Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Tracking The Traffickers" with Foeke Postma
Transcript
- 0:04You're listening to a stage talk titled Tracking
- 0:07the Traffickers. This week, Bellingcat researcher
- 0:10Fuca Postma joined us on stage. Fuca is known
- 0:13for finding things online that shouldn't be there,
- 0:17from exposing flashcard apps that were leaking
- 0:19highly confidential locations of nuclear weapons,
- 0:22to highlighting clues that a woman claiming to
- 0:24offer evacuation flights out of Iranian missile
- 0:27flight paths to major newspapers may be completely
- 0:30AI -generated. In recent years, he's turned his
- 0:33talent to finding these digital trails to looking
- 0:36into animal welfare. He's carried out investigations
- 0:39into influencers showcasing lion cubs on their
- 0:41YouTube and Instagram to profile selling endangered
- 0:45species to customers on Facebook and TikTok.
- 0:48In this talk, he speaks on how he carried out
- 0:50these investigations and what methods you can
- 0:53take to report on animal abuse. You can find
- 0:56links to all the resources mentioned in the talk
- 0:59in the podcast description. This talk was hosted
- 1:01by me, Charlotte Ma, on Thursday, the 2nd of
- 1:04April, 2026, in the Bellicat Discord server.
- 1:12Welcome to a new stage talk. Today's conversation
- 1:14dives into the hidden world of online wildlife
- 1:17trafficking and how it's evolving in plain sight
- 1:20on mainstream platforms. A recent investigation
- 1:24by Usa Billingcat uncovered networks of traders
- 1:27using coded language inside Facebook groups to
- 1:30openly sell protected and endangered animals,
- 1:33often to tens of thousands of members. Despite
- 1:36platform policies banning animal sales, these
- 1:38communities have persisted for years and evaded
- 1:41detection until now. The reporting traces how
- 1:44these networks operate, how sellers mask illegal
- 1:47activity, and how multiple accounts lead back
- 1:50to a single broker coordinating sales across
- 1:52borders. To unpack how this works and what it
- 1:56means for tech platform moderation, conservation
- 1:58efforts, and digital investigations into environmental
- 2:01harms, I'm joined by my colleague, Fuka Postma.
- 2:04He's also the researcher behind this investigation.
- 2:07Carried out, by the way, with the excellent environmental
- 2:10investigations outlet, Monga Bay. Before we start,
- 2:13and before I pass it over to Fuca, a short reminder
- 2:16that you can place your questions in the chat,
- 2:19accessible in the right -hand corner of your
- 2:21screen. But please remember that this is being
- 2:23audio recorded for the podcast. So if you want
- 2:26to keep your Discord username private, please
- 2:29mention that in your question. Okay. Fuca, I
- 2:33will shut up and the stage is yours. Thank you
- 2:37very much. So I'll start off by setting the scene
- 2:41and our broader interest in investigating wildlife
- 2:46issues online and why I think Bellingcat and
- 2:49open source investigators can play a crucial
- 2:52role in trying to prevent or stop this kind of
- 2:57stuff happening. So if we think about wildlife
- 3:01issues online, it's always broader than people
- 3:05think. You have the trait, which we'll discuss
- 3:09in a bit, but there's also all types of abuse
- 3:15going on. Farming, poaching, people who collect
- 3:23rare bats for taxidermy or gorilla skulls. People
- 3:27who think specific animals have medicinal properties
- 3:33when you consume them. Or there are communities
- 3:37who think certain owls represent witchery and
- 3:41so they should be exterminated or chased away
- 3:43once you come across them. So it's a large scale
- 3:48issue that you can approach from many angles.
- 3:51But what the research shows is that most of this
- 3:56place where animals get traded takes place on
- 4:01Facebook. So that's where a lot of this stuff
- 4:06can be found. Even with different platforms around,
- 4:10even with knowing that there are local shops
- 4:13or whatever, like every country has their own
- 4:15specific sort of like commercial website, right?
- 4:18Still Facebook is very much a large source for
- 4:22wildlife issues, especially once you delve into
- 4:26the illegal wildlife trade. And so you already
- 4:31said it, there are measures that Facebook takes
- 4:34to sort of combat this issue. But it's always
- 4:40an evolving scene and illegal wildlife traders
- 4:44know this. So for example, even years ago, I
- 4:52came across posts which clearly showed cheetah
- 4:56cubs. in the Middle East in a small basket. And
- 5:01already back then people were wise enough to
- 5:05never use the word cheetah and buy or sell in
- 5:08the same post. The comments would ask, is it
- 5:12for sale or are you selling it? And the seller
- 5:16would say it's sold, it's sold, it's sold. And
- 5:19no one would say the word cheetah specifically.
- 5:22Now you can still often... Not often, but if
- 5:27you're lucky, find people in groups who are not
- 5:31smart enough to avoid doing this. But by and
- 5:36large, if a wildlife trader is successful and
- 5:40has built up a reputation online, you'll find
- 5:43that they are very good at avoiding certain types
- 5:45of language. And that makes it a bit more difficult
- 5:49to detect. You'll also see that they use certain
- 5:53emojis, for example, because you can't really
- 5:56search Facebook with emojis. Or they will try
- 6:01to edit the photo. So the animal on it is not
- 6:07easily recognizable, I guess, to an algorithm,
- 6:10but humans can still see what they mean. The
- 6:18same goes for these groups that are the topic
- 6:20of this latest investigation. A lot of these
- 6:23groups were called animal adoption. If they mentioned
- 6:28a species, they would mention a species that
- 6:30is legal to trade in, but is very adjacent to
- 6:35more illegal wildlife trade. So for example,
- 6:40they would use group names that focus on sievats.
- 6:48And, uh, they are, I mean, more rare than, than
- 6:52your average animal, uh, more uncommon. Um, and
- 6:57they draw a certain crowds, right? Um, and in
- 7:01those groups, you would find more and more rare
- 7:04and specific, uh, species that were not meant
- 7:08to be, uh, sold at all. Um, and that, that language
- 7:14that they use to avoid immediate detection is
- 7:17something that reminds me of previous investigations
- 7:19where animal traders, illegal wildlife traders
- 7:25in the Middle East, they would just say they
- 7:27have a private zoo or they would have an animal
- 7:31rescue. And that's their reason why they show
- 7:35off animals at the profile and why they hold
- 7:38them. And then if you duck just a little bit
- 7:40further, you can immediately see now they're
- 7:41buying and selling these species. That being
- 7:48said, you can still use keywords to find this
- 7:52kind of posts, these groups. You just have to
- 7:59go through a couple of steps and put yourself
- 8:01in the context that they themselves live in.
- 8:06So obviously a language barrier, you need to
- 8:10switch to Bahasa Indonesian in this case, but
- 8:14then also the dealers figure out their own sort
- 8:19of colloquial language, type of lingo that takes
- 8:22place once you deal with certain material long
- 8:26enough. So a buffy fish owl, for example, becomes
- 8:32just a buffy. Now, if I see something that's
- 8:37just called a buffy or you search for a buffy,
- 8:40you For those older amongst us, you might end
- 8:44up with Buffy the vampire slayer. But in the
- 8:47right context, you get a certain type of owl
- 8:50that people were very interested in, right? So
- 8:54these keywords, even though these sensors like...
- 8:59You have the sensors, you have the traders rotating
- 9:02around the sensors. If you take the effort to
- 9:05figure out the keywords, you might still find
- 9:06those traders and those groups. It just takes
- 9:10a little bit more research ahead of finding material
- 9:15that you're interested in. You can still do this
- 9:20right now if you search, for example, on Telegram,
- 9:25if you're interested in dog fighting, one of
- 9:27these other wildlife issues, or at least animal
- 9:30issues, if you just go to Telegram and you search
- 9:33for dogs, you're not going to find much. You
- 9:36can search for game dogs, and then you're getting
- 9:39closer to the type of groups that you are interested
- 9:43in. But if you specifically look for APBT, American
- 9:52Pit Bull Terrier, You're going to find all of
- 9:54these accounts and groups that are dedicated
- 9:57often to dog fighting because the, the American
- 10:01pit bull terrier is one of the favorites that
- 10:03they use. They use that short harm, that acronym
- 10:06for that dog. And that's sort of like commonly
- 10:08known in that community. Um, so that's what I
- 10:12mean, like you need to sort of, uh, get in there,
- 10:17um, or at least do some research and find those
- 10:21other ways. in which you can track these people.
- 10:27So one interesting aspect to this research that
- 10:30we did is finding out the admins of these groups.
- 10:38So sometimes when you read about the amount of
- 10:41Facebook posts that contain illegal advertisements
- 10:44on wildlife, it always feels hopeless. Like the
- 10:48numbers are in the thousands, tens of thousands.
- 10:51And if you're in this group, you see like hundreds
- 10:54of posts every week, right? And just the scale
- 10:58is sort of overwhelming because it might just
- 11:03mix in with legal trade. And none of us are an
- 11:09expert on every species. So you might see like
- 11:12a dozen adverts for others. And some others you
- 11:17can trade in and some others you can't trade
- 11:20in. Uh, but you have to sort of be able to determine
- 11:23that, but good luck if you're not an author expert,
- 11:25right? So, uh, for this research, uh, it was,
- 11:31I guess for the first time that I properly made
- 11:33use of AI as well. And I know this is, um, already,
- 11:40uh, dangerous to go in because every time you
- 11:43refer to AI, immediately people think, oh, hallucinations.
- 11:47uh, you know, double check your work. And it's
- 11:50true, you need, you need to double check your
- 11:51work, but it can still speed up your work, even
- 11:54accounting for the double checking. Um, so, um,
- 12:01if, if I had such a large volume of posts, um,
- 12:05and you start off with some animals that you
- 12:08learn to recognize, like I now know what a buffy
- 12:10owl looks like and sort of what otter is protected
- 12:13and which ones, uh, aren't. But if you prepare
- 12:20an environment, a project or a notebook or whatever
- 12:26your LLM or your AI offers, where you can sort
- 12:30of prepare the stage. You throw in documents
- 12:33related to the specific laws of that country.
- 12:39You tell it that you want the... You needed to
- 12:44check the IUCN listing for the species. And then
- 12:49quickly, sorry, provide feedback on whatever
- 12:53photo or name of an animal you throw in there.
- 12:57You are able to deal with a large volume of animals
- 13:01much more faster. And you learn a lot this way
- 13:05as well, especially if you, you know, do what
- 13:08you need to do, which is double check whatever
- 13:10the LLM is. providing you. So you're in this
- 13:14group that is hiding under adopt an animal. You
- 13:19see a large volume of posts and you're using
- 13:21AI to sort of like quickly learn more and more
- 13:24about, okay, which animals are we looking at?
- 13:28Which ones should I pay extra attention to? And
- 13:32then once in a while you'll probably find adverts
- 13:35that contain animals that are protected or vulnerable
- 13:40and endangered or both, both meaning endangered
- 13:42and protected. Um, and that's where the digging
- 13:46starts, right? Um, it already says something
- 13:49about the group, obviously. Um, but you want
- 13:54to start with the people who are actually, actually
- 13:57sending those adverts into the group to begin
- 14:01with. And more often than not, you'll end up
- 14:03with a locked Facebook profile. Which sucks,
- 14:07but it's not the end of the world. Because you
- 14:10can search old Facebook profiles, or you can
- 14:13search locked Facebook profiles for older posts,
- 14:16sorry. If you don't know how to do this, if you
- 14:20ever end up in a locked Facebook profile, there's
- 14:22three dots on the right hand side and you can
- 14:24do search. And you have to fill in a keyword.
- 14:29And depending on if they've ever used that keyword,
- 14:32you might get results. suddenly you might see
- 14:36posts that they posted that you were not able
- 14:39to see when you just visited their profile. And
- 14:42the good thing about this is that if you visited
- 14:45their, or if you came across their adverts, you
- 14:50probably have some indication of the language
- 14:52that they might be using to send out ads into
- 14:58groups. So in this case, I came across several
- 15:04locked Facebook profiles through advertisements.
- 15:09And for example, one, I only had an advertisement
- 15:11for Buffy Fish Owl. And so I just go to the profile,
- 15:14profile's locked, it's empty, but I do this thing
- 15:17where you open up the search button. Pro tip,
- 15:20if the search button doesn't appear, you can
- 15:22still make it appear through a bookmark. I'm
- 15:29not going to explain this right now, but I'm
- 15:31happy to in the Discord. But yeah, just so you
- 15:35know. So you can search the looked Facebook profile,
- 15:37right? I have the adverts. I search for Buffy
- 15:41and suddenly I see where else this person has
- 15:44placed this Buffy advert. You might also see
- 15:47the posts that don't just contain Buffy, but
- 15:51maybe their phone number or maybe a different
- 15:53species that they've also been selling at a different
- 15:56time. It does not matter in particular if the
- 16:00advertisement is years old. Um, I mean, the animal
- 16:07will be, will be gone probably. Uh, but for research,
- 16:12if you, even if you have an advert that is really
- 16:15old, I still see people comment on adverts that
- 16:19are like two years old, um, just to make the
- 16:24connection with the seller. And I mean, there's
- 16:30all kinds of information you can gather from
- 16:32this, right? Who are the people who are responding
- 16:34to the adverts? Who are people who are liking
- 16:37the adverts? What are they up to? So all the
- 16:43posts are interesting, not just because you have
- 16:45those connections, but also because they might
- 16:48lead you to different groups, more information,
- 16:51other keywords that that user has been using
- 16:55in their adverts. And slowly but surely you can
- 16:57unravel an identity behind the locked Facebook
- 17:01profile. In this story, once I started doing
- 17:05this, I noticed that there was a collection of
- 17:11profiles that were using the same keywords, the
- 17:15same like buffy fish owl. They will use WC, WildCod
- 17:21or BC, which is bred in captivity. WildCod is
- 17:25usually more worse and it's like the laws are
- 17:29more stringent when it's wild caught. And yeah,
- 17:34I started noticing that they posted the same
- 17:38kind of stuff. And they also, many of them had
- 17:42admin roles or moderator roles in several of
- 17:45these groups that I kept running into. And here's
- 17:49where it becomes a bit more typical Bellingcat
- 17:51investigation, where you look at the photos and
- 17:54you start to... understand I'm looking at the
- 17:57same kind of interior. From the interior, eventually
- 18:01I saw a poster in the background that led me
- 18:04to a specific shop. I also started noticing that,
- 18:07you know, as they hold the animal to photograph,
- 18:12they photographed part of their wrist and they
- 18:15had a nice mole on that wrist. And so even though
- 18:20they were photographing different animals in
- 18:22different positions, sometimes different interiors,
- 18:25They all showed the same exact model on the same
- 18:28wrist. And so I started thinking, oh, wait, are
- 18:30all these different profiles, if we have different
- 18:34admin roles and moderator roles in different
- 18:35groups, they appear to come from one person and
- 18:40the phone number also started to point to one
- 18:42person. Yeah. And so with the geolocation, I
- 18:48eventually figured out, okay, this is a store
- 18:51that they're connected to. And in the story,
- 18:56you see this pet shop. It's a very small pet
- 18:58shop in Indonesia near Jakarta. And we decided
- 19:06to partner up with Mongabay, which is a great
- 19:09outlet, great environmental focused outlet that
- 19:12decided to help us out. And they had someone
- 19:17visit that store. Saw Javan Kugal, which is a
- 19:25protected species there. And gave us more information
- 19:32to work off. So it turns out that the person
- 19:37that I came across from all these different profiles
- 19:40is a broker who hangs out at that shop. And that
- 19:45makes sense if you see the shop, it's relatively
- 19:46small. But the way this usually works. uh, is
- 19:52a broker is like dedicated to connecting people
- 19:56who source these animals, who sell animals and
- 19:58people who want to buy these animals. Um, and
- 20:01they make sort of these essential nodes in, in
- 20:04networks. Um, it's very rare for, for example,
- 20:08someone who, um, works in, um, some remote area,
- 20:15um, like a farmer or a, uh, let's say woodcutter.
- 20:20They might come across a rare species like out
- 20:23there in nature. It's rare for those people to
- 20:29immediately go to Facebook and like start trying
- 20:31to sell whatever they found. Usually it's they
- 20:34know a guy who knows a guy who knows a guy and
- 20:36that guy knows the broker who has a large network
- 20:41and is able to make the trade for you and gets
- 20:44a portion of the profit. And so in this case,
- 20:48I suspect they were helping out that pet shop
- 20:50just connect to a wider audience. We didn't go
- 20:53as far as trying to figure out where the pet
- 20:55shop sourced their animals because like I said,
- 20:59it might very well be that they just have some
- 21:01guy on WhatsApp who came across this rare bird
- 21:03in their backyard or on the farm or whatever.
- 21:08The good thing about being able to identify one
- 21:12of sort of these essential nodes in a network
- 21:14is that Yeah, once you've identified the person
- 21:19and you can demonstrate that they are selling
- 21:22protected species themselves and facilitating
- 21:25it for a very large portion of this wildlife
- 21:28trade online, like the groups that they had an
- 21:32admin or moderator role in together had like
- 21:3670 ,000 people in them. And because we reach
- 21:41out to Meta and we ask questions, Meta eventually
- 21:44takes down these groups and those accounts. And
- 21:47that matters. That matters a lot. Like I said,
- 21:53these accounts, their history also matters, right?
- 21:57You can't just make a new account and a new group.
- 22:01I mean, they can, but it will never have the
- 22:03same weight of groups that have been online for
- 22:07five years or more. where they have demonstrated
- 22:12that they are authentic sellers that can be trusted.
- 22:16Where old adverts still demonstrate the types
- 22:21of animals that they might be able to fetch for
- 22:24you or have on offer. So I consider this a more
- 22:29successful impact than just trying to take down
- 22:33posts. And on top of that, It also I think is
- 22:40somewhat inspiring to think that yes, there are
- 22:42thousands of these posts and a lot of groups,
- 22:47but apparently if you manage to find the right
- 22:50person and identify them, you can take seven
- 22:56of these groups, nine of these groups. I need
- 22:58to check my own work now. I think it was nine
- 23:00even. Yeah, some smaller groups, nine groups
- 23:03now. Yeah, just by identifying one. crucial guy,
- 23:08you take down a very large portion of this community
- 23:12that is involved in illegal wildlife trade near
- 23:16Jakarta. And, you know, as it's a Bellingcat
- 23:19article, hopefully demonstrate to you, all of
- 23:21you, how you can do the same, how you can search
- 23:23these profiles, how you can make connections
- 23:25and hopefully identify the people who are doing
- 23:28this. Let's see, do I have any other thoughts
- 23:32on this? We'll just open it up for questions.
- 23:37What do you think Charlotte? It sounds good to
- 23:40me. We already have quite a few coming through.
- 23:43I will reshare the article link as well while
- 23:47I'm here, just in case people want to look through.
- 23:51Although I did put the image of the mole in the
- 23:53chat as you were talking about it. In terms of
- 23:56discovery, Saiba asks, are most of these Facebook
- 24:00posts public or do you likely need to join them
- 24:03to see the chats? And there's been discussion
- 24:05in the chat about how you might be able to kind
- 24:08of make your way into these spaces. Perhaps as
- 24:11an addition to that, you could also talk about
- 24:13kind of where we as researchers draw the line
- 24:16in terms of infiltrating Facebook groups or...
- 24:19private Facebook pages as you were talking about
- 24:21earlier. So these are fairly large groups and
- 24:28they might be set to private, but you can join
- 24:33them usually very easily. Because I'm interested
- 24:36in the topic, I just mass join whatever groups
- 24:40even remotely suggest that they're interested.
- 24:43And then once you do a search on Facebook, if
- 24:45you're in those groups, you search those groups
- 24:47as well, right? Um, so it makes it that, that
- 24:52easier. Uh, that's, that's what my approach has
- 24:56been to, um, yeah, search for these groups, especially
- 25:03once they say adoption and they have like, uh,
- 25:06tens of thousands of, of people in them. And
- 25:09then, uh, I guess if you want to get more accurate
- 25:15and find the specific groups, it's always worth
- 25:18to One, check the groups that, like I said, these
- 25:23dealers are in. So once you see an advert in
- 25:26like a broad general group that interests you,
- 25:28find the person, investigate them a little bit
- 25:31and see if you can find your posts in different
- 25:33groups. But also sometimes stuff gets reshared
- 25:36from one group to another. And then that's a
- 25:39useful way of, you know, finding out multiple
- 25:44groups. So yeah, it's not... that difficult to
- 25:49find these groups in my experience. Um, we do
- 25:53draw the line at talking to people and, you know,
- 25:57joining very specific, uh, private groups where
- 26:00you need to engage in a discussion with the admin
- 26:02in order to, uh, get into the group. Okay. Uh,
- 26:07so that's just, uh, where we at Bellingcat draw
- 26:10the line. I use sub puppets to, to join large
- 26:13groups. Um, But I don't just step into a very
- 26:17private group or talk to these people. Yeah.
- 26:22Yeah. Really important. Cybert wrote in the chat,
- 26:25all Bellingcat supporters are getting ready to
- 26:27descend upon Facebook and nab a bunch of these
- 26:29brokers. In regards to privacy, as we're talking
- 26:34about it, before we move on to any other questions,
- 26:36you mentioned that MongoBay as part of their
- 26:38collaboration kind of went on the ground and
- 26:41looked to see if they could find the location.
- 26:44How did they control that situation? Did they
- 26:49approach the individual? Where was their role
- 26:52in this and can you explain a little bit further
- 26:54how they protected themselves as well on the
- 26:56ground? Yeah, so they do a more traditional style
- 27:02of journalism where they just visited the store
- 27:05as a customer, asked some questions, took some
- 27:10photos. And then later on, for the right of reply,
- 27:16they called the people as well. We found phone
- 27:20numbers, obviously. We visited and said, we're
- 27:24working on an article where journalists, what
- 27:27do you have to say about our findings? So obviously
- 27:33a bit further than we can go. Very interesting
- 27:36form of journalism, but a very helpful one here
- 27:40also in this story. Yeah, those underground jailers
- 27:43can often give you a little bit more context
- 27:45than you can find online. Somebody in the chat's
- 27:49put, that's very good advice. Fuca safety is
- 27:51paramount and exposure to some things is not
- 27:53desired. And somebody else has put a little resource
- 27:58for sock puppets accounts, if you're not familiar
- 28:00with what they are. Obviously, be very, very
- 28:04careful. If you are creating sockpocket accounts
- 28:08to join places, make sure that what you're doing
- 28:10is in the public interest and make sure that
- 28:13you're being safe online using VPNs and all of
- 28:16that stuff. There's loads of resources in hashtag
- 28:20infosec in this server that will help you with
- 28:23that and in tools and sites. We had a question
- 28:26earlier about if you'd applied these techniques
- 28:29to other nations other than Indonesia. What I
- 28:32mentioned in your intro is that you've actually
- 28:33been covering this for a little bit. Could you
- 28:36talk a little bit about some of the other investigations
- 28:38on similar communities that you found doing similar
- 28:43activities? Yeah, sure. I've done this for Malaysia,
- 28:51sorry, and for Dubai as well. And there's some
- 28:56side projects that take place in different contexts
- 28:59as well. So it's very replicable. The advice
- 29:03applies to different regions as well. It's not
- 29:06Indonesia specific. In all of these contexts,
- 29:12they tried to avoid sensors in the same way.
- 29:17In Malaysia, you found the trafficker on TikTok,
- 29:21correct? And in Dubai was Instagram, right? So
- 29:24these are across platforms as well that you'll
- 29:27find in these. In Dubai, it was actually spotting
- 29:35the animals in the background of influencer videos.
- 29:37Is that correct? Yes. Yeah, that's true. You'll
- 29:42see that if they are large enough, this will
- 29:46end up a multi -platform investigation, but it's
- 29:50not always. forward for the way we publish the
- 29:53story. It's not always useful to take you through
- 29:56every platform because it's usually very much
- 29:59the same. So in this, in the Indonesia story,
- 30:04I discussed Facebook, but they also have, for
- 30:06example, a presence on TikTok. And with the Dubai
- 30:10story, we focus very much on Instagram, but you
- 30:14could also find posts on Facebook. I like Facebook
- 30:18because it's... It usually provides you a bit
- 30:21more information and it's a bit more easier to
- 30:24research in my experience than TikTok or Instagram.
- 30:31But yeah, it ends up being, even if the story
- 30:37ends up being focusing on the line of inquiry
- 30:41on one platform. Usually on the backside, you'll
- 30:45find that we uncover multiple platforms and the
- 30:48same behavior happening in different places.
- 30:53And you mentioned that you were searching in
- 30:56Indonesian for this particular investigation,
- 30:58the recent one that you were just talking about.
- 31:00Dars has asked, with Facebook being particularly
- 31:02prominent in the Indo -Pacific, these groups
- 31:05of thousands of members, do you find that the
- 31:07buyers are prominently domestic or have you observed
- 31:10transnational trade? A bit of both. So the scale
- 31:20is large enough that you're getting inundated
- 31:23with more domestic trades, it feels like. But
- 31:28then I wasn't surprised when I saw some people
- 31:32ask for international transfers or trades. They
- 31:39will sometimes also openly advertise with saying,
- 31:41no, we can ship this anywhere in the world. So
- 31:47yeah, a lot of local trade, but not excluding
- 31:51international trade. How far do you go when you're
- 31:58trying to map out these networks? Like, do you
- 32:00often try to, you mentioned you can see, you
- 32:04know, who's commenting for a long period of time.
- 32:06He's repeatedly asking for prices. Have you ever
- 32:09taken that extra step and looked at the buyers,
- 32:12not just the sellers? Or is that kind of taking
- 32:15it a step too far in terms of being able to kind
- 32:20of see impact from the investigation? Yeah, it
- 32:23depends on, um, It's almost a case -by -case
- 32:27scenario. If I get in the sense that the buyer
- 32:29is not just a one -off, but somehow has their
- 32:33own business going on, then it becomes a lot
- 32:36more interesting, obviously. Let's see, I've
- 32:42done some investigations that are still sort
- 32:44of ongoing where the buyers also matter, but
- 32:46I can't talk too much about that. Yeah, I can't
- 32:52say anything else, but it's a case -by -case
- 32:54scenario. Most of the times I leave the buyer,
- 32:58I want to say by the wayside, it's yeah, not
- 33:04the most interesting part of the investigation
- 33:06because the bad side is the supply side in this
- 33:14case, right? So yeah, this is not a very fulfilling
- 33:20answer. I know. Uh, but for me, the, the Stellars
- 33:23and figuring out part of the supply chain, uh,
- 33:26is the most interesting aspect. You're keeping
- 33:30us on tender hooks. I like it. Sumi said something
- 33:34related to this, actually. They've just commented,
- 33:36do these groups have overlap with normal trade
- 33:39groups while doing business with captive exotic
- 33:43animals? Or are they staying closed as possible?
- 33:45What's their general tactic? Do they look for
- 33:47outreach, for example? Are you seeing them outreaching
- 33:50on other kind of... wildlife related groups or
- 33:54is it all happening within these groups? They
- 33:56got enough audience already looking for trade.
- 34:02Yeah, I want to say that, and it really depends
- 34:04on the species. There is a crossover where you
- 34:10have dedicated communities that are sort of open
- 34:18and for example, show themselves as hobbyists,
- 34:24just discussing their favorite wildlife or favorite
- 34:29species. And then you'll find that some people
- 34:33are saying that they have one for sale, but people
- 34:38should reach out to them privately. And I've
- 34:42seen indications where I'll mention this case.
- 34:48It was on MorphMarkets, which is a popular US
- 34:55focused, I think, reptile and snakes sort of
- 35:03great place online, marketplace online. In there
- 35:10was an advert for a Simalia bouleni, which is,
- 35:15it's a snake. If you see the snake, it's a beautiful
- 35:19snake. It has sort of like a rainbow shimmer.
- 35:24But it was sold in the United Kingdom and it
- 35:27was sold as one that is labeled wild cult. So
- 35:32we're talking about like, morph market is like
- 35:35an official business, right? It's not some shady
- 35:37group. dedicated space for all of these hobbyists.
- 35:42So a wild god, Simalia Buleni, which according
- 35:45to the description was sold in the UK. They said
- 35:48it was captive for a number amount of years.
- 35:54And if you know a bit about how this trade is
- 35:58supposed to work, Simalia Buleni, that specific
- 36:01snake, only can be found on Papua New Guinea.
- 36:07I believe in a mountain range. It likes to live
- 36:15and mate quite high above sea level. And in theory,
- 36:20it can only be exported by two countries, Indonesia
- 36:22and Papua New Guinea, due to its endemic sort
- 36:29of like nature in those locations. And because
- 36:33all of this trade is now regulated by CITES,
- 36:37If someone tells me this snake is wild caught
- 36:40and I got it nine years ago, I should be able
- 36:45to go to CITES and see did any of these snakes
- 36:48end up in the country that you say where you're
- 36:51at from those places. And I couldn't find any
- 36:56matching records, which means that either it
- 37:00happened under the books without permits or the
- 37:03seller is lying about it being wild caught, which
- 37:05can also happen. But this is a rare snake, which
- 37:08doesn't breed easily. It takes some effort to
- 37:13do this kind of investigation. I should explain
- 37:16to you, I'm happy to explain to you how you can
- 37:19do this. It's not too difficult, but you do need
- 37:22to go to CITES trade database, fill in the species
- 37:26and the country and the years, and then see,
- 37:29are there any matching permits? And there weren't
- 37:32any. All of this to say, Definitely, and depending
- 37:38on these specific, highly specific species, you'll
- 37:42find that the hobbyist communities also do have
- 37:48some negative influences there from people who
- 37:51are trying to sell them. In those discussion
- 37:54groups, I've also seen some general resistance
- 37:57against regulating the trade. The argument that
- 38:01hobbyists usually put forward is saying, no,
- 38:04we take great care of these animals. We try to
- 38:06breed them and in breeding them, we help stop
- 38:10them from going extinct. Which, you know, if
- 38:17I follow experts advice and they say, no, if
- 38:21you want to stop these animals from going extinct,
- 38:23especially in the wild, you just need to stop
- 38:27these poachers from taking them. And these snakes
- 38:32can go for like $10 ,000 a piece. which, uh,
- 38:36you know, for someone living in these more remote
- 38:39areas, there's an incredible, uh, amounts of
- 38:42money. Um, so yeah, if the question is, are these,
- 38:46these sort of like open legal spaces, uh, to
- 38:50do sometimes interject with the illegal trade,
- 38:52then yeah. I wonder if you could put the link
- 38:55to that site that you mentioned in the chat,
- 38:58because I'm sure people would love to explore
- 39:00that. Just on overlap in terms of communities,
- 39:04a comment earlier when you were talking about
- 39:05the codes and the colloquial nicknames of species,
- 39:09somebody put in the chat that most taxonomists
- 39:13raise some colloquial nicknames of species too.
- 39:16Although these nicknames are not intended for
- 39:18search blending, we're just doing it too because
- 39:21we are lazy. So sometimes there are innocent
- 39:24reasons as to why these terms or these animals
- 39:29are appearing in these spaces, but it's really
- 39:32good to understand the overlap. We had questions
- 39:34earlier talking about what to do if you come
- 39:40across these pages and you're pretty sure that
- 39:44what they're doing is illegal. You've been talking
- 39:50about Indonesia, Malaysia, Dubai. If you don't
- 39:53live in those countries, do you have jurisdiction
- 39:56to report it? How does it work and are the laws
- 40:02different in different countries for this kind
- 40:04of activity? Definitely. So there are always
- 40:09three laws that I try to keep in mind. There's
- 40:12the local laws. There's whatever Facebook's rules
- 40:15or TikTok rules or whatever say. And then once
- 40:19you get a sense that it's international trade,
- 40:21CITES also comes into play. So CITES is the regulatory
- 40:27framework for any international trade for animals.
- 40:32So if you come across something and you want
- 40:36to do more, if you want to investigate, then
- 40:39go through these steps. Facebook, I think in
- 40:43general has a rule against selling or buying
- 40:46animals, which is not really enforced. Then there's
- 40:53like your local laws in the local context, which
- 40:56is tricky because often what happens is that
- 41:02template Dubai, they will have strict regulations,
- 41:06but then they will say, unless you have a permit,
- 41:09unless you have a permit. And then how can you
- 41:12demonstrate that someone has or does not have
- 41:14a permit, right? It's not something that they
- 41:17might post on Facebook. So that's tricky. And
- 41:25so then what I tried to focus on is the animal
- 41:30that we're looking at in any way vulnerable or
- 41:33endangered is the species in decline and is the
- 41:37purpose that they are being sold for. the pet
- 41:41trade, is that contributing? And for me, that's
- 41:46what makes it interesting enough to go after.
- 41:49Okay. Regardless of the local laws. And you'll
- 41:54find that usually if the species is in decline,
- 41:58it should be protected. For example, Indonesia
- 42:05does have laws on this, it's just often a matter
- 42:08of capacity for law enforcement. And yeah, if
- 42:16you really want to make work of it, you can go
- 42:19out there and start or take the link of that
- 42:23post and send it to local wildlife organizations,
- 42:30to authorities, flag it for meta. Or if you're
- 42:35really into open source investigations, do what
- 42:39I do and try to uncover identities and see how
- 42:41far the rabbit hole goes. And then write up an
- 42:44article and send it to us. And then hopefully
- 42:48we can have a larger impact and take down a larger
- 42:52network. I love that you suggested that. And
- 42:56if you do want to pitch an investigation to us,
- 42:59it's submissions at billingcat .com and you can
- 43:01find details. How's the submit? on our website
- 43:04under contact. Or, you know, you can just ping
- 43:08Fuka in here in the environment channel, which
- 43:11I shared earlier in the chat. Sumi says, thanks
- 43:14for that answer. I wondered because I met few
- 43:16regulated cases on open markets like public exchanges
- 43:19with exotic animals. Some doesn't need to be
- 43:21CITES, but also GMO related animals. I have seen
- 43:24that. Note they should be strongly regulated
- 43:27in Europe. The thing is some type of folks craving
- 43:30for anything that's rare and it really supports
- 43:32general will to offer this kind of stock. We
- 43:34had a question earlier about CITES actually,
- 43:37is there recourse available with the domain administrators
- 43:40there? If it's a legitimate focusing marketplace,
- 43:43should there be some form of accountability to
- 43:45remove illegal and despicable content? Yes, there
- 43:54could also be some form of accountability. That's
- 44:01actually a good question, I don't have an answer
- 44:02to that. Maybe a way forward if you notice something.
- 44:07People are also saying public name and shame
- 44:10can be a good tactic, but also noting that it
- 44:14can quickly become hazardous to your health as
- 44:17well. BJ Mack asked earlier, Is Foukesh searching
- 44:23in non -Latin scripts and are the traders more
- 44:26brazen in the languages that content checkers
- 44:29are less familiar with? Yes. I am searching also
- 44:38in non -Latin scripts and I do feel that the
- 44:45posts that we come across, people who have taken
- 44:48some steps to use very local colloquial language
- 44:53or lingo, feel more brazen, more confident to
- 44:58talk openly. So they do consider it a form of
- 45:03privacy to retreat into this sort of non -standard
- 45:08or difficult to track language. Do you think
- 45:12there's things that moderate a platform? platforms,
- 45:17social platforms could do more of. Do you think
- 45:19their moderation systems, for example, the AI
- 45:23moderation tools are capable of capturing this
- 45:25coded language? Or do you think, do you think
- 45:29there's anything more that they could be doing
- 45:31than they're currently doing? Yes, easily. So
- 45:38one of the issues I have with people going out
- 45:41there and flagging and reporting stuff for Meta.
- 45:44is that you're basically doing matters work,
- 45:46right? You're becoming a content moderator for
- 45:49them. And people do this out of a passion and
- 45:51out of an interest to stop illegal wildlife trade.
- 45:55But honestly, with how many billion they spend
- 45:58on the metaverse and are now on AI. If I, as
- 46:04a non -Bahasan Indonesian speaker can recognize
- 46:08that a post is advertising an animal, not just,
- 46:12you know, With the description, but people in
- 46:15the comments, um, people repeatedly posting,
- 46:20uh, this animal, people discussing price. Uh,
- 46:26I can't help but think that, and, uh, uh, a lightweight
- 46:31model, AI model should be able to catch this
- 46:34and flag this. Um, yeah. So I am not letting
- 46:41metal off here. without any blame. I think they
- 46:47can do a lot better. There's your pull quote
- 46:50from this episode. Thanks Sabine, so honest there.
- 46:56And yeah, I think it's interesting, like how
- 46:59prevalent this kind of trade is on these platforms.
- 47:03In regards to that, do you have any idea how...
- 47:07How big, how significant this online trafficking
- 47:10is compared to more traditional trafficking routes
- 47:13today? Have you spoken to any people in the conservation
- 47:19in terms of how the volume of endangered protected
- 47:24species being moved in this way, the impact online
- 47:28trading can have on conservation efforts? Yeah,
- 47:33so I mean, the illegal wildlife trade is one
- 47:36of the biggest sort of prime financial flows
- 47:41on the planet. And because it's also one of the
- 47:48lowest priorities, it feels like sometimes you
- 47:51can not easily post a large photo of, you know,
- 47:56your bags of drugs or a stash of weapons. without
- 48:01it drawing some interest. But animals, even rare
- 48:05species, sure go ahead. And one of the reasons
- 48:11is it's a capacity issue because you need to
- 48:15know a lot about all kinds of species. So for
- 48:18example, I think I mentioned this in the beginning,
- 48:21but even ants can be trafficked, right? Or the
- 48:25eggs of birds or whatever. uh, the paste made
- 48:31out of tigers. Um, and it's, it's tricky because
- 48:36once it, especially if an animal is turned into
- 48:38a different product, like, like tiger paste or
- 48:40tiger wine, um, determining that it actually
- 48:44came from a tiger requires a lot more, uh, effort
- 48:48than, you know, uh, detecting drugs or detecting,
- 48:52uh, weapons. And the same goes for, you know,
- 48:54if you see a photo of this kind of stuff, um,
- 48:58So it's a very, very large illegal financial
- 49:06flow that is taking place. It has a very large
- 49:11online presence. And at the same time, the capacity
- 49:17or sometimes maybe even the interest to completely
- 49:20stop this is very low. So there's a lot of good
- 49:25work to be done for open source investigators
- 49:27in this field. It just takes more people having
- 49:33a look at this kind of stuff. So if you have
- 49:36a particular passion for a particular species,
- 49:39or you want to develop one, maybe you have a
- 49:43love for ants, please go out there and search
- 49:47and see what's going on. That would be great.
- 49:51There's your call to action right there. On that,
- 49:56there's a question in, and by the way, we've
- 49:58only got 10 minutes left, so we've only got time
- 50:01for a few more questions. There was a question
- 50:03just before you said that about, there's always
- 50:06a lot of interest on wildlife trafficking of
- 50:09cute animals. How about the non -cute ones? Would
- 50:12there be less visual evidence about their illegal
- 50:15trade? Do you find that to do the traffickers?
- 50:17really prioritize cute looking animals in their
- 50:20adverts in comparison to the not as cute animals.
- 50:27Yeah, I think so. I mean, they definitely draw
- 50:32more attention. And I think with that, the price
- 50:38also goes up and so the interest in dealing in
- 50:41the animal. So like I said, this Buleni snake,
- 50:44I don't think a lot of people would have taken
- 50:46an interest or the price would be as high if
- 50:49it wasn't gorgeous to look at snake. So that
- 50:55matters. You'll often see that these species
- 51:00that are described as rare, it becomes sort of
- 51:04like a self -fulfilling prophecy where hobbyists
- 51:08call it rare. The price shoots up, poachers think,
- 51:11oh, this is rare, I can sell it for a lot of
- 51:13money. go after that animal, making it even more
- 51:16rare. And yeah, we like to think about these
- 51:24big animals like the elephants and the cheetahs
- 51:26and we should rightfully be concerned. But these
- 51:30smaller species, not smaller species, but the
- 51:36ones that get less interest, we should give them
- 51:38more love as well, because many of them are equally
- 51:43at risk of going extinct. Yeah. No, that's true.
- 51:53Yeah. Like you said. Protect the little guys.
- 51:57Tristan in the comments, who is an old colleague
- 52:00of ours, is putting a really cute ant picture
- 52:03in the chat. Cute being the sarcastic word. Thanks
- 52:09for that. Just to kind of wrap up, obviously
- 52:13if there's a few other questions in and we might
- 52:15be able to squeeze them in, but I wanted to ask
- 52:17this. For many forms, for many people, animal
- 52:21abuse and animal trade investigations can be
- 52:24quite a triggering thing to work on. It's one
- 52:28of those things that often gets listed when you're
- 52:30talking to investigators about the things that
- 52:32they're not comfortable working on. So how do
- 52:35you stay sane when doing this type of investigation?
- 52:38What would be your tips for people who are perhaps
- 52:41thinking about, now you've spoken to us, thinking
- 52:43about delving into this area, how do you keep
- 52:47yourself from going crazy if you're an animal
- 52:50lover yourself? Yeah. So, um, I do, I mean, luckily
- 52:59at Bellacat we, do this in different areas and
- 53:03like it's her daytime job. So we also get support.
- 53:08Um, and I would recommend you if, if someone
- 53:11now has a large passion or an interest to, to
- 53:14take it very easy. Um, some things you can't
- 53:17unsee, especially if you end up with like, um,
- 53:21the places where animals get abused for fun,
- 53:23uh, or animals are easily chopped up into pieces.
- 53:28Um, It can be very, very triggering and you just
- 53:33need to be aware of this before you enter the
- 53:36space like this. So thank you for asking this
- 53:37question. What drives me more is that it does
- 53:43feel like a very sort of important undertaking.
- 53:50So we see these species going in the, in the
- 53:53clown, we see a species going extinct. And you
- 53:57see the direct cause of this in Facebook groups.
- 54:03So on the one hand, you have this sort of like
- 54:08risk that you end up with these horrible images.
- 54:12On the other side, you know what you're doing
- 54:14it for. And it's a very important cause. So for
- 54:20me, that helps me sort of like overcome this
- 54:24kind of imagery. uh, or the stuff that I see,
- 54:28knowing that it's for a good cause and then seeing
- 54:31those, uh, groups taken down or the profile disappear
- 54:35and, um, you know, uh, law enforcement visiting
- 54:41homes or commenting all the people that we identify.
- 54:45Um, yeah, it, it feels like I'm doing my part
- 54:48and that helps, um, more practically. Think about
- 54:53turning off audio is always a good idea. Grayscaling
- 54:59your screen if you suspect you're going to see
- 55:03something unpleasant also helps. And taking a
- 55:07lot of good breaks and talking with people about
- 55:10what you're doing. Yeah, we have great articles
- 55:15also on trauma help for those who are dealing
- 55:22with this kind of stuff or think they might encounter
- 55:24this stuff. I highly recommend reading that as
- 55:28well. Yeah, I'm sure one of our mods can helpfully
- 55:31drop our usual article in the chat. Someone's
- 55:36also just put, never watch anything in full screen
- 55:38is also a great tip. We need to wrap up in a
- 55:41second, but I also wanted to ask very quickly
- 55:43because this is a subject that many people don't...
- 55:46cover very often. Is there any particular organizations
- 55:50that you like to share your work with once it's
- 55:53published for impact? Are there any organizations
- 55:56that like to kind of echo these kinds of investigations
- 56:00that you might want to shout out for people to
- 56:02look at maybe as a good resource or to also kind
- 56:06of send their work to just to amplify it a little
- 56:09bit further. So obviously Mongabay, I'm so glad
- 56:13we're happy with it. I'm so happy and glad that
- 56:16we're in touch with them. They do great work
- 56:19on a lot of areas and because they're in so many
- 56:23places, they can almost provide the local context,
- 56:26which so often gets overlooked, but can be very
- 56:30important for an investigation. The International
- 56:34Fund for Animal Welfare, I'm a fan of those.
- 56:37Oh, there's so many organizations. Yeah. the
- 56:44Environmental Investigative Agency, EIA, Graphic.
- 56:52They all do great work in this space. And if
- 56:55you want to get a feel of where to get started
- 56:58or just take an interest in this kind of work,
- 57:01read up on them as well. Amazing tips. And if
- 57:07you don't mind just writing them again in the
- 57:09chat for anybody who is... here and maybe English
- 57:13isn't their first language, that would be super
- 57:15useful. Thank you so much, Fuka, for today. It's
- 57:19been fascinating, not only learning about the
- 57:23amazing work that you've done in this space,
- 57:27but also kind of the tips and tricks as you go
- 57:30along. You're so good at explaining investigation.
- 57:34processes. So that was really great. I know that
- 57:37Tristan earlier may have shared the bookmarklets
- 57:41tip that you gave. So hopefully people have that
- 57:46as well. But yes, if you want to... Stay in contact
- 57:52on this subject. We mentioned earlier, if you
- 57:54want to pitch to Bellingcat, you can via submissions
- 57:57at bellingcat .com, or you can chat about this
- 58:01subject in hashtag environment and wildlife in
- 58:05this very Discord server. And I'll make sure
- 58:07that the links to everything that we've talked
- 58:08about are in the description of this podcast.
- 58:11But for now, thank you so much, Fuca, for your
- 58:14time. Have a beautiful weekend, people. Make
- 58:17sure that you take a break after this very heavy
- 58:21talk. And I will see you in two weeks' time for
- 58:24another stage talk. All right, cool. Thank you,
- 58:28everybody. Thank you for listening to the stage
- 58:32talk. If you'd like to catch a stage talk live...
- 58:35where you can ask the guest questions, join the
- 58:38Bellingcat Discord server by visiting www .discord
- 58:43.gg slash Bellingcat. The music you've heard
- 58:47is titled Dawn by Newer Self and is courtesy
- 58:51of Artlist.