Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Electric Supermini Comparison: Corsa, R5, 208
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the deep dive. Today we are jumping straight
- 0:12into, well, probably the most fiercely competitive bit of the
- 0:16car market right now. Absolutely.
- 0:18The electric B segment hatchback is where things get really
- 0:21interesting. Yeah.
- 0:22Where you know, affordability is supposed to meet everyday
- 0:24usability. And for 2025, wow, we've got a
- 0:28proper three-way fight on our hands.
- 0:30It really is a fight. We've got the updated Opal Corsa
- 0:33Electric, then there's the completely new, very stylish
- 0:37Renault 5 Electric. And the Peugeot 2O8 electric
- 0:40which has had a refresh and seems to be pushing hard on
- 0:43range. Exactly.
- 0:44They're all compact, all electric obviously, but the
- 0:47interesting thing is they're really targeting quite different
- 0:50buyers, different priorities. So our mission today is
- 0:54basically to give you the shortcut.
- 0:55We want to cut through all the, you know, the specs for 2025 and
- 0:58figure out the real trade-offs. Right, like which car is best if
- 1:01you absolutely need the longest range?
- 1:03Or if maybe style and price are your main concerns.
- 1:07And what about just how the car feels to drive?
- 1:10Which one actually wins on that front?
- 1:12Yeah. OK, but before we dive into the
- 1:14tech specs, I've got a slightly different question for you just
- 1:17for fun. Go on then.
- 1:19If you were picking me up for, let's say, a pretty formal gala
- 1:23event this weekend, which one of these three little electric
- 1:27hatchbacks are you turning up in?
- 1:30OK, a gala event that changes things, needs a bit of presence,
- 1:33doesn't. It exactly style, budget, range.
- 1:39You got to pick one. Make an entrance.
- 1:42OK, well, thinking purely about making that entrance, that first
- 1:46impression, I think I'd have to go for the Renault 5 Electric.
- 1:49Really. The Renault.
- 1:50Yeah, the sources we looked at kept highlighting its iconic
- 1:54design, that retro feel. It's just got personality, you
- 1:57know? It's a statement.
- 1:58You wouldn't mistake it for anything else.
- 1:59OK, but hang on, isn't the Renault 5 the one that's being
- 2:02marketed as the cheapest, most accessible of the three?
- 2:05Does pulling up in the buzzet option really scream formal
- 2:08gala? See, that's a fairpoint.
- 2:10You might think the Peugeot 2O8. Maybe it's described as more
- 2:13dynamic, a bit sportier. Right.
- 2:15Maybe a bit more prestige? Perhaps, but I think the two O 8
- 2:19is trying to be a bit of everything.
- 2:21The R5, it knows what it is, it's got character.
- 2:24And you know that little illuminated 5 foot logo on the
- 2:27bonnet? The one that shows the battery
- 2:29level when it's charging. That's the one.
- 2:31It's clever, it's stylish. I think people who appreciate
- 2:33design, that kind of heritage nod, they'd get it regardless of
- 2:36the price. It's got charm.
- 2:37OK, OK, see your point. Bold choice.
- 2:39I'll be waiting for you this weekend then.
- 2:41Let's just hope my gala dress fits in the back.
- 2:43We might need some very careful packing, but that actually leads
- 2:47us perfectly into the core of this deep dive.
- 2:50The trade-offs. Exactly.
- 2:51The tension we found in all the source material is right there,
- 2:54style versus budget versus practicality versus range.
- 2:59These cars, they're pretty close in price, right?
- 3:01Roughly €30,000 up to maybe 36,500.
- 3:04Yeah, not a huge spread. But strategically, they're
- 3:08engineered to appeal to really different instincts in buyers.
- 3:11OK, so let's unpack that. Where should we start?
- 3:14Maybe with what lots of EV buyers think about first range,
- 3:19you know, being able to do those medium trips without getting
- 3:21range anxiety. Good plan.
- 3:23And that brings us straight to the two siblings, the Peugeot
- 3:262O8 and the Opel Corsa. They share that Stellantis
- 3:29platform. Right.
- 3:31They're kind of the benchmarks for range in this class, aren't
- 3:33they? They are.
- 3:34And Peugeot, well, they've really doubled down on
- 3:37positioning the two O 8 electric as the absolute range champion.
- 3:41It's worth remembering this isn't just a minor tweak.
- 3:43No, it was already selling really well, wasn't it?
- 3:45Like best selling electric B segment car in Europe last year.
- 3:48That's what the sources said. So this upgrade is them pushing
- 3:51their advantage. OK, so give us the headline
- 3:54figure. How much range are we talking
- 3:55about now? So the latest version, the one
- 3:57with 156 horsepower motor, that's 115 kilowatts, it
- 4:01achieves 433 kilometers in the WLTP cycle. 433, wow.
- 4:06OK. And WLTP, that's the standard
- 4:08test, right? Worldwide harmonized.
- 4:10Worldwide harmonized light vehicles test procedure.
- 4:13Yeah, it's a lab test, sure, but it's the standard everyone uses
- 4:16for comparison. And hitting 433 kilometers,
- 4:19that's aimed squarely at people who need that cross city, maybe
- 4:23even regional commute confidence.
- 4:25Minimizing those charging stops makes sense.
- 4:28It's the best in the segment then.
- 4:30Yep, best official range figure in its class right now.
- 4:33But what's interesting is Peugeot isn't just about the raw
- 4:35range number. They seem to be packing in tech
- 4:38to help you actually use that range effectively.
- 4:40Like that trip planner thing? Exactly that.
- 4:43Trip Planner is a really key feature.
- 4:44It's not just your standard SAT NAV.
- 4:46It actively optimizes your route based on your battery level
- 4:50right now, real time traffic, even the hills on your route.
- 4:53So it makes that 433 kilometer figure more well achievable in
- 4:58the real world. Pretty much it takes away some
- 5:00of the mental load of planning longer EV journeys.
- 5:03And then there's this other thing mentioned, V2L vehicle to
- 5:06load pre installation. That sounds quite techie.
- 5:09It is, and it's a feature that I think often gets missed on spec
- 5:12sheets, but it's actually a huge deal V2L.
- 5:15So what does it actually let you do?
- 5:16It basically turns your car into a massive mobile battery pack.
- 5:20The two O 8 can output power up to 3.5 kilowatts.
- 5:24Think about, I don't know, going camping and running lights or a
- 5:26small fridge. Or maybe if the power goes out
- 5:28at home. Exactly.
- 5:29Or using power tools somewhere remote.
- 5:31It makes the car more than just transport, it's like a utility
- 5:34tool as well. OK, that is genuinely useful,
- 5:36but there's usually a trade off, right?
- 5:39All that tech, that big battery, does it compromise something
- 5:42else like space? You guessed it, in the two or
- 5:45eights case, it's the boot. It has the smallest luggage
- 5:48capacity of these three, only 265 liters. 265 liters.
- 5:53OK, not tiny, but definitely. Smaller.
- 5:55Which brings us nicely to its sibling, the Opal Corsa
- 5:58Electric. Same basic platform, lots of
- 6:01shared tech, but Opal seems to have aimed for a slightly
- 6:04different balance. More towards practicality.
- 6:06Exactly. Maximizing utility, everyday
- 6:09usability. Well Peugeot chased the dynamic
- 6:11Dr. and those cutting edge features like V2L.
- 6:13Opal, focus on fitting things in.
- 6:15Kind of, yeah. Better packaging efficiency.
- 6:17It's range is still really, really competitive, up to 429
- 6:21kilometers WLTP with the same 51 kilowatt battery and 156HP
- 6:26motor. Wow.
- 6:27OK, so only four kilometers less than the Peugeot.
- 6:29That's barely anything. Pretty much negligible in the
- 6:31real world, but where the Corsa clearly wins is that
- 6:35practicality point. The boot space it's.
- 6:37Got the biggest boot here, 309 liters.
- 6:40OK. Three on 9 versus 265, that's 44
- 6:43liters more. That actually sounds like it
- 6:45could make a difference. It really can if you're trying
- 6:47to squeeze in bulky shopping or pushchair or like you said, a
- 6:50fancy dress. That extra space makes the Corsa
- 6:54feel like the more robust, dependable choice.
- 6:58The sensible shoes of the group. Maybe the car for the family,
- 7:02doing the school run or taking the dog out, It's maybe less
- 7:05exciting, but it nails that everyday practicality.
- 7:08And the course of source has also flagged its efficiency,
- 7:10right? Something like 14.2 kilowaters
- 7:12per 100 kilometers. Why does that number matter?
- 7:15Yeah, that's a really good efficiency figure for this size
- 7:17of car. It basically means the course is
- 7:19very good at converting battery energy into distance travelled
- 7:22less waste. So lower running costs.
- 7:24Lower running cost, definitely, and it also suggests the real
- 7:27world range might hold up better across different conditions.
- 7:30Plus it still charges quickly, 10% to 80% in about 27 minutes
- 7:34on 100 kilowatt ADC charger. Same as a Peugeot basically.
- 7:37OK. So we've got the Corsa and Two O
- 7:408, both pushing close to 430 kilometer range.
- 7:42Great tech, but slightly different.
- 7:45Focuses Corsa on space, Two O 8 on range and features premium
- 7:49choices. Really.
- 7:50Right. But like we said, not everyone
- 7:52needs or wants to pay for 430 kilometers range.
- 7:56Sometimes style or just a lower price is the winner.
- 7:59Which leads us to competitor #3 the Icon Reborn.
- 8:03The Renault 5 electric Yeah, this car isn't really trying to
- 8:05beat the Corsa in 208 on their own terms on maximum range.
- 8:09It's playing a different game. Price and sheer coolness.
- 8:12Pretty much it's designed to be the most accessible option here.
- 8:15And the price definitely reflects that.
- 8:17Absolutely. The estimates put the starting
- 8:19price somewhere around 30,000 to 33,000.
- 8:22Compared to the Corsa and 208 which are both around what,
- 8:2434,000 or more? Exactly.
- 8:26So that's potentially a few €1000 saved right off the bat
- 8:30for buyers on a tighter budget, that's a really big deal.
- 8:32And we already touched on the design.
- 8:34That's clearly a massive part of the appeal, that retro thing,
- 8:37reinventing the old 80s classic. It really leans into it, and the
- 8:41sources described it as dirty and agile, which suggests it's
- 8:45optimized for city driving. Right quick steering, easy to
- 8:47park, that kind of thing. Perfect for nipping around town.
- 8:50Precisely, it's built for the urban jungle, where maybe you
- 8:53don't need 400 plus kilometers of range every day.
- 8:57But here's something really interesting.
- 8:59Even though it's the budget option, the R5 apparently
- 9:02includes a key bit of tech as standard that the others might
- 9:07charge extra for or not offer on base model.
- 9:11Ah yes, the heat pump. That's it.
- 9:12Why is that so important? OK, so this is genuinely a big
- 9:15value add, especially if you live somewhere that gets cold in
- 9:18winter, right? In most standard EVs, heating
- 9:21the cabin uses a simple resistive heater, kind of like a
- 9:24hair dryer element. It works, but it draws a lot of
- 9:28power directly from the main drive battery.
- 9:30Which kills your rain when it's cold.
- 9:32Exactly. You can slash your range
- 9:33significantly. A heat pump is much smarter.
- 9:36It works more like an air conditioner in reverse,
- 9:39scavenging heat from the ambient air and the car's own systems to
- 9:42warm the cabin much more efficiently.
- 9:44So it uses way less battery power to keep you warm.
- 9:47Correct, which means your actual driving range stays much closer
- 9:51to the official WLTP figure, even on cold days.
- 9:54OK, so the R5's official range, what is it?
- 9:57Yeah, 406 kilometers with the bigger battery.
- 9:59Yeah, up. To 406 kilometers, the bigger
- 10:01battery. Yeah, up to 406 kilometers WLTP
- 10:04with the 50 kilowatt of battery still very competitive.
- 10:07But with that standard heat pump, that 406 kilometers might
- 10:10actually be more reliable in winter than say, a competitor's
- 10:13slightly higher number if they don't have a heat pump.
- 10:16That's precisely the point. It's smart, practical
- 10:18engineering aimed at the everyday user, even if the
- 10:20absolute top line range number isn't the segment best.
- 10:24And his boot space is pretty decent too, around 300, three,
- 10:26126 liters, so quite close to the Corsa.
- 10:29OK. Right, We've covered a lot of
- 10:30ground here. We've got the range King two O
- 10:328, the practical Corsa and the stylish value focused R5.
- 10:36Let's try and pull this all together for the listener based
- 10:38on what they might prioritize. Yeah, let's synthesize.
- 10:40I think we've seen the three pretty distinct propositions
- 10:43emerge. So if your absolute main goal is
- 10:45getting the maximum possible range, maybe for longer commutes
- 10:49or Peace of Mind on medium journeys, then you really have
- 10:52to look seriously at the Peugeot 2O8 electric.
- 10:55That 433 kilometer figure, plus the smart trip planner in the
- 10:59V2L potential that puts it right at the top for range and tech.
- 11:03OK, but what if it's less about the ultimate number and more
- 11:07about blending good range with maximum practicality, fitting
- 11:10life into the car? Then the Opal course electric
- 11:13becomes the really logical choice.
- 11:14You sacrifice what, 4 kilometers of official range?
- 11:17Compared to the Peugeot, which is nothing but you gain that
- 11:20significantly larger boot, 44 extra liters.
- 11:23Plus it's proven to be very efficient.
- 11:25The reliable all. Rounder, pretty much.
- 11:27And thirdly, what if your priority is getting into an EV
- 11:31with bags of style? Something fun, maybe for city
- 11:34use, and crucially, at the best possible price.
- 11:36Then it has to be the Renault 5 Electric.
- 11:38We're out of doubt lowest starting price, that iconic
- 11:40design that really stands out and that very valuable standard
- 11:44heat pump for maintaining range in the cold.
- 11:46It's a high value, high style choice.
- 11:48And there was one other factor, the actual driving feel.
- 11:50Any clear winner there? Well, the sources suggested that
- 11:52if you enjoy a slightly more engaging, maybe sportier Dr. the
- 11:56Peugeot 2O8 electric might just edge it.
- 11:59It seems tuned for a bit more dynamism compared to the courses
- 12:02Comfort you pillity focus or the R fives city agility.
- 12:06So really depends what you value most.
- 12:09It does, and I like that analogy.
- 12:10One of the sources used to sum. Up.
- 12:12Oh yeah, those that. They said the Corsa is like the
- 12:15reliable, well made suit but with the biggest pockets.
- 12:18Practical. Dependable.
- 12:19OK. The two OA is the sharply
- 12:21tailored suit, maybe with some high tech fabric or finishing
- 12:25performance range. They're more prestige, right?
- 12:27And the Renault 5 That's the vintage, funky piece of clothing
- 12:30costs less, makes you smile every time you put it on, and
- 12:34it's surprisingly clever in its own way.
- 12:35That actually sums it up perfectly.
- 12:37It really shows how manufacturers are trying to
- 12:39carve out specific niches, even when the basic ingredients seem
- 12:43quite similar. It does, and it leaves you, the
- 12:46buyer, with a really interesting final thought to Mull over in
- 12:50this compact EV world, what's actually more important for your
- 12:54long term happiness with the car?
- 12:56Is it chasing that absolute maximum WLTP range number, even
- 13:00if maybe you don't use it all that often?
- 13:02Or is it finding the sweet spot the best possible balance
- 13:07between a price you're comfortable with, a design that
- 13:09you love seeing everyday, and the kind of agility that works
- 13:12best for how you actually drive, especially in the city?
- 13:16That's the core trade off here. A brilliant question to leave us
- 13:19with and that really defines this deep dive.
- 13:22Thank you so, so much for joining us today as we explored
- 13:25these really competitive little electric cars.
- 13:27Pleasure is all mine. We honestly love getting into
- 13:30the details like this and figuring out what really matters
- 13:32for you, so please do follow the channel so you never miss out on
- 13:36getting this kind of insight. Nice and quick.
- 13:38Thanks again for listening.