Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Spielworxx Bulletin-The Future of Games
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the most informed board game new show on the Internet, with the
- 0:03beating heart of the German boardgame industry, Uli Blenheman and Sam BLOKEI found slammed
- 0:09outside of a pub in a pool of his own offerings, Ben Meadows.
- 0:13This is the spiel Works, So welcome everybody listening to the Spielworks bulletin.
- 0:20And here I am with the center, the flower, the blooming, the
- 0:26greatest person who have ever graced German boardgaming and at Uli Blenheman, Uli,
- 0:31how are you? I'm fine, Ben, and thank you for this introduction.
- 0:35Thanks for having me. So I'm not sure if a single word is
- 0:39correct or true what you said, but I'm here. Well, if you
- 0:43listen to the five Game for Doomsday Awards episode that as we're recording this came
- 0:48out on the same day Uly, you will hear that you've featured as Steve's
- 0:53game of the Year, his biggest disappointment of the year, his biggest surprise
- 0:57of the year, and the greatest moment of the year. Oh so,
- 1:03and now I have to listen to to that episode for sure. Yeah,
- 1:07well, and all of them. OUI were the same thing. It was
- 1:11you, It was your forehead at Larry in the Laria kon stream that I
- 1:15did last year, And if any of the listeners haven't seen that Laria kon
- 1:19stream, go into my YouTube channel and watch it. Uli is in it
- 1:23quite a bit. Yeah, I remember very well. I think it is
- 1:29a moment. I'm not sure if it's a good moment, but it's a
- 1:33moment. It is a moment without a doubt anyway. So I'm going to
- 1:36do another one this year, so you'll you'll get the opportunity to do exactly
- 1:40the same thing. I will try my very best. It's it's difficult to
- 1:46do it in the same quality. Again. Well, just have a couple
- 1:49of drinks and then you know, you'll erase your memory from last year,
- 1:53so we'll all be fresh, right. So yeah, so I want to
- 2:00talk. We have this section where we talk about the games we've been playing
- 2:06recently, and we haven't spoken to each other for a month or so.
- 2:07But you wanted to talk about a con that you went to in early January,
- 2:12So take it away. Yeah. So it is one. In my
- 2:15opinion, it is one of the nicest cons in a year. It is
- 2:22hosted by Mathias Karma, so the gaming author designer and it's invitation only,
- 2:29so there are about twenty people and then there is not more space for it
- 2:31and it's just for war games or eighteen x x involved. Where is this
- 2:38that's in Bauhum, Germany, so in the rural area, very close to
- 2:43us, very close to Essen, and Matias lives in essence, so probably
- 2:49that's the reason. And it was really lovely so for three days. And
- 2:53the good thing is people have to select the games they want to play in
- 2:59advance, and everybody that's very German, and everybody has to read all the
- 3:06rules. You will not have you will arrange everything before. Yeah, but
- 3:10it makes sense for it because if you have to explain the rules for here
- 3:15I stand or Virgin Queen to all the players, then two hours or three
- 3:21hours are gone and so everybody can start normally right into the game and games.
- 3:29And that was wonderful. So I played personally Napoleon's Conquests, which is
- 3:36a five player game from a small French company, Fellowship of Simulations, and
- 3:42I think the game is over ambitious. It's good, but I doubt that
- 3:49that that it will hold its interest. And the box says two to five,
- 3:54but it's a five player game. That's I was glad having played it
- 3:59first time. It would be my last time that I've played it. On
- 4:02Saturday, I played a two player war game, Enemy Action Karkiv, which
- 4:06was a wonderful, cut driven, excellent game. So I definitely will play
- 4:12this game again. And the game took the whole day and on Sunday we
- 4:17played. And I would like to talk to this game about this game a
- 4:21little bit later in more detail. That was Dune, the game by Peter
- 4:28r. Lotkar and Ion Crewe, which came out by Gale Force nine again
- 4:33in twenty nineteen. And that is a magnificent piece of game. And so
- 4:40tell us about Karma Con. Where is it held, what kind of people
- 4:45are there and sort of what's the vibe like? Is it all sort of
- 4:48old men hunched over chicks? Unfortunately not that has changed. So Baurum,
- 4:55Germany, it's not in a hotel complex. It's more like a use hotel.
- 5:00But everybody is also having breakfast, lunch and dinner over there, so
- 5:05and we are getting coffee, we have to get our other drinks ourselves,
- 5:13which is fine. And it is a very mixed group. So some wargamers
- 5:20are pure wargamers, so as l for example, was being played for one
- 5:26day by two people. But there are also there's Martina Hooks from a jury
- 5:31Game of the Year and some people who prefer to play economic games as well.
- 5:41So it's a real nice wipe there and I enjoyed it tremendously and I'm
- 5:46really grateful that a game that's Mattia's wife and Matias are are organizing this event
- 5:53right at the start of the year. And so you know, Mattias is
- 5:58famous for his Midway Yara, you know, Rococo Lancaster. But do you
- 6:01think his real is real passion is heavier wargames? I think so, yes,
- 6:09eighteen xx season, he's playing eighteen xx for thirty years and he's in
- 6:14a real expert Don't be at the same table if you want to play eighteen
- 6:18xx as Matias is, because he will crush you. And also a war
- 6:24games, so Matias played on one day with the Malta they played Downfall,
- 6:30a GMT war game from Europe forty two to forty five, so just two
- 6:34player war game which some nice euro mechanics included. But yeah, I think
- 6:41his real passion is this. But he has a broad range of interests in
- 6:46gaming, and I think he's one of the he's one of the best eurogame
- 6:49designers. I yeah, for sure, and he's he's really excellent. So
- 6:58so tell us about Doom then, because Steve keeps trying to convince me to
- 7:01play this and I always say the same thing, which is, I'm not
- 7:04playing some crappy nineteen seventies design that's completely unbalanced in TXs forever, So tell
- 7:10me, tell me I'm you're wrong. So that is a short answer,
- 7:15long answer. So I bought the game in twenty nineteen, late to twenty
- 7:19nineteen when I had met in person Peter Olotka. And Peter Olotka is quite
- 7:26a character. He's wonderful, and he had a seminar I think at Bggicon
- 7:33or tabletop Networking about how they started the company Eon in the seventies. So
- 7:43the interesting thing is there were hardly any games apart from Monopoly or Risk and
- 7:47all this stuff, and they said, well, we can do better without
- 7:53any real knowledge about the industry, and they did Cosmic Encounter, which is
- 7:59still going strong. They did Dune for Avalon Hill, and they did Hoax,
- 8:05and Hoax is the first game of the Hidden Traitor series. So can
- 8:11I a reprint? Came I sort of five or six years ago. I
- 8:15think so too. And when I'm saying he's quite a character, some people
- 8:20are complaining Cosmic Encounter that's unbalanced, some races in there are unbalanced. And
- 8:28he's in a podcast, in a famous podcast at Ludology. In an episode
- 8:33a couple of years ago, he said a balance is for weenies. So
- 8:37so they simply they say, a game of Cosmic Encounter, it's self balancing
- 8:43at the table and June. The interesting thing is the game does not feel
- 8:50like a seventies game. It feels really fresh. Yeah, in a six
- 8:56player game, combat between just two factions can be a little bit long,
- 9:03could be streamlined, but the game is wonderful. So I'm not a Dune
- 9:07expert. So I've I read the books forty years ago and didn't even see
- 9:13the movie. Yeah, the movies the movie is quite good. The movie
- 9:18is quite good. But got the books. Yeah, at least on the
- 9:22as I said, I didn't see the movie, but the books I wasn't
- 9:24grabbed. But the game is grabbing you. It's asymmetric, so each faction
- 9:30has a different victory conditions. The sandworms are there, the storms are there,
- 9:35and what is really interesting how the characters on the table behave so it
- 9:41is and sometimes for two game routes, I couldn't do a lot. I
- 9:45lost the combat, but then I came back into the game again and you
- 9:48are forming alliances, so really good. The only thing and what was your
- 9:54what was your faction? I played the I played Hardkonen. I played Hardkon
- 10:00and so I'm I'm pretty good. That's a very early yeah, but I
- 10:05think it was horandomly handed out. But I like them so because they can
- 10:09attack, they are they are pretty powerful there and not subtle. So that
- 10:16was good for me. And another thing that that is most interesting is that
- 10:22the box says one hundred and twenty minutes playing time and two to six two
- 10:28to six. It's a six player game. Period. It's a six player
- 10:33game. And we played for more than six hours, so you see,
- 10:37if you're saying, well, this is too long, I can understand.
- 10:41But for such a convention, for a single day, it's a wonderful game.
- 10:46And I have to say, I'm I'm so surprised how good games could
- 10:54be designed in the seventies or late seventies and I think Fantasy Flight redids the
- 11:00game once as Rex because they didn't have the life runs. But this game
- 11:05is Everybody who has a chance to have a six player group and a full
- 11:11day to play this should give it. Give it a try, even if
- 11:15you're not a Dune fan like myself, and if you are a Dune fan,
- 11:18and we had several Dune fans on the table, everybody was wonderful.
- 11:22This is this is great. Yeah, I keep getting I will play it
- 11:28at some point, but it's just the thought of playing it for six hours
- 11:31doesn't appeal. So I want to talk now about a game. We recorded
- 11:37our awards show at the beginning of the week, and one of the comments
- 11:41I chose was from a listener on the discord who said that this game not
- 11:46only was the worst game of the year, but they were embarrassed. Wow
- 11:50for the spielders yr as people. Wow for voting for this one. And
- 11:54this is what I played last week and I played it again last night,
- 11:58and this is challenging. Have you played Child? No, actually not,
- 12:01I have it, but I've heard that it's better with larger groups, so
- 12:07with up to eight. So I never played it. I can just say
- 12:11that I like the company people so very very much. They are lovely so.
- 12:16But the game, in your opinion, is not good, fat absolutely
- 12:22fat so. But some other I was. I was, I was really
- 12:26surprised. So it is a game. It's a game of wars, and
- 12:31you know, you flip over a card and who's got the highest card?
- 12:35But the way that they've built around that is really clever. There are real
- 12:39decisions to be made, and the decisions to be made are essentially in building
- 12:43your deck, right, And we played it last night with a full player
- 12:48kind of eight and it's a real So I guess the best way to describe
- 12:54it is it's and I think it's quite original in this and I think that's
- 12:58why I was so excited. It's a strategy party game. Ah okay,
- 13:03Right, Party games are really are silly and fun and they're often occasions.
- 13:07Right. You often remember playing a big party game, but you don't remember
- 13:13the amazing mechanical interactions or the strategy, and you don't remember doing something which
- 13:18makes you think, ah, I outthought my opponent on this and all that
- 13:22sort of stuff, where whereas this one has the character of a party game.
- 13:28You know, you play a tournament of eight people. You play everybody
- 13:31who's playing the game over the course of the game, and it has that
- 13:35sort of party vibe. It's a lot of fun, but also there are
- 13:39decisions. It's a real game. There are decisions to be made, and
- 13:41so I was really like, is it the best game in the world.
- 13:45Absolutely not, But it's a very original game and it's a great fun game.
- 13:50And I think for something like I think most of us in the gaming
- 13:56world would hope that the Kennishpiel would be a little heavier, right, The
- 14:01Kennerspiel and the Spielders Yours feel very light. I mean, the Spielders Yours
- 14:05feels almost like it's at this point. But the Spielders Yars isn't for us,
- 14:13is it. No, the Spielders Yars is a marketing thing, right
- 14:16for the gaming industry, and so and so a game like this that gives
- 14:22you decisions to make but also gives you an event. Playing this game is
- 14:28an event, I think is a really good indicator of kind of what games
- 14:33can be and why games are exciting. Yeah, but then it's a Then
- 14:37Challengers is a success. If it achieved this, then for me, to
- 14:41me, this sounds like a big success. Yeah, absolutely, no.
- 14:48I think I think as a game it's it's successful. I think it is.
- 14:50I think it is really good. And I think once you because the
- 14:54point is when you play against the person, you just shuffle your deck and
- 14:58you don't get to look at it and you just flip cards over right,
- 15:01And people are really pissed off by that. Gamers are really pissed off by
- 15:05that because they're sort of like, oh, I don't get to do anything.
- 15:09But the point is you've made the decisions before them, You've built a
- 15:13deck, and then you just let the deck run and you hope that your
- 15:16decisions that you've made previously then bear act right. And I think once you
- 15:22get over like I played it with Steve two weeks in a row, and
- 15:26last week he wasn't very happy at all, and I think last night he
- 15:30sort of clicked, oh, there are decisions to be made here, and
- 15:31he was much more in favor of it. And I think once you get
- 15:35over that, over that hump, then you know it's a really enjoyable game.
- 15:39I was really surprised. I really enjoyed it excellent. So yeah,
- 15:45basically I heard very good things about it, and without having played the game.
- 15:50Of course, what I think is flipping over a card. Yeah,
- 15:54it feels like no decision, but it's also, as you said, if
- 16:00you preset your deck, but it's also a very easy decision. So it's
- 16:03people are used in in traditional card games to flip over some cards. Yeah,
- 16:07and this connection is also clever. So and and you know what,
- 16:14people don't realize. They think, oh, I'm just flipping over the card.
- 16:15It's just chance, and it's like, that's not true. You're playing
- 16:18the odds, you're building your deck. You're building your deck to put chance
- 16:23onto your side, right. Yeah, And maybe for a future episode here
- 16:30we should talk about luck, chance, randomness and it's risk management because lots
- 16:37of people think everything is luck, everything is this. No, it is
- 16:42not. It is really not. It's absolutely and I don't think I mean,
- 16:47there is chance in Steve last night built this brilliant deck, but if
- 16:52it didn't come out in the right order, and he made sure that there
- 16:56was the possibility of you know, it was fairly sort of lose either side,
- 17:02but if it didn't come in the right order, you could lose,
- 17:04he could lose the game. But if it came out in the right order,
- 17:07he would destroy someone very quickly, you know, And so it's mitigating
- 17:11that chance. There are decisions to be made, and I was super impressed.
- 17:15Yeah, and to me, a game without a chance element is not
- 17:18a real game without within exceptions of course, and your description sounds it's also
- 17:26risk management. You're building your desk and seeing this can work out and then
- 17:30I'm crushing my opponent. It can really misfire, but then it's your fault.
- 17:37Maybe. Yeah. And it was so nice being at the spielers Ers
- 17:41Award ceremony last year to see how happy they were two of one. Nice
- 17:45nice people, really nice people. They deserve it. And this is fantastic
- 17:49to hear that you are enjoying the game so much. Now I have to
- 17:53grab my copy and play it. Well, we'll play it at Leriac Wonderful
- 17:57One. It takes forty five minutes to play, so we can play it
- 18:00at Laurie Wonderful. So you have to bring your copy. I'm sure they
- 18:06have it there, don't they. Yeah, I am English language. They
- 18:08should have it. Yeah, yeah, excellent, Right, Should we move
- 18:11on to the next Yes, please, let's do this in act cross self
- 18:15promotion. Uli blennem Guts of the German board game industry will tell you what's
- 18:21happening in Worth, all right, so OULI, this is where you get
- 18:26to tell us everything about your company. So let's start off actually with the
- 18:33crowdfunding campaign for Caroling. How is that going? It's slow, It is
- 18:38really slow, but it's it's not the most important gaming event of this year.
- 18:45And we will make the game. Peter and I we are enjoying it
- 18:49doing this together, so it will work out. There are a couple of
- 18:53days. More so, if you are interested in listening this, please check
- 18:56out the game found campaign of cow. It's a great two to six player
- 19:02game set in the ninth century, and the game has a competitive variant and
- 19:07is Carld Gohls exactly Carldim Gaulsen. And to say, my cooperative version as
- 19:12well. So there's a lot in the box. And if you want to
- 19:17hear me speak German, you can watch one of the videos that's up there
- 19:21right in which in which I speak Germany, yes, with an Austrian accent,
- 19:25but that accent is lovely, so I have to say it's a nice
- 19:30act. So why should why should people why should people get Karl? If
- 19:33there yeah, there are several reasons for it. So I in my opinion,
- 19:37it has great production values, but nowadays lots of games have great production
- 19:42values. But it is one of the games that scales very well for from
- 19:48two to six players. So it's not that the box says two to six
- 19:52and you know it only plays well with five or like Dune I mentioned earlier,
- 19:56it is a six player game, although the box says two to six,
- 20:02and of course it is. It was done by a historian, so
- 20:06it was very deep in this topic. So it is definitely not a simulation.
- 20:14But it has a nice action selection mechanic that is true to the age,
- 20:19and it's not area majority, and we have lots of combat. Yes,
- 20:23there is combat, but the game ends in peace. So it's a
- 20:27truly unique, truly unique game. So I think Sebastian and because of the
- 20:33true designers, they made a wonderful packaging. And what is the So you've
- 20:40started a new company with Peter Eggert, Yes, what is the what is
- 20:44the idea for the new company? Yeah, actually that the company was formed
- 20:48to do Peter's a second edition of Peter's first game, which was Duna Vatren
- 20:53and done in the eighties. In a print run of one hundred and fifty
- 21:00copies. Okay, and that's a horse race because Peter is a horse racer.
- 21:06He has his own horses, and that is done at the North Sea
- 21:11coast. But so when the what the tides are going back and forth,
- 21:18so some of the races and if you are at the not in the center
- 21:22of the racing ground, you're already in water. And so it's and it's
- 21:27only one race once a year. And he made a game out of this,
- 21:33and of course the game and we wanted to do a new edition of
- 21:37this, but the game is from the eighties and when I'm saying June has
- 21:44aged very well, Dona Vatren has not. So it has to be totally
- 21:52redone and that takes a lot of time, especially because Peter, of course
- 21:56isn't working on the game five hours a day. And so Peter got introduced
- 22:03to Carolini because the two designers are also from Hamburg, his home city,
- 22:07and that's why we decided to do this game. And then we are doing
- 22:11Donavatrn and then probably that's it. So tell us then also, what else
- 22:18can we get from spiel Works if we go to is it Spielworks dot ds
- 22:23exactly. It Spillworks dot E. And on one hand, what surprises me
- 22:30but maybe it does not surprise me that much is how strong Weima is still
- 22:36going. It's not brand new. It came out in September October, and
- 22:41speed Works is only having the German edition of this game. English is by
- 22:45Capstone, so please check out Capstone's website for the English edition. And it's
- 22:49a four our, four player, six hour game and it costs I think
- 22:56about one hundred and thirty but still there are nice and healthy sales for this
- 23:03game, so well, I think it's one of those new wave of wargames
- 23:07right exactly, So it looks good, the componentre is good, it's from
- 23:12it's from an established eurogame designer, so I think people are curious to see
- 23:17what Mattias Kramer is going to do with the war. I agree, but
- 23:22still it surprises me in some ways. But it's it's nice and there will
- 23:27be also editions in other languages, so there will be a Spanish edition,
- 23:33there will be a Korean edition of the game, so really fantastic. And
- 23:40then Raising Chicago, that's matt Wolf's second entry in the Urban Evolution series that
- 23:48should go on pre order in May from Spielworks, so we are basically done
- 23:52with the game, so probably May in the summer, early summer, we
- 23:57will have Dolcissima Vita by John Simone Migoni, an Italian designer for pre order,
- 24:07and that's a game in the fifties and sixties of Italy, so with
- 24:11lots of events, but it tells you also the early history of Italy after
- 24:17the Second World War because they had a kind of Viaschaftswunda. That's an economic
- 24:22miracle, economic madam like like in Germany, maybe on a slightly lesser scale,
- 24:27and mainly in northern Italy as well. So that's a fantastic economic game
- 24:33we are doing. And of course main work right now, we are finishing
- 24:37epos again this game by Chefan Ristous and this will go to crowd funding in
- 24:45late April. And this game, I'm really excited for this one. So
- 24:51the base game, the base mechanics are fantastic, but it has eight scenarios
- 24:55two campaign games in addition, so so really outstanding work. And and the
- 25:00plan is for this to be out of Yeah, that's a plan to have
- 25:04it at Essen and let's see what the because it will be manufactured in China.
- 25:11What the sea roots across Africa or if it's going through the sewers canal?
- 25:18So yeah, interesting times, interesting times. That's the Chinese curse,
- 25:23isn't it. May you live in interesting times. It is so many things
- 25:30that we cannot control, which probably is a good thing though that we cannot
- 25:36control things. Anyway, this is not the Spielworks politics discussion, so we'll
- 25:42move on, Yes we will. Do you like informed opinions on board game
- 25:47topics that are important to you, then don't listen to then it's our topic
- 25:52of the week. All right, So this is our topic of the week.
- 25:56And I thought, as it's the first month of the year, and
- 25:59I've done on my podcast and I've also done it on my YouTube channel,
- 26:03why not flog this dead horse far past its death. We want to talk
- 26:07about sort of the previous year and then what you see in the upcoming year,
- 26:14right from a sort of publisher's perspective. So first of all, very
- 26:18sort of broad question, but what trends did you see in twenty twenty three?
- 26:23I'm not even sure if I saw a real trends. Definitely, games
- 26:30with animals I saw quite a few, right, And what do you think
- 26:34is this just trying to cash in on the Wingspan thing. I mean,
- 26:37it's been quite a long time since Wingspan. Yes, it is maybe because
- 26:42people are seeing that that's interesting topic or a topic that sells well. But
- 26:49maybe it is also the state of our society because people want to have something
- 27:00that is nice and cute and bright colors, and because we are we had
- 27:06the COVID crisis, or we are having a COVID crisis, then we have
- 27:11the war and the Russian warf aggression in the Ukraine, we have the Near
- 27:15East War, and so maybe this is such a nice topic and we do
- 27:22not have to think about the right yeah, about what's really going on.
- 27:29So could be well, what I see, I think it's really fascinating.
- 27:33I think it's a really fascinating trend in society. The people in their in
- 27:37their sort of arts that they want to consume, don't want things that are
- 27:41challenging, don't want things that are you know, the look at things from
- 27:48particular viewpoints. They want stuff that's pleasant and easy. And yet they're ripping
- 27:52each other apart on social media every day. It's not that people don't want
- 27:57confrontation, they just don't seem to want it in their art right, which
- 28:02I think is which I think is all in their own walls. So but
- 28:08if you can shout to somebody that who's anonymous somewhere in anti social media,
- 28:18then it's fine. Then it's fine. Yeah, And it is indeed a
- 28:22very true observation and also a stranger observation because I think it's absolutely correct.
- 28:30Yeah. And you know, I was looking on Twitter and someone said the
- 28:33other day that people were complaining about the animal themes, and yet they were
- 28:37saying, I can guarantee there's a thousand economic games set in Europe that have
- 28:42been published last year. I mean, do you think do you think the
- 28:45whole animal theme thing is a complaint worth making? I guess my complaint about
- 28:52it is kind of what you said. I'm kind of fed up of this
- 28:56idea that board games don't tackle the world as it is, but it very
- 29:02soft and very very sort of protective fantasy land in which the I guess my
- 29:11biggest issue is it reinforces this idea that games of a kid and that bothers.
- 29:17I agree one hundred percent. And I think that statement was made by
- 29:23Eric Lang, and of course he's true. There are more economic games,
- 29:30more wargames. There are more games about trading in the Mediterranean, probably than
- 29:36animals theme games. But I think or I was hoping that gaming as an
- 29:44art form has advanced further than this. For me, who's in this industry
- 29:49for such a long time, it feels like we are now back in the
- 29:53eighties or seventies, our animals and smiling people, and that's what we want,
- 30:00No, I want more. Games are so much more, and so
- 30:06that's why I'm not sure if it's a good thing, and I'm not sure
- 30:10if it's a trend, but for me, it was an observation. Another
- 30:14trend, in my opinion, is that anything goes. So we have monster
- 30:18games, we have games for people six hours like Weimar that are selling.
- 30:25We have small games, large games, we have still deck builders, we
- 30:29have cut driven games. So anything is there. There is something for everybody.
- 30:36But I must admit I'm not following the gaming scene that closely. I
- 30:42try to focus on this on the games that I'm interested in, and even
- 30:48among them, I'm not playing all of them. So and so, how
- 30:52do you think twenty twenty three was is a year for games? I think
- 30:56if I've been trying to decide myself whether it was a good year. I
- 31:00all on the side of thinking it was maybe a very average year can be
- 31:03for from my observation, I didn't play that many euro games because I again
- 31:10I have to say, in most I had zero interest. I had zero
- 31:15interest, and I played a few of the very hyped games euro type games,
- 31:23and afterwards I said, I don't have to play this game again.
- 31:27But other people, the other people on the table, they were enthused about
- 31:32the games. They loved it. So it may be telling you more about
- 31:37me than about the quality of the of the game. Did you play Plant
- 31:44a Nuba? Not yet? Not yet, because there was a big hypo
- 31:48essence for that, and I'm curious to see. Yeah, I have to
- 31:52say so, first I love order, so who's involved in this game?
- 31:57And I'm one percent sure without having played it, that it is mechanically excellent
- 32:05because Oder and then there you have Wolsenberg and Mike Keller. That is a
- 32:09fantastic combination. So it will be mechanically a great game. But here again,
- 32:15now we are getting back to animals. There are no animals in the
- 32:19game, or that maybe, but it's a world, it's a it's a
- 32:22future but not a dystopian but everything is fine, and the theme and I'm
- 32:30coming often from the theme did not grab me at all, so so no,
- 32:37I didn't play that one, So maybe it was an average game sales
- 32:45wise. I think it was pretty good. Here we have to see some
- 32:52numbers here, but still quite a few companies are thinking in terms of twenty
- 32:59and twenty one, the COVID years, which brought record years, and then
- 33:04we got a decline in twenty two, but still on good numbers if you
- 33:08compare them to twenty eighteen and nineteen. So it's also very difficult. It
- 33:15depends on the expectations of a company, as Moore might be our Embrace our
- 33:20group might be unhappy with some of the sales quarters of last year. For
- 33:24other companies, of course they would say, wow, this is fantastic,
- 33:29So very difficult. Do you think optimism is a dangerous trait in a game
- 33:34publisher? In the you know you have you're a publisher, and you publish
- 33:38a game and it does very well, and something in the COVID year itself
- 33:42far out of out of expectations, and then you see a lot of people
- 33:45they go, Okay, now I'm going to hire two full time graphic designers,
- 33:50and I'm going to hire a full time artist and blah blah blah,
- 33:52blah blah. And you know, two years down the road they're like,
- 33:57oh my god, I can't pay all of these people. Do you think
- 34:00think optimism is an issue within the publishing game publishing industry. I think it
- 34:02is definitely an issue, and I think it is an issue everywhere in the
- 34:08economic world. Why it may be a little bit more dangerous in gaming is
- 34:15most of the people, including me, are not business people, are not
- 34:20businessmen. So yes, we are often driven by what we like or what
- 34:27we think should be successful, and in the end, only a fraction of
- 34:32these games are really successful, and it can be dangerous. And on the
- 34:39other hand, in book and game publishing, you need to have a certain
- 34:45number of new releases each year because you are hoping let's say you're doing ten
- 34:52games or ten books, You're hoping two will be best sellers. Probably out
- 34:58of the other eight too will do okay, and six are not selling it
- 35:02at all, But the two best sellers still mean that you are in the
- 35:07end of the year, you are very happy at a healthy year. But
- 35:09if you have zero best sellers, then you are having a big problem.
- 35:17So yeah, I think the gaming industry is optimism driven, but it's also
- 35:22still a conservative industry I think. And so now, twenty twenty three was
- 35:30a landmark year for one reason. The I mean, I don't know if
- 35:37I I don't know if the English language can fully describe it. But the
- 35:42greatest ever promo for a game was probablished, right absolutely, I mean it
- 35:50stunds. In twenty years, we'll look back and say there's a there's a
- 35:53pre Cafe mcnal time and a post Cafe canal time. Absolutely absolutely, and
- 36:01I would sorry for interrupting, I would enter that game promo whatever it's called,
- 36:09game series. I would enter it as Kids Game of the Year,
- 36:14Family plus experts. So because it's fitting in all three categories. Has it
- 36:20ever happened that a game has won all three of one? Not yet,
- 36:23but I think some game has to start. So yeah, yeah, exactly,
- 36:30and so obviously because on the back of publishing the greatest promo ever designed
- 36:34for a game ever, Spielworks must have done incredibly well just on that.
- 36:38But how did Spielworks do? How was twenty twenty three as a year?
- 36:44It was a good year. It was a really good year. But what
- 36:47is interesting is that spiel Works hardly ever had these ups and downs because I'm
- 36:55normally capping my print runs, so I didn't have record years in COVID.
- 37:02But twenty two was not a bad year for me or twenty three. So
- 37:07it is very difficult if you look at the sales of Spielworks to see,
- 37:14ah, great speed works here must be a great year of the industry can
- 37:16be totally opposite. So and do you think your key is that you have
- 37:22the right amount of ambition? Could be? It could be, And at
- 37:29least I'm willing to look at topics that nobody else, nobody else will ever
- 37:36touch. And I think that's what I'm meaning when I said a couple of
- 37:40minutes ago the gaming industry is also conservative. I'm not meaning this in a
- 37:45political way, but they are doing the same thing over and over, and
- 37:52let's simply do something new. It might be a failure, but of course
- 37:57doing just a thousand copies, and if the game fails for whatever reason,
- 38:02it's not a huge loss. You will still do ocage and at least you
- 38:08have tried it. And we are still talking about advancing the art and advancing
- 38:15the art in gaming. We want to see gaming become a real cultural thing
- 38:21and not some you some some fun whatever fun is. And I'm not saying
- 38:28that the majority of these games shouldn't be just fun. That's fine. Not
- 38:34every game can be a Weimar, right, I mean, do you think
- 38:37this is a this is this is a fundamental this is a fundamental attitude different
- 38:43between German German game people and American game people because the Germany and America are
- 38:51the two big gaming countries and the Schpielziarras award ceremony and you can say what
- 38:55you like, whether you think the games are too like, but there was
- 38:59always this, They always referring to games as a cultural artifact, that the
- 39:04context of games was as a part of culture, and Americans seemed to When
- 39:10I speak to American game publishers, they seem very focused on it being a
- 39:16commercial form. That it's about that you have that you can debate the artistic
- 39:24merits of Wormspan, but that's not important because fundamentally it's going to sell loads
- 39:30and that's the base. That's the base thing for judging whether a game is
- 39:35successful or not. Do you think it's an attitudinal shift between the two countries.
- 39:37I'm not sure. I'm definitely not sure. I have to think a
- 39:40lot longer. I think the question is most interesting, but I do not
- 39:45have an answer for this. You could also say that Americans the US didn't
- 39:53have a long gaming history. They had ever long hill, They had walgame
- 40:00games, and they had of course D and D and fantasy role playing in
- 40:04the seventies, but not much else. That's why the eurotype games, or
- 40:08at that time German type games came over to the US. But in my
- 40:15opinion, at least American designers are tackling more difficult subjects, and not only
- 40:22in war gaming. But yeah, of course some of these companies are thinking
- 40:30just in commercial terms. But I guess it's the same over here with USMODI
- 40:35and with others. And if you have to pay all these checks at the
- 40:40start of the months for all your employees, you better be very commercial and
- 40:45make sure that you have the money paying these bills. And then if you
- 40:50have ten viomas in your catalog and nothing else, I'm not sure if you
- 40:54can pay these bills, right. And so what do you see coming up
- 41:02for twenty twenty four? Do you what do you think will stay the same.
- 41:07What do you think will change in the next year. I think there
- 41:09will be even more games, because as I said, it's very difficult to
- 41:16predict which games itself, so you better make sure that you're having a nice
- 41:21catalog hoping for So do you think it's an ethos of throw shit against the
- 41:25wall and so you will stay Yeah. I think this is very true in
- 41:29the publishing industry, not only in gaming, but also in the book trade.
- 41:34So I'm sure and yes, some companies will try to do less games,
- 41:44but it is very It can be very dangerous if your few games aren't
- 41:49selling. So I think more games, and again I see lots of games
- 41:54that try to follow a perceived trend, so more of the same and more
- 42:04IP games, so from movies, from books, and of course from video
- 42:09games. So I think that we'll see more of that and again, easy
- 42:15games, so get into them in five minutes, complete them in forty five
- 42:21minutes. That will be also true for the future because everybody or most people
- 42:27have a demanding life, so it is easy to set aside. It is
- 42:31not easy to set aside six hours to complete a BioMA. And what do
- 42:37you think of a company like Trick or treat studios that are sort of there.
- 42:43Their strategy is sort of twofold, it seems to me. Firstly it's
- 42:46IP games and then secondly it's commissioning. Commissioning well known designers to design games
- 42:55around their particular theme. But the idea is they're all based around one sort
- 43:00of central core concept, which is horror game. Yeah it is. It
- 43:06can work out. So first, it makes sense to have an IP for
- 43:12a game because some people already know it and maybe fans so they may buy
- 43:16it. So yes, But on the other hand, ipis cost a ton
- 43:21of money, so you have to have a larger print run, and having
- 43:25experienced designers is of course helpful. I doubt that too many people know designers
- 43:34or will buy everything from certain designers. Yes, that may be true for
- 43:40true gamers. Are there's a new karma kysling. I buy it, but
- 43:45I don't think that it's that important. But what experienced designer will assure that
- 43:52he will work according to professional standards. So if you give them a bad
- 43:58line we need this in six months, you will most likely have something in
- 44:02six months. So it's easier to work with these people, which makes sense
- 44:07because normally in an ip game. You have a license for three years,
- 44:12and if a designer needs two and a half years to have the core design
- 44:16in place, then it can be also difficult. But yeah, very difficult
- 44:23if such a company has lots of success over a couple of years. And
- 44:30when I think of a new sort of business model. Now you may tell
- 44:35me I'm talking out of my ass that this is new, but it seems
- 44:37new to me. It is someone like Fantasia Games, right, in which
- 44:43they come up with the concept of the game before they have a designer attached
- 44:49to it, and then they take that concept to the designer unconscious mind.
- 44:53As an example, the new version of Colosseum is an example. Do you
- 45:00think this is something we'll see more in the future? Studios cropping up that
- 45:06have their own core concepts and they take on designers to work on concepts that
- 45:12are suggested to this some more sort of commission based idea than designers pitching games
- 45:19to them. I think we will see more of this in the future because
- 45:24you can form your company or see I need this and this in a more
- 45:30easy way. It's not new. When I was working at Farlanx at the
- 45:35start of the century, we did the same thing, and we commissioned Leo
- 45:38Colovini to do a game on the Julip bubble in the Netherlands. It was
- 45:45a Dutch company, so it made sense, but it did not work out.
- 45:49Yeah, he designed the game and we published the game. But on
- 45:52the other hand, the designer's hard wasn't in because it was commissioned thing.
- 46:00So I think it can work, but it is also dangerous. Again.
- 46:07Nowadays we are having way more professional designers, so it could be easier to
- 46:15achieve results nowadays than maybe twenty years ago when there were mainly hobby designers out
- 46:21there. And so are you excited for anything coming in twenty twenty four?
- 46:25And this can be across all genres in so for instance, I think this
- 46:31year the science fiction coin game is coming out Red Dusty Rebellion, and I'm
- 46:38incredibly excited for that because i love sort of sci fi and fantasy and I'm
- 46:46looking forward to a coin game that is a little less sober than the other
- 46:52world. Is there anything you you're excited about? Definitely also something into GMT
- 46:58catalog. I'm one hundred percent sure there's a game coming out on the Congress
- 47:01of Vienna, So I'm interested in this one. More card driven games.
- 47:09I'm interested in the professional edition of Lent and Freedom by which is coming out
- 47:15by four Circle. We played this game in the in the evening twice at
- 47:21the Matias Karma con and everybody and nobody had played it before and everybody loved
- 47:27it. So I want to have more of this with somewhat better components.
- 47:36I'm looking forward to Blackbeard as well. Yes, it could be. It
- 47:39could be also really a really a good game. But you know, I'm
- 47:45old. I'm not that excited easily. I'm not easily excited on games.
- 47:52But if I see it, if I played, then this can also change
- 48:00easily. And what are you excited for in twenty twenty four as kind of
- 48:07events, things you're going to attend, things that are going to happen.
- 48:12Are there any sort of in person events you're excited? Yeah? I have
- 48:15two in my minds in the first four months. So first of course will
- 48:21be a Laria in Portugal, which will be wonderful and there are so many
- 48:25great people attending it, and the atmosphere, as you know, Ben is
- 48:30simply lovely March at the Atlantic, It's fantastic. And also the convention has
- 48:37the right size in my opinion. So yeah, I'm excited for that.
- 48:42And then months later I will attend my second gathering of friends in the US.
- 48:47So I'm not excited about the traveling to it, to the Niagara Falls,
- 48:53and ah, I'm not sure I will enjoy this in economy class in
- 48:59the place eight but in the planes. But there are about three hundred and
- 49:05fifty people gamers. And also over there there's a fantastic atmosphere and they play
- 49:12from the start of the morning till midnight or longer. And you and it's
- 49:19a very from what I remember. I think I attended in twenty eighteen,
- 49:23maybe seventeen. It's also a very inviting convention. So you're looking at a
- 49:30table and there is a place open. They will tell you. They won't
- 49:34stare at you. They will tell you do you want to play? I
- 49:36love that because I can then decline no, not this game, what's that?
- 49:42And with you no, I'm not playing this rubbish, this rubbish,
- 49:45And then on top of you, with you guys here, no and so
- 49:50and so, just to rub a section up. Then how optimistic are you
- 49:53for twenty twenty four is a gaming year. I think it will be a
- 49:59pretty good year. So of course, there are so many things we cannot
- 50:05determine, but that's why I leave them out of anything. So we do
- 50:12not know what the Near East conflict. Will it stay as a Near East
- 50:15conflict, but we cannot really we do not know what will happen in the
- 50:20future. But looking at the games and what companies are planning, are pretty
- 50:23excited and I think it will be a really solid gaming year twenty four.
- 50:34Excellent. Well, let's move on to the next section then, now the
- 50:37big toe of the German board gaming industry, Ulie Bladamm, will regale you
- 50:42with all right, so, Ouli, this is sort of broadly actually sort
- 50:50of thematically connected to the absolutely where you were sort of talking in the last
- 50:54section about a lot of animal games, and essentially I think what you were
- 50:59saying that there is a sort of stagnation in terms of development, and you
- 51:06were sort of saying that, I think you were implying that people are trying
- 51:14to rather than determine what people will like in six months, they're pitching to
- 51:22where people are standing right now. Yes, and that that is as you've
- 51:29written in the notes, that's that's following trends it's not setting them. So
- 51:32I mean you as a you, as a publisher, how do you how
- 51:36do you set trends rather than follow. I'm not that important. Shpieedworks cannot
- 51:44set trends, I think so. But what we try to do from time
- 51:49to time is at least bring games to the table that are really different.
- 51:53For example, of the cost the game about asbestos, and you will have
- 51:58mat Sick Girls by the say designers, which is on strikes in Britain with
- 52:02the girls and women who were doing the matches and match boxes, which in
- 52:08a toxic environment, which is a very unusual and great gain. But I
- 52:16doubt that I can set trends. And again you have to see if you're
- 52:21running a company with let's say ten twenty fifty employees, and if you just
- 52:25try to reinvent the wheel and advance the art, for that may be the
- 52:32easiest way to ruin the company, because if nothing works, you're done.
- 52:38So I understand why you try to follow trends, but in my opinion,
- 52:45it is of course superior to set new trends. And there was a book
- 52:53editor in last year from the Brook Book Trade who said the main miss take
- 53:00in the book industry right now? Is that in the novel book industry that
- 53:07we try in Germany, he said, we try to have readers pick up
- 53:16where they are already are, So it doesn't make any sense. It would
- 53:21be better to pick up the readers and bring them to new places that they
- 53:25have not discovered. So I think that is much superior. And from companies
- 53:34that have a certain size, so a certain impact pact in the hobby.
- 53:38Let's say feuer Land, who are having quite a bit of money with Archnover
- 53:47and some other companies, they could give it a try, And so I
- 53:53think it. I think it's interesting that you were talking about earlier, and
- 53:58I think so, never more are people in terms of what they want to
- 54:06consume in terms of art. Never more are they more conservative than when the
- 54:12world itself is in an insecure place, right Because so when I think back
- 54:17to you know, theater and novels of the nineties, in the early two
- 54:22thousands, it felt people felt more adventurous, it felt more challenging. And
- 54:29the reason for that is the art still fundamentally is a recreation for most people,
- 54:36right The people who consume are and it's a recreation. And when you're
- 54:40constantly seeing the Israel Garza conflict, the war in Russia, the ongoing environmental
- 54:47disaster, the possibility of fucking Trump being back in the White House. You
- 54:52know, I think people when they're on their time off, they just think,
- 54:57I need can't think about this shit. And so I think there is
- 55:04an issue with taking people to new places. We've seen in the last decade
- 55:09every blockbuster is a comic book film. And it's not because comic book films
- 55:15are incredibly superior art. It's just because they're very familiar. The good is
- 55:19the bad is good is when bad is lose, And that's an insecurity that
- 55:23we it's something that we know when we go and see this movie, that
- 55:30we're not going to be challenged and we're not going to be stressed because the
- 55:31whole rest of the world is so bloody stressful. So do you think we
- 55:36live in a time where it's difficult to take people to new places because they
- 55:40just don't want to go there. Yeah? I think so. I think
- 55:43your description is absolutely correct, and I would agree or I'm agreeing with you
- 55:50one hundred percent. And you even seeing this in furniture. I saw on
- 55:53an an article a couple of days or I read it a couple of days
- 55:59ago. But the sofa couches so far as they are now more roundish,
- 56:05so they are not because it feels more cozy. So even if you want
- 56:09everything nice and cozy in your own home. And I think this is a
- 56:16trend, we are seeing that's and that's why it's easy. When spied works
- 56:22tiny speed Works is saying, well, well set new trends don't follow trends.
- 56:28But for larger companies who have to pay their bills their checks, it
- 56:32is of course a risk. And do we want to take this risk If
- 56:37I'd be in this position, if I'd be fierlant and there comes a new
- 56:43the cost or something else, I'm not sure if I would do the game
- 56:46for speed Works, it's way easier, but of course I'm making no impact.
- 56:51So do you think, well, this is not true though, is
- 56:53it? Because because often you will see if you look at great commercial trends,
- 57:00if you go far enough back to the origin of that thing, it
- 57:06was often some very original person who created something that was probably flawed and probably
- 57:13had zero mass appeal, but created something that was so original and vibrant that
- 57:20it was taken on by bigger entities that were then able to take the core
- 57:24of that original thing and then put it out into the world in a more
- 57:30sort of widespread form. Isn't it up to small people like you whose risk
- 57:37is less to plow the furrow originally and then hope later that people will realize
- 57:45the work. Yeah, I think so. You're correct and very well stated.
- 57:51But I think and now we are talking just about the gaming field and
- 57:55not about other industries or hobbies where it may be the case, but we
- 58:01are having way too many games right now, and our hobby media is simply
- 58:10not covering these games when they are out. They do not know them.
- 58:16When they know them, they are not interested in them. Some of these
- 58:22games are too complex for them and outside of their sphere. So I fear
- 58:30that quite a few of these games will never make a bigger splash, which
- 58:36is okay for spielworks. But again, let's take a look at the cost
- 58:42asbestos industry. Brilliant mechanics, very original, so you could say Action Selection
- 58:51is wonderful. It has even some eighteen x X feel for it, and
- 58:55people who played the game loved it. But still to have another company pick
- 59:01the game up, ah, very very difficult. I think with the with
- 59:07the hobby media, it's it's difficult because well, I think there is a
- 59:12very pernicious trend of people saying I don't do negative reviews, which is which
- 59:17is fucking mind blowing to me, because if you're a pretty critic, you're
- 59:22it's incumbent upon you to do positive and negative. But also I think if
- 59:25you're I think there is a big problem is if you're funding yourself doing sort
- 59:32of board game content and you have a choice, and especially when it's driven
- 59:37by engagement and views. If you have a choice, I could I could
- 59:44review the cost or I could review wormspell. And when it's based upon engagement,
- 59:50when it's based upon sort of Patreon money, people eyes being put on
- 59:54your on what you produce, unfortunately, the choice is absolutely absolutely I agree
- 1:00:02again here and I see this also in my papers on books. Yeah,
- 1:00:07from time to time they are covering books that are really niche, but it's
- 1:00:12often it is where you see the advertisements in they are so a big publisher
- 1:00:17is advertising that book. Then you get a review of the book. So
- 1:00:22right, very difficult, very difficult. And so do you see are you
- 1:00:30pessimistic about the variety within the gaming world. Do you think it'll all become
- 1:00:37animal games or do you think that's oversimplification and it'll always be room for niche
- 1:00:44and weird. Yeah. I think there will be always one hundred percent room
- 1:00:47for weird niche games it and for successful games. It depends on how you
- 1:00:55define success. Is it selling fifty thousand copies? Is this a success?
- 1:01:00Is it selling one hundred thousand copies? Or is this completely decoupled from quantities?
- 1:01:07Is it that you are happy, that the designer is happy, that
- 1:01:10the graphics artist is happy, and that people who have played the game are
- 1:01:15enjoying it. Do you need lots of awards? If you're not getting an
- 1:01:19award for a game, is are you unhappy? So it really depends,
- 1:01:22and I think looking at the games right now that are available, from really
- 1:01:29monster wargame to role playing game, to narrative games to simple card games to
- 1:01:36the trick taking trend, maybe that is still a trend. So from going
- 1:01:40back to earlier so, I've seen quite a few trick taking games and good
- 1:01:45trick taging games. Maybe this will continue. But I think there is a
- 1:01:50game for everyone out there, no matter what you would like to play excellent,
- 1:01:57So just to wrap up. Then, Uli, I've got my list
- 1:02:00in front of me. So where can we go to find spiel Works?
- 1:02:02Yeah, please drop me a mail at Uli Edge Spielworks dot e. That
- 1:02:07is uli Ede Spielworks dot e. My website is surprisingly also Spielworks dot Do
- 1:02:14you also see me but less and less at Twitter x at uliblay that's U
- 1:02:21l I b l E and with the same I d you see me also
- 1:02:24on this wonderful place that is blue Sky? Do you post a blue sky
- 1:02:31at all? I haven't looked at blue Sky in a mile. I post
- 1:02:35from from time to time, but there is no discourse at all, So
- 1:02:39it's it's it's simply there and everybody loves everybody, which is nice. But
- 1:02:45maybe this is now we are getting back to what we are talking about here,
- 1:02:49that everybody loves a cozy place and blue Sky is that. Maybe it's
- 1:02:53that cozy place for people who love to be there. But for me right
- 1:03:00now, I do not see it as an alternative at all. As I
- 1:03:04said, no discourse, and we had this before. If I look at
- 1:03:08Dorsey and all this, I know, yeah, wonderful person that is also
- 1:03:15to be destroyed like ex Twitter, like meta destroy them all. Social media
- 1:03:22is horrendous and if you'd like to support five Games for Doomsday and what we're
- 1:03:27doing, we do many shows like this a month, but only one with
- 1:03:31the with the beating heart of the German board game industry. You can go
- 1:03:36to thank you, thank you, I'll cut out. You can go to
- 1:03:42Patreon dot com forward slash five g for D and there's loads of there's loads
- 1:03:46of pledge levels and you can also join for seven days for free just to
- 1:03:53test it out and finally just to end duley. What can we get from
- 1:03:58spiel Works full games we get so next one will be probably next new one
- 1:04:03will be probably eight apos in crowdfunding in late April, so that's what you
- 1:04:10expect. Excellent. Well, Ulie Benneman, thank you very much. I
- 1:04:14thank you ben What it was again a pleasure, So thank you for listening
- 1:04:19and come back next month for another speedw