Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP278: Optimising Ecommerce Returns & Exchanges, with Oh Polly Customer Journey Manager Emily Mcmorran & Loop's Senior Product Marketing Manager Samir Kamnani
Transcript
- 0:00We have a rewards program and for our UK rewards program, our
- 0:04Gold and Platinum tiers, which are the top 2 tiers of A4 tier
- 0:08program, receive unlimited next day delivery.
- 0:11And we've extended that recently to their exchanges as well.
- 0:16So they're free anyway for all UK customers to exchange, but it
- 0:20means that they're still receiving their next day
- 0:23delivery on their exchanges too. You listen to Inside Commerce, a
- 0:27weekly ecom strategy, technology and CX focus podcast hosted by
- 0:30experienced digital consultants and re platform specialist James
- 0:33Get and Paul Rogers. Get insights into ecom strategy,
- 0:35leading brands, hear from industry thought leaders and
- 0:38leading tech vendors with practical advice to help you
- 0:40improve your online CX. Hello and welcome to the Inside
- 0:44Commerce podcast sponsored by Shopify.
- 0:47Today's episode or for today's episode, we're joined by Samir
- 0:51from Loot and Emily from Opoly. And we're going to talk a little
- 0:54bit around, well, return strategy in general, but also
- 0:58paid returns and how Opoly have implemented paid returns and
- 1:02some of the impact. And then also how Opoly using
- 1:06some of the other new features within the Loop platform.
- 1:09So maybe just to get us started, Emily, do you mind starting us
- 1:12off with a bit of an introduction and then we'll ask
- 1:14you to do the same Submit. Yeah, of course.
- 1:17So I'm Emily. I'm the Customer Experience Lead
- 1:20at Opoly. I've been in customer experience
- 1:22for the past four years and in the company for six.
- 1:26And I help look at the customer's end to end journey,
- 1:30all the different touch points and gather customer feedback
- 1:33through and essentially work on delivery returns and the on site
- 1:39experience. They're the main three touch
- 1:41points that I kind of look at. So returns being a major part of
- 1:46customer journeys, hence why I'm here today to chat about
- 1:50returns. Perfect.
- 1:52And then Samir. Yeah.
- 1:54Hi. I'm Samir.
- 1:55I'm from Loop. I'm on our product marketing
- 1:58team. I'm based in the States, but
- 2:00work with a lot of our Loops UK based team as well as our
- 2:05merchants there. And yeah, really excited to chat
- 2:09with you all today about returns.
- 2:10If you aren't familiar with Loop Returns, just a quick
- 2:13background. We're a returns and exchange
- 2:16platform for Shopify brands. And so Shopify is invested in US
- 2:21and was a part of our Series B. And so we kind of like to see
- 2:25ourselves as that premier returns partner for Shopify
- 2:28brands. And our claim to fame was really
- 2:30going hard at exchanges and kind of pushing that a return doesn't
- 2:35have to mean a refund. And a return could be something
- 2:38you see as an opportunity in the customer journey as opposed to,
- 2:41you know, a headache, which is what most people see returns as.
- 2:45Perfect. And yeah, I should thank you and
- 2:47Emily as well for perseverance that this episode, we started
- 2:50back now about 3 months ago and my lack of organization has
- 2:55meant that we're in 2025 recording it.
- 2:58But we got there in the end. And then first question.
- 3:01So this is for you, Samir. So I think everyone at least
- 3:042024 was the year of paid returns.
- 3:07So there was a lot of discussion in the industry and the
- 3:09ecosystem around this area and a lot of big brands move towards
- 3:14charging for returns. Can you talk us through how this
- 3:18impacted loop and what you saw across the industry?
- 3:22Definitely, Yeah, it's something we we're noticing as well
- 3:26towards the start of 2024. I believe now in at this stage
- 3:32over 60% of loop merchants are charging for a return in some
- 3:36way. And that's about a 45% increase
- 3:39from if we go back to the pandemic, I think when everyone
- 3:43was optimizing for everything should be convenient and free
- 3:46and make it as easy as possible. And so it's definitely been a
- 3:50shift in the market. And I think it's obviously
- 3:52because operating costs are so high, you know, shipping is
- 3:56expensive, warehousing costs are expensive.
- 3:59And I think shoppers are getting a bit more savvy about returns
- 4:04as well. We're seeing the rise of
- 4:06practices like bracketing and wardrobing where you will order
- 4:11a bunch of things or order a couple of the same item in
- 4:14different sizes knowing you're going to return them or you plan
- 4:18to wear something for a night out and see if you can return it
- 4:20after. Things like that are on the rise
- 4:23and shoppers are unfortunately abusing some of those return
- 4:27policies. And so it's making operating
- 4:30costs high and that kind of brought about I think the more
- 4:34popularity of return fees. I think we've seen, you know,
- 4:37really big brands embrace this like Zara a few years ago, I
- 4:43know a sauce this past year and that was a big like, oh, if
- 4:46they're doing it, then maybe we should be doing it for a lot of
- 4:49brands. And so, yeah, it's definitely
- 4:51something we've been seeing grow and how that's changed Loops
- 4:56strategy in terms of our product is it kind of gave us the signal
- 5:01to maybe lean a little bit more into that.
- 5:04So if six months ago we were talking, we have a fee structure
- 5:09that you can coordinate based on the outcome of the return.
- 5:13So what we would recommend to a lot of brands is, hey, give a
- 5:18free exchange but charge for a refund.
- 5:21So you're trying to push a shopper to that desired
- 5:24experience of an exchange instead.
- 5:27But we were hearing from a lot of our brands that they wanted
- 5:31to kind of leverage this concept of return fees even more.
- 5:34And so that led us to a new product recently called Offset.
- 5:39I don't know if you want me to get into that right now, Paul,
- 5:42but basically just different way of charging fees that we can
- 5:45touch on. We've got a question on that
- 5:47later on, so let's leave that one.
- 5:49Paul, so many questions, so little time on returns.
- 5:55Yeah, they this is really interesting.
- 5:56We did it, we did a pod where we touched upon it last year about
- 6:00what fair usage means. So it's interesting to hear
- 6:02where you're seeing the driver for this.
- 6:04So question related to that is we know that people are lots of
- 6:07retailers are charging for returns, but they're starting to
- 6:10think about what what fair usage means and when it's valid to
- 6:14charge and when you shouldn't because you don't want to
- 6:15alienate customers. I guess we can then come come
- 6:18back to you after Zemly on the on the brand perspective on this
- 6:21is so Samir from your point of view work with those merchants.
- 6:24How have you seen an impact there that people's metrics site
- 6:28particularly on on new customers?
- 6:29One of the big concerns is we're just going to put new customers
- 6:32off because they they perceive this as a barrier to purchase.
- 6:35Definitely. It's definitely something of
- 6:37concern. I think when you go from not
- 6:41charging for returns to then trying to implement that
- 6:44strategy. It's something that, you know,
- 6:47shoppers might be surprised by the first time they see it might
- 6:50have a little bit of negative feedback.
- 6:52But we have seen that the overall impact of a brand doing
- 6:56this is little to none. We saw that the return rates
- 7:01remain stable for brands who previously were doing free
- 7:05return policies and then implemented a fee.
- 7:08And then we also saw that their repeat purchase rates remain
- 7:12stable as well. So I think it's expected to
- 7:15maybe get a little bit of negative feedback from customers
- 7:20initially. But then the overall impact of
- 7:23that is it's not really affecting the rate of the return
- 7:26or the rate of those customers coming back to you.
- 7:30And I think we've also seen that customers are becoming more
- 7:34willing and aware of return fees.
- 7:37I think as they become popular with merchants, we're also
- 7:40seeing more customers admitting that they have already paid a
- 7:44return fee or they're willing to pay a return fee.
- 7:47And that usually comes with a good return experience.
- 7:50So if you're making it easy for the customer, if you have a good
- 7:55drop off experience, things like that, then they're more willing
- 7:58to pay for that return as opposed to if you're making it,
- 8:01you know, a headache for the customer as well, then they're
- 8:03going to be really upset about needing to pay.
- 8:06Emily, you've moved to charge him for returns and this may not
- 8:10fall under your agreement, but I guess as a business, what level
- 8:14of impact have you seen from AI guess new customer, but also
- 8:18customers in general or in terms of, as James says, the kind of
- 8:22trade impact and customer perception?
- 8:25Yeah. So I mean, we've had return fees
- 8:28in place for our international customers for for quite some
- 8:31time now, I think since we had a specific portal for them to go
- 8:37to and return. But in terms of UK return fees,
- 8:42I think we introduced fees around three years ago.
- 8:45We've kind of iterated on that since we introduced them.
- 8:52And I think the impact honestly what what we've learned is to
- 8:56just keep it simple for the customers, simple flat fee, keep
- 9:01it fair, keep the return policy as straightforward as possible.
- 9:05And in doing that, then the kind of feedback that we have from
- 9:11customers and kind of the reaction of based off that, that
- 9:16decision isn't as bad as you've if you were to make like quite a
- 9:19big bold change overnight. And like you said, Samir, like
- 9:23you touched on how customers are more accustomed to their
- 9:29favorite brands and are now in store and online charging fees
- 9:34such as Zara and I mentioned, which like you said, a lot of
- 9:37brands have kind of followed suit from that.
- 9:39So I think it's it's almost an expected part of the return
- 9:43journey now, especially coming into into this year.
- 9:48I know last year there are a lot of changes that took place in E
- 9:53com. So I think, yeah, I think
- 9:56customer is definitely more accustomed to it and it's
- 10:01something that we've we've it's definitely been a learning curve
- 10:03for us. So and also since we've
- 10:07introduced things like store credit and exchanges for our UK
- 10:11customers, we are able to keep those return methods 3 free to
- 10:15obviously move the needle and customers option for those
- 10:18return outcomes over refund. So we currently only charge for
- 10:23a refund for a return fee if it's AUK refund.
- 10:28And then international fees have remained somewhat the same.
- 10:32But then we've also been able to offer cheaper return methods
- 10:36with store credit as well. So although we're charging for
- 10:39fees for returns, we've been able to kind of play around with
- 10:44the different outcomes and offer some benefits elsewhere so that
- 10:49they're still able to exchange and offer store credit at a
- 10:52reasonable rate as well. What do Mattel, Victoria,
- 10:58Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier all have in common?
- 11:03They power their businesses with Shopify.
- 11:07Shopify is the most innovative and scaled commerce platform on
- 11:10the planet. It also happens to have the best
- 11:14converting check out on the planet.
- 11:17Shopify powering the future of enterprise commerce.
- 11:21Find out more at shopify.com/enterprise.
- 11:25Great. And it didn't to Samir's point
- 11:28earlier, I do think that having that charge in place will also
- 11:33increase the likelihood of someone exchanging as you say.
- 11:37And I've done that behaviour from my fiance who is a Siri or
- 11:41she's a bad customer of isolation.
- 11:43But and so one quick sub question.
- 11:48So currently, do you have a blanket rule around charging for
- 11:52returns or do you, for example, like more loyal customers or
- 11:56even returning customers, do you treat that differently?
- 12:00Yeah. So we offer for new customers
- 12:04their first return free mostly so that they can kind of gauge
- 12:07our sizing and and things like that.
- 12:12And then we also we have a rewards programme and for our UK
- 12:17rewards programme and our Golden Platinum tiers, which are the
- 12:21top 2 tiers of A4 tier programme receive unlimited next day
- 12:26delivery. And we've extended that recently
- 12:29to their exchanges as well. So they're free anyway for all
- 12:35UK customers to exchange, but it means that they're still
- 12:38receiving their next day delivery on their exchanges too.
- 12:43So we have that in place. And as I mentioned the first
- 12:47return free. But we've steered away from
- 12:52offering the the customers in the higher tiers of our rewards
- 12:56program and free refund returns because they do have the
- 13:01unlimited next day. And the type of behaviour that
- 13:04we want to hopefully try and avoid from a sustainability
- 13:06point of view as well, but was also from a business perspective
- 13:11is ordering lots of things on next day delivery and then just
- 13:15returning them all. We want to try and avoid that
- 13:18type of behaviour but whilst also being able to offer some
- 13:22benefit for the loyal customers in those tiers as well.
- 13:29Question I've got for you, Emily, because your role is
- 13:32broader, obviously much broader and returns.
- 13:34Returns is a subset of a wider customer experience strategy.
- 13:38And the things that, that, that, that I speak to a lot of
- 13:41businesses about is a historically and, and I think in
- 13:45most businesses, returns are seen as like a policy and a need
- 13:47and what we've got to do. And it's a cost.
- 13:50And when something's a policy and a cost, you don't invest in
- 13:53it. You just try and handle it and,
- 13:54and mitigate cost. When you flip the switch on that
- 13:57and go actually, this is part of customer experience.
- 14:00This is a service. Services get treated differently
- 14:04and they get invested in and they get prioritised and you
- 14:06think about how you deliver them.
- 14:08I'd love to know, like what was the old Poly lenses?
- 14:10How do, what advice can you give to people about how you can get
- 14:14people to think about returns more strategically in a business
- 14:17so that they don't end up just going right?
- 14:19We need to minimise cost and we just need to have a functional
- 14:21service. Yeah.
- 14:23I mean, obviously I'm always customer fair.
- 14:26So the main thing is to gather customer feedback.
- 14:29So we we run focus groups on certain topics, returns
- 14:33obviously being one of them. I think it's key to gather
- 14:37customer feedback before you make decisions and not just
- 14:42after the fact as well so that you can hear your customers out.
- 14:46Obviously in an ideal world, everyone's going to say, yeah, I
- 14:49want free returns, but it doesn't work.
- 14:54We know it doesn't work for an e-commerce business.
- 14:58So I think it's really like understanding the customer
- 15:01feedback, taking that on board, feeding that back to all the
- 15:05relevant departments. So as part of my role, I run the
- 15:08voice of the customer program. And so each month we'll have a
- 15:12meeting with key stakeholders and kind of like the decision
- 15:18makers from from each department and we'll go through the
- 15:22feedback and come up with like a bit of an action plan from it.
- 15:26So, so I think we're, we're fairly decent in a, in as a
- 15:31company in terms of looking at that feedback and, and actually
- 15:34action and things off the back of that.
- 15:36I think the worst thing you can do is get customer feedback and
- 15:40not actually let anyone like feed that back to the relevant
- 15:44people and do anything from it. Just have it stored like, you
- 15:47know, what's what's the point? So I think trying to encourage
- 15:52that customer centric mindset and so that when we all looking
- 15:56at things like, you know, when I'm having meetings with finance
- 15:59about the numbers and OK, well how can we, you know, reduce
- 16:03returns and this and that. I think it's good to have the
- 16:06quantitative data, but also the qualitative data and think about
- 16:11the impact on brand reputation as well and brand image.
- 16:16So yeah, it's sometimes it can be a battle to kind of like
- 16:19what's best for the business, but ultimately the customers are
- 16:23the business. So it's it's about weighing
- 16:26those things up and then trying to come to like a happy medium
- 16:30where the customers aren't going to be annoyed with new policies
- 16:33that are coming into play. But then they were also trying
- 16:35to move the needle with reducing refunds and trying to be
- 16:40strategic about things as well. It's a balance, yeah.
- 16:45Yeah, that makes sense. And I just want one quick
- 16:48question actually before I move on to the next one.
- 16:50How do you collect that feedback as well on is it?
- 16:53Is it something that you send as part of a loop return or do you
- 16:56have like end to end NPS? Yeah.
- 17:00So we we look at NPS of course in surveys.
- 17:06So we have surveys and different touch points of the customer
- 17:09journey. So we have on site feedback
- 17:15after the customers place their order, after the customer the
- 17:20order's been delivered and then after any return or exchanges
- 17:24being processed. So we have it at the various
- 17:27different torch points. We track return MPs versus, you
- 17:31know, online UXMPS and, and all those various things.
- 17:34So and that's our main kind of stream of feedback that we get
- 17:38through and analyse and, and set actions off the back of.
- 17:43But then we we also look at things like Trustpilot, super
- 17:49keen on our trust score and try to tackle any issues that come
- 17:53off the back of that. And then I have obviously worked
- 17:56really closely with customer service as well at the tickets
- 17:59coming through and making sure that we're tagging them and
- 18:02understanding the different like the common topics that are
- 18:06coming up if they are to do with returns.
- 18:11Yeah, so that they're kind of the main streams of feedback
- 18:14that we receive. And then as I mentioned, focus
- 18:17groups, definitely want to run more focus groups this year as
- 18:19well because it's completely different having that open
- 18:22dialogue as well with customers and getting more information
- 18:27from them, loyal customers, trying to incentivize for, you
- 18:30know, maybe the first time customers are lost customers as
- 18:34well. So really trying to understand
- 18:38different perspectives as well, and not just from 1 customer
- 18:41group that are replying to this to the surveys that we're
- 18:45sending out. And then we're also looking at
- 18:49new ways to gather feedback this year because I do think that
- 18:52sometimes surveys can become a bit stagnant and customers don't
- 18:57always want to complete that sort of traditional method of
- 19:00leaving feedback. So we're also going to look at
- 19:02things like voice and video feedback and how we can kind of
- 19:06use that and analyze that. That's great.
- 19:09Yeah, I think it's, it's really cool that oh, probably I've got
- 19:11your role in the business actually, you don't see it with
- 19:14too many brands, like there's obviously different departments
- 19:17or collate feedback and analyse. I think having that person in
- 19:22that role is a really good way to like build the kind of
- 19:25championing of these areas. And so now coming back to you
- 19:28Samir, because I realise we haven't spoken to you for a
- 19:30little while, which isn't intentional.
- 19:33So you've recently introduced offset or the ability to offset
- 19:36returns that is part of the purchase journey.
- 19:39Can you talk us through what this is and how it?
- 19:42Works. Yeah, definitely.
- 19:44So kind of off the back of the trends we were seeing of, you
- 19:48know, brands adopting return fees so much, consumers being
- 19:52more, like Emily was saying, more of an expectation that, you
- 19:56know, that's something you'll probably have and just being
- 20:00more willing to pay. What we saw kind of picking up a
- 20:03little steam in mainly in the US market was this concept of
- 20:09returns coverage or almost like like shipping insurance or trip
- 20:13insurance of when you're going to actually place your order,
- 20:17paying a smaller fee to ensure a free return later.
- 20:23So for example, if a brand has a 10 LB return fee, maybe you give
- 20:30the option of only paying 2 lbs at checkout and then you don't
- 20:34have that fee later if you do return.
- 20:37And So what we see is this is really kind of a win win for all
- 20:41parties. I think for the brand, it's a
- 20:44way of getting a little bit of extra money to cover your
- 20:49operating costs upfront as opposed to only at the time of
- 20:53the return. And ideally you have more people
- 20:56paying this small fee then are actually returning because they
- 21:00want that Peace of Mind and hopefully they'll like their
- 21:03item and they don't need to return.
- 21:05But it does give that assurance. And then for the customer, I
- 21:09think exactly what I was just mentioning of kind of gives that
- 21:13Peace of Mind of especially if you're shopping with the new
- 21:16brand, you know, trying it for the first time or you don't know
- 21:18your size or maybe they dropped a new collection and you want to
- 21:21try that out. Things like that kind of gives
- 21:24you that Peace of Mind of knowing, OK, I can try this item
- 21:28and if I don't like it, I have that option of a free return
- 21:31later. They can still return even if
- 21:33they didn't pay that small fee upfront.
- 21:35But then they will be more on the hook for, you know, the
- 21:39label cost or the, the larger return fee.
- 21:42And it kind of, I think it also educates the shopper a bit more
- 21:46of knowing like, hey, you're being transparent upfront of
- 21:50hey, if you don't pay the small fee, there will be a return fee.
- 21:53You know, it's for restocking for and we even mentioned the
- 21:57sustainability aspect. I think consumers are more aware
- 22:00of that as well. And so kind of educating them a
- 22:03bit on, you know, returning isn't a desired outcome, but it
- 22:08is still something you're able to do and we're making it easier
- 22:10for you to do that. Interesting.
- 22:14And I guess Emily, then let's take the the the merchant lens
- 22:18on this. Have you, you know, if you put
- 22:21this in what take up have you seen and what impact?
- 22:23And I guess a sub question for me would be one of the key
- 22:26things we're all trying to achieve in this industry, right,
- 22:28is fair usage and we're trying to reward customers for good
- 22:32behaviour, but also stop people taking advantage and adding
- 22:35crippling cost to, to to retailers so they can't service
- 22:37the good customers. If I'm a bad customer, I'll
- 22:41probably look at this and go, oh, do you know what?
- 22:42I'll pay the £2 and I'll just send everything back and I won't
- 22:44have to pay 10 lbs. So I'd love to know where you
- 22:47where you see it as a merchant and what what you're seeing from
- 22:49a customer behaviour. Yeah.
- 22:52So we, we haven't added offset to our return journey at the
- 22:57moment, but I think it's a really interesting thing and
- 23:00I've it's obviously very new. I've never seen this, never seen
- 23:03any of the companies kind of had this before for returns.
- 23:07So I would be really interested to see what the uptake and the
- 23:11results are across other brands who are currently using offset
- 23:17because have it having it being like a new thing.
- 23:21I wouldn't, I wouldn't know even how customers would kind of take
- 23:24that and also the different markets as well.
- 23:26Like I don't know whether it's something that would be more
- 23:31popular in certain regions like in the UK versus the US or vice
- 23:35versa. So I think it'll be really
- 23:38interesting if you do have any data system here and maybe not
- 23:42right now, but at some point, if you can share that with me, that
- 23:44would be really interesting to see the uptake.
- 23:47I think from a customer experience point of view or from
- 23:55just from a customer perspective.
- 23:56Like I agree with you there, James, like the, the, you know,
- 23:59the barge, however, we're kind of passing the barge customer
- 24:02might see that and think, oh, great, I'll get a cheaper
- 24:05return, especially if it's something like they've done it
- 24:08once and then they go, OK, well, it's, it's always going to be
- 24:10cheaper. I'll do it again.
- 24:11But then again, I know that loop are quite good with how you can
- 24:16tweak your policies with work flows as well to kind of prevent
- 24:19abuse of certain features like like that They can do that with
- 24:24various other things in the like like bonuses, store credit or
- 24:28exchanges, things like that. So I'm guessing potentially
- 24:32there would be a way to kind of combat abuse of of that
- 24:36potentially. And then, yeah, from a business
- 24:41perspective, I guess it's, it's kind of that extra stream of
- 24:47money that you have from, from the upfront fee.
- 24:52I would be interested to see how customers who who don't then
- 24:55return if they would ever get in touch and say, oh, I didn't
- 24:59return. Can I have that refunded?
- 25:01Which is besides the point because I guess it's it's a
- 25:03service or kind of A and insurance almost, I suppose.
- 25:08Also, I don't know if it's in classes and insurance or a
- 25:11service, but it would be interesting.
- 25:14I feel like it depends on what type of customers the brand has
- 25:19as well and how, how they would react, how demanding they are
- 25:23and kind of what they would expect.
- 25:25So yeah, I'd be interested to hear the customer feedback as
- 25:28well, if that's if that's something that the brands are
- 25:30gathering from the service for customers who are using it and
- 25:33opting for it. Definitely, yeah, I know it's a,
- 25:37it's a relatively new concept and I think to your point, even
- 25:42more new in the UK than in the USI think it's something we're
- 25:47seeing slowly pick up and gain more traction.
- 25:51And definitely the customer feedback I think so far has been
- 25:54very positive and we've been making sure this doesn't, you
- 25:57know, affect the brand's return rate or make shoppers more kind
- 26:02of potentially abusive. And so very much monitoring how
- 26:06it plays with all of those things.
- 26:09And like you were mentioning with the workflows, you can
- 26:13still use all the different customization tools within loop.
- 26:18So like Emily was saying about doing free exchanges still, but
- 26:22charging for refunds or giving a first time customer a free
- 26:26return anyways, regardless, all those things are still options
- 26:31that a brand can choose to do. So we kind of see this as just
- 26:36another way of charging for returns depending on what the
- 26:41brand needs. You know, if you're a brand with
- 26:44a really high return rate or you know, you have common sizing
- 26:48issues and people are constantly, you know, worried
- 26:51about getting the wrong size, things like that, then giving
- 26:55that assurance upfront is maybe a strategy to explore.
- 27:00And like Emily was saying as well, maybe even try out in AUS
- 27:04market at first, then see how it goes, bring to a different
- 27:07market, but definitely a lot of different levers that you can
- 27:11do. We're seeing strong uptake on
- 27:14this right now because how the model currently works is it's
- 27:20something that is set as default on in the checkout experience.
- 27:24So it's something that is on already and the customer would
- 27:27remove from their basket if they don't want it.
- 27:31But if you heard from Shopify earlier this year, Shopify
- 27:37announced I think it was maybe in December or early January
- 27:40that all kind of upsell type add on in car or check out are
- 27:47having to move to a default off state.
- 27:49So like any sort of shipping insurance or if you use a maybe
- 27:53like a sustainability upsell or anything like that and including
- 27:57this offset returns coverage model, all that will be moving
- 28:00to a default off state. So the uptake right now we're
- 28:05seeing is strong, but once that change goes into effect, we're
- 28:08sure the the uptake is going to change a little bit.
- 28:11So I don't want to give any like concrete numbers, but we're
- 28:14monitoring that and I think we're still very confident in
- 28:18the value that this service provides again both to the brand
- 28:21and to the consumer. And so we're very still feel
- 28:24very strongly about it. Right, and then go back to you,
- 28:28Emily. So I've I chat to Lauren semi
- 28:32regularly and we we briefly worked together, I think it was
- 28:35last year maybe the info and I know the return is a big focus
- 28:40for O Poly is a business as it is with most fashion brands,
- 28:43even more so kind of lower price point fashion brands.
- 28:48So can you just talk us through what else you have planned for
- 28:492025 and also maybe how that differs by market?
- 28:53You talked a little bit around kind of nuance and consumer
- 28:55expectations by market. Yeah, definitely.
- 28:59So I think we, we currently offer labels to I think around
- 29:05like 33 countries because we ship internationally.
- 29:11So we, we want to try and expand that list to have fewer
- 29:15countries who are having to like essentially like South Post at
- 29:18the post office, whatever, with much higher fees.
- 29:22So we want to be able to service those customers and provide
- 29:24labels just for ease of ease of customer experience, to be
- 29:29honest. And then that way we can
- 29:33obviously avoid them having to pay higher fees themselves and
- 29:37we can also provide them with a quicker return outcome.
- 29:41So for the international lanes that we do offer labels for,
- 29:45we're able to do things like trigger their outcome in transit
- 29:49or drop off. So we want to be able to provide
- 29:53that to as many countries as possible just for a better
- 29:56experience. We are also hoping to
- 30:01potentially expand looking at third party logistics in
- 30:06different countries, again to offer that quicker, quicker turn
- 30:10around, quicker refund time frame and quicker processing for
- 30:15us as well. So we already have this in
- 30:20Australia and the US, so customers can return
- 30:24domestically and it also means that we can reduce their fees as
- 30:29well, which ultimately customer experience like that's what I
- 30:32want to do. I want to make the customer
- 30:33happy, reduce fees where we can. And so it will be beneficial
- 30:38operationally as well As for the customer's experience.
- 30:43And then I think also from like a business perspective looking
- 30:47at utilizing more of loops features to kind of optimize
- 30:52store credit and exchange rates over refund and encouraging
- 30:59customers to to opt for those return outcomes.
- 31:03I think that the overall aim as it is every year is to reduce
- 31:08returns, right? I think that this past year,
- 31:12although the returns which I think Samir kind of mentioned is
- 31:17across the board with brands at the moment that he's working
- 31:20with, I think although the returns rate overall hasn't
- 31:26really reduced, it's kind of stayed the same.
- 31:29Our refund rate has reduced and our store credit rate has
- 31:33increased and that's just from iterations like tweak and return
- 31:37policies offering incentives for for store credit and exchanges.
- 31:44So I guess really just again focusing on that, what else we
- 31:49can do. So yeah, bit of everything
- 31:54really, but reduced return rates where we can whilst improving
- 32:00the return time frames and customer experience.
- 32:03One of the key areas is always going to be difficult for for
- 32:07selling clothing online is size fit, getting a real feel for the
- 32:13the product quality and the material.
- 32:14Because it doesn't, let's face it, we all know it.
- 32:16It doesn't matter how good our product data is or or which
- 32:19third party towards you like a true fit or whatever it might be
- 32:22to to get size in, there's always a margin of error.
- 32:24So I'd love to know how you use returns data to help you
- 32:31identify issues. And because I know you said like
- 32:34you'd play back customer data, how do you use a business like
- 32:37take that returns data to look at whether it might be a product
- 32:40issue or a quality issue or or something, or it might just be a
- 32:44data issue where you didn't need to put better information onto
- 32:46the website. Yeah.
- 32:48So we obviously we have our parent and child reasons in
- 32:55returns which are able to customise to cater to our
- 32:59different collections. It can be product specific as
- 33:02well and kind of common return reasons that we see.
- 33:06And we also have open text fields for certain return
- 33:12reasons to kind of gain additional feedback from the
- 33:14customers, obviously optional. And then our QC team will look
- 33:20at these week reports. They can do it by various
- 33:23things, by SKU, by varying by specific collections sizes,
- 33:29etcetera, all within the loop dashboard.
- 33:32And then they can use that data monthly to kind of draw any key
- 33:37issues or patterns that they're seeing with particular garments
- 33:41and popular return reasons for that garment, whether it's
- 33:45quality or too big, too small. And then they feed that back to
- 33:50the design and product teams. So we've got that kind of
- 33:54process in place looking at customer feedback in in the
- 33:58return data and their return reasons.
- 34:02And then kind of to help support that.
- 34:05We also look at things like our product reviews as well.
- 34:09And then we kind of use a combination of the return
- 34:13reasons and loop and the product reviews to gather the the fit.
- 34:18So like we have a true to fit sort of slider on the product
- 34:21page where for like, you know, oversized, too small, just right
- 34:26kind of thing to help customers make that decision because
- 34:29you're right, like one of the hardest things and it's
- 34:32different brand by brand is sizing and, and trying to get
- 34:35that right on your order. And we want to, where possible,
- 34:40avoid customers ordering multiple sizes and then just
- 34:43returning off any of that don't fit.
- 34:45So yeah, I think loop definitely helps with looking at that side
- 34:50of the feedback. And we do try to update our
- 34:52product pages with as much information as possible on
- 34:57sizing fit, things like if the products share even like if the
- 35:05lighting is different in certain light photo shoots that we do.
- 35:08So the product might have a slightly different colour.
- 35:11We tried to be as transparent as possible on the product pages to
- 35:16to reduce returns. And then we we also have the
- 35:19likes of true fit to help to helplessness with their size and
- 35:22as well. Great.
- 35:27And then coming back to you again, Samir, so Loop are
- 35:31obviously, you know a market leader in the return space.
- 35:35I know you've got some really big merchants in North America
- 35:37and also the UK amongst those merchants.
- 35:41And I guess also generally within your road map, what are
- 35:44the big trends that you're seeing around returns going into
- 35:472025? Definitely, I think specific to
- 35:53the UK market, we're seeing more brands lean into exchanges and
- 35:58seeing returns as an opportunity.
- 36:01I think what a lot of brands mindset was maybe a year ago,
- 36:06two years ago was returns as just, you know, kind of we were
- 36:11talking about earlier like a necessary evil, like you just
- 36:13have to do it. And so Emily, I know even like a
- 36:17Polly before coming to Loop a few years ago, we're servicing
- 36:22refunds, but not servicing kind of self-serve exchanges online.
- 36:27And I think that's something we've seen more brands look to
- 36:31do going into this year. And so it really creates that
- 36:35opportunity within the returns flow of you're not you're
- 36:40opening that door to retain the revenue and keep it within your
- 36:45business as opposed to just, you know, getting the return done,
- 36:48getting rid of the support ticket and offering the refund.
- 36:52You create that nice touch point in the customer journey that
- 36:55almost makes it feel like shopping again.
- 36:58And so the impact of that is only a benefit of especially if
- 37:04you're a brand that is currently only offering refunds by opening
- 37:09that door again, there's only upside to that of keeping that
- 37:12money within your business. And I know it's been really
- 37:15impactful for O Polly so far as well.
- 37:21I think other than that, the other big trend that we're
- 37:25seeing is kind of similar to the topic of we've been talking
- 37:28about, of part of why return fees has become a big thing is
- 37:33because of, you know, policy abuse.
- 37:36And shoppers may be taking advantage of return policies a
- 37:39bit more and, you know, doing practices like ordering a bunch
- 37:43of items in a different sizes and then knowing you're going to
- 37:46return. And so we have built a machine
- 37:50learning AI model to kind of proactively identify potentially
- 37:55fraudulent returners or return abusers.
- 37:58And we can give that information to brands to help them fine tune
- 38:02their return policies and kind of, again, maybe play some
- 38:07strategic guardrails around shoppers that are doing
- 38:10practices like that, but keep the experience really seamless
- 38:14and convenient for your good shoppers that you know are not
- 38:18taking advantage of your policies.
- 38:20I would say those are the two big trends.
- 38:22It's, it's a real sensitive balance in that, isn't it?
- 38:25Because it's hard, because as a brand, you've got to be
- 38:28commercially viable, otherwise you can't service your
- 38:30customers, which means you have to manage costs sensibly.
- 38:33But managing costs means making tough decisions.
- 38:35And I guess Emily, there's I kind of got a final question.
- 38:38It's quite, quite a wordy 1, but it's, it's about the if you go
- 38:41down, if you keep your eyes on a fair uses policy, you're going
- 38:45to have to make some hard decisions.
- 38:46And I'm sure you already are about not allowing returns or
- 38:49blocking customers from shopping.
- 38:51How do you approach it? Because you're trying to deliver
- 38:54customer experience and that's almost like the antithesis of
- 38:56it. But actually you have to do that
- 38:58to protect good customer experience.
- 39:00So what strategically, how do you use a business approach
- 39:03this? Yeah.
- 39:04Do you? Is it about stopping people from
- 39:05buying who are bad customers? I don't, I don't mean that on
- 39:08the nursery, but fundamentally some people are bad customers.
- 39:11Or is it more about making people just pay for that
- 39:14behaviour? So I guess when we're talking
- 39:21about bad customers, I guess it's really like how how we're
- 39:25classing bad customers, like are we looking at return behaviour
- 39:30versus fraudulent returns? And I think there's a real
- 39:34distinct difference and we don't want to kind of bundle those
- 39:41customers together. So I think they we treat those
- 39:44two different things very, very differently.
- 39:46So, and obviously we have to be fair.
- 39:50So we've, as I said last year, we, we kind of tweaked different
- 39:55return policies to try and incur or discourage returns, I should
- 40:00say from bad returns behaviour. But I think we, we will, you
- 40:05know, it's a learning curve and we kind of learned the hard way
- 40:08from customer feedback how not to do it and how not to approach
- 40:11it. And we've gotten into it into
- 40:14quite a good place now again with.
- 40:18That better customer feedback and with our policies.
- 40:23So I think really with, with the returns and bad behaviour, I
- 40:29think we are restricted as, as an e-commerce brand with, with
- 40:36fair policies, we are restricted to what we can do and how we can
- 40:40discourage that behaviour. I think where we can really meet
- 40:44more of an impact is with the fraudulent returns.
- 40:47So, you know, customers not returning what they said they've
- 40:49returned, returning non opoly items or, you know, random
- 40:55things and, and saying it's their opoly return.
- 40:58There are more things that we can do with that to try and
- 41:01reduce that type of behaviour. So you know, we have kind of I
- 41:06suppose safeguards in place for returns in transit.
- 41:11We have threshold like value thresholds in place.
- 41:15We are also looking into different ways that we can QC
- 41:20the items and see what's been returned at a drop off rather
- 41:25than, you know, having the refund, refund processed in
- 41:29transit or drop off and then it getting back to us and not
- 41:31being, you know, what it what we're expecting back or worn
- 41:36dirty items, things like that. And then in terms of kind of
- 41:41blocking customers again, we have to be really careful with
- 41:46returns behaviour versus fraudulent.
- 41:47You know, you, you can't necessarily block customers from
- 41:52shopping again if they have a bad, bad return behaviour.
- 41:57But on fraudulent, if they're just returning lots and have
- 42:00like a really high return rate, we've seen other brands kind of
- 42:04look at that and do that in the past.
- 42:07But we're just going against with kind of what our advice and
- 42:11and what is actually deemed fair.
- 42:14But we can block customers if they are fraudulent and we have
- 42:18proof of fraudulent returns behaviour.
- 42:20So it is a balance and we also don't want to put any kind of
- 42:26blanket policies in place or, or things that are going to be
- 42:33detrimental to our loyal customers and customers who we
- 42:36want to return. And is it not not return their
- 42:39clothes, but to return to the website to buy more.
- 42:42And so, yeah, it is, it's really difficult.
- 42:46It's not an easy one. It's complex.
- 42:48And yeah, we don't, we don't want to punish the good
- 42:52customers by putting something in place to avoid the, the
- 42:56badge, you know, quote on quote customers.
- 42:59It's a balance enough. I think that's a really, really
- 43:02nice way of summarising this episode.
- 43:03Is, is it's brands have got takes returns seriously and see
- 43:08it as a proper service, not a cost.
- 43:10And you've got to stress test the policy on different customer
- 43:14groups to make sure you're not alienating people.
- 43:17That's a great one. And it's not easy, is it?
- 43:18I think that's the thing. If it was easy, it it would be
- 43:21resolved years ago, but it's not.
- 43:22It's an ongoing effort. And what I like is, is that
- 43:25you're constantly looking at the data, you're looking at the
- 43:28customer feedback. You're not just seeing the
- 43:30numbers from a cost or a revenue point or whatever it might be.
- 43:32You're looking at the impact on the customer satisfaction.
- 43:35And it's tied up though that journey that's critical.
- 43:39Yeah. And I think it's great talking
- 43:40to other brands about this topic as well, because it's such a
- 43:44massive topic and every brand's kind of feeling, especially
- 43:48since COVID, I feel like customers are returning more.
- 43:52So I think it's, it's good to keep the discussion going with,
- 43:55with other brands and kind of seeing what they're doing and
- 43:57how that they're tackling the situation.
- 44:01But I do think that loop enables us to to, to kind of play with
- 44:08different ideas and, and think of more creative ways to tackle
- 44:11the situation rather than just putting fees up and, and
- 44:15essentially annoying the our customers, which is the last
- 44:19thing we want to do. Yeah, exactly.
- 44:21Look, really appreciate that. That's that's why we could sit
- 44:24and ask and debate the the merits of different approaches
- 44:27for hours. That's what I love about it.
- 44:28But for those, listen, I hope this has given you food for
- 44:31thought. And for those of you working
- 44:32within retailer or e-commerce teams, there's some really good
- 44:35insights here into how a leading brand along with their
- 44:38technology partner is approaching this.
- 44:40If you want to find out more, we've got Emmy's contact details
- 44:44on the landing page. If you want to learn a bit more
- 44:47about Loop and how that portal and the tech works to support in
- 44:51returns management, then also you've got Samir's details as
- 44:54well. Do reach out and always feel
- 44:56free to tap up me and Paul for any questions.
- 44:58So Emily Samir, thanks for joining us today.
- 45:01Thank you. It's been good.
- 45:03Thanks for having us. Yeah.
- 45:04Thanks so much. This is great.
- 45:08You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast, hosted by
- 45:10experienced consultants James Gert and Paul Rogers.
- 45:13Inside Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge,
- 45:16featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 45:18industry thought leads and the C-Suite, key tech companies to
- 45:21explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 45:24and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 45:26really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 45:29to help fine tune your e-commerce strategy and text.
- 45:32Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 45:35like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 45:37We hope you enjoy the latest episode.