Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Mind the Gap: A Tale of Two Exemptions
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Mind the Gap, A Tale of Two Exemptions.
- 0:07I'm Jennifer McNeil Lozano, co -chair of the
- 0:10BHBA's Trust and Estates Law section. Before
- 0:14we begin, I'd like to take a moment to introduce
- 0:16Brian Joy of the Sanborn team. Nancy and Brian
- 0:20of the Sanborn team have been the official sponsor
- 0:22of this section since 2006, 20 years. Brian,
- 0:27say hello. Thank you, Jennifer. Good afternoon,
- 0:30everyone. I want to give a quick update. From
- 0:32the probate and trust real estate market, one
- 0:35thing we're seeing right now is that buyers are
- 0:38still very interested in properties that need
- 0:40repair or updating. Actually, some of the strongest
- 0:43activity we're seeing is on homes that most people
- 0:46would consider fixer uppers. The difference is
- 0:49that today's buyers are very informed. They're
- 0:52looking at repair costs, insurance, interest
- 0:55rates, and renovation timelines before they make
- 0:58an offer. They're not afraid of the work. They
- 1:01just want to know the numbers make sense. What
- 1:05we're telling our sellers is that the market
- 1:07is still very active, but pricing matters more
- 1:10than ever. When a property is priced correctly,
- 1:12the buyers show up and compete. When it's overpriced,
- 1:16even a great property will sit. So despite what
- 1:19the headlines are saying, there's still plenty
- 1:21of buyers out there that they just want value.
- 1:24And when they see it, they're willing to act.
- 1:26Thank you, everybody, for your time. Enjoy the
- 1:28meeting. Thanks, Brian. Sure. In addition to
- 1:33the Sanborn team, the trust and estate section
- 1:37is also sponsored by Bond Services of California,
- 1:42Liberty Mutual Surety, California Title Company,
- 1:46and Pickford Escrow Company. Now I'd like to
- 1:50turn things over to Leah Momsios to provide this
- 1:53month's legal updates. Leah? Thank you, Jennifer.
- 1:57This month's legal update addresses the suspension
- 2:00of FinCEN's real estate reporting requirement.
- 2:04On March 19th, 2026, a federal judge in the Eastern
- 2:07District of Texas imposed an injunction against
- 2:10the enforcement of the Financial Crimes Enforcement
- 2:13Network's FinCEN's real estate reporting requirement
- 2:16created under the Corporate Transparency Act,
- 2:19which went into effect on December 1st, 2025.
- 2:22The federal judge held that Vinson's reporting
- 2:25requirement for certain non -financed real estate
- 2:28transactions involving a transfer to a trust
- 2:30and other entities exceeded the authority Congress
- 2:34granted Vinson under the Bank Secrecy Act. Vinson's
- 2:38compliance page notes that in light of the ruling,
- 2:41quote, reporting persons are not currently required
- 2:43to file real estate reports with Vinson and are
- 2:46not subject to liability if they fail to do so
- 2:49while the order remains in force, end quote.
- 2:52FinCEN has since appealed this ruling, but in
- 2:55the interim, practitioners are not currently
- 2:57required to file FinCEN reports for trust transfer
- 3:00deeds or for other real estate to entity transfers.
- 3:04That's your legal update for June 2026. Over
- 3:08to you, Rosita. Hi, I'm Rosita Yaakobi, Assistant
- 3:16Program Co -Chair of Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 3:19Trust and Estate Law Section. I'm delighted to
- 3:23introduce our speakers, Amy Takeuchi -Wanlas
- 3:26and Elizabeth Glasgow. Amy Takeuchi -Wanlas is
- 3:31a Senior Director of Family Office Planning at
- 3:35BMO Wealth Management, bringing over a decade
- 3:39of expertise in estate planning, tax advisory
- 3:43and complex wealth transfer strategies for individuals
- 3:48and families. Prior to joining BMO, she served
- 3:52as Senior Vice President and Senior Wealth Advisor
- 3:56at Northern Trust and as a Senior Wealth Planner
- 4:01at Wells Fargo Private Bank. And earlier in her
- 4:05career, she practiced as a trust and estate attorney
- 4:09at nationally recognized law firms, including
- 4:13Venable LLP and Mitchell, Silverberg and Knott.
- 4:17LLP. Amy holds a JD from UCLA School of Law and
- 4:23a BA in history and theater from UC Davis and
- 4:27is a member of the California State Park. Elizabeth
- 4:32Glasgow is a partner at Butchelter and national
- 4:38co -chair of the Trust and Estate Group where
- 4:42she advises ultra -high net worth individuals.
- 4:45families and entrepreneurs on complex wealth
- 4:50transfer strategies, tax minimization, business
- 4:54succession planning and charitable gift structures.
- 4:59A fellow of the American College of Trust and
- 5:02a State Council, Elizabeth is consistently recognized
- 5:06as a leading authority in her field, having been
- 5:10repeatedly ranked as a top California attorney
- 5:14by Chambers High Net Worth and honored nationally
- 5:19by the best lawyers in America. She's a sought
- 5:23after lecturer on complex wealth transfer and
- 5:27tax strategies, with recent presentations at
- 5:31the American Bar Association, the USC Tax Institute,
- 5:36and the National Association of Estate Planning
- 5:39Councils. And now let's get started. And most
- 5:44importantly, the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 5:49Thank you, everyone, for having us here today.
- 5:52Amy and I are really excited to bring this presentation.
- 5:54We'll be asking for the slides to be advanced,
- 5:58but we're delighted to kick it off. Thanks, everyone.
- 6:01Today, we're going to talk about estate gift
- 6:04and GST tax planning in a post -OBBBA era. And
- 6:08we're using a simple idea as our framework, which
- 6:11is mind the gap. Now, many of you have probably
- 6:13heard that phrase before on the London Underground,
- 6:15and you're thinking, what does that have to do
- 6:17with estate planning in the United States? Well,
- 6:20really, it's just a fun way to remind us to be
- 6:22mindful of the mismatch that can sometimes occur
- 6:25between an individual's lifetime exemption amount,
- 6:28gift and estate tax exemption amount, and their
- 6:30generation skipping transfer tax amount. So our
- 6:34goal today is to make that gap more visible,
- 6:36to walk through where it comes from, where it
- 6:38tends to show up in planning, and how to address
- 6:40it when a gap does appear. So the first slide
- 6:44here is our journey today. It's our route map
- 6:46that we hope to cover with this presentation.
- 6:49So we'll start with a short reminder of where
- 6:52we started prior to OBBBA and then move on to
- 6:56post -OBBBA and the new $15 million permanent
- 7:00exemption. From there, we'll do a bit of a deeper
- 7:03dive into GST generally and the various allocation
- 7:06rules. And then we'll look at some common scenarios
- 7:09that tend to create that gap between the estate
- 7:11and gift versus GST. After that, we'll work through
- 7:15some planning opportunities to shorten that gap
- 7:18during life. And if that's not possible, then
- 7:21look at some post -death opportunities to address
- 7:23the gap. And finally, we'll take a look at a
- 7:26practical checklist and some takeaways. So while
- 7:29OBVBA gave us more certainty with exemption amounts,
- 7:32it certainly didn't eliminate the complexity
- 7:35regarding potential mismatches between estate
- 7:37and gift and GST. So the train schedule may be
- 7:41clearer, but there are definitely some still
- 7:43missed connections. And today we hope to illuminate
- 7:46some ways to fix some of those missed connections.
- 7:49So next slide, please. We're gonna look at the
- 7:53pre -OBBBA landscape. So in 2017, we know that
- 7:57the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act gave clients a significantly
- 8:00increased exemption, but that did come with an
- 8:03expiration date. And we know that expiration
- 8:06date shaped behavior. It created urgency, it
- 8:09pushed clients and advisors towards rapid gifting
- 8:12strategies. And when planning is done under pressure,
- 8:16some of the first things to get lost are often
- 8:18the most technical items, things like GST allocation,
- 8:21inclusion ratios, and whether or not a trust
- 8:24is actually GST exempt. So this slide, we're
- 8:28just looking at a little bit of where we started
- 8:30with, with the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. So in 2017,
- 8:35the exemption was at about $5 .49 million. And
- 8:38then we know Tax Cuts and Jobs Act increased
- 8:40that. So by 2018, that exemption had doubled
- 8:44to about $11 .18 million. By 2025, we were up
- 8:49to $14 million, basically. But everyone knew
- 8:53that under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, we were
- 8:56looking at a potential drop starting in 2026.
- 8:59And that would have been cutting the exemption
- 9:02somewhere back to around $7 .1 million. And this
- 9:06is the time period we remember as the use it
- 9:08or lose it environment. So clients were funding
- 9:11slats. dynasty trust, digits, and other structures
- 9:14really quickly. And in many cases, that was definitely
- 9:17an appropriate planning technique. But now that
- 9:20we no longer have that looming threat of a sunsetting
- 9:23exemption, there's definitely time now to sort
- 9:26of look thoughtfully at clients' estate plans
- 9:28and see where the estate gift GST exemption mismatch
- 9:32may currently exist in their plans and explore
- 9:35ways to close that gap. So Elizabeth is now going
- 9:39to take us through our post -OBBBA landscape
- 9:42and what we're looking at currently. And this
- 9:47really was sort of a day of independence for
- 9:51all of us in the estate planning world. July
- 9:534th, 2025, with the adoption of the One Big Beautiful
- 9:57Bill Act is that the opportunity became available
- 10:01for us to calm down. We had lived through a number
- 10:04of sunset fears up until this point. And as Amy
- 10:08was saying, clients were probably getting pretty
- 10:10tired of us saying that the sky is falling and
- 10:12the exemption is about to change and we have
- 10:14to hurry up and do something. So now that we're
- 10:17in the new environment starting January 1st of
- 10:20this year, we have this nice round $15 million
- 10:24exemption. This is one of my favorite parts of
- 10:27the new law is that I'm not trying to constantly
- 10:30tell clients that these very specific non -round
- 10:33numbers and get them to remember it, 15 million
- 10:35just rolls right off the tongue. We have continued
- 10:38the doubling of those transfer tax exemptions
- 10:41available for married couples. So we have almost
- 10:44$30 million, or not almost, around $30 million
- 10:47exactly of an amount of exemption that couples
- 10:50can utilize. And as Amy said, we're not dealing
- 10:53with sunset anymore. This has been a tremendous
- 10:56relief to myself and I'm sure all of us to be
- 10:59able to speak with clients in a more calm environment
- 11:01and really evaluate future planning that they'd
- 11:04like to do without necessarily that rushing deadline.
- 11:08We are looking for unfortunately the end of that
- 11:12nice round 15 million dollar number starting
- 11:14next year when we will see the annual index for
- 11:17inflation on the 15 million dollar transfer tax
- 11:20exemptions. Who knows what that will necessarily
- 11:23look like, but it will be tagged going up from
- 11:2615 million starting in January 1st of 2027. Two
- 11:31of the major things that have not changed from
- 11:34the prior rules is that we continue to have our
- 11:37annual exclusion gift amount that has stayed
- 11:39at the $19 ,000 number. Although I anticipate,
- 11:44I suspect we all think that with the inflation
- 11:46adjustment of that number next year that we will
- 11:48creep over into $20 ,000 for annual exclusion
- 11:52amount for gift recipients. And the transfer
- 11:55tax rates remained unchanged. So across gift,
- 11:58estate, and GST tax, we continue to have a 40
- 12:02% tax rate. Next slide, please. The changes are
- 12:10very beneficial, but what we didn't see change
- 12:13were some of the major topics that we'll discuss
- 12:16during the presentation that relate to how it
- 12:19is that these exemptions operate in coordination
- 12:22or lack of coordination with each other. So items
- 12:26that are still on the platform that can cause
- 12:29gaps are the automatic generation skipping. transfer
- 12:33tax exemption allocation rules. These can be
- 12:36traps for the unwary as a mechanism to try to
- 12:40help taxpayers by applying GST tax exemption,
- 12:43but it may not always be as thoughtfully done
- 12:46as we would like it to be. We still have that
- 12:50the GST tax exemption is not portable between
- 12:53spouses, so there's still an opportunity for
- 12:56one of the tax exemptions to be lost. We've also
- 12:59got a continuation still these current rules
- 13:03that the 706 filing rules for clients that do
- 13:07want to take advantage of the portability of
- 13:09the estate tax exemption, that process and procedure
- 13:13still exists the same way. That's unchanged.
- 13:15As I mentioned, the rates remain unchanged. And
- 13:19one thing that we don't necessarily think a lot
- 13:22of here in California, but to be mindful of because
- 13:25clients may have assets in other jurisdictions,
- 13:28or you may be working with someone who's relocating,
- 13:31state -to -state taxes are not affected by this.
- 13:34This change in the law with the OBBA was a federal
- 13:39change. So we're going to review, just quickly
- 13:42at the end, some of the state tax considerations
- 13:45that are still present. Next slide, please. This
- 13:50slide, honestly, we just threw it in because
- 13:52I think it's so remarkable to see how tremendous
- 13:56the exemptions have changed. We mentioned the
- 13:59idea that the estate and gift versus the GST
- 14:02tax exemptions are uncoupled, meaning that although
- 14:05they happen to be the same amounts in this period
- 14:07of time and have been increasing at the same
- 14:10rate, they are uncoupled in the sense that they
- 14:13are used independently. an opportunity to use
- 14:17one does not necessarily mean that you have to
- 14:19use the other. And that's what we're going to
- 14:21be predominantly talking about today. But I love
- 14:23looking at this to appreciate that in such a
- 14:26short, dramatic timeframe of just 10 years, we've
- 14:29seen an almost tripling of these transfer tax
- 14:32exemptions. And it's really remarkable to think
- 14:34we can see that degree of change in such a short
- 14:36time. And so to some extent, as we appreciate
- 14:41now at the far end of the diagram that we have,
- 14:45$15 million in exemptions or $30 million for
- 14:48a married couple. To some degree, that may make
- 14:52this presentation less interesting. Maybe I shouldn't
- 14:55spoil that at the beginning. But for all of us
- 14:57who are aware that with exemptions being so large,
- 15:00the vast, vast majority of taxpayers are able
- 15:05to do all of the planning that they're interested
- 15:07in doing. well within that exemption, potentially
- 15:10well within just one family member's exemption,
- 15:13not even needing a spouse's exemption to do the
- 15:17kind of transfers that they're able to do with
- 15:19their net worth. So to kind of focus on the topic
- 15:23for today, which is times where we are seeing
- 15:25exemptions varied from each other, where we're
- 15:28going to talk about planning opportunities for
- 15:32utilizing kind of the mismatch between the two
- 15:34exemptions, this is very much for a select client
- 15:38audience, right? This is not every taxpayer.
- 15:41These are taxpayers with a net worth at least
- 15:45at, if not in excess of these exemptions so that
- 15:49the fact that these mismatches are occurring
- 15:52is something that's relevant to them that they
- 15:53want to pay attention to or resolve if they have
- 15:57an existing. mismatch. So we just want to put
- 16:00that in context that, you know, this is not necessarily
- 16:03a topic that will be motivating for all of your
- 16:06clients, but still for those who are at a net
- 16:08worth size where this is relevant, we really
- 16:10want to pay attention to the fact that the exemptions
- 16:13can be decoupled. Next slide, please. So Amy,
- 16:19do a quick review for us of, you know, just GST
- 16:22tax world in a little bit so that we can talk
- 16:25more fully about some of the variations. Yes,
- 16:28now we arrive at the fun transfer tax planning
- 16:31technical side. So we're going to look at the
- 16:34different types of GST transfers, a reminder
- 16:36about inclusion ratios, and looking at the automatic
- 16:40allocation rule. So there are three types of
- 16:43GST transfers that are important to identify
- 16:46at the outset. And just as a reminder, as a level
- 16:48set, a skip person is generally an individual
- 16:52who is a generation at least two levels below
- 16:55the transferor. So most commonly, we're looking
- 16:58at a grandchild here. And the first category
- 17:02of transfer is what is known as a direct skip.
- 17:05So it's a transfer made directly to a skip person
- 17:08either during life or at death. You know, again,
- 17:12that straightforward example is outright gift
- 17:14from a grandparent to a grandchild. I was going
- 17:20to say, I think Elizabeth has a little bit more
- 17:22she wants to expand upon on that point. So one
- 17:26of the notes that we've made about direct skips
- 17:28is that we also have circumstances where a trust
- 17:32itself can be the recipient of a direct skip
- 17:35transfer. So if the trust is only benefiting
- 17:39skip persons, this is a scenario where the transfer
- 17:43itself will be a direct skip for GST tax purposes.
- 17:49There's a variation on that, though, that I want
- 17:51to spend just a minute talking about before we
- 17:53move on to the other types of GST transfers.
- 17:56And that's to be thoughtful about how a trust
- 17:59is structured for not necessarily the application
- 18:03of the GST exemption, the larger $15 million
- 18:08lifetime exemption, but to question whether or
- 18:10not the trust might be structured in a way that
- 18:13could use the smaller GST annual exclusion exemption.
- 18:17So among the other rules that didn't change with
- 18:20the new law is how the annual exclusion gifts
- 18:23work. I mentioned that they are both still at
- 18:26the $19 ,000 annual exclusion amount and how
- 18:29that exclusion is applied to either the gift
- 18:32tax concept or the GST circumstance has also
- 18:36remained the same. And we all know that in lifetime
- 18:40gifting for gifts to a trust, the ability to
- 18:44utilize an annual exclusion benefit in a trust
- 18:46requires a beneficiary to have a present interest,
- 18:49a withdrawal rate. Fairly straightforward, we
- 18:52see that quite often. It's a little bit of a
- 18:55different rule, in fact, much stricter rule for
- 18:58utilizing a GST annual exclusion. We have the
- 19:01same concept of an annual exclusion, so a gift
- 19:04directly to a grandchild, to another skip person,
- 19:07can use the same $19 ,000 annual exclusion. It's
- 19:11made to a gift in trust, though. The annual exclusion
- 19:14rules are much stricter for the GST tax annual
- 19:17exclusion, specifically the idea under Section
- 19:212642C that the The nature of the trust is very
- 19:25important. We still need to have that present
- 19:27interest withdrawal right, but the trust itself
- 19:30has to have certain characteristics. It has to
- 19:32be only for the benefit of that skip person beneficiary.
- 19:36It must require that they receive all of the
- 19:38trust during their lifetime, or if they've not
- 19:41received all of the trust assets during their
- 19:42lifetime, that the trust assets are includeable
- 19:45in their estate for generally through a general
- 19:48power of appointment. And so this special rules
- 19:51around GST annual exclusion we're going to come
- 19:53back to, but I just want to mention them in the
- 19:55direct skip context, because a trust itself may
- 19:59be a direct skip recipient, even though internally
- 20:03within the trust, the annual exclusion GST tax
- 20:06rules may not apply. Thanks, Elizabeth. So continuing
- 20:11on on the types of GST transfers, another category
- 20:20would be a taxable distribution. And so this
- 20:22arises when a trust has both skipped and non
- 20:26-skip beneficiaries. And then a distribution
- 20:28is made to a skip person. So in that case, the
- 20:32tax consequence depends on not necessarily a
- 20:35new allocation of GST at the time of the distribution,
- 20:38but on that trust's existing inclusion ratio,
- 20:41so how much GST was already allocated to that
- 20:44trust. And then finally, the third category is
- 20:47a taxable termination. And these occur when the
- 20:51non -skip interests in a trust terminate. So
- 20:54that at that point, the only beneficiaries of
- 20:56these trusts are skip persons. And again, the
- 20:59tax result turns on the trust's inclusion ratio.
- 21:03So if the trust isn't fully GST exempt, the GST
- 21:06tax would be imposed at that point. OK, now moving
- 21:10on to inclusion ratios on the next slide. So
- 21:15an inclusion ratio tells us how exposed a trust
- 21:19is to GST tax. So over here on, well, it's my
- 21:23left -hand side, the green side, an inclusion
- 21:26ratio of zero means that the trust is fully exempt.
- 21:30And typically that's our goal, you know, no GST
- 21:33on future distributions to skip persons. An inclusion
- 21:37ratio of one over here on the right -hand side
- 21:39in red means that the trust is fully exposed.
- 21:43So every taxable distribution or termination
- 21:45is subject to GST at the applicable rate, which
- 21:48we all know is currently 40%. So this can happen
- 21:52for a number of reasons. Maybe it's a trust that
- 21:55for some reason the grantor's affirmatively elected
- 21:58out of GST allocation. So these trusts do exist
- 22:02and at least GST taxation of these trusts is
- 22:05fairly straightforward. Now I would say the more
- 22:08annoying trust is the one with a mixed inclusion
- 22:11ratio and that's the one in the middle. So just
- 22:13quickly going off the example on our slide is
- 22:17let's assume you know, grantors have allocated
- 22:20$500 ,000 of GST tax exemption to a trust, but
- 22:25maybe the return is filed late and the trust's
- 22:27fair market value at the actual time of allocation
- 22:30is now $600 ,000. So that would produce an inclusion
- 22:34ratio of approximately 0 .167. And what that
- 22:38effectively means is that 16 .7 % of future distributions
- 22:44from the trust will be subject to that GST tax
- 22:47at 40%. And this is why partial inclusion ratios
- 22:52are so problematic. They can be easy to overlook,
- 22:55but they create really annoying ongoing complexity
- 22:58and recurring transfer tax exposure. And a lot
- 23:02of times these aren't created intentionally.
- 23:04They result from late allocations, missed elections,
- 23:08valuation changes, or et cetera. There are definitely
- 23:12ways we can alleviate this. Sometimes we'll look
- 23:14at doing a qualified severance and split that
- 23:17mixed ratio trust into two separate trusts. So
- 23:20one is going to be fully GST exempt and the other
- 23:23one fully non -exempt. But the basic takeaway
- 23:26from this is that for any trust that can benefit
- 23:31skip persons, the inclusion ratio should definitely
- 23:33be calculated, confirmed, and documented, hopefully.
- 23:38Because without that analysis, it's difficult
- 23:40to sometimes know whether that trust is GST exempt
- 23:43or if it only appears to be. Moving on to the
- 23:48next slide of automatic allocation. So the automatic
- 23:52allocation rules were initially designed to help
- 23:55taxpayers, but I think sometimes they also create
- 23:58a lot of chaos. So for direct skips, automatic
- 24:03allocation is generally on. outright gifts to
- 24:06skip persons, including many annual outright
- 24:09exclusion gifts, GST exemption can be automatically
- 24:13allocated. For indirect skips, like transfers
- 24:17to trusts that may benefit skip persons, automatic
- 24:21allocation is also generally on, unless the donor
- 24:24affirmatively opts out. Now, this can be helpful,
- 24:28but the automatic allocation can sometimes waste
- 24:31GST exemption on a trust that may never actually
- 24:34benefit skip persons, or maybe it's a trust that
- 24:37holds assets that might not appreciate as much
- 24:39as assets in a different trust that the grantor
- 24:42may want to create in the future. Another automatic
- 24:46allocation we have to think about is when we
- 24:48have Q -tip trusts. And actually, automatic allocation
- 24:52is generally off on these unless... a reverse
- 24:56Q -tip election is made. Otherwise, the decedent's
- 25:00GST exemption can be lost because the surviving
- 25:03spouse actually becomes the transferor for GST
- 25:05purposes. And finally, we have a nine -month
- 25:09post -death issue. So if no GST transfer occurs
- 25:12within the relevant period, automatic allocation
- 25:14may not save the plan. So I think the big message
- 25:18is automatic doesn't mean optimal. Automatic
- 25:22doesn't mean thoughtful. And it definitely doesn't
- 25:24mean that the IRS has kindly handled this for
- 25:26us. So now that we have a bit of a background
- 25:30on GST tax or generally, we're going to start
- 25:32looking at some common scenarios where a mismatch
- 25:35occurs between gift and estate versus GST exemptions.
- 25:40Next slide, please. So creating the gap, even
- 25:48just talking about how complex these rules are,
- 25:50it becomes pretty apparent that the gap creation
- 25:53can happen quite unintentionally. So if we go
- 25:56to the next slide, we'll kind of walk through
- 25:58how the gaps are being created. And we want to
- 26:00spend time focusing on this because when we sort
- 26:04of get to the tail end of the presentation talking
- 26:06about how to merge the gap back together and
- 26:10kind of reclaim disconnects and exemption, many
- 26:14of the things that may have caused the exemption
- 26:16unintentionally can now be utilized. purposefully
- 26:20to cause the gap to come back together. So we're
- 26:22gonna spend a little bit of time really going
- 26:24into detail on how the exemption gaps are created
- 26:27in the first place. And we'll start first with
- 26:30the idea of a circumstance where a client has
- 26:33more GST tax exemption than they have of a state
- 26:36and gift tax exemption. And this is sort of the
- 26:40low -hanging fruit of this discussion because
- 26:42it's something I think every single one of us
- 26:44has experienced. A client comes in, you know,
- 26:47for a first meeting and in the process of onboarding,
- 26:50you learn more about their history of gifting,
- 26:52which has included a number of, you know, generous
- 26:55gifts to children, non -skip people. And, you
- 27:00know, they're very proud of these gifts and it's...
- 27:02And it is wonderful and generous of them to have
- 27:04done so. But by definition, having made these
- 27:07gifts directly to non -skipped people, they didn't
- 27:09need to utilize any of their GST tax exemptions
- 27:13to protect those gifts from transfer tax. And
- 27:15so right off the bat, you're already working
- 27:17with a client where we have a disconnect. That
- 27:20is not to say that this disconnect is problematic.
- 27:22I'm sure their children are very grateful for
- 27:24those gifts that were made. But it has, from
- 27:27day one, put you in a circumstance of seeing
- 27:29this discrepancy. So, you know, an easy one to
- 27:33start off with just to explain this is one of
- 27:35the first and most often ways that we start to
- 27:38see this particular mismatch. And another common
- 27:42way that we see more often now too is, you know,
- 27:44with the advent of portability, a lot of clients
- 27:48do have what are, you know, what I would call
- 27:50a portability only plan. So let's assume the
- 27:53first spouse dies, they leave everything either
- 27:55outright to the surviving spouse or all to the
- 27:58survivor's trust. And from an estate tax perspective,
- 28:01that may seem entirely reasonable. If a timely
- 28:04706 is filed, the deceased spouse's unused estate
- 28:08tax exemption can be preserved through portability
- 28:10and carried over to the surviving spouse as DSU.
- 28:14The problem with that is that GST exemption doesn't
- 28:17work the same way, unfortunately. As we all know,
- 28:19it is not portable. So it doesn't transfer to
- 28:23the surviving spouse just because an estate tax
- 28:25return is filed and it doesn't survive indefinitely.
- 28:29indefinitely if it's not affirmatively used.
- 28:32So that's oftentimes how we see a mismatch. The
- 28:36surviving spouse now has a substantial estate
- 28:39tax exemption available, but they only have their
- 28:43own GST exemption remaining available for planning.
- 28:47And I see that a lot when surviving spouses come
- 28:50in and they want to now create structures for
- 28:54grandchildren, et cetera. And at that point,
- 28:58everyone assumes, oh, we've preserved all of
- 29:00the exemption. But unfortunately, in reality,
- 29:04we've only preserved the estate tax exemption.
- 29:07So the GST side was not preserved. So that's
- 29:11another very common way that I see the mismatch
- 29:14between GST and estate and gifts. And in a perfect
- 29:19illustration that this presentation was actually
- 29:21prepared by Amy and myself and not by AI, please
- 29:25note that that wonderful description that Amy
- 29:27just gave is meant to be on the other side of
- 29:29the chart because it is the circumstance of the
- 29:32estate and gift tax exemption being larger than
- 29:35the GST tax exemption. And so nothing is perfect.
- 29:40So continuing on on the blue side for talking
- 29:44about GST tax exemptions that are bigger than
- 29:47a client's available estate and gift tax exemption.
- 29:50We actually also have a purposeful time where
- 29:54you may be wanting to create this exemption mismatch.
- 29:58And this deals with late allocation of GST. So
- 30:02we're familiar with the idea for gifts made into
- 30:05a trust that the GST tax exemption can be applied
- 30:09at the time the gift is essentially made on a
- 30:12timely filed gift tax return. But there is an
- 30:15opportunity that you can be attentive to in terms
- 30:19of what has happened to the value of that gift
- 30:23in the intervening time since the gift was made.
- 30:26Now this part would not be intentional, but if
- 30:29the assets have unfortunately depleted in value
- 30:32substantially, so a promising gift has not really
- 30:35come to fruition, and unfortunately now in the
- 30:38following tax year as it's time to file the gift
- 30:42tax return, it becomes apparent that there's
- 30:44been a substantial decrease in value, a lot of
- 30:47volatility, whatever it is that has now put the
- 30:50client in sort of a remorseful position that,
- 30:52you know, they have used essentially their gift
- 30:55tax in making this transfer, and it may not turn
- 30:59out to be as successful as they thought it would
- 31:02be. So in this circumstance, there may be an
- 31:06opportunity by doing a strategic plan to opt
- 31:10out of GST, make a purposeful decision not to
- 31:14apply GST to a trust recipient, and then choose
- 31:17to do what's called a late allocation of GST.
- 31:20Late allocation means that after having concluded
- 31:23the period for timely filing a GST allocation,
- 31:27you then at that point in time file essentially
- 31:30a supplemental gift tax return applying GST allocation
- 31:34as of the value of the assets inside the trust.
- 31:39at that time of the filing. Why this kind of
- 31:42works for a trust that has been funded in the
- 31:45prior year with assets that have depleted in
- 31:47value is that if the original gift was a million
- 31:51dollar gift into a trust, unfortunately, it's
- 31:54worth only $600 ,000, say, in April or October
- 31:58of the following year. The decision could be
- 32:02to say, let's affirmatively not apply the million
- 32:05dollars of GST tax exemption that otherwise would
- 32:08be necessary and do a purposeful late allocation
- 32:11at a time point where we think. Hopefully this
- 32:15will not hit rock bottom, but will be some period
- 32:18of time less. And at that point, use only the
- 32:21GST tax exemption that's necessary to cover the
- 32:24gift at that time. Now, obviously this is a difficult
- 32:28conversation to have with clients. They're probably
- 32:30already pretty upset that the asset has declined
- 32:33in value, but it is something to let them know
- 32:36that we're doing everything we can to kind of
- 32:38preserve the exemptions that they do have. Knowing
- 32:41exactly when to make that late, though is difficult.
- 32:46On the one hand, once you've introduced the concept
- 32:48of timing, of course the client may be trying
- 32:51to think about when would be the ideal time to
- 32:54make this supplemental now late GST allocation.
- 32:59trying to identify that perfect moment where
- 33:02it will be as low as possible to use the least
- 33:05amount of their GST. This would, of course, result
- 33:08in them having much more GST tax allocation remaining
- 33:11to them than they do of their estate and gift.
- 33:15One word of warning with this transaction, though,
- 33:18is that it does have to be very carefully timed,
- 33:21not just timed from the perspective of what the
- 33:24value or decreased value of the asset is now
- 33:27that it's inside the trust, but also considering
- 33:30what does it mean to be filing a late allocation
- 33:34of GST after the conclusion of the time period
- 33:38for filing a timely gift tax return. You have
- 33:41to first file your timely gift tax return to
- 33:44have before you can then subsequently file late
- 33:48where I've unfortunately had a client who ended
- 33:51up in a. bit of a pickle on something like this
- 33:54is our new, frankly, world that we live in with
- 33:57the frequency that we see disaster extensions,
- 34:00major weather patterns that are establishing
- 34:03IRS timelines where the traditional April and
- 34:06October deadlines that we're used to may not
- 34:09apply. So if you're ever in a circumstance with
- 34:12a client considering this technique to kind of
- 34:14purposely create this mismatch, be very clear
- 34:17that you understand, you know, where your client
- 34:19is located and physically. where they're filing
- 34:22and using an address to report their gift tax
- 34:25returns because it may be that they have an extension
- 34:28towards another period of time months later.
- 34:31You have to let the entirety of that timely filing
- 34:34run out before you can make the late GST tax
- 34:38allocation. But Amy, walk us through one of the
- 34:41other times that we're seeing more GST than a
- 34:43state and gift available after we've created
- 34:47the gap. Yeah, so from the state and gift tax
- 34:51perspective, we usually talk about zeroed out
- 34:53GRATs that use none of a grantor's estate and
- 34:56gift tax exemption. But GRATs can actually be
- 34:59structured so that they're not fully zeroed out.
- 35:01Maybe they do use some of that grantor's gift
- 35:04exemption. But because of that, if the tax inclusion
- 35:08period or the ETIP rules, GST exemption generally
- 35:12can't be effectively allocated to a GRAT. while
- 35:15that GRAT is still making annuity payments back
- 35:18to the grantor. So in other words, the donor
- 35:22can create the GRAT today, but they can't lock
- 35:24in that GST exemption to shelter that remainder
- 35:27trust during the GRAT term. And so that's where
- 35:30we can see the mismatch occur. A grantor has
- 35:33used at least some gift tax exemption to create
- 35:36that GRAT, but there's no GST allocated to that
- 35:39gift at the time of the funding of the GRAT.
- 35:41So effectively, this leaves a grantor with more
- 35:44GST exemption than their estate or gift tax exemption.
- 35:49So flipping now to look at the exemption gaps
- 35:53on the other side, where the estate and gift
- 35:55exemption is the larger of the two, how is it
- 35:58that this has come about? And this may seem like
- 36:02a silly point to talk about, but it actually
- 36:04was the kind of seed of this entire presentation
- 36:07idea. And this is the crummy trust. So in crummy
- 36:10trust, as we talked about earlier with annual
- 36:13exclusion rights, you have individuals who are
- 36:16you know, have a present interest rate of withdrawal
- 36:19that allows annual exclusion gifts to protect
- 36:22from transfer taxes, gifts that are coming into
- 36:25this trust. But as I discussed earlier under
- 36:282642C, to be able to utilize annual exclusion
- 36:32gift rights, the style of trust has to be very
- 36:35specific. And it's, you know, not really the
- 36:37style of trust that we're seeing for most of
- 36:39our life insurance trusts and, you know, traditional
- 36:42slats and gift trusts. And so why this becomes
- 36:46really important is that a client who may be
- 36:49believing in funding, you know, a somewhat routine
- 36:52life insurance trust, for example, if they think,
- 36:55oh, I'm only ever giving gifts of the annual
- 36:58exclusion amount, my two exemptions remain. you
- 37:01know, aligned. And that may not be the case if
- 37:05there have been the structure of that recipient
- 37:08trust is such that either the client is subject
- 37:12to automatic allocation rules as a trust that
- 37:14has, you know, potential skip beneficiary members,
- 37:17or if it is a trust that the client is voluntarily
- 37:20applying GST tax exemption to. In both cases,
- 37:24though, because of that mismatch and how the
- 37:27annual exclusion gift rules work, we will see
- 37:30a mismatch in exemption where the GST tax exemption
- 37:34is going to be reduced more in the funding of
- 37:38those gifts. Now, again, in the sort of new environment
- 37:41where exemptions are so high, the first reaction
- 37:44might be, okay. these types of trusts, a crummy
- 37:47trust now, maybe they're a little leaky. Yes,
- 37:49they're using a little bit more GST tax exemption
- 37:52than a state and gift, but who really cares?
- 37:5515 million is a pretty big number. And that may
- 37:58be true. And perhaps clients with families of
- 38:01a certain side or have structured their trust
- 38:03with a certain number of beneficiaries, they
- 38:05may feel that that's an acceptable degree of
- 38:07mismatch that they're going to take. But I always
- 38:10kind of think back to a particular case, I think
- 38:12it's almost 10 years old now, a tax court memorandum
- 38:16case called the Mikkel case. And it always stuck
- 38:19with me because of how just substantial it was.
- 38:23And it was a life insurance trust that was at
- 38:26issue that had 60 withdrawal rate beneficiaries.
- 38:30And when you think about that trust, if it's
- 38:32still in operation today, essentially, they'd
- 38:35be transferring every year about $1 .1 million
- 38:39of value, assuming even that it's not gift split,
- 38:43a single donor transferring almost a million
- 38:46dollars in value through annual exclusion gifting.
- 38:50But that could be a dramatic reduction in the
- 38:54GST tax exemption that was available if the family
- 38:56wasn't thoughtfully considering either the fact
- 39:00that the GST annual exclusion was not applying
- 39:02and that they would need to opt out of it or
- 39:04that they were potentially in the reverse purposely
- 39:07going to allocate GST and then we'd be in the
- 39:10mismatch on the opposite side with a lot more
- 39:13GST tax exemption than a state and gift. So,
- 39:16you know, again, crummy trusts, they are personally
- 39:19one of the veins of my existence because I find
- 39:21so often that they're creating these small amounts
- 39:24of discrepancy. And when you consider, though,
- 39:27that it's year after year, you know, those leaky
- 39:30small amounts can become quite substantial over
- 39:33time. So another mismatch that often occurs is
- 39:40allocation to a GST trust, a late allocation.
- 39:46So on the flip side of a GRAT that has been created
- 39:49and used some gift exemption, another way to
- 39:52look at GRATs is that they create a situation
- 39:54where we've used little or no estate tax or gift
- 39:57exemption. But now, if we want that resulting
- 40:00trust to be GST exempt because it's been so wildly
- 40:03successful, then we do have to affirmatively
- 40:06allocate GST tax at the end of the eTIP period
- 40:09if the trust isn't subject to automatic allocation
- 40:13rules. But this type of allocation means that
- 40:17we're hopefully using a large amount. of the
- 40:20donor's GST exemption, since that trust has been
- 40:22so successful. Well, we've used very little estate
- 40:26tax exemption to initially create that trust.
- 40:28So again, here's another area where that mismatch
- 40:31can occur, leaving us with more estate tax exemption
- 40:35than GST. And a broader point is that even when
- 40:39the late allocation is beneficial, it does change
- 40:42your exemption picture. So if no one's tracking
- 40:44these exemptions, it can be easy to miss the
- 40:46fact that the client has now significantly less
- 40:49GST exemption remaining than their estate and
- 40:52gift tax exemption. This next one is one that
- 40:57I'll in candor say I don't know this rule until
- 41:01Amy educated me about it and then of course I
- 41:04ended up having the one to talk about it. So
- 41:05the SLAT gift splitting example is one that is
- 41:10I don't think commonly understood about one of
- 41:12the particular rules where, again, we see a difference
- 41:15in how GST tax rules apply than how they're applied
- 41:18in the gift tax context. So we're familiar with
- 41:21gift splitting, the idea that a married couple,
- 41:25there can be a single donor spouse and a non
- 41:27-contributing donor spouse can essentially allow
- 41:30their gift exemption to be used towards the gift
- 41:33that is being made to split the use of exemption
- 41:36and gifts. With the magnitude that we've seen
- 41:40as exemptions have gotten bigger in families
- 41:43that are using Spousal Lifetime Access Trust,
- 41:46where a spouse is a beneficiary of the recipient
- 41:49trust, one of the questions that has come up
- 41:51often is whether or not gift splitting can be
- 41:54used and how it would apply. So gift splitting,
- 41:58although it's generally not often used in slats.
- 42:03The reason is because there is still the option
- 42:05to gift split, except for the portion of the
- 42:08slat that represents the spouse's interest in
- 42:11the trust that's ascertainable and severable.
- 42:14So depending on how that slot was structured,
- 42:16it is possible to say that gift splitting is
- 42:18available for some portion, just not the portion
- 42:21that the spouse themselves is a beneficiary of.
- 42:25And so where this becomes relevant, however,
- 42:27is that you can have a for example, a million
- 42:30dollar gift coming into a trust. Let's say the
- 42:34spouse's ascertainable and severable interest,
- 42:37the IRS would determine is worth $300 ,000. So
- 42:41we have this $700 ,000 amount that's available
- 42:44for gift splitting. However, there's a different
- 42:47rule in the GST context that for gift splitting,
- 42:51gift splitting, all of the GST tax exemption
- 42:55must be equally split. So while the donor spouse
- 42:59is carrying more of the burden because they have
- 43:02to cover all of the portion with their own exemption
- 43:05for the spouse's interest that's ascertainable,
- 43:08and the non -donor spouse is only splitting half
- 43:12of the remaining portion that they are not part
- 43:15of, each of the spouses is contributing half
- 43:18of the GST exemption. So for the spouse, In both
- 43:22cases now, we've created a mismatch on both sides.
- 43:25The donor spouse is going to be using more gift
- 43:28and estate tax exemption and less GST tax exemption,
- 43:32and the flip will be the case for the gift splitting
- 43:35spouse. They will have used much less of their
- 43:39gift and estate tax exemption, but much more
- 43:41of their GST tax exemption because of this disconnect
- 43:44in the rules. Thank you, Amy, for telling me
- 43:47about that rule. Anytime. So finally, the last
- 43:51example we wanted to go to was an allocation
- 43:54of GST to a lifetime Q -tip. So in a lifetime
- 43:58Q -tip structure, the donor makes a transfer
- 44:01to an irrevocable trust for the benefit of a
- 44:03spouse. And if the trust is properly structured,
- 44:07that transfer can qualify for the unlimited marital
- 44:11deduction. So that means the donor can make a
- 44:14transfer without using gift tax exemption. So
- 44:18from the standpoint of gifts, gift tax, that
- 44:21transfer is essentially exemption -neutral. But
- 44:25GST planning can introduce a different layer.
- 44:28So let's say the donor wants the trust assets
- 44:30to continue for descendants after the spouse's
- 44:33death without future GST tax. In that instance,
- 44:37the donor can allocate GST exemption to that
- 44:40trust. And typically that's done on a timely
- 44:43file, 709, together with a reverse Q -tip election
- 44:48so that the donor not the spouse, not the beneficiary
- 44:51spouse, but the donor remains the transferor
- 44:54for GST purposes. And so that's sometimes where
- 44:58that mismatch can come from. The donor at that
- 45:00point has made a transfer that uses no gift tax
- 45:03exemption because of the marital deduction, but
- 45:06the donor has nevertheless actually used their
- 45:09GST exemption to create a GST exempt trust for
- 45:13later generations. So that's just some of the
- 45:16common ways that we see these mismatches between
- 45:19GST and estate and gift transfer tax coming up.
- 45:25Next slide. But we didn't want, obviously, to
- 45:29just make you aware of all these differences.
- 45:31We do think it's important to understand the
- 45:33nature behind why these are happening without
- 45:36also talking about All right, how would we potentially
- 45:39reverse some of these and bring back symmetry?
- 45:43The symmetry can be important because sometimes
- 45:45for additional planning that you'd like to do,
- 45:47knowing that you're really working with the same
- 45:50amount of both exemptions can be really helpful.
- 45:53Because these mismatches, just before we talk
- 45:55about some of the solutions, one of an example
- 45:58of a footfall I almost had was sort of assuming
- 46:01that a client had matching exemptions. Again,
- 46:04why I say crummy trusts are the bane of my existence
- 46:07is because it was due to a crummy trust that
- 46:08they had a much lower GST tax exemption, we were
- 46:12preparing to do a significant WANDRI gift. WANDRI
- 46:15gifts are the gifts by formula where oftentimes
- 46:18the description of the formula is to say that
- 46:21you're making a gift to utilize or that is equal
- 46:25to the taxpayers available. maximum gift tax
- 46:29exemption and was somewhat, you know, innocently
- 46:33working along on that assumption and fortunately
- 46:36at the 11th hour was doing a more substantial
- 46:39analysis of a previous history of gifting and
- 46:42realized that if we proceeded with that gift
- 46:44as is, we would have ended up with a gift that
- 46:46was made that, you know, under wandering, yes,
- 46:49would have been a gift that was free of any gift
- 46:52tax exemption, but going to a trust that would
- 46:54have had a pretty unfortunate inclusion ratio
- 46:58because there was just enough shortfall in the
- 47:01taxpayer's GST tax exemption that we would have
- 47:05had to do a lot of cleanup at the back end. So
- 47:07by going through this really thoughtful review
- 47:09of what the exemptions were, that there was a
- 47:12gap, we were able to avoid a pretty serious footfall
- 47:15and revise that laundry gift to say the statement
- 47:20of the gift will be the lesser of the client's
- 47:24available gift tax exemption or their lower GST
- 47:27tax exemption. And so that opportunity to be
- 47:31aware that these were happening was a real saver
- 47:33in that point, but we want to now kind of pivot
- 47:36and talk along the changes that we can do proactively
- 47:40when we have clients who are in this circumstance
- 47:42and we want to kind of bring them back into parity.
- 47:47Yeah, so our first example is on the next slide.
- 47:50which highlights a somewhat counterintuitive
- 47:52planning point. So in the right circumstances,
- 47:56paying the gift tax during life can actually
- 47:58be more efficient overall than waiting to incur
- 48:02a state tax at death. And the reason for this
- 48:06difference is because of how the two taxes are
- 48:09structured. So gift tax is tax exclusive, which
- 48:14means that the tax is paid from assets outside
- 48:16of the gift itself. Whereas by contrast, estate
- 48:19tax is tax inclusive, meaning that the dollars
- 48:23used to pay the tax are themselves part of that
- 48:25taxable estate. So using the example on this
- 48:29slide, let's say a donor has excess GST exemption,
- 48:33and they want to allocate it to a trust to make
- 48:35that trust GST exempt. But they've already used
- 48:38up all of their gift tax exemption. So if the
- 48:41goal is for the trust to ultimately receive $100
- 48:45,000, and that transfer is made during life,
- 48:49then the donor can transfer that $100 ,000 to
- 48:51the trust and pay $40 ,000 of gift tax separately.
- 48:56So in total, the donor has parted with $140 ,000.
- 49:00$100 ,000 to the trust, $40 ,000 to the IRS.
- 49:04But at death, this math works a little differently.
- 49:07So because the estate tax is tax inclusive, the
- 49:11dollars used to pay the tax are themselves part
- 49:13of that taxable estate. So if the client wants
- 49:16the trust to end up with, again, $100 ,000 after
- 49:19estate tax, then the estate needs to contain
- 49:22$166 ,000 because at a 40 % estate tax rate,
- 49:28$66 ,000 goes to tax and only $100 ,000 remains
- 49:32for the trust. Now, this is definitely not a
- 49:35strategy for every client. It does require that
- 49:38the client have the liquidity to pay that gift
- 49:41tax during life. But in circumstances where the
- 49:48client has that excess GST exemption, and the
- 49:51goal is really to fund a trust for descendants
- 49:53the most tax -efficient way, paying the gift
- 49:56tax can be a very rational strategy. And I hear
- 50:00clients say all the time, you want me to pay
- 50:01tax now? But the answer is maybe, because paying
- 50:05this tax now may actually be more efficient in
- 50:08the end. So that's one of the ways to use a donor's
- 50:12excess GST exemption during life. Next slide
- 50:17please. So another technique that I think of
- 50:23as kind of a sponge to soak up extra GST tax
- 50:27exemption is to look back to the technique we
- 50:30were talking about earlier related to GRATs.
- 50:33So we discussed the idea that a GRAT, particularly
- 50:36if it's structured as a zeroed out GRAT or very
- 50:38low gift -sized GRAT, must wait until the conclusion
- 50:43of that term to apply its GST or... for the donor
- 50:47to apply GST tax exemption and see basically
- 50:50if the grant was successful, how much GST tax
- 50:53exemption is needed to protect the gift now that
- 50:56the grant period has closed. This was exceptionally
- 50:59popular in sort of 2022, 2023, when we were looking
- 51:06for clients who had sunset on their mind that
- 51:09was coming up on December 31st of 2025. And they
- 51:12were saying, well, if I have a circumstance where
- 51:14I have this unused GST, that is going to be wasted.
- 51:18I do not want to do what Amy has just suggested
- 51:21and just pay gift tax and make these gifts that
- 51:24will, you know, unfortunately cause me to pay
- 51:27tax, but I don't want to leave my GST tax unused.
- 51:31I want to use that allocation while it's available
- 51:33to me before the sunset occurs. These relatively
- 51:37short -term grads were a great opportunity to
- 51:40give a client a chance to use that extra GST
- 51:43tax exemption. Because the gift at the front
- 51:46end, if the GRAT is structured in a way that
- 51:48is what we call zeroed out or has a very low
- 51:51sized gift, we can then have the opportunity
- 51:54to wait and see and apply our GST exemption at
- 51:58the conclusion where that's all we're applying
- 52:00at the tail end. Now, again, this is not going
- 52:03to be perfectly timed. Some of my clients who
- 52:05did this, their GRATs Performed even better than
- 52:09we anticipated and though while it did end up
- 52:11using their excess GST tax exemption ultimately
- 52:14the total success of the GRAT even exceeded their
- 52:18available and excess GST tax exemption. So we
- 52:21did end up with circumstances where we had essentially
- 52:24at the GRAT's conclusion, one fully GST exempt
- 52:27trust that we applied our remaining GST exemption
- 52:30to, and another trust that was not. We did sort
- 52:33of the model that Amy's referring to of having
- 52:35a severance between the two, two distinct trusts.
- 52:38But at least, you know, we gave them an opportunity
- 52:42to utilize that excess GST tax exemption in a
- 52:45circumstance where sunset was looming and we
- 52:48were at risk of losing it. We're not in that
- 52:50environment anymore under the new laws, but as
- 52:53we all know, legislation can change any time,
- 52:55and so who knows how long this permanent law
- 52:57will be in place. Next slide, please. We already
- 53:02talked about this a little bit briefly earlier,
- 53:05but when a donor has, again, excess GST exemption.
- 53:10What they can do is create a trust for their
- 53:12spouse that's designed to qualify for the marital
- 53:15deduction and then as we know they can make that
- 53:18transfer without using a gift any of their gift
- 53:21or estate tax exemption and then they can allocate
- 53:25their remaining GST exemption to that trust.
- 53:29In order for this to work, typically the donor
- 53:32does have to make that reverse Q -tip election
- 53:34on a gift tax return so that, again, the donor
- 53:38remains the transferor for GST purposes, which
- 53:42means that the donor's GST exemption can sort
- 53:45of attach to that trust and protect it as it
- 53:48continues for defendants. So this structure does
- 53:51create, I mean, uses that additional GST exemption
- 53:56because we don't have that gift tax exemption
- 53:59to make the initial gift, and then we use the
- 54:02donor's remaining GST exemption to create that
- 54:05GST exempt trust. Next slide, please. So one
- 54:12of the kind of final planning points for when
- 54:14you have a client with extra GST exemption, sorry,
- 54:18next slide, will be to look at a late allocation
- 54:22of GST now, not because of the circumstance I
- 54:25described earlier, where the value has gone down
- 54:29dramatically, but more a circumstance where a
- 54:32client previously funded a trust, sorry, next
- 54:34slide, please, where there was a sort of affirmative
- 54:40decision not to... allocate GST tax exemption
- 54:46to a gift to a trust such that the trust is a
- 54:49non -exempt trust, but we are now finding later,
- 54:53kind of regardless of what the value is, if we
- 54:55have unused GST tax exemption that we'd like
- 54:57to allocate, we can go ahead and do a late allocation
- 55:00now and essentially just make either all or part
- 55:05of that previously non -exempt trust exempt now.
- 55:09Again, that may not necessarily be because we
- 55:12think we're in a moment following a gift where
- 55:14we've declined in value, this may be a circumstance
- 55:17where a client is just re -evaluating their portfolio
- 55:20of trust structures and realizing that maybe
- 55:23based on their appetite for further gifting,
- 55:26they're not going to do anything with some excess
- 55:28GST exemption that they have now, but they appreciate
- 55:31the adage that we tell clients most of the time,
- 55:34which is using it early is a better long -term
- 55:37solution because we have the opportunity for
- 55:41further growth to apply. based on any allocations
- 55:44that are used now. So we may have a circumstance
- 55:47where a client who previously established a non
- 55:50-exempt trust is reconsidering that decision
- 55:54and going to now apply their excess GST tax exemption
- 55:57to that, whatever the value of the trust is at
- 56:01that time in the hopes though that they will
- 56:03have hope. hopefully many more years and time
- 56:06to see that now exempt trust increase and continue
- 56:10to benefit their intended beneficiaries. Now
- 56:13this has predominantly been focused so far on
- 56:16excess GST, but sometimes we have the reverse
- 56:19circumstance and we really want to talk particularly
- 56:21about how post death there are some strategic
- 56:25planning opportunities as well for dealing with
- 56:27gaps. So next slide, please. And actually just
- 56:30next slide after that already. So this slide
- 56:38is, you know, sort of our traditional joint revocable
- 56:41trust plan after the first death. So it splits
- 56:43into a survivor's trust, which holds the survivor's
- 56:46half of community property and any of their separate
- 56:49property. The bypass trust, which typically holds
- 56:53the remaining exemption, a state tax exemption
- 56:56from the decedent, and then the marital trust,
- 56:58anything above and beyond what that exemption
- 57:01amount is. So if we go to the next slide, in
- 57:04order not to leave any exemption behind, in the
- 57:08scenario in which the decedent may have more
- 57:12GST exemption than a state tax exemption, In
- 57:16this situation, we would recommend looking at
- 57:19an exempt marital trust to be able to use the
- 57:22decedent's full remaining GST exemption. So what
- 57:25this looks like in the documents is a structure
- 57:28that divides the marital trust into separate
- 57:30trusts. One that's fully GST exempt and uses
- 57:33the decedent's remaining GST exemption. and then
- 57:36the other consisting of all the remaining marital
- 57:39trust assets. And that trust is fully non -GST
- 57:42exempt. In the interest of time, I'm going to
- 57:44skip to the next slide, which is sort of the
- 57:47opposite end of the scenario. So let's assume
- 57:50in this scenario, the deceased spouse has more
- 57:53estate tax exemption than GST exemption. So in
- 57:57this case, we would recommend a structure that
- 57:59splits the bypass trust into GST exempt and GST
- 58:03non -exempt trust. rather than funding a single
- 58:06bypass trust that may create that mixed inclusion
- 58:09ratio. Then I think we're gonna go on to disclaimers
- 58:13real quick. Yes, so recognizing we're running
- 58:16out of time, we just wanted to talk at the next
- 58:19slide, disclaimers. This is again, something
- 58:21that is often coming up for clients, more in
- 58:25the context of thinking about... What is right
- 58:28for my beneficiaries? Once a parent has passed
- 58:31away, the beneficiaries may be contemplating
- 58:33whether or not someone who's designed to, under
- 58:36the current estate plan, inherit. If they don't
- 58:38need the funds, do they feel comfortable moving
- 58:41those assets through disclaimer onto the next
- 58:44beneficiary who would otherwise inherit? All
- 58:46we want to talk about in this case is that, particularly
- 58:49in a lens of having excess GST tax exemption
- 58:53over estate and gift tax exemption, that this
- 58:55is something that you might take a particular
- 58:57tax focus to and not just think about the personal
- 59:00financial situation of the family members. That
- 59:03this is an opportunity to maybe understand that
- 59:06if a disclaimer, the result of which causes a
- 59:09skip person to inherit through the estate plan
- 59:11rather than a non -skip person, there may be
- 59:14an opportunity for kind of global planning amongst
- 59:17the family to be more thoughtful about the use
- 59:20of the decedent's GST tax, particularly if they
- 59:22have excess GST tax. We'll move to the next slide
- 59:26and admit that this slide was really brought
- 59:29about and sorry, onto the next one, because we
- 59:32really wanted the idea of local trains and express
- 59:34trains. So the local train is a consideration
- 59:37of state estate taxes. Next slide, please. just
- 59:42mentioned that there are 19 jurisdictions, 18
- 59:45states in the District of Columbia that still
- 59:47have an estate or inheritance tax that's applicable
- 59:51at the state level. Why this is relevant is that
- 59:55in planning for how to structure an estate for
- 59:58an individual living outside of California that
- 1:00:00may be subject to one of these states, to be
- 1:00:03aware of the fact that there are some planning
- 1:00:05opportunities to be aware that local state rules
- 1:00:09may have much lower exemptions that apply at
- 1:00:12the federal level. Why this is important, though,
- 1:00:15is in this structure, which creates what's called
- 1:00:17a contingent marital trust, a marital trust that
- 1:00:20is making a basically state -only marital election
- 1:00:24and Q -tip election, but not doing so at the
- 1:00:27federal level. This is to allow the bypass trust
- 1:00:30that's created to only be funded with the lower
- 1:00:33of the two state and federal exemptions and then
- 1:00:36basically use up in this contingent marital trust
- 1:00:40remaining balance of the federal election q -tip
- 1:00:43sorry federal estate tax exemption utilizing
- 1:00:46however a state q -tip election in order to successfully
- 1:00:50avoid any of the state -level estate tax is just
- 1:00:53to be thoughtful about where it's most effective
- 1:00:55to use GST allocations amongst these different
- 1:00:59trusts. And I realize with that we're out of
- 1:01:01time. We'll advance to the next few slides and
- 1:01:03just say, you know, the takeaway points out of
- 1:01:05your materials. We have a couple of checklists
- 1:01:07and other tasks to just take everything that
- 1:01:10we've talked about today and bring it top of
- 1:01:12mind for you. So we have checklists and takeaways
- 1:01:15for ideas that... both practitioners to be able
- 1:01:19to identify when these gaps are happening. And
- 1:01:22then in part two, to take some of the proactive
- 1:01:25measures that we've talked about to, again, eliminate
- 1:01:28some exemption discrepancies that might have
- 1:01:30been created. And our contact information was
- 1:01:33in the materials. We're happy to answer questions
- 1:01:35because we realized we rushed a little bit at
- 1:01:37the end. It was a real pleasure to be here today
- 1:01:40and to talk with all of you about what was an
- 1:01:43exciting project for us to put together and which
- 1:01:45all originated from the lowly crummy. So, you
- 1:01:48know, that is something that we're really cognizant
- 1:01:50of in creating these exemption disconnects. This
- 1:02:03concludes today's program. We would like to thank
- 1:02:06our speakers today, Amy Takeuchi -Wanlas and
- 1:02:11Elizabeth Glasgow. for an excellent presentation.
- 1:02:14Our next program will be on July 21st featuring
- 1:02:19Chang Che. Thank you all for joining us this
- 1:02:22afternoon. Thank you.