Latest / The Clio Dialogues: Conversations About History / Hair Apparent: How Americans Learned to Read Race, Gender & Power in Hair | Sarah Gold McBride | Whiskerology
Transcript
- 0:01Jennifer Robin Terry: Hello and welcome to the Clio Dialogues, the podcast that links history with the present to help us better understand the world we live in today.
- 0:10Speaker 1: I'm your host, Jennifer Robin Terry.
- 0:13Speaker 1: What does your hair say about who you are?
- 0:16Speaker 1: It depends on who you ask.
- 0:19Speaker 1: And what century you're in.
- 0:24Speaker 1: My guest today is Dr.
- 0:25Speaker 1: Sarah Gold McBride, a historian and award-winning lecturer in the American Studies program at the University of California, Berkeley.
- 0:33Speaker 1: She is the author of Whiskerology: The Culture of Hair in Nineteenth Century America, published by Harvard University Press.
- 0:42Speaker 1: Welcome, Sarah.
- 0:43Speaker 1: I'm so glad you could join me here on the Clio Dialogues.
- 0:46Sarah Gold McBride: Hi, thanks so much for having me.
- 0:47Sarah Gold McBride: I'm excited to be here.
- 0:48Jennifer Robin Terry: I'm so excited to talk to you about your book.
- 0:50Jennifer Robin Terry: As I was reading it, my mind kept going back to the fall of 2010.
- 0:55Jennifer Robin Terry: Particularly that chapter on facial hair.
- 0:58Jennifer Robin Terry: Because that was when the San Francisco Giants pitcher Brian Wilson inadvertently set off this Fear the Beard craze.
- 1:05Jennifer Robin Terry: Do you remember that?
- 1:06Sarah Gold McBride: Oh, yeah, of course.
- 1:07Sarah Gold McBride: Right.
- 1:08Jennifer Robin Terry: It's kind of funny because it's tied in my mind to you.
- 1:11Jennifer Robin Terry: Because that semester we were also taking David Henkins' class on the ordinary and the extraordinary.
- 1:17Sarah Gold McBride: That's right.
- 1:18Sarah Gold McBride: Yeah.
- 1:19Jennifer Robin Terry: The Giants kept coming up and people were talking about beards.
- 1:22Jennifer Robin Terry: And I know you weren't exactly working on this project, and yet I remember that you had things to say.
- 1:30Sarah Gold McBride: Maybe it was planting a seed because that was just about six months before I did start working on this project.
- 1:35Sarah Gold McBride: It's kind of amazing that there's a whole chapter in the book that started as a grad school seminar paper the semester after that semester.
- 1:44Sarah Gold McBride: So it really does go almost all the way back to Fear the Beard.
- 1:47Sarah Gold McBride: Maybe there was something, you know, subconsciously planted that semester.
- 1:51Jennifer Robin Terry: Yeah, maybe.
- 1:52Jennifer Robin Terry: That was also the time that I started noticing that a lot of young millennial men were starting to wear beards.
- 1:58Sarah Gold McBride: Yes.
- 1:59Sarah Gold McBride: This was a funny moment when I was a graduate student.
- 2:01Sarah Gold McBride: So it was spring of 2011 when I wrote my first uh paper for a seminar in which I initially started with an interest in bearded ladies of the late 19th and early 20th century freak show.
- 2:11Sarah Gold McBride: That's where this whole book started was with bearded ladies, which is surprising, I think.
- 2:17Sarah Gold McBride: Um it surprises me.
- 2:18Sarah Gold McBride: It certainly surprises readers, I think.
- 2:20Sarah Gold McBride: I had had an interest for a while about freak shows and the way that freak shows, as this enormously popular type of popular entertainment, became this almost site of public learning about race and gender.
- 2:31Sarah Gold McBride: And so I thought, oh, bearded ladies, there's probably something there about gender.
- 2:35Sarah Gold McBride: And I later learned about race as well.
- 2:37Sarah Gold McBride: I started with bearded ladies through researching bearded ladies.
- 2:40Sarah Gold McBride: I learned a lot about beards on men and what beards meant to American men in the same time period, the late 19th and early 20th century.
- 2:47Jennifer Robin Terry: When you saw beards on men back in 2011, did you start to see something like reading into it?
- 2:54Sarah Gold McBride: You know, it's this is a good question.
- 2:56Sarah Gold McBride: I think in true historian fashion, I didn't think a lot about the contemporary world when I was very enmeshed in the 19th century.
- 3:05Sarah Gold McBride: But journalists were noticing that there were a lot more beards being worn by millennial men.
- 3:10Sarah Gold McBride: And there were a variety of beard trends over the next three, four, five years.
- 3:14Sarah Gold McBride: There was one summer where men were putting, some men were putting like little flowers in their beards, at least for Instagram.
- 3:19Sarah Gold McBride: I don't know if anyone was wearing bearded flower beards out in daily life.
- 3:23Sarah Gold McBride: But I started getting inquiries from journalists for the first time ever because of that beard research, because there weren't a lot of scholars who were experts in the history of the American beard.
- 3:33Sarah Gold McBride: And so, yes, there was this moment.
- 3:34Sarah Gold McBride: And it was challenging for me to answer the question of why are they coming back now?
- 3:39Sarah Gold McBride: Because I felt like the context we have with hindsight of the late 19th and early 20th century allowed me to see that much more clearly what beards meant to that era.
- 3:47Sarah Gold McBride: Part of what I really insist on as a historian, specifically of hair, is that hair has historically specific meanings and culturally specific meanings as well.
- 3:56Sarah Gold McBride: What a beard meant in 1880 is different than what a beard meant in 2010, for example.
- 4:00Sarah Gold McBride: And right now we're actually in an interesting moment of beards as well.
- 4:03Sarah Gold McBride: This has come up a little bit in the last year since my book came out.
- 4:06Sarah Gold McBride: A lot more politicians actively in public life, as opposed to post-leaving office, are wearing beards.
- 4:13Sarah Gold McBride: The most noticeable, of course, is JD Vance.
- 4:15Sarah Gold McBride: He's our first bearded vice president since the 1930s.
- 4:19Sarah Gold McBride: And it's not just Vance, and it's not just men associated with the right or with the Republican Party.
- 4:24Sarah Gold McBride: There are men on the left and the right who are wearing facial hair.
- 4:26Sarah Gold McBride: Pete Buddha judge, Zuhan Mamdani, John Fetterman.
- 4:29Sarah Gold McBride: There's all there are men from across the political spectrum wearing beards while in office.
- 4:33Sarah Gold McBride: I think that what this moment now and the 2010 sort of millennial hipster beard and the late 19th century beard all share in common is eras in which masculinity was fraught, or I might even go so far as to say in crisis or unsettled in some kind of way, that beards have meant different things in different cultures and times and places, but often they have had some association with masculinity or shorthand for masculinity.
- 5:01Sarah Gold McBride: And I think in all three of those eras, it was a moment in which what a man should be, who is a good American man, has been unsettled.
- 5:10Jennifer Robin Terry: Where did this begin?
- 5:11Jennifer Robin Terry: Because when I think of founding fathers, we don't see these beards and, you know, burliness.
- 5:18Sarah Gold McBride: Yes, absolutely.
- 5:19Sarah Gold McBride: So in the era of the founding fathers, the late 18th century, even the first few decades of the 19th century, barefacedness was the absolute norm.
- 5:28Sarah Gold McBride: There are some very scattered references to men with beards or specific public figures who wore beards in these periods, but almost without exception, these are people on the fringes of American society.
- 5:40Sarah Gold McBride: The norm was to shave, to shave sometimes multiple times a week.
- 5:44Sarah Gold McBride: And most shaving was done by a barber.
- 5:46Sarah Gold McBride: It was very uncommon for men to shave themselves prior to the turn of the 20th century with the invention of the first safety razors, which makes it more comfortable and safer to not cut yourself if you're shaving at home.
- 5:59Sarah Gold McBride: And there's other kinds of technological changes, um, better lighting, easier access to clean running water, better eyeglass technology, the all of which make it easier to shave oneself at home.
- 6:08Jennifer Robin Terry: Probably better mirrors as well.
- 6:10Sarah Gold McBride: Yes, better mirrors, exactly.
- 6:11Sarah Gold McBride: Yes.
- 6:11Sarah Gold McBride: All the pieces required to shave one's face safely.
- 6:14Sarah Gold McBride: So in the 1700s and the early 1800s, barbers did this labor.
- 6:19Sarah Gold McBride: A lot of barbers were black men, especially in the American South.
- 6:21Sarah Gold McBride: It was just a normal part of men's routines to go to the barber at least once, sometimes multiple times a week, to get a shave.
- 6:27Sarah Gold McBride: The shifts around the 1850s, that's really the pivot point I write about in the book between barefacedness being the norm and beardedness becoming much, much more common.
- 6:36Sarah Gold McBride: Even I would go so far as to say is a norm.
- 6:38Sarah Gold McBride: So prior to the 1850s, there are these interesting examples of writing that is pro beard, magazine articles, books, newspaper articles that talk about how great beards are, how annoying it is to shave so often, how much money you waste going to the barber so often.
- 6:54Sarah Gold McBride: One of my favorite sources is a guy writing about he calculated how many books he could read per year, more if he didn't have to go to the barber twice a week.
- 7:03Jennifer Robin Terry: That's a guy after my own heart.
- 7:05Sarah Gold McBride: I know, right?
- 7:05Sarah Gold McBride: That's what I thought too.
- 7:06Sarah Gold McBride: So even in these eras when the norm is men are going to the barber, they are shaving their faces.
- 7:12Sarah Gold McBride: And yet there are these examples of sort of wistfully, "Aren't beard's great," even if they're making these different choices at home or, you know, with their barber.
- 7:19Sarah Gold McBride: But around the 1850s, this there is a pretty massive shift.
- 7:22Sarah Gold McBride: What changes is the choices men are making for their own faces.
- 7:26Sarah Gold McBride: And wouldn't it be great if there was like one single cause that changed everything?
- 7:31Sarah Gold McBride: Right.
- 7:31Sarah Gold McBride: It would make my job so much simpler.
- 7:33Sarah Gold McBride: But as we know, as historians, it's never that simple, right?
- 7:36Sarah Gold McBride: History is so complicated and nuanced.
- 7:38Sarah Gold McBride: So I think it's a combination of a few different factors that resulted in many men and then almost like a domino effect or a sort of snowball effect that so many men, white men and black men alike, start not shaving off their facial hair.
- 7:50Sarah Gold McBride: One of those causes, because barbering is such a commonly practiced profession by black men, that as sectional tensions start becoming more intense and as white Southerners start becoming more and more anxious about the possibility of slavery exploding into something violent, which we know it obviously does with the Civil War in 1861.
- 8:09Sarah Gold McBride: But as tensions and really nervous fear among a lot of white Southerners about the potential for violence amps up in the 1840s and especially the 1850s, for a lot of white Southern men, the idea of going multiple times a week to a black man who's holding a blade against your throat maybe feels a little bit scarier than it would have for a previous generation.
- 8:27Sarah Gold McBride: And some men start trying to shave themselves at home instead of going to a black barber and find that it sucks.
- 8:35Sarah Gold McBride: They find that it's painful and it's uh challenging to do with a straight razor and without yet those changes in technology we talked about earlier.
- 8:46Sarah Gold McBride: And so some men just stop shaving altogether because they don't feel comfortable going to a black barber and they don't feel comfortable being their own barber.
- 8:54Sarah Gold McBride: So we see some men growing beards for that reason.
- 8:56Jennifer Robin Terry: Do you see this beard growth in the north as well as the south?
- 9:00Sarah Gold McBride: Yes, it is quite surprisingly widespread across the north, the south, the west, the east.
- 9:04Sarah Gold McBride: There's some beardedness in the frontier before we see it more widespread in cities.
- 9:09Sarah Gold McBride: For example, the first person to run for president, John C.
- 9:12Sarah Gold McBride: Fremont from California, he ran for president.
- 9:15Sarah Gold McBride: He didn't win, but was the first person to run for president with a beard.
- 9:18Sarah Gold McBride: So someone from California is quite fitting, right?
- 9:20Sarah Gold McBride: Someone on kind of the frontier of the nation.
- 9:22Sarah Gold McBride: Of course, the first bearded president is Abraham Lincoln.
- 9:24Sarah Gold McBride: He's elected in 1860 famously, having grown what we now call chin strap style beard between the primary and the general election.
- 9:32Sarah Gold McBride: The printing company had made all these prints of Lincoln's face to celebrate his win.
- 9:36Sarah Gold McBride: They thought it would be a popular consumer good, but then he was barefaced in these prints because that's what he looked like before the primary.
- 9:42Sarah Gold McBride: And then they got all these complaints like that's not what he looks like anymore.
- 9:45Sarah Gold McBride: Now he has this beard.
- 9:48Sarah Gold McBride: So I wouldn't claim that there was sort of regional evenness, like equal numbers of men in all four quadrants of the US and North and South.
- 9:54Sarah Gold McBride: That's partly why I see this sort of patchwork of different causal factors.
- 9:58Sarah Gold McBride: Once men start growing beards and there are these public figures like Lincoln, their face is very visual, their faces are represented in photography and in print and illustration and newspapers that we see this sort of ramping up, and even more and more and more men start wearing beards all across the United States.
- 10:13Sarah Gold McBride: What I saw in the evidence is that there's a lot of symbolism in the desire by men to start wearing beards in the middle of the 19th century when their fathers, their grandfathers had scorned facial hair for so long, that this is a moment in which political citizenship is quite unsettled.
- 10:31Sarah Gold McBride: White women are pushing for more political rights in the first wave of feminism.
- 10:35Sarah Gold McBride: Black men and black women are pushing for more political rights.
- 10:38Sarah Gold McBride: And certainly in the aftermath of the Civil War, we have the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments, which accord greater political citizenship and political rights to black men.
- 10:46Sarah Gold McBride: So white men are no longer the same de facto soul holders of political power and political citizenship as they had been for decades.
- 10:55Sarah Gold McBride: We see this in some of the writing of the 1850s and beyond.
- 10:59Sarah Gold McBride: This sense that a beard can symbolize the supposed naturalness of white men's political power.
- 11:05Sarah Gold McBride: I expected to find sources talking about masculinity and beards being sort of men's birthright in a way.
- 11:12Sarah Gold McBride: That wasn't surprising to find.
- 11:13Sarah Gold McBride: And I did find sources that said that.
- 11:14Sarah Gold McBride: But I was surprised to find sources that also talked about the white supremacy of the beard, that sources arguing that only white men could grow a beard and that black men could not grow beards and indigenous men to North America could not grow beards and East Asian men could not grow beards.
- 11:29Sarah Gold McBride: And if you saw some hair on the face of a man who was non-white, it wasn't truly a beard, it was just a little bit of hair on the face.
- 11:36Jennifer Robin Terry: When I was reading your book, I thought, well, do they not see?
- 11:40Sarah Gold McBride: Great question.
- 11:40Sarah Gold McBride: Do they not see?
- 11:41Sarah Gold McBride: I think it's a combination of things.
- 11:43Sarah Gold McBride: I read a lot of contemporary medical literature from the 20th and 21st centuries, modern studies about hair and race and hair and gender, because I wanted to understand if there was any basis.
- 11:52Sarah Gold McBride: A lot of the claims being made about hair, whether facial or head hair and its relationship to race and gender in the 19th century are rooted in logics of science.
- 12:00Sarah Gold McBride: Most of the scientific conclusions they're coming to, we today would say this is nonsense science, this is pseudoscience.
- 12:06Sarah Gold McBride: This is the scientific method done backwards, where the scientists would begin with the conclusion they want to prove and sort of cherry pick the evidence going backwards that would lead them to that conclusion.
- 12:15Sarah Gold McBride: But I wanted to know is there any validity or any resonance with contemporary scientific findings that corroborate or reinforce any of what the 19th century folks were claiming?
- 12:25Sarah Gold McBride: The short answer is that all of this is a spectrum.
- 12:27Sarah Gold McBride: To what degree men whose ancestors come from different parts of the world have thicker or thinner facial hair, it's a spectrum, unsurprisingly.
- 12:35Sarah Gold McBride: There is some degree to which men from European countries on the average might have thicker, fuller beards than men from East Asia and Indigenous to North America in particular.
- 12:45Sarah Gold McBride: By the time white supremacist scientists are trying to find some scientific proof for white supremacy, they have this long lineage of not necessarily scientists, but people who were traveling the world making observations about the faces of non-white peoples.
- 12:57Sarah Gold McBride: John Smith, for example, writes of encountering people who were indigenous to North America and being very fascinated by how thin the beards were of some of the men.
- 13:06Sarah Gold McBride: In some cases, biologically, they just didn't grow very thick beards, but in some cases culturally.
- 13:10Sarah Gold McBride: He noted that some indigenous tribes practiced hair plucking from men's faces.
- 13:14Sarah Gold McBride: So they're not making this up whole cloth, I would say.
- 13:17Sarah Gold McBride: It's very cherry-picked evidence, absolutely.
- 13:20Sarah Gold McBride: It's very much rooted in the claim they already tried to make.
- 13:23Sarah Gold McBride: And the fact that the claim of white men's supremacy could be rooted in beardedness just really tells us how much beards matter to claims of political power.
- 13:33Jennifer Robin Terry: Because white men grow beards, white men are more masculine, more authoritative, and better suited to lead the nation.
- 13:40Jennifer Robin Terry: Is that the argument there?
- 13:42Sarah Gold McBride: Yeah, exactly.
- 13:42Sarah Gold McBride: There's this one guy, John Van Every, who was a real vehement white supremacist.
- 13:49Sarah Gold McBride: He also owned a printing press and lived in New York, and he wrote a lot about race and political participation during and just after the Civil War.
- 13:58Sarah Gold McBride: We cannot underestimate access to the printing press, right?
- 14:01Sarah Gold McBride: The fact that he was able to be such a mouthpiece for and spread his ideas quite widely because he owned the means of production.
- 14:08Sarah Gold McBride: So he also had a newspaper.
- 14:09Sarah Gold McBride: He wrote pamphlets, he wrote books, he printed them, he circulated them.
- 14:12Sarah Gold McBride: He had wide reach in the mid-19th century.
- 14:14Sarah Gold McBride: He also would take these dense, like 400-page scientific tomes about racial science and he would condense them into much shorter texts that would synthesize and simplify some of these scientific ideas for a broad audience.
- 14:28Sarah Gold McBride: Scientific racism for dummies, equivalent to, you know, something.
- 14:31Sarah Gold McBride: In one of his publications, In the Era of Reconstruction, he basically says all of these people, these white northerners are trying to reconstruct the black race, but no attempt to elevate black men will ever be possible until they can also reconstruct the beard.
- 14:46Sarah Gold McBride: That unless you put a beard on black men's faces, they will never truly be equal.
- 14:50Jennifer Robin Terry: I wonder what he thought about black men after when they start growing these beards.
- 14:54Sarah Gold McBride: Exactly.
- 14:54Sarah Gold McBride: And that's one of my favorite sort of tiffs in the book is Frederick Douglass versus John Van Every.
- 15:01Sarah Gold McBride: Douglas is a perfect example.
- 15:03Sarah Gold McBride: Douglas was a very visible, prominent black political figure and cultural leader.
- 15:08Sarah Gold McBride: And he wore for almost his entire adult life a very full beard, from ear onto the chin to the other ear with a mustache over the lip.
- 15:15Sarah Gold McBride: Douglas wrote a lot about photography during his lifetime.
- 15:18Sarah Gold McBride: He had his portrait taken so many times.
- 15:21Sarah Gold McBride: He's actually the most photographed person of the 19th century US.
- 15:25Jennifer Robin Terry: Really?
- 15:26Sarah Gold McBride: Yes.
- 15:26Sarah Gold McBride: Did that surprise you?
- 15:27Sarah Gold McBride: Did you know that?
- 15:28Sarah Gold McBride: I was shocked to learn that.
- 15:30Sarah Gold McBride: Once I learned more about Douglas' ideas about photography, it made perfect sense.
- 15:34Sarah Gold McBride: It no longer shocked me.
- 15:35Sarah Gold McBride: We have 160 existing different photographic portraits of Douglas taken over the course of his lifetime.
- 15:42Sarah Gold McBride: He wrote very explicitly that the way black men and women's bodies had been captured visually through illustration and through sculpture.
- 15:51Sarah Gold McBride: If a white artist is the vehicle for that image, even if the person is trying their hardest to be true to life, to give the perfect rendering of the appearance of a black face, that the cultural conditioning of white supremacy makes it impossible for a caricature not to slip in in some kind of way.
- 16:07Sarah Gold McBride: Fascinating.
- 16:08Sarah Gold McBride: He thought that photography was the only way to truly represent black bodies and black faces as they were true to life.
- 16:15Sarah Gold McBride: So he used his own photographed face as kind of counterevidence to the kind of claims that Van Every was making.
- 16:20Sarah Gold McBride: So when someone like Van Every is saying black men don't grow beards, I don't think that they're just, you know, operating like this, pretending like they don't see Douglas and the many, many, many other black politicians in particular.
- 16:32Sarah Gold McBride: There's so many portraits of the first black elected officials, the first black um house representatives, the first black senator, other um state and local officials.
- 16:40Sarah Gold McBride: Almost across the board, these men are wearing some kind of facial hair, whether it's a beard or a mustache or very extensive sideburn.
- 16:46Sarah Gold McBride: Anyway, I don't think that Van Every was just ignoring or pretending he didn't see.
- 16:49Sarah Gold McBride: It didn't just mean hair on face.
- 16:52Sarah Gold McBride: It had this symbolic meaning as well.
- 16:53Sarah Gold McBride: To see a black man with some hair on his face, you say, well, that's not a beard.
- 16:57Sarah Gold McBride: A beard is this quasi-physical object, quasi-symbolic object that signifies white men's political power in all realms of life.
- 17:06Jennifer Robin Terry: This could have been a whole book on facial hair, but it's one chapter.
- 17:09Jennifer Robin Terry: So you also talk about long hair, you talk about hair science, hair as a disguise.
- 17:14Jennifer Robin Terry: So there must be a meaning to hair overall that Americans in the 19th century are getting.
- 17:19Jennifer Robin Terry: What can you tell us about hair in the 19th century, writ large?
- 17:23Sarah Gold McBride: Yeah.
- 17:23Sarah Gold McBride: You're so right about this.
- 17:24Sarah Gold McBride: I mean, I mentioned that this whole research project started with the bearded ladies and from that to the beards on men's faces.
- 17:31Sarah Gold McBride: But what I realized is that this was just a small slice of the story, that the facial hair story was part of a bigger hair story of 19th century American life.
- 17:40Sarah Gold McBride: What I found through my research is that in contrast to the way hair was understood before the 19th century, and I think to a large degree since the 19th century, for 19th century Americans, hair was understood to be a body part.
- 17:52Sarah Gold McBride: And I don't mean that sort of symbolically, metaphorically, hair was treated as a part of the body.
- 17:57Sarah Gold McBride: It was within the boundaries of the body.
- 17:59Sarah Gold McBride: It wasn't an accessory to it or attached to it.
- 18:02Sarah Gold McBride: It was of the body.
- 18:03Sarah Gold McBride: And that because hair was understood to be a body part, it was thought to be capable of communicating truths about the interior person reflected on the outside.
- 18:12Sarah Gold McBride: And then in this way, hair is really similar to some of what we already knew about 19th century Americans' efforts to read the body in some kind of reliable way.
- 18:21Sarah Gold McBride: Um, the two most famous iterations of this are phrenology and physiognomy.
- 18:25Sarah Gold McBride: Phrenology is about the shape of the head, which was thought to reflect the shape of the skull, which in turn reflected the shape of the brain.
- 18:32Sarah Gold McBride: And so this is all about mapping correspondences between parts of the brain that were heavily or underdeveloped, and how that in turn shaped the skull would shape the head.
- 18:40Sarah Gold McBride: Physiognomy essentially is similar, but for the shape and the size of the facial features.
- 18:45Sarah Gold McBride: So physiognomists would look at the shape of the nose, the shape of the chin.
- 18:49Sarah Gold McBride: Generally speaking, certainly in the scientific world, phrenology and physiognomy are absolutely pseudosciences.
- 18:54Sarah Gold McBride: And yet I think that we can kind of understand the logic here.
- 18:58Sarah Gold McBride: It's part of the flesh and bone part of the body.
- 19:00Sarah Gold McBride: What I found in my research was that hair also was understood to be a body part that, like the shape of the skull or the nose of the chin, reflected the inside on the outside.
- 19:10Sarah Gold McBride: That because hair was biological, because hair grew from the body through the um skin, that its color, its texture, its length, even were invested with biological meaning.
- 19:23Sarah Gold McBride: Even stylistic choices are invested with biological meaning.
- 19:25Sarah Gold McBride: So we start to see sources say things like only women can grow long hair.
- 19:29Sarah Gold McBride: Only non-white men grow long hair.
- 19:32Sarah Gold McBride: Men can only grow short hair among white men.
- 19:34Sarah Gold McBride: And we're like, what?
- 19:35Sarah Gold McBride: This no, of course not.
- 19:36Sarah Gold McBride: That's Sophie, right?
- 19:37Jennifer Robin Terry: So barbers are kind of operating in secret, right?
- 19:40Jennifer Robin Terry: They don't want to blow their cover.
- 19:42Sarah Gold McBride: I mean, it's it's so it's so farcical to read.
- 19:44Sarah Gold McBride: It's sort of false on its face that we can only ask, like, well, what's going on here?
- 19:48Sarah Gold McBride: But what it shows us is how much biological meaning is the foundation of what hair means in the 19th century.
- 19:55Sarah Gold McBride: That investing hair, color, texture, like thickness, thinness, how much coverage on the face or not with biological meaning, but also stylistic choices like length with biological meaning speaks to the way that hair becomes understood in these largely biological terms, that it is a representation of sort of the biological self, the true self, not in the sense we now think of true self like who you really understand yourself to be based on years of reflection, self-discovery.
- 20:21Sarah Gold McBride: So if a person was trying to misrepresent or hide or obscure or falsify their identity, their hair might give them away.
- 20:29Sarah Gold McBride: Their hair was the tell of who they really were on the inside.
- 20:33Jennifer Robin Terry: So I'm wondering, are people changing their hairstyles?
- 20:36Jennifer Robin Terry: Because in the 21st century, we change our hairstyle to fit the way we feel or the way we want to present ourselves.
- 20:42Jennifer Robin Terry: But you're saying it didn't matter because the texture, the color, the length, it transcended that.
- 20:49Sarah Gold McBride: Yeah.
- 20:49Sarah Gold McBride: So people absolutely were changing their hair.
- 20:51Sarah Gold McBride: I found as far back as the 17th century a recipe book that has both like how to make a stew, but also how to remove unwanted hair, for example.
- 21:01Sarah Gold McBride: Um, I've seen recipes in these books as far back as the 1600s that include recipes for removal of unwanted hair or dyeing of the hair a different color.
- 21:10Sarah Gold McBride: Often the ingredients are ghastly, like lead, um, lye, things like this.
- 21:16Sarah Gold McBride: But there are both home remedies for changing the hair.
- 21:20Sarah Gold McBride: And then in the 19th century, with the explosion of the market economy, tons of consumer products that can be purchased to change the hair, to grow more hair when you're balding, to remove hair you no longer want to have, to change the color.
- 21:33Sarah Gold McBride: There's all kinds of fake hair that people can purchase as well: wigs, toupees, fake beards, fake mustaches, augmentation to the natural hair.
- 21:41Sarah Gold McBride: There's puff a woman could clip a puff in to give herself extra volume here, or a braid across the crown.
- 21:45Sarah Gold McBride: So many different types of fake hair pieces that can be added to augment or cover up the hair as it is.
- 21:51Sarah Gold McBride: Do other people perceive them as being disingenuous if they use those products?
- 21:55Sarah Gold McBride: It depends.
- 21:55Sarah Gold McBride: And in some cases, yes.
- 21:56Sarah Gold McBride: Fake hair pieces like wigs and fake beard.
- 21:59Sarah Gold McBride: Become by the end of the 19th century almost like evidence that you either have committed a crime or that you're suspiciously likely to commit a crime.
- 22:08Sarah Gold McBride: Newspapers all across the country reporting local crime stories of someone who was caught, arrested by the police because they kept touching their hair in a way that was a little suspicious.
- 22:17Sarah Gold McBride: And it turns out, aha, they had a wig on their head.
- 22:19Sarah Gold McBride: And when they were arrested, they were found in their briefcase.
- 22:21Sarah Gold McBride: They also had a skeleton key and they also had other burglar tools in their, you know, bag or whatever.
- 22:27Sarah Gold McBride: So, but the wig, the wig was the thing that kind of drew the police's attention.
- 22:30Sarah Gold McBride: Sometimes these hair pieces are uh the way we might associate them, even in a cartoonish way with crime, like you commit a crime, you put on a fake beard, you try to escape, and no one will understand that it's you.
- 22:42Sarah Gold McBride: And that does happen in some of these stories as well.
- 22:44Sarah Gold McBride: And in other stories, it just seems that the beard itself is evidence or likelihood of criminal intent.
- 22:51Sarah Gold McBride: One of the most fun parts of working on this project for so long, almost 15 years, so many friends, including you, at various points, sent me something that they found in their own research that was related to hair.
- 23:03Sarah Gold McBride: Hair is all over the place in the archive.
- 23:05Sarah Gold McBride: It turns out when you look for it.
- 23:07Sarah Gold McBride: So a friend was researching at UC Berkeley's Bancroft Library, which is a rare books manuscript library at Berkeley.
- 23:13Sarah Gold McBride: She was looking at these police records for San Francisco in the 19th century, and she sent me an email with these pictures of arrests for wearing a fake beard.
- 23:21Sarah Gold McBride: And she was like, What's up with these beard arrests?
- 23:24Sarah Gold McBride: At the time, I said, I have no idea.
- 23:26Sarah Gold McBride: So the very act of having a fake beard or mustache or fake hair piece was at least a telltale sign, if not definitive proof of some kind of criminal intent.
- 23:37Jennifer Robin Terry: I know there was a real concern about authenticity and being able to read people.
- 23:41Jennifer Robin Terry: I was recently in the Folsom History Museum, and they have a book of people's names and their sentences and the crimes they committed who were in Folsom prison in the 19th century.
- 23:52Jennifer Robin Terry: And one of them was this man had to serve 18 months because he was impersonating a woman.
- 23:58Sarah Gold McBride: Yes.
- 23:59Sarah Gold McBride: Okay, so this also could be potentially related because some states and municipalities had anti-cross-dressing laws in the late 19th century.
- 24:05Sarah Gold McBride: Um, San Francisco, for example, definitely had an anti-cross-dressing law, which actually funnily enough brings us back to bearded ladies.
- 24:10Sarah Gold McBride: The first bearded lady came to perform in American Freak Show in 1853.
- 24:15Sarah Gold McBride: Her name is Madame Clefulia.
- 24:17Sarah Gold McBride: Of course, who other than P.
- 24:18Sarah Gold McBride: T.
- 24:18Sarah Gold McBride: Barnum was the person who hired her and brought her from Europe over to the US.
- 24:23Sarah Gold McBride: And because she was the first bearded lady, she was a total sensation.
- 24:26Sarah Gold McBride: And there's all these articles written about her, at least one biography.
- 24:30Sarah Gold McBride: In some of the writings about bearded ladies, they would say that bearded lady freak show performers would cover their beards with a handkerchief or a scarf when they were in public, in between shows, essentially.
- 24:40Sarah Gold McBride: There are two potential explanations for why they would do this.
- 24:43Sarah Gold McBride: One is an anti-cross-dressing law, concerned about being arrested for presumption that they are indeed a man wearing a dress, because bearded lady, the sort of normative presentation style of a bearded lady was a dress and a hairstyle that was whatever the contemporary popular hairstyle for women, often earrings, necklaces, other forms of jewelry.
- 25:01Sarah Gold McBride: So they were otherwise unambiguously a woman.
- 25:04Sarah Gold McBride: Exactly.
- 25:05Sarah Gold McBride: But for their unusual appendage, it was sometimes called, right?
- 25:08Sarah Gold McBride: Using again the language of the body, their appendage being their beard.
- 25:11Sarah Gold McBride: They were women in all other senses of the words.
- 25:13Sarah Gold McBride: So one possibility is they covered their beard in public for fear of being arrested in some cities for violating a cross-dressing law.
- 25:19Sarah Gold McBride: The other explanation is a much more sort of market explanation, which is like maybe people wouldn't pay for the show if they just got to see the bearded lady in public.
- 25:27Sarah Gold McBride: I could see Barnum putting that in their contract.
- 25:31Sarah Gold McBride: I know, right?
- 25:31Sarah Gold McBride: I could totally see him doing that too.
- 25:33Sarah Gold McBride: Yeah.
- 25:34Sarah Gold McBride: Hair is such an interesting body part to be invested with this ability to tell reliable truths about the person inside.
- 25:42Sarah Gold McBride: Because, as we both know, as all of us know today, it's so malleable.
- 25:46Sarah Gold McBride: You can change your hair in an instant, right?
- 25:49Sarah Gold McBride: You can put on a wig, you can shave your head, you can color it, you can uh crimp it or um braid it or whatever.
- 25:56Sarah Gold McBride: Hair is among our most malleable body parts.
- 25:59Sarah Gold McBride: And so it almost seems ludicrous to invest something so malleable with the power of truth telling in a 19th century context.
- 26:09Sarah Gold McBride: I don't want anyone to hear that and to think like, well, people were just stupid or something.
- 26:13Sarah Gold McBride: No, no, no.
- 26:14Sarah Gold McBride: I don't want us to go there.
- 26:15Sarah Gold McBride: Because hair is very unusual.
- 26:17Sarah Gold McBride: It occupies this very middle ground place that almost no other part of the body does.
- 26:22Sarah Gold McBride: It has a biological component to it in that it there are some elements of the hair that we don't have the ability to change.
- 26:28Sarah Gold McBride: It grows out of us, at least in a certain way, but it's also cultural.
- 26:32Sarah Gold McBride: It's not fully adornment of the body, like jewelry or clothing or hats or shoes, but it's not fully flesh and bone in the way that arms and legs or noses are.
- 26:41Sarah Gold McBride: So it has this capacity to offer stable meaning for people who were seeking stable meaning, but also subversion and play and manipulation for those who wanted to change the way they were perceived publicly in some kind of way.
- 26:55Sarah Gold McBride: I read a lot of advertisements for enslaved people who had escaped enslavement that document the hair of the person as they had escaped, but sometimes would say things like, he escaped with a wig and probably he's going to use it to try to obscure his identity.
- 27:08Sarah Gold McBride: Or in some cases, he shaved his head just before he left.
- 27:12Sarah Gold McBride: He is very fair-skinned and he has blue eyes.
- 27:15Sarah Gold McBride: And the only thing that betrays that he is black and therefore enslaved is the kinkiness of his hair.
- 27:21Sarah Gold McBride: I bring up the uh folks who are running away from enslavement because this is a great example of a population for whom the ability to manipulate hair could be a vehicle for escape.
- 27:29Sarah Gold McBride: Even if it's just temporary, just so they can not answer to the written description of their appearance in the newspaper.
- 27:35Jennifer Robin Terry: So, what would you say is the biggest difference between the way we view hair now and the way they viewed hair in the 19th century?
- 27:44Sarah Gold McBride: I think the biggest difference is that we don't see hair as a body part anymore.
- 27:48Sarah Gold McBride: We see hair as important, absolutely.
- 27:51Sarah Gold McBride: And cultural norms in the US still mandate that taking care of one's hair is important, whether you do it yourself or you go to a salon or a barber or so on, that hair matters and it has meaning and we care for it.
- 28:03Sarah Gold McBride: But what has changed is that hair no longer has this ability to kind of talk unto itself about who we are on the inside.
- 28:10Sarah Gold McBride: That we use our hair as a form of creative expression or as a way to communicate to the public something about our social or individual identity.
- 28:20Sarah Gold McBride: Like a teenager who wants to be a punk rocker might shave their hair into a mohawk.
- 28:24Sarah Gold McBride: A shaved head can be like a neo-Nazi signifier as well.
- 28:27Sarah Gold McBride: Queer people cut their hair as a kind of coming-out haircut, or like a trans woman growing her hair long as part of her social transition.
- 28:34Sarah Gold McBride: So we still see absolutely that hairstyling is very important to contemporary Americans to communicate who we are to the public.
- 28:41Sarah Gold McBride: What we don't see today is the sense that the hair is speaking for itself, that our ability to intervene is fairly limited.
- 28:50Sarah Gold McBride: That's such a huge difference from a 19th century perspective.
- 28:52Sarah Gold McBride: There was a belief that if a person is walking down the street, you could know something almost immediately about that stranger just based on looking at their hair.
- 29:01Sarah Gold McBride: Even if the stranger was trying to misrepresent themselves, even if the person had dressed differently or they had put a wig on top or something, the hair would give away who they really were, almost like it had power beyond the capacity of the human themselves.
- 29:14Sarah Gold McBride: Understanding the past requires such a fundamental curiosity to start from no assumptions about what you're going to find and what similarities we may or may not hold today compared to the people we're studying in the past.
- 29:27Sarah Gold McBride: Our understanding of hair is so part of our daily life, our own care and thoughts and feelings about our hair, we deal with it every single day.
- 29:35Sarah Gold McBride: It is easy to assume that this very bodily experience we have must have been more or less the same as people living 200 years ago.
- 29:44Sarah Gold McBride: But I think I had to spend a lot of time with the sources and really release every preconception I had about what hair meant, even from its most material sense, to people in the past and how it might be different from today.
- 29:56Sarah Gold McBride: Trusting our sources when they tell us something that feels weird or counterintuitive about the way they understand their bodies, the way they understand their senses of selves, their communities, et cetera.
- 30:05Sarah Gold McBride: In this case, I had to really let them tell me my hair is part of my body.
- 30:10Sarah Gold McBride: That's it.
- 30:10Sarah Gold McBride: I had to trust them and sort of listen to them saying this and let that be the baseline.
- 30:14Sarah Gold McBride: Once I understood that the hair was a part of the body, it really unlocked everything.
- 30:19Sarah Gold McBride: It helped me see why hair could be so powerful as a signifier of race, of gender, of whether or not a person has a capacity to become an American, because it had these truly bodily meanings, these bodily foundations.
- 30:32Sarah Gold McBride: So hair was a body part, and that is different than we think of it today, but that doesn't mean that we should dismiss that.
- 30:38Sarah Gold McBride: We should really take that seriously.
- 30:38Sarah Gold McBride: And if we do, we really can learn a lot, not just about hair, but about the way that 19th century people thought about race, about gender, about nationhood, about belonging, and so many other things.
- 30:53Jennifer Robin Terry: This has been the Clio Dialogues.
- 30:55Jennifer Robin Terry: Please like, follow, and subscribe.
- 30:58Jennifer Robin Terry: And join me again next time because history isn't finished with us.