Latest / CXOTalk / CXO's Guide to Effective Storytelling in Business
Transcript
- 0:00Storytelling is essential for everyone in business.
- 0:04If you're selling your ideas, you're selling products, you're
- 0:08trying to convince your team to follow your idea.
- 0:12Today on Episode #794 of CXO Talk, we're speaking with Josh
- 0:20Bernoff. He's an author.
- 0:22He's a famous ghostwriter. It's funny thing, right, to say
- 0:26you're a famous ghostwriter, but but he is, he's a former
- 0:30industry analyst and most of all for us today, he is an expert
- 0:35storyteller. I spent 14 years as a startup
- 0:38executive in the Boston area and then 20 years as an analyst at
- 0:42Forrester. I wrote a book called
- 0:45Groundswell along with Charlene Lee, another analyst that sold
- 0:49150,000 copies. So since that time.
- 0:52I've been focused on books and stories, working with analysts
- 0:56at Forrester on those, and then for the last eight years doing
- 1:00that independently. And that's those.
- 1:04All that experience is what's in here.
- 1:06Build a Better Business book, which is how to plan, write and
- 1:12promote a book that matters, really a topic that anybody
- 1:16who's going to be writing a book, but especially.
- 1:18Senior executives need to pay attention to if they want to
- 1:21create influence. Why are stories so important in
- 1:26your book? You begin the whole book with a
- 1:29discussion about storytelling. Why?
- 1:34Stories are what resonate with people.
- 1:36The first time I tried to write a book, I sent the book proposal
- 1:39to to the agent we were working with.
- 1:42And he's like, well, I can't sell this.
- 1:46I said why not? He said well because business
- 1:48books are made of people and stories and there are no people
- 1:51and stories in here. Reads like a research report.
- 1:54Well, I was an analyst. I wrote research reports.
- 1:57But at that moment I was I thought that we're on this, that
- 2:00I can do that I can find people and stories and and since that
- 2:04time I have realized that that is essential to communicating
- 2:09any idea is to allow the person reading to put themselves in the
- 2:13position of the. Person you're describing and
- 2:16say, Oh yeah, that's what that felt like.
- 2:18That's what it's like for me. Oh, he did that and it worked.
- 2:21I guess that might work for me. Oh, she did that and it didn't
- 2:23work. Maybe I should learn from that.
- 2:26Companies are stories. You tell a story to every
- 2:30consumer and every employee about who you are and what
- 2:33matters to you. And if that story coheres and it
- 2:36resonates with them, you can succeed.
- 2:38And if it doesn't, then you're just a collection of people who
- 2:41who happen to be working together right now.
- 2:44Josh, listening to you talk about your early experience
- 2:49writing a book where you were an analyst and you were used to
- 2:52writing research, I think many business executives, especially
- 2:57technology focused ones, come out of that very intellectual as
- 3:03opposed to emotional mindset. And so there is a challenge in
- 3:09translating. Our ideas, our intellectual
- 3:13ideas into stories that convey emotion.
- 3:17How does one go about doing that?
- 3:19It really is a question of empathy.
- 3:22I mean as to why this matters, I I like to cite this little study
- 3:26Dan Heath, the author I did with his students at Stanford.
- 3:31He had some people give a presentation that included some
- 3:35stories and some statistics. And then later he came back to
- 3:38the students and said. Do you remember the statistics?
- 3:425% remember the statistics. Do you remember the stories?
- 3:4763% remember the stories. And that just shows you the
- 3:51power here. Now, as far as what what CE O's
- 3:56need to do, you're going to be telling two kinds of stories.
- 4:00One is a story about people who matter like a customer.
- 4:06Who whose life was changed by something that you did or
- 4:10another customer who had problems.
- 4:13And they we use that story to help illustrate why we do things
- 4:16one way and not another. But it also relates to the
- 4:19brands that companies have, because every company is a
- 4:23story. And that story basically says
- 4:26this customer has this problem, we come along and we offer this
- 4:30solution. The customer uses our product or
- 4:33our service. And therefore, they have a happy
- 4:37ending. And that's certainly the kind of
- 4:39story that marketers tell, but it also motivates employees and
- 4:43everyone else associated with the company to know this is our
- 4:46story. We help these people solve this
- 4:48problem with this product, and then they live happily ever
- 4:51after. But what about folks who are,
- 4:55again, technology oriented, who are used to speaking with other
- 5:02tech folks? And in a kind of shorthand, this
- 5:06could be CIOs or Ctos for example, right?
- 5:09They speak in a kind of shorthand to convey the message,
- 5:14and the expectation is that you know I'm giving you the
- 5:18information and therefore you should act on this information.
- 5:23The idea that we can reduce everything to some simple and
- 5:26logical set of statistics is I think.
- 5:30At the root of a lot of these problems I you know that
- 5:33companies have, you don't think Apple could have been where it
- 5:37was now without a story about why it was better.
- 5:40It wasn't just about the products, it was about the story
- 5:43that they told. And I mean let's just talk about
- 5:46technology products. We we before we got on the air,
- 5:49we're talking about a Zoom, the the video conferencing company
- 5:55and yes. They can tell people about how
- 5:59they're more effective and they work with large companies and
- 6:02small using the same technology and you know how dependable they
- 6:06are. But the story of Zoom is when
- 6:09you need to connect with somebody else on video, it's
- 6:12really easy and it just works. And therefore you can have a
- 6:17relationship with the person you're connecting with on video,
- 6:19even if you're not in the same room.
- 6:21And therefore that's really good for you and the when.
- 6:26Some other video conferencing company tries to come into, say,
- 6:30ACIO and say, well, you should use us instead of Zoom.
- 6:34All the people have heard that, you know, they're like, no wait,
- 6:37Zoom is really easy. I've been using, well, can't we
- 6:39use Zoom? Well, that's because this, the
- 6:41Zoom story is stuck in their brains.
- 6:44That's even if you're dealing with selling technology on a
- 6:48technologist to technologist basis, somewhere beneath that
- 6:52someone is like, oh, this just works better and it solves my
- 6:55problem. But the the message zoom is
- 6:59simple or any product is simple and easy.
- 7:04That's kind of a marketing message as opposed to telling a
- 7:09story, right? Or where am I not correct in
- 7:12that? No.
- 7:13Well, that is a marketing message.
- 7:14But a marketing message is a story.
- 7:16A purpose statement from a company is a story.
- 7:21A marketing statement is a story about customers.
- 7:24If this customer uses this thing, then they'll be happier.
- 7:27And when you see a commercial, let's say the commercial doesn't
- 7:33say, you know these things are better for these people.
- 7:37Now they have, they show a person who's actually has a
- 7:42problem and then solves the problem.
- 7:44But that's the story about a person that's not just a
- 7:46marketing message. What is it, then, about stories
- 7:51that make them? More memorable than the facts
- 7:55and figures as you were describing.
- 7:57Earlier, I wish I could completely answer that, but I
- 8:01think that solution is what's deep in people's brains, about
- 8:05the way their brains work. You know, we've been telling
- 8:09stories to each other since we were cave people sitting around
- 8:13the campfire. So it's just how people think
- 8:19and. I I mean, this comes up
- 8:21specifically in the books that I help people with where if you
- 8:26have a, you know, extremely logical and well supported,
- 8:29statistically supported set of information about why this thing
- 8:33is better than that thing, people may read it, they may
- 8:37even understand it, but they won't remember it.
- 8:40But if you say, Oh well, you know, this person had this
- 8:43problem and then they did this and it didn't work and they did
- 8:46this other thing and it did work and therefore it's better to do
- 8:48it this other way. The next thing that happens is
- 8:52they go into the somebody else and say, Oh yeah, well, I heard
- 8:54this story about this person who had this problem and they solved
- 8:56it. It's just how people's brains
- 8:59work. So you're really tapping into a
- 9:02fundamental psychological principle or truth of us people.
- 9:09Yes, it is absolutely part of the human experience And you
- 9:15know, people in India don't. Solve problems the same way as
- 9:20people in France, as people in Japan, but they're all telling
- 9:25stories. You can see a television
- 9:29commercial from Japan and get the message, even if you don't
- 9:32understand a word they're saying, because you see that
- 9:34people are solving problems and that's the story that you
- 9:38remember. Please subscribe to our YouTube
- 9:42channel. Hit the subscribe button.
- 9:44It's now at the bottom of our website.
- 9:47On almost every page, so you can subscribe to our newsletter so
- 9:50we can inform you of upcoming live shows.
- 9:54OK, we we have an interesting question from Twitter from
- 9:59Arsalan Khan. He's always, Arsalan always
- 10:01listens and he asks very intriguing questions.
- 10:05And so thank you for listening, Arsalan.
- 10:08And he asks a hard question. Here's what he says he says data
- 10:12transformation is a part of. Business transformation and it
- 10:18requires us to create a story to convey what the data is trying
- 10:25to tell. And I'm you must be very
- 10:28experienced with that from your time as an analyst using data to
- 10:31tell the story. Now here's his question.
- 10:34How do you address the challenge of a narrative and story and
- 10:40bias that executives have even before you convey?
- 10:45Your data story. So you walk into a room with
- 10:48your data story and people have a bias before you even begin.
- 10:53How do you address that? Basically you have to fight fire
- 10:56with fire. So I certainly executives, we've
- 11:02all heard these these stories about how somebody comes in to
- 11:06talk about you know what the business has to do from a
- 11:09technology basis and the. CEO says, Oh well, my daughter
- 11:14just learned about this new thing and you're like, we're
- 11:19going to have to deal with this. But that's the problem is that
- 11:22the daughter's learned experience is somehow more real
- 11:27to that CEO and all of the data that you've brought.
- 11:32And that means that you need to put your own story together.
- 11:36Now, a story supported by data is much better than a story by
- 11:38itself. And that very much was what we
- 11:41did at Forrester. We collected lots of data of all
- 11:46different kinds, and then we would use it to support our
- 11:50perspective, which was assembled based on lots of research about
- 11:55the truth. But in the end, it all boiled
- 11:58down to well, here's a story that I'm going to tell you
- 12:00about. These people have these
- 12:01problems. Here's how they solve them.
- 12:03Here's an example of somebody who.
- 12:05Had this issue and here's some statistics so you know I'm not
- 12:08just making this stuff up. Let's jump on to another
- 12:12question from Twitter, another really good one.
- 12:16This is from Carmen Hill, and I'll thank Carmen for asking
- 12:21this in advance because I was thinking of the same the same
- 12:24question, she says. I often get pushback from sales.
- 12:29Typically that storytelling is just marketing fluff.
- 12:34Especially in the context of sales emails, she wants to know.
- 12:40She wants an effective response to that pushback.
- 12:46I love the idea that's that sales people are saying, oh,
- 12:49this stuff is just marketing fluff.
- 12:51Well, where does sales come from?
- 12:53What's this? What's the raw material that
- 12:56they have? You know, it's all coming from
- 12:58the marketing department. So already it's like, OK, yes,
- 13:02you can complain and whine about that, but in the end, that's the
- 13:05truth. But take a look at what
- 13:09marketers typically do assemble for salespeople to use and
- 13:14among. All of the speeds and feeds and
- 13:19the the statistics and the product descriptions are case
- 13:24studies, very powerful. It's like, you know, here's how
- 13:28we helped General Motors to streamline its supply chain.
- 13:34Or here's how we used agile processes to enable this bank to
- 13:40respond to its customers 40% faster and.
- 13:44Those case studies matter because then the the person on
- 13:49the other end of the sales calls like, Oh well, if they help this
- 13:53bank, I wonder if they could help me.
- 13:55And if you have those stories, you can succeed.
- 13:58If you don't and the sales guy for your competitor does,
- 14:02they're more likely to succeed. So I I guess I'd go, I'm going
- 14:06to make an extreme statement here, which is that any
- 14:09salesperson who's not adept at telling.
- 14:13Stories about customer success is going to fail, because if you
- 14:18can't do that, there's no way the person on the other end of
- 14:21the phone or the other end of the e-mail is going to feel
- 14:23like, Oh yeah, this will work for me.
- 14:26I totally agree with that. I mean, even at the most basic
- 14:30level, explaining how customers are using whatever we sell to
- 14:38support. The the goals of of of these
- 14:43customers and audience and to describe audiences that are
- 14:47similar to the folks that you're selling to.
- 14:50Again, I think it comes down to having that empathy that you
- 14:54mentioned earlier because you really have to have a good sense
- 14:57of who am I speaking to and what kind of story will resonate with
- 15:01that person. One of the things I want to get
- 15:03at here is talk about ideas, because in the end.
- 15:10Companies that really grow and are really successful are based
- 15:13around an idea. And that idea might be that you
- 15:17know, design is really important in the design of computers.
- 15:20In the you know usage of computers.
- 15:22Or that idea might be you should be able to do everything that
- 15:26you need to do with this bank without ever going into a
- 15:28branch. And but the ideas are abstract.
- 15:34Ideas can be motivational. But until you.
- 15:38Actually reduce that to stories. It doesn't resonate.
- 15:42I mean chewy, right? The the pet food company, their
- 15:47idea might be we know more about pet owners and pets and what
- 15:53they need than anybody else. But you hear a story about how
- 15:58an owner says I need to send this product back because my dog
- 16:01died and then the next thing you hear is that they they they.
- 16:07Comped the product, told them to give it to the local shelter and
- 16:10send flowers to the person. That's what people remember.
- 16:14And they're like, Oh yeah, chewy really.
- 16:15Does actually understand pet owners.
- 16:18All of this begs the question of how do we put an effective story
- 16:24together? What are the components of a of
- 16:28a great story, An effective story?
- 16:31At one point when I was at, Forrester hired a guy named Doug
- 16:35Lipman. Who is a professional
- 16:37storyteller to come in and address the analysts and explain
- 16:43storytelling to them. So I want you to imagine this
- 16:45guy who was actually known for Yiddish stories standing up in
- 16:49front of a bunch of technology analysts and saying this is how
- 16:51stories work. But all of our research reports
- 16:55in the end were were stories. And what what I learned from him
- 16:59is that the essential things about stories are that they
- 17:03start with people. And the things are told in
- 17:06sequence. First this happened, then this
- 17:08happened, then this happened, then this happened, and then
- 17:10this other thing happened. And we're all trained in that
- 17:14from childhood by looking at, you know, hearing stories in
- 17:19books and and in, you know, video programs and so on.
- 17:24So the the sort of archetypal business story is this person
- 17:31had a problem. These are the This is why it was
- 17:34a problem for them. These are the things that they
- 17:36tried tried this. They tried this, they tried
- 17:39this. It has to be in sequence.
- 17:42And then you explain what the knowledge was that they gained
- 17:48and how that worked to succeed with them.
- 17:51And I'm going to tell you something that I learned from,
- 17:54from many years of writing business books, that if you
- 17:58start a chapter with a story like that.
- 18:02The people will always read from the beginning to the end of the
- 18:05story. They always want to know what
- 18:06happened. And then at the end of the
- 18:08story, you can say anything you want is the lesson of the story.
- 18:13And people will nod their heads be like, Oh yeah, yeah, that's
- 18:16right. That's how powerful it is.
- 18:19It's like, you know, and that's, that's how you get ideas to
- 18:22stick in people's brains. And yeah, you're going to back
- 18:25that up and say, well, here's some statistics and here's what
- 18:28an expert had to say. And you know, here's why other
- 18:32alternatives that you think of wouldn't work.
- 18:34But in the end, that story, plus the moral of the story is X is
- 18:38what sticks in people's brains. So the basic form Here's the
- 18:45situation, and here's why the situation is hard for whoever is
- 18:53the subject of the story. And here's.
- 18:58The way it need it can be solved in order to fix the problem and
- 19:04everything turned out. And here's the summary, here's
- 19:09the moral of the story, Is that the basic structure?
- 19:12It is. I'm going to mention one more
- 19:14thing, which is detail. So you know, when if you read
- 19:20about somebody in a fiction book, it's like, Oh yeah, she
- 19:23had long flowing hair and penetrating blue eyes.
- 19:27That doesn't belong in a business story.
- 19:29That because unless it's a story about shampoo, right?
- 19:33But but it does help to provide little details that make you
- 19:39empathize with the protagonist of the story.
- 19:44So I when I ghost wrote a story about Echostar the the the
- 19:53satellite television company. In one of the books that I wrote
- 19:57about artificial intelligence, the protagonist grew up in a in
- 20:03a Indian family that's that spoke Hindi and always watched
- 20:08Hindi television programs on satellite.
- 20:10So the fact that he would then grow up to go work for this
- 20:14satellite company becomes a little more interesting because
- 20:17of that. Now is his in general ethnic
- 20:21background is not going to matter but in his case it was
- 20:23like okay. Here's a little detail that
- 20:25matters. You don't read that and say,
- 20:27what was he tall or short? That doesn't matter.
- 20:31But but his the idea that satellite TV was really
- 20:35important to these, these people in ethnic families and that that
- 20:39would meant that he had to help the satellite TV company to be
- 20:42successful. That helped to make the story
- 20:44resonate. OK, we have another question.
- 20:46Arsalan Khan comes back again and he says, I know he asked
- 20:50good questions and sometimes they are complicated, so but
- 20:53that's good you have you know. Have to put our thinking caps on
- 20:56you. So Arsalan says there are
- 20:59different levels of storytelling.
- 21:01One is conveying your message to customers, another is conveying
- 21:04your message to employees. And yet another level is
- 21:08connecting these stories together for a holistic view.
- 21:13Are there other levels of storytelling?
- 21:15At one point I wrote a blog post about business books, and I
- 21:19basically said they're like the turtles and that fable.
- 21:22It's narratives all the way down.
- 21:24There's an overarching narrative.
- 21:26Each chapter is a narrative and within that they're that they're
- 21:29separate stories. So really at every level of
- 21:32detail it's like fractal stories.
- 21:35But these things all do have to come together.
- 21:38So if the story that you tell to customers is we're there for you
- 21:43no matter what time of day 24/7, we can be depended on.
- 21:48And the story that you're telling to employees is go ahead
- 21:51and knock off early on Friday, because we love you.
- 21:55Those stories don't connect up, do they?
- 21:57So you want to be able to inspire everybody with a common
- 22:02story and that's that's where you know, vision and purpose in
- 22:06companies comes together. And it's why the individual
- 22:10stories about customers or about problem solving.
- 22:17Connect up because they all align along that you know,
- 22:20whatever it is that that makes the company unique.
- 22:23Now I want to jump back to something you said earlier.
- 22:25You spoke earlier about case studies and of course many, most
- 22:31companies even write a variety of different case studies.
- 22:35You look on their website, you know we're great because of this
- 22:37and we're great because of that. What I see in many of these case
- 22:42studies is the. The study is not about the
- 22:48customer or we can even broaden this to marketing materials and
- 22:51marketing stories in general. It's not about the customer,
- 22:55it's about the company who's doing the selling.
- 23:00And so instead of having a customer talking, these case
- 23:04studies are really, you know, let me extend my arm so I can
- 23:08pat myself on the back and tell you how great we are.
- 23:12That's pathetic. All of us are.
- 23:14Programmed to be suspicious of marketing because we've been
- 23:18marketed too since we were small children.
- 23:21So the the more you talk about yourself, the the less effective
- 23:25it is. And I do think you're right.
- 23:27I read these cases I I recently did a ghost writing project
- 23:31where I had to take case studies that these these companies had
- 23:35posted on their site and turn them into stories for a book.
- 23:38And I was like, Oh well I need to interview this person because
- 23:42most of what I need is not here. If you read an actual Harvard
- 23:46Business School case that they use, you know that Harvard
- 23:49originated this at Harvard Business School.
- 23:52It starts with something like, you know, Ellen had only been
- 23:57the CEO for 41 days when this crisis happened and these things
- 24:01happen, and then she had to make this decision.
- 24:04You're like, OKI can put myself in the position of that
- 24:07protagonist and say, what would I do?
- 24:10What can we learn from this? And yet if you read the case
- 24:14studies that are published on people's websites, it's often
- 24:16hard to do that. So I'd I'd rather see things
- 24:20that that elevate the customer to the point where you can say,
- 24:23Oh yeah, that could be me as I I want to mention one other thing
- 24:27here, which is that, you know, there's all this anti woke talk
- 24:31here and people who are upset about diversity.
- 24:34But unless you have some diversity in your case studies.
- 24:39You are going to leave customers behind if all your case studies
- 24:45are about old white guys and there's a young black woman
- 24:48saying, I wonder if this product is right for me.
- 24:50It's an obstacle for her to say, Oh yeah, I guess I think just
- 24:54like these old white guys do. And I don't just mean ethnic
- 24:58diversity or gender diversity. I mean.
- 25:00Diverse industries, diverse situations.
- 25:03If you really want to hit all of your customers, then you're the
- 25:06stories you tell should be about a variety of different kinds of
- 25:09customers. But how do you overcome the
- 25:12issue that your marketing sort of takes inputs in and then
- 25:19regurgitates it out so that it's not about the customer, but it's
- 25:23about you as a company? This is endemic to technology
- 25:27companies and technology marketers.
- 25:30I don't even know why we're having this conversation.
- 25:32They companies that talk about how they help customers succeed
- 25:36and companies to talk about how great they are generally don't.
- 25:40And I it's really, really rare to see a company that that
- 25:47succeeds based only on one talking about itself.
- 25:51And I want to exempt Apple here. Apple's always the weirdo
- 25:56example that. That you shouldn't look at,
- 25:58because nobody can be like Apple, but if we put them aside,
- 26:01every other company on the planet succeeds because they
- 26:05talk about how they help customers.
- 26:07Well, the interesting thing to me about Apple is from a
- 26:12storytelling standpoint, you alluded to this earlier.
- 26:16It's all about the core message and the core set of values.
- 26:22And so everything, so the so the story therefore is everything.
- 26:26We produce, all these products, all these features.
- 26:29The only reason that we do this is because we are trying to make
- 26:34your lives better and come into our into our journey of helping
- 26:42you. There's probably better
- 26:45engineering inside of Apple than inside of any other hardware
- 26:50company you can think of. And yet that's not what they
- 26:52talk about, right? They're not saying, oh, we're
- 26:56four times faster than the other guys.
- 26:59They're saying look at this beautiful device you can hold in
- 27:02the palm of your hand that lets you do a thing you could never
- 27:04do before, lets you, the customer do a thing you could
- 27:07never do. Before, that's a very, very
- 27:10important point that you just mentioned because again most
- 27:15technology companies. Don't approach it that way.
- 27:19They approach their storytelling through features.
- 27:24Oh, our latest release now does this.
- 27:29Have you ever had Scott Brinker on this program from HubSpot?
- 27:32Oh, of course. I've known Scott for many years.
- 27:34OK. Yeah, so he makes these.
- 27:36Yes, Mr. Chief Mark on Chief, right, right.
- 27:40Yeah, so he makes these huge, huge charts of, like, the, the.
- 27:471962 companies that make marketing technology or the, you
- 27:53know, 270 companies that do artificial intelligence.
- 27:58And it's impossible to look at all the logos of all of those
- 28:02companies and say, oh, well, we're going to succeed because
- 28:08we are, you know, our we're 11% faster than than the other guy.
- 28:14No. Well, those companies in there,
- 28:15they only succeed to the extent that they tell us a better story
- 28:18than the other people is at that level of competition.
- 28:21That's the only thing that stands out.
- 28:23Okay, let's jump back to Twitter.
- 28:25We have a few more questions. This is from Chris Peterson and
- 28:30Chris says from your blog, Does a quote UN quote Malcolm
- 28:34function as a form of bottom line upfront communication that
- 28:41business folks seem to like? So you need to explain that for
- 28:43us. There recently was a blog post,
- 28:45I don't remember the guy's name, that wrote it.
- 28:48It was a post on Medium about these things called Malcolm's.
- 28:52So he was complaining that he was reading business books.
- 28:56And they they always have these chapters that start with a a
- 29:00story about somebody in the problem that they had which is
- 29:04called a Malcolm because Malcolm Gladwell is famous for for using
- 29:07these stories and that it's become this this trite thing.
- 29:13But. If you look closely at the stuff
- 29:17that he complained about, the problem is people who are using
- 29:21secondhand stories that have been told over and over and over
- 29:26again, you know, so you know the the the story about Dave Carroll
- 29:36and what United Airlines did when they broke his guitar, that
- 29:39was interesting in the beginning, how he got revenge by
- 29:42making a music video. But my God, we've all heard this
- 29:45story 100 Times Now. So if you start your chapter
- 29:49with that, it's like really you think that that's interesting.
- 29:52I've I've. I've already heard this.
- 29:54I. So I I think that that the idea
- 29:58of tracking down unique content, people who did things that have
- 30:05not been heard about before, and then actually telling their
- 30:09story in a way that connects up to the ideas that you're talking
- 30:11about. Is successful, and yeah, you can
- 30:14denigrate it and call it a Malcolm, but that's a way better
- 30:17way to start your chapters than it is to start your chapter with
- 30:20with a bunch of argumentation that puts people to sleep.
- 30:24So again, you're doing an emotional kind of grabbing them
- 30:30by their shirt, by the throat and pulling them closer.
- 30:35People want to hear stuff they haven't heard before.
- 30:38It's still successful and the fact that.
- 30:41I mean I think this the guy who wrote about this was writing
- 30:43mostly about economists writing stories about the economy and
- 30:48they don't have a whole lot of stories to draw on.
- 30:51So they go back and they they retell the story about how Harry
- 30:54Truman asked for A1 handed economist.
- 30:57So we wouldn't say on the one hand and on the other hand,
- 31:00right. Yeah, that was funny the first
- 31:03time I read it and it is sort of funny but.
- 31:06You can't really make the point that I have a unique perspective
- 31:10here if that's all you got, is that Hackney thing that
- 31:13everybody's heard before. If you want to present a unique
- 31:16perspective, then you actually have to have a unique
- 31:19perspective. Otherwise you're you're not
- 31:22presenting a unique perspective. We have a couple of other
- 31:25questions from Twitter. This is from Elizabeth Shaw who
- 31:30says assuming the story arc is important.
- 31:35How do you create a story arc and how can you use examples to
- 31:41serve that story arc? It's a really good question.
- 31:44When you talk about story arcs that relates to literature and
- 31:50television and movies where people have they, they have an
- 31:56ongoing growth. It's, you know, you look at the
- 32:00Joseph Campbell, you know, traditional hero's journey.
- 32:05They have to learn things along the way and have obstacles and,
- 32:10you know, have despair and then come out of the underworld and
- 32:13they have to have companions. And then at the end you're like,
- 32:16not only did they have a happy ending, but now they're smarter
- 32:20or more mature, or they finally realized that everything they
- 32:23needed was in themselves. And that's, that's wonderful if
- 32:26you were in Hollywood. But case study stories don't
- 32:30have an arc like that. Case study stories are, you
- 32:33know, you know, Alan I had was spending 25% of his time in his
- 32:41small business keeping track of expenses.
- 32:44And then he realized that he could use this, this product and
- 32:48now he now he can spend his time with his customers and he gets
- 32:51home in time to be able to read stories to his kid at bedtime.
- 32:56And that's not really a story arc, right?
- 32:59We don't know whether Alan is somehow realized something
- 33:02important about himself that he didn't know before.
- 33:05So no, we don't need, we don't need Hollywood level stories
- 33:09here. We really need something much
- 33:10simpler. You say that case studies,
- 33:14business stories, don't have a story arc.
- 33:17What do they have? OK, how do we, how do we decide
- 33:20what the flow should be? And if you could tell us that
- 33:23really quickly, that'd be great. What they have is a person who
- 33:26you can empathize with. That person has a problem and
- 33:31they have a method for solving that problem that shows why that
- 33:35method is new and works better versus something that that that
- 33:41maybe isn't. So I mean that's in the in the
- 33:44book that I wrote here. Believe it or not, this is 24
- 33:48chapters. It's got 24 case studies about
- 33:51authors. Each chapter starts with one.
- 33:53And that's because you can look at this and say, oh, how did
- 33:57this person get past writer block, writer's block?
- 34:00Oh, how did how did Charlene Lee actually differentiate her idea?
- 34:04What did the Laurie Gesner honing do that was so powerful
- 34:08in her book that one of the readers got the cover of the
- 34:12book tattooed on her arm? These these are things worth
- 34:16reading about but, you know, don't require investment in a
- 34:19huge story arc. So if I can summarize that the
- 34:22customer. Here's the case here.
- 34:24Here's the business story flow. Customer has a problem.
- 34:28Your method is solving the problem, the great outcome, and
- 34:32then a moral, A moral of the story.
- 34:35Yeah, and it would help in there if if we can talk about how
- 34:38other methods of solving the problem that they might have
- 34:40tried before it didn't work because you need a little bit of
- 34:43conflict, It's I can't resist saying this that.
- 34:48Occasionally I've I've interviewed people for a case
- 34:50study story and then somebody in PR says take out the bad parts.
- 34:53So your story then becomes they were happy and they tried this
- 34:57thing and then they were happy and that's not really a good
- 34:59story. Actually, thank you for that,
- 35:01because you know, we with CXO talk, we tell stories and.
- 35:11It's amazing to me sometimes that PR people want to sanitize
- 35:15it. So it's exactly as you said, you
- 35:16know, everybody was happy and then we got involved and they
- 35:20were still really happy. The end.
- 35:23That's that's not a story. Sorry.
- 35:25That's a sequence of words, but it's not a story.
- 35:28I love that. OK, another another question
- 35:32from Twitter. I'm just going down to find them
- 35:36here. Arsalan Khan, for the third
- 35:39time, comes back to the well. And he says what is the
- 35:43importance of storytelling in the for business IT alignment So
- 35:49and and you have any examples. Can you help CI O's chief
- 35:52information officers help them tell stories.
- 35:55Really, what it amounts to is that every business has a story
- 35:58at the heart of it of of how they solve problems.
- 36:01The marketing department typically tells that story, and
- 36:04I T needs to find ways to become a part of of the solution there.
- 36:09If the story of it is we block it when you're trying to help
- 36:13the customer, that doesn't work so well.
- 36:15So for if you can, at Forrester, they call this the Business
- 36:21Technology Officer, because your job is to provide technology
- 36:25that will help the business to solve a customer's problem.
- 36:29This is from Steve Eisenberg. This is a very specific one.
- 36:32We're going to test you on this one, Josh.
- 36:35Oh no. He says.
- 36:38What are the top three AI tools for B2B storytelling?
- 36:43AI tools are not good for storytelling because they say on
- 36:46the edges off and they do the generic thing that's like what
- 36:49everybody else is doing. So the best AI tool for
- 36:53storytelling is your own damn brain.
- 36:55Steve Eisenberg comes back and he says are you aware of a
- 36:58directory of mastermind group for different industries?
- 37:03And functions. Alternatively A mastermind group
- 37:06for B to be book authors. The first I don't know about,
- 37:11and there are there are groups for B to be book authors.
- 37:15I'd encourage people to actually contact me at Josh at Bernoff
- 37:19Calm and I'll make those connections because the reason
- 37:22that those groups work so well is because they carefully gate
- 37:26the people that go into them. And I can't just be sort of
- 37:29sending everybody into a group like that.
- 37:31Another question. Wow, from Steve Eisenberg again,
- 37:34he's like rivaling Arsalan Khan. Here he says Do you have any
- 37:39opinions about Amazon creating AI to write books and cut out
- 37:45the human author? That would be you.
- 37:47I don't want to read a book written by an AI because
- 37:50there's, let me tell you in one sentence, in one word, what AI
- 37:55authors don't have that humans have wit.
- 38:00OK, what is wit? Wit is knowing when to switch
- 38:04from one mode to another. Wit is humor.
- 38:07Wit is what makes human storytelling interesting.
- 38:10And if you read stuff that's written by AI, it doesn't have
- 38:14that. And so in general, people are
- 38:17just not going to be willing to settle for that.
- 38:19I use ChatGPT for various purposes all the time, and I
- 38:22asked ChatGPT to. Take something and write it in
- 38:27various very business dry and write it in various styles.
- 38:30You know, rap song in the style of Shakespeare, maybe in the
- 38:35style of Chaucer, and it's pretty darned funny.
- 38:40It's unintentionally funny. It's not trying to be funny.
- 38:43And that's the whole point, is that if you want to be
- 38:46imitative, if you want to write in the style of Chaucer, it's
- 38:50good at that. But that's not the originality
- 38:53that draws people to it. This is again from Carmen Hill,
- 38:57she says. Good question, thoughtful
- 38:59question here. One challenge in telling
- 39:03authentic, resonant customer stories is the reluctance of
- 39:07customers to share unvarnished details about their pain points
- 39:12and weaknesses. How do you handle that?
- 39:15Because nobody wants to present a bad face.
- 39:20They don't want to expose those weaknesses.
- 39:22If you have the confidence of a customer, if you've worked with
- 39:26them from beginning to end, you often can get them to admit that
- 39:30they had a problem in the beginning, which is what you
- 39:32need to do. And as long as there's a happy
- 39:35ending, you can do that. And sometimes there's not a
- 39:38happy ending. I've certainly done business
- 39:41stories where things ended badly.
- 39:43There are some in my book about authors that made terrible
- 39:46mistakes, but I don't identify people by name.
- 39:49We use pseudonyms because. Yeah, Nobody wants to have the
- 39:53story of how they've they ultimately failed be the thing
- 39:56that they're reading about. And you know, you don't need a
- 40:00whole lot of disaster stories. You only need one or two.
- 40:03And if those two are anonymized and everything else, as people
- 40:06mentioned by name, then you can do just fine.
- 40:08Can you distill down everything that you know and have
- 40:12experienced about storytelling into kind of capsule advice?
- 40:19For those of us in business who need to tell stories, and maybe
- 40:23we're not expert at it. Really at the center of that is
- 40:27empathy, and you help us to understand how somebody feels
- 40:32when something doesn't work, when something is a challenge.
- 40:36If you can do that and then make the connection to how your
- 40:40business makes a difference for them, then you will be
- 40:43successful. And if you can't do that, then
- 40:45you won't succeed. That's really interesting, so.
- 40:48At the very basic, at the most basic level, if you want to tell
- 40:54a successful story, you must establish an emotional
- 41:00connection with the audience, and that means understanding who
- 41:05your audience is and what they care about and what their pain
- 41:10points either are or like or are likely to be.
- 41:14Does that sound right? That's exactly right, and what
- 41:17you just described is also what makes the business successful.
- 41:20It's not just making us the storytelling successful, but
- 41:23understanding your customers pain points is pretty essential.
- 41:26Then I'm reminded of the phrase in Ted Lasso, which many people
- 41:33have seen on Apple, where one of the players says soccer is life,
- 41:38and according to what you just said, storytelling is business.
- 41:41OK. Sounds good to me.
- 41:44I think you're right. All right.
- 41:47And on that note, I, I want to say a huge thank you to Josh
- 41:52Bernoff. Josh, thank you so much for
- 41:54taking time and sharing your great expertise and storytelling
- 41:58with us today. I really, really appreciate it.
- 42:00Michael, what you do with CXO Talk is unique and excellent and
- 42:04just the ability to be a part of that is really means a lot to
- 42:08me. So I'm glad that you gave me the
- 42:10chance to be here. Well, thank you so much.
- 42:12I really appreciate that and everybody that watch, thank you
- 42:16for watching, especially those folks who ask such great
- 42:19questions. I always say this because it's
- 42:21really true. You're such an insightful and
- 42:24intelligent and thoughtful audience and your questions make
- 42:28CXO talk. Now before you go, please
- 42:32subscribe to our YouTube channel, hit the subscribe
- 42:36button, It's now at the bottom of our website.
- 42:39On now almost every page so you can subscribe to our newsletter
- 42:42so we can inform you of upcoming live shows.
- 42:46So you can participate and continue to ask your brilliant
- 42:50questions. Thanks so much everybody.
- 42:52We have amazing shows coming up. Check out cxotalk.com and we
- 42:55will see you again next time. Have a great day.
- 42:57Bye, bye.