Latest / Educate Me Well / Finding Balance With Technology In K-12 Classrooms
Transcript
- 0:04Tonya: Welcome to Educate Me Well, the podcast that brings faith and education together.
- 0:10Tonya: Hi, I'm Tonya, and I'm so glad you're here.
- 0:13Tonya: Hello, fellow educators, parents, administrators, anyone interested in education.
- 0:30Tonya: How are you today?
- 0:32Tonya: So glad you're here.
- 0:33Tonya: I've been seeing concerns from parents in the education world and also from some educators about too much technology in the K through 12 school environment.
- 0:49Tonya: And so today I thought I would talk about that.
- 0:53Tonya: We know that before the pandemic, a lot of technology was in schools, but there were some schools that were struggling to get the technology that they needed.
- 1:09Tonya: And so technology was kind of an aside thing that we were really using, but it wasn't as important as it is today. And so when the pandemic came along, a lot of technology came into play because we know that we couldn't get together.
- 1:32Tonya: And so educators and parents, you know, were working together to use technology to help get education for the students.
- 1:41Tonya: About 80% of K through 12 students now use computers or tablets at school.
- 1:50Tonya: That's up from 50% pre-pandemic.
- 1:55Tonya: Many teachers report being required to use mostly digital materials now, even when they feel it's not the best instructional choice.
- 2:06Tonya: So schools are beginning to reassess how much screen time they use with students, especially in the early grades, like pre-K through 2.
- 2:18Tonya: I just want to say at the very beginning of this episode that I believe technology is valuable, but we do have to have a balance for students to make it healthy for their development.
- 2:33Tonya: What are we seeing in K through 2 classrooms?
- 2:37Tonya: We're seeing increased device use for reading, math, centers, and assessments.
- 2:46Tonya: Research consistently points to a negative correlation between heavy device use and academic performance.
- 2:55Tonya: The constant multitasking that is required by digital interfaces fragments attention, preventing the deep work and sustained focus necessary for mastery in subjects like math and literacy.
- 3:12Tonya: Excessive screen interaction overloads the brain's capacity for self-regulation and impulse control, leading to decreased working memory and a diminished ability to achieve between complex tasks.
- 3:29Tonya: It affects their executive functioning.
- 3:32Tonya: And then for younger children, screen time often displaces the verbal interaction with educators and peers that is essential for language development.
- 3:44Tonya: Passive media consumption is no substitute for human discourse.
- 3:50Tonya: Teachers say that screens are hurting attention and engagement.
- 3:55Tonya: As we can see by the research, this is a concern.
- 4:00Tonya: A national study found 85% of teachers believe students spend too much time on screens during class.
- 4:09Tonya: And many say devices intended for learning often lead to distraction and diminished focus.
- 4:18Tonya: And then parents are pushing back, and I mean hard.
- 4:22Tonya: Parents who once advocated for school cell phone bans are now targeting school-issued devices, saying they undermine screen time limits at home and compete with teachers for attention.
- 4:38Tonya: Also, districts are beginning to scale back.
- 4:41Tonya: The Los Angeles Unified School District, the second largest in the United States, is eliminating devices for grades K through 2, setting screen time limits, banning YouTube on school devices, and restricting device use during lunch and recess.
- 5:01Tonya: In my own opinion, I'm wondering why kids were ever allowed to get on YouTube at school.
- 5:09Tonya: And I do know that there are some good like science channels and there are some math channels that are really good to help students with different concepts.
- 5:19Tonya: And I can understand that, but it man, YouTube would really need to be monitored heavily, even if you had YouTube for kids.
- 5:29Tonya: Lunch and recess.
- 5:30Tonya: I mean, why would kids be using devices during lunch and recess?
- 5:36Tonya: Why are they not playing?
- 5:39Tonya: This has been a great discussion for a long time about kids not getting enough play.
- 5:46Tonya: Yes, it's a good thing this is going on because it really needs to be addressed.
- 5:51Tonya: We all know that in order for students to develop properly in early childhoods, you we're talking about K-2 learners, they need tactile, hands-on experiences.
- 6:06Tonya: This helps their brains learn.
- 6:09Tonya: And then they also need to learn have face-to-face social interaction.
- 6:14Tonya: That's how they learn how to be to interact well with other kids and also with adults.
- 6:22Tonya: Also, foundational writing and fine motor practice.
- 6:26Tonya: Their muscles are still developing in their hands and their wrists, and and they just need that physical practice, not to be replaced really by a device, an electronic device.
- 6:40Tonya: And then, just as I said, movement, play, they need sensory learning.
- 6:46Tonya: Parents have concerns about this, and so do teachers.
- 6:49Tonya: Teachers report that students are struggling with sustained writing without using spell check.
- 6:56Tonya: And this is probably in the older grades, but also students are beginning not to be able to focus without some digital stimulation.
- 7:05Tonya: And when they are when the device is taken away, I've read in some of the articles and research that some kids rebel and they they give the teacher problems.
- 7:18Tonya: So there are behavior issues that are we can be concerned about there.
- 7:23Tonya: Also, maintaining attention during non-screen tasks.
- 7:28Tonya: And so these concerns are making teachers and parents call for a reset toward more paper and pencil and hands-on learning.
- 7:40Tonya: That doesn't mean that we're going to get rid of devices, but that means we could scale them back and be sure we're getting the other end because there are developmental questions about that with students.
- 7:53Tonya: Another factor is AI.
- 7:55Tonya: And I know that I have done an episode on AI in schools.
- 7:59Tonya: And so if you want to hear that, go back and listen to that episode.
- 8:04Tonya: So I'm just going to briefly mention it here.
- 8:06Tonya: But AI is helping to accelerate this conversation because AI has come in quickly.
- 8:14Tonya: While it has come in quickly, the training and policies about AI have lagged behind.
- 8:22Tonya: And parents and students worry that AI may harm critical thinking skills or lead to false accusations of cheating.
- 8:32Tonya: So teachers need trained, and policies need to be put in place to control AI use.
- 8:40Tonya: Students should also be trained how to use AI and not abuse it.
- 8:47Tonya: What else are researchers and experts saying?
- 8:50Tonya: They are saying that too much tech leads to reduced attention span and increased distraction.
- 8:58Tonya: And early reliance on devices leads to weaker handwriting and slower reading fluency, which I've already mentioned, both of those.
- 9:08Tonya: Balanced technology use leads to stronger engagement and better retention.
- 9:15Tonya: We want that, don't we?
- 9:17Tonya: That retention is so important.
- 9:19Tonya: So is engagement.
- 9:20Tonya: So what does balanced tech actually look like?
- 9:36Tonya: You could set clear limits on daily screen time.
- 9:39Tonya: This would be at school and at home.
- 9:43Tonya: And then intentional use like tech for creation, not just passive consumption.
- 9:51Tonya: That would be an indicator right there.
- 9:54Tonya: And then paper-based literacy and math foundations, hands-on centers for younger kids and real-world problem solving.
- 10:04Tonya: They have got to have that.
- 10:06Tonya: We see nowadays just how much kids don't have that when they graduate from high school and go to college.
- 10:14Tonya: It's an epidemic, really.
- 10:17Tonya: They really need real-world problem solving.
- 10:19Tonya: And then teacher let instruction come first, and then the devices second.
- 10:25Tonya: And then use digital tools sparingly and on purpose.
- 10:30Tonya: It should have a definite purpose.
- 10:33Tonya: Review, reinforcement, not teaching a new skill.
- 10:39Tonya: We don't need that unless, and I have to bring this up here because I was a principal in a private school, and we use digital devices all day long for grades three and up.
- 10:53Tonya: Now in grades pre-K through two, no, we didn't.
- 10:57Tonya: We used those as reinforcement.
- 10:59Tonya: But for grades three and up, we had a digital curriculum.
- 11:04Tonya: Now we added other things in that weren't on a device, but their core instruction was digital.
- 11:10Tonya: Then they had a teacher stand by to reinforce and help and encourage there.
- 11:16Tonya: But that was in a private school, and we didn't have the ability to have a teacher for every grade level.
- 11:22Tonya: We just weren't able to staff that.
- 11:24Tonya: You know, it's about protecting childhood and strengthening those foundational skills and using technology in a wise way.
- 15:04Tonya: What does it look like to you to balance technology between school and home?
- 15:12Tonya: Let me know your thoughts.
- 15:13Tonya: I would love to hear from some of you.
- 15:15Tonya: I haven't heard from anyone yet.
- 15:18Tonya: So I can tell there's people out there because I can look at my statistics.
- 15:22Tonya: But it would be great to hear from some of you.
- 15:25Tonya: So send me a text.
- 15:27Tonya: You can do that on the episode webpage, or send me an email at my email.
- 15:35Tonya: I'd love to hear from you and just see how this is helping you.
- 15:40Tonya: Thank you for joining me today on Educate Me Well.
- 15:44Tonya: I'm grateful you spent this time with me, and I hope the conversation encouraged and equipped you.
- 15:51Tonya: If you have ideas for future episodes or questions you'd like me to explore, you can reach me anytime at admin@educatemewell.com.
- 16:00Tonya: And be sure to check out our social media pages for great resources.
- 16:08Tonya: You can find those on each podcast episode page.
- 16:13Tonya: Until next time, keep making a difference in the lives of children.