40their cholesterol.
- 18:407% of people who are classified.
- 18:44As
- 18:44overweight or obese,
- 18:46call it whatever you guys feel comfortable with.
- 18:49Only 7% are classified as healthy.
- 18:51Say that was true.
- 18:52Say we knew for certain grab the data for you right now if you want.
- 18:55Say we knew for certain that it was unhealthy,
- 18:57that,
- 18:58that what you're saying is true.
- 19:00Even
- 19:00then,
- 19:00here's the class but even then,
- 19:02even then we'd be in this place.
- 19:03Where,
- 19:04OK,
- 19:04so what do we do?
- 19:05Are we going to send someone down a path of trying
- 19:08to lose weight and then gaining and trying and gaining?
- 19:09And we know that weight cycling in and of itself,
- 19:11bad for the heart,
- 19:12bad for insulin,
- 19:13bad for the brain,
- 19:14bad for all the things we,
- 19:15we work with that individual.
- 19:17That's what I do in my private practice.
- 19:18Well,
- 19:18that's wonderful.
- 19:19Yeah.
- 19:19And I don't,
- 19:20I don't encourage weight loss because it's unethical.
- 19:23I disagree with you.
- 19:24And what's ethical?
- 19:25You were asking before,
- 19:26what's unethical not to be transparent with people and transparent dangers.
- 19:30Yeah,
- 19:30transparency is the dangers of weight cycling.
- 19:32You can go down that path,
- 19:34a separate issue.
- 19:35You're presuming they're weight cycling.
- 19:37If you're doing your job,
- 19:38they shouldn't have to weight cycle,
- 19:39right?
- 19:40No,
- 19:40it's not about me.
- 19:41It's about the body.
- 19:41The body is so smart.
- 19:42We are,
- 19:43we are,
- 19:43but we're animals.
- 19:44Our bodies,
- 19:44when we lose weight,
- 19:45our body goes,
- 19:45oh shit,
- 19:47she just starved me.
- 19:47I'm going to do everything I can to try to get back to that place.
- 19:50I think it's drive up thoughts about food.
- 19:52I think it's slow.
- 19:53Down metabolism to conserve the energy you are getting.
- 19:56So are you suggesting that because it's hard and it's multifactorial,
- 20:00we should negate the dangers and not try to get healthier,
- 20:02that it's more dangerous to weight cycle than it is to stay in a fat body.
- 20:06It's still not the claim.
- 20:08And if,
- 20:09if you want to show me that,
- 20:10I'd like,
- 20:10sure,
- 20:11show me the data.
- 20:11I'm not going to argue with that.
- 20:12It's not healthy to do that either.
- 20:14That's still not the claim.
- 20:16This isn't a hierarchy of what is unhealthy.
- 20:18We're out of time.
- 20:19We have to pause there.
- 20:20Yeah,
- 20:20thank you for that exchange.
- 20:23My next Gronded claim is that the large
- 20:25food companies are one of the primary beneficiaries
- 20:28of the body positivity movement.
- 20:30All right,
- 20:30if you want to be the next debater,
- 20:32get to the chair in 321.
- 20:38Hi.
- 20:39Hi.
- 20:40How are you?
- 20:40I'm Siha.
- 20:41Nice to meet you,
- 20:42Siha.
- 20:43So,
- 20:45what are you classifying as large food companies?
- 20:47OK,
- 20:47um,
- 20:48PepsiCo,
- 20:49Coca-Cola,
- 20:51uh,
- 20:51General Mills.
- 20:52OK.
- 20:53Now,
- 20:54if they were beneficiaries and benefactoring and making all this money
- 20:58off of the body positivity movement,
- 21:01why is it that they spend billions
- 21:04on calorie counting apps
- 21:06on a lot of things that we see in society.
- 21:10As
- 21:10forcing the losing weight or talking about losing weight
- 21:13because that to me
- 21:15doesn't make sense and doesn't correlate,
- 21:17but also
- 21:18people that are benefiting from this
- 21:21are the people in the body positivity movement themselves.
- 21:25A little bit about myself.
- 21:26Wait,
- 21:26can I clarify one thing,
- 21:28I'm,
- 21:28I'm talking predominantly about finance.
- 21:29OK,
- 21:30sorry,
- 21:30perfect.
- 21:31Thank you.
- 21:31Even,
- 21:32even that,
- 21:33I still will say,
- 21:34so I come from the wedding industry.
- 21:37So I created the first publication in the world for plus-size brides.
- 21:40I've now gotten 13 wedding publications around the world,
- 21:45and my biggest thing is,
- 21:46is the wedding industry is very centric
- 21:49on
- 21:50this is what the wedding industry looks like.
- 21:53I have created a platform
- 21:55where body and not just larger bodied
- 21:58body positivity,
- 22:00but body positivity for all sizes,
- 22:03and I'm going to come specifically from the wedding industry,
- 22:05which is very different,
- 22:05I know,
- 22:06but it still is a very weight centric.
- 22:09So,
- 22:09so your argument is the,
- 22:10the wedding industry is the primary
- 22:13beneficiary.
- 22:13I'm not saying that.
- 22:14I'm saying that's where my knowledge comes from,
- 22:17but the body positivity movement.
- 22:19It is really for us.
- 22:21We are the main,
- 22:22and I'm saying we because I'm a large-bodied person.
- 22:24I totally understand.
- 22:25That's where it's really coming from they're exploiting it.
- 22:28Oh please,
- 22:29please,
- 22:29please.
- 22:29So there have been
- 22:30two really big exposes,
- 22:32one by the Washington Post
- 22:33and one by The Examiner.
- 22:35So they're coming at this from
- 22:37numerous angles.
- 22:39So the first one is they've gone after
- 22:41a lot of the intuitive eating dietitians.
- 22:44So let me just,
- 22:44can I give you some statistics?
- 22:46OK,
- 22:47so Washington Post analyzed more than 6000 social media posts.
- 22:52By 68 registered dietitians with a combined reach of over 9 million followers,
- 22:5640% of them were using
- 22:58the anti-diet language,
- 22:59right?
- 23:00Like food freedom,
- 23:01no food rules,
- 23:02ditch the diet,
- 23:03healthy in any size,
- 23:04so on and so forth.
- 23:06Very often not disclosing the fact
- 23:08that they were paid
- 23:09by the big food companies.
- 23:11OK,
- 23:11OK,
- 23:12so
- 23:13they're basically going after
- 23:15the intuitive eating dietitians.
- 23:16I can give you Abby Sharp.
- 23:18That's OK though,
- 23:18but,
- 23:19but,
- 23:19but I want you to listen
- 23:20because they are doing that.
- 23:22Yes,
- 23:23but the
- 23:24Expect that the body positive movement is really for us,
- 23:27that is not even anywhere we need to equate into it.
- 23:31It really is when they're using your movement,
- 23:34but that,
- 23:34but do you,
- 23:35and I'm gonna say this clearly and for right now,
- 23:38I don't care who uses my fucking movement.
- 23:40I want the movement to be there.
- 23:43And that right there,
- 23:44they can take it.
- 23:45It's marketing and sales one on one,
- 23:46of course they're gonna use the fucking movement
- 23:48because they can't you guys
- 23:50say
- 23:51you don't get to co-opt our movement.
- 23:53That's not for me to do.
- 23:54I don't care about that.
- 23:55The thing is,
- 23:56is we don't care,
- 23:58but it's not about we should.
- 24:00We are doing what we're doing
- 24:01because this is our family.
- 24:03This is our world.
- 24:04It doesn't matter about what do you think I can,
- 24:08but the thing is we don't care.
- 24:10We are the movement,
- 24:12but there are a lot of people that are being hurt by this,
- 24:15and these guys
- 24:17essentially are engineering food to be addictive
- 24:21to quite and,
- 24:21and you know what,
- 24:22and I will say this,
- 24:23I will say this,
- 24:24I will give you
- 24:25the claps on that.
- 24:26I will say yes,
- 24:27that is true,
- 24:29but what I do wanna say
- 24:31is that
- 24:31that it it happens all the time.
- 24:33A movement starts and someone comes in and takes it and
- 24:36someone comes in and comes in it and someone comes.
- 24:38Don't deny it.
- 24:39You just don't care.
- 24:40No,
- 24:41I'm saying it's fine for them to do that,
- 24:43but the bigger issue
- 24:45that I want you to realize
- 24:47is that the body positivity movement
- 24:49is ultimately for us.
- 24:51If someone wants to come and get on our coattail,
- 24:53that's perfectly fine,
- 24:54but for us it doesn't need to go away.
- 24:57It doesn't need to go anywhere.
- 24:58It doesn't go away.
- 25:00But I'm,
- 25:00I'm suggesting now see,
- 25:02there's a suggestion.
- 25:03I like it.
- 25:04I like a suggestion.
- 25:05I'm suggesting that it could.
- 25:06Evolve
- 25:07that you guys could call out
- 25:09when you're co-opted
- 25:10that you could centralize messaging so that it's not all over the place.
- 25:14Now that jury I am not opposed to.
- 25:16I'm not opposed to that.
- 25:17I'm not saying it's that's not a claim.
- 25:19No,
- 25:20but the thing is,
- 25:21is I want you to know who the true beneficiaries are.
- 25:23You're saying that they are
- 25:25the main beneficiaries financially.
- 25:27Yeah,
- 25:27and I apologize,
- 25:28and that's OK,
- 25:29but you're saying the claim says that the large food companies are the main.
- 25:34Main beneficiaries of the body positive movement,
- 25:37that is not correct.
- 25:38I understand
- 25:39because we
- 25:40are the main people.
- 25:41We are the main beneficiaries
- 25:43of the body positive movement.
- 25:44If someone wants to come and get on our coattails,
- 25:46by God,
- 25:46go ahead.
- 25:47Disagree with you on that.
- 25:48I think that's a mistake and that's OK.
- 25:50I think that you guys
- 25:52could tell them
- 25:53you could expose what they're doing.
- 25:55I like,
- 25:55can I,
- 25:56can I read you something else,
- 25:57please?
- 25:57OK,
- 25:57I'm,
- 25:57I'm here to hear just how diabolical this is,
- 26:01OK.
- 26:02I have a friend
- 26:04that's on the inside.
- 26:05He sent me this.
- 26:06He goes,
- 26:06I just want to show you
- 26:08the ways in which this is being in the inside of,
- 26:10of,
- 26:11uh,
- 26:11I can't say that a big food.
- 26:13You got it.
- 26:13Exactly.
- 26:14OK,
- 26:14so,
- 26:15so
- 26:15here's
- 26:16the intentional message overlap,
- 26:18right?
- 26:18So,
- 26:19healthy at every size.
- 26:21Quote,
- 26:21you can be healthy in any size,
- 26:23corporate benefit
- 26:25removes health concern barrier to sales.
- 26:27Stay with me,
- 26:28OK?
- 26:29Dieting doesn't work.
- 26:31Protects snack foods from being cut.
- 26:35Healthy in any size,
- 26:36weight and health are unrelated,
- 26:38corporate benefit,
- 26:40deflects from products causing obesity.
- 26:43Healthy at any size.
- 26:44Weight stigma causes disease,
- 26:47not weight.
- 26:48Wait,
- 26:48wait,
- 26:48wait,
- 26:48OK,
- 26:49I'm,
- 26:49I'm just showing you this is,
- 26:50this is what I was an internal to bring
- 26:53what I would love,
- 26:54and I'm saying
- 26:55love because I want it,
- 26:56but I love it more.
- 26:58If there is such a resistance
- 27:00to the body positive movement,
- 27:02and I'm speaking specifically kind of from your standpoint,
- 27:05yes,
- 27:05if there's such a resistance
- 27:08to the body positive movement,
- 27:10why are you saying,
- 27:11why are you letting them take money from you?
- 27:14Why
- 27:14why is the resistance?
- 27:15I'm telling resistance of acknowledging or saying that it's actual,
- 27:18that it needs to be.
- 27:20I think that there are absolutely,
- 27:22I think that intuitive eating is
- 27:24a goal,
- 27:25not a,
- 27:26not a treatment plan.
- 27:27Um,
- 27:28I think that
- 27:29having access to health,
- 27:31which is what
- 27:32health in any size at every size was initially intended to do,
- 27:35I think all those things are important.
- 27:37I think unfortunately,
- 27:38the fact that the movement
- 27:39is decentralized and it's prone to.
- 27:42Being co-opted,
- 27:44it can do harm in the ways that I have shown you.
- 27:47That's what I'm saying and that we could agree to,
- 27:50we got a pause there.
- 27:51That's good.
- 27:52We got to pause there.
- 27:53You've been voted out by the majority.
- 27:55Well,
- 27:55I really appreciate this.
- 27:56Thank you.
- 27:57Thank you very much.
- 28:01So
- 28:02I really want to focus on what you've just
- 28:04been saying about the co-opting of the movement,
- 28:07because
- 28:08what you seem to be critiquing is the people who've co-opted the movement,
- 28:11not the people who actually built the movement,
- 28:13not the people who actually are the movement.
- 28:15So,
- 28:15so the,
- 28:16the idea that the movement though.
- 28:19So the thing is,
- 28:19well,
- 28:20I don't want to name names,
- 28:21but there are many,
- 28:22OK,
- 28:23influencers who have said these things.
- 28:25So who's movement?
- 28:26Influencers and activists are not necessarily the same thing.
- 28:28We were allegedly invited.
- 28:30Here as activists and advocates,
- 28:32not always the same thing,
- 28:33right?
- 28:33I don't disagree,
- 28:34but it's become,
- 28:36as I mentioned,
- 28:37a patchwork quilt
- 28:39of like,
- 28:40I'm an activist,
- 28:40I'm an influencer,
- 28:41I'm a dietitian.
- 28:42It,
- 28:42it's whereas like when you look at something like AA.
- 28:45Well,
- 28:45let me,
- 28:46so let me guide you to something very clear about the health at every size movement.
- 28:49Health at every size is actually a
- 28:51registered trademark of the Association for Size,
- 28:53Diversity and Health.
- 28:54So when people are misusing that,
- 28:57we are a movement that doesn't have the same resources as
- 28:59the health and wellness industry or the health and wellness grifters,
- 29:03um,
- 29:04or the
- 29:04major food industry,
- 29:06right?
- 29:06We don't have those same resources to
- 29:07fight every time somebody misuses our terminology,
- 29:10our philosophies,
- 29:12our practices,
- 29:13our values.
- 29:14But there are
- 29:16some of us out there who are doing that,
- 29:18right?
- 29:18I never see the caveats.
- 29:20I never ever see the freaking caveats.
- 29:23So
- 29:24maybe today,
- 29:25maybe,
- 29:25maybe you could help amplify some of the caveats.
- 29:27I am doing that right
- 29:29now.
- 29:30OK,
- 29:30so let's go to the claim,
- 29:32the claim that body positivity is primarily benefiting big food companies.
- 29:35I mean,
- 29:36I mean financially,
- 29:37I got it because individual benefit,
- 29:39I can't,
- 29:39I can't,
- 29:40it's not quantifiable.
- 29:41I,
- 29:41I'm talking about the way these bastards.
- 29:43are manipulating this message to
- 29:46to do things that I think
- 29:48are
- 29:48very unethical.
- 29:50So
- 29:50if body positivity is feeding their profits,
- 29:54will we see their profits reduce as this pendulum
- 29:56swing away from body positivity continues to go back to
- 30:00the um.
- 30:01Like I get asked all the time as the director of NAFA,
- 30:03is body positivity over?
- 30:05Is body positivity over because of Ozempic?
- 30:07Is body positivity over because of Maha?
- 30:10You know,
- 30:10is body positivity over?
- 30:12Part of my argument is it depends on what you're in body positivity for.
- 30:15If you're in it for systemic change,
- 30:16it ain't over because the system ain't changed,
- 30:18right?
- 30:19But I do concede the point that like we are moving away from
- 30:22some of what we saw as body positivity for the last 1015 years.
- 30:26What do you mean as we move away from that.
- 30:27It's less popular,
- 30:28it's less trendy,
- 30:30we're moving more towards a thin centric ideal again or,
- 30:33you know,
- 30:33leaving behind we,
- 30:34we've labeled body positivity DEI and we're turning away from that,
- 30:37whatever.
- 30:38As we move away from that,
- 30:40are we going to see the profits of the.
- 30:42Food industries drop.
- 30:43Well,
- 30:44you are.
- 30:45Why would you need to make food genetically addictive
- 30:49if body positivity can just sell that food?
- 30:51If you could just tell people
- 30:52when you feel good in your body,
- 30:53you're going to eat all the
- 30:55Nabisco snacks that you want to,
- 30:57then why do we have to make them addictive?
- 30:58They don't even want you to stop eating one chip.
- 31:02Can,
- 31:02can this is how,
- 31:03this is how incremental.
- 31:05They are about this.
- 31:07They literally engineer,
- 31:08just,
- 31:09OK,
- 31:10just,
- 31:10just hear me out.
- 31:10They don't even want you to have to stop and take a drink of water
- 31:14when you're eating their chips.
- 31:17So they engineer how much fat is in your mouth in each bite.
- 31:21There are a team
- 31:23of multidisciplinary scientists
- 31:25that literally work around the clock
- 31:2824/7,
- 31:29day after day,
- 31:30year after their body positivity.
- 31:32No,
- 31:32no,
- 31:32no,
- 31:32no,
- 31:33no,
- 31:33no,
- 31:33no,
- 31:33no,
- 31:33no,
- 31:33no,
- 31:33no,
- 31:33no,
- 31:34no,
- 31:34no.
- 31:35So so this is the thing,
- 31:37what you're describing is a misuse of science.
- 31:40What you're describing is,
- 31:41you know,
- 31:41what you're describing is friction
- 31:43business.
- 31:43What you're describing is capitalism.
- 31:44What you're describing is greed.
- 31:46Body positivity is not
- 31:49the reason for that.
- 31:50No,
- 31:50I'm suggesting
- 31:53that.
- 31:54I think you guys should get pretty freaking vocal and pissed
- 31:58because these guys are actively manipulating your message so much.
- 32:02I haven't even gotten to half the shit that they do.
- 32:04So for example,
- 32:05they have effectively lobbied
- 32:08to remove nutrition guidelines and warning labels on food packaging because of
- 32:12harmful shame.
- 32:14It's like,
- 32:15it,
- 32:15it,
- 32:15it,
- 32:16trans
- 32:17fats are bad for your health.
- 32:19It's a fact.
- 32:20They have advocated for that.
- 32:22The body positivity movement,
- 32:23the fat activist movement,
- 32:25the fat,
- 32:25they're using our language,
- 32:27right?
- 32:27Like you said,
- 32:28co-opting,
- 32:29right,
- 32:29so they should stop co-opting our shit,
- 32:31but they're not going to.
- 32:32But yes,
- 32:33that's what I'm saying.
- 32:34So how do I think you guys should get pissed about it.
- 32:36Like I,
- 32:36I get the things you're pissed at.
- 32:38We are pissed about a lot of things.
- 32:39I get it.
- 32:40Can you add this to the list?
- 32:41Add this,
- 32:42this I'm saying they're the primary.
- 32:44You want to indict someone.
- 32:46It is indict.
- 32:47It is on the list for some people whose focus is body positivity,
- 32:51right?
- 32:51We have different folk.
- 32:52I,
- 32:53I,
- 32:53you know,
- 32:53I do civil rights stuff.
- 32:54Some people do fashion stuff,
- 32:56wedding industry,
- 32:57health,
- 32:57you know,
- 32:57health and wellness,
- 32:58eating disorders.
- 32:59We have,
- 32:59there are folks who are thinking about the food industry.
- 33:02There are folks who are nutritionists who are,
- 33:04you know,
- 33:05like I can't,
- 33:05without seeing the list of like the people that I,
- 33:07the,
- 33:07I remember the Washington Post article.
- 33:10Some of those people are not people that I would associate with them.
- 33:13I understand,
- 33:13but they're literally,
- 33:15many of them are certified in.
- 33:16Intuitive eating,
- 33:17OK,
- 33:18but they're not be sharp,
- 33:19OK,
- 33:20but that's not health at every size.
- 33:21Intuitive eating is not a health of every size principle.
- 33:24Part of
- 33:25the
- 33:26my problem
- 33:27with the movement is that it's like,
- 33:28oh,
- 33:29but it's not,
- 33:29it's not that part.
- 33:30But it,
- 33:31but it is that part.
- 33:32It's you're saying our problem is that we conflate that
- 33:35all the things get con I'm saying it's your problem.
- 33:36You're conflating.
- 33:37I'm saying my,
- 33:38I'm saying my issue
- 33:40is that because it's become
- 33:43a patchwork quilt,
- 33:44an amalgamation.
- 33:46Of movements and voice.
- 33:48Oh,
- 33:48it's an activist.
- 33:48It's a,
- 33:49it's a,
- 33:49it's a political it's a,
- 33:50it's an influencer.
- 33:51It's a celebrity.
- 33:52It's a,
- 33:52it,
- 33:53there's no
- 33:55accountability for any of this.
- 33:56There's no
- 33:57through line,
- 33:58and it allows exploitation are in ways that I think can be hurtful.
- 34:02What,
- 34:02why isn't the entire public holding food companies,
- 34:06uh,
- 34:06accountable for food company evils?
- 34:08I think like why is it that,
- 34:10why is it
- 34:11you don't,
- 34:12you don't think so?
- 34:13I mean,
- 34:13they're,
- 34:14they're reevaluating the generally.
- 34:15Recognized as safe rule,
- 34:16they just changed the food pyramid,
- 34:18which guides.
- 34:19Do you want to talk about that one?
- 34:20It guides hundreds of billions of dollars in subsidies.
- 34:23And now they're mandating is,
- 34:26I'm saying that focused on the,
- 34:28on the definitely focused on it or part of it.
- 34:30OK.
- 34:31I think there are a lot of people that are focused on you do understand how,
- 34:33how and why they have significantly more
- 34:36resources than actual body positive activists,
- 34:39right?
- 34:40Saying that they don't have more resources.
- 34:42I'm saying,
- 34:43can you see this issue.
- 34:46What do we do about it?
- 34:48Um,
- 34:49well,
- 34:50do you think it's a pro,
- 34:50I think it's a problem.
- 34:52Uh,
- 34:53well,
- 34:53I think there are a lot of problems.
- 34:54I think one of the problems is the assumption
- 34:56that everything that has to do with,
- 34:59um,
- 35:00with,
- 35:01with food and its lack of health correlates with fatness
- 35:04because we are saying body positivity.
- 35:07Well,
- 35:07no,
- 35:07I'm saying we are saying body positivity,
- 35:09and body positivity
- 35:11includes all kinds of ways of being in a body,
- 35:13right,
- 35:13not just body size.
- 35:14It includes
- 35:15all of the things about disability and skin color
- 35:18and hair texture and all of the things,
- 35:19right?
- 35:19Body positivity,
- 35:20but we really have.
- 35:21Encoding that in this conversation to talk about body size,
- 35:25right?
- 35:25And,
- 35:25and you can understand about,
- 35:27OK,
- 35:27I actually didn't think body positivity,
- 35:29to be dead honest with you.
- 35:30I've never interpreted body positivity to be about skin color or gender ideology,
- 35:36but some of I really never did.
- 35:37I didn't.
- 35:38But some of the people who started body
- 35:39positivity and practice it today and talk about
- 35:43the values that,
- 35:44uh,
- 35:44I don't think anybody sees it that way.
- 35:46That is not a part of the movement.
- 35:48I think the general presumption.
- 35:50The general presumption is that it must
- 35:53focus on weight and weight loss because that's
- 35:54a bigger narrative in the culture than that is who we are seeing advocate.
- 35:59We're not seeing a person who's black being like,
- 36:02I'm body body positive because I'm black.
- 36:04They're in,
- 36:04they're generally in a different civil rights movement.
- 36:07So I think that discounts the black leadership in this movement,
- 36:09right?
- 36:10I'm saying it's an intersexual movement where I very rarely see
- 36:15people of color
- 36:16simply based on
- 36:18prejudice
- 36:19regarding their skin color.
- 36:22Using body positivity to make their point.
- 36:24I see them in like this is a movement.
- 36:27I see people who see people who
- 36:28have multiple identities
- 36:30that include their skin color,
- 36:32their gender presentation,
- 36:34their disability.
- 36:35They are talking about body positivity related to
- 36:38their body size and those other issues.
- 36:41We had somebody else earlier talk about that.
- 36:43I,
- 36:43I,
- 36:43I just,
- 36:44I've never seen it in all the years.
- 36:46Like I,
- 36:46I've seen active,
- 36:47I mean,
- 36:48has anybody else here seen that?
- 36:49Hang on,
- 36:50which you started,
- 36:51which you started,
- 36:52right?
- 36:52Or I'm sorry,
- 36:52I'm sorry,
- 36:53the organization that you work for,
- 36:55had to do with the gentleman that started this organization because his wife,
- 36:58label it however you would.
- 36:59I don't know what word you guys feel comfortable with.
- 37:02We've been using fat for 57 years,
- 37:04so.
- 37:04That's OK to use.
- 37:06OK,
- 37:06yes,
- 37:07but see,
- 37:08OK,
- 37:08like
- 37:09you are,
- 37:10but listen,
- 37:11Jillian,
- 37:12you've positioned yourself,
- 37:13you've positioned yourself as really,
- 37:15really knowing this movement and really knowing where we're showing up,
- 37:18and it is really,
- 37:19really common
- 37:20for activists and advocates to talk about using fat as a neutral descriptor.
- 37:28We just say fat,
- 37:29right?
- 37:29OK,
- 37:30fine,
- 37:30so this was started by a gentleman whose wife was fat,
- 37:33who was discriminated against.
- 37:35That's where your part began.
- 37:37Intuitive eating that's not how an animal came into it through body positivity,
- 37:41right,
- 37:41because we're mixing a lot of movement.
- 37:44that's how my organization started.
- 37:47The movement started with size black women and fems in the civil rights movement,
- 37:52with,
- 37:52with women,
- 37:53with people at Stonewall who were fat people,
- 37:56with fat performance.
- 37:57That's how the what's the through line though?
- 37:59What's the through line?
- 38:00What do you mean?
- 38:01OK,
- 38:01so,
- 38:02so people at Stonewall,
- 38:03is it because they were gay or because they were gay and as you guys say,
- 38:06fat,
- 38:06right?
- 38:07Is it because
- 38:08it was because they were gay.
- 38:10But there were fat people there and those fat people talked about their fat bodies.
- 38:15Gay people are part of the body positivity movement,
- 38:18uh,
- 38:18a huge part of it
- 38:19on the merits of just being gay,
- 38:21guys.
- 38:22That's what I'm
- 38:23gay
- 38:23and
- 38:24defending people's body sovereignty,
- 38:27people's body autonomy,
- 38:28uh,
- 38:29people's right to live freely in their body.
- 38:31We have different angles of discrimination.
- 38:33The core started with regard to being
- 38:36that.
- 38:37Am I right?
- 38:38That is what he started your organization.
- 38:41OK,
- 38:42healthy at every size.
- 38:43The beginning is about access for people,
- 38:47right,
- 38:47and health at every size principles talk
- 38:49about intersectionality and multi multiply marginalized people.
- 38:53All right,
- 38:53we
- 38:54we have to pause there now we have to pause
- 38:58of the movement.
- 38:59I'm sorry,
- 38:59we got to pause,
- 39:00guys.
- 39:00You've been voted out by the majority.
- 39:02Please return to your seat.
- 39:10So one thing that I want to clarify,
- 39:12I said it on the sidelines,
- 39:13which I know I shouldn't do,
- 39:13but it's health at every size,
- 39:15not healthy at every size,
- 39:16and you've misspoken that just a couple of times.
- 39:18I think it's important just for the audience to know that.
- 39:21Um,
- 39:22because there's a really big distinction there.
- 39:23Yes,
- 39:24you're absolutely right,
- 39:25and I think it started as health at every size,
- 39:28and I think now it has been
- 39:30co-opted by many or misinterpreted,
- 39:32misutilized.
- 39:33You don't think so.
- 39:33OK,
- 39:33I've seen very many people say I can be healthy at any size.
- 39:36Well,
- 39:36I think that size,
- 39:37I mean,
- 39:38I think that I can be very many people,
- 39:40and.
- 39:41I've debated with very many people who've utilized that point.
- 39:45Well,
- 39:45I do.
- 39:45I mean,
- 39:45I personally believe you
- 39:47can be healthy at any size.
- 39:49I don't.
- 39:50OK,
- 39:51that's fine.
- 39:51I'm not gonna debate that point because I don't
- 39:54think that that's what we're talking about right now.
- 39:56So
- 39:57I want to come back to when you were saying that.
- 40:00You know,
- 40:01big food is profiting off of the body positivity movement,
- 40:04and that's like a really terrible bad
- 40:07thing.
- 40:07OK,
- 40:08I don't think it's good.
- 40:09OK,
- 40:10so what is,
- 40:11what is your fear with that?
- 40:12Like,
- 40:12what's the what's,
- 40:13I want to understand your concern.
- 40:16I don't think we have enough time for me to tell you how deep my concerns are with.
- 40:19Let's do the TDRL.
- 40:21I didn't.
- 40:22I think that they,
- 40:24OK,
- 40:25let's,
- 40:25let's go back.
- 40:26God.
- 40:27All right,
- 40:27if we go back to the 70s.
- 40:29Uh,
- 40:29or,
- 40:29or like late 60s,
- 40:315% of American adults were obese or overweight,
- 40:34right?
- 40:35Now it's 74%.
- 40:37Like what happened?
- 40:38Did everybody just have a moral failing?
- 40:39Was it a quantum leap in genetics?
- 40:42They changed the BMI overnight I'm,
- 40:42no.
- 40:46Look at pictures,
- 40:47look at pictures of.
- 40:50It's more than BMI.
- 40:54childhood obesity did not even,
- 40:56it wasn't even a thing.
- 40:58Type 2 diabetes used to be called adult onset diabetes.
- 41:02What happened over the last 50 years?
- 41:04And what I'm saying is,
- 41:06I don't think it's a sudden moral failure.
- 41:08I don't think it's because 74% of American adults
- 41:11are lazy and weak and stupid and pathetic.
- 41:14I don't think so at all.
- 41:17No,
- 41:17you're misunderstanding what I'm saying.
- 41:19I think it's not.
- 41:21I think,
- 41:21but you do think it's an individual's
- 41:24responsibility when they do become in a fat body.
- 41:28I think that the system is largely rigged and 74% of American adults
- 41:34are having a real hard time fighting against it for a host of reasons.
- 41:38Hold on,
- 41:38for a host of reasons.
- 41:40One of those big reasons,
- 41:42one of those huge reasons is big food.
- 41:44And when you look at,
- 41:46but if big food,
- 41:46wait,
- 41:47can I want to pause you there,
- 41:47because if I know that you're very big in the Maha movement.
- 41:51And you're saying they're doing all of this amazing stuff,
- 41:53but then they cut SNAP benefits.
- 41:54And so access to food is such a huge reason
- 41:57for people to be able to have a nutritious diet.
- 42:00So how can you explain that when you're saying that big food is awful,
- 42:03terrible,
- 42:03all of these things,
- 42:04but then
- 42:05still align yourself with the movement that cut
- 42:07billions of dollars to people to get access to food.
- 42:11That,
- 42:11OK,
- 42:11hold on.
- 42:12I'm,
- 42:12I'm not saying this movement is perfect.
- 42:14I would not like to see people,
- 42:16what,
- 42:16what is called nutrition assistance.
- 42:17I don't think that's soda and chips and candy.
- 42:20Now,
- 42:20having changed the food pyramid,
- 42:22it's calories,
- 42:23it's not nutrition.
- 42:24I do think
- 42:26changing the food pyramid has now mandated
- 42:28that access to the foods on the food pyramid.
- 42:32is going to make it more available and it's going to take
- 42:35the hundreds of billions of our tax dollars
- 42:38that these guys captured in a subsidy flow.
- 42:40They the food pyramid is not about guidance for you,
- 42:43me,
- 42:44you.
- 42:44The food pyramid is about grabbing
- 42:47$600 billion over the past two decades
- 42:51to grow ultra processed food
- 42:54from the shitty ass GMO crops that are covered in poison,
- 42:57that then get grabbed by big food and loaded with more.
- 43:00Poison
- 43:01and then tinkered with,
- 43:02so you quite literally cannot eat just one.
- 43:04I think these guys are the
- 43:06devil.
- 43:07I do.
- 43:08And and the depth of my feeling about this,
- 43:11unfortunately,
- 43:12like this is what I mean.
- 43:13I don't,
- 43:13if we,
- 43:14if we're going to indict someone,
- 43:15like when you look at intuitive eating,
- 43:17it's awesome in theory.
- 43:19Feel your fullness.
- 43:20You can't,
- 43:21you cannot.
- 43:21I disagree with that though.
- 43:23We're out of time.
- 43:25Thank you.
- 43:26My next surrounded claim is that the body
- 43:28positivity movement oversimplifies disordered eating and trauma.
- 43:33All right,
- 43:33whoever wants to be the next debater,
- 43:36get to the chair in 321.
- 43:46I'm not going to assume,
- 43:47but I imagine you have some sort of maybe
- 43:50personal experience with eating disorders or disorder eating.
- 43:53Um,
- 43:54definitely as a kid,
- 43:55uh,
- 43:55would overeat.
- 43:56I wouldn't say binge eating disorder,
- 43:58but I would compulsively overeat.
- 44:00I would eat,
- 44:01uh,
- 44:01I have a connection with my father.
- 44:02I would eat to feel a sense of comfort.
- 44:04I would eat to feel a sense of control,
- 44:06um,
- 44:07without question.
- 44:07And did you
- 44:09feel shame and then go to therapy to work on that,
- 44:12or did you just
- 44:14I oversimplify it and then
- 44:16kind of,
- 44:17I didn't oversimple.
- 44:18I was 1314,
- 44:19and 15,
- 44:20so I didn't have the bandwidth,
- 44:23uh,
- 44:24to process what was actually going on.
- 44:26Um,
- 44:27I was in therapy for other things that were going on in my household,
- 44:30and I definitely was helped.
- 44:33So,
- 44:33um,
- 44:34I'm glad that you're able to,
- 44:35you know,
- 44:36go to therapy.
- 44:36That's not something that everyone is able to go to.
- 44:39It's a,
- 44:39it's a luxury and a privilege for a lot of people,
- 44:41especially in the United States.
- 44:43Um,
- 44:43I have dealt
- 44:45with an eating disorder since I was 7.
- 44:47That's when it was first
- 44:48realized.
- 44:49It wasn't diagnosed at 7,
- 44:50but it was realized at that point.
- 44:52Um,
- 44:52and my body fluctuated.
- 44:53I'm not going to use numbers because I think
- 44:55there are a lot of people that,
- 44:56um,
- 44:56have disordered eating that use numbers as a metric.
- 44:58And so they'll look at me and they'll,
- 45:00I'll say a metric,
- 45:00and then
- 45:01It'll,
- 45:01it'll cause,
- 45:02um,
- 45:03someone to be,
- 45:03um,
- 45:04someone to have what I like to call a shift
- 45:06in where they are now to where they're going to
- 45:08be down like a rabbit hole of disordered eating behaviors.
- 45:11Um,
- 45:12and,
- 45:12um,
- 45:12I think that trauma and
- 45:14eating disorders go hand in hand,
- 45:17um,
- 45:17but they're not exclusive.
- 45:18There are people that don't necessarily have any trauma,
- 45:20but somehow have developed some sort of eating disorder.
- 45:23My,
- 45:24my eating disorder.
- 45:25Um,
- 45:26was something that I,
- 45:28I had from a really young age and then just worsened
- 45:31because of my physical perception around people.
- 45:34But it wasn't something that,
- 45:35um,
- 45:36innately was trauma-based.
- 45:38Um,
- 45:38I am neurodivergent,
- 45:39and it was never diagnosed until I was,
- 45:41you know,
- 45:42almost 30.
- 45:43So,
- 45:44but that's not because of trauma.
- 45:45That's just because of my neurodivergence.
- 45:47That's how my brain is connected.
- 45:49And so sometimes with neurodivergent people,
- 45:51they have eating rituals,
- 45:52eating routines that are rigid.
- 45:54And So that's where mine came from.
- 45:56So to say
- 45:58it's
- 45:58oversimplifying,
- 46:00um,
- 46:00EDs,
- 46:01like body positivity is oversimplifying EDs,
- 46:03oversimplifying trauma,
- 46:04you're taking away the,
- 46:06the,
- 46:06the people that,
- 46:07um,
- 46:08that use the body positivity moment to find someone who they can relate to.
- 46:14And so they,
- 46:15someone that they can
- 46:16connect with that doesn't have the same road that maybe
- 46:19the,
- 46:20the,
- 46:20the masses had but has their same road.
- 46:23You've been voted out by the majority he's returned to your seat.
- 46:30Hi,
- 46:31hi,
- 46:32I'm Summer.
- 46:32How are you Gillian?
- 46:33Nice to meet you.
- 46:34Nice to meet you.
- 46:35OK,
- 46:35so the body positivity movement actually got me out of
- 46:39my eating disorder.
- 46:40And if that's OK,
- 46:41I would like to tell you a little bit about it.
- 46:43Absolutely.
- 46:43So
- 46:44growing up,
- 46:44I wasn't ever fat.
- 46:45I just have like I have large breasts.
- 46:47I have got a condition basically.
- 46:49I'm laughing because that would be my dream.
- 46:51That's the only reason I'm laughing.
- 46:53I was like,
- 46:53poor you.
- 46:55I'm sorry,
- 46:56go ahead.
- 46:57Not to,
- 46:57not to try to invalidate how you feel.
- 46:59That's OK.
- 47:00That's sorry,
- 47:00go ahead.
- 47:01Um,
- 47:01so I basically,
- 47:02I've got a condition called macromastia.
- 47:04Um,
- 47:05it means that my breasts will just continuously keep growing.
- 47:08Um,
- 47:08so I had to deal with this like my whole childhood
- 47:11and I got like picked on and bullied and stuff
- 47:14because I was 8 years old with like double D's.
- 47:16So
- 47:17that's absolutely OK.
- 47:19I went to the doctors and they actually told me that
- 47:21I had to lose weight in order to get a reduction.
- 47:24Um,
- 47:25at this point I was actually
- 47:26a Scottish size 6,
- 47:28which is a UK size 2.
- 47:31so
- 47:31like on the bottoms,
- 47:32just obviously not on my top.
- 47:34Uh,
- 47:35so this actually drove me into an eating disorder.
- 47:37And I started to starve myself and try and make myself thinner
- 47:41so that my breasts would get smaller
- 47:43and that never ever happened like they just continuously
- 47:47because it's a it's obviously a condition,
- 47:49so they just
- 47:50kept getting bigger as I was getting smaller and smaller.
- 47:53Um,
- 47:54and it wasn't until obviously the online platform
- 47:56made the body positivity movement
- 47:59more aware to me.
- 48:00And then that made that really,
- 48:01really helped me and it
- 48:03made me start eating more.
- 48:04It made me start
- 48:05posting more online about my body and
- 48:08I just think that your claims a little bit silly.
- 48:10Can I give you,
- 48:10can I give you some examples of course,
- 48:12please.
- 48:15While
- 48:16intuitive eating is actually not intended for people with eating disorders,
- 48:20I cannot tell you how many people
- 48:23have misinterpreted that.
- 48:24And I've ended up dealing with it personally for quite some time now.
- 48:28So for example,
- 48:29things like
- 48:31avoid
- 48:32diets where
- 48:34mechanistic
- 48:35eating is actually recommended
- 48:38for people with many different types
- 48:41of eating disorders.
- 48:42And even the women who started intuitive eating
- 48:45suggested that like,
- 48:46hey,
- 48:46this is a goal,
- 48:47not a treatment plan.
- 48:49But when you've got,
- 48:50I mean,
- 48:52Random people online
- 48:54who are,
- 48:54hey,
- 48:55you know,
- 48:56just listen to your feelings of fullness.
- 48:58You can't do that when you're anorexic.
- 49:00Your body no longer recognizes those satiety cues.
- 49:04It,
- 49:05it absolutely shuts it down
- 49:06and it's,
- 49:07oh,
- 49:07what was it,
- 49:08uh,
- 49:09listen to your hunger.
- 49:10Like these are,
- 49:11you cannot do that if you have binge eating disorder
- 49:14and
- 49:15You're feeding a deeper hunger.
- 49:17It's the fundamental
- 49:19ways in which things like intuitive eating
- 49:23have been misrepresented by the masses.
- 49:25And of course,
- 49:26I understand
- 49:27what it was intended for,
- 49:28but if you think that the vast majority of these people
- 49:31posting on TikTok have read the freaking guidelines of mechanistic eating,
- 49:35I think we're both dreaming.
- 49:37No,
- 49:38I get that,
- 49:38but
- 49:39I think the thing in my head is like,
- 49:41why do you care so much
- 49:43about someone else's body?
- 49:45In order to like try and argue against body positivity,
- 49:48like say someone's like
- 49:51fat,
- 49:51obese,
- 49:51whatever,
- 49:52walking on the street,
- 49:53that doesn't actually affect you as a person.
- 49:56So
- 49:57I don't understand why you would feel the need to fight
- 50:00for people that are arguing for that person to feel validated as a person.
- 50:05I'm not arguing for the person I don't know.
- 50:08However,
- 50:09there are people that do want help,
- 50:11and I think that this can.
- 50:15Leave them feeling
- 50:16exceptionally confused.
- 50:18Uh,
- 50:18and there are many that I have.
- 50:22Tried to personally help
- 50:23that have experienced
- 50:26feeling misled,
- 50:27misguided by some of the,
- 50:29or
- 50:29almost,
- 50:30almost all
- 50:31of the intuitive eating principles,
- 50:33and they're not being educated on that.
- 50:34But you could also argue like the latter,
- 50:36but there are a lot of people
- 50:38that actually want help,
- 50:39and I care that they,
- 50:40they get the most,
- 50:41but I don't think the body positivity movement is like just for obese people.
- 50:46Just for people that are drastically need help.
- 50:50So I was anorexic,
- 50:52and the body positivity movement helped me.
- 50:54Do you not think that the body positive movement
- 50:57helps them
- 50:58rather than shaming them?
- 50:59Because that's how they get in that place in
- 51:00the first place with other people shaming them constantly.
- 51:03I am not suggesting anyone should be shamed.
- 51:05You're completing two different issues.
- 51:07I,
- 51:07I don't think that I think in one,
- 51:09it's all one issue.
- 51:11It's not though,
- 51:11sweetheart.
- 51:12You're telling me that you think,
- 51:13uh,
- 51:15I,
- 51:15you think,
- 51:15I think
- 51:17shame is awesome.
- 51:18I,
- 51:18I don't.
- 51:19No,
- 51:19I didn't,
- 51:19I don't.
- 51:20I think that these tools or things like,
- 51:23oh,
- 51:23you know what,
- 51:24it's society,
- 51:25it's diet culture,
- 51:26it's this,
- 51:26it's that,
- 51:26it's bigotry.
- 51:28I'd like,
- 51:28no,
- 51:29dude,
- 51:29it's probably the fact that like somebody.
- 51:32God forbid
- 51:34touched you when you were a kid.
- 51:36I don't think that's appropriate or even.
- 51:38In the slightest bit,
- 51:40no one touched me.
- 51:41No,
- 51:41not you,
- 51:41dude.
- 51:42I'm not talking about you.
- 51:43No,
- 51:43I completely get that and I'm not talking about you mentioning like
- 51:46parents.
- 51:47I have two very loving parents.
- 51:49My parents never made me feel ashamed about my body.
- 51:51It was
- 51:52like
- 51:53TV shows like The Biggest Losers
- 51:55in the UK we've got
- 51:57um Supersize versus Superskinny,
- 51:59like it was all of these TV shows
- 52:01that made me feel like this.
- 52:02It wasn't my parents.
- 52:03I'm gonna suggest
- 52:05that I don't think you would be vulnerable.
- 52:08To TV shows
- 52:10if there wasn't a primary injury,
- 52:13because who cares,
- 52:14buddy?
- 52:15Do you know how much stuff like goes after me personally or
- 52:18after people of color or after gay people or after like.
- 52:22You have to remember I'm quite young,
- 52:24so when these came out I was very young,
- 52:26very impressionable,
- 52:27and I have like adults telling me that my body because my BMI is higher,
- 52:31I have adults telling me that my body is like
- 52:33you have to lose weight
- 52:35to fit in with normal people
- 52:37like you're young when you're impressionable and for
- 52:39you to be arguing against like body positivity,
- 52:42like I hope you don't have a daughter
- 52:44because my little sister
- 52:46like.
- 52:47It needs the body positivity movement.
- 52:49I think people need the body positivity movement
- 52:51because without it,
- 52:53everyone's just going to be looking at other people,
- 52:54judging other people like,
- 52:56I'm sure
- 52:57you think the body positivity movement is stopping people from being assholes?
- 53:01No,
- 53:01that's not what I said I think you're not right.
- 53:04That
- 53:05no,
- 53:05that's not what I don't think
- 53:07I said you think it stops people from judging other people.
- 53:09Yeah,
- 53:10no that's gonna happen.
- 53:12It's just not gonna hide it on their size or
- 53:14what they're like of course they are.
- 53:16They're not.
- 53:17OK,
- 53:17OK,
- 53:17pause.
- 53:18You've been voted out by the majority.
- 53:20Please return to your seat.
- 53:26Really nice to meet you Lilia.
- 53:28So I think the,
- 53:29the language there is a little bit tone deaf just because I actually believe that
- 53:35gym talk diet culture
- 53:38oversimplifies
- 53:39eating disorders,
- 53:41two separate issues though,
- 53:42both can be true at the same time.
- 53:44Both can be true,
- 53:45as in,
- 53:46as in you could absolutely be making,
- 53:48first of all,
- 53:48gym talk should have nothing to do with eating disorders.
- 53:51So you're right,
- 53:52but it's a separate issue than the claim I'm making.
- 53:54How is it separate?
- 53:55Well,
- 53:56OK,
- 53:56so you're saying gym talk
- 53:59oversimplifies trauma and eating disorders,
- 54:00right?
- 54:01Well,
- 54:01I not just gym talk,
- 54:03but just the way that our youth,
- 54:05all of us are.
- 54:08We are all exposed
- 54:10to that.
- 54:11Like we can't just avoid it.
- 54:12And
- 54:13when you see issue though,
- 54:15I,
- 54:15I'm trying to say
- 54:17that the ways body positivity suggests
- 54:22people
- 54:23deal with
- 54:24body issues and trauma
- 54:26is an oversimplification,
- 54:27and it has to do with things like
- 54:28intuitive eating principles that get misrepresented by influencers.
- 54:33OK,
- 54:33I can,
- 54:34I can definitely agree with that.
- 54:35Well then,
- 54:36unfortunately,
- 54:36you and I have.
- 54:37So far on the same page.
- 54:38Well,
- 54:38no,
- 54:39I think,
- 54:40well,
- 54:40well,
- 54:40the way I see it is that body positivity is actually the bridge between
- 54:45health experts
- 54:47and
- 54:48anybody else really
- 54:51because I think that.
- 54:54If I go to a doctor,
- 54:55it should be empowering for me to talk about my body.
- 54:59However,
- 55:00when I
- 55:01usually speak to a health expert,
- 55:02it's really not.
- 55:04I'm really more just afraid that they're going to
- 55:06speak to me in a way that degrades my body
- 55:09and makes me feel that shame that you've mentioned.
- 55:12Shame is not a motivator.
- 55:13It really
- 55:15turns people.
- 55:15Away
- 55:16whereas the body positivity movement teaches people to have the
- 55:20kind of confidence they need to make choices for themselves.
- 55:24When you look at yourself in the mirror and you tell
- 55:28yourself I'm ugly,
- 55:29I'm fat,
- 55:29I'm gross,
- 55:31I,
- 55:31I don't deserve to be,
- 55:32you know,
- 55:33alive to like some people get to that extent,
- 55:36right?
- 55:37When you do that to yourself,
- 55:39that is not going to motivate you to then go make the
- 55:42choices that I think we all know are healthy for us,
- 55:45which,
- 55:46which doesn't,
- 55:47then what's the next step though,
- 55:48dude?
- 55:49I think that's what we're here looking in the
- 55:51speak about.
- 55:51I think that actually.
- 55:54I'm,
- 55:54I'm healed.
- 55:56So that's not,
- 55:57that's not what body positivity,
- 55:58that's not what body positivity is.
- 56:01Body positivity is
- 56:02promoting the healing of said wounds.
- 56:06By,
- 56:06by I'm telling you it's an oversimplification.
- 56:09It's not though,
- 56:10tell me how,
- 56:11because how is it going to heal you by looking in the mirror and
- 56:14saying I know in the mirror and and saying these shameful things to yourself,
- 56:18you already know that it degrades you and you're not gonna want to do the things that
- 56:22most people comes after deciding not to beat yourself up.
- 56:25We're both on the same page there.
- 56:27Now get below the tip of your iceberg different perspectives of the same page,
- 56:31right?
- 56:32And I,
- 56:32that's why I do believe that body positivity is the bridge that we.
- 56:35All need.
- 56:36Tell me in order what comes after
- 56:39the moment you decide
- 56:41you're not going to say that shit in the mirror anymore,
- 56:43then what?
- 56:44Then I should be able to consult health experts
- 56:46that are also body positive towards my body.
- 56:50No one's saying not to.
- 56:52OK,
- 56:52so,
- 56:53so tell us who the health experts are
- 56:55that are body positive,
- 56:56because if I should be able to go to a doctor or would you want,
- 57:00when you say body positive,
- 57:01what kind of health expert are you looking for?
- 57:03I know a million doctors
- 57:05and all.
- 57:05would love to help somebody.
- 57:07But what is help is help saying you need to get your,
- 57:11your ass in the gym,
- 57:12you need to restrict your eating,
- 57:14whatever what is for you when you go to that.
- 57:16That's what I think everybody should have the opportunity
- 57:18and confidence to do,
- 57:20and that's what body positivity is
- 57:22teaching people.
- 57:23It's not teaching people that they're perfect in the mirror and that they don't
- 57:27deserve to have the courage to change.
- 57:29You still haven't given me a how.
- 57:31All you're telling me,
- 57:31I think we all are here to figure out how,
- 57:33because nobody has the answer.
- 57:35Not true.
- 57:37Many people have the answer,
- 57:38sweetheart.
- 57:39Psychoanalysts have the answer.
- 57:40Sorry,
- 57:40I don't like to be called sweetheart when we're like debating.
- 57:43Forgive me,
- 57:43but many people
- 57:45have the answer.
- 57:47OK,
- 57:47so,
- 57:47but you believe you have the answer,
- 57:49and you believe that somehow body positivity is not involved in
- 57:54bettering yourself.
- 57:56I just think that's contradictory.
- 57:58I really do.
- 57:58I don't see how.
- 58:00I,
- 58:00I think
- 58:01that there are absolutely experts that have
- 58:04the answer,
- 58:04and it's more.
- 58:05Than platitude.
- 58:06So what is the answer then to you if it's,
- 58:08if it's not getting treatment with a person who's gone to school and specializes in
- 58:12that would be great if you feel welcomed and comfortable in that person's space.
- 58:17There are many experts in the world that would welcome,
- 58:20OK,
- 58:20but especially ones that specialize in this category
- 58:24of medicine.
- 58:25But in this category of medicine,
- 58:26if there's not room for body positivity,
- 58:29then you're
- 58:30I I didn't say that's not the claim is that there's not room.
- 58:33I said it oversimplifies.
- 58:35It oversimplifies.
- 58:36Are you saying
- 58:38it oversimplifies people's trauma?
- 58:41No,
- 58:42I'm telling you it oversimplifies
- 58:44the complexity
- 58:46and the depth of these types of disorders,
- 58:49whether it's anorexia,
- 58:50whether it's bulimia,
- 58:52whether it's binge eating disorder,
- 58:54whether somebody is eating,
- 58:55and Summer was not referring to you,
- 58:57somebody's eating because let's say they were molested.
- 59:00And but,
- 59:01OK,
- 59:01but you saying you bringing up somebody's like eating because they were molested,
- 59:06I mean,
- 59:06most people,
- 59:07that's not why like necessarily people are eating.
- 59:10That's what the claim is about.
- 59:11It is about the fact
- 59:13that people
- 59:14who have disordered eating and trauma.
- 59:17I think the body positivity movement
- 59:20with things like intuitive eating specifically
- 59:23oversimplifying can actually give bad advice,
- 59:26but the fundamentals of the pause.
- 59:28You've been voted out by the majority.
- 59:30Please return to your seat.
- 59:35I've been on a diet since I was like 6.
- 59:38You've talked a lot about trauma,
- 59:39being molested,
- 59:41parents,
- 59:42this and that.
- 59:43I've heard of someone mentioned the BMI.
- 59:45I've heard people use the word obese.
- 59:48So what
- 59:49is your thought on
- 59:51this oversimplification?
- 59:52I think actually the medical industry and a lot of health professionals
- 59:56have oversimplified.
- 59:57I'm sorry if that's happened to you.
- 1:00:00I think you're seeing the wrong people.
- 1:00:02I know a lot of really good people,
- 1:00:04but that's also privilege.
- 1:00:05Of course,
- 1:00:05you know,
- 1:00:06a lot of good people.
- 1:00:06You're a rich white woman who's been on television.
- 1:00:10And I would love to know,
- 1:00:11you know,
- 1:00:11somebody mentioned the shows.
- 1:00:14Oh,
- 1:00:14I could read a book.
- 1:00:15I've read a lot of diet books,
- 1:00:16Gillian,
- 1:00:17not a diet book or whatever.
- 1:00:19What kind of book,
- 1:00:19a self-help book.
- 1:00:20Well,
- 1:00:21I mean,
- 1:00:21if you're struggling with an eating disorder and you're telling me I have no access
- 1:00:26to,
- 1:00:26how do I know if I'm struggling with an eating disorder?
- 1:00:29Where does genetics play into all of this?
- 1:00:31Do you want to take on genetics?
- 1:00:32We can go ahead.
- 1:00:33Are you a scientist?
- 1:00:36Do you think you have to be a scientist to understand,
- 1:00:38but I haven't heard one comment about where do genetics play in,
- 1:00:42that's not the claim.
- 1:00:43If,
- 1:00:43if you want to get into genetics
- 1:00:45and obesity.
- 1:00:47First of all,
- 1:00:47obesity is a very outdated term.
- 1:00:50It's based on the BMI,
- 1:00:52which.
- 1:00:52Based on white men in this,
- 1:00:54come on,
- 1:00:55Jillian,
- 1:00:55you could be single-handedly responsible for updating the BMI,
- 1:00:59OK,
- 1:00:59but we also have waist to hip,
- 1:01:01and we have DEXA
- 1:01:03and we have MRI,
- 1:01:04but let's be honest,
- 1:01:05what are the MRI,
- 1:01:06meaning like a machine most fat people don't even fit in.
- 1:01:09You have DEXA and I've never heard of that girl.
- 1:01:12What's a DEXA?
- 1:01:13These are normal people.
- 1:01:14We are on TikTok and hold on.
- 1:01:17There's also been a lot of like blame,
- 1:01:19sure,
- 1:01:19waist to hip ratio,
- 1:01:20but
- 1:01:20that's also like skeletal and like how do you know,
- 1:01:24waist to hip is not.
- 1:01:24It has to do with a ratio of
- 1:01:27your waist to your hips and it's,
- 1:01:29uh,
- 1:01:30evidence,
- 1:01:32sorry to say.
- 1:01:33Of excess visceral fat,
- 1:01:35that's what it's for,
- 1:01:36and that's an indicator
- 1:01:38of obesity.
- 1:01:39So obesity,
- 1:01:40that term,
- 1:01:41what does that mean to you?
- 1:01:43Obesity,
- 1:01:43it means that you have an unhealthy percentage of body fat.
- 1:01:46What is healthy?
- 1:01:47What is unhealthy?
- 1:01:49Like what is the measure of health for human beings?
- 1:01:52Women,
- 1:01:52I think it's in the 35+ percentile,
- 1:01:5535+ percentile of what by what measure?
- 1:01:58The DEXA.
- 1:01:5935%
- 1:02:01of your body weight being comprised of body fat.
- 1:02:04The thing that I think is most interesting is that you didn't get to earlier.
- 1:02:07You didn't ask me earlier.
- 1:02:08Well,
- 1:02:09I haven't gotten there is no,
- 1:02:10with someone else.
- 1:02:11You
- 1:02:12said,
- 1:02:12because I'm seeing a very different person
- 1:02:14than from who we've seen on television,
- 1:02:16and I think there's been a lot of blame shifting.
- 1:02:19To influencers and TikTok and the reality is,
- 1:02:21girl,
- 1:02:22that's where we're all getting our info now.
- 1:02:24I've never seen a full episode of The Biggest Loser
- 1:02:27because my parents told me to watch it and I said
- 1:02:29all the way off,
- 1:02:30right?
- 1:02:30But,
- 1:02:31but you have no rage at your parents whatsoever,
- 1:02:33right?
- 1:02:33Oh well,
- 1:02:34I'm not mad because of the rage all the way off.
- 1:02:36That doesn't sound like a primary wound telling your parents to
- 1:02:40all the way off the primary evidence of what I'm saying.
- 1:02:44Totally primary wound
- 1:02:46plus genetics
- 1:02:47plus whatever choices I make in my life is where what can I ask you something?
- 1:02:51Pick the argument we wanna have.
- 1:02:53Do you wanna have a debate?
- 1:02:54I want to hear who you are on the show,
- 1:02:56who that person is and was,
- 1:02:58and who this person is now,
- 1:02:59because I'm seeing.
- 1:03:01It's not at all.
- 1:03:02Can I say something?
- 1:03:03You just told me you never watched an episode of Big.
- 1:03:05Oh,
- 1:03:05but I've seen TikTok clips.
- 1:03:06I saw the documentary.
- 1:03:07I mean,
- 1:03:08have you,
- 1:03:08have you ever seen?
- 1:03:10A full episode,
- 1:03:12let's say with one of my contestants like Abby Wright.
- 1:03:15Tell me about the show.
- 1:03:16Tell me whatever.
- 1:03:16Tell me who you were on the show.
- 1:03:17Tell me where that
- 1:03:19Jillian Michaels,
- 1:03:19because to be honest,
- 1:03:20we've all talked.
- 1:03:22OK,
- 1:03:22I'm the exact same person that you see now.
- 1:03:25Now,
- 1:03:25of course,
- 1:03:26yes,
- 1:03:27you would see parts
- 1:03:29of what I was doing.
- 1:03:30You would never see the entire picture of what I was doing,
- 1:03:33and you would never understand why I was doing it.
- 1:03:36So let me address
- 1:03:37the part that you're thinking of,
- 1:03:39OK.
- 1:03:40I had a contestant,
- 1:03:42um,
- 1:03:42500 pounds.
- 1:03:45This
- 1:03:46contestant in particular
- 1:03:47had an exceptionally traumatic background.
- 1:03:50Can I
- 1:03:50tell you about it or you don't care?
- 1:03:52OK.
- 1:03:53So her mother was a prostitute.
- 1:03:55Uh,
- 1:03:56a sex worker,
- 1:03:57we say now
- 1:03:58her mother was a sex worker if,
- 1:03:59if,
- 1:04:00if that makes you feel
- 1:04:02safer,
- 1:04:03OK.
- 1:04:04That's a separate debate.
- 1:04:06And I'm not,
- 1:04:08let's standpoint.
- 1:04:09Let's standpoint before we get into all the woke ideology.
- 1:04:12So,
- 1:04:13having said that,
- 1:04:16The
- 1:04:17contestant
- 1:04:18named Shay,
- 1:04:19her mother
- 1:04:20used to
- 1:04:21sleep with men for heroin while she was locked in a closet.
- 1:04:25And
- 1:04:26she's gonna go home.
- 1:04:28Based on the percentages.
- 1:04:29I didn't make the game,
- 1:04:31not a producer,
- 1:04:32very publicly had
- 1:04:34issues with the name
- 1:04:35and
- 1:04:36the gamification.
- 1:04:37So
- 1:04:39I don't want her
- 1:04:40to go home.
- 1:04:41And certain things need to happen before
- 1:04:45I feel,
- 1:04:45and I have seen that there would be any hope
- 1:04:48of her being able to live past 40 years old.
- 1:04:52And she has
- 1:04:54all of the things,
- 1:04:55type 2 diabetes,
- 1:04:57the beginnings of chronic kidney disease,
- 1:04:59arterial plaque,
- 1:05:00all the things that are legitimately alarming.
- 1:05:04So
- 1:05:05I can't get her on this freaking ladder.
- 1:05:06It's day one.
- 1:05:08I can't get her on for 15 seconds.
- 1:05:10Tried everything.
- 1:05:12Cannot
- 1:05:12get her on this ladder
- 1:05:14for 15 seconds.
- 1:05:16And we're playing this out and we're playing it out,
- 1:05:19not getting anywhere,
- 1:05:20because the story is,
- 1:05:22I'm weak,
- 1:05:23I'm fat,
- 1:05:23I'm worthless,
- 1:05:24I'm this,
- 1:05:24I'm that,
- 1:05:24all the internalized shame.
- 1:05:27And at that moment,
- 1:05:28I've pretty much tried everything.
- 1:05:29What you don't see is this has gone on for about
- 1:05:314 hours and I can't get her on the freaking ladder.
- 1:05:34She comes in the room and I'm like,
- 1:05:35alright,
- 1:05:36that's it.
- 1:05:36I'm like,
- 1:05:37god damn it,
- 1:05:37get on this
- 1:05:38ladder,
- 1:05:39I swear to God,
- 1:05:40get on the
- 1:05:41ladder
- 1:05:42or you're gonna
- 1:05:43go home,
- 1:05:43get on the
- 1:05:45ladder,
- 1:05:45going crazy.
- 1:05:47And
- 1:05:48I'm utilizing her fear of me,
- 1:05:50quite honestly,
- 1:05:51to circumvent the story that she thinks is true.
- 1:05:54Long story short,
- 1:05:55she gets on the ladder,
- 1:05:56she climbs 15 seconds.
- 1:05:58Show up the next day.
- 1:06:00She's like,
- 1:06:01I got back on the ladder for 15 minutes last night.
- 1:06:04I was like,
- 1:06:04that's awesome,
- 1:06:05dude.
- 1:06:06And she ended up losing 300 pounds,
- 1:06:09so
- 1:06:10you may not agree with it,
- 1:06:11but it worked for me and it worked for Shay in that moment.
- 1:06:14You don't know why I'm doing it.
- 1:06:17You don't understand that it's a life or death intervention on a ticking clock.
- 1:06:21You don't understand all the other things I've tried,
- 1:06:23so I kind of don't
- 1:06:25care
- 1:06:26what she does.
- 1:06:27How much of her weight did she gain back?
- 1:06:29She gained,
- 1:06:30well,
- 1:06:30good one,
- 1:06:31because 95% of diets don't work,
- 1:06:33not,
- 1:06:33not my contestants.
- 1:06:3435% of them kept the weight off,
- 1:06:36which is actually exceptional,
- 1:06:37and I could give you all the names
- 1:06:39if 5% are able to keep it off.
- 1:06:41There are obviously
- 1:06:42a host of myriad of reasons as to why that's the case,
- 1:06:45but if I had a 35% success rate.
- 1:06:48Can you at least concede
- 1:06:50that maybe I'm doing a little bit better?
- 1:06:52The norm than the baseline.
- 1:06:53I can agree that the 1 celebrity trainer in the entire world has a success rate
- 1:06:58that I can concede to keep it off.
- 1:07:00They kept it off.
- 1:07:0130% of people that went on a public TV show 5%.
- 1:07:04All right,
- 1:07:04we gotta pause there.
- 1:07:05We are out of time.
- 1:07:07My final surrounded claim is that the
- 1:07:09body positivity movement is fundamentally disempowering.
- 1:07:13If you want to be the next debater,
- 1:07:15please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:07:22Hi,
- 1:07:23nice to meet you.
- 1:07:23Hi,
- 1:07:23nice to meet you.
- 1:07:24Hi,
- 1:07:25Zane.
- 1:07:26What form or what do you mean it's disempowering?
- 1:07:28Well,
- 1:07:28I perceive it as follows.
- 1:07:31First,
- 1:07:31it's externalized shame
- 1:07:33as opposed to appreciating that this is something that does arise within.
- 1:07:38And if you'll hear me all the way out,
- 1:07:39I,
- 1:07:39I think I can illustrate that for many it is actually a choice.
- 1:07:43Which I know sounds shocking to you,
- 1:07:45but just,
- 1:07:45just stay with me.
- 1:07:47So it externalizes it first,
- 1:07:49and then
- 1:07:51it invalidates it right off the top,
- 1:07:52right?
- 1:07:52It's bad,
- 1:07:53it's evil,
- 1:07:53it's this,
- 1:07:53it's that,
- 1:07:54instead of like,
- 1:07:55what can we explore?
- 1:07:56What can we learn here?
- 1:07:58And then it replaces it
- 1:08:00with things that I think are platitudes and really difficult to believe.
- 1:08:04Like,
- 1:08:04oh,
- 1:08:04no,
- 1:08:04I'm perfect,
- 1:08:05I'm beautiful,
- 1:08:06this,
- 1:08:06that,
- 1:08:06but
- 1:08:07it's not so easy to just believe those things.
- 1:08:09There's a lot of work that comes along with believing those things.
- 1:08:12So it can feel like gaslighting.
- 1:08:14And then the last thing is like anybody who tells you otherwise
- 1:08:17gets framed as a victimizer and concern
- 1:08:22can be shut down where I think it might be necessarily appropriate.
- 1:08:27So the way I would handle shame would be
- 1:08:30very different than the way I perceive the movement handling shame.
- 1:08:34And the same with acceptance.
- 1:08:35I think
- 1:08:37acceptance is key.
- 1:08:38But when I look at acceptance
- 1:08:41in terms of helping people,
- 1:08:43I like the serenity prayer best when it comes to Alcoholics Anonymous,
- 1:08:46right?
- 1:08:46So it's,
- 1:08:47God,
- 1:08:48give me the strength
- 1:08:49to accept what I cannot change,
- 1:08:51right?
- 1:08:52Give me the courage to change the stuff I can.
- 1:08:56And give me the wisdom to know the difference.
- 1:08:59I don't see 2 and 3 in the movement.
- 1:09:01But,
- 1:09:01but if you can
- 1:09:02illustrate it for me,
- 1:09:04yeah,
- 1:09:04I like to kind of like just share my personal story.
- 1:09:07I do want to share,
- 1:09:07and I think it's important that at my biggest,
- 1:09:09I was 335,
- 1:09:11which,
- 1:09:11you know,
- 1:09:11that
- 1:09:12that's my story
- 1:09:13and body positivity has has given me the confidence
- 1:09:17to,
- 1:09:17in my opinion,
- 1:09:18appropriately lose weight because I've lost 80 pounds.
- 1:09:20I don't think you
- 1:09:22have to do that.
- 1:09:22That's,
- 1:09:22you know,
- 1:09:22a personal choice.
- 1:09:23I think it's all about body sovereignty,
- 1:09:25more about.
- 1:09:26Not just losing weight,
- 1:09:27it's about
- 1:09:28what fits in your body,
- 1:09:29what are the best health choices for you specifically.
- 1:09:31It's different for everyone.
- 1:09:32Everyone has different goals.
- 1:09:33If it's
- 1:09:34building muscle or losing fat or also just
- 1:09:36increasing their mobility.
- 1:09:37I mean,
- 1:09:37I go to Pilates and yoga and it's great for those kind of things and it's super fun.
- 1:09:41But I think for me,
- 1:09:43that body positivity was the one thing that really helped me
- 1:09:46feel comfortable in my body.
- 1:09:48And what I can say is,
- 1:09:48and I see body positivity is,
- 1:09:50of course,
- 1:09:51you know,
- 1:09:51just
- 1:09:51welcoming who you are,
- 1:09:52accepting your body,
- 1:09:53and because I was able to do that,
- 1:09:55I was able to,
- 1:09:56you know,
- 1:09:57identify what I wanted to do with my body and that was to lose weight.
- 1:09:59Again,
- 1:09:59not something that you have to do.
- 1:10:01And I did it in a way where I appreciated myself.
- 1:10:03I appreciated my body rather than this inspiration of hatred.
- 1:10:07I think there's some people that
- 1:10:08are inspired by the hatred of their body
- 1:10:10and that they'll lose weight even at a rapid pace,
- 1:10:13losing like 30,
- 1:10:1340 pounds a month,
- 1:10:14which we know is not healthy.
- 1:10:15You know,
- 1:10:16sometimes like losing like,
- 1:10:17yeah,
- 1:10:18right.
- 1:10:18Average person,
- 1:10:19yes,
- 1:10:19I agree.
- 1:10:19I think people agree that,
- 1:10:20or I've seen like,
- 1:10:21you know,
- 1:10:215 to 8 or 10 pounds a month is
- 1:10:24kind of what you want to do in a healthy,
- 1:10:25like rapid,
- 1:10:26a way to lose weight.
- 1:10:27And I think sometimes if you're doing too much,
- 1:10:29that's right,
- 1:10:30it can
- 1:10:31and it can become unsustainable if that can happen.
- 1:10:35So.
- 1:10:36That's kind of what I would say.
- 1:10:37And because body positive was such a gateway for me
- 1:10:40to accept my body,
- 1:10:41that's how I think it's so appropriate and just so amazing for people who,
- 1:10:44and like you said,
- 1:10:45they are doing the work,
- 1:10:47maybe not necessarily physically,
- 1:10:48but I think that there is a mental component they have to address
- 1:10:51because
- 1:10:52without that mental component or that,
- 1:10:54that mental work you're doing,
- 1:10:55again,
- 1:10:55maybe they're just
- 1:10:56exercising or losing weight or whatever it is,
- 1:10:58or changing their body,
- 1:10:59altering it out of shame rather than,
- 1:11:01you know.
- 1:11:02My concern is that when I've worked with people who are obese or overweight.
- 1:11:09They don't appreciate,
- 1:11:10they,
- 1:11:10they feel victimized,
- 1:11:12and by the way,
- 1:11:12they,
- 1:11:12they have been victimized at one point or another in their lives.
- 1:11:16But if I cannot show them
- 1:11:18that where they are now
- 1:11:20is ultimately their own choosing,
- 1:11:23then they're fundamentally
- 1:11:24disempowered to make a different choice.
- 1:11:26So hear me out on shame for a second.
- 1:11:29So
- 1:11:30the movement is like
- 1:11:31diet culture does this to me.
- 1:11:33And,
- 1:11:34you know,
- 1:11:34uh,
- 1:11:35pick your,
- 1:11:35I have a whole list of stuff that,
- 1:11:37you know,
- 1:11:37beauty standards does this to me,
- 1:11:38media does this to me,
- 1:11:39all these different things do this to you.
- 1:11:42To me,
- 1:11:42that is a
- 1:11:43screen.
- 1:11:43It's a projection
- 1:11:45for when you actually first felt
- 1:11:47unloved,
- 1:11:48unsupported,
- 1:11:49not validated,
- 1:11:50right?
- 1:11:50And it's so much easier to say like Victoria's Secret is me instead of.
- 1:11:54My mother never came
- 1:11:57to any of my sporting events.
- 1:11:58My father was an alcoholic
- 1:12:00who never showed up for me.
- 1:12:02I,
- 1:12:02you know,
- 1:12:03all of these different primal wounds that occur when
- 1:12:05we're making it about the shit on the outside,
- 1:12:07who gives a fuck
- 1:12:09about Victoria's Secret,
- 1:12:10dude.
- 1:12:11So then on top of that,
- 1:12:12right,
- 1:12:13what I think most people don't appreciate
- 1:12:15is that we end up
- 1:12:17choosing shame,
- 1:12:18not consciously.
- 1:12:19Have you ever heard the quote?
- 1:12:21I'd rather be
- 1:12:23a sinner
- 1:12:24in a world with a God
- 1:12:25than a saint in a world without one.
- 1:12:28So in this analogy,
- 1:12:29the sinner is the child
- 1:12:31and God is the parent.
- 1:12:32I pause.
- 1:12:33You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:12:35Please return to.
- 1:12:37OK,
- 1:12:38it was a pleasure and thank you for sharing your story.
- 1:12:45Hi,
- 1:12:46hi,
- 1:12:47lovely to meet you.
- 1:12:48Um,
- 1:12:49so you said something about
- 1:12:51being inherently disempowering because you don't believe you can make changes,
- 1:12:55right?
- 1:12:55Am I?
- 1:12:55Am I,
- 1:12:57I'm suggesting that there is no framework.
- 1:13:00There's no,
- 1:13:01now that we've accepted where we are today,
- 1:13:04what can we take responsibility for and how can we take action?
- 1:13:08Sure.
- 1:13:09So,
- 1:13:10uh,
- 1:13:10are you familiar,
- 1:13:11you brought up a quote of your own.
- 1:13:12Are you familiar with the quote to those accustomed to privilege,
- 1:13:14equality can feel like oppression.
- 1:13:17Do you understand how weight
- 1:13:18is
- 1:13:19interactive and intersectional with all these other identities?
- 1:13:23When somebody is a fat person,
- 1:13:24it intersects with other aspects of the world that have marginalized them.
- 1:13:27Give me,
- 1:13:28give me examples.
- 1:13:29Example of a person,
- 1:13:30or no,
- 1:13:31no,
- 1:13:31no,
- 1:13:31uh,
- 1:13:31uh,
- 1:13:32of how you're feeling.
- 1:13:32What,
- 1:13:33how in ways you feel marginalized.
- 1:13:35And uh this,
- 1:13:37who are you speaking for?
- 1:13:38um.
- 1:13:40Anyone.
- 1:13:41I don't think it's about a specific person.
- 1:13:43I think.
- 1:13:44When you say that
- 1:13:46it is important to take responsibility for what you can change,
- 1:13:50you have seemed to have acknowledged that at the beginning,
- 1:13:53at that,
- 1:13:54um,
- 1:13:54first stage of,
- 1:13:55of acceptance or of understanding
- 1:13:57that you're
- 1:13:59trying to acknowledge that you can't hate yourself into
- 1:14:02a version of yourself that you can love.
- 1:14:04No,
- 1:14:05not really.
- 1:14:05No,
- 1:14:05you can't,
- 1:14:06but what I do think,
- 1:14:07hear me out,
- 1:14:08I do think that when you are feeling.
- 1:14:11Pain or shame,
- 1:14:12it is a signal to explore.
- 1:14:15I do think that,
- 1:14:16and I appreciate that you're coming at this from
- 1:14:17a place that involves the mental health as well.
- 1:14:20It sounds like you
- 1:14:21would be pro-therapy and pro understanding where these roots come from,
- 1:14:25um,
- 1:14:27but.
- 1:14:28Again,
- 1:14:29you can't,
- 1:14:29you can't change yourself.
- 1:14:31You can't go into changing yourself
- 1:14:34from the expectation that that will make you feel better about anything.
- 1:14:38And I don't think that our choices to
- 1:14:40make changes about ourselves reflect more self-love necessarily.
- 1:14:44They can,
- 1:14:45I think,
- 1:14:45if you choose to take,
- 1:14:46yeah,
- 1:14:47if you are choosing to take care of yourself,
- 1:14:50that comes from something within you
- 1:14:52that feels good for your body.
- 1:14:54And so the body positivity movement to me is not inherently about.
- 1:14:58It's not about taking,
- 1:15:01you know,
- 1:15:01diet culture and just saying that is the root of all evil.
- 1:15:04It,
- 1:15:05it amplifies
- 1:15:07the ways that we have been harmed and feel shame inside.
- 1:15:10It is
- 1:15:11a harmful thing that actively causes pain.
- 1:15:13Talk to me about
- 1:15:15what you'd like to see change.
- 1:15:17Diet culture.
- 1:15:17Eradicated.
- 1:15:18It's not going to though,
- 1:15:19buddy.
- 1:15:20And here's the thing,
- 1:15:21hear me,
- 1:15:21it's just not.
- 1:15:22This is the world we live in,
- 1:15:23right?
- 1:15:24There's,
- 1:15:24so you think that's acceptable?
- 1:15:25We also live in a world of racism and homophobia.
- 1:15:27I don't understand.
- 1:15:28But all the more to my point,
- 1:15:29right?
- 1:15:30So think of it as follows.
- 1:15:32I would say there are probably millions of people that hate me.
- 1:15:34I get death threats all
- 1:15:36the time too.
- 1:15:39Oh well,
- 1:15:40it is what,
- 1:15:41but wait,
- 1:15:41just so that is what you say there is accepted.
- 1:15:44Let me,
- 1:15:44no,
- 1:15:45let me finish my thought.
- 1:15:46What I'm telling you is that I don't define my worth
- 1:15:50on the ways in which external,
- 1:15:52absolutely,
- 1:15:53no,
- 1:15:53I fully agree with you because I can't change that.
- 1:15:55I can change how I respond to it.
- 1:15:57I can change how I feel about it.
- 1:15:59But you are trying to change the world
- 1:16:03because something I think the world needs to be changed,
- 1:16:05and it,
- 1:16:06it does,
- 1:16:06but we can't rely on that for your feeling of well-being.
- 1:16:09You're right,
- 1:16:09but we shouldn't rely on validation that we are thin enough either.
- 1:16:13Who's relying on that?
- 1:16:14Plenty of people.
- 1:16:15Do you realize 74% of the country is overweight or obese?
- 1:16:19All right,
- 1:16:19pause.
- 1:16:20You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:16:22Please return to your seat.
- 1:16:30Uh,
- 1:16:30I'm curious about what your definition of
- 1:16:31body positivity is because you're talking about shame
- 1:16:34and you're talking about personal feelings and emotion,
- 1:16:37and I have a little bit different of a definition of body positivity.
- 1:16:39Some of yours,
- 1:16:40so.
- 1:16:42When I think about the body positivity movement,
- 1:16:44I actually think about its roots in the fat rights movement,
- 1:16:46which is where I worked in the 60s.
- 1:16:48In the 60s.
- 1:16:49I run NAFA,
- 1:16:50which is a fat organization that was founded in the 60s.
- 1:16:53And,
- 1:16:53um,
- 1:16:54and when I think about
- 1:16:55the folks who have been using that terminology since the 70s,
- 1:16:5980s,
- 1:16:5990s,
- 1:17:00not just the people who kind of popped up using it.
- 1:17:02On Instagram and Tumblr in the 2000s,
- 1:17:05but that it has this long,
- 1:17:06long history.
- 1:17:07That long,
- 1:17:07long history is actually about body justice.
- 1:17:09It's not just about individual feelings.
- 1:17:12It's not just about,
- 1:17:13you know,
- 1:17:14my mother-in-law said something to me at dinner or
- 1:17:17my,
- 1:17:17you know,
- 1:17:18this guy didn't want to date me because I was fat.
- 1:17:19It's actually also about things like.
- 1:17:21Do I have access to health care,
- 1:17:23weight neutral healthcare that actually treats my sys symptoms,
- 1:17:26not just my body,
- 1:17:28right?
- 1:17:28Do I have access to equal pay?
- 1:17:30Do I have,
- 1:17:31um,
- 1:17:31accommodations for the body that I'm in right now,
- 1:17:33not the body that I might be in someday?
- 1:17:35And so I think about these
- 1:17:37systemic
- 1:17:38disenfranchisements and discriminations that happen to people,
- 1:17:42especially people in larger bodies,
- 1:17:44and
- 1:17:45when I
- 1:17:46want to.
- 1:17:48Embrace body positivity,
- 1:17:50it's more than just that personal self-esteem piece,
- 1:17:53but what you seem to be talking about is the personal self-esteem.
- 1:17:56Not true.
- 1:17:57That's not just what I'm talking about,
- 1:17:58and I'm not going to
- 1:18:00disagree with you on any of what you just said.
- 1:18:01I'm well aware of where this started,
- 1:18:03and it was,
- 1:18:03I think,
- 1:18:03a gentleman that was pretty.
- 1:18:04Upset about how his wife was being treated,
- 1:18:06right?
- 1:18:06And he started it.
- 1:18:07I do know that origin story.
- 1:18:08I do know a lot about it.
- 1:18:10In my opinion,
- 1:18:11there's no question it has been co-opted.
- 1:18:13And
- 1:18:14when the vast majority of your TikTok influencers don't know
- 1:18:19the origin of your story,
- 1:18:21and those messages are communicated in 15 2nd memes,
- 1:18:25then you own meme consequences.
- 1:18:27And that's where I take umbrage with it.
- 1:18:30And it's become this amalgamation.
- 1:18:33Of rolling up different movements along the decades.
- 1:18:36So we can't be like,
- 1:18:37well,
- 1:18:37I'm gonna carve out the part that's the,
- 1:18:39you know,
- 1:18:39the,
- 1:18:39the,
- 1:18:40the bride's piece and forget,
- 1:18:41don't,
- 1:18:42don't look over here.
- 1:18:43I look at it in its entirety,
- 1:18:45and there are parts of it
- 1:18:46that I take umbrage with.
- 1:18:48That's,
- 1:18:49that's how I feel about the health and wellness industry,
- 1:18:51right?
- 1:18:51I look at it in its entirety.
- 1:18:53There are parts that I take umbrage with,
- 1:18:54and we know,
- 1:18:55when you introduced yourself,
- 1:18:56you talked about being a health advocate.
- 1:18:58Does your advocacy include
- 1:19:00making sure that people are not discriminated against?
- 1:19:02Without question.
- 1:19:03So how do you do that for people in larger bodies?
- 1:19:06Well,
- 1:19:07personally,
- 1:19:07I don't get involved in that kind of policy outside of.
- 1:19:09I do in relationship to big agriculture,
- 1:19:12big food,
- 1:19:13big pharma,
- 1:19:14big insurance.
- 1:19:14That's my primary focus when it comes to policy.
- 1:19:17To be dead honest,
- 1:19:18I think you probably do a better job in this area than I do.
- 1:19:21Um,
- 1:19:22but I would never
- 1:19:23ever,
- 1:19:24uh,
- 1:19:24disagree with you here.
- 1:19:26Um,
- 1:19:27I would cooperate with you in any way you ask me to.
- 1:19:30So would you say
- 1:19:31that it should be against the law to
- 1:19:33discriminate against people based on their body size?
- 1:19:35Unquestionably.
- 1:19:36So why don't we see more fitness and wellness advocates
- 1:19:39asking for that?
- 1:19:40I'm happy to ask for it.
- 1:19:41I'll ask for it right now.
- 1:19:42I didn't know that you thought I wasn't for it.
- 1:19:44Of course I feel that way.
- 1:19:45Well,
- 1:19:46I feel,
- 1:19:46I,
- 1:19:46I didn't know your personal view on the laws
- 1:19:49specifically or public policy specifically in this particular.
- 1:19:51Or civil rights way,
- 1:19:53but certainly,
- 1:19:53would you agree with me that your industry is not like we
- 1:19:55don't see a bunch of fitness professionals coming out and being like,
- 1:19:58hey,
- 1:19:58we should actually talk more about the way that people are discriminated against
- 1:20:02instead of,
- 1:20:02hey,
- 1:20:02we should actually talk about how those people should
- 1:20:04lose weight if they don't want to be discriminated.
- 1:20:06Absolutely fair point.
- 1:20:07Thank you.
- 1:20:11Will you contact your representative and say it to them?
- 1:20:15You're looking at her.
- 1:20:15I'm like,
- 1:20:16girl,
- 1:20:17y'all heard it right here.
- 1:20:18Jillian Michaels said,
- 1:20:20I will,
- 1:20:20I will contact my representatives.
- 1:20:22I'm right here.
- 1:20:23I'll give you my cell phone.
- 1:20:24All right,
- 1:20:25pause.
- 1:20:25Uh,
- 1:20:26Tiger has won her section of Tiger.
- 1:20:37Hi,
- 1:20:38my name is Rachel.
- 1:20:39Nice to meet you,
- 1:20:39Rachel.
- 1:20:39Um,
- 1:20:40a little bit of background on me first.
- 1:20:42Um,
- 1:20:43I'm a personal trainer.
- 1:20:44Um,
- 1:20:44I would consider myself an
- 1:20:47advocate for the body positivity movement,
- 1:20:49um,
- 1:20:49not particularly an activist,
- 1:20:51but somebody who supports all bodies being in the fitness industry,
- 1:20:56um.
- 1:20:57But then we're talking about shame.
- 1:21:00So
- 1:21:00I'm trying to show you.
- 1:21:03Why somebody would choose
- 1:21:05to internalize a lack of worth,
- 1:21:07which results in toxic shame.
- 1:21:10So,
- 1:21:10real quick,
- 1:21:11healthy shame is
- 1:21:12if I acted like a douche to one of you.
- 1:21:15And
- 1:21:16I went home tonight and I was like,
- 1:21:17oh God,
- 1:21:18I was feeling insecure.
- 1:21:19I was feeling overwhelmed.
- 1:21:20I acted like an asshole.
- 1:21:22I regret that.
- 1:21:23How can I change that next time?
- 1:21:25That's gonna be something very different.
- 1:21:27Just,
- 1:21:27just wait,
- 1:21:27just hold on.
- 1:21:28OK,
- 1:21:29then something toxic shame,
- 1:21:30you're bad.
- 1:21:32Not the thing you did could improve,
- 1:21:34not being.
- 1:21:36Uh,
- 1:21:37analytical and exploring your behavior and agreeing to change it.
- 1:21:40So toxic shame is the internalization
- 1:21:43of not being good enough,
- 1:21:44right?
- 1:21:45So what I'm trying to illustrate is that many of the people
- 1:21:48who
- 1:21:49end up in that position feeling that way.
- 1:21:52have chosen that feeling because it is safer
- 1:21:56than accepting
- 1:21:58you were pri primally abandoned as a kid.
- 1:22:02So the idea
- 1:22:03is that if you can be better.
- 1:22:06Then you'll get what you need.
- 1:22:08If I'm externalizing shame on shit like diet culture,
- 1:22:12this
- 1:22:13origin wound
- 1:22:14never gets healed.
- 1:22:16And if I don't accept
- 1:22:18that it wasn't them who did this to me,
- 1:22:20if I can say wow.
- 1:22:22I let this defense structure build inside of me to protect myself at a time
- 1:22:28when it meant my psychological survival,
- 1:22:30but now this is no longer serving me.
- 1:22:34I think that's a better way to work it through.
- 1:22:37OK.
- 1:22:38How did we go from the word body positivity
- 1:22:42to shame?
- 1:22:43It,
- 1:22:44this is an umbrella that we're looking at.
- 1:22:46We're talking about diet culture,
- 1:22:47which is like
- 1:22:49such like a micro point in the movement.
- 1:22:52Like we're not just talking about big bodies,
- 1:22:54we're talking about
- 1:22:55all bodies.
- 1:22:57So all bodies don't feel shame.
- 1:23:00But shame,
- 1:23:01I mean,
- 1:23:02it is a core
- 1:23:04we're talking about positive.
- 1:23:05Have you ever felt shame?
- 1:23:07Of course
- 1:23:08shame is not size exclusive.
- 1:23:11I didn't say it was,
- 1:23:12but then why is a movement that was created to make
- 1:23:16people feel better about the body that does it do that?
- 1:23:19Tell me.
- 1:23:19You don't think it has a protocol for addressing shame.
- 1:23:22It's pretty explicit.
- 1:23:24No,
- 1:23:24but have you ever been in a bigger body?
- 1:23:27Yeah,
- 1:23:27I was 175 pounds at 13
- 1:23:295 ft tall.
- 1:23:30OK.
- 1:23:31Um,
- 1:23:31I also was,
- 1:23:33uh,
- 1:23:33overweight previously.
- 1:23:35Like when everybody is telling you that you are not good the way that you are,
- 1:23:39like
- 1:23:40you have to like love yourself.
- 1:23:42You have to invite love into the space.
- 1:23:44How?
- 1:23:45By looking at yourself in the mirror and telling yourself,
- 1:23:48I'm beautiful,
- 1:23:49it's not gonna work,
- 1:23:49kid.
- 1:23:50It does.
- 1:23:50It's an SNL skit.
- 1:23:52It's not.
- 1:23:52Yes,
- 1:23:53it is.
- 1:23:54How it's positive affirmations like we're like,
- 1:23:56no,
- 1:23:57no,
- 1:23:57no,
- 1:23:57this is like real,
- 1:23:58like how we affirmation,
- 1:23:59how he's dealing with a bullet wound
- 1:24:02with a band-aid,
- 1:24:03OK,
- 1:24:04but
- 1:24:04you're,
- 1:24:05you have to speak to yourself with love.
- 1:24:07Exercise can be a very shameful thing for people in a
- 1:24:09bigger body where they already don't feel invited into the spaces.
- 1:24:13No,
- 1:24:13but it's the.
- 1:24:14I brought up body positivity and you brought up shame.
- 1:24:17Shame is how shame is dealt with
- 1:24:20is an integral part of the body positivity movement.
- 1:24:23You're saying it's not
- 1:24:24how shame is dealt with.
- 1:24:26No,
- 1:24:26it's how people manage their shame.
- 1:24:28It's externalized
- 1:24:29and then it's invalidated
- 1:24:31and
- 1:24:32that same form of self,
- 1:24:33that same form of what you call shame,
- 1:24:35I call self-love,
- 1:24:37and that same feeling shame.
- 1:24:40You're calling the feeling of feeling uncomfortable in the size of your body shame.
- 1:24:44No,
- 1:24:45I'm not.
- 1:24:45I'm saying that the movement
- 1:24:48suggests
- 1:24:49you address shame by externalizing it.
- 1:24:52Diet culture made me feel this way.
- 1:24:55Uh,
- 1:24:57made me feel this way,
- 1:24:58not diet culture,
- 1:24:58bye-bye,
- 1:24:59body positivity.
- 1:25:00I'm a woman with a baby.
- 1:25:01I am 6 months postpartum.
- 1:25:04I,
- 1:25:04body positivity is for me too.
- 1:25:06I have loose skin on my stomach.
- 1:25:08I don't look the same as I did before I had a child.
- 1:25:11I gained 70 pounds and had to work to lose it because that was my choice,
- 1:25:15and I wanted to move my body to feel better.
- 1:25:17So body positivity.
- 1:25:18It's not diet culture.
- 1:25:19There's like more bodies that fit into this
- 1:25:21umbrella that you're talking about than just like,
- 1:25:23oh,
- 1:25:24big people.
- 1:25:25Oh,
- 1:25:25I'm not saying that there aren't.
- 1:25:27Then what is this diet like?
- 1:25:28Why diet culture?
- 1:25:29Like why is that the first thing that rings your bell?
- 1:25:31Like when you think of that the first thing that rings my bell,
- 1:25:33but what I'm suggesting
- 1:25:35is that very often,
- 1:25:36what's the first thing you think of?
- 1:25:38What's the when you first think of gosh,
- 1:25:39there's many different
- 1:25:41pieces to this patchwork first thing you think of when you think of.
- 1:25:45Honestly the word fat?
- 1:25:46I think no.
- 1:25:47Then what is it?
- 1:25:48Uh,
- 1:25:48I think of
- 1:25:49people who have been really hurt,
- 1:25:52uh,
- 1:25:52rejecting the things that they have felt rejected by.
- 1:25:57All right,
- 1:25:57boss,
- 1:25:58we're out of time.
- 1:25:59Please return to your seat.
- 1:26:01Thank
- 1:26:02you.
- 1:26:04OK,
- 1:26:04Jillian,
- 1:26:05great job,
- 1:26:05great job,
- 1:26:06everybody so far.
- 1:26:06We have 10 minutes for one final debater,
- 1:26:08so look around the room
- 1:26:10and select somebody who you would like to spend that last 10 minutes with,
- 1:26:14somebody maybe who you think you haven't finished
- 1:26:16the conversation with or you think they,
- 1:26:18they challenged you in a way that you want to keep moving.
- 1:26:19I,
- 1:26:20I wanna talk about the genetics piece.
- 1:26:22I,
- 1:26:22OK,
- 1:26:23I
- 1:26:24talk about a lot of things.
- 1:26:25My surrounded claim is that
- 1:26:27shame.
- 1:26:28Is far more dangerous than body positivity.
- 1:26:33I don't disagree with you.
- 1:26:34I disagree with how it handles shame.
- 1:26:36Let's talk about the show.
- 1:26:38OK.
- 1:26:38Tell me more about your,
- 1:26:40I guess,
- 1:26:40tactics or who,
- 1:26:41who Jillian Michaels is to the world.
- 1:26:44I can't describe who Jillian Michaels is to the world.
- 1:26:46I'm something to everybody,
- 1:26:47to some people,
- 1:26:49I,
- 1:26:49I,
- 1:26:50I'm a hero that saved their life,
- 1:26:51which I never listen,
- 1:26:53I disown% of people.
- 1:26:54Hold on,
- 1:26:54I disown that completely.
- 1:26:55I'm.
- 1:26:56It's not my accomplishment.
- 1:26:57It's a projection,
- 1:26:58right,
- 1:26:58of,
- 1:26:59of,
- 1:27:00I know you guys don't like this talk,
- 1:27:01but it is a projection of the,
- 1:27:02the good mommy.
- 1:27:03I'm,
- 1:27:03I'm not that.
- 1:27:04I'm also the bad mommy.
- 1:27:05I'm the evil person that made them
- 1:27:07overweight and I did this to them.
- 1:27:09I'm all these things to all these people.
- 1:27:11Who's Jillian Michaels?
- 1:27:12I mean,
- 1:27:13I'm 5'2.
- 1:27:14Uh,
- 1:27:15I spend a lot of money on laser hair removal.
- 1:27:17Uh,
- 1:27:18I got two kids.
- 1:27:19Uh,
- 1:27:20I,
- 1:27:21I mean,
- 1:27:22how do you raise your kids?
- 1:27:23You use fear and shame to raise them?
- 1:27:25Does it seem like I use fear and shame to raise them?
- 1:27:28Yeah,
- 1:27:28because you talk about using fear and shame.
- 1:27:31I don't
- 1:27:32talk about,
- 1:27:32first of all,
- 1:27:33that is a
- 1:27:34Life or death
- 1:27:36intervention
- 1:27:37on a ticking clock because you look at me and see
- 1:27:40a life or death need for an intervention right now.
- 1:27:43Be honest,
- 1:27:44you might do.
- 1:27:46We don't have a ticking clock,
- 1:27:48which means that if you chose to
- 1:27:52reach out to me,
- 1:27:52we're all on a ticking clock,
- 1:27:54not in the way that you go home in a week,
- 1:27:56dude,
- 1:27:57in the way that I get 6 days
- 1:28:00to try to figure out,
- 1:28:01to try to help you.
- 1:28:02OK,
- 1:28:03that's,
- 1:28:03so you're back to the show now,
- 1:28:04the ticking clock.
- 1:28:05I thought we were talking about,
- 1:28:06but you're asking me about fear,
- 1:28:08and I'm telling you that parenting and Biggest Loser,
- 1:28:12there's no parallel.
- 1:28:13OK,
- 1:28:13so shame.
- 1:28:14OK,
- 1:28:15shaming someone.
- 1:28:16So like,
- 1:28:16I didn't say it's OK to shame someone.
- 1:28:19I'm telling you that the utilization
- 1:28:22of these emotions,
- 1:28:23I'm telling you that shame is a signal.
- 1:28:26It's telling you,
- 1:28:26hey,
- 1:28:27look over here.
- 1:28:29This,
- 1:28:29this here,
- 1:28:31so,
- 1:28:31but shame from the world,
- 1:28:33like any shame I've felt from,
- 1:28:34OK,
- 1:28:35we'll start here.
- 1:28:37And you're externalizing shame,
- 1:28:38which is exactly what I don't agree with,
- 1:28:40and you're saying that I've externalized it by carrying it on my body as well.
- 1:28:44No,
- 1:28:44I'm saying that's a little bit of what
- 1:28:46you said earlier about the trauma is externalized.
- 1:28:48Well,
- 1:28:48that would be
- 1:28:50utilizing your body.
- 1:28:52As a container to manage
- 1:28:54emotions,
- 1:28:54if we're talking about in this particular instance.
- 1:28:56I can give you an example of that,
- 1:28:58but we're not.
- 1:29:00So I'm not talking about shaming someone.
- 1:29:02I fundamentally disagree with that concept.
- 1:29:04I'm talking about the shame that is already there,
- 1:29:08not externalizing it.
- 1:29:10I'm talking about
- 1:29:11appreciating the fact that like,
- 1:29:13OK,
- 1:29:14this is arising from within me.
- 1:29:16Where is this coming from and why?
- 1:29:20If we instead of going,
- 1:29:21oh,
- 1:29:21I think I'm ashamed because of what they did or what they told me or what,
- 1:29:23now listen,
- 1:29:24people are absolutely
- 1:29:26at one point or another,
- 1:29:28very often victims.
- 1:29:29However,
- 1:29:30how we choose to respond.
- 1:29:33To that injury,
- 1:29:34OK,
- 1:29:35at one time,
- 1:29:36absolutely meant your psychological survival.
- 1:29:39It is how you survived that injury.
- 1:29:42The problem is it perpetuates
- 1:29:44and it no longer serves.
- 1:29:46But if we continue to repeat the pattern,
- 1:29:48it's actually called,
- 1:29:49has a name.
- 1:29:50It's called a repetition compulsion.
- 1:29:52And the goal,
- 1:29:52right,
- 1:29:53is I will master this.
- 1:29:54I will play this out.
- 1:29:55It's safer to play it out externally than
- 1:29:58where those feelings really belong because that's painful.
- 1:30:01It's also safer because you don't have to suffer
- 1:30:04the
- 1:30:05primal loss of whatever was missing.
- 1:30:09So now,
- 1:30:09can I give you an example?
- 1:30:11I'm a shitty parent.
- 1:30:12We talked about this,
- 1:30:12but just follow me,
- 1:30:13right?
- 1:30:14I'm a shitty parent.
- 1:30:14I'm not there for you.
- 1:30:16OK.
- 1:30:16Instead of you saying,
- 1:30:18oh my God,
- 1:30:18my mom was never available,
- 1:30:20I didn't get what I needed,
- 1:30:21and there's a,
- 1:30:22you know,
- 1:30:22there's
- 1:30:23people that feel that way,
- 1:30:24OK.
- 1:30:26We then internalize it and go,
- 1:30:27it must be because I'm not good enough.
- 1:30:30Hence the center part,
- 1:30:31OK?
- 1:30:32Not because mommy is unavailable due to her own limitations.
- 1:30:36Instead,
- 1:30:36it gets internalized,
- 1:30:38and that is what becomes toxic shame.
- 1:30:41What is the primal injury
- 1:30:44that
- 1:30:44begot this emotion
- 1:30:46and subsequently,
- 1:30:47how do I deal with it where it's appropriate,
- 1:30:49meaning
- 1:30:50the right,
- 1:30:50like,
- 1:30:51not Victoria's Secret,
- 1:30:52OK,
- 1:30:52that the primal wound.
- 1:30:54And then in
- 1:30:55experiencing that loss,
- 1:30:56feeling those feelings,
- 1:30:57which really sucks and really hurts,
- 1:30:59which is why people have
- 1:31:00defense structures,
- 1:31:01coping mechanisms,
- 1:31:02so on and so forth.
- 1:31:04The way through that,
- 1:31:05you feel it,
- 1:31:06and then
- 1:31:07after you grieve it,
- 1:31:08after you explore it,
- 1:31:09then
- 1:31:10we can implement
- 1:31:11await release.
- 1:31:14No,
- 1:31:14my trauma.
- 1:31:15No,
- 1:31:15a perspective I've released it and therefore,
- 1:31:18then I will be fit.
- 1:31:19A perspective shift and a behavior change.
- 1:31:22Yes,
- 1:31:22of course.
- 1:31:23I've been
- 1:31:24desperate.
- 1:31:24My Entire life to change my behaviors
- 1:31:27and shift my this and change my eating
- 1:31:29and by factor and go on this diet and sign up for the trainer and go to the gym
- 1:31:34and do the thing and pay thousands of dollars and get the peloton and go to SoulCycle.
- 1:31:37That's all surface stuff,
- 1:31:39Sure,
- 1:31:39but the shame,
- 1:31:41yes,
- 1:31:41never came
- 1:31:43from
- 1:31:44myself.
- 1:31:44I
- 1:31:45The shame is external factors,
- 1:31:47and now it is why remember when you said to me positivity.
- 1:31:49Remember when you said to me earlier,
- 1:31:51fuck my parents.
- 1:31:52OK,
- 1:31:53I didn't say it like that.
- 1:31:54Mommy's watching.
- 1:31:55Me and mommy's watching.
- 1:31:57But here,
- 1:31:57let's talk about the parental wound.
- 1:31:59I'll tell you how my parent was wounded.
- 1:32:01Wanna talk about that?
- 1:32:03Because here's the thing,
- 1:32:03I feel like you are saying.
- 1:32:06Maha Maga,
- 1:32:07it's too close.
- 1:32:08I think they should have picked a different name.
- 1:32:09We could work on that.
- 1:32:10But my thing is,
- 1:32:12is that
- 1:32:13what you're saying is I feel that there's,
- 1:32:15you're coming to the table.
- 1:32:16You're like,
- 1:32:16listen,
- 1:32:17I think that I'm a little bit scared this is an ad for Maha,
- 1:32:20but no,
- 1:32:20forget,
- 1:32:21I'm not talking about Maha.
- 1:32:22Jillian Michaels is saying she wants a seat at the table.
- 1:32:25She's gonna go to Southwest with Tigress and say
- 1:32:27fat people deserve 2.
- 1:32:28Seats,
- 1:32:28don't charge them extra.
- 1:32:29Let them on the plane,
- 1:32:30bitch.
- 1:32:31She's gonna go to
- 1:32:32Nabisco and say,
- 1:32:34stop putting this shit in the food
- 1:32:36because Jillian,
- 1:32:37I like the food in Europe.
- 1:32:38I like the makeup in Europe even I've been doing the Nabisco part.
- 1:32:42The Southwest part has a bit of a separate conversation,
- 1:32:44but the Nabisco there's a lot of conversations.
- 1:32:46I think you're coming to the table to say
- 1:32:48whether or not,
- 1:32:48it's just like Oprah,
- 1:32:49we acknowledge our part in diet.
- 1:32:51Culture and
- 1:32:52and whatever whatever like let's make the change.
- 1:32:53Let's blame it on the bad guys
- 1:32:56diet culture.
- 1:32:57We haven't even talked about diet culture today.
- 1:32:58That is a separate episode.
- 1:33:00Body positivity is what we're talking about.
- 1:33:02I think we have turned to body positivity
- 1:33:05because of the shame
- 1:33:06because at
- 1:33:089 years old,
- 1:33:09my mother,
- 1:33:10who was a translator for her mother who was an immigrant.
- 1:33:14At that time it was very legal to easy to come to this country.
- 1:33:18My grandfather came here with a letter
- 1:33:20in 1964,
- 1:33:21100 bucks in his pocket.
- 1:33:22They are the American dream.
- 1:33:24My mother was at
- 1:33:26the doctor with her mother,
- 1:33:28and a doctor,
- 1:33:28a professional man,
- 1:33:30I'm sure he was likely white,
- 1:33:33turned to her and said,
- 1:33:35Ask your mom if she can have sex.
- 1:33:39Ask your mum,
- 1:33:40just
- 1:33:41tell your mom
- 1:33:43she's like a VW bug
- 1:33:45going up a hill with 9 people in it.
- 1:33:49A child,
- 1:33:51I get it.
- 1:33:52I mean,
- 1:33:52that's where it all comes from,
- 1:33:54right?
- 1:33:54Like my mommy wound is only because of her own trauma.
- 1:33:59She's
- 1:33:59of course,
- 1:34:00multi-generational.
- 1:34:01It gets into the epigenetics.
- 1:34:02It gets into how she raised me.
- 1:34:04Maybe you don't know you're on a diet till you're like 6,
- 1:34:08and then you go to your aunt's house who's like,
- 1:34:10anything you want.
- 1:34:12Right here.
- 1:34:13What do you want?
- 1:34:13The grocery store will get you whatever.
- 1:34:15What did I want?
- 1:34:15I wanted yoo-hoo
- 1:34:17like everybody else,
- 1:34:18because I wasn't allowed to
- 1:34:19have yoo-hoo.
- 1:34:20I wasn't allowed to have
- 1:34:22a ding dong.
- 1:34:22When I came home and I said,
- 1:34:23I want ding dongs in my lunch.
- 1:34:26You know what my mom bought me?
- 1:34:27Low fat ding dongs,
- 1:34:28and low fat ding dongs aren't wrapped in foil,
- 1:34:30so everybody knows
- 1:34:32they're fucking low,
- 1:34:33it's not a fucking ding dong.
- 1:34:34I want the foil.
- 1:34:35I want the foil.
- 1:34:36So she's acting out of her trauma.
- 1:34:38Now I'm just like,
- 1:34:39I didn't choose to be here,
- 1:34:41and now I'm like,
- 1:34:42literally this woman is crying as I get off the plane from the Yoohoo trip
- 1:34:46because I had gained so much weight,
- 1:34:47my grandparents had to buy me new clothes.
- 1:34:50But I think that that great aunt that offered me the Yoo-hoo and said,
- 1:34:53it's right here,
- 1:34:54honey,
- 1:34:54and you don't have to ask anybody when you want one.
- 1:34:58She knew.
- 1:34:59She knew I was being restricted at 6 years old,
- 1:35:01and that is why at 26,
- 1:35:05when you hear about body positivity and you're like,
- 1:35:07well,
- 1:35:07I've been on a diet for like 20 years,
- 1:35:10maybe there's more to life than
- 1:35:12trying to lose weight.
- 1:35:14That's what body positivity
- 1:35:15has given me.
- 1:35:17So,
- 1:35:18do I still want,
- 1:35:19of course,
- 1:35:20to make the right choice every day for my nutrition?
- 1:35:24Yes.
- 1:35:25I,
- 1:35:25I mean,
- 1:35:25I can see there's,
- 1:35:26like,
- 1:35:26empathy.
- 1:35:26I also feel like when you were talking and you thought I was going to interrupt,
- 1:35:29you could,
- 1:35:29like,
- 1:35:30hear my thoughts through my eyes.
- 1:35:32And,
- 1:35:32and people like you only get to be people like you because
- 1:35:36you're a
- 1:35:36A unicorn.
- 1:35:37You're,
- 1:35:37you're a very
- 1:35:39special person to have gotten to the place that you've gotten in this world.
- 1:35:41But the reality is,
- 1:35:43I'll finish.
- 1:35:43My point is that
- 1:35:45that's where body positivity came from.
- 1:35:47I came,
- 1:35:48body positivity actually came to me.
- 1:35:50They,
- 1:35:50you know what I was doing on YouTube?
- 1:35:52My first YouTube video is me doing the master cleanse.
- 1:35:56And showing people how to cut the lemons and put their maple syrup in,
- 1:36:00but then body positivity came
- 1:36:02and said,
- 1:36:02hey,
- 1:36:03you should be talking about plus size fashion,
- 1:36:04not the master cleanse,
- 1:36:05girl.
- 1:36:06Sounds to me like you still have a,
- 1:36:07a lot of stuff that is upsetting you.
- 1:36:10It sounds to me like you're still contending with a lot.
- 1:36:13I'm contending with a society
- 1:36:15that
- 1:36:15every day,
- 1:36:16every minute of the day
- 1:36:17tells me not only I have to buy a product to be thinner,
- 1:36:20I have to take a GLP-1.
- 1:36:22Serena Williams is selling me a GLP1.
- 1:36:24Jillian,
- 1:36:24that's problematic.
- 1:36:26You listen to me and then I'm now I'm old.
- 1:36:27Will you listen?
- 1:36:28You're still,
- 1:36:29you're still
- 1:36:31externalizing.
- 1:36:33The wound,
- 1:36:34the first conversation.
- 1:36:36I think that's where we stay,
- 1:36:38the first conversation.
- 1:36:41That
- 1:36:42is the most important thing.
- 1:36:43I don't care about Serena Williams.
- 1:36:45I couldn't care.
- 1:36:46Serena Williams.
- 1:36:47That's been mama,
- 1:36:47who gives a fuck because Jillian,
- 1:36:50she's not when you're fat,
- 1:36:51when you,
- 1:36:52no,
- 1:36:52no,
- 1:36:52no,
- 1:36:52no,
- 1:36:52no,
- 1:36:52but when I am getting a GLP one ad every time I open any app on my phone,
- 1:36:57watch the TV.
- 1:36:59Drive down the
- 1:37:00sure,
- 1:37:00but imagine in my position,
- 1:37:02Gillian,
- 1:37:03I went six months where
- 1:37:04every
- 1:37:05waking
- 1:37:06hour,
- 1:37:07including the 3 a.m. pee,
- 1:37:10my mind
- 1:37:11said,
- 1:37:12should I go on a GLP1?
- 1:37:13Should I go on a GLP1?
- 1:37:15Should I go on a GLP-1?
- 1:37:17OK,
- 1:37:18would you call that food noise?
- 1:37:20What do you call that?
- 1:37:21You tell me.
- 1:37:23I call it fucked up.
- 1:37:25I call it fucked up because I'm over here like I own a plus size fashion store.
- 1:37:29I look like the first fucking fat housewife of Beverly Hills.
- 1:37:32I'm fucking gorgeous.
- 1:37:33I got they thems,
- 1:37:34hey she's coming out of my ears.
- 1:37:36I can fuck anybody on the street,
- 1:37:38but this world
- 1:37:39wants to tell me that I need to shrink myself,
- 1:37:41that there's a thin woman within waiting to get out.
- 1:37:44Can I say something?
- 1:37:45I don't,
- 1:37:45I think I ate her.
- 1:37:46Can I say something?
- 1:37:46I,
- 1:37:46I don't think she's here.
- 1:37:49You also told me
- 1:37:51that,
- 1:37:51that
- 1:37:52what the world,
- 1:37:53tell me how the,
- 1:37:53OK,
- 1:37:54back up.
- 1:37:54OK.
- 1:37:55Tell me how the,
- 1:37:56the world makes you feel.
- 1:37:59I constantly feel like I have to be smaller.
- 1:38:03I have to be quieter.
- 1:38:04I have to be more submissive in my marriage.
- 1:38:07I have to shrink my body to fit on a plane.
- 1:38:10I have to
- 1:38:11have a bigger car
- 1:38:13because I need a little more room.
- 1:38:15I need to go to a special store or actually even better,
- 1:38:18order it online.
- 1:38:19It makes me feel like circumstances shit
- 1:38:21makes you feel worthless.
- 1:38:23It makes you feel like
- 1:38:24I can't go to the mall and spend my money.
- 1:38:26It makes you feel how
- 1:38:28devalued.
- 1:38:28OK,
- 1:38:29OK,
- 1:38:29stop.
- 1:38:30When's the first time you felt that way?
- 1:38:35Um,
- 1:38:36when I was in ballet and the teacher picked an outfit I didn't like
- 1:38:41for the recital,
- 1:38:428,
- 1:38:44when was it when you did your mom put you on a diet?
- 1:38:46You said 6.
- 1:38:47I mean,
- 1:38:47after that yoohoo incident,
- 1:38:49it was a,
- 1:38:49it was a real,
- 1:38:50did that make you feel the way you're currently describing?
- 1:38:52No,
- 1:38:53I didn't know what was at 6 years old,
- 1:38:55I just,
- 1:38:55it's like I knew that I knew the ding
- 1:38:57dong was different because it didn't have the foil,
- 1:38:59but I didn't understand.
- 1:39:00I know because it becomes.
- 1:39:02You,
- 1:39:03but unconsciously you do understand.
- 1:39:05And now
- 1:39:07This pattern
- 1:39:08is playing out everywhere.
- 1:39:10It has a name.
- 1:39:11It's literally Freudian.
- 1:39:12It is called a repetition compulsion.
- 1:39:14What about the genetics?
- 1:39:15Like when I look at photos,
- 1:39:16you said there were no fat children 100 years ago.
- 1:39:19No,
- 1:39:20no,
- 1:39:20no,
- 1:39:20I find that very strange,
- 1:39:22very few.
- 1:39:23And OK,
- 1:39:23there were fact
- 1:39:25fact check me.
- 1:39:25But there are,
- 1:39:26there have always been fat people,
- 1:39:29and there always will be.
- 1:39:29We will not be eradicated and we're not going anywhere.
- 1:39:32Fat's where it's at.
- 1:39:33We've reclaimed the word.
- 1:39:34You don't have to do this anymore.
- 1:39:35You can say bigger bodied,
- 1:39:37you can say fat.
- 1:39:38I want to ask you right now to stop using obese and be a part of that.
- 1:39:42OK,
- 1:39:42so you want obese is a slur.
- 1:39:44I've always thought that calling someone fat was actually far.
- 1:39:48It was it was fat is if fat is
- 1:39:50tissue,
- 1:39:51it's not a person,
- 1:39:52but society,
- 1:39:53it's the worst thing you can be.
- 1:39:54It's absolutely what every woman and woman and child,
- 1:39:57mostly.
- 1:39:58So you're saying fat is the worst thing you can be.
- 1:39:59So is this what our society projects,
- 1:40:02so you guys that's what you're yelling at people on the,
- 1:40:05the,
- 1:40:05the show.
- 1:40:06Like,
- 1:40:06don't you want more than to just be fat?
- 1:40:08It's what everyone is so afraid of.
- 1:40:10Why do you think they showed up because they didn't want to be there?
- 1:40:13You think that they showed up because they were forced?
- 1:40:15There were hundreds thousands of people.
- 1:40:17They showed up because they wanted to change,
- 1:40:19because the world is telling us we have to change.
- 1:40:22Listen to me.
- 1:40:24Stop making it about the world,
- 1:40:27because if you cannot stop,
- 1:40:28listen,
- 1:40:29you can't change the world.
- 1:40:30I mean,
- 1:40:31sure,
- 1:40:31hopefully,
- 1:40:32maybe some people can.
- 1:40:33I don't know.
- 1:40:33It's not that freaking easy.
- 1:40:35You might be able to change it's not that easy.
- 1:40:36Just,
- 1:40:36just do,
- 1:40:37but what we can change
- 1:40:39is how we respond
- 1:40:40to the world.
- 1:40:42That's what I'm trying to get you to understand what I think you're doing,
- 1:40:45OK,
- 1:40:46with the world.
- 1:40:47Is reenacting this pattern that you,
- 1:40:50you have from being very young,
- 1:40:52and I don't think it's healthy for you
- 1:40:54because it keeps you pretty angry all the time,
- 1:40:56it seems like.
- 1:40:57Oh,
- 1:40:57you don't know me well.
- 1:40:58I'm not an angry person.
- 1:40:59I think in this context,
- 1:41:00it's harmful to say that the world doesn't have an
- 1:41:04impact on why people want to be on a show
- 1:41:06that's about weight loss.
- 1:41:08I think that people want to be on a show
- 1:41:10that's about weight loss because they want to lose weight.
- 1:41:13I think it's because
- 1:41:14everyone has told us we have to lose weight,
- 1:41:16that you are not good if you don't lose weight.
- 1:41:18If your friends are at
- 1:41:19a burger joint,
- 1:41:20you're the one getting the salad because you
- 1:41:23know you should restrain from the burger,
- 1:41:25even though we're at a burger place,
- 1:41:26because why should you restrain from the burger?
- 1:41:28Because that is what the world has told me that I have.
- 1:41:30Have to make the good healthy choice.
- 1:41:32Also,
- 1:41:33let's talk about the fact that no one here said
- 1:41:35that we don't owe anybody health.
- 1:41:36I don't owe anybody my health.
- 1:41:39Do you want to be healthy.
- 1:41:41I am healthy.
- 1:41:42I'm healthy for me,
- 1:41:43and this is what healthy for me looks like.
- 1:41:45Can I ask you this?
- 1:41:46If,
- 1:41:46if I,
- 1:41:47if I sent you
- 1:41:49to a doctor who ran a full comprehensive
- 1:41:52blood panel.
- 1:41:54If there were biomarkers,
- 1:41:55yeah,
- 1:41:55there would be some fatty liver stuff coming up.
- 1:41:57OK,
- 1:41:58sure,
- 1:41:58yeah,
- 1:41:58the cholesterol classify that as physio,
- 1:42:00not
- 1:42:01value.
- 1:42:03This has nothing to do with your value.
- 1:42:04Yeah,
- 1:42:04no,
- 1:42:04I'm talking about numbers,
- 1:42:05the data,
- 1:42:06liver,
- 1:42:07sure,
- 1:42:07healthy,
- 1:42:08but
- 1:42:09thin people get fatty liver too.
- 1:42:11They're far less inclined.
- 1:42:13Time,
- 1:42:13we're out of time there.
- 1:42:15Thanks for sharing your story.
- 1:42:16I really do think that was valuable.
- 1:42:17Thank you all for being a part of this episode.
- 1:42:19I know you had to talk about your bodies,
- 1:42:20you had to talk.
- 1:42:21About your lives.
- 1:42:22Jillian,
- 1:42:22thank you for being on this episode,
- 1:42:24bringing your passion,
- 1:42:26and Elon Musk.
- 1:42:27I know you're watching this,
- 1:42:28so why don't we get you in the center?
- 1:42:30You know what,
- 1:42:30I really appreciate everybody showing up.
- 1:42:32Uh,
- 1:42:33I really appreciate them sharing their stories.
- 1:42:35My
- 1:42:37issue with body positivity remains though.
- 1:42:39Oh,
- 1:42:40it means this for me.
- 1:42:41Well,
- 1:42:41it means that for them.
- 1:42:43Well,
- 1:42:43it's about political activism.
- 1:42:44Oh yeah,
- 1:42:44but big food like that,
- 1:42:46they,
- 1:42:46they can do whatever they want with the movement.
- 1:42:48Oh,
- 1:42:48but the influencers,
- 1:42:49that's not really us,
- 1:42:50like,
- 1:42:50but it kind of is,
- 1:42:51and that's kind of the problem
- 1:42:53is that there's no
- 1:42:55centralized guidance.
- 1:42:56Line.
- 1:42:57I think she
- 1:42:58is
- 1:42:59really limited in what she sees the movement as.
- 1:43:02She's blaming the movement for the things that
- 1:43:04people who have co-opted the movement are doing.
- 1:43:06Call out the co-opters,
- 1:43:07don't call out the movement for not calling out the co-opters.
- 1:43:10I do think there's a kernel in what Jillian said about like
- 1:43:13um.
- 1:43:14You know,
- 1:43:14thinking that body positivity focuses a little too much on the personal,
- 1:43:18um,
- 1:43:19from our perspective,
- 1:43:20we want to move beyond just the personal.
- 1:43:22We think the personal is important.
- 1:43:24You,
- 1:43:25you got to believe you're worthy of fair and equal
- 1:43:28treatment in order to demand fair and equal treatment,
- 1:43:31but we're going to work on the fair and equal treatment pieces of it.
- 1:43:34She was cool,
- 1:43:35she was calm,
- 1:43:36she was collected,
- 1:43:37and I don't know
- 1:43:39what exactly she's totally talking about,
- 1:43:41but she is confident
- 1:43:43in her messaging.
- 1:43:45What we're here to say is that we don't wanna
- 1:43:48spend our entire life trying to change our body,
- 1:43:52shaming me into thinking that I should get on that thing,
- 1:43:55I should get on the scale or whatever,
- 1:43:56that's not gonna work on me.
- 1:43:58Shame has no place
- 1:43:59in my life,
- 1:44:01and to me that's true liberation.
- 1:44:03Shame is not a part of this.
- 1:44:05I can't,
- 1:44:05I can't continue on with this shame.
- 1:44:08It's,
- 1:44:09it's,
- 1:44:10again,
- 1:44:10it's more of the same defense mechanism.
- 1:44:12Every single person who came up and debated me had tried to lose weight,
- 1:44:15and then when they felt like they couldn't,
- 1:44:18this is where they resigned themselves.
- 1:44:20I'm not telling you
- 1:44:22that getting healthy is easy.
- 1:44:25I'm telling you it's doable and you have to decide if you're worth the work.
- 1:44:30Don't forget to subscribe to Surrounded wherever you get
- 1:44:33your podcasts so that you don't miss an episode.
- 1:44:35And if you want to watch the video version of Surrounded,
- 1:44:37subscribe to Jubilee on YouTube.