Latest / Growing the Forest & the Trees: Big Pictures and Everyday Realities in Education / Alabama's Numeracy Act Explained - Growing the Forest & the Trees
Transcript
- 0:01Being a teacher is not easy. I know, understatement of
- 0:05the year. Teachers juggle test score pressure and parent expectations,
- 0:09not to mention a classroom of 20 to 30 young people
- 0:13who would rather be anywhere else. It is easy to get
- 0:17overwhelmed and miss the forest for the trees. That's why we're here.
- 0:21We're getting to the root of the issues facing educators
- 0:24today, connecting teachers with experts and finding resources
- 0:29and solutions. Through conversations with our guests,
- 0:33and hopefully you as well, we'll all learn and grow together.
- 0:37From the little saplings to the wise old oaks,
- 0:41this is Growing the Forest and the Trees: Big Pictures and Everyday
- 0:44Realities, a podcast from the College of Education and
- 0:49Behavioral Sciences at Troy University. I'm Dr.
- 0:52Shirley Farrell, retired associate professor, here with
- 0:56my co-host, Dr. Lisa Etheridge, a classroom
- 0:59teacher of 24 years and an associate professor
- 1:03in the Department of Teacher Education. Whether we realize it
- 1:08or not, we all use math every single day.
- 1:11But for many children, and even some adults, math can
- 1:15be a scary concept. Today, we're talking to
- 1:18Dr. Ann Dominick with the Alabama State Department of Education
- 1:22Office of Mathematics Improvement. That office was
- 1:26established under the Alabama Numeracy Act of 2022
- 1:31as part of a statewide plan to improve Alabama
- 1:34students' math proficiency. Dr.
- 1:38Dominick has decades of experience in education.
- 1:41She was an elementary school teacher for 16 years and
- 1:45has also worked as a mathematics coach, helping students and
- 1:49teachers improve their math skills. Starting out with maybe
- 1:54the first question for people that maybe really are not familiar,
- 1:58what is the Alabama Numeracy Act? What is its purpose,
- 2:01and why do we— what's the goal of the
- 2:05change for Alabama students in elementary through
- 2:09high school? So,
- 2:11I'm sure all the listeners will be aware that
- 2:15mathematics has not always been at the top of
- 2:21the achievement ladder, and this is not unique to Alabama,
- 2:25but it certainly is true in Alabama, as well as most
- 2:29other states around the country, that people have not
- 2:33felt confident in their ability
- 2:36to know and understand mathematics. And we have a lot
- 2:41of students who graduate from high school and are still not
- 2:45confident in mathematics. And, um,
- 2:49when I was teaching at the university, I sometimes
- 2:53taught a remedial math course for which students
- 2:58don't get any credit and they still pay tuition. And I was
- 3:02shocked at the number of students I would have in my class who had been
- 3:05valedictorians of their class, and yet they still
- 3:09did not understand. So the Alabama Numeracy Act really
- 3:13is focused on trying to address that problem,
- 3:16and it was put into, into play and became
- 3:21legislation in 2022 when there were,
- 3:25I believe at the time there were 4, 4 schools in the
- 3:30state where not one child was proficient in mathematics
- 3:33on the ACAT test, and that, along with
- 3:38many schools where students were achieving,
- 3:42maybe the percentage of students who scored proficient on
- 3:46those tests was in the single digits, and that's not about the
- 3:50children, that's about the opportunities that they have had to learn mathematics.
- 3:55And so thankfully, we had legislators who,
- 4:00who decided to do something about that issue. And so
- 4:04that's where that legislation came from. And the goal is that
- 4:08by 5th grade, all students
- 4:12would, would be proficient in mathematics.
- 4:17So we have 860-some-odd
- 4:22elementary schools in the state, and they
- 4:27provided in that legislation that teachers would
- 4:32have professional learning opportunities,
- 4:36that, that the— every school would have a mathematics
- 4:40coach to help keep math on the front burner and to help teachers,
- 4:46again, to be that thought partner to help teachers understand
- 4:51mathematics content more deeply and have teaching
- 4:55strategies at their disposal to, to help students
- 5:00understand it deeply. There's also provisions in
- 5:04the law for working with administrators so that they
- 5:07know how to support good mathematics
- 5:12teaching. And then on the higher ed side,
- 5:16it provided for a change in what
- 5:21the teacher preparation looks like. So prior
- 5:25to the Numeracy Act, a teacher who was preparing
- 5:28to be an elementary or early childhood or special
- 5:33education teacher would take 4 courses in
- 5:37the math department, and with few exceptions,
- 5:41as long as it had a math prefix, it was accepted. So they
- 5:47could take a calculus course or statistics or algebra course.
- 5:52However, that doesn't necessarily prepare you to
- 5:56teach 3rd grade well and to understand
- 6:00the content and the pedagogy that's
- 6:03needed to really help children move along.
- 6:07And so in addition to those 4 math courses, then there
- 6:11was one required math education course.
- 6:15So students would graduate,
- 6:19and oftentimes,
- 6:22because to prepare to be an elementary
- 6:26teacher you didn't have to have a lot of higher-level math,
- 6:30sometimes there would be people who would come into programs
- 6:34and they would readily say, I'm not a math person,
- 6:37I'm, I'm afraid of math. And then they
- 6:41would also graduate with that same attitude and
- 6:45feeling towards mathematics. And, and we know that you
- 6:49cannot teach well what you don't understand.
- 6:53And so to address this problem,
- 6:56the Numeracy Act now requires
- 7:00that educator preparation programs, so the higher ed colleges
- 7:05and universities that prepare teachers,
- 7:09would have 4 math education courses.
- 7:13So they're, they're mathematics courses,
- 7:17but they're focused on the mathematics that
- 7:20elementary children need to know and understand deeply.
- 7:25And so those teachers need to know that mathematics and the
- 7:29teaching strategies so that they can help children
- 7:34become confident in this deeply important
- 7:38subject. Absolutely.
- 7:41And listen, I am wholeheartedly with you on
- 7:45the math anxiety end of things because I was a student
- 7:50going through school that had math anxiety. It was not
- 7:53my favorite thing to do in the— in as a child. Now I
- 7:58teach math, so I have a different perspective of things now.
- 8:02But I agree that we see a lot
- 8:05of people that are afraid of math and just
- 8:10afraid of numbers in general. So I'm glad to see that this
- 8:15act is being brought and being implemented to help curb
- 8:19some of that for our future generations.
- 8:22So we're helping the teachers gain that deeper understanding
- 8:26to better teach, But you know, being an educator,
- 8:30anytime we change anything in education,
- 8:34parents are confused. They don't understand what's
- 8:37going on. And I just remember over the years
- 8:41when we were changing AMSTI math and
- 8:45doing different things, you started hearing parents go, what's this
- 8:48new math? Math is math, and it was good enough for me.
- 8:52What's going on? With the students, I can't help with
- 8:56the new math. What can you tell our parent listeners
- 9:01to help them understand what it is that's
- 9:04going on? I know you keep saying deeper understanding of math, but can
- 9:08you put it for the parents to understand what this all means?
- 9:13I guess for my first thought is math
- 9:17is, is not new. It's always
- 9:21worked the way it works today. And I've been
- 9:25teaching— this is my 42nd year in education.
- 9:29I've been doing this a long time, and almost my entire
- 9:34career, this has been the
- 9:38way I taught. And, and as I learned more about
- 9:41mathematics, I was able to help my children,
- 9:45my students, understand more. So the math is
- 9:49not new. It's— and I've worked
- 9:54with parents too my whole career, and I
- 9:58would invite them in to see what was going on,
- 10:01because if you say to a child,
- 10:04how did you think about that? So for instance,
- 10:07if the problem is, you know,
- 10:10100 minus 97, if a child
- 10:14says, can I have some paper and pencil and think about that? And they
- 10:18start to mark out the zeros, As a teacher,
- 10:22I'm concerned because that should
- 10:26be an easy problem if a 2nd or 3rd
- 10:30grader is looking at that and they know about
- 10:34subtraction, that that's the difference. That's what we call an
- 10:37answer in subtraction. If they know that, that,
- 10:41that the difference between 97 and 100 is 3,
- 10:45then if they need to write it down
- 10:49and mark out the zeros and regroup,
- 10:53I'm concerned that they've missed something really important
- 10:57about understanding subtraction. And so that, that's just
- 11:02one example, and, you know, we can take any, any piece of mathematics
- 11:06and, and think about what are the underlying pieces, but those
- 11:11are the types of things that I that people
- 11:15who are good at math do mentally
- 11:19all the time. If you think about how you approach
- 11:23problems when you're in the grocery store or when you're wherever,
- 11:29then usually you're using that
- 11:33logic of how numbers
- 11:37work. You know, there's what we call number
- 11:41sense, like I have an idea about what this
- 11:45answer should be close to. And so if
- 11:49we can help children lean into the
- 11:53logic that they have and think about what makes
- 11:57sense, then they have a
- 12:01lot of logic, a lot of number sense that they bring to the table,
- 12:05even very early on. And so those
- 12:09are the types of things that we're trying to just make sure
- 12:14that all children have access to.
- 12:16Sometimes when children are in school,
- 12:21they give up their intuition
- 12:25to try to make sense of things. They're just trying to follow directions,
- 12:30and we know that that the study of mathematics is
- 12:33the study of logic. And so we need to make
- 12:37sure that that's in the forefront of what we're doing
- 12:40to help children understand mathematics instead
- 12:44of, you know, the word problems at the end of the page.
- 12:48The— we need, we need to really lean into
- 12:52the fact that this, it's supposed to make sense.
- 12:55Math is not supposed to be something that
- 12:59only a few people are good at. If I really, if I did not believe
- 13:03that all children were capable, then I probably would not
- 13:07have stayed in this career so long, but I really do believe
- 13:10that all people are capable, even, even adults who might
- 13:15have had bad experiences are still capable of learning,
- 13:19and, and it's really a beautiful opportunity
- 13:24when you see that light bulb come on that people sometimes
- 13:28say, what's your favorite sound? My, I think my favorite sound is when,
- 13:33when there's something that just connected. It's just,
- 13:37it's such a privilege to be there to witness that.
- 13:41Yes. And I think a lot of times parents think it's just being able to
- 13:46do the algorithms, complete the worksheets, and not gain that
- 13:50understanding behind it. I, I've always loved
- 13:54math, but when I worked fast food as a teenager,
- 13:59my challenge was to beat the machine in
- 14:03calculating the change that someone would get back.
- 14:08So I started thinking in hundreds and
- 14:11thousands in order to be able to do that, and that really helped
- 14:16me with mental math. And You know, we do activities in schools
- 14:20to help students with that. So, in explaining
- 14:24this to parents, then what can they do,
- 14:29even practical ways to support this mathematical thinking
- 14:33at home? Because we do know math
- 14:36is in our everyday lives many times throughout
- 14:41the day. What can parents do to help support it?
- 14:45I think first of all, I would, I would say if there's
- 14:50a parent who did not have a good experience with mathematics,
- 14:55don't share that. Don't share that piece.
- 14:58Um, when I've talked to parents, sometimes they will say to
- 15:03their children, oh, I wasn't good at math, don't worry if you're not good at
- 15:06it either. And there's not a gene that's passed
- 15:10on that makes someone good at math. And so I,
- 15:15I think when parents have had sometimes
- 15:18traumatic experiences, unfortunately, with mathematics,
- 15:22that's the default, is to, to reassure
- 15:27their children that it's okay if they're not good at it either, when, when in
- 15:31fact, I think it's really important to have a positive attitude
- 15:35about mathematics. And so I think one of the,
- 15:38one of the nice ways to bring that into the home is first of all,
- 15:41just to have discussions. Like you're at the grocery store
- 15:45and you're wondering how many apples we need and wow,
- 15:49how many pieces of fruit do we have now? They're, they're just common
- 15:53conversations that you can have that involve
- 15:57mathematical thinking that people probably don't even
- 16:01realize are setting a really important stage for future learning.
- 16:06So I think first of all, just talk to your children about
- 16:11anything mathematical, but then there are so many ways
- 16:14to enjoy math together. And so
- 16:18there are, there are wonderful math games that you
- 16:21can play and lots of resources
- 16:26for just trying to enjoy math together. We,
- 16:30I worked with the National Science Foundation grant for
- 16:35over 10 years, and we would have math nights
- 16:40for parents and their children, and they would come together and
- 16:45we would teach math games, and they would play together and talk about,
- 16:49oh, how did you think about that? And so those types
- 16:53of conversations kind of just loosen up that
- 16:57anxiety around math. I think so many people think,
- 17:01you know, to help my child, I'm sitting at the kitchen table and it often
- 17:05ends in tears. And that is not what we want. Yes.
- 17:09We're trying to help parents
- 17:12have a positive experience with their child
- 17:16so that they can help build that confidence that
- 17:20you're capable of this. And, and if you just ask questions
- 17:24like, how did you think about that? Oh, I thought about it this way.
- 17:28I wonder how we both got to the same answer. And,
- 17:31and oftentimes they may have the same strategy, but I think it's,
- 17:35it's really important to try to maximize
- 17:39the positive experiences at home around mathematics
- 17:43so that it doesn't become a subject
- 17:47that children are afraid of, because they are capable,
- 17:51we know that. And so we want the parents
- 17:54to also feel that curiosity,
- 17:59and enjoyment, and confidence,
- 18:04and the ability to just have some fun with math.
- 18:08Yes, I agree. And, you know, the math games
- 18:12are a great way to even help the parents get
- 18:17over their anxieties if they have them. And so
- 18:20thank you, that will be helpful for our listeners to hear and
- 18:24even the educators who listen to better help
- 18:28their— the parents of their children, our students as well.
- 18:34That's awesome, and I really appreciate the,
- 18:38the math games because it allows students to be completely interactive
- 18:43and they don't realize that they're really learning math They're just
- 18:47interested in having a fun game to play. It's truly a
- 18:51foundational piece for our students to have and to gain that
- 18:54math foundational knowledge, and math
- 18:58games to me is one of the best ways to do that.
- 19:02At the beginning of the podcast, when you were kind of giving an overview of
- 19:06the Numeracy Act, you mentioned that the goal is
- 19:10for students to be proficient in math by 5th Great.
- 19:14So if a student is not proficient,
- 19:17what additional supports would be made available?
- 19:22What happens next if they're not proficient,
- 19:25and how can schools help in providing intervention
- 19:29so that that student can move toward being
- 19:33proficient? So that involves
- 19:37a lot of work that we're doing with administrators
- 19:41and math coaches and teachers in the schools.
- 19:45The Elementary Math Task Force that was established with the New
- 19:48Mercy Act has chosen the
- 19:53regular curriculum for schools to use that,
- 19:56that help students stay on
- 20:00grade level and, and get to where they need
- 20:04need to get by the end of 5th grade, but in addition to that,
- 20:08they have chosen an early
- 20:13numeracy screener that helps identify where
- 20:17there are gaps if students are not achieving.
- 20:22There's also a fractional reasoning screener that's given
- 20:26in the upper grades to see where there are potential
- 20:30gaps in understanding, that we have benchmark
- 20:34assessments to make sure that we're on track,
- 20:39and, and then we have an intervention program.
- 20:42So if within the regular classroom
- 20:46time students need extra support,
- 20:50then there's first an extra time
- 20:54that's, that's devoted to helping those students
- 20:58understand what they may just need a little bit more
- 21:02work on. So if in the regular classroom
- 21:06a teacher notices there are some students who,
- 21:09who, who need a smaller group, another pass at what
- 21:14they were doing, then they are pulled forward for that time
- 21:17outside of the regular math block. And then
- 21:22if there are some deeper issues then the
- 21:26Math Task Force has also identified some intervention
- 21:31resources to really get at some of those underlying missing
- 21:35concepts to help bring them back up to grade level.
- 21:40That's awesome. Well, it sounds like y'all have thought this out very well
- 21:44to provide that extra support and intervention,
- 21:48if needed, to students to help them in any
- 21:51way, shape, form, or fashion get to the grade level
- 21:55and expectations that need to happen.
- 21:59I'm going to kind of throw our last question, I'm going to combine the last
- 22:022 maybe into one. What have you heard most often
- 22:06from educators and students about this implementation of the Numeracy
- 22:10Act? And what have you learned so far
- 22:14about the Numeracy Act's impact? And what are
- 22:18the next steps for sustaining progress across Alabama?
- 22:23So, I think one of the overarching
- 22:27themes that I hear is gratitude.
- 22:31I, I think people want to feel confident
- 22:36in math, and it's often been a
- 22:41subject that produces a lot of anxiety.
- 22:44I was surprised many years ago to learn that math
- 22:49anxiety is actually listed in the American Psychological Association
- 22:53for things that people get counseling for.
- 22:57And it does produce a lot of trauma for
- 23:01a lot of people, and that's not what it's meant to do.
- 23:05It's meant to empower and to help people navigate life
- 23:09well. And so I'm I'm
- 23:14really grateful that people
- 23:18recognize this need, and I do hear that across
- 23:22the state at many levels. It's, change is always hard.
- 23:26There's not at any level,
- 23:30you know, that it's been smooth sailing 100%,
- 23:34but I think once people recognize where
- 23:38this is taking us, I, I just hear gratitude
- 23:42from administrators, from math coaches,
- 23:46from teachers, university people, that,
- 23:50that this is putting us on a path. And I mentioned before
- 23:54that the issues that we're dealing with in Alabama are not
- 23:57unique to Alabama. They are national issues,
- 24:02and the rest of the country is looking at Alabama to
- 24:06to lead the way, and, and we're, we're seeing
- 24:10that progress in our test scores just
- 24:13in the few years that the New Mercy Act has been in play. And I
- 24:18need to say too, this is built on the work that AMSTI was
- 24:21doing for decades, so we, we're in
- 24:25a unique position in Alabama because we're
- 24:29not just starting this brand new. There's already been
- 24:33an attention to helping people understand
- 24:36mathematics. That foundation has been there for decades,
- 24:41so the Numeracy Act is just taking it to
- 24:44the next level to make sure that all students have
- 24:49access to this way to open
- 24:53up understanding and to focus on it. That— the
- 24:57law has some really basic pieces to it,
- 25:00children need to have math for 60 minutes a day,
- 25:04and it doesn't need to be from 2:30
- 25:08to 3:30, and we know that the buses are coming at 3.
- 25:13So it, you know, really basic things
- 25:16are, are being put in place so that all children
- 25:21have those opportunities to learn, and that when we have
- 25:26schools where, where we've got a shortage
- 25:30of teachers, that we're doing something to help shore up
- 25:36the opportunities that some of the adults in the building have not had either.
- 25:41And so, I'm really, I'm hearing
- 25:44from all levels that while this is hard work,
- 25:49it's so rewarding when you see people at all
- 25:53levels feeling like we're moving forward,
- 25:57and then you have test results that also
- 26:02give credence to the fact that we are moving forward,
- 26:05it really is, it's an
- 26:09exciting time. It is, and I will just tell you,
- 26:13just working with you from the higher ed perspective,
- 26:17It has invigorated me and excited me, and as
- 26:21one of the instructors of one of the higher ed math courses,
- 26:26I'm excited to see how our teachers
- 26:31are gaining a new excitement for math.
- 26:35Again, it's going back to seeing that light bulb moment,
- 26:39but it's with our adults, our young adults
- 26:42that are coming in, and even some older adults
- 26:46that want to come into teaching that they've never been exposed
- 26:50to math this kind of way,
- 26:52and it's exciting to see what the
- 26:57implications are going to be for generations to come,
- 27:00and I can only say that I think it's going to be extremely positive.
- 27:05Ann, we'll leave it with you and say, if you've got any last parting
- 27:09words, the floor is yours.
- 27:13Thank you. I do I do want to just emphasize
- 27:18that, that this is not new. My father was
- 27:22born in 1920, and he was still alive when I
- 27:25was beginning to learn about this decades ago,
- 27:29really at the beginning of my career.
- 27:32And, and he, he said,
- 27:35that's not new. We, we just used to call that ciphering.
- 27:40So there is nothing new about
- 27:44the math. Even the teaching strategies are
- 27:48not new. It's just a matter of improving
- 27:52our questioning and paying attention to how people
- 27:56learn and helping them make connections.
- 27:59So it, it's more intentional in terms
- 28:04of making sure that we spread it across the, the whole state
- 28:08so that, again, all children have access to
- 28:12good instruction, but, but it's not really new.
- 28:17We're just trying to, to make sure that everybody has access,
- 28:21and memorization is still important,
- 28:25algorithms are still important, but it's not the only thing
- 28:30that's important, and we need to make sure that people do
- 28:33make those connections and they do have that understanding And
- 28:37then those, all the tools that we have
- 28:41available to us will just help take us farther.
- 28:47Our guest today has been Dr. Ann Dominick, Policy Task Force Administrator
- 28:52with the Office of Mathematics Improvement. We hope you'll share
- 28:55this podcast with the teachers in your life and give us a review
- 29:00or rating on the podcast platform of your choice.
- 29:03Growing the Forest and the Trees is a production of Troy Public Radio
- 29:08and the College of Education and Behavioral Sciences at Troy
- 29:11University. For Lisa Etheridge, I'm Shirley Farrell.
- 29:15We'll see you again next time on Growing the Forest and the Trees:
- 29:19The Big Picture and Everyday Realities.