Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Read the 10-K (Annual Report) Like a Detective
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to The Deep Dive. Today we are stripping away all
- 0:03the noise. We're not talking about the
- 0:05latest hot tip you saw on Twitter or.
- 0:07What the talking heads on TV are shouting about.
- 0:09Exactly. Or you know even what your cab
- 0:12driver thinks about the market. We are going straight to the
- 0:14source, to the the molecular level of investing.
- 0:18We're decoding the 10K. The 10K.
- 0:20The annual report. And to the uninitiated, it is,
- 0:23let's be honest, a boring, dense, maybe even terrifying
- 0:27compliance document. It is.
- 0:29I think that's the stigma, right?
- 0:31For most listeners, when I say annual report, they're picturing
- 0:33a PDF. It's probably 150 pages of just
- 0:37Gray legal text, endless tables, and these footnotes that feel
- 0:41like they were designed specifically to put you to
- 0:43sleep. It feels like homework and.
- 0:45Definitely not the fun kind. It is homework, but it's the
- 0:48kind of homework that, if you do it right, can make you rich.
- 0:51I mean, think of it this way, relying on a news headline or,
- 0:55you know, a little summary on your trading app to buy a stock.
- 0:59That's like marrying someone after one date.
- 1:01You know what they look like, you know what they told you on
- 1:03that date, but you have no idea who they really are.
- 1:05Right, You don't know their history.
- 1:07Not at all. Reading the 10K is like hiring a
- 1:09private investigator to run a full background check.
- 1:12You're reviewing their credit score.
- 1:14You're talking to their previous employers.
- 1:16Maybe you're even interviewing their exes.
- 1:19You're getting the full story, The unvarned truth.
- 1:22It is adna test for the business, that's what it is I.
- 1:25Love that. So our mission today then is to
- 1:28turn our listeners from, let's say, passive stock pickers,
- 1:33people who just sort of buy and hope things go up into active
- 1:36business detectives, yes. The detective mindset is key.
- 1:40And to guide us through this whole investigation, we're
- 1:43breaking down a very specific protocol.
- 1:46It's a method developed by the investor Hamish Hotter, right?
- 1:49Hotter is a deep value guy, a long term investor.
- 1:52He's all about the fundamentals, the nuts and bolts of the
- 1:54business. And his core philosophy, and
- 1:56this is what I found really surprising, is that you
- 1:59absolutely do not read the annual report from cover to
- 2:02cover. That is probably the most
- 2:04important lesson, and it's a massive relief, isn't?
- 2:06It it's a huge relief, honestly, because if the advice was read
- 2:10every single word of legal jargon from Page 1 to 180, I
- 2:14think we'd lose half our audience, right?
- 2:16Now we would, and they'd be right to leave.
- 2:18It's a crucial point. If you try to read it
- 2:20sequentially, like a novel, you will burn out.
- 2:24I guarantee it. You'll get bogged down in
- 2:25useless details before you find anything good.
- 2:28But not a novel. It's not a novel, it's a
- 2:30database. Or better yet, a crime scene
- 2:32full of evidence. Hotter's method is all about
- 2:35extraction. We're going to show you exactly
- 2:38what to read, what to skim, and maybe most importantly, what to
- 2:41just completely throw in the trash.
- 2:43OK. And to keep this from being just
- 2:44a dry theory session, we're going to apply this to a live
- 2:47patient, a real company. We're going to be looking at
- 2:50Texas Roadhouse. A classic, A really interesting
- 2:53business. A compounder.
- 2:54So why them? Why Texas Roadhouse?
- 2:56Why not, you know, a hot tech stock like NVIDIA or some
- 3:00complex biotech company or a big bank?
- 3:03Because complexity hides the mechanics.
- 3:05It really does. If we started with a major bank,
- 3:08we'd be bogged down in 5 minutes talking about interest rate
- 3:11swaps and balance sheet leverage and, you know, tier one capital
- 3:15ratios. My eyes are glazing over just
- 3:16hearing you say that. Exactly.
- 3:18Texas Roadhouse is beautifully simple.
- 3:20They buy beef, they cook it, they serve it in a fun
- 3:23atmosphere, and they collect cash at the end of the night.
- 3:25That's it. If you can learn to strip mine
- 3:28the 10K of a steakhouse, you can apply that same framework to
- 3:33Apple or Ford or anything else. So the logic of the
- 3:36investigation is universal. It's completely universal.
- 3:38The fundamentals are the same. All right, so we have our
- 3:40target, we have our method, but before we even download the PDF,
- 3:44before we even put on our detective gloves, Hotter argues
- 3:47there's a step 0. You don't just rush into the
- 3:49crime scene. No, you don't walk into a crime
- 3:51scene without knowing the weather, right?
- 3:53Is it sunny? Is it about to be a hurricane?
- 3:55OK, so you need context. You need context, you need the
- 3:59macro before the micro. And this is so important.
- 4:02You can find the best company in the entire world.
- 4:05I'm talking a flawless balance sheet, brilliant management, a
- 4:09product everyone loves. But if you buy it when the
- 4:13entire market is in a historic bubble.
- 4:16You're still going to get hurt. You are still going to lose a
- 4:19ton of money, or at least you'll sit on dead money for years.
- 4:23It's that old saying about the rising tide lifting all boats.
- 4:26But the receding tide grounds them all, good and bad.
- 4:29Precisely, You need to know the temperature of the water before
- 4:32you dive in. Knowing when to look for value
- 4:34is just as important, sometimes more important, than knowing how
- 4:38to look. You need a thermometer for the
- 4:40market. And for our listeners who want a
- 4:42reliable thermometer for that water, who want to to engage
- 4:45that context, we do have a specific tool recommendation
- 4:48that can help. It's a really useful way to get
- 4:50that big picture view. To track total market
- 4:52temperature, welcome to search and download the iOS app.
- 4:55Buffett Indicator from the Apple App Store gives you a daily
- 4:58update on that macro picture we're talking.
- 5:00About. OK, so we've checked the
- 5:11weather. The market context is set.
- 5:14Now we proceed to the investigation.
- 5:16Let's start with the basics, the logistics.
- 5:19Where do we actually get this document?
- 5:21We want the unvarnished truth, not the glossy marketing
- 5:25brochure with smiling employees on the cover.
- 5:28Right, the real deal, you have two main options.
- 5:30Option A, which is the most common, is the company's own
- 5:34investor relations website. OK.
- 5:36Almost every public company has a tab on their website that says
- 5:40investors or IR. You click there, look for a link
- 5:45that says SEC filings or annual reports and you'll find it.
- 5:48That seems easy enough, but you said there are two options.
- 5:51You prefer the other one. I do.
- 5:53I prefer option B, which is to go directly to the source.
- 5:57Edgar. Edgar, It's the SEC's database.
- 6:00It stands for Electronic Data Gathering, Analysis and
- 6:03Retrieval. It's a bit of a mouthful, but
- 6:05essentially it's the governments library of all these filings.
- 6:08You just search the companies ticker symbol and you filter for
- 6:1110K. So why do you prefer the
- 6:13slightly clunkier government database over the company's nice
- 6:18user friendly website? It's a small thing, but it's
- 6:21important. The company website often pushes
- 6:23what they call the annual review or the glossy version first.
- 6:26They want you to see the beautiful photos of their
- 6:28charity work and the CEO smiling with a hard hat on.
- 6:32The marketing version. And the marketing version ADGA
- 6:35here gives you a raw text file. It strips away all the marketing
- 6:39fluff. We're here for the data, not the
- 6:40brochure. Got it.
- 6:41We want the facts, not the spin. OK, so we've downloaded the 10K
- 6:45for Texas Roadhouse from Eddie GR.
- 6:47We open it up and it's a wall of text.
- 6:50Panic starts to set in. Where do we make the first cut
- 6:53in this autopsy? You don't panic.
- 6:55You scroll immediately to a section called Item One, the
- 6:57business. Item one simple enough name.
- 7:00What are we looking for in here? What's the mission?
- 7:02This is The Who, what, and where of the company.
- 7:06If you cannot explain to a 5 year old how this company
- 7:10generates $1.00 of revenue, you have absolutely no business
- 7:13owning the stock. Period.
- 7:15So this is the foundational understanding.
- 7:17It's the operating manual. It covers how they source their
- 7:19products, how they market them, who their competition is, how
- 7:23they distribute everything. It's the blueprint of the
- 7:25machine. So for our case study, Texas
- 7:27Roadhouse, what specific insights are we trying to
- 7:30extract? Is it really just we sell steaks
- 7:33or is there more to it? Oh, there's always more.
- 7:35It's much deeper. For example, the very first
- 7:38thing you'll find if you read item one for Texas Roadhouse is
- 7:41that they aren't just one brand. Really.
- 7:43Yeah, they also own a completely different restaurant concept
- 7:46called Bubba's 33. Bubba's 33.
- 7:49I've never heard of that. And most people haven't.
- 7:51That's exactly why you read the 10K.
- 7:53It's a sports bar chain. They sell burgers, pizza, beer.
- 7:56It's a different vibe, a different customer.
- 7:58So you might think you're investing in just steakhouse.
- 8:01But you're actually investing in a steakhouse plus a growing
- 8:04younger sports bar concept on the side.
- 8:07Precisely. And that could completely change
- 8:10your calculation of their future growth runway.
- 8:12But that's just an appetizer. The real diamond in item 1, and
- 8:16this is the technical part that listeners really need to grasp,
- 8:19is the unit economics. OK, define that for us.
- 8:22Unit economics is a buzzword that gets thrown around a lot,
- 8:25especially in Silicon Valley and on Wall Street.
- 8:27What does it actually mean for a steakhouse?
- 8:30It's actually very simple. It just means how does one
- 8:34single store perform financially?
- 8:37Forget the whole company for a second.
- 8:38Forget the stock price, forget the billions in market cap.
- 8:41If I build 1 new Texas Roadhouse restaurant does it make money
- 8:45and how much? OK, so we're zooming way in from
- 8:48the whole corporation down to the atomic level of one single
- 8:51restaurant. Correct, and the 10K usually
- 8:53right there in item one will explicitly stay at the
- 8:55approximate cost to open a new restaurant.
- 8:57It's a number they have to disclose.
- 9:00For Texas Roadhouse, at the time of Hotter's analysis, it was
- 9:02about $5.2 million. OK, $5.2 million.
- 9:08That's to build the building, put in the kitchen equipment
- 9:11that tables, hire the staff and open the doors.
- 9:14Why is that specific number that 5.2 million?
- 9:18Why is that the diamond? Because that is your denominator
- 9:21in investing everything and I mean everything eventually comes
- 9:25down to ROIC return on invested capital, right?
- 9:29To calculate the return, you first have to know the invested
- 9:31capital. We now know it cost $5.2 million
- 9:34to build the cash generating machine I.
- 9:36See where this is going? Because later on when we dig
- 9:40into the profits, we can do the math and figure out the return
- 9:42on that machine. Bingo.
- 9:44If we look at other parts of the report and find out that a
- 9:47single mature store makes let's say $1 million a year in profit,
- 9:51we can do the simple division 1,000,000 in profit on a $5.2
- 9:55million investment. That's what, just under 20%,
- 9:59Nineteen, 20%. Yeah, a 19 to 20% return on your
- 10:02investment. Which, just to be clear for
- 10:04everyone listening, is an absolutely incredible return.
- 10:07It's world class. Most businesses are thrilled to
- 10:09get 8 or 10%. But you see the point, If you
- 10:12didn't dig out that 5.2, 1,000,000 number from item one,
- 10:16you'd just be looking at APE ratio or stock chart.
- 10:19You wouldn't understand the engine driving the value.
- 10:22You wouldn't know why it's such a good business.
- 10:24That's the real difference between gambling on a stock
- 10:26ticker and actually analyzing a business you own.
- 10:30You're assessing the machine itself, not just the hype around
- 10:33it. 100%. So a practical question, if I'm
- 10:36looking at a company like Texas Roadhouse that's been around for
- 10:3920 or 30 years, do I need to read item one, the business for
- 10:45every single year going back decades?
- 10:47That sounds exhausting. No and please don't.
- 10:49That is a complete waste of your life.
- 10:51This is where Hotter applies what he calls the one and done
- 10:54rule. One and done.
- 10:55I like the sound of that. The basic business model of a
- 10:58steakhouse doesn't change drastically year to year.
- 11:01They aren't going to suddenly pivot to blockchain technology
- 11:04or AI powered manufacturing overnight.
- 11:06Unlikely, yes. So you read the latest item one
- 11:09very deeply, internalize it, understand the machine as it
- 11:14exists today. So we aren't really looking for
- 11:16historical trends in the business section itself.
- 11:19Not really. I mean, you might glance at a
- 11:21report from 10 years ago just to see if Bubba's 33 existed back
- 11:24then, or to see how the total store count has grown, just to
- 11:27get a quick sense of scale. But you don't need to reread the
- 11:30boilerplate paragraph about how we serve hand cut steaks and
- 11:34fresh baked bread 10 different times.
- 11:36It's just copy pasted from year to year.
- 11:38Skip it. OK, got it.
- 11:39Efficiency is the name of the game.
- 11:41We're detectives on a mission, not librarians or archivists.
- 11:44So next section, we've understood the business.
- 11:48We Scroll down a little further to item 1A, Risk Factors.
- 11:52This section is usually a long, scary laundry list of everything
- 11:56that could possibly go wrong. Doom and gloom.
- 11:59It is the official why you might lose all your money section.
- 12:03It always feels a bit like legal cover to me.
- 12:04Yeah. You read things like if an
- 12:06asteroid hits the Earth, our sales may decline, or if the sun
- 12:09explodes, our margins might suffer.
- 12:11Do we really need to read this stuff?
- 12:13It can feel that way, yes. A lot of it is just lawyers
- 12:16covering all their bases, but you absolutely have to read it.
- 12:19This is your reality check. This is where the company is
- 12:23forced to list everything that could derail that beautiful 20%
- 12:27return on invested capital we just got so excited about.
- 12:30So how do we filter the signal from the noise here?
- 12:33Because there is a lot of noise. You're looking for material
- 12:37risks that are specific to the business model.
- 12:39Forget the asteroid stuff, you're looking for the real
- 12:42threats. For a company like Texas
- 12:44Roadhouse, they list things like disease outbreaks in cattle
- 12:47herds. Which directly impacts the price
- 12:50of beef, their main ingredients. Drastically.
- 12:52If there's a mad cow scare or a major drought in cattle country,
- 12:56beef prices spike and since beef is their number one input cost,
- 13:00their margins get absolutely crushed.
- 13:02Makes sense. They also talk a lot about
- 13:04minimum wage legislation. Right, because restaurants are
- 13:06incredibly labor intensive. All those servers, cooks, hosts.
- 13:10Exactly, If the federal minimum wage double S tomorrow, that
- 13:14$5.2 million store might not make $1,000,000 in profit
- 13:18anymore, it might only make 500,000 and that cuts your
- 13:22beautiful ROI in half just like that.
- 13:25The risk factor section forces you to confront these scenarios.
- 13:29It tempers your optimism with a dose of reality.
- 13:32So if item one makes you fall in love with the business, item 1A
- 13:35reminds you that the business has baggage and lives in the
- 13:38real messy world. That is the perfect way to put
- 13:40it, but again, just like with the business section, apply the
- 13:43one and done rule here. Read the latest 1 thoroughly.
- 13:45Yes, the fundamental risks don't change that much overnight.
- 13:50The risk of beef prices rising is always there.
- 13:52The risk of Labor costs going up is always there.
- 13:55So read the latest one to understand the current threat
- 13:58landscape. You don't need to go back and
- 13:59read 2015's risk factors unless you're a historian writing a
- 14:02book. OK, so we've done our homework
- 14:05on the business, the machine and the risks, the threats to the
- 14:10machine. Now we arrive at what Hamish
- 14:12Hotter calls the meat of the report.
- 14:15And surprisingly, it's not the financial tables yet.
- 14:18It's a section with a clunky name MDNA.
- 14:21Management's discussion and analysis.
- 14:24Why does Hotter identify this block of text as arguably more
- 14:28important than the actual numbers themselves?
- 14:30Because the numbers, the financial statements, they only
- 14:33tell you what happened. The MDNA is supposed to tell you
- 14:35why it happened. OK, give me a concrete example.
- 14:37Sure. Imagine you look at the income
- 14:39statement and it shows that profit is down 10% this year.
- 14:43That's a fact. It's a number.
- 14:45But is it bad news on its own? You have no idea.
- 14:48It sounds bad. It sounds bad, but then you go
- 14:50to the MDNA and management explains profit is down because
- 14:52beef prices rose 15%. But we made a conscious
- 14:56strategic decision not to raise our menu prices because we want
- 15:00to gain market share and keep our customers loyal for the long
- 15:03term. Whoa, that is a huge
- 15:06distinction. One scenario looks like a
- 15:08failure on the spreadsheet, but the explanation reveals it's
- 15:11actually a very smart long term strategic choice.
- 15:14Exactly. Or conversely, the MDNA might
- 15:17say profit is down 10% because we lost a lot of foot traffic to
- 15:21our new competitor across the street.
- 15:23That's a disaster. That's a 5 alarm fire.
- 15:26And the number on the income statement was the same in both
- 15:28cases. Identical.
- 15:29You need the narrative from management to interpret the
- 15:33number correctly. Now this is where the strategy
- 15:35gets really interesting. For the business section and the
- 15:38risk section, the rule was one and done.
- 15:41Read the latest one. But for the M DNA, Hotter
- 15:44insists on a completely different and much more labor
- 15:47intensive strategy. He calls it The Time Machine
- 15:49method. Yes, and this, this is the part
- 15:52that separates the amateurs from the pros.
- 15:54This is where the real work, the real detective work, begins.
- 15:57So what is The Time Machine method?
- 15:59It's exactly what it sounds like.
- 16:00You must read the section. Historically.
- 16:03You start with the current year's MDNA, then you download
- 16:05last year's 10K and read that one.
- 16:08Then the year before that, and the year before that.
- 16:10Going back maybe 10 years if you can.
- 16:11OK, I have to push back a little here.
- 16:13Reading 10 years of management commentary, that is a lot of
- 16:17reading for a big company. We could be talking about
- 16:20thousands of pages. Is the payoff really worth that
- 16:24massive time investment? It absolutely is 100%.
- 16:28And here is the single most important reason why you are
- 16:32testing for integrity. Integrity.
- 16:34You want to see if they lie or you know if they're delusional.
- 16:37You go back and you pull up the 2018 M DNA.
- 16:40What were they saying then? Did they promise to improve
- 16:42their margins by 2020? Did they say we are investing
- 16:46heavily in this new technology that's going to lower our labor
- 16:49costs? You're finding their promises
- 16:50from the past. Yes.
- 16:52And then you jump forward in your time machine, you open the
- 16:542020 MDNA, and you check their work.
- 16:57Did they actually do it? Did the margins go up?
- 17:00Did labor costs go down? Or did they just make a new
- 17:02excuse for why it didn't happen? So you're fact checking their
- 17:06past selves. You're holding them accountable
- 17:09to their own predictions and their own goals.
- 17:10You are building a psychological profile of the management team.
- 17:14It's unbelievably revealing if a company has a temporary problem
- 17:18like, oh, unusually bad weather impacted our sales this quarter
- 17:22and you see that same excuse appear in the MDNA every single
- 17:26year for a decade. It's not temporary.
- 17:28It's not temporary, it's a structural problem with their
- 17:31business and they are either lying to themselves or they are
- 17:34lying to you. And you can only see that
- 17:36pattern if you use The Time Machine method.
- 17:39That is a really powerful insight.
- 17:41It's like having a friend who is always late, but they always
- 17:44have a different excuse. The traffic was crazy.
- 17:46My alarm didn't go off, I couldn't find my keys.
- 17:49Perfect analogy. Individually, any one of those
- 17:52excuses seems plausible, but collectively, over time, they
- 17:56reveal a character flaw. The person is just not reliable.
- 18:00Perfectly put. If you only read this year's
- 18:02report, you'll believe this year's excuse.
- 18:05If you read 10 years of reports, you see the character flaw and
- 18:09you do not want to be in business with management that
- 18:12lacks integrity or is consistently wrong about their
- 18:15own future. So while we're in the MDNA
- 18:18traveling through time, we're also looking for their KPIs,
- 18:21right, their key performance indicators.
- 18:22Yes, every industry, every business has a different set of
- 18:26metrics that really matter. The MDNA is where management
- 18:29reveals what numbers they use to grade themselves.
- 18:32It's like they're giving you the answers to the test.
- 18:34So for Texas Roadhouse, what are those critical numbers we should
- 18:37be looking for? Well, the obvious one is the
- 18:39number of new restaurant openings, their store count
- 18:42growth. But the really critical one, and
- 18:44this applies to almost all retail and restaurant
- 18:47businesses, is comparable restaurant sales growth.
- 18:50OK. Why is comparable the magic word
- 18:52there? Why isn't it good enough to just
- 18:54look at their total sales growth?
- 18:55This is a classic trap that new investors fall into constantly.
- 19:00It's so easy to be misled. Imagine I have 10 stores this
- 19:03year and they do $100 in total sales.
- 19:06OK, next year I go out and I build 10 brand new stores.
- 19:10So now I have 20 stores in total and let's say my total revenue
- 19:13is now $180. Wow, your revenue almost
- 19:17doubled. It looks like massive growth.
- 19:19Looks great on a chart. It looks like I'm a genius,
- 19:22right? But wait, do the math.
- 19:24I doubled my store count from 10 to 20, but my revenue didn't
- 19:27double. It only went up 80%.
- 19:30What does that mean? It means the original 10 stores
- 19:32are actually making less money than they were before.
- 19:35The core of the business is rotting.
- 19:37The core is rotting, but I'm masking that decay by building
- 19:41new stuff to pump up the top line number.
- 19:43It's a very common trick. That is sneaky, and you'd never
- 19:46see it if you just looked at the headline revenue number.
- 19:48Never. Comparable sales, Sometimes it's
- 19:51called same store sales, strips out the effect of new openings.
- 19:55It only measures the health of the existing fleet of stores
- 19:58that have been open for more than a year.
- 20:00If that number is consistently negative, the business is dying
- 20:03no matter how fast they expand. The MDNA will highlight this
- 20:07trend over time. So we're looking for organic
- 20:09growth from the existing business versus purchase growth
- 20:13from just building more things. Exactly.
- 20:15And the third big KPI for them is average unit volume or AUV.
- 20:20How much in sales does one single building generate per
- 20:23year? If that number is trending up
- 20:26over 10 years from say 4 million to 5 million to 6,000,000 per
- 20:30store, that is a very, very strong sign of brand power and
- 20:35operational excellence. OK, I am completely sold on The
- 20:38Time Machine method. It sounds like a lot of work,
- 20:41but it also sounds like the kind of work that prevents you from
- 20:43losing your shirt on a bad investment.
- 20:45It is. It's your best defense.
- 20:46So we've analyzed the narrative. We've checked their honesty over
- 20:49a decade now. Section 5.
- 20:51We finally get to look at the spreadsheets, the financial
- 20:54statements. Scorecard where the numbers
- 20:57live. Now, Hunter mentions using an
- 20:58external tool like Quick fs.net to pull the raw data.
- 21:02If we have a tool that just scrapes the numbers for us and
- 21:04puts them in a nice table, why do we need to bother looking at
- 21:07the actual tables in the 10K at all?
- 21:09Trust but verify. It's that simple.
- 21:12Data aggregators are great. They save a ton of time, but
- 21:15they make mistakes. Algorithms can scrape the wrong
- 21:19sell. A company might change how they
- 21:21report a certain item one year and the scraper doesn't catch
- 21:24it. You use the selected financial
- 21:26data table in the 10K to spot check the numbers from your
- 21:29external tool. If the 10K says revenue was $2
- 21:33billion and your app says it was 2.5 billion, you have a big
- 21:37problem. You have to figure out which one
- 21:38is right. You're using the source document
- 21:41to verify the third party data. Always.
- 21:43We're looking for the big three financial statements here.
- 21:46Let's do a quick rapid fire definition for the non
- 21:48accountants who might be listening.
- 21:50Just a one sentence summary of what each one tells us.
- 21:52Sounds good. First up, the income statement,
- 21:55this is your profit and loss or P&L.
- 21:57It shows revenue coming in at the top, all the expenses in the
- 22:00middle and the profit or earnings at the very bottom and
- 22:03answers the question, are we profitable?
- 22:06Simple enough #2. The balance sheet.
- 22:09This is a snapshot of the company's financial health at a
- 22:12single moment in time. It lists what the company owns,
- 22:16which are assets, versus what the company owes, which are
- 22:19liabilities. This is where you find the all
- 22:21important debt number. It answers the question, are we
- 22:25solvent? And the third one.
- 22:27The cash flow statement. This is the ultimate lie
- 22:30detector. The earnings number on the
- 22:32income statement can be manipulated with all sorts of
- 22:34accounting rules and non cash expenses.
- 22:37The cash flow statement tracks the actual physical dollars
- 22:41moving in and out of the companies bank account.
- 22:43It answers the question, do we actually have any money?
- 22:46And the goal here isn't to become ACPA overnight, right?
- 22:48They aren't trying to memorize every line item on the balance
- 22:51sheet. No, not at all.
- 22:52You are on an extraction mission.
- 22:54You take the key numbers, the revenue, the debt, the cash
- 22:57flow, and you plug them into your own valuation model or
- 22:59spreadsheet. You're just gathering the
- 23:01essential ingredients for your own recipe.
- 23:03You're moving the data from their PDF into your own analysis
- 23:06tool. OK, now buried beneath these big
- 23:09three tables, there's always this enormous section of fine
- 23:12print. It's called the Notes to
- 23:15Consolidated Financial Statements.
- 23:17Goes on for pages and pages. Starter calls this the
- 23:20dictionary. That is exactly the right way to
- 23:22view it. And here's the key.
- 23:24Do not read the notes linearly. I repeat, do not try to read
- 23:29from note one through note 25. You will fall asleep, I
- 23:32absolutely guarantee it. So how do we use it then, if
- 23:34we're not supposed to read it you?
- 23:35Use it to answer specific questions that arise when you're
- 23:39looking at the big three statements.
- 23:41You treat it like a reference book, like an encyclopedia.
- 23:43OK, give me an example of a question that would send you
- 23:45diving into the notes. All right, a perfect one is
- 23:48debt. Let's say you're looking at the
- 23:50balance sheet and you see a scary looking line item, long
- 23:54term debt, $500 million. That sounds like a lot of debt.
- 23:58It does, but is it actually dangerous?
- 24:00The number alone doesn't tell you anything about the risk, so
- 24:03you flip to the notes section. You find the note that
- 24:06corresponds to debt and it will give you all the juicy details.
- 24:09What kind of details are we looking for?
- 24:11It will tell you the interest rate on that debt and crucially
- 24:14the maturity date when the money has to be paid back.
- 24:19So maybe that note tells you the 500 million is locked in at a 3%
- 24:23fixed interest rate and isn't due until the year 2035.
- 24:27In today's environment, that's basically free money.
- 24:30That's actually an asset, not a liability.
- 24:32Exactly. So you see that and you stop
- 24:34worrying about the debt. But maybe the note says that the
- 24:37debt is at a variable interest rate, currently at 9%, and the
- 24:42entire 500 million is due to be repaid next Tuesday.
- 24:46That's a potential bankruptcy. That's a full blown crisis.
- 24:49The line item on the balance sheet, long term debt, $500
- 24:52million, looked exactly the same.
- 24:55In both of those scenarios. The note gave you the critical
- 24:57context. That's why you use it as a
- 24:58reference tool. You see something weird or
- 25:01important in the main statements, you go to the notes
- 25:03to investigate further. That makes the notes section
- 25:06seem so much less intimidating. It's not a book to be read, it's
- 25:08a glossary. You check when you're confused
- 25:10about a term. OK, so we're nearing the end of
- 25:13the report. We get to the very bottom of the
- 25:15document, the final exhibits, the employment agreements, ah.
- 25:20Yes, the trash section. Hotter is pretty brutal about
- 25:24this particular section. He is.
- 25:25He calls it rubbish and a complete time waster.
- 25:28And for most investors, he's right.
- 25:30So what's actually in there? It's pages and pages and pages
- 25:34of dense legal jargon about executive compensation packages.
- 25:38It's how many stock options the CEO gets, what happens to their
- 25:42bonus if the company gets acquired, the specific details
- 25:45of their severance package and their golden parachute.
- 25:48Now wait a minute, is it really trash?
- 25:50Don't we care if the CEO is being wildly overpaid?
- 25:53Don't we care if they're looting the company with an insane
- 25:55contract? We do care about that,
- 25:57absolutely, but you can usually find a high level summary of
- 26:00that information in a different document called the proxy
- 26:03statement for the purpose of a fundamental valuation, which is
- 26:06trying to figure out what the future cash flows of the
- 26:08steakhouse are worth. Knowing the specific details of
- 26:11the CE OS dental plan or their private jet allowance is just
- 26:14noise. It's.
- 26:15Not going to help you predict if they're going to sell more
- 26:17steaks next. Year.
- 26:18Not at all. It's a distraction from what
- 26:19really matters for the business's value.
- 26:21So unless you're an activist investor planning a coup to fire
- 26:24the board. Just skip it.
- 26:26Skip it entirely. Focus on the business, not the
- 26:29bureaucracy. I have to say, getting
- 26:31permission to just skip 50 pages of a document feels pretty good.
- 26:35It's liberating, isn't it? It can save you an hour of
- 26:38painful reading right there. So let's synthesize all of this.
- 26:41We have a clear protocol. Let's just recap the full Hamish
- 26:45Hotter method for our listeners step by step so they have a
- 26:47checklist, OK? Here it is step one, the
- 26:49business section Item 1. Read the latest one deeply find
- 26:54the unit economics. Your goal is to understand the
- 26:56machine. How much does it cost to build 1
- 26:59unit and what is the return on that investment?
- 27:02Step 2. Step 2 Risk Factors Item 1A Read
- 27:07the latest one thoroughly. Know what can kill the machine.
- 27:10Is it rising beef prices? Is it government regulation?
- 27:13Is it competition? Step 3.
- 27:15The big one. Step three MDNA.
- 27:18This is the deep work. Use The Time Machine.
- 27:21Read back at least 5, preferably 10 years.
- 27:24Your goal is to test management's integrity and
- 27:26strategic competence. Are they honest?
- 27:29Do they do what they say they're going to do?
- 27:30Step four. Step 4.
- 27:32The financials. This is the extraction phase.
- 27:34You pull the raw numbers you need for your own analysis and
- 27:38you use the 10K to verify the data you get from 3rd party
- 27:41tools. Step five.
- 27:42Step 5. The notes.
- 27:43Use it as a dictionary, a reference tool.
- 27:46You only go there when you have a specific question about a
- 27:48number in the financials. And finally, step 6.
- 27:51Step 6 Employment agreements and other exhibits.
- 27:54Ignore them, Throw them in the trash.
- 27:56It really does turn this overwhelming 180 page monster
- 28:00into a targeted strategic strike.
- 28:02You know, the big HA moment for me in all of this is that real
- 28:06investing it isn't about trying to predict the future.
- 28:09It's about understanding the present so clearly and so deeply
- 28:12that the future doesn't scare you as much.
- 28:14That's it. That is the entire game.
- 28:17If you know it costs 5.2 million to build a store, and you know
- 28:21the returns on that store consistently solid, and you know
- 28:23the balance sheet is strong enough to survive a recession,
- 28:27then when the stock drops 5% on a random Tuesday because of some
- 28:31market noise, you don't panic. You might even get excited to
- 28:34buy more. You know what you own.
- 28:37It grounds you in the reality of the business, not the volatility
- 28:40of the stock price. It turns you from a gambler, a
- 28:43speculator, into a business partner.
- 28:45You aren't just betting on a ticker symbol that wiggles on a
- 28:48screen. You are a partial owner of a
- 28:50chain of actual physical steakhouses.
- 28:53So here's a final provocative thought for everyone listening.
- 28:55Today we talked about The Time Machine method for the MDNAI.
- 28:59Want to challenge you to try this?
- 29:00Go find the 10K from 2015 for the biggest single stock holding
- 29:04in your portfolio right now. The company you love the most.
- 29:07It's a very sobering exercise, I recommend it.
- 29:10Find the MDNA from that report. See what they promised back
- 29:13then, What were their goals, What was their strategy.
- 29:16Then look at where that company is today and ask yourself
- 29:19honestly, would you trust that management team more or less
- 29:25after doing that research? The answer is almost always
- 29:27found in the gap between what they said would happen and what
- 29:30actually happened. And a detective's job is to find
- 29:33and measure that gap. And if you're lucky enough to
- 29:35find a management team where there is no gap, where for 10
- 29:39years they have done exactly what they said they were going
- 29:41to do, hold on to that stock and never let it go.
- 29:43Absolutely. Now, before we sign off, we just
- 29:46have some important housekeeping to take care.
- 29:47Of Disclaimer Full deep value research reports can be found
- 29:51found in the description links. All analysis is based on
- 29:54publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions or
- 29:57differing interpretations. The content is for educational
- 30:00purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 30:04Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 30:06decisions. And if you want to listen to our
- 30:09full deep dive about this topic or get access to even more
- 30:14advanced content, you're welcome to join the Deep Value Club
- 30:17membership or just. Subscribe to us on.
- 30:19Deep values dot AI. For from where to then you saw.
- 30:24Zensher this year is sheer too. Nito Ricci Antoneshi.
- 30:30Nen 9 to Chiangye. You don't know, you don't know.
- 30:40You don't want to be a harsh TV send, you know, to see Lyle
- 30:59Chunihunya burns the body. Thanks for listening everyone.
- 31:06Go download a 10K, skip the legal jargon, and find the
- 31:10treasure that's buried inside. We'll see you on the next deep
- 31:15dive. Happy hunting.