Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When You Were Just Hired
Transcript
- Lucas: So you just landed a new job, you're three months in, you're doing great work, and then you find out the person two desks over with the same title is making twelve percent more than you. What do you do? Luna: That's such a specific gut-punch. And it's more common than people think. Lucas: It really is. We've covered a lot of raise scenarios on this show, but we haven't talked about the one where you haven't even been there a year. And that's a different beast. You don't want to look ungrateful or entitled, but you also don't want to leave money on the table for the next four years. Luna: So what's the first move? Do you march into your manager's office and demand a market adjustment? Lucas: You don't march. You walk, slowly, with data. The first thing is to know what 'underpaid' actually means. One data point from a colleague isn't enough. You need a spread of comparable salaries for your role, your industry, and your region. Luna: Where do you get that without making it weird? Lucas: There are salary aggregators, industry surveys, and sometimes your professional network. But here's the thing: you need to compare apples to apples. A title alone isn't enough. What's the level of responsibility, the team size, the scope? That's where most people mess up the comparison. Luna: Right, so you have to build a case like you're a lawyer. Lucas: Exactly. And the second piece is timing. Most companies have a compensation cycle, and your manager may have zero authority to change your salary outside of that. So you need to understand when decisions get made. Is it quarterly? Annually? That's going to shape your approach. Luna: But you don't want to wait nine months if you're truly underpaid. Lucas: No, you don't. And that's where the conversation gets strategic. You're not asking for a raise because you've been there a year and you deserve it. You're asking for a correction because the market rate for your role is higher than what you were offered. That's a different argument, and it's stronger. Luna: Can you give an example of how that actually sounds? Lucas: Sure. A few months ago I talked to a software engineer who'd been at a mid-sized fintech for about six months. He found out his peer was making fifteen percent more. He did the research, found that the market had shifted since he accepted the offer, and went to his manager with a specific number. He said something like: 'I'm really enjoying the work and I want to stay for the long term, but I've done some research, and the market rate for my role has moved. I'd like to discuss aligning my salary with that.' Luna: That's direct but not hostile. Did it work? Lucas: He got a bump of fifteen percent, actually. But the key was he framed it as a market adjustment, not a personal grievance. He also gave his manager an easy out by tying it to retention. He said, 'I want to make sure I'm not falling behind, because I want to be here for years.' Luna: So you're selling it as a way for the company to keep you? Lucas: Yes. Because from the manager's perspective, a small raise is cheaper than hiring and training a replacement. That's the logic you're appealing to. And that's why timing matters. You want to have some wins under your belt so you can point to concrete contributions. Luna: What if you haven't had time to rack up wins? Like you're two months in. Lucas: Then you might need to wait. If you're two months in and you haven't delivered anything yet, your manager has no reason to invest in you beyond what they already have. But you can use that time to build your case—document your projects, get feedback, and set up a baseline for a conversation at the six-month mark. Luna: So the ideal window is around six months? Lucas: That's a good rule of thumb. By then you've got some momentum, you've learned the ropes, and you've probably delivered something tangible. And if you're in a high-demand field like engineering or data science, the market may have already shifted since you signed your offer. Luna: That's a thought—the market moving. With everything going on in August 2026, some salaries have really jumped. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the market adjustment argument works. You're not saying you're underpaid relative to your own expectations. You're saying the market has moved, and your salary hasn't. That's an objective fact, not a complaint. Luna: But what about the risk? What if your manager takes it the wrong way? Lucas: There's always risk. But here's the thing: if you've done the research and you're respectful, the worst case is your manager says no. And that's not a catastrophe. It might hurt your pride, but it doesn't usually end the relationship. And if it does, that's a signal about the culture anyway. Luna: So you're saying the downside is manageable if you play it right? Lucas: Mostly. But there are some landmines to avoid. Don't threaten to quit unless you're truly prepared to follow through. Don't compare yourself to a specific coworker by name. That puts your manager in an awkward spot and turns it into a gossip problem instead of a compensation problem. Luna: And don't do it during your first month, right? Lucas: Right. That's a classic rookie mistake. You haven't earned any credibility yet, and it looks like you're not grateful for the offer you accepted. Save it for when you have some leverage. Luna: What if your manager says the budget is frozen? We've talked about that before. Lucas: Then you ask for a timeline. 'When might the budget open up? Can we revisit this in six months?' And you also ask for something non-monetary in the meantime—like a title change, a certification, or a stretch project that will position you for the next cycle. That way you're not walking away empty-handed. Luna: So you're building towards the raise even if you don't get it today. Lucas: Exactly. And one more thing: you need to get it in writing. Send a follow-up email summarizing the conversation. Not to be aggressive, but to make sure you're both on the same page about what was discussed and any commitments that were made. Luna: That's a good tip. It's like a paper trail without being weird about it. Lucas: And it protects you later. If they say 'we never agreed to that,' you have the email. It's professional, not paranoid. Luna: Hey, before we wrap up, you know what I love about this show? We never have to cut to a commercial break. It's just us, talking it through, no ads. Lucas: That's deliberate. We don't run ads on these episodes. If you want to support that choice, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's optional, but it keeps us independent and focused on the advice. Luna: Yeah, and we appreciate anyone who does. It lets us keep the conversation real. Lucas: So back to that engineer—the key wasn't just the right words. It was the preparation. He knew his numbers, he had a clear ask, and he framed it as a win for both sides. That's what you want to do. Luna: And if your manager says no? You've lost nothing, and you've learned something. Lucas: Right. You've learned whether this is a place that invests in its people. And that's valuable information for your next move—whether that's staying and growing, or updating your resume. Luna: So the takeaway: do the research, pick the right moment, and make it about the market, not your feelings. Lucas: Exactly. And remember, the worst they can say is no. But if you've done your homework, you might just get a yes.