Latest / Consumerpedia / 57 - What Ever Happened to Customer Service?
Transcript
- 0:02Do you remember that old Simon and Garfunkel song?
- 0:04Just trying to keep the customer satisfied?
- 0:06Satisfied. Well, there was a time when most
- 0:09retailers really tried to do that.
- 0:11Today, not so much. The goal is to make the sale and
- 0:15then move along to the next customer.
- 0:17It's really annoying. I'm her Weissbaum, the consumer
- 0:20man, a contributing editor at checkbook.org.
- 0:23Welcome to Consumerpedia at checkbook.org, where the
- 0:26nonprofit that helps consumers select services, avoid trouble,
- 0:30and save money. Because we don't accept any
- 0:33advertising or take money from any business, we recommend you
- 0:36can rely on checkbook.org to be completely independent and
- 0:39objective. Now here's the host of
- 0:42Consumerpedia America's consumer expert, the Consumer Man Herb.
- 0:46Weissbaum in this episode Why so many Companies see customer
- 0:50service as a costly problem rather than a way to keep the
- 0:54customers they work so hard to get?
- 0:56Why is calling on the phone so difficult or impossible?
- 1:00And is there anything you can do to get your problem solved after
- 1:03the sale? Joining us today, two experts in
- 1:06the field of customer satisfaction, John Pico, founder
- 1:09of Watermark Consulting based in Hartford, CT.
- 1:12He's also the author of the new book From Impressed to Obsessed.
- 1:16Hi Herb. It's good to be here with you.
- 1:18And Forrest Morgeson? He's an associate professor of
- 1:20marketing at Michigan State University and director of
- 1:23research emeritus at the ACSI, the American Customer
- 1:27Satisfaction Index. Hello, Forrest.
- 1:29Hi, Herb. So from my viewpoint and from
- 1:31what consumers tell us here, checkbook customer service in
- 1:34this country is pretty bad. Stores with almost no employees.
- 1:38And when you do find one, they're often unfriendly
- 1:41customer service lines that can keep you on hold for hours and
- 1:44companies that don't respond to complaint letters or emails.
- 1:47So I'd like to start off with how both of you would rate the
- 1:50state of customer service in America right now.
- 1:52And I'll start with you, John. Well, I think it's pretty
- 1:54crummy, as you might expect, I'd say.
- 1:56And I think if you look at the research out there, it really
- 2:00provides a lot of evidence of that and it's everything that
- 2:03all of us feel day-to-day when we're engaging with businesses
- 2:06just as consumers. You know, just to give you a
- 2:09taste of the data that I think sort of illustrates this, my
- 2:12firm did a study recently, Consumer Polling, to understand
- 2:15people's sentiment and their expectations.
- 2:17And amazingly, we found that only 23% of consumers say that
- 2:22businesses consistently meet all of their expectations.
- 2:26That is setting the bar awfully low.
- 2:28And then you know, to add insult to injury, people actually say,
- 2:32yeah, we found 36% of of consumers say that when they're
- 2:36about to engage with a business, only 36% believe that it's going
- 2:40to be easy to work with that business.
- 2:42So I think that we as a society have become so accustomed, so
- 2:45habituated to crummy customer service that it's almost like
- 2:49we've we've come to expect it to some degree.
- 2:51I I agree with you for the A CSI surveys hundreds of thousands of
- 2:55consumers every year about dozens of industries, from
- 2:58airlines and mobile phones to healthcare and financial
- 3:00institutions. What are some of the universal
- 3:03problems that people have when they deal with companies today?
- 3:06Well, I think the reality is, is that the problems that people
- 3:09have with industries are to some extent idiosyncratic.
- 3:11They vary industry by industry. No industry does a really
- 3:15outstanding job in the sense of always meeting or exceeding
- 3:19customers expectations. There's always problems,
- 3:22consumer experience somewhere, whether they be big or small.
- 3:26But of course we do see that some industries perform well
- 3:29below others and I'm thinking of telecommunications industry.
- 3:32Subscription TV and Internet service providers are some of
- 3:36the least pleasing industries across the US economy, and they
- 3:40all have their own reasons why. And those cases, it's, you know,
- 3:43rapidly increasing prices and not terribly efficient service,
- 3:47and you have a large number of outages and those kinds of
- 3:50things that have a negative effect on consumers.
- 3:53But it does vary industry by industry.
- 3:55John, you work with businesses. Are there some overriding issues
- 3:58that you tend to deal with? I think a key issue is people
- 4:01simply not doing what they said they were going to do.
- 4:03That is representatives of a business that you're working
- 4:06with. You know, whether it's saying
- 4:07that they're going to call you back at the end of the following
- 4:10day or are they going to get you some pieces of information, I
- 4:13think that there's just sort of this lack of focus and
- 4:16consistency around honoring one's commitments to you.
- 4:19I think that's a common source of frustration.
- 4:21I think that another one too is the difficulty that consumers
- 4:25have interpreting information that businesses provide to them,
- 4:29whether it is instructions for how to assemble a product or a
- 4:34financial statement, a billing invoice.
- 4:37Very often those documents are viewed by companies as sort of
- 4:42administrative touch points and they don't realize that it's
- 4:45actually a very meaningful part of the entire customer
- 4:48experience. And if you don't craft those
- 4:50documents effectively, you end up creating the need for
- 4:54customer service because people have to contact you to
- 4:57understand, you know, why is my billing statement say this or
- 5:00I'm having trouble assembling this product.
- 5:02Can you help me? Let me share a personal customer
- 5:04service Horror Story. My wife and I went to the local
- 5:06branch of Chase Bank, been doing business there for decades.
- 5:10We wanted to open a new savings account and the friendly greeter
- 5:13at the door asked why we were there, looked around and said I
- 5:15don't think there's anybody here right now can help you.
- 5:18I saw the branch manager was in his office.
- 5:20We've worked with him before. So I said what about him?
- 5:22Oh, he doesn't open new accounts, she said.
- 5:25So she took us over to their personal banker, someone we'd
- 5:28worked with before and he was in a really bad mood.
- 5:30Said he was called in on his day off.
- 5:32Really didn't want to be there. So how about we come back next
- 5:35week? By the way, we had a $20,000
- 5:37check in our hands that we wanted to deposit.
- 5:39To me, that's the state of customer service these days.
- 5:42That's not a terribly unusual experience and across a lot of
- 5:46service providing industries and of course we've seen it get
- 5:49particularly bad over the last few years as the labor markets
- 5:52become tighter and tighter and companies particularly customer
- 5:55facing service positions, they're having problems filling
- 5:58those positions. And with that you get more
- 6:00stress on existing personnel who may be wonderful customer
- 6:03service deliverers under normal circumstances, but now are being
- 6:07asked to do more and more for the same pay and add into that
- 6:10inflation. Their pay is, you know,
- 6:12functionally going down in many cases, and it's a really, it's
- 6:15sort of a nasty recipe for disaster for a lot of companies.
- 6:18John, I know companies are trying to reduce costs, but they
- 6:21spend so much money getting customers, why risk losing them
- 6:25to lousy customer service if they have a problem after the
- 6:27sale? Doesn't seem to make economic
- 6:29makes sense. It does leave you kind of
- 6:31scratching your head, but there are two ways that you can run
- 6:34your business. You either run it with the goal
- 6:37of maximizing customer loyalty or you run it with the goal of
- 6:41minimizing customer attrition. And those are two very different
- 6:44approaches, 1 focuses on enriching customers lives and
- 6:49the other focuses on exploiting them, frankly.
- 6:52Unfortunately, many businesses choose the exploitation route.
- 6:55They focus on minimizing customer attrition.
- 6:58They try to do only as much as is absolutely necessary to get
- 7:02you to stick around. That's their business model.
- 7:05They feel that makes more economic sense, do as little as
- 7:08possible, invest as little as possible and just make sure that
- 7:12the customer doesn't get so angry and frustrated that they
- 7:15leave. And I'm not suggesting that
- 7:16that's a good model indeed, you know, it might drive financial
- 7:19results in the short term potentially, but in the long
- 7:21term it's a one way ticket to the business graveyard because
- 7:24you can't grow a business over the long term if your existing
- 7:28customers despise you. In your book, John, you make the
- 7:31case that great customer service can actually cost less for a
- 7:34company to deliver. Yeah.
- 7:35And I firmly believe that many companies think that to deliver
- 7:39better service, they're going to have to dip into their pockets
- 7:41and spend a lot more and create sort of this Ritz Carlton white
- 7:45glove kind of experience. But the fact is that great
- 7:48service costs less, because when you do things right upstream on
- 7:52the front end, it obviates the need for customers to contact
- 7:56you downstream, often with dumb, avoidable questions.
- 8:00Smart companies focus not just on making customer service
- 8:04better, they focus on making the need for customer service to go
- 8:08away entirely. Because everything just works
- 8:11perfectly as it was intended at the point of sale and shipping
- 8:15and delivery, at product assembly, whatever.
- 8:18And so when customers stop calling and chatting and texting
- 8:21you about dumb things, it puts less stress on your operating
- 8:24infrastructure and you're able to deliver that better customer
- 8:28experience at a more competitive cost.
- 8:31Here's the problem. And and you might say, well, why
- 8:33don't more companies just get that and do it?
- 8:35And the issue is that the way many companies measure their
- 8:38performance, the way they monitor their financials, the
- 8:42benefits of great service and the penalty exacted for poor
- 8:46service can often be kind of invisible to them.
- 8:49And I'll give you an example here, Herb, with product
- 8:51assembly, you know, we've all had the experience of ripping
- 8:54our hair out, trying to decipher some incomprehensible exploded
- 8:58parts diagram and instruction manual.
- 9:00And if you think about it, the investment that's required to
- 9:03create clearer instructions, it's something that would be
- 9:05borne by like the product development area in a company.
- 9:09But the issue is that the benefits of those clearer
- 9:11instructions, they would be manifesting themselves in a
- 9:14totally different part of the company.
- 9:16They'd be manifesting themselves in the customer service
- 9:19financials because that's where you would see a reduction in
- 9:21call volumes. And as simple and silly as it
- 9:24may sound, many businesses just can't wrap their heads around
- 9:27that. Like they have a very siloed
- 9:29mentality when it goes to justifying investments and
- 9:32evaluating the ROI on investments.
- 9:35So if I do something in Department A and the benefit is
- 9:38in department B, it's a lot less likely that's going to get
- 9:41approved. Because if I'm heading up
- 9:43department A, I'm just going to do things that are going to help
- 9:46me and my performance review and making sure that, you know, my
- 9:49financials look good. And unfortunately, that's why
- 9:52there's a disincentive in many organizations to pursue those
- 9:54kinds of improvements. I've always heard that a happy
- 9:57customer tells three people and unhappy customer tells 10.
- 10:00Is that still the basic rule applied here these days?
- 10:03I think it is absolutely. You know, there's many studies
- 10:05that illustrate that dichotomy in terms of how often a customer
- 10:09with a poor experience is going to tell others.
- 10:11I think also these days that dynamic is amplified because now
- 10:16with the advent of social media, everybody can shout from the
- 10:20rooftops in a way that wasn't possible before that technology
- 10:24existed. So there's a lot of risk for any
- 10:26company that disappoints its customers to the level where
- 10:30they actually go online and they start raging about it because a
- 10:33lot of other people are going to see that.
- 10:35Force, you mentioned not being able to get help.
- 10:37You know, you go to the supermarket now, my local
- 10:39Safeway, and I'm thrilled when there's actually a check line
- 10:41open. Usually there isn't one at all.
- 10:43Going to self-service a couple of weeks ago and there was a
- 10:46digital coupon and I left my phone in the car.
- 10:49So I asked the person who was managing self checkout, could
- 10:52you please give me the discount? Which Safeway says if you don't
- 10:54have your phone, they'll do that.
- 10:55And I was basically given a lecture.
- 10:57I'll do it this time, Sir, But you know, you better get used to
- 11:00figuring this out, 'cause this is the shopping experience of
- 11:03the future. That's where we are.
- 11:05Well, self-service technologies are, they have a long learning
- 11:08curve and we're seeing that in consumers not being able to
- 11:10efficiently check themselves out of a variety of retail
- 11:13environments. You're finally seeing some
- 11:15retailers here in the United States go away from self-service
- 11:18technologies and go back to actual human delivered customer
- 11:22service in the checkout process. Because they're finding not only
- 11:25do self-service technologies not work for a lot of consumers and
- 11:28create the need for human intervention anyway, but the the
- 11:31loss ratio is much higher on the self-service technologies as
- 11:35people figure out ways to circumvent paying for what
- 11:38they're actually buying and leaving the store with.
- 11:41So you're seeing some of that pushback.
- 11:43I think the reality is that in the long run we're going to see
- 11:46more and more self-service technologies.
- 11:47We're going to see retail environments that have virtually
- 11:50no or possibly no human customer service delivery at all.
- 11:54And so we are going to have to get used to that.
- 11:56Retailers would be well served in terms of maintaining positive
- 12:00relationships with their customers and creating long term
- 12:03customer loyalty by easing the frictions and and making that as
- 12:07palatable a process as possible in the interim.
- 12:09But I think the reality is that over the long run, that's
- 12:12definitely where we're going to be going and keep heading in
- 12:14that direction, you know? Every time I do something now,
- 12:17whether it's buy a can of paint at Home Depot, or have my car
- 12:20serviced at the auto shop or have a blood draw from my
- 12:23doctor's office, I get an e-mail asking me to rate my experience.
- 12:26I've actually taken the time to fill them out, responding that I
- 12:29had a horrible experience and would never buy something from
- 12:32that retailer again. And crickets.
- 12:34No response. Does anybody read these things
- 12:37or is it just done to give me the illusion that they care
- 12:39about me? What many companies don't
- 12:41realize is that customer surveys aren't just an instrument for
- 12:45measuring the quality of your customer experience.
- 12:48They're a bona fide part of the customer experience itself.
- 12:52You know, some companies send out surveys with dozens and
- 12:55dozens of questions, and what they don't realize is that their
- 12:57customer satisfaction surveys are actually dissatisfying their
- 13:00customers. You know, it's like you don't
- 13:02want to end up there. Furthermore, they don't have the
- 13:05the organizational discipline around doing something with the
- 13:08feedback that they get, and that risks reinforcing negative brand
- 13:12impressions. You know, just like you
- 13:13described. I've been there too.
- 13:15The nature of the business I'm in, I always respond to surveys
- 13:18just 'cause I want to see what's the company going to do.
- 13:21And when you express a lot of frustration in a survey response
- 13:24and then you don't hear anything but crickets in return, what
- 13:27signal do you think that sends to the customer about the
- 13:30company in terms of how important their feedback is?
- 13:32It just really serves to cement the negative impression that you
- 13:36had formed when you first chose to fill out the survey.
- 13:39And that's what companies miss. I mean, imagine, Herb, if if in
- 13:42one of those companies that you just provided really awful
- 13:45feedback towards, imagine if the next day you got a phone call
- 13:48from a manager at that company saying, hey, we got your your
- 13:51survey feedback. Just wanted to have a chance to
- 13:54to talk to you about it better, understand it, see how we can,
- 13:56you know, do better in the future.
- 13:58That might not completely turn the tide in terms of your
- 14:01impression on that company, but it'll start 'cause that'll be
- 14:04surprising to you that somebody actually read it and reached out
- 14:07to you to have a conversation and companies need to do.
- 14:10That, you know, something that really gets my blood boiling is
- 14:12being kept on hold for what seems like forever to speak to
- 14:15that customer service agent, if you can even find the number to
- 14:18call in the first place. So how do we deal with that?
- 14:20We're going to talk about that next and hear from some
- 14:22checkbook subscribers who have a few gripes on their own about
- 14:25that. I'm Herb Weisbaum and this is
- 14:27Consumerpedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 14:31If you like what you hear, we hope you'll consider being a
- 14:34consumer PDS supporter by using the link at the bottom of the
- 14:37show notes to make a small contribution each month.
- 14:40This is Consumer Pedia. OK, let's talk about trying to
- 14:45reach a company by phone. The first challenge is trying to
- 14:48find the number, which many companies make it difficult or
- 14:51impossible to find on their websites.
- 14:52I want you to listen to what Cleo, a Checkbook subscriber,
- 14:55said about that. That I'll dial A number that's
- 14:58listed for customer service once I find the number and usually
- 15:01they'll tell me to go online, which is very frustrating
- 15:05because obviously I wouldn't be calling if the online option had
- 15:08worked for me. And once I finally do get a
- 15:10person on the phone, it's just a circle of hell.
- 15:14Sometimes I don't get an answer. I'm told the exact same thing I
- 15:18read on the website and when I try to escalate, usually that
- 15:22just leads to further frustration time and time again
- 15:26and it is extremely frustrating. John, I assume that's
- 15:29deliberate. Companies are trying to make it
- 15:30hard for you to find the number to call.
- 15:32It absolutely is. You know, that is their
- 15:35seemingly clever way they think to reduce incoming calls.
- 15:40What they fail to realize is that you're not really
- 15:43materially reducing calls. All you're doing is ensuring
- 15:47that the customer's temperature gets turned up before they reach
- 15:51one of your service reps, And so it you're just adding insult to
- 15:55injury, you're making it more difficult for the reps that are
- 15:58taking the calls and it's obviously not a good outcome for
- 16:01the customer. Then, if you do find the number
- 16:03to call, you have to navigate the phone tree.
- 16:05Here's how another Checkbook subscriber, Tracy, described
- 16:08that experience. And then once you get there,
- 16:11then you have to go through their system of press one or
- 16:13press 2. And sometimes they want you to
- 16:16use words instead of numbers. They can't understand you, The
- 16:19options don't necessarily fit your situation, and you're now
- 16:23getting transferred to the wrong place and now they want to
- 16:26transfer you to the right place. And they disconnect you.
- 16:29So now you got to start all over again.
- 16:31It makes me feel very very frustrated with the amount of
- 16:34time that is lost and I am not even making this up.
- 16:38I have spent 45 minutes to two hours just.
- 16:41Trying to reach a. Person.
- 16:43Who can answer a simple question?
- 16:45So Forrest, I know there's a need for phone trees because
- 16:47they're trying to send you off to the right customer service
- 16:50agent, but they are getting a little bit ridiculous,
- 16:52especially when you can't push over, say, human, when none of
- 16:55the options make sense to you. It's not what you're calling
- 16:57about. Yeah, that's right.
- 16:58I mean, they do make it exceedingly difficult to get a
- 17:01human being on the line to ask that.
- 17:03And I understand the caller's point.
- 17:05Most of these companies are trying to as much as possible
- 17:08minimize the number of call center customer service
- 17:11personnel they have available for cost reasons of course and
- 17:14profitability reasons. I think the near term hope is
- 17:17that as we get better and better artificial intelligence
- 17:20technologies that are able to answer many of these questions
- 17:23for consumers and that's rapidly improving as we see in the world
- 17:26around us. We're going to get some of that
- 17:29kind of technology to bear here in a much more efficient way,
- 17:32which will replace some of the customer service personnel that
- 17:35these companies are trying to trim and at the same time have a
- 17:38difficulty filling those jobs to begin with.
- 17:41But the frustration, the true frustration, is when none of the
- 17:43options on the phone tree meet what you're calling about John,
- 17:46and you can't push zero. You can't say customer service
- 17:50agent or agent or representative, because they
- 17:51don't have the system designed for that.
- 17:53You are trapped in phone tree hell and can never get out of
- 17:56there. Yeah, like Forrest said, I mean
- 17:58they're the tricks of the trade or just keep saying customer
- 18:01service Rep agent, if it's a voice response system or just,
- 18:04you know, keep hitting zero over and over again and sometimes
- 18:07that will work. But yeah, in its worst form,
- 18:10you're right that there are companies that just engineer
- 18:13this in a way so that you can't get to somebody.
- 18:17I think this is actually indicative of a larger issue
- 18:20which is that companies don't step into the shoes of their
- 18:23customers that often. You know, when was the last time
- 18:26the CEO of any company actually called their 800 line and
- 18:31pretended to have an issue And you know they get to experience
- 18:34the horror of going through the all those menu levels and not
- 18:38having one that matches what they need to do.
- 18:41And you know, getting routed to a web page that gives you a four
- 18:44O 4 error back and doesn't give you any information.
- 18:47I I don't think the top executives at companies are
- 18:50routinely immersing themselves in their customer service
- 18:54experience, and so they're somewhat ignorant to what it
- 18:57really feels like to be their customer.
- 18:59One more comment from a checkbook subscriber.
- 19:01Nancy said that if you do make it through the phone tree, you
- 19:04can find yourself on hold for a really long time.
- 19:07The music that you have to listen to while you're waiting
- 19:10online, which in some cases is just the same little Jingle over
- 19:14and over and over again. And you can't turn it off.
- 19:18And you don't want to sign off because you're afraid you'll
- 19:21lose your place in line. So it's like Chinese water
- 19:24torture. It's painful and it's
- 19:25irritating. The skeptic in me wants to
- 19:28believe that maybe they have such terrible music because
- 19:30they're hoping you will ditch the call and not bother them.
- 19:33Possibility, John. You're definitely looking at the
- 19:38world through a very nefarious lens.
- 19:40But you might be right. You know, I try to be a little
- 19:43more optimistic in the goodness of people, but yeah, that is
- 19:47possible. But the fact is that companies
- 19:50could do so much more with that time and that space.
- 19:54So for example, one of the fundamental things about
- 19:58delivering better experiences to people is you want them to feel
- 20:02like they have some control over the experience.
- 20:04And so when you're waiting on a 800 line, instead of playing
- 20:08awful music, you should be giving people an update to say,
- 20:11we expect that your call is going to be answered in 5
- 20:13minutes. And there's technology that does
- 20:15that, and it's very effective because unknown weight feels
- 20:19much better to people than an unknown weight.
- 20:21And so using that kind of technology, it's like they might
- 20:24not answer the phones any faster, but just having the
- 20:27expectations set when you're there actually makes that
- 20:30experience feel a lot more palatable.
- 20:32And I would argue that's a much better way to use that time than
- 20:36to play. Some awful music companies could
- 20:38also give you relevant information about products or
- 20:41features. You know that you might not be
- 20:43using, something that's better than making your ears bleed from
- 20:46some terrible Symphony. And John, some companies give
- 20:49you the option. God bless them to leave your
- 20:52number so they can call you back.
- 20:53That's a fabulous option. Keep you in the same place in
- 20:56line, but they'll call you back. It is.
- 20:58And it's a shame that more companies don't use that
- 21:00technology because it's not terribly expensive.
- 21:03It's readily available. And it again goes back to this
- 21:07notion of giving people the sense that they have control in
- 21:10the encounter. If I feel like I'm railroaded,
- 21:12meaning the only way that I can speak to you is by phone, and I
- 21:16have to stay on this line. And what is that a signal of?
- 21:19It's a signal that, you know, we don't value your time as a
- 21:22customer. But if you give me the option
- 21:25that, hey, you could call me back when someone is ready and I
- 21:28don't lose my place in line, I feel like I've got more control
- 21:31over the experience because I'm able to go about my day and live
- 21:34my life until you are ready to speak with me.
- 21:37And so it might seem like a very a subtle difference, but it
- 21:40really sends a signal to the customer that hey, we're not
- 21:43trying to waste your time and that's a much better experience.
- 21:46How many times do you need to hear this message?
- 21:49Your call is important to us. Please stay on hold before it's
- 21:52obvious your call isn't important to them.
- 21:54Is it 10? Is it 12?
- 21:55Is it 75? I I I I don't know if I have a
- 21:58good answer to that one. But you're getting my point.
- 22:01They keep running that same message over again, telling
- 22:03you're important when it's clearly you're not important.
- 22:05Yeah, It's another example of companies not walking the talk.
- 22:08They say one thing, but their actions demonstrate something
- 22:11else. And and I don't think what
- 22:12companies appreciate is that ultimately customers loyalty
- 22:16towards you is not going to be governed by what you say and
- 22:21what your marketing materials communicate and do what the
- 22:24Billboard says. It's going to be governed by the
- 22:27experience that they have. And no matter what you say, the
- 22:31experience is going to speak for itself.
- 22:33So is there anything we can do to get companies to improve
- 22:35their customer service and help us when we have a problem that's
- 22:38coming up next? I'm Her Weissbaum the consumer
- 22:41man, and you're listening to Consumerpedia, powered by
- 22:44checkbook.org. Consumerpedia Fast Fax According
- 22:50to research by Salesforce, 91% of the customers surveyed said
- 22:53they are more likely to make another purchase when they have
- 22:56a positive customer service experience. 83% expect to engage
- 23:00with someone immediately when contacting a company. 78% said
- 23:04they would forgive A company for its mistakes if they received
- 23:08excellent service. 71% said they've made purchase decisions
- 23:11based on the quality of customer service they received.
- 23:15So how do we deal with this reality?
- 23:17Is there anything we can do to encourage companies to take
- 23:20better care of us? John, your thoughts?
- 23:22Well, I think that the key thing for consumers is you need to be
- 23:25aware of and work to combat what's known as consumer
- 23:29inertia. Human beings, we're lazy
- 23:32creatures at heart. We prefer the path of least
- 23:35resistance, and companies count on us to be lazy.
- 23:39Herb, you mentioned earlier your your experience with the bank.
- 23:42Well, banks are notorious for this because it takes a lot of
- 23:45work to switch banks. They're counting on that
- 23:48friction to keep you around even if they're not good to you.
- 23:52So consumers need to be cognizant of that and they have
- 23:54to vote with their feet, even if it results in more work for
- 23:57them. In the short one, whether it's,
- 23:59you know, researching a new bank, for example, or in
- 24:02arranging for all the automatic payments and credits to be
- 24:05transferred over. Also, whether it's a bank or any
- 24:08other type of company, another thing to do is to make sure that
- 24:10you're telling this business that you're thinking of taking
- 24:13your business elsewhere and you need to make that statement
- 24:17credible to them. So when you're calling in and
- 24:20you're frustrated, good trick is to indicate that you're planning
- 24:24on cancelling your service. You know whether that's a menu
- 24:26option or or saying that. And I think the best recent
- 24:29example of her by half of this, which I just thought was
- 24:31classic, was with my cell service provider who I've been
- 24:35with for nearly 1/4 of a century.
- 24:37Not that I'm happy about it, it's just that I haven't had
- 24:39good alternatives and I was actually just recently I was
- 24:43exploring moving my cell phone service because all of my phones
- 24:46and my family are all paid off. What I realized was that in
- 24:50order to transfer your phone number, you actually have to get
- 24:53a special code from your current cell phone carrier and you give
- 24:56it to your new one to transfer your number.
- 24:58So when I went to my current cell phone provider's website
- 25:03and I clicked on the link just to see how you go about getting
- 25:06that code. Miraculously, the next day I got
- 25:10an e-mail from my current provider telling me that I was
- 25:13getting $10 off per line per month on my account for the next
- 25:19year. As a thank you for my loyalty, I
- 25:22guarantee you they would never have sent that out if I had not
- 25:26clicked on that link. But that's what I mean about
- 25:28sending a credible signal to the company that you are serious
- 25:31about looking for alternatives. But the bottom line is we as
- 25:34consumers have to vote with our feet, don't get lazy.
- 25:37And that's when companies are going to see that there's a cost
- 25:40that is exacted to delivering poor service.
- 25:43Forests are the days of trying to talk to a human being over
- 25:46and we just need to deal with live chat.
- 25:48Well, I don't know if they're entirely over.
- 25:50I think we're certainly headed in that direction.
- 25:52The reality is that while we as consumers may really prefer the
- 25:58opportunity to talk to an actual person, when we are forced to
- 26:01call into a contact Center for some kind of problem with the
- 26:05product or service that we're consuming, we may like that
- 26:08ability to talk to a human. But the reality is for most
- 26:10industries, it's not the norm any longer.
- 26:13The idea is across these industries that companies tend
- 26:17to mimic one another within the industry and do what the
- 26:19industry leaders are doing. And so as long as you have
- 26:22industries where those industry leaders are going away from
- 26:25those kinds of technologies, and I'm thinking of big companies
- 26:28like Amazon and retail now and just think of the largest
- 26:31company in each industry. And if that company isn't doing
- 26:33it, if they're not giving customers the opportunity to
- 26:36talk to an actual person during a product or service failure
- 26:39episode, then it's very unlikely anyone else is going to do it.
- 26:43I think the the saving grace is probably the fact that we're
- 26:46going to get better and better live chats, better and better
- 26:48virtual agents that are more capable than ever before of
- 26:51answering our questions, questions as consumers and that
- 26:53may be what is ultimately responsible for helping improve
- 26:57customer satisfaction and service across the economy we.
- 27:00Used to give the advice that if you're talking to somebody and
- 27:03they can't help you, try to escalate, say, can I talk to the
- 27:06manager or supervisor? But these days you'll get an
- 27:09answer like I am the manager or there's no one else here.
- 27:12I got to get this off my chest. This is a true story.
- 27:14I was on a call with the American Express online bank
- 27:17trying to fix a serious problem with a hold on a $20,000 deposit
- 27:21that had gone on for months. And when I very nicely asked if
- 27:24there was anyone who could expedite the situation because I
- 27:27was running out of money, I was told, quote, Sir, if you don't
- 27:30like what I'm telling you, you can hire a lawyer and sue us.
- 27:33How's that for a customer service response?
- 27:35I doubt American Express trains their people to say something
- 27:38like that. Yeah, I I certainly hope they
- 27:40don't train their people to say that.
- 27:42But, you know, I think that if you encounter a situation like
- 27:46that where you're treated so poorly, you know, I do think
- 27:48that it is. It's still worth asking for that
- 27:51to speak to a manager. That's the first step I would
- 27:53say. But second, I would enlist the
- 27:55help of a regulatory or an oversight body.
- 27:59That would be the second step in my view.
- 28:01And then the third step is post on social media.
- 28:04If you're active on social media and tag the offending company,
- 28:07this might sound crazy that you know you're talking to someone
- 28:10on the phone or you're in the retail location and they won't
- 28:14help you. Yet if you tag them on social
- 28:16media, they'll respond. But that actually is what
- 28:20happens often times because there's a team of people that's
- 28:22monitoring the social media channels 'cause they don't want
- 28:25anything toxic to be going out there and you might actually
- 28:28garner more attention with them as compared to, you know, just
- 28:32talking to someone on the phone. And then lastly, if none of that
- 28:34works, I'll go back to my earlier statement, take your
- 28:36business elsewhere and vote with your feet.
- 28:38Well, this has been a fascinating conversation, and I
- 28:41want to thank both of you for being with us.
- 28:43John Pico, founder of Watermark Consulting and the author of the
- 28:46new book From Impressed to Obsessed.
- 28:48Thank you, John. Thank you.
- 28:50It was great to be with your herb.
- 28:51And Forrest Morgeson, he is Director of Research Emeritus at
- 28:54the American Customer Satisfaction Index.
- 28:56You can see what they do at this website, theacsi.org.
- 29:01Forrest, thank you. Thanks for having me.
- 29:03Well, that's it for this edition of Consumerpedia.
- 29:05We hope you'll rate this episode and follow us on Apple Podcast,
- 29:09Spotify, or wherever you listen to your podcast.
- 29:12Remember, we release new episodes every other Thursday.
- 29:16Another way you can support this show is to follow us on
- 29:18Consumerpedia on Facebook and Instagram.
- 29:21And at my Consumerpedia on Twitter.
- 29:23I'm Her Weissbaum. Thanks for listening.
- 29:26Consumerpedia is a public service of checkbook.org.
- 29:30We're a unique nonprofit that helps you save money and make
- 29:32smarter choices. You can count on Checkbook to
- 29:35help you find the best services and avoid the worst with local
- 29:38ratings that are accurate and unbiased.
- 29:41If you live in or around these seven cities and haven't joined
- 29:44Checkbook yet, check us out Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia,
- 29:49Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and
- 29:52Washington DC To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 29:56checkbook.org/consumerpedia. If you like what you've heard,
- 30:00we hope you'll become a supporter by using the link at
- 30:03the bottom of the show Notes to make a small contribution each
- 30:05month. Consumerpedia Empowering
- 30:08consumers to save money and make smarter choices.