Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [13F] Peter Thiel Macro's Violent Pivot: Q3 2025 Fortress Portfolio #aapl #nvda #msft #tsla
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive where we cut through the market noise,
- 0:03We take financial filings, we take data, and we try to extract
- 0:06the insight you really need. And today we have a fascinating
- 0:101. It's a strategic document that
- 0:13it really reads like a declaration.
- 0:15It does. We're looking at Peter Thiel,
- 0:17Macro LL CS Q3202513-F filing, and our mission today is to
- 0:24unpack what one of Silicon Valley's, you know, most
- 0:27successful figures has just done.
- 0:28It's been called a violent pivot, and that's not an
- 0:30exaggeration. Exactly.
- 0:32So we're going to look at why he made such a dramatic move and
- 0:35what this this extreme concentration tells us about the
- 0:37market and maybe the AI hype cycle.
- 0:40And it's really crucial right up front to be clear about the
- 0:43entity here. This is Teal Macro LLC.
- 0:45Right, this isn't his personal stuff or founders fund.
- 0:47No, not at all. This is his liquid public market
- 0:50trading arm and that distinction is everything because what we're
- 0:54seeing is a fundamental rejection of his previous public
- 0:57market strategy. So in short, he shed these these
- 1:00high flying narrative driven stocks.
- 1:02The market darlings, yeah. And he consolidated all of that
- 1:06capital into what you could only call a hyper concentrated
- 1:10fortress, a fortress built on just three stocks.
- 1:13OK, let's get into that. The great liquidation.
- 1:16I mean, the numbers here are just staggering.
- 1:18They really. Are the fund saw a massive what,
- 1:21around a 65% contraction in its reported asset.
- 1:24That's right, it plummeted from about $212 million all the way
- 1:28down to just 74.4 million. And this wasn't just the market
- 1:33going down. This was a surgical intentional
- 1:35liquidation. Absolutely.
- 1:37It resulted in an 80% portfolio turnover rate. 80% that that
- 1:41just screams a total loss of faith in what you were doing
- 1:44before. It's a huge conviction move,
- 1:46yeah. And it was really defined by two
- 1:49major complete liquidations. First, the fund completely
- 1:53exited NVIDIA and VDA. Selling every single share.
- 1:57All 537,000 of. Them.
- 1:59And you have to remember this wasn't just some small position.
- 2:01NVIDIA was the anchor of the fund.
- 2:03It was. It was over 40% of the entire
- 2:06portfolio in the second quarter to sell the AI bellwether, the
- 2:09absolute centerpiece of this market cycle.
- 2:12Right at its. Peak that sends a massive signal
- 2:14and second they got out of Vistra PST the energy generation
- 2:18firm. So he's selling the AI hardware
- 2:21and the power needed to run it. Exactly.
- 2:22He's stepping away from that kind of diversification and
- 2:25speculation for something much purer, a higher quality tech
- 2:30portfolio. Let's stick with that NVIDIA
- 2:33exit for a second, because this is where it gets really
- 2:35interesting, I think. Yeah, he sold the definitive AI
- 2:38winner just as its valuation was screaming past $5 trillion.
- 2:43He's basically putting his money where his mouth is after all
- 2:45those warnings about an AI hype loop.
- 2:48He is, And this isn't some outsider looking at this is the
- 2:51ultimate industry insider. Co founder of PayPal Palantir.
- 2:54His VC peers are the ones funding the startups that are in
- 2:58his main customers. So for him to exit, it suggests
- 3:01the leaf that this this VC funded spending boom that's
- 3:05fueled Nvidia's rise is either peaking or the risk reward just
- 3:09isn't there anymore. It's a classic top of the cycle.
- 3:12Move it. Really is so.
- 3:13He liquidates all that, and he's left with this pure tech book
- 3:16that you've described as a barbell.
- 3:18What does that structure actually look like?
- 3:20It is extremely focused. As of September 30th, 2025, the
- 3:25fund holds exactly 3 stocks. Just three.
- 3:28That's the entire portfolio. That's it.
- 3:30Wow. OK, so tell us which three made
- 3:33the cut? How are they weighted all?
- 3:35Right, so #1 and this might be a surprise, is Tesla TSLA.
- 3:40It's still the largest single position at 38.8%.
- 3:43Didn't he sell a lot of it? A huge amount.
- 3:45The share count was slashed by 76.2%.
- 3:49Wait, so it's still almost 40% of the fund but he sold 3/4 of
- 3:52his stake? That that sounds like deep
- 3:54conflict. It's the definition of it.
- 3:56Huge conviction in the long term idea, but extreme worry about
- 4:00the current price. OK, what's #2?
- 4:02#2 is Microsoft MSFT. This is a brand new massive
- 4:07position at 34.1%. The third.
- 4:10The third is Apple AAPL, also a new large stake at 27.1%.
- 4:15So the new thesis is crystal clear. 1/3 is a high risk.
- 4:19You could say non consensus venture bet.
- 4:21That's Tesla. And 2/3 is locked down in these
- 4:25these impenetrable platform monopolies, Microsoft and Apple.
- 4:31It's a defensive, quality first stance.
- 4:34And to really get it, I think we have to run these three through
- 4:36a classic quality focus lens. What would Warren Buffett look?
- 4:40For the Mote Financials management valuation.
- 4:44Exactly. Let's start with Tesla, the huge
- 4:47binary bet. So why?
- 4:49Why after slashing his exposure, does Teal still commit nearly
- 4:5340% of this super concentrated fund Tesla?
- 4:56What's the logic? Well, a traditional value
- 4:58investor would look at Tesla and say there's no durable Moat.
- 5:01Right, Buffett wants that stable castle.
- 5:03And Muskis philosophy is the exact opposite.
- 5:05He says the only Moat is the pace of innovation, which is a
- 5:08high risk treadmill. If you're just looking at the
- 5:10car business, the Moat is basically non existent.
- 5:13But Teal's not betting on the car business, is he?
- 5:15What's the real mode here that he's betting on?
- 5:17It has to be the FSD data network effect.
- 5:19It's a pure AI mode. FSD being full self driving
- 5:23right? Tesla has collected over 2.2
- 5:26billion city miles of real world driving data from its cars.
- 5:31That massive proprietary data set?
- 5:35It's the raw material for autonomy.
- 5:37Competitors just can't replicate that scale.
- 5:39So this holding is really just a VC bet on an AI outcome, but
- 5:43placed in the public markets. That's the only way it makes
- 5:45sense. OK.
- 5:46Now let's look at it through that Buffett lens, the
- 5:48financial. And this is where it really
- 5:50falls apart. From a value perspective, it
- 5:52looks deeply concerned. Buffett wants predictable
- 5:54earnings. And toughly give you volatility
- 5:57the 2025 reports all showed declining net income that's the
- 6:01opposite of what a quality investor wants and management.
- 6:05Elon Musk is the antithesis of discipline, capital allocation.
- 6:08He creates massive key man risk and the.
- 6:11Valuation. The numbers are just terrifying.
- 6:13And they are. The PE ratio is sitting at an
- 6:15astronomical 270. If you run any standard
- 6:19discounted cash flow on the car business, the stock looks wildly
- 6:22overvalued. Fair value estimates are, you
- 6:25know, often below 150 bucks. The only way you justify the
- 6:28price is if you value it as a physical AI or a robo taxi
- 6:33company. So the conclusion is pretty
- 6:35clear, his Tesla holding is a bet on the binary outcome of
- 6:38FSD, while at the same time he's acknowledging the massive
- 6:42valuation risk by cutting his share count so much.
- 6:44Exactly. So now let's pivot to the other
- 6:47side of that barbell, the defensive flight to quality.
- 6:50Microsoft and Apple the fortresses.
- 6:53This is what traditional value investing is all about.
- 6:55Let's start with Microsoft. Microsoft's traditional Moat is
- 6:58jested. It's a fortress of high
- 7:00switching costs. You have over 90% enterprise
- 7:03penetration with Microsoft 365 and Windows.
- 7:05It's almost impossible for a corporation to RIP that out.
- 7:08But now there's a new Moat, right?
- 7:09The AI infrastructure. That's the new layer.
- 7:12Because of their exclusive Open AI partnership, Azure is now the
- 7:16default cloud platform for large scale AI.
- 7:20And Satya Nadella has been exceptional.
- 7:22He pivoted to the cloud, and now he's expertly integrating
- 7:25Copilot into all their existing products, just making those
- 7:28modes even wider. And the financials are just a
- 7:31model of stability. They are.
- 7:33The company generates this enormous, predictable free cash
- 7:36flow. We're talking well over $70
- 7:38billion a year. So the synthesis for Teal here
- 7:42is profound. He's selling the volatile AI
- 7:45hardware NVIDIA and buying the stable recurring high margin AI
- 7:49software. Microsoft It's a classic
- 7:50substitution for quality. But let me challenge that for a
- 7:53second. Aren't Microsoft and Apple
- 7:55trading at historically high valuations?
- 7:57Is this really a defensive move or is he just paying a huge
- 7:59premium for perceived safety? And that is the core tension of
- 8:03the entire strategy. He's signaling that even if they
- 8:06aren't cheap in a conventional sense, they are the absolute
- 8:09safest place to put capital right now.
- 8:12He's prioritizing business dominance and predictability
- 8:14over valuation. He's saying I'd rather pay up
- 8:17for a guaranteed fortress than risk capital on cheap
- 8:20speculation. Let's turn to Apple, then his
- 8:2327% stick. Apple is the ultimate consumer
- 8:26monopoly. The Moat is that walled garden.
- 8:30The ecosystem is so powerful that the switching costs are
- 8:34just astronomical. Once you're in with the App
- 8:36Store, iCloud, iMessage, it's basically impossible to leave.
- 8:40Exactly. And financially, it might be the
- 8:43greatest cash flow generating business in history.
- 8:45Astronomical Roe, Huge cash generation.
- 8:48And Tim Cook gets praise from Buffett himself for his capital
- 8:51allocation, diversifying into high margin services, that
- 8:54massive share buyback program. Again, Teal is willing to pay a
- 8:58premium for that kind of dominance and predictability.
- 9:01It is the ultimate defensive core holding.
- 9:03So let's bring this all together.
- 9:04What's the final thesis here? He's built a perfect barbell.
- 9:08You have one company, Tesla, that represents high risk
- 9:11venture style optionality. It fails every traditional value
- 9:14metric and that's anchored by two companies, Microsoft and
- 9:17Apple that literally define what a Buffett style quality fortress
- 9:21is. So.
- 9:22What does this actually mean for you, the investor?
- 9:24Listening to this, it seems like Thiel, a master of growth and
- 9:28speculation, is basically declaring that the speculative
- 9:31hype driven phase of AI is over. I think so.
- 9:35The strategy is to move capital out of the assets fueled by hype
- 9:38and into the hands of the platform owners, the companies
- 9:41that already have the infrastructure, the customers
- 9:44and the cash flow to monetize this technology for the long
- 9:47haul. It's a really powerful risk off
- 9:49signal, but it's packaged inside a high conviction tech
- 9:52portfolio. It is, and when an influential
- 9:55founder focused VC like Teal resorts to such a defensive
- 9:58public market structure, it signals a deep skepticism about
- 10:01the quality and valuations in the broader market.
- 10:04That's a great thought to leave everyone with.
- 10:06What does it signal when even a venture capitalist is hiding out
- 10:09in just two behemoths and one calculated moon shot?
- 10:14Before we wrap up, just a quick reminder for you.
- 10:16All the analysis we've discussed is based on publicly available
- 10:19sources. It is for educational purposes
- 10:21only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 10:25Please always conduct your own due diligence before making any
- 10:28investment decisions. And if you want to track total
- 10:30market temperature yourself, we encourage you to search and
- 10:33download the Buffett Indicator iOS app from the Apple App
- 10:36Store. It's a great tool for daily
- 10:39reminders on market valuation. Thank you for joining us for
- 10:42this deep dive into Peter Thiel's decisive macro pivot.
- 10:45And if you found this interesting, want to access more
- 10:47advanced content, welcome to join our Deep Value Club
- 10:50membership. Or you can subscribe to our
- 10:51channel on Apple and Spotify Podcasts.
- 10:53Deep value investing. We'll cash you next time.