Latest / Decrypted: The UK Cyber Briefing / Ofcom asks Pornhub's owner if it tested the age check it borrowed from Apple
Transcript
- 0:03This is Decrypted. Thursday, the twenty-fourth of September.
- 0:07Ofcom asks Pornhub's owner if it tested the age check it borrowed from Apple.
- 0:13On 23 September Ofcom opened an investigation into Aylo, the company behind Pornhub, under the Online Safety
- 0:23Act. The interesting part is the method.
- 0:27Since May, Pornhub has relied on signals from Apple suggesting that a UK visitor has passed Apple's own age c
- 0:35hecks. Ofcom isn't judging Apple.
- 0:39It's asking whether Aylo tested that arrangement properly before trusting it.
- 0:44And that question applies to any UK organisation that has ever bought a control from someone else.
- 0:50Next.
- 0:57Ofcom says it will examine whether Aylo used "highly effective age assurance" to keep children away from por
- 1:04nography. It will also look at whether Aylo completed a "suitable and sufficient children's access assessment"
- 1:12. Providers, it says, must do that assessment before making any significant change to the design or operation
- 1:19of their service. And it adds: "Our investigation will not make a determination on how Apple operates its age
- 1:27checks."
- 1:30Aylo says it believes Apple's device-level check is among the hardest to circumvent protections available.
- 1:36If Ofcom does find a breach, fines can reach £18 million or 10% of qualifying worldwide revenue, whichever is
- 1:45greater.
- 1:51Picture a nightclub that stops checking I D because another venue's wristband says the wearer is over 18.
- 1:57The wristband may be excellent.
- 2:00But the licence belongs to the club.
- 2:02So the club has to know what the wristband proves, who can get one, and what happens when a wristband is miss
- 2:08ing or looks odd.
- 2:12The signals "suggest" users "may have completed" Apple's checks.
- 2:18A signal that suggests something is evidence, not a verdict.
- 2:22Between evidence and decision sit design choices.
- 2:25What counts as a pass? What happens when the signal is absent or ambiguous?
- 2:31How would you notice if the whole arrangement were quietly failing?
- 2:34An access assessment exists to answer those before launch.
- 2:38And also.
- 2:43Secure by Design says the party that ships the service owns its safety.
- 2:48Buying in a component doesn't buy in the duty.
- 2:51And the decisions that matter are unglamorous.
- 2:54Write down what you assume the third-party signal proves, and what it doesn't.
- 2:59Test the control against people who should fail it, not only people who should pass.
- 3:04Measure failure in production, so you find out before anyone else does.
- 3:09And decide in advance whether the service fails closed or open when the signal disappears.
- 3:14Ofcom's expectation that a fresh assessment comes before any significant change is Secure by Design written
- 3:22into law. The same logic covers swapping an identity provider, a fraud engine or an AI model.
- 3:29And finally.
- 3:34None of this needs new technology.
- 3:36It needs someone to list every control the business relies on because a supplier says it works.
- 3:42Then gather the evidence that it does.
- 3:43And re-do that work whenever the supplier or the method changes.
- 3:47Call it a day per control.
- 3:50The alternative is discovering the gap in a regulator's notice, with your board asking why nobody wrote the
- 3:56assumptions down.
- 4:01Any organisation leaning on someone else's assertion, whether about a customer, a device or a login, should a
- 4:08sk the same question. If that signal were wrong, would we know?
- 4:13That was Decrypted. The written version and every source are linked in the show notes.
- 4:18Thanks for listening.