Latest / Word Balloon Comics Podcast / Star Trek Master Class with Robert Meyer Burnett
Transcript
- 0:03Hi, everybody, welcome back. It's Word Balloon, the comic book conversation
- 0:07show. John suntris here. I'm happy to welcome Robert meyer Burnett back to
- 0:11Word Balloon. Rob is one of my favorite YouTubers. I've enjoyed his robservations
- 0:17over the years. I'm a massive Star Trek fan, as you well know.
- 0:21Rob is a chess master to my student level appreciation of Star Trek,
- 0:27and neither of us are big fans of the current product. We talk in
- 0:32general terms. Now that Discovery is back, I'm going to do a full
- 0:37Trek watch about the first two episodes of Discovery. That's going to happen on
- 0:40Monday night. So I hope you'll join me, Mitch and Franco and Wayne
- 0:46as we talk about the opening of the fifth season of Discovery. But this
- 0:50is really a general conversation, and you know, I think you'll enjoy it
- 0:55if you're a Star Trek fan, because we point out what makes Star Trek
- 0:59good and I think we have some serious opinions about that. Robert meyer Burnett
- 1:03talking Trek with me on today's Word Balloon. Word Bulloon is brought to you
- 1:07by Alex ross Art dot Com. Alex is a good friend of the show,
- 1:11and I am honored that he aligns himself with word Balloon and good Lord.
- 1:18We all love his iconic art, whether it's for DC Marvel things like
- 1:23Bonni, Python, the Monkeys, David Bowie, so many other great license
- 1:26things the Beatles. If you go to Alex rossart dot com, you will
- 1:32find great value for your dollar, whether you can spring for something like original
- 1:38cover art or pages to lithos and posters. Every price point you can imagine,
- 1:47you will find something and a beautiful image from Alex Rossart dot com.
- 1:52Coming to Kickstarter from the mind of Franco, the man behind Teen Titans,
- 1:56Go to the Library, Fay and the Moon and all yat comics come the
- 2:00new LXT the Adversarial fighting card game Live now on Kickstarter. Lxt Lux versus
- 2:07Tenebris. Imagine a loved one has been spirited away to a land of terror
- 2:13and torture. Would you be willing to go after them and fight through a
- 2:16horde of acolytes of the Dark One just to get them back? Developed as
- 2:21a role playing card game that can be played multiple ways. The cards will
- 2:24have full color illustrations on the front and chock full of steps and moves.
- 2:29On the back. You can also get the LXT Who's Who book with origin
- 2:34stories and information about all the characters still on more. Also available is the
- 2:39LXT Dark Atlas book, filled with pro stories about all the batties and illustrations
- 2:46from a wide selection of comic artists. There are plenty of ad ons you
- 2:50could purchase separately, like comic books, stickers, original art from the game,
- 2:53and more. It's going to be a howling good time LXT live now
- 2:59on Kickstar. Word Balloon brought to you by my league of word Balloon listeners.
- 3:04That's right, my financial backers. Of what I'm trying to do here,
- 3:07it's pretty simple. Everybody. Word Balloon is free. It'll always be
- 3:10free. But I could sure use your financial help. If you've ever thought
- 3:15about subscribing to word Balloon, I certainly would appreciate it. Now. Is
- 3:20word Balloon worth the price of a comic book a month? Is it even
- 3:23worth a dollar a month? If you think so, If you can swing
- 3:24it, I sure would appreciate your support. All I try to do is
- 3:29bring you fantastic content, talking to some of the greats of pop culture.
- 3:34Consider subscribing to word Balloon by going to my Patreon Patreon dot com slash word
- 3:40Balloon. Thank you very much for your support. League of word Balloon listeners.
- 3:47Welcome back everybody time again for word Balloon, the Comic Book Conversation Show.
- 3:52John cuntris here, and you know I stay up for only a very
- 3:57very few people on the West Coast, but happy to welcome the uh the
- 4:01Viceroy of the ver Similitude and uh the the headman for the imagination Connoisseurs,
- 4:10Rob Meyer Burnett. Robert could have seen buddy, John. You know,
- 4:13I was saying to you that what have we We've been doing this for almost
- 4:15a decade now. You predate me being on YouTube, I think, or
- 4:21when I just started with in a in a spotty way, because I really
- 4:26didn't start doing well. I started doing it, I guess during COVID and
- 4:30you did it. You started doing it actually prior to that. Well,
- 4:32but I mean in terms of being on your podcast even before you're on YouTube.
- 4:36Well, that's right, that is true. We've been talking for a
- 4:40long time, which so it's good to see you again. Well I was
- 4:43good to be here, No, I'm thrilled to have you man. And
- 4:46again you you're almost daily vid casts on YouTube on the Observation and the Burn
- 4:55Network, every network. Yeah, and if you don't already, although I
- 4:59am mad, a lot of your ominions are here watching us because we share
- 5:03a good portion of our audience and everything. So that's great. But yeah,
- 5:08man no, you're always entertaining. I want to hear your point of
- 5:11view. I am a student to your chess master as far as Star Trek
- 5:17knowledge and experience and work experience with Paramount and with the franchise, truly,
- 5:25man No, And I've and I've enjoyed your work not only Free Enterprise,
- 5:28but your wonderful work on the videos back at the Vegas Hilton for the Star
- 5:32Trek Expose. Oh yeah, thank you. It takes me back. You
- 5:36know that was that was that that job actually led to us making Free Enterprise,
- 5:42which is kind of that's man. Yeah, Hayden. Hayden says,
- 5:46hello, man lot everybody that you're you're joining us tonight because certainly we are
- 5:51going to talk about the first at least the first two episodes of Discovery.
- 5:57I know Rob seen at least the first five. I think you have.
- 6:03I mean, it is it is the new Star Trek that's airing the new
- 6:08Star Trek. Oh wait, no, I don't want to be negative.
- 6:12Oh why up? Now you can be negative on my show. You know,
- 6:15honestly, Rob, you come from this as do I. We want
- 6:18good Star Trek, that's all. And I'm sure you're the same way where
- 6:21like, all right, well maybe I'll like this episode more. Well I
- 6:26even finally listen and give us what we truly want. I mean, I
- 6:30think, look, I've been watching Star Trek my whole life, and there
- 6:35has been good Star Trek and bad Star Trek in every series and movie and
- 6:40you know all that. And sorry, somebody's it's not my birthday, but
- 6:46I running joke is the greatest thing ever. I love my viewers, thank
- 6:49you, thank you all for that. I think that what would be the
- 6:54ultimate thing about this joke is if on my actual birthday, which is next
- 6:58month May fifteenth, that nobody, nobody will wish me happy birthday and it'll
- 7:01be a total disaster. But no, I think you know what's really interesting
- 7:08is there's this idea that that there's toxic fandom. Everyone's talking about fans being
- 7:15toxic, and all anybody wants is great stuff. They want great programming.
- 7:23And all of these franchises that have been around started out great. That's why
- 7:28they're franchises. They've endured because they were amazing. And what's happened is the
- 7:33corporate controlled media they treat an IP or a franchise the way they would any
- 7:41product. Now, like Coca Cola, people know what Coca Cola is.
- 7:45They're just going to buy Coca Cola because they know what it is. Star
- 7:49Trek is not a product. It's not Coca Cola. And if you don't
- 7:54know how to make old formula coke, if you don't know what the readings
- 8:00were that made it special, that made people like it for fifty eight years,
- 8:05it isn't. You can't just slap a Star Trek label on something and
- 8:07have it be successful. You have to understand the ingredients, the essence what
- 8:13made Star Trek or what made Star Wars or Doctor Who or the MCU,
- 8:18take your pick. If you don't understand the very essence of the IP,
- 8:22and why would a corporation understand that? There's no way a corporation could understand
- 8:26that because it doesn't fit. You know, art and commerce. Hollywood was
- 8:31all about that friggon between art and commerce. Now all there is is commerce.
- 8:35They don't understand art. People don't the people that run things, they're
- 8:41not readers. They don't know literature. You know, they don't know.
- 8:45It is a balance sheet, and there's not a column for it is the
- 8:50product entertaining right and DNA it's a good story or bad story. They just
- 8:56look at Star Trek and they look at okay, in the fifty eight years
- 8:58it's exists. Here's how much money it made. But like with real estate,
- 9:05you know, you can go okay in this neighborhood at this much square
- 9:09footage. If you build a ten story building and the first two stories are
- 9:13mixed use, you got retail space. You know, you can say okay
- 9:18with this much square footage and these big box retailers or whoever, and then
- 9:22the next eight floors are you know, living. You can rent condos whatever
- 9:28they are. You know how much money you're gonna make, and it's easy,
- 9:31you can quantify it. But you can't do that with art. You
- 9:35can't do that with storytelling because how do you explain to somebody who's never read
- 9:41a science fiction novel what good science fiction is. Well, I was hired
- 9:46to make this you. You don't know what's not well, isn't any story,
- 9:50isn't any TV show the same? Don't we make No? No,
- 9:54it's not. And we live in that world now, and I think less
- 9:58people because classical education is less. Now. Now let's make well. We
- 10:03have to make sure that the kids, you know, we don't want to
- 10:05we don't want to bother. We have to make sure that they don't have
- 10:07to read things that are a little beyond them. And it's like, no,
- 10:11we used to require people to step up to the plate, you know,
- 10:16you need to be better, and now we're catering to the lowest common
- 10:20denominator, which I don't understand at all. Well, yeah, but you've
- 10:22made the observation, and I agree with you. No, no, no
- 10:28observation. If I may, You're one hundred percent right now, man,
- 10:31it's all good. I love this. Oh, by the way, real
- 10:33fast, Mike Konrad, what's up? John and Robb celebrating the start at
- 10:37Disco's filed season. So wants us to know he's got two hundred and fifty
- 10:45five subs Man channel keeps growing and it's congratulations, congratulations. His plan is
- 10:50after college, he wants to move to California and grows channel eventually become a
- 10:54full time critic. Very nice. Uh, Which way is David Ellison the
- 11:00next CEO of Paramount? Which is why David Ellison, excuse me, has
- 11:05announced Robert Bryan Brinet will take over Star Trek project is going forward. You
- 11:09know, it's April fourth, It's not April first anymore. I understand,
- 11:13But no, what I was gonna say is, and you've made their observation
- 11:18that the audience today's audience wants to see themselves, and I disagree with that.
- 11:26But because like you, I started watching Star Trek my earliest memory.
- 11:31I don't remember plot, but I do know that last season in sixty nine,
- 11:35when I was four, my parents were watching, and I know it
- 11:39was on TV, and I remember, like you, the first wave of
- 11:43syndication in the seventies, and it was on in Chicago, and I'd watch
- 11:48it every Sunday morning, and ultimately they started running it five nights a week,
- 11:52and I was hooked. And I mean, and also, like you
- 11:54said, a lot of stuff went over our heads, but we appreciated.
- 12:00We know we were watching the best of the best. The Apollo missions were
- 12:03winding down, and we I mean, we could extrap and go you know,
- 12:07three hundred years in the future. Sure, why not? It could?
- 12:11You know, it could it could be uh uh the Enterprise in US
- 12:15in space the way they're in deep space. Yeah, I mean, well,
- 12:18you know what people forget is is Star Trek was born out of that
- 12:22Camelot spirit of the Kennedy White House. You know, we're going to go
- 12:26to the Moon and do the other things, not because it is easy,
- 12:30but because it is hard. And you know, Kennedy was one of the
- 12:35great orators of the speeches he made were incredibly rousing and very aeradite, and
- 12:43they always spoke to that can do coming off of I'm pt one oh nine,
- 12:46you know, coming out out of the World War two generation, the
- 12:50Greatest generation, the building of the middle class in the nineteen fifties, and
- 12:54then what Star Trek represented, I mean, we were in the middle.
- 12:58We'd seen Mercury, would see Geminy, We're in the middle of the Apollo
- 13:01program. And literally the third season of Star Trek ended and we landed on
- 13:07the moon, yep, and that was that was a very heady time.
- 13:11So even though you were in the middle of the civil rights movement and Vietnam,
- 13:15and American culture was very in a very tumultuous state. Culture was changing
- 13:20rapidly. Star Trek represented this beacon of a future that was really an American
- 13:26future, which is why Star Trek has never really traveled very far foreign.
- 13:31But it represented that American that that idea that we're going to be here in
- 13:37three hundred years and things are going to be great, and there is going
- 13:39to be a quality you know, I mean a Star Trek believe what I
- 13:45believe. There is one race of human beings on this planet. One that's
- 13:50it, and our whatever exterior differences we have between us just means that we
- 13:54are from a stock that grew up in various geopolitical situations in the world,
- 13:58like you're from here, you're from here, you're from here, But our
- 14:03DNA is the same. If you can procreate your one race, it's not
- 14:07like you figure out this. How do the cylons and humans procreate? And
- 14:11the new Battlestar galact I don't know, But on this planet there's one human
- 14:13race. And that's that's what Star Trek told us. Well, Roddenberry,
- 14:18gene Kon and company, they all pushed us in the right direction. Berman
- 14:22comes in really believe at least believes in the Roddenberry ethic and says, no,
- 14:30we're gonna keep doing a Gene's way in the eighties and nineties, and
- 14:33maybe to the detriment in some ways because of that. Well, there's no
- 14:37conflict within the humans in the future. Thank god, they make DS nine
- 14:41and now there's alien races to have conflict in everything, and it's great and
- 14:46my god, it I mean, DS nine just gets better and better with
- 14:50Age, and you really appreciate the writing. And of course I love Next
- 14:54Generation, you know, and I know you and Mark Allman and the the
- 15:00glorious Trexperts. Sometimes, you know, you guys had your issues with Voyager,
- 15:03and I totally understand because you know, the network again was hey,
- 15:07we want more Next Gen, and it's like, well, we already did
- 15:11that for seven years. You know, the Enterprise even worse. Go ahead,
- 15:15please reassessing Voyager. Though Voyager is very schizophrenic. But when Voyager was
- 15:20good, it was great. Totally Age, and I think that, you
- 15:24know, it's people like like John Atman, the editor and composer and director
- 15:28John Outman, who I met working on movies like Supermer Returns and usual suspects
- 15:33him and Brian Fuller, who was one of the co creators of Discovery.
- 15:37It was the two of them, and Fuller worked on Voyager, who I
- 15:41mean, yeah, on Voyager, who told me like, you need to
- 15:46go back and look, you know, and and they gave me certain episodes
- 15:48to look at again. And because I was kind of checked out when Voyager
- 15:52was first airing, and they're right, you know, Voyager was. I
- 15:58think they made missteps like leaning into the Borg as heavily as they did and
- 16:02humanizing the Borg and all that. I think they went in the wrong direction.
- 16:07But yeah, I mean there's a reason why Voyager was the most popular
- 16:11Star Trek streaming series for a while, because people were rediscovering it. Yeah,
- 16:15And I also think there's that nostalgia cycle and right now, much as
- 16:22you know, I remember, you know, the eighties was the big craze
- 16:25for a while in the nineties, I mean, certainly coming from radio,
- 16:27I saw those trends, and so now it is, you know, the
- 16:32nineties are still kind of the new Oh I remember when, And I think
- 16:34that also contributes to Voidger's success. But also I've always said a third of
- 16:41Voyager was not good a third of it was okay and a third of it
- 16:45was exceptional. And you're right, that great episode where they go to the
- 16:48planet that time moves faster, oh, like of an eye. Fantastic.
- 16:55That is a great Not only is that a great episode of Star Trek,
- 16:56it's a great episode of science fiction, you know, because you're dealing with
- 17:00time dilation and really interesting stuff. So something that, as we both agree,
- 17:07Star Trek Discovery science fiction eludes them. Well, you know, if
- 17:12somebody pointed out, my friend Dan Coyle pointed out that if you look at
- 17:17the recap, you know, last year or last season on Voyager, they
- 17:22concentrate on the interpersonal romantic relationships of the characters. Yep, you know,
- 17:26like Saurou's hooking up with his vulcan hottie, you know, and and and
- 17:30and Book is broken up with Michael Burnham and here's here's and I'm not the
- 17:37only person with this theory. I believe that many of the TV creators now
- 17:41that are working on genre television, they all came of age watching Buffy and
- 17:45Angel. They're all completely in it. And and to be fair, Buffy
- 17:49and Angel were great shows. They were and the interpersonal relationships and the fact
- 17:53that they were some of the first to embrace same sex relationships amongst principal characters,
- 17:59and they had diversity down way before everybody before twenty twelve twenty thirteen,
- 18:03where our entire civilization was derailed by social media, they were already doing those
- 18:11things and it felt natural. It didn't feel forced, like, oh,
- 18:15we're gonna we're gonna shoehorn all this stuff. It was done very naturalistically.
- 18:19There's a there's a great way, a great there's a great scene where Willow
- 18:23kind of comes out to Buffy. Beautifully written scene, really well done,
- 18:30way better than anything you'd see today, which is the most heavy handed beat
- 18:34you over the head and everybody like you know, John, It used to
- 18:40be Star Trek expected you to come up to its level. You needed to
- 18:45step up. It was presenting you with concepts and ideas that made you a
- 18:49better person. By now it's the reverse. Now it's it's it's like Star
- 18:56Trek is no longer about the best of the best. It's about all of
- 19:00us. All of us get our we all get to be on a starship
- 19:03and travel around the universe. And like, I don't believe any of those
- 19:07people would survive an episode, much less multiple seasons of episodes. I hear
- 19:11you, Wesley, Uh, and I respect this, Wesley. Wesley says,
- 19:15I don't need to see myself, but I do love seeing a lot
- 19:18of different types of people. Yeah, pretend it's not awesome when I do
- 19:21see characters I relate to. Now, I'll say, and I want to
- 19:23hear Rob's thoughts as well. I absolutely agree with that. However, you
- 19:29can do it in a much more subtle fashion. I go back to when
- 19:32Adira and Gray were introduced on Discovery, and Rob has talked about this scene
- 19:37as well, where uh stammets uh gives the wrong pronoun to a dera and
- 19:45she says, and I and I forget if she identifies as they. I
- 19:48think she does identify. She does. They have a whole conversation they identify
- 19:52as they pardon me, and he has there's that pregnant pause on standardism.
- 19:57Okay, but again, as you just pointed out, Saru and I'm sorry
- 20:02everybody, there's gonna be spoilers if you haven't watched the first few episodes of
- 20:06Discovery. But Saru and the woman from Navarre half folk and half romulent.
- 20:12However it works they've announced that they're probably gonna get married. Well that's fine.
- 20:18So in this era of the thirty one hundreds, and also ever since
- 20:23Star Trek began, we've had inner species relationship. Yeah, I mean,
- 20:27if you're if you're a thousand years from now and we're still talking about pronouns,
- 20:33the human race is doomed because we've evolved, We've gone nowhere. Yes,
- 20:37and not in a negative way to not address it, but why don't
- 20:42you just make it matter of fact? Well, and also with surgical techniques,
- 20:49I mean they'll they'll let's let's say, like I'm of the opinion that
- 20:52that say, if you're trans, I really do believe, because there's now
- 20:57evidence to suggest that, uh, gender dys morphia is a real thing,
- 21:03like people's brains are literally you could literally have a woman's brain, the brain
- 21:07chemistry of a female in a male body. Sure, and I've always believed
- 21:11that. I've always believed it's a naturally occurring thing. Well, in the
- 21:12thirty second century, with the surgical techniques, they would identify this at birth.
- 21:18You'd do a brain scan and go this person was it would be in
- 21:21utero. They would argue, our technology would be so far advanced that they
- 21:26would handle this instantaneously, so there would be nobody who has gender dysmorphia because
- 21:30it would be fixed by the surgical techniques and the scientific advancements a thousand years
- 21:36from now. But even let's say gender fluid people, fine, I mean
- 21:40again, by all means, show somebody we're marrying different species. That's not
- 21:45even gender fluid, that's species fluid. That's so far away from what we're
- 21:49talking about now. It's so far evolved. And Star Trek already went there.
- 21:56Our main character of Spock was half vulcan and half human. If you're
- 22:00not looking at that, going that's pretty progressive. I mean that that that
- 22:04flew in the face. If you think about the sixties, we couldn't even
- 22:08allow inner marriages at parts of in parts of this country, and you have
- 22:12a human woman marrying an alien. There were stations in the South that were
- 22:18really pissed when kissed. Oh my god. Yeah, that was in the
- 22:22third season, right, and I mean that's well, hell man, Even
- 22:26before that, Dick van Dyke, when they did the joke about Rob thinking
- 22:30they had the wrong baby and it turns out it's a black couple. Greg
- 22:33Marts than I get the actually played a couple, and I heard Ryaner say
- 22:37that, you know, the network was scared that the South wasn't going to
- 22:41show those episodes. No, we understand, but we're past that. And
- 22:45that's the thing. So by all means, it's cool to have Adra and
- 22:48Gray in a relationship, but you Gray, I mean, I'm really interested
- 22:55because I know eventually Gray will be back on the show. What are they
- 22:59going to show because I never understood what Grace function was on the ship other
- 23:03than being a dear significant other. And it's like, well, I mean,
- 23:07but also he was a go or they were a ghost or whatever and
- 23:11came back. I mean, it was so anti science and anti science fiction.
- 23:15That's the thing that I really object to is that is that at least
- 23:18even when you had magic technology, you know, like a transporter, which
- 23:23was a production issue, they didn't want to have to launch a shuttlecraft and
- 23:26show a miniature shot. So they found an elegant solution and created this tech.
- 23:32But the thing is the reason we believed it is because the tech had
- 23:34limitations. You know, line of sight beaming, you have to be in
- 23:37orbit, you have to reach a position because the beam could only go from
- 23:42the ship to the planet, and if there was an ion storm like we
- 23:45saw in Enemy Within when Kirk was split into two, the transporter wouldn't work,
- 23:51and you know, Sul's out stranded on the planet going hey, can
- 23:53you lower some coffee down for me on a rope or something, And it
- 23:57became believe you're believe in the fantasy because it's I've often said that the best
- 24:03fiction is truthful. You know, you the best fiction. You have to
- 24:08have a lot of truth in your fiction to make the fiction believable. And
- 24:12there's no for me, there's no believability in Star Trek Discovery at all,
- 24:18not from they don't understand the internal design of their own starships. They don't
- 24:22understand these characters. They're they're they're telling us that human beings a thousand years
- 24:27from now are going to correct. You have a non binary person correcting a
- 24:32gay man over pronouns really well, and also how important. There are a
- 24:40lot of scenes where all the black characters are together, all the uh uh,
- 24:45gay and trans characters are only together. It's so weird. It would
- 24:49be really nice to see it interact. Now, the segregation in Star Trek
- 24:55Discovery. One day when the show's gone away, people are going to start
- 24:59writing about how how the subtlety of the segregation in the show is abhorrent and
- 25:04it's the most anti Star Trek because the thing is, there is a level
- 25:11in activist circles that are segregationist. They're as bad as the South was during
- 25:18Jim Crow. They want to have their spaces. We don't want these people
- 25:25here. I mean, it's so weird how we've gone from a Star Trek
- 25:29future which where everybody makes the whole stronger, you know, and yet individuality
- 25:37and individual achievement was celebrated, and nowadays that's not the case. You know,
- 25:42we have all these little young Marxists running around going yeah, because you
- 25:47guys didn't you apparently didn't go to school and learn about the twentieth century.
- 25:52But what are you gonna do? Mike? I agree with Mike pretty much.
- 25:56All the modern Trek is more science fantasy than science face. I wonder
- 26:00in the five episodes, and I don't want you to spoil per se,
- 26:03but are we seeing the Nasceelles split off from the ship like like we did
- 26:08whenever they made it to the thirty first century? Yeah? I mean,
- 26:12look what we saw in the first episode of Discovery that's already aired, with
- 26:15two starships smashing literally crashing nose down into the ground. I mean, I'm
- 26:21out out again. Where's the realism? Where is because as you say,
- 26:26the ships move, the ships in space should move like battleships, not like
- 26:30fighter jets. No. And that's another thing. I mean, it's very
- 26:36funny to me that if you look at something like Star Trek to the Rathacon,
- 26:40when the Enterprise and the Reliant are fighting there, they might as well
- 26:44be close quartered seventeenth century, you know, triple masted sailing vessels that are
- 26:49shooting cannons at one another, and they move the way that starships move is
- 26:55to convey their size. You know, it's all made up anyway. But
- 26:59what they're doing is they're using our understanding of seafaring vessels putting them in space,
- 27:04and they're using that. I mean, look, if space combat was
- 27:08real, nobody would see anybody else. The ships are thousands of kilometers apart
- 27:14they were you know, they're firing weapons that fire that that travel at light
- 27:18speed. You know, they they would never see one another. But that's
- 27:22not dramatically interesting. So when you when you put these ships in close quarters.
- 27:26You have to give us something that we can understand from our world today,
- 27:30because that kind of combat, with those kinds of weapons, you wouldn't
- 27:33see anything. So how do they do it? They do it the way
- 27:37they do it so well. As Wayne points out that first episode, Burnham
- 27:41standing on a hall during warp makes no sense. No, it doesn't.
- 27:45So it's it's ridiculous. Well, the funny thing is is is the people
- 27:51that are that are making this show, they don't stop to go, Okay,
- 27:56well, how does warp work? If you have engines, if you
- 27:59have warped a cell that are creating a warp bubble around a ship, so
- 28:02it can warp space and travel. It's not like you're going fast. It's
- 28:07not like you know, it's the Road Warrior where you're on a semi and
- 28:11you can crawl up on the top of the semi and no, no,
- 28:12no, and and and so when you watch this stuff, you're like they're
- 28:17thinking, they're thinking, is so earthbound and it's so just uncreative and and
- 28:25frankly dumb. It's really dumb. Rob I'm sorry, finish yours. That's
- 28:33it. I was gonna say. I think you give them credit, saying
- 28:37that they watched Buffy and Angel I think they just grew up on teen romance
- 28:41period and everything is teen romance, and I as you do. I dread
- 28:47Starfleet Academy because that's gonna be even worse. And you know, again,
- 28:52we we love the First Duty fantastic next Jennifer I said, I love the
- 28:59Deep Space nine one where they're with Red Squad, right yea or jac and
- 29:03not. And it's like, no, you can do good Cadet stories,
- 29:07lower Deck, the original next Gen lower Deck story, which is about young
- 29:11officers. But you know, fine, okay, so you could do it,
- 29:15but again, good lord, the whole Serou and the woman from Navarre.
- 29:19Do you think she likes me? I don't know if she likes me.
- 29:21It's like, what the fuck am I watching? This isn't Degrassi Star
- 29:25Trek. But that's all they know. That's all they know. Yep,
- 29:27you know, and they haven't read you know, recently, werner VINGI died.
- 29:33Verner Vini was one of our great grand masters of modern science fiction.
- 29:37He wrote a novel called A Fire upon the Deep that I recommend everybody read
- 29:41that book alone, if that's all they read. There was enough ideas in
- 29:47that one science fiction novel that could have powered seasons of modern Trek. Because
- 29:52remember, a season of Trek is only ten episodes, or fifteen. They
- 29:56got out of Discovery thirteen, but now this season's ten. There were twenty
- 30:00six episodes of the Berman era Trek shows, twenty six And I don't know.
- 30:06I mean, I don't like to hate on things, but in the
- 30:11long run, dumb Star Trek is bad for our civilization because it's not asking
- 30:18our audience is being pandered to by lowest common denominator material. Whereas Star Trek
- 30:26used to be the exact opposite. At a time when America was tearing itself
- 30:30apart, Star Trek offered optimism, and it offered intelligence, and it offered
- 30:37a future where you had to be good at what you did. It expected
- 30:42humanity to be up here, not mediocre Star Trek. Discovery is a show
- 30:48about mediocre people who were either miraculously helicopter parented, people that are just perfect,
- 30:55or people that are just they're okay. There was an early review of
- 31:00this season and they compared to the crew of Discovery to an office atmosphere of
- 31:06cubicles, and it's like these are your co workers who demand you look at
- 31:11their photos of their grandchildren and let's make sure we all get together and sing
- 31:15happy birthday, you know for whoever, as opposed to the people that need
- 31:19to get your ass out of that foxhole while enemy fire is overhead. And
- 31:22it's so true, man, And I also know, and it drives me
- 31:26nuts that now they question, wells Starfleet a military you know system or not,
- 31:33And it's like, well, no, they're explores, yes, but
- 31:37they're military explorites, and there's a chain of command. And my god,
- 31:41any other Starfleet captain that we've ever seen has been you know, one of
- 31:47if you sneak out against the captain, hey, why don't you go to
- 31:49your quarters? Or even better, why do a'tlways put you in the brig
- 31:52And that's why Michael Burnham from day one has been this annoying character. And
- 31:57I'm sorry, I'd like to I know every one of these actors are decent
- 32:02and delightful, delightful people, and it's not their fault they're giving ship to
- 32:07me. And and she's a she's a classic example. And it bums me
- 32:10out because and also she Spock's sister, and it's like fuck you, I'm
- 32:15sorry. It's what the what they've done to Spock on Strange New Worlds is
- 32:22a crime. Yeah. And and this idea that will Spock, the Spock
- 32:25we know, wasn't fully formed. No, no, no, he was.
- 32:29He had to be better than any Vulcan because he was he was decried
- 32:34by Vulcan society, and you know, he had he was the first person
- 32:37to leave to join Starfleet, the first Vulcan to join Starfleet or maybe okay,
- 32:43that might not be necessarily canonical, but he had to be better than
- 32:46any Vulcan. And the way they saddle what do they do. They saddle
- 32:51him with a relationship with Nurse Chapel. Spock would never have a relationship on
- 32:55his ship, I mean, and what they did with him and to Pray
- 33:00and all that, they just they just turn these characters into generic TV characters.
- 33:05They're all involved because they don't know, they don't know how to write
- 33:07science fiction, so all they write is relationship drama stuff from any generic I
- 33:13mean, when you're watching I've been watching with Elizabeth, I've been watching The
- 33:15Residents, which is a network another medical drama. Half half the show,
- 33:22like with any medical drama, it's formulaic. You see people come in every
- 33:25week and they have medical problems, and then you have the soap opera.
- 33:29Who's involved with who and what's going on? That is just a generic TV
- 33:34trope, right, and Star Trek didn't used to have that. Star Trek
- 33:37was an anthology show, you know, that had the recurring characters, and
- 33:43now now it's not. Now they focus they're more interested in who's hooking up
- 33:46with who, who's shipping who, and it's it's utterly ridiculous because these characters
- 33:54would not be involved with each other. At least we wouldn't be seeing it
- 33:59because we only have an app an episode, so to spend any time on
- 34:01their inner personal relationships is bizarre to me. The the episode it was second
- 34:12yes, it was second season of US Strange New Worlds. When the ethereal
- 34:15beings, I forget what the problem was with them, But when Chapel was
- 34:22with Uhura, and I forget and maybe the helmsman and they were they were
- 34:29on that planet and they well they you know, they reconfigured Spack into a
- 34:32funeral. She's trying to plead the case of why, you know, they
- 34:37need to make him the way he was and she has to profess her love
- 34:40and she makes the two other crew members turn around while she's talked to these
- 34:45ethereal things, and it's like, come on, man again, this is
- 34:49not Degrassi. What the hell are you doing? Why are you wasting our
- 34:52time with this crap? And you you're absolutely right. They made Spack a
- 34:57freshman at high school. And it's like, you know, he was at
- 35:00the academy in San Francisco, likely interacting with humans. I don't know people,
- 35:06you know, it's so ridiculous, I mean, you know, but
- 35:08it's funny if you look at if you look at you know. So you
- 35:14have the Twilight Zone that aired from fifty nine to sixty four and Rod Sterling,
- 35:19like Gene Ronberry and like Joseph Stefano and Leslie Stevens on Outer Limits.
- 35:23These are there were subjects you couldn't you couldn't do on TV because of network
- 35:28standards and practices. They wouldn't let you do it. But if it's from
- 35:31the Twilight Zone or it's in the twenty third century, you could. You
- 35:37could allegorically tell your story about Vietnam or an anti war story, or deal
- 35:42with religion, or or deal with racism or deal with any number of things,
- 35:46because it's in the Twilight Zone, so that's not our world. And
- 35:52that's and then of course the people that wrote those those were some of the
- 35:55great fantasists of the time as a matter of fact, whether it's Richard Mathison
- 36:00or Charles Bowmont. I mean, Matheson wrote on on twilight Zone and Star
- 36:04Trek, you know. And Matheson wrote for Shatner on Twilight Zone and Chatner
- 36:08on Star Trek, you know. And you had these these these writers who,
- 36:13by the way, were people of letters, you know. They not
- 36:15only they come out of the Greatest generation and lived through a war, but
- 36:20but they also were playwrights and novelists and short story writers, and they were
- 36:24well read, and they and they didn't have television, so they i mean
- 36:28all they had were movies and radio, uh you know, as far as
- 36:31entertainment, and yeah, you're right, man. And and nowadays the only
- 36:36people people they know TV shows. They know Joss Whedon, they know Buffy
- 36:40the Vampire Slayer, they know Firefly, they know Angel maybe a little Dollhouse
- 36:45and and their entire everything they write. It doesn't matter whether it's a medical
- 36:49show, whether it's a science fiction show, whether it's a horror show,
- 36:52it's all the same. It's all this generic interpersonal relationship bs. I mean,
- 36:58you're you're never going to get an episode like the Doomsday Machine. And
- 37:01then modern Star Trek is constantly dipping in there. They're saying that, well,
- 37:07you know, we're gonna go into the thirty second century so we can
- 37:09leave Star Trek Cannon behind. And what is this fifth season of Discovery about
- 37:15a six season TG episode? The whole thing is a sequel to The Chase,
- 37:19The Chase yep, and like, what is are you being clever?
- 37:24You know? And again, Rob, you've seen five episodes. I've only
- 37:28seen two, And like many other Discovery seasons, you might start with,
- 37:32all right, well I don't know where they're going, but at least it's
- 37:36an intriguing opening. But it's it's that JJ abrams mystery Box, mystery Box,
- 37:40mystery Box. And this season my buddy Wayne, who does my Star
- 37:46Trek review show, he'll be on on Monday. We were talking today and
- 37:51he's like, so basically we do a national treasure at Star Trek. This
- 37:54Yeah, yeah, you know, listen, man, what's the great Romulin
- 38:00First? Season track episode that you love Bounce a Terror, Bounce to Terror
- 38:06is Run Silent, the Enemy of the Enemy below, any classic submarine thing
- 38:10and in fact, Rob I don't know if you heard it, but one
- 38:14of the satellite Trexpert shows, the one that Lisa Clint does an episode.
- 38:20Man, this week's episode is fantastic, and they got the guy who wrote,
- 38:22who co wrote Future Imperfect, the Reiker episode Everybody where Riker wakes up.
- 38:30It's fifteen years later. He's like, yeah, and he's like,
- 38:32I don't know what that was going on. It's a fantastic episode, very
- 38:36strong, and he, to his credit admitted because he had years of seventy
- 38:42dramatic writing as well as Star Trek and other eighty shows, and he's like,
- 38:45listen, we stole from everything. You know. You know, the
- 38:49gun on I Plannet zero a hero and that's what you know, Kelly Dirty
- 38:57does it doesn't seconially, you know, yeah, or guns of Navarone,
- 39:00you know, the Navarona absolutely, and it says, look, that's fine,
- 39:05but you got to be clever with your adaptation. And so you know,
- 39:07when last season of Discovery started and all the oh no, it was
- 39:13two seasons ago. No, yeah, it was two seasons when the di
- 39:16lithium was inert. Okay, go ahead, Well that was I mean,
- 39:22I understand there's a you're looking at the fuel crisis. Somebody was like,
- 39:24that's mad Max. Well yeah, it's idea, but it was so first
- 39:30of all, it was completely implausible. It was so stupid. And not
- 39:35every species in the Star Trek universe that he uses dilithium for faster than light
- 39:39travel. The romulants, especially in the era of Next Generation, have controlled
- 39:44singularities. They have artificial singularities powering their warp drive. So the idea that
- 39:50I understand, you want to have a fuel crisis, but then you have
- 39:52this character that is like his DNA is tied to dilithium and him screaming out
- 39:58blew up. It was it's so stupid crying and that's why all the dialethium
- 40:02went in Earth. And it's like, you're going, do you guys,
- 40:06have you ever read a second grade biology book? Have you ever studied science
- 40:10at all? And they come up with these ideas, and I wonder,
- 40:13like who thought of that? You know? And another thing that's really frustrating
- 40:17is I'm I'm a huge fan of I don't think it's going to come as
- 40:22any surprise to anyone who knows that I love Star Trek novels. Me too,
- 40:27buddy, And like, I don't want to stack these up, but
- 40:30I've been this novel, The Final Reflection, Oh, Yes, Ford john
- 40:36Ford's The Final Reflection, Yes, sir, this is the definitive book written
- 40:42on the Klingon Empire. Yes. And if you want to know what a
- 40:45great Star Trek story is, if you want to understand the Klingons, this
- 40:49book. It's not canonical, but it's a better Klingon story than ninety percent
- 40:54of what we've ever seen in Star Trek. And the frustrating thing for me
- 40:59is, as a Star Trek novel fan, I've discovered my first James Blish's
- 41:04Spock Must Die in my elementary school library. I'm in Park Elementary School,
- 41:07I Mersa, Washington. That's why I discovered it and read it. And
- 41:10I'm like, there's more thought and consideration put in to many of the Star
- 41:17Trek novels than anything we've been getting since twenty seventeen on TV, actually since
- 41:22two thousand and nine. JJ abrams Star Trek movie, and it's frustrating same
- 41:28as true of Star Wars. It's frustrating when the best of the novels understand
- 41:35way more about the universe than the people that are getting really well paid to
- 41:38write Star Trek episodes or episodes. And it's like I would say, if
- 41:45you're going to write for Star Trek, you should just read. If they
- 41:47only read one Star Trek novel, I would say, this should be it,
- 41:52you know. And one of my favorite science fiction writers wrote this book,
- 41:57Corona. Greg Barry passed away back two years ago. But this book
- 42:01alone has more interesting science fiction concepts than most of modern Star Trek, which
- 42:09have barely any science fiction concepts. And hell, just to keep going,
- 42:15here's another one, the early Star Trek book, Sonny Cooper's Blackfire. Spock
- 42:20becomes a space pirate. This is the kind of thing that they're writing today.
- 42:24But this is oh so much better. I hear you, man,
- 42:30Larry Young just sent me a care package of Star Trek novels. So here,
- 42:34let me let me match what you were doing and everything. And these
- 42:37are a lot of the early ones. You can't even see him because of
- 42:40my well, Corona, that's it. That's that's the same book. I
- 42:45just showed the hardcover. You did, yes, so I did just get
- 42:49Corona. He also sent me the box set of all the James Busch stuff.
- 42:52Well, James Bush, now all I knew him from was his Star
- 42:55Trek adaptations. Shame on me. I'm listening to an old X minus one
- 43:00science fiction anthology show and it's a fantastic story. It's called Surface Tension,
- 43:06written by James Bush, a very fantas story, too, fantastic story,
- 43:10and a good adaptation of the short story as well. You know again,
- 43:15you're right, man, I mean we get we get weak writers writing Star
- 43:21Trek these days. I'm sorry, everybody, It's just the way it is.
- 43:23And I and also when they go, well, you know, we
- 43:27do have a science advisor on the show, and that first in the first
- 43:30season has strange in your worlds the Ahura episode where they're on the planetoid and
- 43:35they have the thing that's singing or whatever, and the crew member goes,
- 43:38well, as we all know, space is very loud, and it's like,
- 43:43that's not how my science class went. And you know, I'm like,
- 43:46wait a minute, no, they're in a vacuum. I'm like,
- 43:50no, there's that sound. I'm sorry, and I don't know if there
- 43:52is, because I know there have been pulsars that I think they have done
- 43:55and make sound or whatever. But I'm it's like they get one idea,
- 44:00like the idea of a tartar grade. You know, when Brian Fuller first
- 44:04developed Discovery, there was going to be a tartar grade crew member in the
- 44:10engineering section that worked with Stam It's named Ephraine, and then they turned him
- 44:15into that spacefaring tartar grade that could like somehow travel through warp you know,
- 44:21in the mycellular network, which is just utterly ridiculous in the first place,
- 44:25Like you have a propulsion system that's based on plants and you're looking at this
- 44:31going and you can tell because that wasn't in Fuller's original conception of the show.
- 44:37The entire thing about the mycellular network was a terraforming issue. And when
- 44:40you read I'm not saying i've read them, but if you read Fuller's original
- 44:46story outlines, there's about one hundred and fifty pages where they beat out the
- 44:50entire first season. When Fuller was let go because of budgetary issues because apparently
- 44:54they didn't realize they have to pay a lot up front because you have to
- 44:58build sets that you're going to add ties across the whole season. That's why
- 45:01it's expensive upfront. You make up those costs later. They took those ideas
- 45:08and they wanted to make them. Kurtzmen and the people he hired wanted to
- 45:10make them their own. So they're like, oh, well, there's like
- 45:15the mycellur network. It'll be like Dune or something. And it just Okay,
- 45:21none of that works. You're telling me a starship is going to travel
- 45:24through a mushroom network of what. And so they adapted an idea that was
- 45:32about terraforming and turned it into a propulsion system and you're like, come on,
- 45:36man, that's not credible. You can't have a propulsion system that takes
- 45:40you anywhere in the universe whenever you want. Why are you in the Milky
- 45:43Way galaxy? Then why don't you go ten trillion light years away to another
- 45:46galaxy? Well, you see how the instantaneous travel that Discovery shows with that
- 45:54ship, and I loved again in the first episode where they're like, oh,
- 45:58they're going to abandon the maceionial engines and stuff, and it's like,
- 46:04wow, at least Discovery still has its one and it's like, you guys
- 46:07do not get it. Goodbye, go Well that's the eighth episode and you
- 46:10guys can leave out. I mean, one of the things that drove me
- 46:14crazy in the second season with the Red Angel or whatever, they talk about
- 46:19how these beacons appeared all at the same time throughout the galaxy. And it's
- 46:23like, guys, light travels one hundred and eighty six thousand miles per second,
- 46:30and all of these lights are in different parts of the galaxy. Some
- 46:35of them would the light would have taken how long to get here? You
- 46:38can't just see these beacons and then we observe them. And when I see
- 46:42stuff like that, it's like even I as a cursory, when I was
- 46:46a kid, I would have known the reason it took them seventy five years
- 46:50to get back from the delta quadrant is because of the distance. And when
- 46:53you're telling me that lights are turning on at the same time throughout the galaxy,
- 46:57I'm like, you people are stupid, and why are you writing the
- 47:00show. They weren't paying attention to their grade school science class when they would
- 47:05say, you know, this star is burning out, we're just seeing it
- 47:08now. But that happened thousands of years ago. I remember learning that in
- 47:13grade school science. It's like, again, these people are ridiculous, Wayne,
- 47:17I hear you. If the writers don't want to read, they can
- 47:21watch Star Trek the animated series to see how you can incorporate science with the
- 47:23story. Because the same people that wrote the original series were writing the animated
- 47:29series. Samuel Peeples, was it Larry Larry Larry Niven, They wrote Slaver
- 47:36Weapon, you know, his known space series. I mean, how cool
- 47:39is that his known space series crossed over with Star Trek The Chuffed Captain of
- 47:45the KAZINTI good it was. I'm with you, So I'm so with you.
- 47:51Absolutely go ahead. If I ever met Michelle Paradise, I'm like,
- 47:54you know, it's like when Larry Niven wrote a wrote an episode the animated
- 47:58series, she'd be like, well, who's lay Niven? And was there
- 48:00an animated series? You mean it's not Prodigy or lower Decks. You're not
- 48:04talking about really short treks? Are you that fantastic? Oh my god?
- 48:07I know, dude, dude honest. And again you see Wayne is on
- 48:12Like I said, Wayne will be on my Monday show with my buddies,
- 48:14Franco and Mitch as well. But really, I'm like kind of you on
- 48:20that show, and they, God bless them, they tolerated me, but
- 48:22truly, man, you know, I was literally tearing my vast amount of
- 48:27hair out watching those very short treks. They weren't even funny, let alone
- 48:31clever or interesting. They were just gross. And I mean that that that
- 48:39that was an abasement of the franchise. I mean, you know, it's
- 48:45funny people get mad at me for you know, you're an old man shouting
- 48:49at the Simpsons meme, which I've gotten a hundred million times, and everybody,
- 48:52every yeah, everybody sends it to me like you're an old man shout.
- 48:54No, No, I'm not an old man shouting at clouds. You
- 48:58might think I'm old, which guilty is charged. But this stuff is bad,
- 49:04It's stupid, and it's degrading to the franchise, which is why the
- 49:07franchise. I mean, it's really interesting because as an old school Trekker like
- 49:12myself, you know, I love the original series. But you could make
- 49:15an argument that Star Trek reached its zenith in nineteen ninety four on when Next
- 49:20Generation ended its seven year run with all good things. You had generations coming
- 49:24out. Whether you love generations or not, it still is a feature film
- 49:28that brought both generations together, Shatner and Kirk and Picard. It was on
- 49:31the cover of Time magazine when Next Generation ended with all good things. It
- 49:37went out with huge ratings, especially for a first run syndicated dramatic show.
- 49:42It changed the face it Star Trek. The Next Generation proved one hour dramatic
- 49:46syndication could work because before that it was all game shows and talk shows.
- 49:51Changed the face the TV, which led to our streaming that we have today.
- 49:55And Star Trek was at its most popular in ninety four as a result
- 50:00of Next Gen. And then you know, obviously things started to change.
- 50:05I mean, I love Deep Space nine, but that kind of was the
- 50:07bastard stepchild of everything. And it's unfair because what happens when a post scarcity
- 50:15utopian civilization has to deal with an existential threat from another part of the galaxy
- 50:20that isn't a utopian civilization that has bent on destroying us, whether we deserve
- 50:25it or not. And when a war is thrust upon it's like Aragorn saying,
- 50:30wars upon you, whether you wish it or not. And The great
- 50:34thing I love about Deep Space nine when people like let you know, Rob
- 50:37Bradenberry would have hated Deep Space nine, and that might be true. But
- 50:42what I love about Deep Space nine is it is about how do utopians maintain
- 50:47their utopian ideals in the face of an extinction event that is brought about by
- 50:52other sentient creatures who might have a point. And that because comes fascinating when
- 51:02this summer at terrific on late or mid August, I'll be a terrific on
- 51:07and here's the various Trek people that are going to be there. And right
- 51:12there in the center underneath the Chekhov is Nana visitor Major Kira. She's amazing,
- 51:17absolutely, and the character is amazing, amazing. You go back to
- 51:22that first season and you really understand that Kira, who was a terrorist,
- 51:28has to deal with this new the intrusion of Starfleet and all the different things
- 51:32that happened to her character. And then in the seventh season she has to
- 51:37teach the very oppressors that she was dealing with how to be terrorists. And
- 51:44yes, Odo absolutely, and it's uh, it's great and I'm really I'm
- 51:47looking forward to talking to it. And before the convention and have a zoom
- 51:52talk or a streamer talk like we're doing. She's amazing. And a woman
- 51:57who's in her sixties who proves that you never have to lose that sex appeal
- 52:00because she's She's an incredible woman. I could say the same about Terry Farrell,
- 52:06who was not quite sixty, but yeah, I met her at a
- 52:09terrific on last year. Could not have been nicer. They're all in I
- 52:13mean, all of them are so great. Me and Andrew Robinson had a
- 52:16wonderful conversation here and that was terrific. And Frank's was great to me.
- 52:22Andrew Robinson wrote one of the greatest Star Trek novels ever written, A Stitch
- 52:25in Time, and people forget that he did that. And you know,
- 52:30these are Andrew, These are also as actors. These are people have really
- 52:35long running careers, you know. And me and Andrew Robinson was the Psycho
- 52:38and Dirty Harry, right, you know, he was Scorpio and then he
- 52:43was of course in Clive Barker's Hell Raiser back in eighty seven, and he
- 52:46was Liberachi. He was Liberty Biography, and he was Kennedy on the eighties
- 52:52Twilight Zone. Yes, he was great, great actor, wonderful. Range
- 52:57could not have been sweeter. And again, Garrett, I mean that's the
- 53:00great thing. DS nine evolved from Next Gen and gave us even more complicated
- 53:06characters. And Gerrik is fantastic that way. At times you love him.
- 53:10At times he's ready to kill everybody because that is the only way out of
- 53:15a situation. And Deep Space nine gave us Section thirty one where it was
- 53:19just one guy. One guy would show up, you know, William Sadler,
- 53:22Sloan would show up. And now Discovery to show how they don't section
- 53:28thirty one. In Discovery, they have their own memberships, they have their
- 53:30own com badges, they have their headquarters, they have their own ships.
- 53:32It's like no, no, no, no, no, no no.
- 53:35The whole point of Deep Space nine is that Deep spaces line pointed out as
- 53:39Section thirty one doesn't exist. You can't prove they exist. You don't know
- 53:44where they are. Sloan would just show up in Basher's room and we'd walk
- 53:49out and he'd disappear. And that's the way it should have been. It
- 53:52should have stayed that way. Now we're getting a Section thirty one movie that
- 53:54Michelle Yoh herself says, well, it's mission impossible in space. And it's
- 54:00like, of course, because you don't know what Star Trek is. You
- 54:02never watched Deep Space nine, so you don't even know what and you're gonna
- 54:07rip off those fault. No, it's certainly not Michelle Yeo's fault. Yes
- 54:09again, writers, Well, dude, as you know, Strange New Worlds,
- 54:14they have the big trial for number one being revealed as being genetically enhanced.
- 54:19Compare that to Deep Space nine, doctor Bischer, I presume, and
- 54:23and again as opposed to asking the debatable question. You know, there's a
- 54:30slippery slope with genetic enhancements, and that's why the Federation is careful about it.
- 54:35Instead it's well, this is discrimination and this is death wrong, and
- 54:38it's really it's like this bossy girl from Mean Girls suddenly just you know,
- 54:45scolding us that well that's the way it should be. And it's like,
- 54:47yeah, you really like lost the message of the debate because it isn't easy
- 54:53and all they I mean, there was no equal weight to Starfleet and the
- 54:57Federation's point of view of listen, we want people that are blind to be
- 55:01able to see, and we want to be able to help people with scientific
- 55:05advances. However, we had this real threat from Ton you know, in
- 55:10the nineties, and Spock said it, you know, the scientists forgot that
- 55:16when you breed superior human beings, you get superior ambition. And he says
- 55:22it in Space Seeds so and and also what they also forget is eugenics was
- 55:28something that was spoken about here in American history and really ugly ways to get
- 55:31rid of certain races. The Germans with their eugenicis eugenics programs. The Uber
- 55:38mentioned all of that. Eugenics programs go back to the nineteen even the eighteen
- 55:43hundreds, and it was it's a really ugly idea. And in science fiction,
- 55:49when you deal with things like gatica, you know, it does a
- 55:52really great job of dealing with you know, Ethan Hawk's character being somebody who's
- 55:55not genetically enhanced and has to It proves that a human being can step up
- 56:00to the level. Just because you are given genetic gifts through genetic tampering doesn't
- 56:05mean that people necessarily who aren't that way are lesser human beings. And Blade
- 56:10Runner, you know, I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. We've been
- 56:14dealing with this in science fiction all the time, and with UNA's backstory,
- 56:17it felt like no one ever even thought about the fact that these have been
- 56:22dealt with, not just in Star Trek history, but in science fiction and
- 56:25in our literature for the last hundred years. And because nobody on the show
- 56:30knew. And I'll tell you something else, UNA's entire backstory was stolen from
- 56:35Dorothy Fontana's one Star Trek novel Vulcan's Glory, and they never gave her credit,
- 56:42just like just like Strange New worlds ripped off Ursula kay Lea Gwyn's story
- 56:45Those Who walk Away from Umlass, you know, which is a great short
- 56:50story where one one child, you know, you have this utopian civilization that
- 56:54everybody's living in this perfect life, but one child, one child has to
- 57:00take the pain and the suffering of all. They just flat out ripped that
- 57:04short story off without a credation. And and and if you go back to
- 57:08the original series Arena that Frederick Brown is credited for gene Kon like they thought
- 57:15that, you know this, this is really this skews really close to a
- 57:20Frederick Brown short story, and they're they admitted like, well, maybe I
- 57:22read that I don't know, but they gave him credit anyway. Now Ursula
- 57:29Kaylea Gwinn is no longer with us, I don't believe so, of course
- 57:35Dorothy Fontana is either. And good Lord the Great, the the the first
- 57:39lady literally of Star Trek, who to the Vulcans to find the Vulcans,
- 57:47and and it's like they're just going in there and taking this stuff. You
- 57:52know. I don't even know if I can say this. I don't even
- 57:55know if I can say this, but I'm gonna say it anyway because I'm
- 58:00shocked by this. So Dave Blass, who is the production designer of Star
- 58:05Trek Percard season three, Okay, he lives in Toronto. He's a local
- 58:09where they shoot. He did a ninety page presentation for Starfleet Academy. Ninety
- 58:22pages it is, and I've seen lots of presentations of all different kinds of
- 58:25people in my time in the industry. It is one of the most impressive
- 58:30documents I've ever seen as far as production design. And because he's a huge
- 58:36Star Trek fan, they wouldn't even see him. And he did the card
- 58:40season three he rebuilt. I'm sure they had already hired somebody. But to
- 58:45look at that document, I mean it shows right there. It's like this
- 58:51guy, I don't know what you're doing as star Trek, but this guy
- 58:54proves he already did Percard season three for you. You know, see you
- 58:59have multiple starships, you have Federation things. I mean, he did such
- 59:04great work. But this document, this document is one of the most incredible.
- 59:07If you were to publish this as an art book, it doesn't,
- 59:12you know, have the text. You could have somebody to write text.
- 59:14Jeff Bond could write the text. They should, They should publish this book
- 59:16The Unseen Dave Blast's Unseen Starfleet Academy. It's incredible. Didn't get brought back,
- 59:27no, I hear you, man, and I certainly I'm in Metallis's
- 59:30character camp as well. And also the thing everybody has to remember regarding Cards
- 59:36season three, because we all, the majority of us loved it. And
- 59:39the thing is they were operating with less money than the well and I don't
- 59:44know about the COVID year obviously with season two, but he was operating with
- 59:47less money and they managed to make it work and be effective and impressive.
- 59:53And it's like, so that's why you need a Dave blessed the way these
- 59:57people, they spend money to use them metaphor like a drunken sailor. They
- 1:00:01when ash. In the first season of Discovery, they're in the mess hall
- 1:00:07and he puts his feet up on a table and you see the gold lamet
- 1:00:12edges on his shoes. It's like, you're spending money on that, but
- 1:00:15you couldn't find money in the budget to get better writers. What the fuck
- 1:00:19is going on? Well? Are there better writers? I mean they're working
- 1:00:24on Star Trek, right, I mean they're you're seeing we're living We're living
- 1:00:29in a Oh what they did to him was I that? To me,
- 1:00:35it was the most anti Star Trek thing I've ever But again it shows the
- 1:00:39fact that this younger generation, this activist generation, they all are. We
- 1:00:44we saw it unfortunately a week ago or two weeks ago with what happened ed
- 1:00:47piscoor and and which is a damn shame. But uh it does. It
- 1:00:54drives me. It just drives me bananas what goes on? But I but
- 1:00:59I think that you know, we are living through a golden age. Look
- 1:01:02at a husband and wife team that are bringing a showgun who great show,
- 1:01:08great show, unbelievable I mean Shogun forty four years ago, in nineteen eighty
- 1:01:13when at first they first adopted Glavelle's novel. It is one of my favorite
- 1:01:15things I've ever Shogun is and I try and explain this to people. Shogun
- 1:01:22is a Star Trek story. Shogun is about a man from the Federation who
- 1:01:28travels to a different world, an alien world that he's that's completely and he
- 1:01:35finds himself lost, stranded in an alien world, and in the best Star
- 1:01:39Trek tradition, ends up getting embroiled in the politics, learning new traditions,
- 1:01:45seeing an alien, seeing these aliens that that, and he has to come
- 1:01:49up to their level even though they're very different than him. And it's funny.
- 1:01:52That's why I've always thought when I was a kid, and I love,
- 1:01:54I was thirteen when Shogun was on, and I'm like, this is
- 1:01:59the greatest thing, like ever and I love I've watched Shogun and now seeing
- 1:02:05the new version, I was so worried it was gonna be terrible. But
- 1:02:07here you have two people and the husband and wife, the showrunners, they
- 1:02:10knew what they're doing, and you look at Showgun and you're like, that's
- 1:02:15a Star Trek show. You know, people look at me like, what,
- 1:02:19I go, Showgun. Star Trek should be the Tiffany the gold standard
- 1:02:23of what science fiction on TV is. It has become the bottom the well
- 1:02:28Doctor who's probably in the lower basement than Star Trek. But Shogun is the
- 1:02:31gold stand doctor. Who Oh my god, but Showgun Showgun. If somebody
- 1:02:38said to me, what's the best Star Trek show on TV? Showgun Shoguntar
- 1:02:43Trek show if you've made the analogy before too for at October is a great
- 1:02:46Star Trek story. Master and Commander is a great Star Trek story. The
- 1:02:51West the West Wing was a great Star Trek TV show. Yes, oh
- 1:02:55my god. And again the way they handled with whatever that anomaly was called
- 1:03:00last year on Discovery and it's like, well, now you've got an opportunity
- 1:03:04to really do a West Wing kind of episode where the Federation for all the
- 1:03:08different planets. What do you think we got to do? What do you
- 1:03:10think we're now? We get a knucklehead story. And I always love and
- 1:03:15I always pick on all of a new New Trek. Until Picard season three,
- 1:03:21you had this background actor in a Ferengi mask, never speaking, but
- 1:03:25just always like like like a kid in fourth grade that doesn't understand what's going
- 1:03:30on. And it's just like Jesus man, can we have like another race
- 1:03:37beyond sirouse and and you know the president who was multi racial or whatever,
- 1:03:43Yeah, we have somebody else talk because again it's like, you know what,
- 1:03:46what are the Cleons think of this? What do the Romulans think of
- 1:03:50this? All the different races? Well, we never, we never.
- 1:03:52And that's the funny thing. What is the geopolitical situation in the galaxy?
- 1:03:58If they show this, I mean it's gonna be It's so funny to me
- 1:04:01that Discovery goes into the future and leans into the post apocalyptic. They turn
- 1:04:06the Star Trek universe into a post apocalyptic landscape, because that's all anybody knows
- 1:04:12how to do is dystopia. It's harder to write a utopia than it is
- 1:04:17to write a dystopia because they don't These people don't know, they don't know
- 1:04:21how to build. They can't envision what a future would be like. That's
- 1:04:27why everything is so of today. You know. It's it's like, let's
- 1:04:30lean back on our activist culture today. And I think that's what you know,
- 1:04:35people are. It's not about. It's not like we're anti any kinds
- 1:04:42of people. What we're what we're about, though, is if you bring
- 1:04:47the politics of the future and make it of today, it's no longer speculative
- 1:04:53fiction. It's no longer science fiction. You're not extrapolating. It's very first
- 1:04:58of all, it's very unimaginative. It's very uncreative, and it's easy because
- 1:05:03the people writing aren't science fiction fans, so they can't science fiction takes.
- 1:05:11Brian Aldus said that science fiction was always a way to in our confused state
- 1:05:16of technological achievement. It was a way that we made sense of our world.
- 1:05:21You know that we don't quite know where it's going and where all of
- 1:05:25this is is taking us. So science fiction was a way to try and
- 1:05:29examine that and sort of extrapolate where might we go and what are we going
- 1:05:34to have to deal with? You know, I've seen things you people wouldn't
- 1:05:38believe. Attack, ships on fire, off the shoulder of Orion, all
- 1:05:43those moments, I've seen seabeams glittering the dark. Now the ten Holser gays,
- 1:05:46all those moments will be lost in time like tears in the rain.
- 1:05:50Because replicants had souls and humans didn't think that artificial people could, but they
- 1:06:00did and and and they were being It was the same thing in the Measure
- 1:06:03of a Man second season of TNG, Whoopy Goldberg says, oh, disposable
- 1:06:09people. You're going to create an entire race of disposable people. And Picard's
- 1:06:14like, you're talking about slavery, now, yeah, you finally had to
- 1:06:17say it. You had to say the word slavery to make people understand.
- 1:06:20But you're dealing with an android. You're dealing with a Sun's creation, positronic
- 1:06:26brain. And if you could figure out how to duplicate that, which,
- 1:06:29by the way, in Picard's season number one, you know, like they
- 1:06:33no one saw that episode. No one is most because we have we have
- 1:06:38the disposable race in the sense on Mars, totally disposable. Yes, they
- 1:06:44missed the point completely formalousness nodgress. Thank god, people like you and I
- 1:06:48are raising a torch to her, and God, you're awesome, buddy.
- 1:06:50We don't know what the hell they did to your shit, but all they
- 1:06:54did was ruined the best episode of season two. Well, it's clear that
- 1:06:58no one had actually watched the Measure of a Man that's the thing that kills
- 1:07:03me. I don't think Alex Kurtzman ever watched Space Seed when I watched Star
- 1:07:09Trek Into Darkness, which I think is one of the worst big budget science
- 1:07:12fiction movies ever made. They don't know who Con is. If you were
- 1:07:15to ask Alex Kurtzman who was Con Noonian Singh? Where did he come from?
- 1:07:20Because in Strange New Worlds, apparently it's from Toronto. I mean,
- 1:07:25they completely changed the timeline and it's like, I cannot watch this garbage because
- 1:07:30you people prove episode after episode you haven't watched your own continuity, and at
- 1:07:36the same time you gaslight your own audience, going oh no, no,
- 1:07:40this is the continuity. I'm like, you can't change characters that you didn't
- 1:07:43create. Star Trek made, you know, Star Trek pioneered the idea.
- 1:07:47The most genius thing was when they used the rejected pilot the Cage in the
- 1:07:53two part episode The Menagerie in the first season of the original series, because
- 1:07:58they showed us what you're watching eleven years ago. So you got to see
- 1:08:01the bridge of the Enterprise with a different captain, slightly different colors, different
- 1:08:05uniforms, and you're like, wow, there's now a continuity here in Wrath
- 1:08:11of Khn. You show me a man who I've been seen in fifteen years
- 1:08:15and wants to kill me. You now have a timeline, so you can
- 1:08:18go from Space Seed to Wrath of Khan. It's been fifteen years and then
- 1:08:24before Space Seed it was eleven years ago. So suddenly Star Trek, It's
- 1:08:28fictional universe has a continuity. It has canon. We've seen it on camera
- 1:08:33the people who in for the thirtieth anniversary, the crew of the Deep Space
- 1:08:36nine uses the orb of Time and goes back to Space Sea. It goes
- 1:08:42back to trouble with Tribles, and you see the Enterprise the way it looked
- 1:08:45in nineteen sixty six. In nineteen ninety six, thirty years later, nobody
- 1:08:50came out and said, you know, we have to redesign the Enterprise.
- 1:08:54No, the Enterprise, that's that's history. It's it's a history of the
- 1:08:58future that will never exist, but with its in its own continuity. It
- 1:09:01has a history. That's why people love Lord of the Rings, That's why
- 1:09:03people love Game of Thrones. That's why people love Star Trek and Star Wars
- 1:09:08and Doctor Who. New writers of Doctor Who let's subvert where the doctor came
- 1:09:11from. I mean, it's unbelievable to me that they don't understand. Part
- 1:09:16of the value of being a fan is you can go back. Star Trek
- 1:09:20is the most documented fictional universe of all time. How I have shelves of
- 1:09:25books over there, so do what continent chronologies, technical manuals, blueprints?
- 1:09:31I mean, it's all there, and they don't. It's apparent that the
- 1:09:35people work on Star Trek now don't look at any of this stuff. Well,
- 1:09:41and also you got Kurtzman in all those pre launch of season five interviews.
- 1:09:47He did and well, you know, we've created different tricks for different
- 1:09:50fans, and we and like Pee, we were I meant to do that.
- 1:09:54No you didn't. Now you didn't, and you're full of shit and
- 1:09:57we all know you're full of shit. And it was never necessar Si.
- 1:10:00It's you know, we never wanted to make Star Trek for everyone. No,
- 1:10:03well, Jesus has certainly worked for almost fifty years prior to you.
- 1:10:06Eddiot's taking shit over and ruining it the way that you have. I fell
- 1:10:12in love with Star Trek when I was five years old, and every year
- 1:10:15that went by Star Trek meant something new, and I could see something new
- 1:10:17in it my entire life. I'm five years old watching Star Trek in seventy
- 1:10:21two. In seventy nine, Star Trek the motion picture comes out. When
- 1:10:25I started junior high, you know, my teenage years. Then I've got
- 1:10:29Wrath of Khan. I've got Search for Spock in nineteen eighty six when Voyage
- 1:10:36Home came out, first year of college, you know. And Star Trek
- 1:10:42has grown up with me up until two thousand and nine, when they're like,
- 1:10:46Nope, we're gonna go back and retaell the story of Kirk and Spock.
- 1:10:49And I'm like, wow, my youth, my life. Up to
- 1:10:54this point, I have been watching Star Trek grow and breathe. It started
- 1:10:59in sixty six. In two thousand and nine, Star Trek was what forty
- 1:11:01three years old then, and it's like, you guy, you have forty
- 1:11:05three years old. So you're like and and you're gonna rather than move forward,
- 1:11:11you're gonna go back and retell Kirk and Spock. But you're now going
- 1:11:14to reframe it in a Star Wars box. I hear you, man,
- 1:11:17But at least it was a different time. It was the Calvin universe and
- 1:11:20our old continuity still existed. But what they write, But the thing is
- 1:11:26they weren't going forward. They were to start. Star Trek has lived,
- 1:11:30evolved and changed with the times. Now Star Star Trek, Star Wars,
- 1:11:34I said, Star Wars, Star Trek is now. It's no longer.
- 1:11:39It's no longer commenting on our time. It is our time. Oh and
- 1:11:45that's what is the mistake. Well, and also again these weird choices and
- 1:11:51without any real explanation how it works. But again in strange worlds, when
- 1:11:57they re or introduced the idea that the eugenics war keeps getting pushed further into
- 1:12:02the future, how the fuck does that work? Well? And also this
- 1:12:06idea too, that's so stupid that the Star Trek past is our exact past.
- 1:12:14Yep, I mean in the first Sea actually the end of the second
- 1:12:15season in Assignment Earth, when Gary seven is introduced. Yeah, there's a
- 1:12:20nuclear weapons platform that didn't really exist in history. You know, it's not
- 1:12:24real, it's fake. It's we share a past, but it's not the
- 1:12:29same past. So in the Star Trek University, eugenics wars broke out in
- 1:12:33the nineties, and this idea that they're that. They're like, I don't
- 1:12:38think any person other than people working on Star Trek today think that it's supposed
- 1:12:43to be our past. And I know when Greg Cox wrote his con novels,
- 1:12:46he was like, well, how come we didn't have a real eugenics
- 1:12:48wars unlike? Because Star Trek is a fictional universe. It's it's Star Trek
- 1:12:54is the history of a future that will never occur, just like any future,
- 1:12:58just like any alternate universe. And you know, in Blade Runner twenty
- 1:13:02forty nine, no one thought to themselves, well, you know when Blade
- 1:13:05Renner was made, there were no cell phones, and Blade Renner took place
- 1:13:10in twenty nineteen and the technology was no dnevil Nuf said, Blade Runner is
- 1:13:15not our future. So in Blade Runner twenty forty nine, we're gonna have
- 1:13:18like wooden balls that have data on them and we're going to use it.
- 1:13:24It's an analog future. And because that didn't matter, what mattered is the
- 1:13:30idea of replicants, the idea of artificial people. What would they be like,
- 1:13:32what does it mean to us? And they know that, but the
- 1:13:35people that make modern Star Trek, it's like, no, no, no,
- 1:13:39we're gonna push the eugenics if you push the Eugenics wars forward. If
- 1:13:43you're gonna do that, then just say this isn't the continuity. Don't try
- 1:13:46and make Star Trek online shoehorn the Discovery into the goddamn game drives me crazy
- 1:13:53because that stuff is so ill thought of. Chris Subin, I agree with
- 1:13:58it. I know Rob does. Two Star Trek is that when both sides
- 1:14:00of the argument are given. I believe in a little rationale. Not really
- 1:14:03something I've seen in the new stuff. One little I've seen. No man
- 1:14:06again, they tell you how to think rather than think for yourself, private
- 1:14:10little war Man, Great Vietnam analogy from the original series. Hey, I
- 1:14:14don't suppose I could duck out for like a second. Well it means,
- 1:14:16man, I'll keep vamping on entertain entertain the mass. That'll be right back.
- 1:14:21You're a good man for sticking around. It's all good man, hilarious.
- 1:14:25See, this is why I have the guy on. Man is this
- 1:14:27kind of conversation here, I'm gonna take some comments made by the audience and
- 1:14:31we'll keep going here. Let's see. Uh. Cooper says, Yeah,
- 1:14:36the spot character is way too human. The kh is the pilot. They
- 1:14:40hadn't figured out the Spot character at that point. That shouldn't be the basis
- 1:14:44for Emo Spock. No. In fact, name Way in an interview said
- 1:14:47Jeffrey Hunter playing Pike was playing it cold, so I felt it was okay
- 1:14:54to you know, smile and the things he did. And then he said,
- 1:14:57you know, Shatner comes in very emo, very hot, and he
- 1:15:00goes, you can't have two hot people. So I pulled back a bit.
- 1:15:03And then Gene Koon is the man that really gave Spock the ammunition.
- 1:15:09I want to say it was in the Corbonite maneuver when they were observing what
- 1:15:13was going on, and Spock made the you know comment fascinating and it was
- 1:15:16like, say it a little more like this really does shock you or impress
- 1:15:21you. You're not scared, You're just intrigued by the mystery that's being presented.
- 1:15:28And that's when Spock became Spock. And it still took a couple episodes
- 1:15:31to really get him to the Spock we knew. So yeah, you know,
- 1:15:34Mike says, as far as we know for sure, range New Worlds
- 1:15:40and therefore disco or alternate altered timelines they admitted in season two of Strange New
- 1:15:44Worlds. Yeah, they did, but again in a very clunky way.
- 1:15:46Hey Lorenzo, you say you've got some other great black and white anthology shows
- 1:15:50you that Rob should watch. Well, i'd bet because Rob and I are
- 1:15:55such TV nerds, we've probably seen them. But I would love to hear
- 1:15:59your list. So if you are still watching, please give us some examples.
- 1:16:03Chris again says people don't realize it, but Spock is in the Menagerie
- 1:16:09has had just that's a pod far Yeah. Maybe I don't know b things.
- 1:16:15When I was twelve in two thousand and eight, I tried to reconcile
- 1:16:16Star Trek's history with her own, but then I realized I didn't need it
- 1:16:20to match up. I radiate that I was twelve when I figured this out.
- 1:16:25Absolutely, man, Absolutely, I completely agree with that. I also
- 1:16:30love that when Rob is gesturing that sometimes he gets the emojis happening on his
- 1:16:38screen. Yeah, let's see if the thumbs Ah, there you go,
- 1:16:40fantastic. This is why I call you magic man. There you go.
- 1:16:45So I got this book. I just picked so, I mean, I've
- 1:16:49had this book when it came out. So this book was written by Mike
- 1:16:54and Denise A. Kuda, who were the art department. Mike started working
- 1:16:58on Star Trek. His first Star Trek job was on Star Trek four,
- 1:17:00the Voyage Home. He's worked on all of the Berman Air iterations of Star
- 1:17:05Trek. Now he's working on for All Mankind with Denise. Yes. So
- 1:17:10this book, and if you look at it, this is the second version.
- 1:17:15This book is the entire chronology of the Star Trek universe. Now,
- 1:17:20this kind of stuff, you know, I grew up worshiping because it has
- 1:17:26everything contextualized. Now, if you go and you look at the very beginning,
- 1:17:30the first entry in this book is fifteen billion years ago in the Star
- 1:17:39Trek universe. Fifteen billion years or years ago, here's the first entry.
- 1:17:44The universe was formed in a massive explosion known as the Big Bang. In
- 1:17:46the aftermath of the explosion, matter and energy gradually condensed into the universe we
- 1:17:51know today. At least two members of the Q continuum traveling back from the
- 1:17:57future, took refuge in the first moments of the Cosmos. One, the
- 1:18:01individual later known as Quinn, also briefly tried to conceal the starship Voyager in
- 1:18:08the Maelstrom of creation and then underneath it gives you accredation scientific theory. The
- 1:18:14qu's visits were established in the episode Death Wish in Voyager. Yeah, that's
- 1:18:19the first entry in this book. This book is hundreds of pages long,
- 1:18:25hundreds of pages. So what happens is modern Star Trek rolls along and because
- 1:18:30they have no care at all about continuity, everything in this book is thrown
- 1:18:36into disarray, right, you know, because because and I'm not I don't
- 1:18:41expect it's it's not fair to expect. But this is part of where Star
- 1:18:46Trek fandom comes from, because when I was a kid growing up getting these
- 1:18:50books and diving into this stuff. When you have somebody who actually works on
- 1:18:56the show, who has worked on Star Trek in terms of continuity from the
- 1:19:00Voyage Home all the way through Enterprise, you know, hundreds of years of
- 1:19:05Star Trek history, and then they write this. This is part of why
- 1:19:10you become a fan, because the universe is real and somebody is documenting it.
- 1:19:16And then the people that work on the show then go back and have
- 1:19:20these books to look into and go oh okay. Well, also all the
- 1:19:26novels that came out the picture novels where they adapted the original series, the
- 1:19:31photo novels, the photo novels, thank you, Yes, yeah, I
- 1:19:34mean that period from when Star Trek was first in syndication to the seventy nine
- 1:19:41movie. We weren't hurting for more stories because we were getting them in books
- 1:19:45and the source books and the technical manuals and things like the Akuda's Timeline.
- 1:19:50And David Gerald, who wrote, you know, he worked, He wrote
- 1:19:54Trouble with Troubles, He worked on Cloud Minders. He wrote a Star Trek
- 1:19:58novel called The Galactic Whirlpool, which gave like, when I was reading that
- 1:20:01novel to me that novel was canon because David Gerald wrote it, so why
- 1:20:05wouldn't it be one un And like you said, most of the Star Trek
- 1:20:12novelists gave us shit more. And of course we're vetted, you know.
- 1:20:15I mean, Mike, Michael Jan Friedman's been on my show many times.
- 1:20:18He's gonna be on it in a couple of weeks, but he has a
- 1:20:20new project, and I demand every time I talked to him to talk about
- 1:20:25a couple of specific Star Trek novels because he wrote so many. He wrote
- 1:20:29and Michael Jan Friedman did something that I would normally have said, you can't
- 1:20:31do that. He wrote the X Men and Star Trek, the next Generation
- 1:20:34crossover novel, which is awesome. Yes, it is so, I mean,
- 1:20:41you know, and it's no ideas. I mean, Peter David and
- 1:20:45I know you've talked about the new Frontier of books with Mackenzie Calhoun. There's
- 1:20:50there's why don't you adapt that? Adapt that? I hear you, Mike,
- 1:21:00I heard You're right, My god, well here there's Mike Conrad.
- 1:21:04But but it's it's the funny thing is is that? Now, what's what's
- 1:21:11maddening is there's an episode of Discovery where where you're looking at the exterior of
- 1:21:15a turbo lift and it's on rails like it's a roller coaster car, and
- 1:21:21you're like, does anyone who work on this show have you ever looked?
- 1:21:27I mean, you can look at blueprints. You can look at there's blue
- 1:21:30prints of the Enterprise D the Enterprise A. There's do you guys not understand
- 1:21:34there's not it's not a star destroyer, there's not these giant empty cavernous space.
- 1:21:39They even have an action scene in this gigantic empty space that you're supposed
- 1:21:44to think is on the Discovery somewhere and I'm watching this and I'm like,
- 1:21:48who who's making this show? Like, tell me you've never watched Star Trek
- 1:21:54or delved into Star Trek without telling me you've never delved into Star Trek.
- 1:21:57And it's and by the way, my frustration, this frustration, I don't
- 1:22:00think is born out of me being a white, middle aged CIS male that
- 1:22:04doesn't want to see representation. It has nothing to do with that. I
- 1:22:09want that representation. What I want is I want somebody to give me a
- 1:22:14believable, fictitious universe that I've been following my entire life that I can believe
- 1:22:18in. Like I said, you have to have truth in your fiction.
- 1:22:23And we're seeing all of our franchises now have the same problem all of them,
- 1:22:27which is the people that are now creating new entries into the franchises haven't
- 1:22:32done the work. They haven't done the work, and why because it's so
- 1:22:36daunting. There's fifty years sixty years in Doctor whose case, fifty eight years
- 1:22:42in Star Trek. Actually more than six years fifty eight years in the case
- 1:22:45of Star Trek. So everyone's like, well, and nobody wants delve into
- 1:22:48it, and I'm like, you are killing the value of your own franchise
- 1:22:55by not making it work within established continuity. And by the way, established
- 1:23:00continuity means that don't go and think you're being cheeky by going back to Harlan
- 1:23:05Ellison's original draft of City on the Edge of Forever and turning the Guardian of
- 1:23:10Forever into some ambulatory humanoid that's like Doctor Who, which they did in Discovery.
- 1:23:15Yes they did. You know, Brass from CSI is now the fucking
- 1:23:18Guardian Forever. A great character actor, but unfortunately, you know, again
- 1:23:21it's not his fault. It's a ridiculous idea. Another thing that that that
- 1:23:27writer of Future in Perfect brought up just randomly, was talking about how the
- 1:23:32Jefferys tube set. He's like, you know, that's like one of the
- 1:23:35last times we used it was in this episode, and Lisa said, Lisa
- 1:23:41Klik said, well, you know, we built a new one. I
- 1:23:43don't think they used Jeffreys tubes anymore. And what's ridiculous is not only does
- 1:23:47it show the confinement of what should be a limited space within a starship,
- 1:23:53but it also provides you with different camera angles that just you know, subconsciously
- 1:23:59for the eye might be more appealing than the cable car, turbo lift or
- 1:24:04pikes of fireplace in his gigantic captain's quarters. But it also gives you a
- 1:24:11believe because we all live in the real world. We all know that if
- 1:24:15you need to access plumbing, you got to get under a sink, you
- 1:24:19know, or you have to get into the wall. Somehow we understand that.
- 1:24:23And a starship, which is based on like a naval vessel, there's
- 1:24:26not unlimited space. You know. Space is at a premium. That's why
- 1:24:30cabins aren't huge. Kirk didn't have some palatial condo in the middle of the
- 1:24:33Enterprise somewhere, and it's you're on a naval vessel. And I think that
- 1:24:41that what's happened across all of our franchises is this idea that that whether you're
- 1:24:47being crushed under the weight of continuity or cannon. I mean, I'll say
- 1:24:51this. One of the great examples to me of cannon modern cannon is House
- 1:24:57of the Dragon, you know, the the Game of Thrones prequel, because
- 1:25:01we'd heard about these things and whatever you think of how Game of Thrones ended,
- 1:25:05and obviously Weiss and Benioff, there was no more books to follow,
- 1:25:09so whatever. But Game of Thrones had, I mean of House the Dragon
- 1:25:13had George R. Martin come back. He had already told the story of
- 1:25:16the Dance with Dragons in sort of more of a historical form, not a
- 1:25:21novel form, but so he had the story. He knows where it's going.
- 1:25:26They've done that first season brought everybody back to a franchise that was essentially
- 1:25:30dead that people were angry about. It's still great. The first five seasons
- 1:25:33of that show are still amazing. A lot of it's amazing. I mean,
- 1:25:35it's really the last six episodes that really are bad. Season seven goes
- 1:25:42down that direction, but season eight is a complete betrayal of what's happened.
- 1:25:45Because what Danny, who's been riding this wave of being a good leader and
- 1:25:49then being a death spot, is suddenly just going to go crazy like her
- 1:25:54grandfather because she was supposed to. You know, It's like that doesn't make
- 1:25:57any sense. But House the Dragon comes back and sets up this incredible conflict,
- 1:26:02does a wonderful job establishing these characters. Heartbreakingly takes these two childhood friends
- 1:26:08and puts them on opposing sides. Sets up an incredible conflict and and it
- 1:26:12works because the people who were making that show are like, well, I
- 1:26:15can't fuck this up, you know, And and and there there is no
- 1:26:20there is no thought like that with Star Trek because somebody wrote here, No,
- 1:26:28it was something that said that they don't treat start somebody actually somebody,
- 1:26:35I thought I missed somebody. I think they were saying that they don't they
- 1:26:39don't treat Star Trek, you know, as being real or that was the
- 1:26:43idea essentially. And and the thing about the Star Trek universe is the first
- 1:26:48rule of business is uh, that's this is what it was. Yeah,
- 1:26:53Christopher Zubin's comment, they feel comfortable doing this with Star Trek because it's streaming,
- 1:26:58and nobody really I don't think it's because it's streaming. I think it's
- 1:27:00because nowadays Star Trek, like always, has been ghettoized by any Rick Berman
- 1:27:06believes he still to this day, he believes he was above Star Trek.
- 1:27:10You know. Rick Berman is a man of taste, and he traveled all
- 1:27:12around the world making Big Blue Marble in the seventies. He's a guy that's
- 1:27:15incredibly well traveled, loves culture, and he got saddled with This show is
- 1:27:18kind of his last eraw at paramount that he fell into and he did a
- 1:27:21good job, but it was the last thing you wanted to do, you
- 1:27:25know. And I just think that you know, these cultural touchstones and also
- 1:27:33were these shows should be outside of what's going on in our culture. Now
- 1:27:41you can't make these shows. I mean, if you want to talk about
- 1:27:44gender identity issues, they did that next generation in episodes like the Outcast or
- 1:27:48the Trill species, where a Trill could be a male or female. Over
- 1:27:51their entire lifetime, they might be ten of each. You know, they
- 1:27:55did that in a science fiction way, but by suddenly hitting it on the
- 1:27:59note, it's no longer an action adventure allegorical science fiction show. Now you're
- 1:28:03just preaching, and you're picking an ideological side based on our politics today.
- 1:28:10Now you could say that Star Trek was always progressive, and indeed it was,
- 1:28:14but it was progressive in the sense that humanity had a future and that
- 1:28:18ultimately there is one race of human beings on this planet, which I've said,
- 1:28:23the human race. We might have different ethnicities, but as we move
- 1:28:27out into the stars, the aliens we meet are not going to be like,
- 1:28:30oh, you're a Black Earther or you're an Asian earther. We're just
- 1:28:34all going to be from Earth, you know. And the idea that Star
- 1:28:38Trek said to all of us is that when the human race becomes a spacefaring
- 1:28:42civilization, we are indeed the human race, that any ideas of racism or
- 1:28:46the petty differences we have being earth bound are going to be swept away as
- 1:28:51we're all from Earth. Now, we're all one. The way we are
- 1:28:56ultimately are, there's one race of humans on this planet, the human race.
- 1:28:59That's it. We might have different ethnicities, but when we go out
- 1:29:01into space and we meet alien cultures, they're not going to see differences in
- 1:29:06color. They're not going to be worried about, oh you're from this place,
- 1:29:10you're from that place. They're not going to think about our ethnic strife.
- 1:29:14They're going to say, you're from that planet. It's like the astronauts
- 1:29:16first seeing Earth from the Moon, looking back and seeing that big blue and
- 1:29:20white marble in space, and how few people on Earth have ever had that
- 1:29:25experience. But they look back and they're like, everything that's ever happened to
- 1:29:30the human race is happening on that little tiny speck in the dark infinity of
- 1:29:34the cosmos, and we still can't get it together, and star Trek says,
- 1:29:39one day we will. You know, another article that you pointed out
- 1:29:43and I wanted to discuss with you was and I don't remember the source that
- 1:29:46I don't remember the writer's name, but essentially pointed out the fact that for
- 1:29:50star Trek to work, you have to believe in institutions like the Federation,
- 1:29:55like Starfleet, and in today's society, never have has been questioned more than
- 1:30:01ever And maybe because of that, a younger audience can't relate to the idea
- 1:30:08of well, the Federation is a good group of you know, people doing
- 1:30:12the rest and everything. Same with Starfleet and stuff. No, the the
- 1:30:15writer's attitude is there's got to be something rotten. Well, of course,
- 1:30:19y Starfleet is rotten, and that was you know, it's funny. That's
- 1:30:23why I read that article because I'd never considered that before. Absolutely. Yeah,
- 1:30:29now, we're so you're right that that nowadays everybody wants to believe that
- 1:30:32all institutions are rotten. And not only that, let's go further, they
- 1:30:36believe Western civilization itself is rotten. Yep, but that's because I hate to
- 1:30:43say this, but we have a whole generation of people that did not understand
- 1:30:48or do not understand that life is hard and this idea that that there are
- 1:30:54safe spaces. There's no when you were born, there's no safe space.
- 1:30:57Yeah, and you are destined to there's no way around that. And I
- 1:31:02feel that nowadays people just don't realize that you are living on borrow time and
- 1:31:10the time that you're here on this planet. It's not the world's job to
- 1:31:15make you happy. Star Trek told me boldly, go that doesn't mean you
- 1:31:20sit at home and you wait for people to treat you the way you want
- 1:31:24to be treated. You've got to get up and open that door and go
- 1:31:28out into the universe and make the life that you want for yourself. And
- 1:31:30you know what, it's like, my dad said, my life life.
- 1:31:34My dad always said that life is hard and when you go out into the
- 1:31:39world, it's up to you to make of yourself what you want to be
- 1:31:44because the world isn't going to do it for you. I don't expect anybody
- 1:31:47else to do it either. Absolutely, man now one hundred percent on that.
- 1:31:51As Chris Suban again says, Starflee should be interacting with backward aliens cultures
- 1:31:57who in fact represent our current world. Well, you know that's what Classic
- 1:32:00Trek did. Yeah. Dan Shan a guy who was doing a Star Trek
- 1:32:04show for a while with our buddy Larry Young. He I was on their
- 1:32:09show once and Dan's like, you know, the Federation is really greedy because
- 1:32:12they're going all especially in the original series, because they're going to all these
- 1:32:15worlds. It's like, say, you have any dilithium for us, We'd
- 1:32:17really like some dilithium or whatever. I'm like, no, man, I
- 1:32:20go Starfleet and the Federation they were the peace Corps. I mean, they
- 1:32:25really were this analogy of Hey, we're going to these underdeveloped countries and we
- 1:32:30certainly want to We're gonna give you a clean water. We're just gonna show
- 1:32:33you a better way, but we don't want to fuck up the way you're
- 1:32:35doing things. Right. Well, you talk about dilthium to in Mirror Mirror
- 1:32:42one of my favorite Trek episodes, right the Hawkins. The Hawkins say the
- 1:32:45leader of the Hawken Council says, well, Captain, you do have the
- 1:32:49might to take them from us, and Kirk says, but we won't.
- 1:32:55That's right. I hope you consider that, you know. And and that
- 1:32:59was like you said, it's the Peace Corps. I mean, look,
- 1:33:00you can say, and it's undeniable that Star trek as America goes to space.
- 1:33:08I mean, I get it. It's not only that it's the Kennedy
- 1:33:11America going to space, but it was that idealism, you know, that
- 1:33:15idealism in the sixties. That imagine with all the tumult that was going on,
- 1:33:21the race riots, Martin Luther King, Malcolm X, John F.
- 1:33:27Kennedy, Robert Kennedy, the assassinations, the Cuban Missile crisis, the Cold
- 1:33:31War, Vietnam, there was no reason to think. I mean, the
- 1:33:35world was tearing itself apart. More people now are like, oh, the
- 1:33:39world's tearing itself apart now. No, no, no, no, no,
- 1:33:41there There's been tumultuous times in all of human history. It's just now
- 1:33:45we have a twenty four to seven with the black mirrors that we keep in
- 1:33:47our pockets all day long. But back then you still had people that believed
- 1:33:53in That's whe they got the name black Mirror from, you know, they
- 1:33:58we had that that optimism and that's what Star Trek was all about. Well,
- 1:34:04now Star Trek itself is being made by people that aren't optimistic, like
- 1:34:09they don't believe in institutions. It's like, I can't understand that for all
- 1:34:14of its faults. You know, people talk about all Western civilization, remember
- 1:34:16Britain first and the United States. We stopped slavery. Slavery was something that
- 1:34:24went on and still goes on. It's been going on in human history for
- 1:34:26thousands of years. But the Brits and the Americans said no, we fought
- 1:34:32a war over it. And and does that mean like everybody who's lived wants
- 1:34:36the world to be perfect? Everybody it's not. But we we ended a
- 1:34:41practice that had been going on for aout for millennia and we stopped it.
- 1:34:46Now, are we still racist? Fuck? Sure? Sure, but but
- 1:34:49it's a slow process. You can't expect it to all happen. But we
- 1:34:53did stop it. And after the Reformation, after the Dark Ages, I
- 1:34:57mean the Age of Enlightenment West and civilization has done. I mean, where
- 1:35:01else would you want to live on the world? People are talking about you.
- 1:35:03There was this Young Marxist conference in Melbourne last week or two weeks ago,
- 1:35:08over Easter last week, over Easter weekend, and you've got all these
- 1:35:11people workers, workers rise up as if no one's seen that before, right,
- 1:35:15I mean, my god, you want to see what happens. Watch
- 1:35:17The Three Body Problem, the first episode of The Three Body Problem that shows
- 1:35:21you where where our young our young charges are at. Okay, we're going
- 1:35:27to stop the conversation there and pick up Robin mid Rant when we get back
- 1:35:31to that conversation later this week. But I hope you enjoyed it. I
- 1:35:34hope you were enjoying word Balloon. We're having a great April and the hits
- 1:35:40keep on coming. I'm going to have some great conversations this week with Mark
- 1:35:44Laming and Mark Wade, So a couple of marks coming up this week,
- 1:35:49and as I said Monday Night, we're gonna do that Trek Watch show.
- 1:35:53All that coming up this week, plus great conversations from the panels at Dublin
- 1:36:00Comic cont from last month. So it's gonna be a fun week and I
- 1:36:02hope you'll enjoy it as much as I do. Thanks for listening. Until
- 1:36:06next time. Word Balloon is a copyright feature of Shaky Productions. Copyright twenty
- 1:36:12twenty four.