Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / My Casket is Not Your Soapbox
Transcript
- 0:00We understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:19it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking, feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom
- 0:33will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start
- 0:40thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. Hey,
- 0:56beautiful people, So glad you're here. I just had something on my mind,
- 1:00and I thought maybe i'd wrap a show around it. Hopefully I'm not
- 1:03guilty of the very thing that I am concerned about, the thing that I'm
- 1:10going to be exploring on the show. I don't think so. I don't
- 1:14think so. But you know, when something happens in your personal life,
- 1:18you, I don't know, you want to express it and talk about it,
- 1:21and I don't have a lot of people here I can really talk about
- 1:23it with, so I'm talking to you. Terrible tragedy a friend of mine
- 1:30on my tennis team his daughter. Fifteen year old daughter was just in a
- 1:34terrible car accident that she was killed, and the funeral was at a church.
- 1:41There were Christian family heavily wired in, and so I joined so many
- 1:45other people to attend the funeral. And I had some people ask me,
- 1:49well, why would you do that, Why would you go to a church?
- 1:53How do you even enter a church? This is a religious exercise,
- 1:57And I replied, well, it's not really about me, right, I'm
- 2:01going to express love and support. I'm here for you. What can we
- 2:07do. I want you to see my face and know that I care.
- 2:09So it's not really about me walking in and so boxing about the fact that
- 2:15I don't believe that there was a God in control, etc. It's more
- 2:21about being a humanist, being a human being, demonstrating compassion, saying I'm
- 2:25bigger than our theological disagreements. I mean, it sounds noble when I say
- 2:30it that way, but I just that's how I phrase it, Okay.
- 2:34And I was there and it was tremendously sad. It's just it's a horrible
- 2:38thing, the loss of a child. I just can't even imagine how you
- 2:42deal, how you cope and I'm sure there were people in the audience who
- 2:46have stories of their own journeys through and I'm sure that journey continues every single
- 2:51day. But I was sitting there and it was an hour and forty five
- 2:57minutes. The service started with thirty minutes of praise and worship music, and
- 3:04it was that typical sort of integrity music, hillsong stuff, you know,
- 3:07that homogenized you alone are worthy. Yes, we love you Jesus even though
- 3:16we are in sex. You're my God. It was all that kind of
- 3:21thing. But apparently these were her favorite songs or some of them. Okay,
- 3:24fine. The funerals about her first pastor comes out, to his credit,
- 3:30he talks some about Jesus and her faith, but he talked a lot
- 3:35about who she was, and I think that's critical. It's often missing.
- 3:38We've all seen those funerals, and I want to hear your stories where you
- 3:43know, somebody comes out at a funeral and they don't talk about the deceased.
- 3:47They're busy selling their gods. My father's funeral and he was a devout,
- 3:52devout, devout Christian, but I was so frustrated because while I expect
- 3:57and I guess it's appropriate because this was who he was that they say,
- 4:00he's a man who loved Jesus. He loved Jesus, he loved the Lord,
- 4:03he loved the Lord. He was he just do you know? Blah
- 4:06blah blah. But there was so much of it that nobody was talking about
- 4:10him. Who was he, what was his personality like, what were his
- 4:15interests? Where did he travel, what experiences did he have? Give me
- 4:19an anecdote some of his jokes that he used to tell over dinner, What
- 4:24were his favorite foods at dinner? The things that you carry with you in
- 4:28memory, those were missing. In fact, it was me, and I
- 4:30can't believe they actually gave me a few minutes behind the microphone, given our
- 4:34history, but they did. It was me going up there and saying,
- 4:40this is what he was like, and I remember this when we had did
- 4:44this and he did that, and now remember what he wore, and now
- 4:46remember this quirk that he had. And it was very personal. But it
- 4:49took the atheist to go up there and describe the man. To their credit,
- 4:58at this funeral, they described and honored this young girl. There was
- 5:03a slideshow with images and then there was a second preacher and he came up,
- 5:12and he was much more overt. Now, the cynic says, they
- 5:17are preying on people at a time of intense vulnerability, and those things do
- 5:23happen, but often the skeptic misses the reality that in Christian churches and Christian
- 5:30cultures, these things are said and done with absolute sincerity and a desire to
- 5:35be good. He came forward, and he genuinely believed that she would have
- 5:43wanted something good to come out of her death, and he began to talk
- 5:47about her love for Jesus and how she would not want anyone to miss heaven.
- 5:53And did I start to sit forward in my chair a little bit that
- 5:58I start to vibrate a little bit, Yeah, okay, But I also
- 6:03saw this almost like you would see. It's in a laboratory where I was
- 6:08in the faith years ago, when I would be there, you know,
- 6:12thinking about reuniting with her in heaven and we'll all be at this happy place
- 6:16where there is no pain, there are no car accidents, there's only going
- 6:19to be joy. It's going to be amazing. And I would have been
- 6:23thinking about that. It would have been a balm to my grief in that
- 6:27way. But now I really became interested in how human beings have long created
- 6:34the mechanisms for their coping right we are faced with the unthinkable. How natural
- 6:44is it that so often we grabbed the first pencil we see, or the
- 6:48one that has been put in our hand, and we draw the happy ending.
- 6:56We create the mechanism for dealing with this. I understand the appeal.
- 7:03All things work together for good to those who love God and are called according
- 7:10to his purpose. The Lord works in mysterious ways. The pastor said,
- 7:14she was given to us for a time, and in his timing he drew
- 7:17her home. But one day we will be together, and we should be
- 7:21thankful for the gift of her life the time we did have. What a
- 7:27blessing, What a blessing. The rationalist in me is just kicking God's master
- 7:35plan, even if you only wanted her on earth for fifteen years, which
- 7:40is sadism. By the way, you give the gift of a baby girl
- 7:44to a mother and father and they raise her to her teen years, there
- 7:48is a familial love and bond that cannot be described in language. And then,
- 7:55just because what God needed another angel in heaven, he pulls the plug.
- 8:00He strips this daughter away from a parent. Nobody at the church service.
- 8:07I don't know. Maybe somebody was thinking about that, like why what
- 8:09father would do that? And what was his method? Did he show up
- 8:15and the family's all in the house, and Jesus says, all right,
- 8:18you won't understand my reasons, but I want to draw this young lady back
- 8:22into heaven and she will be waiting for you. And then peacefully he reaches
- 8:26over and he lays a finger on her face or grabs her hand, and
- 8:31she quietly, peacefully, without pain, goes to sleep. No. No,
- 8:35God's method is to have her body literally beaten to death inside a car,
- 8:41a smashed, crushed car. But I understood why they were building this
- 8:48scenario where something good will come out of the pointless. There is a reason
- 8:54for something that seems reason less. And then the music. I get that
- 8:58We've all really begun to understand brain chemistry. Communal music is therapy. Communal
- 9:07music produces brain chemistry. It fires off those endorphins which are balming and calming
- 9:16elements and bonding elements. They pull people together. It's the same phenomenon you
- 9:24can get from music in another context, but when you see it in church,
- 9:28grieving people all singing, raising hands. We understand this is therapy.
- 9:33These are people trying to deal with pain, and I think that has to
- 9:37be approached with compassion. But then the pastor led a salvation prayer, and
- 9:45this is where I start to really get pissed again. He's totally sincere.
- 9:52But sometimes the worst ideas are done with the best of intentions. I think
- 9:58the family may have felt better knowing that maybe their daughter's death produced eternal life
- 10:05in people within the auditorium who said the salvation prayer. But we've all heard
- 10:11this. There may be some people in this auditorium who came here today who
- 10:13don't know. They haven't experienced the love of Jesus. They don't know what
- 10:18it's like to know that when they die one day, they will not die,
- 10:24but they will enter eternity at the hand of God. If you're one
- 10:31of those people, I want you to pray with me. Everybody, please
- 10:33bow your heads, nobody looking around, nobody looking around, and you don't
- 10:37have to say this prayer out loud, but I just want to pray with
- 10:41you today. If you don't know the Lord Jesus today, pray this prayer
- 10:46with me. Dear Lord, I am a sinner. I'm unworthy. I
- 10:54was born without you, and I need to open up and let you in.
- 11:01It was that kind of thing, and there was that kind of unworthiness.
- 11:05Jesus came and died because we're just so shitty. They didn't say it
- 11:09that way, but that's really the under It was a subtext. Lord.
- 11:15I asked that you come in, and instead of it being all about me,
- 11:18it's you, not I. But Christ lives in me, and I
- 11:24accept you. Please save me. I dedicate my life to you in Jesus'
- 11:28name. Amen, Now with nobody looking around, If you just said that
- 11:33prayer, I want you to raise your hand, raise it high so I
- 11:37can see it. They're oh, look at those hands. I see those
- 11:41hands. Yes, so many hands. Thank you. You can put your
- 11:46hands down. Now. If you said that prayer and you don't have a
- 11:54church home, I want you to find somebody here, somebody on staff at
- 11:58this church. Tell them what just happened, and let us lead you through
- 12:03those first steps. And if you have a church, I want you to
- 12:05find somebody there. When I was a devout Christian, this would have been
- 12:09a beautiful thing. We knew a guy I remember when I was in high
- 12:13school. There was a guy and he was in a car accident. I
- 12:16think I was seventeen, and so was he. He was horribly killed.
- 12:22People were devastated. The whole school was devastated. We attended the funeral,
- 12:26but we heard a story there was somebody else in the car and they were
- 12:31traumatized by what had happened, and through it they came to a point where
- 12:37they were just devastated, looking for healing, They accepted Jesus and became a
- 12:41Christian, and so that became the story. You know, the Lord took
- 12:46him. But did you hear about Bobby over here or whatever his name was.
- 12:50You know, he got saved. You know, maybe there's a master
- 12:54plan. Maybe maybe God used our light and momentary affliction to yates an eternal
- 13:01glory that far out weighs them all his ways, not my ways. The
- 13:05Lord is good. One hour and forty five minutes, I was a long
- 13:11ass thing. So glad I went for the people I care about, But
- 13:16it was hard to listen to. Now we can talk about whether or not
- 13:24it's healthy or unhealthy to tell ourselves these stories in order to cope with the
- 13:30unthinkable. And I do think that people need to be approached with compassion when
- 13:35they tell the stories of heaven and reuniting with those they've lost. Certainly when
- 13:43it comes to the loss of a child, these people deserve our compassion,
- 13:48but our desire to see them not in pain and their desire to navigate through
- 13:54somehow doesn't mean that any of this is true, doesn't mean that any of
- 14:01it is healthy. I had some people on my page and they're like,
- 14:07well, I wouldn't put up with any of that. I'd have got up
- 14:09and walked out. Understand it. I get you. I understand what you're
- 14:13saying. I wouldn't have even walked into that church. After all, it
- 14:16is a church. Well, if you've been scarred by the church, I
- 14:20get that, totally valid. Other people said they would have just they would
- 14:26have just told the family, you know, I'm sorry for what happened to
- 14:30you. But there's just you know, there's no evidence for anything that you're
- 14:33saying. Whoa whoa WHOA time and place, right time and place that was
- 14:41the time for love and empathy and compassion and going up to someone in the
- 14:46moment of unspeakable grief and saying your theology is bullshit is not empathy and love
- 14:52and compassion. And while those conversations should be had at some point, I
- 14:56just don't think they should be had in those days and in those moments.
- 15:01I just don't buy it. What message do I send as an atheist by
- 15:05attending and sitting in the auditorium and just being respectful. I don't have to
- 15:09pray when they pray. If I bow my head, I don't close my
- 15:13eyes. Maybe I don't even bow my head. I don't sing the songs.
- 15:16But I'm there. I'm there in somebody else's context because I care about
- 15:20them as people. But it's frustrating. It's frustrating, and I find the
- 15:28Salvation prayer especially frustrating. Now. The church, often for the best of
- 15:35intentions, will find people that they're most raw, and they'll say, you
- 15:39know what, We've got the medicine for you. You lost somebody, you're
- 15:46going through depression. You went through a terrible breakup or a divorce or whatever.
- 15:52You know, you lost a relationship that you cared about. You were
- 15:56fired from your job, You have of addiction recovery issues. You're navigating coming
- 16:03out of an addiction to a substance of some kind. You have been living
- 16:07by yourself and you have no one, and here the doors open, and
- 16:11people say always welcome, our doors are open, will be your family.
- 16:15Whatever they find you at that moment. And because they see it as part
- 16:21of their work as good people, they will say, hey, we're here,
- 16:26we have a ministry for you, we have people for you. But
- 16:30it's also and we have to be honest about it. It's also preying on
- 16:33those who are most susceptible in a time of real vulnerability. They're just they're
- 16:41an open wound. They are in that moment, going to respond more quickly
- 16:45to whatever you are selling. They are they are more apt to buy it.
- 16:55And then what they enter that cycle of heel is worthy. I am
- 17:02not worthy, not me, but Christ lives in me. Jesus came to
- 17:07forgive me because I have a sin nature. All of this communicating what the
- 17:14problem is me, it's victim blaming. So if I'm going through a breakup,
- 17:17or I've had addiction problems, or if I'm depressed or going through some
- 17:21other life crisis, well it's because it's a fallen world. It's just sad.
- 17:26It's you know, it's just the way human beings are. Fortunately,
- 17:29Jesus came and he died on the cross. To fix it, all we
- 17:33have to do is be essentially slaves to him for the rest of our lives.
- 17:40We've seen ritual, the power of ritual, and that was at play
- 17:45at the funeral as well. I mean we see structure helps us to frame
- 17:49the human experience. That's why there are funeral rituals in cultures, religions,
- 17:56traditions worldwide, all kinds of death rituals that helped you mark the passing of
- 18:03someone to remember and then what they go off to some other place. Maybe
- 18:08they become an ancestor that you will one day live with in some other plane.
- 18:14Maybe they become a spirit. Maybe they visit you in the form of
- 18:18I don't know, signs, an animal or something. Maybe they come to
- 18:22you in your dreams. They blend into the energy of the universe. How
- 18:25many religious traditions, how many faith traditions have an after life scenario that is
- 18:30framed in ritual where they say it ain't over totally understandable, it's the medicine
- 18:40we make for ourselves. But does that mean that what we're saying is true?
- 18:48Should we say, you know, there's no evidence that we'll see them
- 18:52again, and I have to deal with that, but I had them,
- 18:57they were here. Life is random and unfair and occasionally shitty. Karma is
- 19:03total crap. Terrible things happen to wonderful people, and terrible people get away
- 19:10with it. Every single day. I live a fragile, finite existence on
- 19:17this rock in a universe that doesn't care. And I understand that there is
- 19:22no evidence for and after life. I accept that, but you know,
- 19:26I'm glad we were together. I'm glad I had the privilege of knowing this
- 19:30person and they and memory will live on in me and in the minds of
- 19:36everyone whose life they touched. Isn't that a healthier way to deal with grief
- 19:42and loss? No victim blaming, no original sin, no statements that we
- 19:49are not worthy, no allegiances to someone that we will essentially have to be
- 19:55a slave to for the rest of our life, and an urgency to live
- 19:59now because there's no evidence of a heaven. We're not living for dying.
- 20:04We're living. An hour and forty five minutes, I'll tell you I came
- 20:11out. I actually recorded a rant about it, and then I walked away
- 20:18and came back and deleted the whole thing because it was a little bit too
- 20:22hot, it was a little bit too much. I was kind of worked
- 20:25up. But even now I feel like it's a conversation worth having because so
- 20:33many people could relate to it. Can you relate to it? I'm sure
- 20:38many people have a story. I would like to talk to you, and
- 20:41I will start with area code nine zero one. Are you there, well,
- 20:48Seth? What's your name? Colin? Colin? Thanks for calling?
- 20:53What are your thoughts on the subject today? When I was a kid,
- 20:59my childhood neighbor was pretty much a surrogate grandmother to us. She would watch
- 21:03us when my parents had to work because my mom worked at a nursing home
- 21:07overnight. My dad was a firefighter so for twenty four hour shifts, so
- 21:11she'd take care of us. She'd take us out to eat. She was
- 21:15just always there for us. Our Christmas tradition, we'd wake up open presents
- 21:19and then go over to her house open presence there because we'd always get her
- 21:23presence and she would always wrap a bag of peanut Eminem's and about fifteen layers
- 21:30of boxes and tissue paper to all of that. She was an absolute,
- 21:36sweet, wonderful lady. She was a teacher her entire life, and her
- 21:41whole expression was teachers don't have kids, they raised them, so she never
- 21:48had any kids. And when she ended up dying, she didn't have any
- 21:52family at her funeral, and she wasn't really religious, but they hired a
- 21:59preacher because of her distant niece arranged the whole thing, and the preacher just
- 22:03read the back of the funeral pamphlet that was basically just saying miss Wilma was
- 22:08a good lady. She loved her dogs, and she loved her pond.
- 22:14And she died and that was pretty much it. And this lady built an
- 22:19entire backyard of a handdug six foot deep pond when she was in her sixties.
- 22:25She was fucking incredible. But the only mention of her at her funeral
- 22:30was the back of that pamphlet, summed up in under two minutes, and
- 22:36then there was forty five minutes of gospel preaching. She wasn't even fucking religious,
- 22:41but that was her final sendoff. And I wish I had said something,
- 22:48but I didn't want to because I just didn't want to rock the boat.
- 22:52But fuck, it's it's fucking frustrating to see somebody that I loved my
- 22:56entire life. I'm thirty one. She died about two three years ago,
- 23:02and just to see her final sind off not even be about her, Like,
- 23:07what do you fucking do about that? It's hard when somebody hijacks somebody
- 23:14else's life in that way? Did she ever attend church? When I was
- 23:18a kid, I used to be super religious, and every Sunday I would
- 23:23ask her if she went, And eventually she started saying she did. I
- 23:26don't know if she ever did. She may have just said that to appease
- 23:30me. I'm assuming she didn't go, but her niece arranged the whole funeral
- 23:34thing. The only thing that I think she did right was it instead of
- 23:37burying her in a dress, they buried her in one of her little sweatshirts
- 23:41with a Boston Terrier on it. What would you have said had you been
- 23:45given the microphone at that moment? I would have talked about how much she
- 23:51loved her garden and how much she loved her pets, and she just liked
- 23:55people, and she was always there for anybody that needed her. But she
- 23:59was that one of those happy, go lucky Yeah, I'm right here,
- 24:03I'm going to help you. It was a yeah, fine, I got
- 24:07you. You know, she wouldn't want to, but she still would because
- 24:10she loved you, and that's the kind of human we should all be.
- 24:14And they never mentioned that. Well, you've given her a better eulogy here.
- 24:19I'm sorry to hear the story, Cullen, but I appreciate you sharing
- 24:22it. Unfortunately, many can relate, but I think we also sort of
- 24:26can support each other in our frustrations and maybe we'll find some solutions if it
- 24:32happens again. Okay, okay, which is I wish we could take religion
- 24:37at a funeral, stop making it about where they're going, and talk about
- 24:40where they've been. I appreciate it, man, thanks for calling. Thank
- 24:45you, sir. I have a great day. It sounds weird when I
- 24:48say that if somebody was religious and wanted a religious send off, that's their
- 24:56prerogative. If somebody wants a religion funeral and they express that, then great,
- 25:03right their last wishes. I know that the memorials are for those left
- 25:08behind, but I'll tell you this, when my time comes, I am
- 25:12going to determine the temperature of how I am memorialized, meaning I'm going to
- 25:18tell those who are running the show if I know it's coming, Actually,
- 25:21they already know how I feel. Don't you dare let this happen in a
- 25:25church. I do not want a pastor. I do not want religious prayers.
- 25:30I do not want a theme about God. I certainly don't want religious
- 25:33relatives coming up and grabbing a microphone and doing an editorial about the black sheep,
- 25:40the lost soul, the prodigal son. We wish she was in heaven.
- 25:44Don't be like Seth. I mean, I don't know if that would
- 25:45ever have. I'll set some parameters, and I do think that the memorial
- 25:51service should represent those who passed on therefore those who are left. But it
- 25:56better reflect me, my life, my values, my attitude, my personality,
- 26:00you know, or I will find a way to come back and haunt
- 26:03your ass. Relating to what he had said about this woman who was not
- 26:08religious, but she ended up having a church service for a funeral against her
- 26:14wishes, I'm sure. I used to be in corporate radio FM radio with
- 26:18a guy and he was not religious. I'm telling you he never talked about
- 26:25God. I know he didn't go to church. He was kind of this
- 26:27hard living dude. But he was a real nice guy. Died of a
- 26:30heart attack too young, he was in his fifties. And I went to
- 26:34the funeral. It was held in a church. I know it wasn't his
- 26:38church. Maybe his name was scribbled on a roster because he visited, but
- 26:41he didn't go to church. And you know what the pastor talked about,
- 26:45Well, you know, he loved the Lord, and you know, you
- 26:48always you didn't always see it out there when he was talking to you.
- 26:52You know, we didn't bring it up very often, but we know he
- 26:55was a good Christian. He loved him some Jesus. And I was sitting
- 26:59in the pew when it was a few going that's a bunch of crap.
- 27:03This is fiction. This is not what that guy. He wasn't like that
- 27:07at all. And yet they tend to take this person's life and they air
- 27:11brush it into something that looks more like the Lord. And I think that's
- 27:15offensive. I mean, sure, yeah, the guy didn't go to church,
- 27:22never mentioned out loud he was a Christian, didn't pray before meals,
- 27:26didn't have a Bible, no, the Bible, didn't act in any way
- 27:29religious in any aspect of his life. But he's with the Lord now,
- 27:34because what when he was six he knelt down and said a prayer that his
- 27:41parents wanted him to pray, and then he lived a totally non Christian life,
- 27:47and then they spend all this I think that pastor had I think he
- 27:52did a salvation prayer too, you know, I think he said, we
- 27:56hold to a Christian faith here and we'd hate to see anybody miss out on
- 28:02the heaven that he is now enjoying him is the same stuff, same stuff.
- 28:06Anyway, I've got to take a break. We have so many people
- 28:10cueued up wanting to talk about this topic. We will continue next. My
- 28:19patrons help me to do what I do, and if you are not a
- 28:25patron, let me encourage you. Just a few bucks a month makes a
- 28:27real difference. You get the show early and commercial freepatreon dot com slash Seth
- 28:34Andrews, Bethany, thanks for waiting. Are you there, Hi, Seth?
- 28:42How's it going? I'm well, what's on your mind? Bethany?
- 28:45What's your perspective? So I had this similar type of experience this past July,
- 28:52well twenty twenty two. I had traveled to Madison, Wisconsin for my
- 28:56grandfather because it took a while for us to even get the funeral schedule.
- 29:00Thought it was going to be pretty basic eulogy. He had this life.
- 29:06He was a machinist kind of more of a celebration of life type of ceremony,
- 29:11and my uncle, with my mom's brother, the oldest son of the
- 29:17family, decided he was going to be doing the eulogy, and unbeknownst to
- 29:21me, it turned into a massive sermon, diatribe, altar, call Jesus,
- 29:29Romans Corinthians. It was horrific and I had that was probably my second
- 29:37funeral that was like full blown Christian type of preachy things since I've converted as
- 29:44an atheist. And I was so mad. I didn't realize. I didn't
- 29:48even realize this was happening to me in the moment until I was picking at
- 29:52the grass because it was outside. I was I was pulling at the grass
- 29:55so hard because I was so furious, like I could not function, and
- 30:00I was just sitting there just like, Okay, this is just who they
- 30:03are, but like, what is happening right now? And it was It
- 30:07was bananas. And I asked my mom about it later, I said,
- 30:10did you know he was gonna do that well, he wasn't supposed to go
- 30:11into all that at the funeral. It was a little heavy and like you
- 30:15think, because two of us were atheists in that crowd. So they just
- 30:21ambushed everybody and excused it because this is what the Lord would have wanted.
- 30:26You know. Probably my mom denies, like, oh, yeah, this
- 30:30is a chance to like, let's just preach out, because your family probably
- 30:33too when you growing up. Oh isn't this a great chance? Everybody heard
- 30:37the word and the plan of salvation, So now everyone doesn't have any excuse
- 30:41when they stand before God one day. Excuse me? What? Yeah,
- 30:45that's not even passive aggressive, that's just aggressive. That's a threat. Now
- 30:49you're on the hook except or reject. The choice is yours. Yep.
- 30:56And I was like, you know, I don't care for your version of
- 30:59substitutionary atonement. I don't. I don't care. Go wash off the grass.
- 31:03Stanes Tega deep breath, Thanks for sharing this and hang in there.
- 31:07Okay, absolutely, thank you so much. You later six zero five?
- 31:15Is it Rachel? Yes, it is hi, Rachel. What's your experience?
- 31:19You want to talk about her? I've just immediately I saw your live
- 31:26I'm like, oh, I have to call a couple of years back.
- 31:30I grew up in a very like an evangelical Word of Faith church, and
- 31:33there were several families that we were all very close to, and our whole
- 31:37life was the church, right Like, we spent a lot of time there.
- 31:41Our parents were all either in like music ministry or children's church. So
- 31:45the pastors and everyone, we all knew each other very well. Well.
- 31:49Sadly, one of the friends, like in this group, she was closer
- 31:53to my brother's age, passed away do it to a drunk driving accident.
- 31:59She was like twenty two, very vibrant, beautiful, intelligent, just social
- 32:05person, and so you can imagine it was a surprise to everyone. We'll
- 32:09get to this funeral and the place is packed and it's very emotional. And
- 32:16I thought, you know, thinking, like these pastors grew up with her,
- 32:20like we all know each other really well, I'm expecting to hear some
- 32:24heartfelt stories about her and her life and her as a child growing up here.
- 32:30And I think the only anecdote they added outside of just reading the back
- 32:35of her pamphlet was how close she was, you know, reigniting her relationship
- 32:42with God. It was so insulting and so hurtful, especially since you know
- 32:49they should have known something. But the whole service was about Jesus and coming
- 32:53to Christ and at one point, you know, making I believe the point
- 32:58of this was to say that, like, this earthly life doesn't matter,
- 33:01which is messy all in itself. But it was starting to talk about the
- 33:07story of Lazarus, and I think there was just a cold chill that ran
- 33:10through the room, like are you going to try to resurrect her Lazarus?
- 33:17Yeah? I was just like dumbfounded. Wow, did you fantasize about going
- 33:24up there and giving a better eulogy? Because I've done that when I've heard
- 33:28somebody who has been going on and on waving the Bible, I have fantasized
- 33:31about shutting their microphone off and marching up to the front and saying, all
- 33:37right, everybody, we're going to talk about Karen or whoever. I mean,
- 33:40do you fantasize about doing that? I think it was more of an
- 33:45angry fantasy of being like, go sit down, sir, you should know
- 33:51better. The one who's dedicated so much of their life to this poor preachers
- 33:55suddenly mute. You know, he can't speak it's like that scene in the
- 33:59Matrix squere Neo's mouth disappeared. It's oh, it's too bad for you.
- 34:02I guess we'll have to do it differently. Rachel, thank you for sharing
- 34:07your story and thank you for calling. I appreciate you. Thank you.
- 34:12I'm going to read for you when we're almost done. Here a beautiful piece
- 34:16that was brought to my attention. This has been a few years. It's
- 34:21called you want a Physicist to Speak at your Funeral? And I thought it
- 34:28was really good someone to read it for you here in just a little bit.
- 34:32I told Natalie Wants that if I knew it was coming, like I
- 34:38had just I've recently been reading about the tragic story of Bruce Willis, the
- 34:43movie star, and he has a horrible disease, a kind of dementia that
- 34:51is just robbing him of who he is. And he had been starring in
- 34:58these really, really bad sort of indie movies. They paid him a million
- 35:04bucks. He stood on screen for about four minutes, he did some non
- 35:07acting, and people were like, what the hell is going on? Bruce
- 35:13Willis is starring in all these crap movies? Is he just cashing in?
- 35:16He's taken a check. The Raspberry Awards, which is the antithesis of the
- 35:22Academy Awards, gave him a Razzie for the Worst Actor, and we were
- 35:25all thinking, God, he's just he just fill in his pockets. He's
- 35:29lazy, right, I remember. There were a lot of conversations along those
- 35:32lines, and then we heard about the fact that Snow he had a disease
- 35:38and he was taking work that would allow him to pretty much stand in one
- 35:43place and say a few lines which likely had to be recited for him,
- 35:47and he would repeat them back. And he was doing what he could because
- 35:52he had a terrible fatal disease. And the Raspberry Awards people found out and
- 35:59they withdrew it immediately with an apology. My context, we began to understand
- 36:04what was really going on, and I just read that he is now nonverbal.
- 36:08Bruce Willis is nonverbal. He may be understanding what you're saying, but
- 36:14he cannot articulate anything with language verbally. And it just breaks the heart.
- 36:19And I thought, well, you know, if my death whenever that is,
- 36:22and I don't really fear death, but the process of dying does give
- 36:27me pause. The process of suffering gives us all pause. Nobody wants to
- 36:30suffer the idea of not being me, of having some kind of condition where
- 36:37I no longer exhibit the characteristics, the traits, the personality. I don't
- 36:43have the memories to draw upon. I am not seth anymore. I've become
- 36:49a shell or even someone else. That is scary. That's scary. What
- 36:54I was telling Natalie was like, let's say I was diagnosed with something and
- 37:00this is it. Who would give the eulogy at my memorial? I think
- 37:05I would want a memorial? What would I do? And I just I
- 37:10do not know. I wouldn't saddle Natalie with that. I wouldn't burden her.
- 37:15No, I need you to go on stage and speak about me after
- 37:20losing your husband. I mean, she would do it, certainly, because
- 37:22she is the most beautiful person I know, and I know her heart,
- 37:27and she may speak. But I just wouldn't do that. So would I
- 37:30do it myself? I thought, you know what, if I was still
- 37:35lucid and still able to use all my faculties what I knowing it was coming
- 37:40even a year or year and a half later, would I pre record my
- 37:45own eulogy and say, hey, everybody, I didn't want to burden anybody
- 37:49or I didn't trust a preacher to give this eulogy. So here I am
- 37:52thanks for coming, and then for twenty minutes via recorded video, I would
- 37:57just communicate with the attendees and say all the things that I wish would be
- 38:02said at a memorial in my name. I would tell my wife that she
- 38:08has been my whole heart, and I would thank her and her children.
- 38:15I would talk about the journey of my life, which has been a roller
- 38:20coaster and ultimately a wonderful one. I'd talk about the privilege of having you
- 38:24in my life and doing what I care about, and being able to do
- 38:30full time activism that speaks to my values to try to build a better world,
- 38:37and you know, my tennis community. I talk about some of the
- 38:40stuff that we had done together. I'd tell jokes, i would share anecdotes.
- 38:46I would I just take people on the ride, and then I would
- 38:51say it's time for you to leave, go and get on with your lives,
- 38:59because life. Life is short and precious. That's tempting. I don't
- 39:05know or who would you have give my eulogy? Who would you have give
- 39:08you r eulogy? If you had to have that conversation. Do you hear
- 39:12about that one woman who they handed out brochures at her funeral and they all
- 39:17had the imprint of a Ouiji board with the words keep in touch. I
- 39:25would be tempted to do that. Can you imagine the evangelicals at my funeral
- 39:30and they get that, Oh, it's a Oiji board, keep in touch,
- 39:34talk to you soon. There was somebody who said that there was a
- 39:37joke where an auto text went out to everybody right after the funeral service was
- 39:44over from the number of the deceased, from their personal number, and it
- 39:49said thanks for coming. Humor I think is an important part of life celebrations.
- 39:55We grieve, and I think we often grieve naturally and in healthy ways,
- 40:00using ritual, using each other, connecting, crying, sharing, maybe
- 40:07being silent, taking time. I don't know everybody grieves in a different way,
- 40:12but I think if you're going to celebrate somebody's life, there needs to
- 40:14be some joy and humor and affection. You know, there needs to be
- 40:17a little bit of levity in there. Have you heard of the process of
- 40:23extreme embalming. There are apparently funeral homes who will do like embalming two point
- 40:32zero extra embalming so that the deceased can be handed over to you and then
- 40:42you can pose them. You have a party at your house. I am
- 40:46not making this up. They have a party away, a celebration, memorial,
- 40:52whatever they want to call it. And they put you in a chair
- 40:58or something in the corner. He dress you in your favorite T shirt and
- 41:00tennis shoes, put a hat on you, sunglasses some people did sunglasses,
- 41:05and they put you in the corner and then everybody comes over and they have
- 41:07a little party for you. I saw one guy. He was embalmed.
- 41:12I guess he was a football player. They put him in a football jersey
- 41:15and a helmet dead. He was dead, and they had him in the
- 41:19room, and that for them was a satisfying send off. Hey, we're
- 41:24not going to have a party without you. Can you imagine? I looked
- 41:31this up quickly. There's someone who is embalmed and posed in front of his
- 41:37Xbox and they put an Xbox controller in his embalmed hands, sunglasses on his
- 41:46face, and he looks like he fell asleep playing video games. Another guy
- 41:54was a Green Lantern fan. They posed him in a Green Lantern superhero costume.
- 42:02They will place you at a dinner table and have a meal. I
- 42:07am not kidding. I would never tell someone not to do it. I
- 42:13mean, if it works for you, you know. But I don't think
- 42:17I could. I don't think I could eat a meal with an embalmed body
- 42:22sitting next to me. I don't know. Could you do it? Sorry?
- 42:28Bizarre digression? My fault? Is it? Norma? At four seven
- 42:34nine, I said, this is Norma. I wanted to tell you a
- 42:37humorous story about my sister and I when we were very small. I was
- 42:43seven, she was eight, and my grandmother's sister, Aunt Lucy, was
- 42:49a drunk. We all knew she was a drunk, and she was one
- 42:52of those kind of drunks that were just nasty and mean. And so one
- 42:58fine day she on her car and then into an embankment and killed herself.
- 43:04And my mother made us go to this funeral, and we were sitting there
- 43:07in our little dresses and our patent shoes. This is the late sixties,
- 43:10and the preacher was going on and on about what a wonderful lady Aunt Lucy
- 43:16was and what a good Christian she was, and how everybody loved Aunt Lucy
- 43:22and my sister and I were looking at each other, and finally my sister
- 43:25leaned across me and poked my mom and said, why is he saying all
- 43:30that stuff about Aunt Lucy? And my mother shushed her and you know,
- 43:34don't, don't say anything, Ambique. And so we just kind of rolled
- 43:37our eyes and kind of went with it and rocked the clock forward a few
- 43:42months, we're on a fishing trip and we're coming back down a dirt road
- 43:46getting close to our house, and this idiot in this little bitty cards comes
- 43:52tearing by us like a lunatic, throwing gravel all over the place, almost
- 43:57ran my dad off the road. Mother said, look at that idiot.
- 44:01We're going to find him up this road a little while up in a ditch,
- 44:05upside down, dead, And my sister never missed a beat. Yeah,
- 44:09and the preachers stand up there and talk about what a good boy he
- 44:13was. Already she was on to him, Oh yeah, out of the
- 44:16mouths of babes. Absolutely well. We don't have any filters, so we
- 44:22didn't call it like we saw it. You know. My mother almost choked
- 44:25the death laughing so hard, but I'm like, you know, we saw
- 44:29this, and we were just kids and everybody else just wit with it.
- 44:31So I think we can all learn a lesson from her. Yeah, heavy
- 44:35conversation today, but I thought you might use a little liberty. I appreciate
- 44:38that so much. Norma, thanks for calling. Hang in there, Sure
- 44:43you too. Thanks. I'll tell you something that needs to go away.
- 44:46When somebody says, why are you speaking ill of the dead? I remember
- 44:52when Jerry Folwell died, right, Jerry Folwell of the Moral Majority. He
- 44:59was an antique bigot, He was a conspiracy theorist, he was a Christian
- 45:04nationalist, and he was just not a good person and he died. Christopher
- 45:08Hitchins went on Fox News and he was roasted. I think he was on
- 45:14Shawn and was it Hannity and Colmes back when Sean Hannity and Alan Combs had
- 45:19that sort of a crossfire format, and hitch was there, and I think
- 45:25he said forgive me them, drawing it from memory, I know he said
- 45:29it at some point where Jerry Folwell was so full of shit that had you
- 45:34given him an enema, you could have buried the rest of him in a
- 45:37matchbox, which is really true. But you know he went after Fallwell and
- 45:45mother Teresa after her death and others, and one of the protests on that
- 45:50show and elsewhere was he's gone, his family's grieving. Why would you say
- 45:53such things about him? Why isn't this a moment of reverence? And why
- 45:57can't you at least sit on your hands and be quiet, respectful as other
- 46:00people go through their pain? What's wrong with you? I've mentioned people that
- 46:06we have known who were terrible people, you know, terrible people, abusive
- 46:13or lazy, or they were cruel or whatever, terrible people and something happened
- 46:21and they passed away, and I would say, boy, they were a
- 46:24terrible, lousy human being, right, they were just taken up air?
- 46:29Like what was the net positive having them in our lives? And the response
- 46:32is, oh, you know, they're gone. I mean, don't mind
- 46:36me just talking to me. Just let it go. Don't speak ill of
- 46:38the dead. And I don't understand that. Why does not existing mean that
- 46:45we whitewash your deeds when you were alive? Do you get some sort of
- 46:49a reputation rehab? Is that a default? Isn't that lying to ourselves?
- 46:53Why not be honest? They were a shitty human being when they were alive,
- 47:00which I guess is the only way you could be like, you wouldn't
- 47:02be a shitty human being a few dead. I'm sorry. I had a
- 47:07conversation about my phrasing and an apology from me for it. We will speak
- 47:14more of the dead and remembering the Dead coming up in just a second.
- 47:25Of course, this show is my first love, this community is my primary
- 47:30focus. But I sure have enjoyed my second podcast, True Stories with Seth
- 47:37Andrews. We just broke two hundred shows a couple of weeks ago, and
- 47:42the response has been good and I would hope you would enjoy it. You
- 47:45can subscribe on all major podcast apps, just search for it. True Stories
- 47:52with Seth Andrews Noah at nine to five Are you there? Hi? Yeah?
- 48:02Talking about funerals and memorials and those who hijack them. What's your perspective.
- 48:08I had one of my closest friends die like about a year close to
- 48:13two years ago, and I just I just remember being at the service and
- 48:20something that really caught me off guard when the pastor passed. I can't remember
- 48:25exactly what the term was, but he said something like young men being taken
- 48:32from us earlier, like this isn't a part of God's plan, and I
- 48:39it just really struck me because I'm like, that's not how this works,
- 48:45right, Like that's not how your God works, and I it's it's just
- 48:49something that really bothered me along with the normal like taking things out of our
- 48:53own hands, like our accomplishments or the good things that happened, and like
- 48:59the pausemative impact that this person has made on the world, and just kind
- 49:04of like, oh, look what God let him do. And then out
- 49:07of what he took him away for no reason or apparently didn't. I don't
- 49:12know if I'm not exactly tracking. Is he saying that God didn't want him
- 49:16to die? It was out of God's will? But God could not intervene.
- 49:21That's what I am taking from it is that it's not a part of
- 49:25his plan. But how is anything not a part of God's plan? Because
- 49:31doesn't he control everything? Maybe it was playing into that hole. It's a
- 49:37fallen world. You know, God would like to intervene, but we have
- 49:40restrained him because we are so wicked. Did you see the brand new nightmare
- 49:47of a speaker of the house Mike Johnson after this most recent shooting mass shooting,
- 49:54and what did he do? Well? First of his thoughts and prayers,
- 49:58and then somebody went back through the archives and he was talking about how
- 50:02it's it's because of the teaching of evolution and feminism, and there was something
- 50:09else. Remember when Jerry Folwell and Pat Robertson were blaming LGBT people for nine
- 50:20eleven omnipotent, all powerful God who can do everything, won't or can't do
- 50:27anything because we're disobedient children. So he's going to sit in the corner while
- 50:34his children get the shit kicked out of him, because that's how we're going
- 50:37to learn a little lesson anyway, Sorry for my tangent there, noah,
- 50:44No, no, of course that. Yeah, I just kind of did
- 50:46forget about that aspect of how they just push it off onto us, as
- 50:50if he didn't create us broken or you know, apparently create us broken to
- 50:58follow rules he knew we wouldn't be able to live up to, etc.
- 51:01Yeah, it used to say we are created sick and commanded to be well.
- 51:06Makes no sense. Yeah, noah, thanks for calling. I appreciate
- 51:09you. Yeah, thank you. Take care as I must soon draw to
- 51:15a close. Let me fulfill my promise here and read why you want a
- 51:21physicist to speak at your funeral. It's just a few paragraphs, but let
- 51:25me read it for you. It comes from a transcript of a speech given
- 51:30by writer and performer Aaron Freeman on NPR news is All Things Considered. It
- 51:38says this, You want a physicist to speak at your funeral. You want
- 51:45the physicist to talk to your grieving family about the conservation of energy, so
- 51:51they will understand that your energy has not died. You want the physicist to
- 51:57remind your sobbing mother about the first law of thermodynamics, that no energy is
- 52:02created in the universe and none is destroyed. You want your mother to know
- 52:08that all your energy, every vibration, every btu of heat, every wave
- 52:15of every particle that was her beloved child, remains with her in this world.
- 52:22You want the physicist to tell your weeping father that, amid the energies
- 52:27of the cosmos, you gave as good as you got, and at one
- 52:31point you'd hope that the physicist would step down from the pulpit and walk to
- 52:37your broken hearted spouse there in the pew and tell him that all of the
- 52:42photons that ever bounced off your face, all the particles whose paths were interrupted
- 52:49by your smile, by the touch of your hair. Hundreds of trillions of
- 52:54particles have raced off you like children, their ways forever changed by you.
- 53:02And as your widow rocks in the arms of a loving family, May the
- 53:07physicist let her know that all the photons that bounced from you were gathered in
- 53:13the particle detectors that are her eyes, that those photons created within her constellations
- 53:21of electro magnetically charged neurons, whose energy will go on forever. And the
- 53:29physicist will remind the congregation of how much all our energy is given off as
- 53:35heat. There may be a few fanning themselves with their programs as he says
- 53:40it, and he will tell them that the warmth that flowed through you in
- 53:45life is still here, still part of all that we are, even as
- 53:50we who morn continue in the heat of our own lives. And you'll want
- 53:57the physicists to explain to those who loved you that they need not have faith,
- 54:02indeed they should not have faith. Let them know that they can measure
- 54:07that scientists have measured precisely the conservation of energy and found it accurate, verifiable,
- 54:16and consistent across space and time. You can hope your family will examine
- 54:22the evidence and satisfy themselves that the science is sound, and that they'll be
- 54:29comforted to know your energy is still around. According to the law of the
- 54:36conservation of energy, not a bit of you is gone. You're just less
- 54:43orderly, Amen, and that is what I will leave you with today.
- 54:52Thank you so much for calling, and for listening and being a part of
- 54:55this interesting, sometimes heavy, sometimes humorous conversation as we talk about life and
- 55:04death together. Take care, and I'll see you back here next time.
- 55:07Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and
- 55:13videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links
- 55:17to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions.
- 55:23Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.