Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #19: Recapping Week 6, Comparing Resumes and The AP Poll is Improving!
Transcript
- 0:12Hello and welcome to episode number 19 of the Common Sense Rankings podcast, where we rank the resume, not the expectation.
- 0:19In this episode, I'll recap the most important results from week six.
- 0:23We'll compare a few teams' resumes to see if they're being appropriately evaluated.
- 0:28We'll turn to this week's AP poll to check in on the voters, and we'll finish by looking ahead to a mouth-watering week seven.
- 0:36There were 116 FBS programs in play, none of whom played an FCS team.
- 0:41The other 22 teams had a week off.
- 0:44That includes Miami, Mississippi State, and Texas Tech from the top 25 last week.
- 0:49In the CSR, we don't take averages, we look at the totality of the resume.
- 0:53As a result, those teams will lose ground temporarily in the Common Sense Rankings.
- 0:58Just one game could have impacted the CSR conference rankings in week six.
- 1:02That was the Arizona State Sun Devils versus the Hawaii Rainbow Warriors.
- 1:06Back in week three, Arizona took care of business against Northern Illinois, and the Sun Devils would need to win in week six to confirm the Big 12's head-to-head advantage over the Mountain West this season.
- 1:17The Sun Devils did what they had to do for the sake of the Big 12, defeating Hawaii 30 to 12 in Tempe.
- 1:24Up to this point in the season, most teams have played half their 2026 games, and their opponents have as well.
- 1:30So although we're halfway done on the college football calendar, we're only a quarter of the way done filling in the data at the Common Sense Rankings.
- 1:37In the CSR, half a team's evaluation comes from direct wins and losses, with the other half coming from their opponents' wins and losses in their other 11 games.
- 1:46That will produce in the college football season 144 opportunities for a team to improve their resumes.
- 1:53To this point, we have between 30 and 40 of those completed for each team, with over 100 data points left to fill in.
- 2:01There were three matchups between CSR-ranked opponents in Week 6.
- 2:06The first was the location of ESPN's College GameDay for the week.
- 2:09The CSR number one Alabama Crimson Tide hosted the CSR number six Georgia Bulldogs in Tuscaloosa Saturday night.
- 2:17It was tied 17-17 going into the fourth quarter, and the only three points scored belonged to UGA, giving the Bulldogs their first win in Tuscaloosa since 2007.
- 2:27As a result, the Tide lose their spot atop the Common Sense rankings in this week's Top 25.
- 2:33The Nebraska Cornhuskers were number 12 in last week's CSR.
- 2:36They hosted the team just above them at number 11, the Indiana Hoosiers.
- 2:40The Huskers were up 11 with just 12 minutes left, but two Indiana touchdowns in the final frame gave the defending national champion the victory and a bump up into the top 10 of this week's CSR.
- 2:52Lastly, a matchup in primetime on SEC Network featured the 19th-ranked team in the Common Sense rankings, the Kentucky Wildcats hosting the fringe top 25 team, the LSU Tigers.
- 3:03The Heart Attack Cats finished their game with LSU the same way they did the week prior.
- 3:08Going second in the first overtime and needing a touchdown, the Wildcats got their six points, then decided to roll the dice and go for two.
- 3:15They spread five receivers out wide, spaced out the defense, and a QB draw by Kenny Minchey gave Kentucky their second consecutive one-point overtime win If you're new to the Common Sense rankings, there are two positive and two negative components to the CSR formula.
- 3:31Direct wins based on the conference of the opponent is one of the positives, while the other is the strength of those defeated teams' wins.
- 3:38The negative points components are the opposite.
- 3:40Teams lose points based on the conference of the team they lose to, and they also lose points based on those teams' losses.
- 3:46Conference strength is determined by head-to-head conference records between each and every conference.
- 3:51For each head-to-head matchup a conference wins against another, the more a win against that conference is worth and the less a loss is worth.
- 3:58So against which conferences are the wins worth the most?
- 4:02The SEC remains at the top, followed by the Big Ten.
- 4:05The Big 12 currently sits in third solo, followed closely by the ACC.
- 4:09Among the group of six conferences, the American, Sun Belt, and Pac-12 are tops.
- 4:14The Mountain West comes in eight amongst FBS, and the MAC and Conference USA are tied at the bottom at ninth.
- 4:22In most seasons, you can expect the size of the gap at the top to remain minimal, likely one conference head-to-head separation.
- 4:29However, 2026's gap at the top is larger.
- 4:33The SEC has a winning record against all other conferences, while the other Power Four conferences created a circular pattern of defeat.
- 4:39The ACC beat the Big Ten head-to-head, the Big Ten beat the Big 12, and the Big 12 beat the ACC.
- 4:46With the Big Ten trailing the SEC by two conferences instead of the typical one, there's a larger gap in impact with games regarding an SEC team and a Big Ten team.
- 4:57As a result, the top SEC teams will dominate the top ten of the CSR unless a lot of them start to defeat each other.
- 5:04Furthermore, there is a full four conference head-to-head difference between the SEC and the ACC.
- 5:10That's a massive gap and will make the ACC's chances of getting two teams in the college football playoff much longer according to the CSR.
- 5:19Next, let's put a couple of resumes up against one another to see if the college football pundits are accurately assessing the wins and losses each team has accrued.
- 5:28As we get deeper into conference play, it will become more apparent what conference each team is a part of, but this is still a good exercise to see which team has posted a better resume to this point.
- 5:39Our first blind resume test has Team A at five and one.
- 5:44They're two and one in the Big Ten with two wins over the MAC.
- 5:47Their loss was to an undefeated Big Ten team, and the opponents they've beat have seven FBS wins total.
- 5:54Team B, meanwhile, is four and one.
- 5:56They're two and one in their conference, the ACC, and they have one more FBS win over a team from Conference USA.
- 6:02Their loss was to a three and three ACC team.
- 6:05The opponents they've defeated have a combined three FBS wins.
- 6:09So Team A has more wins, the same conference record in a harder conference according to the CSR formula.
- 6:16They have a better loss due to that opponent being undefeated, and the teams they've beat have also had more success this season.
- 6:23Team A is the unranked Nebraska Cornhuskers who did receive AP votes after suffering their loss to Indiana.
- 6:30Team B, meanwhile, is the SMU Mustangs who are ranked twenty-fourth in this week's AP poll for some reason that I'm not seeing.
- 6:37In the CSR, Nebraska is number twenty-three while SMU is down at number forty-two.
- 6:45Our next blind resume test has team A at four and one.
- 6:48They started two and one in the SEC with wins over the ACC and American as well.
- 6:53Their loss is to a four and two SEC team.
- 6:57The four teams they've won against have seven FBS wins between them.
- 7:01Team B, meanwhile, is five and one with all their games against FBS opponents.
- 7:06They're three and one in the ACC with a win over each of the Big Ten and MAC.
- 7:11Their loss is to an undefeated ACC team, and the five teams they've defeated have a total of eight FBS wins.
- 7:19Team A is number nine in this week's AP poll, the Ole Miss Rebels, while Team B is 12 spots below them at number 21, the Wake Forest Demon Deacons.
- 7:27In this situation, according to the CSR formula, the loss each team has suffered hurts them a similar amount, but the value of the wins is in Wake Forest's favor, and the benefit of having one additional game is giving them the edge in the Common Sense rankings, where Wake Forest is number 14 compared to Ole Miss at number 18.
- 7:47Blind resume test number three.
- 7:49Team A is four and two.
- 7:50They started one and two in their Power Four conference.
- 7:53They have two Power Four wins and one Group of Six win.
- 7:57The teams they've beat have eight total FBS victories, four over Power Four and four over Group of Six schools, and the teams they've lost to have two combined losses.
- 8:07Team B, meanwhile, is an undefeated six and O, starting three and O in their Group of Six conference.
- 8:13All five of their FBS wins have come against Group of Six competition, and their opponents have nine FBS victories, but also all over Group of Six teams.
- 8:23So what we're assessing here with these two resumes is how much Power Four losses should hurt teams and if having Power Four wins should give you a boost over an undefeated Group of Six team.
- 8:33Is two Power Four wins and two Power Four losses more impressive than five Group of Six wins?
- 8:39Well, in this situation, Team A is LSU, who is the only two-loss team ranked by the AP at number twenty-two.
- 8:46Team B was probably an easy one to guess, as James Madison is the last remaining undefeated school outside the Power Four.
- 8:53The Dukes got twenty-nine votes this week by the Associated Press.
- 8:57James Madison is number twelve in the Common Sense rankings, while LSU is down at number thirty.
- 9:02What I will also say, if both teams win out, LSU finishes ten and two and seven and two in the SEC, while James Madison goes eight and O in the Sun Belt.
- 9:10LSU will likely overtake the Dukes in the season-ending Common Sense ranking.
- 9:14But right now, through six weeks, I would argue JMU's resume is more impressive than the LSU Tigers.
- 9:23Let's compare just two more resumes, and this time they'll be from the same conference, the Big 12.
- 9:29Team A is five and one overall, two and one in conference, and their loss is to an undefeated Big 12 team.
- 9:35Their opponents have five total FBS wins, with three over Power Four schools.
- 9:41Team B, meanwhile, is four and one overall, starting two and O against the Big 12, with one additional Power Four win.
- 9:47Their loss is to a three and three American team.
- 9:50Teams they've defeated have six FBS wins, with three over the Power Four.
- 9:55Team A did get votes this week.
- 9:57That would be the Arizona Wildcats at CSR number twenty-five, while Team B is the Oklahoma State Cowboys, who are ranked eighteenth in the AP but are CSR number thirty-three.
- 10:08The difference between these two teams in the common sense rankings is the extra win Arizona has posted, as well as the loss to an undefeated team, compared to OSU's loss to Tulsa in week one.
- 10:18We'll see where each team shakes out after the Wildcats' bye this upcoming week.
- 10:24Let me next introduce to you the top 10 teams in this week's Common Sense rankings.
- 10:29At the top is a new number one, the undefeated Notre Dame Fighting Irish.
- 10:33Each of their six wins is over an FBS opponent, with five of them being from Power Four conferences, netting them the best compilation of victories through six weeks in the season.
- 10:42Their opponents haven't quite put up the wins of a few teams behind them, but Wisconsin being four and one, Purdue winning each of their last two Big Ten games, and North Carolina beating Pitt last week are all working in the Irish's favor to this point.
- 10:56At number two were the winners of last week's top game, the Georgia Bulldogs.
- 11:00The Dogs have the benefit of playing in the strongest conference according to the CSR, so each SEC win they pick up will continue to net them big points.
- 11:08They have the third-largest value of on-the-field wins in this week's rankings, courtesy of starting four and O in conference.
- 11:15Carried by their win over the otherwise undefeated Alabama is giving them the third-highest strength of opponent wins in the CSR This is the second consecutive week that last week's number one dropped to number three.
- 11:27That would be the Alabama Crimson Tide.
- 11:30This is where some of you may be screaming SEC bias, so hear me out.
- 11:34Alabama has not yet played an FCS opponent.
- 11:36That'll come later in the season.
- 11:38So they have five FBS wins and have yet to take their buy.
- 11:41The opponents they've defeated have won a staggering 18 combined games, giving them the strongest strength of opponent wins of any team this week.
- 11:49Their loss is to an undefeated SEC team, which is the least penalizing loss in the CSR formula this season.
- 11:55If you put all that together, then the Tide are deserving of number three this week.
- 12:00Number four is the first Big Ten team, but it is neither of the teams that have yet to lose in the conference.
- 12:05Number four this week is the USC Trojans.
- 12:08I was catching some flack on X this week due to the Trojans being number four, so let me put some data behind the ranking.
- 12:14First, Southern Cal has six FBS wins, including three against the Big Ten and one each against the Sun Belt and the Pac-12, two of the strongest group of six conferences according to the CSR formula.
- 12:26The six FBS teams they've defeated have 12 FBS wins of their own, putting the Trojans among the top five in opponent win strength.
- 12:33They are docked for their loss to Oregon and the Ducks further two losses, but in total resume, USC stands at number four in the CSR.
- 12:41You can expect the Trojans to fall next week as they are on bye in week seven.
- 12:46Number five is the Indiana Hoosiers.
- 12:48They defeated previously undefeated Nebraska last Saturday, gaining points both for that win as well as Nebraska's five other victories.
- 12:56They have several tough matchups the rest of the season, starting this week at Ohio State, so if the Hoosiers can continue to win, they'll not only get credit for those wins but also for each win their opponents have gained this season.
- 13:08Number six is UCLA, the other undefeated Big Ten team following their win over Oregon.
- 13:13Seven is Kentucky.
- 13:14The Wildcats have won consecutive games by the score of 35-34 after one OT, having gone for two after their touchdowns.
- 13:22Number eight is the top ACC team, the Miami Hurricanes, who did drop a few spots after taking their buy.
- 13:29Number nine is the Texas Longhorns following their loss to Oklahoma.
- 13:33They get further dinged for Oklahoma's losses, but three of the teams they beat have no other defeats, giving them the second highest strength of opponent victories after just Alabama.
- 13:43Rounding out the top 10 is Mississippi State, whose big win over Missouri is giving the Bulldogs their top 10 ranking this week in the CSR.
- 13:52The rest of the top 25, 11 is Ohio State.
- 13:55Number 12 is the top group of 16, James Madison.
- 13:5913 is BYU.
- 14:0014 belongs to Wake Forest.
- 14:0215 is Missouri.
- 14:0316, Utah.
- 14:0417, Texas Tech.
- 14:0618 is the Ole Miss Rebels.
- 14:0819 is Tennessee.
- 14:0920, Iowa.
- 14:1121, Houston.
- 14:1222, Boise State, who finally cracks the CSR top 25.
- 14:16Nebraska is number 23.
- 14:18Pitt is at number 24.
- 14:19And rounding out the top 25 is Arizona of the Big 12.
- 14:24There are still just undefeated or one-loss teams in this week's Common Sense rankings, but that will likely change next week as there are a couple of two-loss teams knocking on the door.
- 14:33This week's CSR has eight teams from the SEC, six from the Big Ten, five out of the Big 12, three from the ACC, and then Notre Dame, Boise State, and James Madison.
- 14:45If we compare that conference breakdown to what the AP poll gives us, we'll see that it's pretty comparable.
- 14:50We do have one fewer SEC team because LSU is undeserving.
- 14:54We have the same amount of Big Ten teams, but swap in Nebraska instead of Northwestern.
- 14:59We have the correct number of Big 12 teams, but give me Arizona in lieu of Oklahoma State.
- 15:04The ACC also got the right number, but SMU shouldn't be there.
- 15:08Give me Pitt instead.
- 15:09Notre Dame and Boise State's rankings are legit, but James Madison deserves more credit than they're getting in the human polls If the college football playoff used the CSR to build their bracket, it would look a little something like this.
- 15:23Our byes would go to numbers one through four, Notre Dame, Georgia, Alabama, and Southern Cal.
- 15:29In the first round, we would see number five Indiana hosting number 12 BYU, who gets in courtesy of winning the Big 12.
- 15:36Number six UCLA would face number 11 James Madison, the Group of six representative.
- 15:41Number seven Kentucky would be paired up with number 10 Mississippi State, and number eight Miami would play host to number nine Texas.
- 15:48Ohio State, even though they are ranked number 11 in the common sense rankings, they would get pushed out to include the Group of six representative James Madison and the Big 12 champion BYU.
- 15:59The other teams just missing out are Wake Forest and Missouri.
- 16:04Our AP poll voters are getting closer to correctly evaluating the top 25 teams, correctly identifying 21 of the top resumes to this point in the season.
- 16:13They're starting to realize the resumes of both UCLA and Kentucky, and the CSR finally agrees with Boise State's AP rank.
- 16:22The places to improve include the evaluation of the James Madison Dukes.
- 16:26The Oklahoma State Cowboys were on every single ballot, and the omission of any votes for five and one Pittsburgh out of the ACC.
- 16:33Not a single voter put the Panthers on their ballot, showing they're accounting for future expectations since Pitt's starting QB was injured recently.
- 16:42Talking about individual ballots, uh, each week I look for a few specific thing among those who turn in an AP poll vote and call out men and women who are properly evaluating a few key teams.
- 16:53Among those who are, uh, properly evaluating teams, James Madison is number 12 in the CSR but remain in the others receiving votes category in the AP poll.
- 17:03Almost everyone who did have the Dukes on the ballot threw them a bone by putting them either 24th or 25th.
- 17:09But Alex Taylor has them 21st, and Brian Fonseca has them 20th.
- 17:13So thank you to those two for going against the grain on JMU.
- 17:18In addition to James Madison, the other teams that made the CSR top 25 that were omitted from the AP poll were Nebraska, Arizona, and Pitt.
- 17:26No votes for the Panthers, but a couple of voters did correctly rank the Wildcats and the Huskers on their ballot.
- 17:32Javonte Edmonds, who is becoming a staple in this portion of the podcast, Kevin Carter, Cokie Riley, and Steven Means all ranked both teams on their ballots.
- 17:41There were four teams that were included in the AP top 25 that are undeserving according to the Common Sense rankings.
- 17:47Oklahoma State, which was on every ballot, SMU, Northwestern, and LSU.
- 17:53David Jablonsky, Sarah Hughes, and Spencer Ripchek each left off those three teams, which absolutely deserves a shout-out.
- 18:02For every ballot submitted that does something right, there are several more who do not.
- 18:07USC has six FBS wins, tied for the most in the country, including three wins over Big Ten schools, but that wasn't enough for six voters.
- 18:15Alex Taylor, Andy Yamashita, Dylan Sinn, Eric Hansen, Ian Kress, and Cokie Riley each left the Trojans off their ballot.
- 18:23I've mentioned twice already the Oklahoma State Cowboys are overrated in the AP poll, and the highest any voter had them this week was at number 11.
- 18:31Both Dylan Sinn and Murray Evans are improperly evaluating the strength of the Cowboys' resume As we look ahead to week seven, there are four of this week's CSR top twenty-five on bye.
- 18:44Each of those teams will likely drop down next week's rankings.
- 18:47Three Power Four teams will play their seemingly required game against FCS competition in twenty twenty-six as Clemson, Texas A&M, and Stanford all take the easy way out.
- 18:58There's just one non-conference matchup that could impact the CSR conference strength rankings this week, and it would impact which conference is at the bottom.
- 19:07The MAC is a surprise two and one against the American this year, the only head-to-head against any conference in which they're ahead.
- 19:14In week seven, we have the fourth and final matchup between the two conferences when Kent State plays South Florida.
- 19:20If the Bulls were to beat the Golden Flashes, the MAC would descend into the basement of the conference rankings without a head-to-head winning record to their name.
- 19:27With each MAC team sporting at least two losses to this point, it likely wouldn't impact conference members much.
- 19:34Who it would impact would be the teams that have a win over a MAC team this season, as a win would be worth fewer points to those victors.
- 19:41The Big Ten should be cheering hard for the Golden Flashes as they want each of their eleven wins over the MAC to provide them more credit in the CSR.
- 19:51There are four matchups this upcoming week between ranked teams in the CSR, including yet another including CSR number one.
- 19:59College GameDay will be live from Provo, Utah, covering CSR number one Notre Dame's trip to number thirteen BYU, airing on ABC in primetime.
- 20:09The Cougars are looking for a statement win, not just for themselves, but for the Big 12, a conference that is pining for multiple entries into this year's college football playoff.
- 20:18Coincidentally, a win over BYU may not be enough to maintain the Irish's hold on the top spot in the CSR.
- 20:24Georgia receives the benefit of playing another SEC team, so a Dogs win over Auburn would potentially be enough to put them ahead of the Irish, depending on results elsewhere.
- 20:34CSR number three Alabama will play their third consecutive ranked opponent, taking a trip up to CSR number nineteen Tennessee, airing at three thirty on ABC.
- 20:44The Tide already has the strongest value of opponent wins, and a dub over a five-win SEC team would likely keep them right near the top of the CSR, while a Tennessee win would launch them into the top ten.
- 20:56CSR number five Indiana is right in the middle of their toughest stretch of the season.
- 21:01They'll face number eleven Ohio State Saturday at noon Eastern on Fox.
- 21:05That is a top five AP matchup and the location of Fox's Big Noon Saturday this week.
- 21:11The final CSR ranked matchup will feature number fifteen Missouri and number eighteen Ole Miss.
- 21:16That's the mid-afternoon game on SEC Network.
- 21:19Both teams are overrated in the AP poll, but Ole Miss more so.
- 21:23So even though Missouri has to go on the road, I may put a little sprinkle on the Tigers to take down the Rebels.
- 21:29There are two additional matchups between AP ranked teams this week.
- 21:33First, four and one Mississippi State will travel to four and two LSU at twelve noon on ESPN.
- 21:39The Tigers are the lone two-loss team to have earned a spot in the AP poll this week, but a loss would surely kick them out of the top twenty-five.
- 21:46The other is a Big 12 matchup between Oklahoma State and Houston at seven thirty on Fox.
- 21:52Oklahoma State has already taken their bye this season, which is keeping them unranked in the common sense rankings.
- 21:57But at number eighteen in the AP, they could be looking at something close to the top ten in the AP next week were they to win.
- 22:05I hope each of you enjoy this week of college football.
- 22:08We're about halfway through the season, but we still have three-quarters of our data points to be determined in the Common Sense rankings formulas.
- 22:15Thank you for listening to another episode of the podcast.
- 22:17I'm trying to remain active on the socials if you wanna follow at Common Sense Ranking, and I'll be updating Common Sense rankings after each round of games each week.
- 22:26Thank you again for listening, and please, as you go about your day-to-day, use some common sense