Latest / The Vegan Report / Is Cell-Based Meat Good for Animals? With Leah Garces, Bruce Friedrich, Vasile Stanescu & John Sanbonmatsu | BONUS
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, you are listening to The Vegan
- 0:03Report and this is a bonus episode. As you might
- 0:07know, this movement is a big fan of debating
- 0:10non -vegans. However, debates around major deciding
- 0:16strategy questions on how to progress forward
- 0:19as a movement are much less discussed. Well,
- 0:23for today, I am happy to present you with an
- 0:26exception to this rule. What you are about to
- 0:30listen is a clash of minds about cultivated meat,
- 0:35an industry worth billions of dollars that promises
- 0:38vegans a future without factory farming. I invited
- 0:44one of the debaters, John Sanbonmatsu, for a
- 0:47conversation about the behind the scenes of this
- 0:50debate and the release of his new book. Don't
- 0:54miss our talk which is episode 79 of the podcast.
- 0:59And an enormous thank you to United Poultry Concerns
- 1:04who organized this debate and gave me the green
- 1:07light to release it as a podcast episode. They
- 1:11are an impactful non -profit that deserves your
- 1:14support. Visit the episode notes to access their
- 1:18website. and the original YouTube video of the
- 1:22debate they recorded. We're going to call it
- 1:51cell -based meat. That's what we have as a panel
- 1:55determined that we all can agree on to call it
- 1:58at this point. Yes, this is the title. It has
- 2:04a lot of other names. There's cultured meat,
- 2:06clean meat, in vitro meat, slaughter -free meat,
- 2:10lab -grown meat, alt meat, I heard recently.
- 2:13That was an interesting one. So, and what we're
- 2:18talking about, we're not talking about products
- 2:21that are out now like Beyond Burger and Impossible
- 2:24Meat, where it's a plant -based product that
- 2:28mimics meat. That's not what we're talking about
- 2:32at all. Those are products on the market now
- 2:36and they are made. buy from plants and mimic
- 2:42meat in ways that the texture and everything
- 2:45is very similar. What we're talking about is
- 2:48a product that's not on the market yet, doesn't
- 2:50exist yet. And it's taking cells from living
- 2:56animals and growing those cells in a nutrient
- 3:03-rich liquid type thing that, and I'm sure they'll
- 3:10be able to describe it a lot better than me.
- 3:14But this cultured medium, it provides nutrients,
- 3:18there's like salt, sugar, amino acids, those
- 3:20kinds of things. I think they use a scaffolding
- 3:24that periodically moves so it mimics muscle movement
- 3:27to develop and it can develop into different
- 3:31types of. Muscle cells fat cells tissue to create
- 3:35meat like products different cuts of meat if
- 3:38you will so So that's what we're talking about
- 3:43okay, just so we're very clear and we'll and
- 3:46we'll get even more information about that and
- 3:50Another thing that I want to just touch on and
- 3:52I think it's really a cool thing about this is
- 3:55that? Everyone here up on this panel I think
- 4:00can agree on the big picture of, we all want
- 4:05to see a world where no animal suffers at human
- 4:10hands. Can we all agree on that? Yes. We all
- 4:13agree on that, and that's great. That's awesome.
- 4:15That is a beautiful thing. So what we're debating
- 4:21is ideas, strategies, tactics, these kinds of
- 4:26things. So we're not debating that we want a
- 4:30vegan world. We all want that. So just to keep
- 4:36that in mind as we go forward, this is really
- 4:40a playing of ideas, a debating of strategy and
- 4:47tactic and not like attack on character or individuals
- 4:51or organizations. It's really about the tactics.
- 4:58Just a thought on that. And I'm personally in
- 5:02the perfect place here, being right in the middle,
- 5:05because I am right in the middle on this issue.
- 5:11When I first heard about it, I think that I reacted
- 5:15like I would say probably most vegan animal rights
- 5:19activists react. My reaction was, ew, I'd never
- 5:22eat it, but great if it's going to save animals.
- 5:26Generally, that's my reaction and I think most
- 5:29people's initial reaction. So I was for it, I
- 5:32was fine with it. But something, I don't know,
- 5:36just was not sitting right with me. Every time
- 5:39I thought about it a little deeper. There were
- 5:43questions that were coming up in my mind, and
- 5:45then suddenly I was seeing that other activists
- 5:48and vegans were having the same kind of concerns
- 5:51and questions. And I was like, ah, okay, so I'm
- 5:54not alone. That's interesting. And so I think
- 5:59that's why we're here today, is to explore this.
- 6:03I haven't made any kind of decision. I feel like
- 6:05I need way more information, and that's why I'm
- 6:08very excited that we're doing this. So, you know,
- 6:12just a little background, I'm sure we'll get
- 6:14more. There's numerous cell -based meat companies
- 6:16that are not necessarily in production now, but
- 6:20in the research and development phase trying
- 6:22to get this product happening. We have in the
- 6:26U .S. Memphis Meats, Mosa Meats, Was Hampton
- 6:30Creek is now Just, you know, Just Egg, Just Mayo.
- 6:34They create plant -based foods, but they're also
- 6:37looking into cell -based meats. Finless Foods,
- 6:41I love the name, is a seafood plant or cell -based
- 6:46meat company that's also planning to produce
- 6:51seafood, cell -based seafood. And across the
- 6:56world, we're seeing it as well. In Israel, we've
- 7:00got super meat, future meat technologies, meet
- 7:04the future. Another good name So, you know, so
- 7:09it's really interesting it's it's very much Incredibly
- 7:14prevalent and even big ag is getting in the game.
- 7:17They are Seeing a potential here. We've got Tyson
- 7:21Cargill. I'm sure others are looking into it
- 7:24are investing in it So it's fascinating. And
- 7:28there's also, we're already starting to see legislation
- 7:32around it, around the labeling, what's it gonna
- 7:35be called? The meat industry is getting a little
- 7:38concerned about this. There's a piece of legislation
- 7:42going around Washington State right now that
- 7:44would actually make it a crime to sell cell -based
- 7:48meat. It's fascinating. It's basically, of course,
- 7:56Their line is that we don't know if it's safe,
- 7:59it's also new, all of that kind of thing. But
- 8:02of course, it's the meat industry getting scared.
- 8:04So it's fascinating, fascinating. So we're going
- 8:07to get into it all today. I am going to introduce
- 8:11all the speakers, I think, right now. And then
- 8:17how it's going to work is that each speaker is
- 8:21going to have a 12 -minute introduction Some
- 8:26are going to use PowerPoint. Twelve minute introduction
- 8:29just to get us all on the same page really understanding
- 8:32the arguments. Then I'm going to start asking
- 8:36some questions and we're going to just open it
- 8:38up and go back and forth. So I'm going to introduce
- 8:42everyone first over here. This is the pro side,
- 8:48the four side over here and the against. So you
- 8:52know. What's going on in Who's Who? Bruce Friedrich
- 8:55has been a long time activist. He is the executive
- 9:01director of the Good Food Institute. That's a
- 9:045 -1 -C -3 nonprofit that promotes innovative
- 9:07alternatives to industrially produced animal
- 9:10foods. Bruce has pinned opinion pieces for USA
- 9:13Today, The Wall Street Journal, Los Angeles Times,
- 9:16many other publications. He's a popular speaker.
- 9:20at college campuses, he's presented at top universities,
- 9:25Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Stanford, MIT. He's
- 9:28co -authored two books, contributed chapters
- 9:30to six books, authored seven law review articles,
- 9:35and graduated from Georgetown Law, and also graduated
- 9:41Pi Beta Kappa from Grinnell College. And he also
- 9:46holds degrees at John Hopkins University and
- 9:48the London School of Economics, so quite a background.
- 9:53And I just saw him recently actually on CBS This
- 9:56Morning. I was watching my little, on the elliptical,
- 10:01my little Morning CBS This Morning clips and
- 10:05he was there giving an interview about vegan
- 10:08seafood. So, Bruce is everywhere. That's awesome.
- 10:13Thank you for being here. Yeah. Okay, and then
- 10:17also on the pro side, we have Leah Garces. Am
- 10:22I saying it good? Yay! She is the new first female
- 10:28president of Mercy for Animals. Yay! She was
- 10:36the founder of compassion in world farming USA
- 10:39and She's the author of a forthcoming book called
- 10:43grilled turning adversaries into allies in the
- 10:46fight to change the chicken industry She is an
- 10:49animal advocate who has partnered with some of
- 10:50the largest food companies in the world with
- 10:52a mission to end the exploitation of animals
- 10:54for food Her work has been featured in many national
- 10:57and international media outlets including the
- 11:00New York Times Washington Post BuzzFeed vice
- 11:03Chicago Tribune on and on. She's the contributing
- 11:06author to Huffington Post and Food Safety News.
- 11:10Leah serves on the advisory board of Encompass
- 11:14and Seattle Food Tech. And she's the mom of three
- 11:17incredible kids. All right. Only two? Okay. Well,
- 11:23he knows. He's met him. Okay. So, all right.
- 11:30On the opposing side, we have, this is Vasile
- 11:37Staniskew. He has received his PhD in the Modern
- 11:41Thought and Literature at Stanford University.
- 11:44So he was here with us at Stanford, but now he's
- 11:46in Atlanta, Georgia. He is currently Assistant
- 11:48Professor of Communication at Mercer University.
- 11:52His current research interests include locovorism,
- 11:55humane meat, invasive species, the linkage between
- 11:58food and colonialism, and the intersection between
- 12:01environmentalism and animal studies. Vasile is
- 12:05the co -senior editor of Critical Animal Studies
- 12:08book series and the former co -editor of the
- 12:11Journal of Critical Animal Studies. He's the
- 12:13author of over 20 peer -reviewed publications
- 12:15on critical animal studies, and his research
- 12:17has been recognized by the Woods Institute for
- 12:19the Environment, Minding Animals International,
- 12:21the Andrew Mellon Foundation, the Culture and
- 12:24Animals Foundation, and the list goes on. So
- 12:28thank you for being here. All right, and then
- 12:31finally over here in his wonderful Renaissance
- 12:34man coat. I love this coat. Fabulous. The postmodern
- 12:41prince. Yes. So John Sanbanmatsu, PhD, is the
- 12:47associate professor of philosophy at, I can never
- 12:50say it. Worcester. I always want to say Worcestersh.
- 12:54It's not. Polytech Institute in Massachusetts.
- 13:00John's work in critical animal studies probes
- 13:04the nature of speciesism as a mode of production,
- 13:07particularly as it intersects with capitalism.
- 13:10His articles and essays have appeared on Huffington
- 13:12Post, Christian Science Monitor, and other venues.
- 13:16In addition, he's the editor of the book Critical
- 13:18Theory and Animal Liberation, and the author
- 13:21of The Postmodern Prince. At present, he is at
- 13:26work on a new book, which I'm very excited about
- 13:28and can't wait to read. It's called The Omnivore's
- 13:31Deception. Yes. Great name, right? Great title.
- 13:38about the ecological crisis, the myth of humane
- 13:41meat, and the troubling nature of our relationship
- 13:44with other animals. Okay, what a fantastic panel
- 13:48we have. Let's give them all a hand. Okay, so
- 13:56we are going to have the pro side go first. Who's
- 13:58going to go first? Bruce? Bruce is up. All right,
- 14:04so... Thank you very much Hope for the introduction.
- 14:07You did give a lot of my talk just for the record.
- 14:12And thank you Voss and John for agreeing to do
- 14:14this and Karen. No, thank you Leah for agreeing
- 14:20to do this. And there's Karen, thank you for
- 14:23having us. Thank you for working with Hope to
- 14:26organize the conference. It is a delight and
- 14:29an honor to be here with all of you chatting
- 14:31about. why Leah and I believe, so I was thanking
- 14:35everybody on behalf of both of us, Leah, why
- 14:38Leah and I believe that, what's the title of
- 14:41the resolution? Resolved, cell -based meat is
- 14:43good for animals. So I want to start by just
- 14:46talking about a couple of things that I think
- 14:48most of you, most of us know, but that I think
- 14:51are useful as sort of background for the conversation
- 14:54that we're about to have. I think folks here
- 14:57probably know that animal agriculture, causes
- 15:00more climate change than all forms of transportation
- 15:03combined. So then all of the trains and the planes
- 15:07and the cars and the trucks, animal agriculture
- 15:09is responsible for about 14 .5 % of climate change.
- 15:15At GFI we're talking more and more. There we
- 15:18go. About antibiotic resistance bacteria. According
- 15:22to a report from the UK government a couple of
- 15:24years ago, antibiotic resistant bacteria is going
- 15:27to kill more people than cancer by 2050. It'll
- 15:30be killing 10 million people a year by 2050.
- 15:32Will be costing the global economy $10 trillion.
- 15:36And then I'm guessing if you didn't see this,
- 15:39that you'll be surprised to hear that all of
- 15:41you who oppose slaughterhouses, it's actually
- 15:43about 47 % of Americans also. oppose slaughterhouses.
- 15:48Now, the meat industry read about this, and they
- 15:49were absolutely flabbergasted. And they realized
- 15:52it was a group called the Sentience Institute
- 15:54that had released their report. And that's an
- 15:56animal rights think tank, the Sentience Institute.
- 16:00So they picked a researcher at Oklahoma State
- 16:02University, a hand -picked ag researcher at Oklahoma
- 16:06State University, and said, you know, prove these
- 16:08vegans wrong. And he ran the numbers and he came
- 16:11up with the exact same number. 47 % of Americans
- 16:14want to ban slaughterhouses. And yet, when surveys
- 16:18are actually done, what we find is that 98 %
- 16:22of Americans continue to eat meat. So we see
- 16:25numbers like 5 % vegetarian, 7 % vegetarian,
- 16:292 % vegan or whatever. Once Fawnalytics actually
- 16:33asked people in the last month, what products
- 16:36have you not eaten? What they determined was
- 16:39that two out of three vegetarians had eaten fish
- 16:41or chicken in the last month so not vegetarian
- 16:44and This is what meat consumption looks like
- 16:47in the United States and those of you who are
- 16:49attentive to the small bird the small animals
- 16:52as opposed to the large animals will also realize
- 16:55that this graph for the United States is similar
- 16:59to the graph globally, so Although it looks like
- 17:03meat consumption is skyrocketing on the previous
- 17:05slide, and it looks like meat consumption is
- 17:07fairly stagnant since 1970 on this slide, because
- 17:11chicken consumption has skyrocketed, even as
- 17:14beef consumption has somewhat fallen, the actual
- 17:17number of animals slaughtered has gone up from
- 17:20somewhere on the order of 5 billion animals per
- 17:22year to almost 10 billion animals per year. And
- 17:26in the United States alone, we eat about 100
- 17:28million pigs, about 40 million cows and 9 billion
- 17:32chickens. It's literally 250 chickens for every
- 17:35cow, 100 chickens for every pig. 2018, according
- 17:40to the USDA, was the highest per capita meat
- 17:42consumption in US history. USDA says that in
- 17:462019, per capita meat consumption is going to
- 17:49be even higher. All that despite the revolution
- 17:55almost 50 years ago. This is the book that turned
- 17:57me vegan in 1987. So I'm going on 32 years of
- 18:00veganism. So the book that started. Thank you.
- 18:06So the book that started a revolution in the
- 18:08way that Americans eat. Since that revolution
- 18:11started almost 50 years ago, we are now eating
- 18:14annually about 5 billion additional animals.
- 18:17I wish the revolution had been more successful.
- 18:2020 years ago this year, I put this video together,
- 18:22Meet Your Meat. It's now been seen by literally
- 18:25millions of people. Ten years ago, I put together
- 18:29the glass walls video, which was narrated by
- 18:31Paul McCartney. And I just want to underline
- 18:33again, this is what's happening with meat consumption.
- 18:39Number of animals since 1996, it's about two
- 18:43billion additional animals every single year.
- 18:48And globally, we're expected to need 70 % more
- 18:51meat. by the year 2050. So hopefully people listened
- 18:55to Karen's presentation a moment ago. Nobody
- 18:58paints a picture of what animal suffering looks
- 19:01like better than Karen Davis paints a picture
- 19:03of what animal suffering looks like. But chickens
- 19:11on these farms, as Karen illustrated, every single
- 19:15moment of their lives is categorized by abject
- 19:18misery. poultry scientists at the University
- 19:20of Arkansas said that if a human baby grew as
- 19:23quickly as a modern broiler chicken She would
- 19:25weigh more than 600 pounds by the time she was
- 19:28one year old 600 pounds every moment of these
- 19:33animals lives is categorized by unmitigated misery
- 19:37So we need to be very laser focused on asking
- 19:41the question if I were a hen in one of these
- 19:43battery cages If I were a chicken in one of these
- 19:47broiler sheds What would I want my advocates
- 19:51to be doing and supporting? So Chatham House,
- 19:55the Royal Institute of International Affairs
- 19:57is the foremost think tank in Europe. About three
- 20:01years ago, they were looking at the climate issue
- 20:04and they said, it is a scientific impossibility
- 20:08that the governments of the world meet their
- 20:10obligations under the Paris Climate Agreement
- 20:12to keep climate change under two degrees Celsius
- 20:14by 2050. A scientific impossibility. unless animal
- 20:18product consumption goes down. The Chinese government
- 20:22rose to the, yeah, it's good, right? The Chinese
- 20:26government rose to the challenge in 2015. They
- 20:28said we are going to cut our meat consumption
- 20:31in half by 2030. What do you think's happened
- 20:34to Chinese meat consumption since 2015? Yeah,
- 20:38it's skyrocketing. It's absolutely skyrocketing.
- 20:40It seems to me, that what we have been doing
- 20:44for 50 years or 20 years or 10 years or whatever,
- 20:48it's important. We need to change the zeitgeist.
- 20:51We need to educate people. We need to be a voice
- 20:53for animals. And I'm not advocating that anybody
- 20:56change what it is that they're focusing on or
- 20:59what it is that they're working on. But it certainly
- 21:01seems to me that we should be looking at, we
- 21:03should be using all the tools in our toolkit.
- 21:06So at GFI, we think this is the tool of choice.
- 21:12Ben and Jerry's vegan ice cream Who here likes
- 21:16Ben and Jerry's? All right a couple of people
- 21:20are you know don't probably don't like them because
- 21:22Unilever bought them, but almost everybody raised
- 21:24their hand And the reason you raised your hand
- 21:27is that Ben and Jerry's tastes amazing Right
- 21:30everybody nobody thought that's not healthy.
- 21:32You know everybody thought it tastes amazing
- 21:35It's reasonably priced That's what you were focused
- 21:39on and in fact 100 % of the world Thinks about
- 21:43taste and price when they're thinking about when
- 21:45they're making their dietary choices even at
- 21:47Whole Foods Even at the co -op you look at what
- 21:50people are buying like these are the two dichotomous
- 21:53factors of food choice But doesn't taste at least
- 21:55acceptable. Nobody's gonna eat it. You can't
- 21:58afford it. You're not gonna eat it And then convenience
- 22:01is also important. If you can't find it, you're
- 22:03not gonna eat it I actually use this slide in
- 22:04Mexico and everybody just sort of looked at me
- 22:06like We don't know what this Ben and Jerry's
- 22:08thing is. So the slide didn't go over well, which
- 22:10underlines the idea that no matter how awesome
- 22:13a food is, if you can't find it, you're not going
- 22:15to eat it. But how do we apply the Ben and Jerry's
- 22:20trifecta to food? One way we do it is we grow
- 22:24meat directly from cells. Because for the vast
- 22:27majority of people, they think meat tastes great.
- 22:30They're not eating it because they want to see
- 22:32animals slaughtered. 47 % of them, all of whom
- 22:35know slaughterhouses are essential to meat, still
- 22:37think slaughterhouses should be banned, remarkably.
- 22:41Nobody is a fan of causing more climate change.
- 22:44Nobody is a fan of factory farms. Nobody is a
- 22:46fan of slaughterhouses. We all have loved ones
- 22:50who continue to eat meat, and they say things
- 22:52like, I don't want to know. Where else in your
- 22:55life do you not want to know? Where else is there
- 22:57this cognitive dissonance? There's something
- 22:59in human beings. I don't know if it's psychology
- 23:01or physiology or emotion or what, but there's
- 23:04something that causes a lot of people to want
- 23:07to continue to eat meat. And we can grow meat
- 23:10directly from cells. Take a biopsy the size of
- 23:13a sesame seed from a live living turkey and grow
- 23:16turkey meat in perpetuity for everybody. Seems
- 23:20to me if I'm a turkey on a factory farm, that's
- 23:22something I'm pretty excited about. So this is
- 23:25Memphis Meats cell -based clean. We call it clean
- 23:29meat oftentimes as a nod to clean energy. Clean
- 23:32energy is energy that's better for the environment.
- 23:34Clean meat is meat that's better for the environment.
- 23:36It's also just literally a cleaner product. That's
- 23:39a meatball. That's clean meat duck. And that's
- 23:44what clean meat will look like at scale. Your
- 23:47friendly neighborhood meat brewery, essentially.
- 23:51I'm going to spare you. Everybody in here knows
- 23:53what a factory farm and a slaughterhouse looks
- 23:54like. Not this pretty. You know, Memphis Meats
- 23:57is planning on streaming their production on
- 23:59the internet. Get boring after about 10 seconds,
- 24:02but it makes, I think, a critical point. So who's
- 24:05excited about clean meat? Ingrid Newkirk is excited
- 24:07about clean meat, the president of PETA. Her
- 24:10deepness, Sylvia Earle, the foremost living marine
- 24:12biologist, is excited about clean meat for its
- 24:14capacity to save our seas. GFI had a conference
- 24:20and we had at our conference we had USDA, ADM,
- 24:24Tyson Ventures, DFJ, Kraft Heinz. We had moderators
- 24:27from the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times,
- 24:28Inc. magazine, Good Morning America. This is
- 24:31something that an animal rights conference is
- 24:33not going to bring these sorts of thinkers together.
- 24:36I love this quote from Tyson Ventures talking
- 24:37about how awesome he thought our conference was,
- 24:40how excited he was about it. As Hope mentioned,
- 24:43I know that John and Voss are planning to use
- 24:46this against us, but we can have that discussion
- 24:49at the discussion. Former CEO of Tyson Foods,
- 24:55the last sentence of the cover story about this
- 24:57guy, if we can make meat without the animal,
- 24:59why wouldn't we? Former CEO of Google, Eric Schmidt,
- 25:03very excited about plant -based meat and clean
- 25:05meat, not because he cares about animals, but
- 25:07because he wants to feed the world high quality
- 25:09protein without the climate impact. Bill Gates,
- 25:13very excited about the capacity to feed hundreds
- 25:15of millions of people in the developing world
- 25:17using clean meat. This is a slide that shows
- 25:21the clean meat investment landscape. So the first
- 25:26clean meat company was incorporated in 2016.
- 25:30Clean meat companies, there are now more than
- 25:31a dozen of them that have raised a million dollars
- 25:33or more. And then I'm going to just say a couple
- 25:36of words about what the Good Food Institute does.
- 25:39And wow, 12 minutes goes fast. All right, so
- 25:42at the Good Food Institute, we have four programmatic
- 25:45departments, science and technology, innovation,
- 25:48corporate engagement, policy, and international
- 25:50engagement. International engagement is a multiplier.
- 25:52So science and technology, we're laying the groundwork
- 25:55for both plant -based meat and cell -based meat.
- 25:57Innovation department is starting companies,
- 26:00among other things. Corporate engagement, we
- 26:02are actually meeting with Tyson and Smithfield
- 26:04and Purdue and other companies. And policy, we
- 26:06are inspiring governments, including the US government,
- 26:09to put money into this space. Animal Charity
- 26:12Evaluators has done an evaluation and ranked
- 26:14us a top charity three years in a row. The last
- 26:17thing I want to say is this is not for you. We
- 26:19don't care if you eat it. You're vegan. You're
- 26:21on our side already. It will save massive numbers
- 26:25of animals or at least has a very good prospect
- 26:27to do so. The bar for the opposition is insanely
- 26:29high. Think about the hens and the cages. And
- 26:32in 100 years, all meat is not even going to be
- 26:34thought of as an animal product any more than
- 26:37insulin is today. 1951, 10 ,000 pounds of pig
- 26:40pancreas to make a pound of insulin. We'd be
- 26:43having this debate and somebody would be saying,
- 26:45insulin is an animal product. We absolutely can't
- 26:48go to synthetic insulin. If you want to learn
- 26:50more about GFI, you can find our annual report
- 26:53at gfi .org up slash 2018. You can go to gfi
- 26:56.org to get our bi -weekly newsletter. You can
- 26:58email me if you want our monthly highlights.
- 27:00Thank you. I came here today to bring you three
- 27:14simple truths about in vitro meat simple truth
- 27:19number one in vitro meat harms the planet proponents
- 27:25of in vitro meat like to claim that it will help
- 27:28the planet however what they fail to mention
- 27:30is that the only peer -reviewed study, positive
- 27:34peer -reviewed study was both commissioned and
- 27:37funded exclusively by the in vitro meat industry,
- 27:41was published by a graduate student, and was
- 27:43based solely on a series of possible future thought
- 27:46experiments, assumptions which are premised on
- 27:49a series of technologies which currently do not
- 27:52exist and are unlikely to exist in the future.
- 27:56To provide one example among many, the study
- 28:00assumed that all in vitro meat would be grown
- 28:02exclusively in cyanobacteria hydrostate, a type
- 28:07of algae, even though no in vitro meat is currently
- 28:10cultured in this process and there is no current
- 28:13research proving that it would be possible to
- 28:17do so in the future. Unsurprisingly, I have not
- 28:21been able to locate a single other peer -reviewed
- 28:24study that has duplicated these findings. In
- 28:28fact, Later research has found that in vitro
- 28:31meat may be more harmful in terms of climate
- 28:34change than even traditional animal agriculture
- 28:38as one recent study concluded Cultivation of
- 28:43in vitro meat requires more industrial energy
- 28:46often produced by burning fossil fuels than pork
- 28:51poultry and maybe even beef The reason for these
- 28:56counterintuitive results is that while cultured
- 28:58meat uses less land, it requires more energy
- 29:02inputs, i .e. fossil fuels, than even factory
- 29:05farms. As a thoughtful article in The Atlantic
- 29:08explained, cell culture is the most expensive
- 29:12and most resource -intensive technique in modern
- 29:15biology. Keeping the cells warm, healthy, well
- 29:19-fed, and free of contamination takes incredible
- 29:23labor and energy, even when scaled to the 10
- 29:26,000 liter vats the biotech companies use. And
- 29:30on top of that, the fact that these three dimensional
- 29:33wads of meat would have to be exercised regularly
- 29:36with stretching machinery, essentially elaborate
- 29:40meat gems, and you begin to understand the incredible
- 29:44challenges of scaling in vitro meat. As Marco
- 29:48Springman, a post -graduate researcher at Oxford
- 29:51University, phrased the same critique, although
- 29:55the technologies are evolving, there is no indication
- 29:58the lab -grown meat is significantly better for
- 30:01the environment and health than existing alternatives
- 30:05to beef. The latest reviews have put the emissions
- 30:08of lab -grown meat at several times that of chicken
- 30:12and far beyond any plant. based alternative simple
- 30:18truth number two in vitro meat hurts animals
- 30:22lots of animals the proponents of in vitro meat
- 30:26like to focus on how the meat is grown from a
- 30:30cell of animals without any animals have to be
- 30:33killed to produce these cells which is true what
- 30:36however they fail to point out is that these
- 30:39cells can currently only be grown in fetal bovine
- 30:42serum i .e. the blood of unborn cows Therefore,
- 30:46it is hard to argue that shut up practice should
- 30:49be considered either vegan or cruelty free. And
- 30:52just to be clear, such extraction causes massive
- 30:55suffering as both the mother is killed in order
- 30:58to have her fetus extracted and the fetus is
- 31:01kept alive outside of the womb for the entirety
- 31:04of the extraction without any form of anesthesia
- 31:07ever being applied despite the scientific reality
- 31:10that they show normal brain activity and pain
- 31:13responses for the entirety of the procedure.
- 31:16As a peer -reviewed study specifically on the
- 31:19topic of fetal bovine serum concluded, quote,
- 31:23fetal bovine serum, FBS, is the common component
- 31:26of annual cell culture medium. It is harvested
- 31:29from bovine fetuses taken from pregnant cows
- 31:32during slaughter. FBS is commonly harvested by
- 31:36means of cardiac puncture without any form of
- 31:39anesthesia. Fetuses are exposed to pain and discomfort,
- 31:44so the current practice of fetal bovine serum
- 31:47harvesting is inhumane. Nor are these amounts
- 31:51of bovine fetal harvest small, since each bovine
- 31:54fetus produces relatively little FBS, and since
- 31:58a large amount is necessary to culture these
- 32:01cells, a large number of bovine fetuses are required
- 32:05to produce in vitro meat. Current estimates place
- 32:10the total at over 2 million bovine fetuses and
- 32:14their mothers annually. And this number is growing.
- 32:18And the financial benefit to the factory farms
- 32:20is massive. Since research on in vitro meat has
- 32:23begun, the price that CAFOs can charge for FPS
- 32:27has increased by over 300%. It is currently the
- 32:32single most profitable item that a factory farm
- 32:36sells. Even if other countries do develop new
- 32:39technologies and some are in vitro meat represents
- 32:43animal experimentation on a mass scale and Pretending
- 32:47it doesn't because the suffering happens on the
- 32:49farm and not technically in the lab is a distinction
- 32:52without a moral difference Simple truth number
- 32:58three in vitro meat helps factory farms. It does
- 33:02it in three ways one It keeps people eating meat.
- 33:08Driven by increasing population, increasing obesity
- 33:10rates, and in particular, increasing rates in
- 33:13meat consumption in countries such as China,
- 33:16India, and Brazil, global meat demand is increasing.
- 33:20However, because of hard limits, they're running
- 33:23out of room, space, and the environment. Factory
- 33:26farms cannot meet this demand. In -vitro meat
- 33:28is being developed to supply this new demand
- 33:31that Bruce talked about. to keep people eating
- 33:34meat, not to trade off with factory farms. Two,
- 33:39to act as a new filler. Tyson's own internal
- 33:42studies show that people no longer want their
- 33:45meat to look like animals. Think boneless chicken
- 33:48nuggets, which creates the opportunity to create,
- 33:51in their words, a blended product. However as
- 33:55controversy over Taco Bell blending in soy with
- 33:58its beef or the controversy over so -called pink
- 34:01slime highlights Consumers often resist this
- 34:06blending process Factory farms are funding in
- 34:09vitro meat not to trade off with factory farms
- 34:13But to be able to use it as a new filler so they
- 34:16can label their product 100 % beef Perhaps they
- 34:20will even market it as an eco burger Assuming
- 34:23a 50 -50 blend, in vitro meat won't trade off
- 34:27with the number of people who are eating factory
- 34:29farm meat. It will effectively double it. Three,
- 34:34to help with public relations. As you can imagine,
- 34:37Tyson and factory farms do not currently pull
- 34:40well with consumers. Funding clean meat and their
- 34:43small amount of funding for plant -based protein
- 34:46is designed to improve their image and public
- 34:49relations. While the first two are still purely
- 34:52theoretical, this last goal is already working.
- 34:55In January of this year, in part because of their
- 34:59funding of in vitro meat and plant -based protein,
- 35:02even Bruce claimed in a published interview,
- 35:06quote, for the Good Food Institute in particular,
- 35:10we have really good relationships with Tyson
- 35:13Foods, with Smithfield Foods, with Purdue. with
- 35:17huge chicken conglomerates and meat companies.
- 35:21It's helpful to recognize that the people who
- 35:23run these companies want to do something noble.
- 35:29I don't believe they do. Because the most basic
- 35:33problem of in vitro meat is that it represents
- 35:36a solution without a problem. The idea that the
- 35:39reason that people are refusing to give up meat
- 35:42is because of a lack of adequate meat substitutes
- 35:44is simply untrue. From taste to texture to nutritional
- 35:49quality, a cornucopia of options, both natural
- 35:52and artificial, already exist, are widely available
- 35:56and reasonably affordable. Just to highlight
- 35:59the absurd degree to which meat has already been
- 36:03successfully imitated, impossible foods even
- 36:06produced a completely vegan hamburger that bleeds.
- 36:10In fact, under taste tests, many non -vegans
- 36:13cannot tell the difference between the real and
- 36:16some of the new imitation products unless they
- 36:19are told. Even Michael Pollan. One of the most
- 36:22famous proponents of humane meat and one of the
- 36:25most ardent critics of so -called mock meat had
- 36:28to admit in a blind taste test aired on PBS that
- 36:32he could not tell the difference with a sub of
- 36:36actual KFO meat and a sub made from the new types
- 36:40of mock meat. In conclusion, in response to rising
- 36:45concerns about its effect on climate change,
- 36:48coal companies, hire consultants to come up with
- 36:52new marketing campaigns, to decrease protest,
- 36:55ward off government oversight, confuse consumers
- 36:58and activists, and most importantly, to ward
- 37:01off the growth of actual valid alternatives such
- 37:05as solar and wind. Their terminology was clean
- 37:10coal. Likewise, responding to similar criticism
- 37:15from environmentalist, animal rights organizations,
- 37:18and growing fears of governmental oversight and
- 37:20shifts to actually valid options of identically
- 37:24tasting plant -based options, the meat industry
- 37:27has started to fund a new technology it calls
- 37:30clean meat. However, what we need, what I believe
- 37:36in, the simple and obvious truth is that what
- 37:40we should be fighting for is not for clean meat,
- 37:43but for no meat at all. Thank you. Hi, everyone.
- 37:56How you doing? Good, good. Thank you for that
- 38:00lively discussion. Some facts we will dispute
- 38:06in the coming session. And if I have a couple
- 38:09minutes, I might hand it over to Bruce for at
- 38:11least one fact we would dispute. However, I want
- 38:16to talk a little bit about myself, why I'm here.
- 38:19I am Leah Garces. I am the president of Mercy
- 38:22for Animals. Yay! And this is our mission. And
- 38:28our mission is to construct, an important word,
- 38:32a compassionate food system by reducing suffering
- 38:34and ending the exploitation. of animals for food.
- 38:37I use the word construct because it's very important
- 38:39to me. It's not good enough for us to just point
- 38:42out what's wrong. We have to be actively working
- 38:45to solve the problem and constructing a better
- 38:48food system. And that's important to keep in
- 38:50mind today as we tear apart what I think is a
- 38:53very valid solution that we should not be throwing
- 38:57away at this early stage in its development.
- 39:03So why are we all here? Let's just remember that,
- 39:05because that was a heated exchange, I would say.
- 39:08We're all here for the same reason. Hope brought
- 39:10us all here for the same reason. We all are trying
- 39:13to stop this. Because as a reminder, there are
- 39:17nearly 80 billion farmed animals that move through
- 39:20our food system. And that's just land. That's
- 39:22not sea animals. Those are not water animals
- 39:24that are in systems like this that are atrocious.
- 39:28And we're in crisis mode now. We're at an urgent
- 39:32point in our history because guess what? This
- 39:37is not working very well. More people are eating
- 39:43animals than ever before in history. More animals
- 39:48are being slaughtered than ever before in history.
- 39:52That is the reality that we have to keep in mind
- 39:54and we have to keep in mind for the animals that
- 39:57I just showed you. That's a fact. And that trend
- 40:00has not changed, and in fact, it's exponential.
- 40:03And there are two reasons for that. One is this.
- 40:08Human population growth. By 2050, we predict
- 40:12there will be, the United Nations predicts, there
- 40:14will be 10 billion people on the planet. That's
- 40:18not slowing down. That's not stopping, that's
- 40:21not what we're here to debate or try to stop.
- 40:23That's gonna happen. 10 billion people, and they
- 40:26all need to eat. And what's more, second trend,
- 40:32is that there's undernourishment is decreasing.
- 40:34Across the world, people are living higher qualities
- 40:37of life, and that's a great thing for human beings.
- 40:39And in some countries, that's really pronounced,
- 40:42like China and Brazil, where childhood mortality
- 40:46is dropping off a cliff. We've stayed pretty
- 40:49steady, but in some countries, where, by the
- 40:52way, the population is rising astronomically,
- 40:55They're also having higher quality of life. And
- 40:59comes with that, the unintended consequence,
- 41:01the negative consequence, is that people are
- 41:03eating more meat. And this is why more animals
- 41:06are being slaughtered than ever before in history.
- 41:09So by that thought, we are failing miserably
- 41:14at doing our job, Bruce and I, as activists.
- 41:18And we are hopeless optimists, is why we're still
- 41:21here, we're still working, because we believe
- 41:23we can change it. And I think that's why you
- 41:26all are here today, too. But we have to keep
- 41:29in mind these real figures, these cold, hard
- 41:31numbers that we're faced with. Because if population
- 41:37increases as it's set to increase, the Food and
- 41:40Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
- 41:42says that we're going to have to more than double
- 41:46the number of animals in factory farms to meet
- 41:48this demand. This is not my figure. This is the
- 41:51United Nations. So, we did a math problem. We
- 41:58said, what if we modestly, modestly, because
- 42:02we want zero, right? What if we modestly wanted
- 42:04to half the number of farmed animals that are
- 42:07slaughtered today by 2050 given the rising population?
- 42:12So we want to go from 74 billion to 37 billion,
- 42:15let's say. What would that mean per person? Would
- 42:21it mean? half the number of farmed animals per
- 42:23person? No, because there's going to be so many
- 42:28more humans on the planet. What it would mean
- 42:31is 10%. That would mean everybody in the United
- 42:35States today would have to eat 90 % less of what
- 42:41they eat today to get us to only half the number
- 42:44of farmed animals today by 2050. What's, it's
- 42:50realistic for us to look. Oh, so this is around
- 42:55the world, it's very similar. So, I know, cute
- 42:57picture for a second so we can just have a cute
- 43:00picture moment to make us happy again. Oceana,
- 43:05the same thing, which is where Asia is housed.
- 43:09Brazil, Latin America, they're all the same.
- 43:11They all have to do major reductions, 90%. Just
- 43:15to get us to half, just to get us to 37 billion,
- 43:18which is totally unacceptable, right? And okay,
- 43:22so let's think, okay, what's been happening in
- 43:24the last 20 years in terms of meat consumption?
- 43:28Or vegetarianism, plant -based? It's not good.
- 43:33Actually, a Gallup poll recently showed that
- 43:36it stayed the same. Over 20 years in the United
- 43:39States, it's been at 6%. It hasn't changed. So
- 43:43again, Something's not right in the way that
- 43:46we're approaching this problem So let's review
- 43:5010 billion people on the planet by 2050 they're
- 43:53gonna have higher standards of living And we're
- 43:55gonna have to more than double the number of
- 43:57animals to meet that demand To reduce the number
- 44:01of farmed animals by even half an American would
- 44:03have to eat 90 % less of what they eat today
- 44:05But vegetarianism has stayed around five to six
- 44:08percent of the last 20 years in this country
- 44:11So What should our approach be? What should we
- 44:16do? This is what I think about every day in my
- 44:20job, what Bruce thinks about every single day
- 44:22as activists. We are thinking, how do we stop
- 44:26this trend? Now, our opponents might try to tell
- 44:31you that clean meat is the holy grail for us,
- 44:35that we think this is the only answer, we're
- 44:37gonna throw all our resources, we're giving up
- 44:39on everything else. It is not true. But clean
- 44:43meat didn't exist only a few years ago. We're
- 44:46in the first stages of developing this should
- 44:48we throw it out right now forget it Should we
- 44:53say no to this obviously a technology that has
- 44:57a great amount of potential Is clean meat bad
- 45:03for animals absolutely not it doesn't harm one
- 45:06animal in the process given its full potential
- 45:09and Is it something that is the answer to stopping
- 45:16the exploitation of animals for food? Maybe.
- 45:20It might be. Or maybe not. But we shouldn't stop
- 45:22now. And is it good for animals? Absolutely.
- 45:28It's worth exploring. But so are all of these
- 45:31to continue doing. All of these things we do.
- 45:34There's not one answer. And I think we get into
- 45:36this idea of there's one hero to the story of
- 45:39ending factory farming. But there's not one hero.
- 45:42We're all part of this story. And all of the
- 45:45options that we're exploring, we have to support.
- 45:49And our opponent also talked about stopping consumption
- 45:53of all meat. But what is meat? Meat is a word,
- 45:58is a social construct that we created, that we
- 46:03decided comes from a slaughtered animal. Our
- 46:06opponents might say that meat shouldn't be eaten,
- 46:10even if it comes from an animal that was never
- 46:12slaughtered, that was never harmed, that was
- 46:15never alive. So should we reject it for that
- 46:20reason? Because it comes originally from a system
- 46:25of injustice and exploitation? Well, it turns
- 46:29out that we can reassign things at any time,
- 46:32and we are doing so, and we have done so. The
- 46:36industry feels really threatened by this and
- 46:38confused and they're conflicting internally about
- 46:40this. They don't know what to do. We have the
- 46:43Cattlemen Association who are throwing petitions
- 46:45to stop us from redefining meat as a word because
- 46:49this is super threatening to them. Where we're
- 46:51saying, you don't get to decide what meat is,
- 46:54we do. And it doesn't come from a slaughtered
- 46:56animal. And companies like Cargill are thinking,
- 47:01I got to stay in business in the future. They're
- 47:03not doing out of mal intent. I work with these
- 47:06companies. They're just caring about the bottom
- 47:09line. And if we can convince them that the bottom
- 47:11line can come from an animal that was never slaughtered,
- 47:14they're like, thumbs up. That's all they care
- 47:17about. They don't care about animals. They don't
- 47:20really care about consumers. They care about
- 47:22money. Right? And if we can make it so that it
- 47:26just makes money, they're all for it. And CARG
- 47:30will prove that. Cargill renamed their meat department.
- 47:34They read just listen they renamed their meat
- 47:36department to be a protein department Because
- 47:40they're preparing for the future they know this
- 47:42is where we are headed Where this word and protein
- 47:46we're in a protein revolution right now Where
- 47:49this word is changing? And is there any history
- 47:55that where we reassigned a word And to do that
- 47:58I have to tell you the story, the tale of the
- 48:01two Henrys. Has anybody heard the tale of the
- 48:02two Henrys before? Oh good. Does anybody know
- 48:06who is on the left? Or on the right? Henry Ford,
- 48:11okay. On the left is Henry Berg. Henry Berg is
- 48:14the founder of the ASPCA and Henry Ford made
- 48:18cars. So Henry Berg in 1863, he was an American
- 48:24diplomat and he went over to Russia and he saw
- 48:27this driver beating a fallen horse and he got
- 48:32out and he stopped him and right then and there
- 48:34he realized he was an activist and he could do
- 48:37something to change the world. He went back to
- 48:39the United States and in 1866 he founded the
- 48:42ASPCA with the primary focus of protecting those
- 48:44horses, of stopping the abuse and cruelty towards
- 48:48horses used for the simple thing that humans
- 48:50needed, transportation from A to B. But his dream
- 48:55was really accelerated, really driven home when
- 49:00Henry Ford came up with a car. Henry Ford very
- 49:04famously said, if I had asked my customers what
- 49:08they wanted, they would have said a faster horse.
- 49:11I gave them a car. And it was the car, it was
- 49:16this vehicle, this transportation, innovation
- 49:20that led to the near end of the use of horses
- 49:24for transportation. Because human beings were
- 49:28going to continue to need transportation from
- 49:31A to B and demand that. And as population grew
- 49:34and our world grew smaller, they still wanted
- 49:37to get from A to B and they still needed it.
- 49:41And that's the... Okay, my last one. So, in this
- 49:47same way, where... The abused horse is now the
- 49:57forgotten ancestor of our modern car. One day,
- 50:01with any hope of this technology working, the
- 50:06burger or the farmed animal that is slaughtered
- 50:09will just be the distant memory, the ancestor,
- 50:13the forgotten ancestor of the burger. And cell
- 50:18-based meat will have helped us get there, hopefully.
- 50:20And farmed animals will thank us for not stopping
- 50:23to explore every avenue, take every option, because
- 50:27of those astronomical numbers we are up against.
- 50:30Thank you. Our resident pirate, John Sanbanmatsu.
- 50:46Thank you, Hope. Thank you, Hope, and thank you,
- 50:48Karen, for having me here. I'm going to speak
- 50:49very quickly, because I have about 20 minutes.
- 50:51I'm combining into 10. I get it. We have some
- 50:56courageous activists on the stage. And I get
- 50:58that after so many years of frustration with
- 51:01people eating more meat, more animals suffering,
- 51:04we see something bright and shiny and new, a
- 51:07high -technology item, something that has the
- 51:09backing of a lot of very powerful, rich white
- 51:12men. So it must be award -winning, kind of like
- 51:15the film Green Book. Well, my message for you
- 51:21today, my message for you today is that all that
- 51:24glitters is not gold. Sometimes under further
- 51:27scrutiny it turns out to be fool's gold, which
- 51:29has all, actually none of the properties of real
- 51:32gold, but all of the sheen. Geologists call that
- 51:35pyrite, which is why I have come dressed as a
- 51:37pyrite myself tonight. Ladies and gentlemen,
- 51:42welcome to the land of make -believe, where the
- 51:46Good Food Institute tells us that the two forces
- 51:49which have destroyed most animal life on the
- 51:52earth, which are capitalism and the meat economy,
- 51:56the meat industry, are going to, guess what,
- 51:58be the solution to saving the animals. It would
- 52:01be funny if it wasn't horrifying. So I have many
- 52:07different arguments to make. The main one is
- 52:09that synthetic meat is an opportunity for the
- 52:11meat industry to diversify its markets and to
- 52:14ensure its long -term survival, including of
- 52:17its... I need the clicker. Where's the clicker?
- 52:24We've been in heated negotiations about time
- 52:27here. Clean meat is part of a strategy not to
- 52:32replace animal agriculture, but to enshrine the
- 52:34meat economy forever. Oh, by the way, so this,
- 52:39you'll be able to, I'll show the slide later.
- 52:40We are putting together a website, thecleanmeathoax
- 52:43.com. My first point is that clean meat strengthens
- 52:46meat culture. Synthetic meat reinforces meat
- 52:49culture as a whole. As Justin Van Cleet points
- 52:52out, quote, the problem with clean meat is that
- 52:55it keeps meat as a concept on the plate. The
- 52:58continued preponderance of meat will therefore
- 53:00mean that real meat will always have a cultural
- 53:02cache that nothing else will. I think that aestheticizing
- 53:05meat as an attractive commodity is a terrible
- 53:08idea. Consumers are being thrust into a twilight
- 53:11zone of ontological ambiguity. Is it real or
- 53:15is it Memorex? Is it real meat or is it real
- 53:17meat? Who can say? Much of the public relations
- 53:21and marketing discourse around clean meat actually
- 53:24reinforces myths about meat. The idea that animal
- 53:27flesh is essential, indispensable, inevitable,
- 53:30irreplaceable, natural, something we need rather
- 53:32than merely want. When Bruce was interviewed
- 53:35on Vox, his interviewer said, quote, you often
- 53:37hear that eating animals is natural. And it is,
- 53:40but not the way we do it. Bruce, unfortunately,
- 53:43did not correct the interviewer. But in fact,
- 53:45it is not natural. It's a historical cultural
- 53:47artifact, as Leah was saying. Meat is even being
- 53:50depicted as aesthetically beautiful. Here's how
- 53:53the Israeli synthetic meat startup Aleph Farms,
- 53:55a beneficiary of one of Bruce's two venture capitalist
- 53:59firms. You're too modest, Bruce. You talked about
- 54:01your non -profit work, not the fact that you
- 54:03are principal in two venture capitalist firms
- 54:06to produce and profit from this. Yes, debate
- 54:22later. One of the firms that's profiting from
- 54:25these capital venture firms is Aleph Foods, which
- 54:28says, quote, we believe meat is one of life's
- 54:31pleasures to be celebrated and enjoyed, but without
- 54:34the downsides to health and the environment.
- 54:37Finally, meat you can enjoy that's good for your
- 54:39health and good for the planet. So, two messages.
- 54:42One, meat is one of life's essential pleasures.
- 54:44Two, you should eat the new meat for health and
- 54:46the environment. And my friends, it's not about
- 54:49the animals in most of the discourse of the advertising.
- 54:52It's an anti -vegan discourse. The animals barely
- 54:55get mentioned a lot of the time in many of the
- 54:57presentations, as though they're an embarrassment.
- 54:59It's doing the opposite of what we want to do,
- 55:01which is try to get people to actually care about
- 55:03animals, not to trivialize them. But Bruce himself
- 55:06says that the whole point of clean meat is, quote,
- 55:10take ethics off the table for the consumer. But
- 55:14taking ethics off the table subverts animal justice
- 55:17and damages the long -term interests of both
- 55:19animals and our movement. Secondly, Clean meat
- 55:24is not intended to replace animal agriculture.
- 55:27Neither the Good Food Institute nor the venture
- 55:29capitalist firm's new crop capital or clear current
- 55:31capital are against animal agriculture. Quote,
- 55:35our team views conventional animal agriculture
- 55:37as an antiquated and inefficient food production
- 55:41system. And Bruce himself said at a debate, quote,
- 55:45I understand the concern of people in slow food.
- 55:47And we're absolutely not trying to make people
- 55:50unhappy about, you know, animal farms. I would
- 55:53be completely shocked if the fact that clean
- 55:55meat is being promoted, if that had any negative
- 55:57ramifications for the folks in the regenerative
- 56:00animal agriculture, slow food, high welfare crowd.
- 56:03And in fact, to the degree that clean meat is
- 56:05successful, it replaces conventional animal agriculture.
- 56:09We see Tyson, Smithfield, and everybody else
- 56:11go to clean meat. And then the options are clean
- 56:14meat on one hand and then the sort of regenerative
- 56:18high -welfare meat on the other. So it's reducing
- 56:20the future to these two possibilities. Quote,
- 56:23so I don't see them in competition at all. I
- 56:26don't think there are any real negative ramifications
- 56:28for high welfare regenerative agriculture. Just
- 56:31as a reminder, this is what high welfare animal
- 56:35agriculture looks like. Camus Davis, of course,
- 56:39the local hunting people, and all the animals
- 56:41end up in these slaughterhouses anyway. This
- 56:44is high welfare. And these people basically get
- 56:46a pass. Make no mistake. This is an anti animal
- 56:52justice position. It is a welfare's position
- 56:54It is not an abolitionist one the clean meat
- 56:57Lobby has set up a false dilemma a choice between
- 57:00conventional animal agriculture on one side and
- 57:03new synthesized animal flesh on the other What
- 57:06we need is an is a choice between animal agriculture
- 57:09and animal free agriculture This, by the way,
- 57:12is an intensification of humane meat discourse,
- 57:15which I've written on. We don't have time to
- 57:17go into it. Bruce has been a promoter of that.
- 57:20I think humane meat and the myth that animals
- 57:22can be killed, gassed, shot, stabbed in the billions
- 57:26or millions ethically is horrific and has done
- 57:30great damage to our movements. Clean meat won't
- 57:36eliminate meat from animals killed on factory
- 57:38farms either so I could agree with my partner
- 57:41in this facility Who quoted Bruce is saying for
- 57:45the good food Institute? We have really good
- 57:46relationships with Tyson Smithfield Purdue and
- 57:49so forth and says that the people who run these
- 57:50companies want to do something noble They want
- 57:53to feed the world high quality protein. That's
- 57:55their goal But as Leah said, it isn't their goal.
- 57:58They have one goal. It isn't to feed the world.
- 58:00It's to make profit. And if they're going to
- 58:02kill billions and billions of animals to do that,
- 58:04they'll do that. So that much of the argument
- 58:07is clear. Well, James Levesque, over a decade
- 58:11ago, wrote this really great article. You should
- 58:12look up online. It's called Invasion of the Movement
- 58:14Snatchers. And it's about how the meat industry
- 58:17is taking over the vegan movement and the animal
- 58:20rights movement, believe it or not. So you have,
- 58:23just in the last A few years, you have all of
- 58:27these companies now taking over the vegan foods
- 58:31industry. In 2016, the Danone Dairy Company in
- 58:36France bought White Wave and Silk Soy Milk. In
- 58:402017, Field Roast and Light Life, the vegan meat
- 58:43companies, were purchased by Maple Leaf Foods,
- 58:46the biggest killer of animals in Canada. So this
- 58:54is maple leaf foods. In 2017, the Daiya Cheese
- 58:58Company was purchased by the Otsuka Pharmaceutical
- 59:02Company, the second biggest big pharma in Japan,
- 59:04which of course tests on animals. Last year,
- 59:08Good Catch, which is one of the companies that
- 59:10Bruce has promoted, I believe. raised 8 .7 million
- 59:14dollars in new funding, including from the PHW
- 59:18Grupa Lohmann Company. Who are they? One of Europe's
- 59:21largest poultry producers. They killed 350 million
- 59:24chickens just last year. Meanwhile, thanks to
- 59:28these capital investment firms, the biggest meat
- 59:31companies are now buying into synthetic meat.
- 59:33Tyson and Cargill are investing in Memphis meats,
- 59:36and it could give you many other examples. So
- 59:40why are companies doing this? Why are they gobbling
- 59:44up the vegan industry? Well, I want to concur
- 59:47with my debate partner here. First of all, there's
- 59:51vegan washing and green washing. These companies
- 59:54are able to put a compassionate label, sustainability
- 59:57label on their products. Secondly, they are hedging
- 1:00:01against future risk by buying up vegan enterprises.
- 1:00:03They gain strategic, growing influence and advantage
- 1:00:06over the vegan market and the animal rights movement.
- 1:00:10They're defining our discourses for us and now
- 1:00:12here we are as though summoned. Three, it's about
- 1:00:16the money. to ensure future market dominance
- 1:00:19through a two -track strategy to preserve and,
- 1:00:22where possible, to expand traditional live animal
- 1:00:24markets. It is quite clear these companies have
- 1:00:26no intention ever of ending animal agriculture.
- 1:00:30Now, it's possible that if they could do it cheaply
- 1:00:33and so forth, that is a possibility, but I think
- 1:00:36it's an extremely remote one. Here's what Cargill
- 1:00:39said. Now, they're an investor in Memphis Meats.
- 1:00:42Quote, Cargill is committed to growing our protein
- 1:00:45portfolio. This includes investing in and growing
- 1:00:48our traditional animal protein businesses. Our
- 1:00:51commitment is reinforced by nearly $600 million
- 1:00:54in recent investments in conventional protein,
- 1:00:57meaning factory farming, in North America alone,
- 1:01:01including acquisition of five -star custom foods,
- 1:01:04modernization of our turkey hatchery in Virginia,
- 1:01:06the conversion of our Columbus Nebraska plant
- 1:01:08into a cooked meats facility, and on and on and
- 1:01:11on. They say this underscores This further underscores
- 1:01:16Cargill's overarching commitment to animal protein.
- 1:01:20At Cargill, we recognize that meat is a core
- 1:01:23part of consumer diets, central to many cultures
- 1:01:26and traditions. Our traditional proteins as well
- 1:01:30as new innovations like cultured meats are both
- 1:01:32necessary to meet that demand. What Leah didn't
- 1:01:36mention is that, no, the desire for meat is not
- 1:01:39natural. It's actually marketed. And these companies,
- 1:01:41like Cargill, spend billions of dollars to make
- 1:01:43people want to buy the meat. So it's creating
- 1:01:47the demand. And these are the people who are
- 1:01:49supposed to trust. And we see the same thing
- 1:01:52with the Danone Company. pronged strategy, a
- 1:01:57dual track strategy. There is room for dairy
- 1:01:59alternatives and milk products. Our data shows
- 1:02:02that both milk alternatives as well as dairy
- 1:02:04products can perform well and not necessarily
- 1:02:08take share from one another. That in turn suggests
- 1:02:11that consumers can be swayed either way. So basically,
- 1:02:15this is how the future looks to maple farms.
- 1:02:17They're going to have ham, and then they're going
- 1:02:18to have field roast vegan. They're going to preserve
- 1:02:21this. There's no intention. There's nothing that
- 1:02:24suggests they're going to get away from it. The
- 1:02:27introduction of a versimilitude in a commodity
- 1:02:30does not have anything to do with how it changes
- 1:02:34consumption. Faux fur has been around for decades.
- 1:02:39And guess what? Fur consumption is increasing.
- 1:02:41I've never seen so much fur. This is actually
- 1:02:44fake fur. This has not replaced real fur, just
- 1:02:48as the meat, the synthetic meat, is not going
- 1:02:51to replace the other meat. It's going to come
- 1:02:53right along with it. Now, the last thing I wanted
- 1:02:57to say, almost the last thing, is that the clean
- 1:03:00meat is the strategy of robbing Peter to pay
- 1:03:02Paul, and Vasili touched on this. But if you
- 1:03:04buy, say, recycled papers, I do, from Georgia
- 1:03:07Pacific, you're actually supporting Koch Enterprises,
- 1:03:10which is to say the Koch brothers, who own Georgia
- 1:03:12Pacific. So every time we try to do the right
- 1:03:15thing and buy a field roast burger, we're actually
- 1:03:17supporting factory farming. Cargill which has
- 1:03:20been come up come up for praise one of the leading
- 1:03:22companies involved in deforestation right the
- 1:03:25homelessness of orangutans and others and Finally,
- 1:03:28it's not going to work if you take ethics off
- 1:03:31the table There's no longer a compelling reason
- 1:03:33to buy the synthetic meats in the first place
- 1:03:35and as Vasili said they're not it's not even
- 1:03:36clear It's that sustainable and basically you're
- 1:03:39gonna leave consumers with the choice Do they
- 1:03:41want the real thing or they're gonna want the
- 1:03:43synthetic thing? Well, especially if they're
- 1:03:45comparably priced they're gonna want the real
- 1:03:47thing most of the time or half the time or a
- 1:03:49quarter of the time, whatever. But we're talking
- 1:03:51about billions and billions and billions of animals.
- 1:03:54So the last thing I wanted to say is, then what
- 1:03:57is all of this about, you know, fundamentally?
- 1:04:00And I think it really is about this, actually.
- 1:04:04You know, I really do. What's a pirate? No, I
- 1:04:10have two sentences, two sentences. So the new
- 1:04:13meets lobby, including these venture capitalist
- 1:04:15firms, are going to make their investors a ton
- 1:04:18of money. As the new crop capital's chief investment
- 1:04:21officer, Chris Kerr said, quote, we will be rich
- 1:04:24no matter what. That's a direct quote, Bruce,
- 1:04:26from Chris Kerr. We will be rich no matter what.
- 1:04:29We are being treated as fools. They get the gold,
- 1:04:32and the animals lose. Thank you. OK. Wow. Lively.
- 1:04:46I'm feeling like, I was going to get right into
- 1:04:49questions, but I want to check in with the panel.
- 1:04:52And I wonder if either side would like to just
- 1:04:56have five minutes to respond to what was said.
- 1:05:00It feels like we might want to clear up a little
- 1:05:07bit. I don't know. I just saw a lot of frantic
- 1:05:09notes being taken and all that. So does any side
- 1:05:15want to take just five minutes to respond to
- 1:05:17anything that was said? Bruce, go ahead. So for
- 1:05:23people who don't know, I was at People for the
- 1:05:26Ethical Treatment of Animals for 15 years, Vice
- 1:05:29President of Campaigns for PETA. I put together
- 1:05:32the Meet Your Meat video, put together the Paul
- 1:05:34McCartney Glass Walls video. What I expected
- 1:05:37to be discussing was what John said. That was
- 1:05:40pretty much what I assume both sides would say.
- 1:05:43I just want to say PETA came out in favor of
- 1:05:47and has been vigorously supportive of clean meat
- 1:05:52for probably 15 years since it was just sort
- 1:05:56of a pipe dream and has continued to be vigorously
- 1:06:00supportive. I'm not familiar with any. animal
- 1:06:03rights organization that has come out against
- 1:06:05it. The Humane League has come out in favor.
- 1:06:07Mercy for Animals has come out in favor. Animal
- 1:06:09Equality has come out in favor. The Humane Society
- 1:06:11has come out in favor. If anything that Vlas
- 1:06:15said in his first 12 minutes were true, none
- 1:06:19of those organizations would have come out in
- 1:06:21favor of it. None of them. So you either have
- 1:06:25to believe that Ingrid and David and Leah and
- 1:06:31me who's dedicating my life to this, either we're
- 1:06:36willing to sacrifice animals for the greater
- 1:06:38good, which we're not, or we're stupid, which
- 1:06:41we're not, or we didn't do due diligence and
- 1:06:44just didn't realize all the things that he said,
- 1:06:46which isn't the case. All of the organizations
- 1:06:49and I and Leah did due diligence on the technology
- 1:06:54and really just None of it's true. So that's
- 1:06:58the first thing to say. I am just in the interest
- 1:07:00of sort of settling everything, going to just
- 1:07:04sort of knock down each of the things to tell
- 1:07:06you what our position is. Does it harm the planet?
- 1:07:10Well, the LCA that he said the in vitro meat
- 1:07:13industry had funded came out in 2011. And the
- 1:07:18in vitro meat industry raised its first $50 ,000
- 1:07:22in 2015. and so had not existed for four years
- 1:07:26at that point. There really isn't an in vitro
- 1:07:29meat industry. The clean meat companies so far
- 1:07:33have raised about $70 million, some total across
- 1:07:35all of them. Very little of that so far has come
- 1:07:38from the meat industry, although we're optimistic
- 1:07:40that a lot more will. The LCAs that exist, I
- 1:07:44do agree with him that there aren't many of them
- 1:07:46and they aren't very good. I'm sorry, life cycle
- 1:07:50analyses. Yeah, the environmental impact assessments,
- 1:07:55I apologize. But the study that he cited, which
- 1:08:00I was really very surprised by, the study where
- 1:08:02he said the CO2 requirements of clean meat are
- 1:08:05so high and consequently clean meat will actually
- 1:08:07be worse for the environment. This is a study
- 1:08:10that came out maybe three weeks ago and it said
- 1:08:14at the thousand -year mark in one of the four
- 1:08:18scenarios that they studied starting in 800 years.
- 1:08:22clean meat will be worse than industrial animal
- 1:08:25meat. But the main point that the Good Food Institute
- 1:08:28has made, and if you Google the Good Food Institute
- 1:08:31and life cycle analyses, or my name and life
- 1:08:34cycle analyses, or if you just go to gfi .org
- 1:08:37upslash blog, I think it's like three or four
- 1:08:39blogs down, you'll see our analysis of this.
- 1:08:42It's a little bit like predicting the life cycle,
- 1:08:44the environmental impact of something like an
- 1:08:46iPhone 10 years before there was an iPhone. Basically,
- 1:08:50what's happening is that we are extrapolating
- 1:08:53from medical therapies, which is what tissue
- 1:08:56engineering is being used for now, taking that
- 1:09:00process, applying it to food, and saying that's
- 1:09:03the best it's going to get, which is simply not
- 1:09:07the case. And the price thing is like attacking
- 1:09:09the iPhone in 2012. Both Voss and John said both,
- 1:09:15it's not going to work. It's not going to save
- 1:09:17animals. and it's going to make the meat industry
- 1:09:21insanely profitable. You kind of have to choose
- 1:09:24between those two things, it seems to me. I'll
- 1:09:26give you one more minute, Bruce. Okay. Fetal
- 1:09:33bovine serum. That was going to be my first question,
- 1:09:36so if you've got anything else. Okay. There are
- 1:09:39no animal experiments. Oh, yeah. I started two
- 1:09:45venture capital funds by recruiting the people
- 1:09:46who run them, both Chris Kerr and Kurt Albright.
- 1:09:49The guys who run the two venture capital firms
- 1:09:51are longtime animal rights activists, animal
- 1:09:53rights philanthropists, and vegans. I have no,
- 1:09:56absolutely no. I'm not a principal. I have absolutely
- 1:09:59no interest in either of them, although I am
- 1:10:00an advisor to both of them. The idea of ethics
- 1:10:03off the table, I mean, that's just we want meat
- 1:10:05not to be associated with animals. We want people
- 1:10:07when they are eating meat, like when people take
- 1:10:09insulin now. Does anybody think people shouldn't
- 1:10:11take synthetic insulin? We want to take ethics
- 1:10:14off the table. So when he says not clean meat
- 1:10:17but no meat, the main thing I want to say is
- 1:10:19how is that going for us? How is that going?
- 1:10:22Highest per capita meat consumption 2018, 2019
- 1:10:25is going to be even higher. Nobody has a scenario
- 1:10:28for how education turns back the clock. But both
- 1:10:32of them said over and over, this is going to
- 1:10:33make the meat industry a ton of money. It probably
- 1:10:36will make the meat industry a ton of money because
- 1:10:39it's more efficient. So the idea that they're
- 1:10:41going to be doing 50 -50 blends, how many people
- 1:10:45are riding around by horse and carriage? How
- 1:10:48many pictures are you taking not on your digital
- 1:10:53camera? How much communication is happening with
- 1:10:56landlines? As this scales up, it's going to be
- 1:10:59less expensive. Maybe there are cattle ranchers
- 1:11:02and dairy farmers who actually like the fact
- 1:11:05that they're working with animals, but none of
- 1:11:07the executives at Tyson and Purdue and Smithfield
- 1:11:09and Hormel, For none of them is the idea of factory
- 1:11:13farming and slaughterhouses, the reason they
- 1:11:14get up in the morning. If you meet these people,
- 1:11:17they're like all of our families and friends
- 1:11:19who eat meat. They really do want to provide
- 1:11:21high -quality protein to the world. They went
- 1:11:23to business school. They got the job at Tyson
- 1:11:25or Purdue or Hormel. They could have just as
- 1:11:28easily been just about anyplace else. Yes, a
- 1:11:32capitalist economy, which is what I thought we
- 1:11:34were going to be talking about. We get to animal
- 1:11:37liberation. This is how we take ethics off the
- 1:11:39table. This is how we make meat harmless. And
- 1:11:43if we care about animals, think about the animals
- 1:11:45on the factory farms, think about the animals
- 1:11:47in the slaughterhouses. Do you want 70 % more
- 1:11:49of them dead in 2050? I'm going to wrap you up,
- 1:11:51Bruce. OK. Thank you. So I'm going to give this
- 1:11:59side one of you five minutes, and then we're
- 1:12:01going to get into questions to respond. Okay,
- 1:12:06that's fine. This is a now response to what you
- 1:12:09heard from the introductions. So let me just
- 1:12:12say one thing briefly. I just want everyone to
- 1:12:14know, I personally respect Bruce a great deal.
- 1:12:18And I think most people here do. And I'm just
- 1:12:20now meeting Leah, but I personally respect her.
- 1:12:22And I respect every animal rights organization
- 1:12:24out there. I respect every vegan out there. There's
- 1:12:27not that many of us. I, you know, I disagree
- 1:12:37with this topic and I think that there has been
- 1:12:40some mistakes that have been made. I don't think
- 1:12:43that people are fundamentally different in their
- 1:12:47hearts. I'm just trying to highlight some information.
- 1:12:51So one part of information I'm trying to highlight
- 1:12:53is the preponderance of peer -reviewed research
- 1:12:57that has been done on in vitro meat. So you can
- 1:13:00go to the Good Food Institute. They have a white
- 1:13:03paper. So, and don't trust me, Google it on your
- 1:13:06phone. You can do Good Food Institute, White
- 1:13:09Paper, Clean Meat. They cite three and a half
- 1:13:13studies in favor of the environmental benefit
- 1:13:16of clean meat. Very briefly, I'll go through
- 1:13:19them. So, the first one they cite is the one
- 1:13:23he mentioned from 2011. This is the only positive
- 1:13:27study. As earlier discussed, it was created by
- 1:13:30a graduate student, and that doesn't mean graduate
- 1:13:32students can't do great work. They do. But it
- 1:13:35does mean that there might be some mistakes that
- 1:13:37cropped in. It was funded by the in vitro media
- 1:13:40industry. Maybe that wasn't a precise term. But
- 1:13:43what happened is New Harvest, and you can Google
- 1:13:45New Harvest, take a look. They put out money
- 1:13:48and they said, hey, we want to fund the study.
- 1:13:50Now, it's not the case that funding studies always
- 1:13:54makes bias. But there's better and worse ways
- 1:13:56to do it. And New Harvest did the worst possible
- 1:13:59one. They said, we have some money. and we're
- 1:14:02going to look at all the applications. And then
- 1:14:06after you've applied to us, we're going to choose
- 1:14:09who does the studies, and we're going to choose
- 1:14:11which methodology we support. So that is the
- 1:14:15most amount of bias that you can interject into
- 1:14:19a study. And this was by an organization which
- 1:14:22explicitly wants to promote in vitro meat. That's
- 1:14:26who funded the study. If you take a look at the
- 1:14:29paper, It says it's funded by them at the bottom
- 1:14:32of the paper. It is also on their website. So
- 1:14:35this is not in debate so as I mentioned the study
- 1:14:40had multiple thought it wasn't an actual Lifecycle
- 1:14:44analysis because it doesn't ask light it had
- 1:14:46thought experiments And I mentioned one that
- 1:14:49was untrue and we have time in the questions
- 1:14:51later I can tell you how the other thought experiments
- 1:14:54were all not also possible one of them included
- 1:14:58the statement that she didn't need to consider
- 1:15:01the energy that was needed for the bioreactors
- 1:15:05because cells make heat, even though that's actually
- 1:15:09one of the primary areas that produces GHG. So
- 1:15:14it's a flawed study. And then if I have time
- 1:15:17later in the questions, I can go through the
- 1:15:18rest of the white paper and explain to you how
- 1:15:20each of the studies they cite actually concludes
- 1:15:24that in vitro meat would be more harmful to the
- 1:15:26planet. then pot then all forms of chicken or
- 1:15:30pork and possibly beef and Certainly worse than
- 1:15:34any kind of plant -based alternative. Thank you
- 1:15:38I Just wanted to briefly comment on the horse
- 1:15:45thing because Bruce I've seen you give that talk
- 1:15:48on your TED talk and so we're making that point
- 1:15:50about horses In the horse carriage, yeah, right
- 1:15:55horses transfer, you know Many, many, many more
- 1:15:59animals have been killed and mutilated by Henry
- 1:16:01Ford's innovation than ever died through the
- 1:16:04horse and carriage business. So you have to be
- 1:16:08aware of the unintended consequences of technology
- 1:16:11when they're in the hands of very powerful people
- 1:16:15and where there's no democratic accountability.
- 1:16:17Henry Ford, of course, who's been kind of lionized
- 1:16:20here, was a notorious anti -Semite, you know,
- 1:16:22buddy, very friendly with Hitler, you know, treated
- 1:16:26the workers terribly, etc. My point is that you
- 1:16:29can't, we can't just assume that a market mechanism
- 1:16:32is going to correct a moral problem. It won't.
- 1:16:35It hasn't. Capitalism has destroyed two -thirds
- 1:16:39of all animal life in the last 40 years, according
- 1:16:42to the World Wildlife Federation. destroyed,
- 1:16:45being killed by this metastatic system. So to
- 1:16:48think, regardless of what the particular individual's
- 1:16:52moral character are at the head of Tyson and
- 1:16:53Purdue and so forth, I don't know these people.
- 1:16:56But I can tell you, just look at their record.
- 1:16:57Look at the undercover investigations by PETA
- 1:17:01and so forth of the horrific abuses of animals
- 1:17:04by these companies. Are these people going to
- 1:17:06be trusted? No. What's going to happen is meat
- 1:17:09consumption per capita is going to probably go
- 1:17:13up because they're going to market more of this
- 1:17:15stuff. And what I think is going to happen is
- 1:17:17that, yes, there's potentially fewer animals
- 1:17:20suffering, but it's going to bottom out at a
- 1:17:22certain price point. And then you're going to
- 1:17:23have both factory farmed flesh available and
- 1:17:27the synthetic meat, and it's going to go on.
- 1:17:30And that's why Vasili and I feel strongly that
- 1:17:33it's a mistaken strategy. We're not impugning
- 1:17:37motives here, but we are saying that it's a very
- 1:17:40mistaken strategy. Thank you. Okay, so we're
- 1:17:49gonna get into some questions. We're really I
- 1:17:52mean, it's it's so fascinating and amazing and
- 1:17:54and we're the time is just ticking away so I
- 1:17:58want to get into the specific question of the
- 1:18:04concern with the embryonic, the fetal bovine
- 1:18:08serum, using that as the medium right now. I've
- 1:18:13also heard that horse serum is used, chicken
- 1:18:15embryo extract, things like this. I'm not sure
- 1:18:19how accurate that is, so I'm asking the panel.
- 1:18:25Basically, what is the likelihood that this is
- 1:18:28going to continue? I would hope that, you know,
- 1:18:34that we're working towards not using these, but
- 1:18:37right now it's the best media to use. And you,
- 1:18:43you know, by the pro -side zone admission, you
- 1:18:47know, these people aren't in it for the animals,
- 1:18:50a lot of them. So how can we guarantee that these
- 1:18:55things are going to move towards a more ethical
- 1:18:59vegan process and only use vegan methods and
- 1:19:03medias? And this kind of goes into one of the
- 1:19:08audience's question that says that I'm concerned
- 1:19:12about the animals who will be used for lab -grown
- 1:19:14meat. How will these animals live and be treated?
- 1:19:19Leah, do you want to start since you haven't
- 1:19:21spoken for a bit? Yeah. Well, I'm confused about
- 1:19:26the animals that are used because there was a
- 1:19:30great video that came out created by Just, and
- 1:19:33it was called Ian the Chicken. Did anybody see
- 1:19:36that video? So the whole process was there was
- 1:19:42a chicken named Ian, a feather had fallen. They
- 1:19:45picked up the feather. They extracted the cell
- 1:19:48from the feather. And then they grew the meat
- 1:19:51from this fallen feather. Then they made a nugget.
- 1:19:55They ate the chicken while Ian was wandering
- 1:19:58around. Right? So there's no animal harmed in
- 1:20:02the process, in that process, right? And Bruce
- 1:20:06can answer this better than I can about the serum.
- 1:20:09So am I right that Memphis Meats, are any of
- 1:20:11the company, well you probably should answer
- 1:20:13this question better about the serum. I'll let
- 1:20:14him answer the serum. Because the direction is
- 1:20:17we're not going to use bovine serum. And none
- 1:20:19of it is coming to market yet. Nothing's on market.
- 1:20:22You can't purchase this anywhere. And all of
- 1:20:24the research is looking at a total plant -based
- 1:20:27solution to feed them. And that's every company's
- 1:20:31objective right now, is to only use a plant -based
- 1:20:34serum. So the technology that they're borrowing
- 1:20:38is from cancer research, where, of course, they
- 1:20:41didn't think about that. And they are using bovine
- 1:20:43serum. And that's where the research they're
- 1:20:45borrowing. That's the knowledge to date. But
- 1:20:48all of the work is around finding a plant -based
- 1:20:51solution 100 percent and not using, none of us
- 1:20:54would. Do you think that Bruce and I, collectively
- 1:20:57we have 40 years of animal rights activism between
- 1:21:00us. Would we be supporting that? Absolutely not.
- 1:21:04No way. I also want to point out there's been
- 1:21:08the heads of these companies, they don't really
- 1:21:10care about the animals. That is also not true.
- 1:21:13The head of Memphis Meats is a vegan, he's a
- 1:21:16cardiologist, he cares deeply about animals.
- 1:21:18The head of Just is a vegan, he's an activist,
- 1:21:21he cares deeply about animals. The people who
- 1:21:24are starting these companies, I know them personally,
- 1:21:26care deeply about animals. Because I was talking
- 1:21:28more about Big Ag and Tyson that's getting into
- 1:21:30it and Cargill. Right. Okay. Well, they're investing
- 1:21:33in it because it looks lucrative and they're
- 1:21:35threatened by this and they only care about the
- 1:21:37bottom line and they want to make sure they stay
- 1:21:39in business as the trend. Goes away from this.
- 1:21:43I also I didn't put this in my slides, but there's
- 1:21:46a reality that those businesses are seeing Which
- 1:21:49is arable land is running out So when we have
- 1:21:53a chicken, it's not just the environmental impact
- 1:21:56of raising that chicken in that spot There's
- 1:21:58all of the soy and the grains that are being
- 1:22:01raised and we are running out of land arable
- 1:22:04land We it's just a math problem. We literally
- 1:22:09cannot eat that much meat in the future But people
- 1:22:11are still demanding it. So we're just going to
- 1:22:13run our plan into the ground if we don't come
- 1:22:14up with a solution. If you don't care about the
- 1:22:16animals, the future of our planet is not going
- 1:22:19in a good direction. And one other thing I just
- 1:22:22want to say, well, I didn't get a chance to respond,
- 1:22:25is I get what it feels like to be angry about
- 1:22:29these things. I really loved Renee's talk. And
- 1:22:33I've worked with factory farmers turned activists.
- 1:22:42Bruce is going to that she put Yes, Bruce is
- 1:22:46going to she said that she didn't have the knowledge
- 1:22:48is gonna Let Bruce answer it and now she's making
- 1:22:50a response because she didn't get to speak earlier
- 1:22:52So now she's responding to some of the things
- 1:22:54that were said earlier We're gonna get that that
- 1:22:56response from Bruce Go ahead promise that answer
- 1:22:58and I did answer it I said that plant -based
- 1:23:00serum is being looked at that is where we're
- 1:23:03headed is we're getting plant and most of the
- 1:23:05companies are that's all of their R &D is devoted
- 1:23:08to plant -based solution not the bovine fetal
- 1:23:11solution They're all looking at that. It's not
- 1:23:14the future. And I said that cancer research used
- 1:23:18bovine and all the cancer research, the organ
- 1:23:21transplant research was all using the bovine
- 1:23:23serum. And that's where we started to get the
- 1:23:25science and the ideas to be able to do this.
- 1:23:28But that's not where we're going. And none of
- 1:23:30these companies, they're all looking at plant
- 1:23:32-based only serums. So maybe you'll just answer
- 1:23:34that. Well, Leah, please finish what you were
- 1:23:37going to say. It's OK. Well, I would just say
- 1:23:39that I have been an angry activist for 20 years
- 1:23:45where I'm just beating my head. The industry
- 1:23:48sucks. They're not doing the right thing. It
- 1:23:52feels good. I think Renee, you said angry doesn't
- 1:23:56change them. We're not going to change anybody
- 1:24:00by being angry. We have to put ourselves in their
- 1:24:04shoes. We're not in charge of one animal, not
- 1:24:07one. Not one of us are in charge of those animals
- 1:24:10that Tyson are overseeing. So you have to put
- 1:24:12yourselves in Tyson's shoes and say, what's going
- 1:24:15to make them stop killing animals? Not like I'm
- 1:24:20angry they're killing them, I'm angry they're
- 1:24:21capitalist, we could have a whole debate. We're
- 1:24:23not actually debating capitalism here today.
- 1:24:25I'd love to do that debate, but that's not the
- 1:24:27one for today, so let's just put that aside.
- 1:24:31But you have to. This is my life, is trying to
- 1:24:35think about. How do we stop Tyson from wanting
- 1:24:37to slaughter animals? And it's not going to be
- 1:24:40me sitting in the room yelling at them about
- 1:24:43be ethical. Why aren't you ethical? It's not
- 1:24:46working. One more minute. OK, great. All right,
- 1:24:51so Bruce. Bruce and just about if you can in
- 1:25:00like three minutes Let us know about that the
- 1:25:04you know the bovine serum like I've heard chicken
- 1:25:07embryo extract all these animal Products that
- 1:25:11I have heard are being used in this process.
- 1:25:14What's up with that? Well, I'm not familiar with
- 1:25:16chicken embryo extracts But fetal bovine serum,
- 1:25:21I mean you can get a longer explanation of FBS
- 1:25:23by googling my name and FBS I have an article
- 1:25:26about why This is, as Leah said, this is therapeutics
- 1:25:30applied to food. You have to test every single
- 1:25:33batch of FBS. FBS inclusion is part of the reason
- 1:25:37that the life cycle analysis, the environmental
- 1:25:40assessments that Vas was talking about are bad,
- 1:25:45which if you read our white paper, it goes into
- 1:25:48why their extrapolations are not extrapolations.
- 1:25:52to a technology that actually works. So it's
- 1:25:55certainly possible that when they said clean
- 1:25:57meat isn't going to work, that's certainly possible.
- 1:25:59We don't know if it's going to be able to scale
- 1:26:01up. If it does scale up, it will be the exact
- 1:26:04same product, and it will cost less, which means
- 1:26:07that it'll be like insulin. Insulin is not used.
- 1:26:11It doesn't come from pigs anymore. It used to
- 1:26:13come from pigs. And we will just completely take
- 1:26:15away the idea that meat comes from animals. Multiple
- 1:26:19companies are not using FBS now. Just isn't using
- 1:26:22FBS. Memphis Meats isn't using FBS. FBS is Fetal
- 1:26:26Bovine Serum. Fetal Bovine Serum. And as Leah
- 1:26:29said, all the companies want to move away from
- 1:26:32it as quickly as possible. It won't be used at
- 1:26:34commercialization. Plant solution. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:26:37FBS is FBS. We can Google it. Sorry? I would
- 1:26:42like to know how we can actually get documentation
- 1:26:44of that statement you just made. I mean, you
- 1:26:46do have to believe the companies. So I mean,
- 1:26:49you have to believe Just, which is run by vegans,
- 1:26:52and Memphis, which is run by vegans. But if you
- 1:26:54look at my paper, you can see just for what Leah
- 1:26:58says, which is just that FBS is extremely expensive.
- 1:27:02And there's no way clean meat works if FBS is
- 1:27:05an ingredient. It's one of the reasons that the
- 1:27:07environmental assessments. are bad, because they're
- 1:27:11scaling up with this assumption that they're
- 1:27:12going to keep using FBS. FBS is not allowed in
- 1:27:16a lot of medical tissue engineering. It's absolutely
- 1:27:19not an essential ingredient. It just works really
- 1:27:21well for cell multiplication. So at bench scale,
- 1:27:25a lot of people in tissue engineering use it
- 1:27:27at bench scale. But when they're actually producing
- 1:27:29the products, they can't legally use it. It's
- 1:27:31not allowed. And because these companies are
- 1:27:33run by vegans, Multiple of them have stopped
- 1:27:36using it because they have an ethical objection
- 1:27:37to it. And then as Leah said, all of them, nobody's
- 1:27:41going to be using FBS when this stuff is being
- 1:27:43produced commercially. Okay, we weren't going
- 1:27:50to do questions to the audience, but it's Karen,
- 1:27:52so yes. Okay, as you know, billions of acres
- 1:28:01of land are used just to grow crops. to feed
- 1:28:04chickens and other industrially raised animals.
- 1:28:09And even compared to the heavily sprayed crops
- 1:28:13grown directly for human consumption apart from
- 1:28:16organic, these crops are very heavily sprayed,
- 1:28:21these millions and billions of acres in Brazil
- 1:28:23and the United States and everywhere else, with
- 1:28:26every type of pesticide, herbicide, fungicide,
- 1:28:30and you name it. What is the difference between
- 1:28:33growing all these crops and using all this cropland
- 1:28:38energy and the whole resource to feed actual
- 1:28:43living animals in the food industry versus feeding
- 1:28:48the cellular versions in the vats? They still
- 1:28:54have to be fed, right? The cells have to be fed.
- 1:28:59Could you address that? So, I mean, for people
- 1:29:05who want to dive into the technology of all of
- 1:29:08this, you go to gfi .org upslash essentials.
- 1:29:13There are lots of white papers and other things
- 1:29:15that you can read. The worst case scenario right
- 1:29:18now is that, so as probably most people in this
- 1:29:21room know, it takes nine calories fed to a chicken
- 1:29:24to get one calorie back out in the form of chicken
- 1:29:26flesh, according to the World Resources Institute.
- 1:29:29So that means nine times as much land, nine times
- 1:29:31as much water, nine times as much everything.
- 1:29:34Even with the current technology, without improving
- 1:29:37anything at all, it's three calories in for one
- 1:29:41calorie back out. So it's three times as efficient,
- 1:29:45so three times fewer. Even for chicken. The cell
- 1:29:48-based, yeah. Yeah, exactly. So relative to cattle,
- 1:29:55it's like 95 % to 99 % less land, even with no
- 1:29:59improvement on the current technology. It's like
- 1:30:02so much less land. So one of the critiques that
- 1:30:04we make of those environmental assessments is
- 1:30:07that it assumes that none of that land is repurposed
- 1:30:11in a positive way. for example, for clean energy.
- 1:30:14And this is one of the things that the Gates
- 1:30:15Foundation talks about when they talk about being
- 1:30:18enthusiastic about clean meat. But we do have
- 1:30:20a cost assessment paper in the clean meat section
- 1:30:23on gfi .org upslash essentials that sort of walks
- 1:30:26through media recycling. So nutrient recycling,
- 1:30:30which could make this more and more and more
- 1:30:32efficient. And obviously, because the companies
- 1:30:34are. profit motive driven, they have incentive
- 1:30:37to make it as efficient as possible. So it should
- 1:30:40get more and more and more efficient. So it's
- 1:30:43300 % more efficient than chicken, even more
- 1:30:45efficient relative to killing pigs and cattle.
- 1:30:50OK. OK. So believe it or not, we are four minutes
- 1:30:54away from where we need to give everyone their
- 1:30:56closing statements. And I have eight more questions
- 1:31:03I wanted to ask. Well, I have several questions.
- 1:31:07The FBS, if that's okay. Did you want to respond?
- 1:31:10Please. All right, let's give a couple of minutes
- 1:31:11to respond and then I want to get at least one
- 1:31:13more of my questions in. So the idea that there
- 1:31:18are no longer startup companies of in vitro meat
- 1:31:21which are using FBS is untrue. He is correct
- 1:31:25that Just Foods has stated that they have developed
- 1:31:29a plant -based growth medium which no longer
- 1:31:32uses FBS. They are also correct that Memphis
- 1:31:36Meat has claimed that they have developed one,
- 1:31:38but they haven't actually produced the product
- 1:31:42yet, so they don't have like, they haven't actually
- 1:31:44grown it, but they think they might have a medium.
- 1:31:47All the others do, for example, Finless Foods
- 1:31:50recently reassured us that they had decreased
- 1:31:52their use of FBS by 50%. Since they won't tell
- 1:31:56us how much FPS they used to use, they won't
- 1:31:59tell us how much FPS they currently use, and
- 1:32:01they won't tell us even what their new growth
- 1:32:03medium is, it's hard to be reassured. There are
- 1:32:07two other deeper points I'd make quickly. As
- 1:32:11vegans, we don't believe that it is okay to use
- 1:32:15animals and torture them and experiment them,
- 1:32:19even if there's a claim that it's going to help
- 1:32:21animals later. You heard the earlier talk. All
- 1:32:24animal experimentation makes this claim. If you
- 1:32:27go to any of the websites today, just look what's
- 1:32:31on the website. It says we're experimenting to
- 1:32:33help animals. So I don't think it's acceptable
- 1:32:37to be using FBS, even if the claim is later on,
- 1:32:40it might help animals. Who knows? We can't predict
- 1:32:44the future. I can tell you today those fetuses
- 1:32:47are being taken out and hurt. The second thing
- 1:32:50I would say, and this goes to how we can't predict
- 1:32:52the future, Look, I kind of like and trust the
- 1:32:55people in charge of Just. I kind of like and
- 1:32:58trust the people in charge of Memphis. But Tyson
- 1:33:00just invested in Memphis to an undisclosed amount
- 1:33:04of money. I don't like or trust Tyson. If FPS
- 1:33:08works, and Tyson has a virtually unlimited amount
- 1:33:12of FPS, once they own the startup, what's to
- 1:33:16stop them from using it even if a different plant
- 1:33:19-based alternative is there? There's a plant
- 1:33:21-based alternative to the meat already. So why
- 1:33:24wouldn't they just recycle their own cow blood,
- 1:33:27their own FBS? And then as activist, I already
- 1:33:31have the problem of trying to explain, here's
- 1:33:33a factory farm, what about humane meat? Here's
- 1:33:35humane meat. What's what's really going on? Now
- 1:33:37my burden in addition to that is to be like,
- 1:33:39well, there's clean meat. Well, this is the vegan
- 1:33:41clean meat, and this is the FBS being leaked.
- 1:33:44What's FBS? Final point. Why are you only hearing
- 1:33:48about FBS? Now. From me. Okay. So I feel like
- 1:34:01this is just so riveting and everyone is wanting
- 1:34:05more and feeling they want more. Yeah. So what
- 1:34:08I'm going to propose is that we maybe don't have
- 1:34:10the 10 minute break between... If that's okay,
- 1:34:14and it's got to go and go to the bathroom and
- 1:34:16get whatever do whatever you need to do But maybe
- 1:34:19not having the 10 -minute break and being able
- 1:34:20to take this into that 10 -minute break And then
- 1:34:22we'll just go right in to the larger question
- 1:34:25and answer and bring the other speakers on would
- 1:34:28that be Acceptable we continue this I feel like
- 1:34:30people are wanting that okay, and I just We we
- 1:34:37will we will have to break momentarily to bring
- 1:34:39the other speakers up yes, give me a minute Okay.
- 1:34:44All right. Yes. Well, I'm going to ask my question,
- 1:34:47I think. Okay? And I have a lot of questions,
- 1:34:51but I think this one is the one for me that is
- 1:34:55really, really important. And the thing that
- 1:34:58I keep coming back to with all this, the thing
- 1:35:01that is my biggest concern, I would say, and
- 1:35:06that is that basically this technology Could
- 1:35:13could potentially just you know it certainly
- 1:35:16continues the commodification of farmed animals
- 1:35:19Okay, and you can okay, so does it let me rephrase
- 1:35:25my I'll ask the question Does it continue the
- 1:35:29commodification of farmed animals? the concern
- 1:35:32that You know is this going to hinder the concept
- 1:35:36of animal liberation creating a status? You know,
- 1:35:41the status that animals have a fundamental right
- 1:35:44to live free of human commodification and exploitation,
- 1:35:48i .e. animal rights. Does this reinforce the
- 1:35:52fundamental paradigms of oppression and domination
- 1:35:54that animals are just here for our use? It's
- 1:35:58still meat. So will this help to dismantle speciesism?
- 1:36:03That's the part that I keep coming back to. And
- 1:36:06if we don't establish these concepts, is there
- 1:36:09potential for exploitation in the future? And
- 1:36:12I'll just conclude with a quote. I wrote, I read,
- 1:36:16I didn't write it, I wrote, I read, sorry. Geez.
- 1:36:20I read a really wonderful book recently called
- 1:36:23The End to Animal Farming by J .C. Reese. And
- 1:36:26J .C. is, yeah, it's a great book. And he is
- 1:36:30very pro -cell -based meat. and has an entire
- 1:36:33chapter promoting cell -based meat, getting excited
- 1:36:38about cell -based meat. But at the end of this
- 1:36:41chapter, he had this quote. If society does end
- 1:36:46animal farming with technology for the sake of
- 1:36:48efficiency alone, but fails to develop compassion
- 1:36:52for farmed animals and other sentient beings,
- 1:36:54then our descendants might inflict similar abuses
- 1:36:58in the future comparable to factory farming.
- 1:37:00Such tragedies could be even greater in scale
- 1:37:03as future humans will likely have greater technological
- 1:37:06capacity. So I think what I'm talking about is
- 1:37:10that we need to have an underlying end of speciesism
- 1:37:20Not just another meat product Okay, so yeah and
- 1:37:28I You guys have been though. I think I'm gonna
- 1:37:30let this side start and then you can respond
- 1:37:33how much time oh I don't know how about four
- 1:37:37minutes. Okay. Thank you So Leah you said we're
- 1:37:41not here debating capitalism, and I disagree
- 1:37:43I mean the whole thing everything is going on
- 1:37:45within the matrix of capitalism the same people
- 1:37:48who brought us colonialism slavery to great world
- 1:37:51wars and as I said the destruction of all animals
- 1:37:54on earth and also by the way factory farming
- 1:37:56and etc etc That's the context and so yes of
- 1:37:59course. This is going to preserve the commodification
- 1:38:01of animals now Yeah, I can't say anything about
- 1:38:06the character of the person who's running Just
- 1:38:08Foods. Let's say he's a great guy. Well, I don't
- 1:38:10know who started Field Rose, but weren't they
- 1:38:12great people? And what about Ben and Jerry's?
- 1:38:15Well, they're taken over by Unilever. That's
- 1:38:17the problem with the capitalist system. You have
- 1:38:18to look at this as a structural organism. So
- 1:38:21I don't buy Ben and Jerry's vegan ice cream because
- 1:38:25I'm then supporting their exploitation of cows.
- 1:38:27All that money goes into one coffer. And has
- 1:38:30the alternative, has the growth of the vegan
- 1:38:33ice cream at Ben and Jerry's hurt their dairy
- 1:38:37Ben and Jerry's? No, it's just absurd. And so
- 1:38:41I don't think we're picking nits here. I think
- 1:38:43these are very profound economic, social, political
- 1:38:47issues that are at stake. And again, so I agree
- 1:38:51with, or not to agree with you, but I. I think
- 1:38:54the answer to your question is yes, that the
- 1:38:56commodification of animals will continue and
- 1:38:58this doesn't touch speciesism. Now, if it was
- 1:39:00the case that the people running the show were
- 1:39:03going around showing people what animal suffering
- 1:39:06is like, explaining what speciesism is, explaining
- 1:39:08how it ties into aquaria and zoos and laboratory
- 1:39:11experimentation and structural violence against
- 1:39:14animals in the transportation industry, the destruction
- 1:39:17of all ecosystems, all the freshwater systems
- 1:39:20just being destroyed. You know what I'm saying?
- 1:39:22If the public was being educated, their consciousness
- 1:39:24was being raised about what speciesism is as
- 1:39:27a mode of production of human life, then I could
- 1:39:30perhaps get on board with this. But that's not
- 1:39:33how the messaging is going. to work. And you
- 1:39:35can bet that Cargill and all these other companies
- 1:39:37who end up buying out just in five years when
- 1:39:40they have their IPO. And you bet. When I said
- 1:39:43it's not going to work, it is going to work probably
- 1:39:45as a technical matter, but it's not going to
- 1:39:47work in terms of replacing animals. That's my
- 1:39:49concern. So you can bet that when Cargill takes
- 1:39:52over Just in a few years, they'll sell it on
- 1:39:55the sustainability grounds, whether it's sustainable
- 1:39:57or not, just as they now claim. Smithfield claims
- 1:40:00to be the leader in animal care. Did you know
- 1:40:03that? Smithfield claims to be the leader in animal
- 1:40:06care. And you find these same claims by Tyson
- 1:40:08and Perdue and all of them. That's capitalism.
- 1:40:12So it just seems to me it just seems to me that
- 1:40:16that I don't think we're just being like angry,
- 1:40:18you know cranks to say look whoa Look at the
- 1:40:22history of this process and look at how the stuff
- 1:40:25is being marketed now It's a real problem. And
- 1:40:28and again, it's just gonna we have is Vasili
- 1:40:30said we have so many fantastic delicious sustainable
- 1:40:33Alternatives to animal products. We don't need
- 1:40:36synthetic meat and why don't you get Bill Gates
- 1:40:39to just promote veganism, for God's sakes, right?
- 1:40:49Okay, sure. My turn? Yes. How long do I have?
- 1:40:55Three minutes. I get less than him? Four minutes.
- 1:40:59There's just so little time. It's alright, it's
- 1:41:03been happening. Just on the commodification point,
- 1:41:08I think everybody knows that Mercy for Animals
- 1:41:11doesn't actually work on cell -based meat. We're
- 1:41:14not out there as entrepreneurs trying to create
- 1:41:17it. We're an animal rights organization, and
- 1:41:19we are out there protesting in front of McDonald's,
- 1:41:22and we're doing undercover investigations. To
- 1:41:26be really clear, we're not saying stop doing
- 1:41:29those things. We're not saying stop being activists
- 1:41:33and arguing. to take apart and look at this speciesism
- 1:41:39issue. And these companies are not being, these
- 1:41:43are not just coming out of nowhere. Nothing exists
- 1:41:46in a vacuum. These technologies are not existing
- 1:41:49or being created in a vacuum. They're being created
- 1:41:51because of pressure. Pressure that activists
- 1:41:54are creating, pressure the environment is creating,
- 1:41:57pressure human population is creating, and we're
- 1:41:59gonna keep doing that. I think that it's, It's
- 1:42:03fundamentally important that we don't throw out
- 1:42:05any possible solution right now when especially
- 1:42:08when as Bruce said the first company was created
- 1:42:10in 2015 It's really soon. It's really early and
- 1:42:16Just keep in mind what I said before There's
- 1:42:19only five to six percent vegetarians right now
- 1:42:22in the United States and hasn't changed for 20
- 1:42:24years and every day more animals are being killed
- 1:42:26so you know I we have to be careful as people
- 1:42:30who care so much about this, that we just, we
- 1:42:33don't live in our bubble, and we don't continue
- 1:42:36to just think, we're just gonna be, stand on
- 1:42:38our principles, and we're just gonna be angry
- 1:42:40about this, just think if you were in the room
- 1:42:44with Tyson, and you had the chance to talk to
- 1:42:48them, and this was your one shot, really, put
- 1:42:51yourself in their shoes, and what would convince
- 1:42:54Tyson executives to change? Just think about
- 1:42:58that. Right and Right now it's not working what
- 1:43:05we've been doing and we've got to invite other
- 1:43:08opportunities We've really got to try to invite
- 1:43:12other opportunities so yes They're investing
- 1:43:14in plant -based, and that's great, and we're
- 1:43:15doing that too, but why would we throw out this
- 1:43:17option as well? And I think that I'll just close
- 1:43:20by saying it's not about do we like it, but does
- 1:43:23it work? What will work what will stop animals
- 1:43:28from being slaughtered and that's what we have
- 1:43:29to remember Do you want to continue? Because
- 1:43:35there's still four minute. I mean, you've got
- 1:43:38some time. One minute and a little. I mean, I
- 1:43:42really do think, I mean, obviously all of us
- 1:43:45resonate not with the phrase not clean meat,
- 1:43:49but no meat. Obviously all of us would like to
- 1:43:51see Bill Gates go vegan as a solution. A lot
- 1:43:55of people in this room would probably like to
- 1:43:57see capitalism fall. But if if what we have to
- 1:44:03do is convince Bill Gates to go vegan and capitalism
- 1:44:06to fall in Order to be successful. I mean, I
- 1:44:09guess you know sort of like what Leah just said
- 1:44:11framed a slightly different way Why can't we
- 1:44:15create clean meat and do whatever work we want
- 1:44:19to do to convince Bill Gates to go vegan? And
- 1:44:22to work against capitalism if this is successful
- 1:44:25and John just said he thinks it'll be technically
- 1:44:27successful Because it's so much more efficient
- 1:44:30than the current method of making meat, it will
- 1:44:34be extremely profitable. And it will take us
- 1:44:37from nine billion animals per year, just land
- 1:44:39animals per year in the United States, to very
- 1:44:42close to zero. It'll take us from tens of billions
- 1:44:45to very close to zero animals exploited because
- 1:44:49all of the profit motive goes in this direction.
- 1:44:53So I haven't heard anything from the other side.
- 1:44:56I mean, I haven't heard them attempt to argue
- 1:44:58that what we're doing now is working. Like we
- 1:45:01need to crush capitalism and we need to convince
- 1:45:03Bill Gates to go vegan. Both of those things
- 1:45:07seem unlikely to me, but you can work for both
- 1:45:10of those things while you also try to convince
- 1:45:13Tyson and Cargill and the entire meat industry
- 1:45:15to put its business acumen in this direction
- 1:45:19instead of the other direction. On the precise
- 1:45:22question that you asked, Tobias Leinhardt wrote
- 1:45:25a book called How to Create a Vegan World. It's
- 1:45:28a really good book. And in his book, How to Create
- 1:45:31a Vegan World, one of the things he points out
- 1:45:34is that it really is. I mean, if you look at
- 1:45:36the faunalytics study, it's not 6 % vegetarian
- 1:45:39in the US, it's 2 % vegetarian. It's probably
- 1:45:41about a half a percent vegan in the United States.
- 1:45:45And one of the things that he says is inhibiting
- 1:45:47animal liberation is the fact that 98 % or 94
- 1:45:51% or 96 % of people, when they sit down to eat,
- 1:45:55they're literally dining on the corpses of tortured
- 1:45:57animals. which makes the cognitive dissonance
- 1:46:00over the moon. If we can remove the idea that
- 1:46:04meat comes from an animal, if we can grow meat
- 1:46:07directly from cells, much like insulin no longer
- 1:46:09comes from animals, if we can do that, we can
- 1:46:12open people up to the idea of animals as individuals.
- 1:46:16They all feel pain in the same way and to the
- 1:46:18same degree that we do. They're all made of flesh
- 1:46:20and blood and bone, just like we are. The argument
- 1:46:23is overwhelming for animal liberation, but because
- 1:46:27people eat the tortured corpses of animals, a
- 1:46:29lot of people aren't able to hear it. This is
- 1:46:31the solution to that as well too. This gets us
- 1:46:34closer to animal liberation. All right. Okay.
- 1:46:41So if we do want to do five minute closing statements
- 1:46:44per speaker, we'd need to start that now. Is
- 1:46:47that what we want to do? How do your side feel?
- 1:47:01okay well I okay I want we're gonna open up to
- 1:47:06the to the audience questions when we bring the
- 1:47:09other speakers on this was gonna be for I've
- 1:47:12done a great deal of research on this and I was
- 1:47:14I do I I did and I mean it's you know And it's
- 1:47:23interesting because I got all of everyone's questions
- 1:47:25that were written down. That's why I had people
- 1:47:28write the questions. And almost every single
- 1:47:30thing that people said, I had in my questions.
- 1:47:34So I was going to get to everybody's stuff. But
- 1:47:38anyway, let's go with one more question then.
- 1:47:42And then maybe we'll see where we are. And John
- 1:47:45can give a closing statement, but I feel that.
- 1:47:47You guys should as well be able to if you want.
- 1:47:50Anyway, we'll see what happens. Okay. Another
- 1:47:54question that I had is, I could really see the
- 1:48:00meat advertisers really just having a field day
- 1:48:04with this, a backlash like, well, this is real
- 1:48:09meat, the actual slaughtered animals. Because
- 1:48:13right now, the tendency in the trend in food
- 1:48:19production and food marketing is natural, is
- 1:48:22know your farmer and farmers markets and non
- 1:48:26-GMO and even Triscuit has the non -GMO commercials.
- 1:48:31So that's very much what the trend is in branding
- 1:48:35of food right now is natural. So I feel like
- 1:48:40there's a possibility. Is there the possibility,
- 1:48:44let me rephrase that, is there the possibility
- 1:48:46that the meat industry could say, well, but this
- 1:48:52is real meat. We slaughtered it. It's real meat.
- 1:48:56And that could actually increase possibly. Could
- 1:48:59it increase meat consumption? Because people
- 1:49:05want the real thing. People I mean it really
- 1:49:18is the case if you read the literature people
- 1:49:20make their dining decisions on the basis of price
- 1:49:22taste and convenience like everybody does This
- 1:49:24is going to be less expensive. It's not going
- 1:49:27to have the foodborne pathogens. It's not going
- 1:49:29to have the drug residues And it's not going
- 1:49:32to involve animal slaughter I mean 47 % of people
- 1:49:34want to ban animal slaughter like people are
- 1:49:36not eating meat because it's slaughtered when
- 1:49:38you have a safer product that costs less I mean
- 1:49:41it you know I think it's not inconceivable, but
- 1:49:44it strikes me as horribly unlikely In vitro meat
- 1:49:51absolutely will not prevent the CAFO system.
- 1:49:56I spend most of my time Yeah Sorry, I will not
- 1:50:01prevent the confined animal feeding operations
- 1:50:03will not eat in the factory farm system So you
- 1:50:06talked about not being in the vegan bubble. I
- 1:50:08absolutely agree I spend most of my time in research,
- 1:50:11not reading vegan blogs, but reading the write
- 1:50:14-ups of the industry publications. You can register
- 1:50:17for all of them. I think you should. Like Food
- 1:50:20Link, you know, even going to the conferences.
- 1:50:23There's one in Texas right now. And so the, what
- 1:50:27you heard at the beginning is that the meat industry
- 1:50:30is trying to stop it from being labeled as meat.
- 1:50:33That isn't, well, that's half -flee correct.
- 1:50:35So the people who produce the meat, We like to
- 1:50:38think as vegans monolithically of the meat industry,
- 1:50:40but there's two factors. So the people raising
- 1:50:42the animals are like, hey, we want to not call
- 1:50:46in vitro meat meat. But the people who process
- 1:50:49the animals, Tyson, Cargill, Purdue, they definitely
- 1:50:54want it to be labeled meat. And they're the ones
- 1:50:56who are actively investing in the technology.
- 1:51:00Now, as you can imagine, hey, Why are you investing
- 1:51:04in something that's going to hurt our bottom
- 1:51:06line is not an unasked question. My three points
- 1:51:10of how the factory farm industry is going to
- 1:51:12be helped from in vitro meat is not something
- 1:51:15I came up with, but is in essence, in different
- 1:51:18language, what they are telling their own suppliers.
- 1:51:22And they are telling their own suppliers not
- 1:51:25that we are disrupting the industry, but that
- 1:51:27we are going to sell more meat than ever before.
- 1:51:30What they are telling them is that we have this
- 1:51:32huge demand. We can't meet all of the demand
- 1:51:35globally because we're literally running out
- 1:51:37of room. So we're going to keep the factory farms
- 1:51:40and we're going to add in vitro meat. That's
- 1:51:43not going to replace the factory farms. Remember
- 1:51:45the earlier presentation that both of them did
- 1:51:47about the growth? How is that getting rid of
- 1:51:49factory farms? Can you think of one, take your
- 1:51:52time, one industry that's gotten rid of itself?
- 1:51:57So the second thing they're saying, That no one
- 1:52:00has bothered to respond to is they respond to
- 1:52:04it as a blended product That's their term not
- 1:52:07my term a blended product There's something that
- 1:52:11we call the Jensen paradox and what that means
- 1:52:15is something you think will decrease supply or
- 1:52:18demand actually increases it So let me give you
- 1:52:21an example of the Jensen paradox in real life
- 1:52:24Bottled water look at any bottle water product
- 1:52:28and it will have some kind of label claiming
- 1:52:31that it's like 50 % recycled or the one that
- 1:52:35Coke uses, that they have plants blended in with
- 1:52:39the plastic. The result of that has not been
- 1:52:43to decrease the use of plastic or bottled water.
- 1:52:48The result, because it's blended and can be marketed,
- 1:52:51has been to increase the use of bottled water.
- 1:52:54That's what's going to happen with in vitro meat.
- 1:52:57when the companies that own it start blending
- 1:53:00it together. 30 seconds. It's going to make your
- 1:53:03activism, my activism that much harder. Okay.
- 1:53:12So we have to wrap this up now. But hang on.
- 1:53:18Rest assured. What I think I'm going to do now
- 1:53:21is we're going to give five minutes for closing
- 1:53:24statements and you can divide that any way you
- 1:53:26want. Five minutes for closing statements. You
- 1:53:29can divide that any way you want. And then we're
- 1:53:32going to then bring a couple more chairs. We're
- 1:53:35going to invite Renee, Joanne, and Karen up here.
- 1:53:38And I'm going to run around there for an hour
- 1:53:40and answer all your questions. And you are welcome
- 1:53:44to continue asking about cell -based meat. And
- 1:53:47in fact, I know that Joanne knows a great deal
- 1:53:50about it. She is actually on the this side. And
- 1:53:53Renee. as well supports cell -based meat. So
- 1:53:56we'll put her over here. Maybe they have something
- 1:53:59they'd like to say about it as well. So we could
- 1:54:01continue this if we want, or we can go in a completely
- 1:54:03different direction. But we're going to have
- 1:54:04to wrap this part of it up. So five minutes over
- 1:54:07here. I mean, I think probably Leah and I have
- 1:54:11said most of what we want to say. I just want
- 1:54:13to respond to the last point. And that is I read
- 1:54:17all of the industry publications. They talk about
- 1:54:20blended products. But when they're talking about
- 1:54:21blended products, they're talking about plant
- 1:54:23-based. with meat. I've certainly never seen
- 1:54:26anybody talking about cell -based blend, I don't
- 1:54:28think. And it really does defy capitalism. I
- 1:54:31mean, if this works and you're producing the
- 1:54:34exact same thing, and you can produce it in one
- 1:54:36way that makes you more money, and another way
- 1:54:40that makes you less money, why would you blend
- 1:54:42those things together? You wouldn't. You would
- 1:54:44go exclusively with the thing that makes you
- 1:54:47more money. And that's cell -based meat. which
- 1:54:50is the more efficient product, so it will be
- 1:54:52the more profitable product, and it really will
- 1:54:55be like insulin. I mean, I guess some people
- 1:54:57still have landlines, but the vast majority of
- 1:55:00communication is on cell phones and text message,
- 1:55:03which are more efficient and didn't used to exist.
- 1:55:06Some people may still have film -based cameras,
- 1:55:08but the vast majority of photos are taken on
- 1:55:10our cell phones because it's easier and it's
- 1:55:13more efficient and it's just simpler. When we
- 1:55:17shift from producing meat, in CAFOs to producing
- 1:55:21meat in this other better way. The reason the
- 1:55:23meat industry is investing is that it's going
- 1:55:25to be more profitable and it will completely
- 1:55:28replace the vast majority of animal product production,
- 1:55:33just like 100 % of insulin is now synthetic.
- 1:55:39Okay. Again, I think, like Bruce, I've said most
- 1:55:43of what I want to say. I think my main... Thought
- 1:55:47I want you to go away with is what works. What
- 1:55:51will work. And that's what really matters. And
- 1:55:54sometimes we have to put aside our comfort zone
- 1:55:57for that. And that's a big theme for me, is us
- 1:56:00moving into our discomfort zone. And I've had
- 1:56:03to do that, where I've had to sit down with a
- 1:56:06factory farmer and understand, how did he get
- 1:56:08there? Why is he doing that? Or Renee. is a rancher
- 1:56:11who used to slaughter animals and she had to
- 1:56:14move into her discomfort zone, confront her husband.
- 1:56:16We have to think about it from the other perspective
- 1:56:19because in my view, it's not about winning over
- 1:56:25them, it's about winning them over. How do we
- 1:56:28win the world over? And we have to keep that
- 1:56:32at the forefront of our minds because we're up
- 1:56:34against it. We're up against 10 billion people
- 1:56:38wanting more and more and more and more and more
- 1:56:40and that has to be at the forefront of our mind
- 1:56:43So I ask you to think about that. What will work
- 1:56:47what will work? All right five minutes on the
- 1:56:55other side Wow so We we have a lot to talk about
- 1:57:06still right there. There's I do want to say one
- 1:57:08thing which is there's a there's a flavor to
- 1:57:10this of snatching defeat from the jaws of victory
- 1:57:14To some extent which is to say I and I understand
- 1:57:18that veganism is hardly taking off However, according
- 1:57:20to the Good Food Institute itself Plant -based
- 1:57:24alternatives alternatives to animal based foods
- 1:57:27grew 17 % over the previous year Overall sales
- 1:57:33of vegan items in the U .S. rose 20 % from 2017
- 1:57:38to the middle of 2018. And although, yes, there's
- 1:57:41a flaw in the study, between 2014 and 2017, the
- 1:57:48number of U .S. consumers identifying as vegan
- 1:57:50grew 600 % from 1 % to 6%. Now, whatever the
- 1:57:56flaws are, you know, there's everything. Pretty
- 1:58:00much everything that you folks have said about
- 1:58:03shifting to an alternative to the system could
- 1:58:08be applied to promoting, marketing plant -based
- 1:58:12things. If you want to emphasize, as you have,
- 1:58:18Bruce, price, taste, and convenience, you say
- 1:58:20that's the reason why consumers buy things. Well,
- 1:58:23there is a big assumption here that this new
- 1:58:26technology, first of all, is going to be exactly
- 1:58:29the same in taste, or better, or maybe it won't
- 1:58:33be, whether the pricing is going to be the same.
- 1:58:36But I would caution you all, look at what happened
- 1:58:38to humane meat, right? This is basically a boutique
- 1:58:44product that yuppies buy in the cities mostly.
- 1:58:47It's been the most explosively profitable sector
- 1:58:50of the meat industry, humane meat. It's just
- 1:58:53gone through the roof. And has it improved the
- 1:58:56welfare of animals? No. cut down on the number
- 1:58:59of animals being killed? No. I just want to say
- 1:59:02that we are not, this is not a contradiction
- 1:59:05between the moral purists over here and the pragmatists
- 1:59:08over there. We are arguing, at least I think
- 1:59:10we're arguing, that it isn't going to work. It
- 1:59:13isn't going to work for the reasons we've said,
- 1:59:16that it's by strengthening meat, the idea of
- 1:59:18meat is something we must always have, it is
- 1:59:20going to keep this whole system going. And yes,
- 1:59:24millions of people will buy these new products.
- 1:59:27But the same people who you know own the the
- 1:59:31animal Commodities living ones will continue
- 1:59:34to do that too, and we aren't in charge of that
- 1:59:37so basically we're going to have to entrust The
- 1:59:40fate of the animals to this I want to read a
- 1:59:42poem briefly by it's very short by Langston Hughes
- 1:59:46It's called dreams because I think we can all
- 1:59:48agree on this hold fast to dreams For if dreams
- 1:59:53die life is a broken winged bird that cannot
- 1:59:55fly Hold fast to dreams for when dreams go life
- 2:00:00is a barren field frozen with snow When Bruce
- 2:00:07was interviewed by Ezra Klein Ezra Klein the
- 2:00:12interviewer said there's a tendency to make this
- 2:00:14a moral crusade But increasingly it seems to
- 2:00:17me that if there's going to be an answer to this
- 2:00:19it'll be Technological and I think that sums
- 2:00:22up what we're hearing here, and I I just don't
- 2:00:24believe it And I think even if you find this
- 2:00:27a very attractive glittering new thing, please
- 2:00:30be very skeptical of how it's going to end up
- 2:00:34and consider the fact that it isn't going to
- 2:00:36be in our hands. It's going to be in the hands
- 2:00:39of these incredibly powerful billion dollar corporations.
- 2:00:43And so whether we end up with, because there's
- 2:00:46been some equivocation here, zero. animals being
- 2:00:49used or as Bruce just said, a substantially reduced
- 2:00:52number of animals being used or maybe because
- 2:00:55of Jensen's paradox, meat consumption with population
- 2:00:58growth will go up and then the clean meat will
- 2:01:02replace a certain percentage of the live animals
- 2:01:05and maybe in 10 years we'll still have 50 billion
- 2:01:08land animals being killed. It's just that there'll
- 2:01:11be much more meat and people will also be eating
- 2:01:13the so -called clean meat. One minute. Sorry.
- 2:01:17Can I take up all your time? I'll be, I'll be,
- 2:01:21I think I love what you said. I'll be very quick.
- 2:01:23I want to leave you with one final simple truth.
- 2:01:27We are not going to defeat speciesism with speciesism.
- 2:01:32We are not going to convince people that animals
- 2:01:36should not be treated like machines by trying
- 2:01:39to align with their biases and try to make animals
- 2:01:43more like machines. I can't think of a single
- 2:01:47social justice movement that has ever worked
- 2:01:50by abandoning its principles. And I don't think
- 2:01:54we should start now. Thank you. Again, thank
- 2:02:11you so much for caring, and I will see you next
- 2:02:14Tuesday for a new episode.