Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Constraints Breed Creativity | Liam Nelson | FS-019
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers. Communicating the information
- 0:07superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps and off ramps.
- 0:11Bitcoin is worthless, artificial.
- 0:14Gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:29which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing
- 0:41the role of gun. The one thing that's missing
- 0:44that that will soon be developed is a reliable E cash.
- 0:51All righty. Welcome back to Final settlement
- 0:54everyone. Today is Wednesday, January
- 0:5829th, 2025. I'm joined by my Co hosts Plural
- 1:04Now, Michael Tanguma and Liam Nelson, who we'll we'll get to
- 1:09in a minute. Lots to get to before.
- 1:11Before we get started, just some brief housekeeping.
- 1:14As we mentioned a couple weeks ago, sort of a new format for
- 1:17the show still going to be sort of every other week cadence.
- 1:21And one of those episodes is going to be sort of this
- 1:25internal group of folks across on ramp and early riders and
- 1:30really just talking sort of inside baseball, what we're
- 1:32seeing in the markets, topical news items etcetera.
- 1:36And then the other one on sort of a monthly basis will be an
- 1:39external guest coming in and and riffing with the three of us.
- 1:42So that's sort of the general new format going forward and
- 1:46lots to get to this week. Lots of new in the news from all
- 1:51of Trump's executive orders over the past couple weeks to, you
- 1:55know, Chinese open source AAI models sort of adding some
- 2:00turbulence to U.S. equity markets this week.
- 2:02We'll get into that. But lots of topics on the list.
- 2:06Before we do that, do you want to just introduce the new member
- 2:10of our team and and Co host of this pod, Liam Nelson?
- 2:13Liam is is joining us from a career in traditional finance,
- 2:17much, much similar to myself. He's finally made the jump out
- 2:21of the Fiat world into the Bitcoin ecosystem.
- 2:24And so we're very excited for him to to be doing so.
- 2:26But Liam, maybe if you want to give the audience a little bit
- 2:28more on what your background is, what what you've worked on and
- 2:32and how you came to Bitcoin and and ultimately early riders.
- 2:35Yeah, pleasure to be here. My name is Liam.
- 2:38I originally started off my career previous to that I was a
- 2:42finance major and then made the jump to .72 long short hedge
- 2:46fund based here in New York. While I was there for a little
- 2:50bit over three years understood pretty much how businesses and
- 2:54industries worked in the impact of the performing businesses on
- 2:59the financial markets. After that I made the jump to
- 3:03family office private equity firm focused on corporate carve
- 3:05outs and during my time there and previously at .72 ultimately
- 3:11found Bitcoin. My journey into Bitcoin was
- 3:15fairly similar to many others, even even those who came way
- 3:19before me. I always think of Adam Back who
- 3:23originally created the precursor to Shaw 256 hashing algorithm,
- 3:28which is used in Bitcoins proof of work and how he originally
- 3:31dismissed Bitcoin because it was too small, skeptical that would
- 3:36work, etcetera. I honestly was fairly similar to
- 3:41that as well, but similar to him, once Bitcoin started to
- 3:44gain some additional traction and the best marketing for
- 3:48Bitcoin is the price increases, I had to get curious, especially
- 3:51when I found out that it had best risk, risk adjusted returns
- 3:55of any asset. So from there, I ultimately did
- 4:00a lot of research, found that I think that this is going to be
- 4:04the end. It will end up as the world
- 4:07reserve asset and final settlement asset to use by
- 4:10pretty much everybody that is self interested.
- 4:14And then after that, I found early writers and you guys
- 4:19through the white paper originally definitely resonated
- 4:23with me that Bitcoin is the hurdle rate.
- 4:25And just because I started to price all of my decisions off of
- 4:32the marginal utility of more Bitcoin and ultimately thought
- 4:37that there was a lot of infrastructure for Bitcoin that
- 4:40needed to be built out. And building it out in a way
- 4:43where you consider the opportunity cost of having more
- 4:46Bitcoin is extremely interesting to me.
- 4:49And so trying to build businesses with capital
- 4:53constraints and while still benefiting from the upside of
- 4:58Bitcoin adoption and how and the higher prices was really
- 5:02interesting to me and resonated. So that's ultimately how I found
- 5:06you guys and why I made the joint jump to.
- 5:08Early riders. So appreciate you sharing that
- 5:12and we're excited to have you. I think a lot of your joining
- 5:14plays into the thesis of the best individuals that work in
- 5:18the traditional markets, whether it's on traditional finance.
- 5:21Tech companies across different professions ultimately will not
- 5:25only get Bitcoin, but then really get that business
- 5:28building and capital formation will fundamentally be different.
- 5:32And then they'll start to rethink that from the ground up.
- 5:36And so it was interesting like last week, Chase, the CEO
- 5:40Acropolis had a tweet about reaching out and following,
- 5:44following us and then reaching out, being interested in what we
- 5:46were building. And you know, now he's leading
- 5:48one of the portfolio companies. And I think it's an important
- 5:51thing to call out because the only way you can rebuild a lot
- 5:54of this structure is really to have the world class individuals
- 5:59join and that can see the vision because there's no shortage of
- 6:02things to rebuild. And the whole thesis has really
- 6:06been that the existing 15 years of Bitcoin, well, there's been a
- 6:08lot of infrastructure. It's been more of a nascent like
- 6:12tinkerer type industry. There's been a lot of
- 6:14individuals telling everyone that you're just going to have
- 6:17to go and, you know, put plastic devices in caves and, you know,
- 6:20have fun staying poor and just figure it out.
- 6:23And, you know, the reality is like, it's just such a big
- 6:27problem as we go into this next wave of adoption.
- 6:29We've seen, you know, past two weeks, I feel like there's been
- 6:32no shortage of mishaps all the way to somebody getting their
- 6:37family, their family, getting their their fingers, you know,
- 6:39mailed to them after kidnapping. And that is really going to take
- 6:44individuals to understand where this market goes and how do you
- 6:46commercialize products and how do you build for mass appeal.
- 6:49We'll also stay still retaining the underlying ethos, whether
- 6:52it's the protocol, we think well, like multi sig and what
- 6:54honor it's doing. But then also when you think
- 6:56about capital formation and building that companies don't
- 6:59need millions and millions of dollars to build certain things.
- 7:02And the investment funds certainly don't need 10s and
- 7:05hundreds of millions of dollars. Because it may seem good at
- 7:09first, But then when you go and look back, you're going to
- 7:11benchmark all those dollars that people were allowed about
- 7:14against Bitcoin. And when those prices are
- 7:16deployed and you're going to get to really back into, can you
- 7:18actually outperform, you know, that price?
- 7:21You think about the billion dollar funds, they're definitely
- 7:23never returning them on a Bitcoin.
- 7:24But I would make the case that even if you've expended hundreds
- 7:27of millions of dollars and you earmark that against Bitcoin,
- 7:30you're going to have a very tough, nearly impossible rate of
- 7:33having to return that capital. And so that's really what ties
- 7:36into what we're building here. And then your recognition that
- 7:40it was ambitious, but also it's ultimately the end state, right?
- 7:44It's like Bitcoin being money is ambitious, but we all know
- 7:46that's kind of the inevitability.
- 7:48As long as the asset stays alive, in the same way as as
- 7:51long as the asset stays alive, the only reason people are going
- 7:53to give it up is if you can give them a form of yield on that.
- 7:56But it has to be yield. It has to be yielded in
- 7:59providing real value in the real world.
- 8:02Yeah, it's, it's something I, I've been thinking a lot about
- 8:05recently, is this idea of yield. And, you know, it feels like
- 8:10every bull market there are, there's increased demand for
- 8:12people wanting to borrow against their Bitcoin, obviously.
- 8:16And you know, the sort of core underlying theme of everything
- 8:20that we've been doing at early riders is like, effectively
- 8:23there's a different form of yield in my mind that is, you
- 8:26know, actually just going out into the real world and
- 8:28producing value. And then with that, you know,
- 8:32accumulating more Bitcoin over time.
- 8:34Like, so how do you get a yield on your Bitcoin?
- 8:36It's not just by levering it up. Yes, that's one way to do it,
- 8:40but in our minds, the the real Bitcoin yield is is going and
- 8:44deploying that Bitcoin into the real world to produce value to
- 8:47accumulate more incremental Bitcoin like that is a a pure
- 8:50form of a Bitcoin yield in my mind.
- 8:52But just going back to to Liam joining, we're very happy to
- 8:56have him and you know, he credit to him.
- 8:59He saw the vision early when he read the the white paper of ours
- 9:05and also just put in the proof of work to start working on
- 9:08these ideas with us and thinking through things in a really
- 9:11analytical manner. So very happy to to have him
- 9:14officially on board now. And before we jump into the list
- 9:17of things, I I do have a question for you, Liam, just
- 9:20because you are you're now the closest to having left stratify
- 9:25world. I'm a few years removed now.
- 9:27So I'm curious like as you are leaving, what is the sort of
- 9:32what's the, what's in the air at the Tradfi firms, the point 70
- 9:35twos of the world, the private equity funds of the world, how
- 9:38are they thinking about Bitcoin? Is it being talked about more?
- 9:41When you told your former employer you were leaving to go
- 9:43do something Bitcoin related, did they think you were insane?
- 9:46What is what is the general zeitgeist in Tradfi world right
- 9:49now with respect to Bitcoin? Yeah, I think it was a mixed
- 9:52opinion depending on who you asked.
- 9:55Definitely got some responses that everything in Bitcoin is
- 9:59fraud, which is which is fine. You know people, people if if
- 10:05you're making money and you are doing extremely well in your
- 10:09current position, like there's no reason to spend a lot of time
- 10:12to understand why Bitcoin is different right?
- 10:15I just tried to understand it at a deep level because I thought
- 10:19it had the best risk adjusted returns and that was really
- 10:23interesting to me. I think more and more people are
- 10:26trying to understand what exactly is interesting about
- 10:30Bitcoin at the moment just because it's gone up so much.
- 10:33So there are people that I think really want to do the work and,
- 10:38and think this is interesting and, but are scared to
- 10:42financially be involved just because they think they can,
- 10:45they should get in at a better price or they've missed the
- 10:47boat. But there are also people that
- 10:50are very, very skeptical still. So still think there's a bit to
- 10:54do on the educational front and people ultimately will come when
- 10:58they're ready. I mean, on that thread, it's a,
- 11:01it's a great one to start with, Brian, is how do you see the
- 11:05role of altcoins versus Bitcoin? Because I think like when you're
- 11:07in the the middle of it, you kind of see it escaping from the
- 11:10pack. But then reality is like my, my
- 11:13instincts tell me it hasn't and that there's still going to be a
- 11:15lot of kind of touching the stove before people coalesce
- 11:18around Bitcoin. But curious, like, you know, I'm
- 11:21assuming with the price appreciation, your network has
- 11:23been a little bit more interested in the space.
- 11:25How have they come to like the different assets?
- 11:28Well, there was also a point at points of an ETL where there's a
- 11:34town hall asked the town hall question asked to Steve Cohen,
- 11:40pretty much what is your view on Bitcoin headed into the next
- 11:43year? And the answer was, well, I
- 11:46don't really have a view on Bitcoin.
- 11:48I'm really looking for the regulatory clarity related to
- 11:52crypto in general, right? And so I think there's starting
- 11:55to be some additional regulatory clarity.
- 11:57He may have switched his view since then, but in general, I
- 12:02think people are generally confused right now.
- 12:05Like there's Trump coin. All my friends that you know,
- 12:10know that I've been very interested in Bitcoin for a long
- 12:13time and I always clarify it's Bitcoin only have asked me, you
- 12:18know, what's your view on Trump coin?
- 12:19What's your view on Ripple? And I think they think of
- 12:23everything just in the same exact boat when we obviously
- 12:27know that that's not exactly the same case.
- 12:29Yeah. I think part of it, at least
- 12:32from my perspective of having lived in that world for a long
- 12:35time, I think part of the skepticism around Bitcoin
- 12:42specifically and not being able to discern Bitcoin versus crypto
- 12:47stems from effectively like living in this world of, of
- 12:51traditional finance or asset management.
- 12:55There's, there's sort of this air of sophistication that comes
- 12:58with any investment strategy, right?
- 13:00Like if you're a talented portfolio manager with a great
- 13:03track record, like you have some edge, you have some advantage in
- 13:07the market where you know, you're, you're finding
- 13:10undervalued opportunities before anybody else.
- 13:14Bitcoin kind of flips out on the head on its head in that.
- 13:16Well, one, this has been adopted by individuals first around the
- 13:20world, globally. And you know, there, there isn't
- 13:24necessarily an edge outside of deeply understanding it.
- 13:29And the other component when it relates to crypto is like, it's
- 13:33kind of these these shiny things that people get distracted by.
- 13:38But to that, to that person that has that errors of
- 13:40sophistication around investing, they almost feel predisposed to
- 13:45say, oh, well, there's all these different assets.
- 13:47So what's my edge? How can I find an edge in
- 13:49understanding which of these assets are going to is going to
- 13:51outperform over time? When in reality, like they
- 13:53should just be focusing on Bitcoin and Bitcoin only because
- 13:56it's fundamentally different. But they get lost in the this
- 13:59sort of asset class of all these different crypto currencies and
- 14:03trying to have an educated view on which specific crypto
- 14:06currencies are going to excel and and outperform.
- 14:10And so I think it's they almost without knowing it do themselves
- 14:14sells a disservice and don't and aren't able to see the genuine
- 14:18differentiation of Bitcoin versus everything else because
- 14:21they want to almost feel that that air of sophistication like
- 14:25they have in their traditional world in this new quote, UN
- 14:29quote asset class of all these different crypto.
- 14:31Currencies, yeah. And just to that point, I would
- 14:34say, you know, Bitcoin is completely decentralized.
- 14:38There's no CEO, there's no marketing department.
- 14:43Whereas for some of these other coins, there is actually a
- 14:47company behind the issuance. There are insiders that get
- 14:52allocations of the coins prior to being able to give them to
- 14:56the rest of the public. And so I think there is a big
- 15:01demand for the essentially inside baseball of crypto from a
- 15:06lot of VC and financial firms or as they do not have that same
- 15:11opportunity or exposure in Bitcoin.
- 15:14And so I think it's just fundamentally different.
- 15:17And you know, another reason why it takes some time to understand
- 15:21Bitcoin is there is it's completely different from the
- 15:24model of, you know, 2% inflation rate.
- 15:28There needs to be everything is benchmark to the 10 year yield
- 15:32plus maybe some equity risk premium.
- 15:34It's just completely different than what they're used to.
- 15:37It's. Actually a great call out what
- 15:39you just said about like what we see as a feature they see as a
- 15:45bug because it's a bug that there's no owner, so you can't
- 15:49get in early. And what's interesting about
- 15:51that is like, because it's, it's actually really like interesting
- 15:54thought experiment in that on the Bitcoin side, what other
- 15:59thing that exists that very notable individuals credentialed
- 16:03have been saying positive things about it for effectively 15
- 16:07years. And then you can go back to very
- 16:08early days and there's notable folks that have been adopting
- 16:11and not even like pre Bill Miller and you know, the Strand,
- 16:14the truck and Miller's Paul Tudor Jones.
- 16:18It's really weird and nonsensical when you think about
- 16:20like, it's, it's like 1 aspect to just be like, look, I didn't
- 16:23get in early and that's why I want to touch it.
- 16:24But it's another one to think like it has no value.
- 16:27But that's what I feel like majority of people sit there,
- 16:29but there's just this whole like body of work from individuals
- 16:32that have staked their careers and their names and their
- 16:35businesses on it. What do you think of Fidelity?
- 16:38It's just like, so did they just like concoct some like ghost of
- 16:42an asset in their mind that's going to go to 01 day?
- 16:44Like it's just it's a very interesting dynamic that plays
- 16:48in the markets. And I think it has to do with
- 16:49what you're describing and also just as a symptom of how messed
- 16:52up the whole financial world is that like, you can't wrap your
- 16:54head around this thing that is so fundamental to like, societal
- 16:59growth is like having a good form of money and not being able
- 17:01to be debased that you're like, wait, this doesn't make sense.
- 17:04Like, this just is. I can't wrap my head around it
- 17:06because it when you lay it out that all the proof is there from
- 17:09all these individuals and corporations and ETS and
- 17:11presidents and people still are like, yeah, I don't know about
- 17:14that thing. It's just, it's so insane.
- 17:16Yeah. I think part of it is part of
- 17:20it's like what, you know, people often talk about.
- 17:22Like, on its surface, it does. It does sound too good to be
- 17:25true to some extent, like the idea of Bitcoin, the idea of
- 17:28digital sound money open to everyone, fair launch, all these
- 17:31things that sort of have occurred to to get us to this
- 17:36place where we are now. It does all somewhat on the
- 17:39surface. If you if you haven't done the
- 17:40digging into it feel a little too good to be true.
- 17:43And then the other side of that is, Michael to like sort of what
- 17:47you're alluding to is like, it takes a good amount of, of
- 17:51killing one's ego to admit that they were wrong about it.
- 17:54Because up until this point, if you haven't adopted it and
- 17:57you've been skeptical of it, you're, you know, you're
- 18:00basically saying it has no value.
- 18:01Like if, if you haven't bought it or you're, you're saying, you
- 18:04know, it's a scam or a Ponzi, in order to then adopt it and buy
- 18:09it, even in a small, you know, percentage of your portfolio,
- 18:12you have to then admit that you were, you were wrong, right.
- 18:15And, and most people don't want to do that about anything and
- 18:19particularly this asset that's being adopted globally by
- 18:21institutions, corporates, nation states, etcetera.
- 18:25But as that continues to occur, it basically, you know, it
- 18:30becomes more palatable to say you were wrong about it because
- 18:34basically more people are saying they were wrong about it.
- 18:36So it there is that there's that sort of element of a feedback
- 18:40loop where once enough people are willing to say they were
- 18:43wrong about it, it becomes more acceptable.
- 18:46So I think that's, that's kind of how I perceive it is like
- 18:49there's this massive barrier inherently to someone adopting
- 18:53Bitcoin, particularly if they come from the Tradfy world,
- 18:55because they have to admit that they were wrong for the past 10
- 18:58plus years. And and that's just something
- 19:00that most people in that world. William, to your earlier points,
- 19:03like if you've been very successful in Tradfy, you've
- 19:07made a ton of money in private equity or stress credit or, or
- 19:10wherever else you know, it's you have a certain view of the world
- 19:16and a certain view of your own sort of talent and edge in that
- 19:20world. And admitting that not only did
- 19:23you not have an edge on this asset, but you were actually
- 19:25wrong about it for some time is a difficult leap leap for some
- 19:29people to make. Yeah, and I would.
- 19:31OK. I was just going to say nobody
- 19:34gets fired for being consensus and wrong.
- 19:38You get fired for being, you know, the only one on an island
- 19:42and you're wrong. And it just makes no sense to
- 19:45everybody else. And so there's both like career
- 19:48risk to being the only one or, you know, one of the few people
- 19:54that think about Bitcoin or any asset in a different way than
- 19:58everybody else. But as it becomes more
- 20:00consensus, there's less career risk, there's less political
- 20:04risk because I'm sure we're going to talk about.
- 20:06And I think that more people are willing to not be on the island
- 20:10by themselves, even just like having a couple friends that you
- 20:14know know about it and can speak to you about it is makes it less
- 20:18risky in your mind. Yeah, And I know this isn't a
- 20:20topic of the show, so we can move, but I do want to call it
- 20:23like there's a big percentage that we haven't of this, like
- 20:26adoption that hasn't happened simply because it's an ephemeral
- 20:28asset and it's not tangible and you can't touch it because
- 20:30that's just a mental barrier. It had me think of like thought
- 20:33exercise, where what do you get something that looked like a bar
- 20:35of gold and just put a piece of Bitcoin on it and parked it in a
- 20:38cave? Like, would they be more apt to
- 20:40adopt it? Right, Because people do that
- 20:42with gold doesn't have any kind of like value outside of, you
- 20:45know, a little bit but not much that we know.
- 20:49But people are just like, it's just like it's always elusive,
- 20:52it's always out there. How can I allocate where is it
- 20:54exist and just by like anchoring the real world and it's.
- 20:57So it's just an interesting it's an interesting asset.
- 21:02Yeah. Well, let's get to the list.
- 21:03Michael, you sort of alluded to one of the stories that I wanted
- 21:07to talk about earlier around. So this week U.S. equity markets
- 21:14were a bit turbulent and the main sort of culprit was
- 21:20effectively a new AILOM model that got released out of China
- 21:27called Deep Seek. And the effectively the claim is
- 21:31that they used way less capital to build what seems to be as
- 21:39good, if not better model than ChatGPT and other models being
- 21:43built in the West who are obviously spending 10s or
- 21:47hundreds of billions of dollars to build these things.
- 21:49The alleged claim is that Deepseek only spent about
- 21:536,000,000 with an M dollars to build this model.
- 21:58Now that is obviously coming from China.
- 22:01So it's it's hard to be super confident in that number.
- 22:05But I think at least for me, you know, the first sort of near
- 22:09term take away is that if this is to be any sort of directional
- 22:14truth in that they did this with way less capital, then it sort
- 22:20of, you know, brings into question the valuation of all
- 22:22the companies in the West that are building these models using
- 22:25way more money. So you saw NVIDIA and a lot of
- 22:28of the other sort of AI related stocks in the US sell off this
- 22:33week pretty materially as a result of this.
- 22:37The the takeaways for me are are a few fold. 1 is, you know, a
- 22:41lot of this relates to, you know, a theme that we have sort
- 22:44of internalized at early riders is that companies in this sort
- 22:48of new age are going to continue to do more with less.
- 22:51And what that really means is leveraging deflationary
- 22:54technologies and tools to be more efficient.
- 22:57And so AI is a great example of this.
- 22:59And this is an even more sort of micro example of this particular
- 23:03company in China, you know, using less capital effectively
- 23:07to build a, you know, just as good, if not better LLM model
- 23:12than what currently exists. And so, you know, I think this
- 23:15is just a prime example of what we expect to continue to see
- 23:19around, you know, companies just being more efficient as they
- 23:21leverage these tools like AI and Bitcoin.
- 23:25But I'll pause there to see if you guys have any any thoughts
- 23:27on this in general. Yeah, I mean, there's a lot.
- 23:32There's a lot, especially when you don't really there's like
- 23:34half what you can learn and then the other half that's probably
- 23:36not even true yet because of where it's come from.
- 23:39And the the implications are feel so multifaceted.
- 23:45The thing that I think ultimately comes to mind, and I
- 23:49don't know, like again, how true this isn't Brian, you sounds
- 23:51like you free us chatting. You've done a lot or at least a
- 23:54little more research than we have is that they ultimately had
- 23:58constraints and their constraints allowed them to
- 24:01build this with a lot more than less.
- 24:02And that's ultimately what Brian's referring to is at the
- 24:05end of the day, well, that sounds paradoxical.
- 24:07If you give somebody $1,000,000 or $100 million and tell them to
- 24:09go figure something out more, 9 times out of 10, on a long
- 24:12enough time horizon, the person with a million that is going to
- 24:15come up with a more efficient and optimized way to do it.
- 24:19Because that's just a natural order of things.
- 24:20Like when you have abundance, that's what breeds all this
- 24:22craziness. And it was always part of the
- 24:24discussion that like opening eyes kind of really strange if
- 24:27you're raising billions and billions of dollars every, like,
- 24:29you know, a few months because the definition of having
- 24:30something is you don't give it away.
- 24:32So if you're consistently having a raise, well then what do you
- 24:34really have? But then tying back to the
- 24:39constraints, it's like, well, if you have less capital and then
- 24:42you can optimize for the best outcome, well, then the best
- 24:45outcome. The reason you would optimize
- 24:47for that is naturally because you have the constraints, but
- 24:49you also are trying to return some capital back to yourself or
- 24:52your shareholders, which ultimately means that you're
- 24:54trying to get to the fastest way to do that.
- 24:58And it's interesting because we joked before this, we were
- 25:01talking about it if they weren't Bitcoiners.
- 25:03I can guarantee you the people that are Bitcoiners can build at
- 25:05half the cost that they did if they got to that point.
- 25:07Because if they were spending dollars or yen or whatever the
- 25:10local currency is, and now they're sitting on a money that
- 25:13we know went from 50, let's say they started working at this and
- 25:15the price was 50K and they had this long term thesis of
- 25:17Bitcoin. Well, they're looking at
- 25:18everything like shit, do I spend this Bitcoin today?
- 25:21Because it's going to be 60708090.
- 25:23And so every decision would have been over optimized.
- 25:25And that's effectively what the whole position here that early
- 25:28riders is, whether it's a venture allocator or an
- 25:30entrepreneur, you have to have the individual cannot just be
- 25:34the capital stack. You can give the best you have
- 25:37like an entrepreneur $100 million in Bitcoin.
- 25:40It doesn't mean they're going to go optimize and build a war
- 25:42chest you I would take the other person that was a better
- 25:45entrepreneur with 100 million in USD.
- 25:47They'll still run laps around the person that's the BTC
- 25:50because it's not enough just to have the better form of money.
- 25:52You have to have the individual that is able to optimize in
- 25:55their brain and how they bring products and services to the
- 25:57market. And it sounds like these guys
- 25:59just hit it like at some capacity.
- 26:01Again, we don't know what the motivation was because I think
- 26:04that's the big missing part in all this.
- 26:06Just like what's the actual motivation where they just doing
- 26:07it? Are they really just a hedge
- 26:08fund or is it something more? Yeah, I think there's, there's
- 26:13still some unknowns, but I, I, when you hit on I think is the
- 26:17most important thing is that this this notion of constraints
- 26:21breeding creativity and actually forcing you to be more
- 26:25efficient. And so there was a, a, a great
- 26:29write up by someone Jeffrey Emanuel basically wrote the the
- 26:33short case for NVIDIA stock. I'll I'll link it in the show
- 26:36notes. But he he describes part of what
- 26:39the unlock was for Deepseek in in figuring this out.
- 26:42And he goes the technical breakthrough here was their
- 26:45novel approach to reward modeling.
- 26:48Rather than using complex neural reward models that can lead to
- 26:51reward hacking, where the model finds bogus ways to boost the
- 26:54rewards and don't actually lead to better real world model
- 26:57performance, they developed a clever rule based system that
- 27:01combines accuracy rewards. So verifying final answers with
- 27:06format rewards, encouraging structured thinking.
- 27:08So this simpler approach turned out to be more robust and
- 27:11scalable than the process based reward models that others have
- 27:14tried. So basically because they had
- 27:16these constraints, they had to figure out a way to figure out a
- 27:20better reward reward system to train the model, and that's what
- 27:23they ended up doing. And so it's just like if it
- 27:26hadn't been for those constraints, they probably don't
- 27:28get to that conclusion. Yeah.
- 27:30And Liam, I'd be curious your thoughts because something that
- 27:32I haven't really shared out loud and like it's a little bit on
- 27:35the edges, but there's something I believe to it is so you come
- 27:38out of 21 and 22 and that 21 vintage, everyone knows if
- 27:41somebody raised and allocated a fund in 21 that pretty much like
- 27:44write, write it off or write it down or definitely write it off
- 27:47because of the the valuations there.
- 27:50And so money tightened up from LP's and also venture firms.
- 27:53And so 22, there was really only one narrative to the back end
- 27:56was like AI. So you had all these funds that
- 27:58were either being raised or deploying on that.
- 28:01And then there's all these companies that naturally
- 28:03pivoted. So there were existing AI
- 28:05companies or there were companies that put some tent of
- 28:07AI, right? Everyone had something there.
- 28:09But when this goes back to the incentives, so you know, whether
- 28:14they had called the the venture funds where they had called the
- 28:17capital already had the commitments, they have to raise
- 28:20that money because they're looking at the management fees
- 28:24for either their existing, you know, partnership structure to
- 28:27pay on any other expenditures, liabilities, but then also to
- 28:30grow. And so they needed this
- 28:32narrative. Like it was almost like AI was
- 28:34the valve for this capital to naturally go to.
- 28:37So everyone was incentivized because like this didn't just
- 28:40can't, it can't just pop up out of nowhere that what you just
- 28:42described and nobody pick up on it or build.
- 28:44It's like everyone was incentivized to play the game
- 28:46because when you're an entrepreneur and everybody's
- 28:48raising money, it's like, sure, I want more of that money and
- 28:50you're AVC and more LP's are looking and sovereigns are
- 28:54looking for the next AI breakthrough because they are by
- 28:56nature unsophisticated in the sense of this.
- 28:58That's why they're picking specialist funds to understand
- 29:01this. So it feels like everybody was
- 29:02playing along in something that was never really like sound
- 29:07like, I think it's the end state, right?
- 29:08So open source is going to inevitably be the solutions when
- 29:11it comes to these models. So just curious, Liam, does that
- 29:13like I mean, I haven't fully worked through that one, but it
- 29:16feels like there's something there that everybody was just
- 29:18incentivized to play this game in the same way everybody's
- 29:20incentivized to put all the money in the S&P even that we
- 29:22all know it's overvalued because it's just like a quasi money in
- 29:26store and savings. Yeah.
- 29:28I think for anybody that manages money, you really if some view
- 29:34is consensus, you really want to be on that consensus view,
- 29:38right. I think that there are, if you,
- 29:42you're going to, you have career risk if you underperform the S&P
- 29:46on a really strong year and you have career risk if you
- 29:50significantly underperform in a really bad year.
- 29:53But you don't have career risk if you pretty much do the same
- 29:56thing as the S&P. And so I think that was a
- 29:58narrative at the time. There was a lot of capital that
- 30:01was being allocated into the space.
- 30:03And so essentially you had to just get on board.
- 30:08But ultimately many of the things that you're talking about
- 30:10too don't just apply to AI specifically, but actually apply
- 30:14to every single company based on what the AI models are
- 30:18providing, right? Like Deep seek, providing open
- 30:22source models that I believe can be self hosted are pretty
- 30:26interesting and pretty much can help every business be more
- 30:30efficient no matter what kind of business they are.
- 30:32And we just keep seeing everything from, you know, the
- 30:35printing press to now deep seek open source self hosted models
- 30:41allow every company to be more efficient over time.
- 30:43And that contrasting with the fact that consumer prices of
- 30:48great only gone up over time just doesn't make sense.
- 30:53People and businesses continue to be more efficient and
- 30:58utilizing a money that doesn't allow you to benefit from that
- 31:01just honestly makes no sense to me.
- 31:03What? Do you, what do you guys make of
- 31:05the fact that, you know, I think prior to this happening this
- 31:09week, I think there was a perception or thought that
- 31:13everything that China was going to do from an AI perspective
- 31:16would be closed source. And they kind of, you know,
- 31:19obviously flipped that narrative by open sourcing this model.
- 31:23Do we think that that is what do we make of that one?
- 31:26And two, is it sort of like a purposeful just shot across the
- 31:29bow to the West to say, you know, you're whatever Moat you
- 31:33think you have around these AI models, which you know, most of
- 31:37them in the West are closed source.
- 31:38You know, open AI and ChatGPT being sort of the the one that's
- 31:42most adopted that is closed source.
- 31:45You think that's just a shot across the bow to say like, you
- 31:47know, those those valuations for these companies are are probably
- 31:51excessive because the the moats or the barriers to entry you
- 31:54think you have really don't exist.
- 31:57So that's the hard part because we're definitely over my pay
- 32:01grade. I think ours and it'd be
- 32:02interesting to have somebody on the pod because I think there's
- 32:04so many different geopolitical implications that like whenever
- 32:08you see something pick up a narrative so fast as deep seek,
- 32:10I'm always questioning like, well, what what's happening
- 32:12here? But then also post Trump and
- 32:15inauguration, it's like, well, that's interesting because we're
- 32:20Silicon Valley freedom oriented, all the things.
- 32:22But then they came out and did this.
- 32:24Like is there re questioning who are the leaders in the free
- 32:28world when it comes to innovation?
- 32:29Like that's an angle. I have no idea if that's true.
- 32:31Just sounds kind of good. So like, I don't know, I don't,
- 32:34I think it's hard to like really, again, it's so
- 32:37multifaceted to know what the implications are and it's both.
- 32:40There's multiple orders of it. Yeah, it's definitely above my
- 32:44pay grade. But I thought it was interesting
- 32:46that it came out pretty recently after the Stargate announcement
- 32:51of $500 billion to be allocated to the picks and shovels and
- 32:56essentially GP US that are providing all of the models for
- 33:00all these AI algorithms. Especially just given this
- 33:05company at least says that they were able to do it for
- 33:07significantly lower cost. Do you think I'll leave it to
- 33:13you, Brian, if you want to go deeper here, But I think there's
- 33:15something to bring up that's a corollary to to what Liam said,
- 33:19that this exists across all the markets.
- 33:20Like there's insane inefficiencies because the
- 33:23existing system rewarded just malinvestment across the board.
- 33:26And it's just like we're putting this together.
- 33:29But like I had a hint, it's like this recursive feedback loop
- 33:31where VCs don't really know what they're doing.
- 33:34So because they're not natural builders, like there's only so
- 33:36much capital that really should be out in the real world.
- 33:40So when you put all this capital out there where you have to park
- 33:42it somewhere, then you give it to people that shouldn't have
- 33:43it, then they're building solutions that are not the most
- 33:47optimized. And the example that I think of
- 33:49this is super taboo, but I'm confident it's true, is like all
- 33:52these exchanges that pop up, whether it's Coinbase and you're
- 33:55listening to this, you're like, how can Coinbase have a long
- 33:57standing business? Because if their revenues
- 33:58predicated on trading and then ultimately have custody ends up
- 34:02decentralized because it's not sensible to think of global
- 34:04money ends up as Bitcoin, that Coinbase with hold it all that
- 34:06means it failed. Then it's like, how do you
- 34:08underwrite that valuation? And that's like at the far end
- 34:11of the margins now, like look at any Bitcoin only SAT sacking
- 34:14business and it's like, OK, well, you're investing in it.
- 34:17And then what's the next move? Like raise another ground And
- 34:19then you have to go acquire more customers because it's a
- 34:21compression game on fees. And then they don't custody
- 34:25assets to tell them to all go hold them.
- 34:27But then also is not great because the people holding them
- 34:29are getting their fingers sent back increasingly as ransom
- 34:32goes. So it's like, well, what is that
- 34:33entrepreneur actually planning on for the launch standing
- 34:36business? Are they going to hold all the
- 34:37Bitcoin? Because again, that doesn't tie
- 34:39to like how money is going to end up there because we know
- 34:41where gold failed and so that's sold to LP's and investors.
- 34:45It's like we're going to go invest and do additional rounds.
- 34:48And so I think it's just like these inefficiencies are
- 34:51everywhere. And that's what ties into once
- 34:54the entrepreneur really Crocs like a Bitcoin.
- 34:57But then why you want more of that, you're naturally going to
- 34:59build the most efficient business that actually can have
- 35:02not only winning the client, but then ultimately having the best
- 35:06form of like long standing relationship with them
- 35:09basically. And it doesn't have to be in
- 35:10Bitcoin. This is just the example of like
- 35:12brokerage and how nobody has really figured it out yet.
- 35:16Well, well, maybe pulling on that thread, you know, you sort
- 35:21of mentioned, how do you have a long term view on Coinbase?
- 35:25Coinbase, for example, as a sustainable business model?
- 35:27Well, one you you need to ascribe some value to everything
- 35:31they're doing X Bitcoin, right? Like that is a lot of what
- 35:34they've built their business on is effectively pushing people
- 35:38out the risk curve, getting them to trade all these other assets
- 35:41and think much shorter term than, you know, what they really
- 35:44should be doing is thinking long term about Bitcoin specifically.
- 35:49And then you you sort of tie that into maybe we can we we can
- 35:53bring up SAB 121 being repealed. Well, OK, the other the other
- 35:57component now too as well. If banks are going to custody
- 35:59it, then why do you need a coin base necessarily to, to custody
- 36:02your, your Bitcoin or your other digital assets if all the banks
- 36:05are going to now get involved? So maybe maybe we can pivot
- 36:09there a little bit to some of what's been happening over the
- 36:11past week or two with the creation of the Digital Asset
- 36:17Task Force as well as repealing Saab 121.
- 36:22Any general thoughts on on all of this?
- 36:24I know, you know, there was sort of some talk on Bitcoin Twitter,
- 36:28some people were upset that they didn't name Bitcoin specifically
- 36:31and a lot of this stuff. I think that's just to be
- 36:34expected. Like I, I think it would have
- 36:36been insane if they had called out Bitcoin specifically, you
- 36:39know, whether it's talking about a stockpile or or whatever,
- 36:42mainly because we already have seized other digital assets.
- 36:45So it'd be kind of crazy to just single out Bitcoin at this point
- 36:48in time. But the task force being put
- 36:50together Lum misleading that SAB 121.
- 36:54Any thoughts on on general developments over the past
- 36:57couple weeks? So I've go ahead, Liam, you
- 37:02could kick it off. I mean, well, you can't really
- 37:06talk about this without talking about Trump launching a coin and
- 37:11the fact that essentially the sitting president launched a
- 37:15meme coin and now like, I think it passed 14 billion in
- 37:20outstanding value. Rumors are that he sold $500
- 37:23million of that. And that's essentially what
- 37:26we're we were alluding to earlier with 80% of the supply
- 37:31is allocated to insiders or hasn't been issued yet and then
- 37:35the remainder is just sold on to the public.
- 37:38And so everybody wants the inside baseball of being able to
- 37:42allocate early and then, you know, they sold, including the
- 37:47person who actually created the coin for them mentioned that he
- 37:50sold. And then right now it's like,
- 37:53you know, not not quite dead, but kind of boring has got has
- 37:57gone down a lot. And I think that kind of ties
- 38:00back into, you know, the, the model that Coinbase has of, you
- 38:04know, they now want to to be able to have a faster process to
- 38:08issue 1,000,000 new coins that are being issued for per week,
- 38:14which just, you know, the everything right now in crypto
- 38:18innovation seems to be launching a meme coin and, you know, being
- 38:23able to sell it to the public. With respect to Trump, I think
- 38:29his executive order on digital working group or digital asset
- 38:33working group is to be expected, it sounds like.
- 38:38Oh, the one other thing that I forgot to mention is Trump,
- 38:41Trump Media Company is now acquiring Bitcoin and other
- 38:45digital assets as well. So it seems like he's getting
- 38:48some information from somebody near his group that is into
- 38:54digital assets, right. And you know, that may or may
- 38:57not include Bitcoin, I mean. It's Sax in large part right?
- 39:00Like he's the AI Cryptozar. Like I think he's at least one
- 39:06of the one of the primary people in his ear.
- 39:08I wouldn't necessarily just put it on Sax.
- 39:10I mean, I think that there's a component of that, but it's
- 39:12really just the natural. Like it's known within that
- 39:16administration. People close like for what
- 39:18however they're going to do it. Bitcoin's rising this year.
- 39:21So by nature of that, you're just getting proxies whether Sax
- 39:24is in his ear or not. I don't, I think it's actually
- 39:26less sax. It's more of you're just buying
- 39:29exposure in the same way like 10 T and tap arrows funds like
- 39:32thesis was we're going to go to pensions and all these funds
- 39:34that can't get exposure to spot Bitcoin and we're just going to
- 39:37buy in the growth companies of the Gemini's and ledgers in
- 39:40these firms pre IPO because the sector lists as bitcoins price
- 39:44lifts. That's what it feels like in
- 39:47those because I think that post from their company was like,
- 39:50we're going to invest in like exchanges and stuff versus like
- 39:54crypto coins. Yeah.
- 39:58And and to the point earlier, I think that, you know, most of
- 40:02the exchanges and other coins are, you know, either going to
- 40:07underperform Bitcoin because they're not correctly allocating
- 40:10capital or have insider allocations that are going to be
- 40:13sold to the public without significant real value.
- 40:17And so, you know, there was no mention of creating a strategic
- 40:21Bitcoin reserve that many people are hoping for, but I think, you
- 40:25know. While it's probably a little
- 40:28early for that, it's ultimately going to happen like I'm sure of
- 40:32that because essentially that's going through every single
- 40:35person's journey. You know, I mentioned, you know,
- 40:37Adam back initially dismissed Bitcoin because it had like no
- 40:41value. But then once it got bigger, he
- 40:44was like, OK, this is kind of interesting.
- 40:45Let me do some additional research.
- 40:47And that's same with me. That's going to be same with the
- 40:50United States and every other country in the world, because
- 40:53once they realize that this is a decentralized asset which
- 40:57anybody can plug a note into, it can not be censored, it cannot
- 41:01be seized, and you can send value anywhere in the world
- 41:04within 10 minutes. That's a value proposition.
- 41:07That's while it sounds too good to be true, once people actually
- 41:10understand why it's how it's created and the rules that
- 41:16enforce it, everybody essentially goes to it in the
- 41:18end. Yeah, I think, I think the
- 41:20other, the other component to note here with respect to, you
- 41:26know, the the idea that there would be an executive order
- 41:29specific to a strategic Bitcoin reserve, I think was always a
- 41:34little off in the sense that you'd you'd actually much rather
- 41:39that come through, you know, bipartisan congressional support
- 41:43for an actual bill like Lummus's bill as opposed to an executive
- 41:47order. Because if it's just an
- 41:48executive order, then that is basically a, a less robust form
- 41:55of legislation that in four years, you know, if party flips,
- 42:01then they could just get rid of that and then sell the Bitcoin.
- 42:04And so I think the, the idea that it was going to come
- 42:07through an executive order was, was somewhat misplaced.
- 42:11And it actually makes a lot more sense to come through, you know,
- 42:14something like the, the bill that Lummus has put forward.
- 42:18I think the other aspect, though, is like, I think the
- 42:21number they floated is 157 million from like the crypto
- 42:24industry was in invested or helped support Trump.
- 42:27It's like lobbying effort too many.
- 42:29Yeah, yeah. So it's like, well, even if they
- 42:32want to do this and it's only Bitcoin in there, like they have
- 42:35to throw these people a bone. That's why you see these events
- 42:37in the crypto ball. It's not the Bitcoin ball
- 42:39because they just gave you all that money.
- 42:41So you have to like same way he kept his promise and did what he
- 42:45did with all these other executive orders.
- 42:47It'd be kind of shitty if he if you know, because bitcoiners
- 42:49didn't do the whole 157. It'd be lucky if we did half.
- 42:52The reality is, is the way A16Z has a huge lobbying and and
- 42:56political arm in DC is because of that.
- 42:58So kind of makes sense why there's just like naturally all
- 43:02of it. One thing I just want to share,
- 43:06Brian and Liam though, is the asymmetry and like information
- 43:11in the bank stuff at the margins.
- 43:13Maybe there are certain banks that are somewhat sophisticated
- 43:15and there probably are because of just law of numbers.
- 43:19But anecdotally, I talked to somebody today, friends with I
- 43:23think a top ten bank and talked to his buddy there.
- 43:26And this is like in good authority.
- 43:28It's like they don't even know Fab 121.
- 43:31Gotta feel talked to another firm, family owned.
- 43:33It's been trying to get into this space hard since FTX got
- 43:38slapped down with the regulators been very careful and was
- 43:41talking to them in the middle pre all this FDIC stuff.
- 43:44So you always knew something was wrong, but you couldn't really
- 43:47couldn't talk about it. And so super excited, reached
- 43:50out to them like, hey, this is done, let's talk.
- 43:52You know, there's a lot of opportunity in the space and
- 43:54they're like, hey, let's, let's just wait.
- 43:56You know, they said this pre when we started looking like
- 43:59Trump was coming in and then they said this even after,
- 44:02because there's so much scars and battle wounds of like the
- 44:06past few years. And then to the point of what
- 44:08Liam said and what we've talked about, it's there's still so
- 44:10much learning of like why one asset versus the other.
- 44:13And before you even get there, then you or after you get there,
- 44:15then you have to figure out custody.
- 44:17And we all talk about here. But like the difference between
- 44:19multi party computation and multi sig, like we still have
- 44:22such a slow burn into that. And the best way I can describe
- 44:26is like in proportion of how much dollars or the system is in
- 44:28proportion of how much, like craziness will happen over the
- 44:30course of the next 10 years as it relates to crypto and
- 44:33infrastructure and vulnerabilities until the signal
- 44:35comes out the other side because there's just that much noise in
- 44:39the system. Yeah.
- 44:41I mean, the other thing to me around just just Saab 121 and I
- 44:46think there's an assumption in the market that like, oh, yeah.
- 44:50Like, thanks for just waiting for this.
- 44:52And now they're ready to turn on Bitcoin custody.
- 44:54It's like, well, no, not necessarily.
- 44:56Like unless they've had, you know, unless they've really been
- 45:00focused on it in preparation for this for the past several years.
- 45:04Like I don't know if these banks are ready to turn on Bitcoin
- 45:06custody. I don't know if they're ready to
- 45:07secure private key key material where they have to go out and
- 45:10hire people to to figure out that that out.
- 45:13Or if like, you know, BNY is the one that's that's floated as
- 45:17like the most ready because they got the exception or whatever,
- 45:20you know, prior to this being repealed.
- 45:22But I, I, and this is a blind spot for me.
- 45:24I just don't know how much work they've done to actually be able
- 45:27to, to custody the asset. And Michael, to your point, it's
- 45:30like, well, you know, if they're not even going to be discerning
- 45:33Bitcoin versus crypto that do they just go down the MPC route
- 45:36multi party computation. They don't actually even use
- 45:38Bitcoin native multi sig to store their Bitcoin.
- 45:41Is that who you want to be partnering with as your as your
- 45:43bank, bank grade custodian? If they're using MPC with like
- 45:47an Anchorage or like a firebox, like is it really even that
- 45:50differentiated or are they just going to outsource its Coinbase
- 45:53like the ETFs? Like there's still be all these
- 45:55massive outstanding questions. And I think the perception is
- 45:58like, Oh yeah, game on. Banks can now hold the assets
- 46:00like, well, how, how are they going to do that?
- 46:02Because I don't think they have the expertise in house. 100% and
- 46:06one thing too. It's still not.
- 46:09It's still politically risky to custody Bitcoin if you're a
- 46:13bank. Anybody who's been paying
- 46:15attention to the Bitcoin space and in particular has been
- 46:18following Caitlin Long in custodia knows that she's been
- 46:21trying super, super hard to get a Federal Reserve master account
- 46:25or something similar. I may be misremembering, but she
- 46:29hasn't been able to. And, you know, even despite a
- 46:32more friendly incoming administration to crypto at
- 46:36large, you know, the Federal Reserve hasn't changed over.
- 46:40Jerome Powell is still the Fed chair.
- 46:42And in order to be custody consumer assets, you need a
- 46:46Federal Reserve master charter. And then there are just concerns
- 46:50about, you know, the relationship with other
- 46:52government entities should any bank try to custody Bitcoin.
- 46:56Yeah. And this is such a great
- 46:57conversation because you don't get to talk or hear about it a
- 47:00lot. But like Brian's signal, there
- 47:02are like they're close. They were close back in the day.
- 47:04They this SAB, the bulletin really messed up their launch,
- 47:09BNY in particular. But State Street's we're going
- 47:11to roll out stuff. There's other firms, but to
- 47:13Brian's point, there's multiple levels to this because just
- 47:16because even you even get the tech stack right, they're not
- 47:19equipped to like actually provide the services that an
- 47:23individual that owns Bitcoin wants.
- 47:25So there's always at the margin is going to be people that look
- 47:27at a name like AB and Y and go there.
- 47:29But then the end of the day, like these institutions leverage
- 47:31generally omnibus account structures and they're not
- 47:36equipped mentally or the technicals to actually create
- 47:41what in Bitcoin you just know as a wallet, which is an SMA and
- 47:45like the traditional finance base in the segregated parts.
- 47:49And a cousin of this is where this like conflation of ETFs
- 47:54letting you take delivery means you can go and put your own
- 47:56Bitcoin in or take delivery of the underlying like the
- 48:00authorized participants may do cash or Bitcoin settled and
- 48:04Bitcoin in, but independent of even if they knew how to send
- 48:08the Bitcoin, there is so much compliance perspective,
- 48:12compliance problems when it comes to OFAC sanction address,
- 48:15Where do you send it? Logistics, where does it go that
- 48:19are frankly impossible at this point for anybody at that scale
- 48:22to manage. This was like one of the big
- 48:24dirty secrets of why GBTC could not get unwound.
- 48:26There was a number of them, but one of them was like the level
- 48:28of counterparties from the brokerage.
- 48:30You bought it from the intermediary, which was
- 48:33effectively Grayscale or yeah, grayscale.
- 48:35And then Coinbase sitting there. Imagine the complexity of having
- 48:38to take those UTX OS, send them to somebody's address that you
- 48:41had to make sure wasn't sanctioned by Iran or Venezuela.
- 48:43Like all this plumbing is so far away that these people doing it
- 48:48is just like it again, it's just it's awesome to see because if
- 48:52you know the market and the majority of the market sits with
- 48:55Bitcoiners that are quote UN quote sophisticated, they had to
- 48:57be because they had to hold it this long and not get rubbed at
- 49:01the margins. Again, they'll go into these
- 49:02accounts because they have the names, but then as the price
- 49:04appreciates, they're going to look around and then be like,
- 49:07either AI need a better solution or I need to get it off there
- 49:10because then the balance sheet risk becomes real because the
- 49:12name doesn't matter because the math is a math.
- 49:14If they mess up that omnibus account, all their funds, right?
- 49:16Exactly. If they're doing it omnibus, you
- 49:18know, how are you? How are you going to have
- 49:20assurances that they're not, you know, fractional reserve
- 49:23rehypothecating the Bitcoin like that would be a natural sort of
- 49:27assumption of, you know, if they're going to if they're
- 49:29going to map their traditional banking practices to this new
- 49:33asset Bitcoin, you know, yippee, now they can they can custody
- 49:37it. Well, why wouldn't they just do
- 49:38the same thing they do with other assets where they're going
- 49:40to lend out your Bitcoin? It's going to be in an omnibus.
- 49:42You're not going to have any transparency to say, you know,
- 49:45here's my segregated wallet. So I think, yeah, those are all
- 49:49huge outstanding questions in terms of how this this begins to
- 49:52play out. Yeah.
- 49:54And there is FDIC insurance of up to $250,000 for dollars,
- 49:59right? Because, you know, dollars can
- 50:03be printed, you can't print more Bitcoin.
- 50:05So if your custodian loses your Bitcoin, you're kind of done.
- 50:10Maybe you can get some dollars back, but you're not going to be
- 50:13able to get the same amount of Bitcoin.
- 50:15One of the biggest unlocks for me, and this will be fun when we
- 50:19create a piece around it and talk about it more, is that, you
- 50:22know, price is set at the margins, Bitcoin is adopted at
- 50:25the margins and ultimately the Bitcoin products that will win
- 50:28will be built at the margins. And it sounds like, Oh yeah,
- 50:32that makes sense. But like it's so
- 50:34counterintuitive to everything else.
- 50:36That generally happens when you think about the top down
- 50:38structure that was being created from traditional finance and
- 50:41ETFs and four O 1 KS and all the products that exist all the way
- 50:44to like Facebook and Google. Like the whole thing gets
- 50:47shifted because again, talking about this, it's just like, you
- 50:51need that whole of the individuals to adopt the, the,
- 50:55the app, the standard or they just won't because the status
- 50:57quo has kept their Bitcoin safe. And so this is like The funny
- 51:01thing. It's, it's fun to go talk to
- 51:02these institutions because some laugh and they're like, I don't
- 51:04get it. And then the other ones are
- 51:05like, oh, that's actually interesting because I can't
- 51:07afford to not like be right here.
- 51:11Yeah. And maybe one other thing I
- 51:14wanted to bring up sort of relates to, you know, what we're
- 51:19talking about from a regulatory perspective, the, you know, the
- 51:22new administration being more favorable.
- 51:24I think it's worth pointing out that this isn't happening in a
- 51:27vacuum and other people are watching, other nation states
- 51:31are watching, and we had a report I think yesterday that
- 51:36the Czech central bank chief calls for them to buy billions.
- 51:41This says crypto reserves. I believe he said Bitcoin
- 51:43specifically. I could be wrong on that, but
- 51:48any thoughts on this? Just general sort of sovereign
- 51:50game theory, which we've talked a lot about people waking up to,
- 51:55you know, even if even if the messaging has been somewhat
- 51:57mixed from the Trump administration on Bitcoin
- 52:00crypto. I think other nation states can
- 52:03sort of see the forest through the trees and say like, you
- 52:06know, Bitcoin is, is the reserve asset that we need to be
- 52:08accumulating, particularly if you know, the US is going to
- 52:12have this much more favorable stance towards the industry.
- 52:16Yeah, I think some people saw El Salvador, heard about it last
- 52:20cycle in 2021. And we're like, oh, that's kind
- 52:24of interesting, but it's not big enough for us.
- 52:27Or, you know, it's, it's maybe a scam, maybe too good to be true.
- 52:30And then, you know, the price went down.
- 52:34They were down on their holdings, and then it went back
- 52:36up. And now people are taking
- 52:37another closer look at it, and they're trying to understand
- 52:40what exactly this is. And some people are fully there
- 52:43into understanding that this is going to be the best way to
- 52:47store value over time. I think that is kind of the
- 52:50natural step. We've seen, I think 15 states
- 52:53file for strategic Bitcoin reserves at the state level as
- 52:57well. And I respect, I expect most of
- 53:00those to be rejected. We've seen, you know, I think
- 53:04shareholder proposals to acquire Bitcoin from Microsoft, Amazon,
- 53:08Meta recently, and they're likely all going to be rejected
- 53:14until I'm proven wrong. At least that's my base
- 53:17understanding. But I think it generally is
- 53:20shifting the Overton window a lot in terms of what is
- 53:23acceptable, what is reasonable, and people are getting more
- 53:27educated on this. Yeah.
- 53:30Can you, can you close that one out real quick, Brian, I want to
- 53:33show, I want to pull something up.
- 53:35I've never viscera, this is probably naive on my side, but
- 53:37I've never viscerally felt that 21 million is such a small
- 53:42number until hearing really like thinking about all the tailwinds
- 53:47happening right now, right? Because we have individuals, we
- 53:49have the ETFs, we have corporate treasury narratives, we have
- 53:52sovereign narratives, and then we have everything in the middle
- 53:55of all of that, whether it's a managed wealth management
- 53:58insurance. Like that 21,000,000 number is
- 54:01really actually super small when you realize like where we're at.
- 54:06And to Liam and Brian points like it's been kind of like de
- 54:09risk. It's increasingly becoming de
- 54:11risk and it's going to eventually flip, probably sooner
- 54:13rather than later on. Like, wait, you don't have any
- 54:15exposure. Like how the hell are you
- 54:16supposed to outperform anything else?
- 54:20It's pretty wild. Yeah, it is crazy.
- 54:23I mean, it's, and it's like, you know, it's, it's the number,
- 54:27right? There's 21 million, but it could
- 54:28be any number. Like it's just the finite nature
- 54:30of it that that's what's critical for, for folks to grok
- 54:34around. You know, I, I talk about this a
- 54:37lot, but it's like, you know, if I'm describing the Bitcoin
- 54:41thesis to a, to a normal person or someone who's on the
- 54:44periphery as I was doing this past weekend, I was, I was out
- 54:48in Texas and, you know, having some conversations with some
- 54:51normal folks who were, were genuinely curious, right?
- 54:54Because I think that's one thing that is certainly, you know,
- 54:58we're in the midst of, of seeing happen is, is people getting
- 55:01more curious about it because it is so overtly in the zeitgeist
- 55:05right now. And so there is the curiosity.
- 55:08But where I always sort of come at it from is just like this is
- 55:11supply and demand. We know, we know the finite
- 55:14supply cannot be changed 21 million.
- 55:17But like I'm saying, like it could be one, one coin like it.
- 55:21All that matters is that it's finite and we know that and it's
- 55:23predictable and immutable. And all you have to assume is
- 55:27that demand increases and everything the market is telling
- 55:30us is, is a signal that demand is increasing from the
- 55:34individual level to the corporate level, to the nation
- 55:36state level. Demand is increasing.
- 55:39And so the price necessarily has to go up.
- 55:41And so, you know, over what time frame does, you know, do we get
- 55:44to a million to 10 million a coin?
- 55:46I don't know. I, I don't have a, you know,
- 55:48magic, magic 8 ball to say exactly when that happens, but I
- 55:52know the trajectory. The trajectory is simple supply
- 55:54and demand, you know, economics one O 1.
- 55:57And so that's that's, I think you know what I always sort of
- 56:02anchor to when I'm speaking to someone who is really just
- 56:05beginning to understand this thing is like that, this notion
- 56:08of a finite asset has never existed before.
- 56:11Like that in and of itself is a is a powerful thing to bring to
- 56:13someone and bring to the fore. And then you say, OK, while that
- 56:18that is true, it's also true that demand is increasing.
- 56:21And So what does that mean? Price goes up over time.
- 56:24The scary part in that in like is if you don't play offense,
- 56:28like you lose because like, I think that's the big problem is
- 56:32people think like, you could just like bypass it and it's
- 56:35cool and like you and I'll get it later, which is true.
- 56:39But if you're in a competitive world, which we just like
- 56:42naturally always are, whether it's like your dollars are
- 56:44competing for goods or your business and somebody's
- 56:47competing against you. If you don't figure this thing
- 56:51out, you just are going to be, you know, a victim of like
- 56:54inflation and fee compression or price compression, degradation
- 57:00of the goods and services. This is all the things that are
- 57:02happening, right? And like, this is where we see,
- 57:04you know, all the different tailwinds from interest rates
- 57:06high rising and people being laid off, companies not doing as
- 57:10well, tax receipts, all of those things.
- 57:12So like, if you don't play the game, you, you basically are
- 57:15like you're, you're done. And so it's just a, it's a crazy
- 57:20like dynamic because there's the the price and that's what
- 57:23everybody gets attracted to. But the thing that they don't
- 57:25realize, and I think it's a big part of like what we're doing
- 57:28here and, and why it's important and where this is the end state
- 57:31for capital formation is you have to adopt A Bitcoin standard
- 57:33is because you're just going to out compete the other person.
- 57:36And it's not enough just to have the standard.
- 57:37You have to have the mindset to like build on it.
- 57:40But that firm is going to go just run laps around everyone
- 57:43else. And then, and then it comes down
- 57:45to, well, what investments are you making?
- 57:46And you better pick the right ones that are going to be able
- 57:49to build for the new world. Like the only thing more finite
- 57:54than that than Bitcoin is literally those humans that get
- 57:56it because the whole world has been full of like the opposite.
- 58:02So it's been like, you know, it's kind of following like not
- 58:05the best to save. It's like, you know, it's kind
- 58:07of the different gender coming to play in a in a game like you
- 58:10just dominate because you're just, it's an unfair game.
- 58:13But what happens when you have to go play with your standard,
- 58:16the individual that you're you're supposed to be playing
- 58:18with? Like when the standard changes,
- 58:19you're just basically like, oh shit, you go from being number
- 58:21one to basically last. And that's kind of this angle of
- 58:25like you're used to deploying dollars, building on dollars,
- 58:28returning dollars, But then you wake up and you're like, wait,
- 58:30wait, the markets actually going to coalesce around the benchmark
- 58:32as Bitcoin. I got to build with this.
- 58:34I have to be constrained in my whether it's capital allocation
- 58:38or business building. And there's very few people on
- 58:40the planet earth today can really like manage that.
- 58:42It will occur recently grow, but that's where we're all that's
- 58:46where this all heads because you have to wash it out, right.
- 58:48All this money has just been like there's been noise there.
- 58:50So you have to reduce it. So it's just going to be a
- 58:53fascinating like 5 to 10 years, that's for sure.
- 58:58Well, I know we're we're coming up on an hour.
- 59:00Any other sort of final thoughts on Liam, you just joining the
- 59:05team or, or anything else that's happened over the past couple
- 59:08weeks? Generally speaking, boys, dude,
- 59:11there's there's there's too much we get on calls and catch up
- 59:14since like, I can barely keep up.
- 59:18I'd flip it to you, Brian. And then maybe I'll think
- 59:20because there's no shortage of like interesting things that
- 59:23have happened since, I would say the beginning of the year.
- 59:27Yeah. I mean, Liam sort of mentioned
- 59:31it is like we, you know, it's hard for us to talk about any of
- 59:35this stuff happening with the new administration without like
- 59:39recognizing that the president of the United States launched a
- 59:42Beam coin. Like that is, I think, just a
- 59:46perfect microcosm of like where we are with the crypto industry.
- 59:50And just the, in my mind, the tacit admission of broader
- 59:55crypto that like, there's no utility here.
- 59:58This is just pure degenerate gambling.
- 1:00:01This is a big casino. And like, Trump launching a meme
- 1:00:04coin is, is sort of like the epitome of of that realization
- 1:00:08of all this stuff from, you know, Ethereum calling
- 1:00:12themselves ultrasound money to, you know, moving away from proof
- 1:00:15of work to prove of stake. Like all of this stuff was
- 1:00:17nonsense. It was all just them trying to
- 1:00:19find new narratives to to sell their altcoin.
- 1:00:24And now they're kind of in the place of sort of just admitting
- 1:00:29like, yeah, you know, this is just gambling.
- 1:00:30Like where, you know, meme coins are, are the thing, you know,
- 1:00:34less and less people are talking about like D5 protocols or NFTS
- 1:00:38or all these other sort of promises made by the crypto
- 1:00:42industry over the past several years.
- 1:00:44And so I think we're at this very interesting juncture where
- 1:00:48on one hand, there's an increasing recognition that, you
- 1:00:52know, Bitcoin is different. And I think the biggest sort of
- 1:00:56signal of that is like ETF adoption, like people sort of
- 1:01:00forget that like they also approved Ethereum ETFs and the
- 1:01:03flows have been like almost non existent to those products.
- 1:01:07I think that's a pretty big signal that at least at the
- 1:01:08institutional level, like what people care about is Bitcoin.
- 1:01:12But at the same time, you have like this continued conflation
- 1:01:16of like the literal president of the United States launching
- 1:01:19Bitcoin. And I guess my hope is like,
- 1:01:23it's so overt, it's so in your face that this is speculative
- 1:01:27that people wake up to the realities of Bitcoin being
- 1:01:29fundamentally different sooner rather than later.
- 1:01:32But that's that's kind of, you know, what's been on my mind the
- 1:01:35past couple weeks is like, I mean, it's first of all, it's
- 1:01:38just wild to to think we're on this timeline.
- 1:01:41If you rewound one year, even two years ago and and told me
- 1:01:45like, you know, not only is the government considering buying
- 1:01:50Bitcoin, but yeah, the president launched a meme coin.
- 1:01:53Like we're just, we're just in an insane timeline right now.
- 1:01:57Yeah, I think broader crypto at large is definitely more.
- 1:02:01So just leaning into gambling is like the narrative, which is
- 1:02:04fine, but I think I just saw a stat yesterday.
- 1:02:09I think out of all of crypto as a whole, Bitcoin is now 62% of
- 1:02:14that. And just because I say that it
- 1:02:16will probably crash, but I ultimately think of Bitcoin more
- 1:02:21as competing with gold, debt, real estate, stocks, anything
- 1:02:26with a monetary premium. Unless you're actually doing the
- 1:02:30real work to evaluate a company yourself or evaluate the asset
- 1:02:35by itself, you're essentially giving it a monetary premium.
- 1:02:39So everybody that just puts their four O 1K into the S&P or
- 1:02:44any similar type index is giving it a massive monetary premium.
- 1:02:48And I think Bitcoin just competes with that moving
- 1:02:51forward more so than traditional crypto.
- 1:02:54Yeah. I think the the thing that's on
- 1:02:57my mind having time to think about it is it's it's somewhat
- 1:03:01related to crypto, but more of like this, this whole multipolar
- 1:03:04world we're heading to. And like Trump's immediate past
- 1:03:07three weeks of like it feels like it ties into a little bit
- 1:03:10of the deep seek stuff of there's no more like exporting
- 1:03:13inflation. I mean, it is going to be
- 1:03:15somewhat, but exporting IEP and all this stuff.
- 1:03:17It's like this realization of wait, now we have to be first
- 1:03:21and be best across national levels.
- 1:03:23So we've seen like what the Columbia, you know, president,
- 1:03:25all where that's going, Mexico, China.
- 1:03:28It's like this version of not only accruing or aggregating
- 1:03:31Bitcoin, but it's aggregating the best talent, the best
- 1:03:33people, the best businesses are going to start to competing
- 1:03:36versus just being able to like, you know, kind of play nice or
- 1:03:40be incentivized to play nice because everyone's playing the
- 1:03:43same game now. Everyone's like, wait, we're not
- 1:03:44going to play the same game anymore.
- 1:03:46We have to think about like national or country 1st.
- 1:03:48And that ultimately goes back to doing more with less, right?
- 1:03:51Because now everybody's incentivized to actually be the
- 1:03:53most efficient and most optimized.
- 1:03:54So it's a very interesting time where that always ends up back
- 1:03:57to like, how do you get more BTC, which is a fascinating
- 1:04:01because our whole lives we've never lived in that world.
- 1:04:04First one, RIP. Excited for this going forward.
- 1:04:07So Brian, what's the deal like we're going to do next?
- 1:04:11Are we going to do with a guest from the industry talk about it?
- 1:04:14Yeah, I think on an alternating basis.
- 1:04:16So in two weeks from now, we'll have an external guest on and
- 1:04:19then two weeks from there, it'll be US3 internal RIP again and
- 1:04:23it'll sort of oscillate back and forth between those formats.
- 1:04:27Yep. And to be a little cliche, like
- 1:04:29this whole funny thing about you can just do things, it's pretty
- 1:04:33funny because you really can. Liam reached out.
- 1:04:36We had a chase, but the one that comes to mind, everyone's shown
- 1:04:39this proof of work. I think about Ralph, who reached
- 1:04:41out when he knew we were working on some stuff and honoring Mina.
- 1:04:44And Ralph's an incredible asset. If you're in the Middle East or
- 1:04:47even anything interested in that region, I'd reach out to him.
- 1:04:50But similar if you're interested in building this space or the
- 1:04:53concepts we're talking about. Like obviously we're going to
- 1:04:56get more and more inbound from across to get interested, to get
- 1:04:58involved in early writers and build, but the you can reach
- 1:05:02out. But the thing that's the
- 1:05:03differentiation and some that William had done extensively and
- 1:05:06Ralph was just proof of work. Like everyone has their unique
- 1:05:09backgrounds and professional experiences.
- 1:05:11And if you can translate that and didn't have to be with us,
- 1:05:14I've always talked to folks wanting to break into the
- 1:05:15Bitcoin industry. It's like they really need you,
- 1:05:18even if they don't have any roles that exist.
- 1:05:19You just have to show what you know and why what they're doing
- 1:05:23could like utilize it. And then if they're a good
- 1:05:26entrepreneur or a good founder, they'll be like, well, of course
- 1:05:28I need that because you just helped me see something that was
- 1:05:30a gap and everyone has them. So I'd encourage anybody that's
- 1:05:33looking at if either sounds captivating or interesting to
- 1:05:36reach out to the folks you look at or admire because there's a
- 1:05:39lot of work that's going to need to be done.
- 1:05:42It's very well said. You can just do things, so do
- 1:05:45it. All right boys, thanks for
- 1:05:49joining us and we'll be back in a couple weeks later.
- 1:05:54Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:05:57If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:05:59episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:06:01app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:06:03today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:06:06Before we finish, a quick reminder that on Ramp Media is
- 1:06:09for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:06:11nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:06:15Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:06:17to hear from you. Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:06:21to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:06:23advisors.