Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / A Practical Guide for Attorneys Approaching their First Mediation
Transcript
- 0:03My name is Moira Gibere and I'm an Associate
- 0:06Director with Jams. Today's presentation is with
- 0:11Michael Murphy from Jams and the topic is Your
- 0:15First Mediation, a Practical Guide for Attorneys
- 0:18and Clients Alike. It is my pleasure to introduce
- 0:24Mr. Murphy briefly and then he'll also give a
- 0:28little bit more detail about his background.
- 0:31Mr. Murphy is an internationally recognized attorney
- 0:34with more than 40 years of experience representing
- 0:36clients in straightforward to complex high value
- 0:39matters across the US and abroad. His experience
- 0:43extends across the aisle and across a multitude
- 0:45of business lines and practice areas. And with
- 0:49that, I'll go ahead and turn it over to Mike
- 0:51to start the program and introduce himself. Great.
- 0:54Thank you, Moira. I appreciate it very much.
- 0:56And also my thanks to the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 0:59for inviting me to do this. It's my pleasure
- 1:01to do this today and to at least electronically
- 1:04meet all of you. This presentation today emanates
- 1:09from an article that I wrote about two months
- 1:12ago for the Daily Journal, similarly titled.
- 1:17And the genesis of the idea came from a conversation
- 1:20I had with somebody recently, a brand new attorney
- 1:22who was facing her first mediation and was a
- 1:26sole practitioner and had been practicing for
- 1:28a number of years but had never had a mediation
- 1:30before and was just scared to death about the
- 1:34process, primarily because at the stage of her
- 1:37career she was concerned that it was expected
- 1:40that she would know how to mediate and what it
- 1:42was all about, but she'd never done one before.
- 1:44And so that triggered a thought to write an article
- 1:47about what I would consider to be a practical
- 1:49guide, not only for lawyers, but for clients
- 1:52as well, to review and take into consideration
- 1:56some ideas as they approach their first mediation.
- 1:59Now, for those of you in the audience who have
- 2:01been mediating for years or done it several times,
- 2:03a lot of this is going to seem very, very fundamental,
- 2:06very, very basic. And perhaps... you'll stick
- 2:11around for the entirety of it because they're
- 2:12gonna do a few anecdotes and things I learned
- 2:14along the way over the 40 years or so that I've
- 2:16been practicing and indeed involved in ADR through
- 2:20those four decades. There may be some things
- 2:22that you pick up that you might find useful.
- 2:24I also, I understand that either sometime before
- 2:27or during or after this presentation, my daily
- 2:31journal article will be, a link will be provided
- 2:34for you to... take a look at that. And I would
- 2:37encourage you, if appropriate, if you think so,
- 2:40share it with your clients because it also gives
- 2:42them some idea of what the process is all about.
- 2:45Because while we as attorneys may be familiar
- 2:48either in concept or in practice with what a
- 2:51mediation is, it's probably, in many cases at
- 2:54least, new territory for clients. And it might
- 2:57remove some of the mystery about the process.
- 3:00So I encourage you to take a look at the article,
- 3:02share it with any new or young attorneys that
- 3:04you have in your firm. and also give consideration
- 3:07to showing it or sharing it with clients in appropriate
- 3:11circumstances for them to review and maybe take
- 3:14some of the mystery out of the process for them.
- 3:17So that's the objective here. So we want to start
- 3:22out with our first slide, Maura, if you would.
- 3:25Bear with us for one second, we'll get this up.
- 3:27So again, this is a first mediation practical
- 3:29guide for attorneys and both clients alike. Next
- 3:33slide, please. So the first question is to mediate
- 3:37or not mediate. That is the question. And by
- 3:41that I ask you to consider or take into consideration
- 3:44that while all litigation involves a dispute,
- 3:49not all disputes require litigation. And why
- 3:53do I say that? Because while you're in litigation,
- 3:56Mediation either by the idea of the parties or
- 4:00by recommendation from the court or other authority
- 4:02becomes an option to try to get the case resolved
- 4:05short of trial. That said, disputes not yet in
- 4:10litigation can still benefit from mediation.
- 4:14In other words, you shouldn't be thinking of
- 4:15mediation solely as a remedy in litigation, but
- 4:18think of it as a potential remedy to any dispute.
- 4:21And it can be plenty of reasons why parties might
- 4:24want to consider mediating a case before it goes
- 4:27into litigation. The most obvious one is timing
- 4:32and cost. I mean, the cost associated with litigation,
- 4:35everybody to both sides of the equation know
- 4:37what that is and know how exorbitant it could
- 4:39be and how, and secondly, how much time it can
- 4:41take from beginning to end to get a dispute resolved
- 4:44in litigation. Also, besides getting it into
- 4:50a dispute resolution mode sooner rather than
- 4:53later and saving the cost of litigation. Mediations
- 4:56also provide an opportunity to have the parties
- 4:59who have been at odds with each other over some
- 5:01sort of a dispute actually get into a room and
- 5:03sit down together with the common objective of
- 5:07resolving the dispute. So if you can actually
- 5:09get people to commit to the process before litigation,
- 5:12in some respects, you're halfway there because
- 5:14you've got people willing to sit down and think
- 5:16and mutually agree. that it might be worth resolving
- 5:20it sooner rather than later. So think of mediation
- 5:23as a tool to resolve a dispute, not necessarily
- 5:28limited to litigation, but to any dispute. And
- 5:30also, it avoids the publicity and the visibility
- 5:37of having your dispute resolved via litigation.
- 5:41Because sometimes disputes arise And yet, notwithstanding
- 5:46the dispute, the parties want to preserve a relationship
- 5:49that they might have. They may still be business
- 5:51partners on a going forward basis, and they just
- 5:53can't agree on one matter that has them stuck,
- 5:56and yet they still want to do business with each
- 5:58other. Well, if they can't come to terms with
- 6:00the agreement themselves, they might want a neutral
- 6:02or person in mediation to come in and help them
- 6:05resolve that and preserve the relationship. So
- 6:08these are all things that take into consideration,
- 6:10discuss with your clients in advance. Timing,
- 6:15okay, let's talk about the initial considerations.
- 6:18Do you mediate at the beginning of a dispute?
- 6:21Let's just now convert ourselves into litigation.
- 6:24At the beginning of the lawsuit, during the middle
- 6:26of the lawsuit or as you're approaching a mandatory
- 6:30settlement conference or trial or arbitration
- 6:34for that matter, if you're in the arbitration
- 6:37mode, all different considerations go into the
- 6:40timing of this. Obviously, if you mediate a case
- 6:46early on in the life of litigation, you don't
- 6:49get the benefit of what discovery would show.
- 6:51You don't get the benefit of what each side's
- 6:54expert witnesses might testify to. You don't
- 6:57necessarily get the opportunity to thoroughly
- 7:00size up each party and witnesses as they might
- 7:03present themselves to a jury or to a court. Yet
- 7:06there might be reasons why you would want to
- 7:10consider if not emphasize or pursue push for
- 7:14mediation early on in a case. For example, you
- 7:17may have documents or discovery that you just
- 7:21don't want the other side to know about or your
- 7:23case, as they understand it, that is your opposing
- 7:25party, may be impaired once this discovery happens.
- 7:30So you might want to get the case resolved without
- 7:32having to deliver in discovery responses that
- 7:35will be legally required that you know will perhaps
- 7:39either damage your case or otherwise enhance
- 7:42the other side's belief in the strength of their
- 7:44case. Secondly, initial considerations is the
- 7:48choice of a mediator. In my experience, and again,
- 7:53I've been mediating for over 40 years, almost
- 7:55since the concept of mediation began, I found
- 8:01reflectively over the years that you want to
- 8:04get a mediator that clearly is familiar with
- 8:07the subject matter, whether it be in tort or
- 8:10contract commercial, whatever it might be, that
- 8:13the mediator has some familiarity with it, either
- 8:15from their experience on the bench or from an
- 8:18attorney's standpoint, what they did in their
- 8:20practice. The experience level really helps expedite
- 8:26the process. One of the most frustrating things
- 8:28that I experienced in the years when I was a
- 8:30practicing attorney before I retired this last
- 8:32year was mediators that required an inordinate
- 8:38amount of education on the front end by the parties,
- 8:42not just about the subject matter of the case,
- 8:44but what the actual law was or the dynamic of
- 8:48that particular commercial industry or dispute.
- 8:52That just eats up time that is later would otherwise
- 8:56be available for the negotiation process. So
- 8:59what you want to do early on is get a mediator
- 9:01that's already familiar with either the subject
- 9:04matter or experience in that area of the law
- 9:06so that you don't have to go over all that or
- 9:09spend an inordinate amount of time at the front
- 9:11end of the mediation at the expense of negotiating
- 9:13time later on. Now, one of the questions that
- 9:18comes up is, all right, we have a mediator that
- 9:21we think is qualified. Sometimes you run into
- 9:24the problem with the advocacy aspect. And what
- 9:28I mean by that is Some parties, some lawyers
- 9:31will just simply not recommend to their client
- 9:33any mediator that the other side recommends because
- 9:36they must believe that there's some sort of an
- 9:38inside edge or something like that or a bias
- 9:40in favor of whoever the attorney is that's recommending
- 9:43them or there's familiarity because this lawyer
- 9:45has used that mediator many times before. On
- 9:48the other hand, there's a school of thought that
- 9:50says, you know what, I don't really, subject
- 9:52to qualifications, meaning familiarity with the
- 9:55subject matter legally and factually. I don't
- 9:59care who the other side is. If they're acceptable
- 10:00to them, they're acceptable to me because if
- 10:03the process is unsuccessful or you run into difficulties
- 10:06later on in a negotiating phase, you want to
- 10:10be able to say, well, look, don't blame us on
- 10:12the media. I went with your mediator. I went
- 10:14with your choice. So that you would think would
- 10:18perhaps encourage a party to continue with the
- 10:21process and not give up. So got to give consideration
- 10:24as to whether or not you would agree. with a
- 10:29neutral or a mediator that is recommended by
- 10:31one party. If you can't agree either side, there
- 10:35are alternatives. For example, jams, you can
- 10:38call them up and basically say, Here's our case.
- 10:43We're going to trial in two months. We need a
- 10:46mediator between now and then to give us a day
- 10:48or two on the following subject matter, the following
- 10:50kind of case. Can you provide us with a couple
- 10:52of names of neutrals that are A, available, and
- 10:55B, fit the description of what we're looking
- 10:57for in terms of qualification and experience?
- 11:00And then you at least have a narrowed down list
- 11:02that neither side recommended, but that are coming
- 11:06to you based solely on your description of the
- 11:09need for an experienced person to handle the
- 11:12dispute. And then you can decide amongst yourselves
- 11:15as to whether or not you'll agree to any of those
- 11:17or you can always go back and say, give us a
- 11:18few more names. But it just gives you an opportunity
- 11:20to not get stuck at the choice of mediators stage
- 11:28because neither side can agree upon anybody.
- 11:32Another thing to consider early on in the mediation
- 11:34process is will it be live or will it be virtual?
- 11:38Now, everything was virtual during COVID and
- 11:40that's sort of where Zoom mediations, we call
- 11:43them, or virtual mediations took off by necessity.
- 11:48And since then, a lot of folks have concluded
- 11:51that this is their preferred way of doing mediations.
- 11:54In my experience, for what it's worth, I still
- 11:56prefer and preferred up to the last day that
- 11:58I practiced live mediations over virtual when
- 12:02it was practical and when everybody could agree
- 12:04upon it. And why was that? Well, I can't tell
- 12:07you how many times over the years I'd be in a
- 12:09mediation and we'd be going on for hours and
- 12:11hours and there'd be a dispute or some sort of
- 12:13an issue that would come up unexpectedly or unforeseen
- 12:18and there's just an impasse and you can't get
- 12:21things going and oddly enough you go out in the
- 12:24hallway to have a cup of coffee or have a you
- 12:26know go outside take a break and you run into
- 12:28opposing counsel You can say, hey, can I talk
- 12:31to you for a minute? And you pull into a side
- 12:32room, and the two of you just kind of work it
- 12:34out just because you ran into each other spontaneously.
- 12:37And that kind of thing doesn't happen if you're
- 12:40doing a Zoom or a virtual mediation. You miss
- 12:43the opportunity for a spontaneous, let's just
- 12:46call it a hallway collision. with whoever it
- 12:49is that is presumably the other party. And sometimes
- 12:52even just the mediator. You get the mediator
- 12:55walking down the hallway and you tap him or her
- 12:57on the shoulder and say, hey, what's going on?
- 12:59What's the problem here? As opposed to waiting
- 13:01for that scheduled time when he or she's gonna
- 13:04come into your room and give you an update. So
- 13:06it just lends itself to a little more flexibility,
- 13:08a little more spontaneity that doesn't exist
- 13:11with a virtual mediation. Now, on the other hand,
- 13:13a virtual mediation has its benefits as well.
- 13:15presumably for the client because they will be
- 13:20in a much more comfortable environment. I've
- 13:23seen bodily injury cases where the plaintiff
- 13:27herself is at home and in a very comfortable
- 13:32environment and very much more at ease with the
- 13:36process, less intimidated, less nervous, less
- 13:39curious about what's happening. And that can
- 13:43be a good thing and that can be a bad thing.
- 13:45The good thing about it is you've got somebody
- 13:47who is tuned in, they're comfortable, and that
- 13:54can lend itself to significant progress. On the
- 13:57other hand, there is a certain benefit sometimes,
- 14:00depending on the person or the persons, of having
- 14:04the... the mediation take place not virtually
- 14:09but again in a formal setting because while we
- 14:15as lawyers are familiar with the whole live mediation
- 14:19process going into an office or to an ADR facility
- 14:22to have it done, that's unfamiliar territory
- 14:25to clients and it can be just as intimidating
- 14:26to them as going into the court to a courtroom
- 14:29to have a mandatory settlement conference and
- 14:31so they can be frightened, they can be nervous,
- 14:32they can be uncertain about what it's all about.
- 14:35And there's a benefit to that too, sometimes,
- 14:37because if you have somebody who might not understand
- 14:39the process or be taking it as serious as you
- 14:41want them to, that environment alone can be very
- 14:45significant in getting people to tune in and
- 14:47be focused, even though they might be a little
- 14:49bit nervous or ill at ease. It lends itself to
- 14:53a degree of seriousness that might potentially
- 14:55be lacking in a virtual or Zoom mediation. So
- 15:01again, as you consider those options and consider
- 15:06the impact that it might have on your client
- 15:08by doing it live versus virtual, explain to the
- 15:12client what the process is all about. Explain
- 15:14to them what the environment is going to be like
- 15:16so that at least some of that nervousness that
- 15:18might impair or get in the way of constructive
- 15:20dialogue is eliminated by letting them know in
- 15:24advance what they're walking into, so to speak.
- 15:27Next slide, please. Okay, so the purpose and
- 15:32process of mediation, all right? First of all,
- 15:35it's voluntary. Nobody gets ordered to mediation
- 15:38in a sort of draconian way. The parties agree
- 15:42independently that they want to get their...
- 15:45dispute resolved outside of the legal process,
- 15:49or at least the formal litigation process. And
- 15:51that way it gives the flexibility of setting
- 15:53the time, the location, the circumstances, the
- 15:58preconditions, et cetera like that, all can be
- 16:00negotiated to mutual satisfaction of both sides.
- 16:04And it's also voluntary in the sense that You
- 16:08know, as much as I hate to say this, but you
- 16:10know, meat eaters, neutrals are vendors. If the
- 16:14process isn't working and you realize that perhaps
- 16:16you've selected the wrong neutral or this neutral
- 16:19isn't somebody that seems to be getting the job
- 16:20done or the chemistry just isn't right, you're
- 16:23free to get up and leave. There's no court order
- 16:27that is forcing you to sit there and do this.
- 16:29And now you might be upset because you've...
- 16:32you pay for the day or whatever it is, but you
- 16:34have to weigh all that against the pros and cons
- 16:37of going forward with this person. My point simply
- 16:39is that you have the flexibility that you wouldn't
- 16:41have, say, at a mandatory settlement conference
- 16:43of being able to just get up and leave or suspend
- 16:47the process until some sort of an issue gets
- 16:51resolved. And then you reset it based on your
- 16:55scheduling and convenience and mutual agreement
- 16:57of both parties. Most importantly, mediation
- 17:00is private. It is a private process. The discussions
- 17:06during a mediation, the documents in the mediation,
- 17:09the writings during a mediation, all are confidential,
- 17:12cannot be referred to or introduced into evidence
- 17:14in court, cannot be disclosed to the outside
- 17:18world. You sign at the beginning of a mediation,
- 17:21a settlement, I mean the mediation agreement,
- 17:24confidentiality agreement that lays all of this
- 17:26out. All the parties agree to it. Oftentimes,
- 17:28you'll get that done before the physical mediation
- 17:31takes place to get it done in advance. But make
- 17:34sure that the clients understand what that's
- 17:36all about. And what's the point of that? I mean,
- 17:39what's the benefit of the privacy of it? Well,
- 17:43again, no publicity. It also allows for, and
- 17:48sometimes that's very important, especially when
- 17:49you're dealing with high profile parties. I represented
- 17:54several professional athletes and some politicians
- 17:58in my career. And it was very, very, very important
- 18:01that, and I will just say high profile people
- 18:03who is very important that the contents of the
- 18:08discussions that took place never saw the light
- 18:11of day for. PR purposes, reputational purposes,
- 18:15same thing with professionals, whether you're
- 18:17representing an architect or an engineer or a
- 18:20lawyer or an agent or broker, anybody that has
- 18:22a professional career whose success is rooted
- 18:27in their reputation very much doesn't want and
- 18:31does not, at least in my experience, prefers
- 18:33not to have their disputes subject to outside
- 18:36public scrutiny. And so the private nature of
- 18:41the mediation process is very, very important
- 18:45in those kinds of cases. It also promotes absolute
- 18:48candor. The fact that what is said in a mediation
- 18:52can't later be introduced into evidence in litigation
- 18:56should the mediation not succeed. is really important
- 19:01because sometimes a simple, I'm sorry, or an
- 19:06apology breaks the ice that has been building
- 19:09over the course of time as this dispute has been
- 19:12developing and maturing. And it gets that out
- 19:17of the way and allows the parties to at least
- 19:20express some degree of sentiment back and forth
- 19:23to each other. And it allows for a tone to be
- 19:28set. for the negotiations going forward. You
- 19:33won't run into the situation where if an apology
- 19:36is extended or some sort of a comment of reconciliation
- 19:41is extended during a mediation, you're not going
- 19:44to find the situation at trial that somebody
- 19:47tries to use that as an admission of liability
- 19:49or something like that because it will be inadmissible.
- 19:53Those of you in California on this, which I understand
- 19:55most of you, just take a look, and I won't go
- 19:57through it, but go into the evidence code section
- 19:591119 through 1122, and that kind of lays out
- 20:03all of the... And this is in addition to evidence
- 20:07code, all the other code sections on the inadmissibility
- 20:11of settlement discussions, but these code sections
- 20:14deal specifically with mediation, privilege,
- 20:16and confidentiality. So I'd ask you to... give
- 20:19consideration to becoming familiar with all of
- 20:21those if you're not already. And also lastly,
- 20:24as we say, as you see on the slide here, the
- 20:27purpose and process of mediation is a lot less
- 20:30formal than litigation in court -supervised settlement
- 20:33discussions. I said it earlier and I repeat it,
- 20:36you can take breaks if you want. You can schedule
- 20:38this to the convenience of yourself and the parties,
- 20:41location, wherever it makes the most sense. that
- 20:44the parties agree upon and if it's not working,
- 20:49sometimes the best way to ultimately achieve
- 20:52a settlement is to take a break when the process
- 20:54is not proceeding in the right direction and
- 20:57resume or reconvene at a later point in time
- 21:00when something that has not yet happened needs
- 21:03to occur in order for the process to move on.
- 21:06For example, if you're in litigation and parties
- 21:10are stuck with respect to what a potential witness
- 21:13might say that has yet to be deposed. Perhaps
- 21:16it might make sense if the process stalls at
- 21:18that point to take a break and take the deposition
- 21:22and then reconvene several days or weeks later
- 21:25so that that anticipated testimony what the parties
- 21:29don't know that witness might or might not say
- 21:32is known. And so that's just an example. Another
- 21:36example might be the requirement of a site inspection
- 21:40or something or some review of a product that
- 21:42is defective that might require some additional
- 21:45testing or whatever it is, whatever it might
- 21:47be. The point is that without that incremental
- 21:50event taking place or that incremental piece
- 21:53of discovery taking place, the parties are just
- 21:55not yet in a position where they feel comfortable
- 21:58proceeding with settlement discussions. They
- 22:00want to keep the settlement dialogue open. So
- 22:03the mediation process remains ongoing. However,
- 22:06you take a break, you take care of the unknown,
- 22:09and then you reconvene and the mediation resumes
- 22:11without having to recreate history and start
- 22:14all over again. So that's one of the benefits
- 22:17of the informality of the mediation process.
- 22:22Next slide. All right, so as you're getting ready
- 22:26to prepare for the mediation, it's very important
- 22:29that you as attorneys and individually and with
- 22:33your clients define what the acceptable end game
- 22:38looks like. Typically, it's not necessarily going
- 22:42to be a single number or a single event. You
- 22:44need to give consideration to, and this is where
- 22:48the flexibility issue arises, how flexible are
- 22:51you going to be with the end game, okay? If it's
- 22:55monetary consideration, I'd suggest that you
- 22:59give consideration to thinking in terms of ranges
- 23:02of numbers that would be acceptable depending
- 23:05upon certain circumstances and depending upon
- 23:08how the mediation goes, what the other side produces
- 23:11in terms of argument and briefing and all of
- 23:13that sort of stuff. And we'll get into briefing
- 23:14here in a moment. And then are there non -monetary
- 23:18things that need to be considered. For example,
- 23:22if the mediation, if the dispute resolution involves
- 23:25something other than money, like an action or
- 23:29an inaction, forgiveness of a debt or an agreement
- 23:32to continue in a business relationship, you want
- 23:36to preserve the business relationship and part
- 23:39of the resolution will be trying to get the other
- 23:42side to agree to continue to do work with you
- 23:44or to continue to send you work, et cetera, et
- 23:46cetera. Try to get all of those end game goals
- 23:50defined, and especially with your client so that
- 23:56at least there are some parameters of where you
- 23:59think you're heading, where you'd like to go.
- 24:02All of this, of course, would be subject to unforeseen
- 24:04circumstances that happen during the process.
- 24:06The other side produces a... especially in cases
- 24:09where you've not even completed discovery yet
- 24:11or you're not even in litigation, the other side
- 24:13might produce an exhibit in the mediation that
- 24:15you didn't know existed. That changes everything.
- 24:18So my strong suggestion for your consideration
- 24:21here is that while you define what your monetary
- 24:24goal zones are, whether you're on the paying
- 24:29end or the receiving end or what non -monetary
- 24:32terms might be important, that you remain flexible
- 24:37and you remain flexible with your clients, your
- 24:39clients remain flexible subject to things that
- 24:41you will learn for the first time or new information
- 24:44that is obtained at the mediation and perhaps
- 24:47even just the evaluation of the mediator. Mediators
- 24:49are neutral. They don't represent anybody in
- 24:52the case. They don't give legal advice, but they
- 24:54may say, have you thought about this? Have you
- 24:56thought about that? That argument has some problems
- 25:00with it, blah, blah, blah. So you may get an
- 25:05evaluative opinion or nuance from the neutral,
- 25:11from the mediator about the strengths and weaknesses
- 25:14of your case without advising you what you should
- 25:16or shouldn't do. All of those things should be
- 25:18taken into consideration and everybody going
- 25:20into the process should have some degree of flexibility
- 25:24to move in response to that one way or the other
- 25:28and not be dug in at a particular number or concept.
- 25:33Next slide, please. Yeah, it's good. Moira, next
- 25:40slide, please. Sorry, it went away. Just one
- 25:44second. That's okay. I clicked on the wrong button.
- 25:52Is it back? No, we're still on that slide. Let
- 26:01me reshare. Here we go. Okay, hang on. You wrote
- 26:04this, folks. Sorry, technical difficulties. That's
- 26:07all right. We're going to slide number five,
- 26:08Moira. Okay, here we are. So as you approach
- 26:21the mediation, one of the things that you need
- 26:25to give great consideration to, and in my experience,
- 26:27this is a very, very important factor, and that
- 26:32is you want it to be the most credible party
- 26:37in the equation, even multi -party case or two
- 26:40-party case. You want to use your best efforts
- 26:44to create a strong degree of candor with the
- 26:49mediator because that's gonna be the foundation
- 26:51of the trust that's gonna be necessary as you
- 26:53go forward through the day in terms of sharing
- 26:55information with the mediator because there'll
- 26:57be information that you tell the mediator that
- 27:00he or she might not be authorized to tell the
- 27:04other side. in the process that you want, but
- 27:07you think the mediator needs to know in order
- 27:09to fully understand the position that you're
- 27:10taking. So candor is very, very important. So
- 27:14if you play hide the ball with the mediator,
- 27:16be careful about what you're hiding because you
- 27:19may be hiding or withholding from the mediator,
- 27:24something that would benefit from the mediator's
- 27:27evaluation in terms of its weight in the process
- 27:30or its weight in navigating the case. towards
- 27:34a resolution. I always like to say that one of
- 27:42the things that you want to be able to do is
- 27:46be the most credible room that the mediator goes
- 27:49to when the mediator runs out of ideas. Because
- 27:52sometimes at the end of the day, the mediator
- 27:53has played all of their cards. They've done all
- 27:56of their tricks. They've used all of their experience
- 28:00to no avail. And yet everybody's still there.
- 28:04The process still has life, so to speak. And
- 28:08the mediator will greatly benefit if he or she
- 28:11feels that there's a room where they can go in
- 28:12and say, what do you think? You got any ideas?
- 28:16You know, you want to be the room that the mediator
- 28:17can go to in the first instance when they've
- 28:21run out of ideas. And they're going to go to
- 28:23the room that, from that mediator's perspective,
- 28:26has established the greatest and the strongest
- 28:28credibility through the process to date through
- 28:31the course of that day. Also, another thing to
- 28:35consider is that when you break, when you have
- 28:39the mediation happens and you have the first
- 28:42breakout sessions and the mediator says, who
- 28:44wants to go first? I always suggest that you
- 28:47give consideration to raising your hand and getting
- 28:49into the mediator's head first. Be the first.
- 28:52breakout room that the mediator goes to, if provided
- 28:55with that option. Some mediators already know,
- 28:58based upon reading the briefs and everything,
- 28:59how they want to start the process. They may
- 29:01want to start with the plaintiff first. And sometimes
- 29:03there's cases where there's situations where
- 29:05the mediator will actually engage with one party
- 29:08in advance of the other, hours before or a couple
- 29:11hours before or a day before, whatever, just
- 29:13to understand the case better. But if you're
- 29:16given the option, of deciding who's gonna go
- 29:20first with the private session with the mediator.
- 29:22I always think that there's benefit, at least
- 29:24in my experience, to going first because get
- 29:27your story into the mediator's head first. Advise
- 29:30the mediator what he or she might anticipate
- 29:33hearing from the other side in response and then
- 29:36your rebuttal to that so that as they're listening
- 29:39to the other side say that which you predicted
- 29:41they were going to hear. they're already thinking
- 29:43about what your responses can be and they can
- 29:45continue to press that room for more information
- 29:48and dig deeper into the issue. So I've always
- 29:52found in my experience, there's exceptional benefit
- 29:55in going first if you have that option. Then
- 30:00the other thing that is important as far as candor
- 30:04goes with the mediator is situations where you
- 30:08have an emotionally charged case. You have cases
- 30:11where there's been abuse. You have cases where
- 30:13there has been significant, not only psychological,
- 30:17bodily injury. You've had cases where businesses
- 30:20have been significantly damaged or destroyed
- 30:23or put out of business, so to speak, that have
- 30:25just generated an enormous amount of emotional
- 30:29energy. And sometimes, depending on the circumstances,
- 30:34there might even be hate issues and things of
- 30:35that sort of things. You got to be candid with
- 30:38the mediator that this is something that has
- 30:41been experienced, this is my opinion, along the
- 30:46life of the claim leading up to the mediation.
- 30:49You've picked up this vibe, so to speak, or your
- 30:51client is subject to emotional triggers and things
- 30:55of that sort. It's best to let the mediator know
- 30:57that so that he or she can navigate carefully
- 31:00and with tact through those issues when they
- 31:03come up. And this can also include financial
- 31:07issues. A dispute may have thrown one party into
- 31:10insolvency, into bankruptcy. You may or may not,
- 31:14if it's an insured situation where there's an
- 31:16insurance company or insurance policy involved,
- 31:18you as the attorney may be concerned that you
- 31:21don't have enough settlement authority or that
- 31:24your settlement authority is going to be very,
- 31:25very limited. Or under the circumstances, you're
- 31:28only going to be able to go so far. Again, you're
- 31:31only going to have an open candid conversation
- 31:33with the mediator like that if there's trust.
- 31:35And that trust is going to be, in my opinion
- 31:38and in my experience, directly related to the
- 31:41degree of candor that you have with the mediator.
- 31:44Yes, I agree that I fully appreciate that there's
- 31:49a little bit of vulnerability with that because
- 31:51you're putting an awful lot of trust in the mediator
- 31:53to understand it and not take advantage of that
- 31:55information that you're giving them. But it's
- 32:01It's gonna be a case -by -case thing, but I think
- 32:03on balance, the more you can trust the mediator,
- 32:06the more the meter's gonna be able to navigate
- 32:08most effectively through difficult issues. For
- 32:13a number of years, I had cases that they were
- 32:16abuse cases, and that would be on the defense
- 32:20side on several of those, and the mediation would
- 32:24start, and I knew that there were just... heavily
- 32:28charged emotional issues, and understandably
- 32:30so in the case. In the media, they would first
- 32:33speak with the plaintiff and the plaintiff attorney,
- 32:35and sometimes he or she would be in there for
- 32:37hours. And my client would look at me and say,
- 32:40what's taking so long? And I'd say, you know,
- 32:43and I think this is indeed the case in many situations
- 32:46like this. Oftentimes, it takes a lot of time
- 32:50for the party that has been on the receiving
- 32:55end of of the claim, or I mean that has made
- 32:59the claim, to have an opportunity to express
- 33:02themselves. This is their day in court. This
- 33:03is their opportunity of the first step towards
- 33:06closure for them. And they want to be heard.
- 33:08They need to be heard. It's important that they
- 33:10be heard. And sometimes that takes time. Sometimes
- 33:12a mediator needs to simply provide a shoulder
- 33:15for them to just get it out of their system,
- 33:18so to speak, and get the emotional aspect of
- 33:23the dispute. neutralized so that the parties
- 33:26can then move forward with the technical side,
- 33:28which is discussion of the settlement ranges
- 33:32and terms and circumstances and things like that.
- 33:36And so, you know, if the right relationship has
- 33:40been established with the mediator, then the
- 33:43mediator will feel comfortable taking on that
- 33:45role of sort of, you know, lending a shoulder
- 33:47for the party to express themselves. for as long
- 33:51as necessary in order to neutralize the emotional
- 33:55issue and let the parties proceed on with the
- 33:57technical discussion. Next slide, please. Okay,
- 34:06so both clients and lawyers have work to do in
- 34:10advance of the mediation. The client's pre -mediation,
- 34:12what I'll call homework checklist here, is make
- 34:16sure that they review all of the documents that
- 34:20are likely to be presented at the mediation so
- 34:23that they don't see them for the first time for
- 34:25two reasons. The most obvious one is a timing
- 34:28thing. If you've got a 20 -page document that
- 34:30they've never seen before that is relevant, that
- 34:32the other side has, that you expect them to produce
- 34:34as a deposition at the mediation, why waste the
- 34:39time of having the client read it for the first
- 34:40time or re -familiarize themselves, so to speak,
- 34:43at the mediation? at the expense of what later
- 34:46will be negotiating time. More importantly, though,
- 34:49it's to keep them from anybody from being surprised.
- 34:52Let them see that you've done your homework,
- 34:55that you've anticipated what the other side is
- 34:56going to produce. Show it to the client. Get
- 34:58their version of the story. Find out what they
- 35:01say in response to this. What's their explanation
- 35:03for why this document exists? Is it authentic?
- 35:06Was it authorized? Et cetera, et cetera. Learn
- 35:08all that stuff in advance if you didn't already
- 35:09know it, if you fully expect the other side to
- 35:12produce it at the mediation. If a deposition
- 35:16has taken place, make sure that your client has
- 35:19re -familiarized themselves with their deposition
- 35:21testimony so that they don't say something to
- 35:23the mediator or say something in a general session,
- 35:26which I'm going to come back to that in a second.
- 35:29That's inconsistent with their deposition testimony.
- 35:31That's all about credibility. And so you're trying
- 35:34to refresh their recollection as to what they
- 35:36said, what they testified to, and of course,
- 35:38if you went to trial, what they would be held
- 35:40accountable for. And lastly, I always think it's
- 35:45very important for a mediator to be open to listening
- 35:47to the client's talk. Lawyers represent their
- 35:52client and rightfully so, they should be speaking
- 35:54on their client's behalf and advocating on their
- 35:56client's behalf. Sometimes there's no more compelling
- 36:00version of what happened and no more compelling
- 36:02version of where a party's coming from than from
- 36:05the client themselves to tell the story. the
- 36:09story will come across with credibility or it
- 36:11won't come across with credibility. The story
- 36:13will come across as genuine and authentic and
- 36:18is it still raw in their mind or is it something
- 36:20they're talking about, something from the past?
- 36:22All of these are nuances for the mediator to
- 36:24pick up on. And so in order to, if you have a
- 36:27situation where the mediator is inviting or you
- 36:30believe as counsel believe that it is going to
- 36:33be constructive for the client to speak. dress
- 36:37rehearse their story, work that with them, get
- 36:39them comfortable telling it in advance so that
- 36:44they're not overly impacted negatively by the
- 36:47environment of a mediation in which they would
- 36:49be telling it for the first time. So that would
- 36:52be what I would consider to be the client's homework
- 36:54checklist. And to make sure that they are well
- 36:56-rested, they understand that the process may
- 36:59take all day, all night, may take more than one
- 37:02session. but make sure that they understand what
- 37:05the process is all about and how this thing is
- 37:08likely to play out. Next slide, please. All right,
- 37:12the attorney's homework checklist is obviously
- 37:15much longer. One of the first questions is, should
- 37:19you have a pre -mediation caucus with the mediator?
- 37:24The mediation process starts when you have your
- 37:26first dialogue with the mediator after agreeing
- 37:29that this is going to be the person that's going
- 37:30to the neutral that's going to help with the
- 37:34resolution of your case. Most mediators will
- 37:38actually schedule a pre -mediation call with
- 37:40either one or both or with either both parties
- 37:42individually or collectively just to make sure
- 37:46that they got a grip on what's going on in the
- 37:47case. Perhaps by this point in time, briefs have
- 37:50already been exchanged. The media has already
- 37:52read them and might have some basic questions
- 37:54about the case, some questions about logistics,
- 37:58anything about any of the parties that he or
- 38:00she needs to be aware of, any impediments to
- 38:03negotiating, you know, talking about making sure
- 38:09that whoever is going to attend the mediation
- 38:11has the authority to bind the parties and to
- 38:14agree to a resolution and making sure, and anything
- 38:20else that might be kind of housekeeping nature.
- 38:23Have that all discussed and worked out with the
- 38:25meat eater in advance in a pre -mediation caucus
- 38:28or phone call. It's one thing to anticipate,
- 38:31if not request if the meat eater doesn't offer
- 38:35it up his or herself. As part of your preparation,
- 38:40it's not just presenting your argument, but anticipate
- 38:42what the other side is going to present. You
- 38:45need to be, always I always like to say, you
- 38:48always need to go into a mediation. in rebuttal
- 38:51mode, in addition to whatever your defense mode
- 38:53is or your plaintiff claim mode is. You've got
- 38:57to be prepared with rebuttals. And so it's very
- 39:01important to anticipate where the other side
- 39:03is going to go and how you're going to respond
- 39:05to that. Talked about it a little bit earlier.
- 39:08Also in advance, identify what your client's
- 39:10emotional triggers are. What are the subject
- 39:13matters that will set them off? And impair. or
- 39:17otherwise damage, if not slow the negotiating
- 39:22process. And when you see a situation developing
- 39:26where it looks like that subject matter is coming
- 39:28up and the client may very well have an emotional
- 39:32reaction to it that was not constructive, you
- 39:34may wish to make sure that you step in and at
- 39:37that point speak on the client's behalf. Take
- 39:40over the tone, so to speak, and keep it from
- 39:44spiraling out of control, which can happen. So
- 39:48be prepared for identifying what you believe
- 39:51those moments might be so that you can see them
- 39:53coming in advance. Again, like the client, know
- 39:56the documents that will likely be presented,
- 39:58and I won't repeat the whole process on that.
- 40:01Make sure that your client has had his or her
- 40:03pre -mediation questions regarding the process
- 40:05fully addressed. even though it's informal, it's
- 40:10literally as important as any other mandatory
- 40:14settlement conference or court conference in
- 40:15the sense that the objective is to resolve the
- 40:19case, right? And if it can be resolved. And so
- 40:24that degree of seriousness that the client would
- 40:27have if this was in front of a judge in a courtroom.
- 40:30They bring that same sense of importance to the
- 40:34mediation. And you need to make sure that the
- 40:37client understands that as informal as it might
- 40:39feel, that the process itself is one that requires,
- 40:44if it's going to be successful, the same degree
- 40:48of seriousness the clients would have if they
- 40:49were in a courthouse. Also in advance, again,
- 40:54working with your client, by the use of the attorney,
- 40:57come to your conclusion on what is and is not
- 40:59subject to compromise. Again, emphasizing to
- 41:03the client that they need to be flexible because
- 41:06there's a lot of unexpected things that happen
- 41:08in mediations. Documents get introduced that
- 41:11weren't there before. Arguments that you've never
- 41:13heard before happen. I've had cases where the
- 41:15law changes in the middle of a mediation like
- 41:17the day before a published case comes out that
- 41:19throws everything up in the air and you have
- 41:21to be able to deal with that. work out what is
- 41:26and is not subject to compromise. There may be
- 41:29non -monetary things that are as important as
- 41:34the monetary ones that unless they happen, you're
- 41:37not going to settle. You can agree upon a settlement
- 41:39number, but if the other side, for example, refuses
- 41:44to do any future work with you or is going to
- 41:50somehow do something that impairs your business
- 41:52going forward. If that's what's gonna happen,
- 41:57you want to make sure that it's understood either
- 42:01through the mediator or at least you've established
- 42:04with your client that if this happens or if it
- 42:06doesn't happen, we're done. So make sure that
- 42:10you understand what those lines in the sand are
- 42:12subject to. something to change as I said but
- 42:14it's really worth talking about that with the
- 42:16client and indeed with the mediator at some point
- 42:19giving him his or her the sense of you know where
- 42:22this process will go off the rails so that that
- 42:26can be taken into consideration with the strategy
- 42:32that the mediator employs. Also one other thing
- 42:35to consider and some people will do this and
- 42:37some people won't is consider discussing non
- 42:41-monetary settlement terms with the other side
- 42:43in advance of the mediation, if you can. Now,
- 42:46sometimes the lawyers and the parties aren't
- 42:48even speaking to each other in advance of a mediation,
- 42:50which is why they've gone to mediation, because
- 42:51they can't work it out themselves. And sometimes
- 42:53there's just animosity, sometimes there's bad
- 42:55blood, sometimes there's bad history, sometimes
- 42:58there's just inability to communicate, whatever
- 43:00it might be. There are occasions where there's
- 43:04simply no discussion that's constructive at all
- 43:06that precedes the mediation itself. But sometimes
- 43:10there is, sometimes you've got a good working
- 43:12relationship with opposing counsel. Why not take
- 43:14the opportunity to see if you can work out all
- 43:17the stuff that is non -monitoring in nature in
- 43:19advance. For example, is there going to be a
- 43:21need for confidentiality? Is there going to be
- 43:24a timing period where the money, if you reach
- 43:26a settlement, you must, the payment has to be
- 43:28made in 30 days or 60 days or something like
- 43:30that. Making sure everybody understands that,
- 43:34you know, any settlement that might have qualifications
- 43:36to it, whether it be a minor's compromise or
- 43:38subject to board approval or whatever it might
- 43:41be, that all that's understood in advance. Also
- 43:44consider that if you reach a settlement, that
- 43:48the settlement agreement that would be written
- 43:51up at the end of the day allows, give consideration
- 43:55to the fact that it would be allowed to be admissible
- 43:57for purposes of enforcing the settlement. These
- 44:00are all things that you can work out in advance.
- 44:02Now sometimes it's really interesting when the
- 44:03mediator finds out that you've worked on these
- 44:05things in advance and you've worked out some
- 44:07agreements, that's a great sign that this is
- 44:11going to be a potentially successful mediation
- 44:14in terms of reaching a result because the parties
- 44:16are already talking about the endgame. All you
- 44:18got to do is fill in the box now with a number,
- 44:20so to speak. And it also shows that the parties
- 44:23are flexible and they're working and they're
- 44:25compromising with each other and they're working
- 44:27towards the common goal of resolution. So it
- 44:30sends a signal to the mediator as well, if non
- 44:32-monetary settlement terms, albeit even a few
- 44:35or extensive, can be agreed upon in advance.
- 44:39Next slide. Okay, so there'll be a mediation
- 44:44brief in advance. There's two types of mediation
- 44:47submissions. You can do a regular brief where
- 44:50you lay out your case, the facts, the law, your
- 44:53argument, and whatever settlement discussions
- 44:57may have had in advance of the mediation, if
- 44:59any at all. And you can either exchange those.
- 45:06with each side. Some parties agree to, I'm going
- 45:09to send a brief to the mediator only. We're not
- 45:11going to exchange mediation briefs. Again, we
- 45:13go back to the flexibility of mediation and that
- 45:15the parties can decide for themselves how they
- 45:17want to handle this. Bottom line is that in the
- 45:22first instance with the briefing, your target
- 45:24audience isn't necessarily the other side, but
- 45:27also you want to be speaking to the mediator
- 45:28too. You want to let the mediator know how much
- 45:31you believe in your case. You want to know what
- 45:33strengths there are. If you're not yet comfortable
- 45:37putting it into a brief, which is completely
- 45:42understandable, there's also something known
- 45:44as what we call a mediator's eyes only letter
- 45:46brief. So in addition to exchanging formal briefs
- 45:48that you share with the other side and you give
- 45:50to the mediator and each side gets a copy of
- 45:52each other's brief, you also have the option
- 45:55of submitting what's called a mediator's eyes
- 45:57only letter brief, which is only to the mediator.
- 46:00It is not shared with the other side. And this
- 46:02is where you give consideration to addressing
- 46:05for the mediator's benefit for that he and she
- 46:08can navigate the case correctly. Things that
- 46:10perhaps the other side doesn't yet know but that
- 46:13you believe are material and those can be factors
- 46:15that are advantageous or not advantageous to
- 46:19your side. Things about witnesses. Things about
- 46:22difficulties you might have had up to this point
- 46:24in time with opposing counsel. Credibility issues
- 46:27that you might have with the other party themselves.
- 46:31Issues that are sensitive. literally a letter
- 46:36to the mediator telling him or her, this is why
- 46:39we haven't been able to settle the case so far.
- 46:41Here's the problem. Here's the problem person,
- 46:43whatever it is. Being very open, candid, just
- 46:46lay it all out there. And before doing that,
- 46:48you need to ask yourself, is it better that the
- 46:50mediator knows this or doesn't know it? In my
- 46:52experience, I think it's good for the mediator
- 46:54to know this. And also I never miss an opportunity
- 46:56when I was practicing, I never missed an opportunity
- 46:58to put my version of how I wanted him or her
- 47:01to see the case. into their head, and a letter
- 47:04brief was almost automatic in most of the cases
- 47:06that I did. And it certainly doesn't hurt at
- 47:10all. The other thing is, this is really important.
- 47:16When you write a letter brief, in fact, when
- 47:18you write any kind of a brief whatsoever, and
- 47:20you put into that brief what you believe, you
- 47:24know, whether it's a settlement demand or something
- 47:27to that nature, or anything with a figure in
- 47:29it, Make sure your client understands that the
- 47:33brief is an exercise in advocacy and does not
- 47:38stand in contradiction or in the place of whatever
- 47:41advice that you've given them already. For example,
- 47:46you might have told your client confidentially
- 47:49that the case is worth $300 ,000 or something
- 47:55like that, and yet your brief puts a demand in
- 47:58there for a million dollars. Well, your clients
- 48:00might get confused and say, wait a minute, what's
- 48:02going on here? It might start psychologically
- 48:03spending a million dollars, which is the last
- 48:05thing you want them to do going into the mediation.
- 48:07If you believe that the value of the case is
- 48:09300 ,000, make sure the client understands that
- 48:12the brief is an exercise in advocacy that does
- 48:15not stand in contradiction to the advice that
- 48:17you've already given them. What you don't want
- 48:19to have happen is some sort of a claim down the
- 48:22road where the client says that the case was
- 48:27settled for less than it was worth. And exhibit
- 48:29A is something that you wrote in the brief. It
- 48:33should be kept confidential, but somehow it comes
- 48:35into evidence that there was this brief where
- 48:37you said the case was worth a million dollars.
- 48:41So these are just things to consider how you
- 48:44do it. But these are also ways to avoid what
- 48:50I'll call time. impacting disagreements at the
- 48:54mediation, where the client perhaps is picking
- 48:57up a different signal from you than they did
- 49:00in advance of the mediation, leading up to it
- 49:02with respect to either strategy or the amount
- 49:05involved in the claim and what your objective
- 49:08is going to be. Make sure that they understand
- 49:09that there's a lot of advocacy, call it puffing,
- 49:15whatever you want to call it, but that you're
- 49:17going to do the best you can to get them the
- 49:20right result. You have to start at one number
- 49:23to negotiate down. You have to start at another
- 49:25number to negotiate up. And that's the process.
- 49:29So next slide, please. Okay. So you get into
- 49:35the mediation the day itself. As I said earlier,
- 49:37there will be a confidentiality agreement that
- 49:39everybody signs in advance. The parties and the
- 49:43lawyers are recognizing and formalizing everybody's
- 49:46understanding and agreement that everything that
- 49:48happens in the mediation is confidential. This
- 49:51is also where the mediator will point out his
- 49:53or her style. And you get two styles on this.
- 49:58One is the mediator will say, anything you tell
- 50:00me, I will be free to share with the other side
- 50:03unless you tell me otherwise. Alternatively,
- 50:06there are mediators who take the position that
- 50:07anything you tell me is confidential unless you
- 50:10give me permission to share it with the other
- 50:11side. So make sure you get an understanding with
- 50:14the mediator about which way he or she tends
- 50:17to approach the day going forward on that subject.
- 50:19How many rooms are needed? Do you have parties
- 50:22that, even though they might all be defendants,
- 50:25do they need to be in separate rooms for particular
- 50:27reasons? Do you have situations where there might
- 50:29be insurance issues or coverage questions with
- 50:32the insurance company where they need to be in
- 50:34a separate room from their policyholder? So get
- 50:38all of that squared away in advance. And sometimes
- 50:41some of that can be handled in that preliminary
- 50:43phone call that I was talking about, the pre
- 50:45-mediation phone call. And then one last thing
- 50:49is, it's important, I think, make sure the clients
- 50:52have had all their questions, if they have any,
- 50:55any Q &A about the day ahead, what the process
- 50:57is like, what's going on, and all of that sort
- 51:00of thing. And so, you know, that's, you know,
- 51:04just how you, I think you start the day. The
- 51:06question, one of the questions is, is do you
- 51:08start out with an open session with everybody
- 51:10in the room at the same time? You know, it's
- 51:12interesting. At the beginning of mediation, that
- 51:14was the way to go. You had everybody in the room
- 51:16at an open plenary general session. And far too
- 51:19often, those just turn into shouting matches.
- 51:21Lawyers were not willing to concede anything
- 51:23in front of their clients that the other side
- 51:24might have said it was credible. At this point
- 51:28in time, the parties have not yet had an opportunity
- 51:30to defuse their anger or whatever emotions might
- 51:33be in there. And when they hear the other side
- 51:35laying out the case, it just percolates and makes
- 51:38things worse. There's other occasions where...
- 51:41a joint session at the beginning can be used
- 51:43to help educate the other side about things that
- 51:45they don't know that you believe is very instructive.
- 51:47I've also had a situation where I've seen it
- 51:49where the perception is that the client has not
- 51:55been listening to their lawyer and maybe they'll
- 51:58listen to the argument or the information coming
- 52:04from the other side directly across the table
- 52:06that it might emphasize what they've been hearing
- 52:08all along but have not yet been willing to accept.
- 52:12So these are all things that go into the consideration
- 52:14as to whether you have a joint session. Time
- 52:16has gone by. A lot of folks have concluded that's
- 52:20a waste of time, and all it does is it just raises
- 52:22the prospect of an inflammatory event that sets
- 52:24the process backwards. So they would just prefer
- 52:26that the mediation start with each side in separate
- 52:28rooms and the media just get started straight
- 52:30away. You decide that. The media doesn't decide
- 52:34that. The parties decide. Media may suggest that
- 52:37He or she thinks that open plenary session would
- 52:39be advisable or may advise contrary. So give
- 52:43that consideration in advance as to how you want
- 52:45the day to begin. Excuse me. Next slide, please.
- 52:50Okay. So I'm not going to go into the types of
- 52:54negotiations that happen at mediation because
- 52:56each one of them literally could be a session
- 52:58in and of itself that could go on for quite a
- 53:00bit of time. But typically, you'll have in the
- 53:04mediation session. After the opening sessions
- 53:06are done, the media will meet with each room
- 53:08separately, listen to the case. As I said earlier,
- 53:11if there's emotional issues involved, the media
- 53:13may take a lot of time to defuse those situations,
- 53:17let the parties feel like they've had their day
- 53:19in court, and then get into the actual negotiation
- 53:21of exchanging numbers back and forth. If an offer
- 53:25is made in advance of the mediation, it will
- 53:28typically start this process with the defendant,
- 53:30the other side, excuse me, responding to the
- 53:32pre -mediation demand that they got from the
- 53:34other side and then back and forth and back and
- 53:36forth and back and forth until you reach a number
- 53:38that both sides agree upon. Oftentimes, quite
- 53:44often actually, the parties will go back and
- 53:46forth and then they'll hit an impasse where either
- 53:48they are just simply going tit for tat, so to
- 53:51speak, or one party comes down an amount, the
- 53:52other side goes up the same amount. There's really
- 53:54no movement towards anything other than what
- 53:57the central number with the 50 % number would
- 54:00be between those exercises, which if that number
- 54:02is not acceptable to either side, it's a waste
- 54:04of time to go there. So the parties may revert
- 54:07to what's called bracketing. And again, I'm not
- 54:09going to go into the mechanics of bracketing.
- 54:11That's a whole other section of it. But it's
- 54:12basically negotiating when the offer -counteroffer
- 54:16process has stalled, where one side says via
- 54:21the mediator, I will go up to x if you come down
- 54:25to y. And then typically there will be a counterbracket
- 54:29where y says, well, the other side says, no,
- 54:34I'll come down to Z if you go up to D, whatever
- 54:39it is. And that whole dance, so to speak, lends
- 54:44itself to the creation of midpoints between where
- 54:47they are and where you are that ultimately start
- 54:49to frame where the parties are likely to be headed.
- 54:55But again, it's a whole other subject for another
- 54:57day. My point simply is that you have different
- 55:00types of negotiation that will take place, and
- 55:03parenthetically with respect to bracketing. If
- 55:06the bracket is unsuccessful, you can always go
- 55:09back to the offer -counter offer process. So
- 55:15you can also have what we call high lows, where
- 55:20you can agree maybe not to settle the case in
- 55:22that day, but to go on to trial, where you have
- 55:25an agreement that the parties will let the case
- 55:30go to verdict. But notwithstanding the verdict,
- 55:33the parties agree, for example, the defendant
- 55:35will pay X, no matter what the jury does, and
- 55:39the plaintiff will say that they will take Y,
- 55:41no matter what the jury does, so that at least
- 55:43the high and the low of exposure to both SART
- 55:46parties is understood. And then the jury delivers
- 55:49its verdict, and that triggers whether it's the
- 55:52high or the low, that becomes the number that
- 55:54settles the case. And so then, through that process,
- 55:59through all those things, if the case is resolved,
- 56:01you'll end up with a settlement agreement. Make
- 56:03sure that you give consideration to having the
- 56:07settlement agreement not subject to the confidentiality
- 56:10provisions of the evidence code for purposes
- 56:12of enforcing the settlement agreement. Make sure
- 56:14that your client has signed it, that it is subject
- 56:18to whatever conditions there might be, minors,
- 56:20compromise, board approval, et cetera. And if
- 56:22the case is unsuccessful, at that point, see
- 56:27if your mediator will agree to remain available
- 56:29until all the settlement terms are met. if mediation
- 56:33requires another session due to the inability
- 56:37to understand what a deponent might say or some
- 56:39piece of evidence that is yet to be challenged,
- 56:43set an idea, establish an idea of when that next
- 56:45session takes place in 60 days, 90 days, and
- 56:48schedule it if you can. But your mediator would
- 56:50meet it available and you can pick up where you
- 56:52left off and quite often there might be some
- 56:54telephone negotiation that goes on in the meantime
- 56:56where the mediator starts working with you. independent
- 56:59of the formal setting, the formal mediation process
- 57:01to kind of see how the process is going along.
- 57:04So next slide. There we go. So at this point,
- 57:09we've got just a few minutes. Why don't we take
- 57:11a few questions and answers? I've thrown an awful
- 57:13lot at you. But again, this was just to basically
- 57:16give you the... parameters of what a mediation
- 57:21looks like if indeed this is your first time
- 57:23going into the process. So happy to take a look
- 57:26at any questions that you might want to submit.
- 57:33So Mike, we did have a couple questions come
- 57:35in. One was about... Well, here we are. Here
- 57:39they are. I see it now. There we go. Okay. I'm
- 57:43sorry. There they are. It wasn't on my screen.
- 57:49Okay, looking for the questions. Some of this
- 57:51looks like CLE stuff. Bear with me one second.
- 57:56Oh, there's the, okay, there you go. So here's,
- 57:57okay, it looks like there's two here, Q and A,
- 57:59there we go. Okay, well, most meters agree to
- 58:02either do or some meters only do virtual mediations.
- 58:05You know, I understand some will only do virtual
- 58:10mediations. What I found was that Most meters
- 58:18will do both. Now, if it requires traveling,
- 58:22that introduces a scheduling issue into the equation,
- 58:27because you might want a mediation. And if mediation
- 58:29is going to take place in Texas, well, you need
- 58:30a day to get to Texas and a day to get back from
- 58:32Texas. So you're talking about three days there.
- 58:34So those things need to be taken into consideration.
- 58:37And that's really the personal preference of
- 58:39the mediator. I have myself, I travel all over
- 58:42the country. I'll do them anywhere. Because as
- 58:45I said before, I believe that in -person mediation
- 58:48is a much more effective way of doing it if the
- 58:51parties will agree to it. Next question. Do I
- 58:56generally feel that there is any difference between
- 58:57settlement conferences at court and private mediation
- 59:00benefits to one over the other? It seems to me.
- 59:02that if the parties want to settle, the case
- 59:04will settle, but I would love to hear your experience
- 59:06with private mediation, you can have more time
- 59:08and more engagement when the parties have skin
- 59:10in the gate and put money in play, but I'm not
- 59:12sure I've seen a substantial difference in the
- 59:13number of settlements as a result of mediating
- 59:17versus going to a mandatory settlement conference.
- 59:20Well, again, that's a timing thing. That's a
- 59:22very fair question, but in my experience, mandatory
- 59:25settlement conferences usually happen when you're
- 59:26on the cusp of trial or trials approaching fairly
- 59:29quickly. And so you've got that threat hanging
- 59:31over you in a very immediate way that you don't
- 59:33necessarily have when you schedule a mediation
- 59:35for earlier in the process, giving yourself plenty
- 59:40of time for a second session or third session
- 59:42if need be. Yeah, sometimes the judges can be
- 59:47a little more hard -nosed. You can't get up and
- 59:49leave a mandatory settlement conference if you
- 59:52don't like the way it's going. You can with a
- 59:54mediation. You can stop it. And so you have more
- 59:58flexibility to sort of guide it. Whereas, you
- 1:00:02know, if you're in court and you're at a mandatory
- 1:00:04settlement conference, you don't have that flexibility.
- 1:00:08And, you know, who knows what finds its way to
- 1:00:12the to the in terms of you know, who's reasonable
- 1:00:16or not, not going into the substance of any of
- 1:00:19this stuff, but ultimately there's going to be
- 1:00:21a trial judge that's in that same courthouse
- 1:00:23that will understand that this case didn't settle
- 1:00:26despite the best efforts of whoever it is that
- 1:00:28day without going and not exposing or disclosing
- 1:00:31any of the stuff that happened at the settlement
- 1:00:33conference. There's a judge that says that it's
- 1:00:35going to find out that he or she has to try a
- 1:00:37case that presided over a case that didn't settle,
- 1:00:40notwithstanding the fact that whoever it is that
- 1:00:43did it gave it their best efforts. And so does
- 1:00:47that mean anything? I don't know, but it's one
- 1:00:49more factor that's sitting out there that doesn't
- 1:00:51exist in a mediation. In my experience, mediations
- 1:00:54are extremely successful. I could say, my goodness,
- 1:01:00for having done it for 40 years or so that. I
- 1:01:04think my track record in terms of not what I
- 1:01:08accomplished, but the ones that I participated
- 1:01:09in, I should say, because I think the party settled
- 1:01:11the case, the lawyers don't, is well over 90
- 1:01:14% over time, not necessarily all in one session.
- 1:01:21And so again, the fact that a court supervised
- 1:01:24settlement conference usually has a trial threat
- 1:01:26hanging over it in a very meaningful way. you
- 1:01:31know, that tends to impact parties as well. And
- 1:01:34again, if you're at a mandatory settlement conference,
- 1:01:37you know, the court is going to order you to
- 1:01:39have the person with authority present or available.
- 1:01:42And at a mediation, people represent that they
- 1:01:45have that, but sometimes they don't. You know,
- 1:01:47some you might have an insurance representative
- 1:01:48who only has a certain amount of authority and
- 1:01:50the mediation has developed to the point where
- 1:01:52it looks like a lot more money is going to be
- 1:01:54necessary. But the claims person who attended,
- 1:01:57it doesn't have the authority. It needs to go
- 1:01:58to somebody else who's not available. Okay, that's
- 1:02:01not going to happen in a mandatory settlement
- 1:02:02conference in court. So these are the differences.
- 1:02:07Are there, next question, are there situations
- 1:02:09where you've not given a copy of the mediation
- 1:02:10brief to your client to avoid them thinking the
- 1:02:12case is worth millions and millions in their
- 1:02:14mind? If so, how do you, I've never done that.
- 1:02:16Everything that I, you write, you give it to
- 1:02:19the client. But again, this is what I was, where
- 1:02:21I was going earlier with my comment that you,
- 1:02:23that I believe in my practice is always to put
- 1:02:25a cover note on it. reminding the client that
- 1:02:28this brief is an exercise in advocacy and does
- 1:02:31not in any way change or alter the advice that
- 1:02:36I've previously given them as to what I think
- 1:02:38the case was worth or what the right number was
- 1:02:40that they should settle for. Now, that said,
- 1:02:46I've been on the other side of the equation where
- 1:02:48I can't get a case settled because the attorney
- 1:02:51on the other side didn't do that. And there've
- 1:02:54also been occasions that I've had cases I was
- 1:02:56involved in where, reportedly, never had to look
- 1:03:00into it to verify, but reportedly, lawyers would
- 1:03:04make some sort of a representation to a client
- 1:03:06as to what the case was worth as they were being
- 1:03:08interviewed to be hired by the client to take
- 1:03:10their case on. Now, you know, it's a terrible
- 1:03:14thing to do and yet. If it happens, then the
- 1:03:17client has a number in their head that they think
- 1:03:18they're going to get. And if they start psychologically
- 1:03:21spending that money, they've already bought a
- 1:03:22new boat before you even walk into the mediation
- 1:03:24in their mind. And the case ultimately gets to
- 1:03:30the point in mediation where you're saying, at
- 1:03:34best, we're only going to get half as much. Now
- 1:03:36you've got an issue with your client that shouldn't
- 1:03:39exist if properly handled in the first place.
- 1:03:45Those are all the questions. Any last ones? Let's
- 1:03:47see. I think that I don't believe I missed any.
- 1:03:50Let me see. Thank you and thank you. Okay. That's
- 1:03:56it. So any last questions from anybody? Because
- 1:03:58I think we've reached our time limit here, but
- 1:04:00happy to proceed on if there are any more. Okay.
- 1:04:07Looks like that concludes today's presentation.
- 1:04:09Thank you so much, Michael, for an excellent
- 1:04:11presentation today and for your time. And thank
- 1:04:13you so much to our audience for joining us. Have
- 1:04:15a great day, everybody. Thank you, everybody.
- 1:04:18Take care.