Latest / AV SuperFriends / On Topic Episode 73: It only 3/4s of the way plays nice together
Transcript
- 0:04AV Super Friends On Topic is an
- 0:06independent production wholly owned and
- 0:07operated by AV Super Friends, LLC.
- 0:10For the highest quality recording of all
- 0:11of our shows, visit AVSuperFriends.com.
- 0:14If you've only been listening to On Topic,
- 0:17well,
- 0:17you've been eating the salad bar while the
- 0:19rest of us are in the kitchen watching
- 0:20the fryer catch fire.
- 0:22Here's what you missed on the last two
- 0:23episodes of Off the Rails.
- 0:26First, we hit the road to Northwest Met,
- 0:28where digital signage was declared dead,
- 0:30Android-based room appliances started
- 0:32aging like gas station sushi,
- 0:34and everyone was reminded that
- 0:36cloud-managed is just a fancy way of
- 0:38saying, surprise,
- 0:39your workflow is someone else's roadmap
- 0:42now.
- 0:42Then we were joined by Neutrik to talk
- 0:44about Layer One, cables, connectors,
- 0:47soldering, terminations,
- 0:48and why your beautifully programmed AV
- 0:50system is still worthless if someone
- 0:53globbed an XLR together like they were
- 0:55frosting a cupcake during an earthquake.
- 0:57They're launching a comprehensive training
- 0:59program to address your terrible cable
- 1:01termination skills.
- 1:02so yes on topic is great but off
- 1:05the rails is where the weird esoteric
- 1:07stuff lives the actual higher ed av
- 1:10therapy catch up now before you miss
- 1:12something else and force us to explain it
- 1:14to you slowly you can find everything we
- 1:16do over at avsuperfriends.com
- 1:23This is AV Superfriends On Topic,
- 1:25a thirty-minute monthly roundtable focused
- 1:27on a single topic.
- 1:28This discussion will be opinionated,
- 1:29to the point,
- 1:30and saturated with our well-known blend of
- 1:32painfully won expertise and deeply
- 1:34ingrained immaturity.
- 1:41For July, twenty-twenty-six.
- 1:43Yes, you heard me.
- 1:43It's the best sounding and most explosive
- 1:46podcast in higher ed.
- 1:47This is the AV Super Friends on topic
- 1:49episode number seventy-three.
- 1:52Broadcasting live from the land of
- 1:53liberty, signal pass,
- 1:54and suspiciously overloaded power strips.
- 1:57From sea to shining AV over IP.
- 1:59From rockets red glare to blinking red
- 2:02LEDs.
- 2:03From life, liberty,
- 2:04and the pursuit of one more USB-C adapter.
- 2:07This is the show that believes all
- 2:08classrooms are created equal.
- 2:10but some were clearly designed by
- 2:11committee.
- 2:12I'm Chris Decker.
- 2:12You're tuned in for another Friday
- 2:13afternoon podcast adventure with the AV
- 2:15Super Friends.
- 2:16Hello.
- 2:17This is our Fourth of July show,
- 2:18if you haven't guessed.
- 2:19I mean, you can smell the sulfur.
- 2:21Yeah.
- 2:22I've got stuff queued up,
- 2:23but I'm going to get through this first.
- 2:24Yeah, don't.
- 2:25You've got to hold it, man.
- 2:26Don't blow the load yet.
- 2:27And let's say hello to today's panel of
- 2:29very patriotic AV Super Friends with,
- 2:31uh-oh, where'd it go?
- 2:32This one.
- 2:35Our first panelist handles every classroom
- 2:37emergency that begins with the phrase,
- 2:39when in the course of human events,
- 2:40the projector stops working.
- 2:42He's a director of declaration-based
- 2:44escalations from Kansas City.
- 2:45Say hello to Mr. Jamie Reinhart.
- 2:47I told you that it was going to
- 2:49work flawlessly whenever I said it was
- 2:51going to happen.
- 2:56Our next panelist specializes in
- 2:58preventing dramatic pops, sparks,
- 3:00and smoke from racks that were absolutely
- 3:02working yesterday.
- 3:03He's a senior fireworks mitigation
- 3:05engineer from Corvallis, Oregon.
- 3:06Say hello to Mr. Mark Kolobosinski.
- 3:08We're going to fight fire with fire.
- 3:10My recommendation is to throw more
- 3:12fireworks on the fireworks if you want
- 3:13those fireworks to actually extinguish
- 3:15themselves.
- 3:15It sucks the oxygen right out of the
- 3:17fireworks.
- 3:18Put the fireworks out with fireworks.
- 3:20Which is actually, by the way,
- 3:20how they put out oil field fires.
- 3:22That's what I'm saying.
- 3:24And our final panelist develops long-range
- 3:26classroom technology plans that honor
- 3:28America's semi-quincentennial by replacing
- 3:31displays installed during the
- 3:32bicentennial.
- 3:33He's a two-hundred-and-fiftieth
- 3:35anniversary refresh cycle strategist from
- 3:37Greensboro, North Carolina.
- 3:38Uh-oh, Chris is gone.
- 3:42I wonder which version of DMPS that is.
- 3:47That was one long-distance troubleshooting
- 3:51thing.
- 3:51Yes.
- 3:53So he's Larry Darling.
- 3:56Yeah, that's me.
- 3:58Did it mute?
- 3:59It muted you.
- 4:00It just went away for a hot moment.
- 4:01Your new, like,
- 4:02super high-speed internet crapped out on
- 4:05you.
- 4:05Awesome.
- 4:06It's going to have gigs of garbage.
- 4:07In that quintessential whatever that was,
- 4:10how many computer cycles is that, Larry?
- 4:13Like,
- 4:13how many times did you have to replace
- 4:15the computers to get that bicentennial
- 4:17replacement cycle?
- 4:18I see it once every four years,
- 4:20so therefore it's, yeah, a lot of math.
- 4:23Yeah.
- 4:24At least two.
- 4:26Sixty?
- 4:27How old am I?
- 4:28Sixty times.
- 4:30I got you.
- 4:32So this is our Fourth of July Independence
- 4:34Day, whatever you want to call it,
- 4:36America's birthday show,
- 4:37because you're listening to this in July,
- 4:40except for those of you live right now.
- 4:41But we're going to discuss,
- 4:44that's our theme,
- 4:45so we're going to discuss why we're
- 4:46declaring independence from dumb AV
- 4:48practices.
- 4:49But first, some housekeeping,
- 4:51or as Jamie calls it,
- 4:52all that stupid crap,
- 4:54which I read every time.
- 4:57First of all,
- 4:57if you are listening to this as recorded
- 4:58MP three,
- 4:58congratulations on your exercising your
- 5:00God given right to consume media on your
- 5:02own schedule.
- 5:03But we stream live on Fridays at about
- 5:04three, fifteen Eastern, twelve,
- 5:05fifteen Pacific,
- 5:06or whenever Mark finally declares
- 5:07independence from whatever meeting he's
- 5:09trapped in.
- 5:10You can join us live for that on
- 5:11Twitter, LinkedIn or YouTube.
- 5:12And if you can't join us live,
- 5:13we still like to like for you to
- 5:15connect with us on the socials.
- 5:17You can follow your friends on Twitter,
- 5:18LinkedIn, YouTube,
- 5:19Blue Sky and whatever other else the
- 5:21republic has not yet completely collapsed.
- 5:24Search for AV Superfriends,
- 5:25look for the logo,
- 5:25and pledge your allegiance to the only
- 5:27podcast brave enough to talk about
- 5:28classroom technology,
- 5:29bad procurement decisions,
- 5:30and HDMI handshakes in the same breath.
- 5:32Also, don't forget to spread the word.
- 5:33Share this podcast with your friends,
- 5:34colleagues, enemies, loyalists,
- 5:36revolutionaries,
- 5:36and that one person on campus who still
- 5:38thinks VGA always just seems to work
- 5:40better.
- 5:41We ask you to celebrate your independence
- 5:42from boring AV content by forcing someone
- 5:44else to listen to a few dozen episodes,
- 5:45preferably in public,
- 5:47preferably while you're wearing a tricorn
- 5:48hat.
- 5:49We're not saying you should dump tea into
- 5:50a harbor,
- 5:50but if that tea is a terrible wireless
- 5:52presentation system,
- 5:53we understand and we salute you.
- 5:56If you want to support the show,
- 5:56please consider donating.
- 5:57Your contributions help us to keep
- 5:59bringing you the honest content that you
- 6:00love or love to hate without having to
- 6:01form a committee, issue a bond,
- 6:03or beg the Constitutional, I'm sorry,
- 6:04the Continental Congress for emergency
- 6:07podcast funding.
- 6:08You can find the donation link for that
- 6:09in the show notes or on our website.
- 6:11We are eager to hear from you,
- 6:12so please send us your questions,
- 6:13comments, complaints, grievances,
- 6:14strongly worded declarations,
- 6:15or proposed amendments to the AV
- 6:16Constitution via email mailbag at
- 6:19avsuperfriends.com.
- 6:21If you want to talk AV, ed tech,
- 6:22higher ed, bad installs, heroic fixes,
- 6:24or why your campus still has a projector
- 6:26older than the Bill of Rights,
- 6:27we want to hear about it.
- 6:29So join us live, follow us online,
- 6:30share the show, support the cause,
- 6:31and help us to continue the long national
- 6:33struggle for liberty, justice,
- 6:34and properly labeled cables for all.
- 6:36Thank you for your support.
- 6:37We could not do this without you.
- 6:40So there you go.
- 6:41You did it.
- 6:41You made it.
- 6:43And all that crap.
- 6:44And all the other crap.
- 6:46Whatever that stuff is.
- 6:47Like and subscribe.
- 6:48Oh, we have a button for that.
- 6:49Hold on.
- 6:49Yeah, smash that like button, Jamie.
- 6:51Bang.
- 6:51It's right in front of Larry.
- 6:52Oh.
- 6:52All right.
- 6:53That's enough of that.
- 6:58Actually,
- 6:58you could put one up by your head
- 6:59over there that would have the logo.
- 7:02All sorts of cool stuff.
- 7:02Yeah, you'd be all in the way.
- 7:04So on today's show, being the theme.
- 7:06Not that.
- 7:07Being the theme of Independence Day,
- 7:11Fourth of July, summer stuff, whatever,
- 7:13all that fun stuff.
- 7:14Usually what we do is we have a
- 7:16list of grievances and we celebrate
- 7:18America by blowing up a small part of
- 7:20it.
- 7:21This year we decided we're going to lean
- 7:22into the semi-quincentennial birthday and
- 7:27declare independence from AV stuff.
- 7:31So it could be independence from...
- 7:33poorly documented systems or from
- 7:36proprietary design whatever that may be we
- 7:38all have a thing we're going to declare
- 7:39independence from um and we'll just see
- 7:42how that shakes out as we tend to
- 7:45complain about things aspirational
- 7:46independence very much aspirational it
- 7:50always says so let me see let me
- 7:53get this going oh man
- 7:57Why is that not?
- 7:57There it goes.
- 7:58All right.
- 7:59There we go.
- 7:59Get some music.
- 8:01Set the stage here.
- 8:02Lots of fireworks to fire.
- 8:04There we go.
- 8:07You always get that first one where it's
- 8:08like, it's dark enough.
- 8:10It's dark enough.
- 8:11There's always that kid down the street.
- 8:13You wait for that.
- 8:14Like, what?
- 8:16Oh, Cam.
- 8:18Let's see what else we got here.
- 8:19That's a whole thing.
- 8:21Where's our fireworks?
- 8:23Here we go.
- 8:24Kudos to Cam.
- 8:25We are in the midst of putting together
- 8:26an assessment document.
- 8:27We always get all these manufacturers.
- 8:29Can you try this thing out for us?
- 8:31We want to give them back real stuff.
- 8:34feedback with numbers and what we
- 8:36documented.
- 8:37Here's why we think your thing,
- 8:39your widget, your tchotchke,
- 8:40your plastic and steel is either good or
- 8:43bad.
- 8:45Freedom from not having any documented
- 8:46trial and error and assessment.
- 8:48Kudos to Cam for putting it together.
- 8:50Wait,
- 8:50so what are you declaring independence
- 8:53from?
- 8:53You lost me there.
- 8:54Just trying stuff with no documented
- 8:56feedback to the manufacturer.
- 8:58Does it work?
- 8:59Does it not work?
- 9:00Does it do more than just turn on?
- 9:02Would it work for you or would it
- 9:03not work for you?
- 9:04and why i like the ones that step
- 9:06one uh create an account for our cloud
- 9:08service correct or just pay a bunch of
- 9:11money and we'll let you know if it's
- 9:12any good just saying that's a whole thing
- 9:14too no i don't think to do that
- 9:16just pay us a bunch of money and
- 9:17we guarantee it's good oh yeah there's
- 9:19that too sorry no there's no assessment
- 9:21going on on any of those we thought
- 9:23about it you know we should we should
- 9:24provide them some feedback as to what
- 9:27their thing does well,
- 9:28or what it doesn't do well,
- 9:29and why we think it would work or
- 9:31not work for whatever the solution is,
- 9:32and so we put together a whole document
- 9:33package.
- 9:33So, I mean, we didn't.
- 9:35I mean, you can, you know who,
- 9:36the tokens put it all together for us,
- 9:38but that's a different story.
- 9:40Does it use lots of em dashes?
- 9:43It might.
- 9:43No, actually, it's very clean.
- 9:44Alright, anyway, so what are we doing?
- 9:50What is this?
- 9:52We're declaring independence from AV
- 9:53stuff.
- 9:54I've got a very specific one.
- 9:56I know you do.
- 9:57Start us off.
- 9:58Get us moving.
- 9:59Get it going.
- 10:00I am going to declare independence from
- 10:03single vendor fantasy ecosystem lock-in.
- 10:07Damn it.
- 10:08That was what I was going to do.
- 10:09can you give me a description an example
- 10:11of what one of these may look like
- 10:13so uh we're all familiar with these from
- 10:15the standpoint of your favorite tronesis
- 10:17company out there okay who builds their
- 10:20stuff to work not just best with but
- 10:22usually only with their stuff
- 10:25and sometimes this one of these large
- 10:27companies goes out and purchases another
- 10:28company and now that stuff suddenly only
- 10:31works with the other stuff so you have
- 10:33to kind of like stay in brand lock-in
- 10:35sort of thing digging digging the hole yes
- 10:38although sometimes the new company stuff
- 10:40does not work with the old company stuff
- 10:42i've noticed sometimes yeah so when they
- 10:43do that then they have a new version
- 10:45of that thing that no longer works with
- 10:46the old version of the thing so
- 10:48um it is uh it's eminently frustrating it
- 10:51is uh always a pain in the ass
- 10:53um and usually uh kind of starts uh
- 10:57guiding whether or not you want it or
- 10:59not you're kind of on rails at that
- 11:00point if you are going to stay with
- 11:02the supports uh uh ecosystem stay with the
- 11:05the the available um
- 11:07uh software access and development costs
- 11:10and all these things are kind of locked
- 11:11in and so your choice for whatever stuff
- 11:14you may need down the road uh of
- 11:16any sort of control switching transport
- 11:19encoding decoding appliance whatever it
- 11:21may be is like oh it's whatever one
- 11:24they're offering yeah you can have
- 11:25anything you want as long as it's one
- 11:26of these three that's right
- 11:30Actually, it turns out there's only one,
- 11:31and it's not out yet.
- 11:33It might come out next quarter, maybe.
- 11:37One of the things I've been doing is
- 11:38I've been rebuilding well over a hundred
- 11:40and fifty spaces on campus over the last
- 11:41four years is
- 11:44doing everything i can to avoid that sort
- 11:46of lock-in it is it is required at
- 11:48a certain point because generally the
- 11:50physical interface clicky button or touch
- 11:52thing or whatever only seems to talk to
- 11:55one brand things though check out open abc
- 11:58if you haven't already um and other ones
- 12:00like it but
- 12:02That kind of where things start,
- 12:03but it doesn't mean you're limited to
- 12:05like,
- 12:05I have to use their transport ecosystem.
- 12:07I have to use their audio system.
- 12:09Like there's many other options.
- 12:10I've done everything I can to continue
- 12:12broadening my horizons and the horizons of
- 12:14my staff.
- 12:14So we are better at our own jobs
- 12:17because it means we speak more than one
- 12:18manufacturer language.
- 12:20This is not the case for most people.
- 12:22It is always a challenge.
- 12:23And I understand it's easier to just go
- 12:25spec everything from one manufacturer
- 12:27because then you don't have to worry about
- 12:28it in theory.
- 12:29But my warranty, Chris, my warranty.
- 12:32I want a single throat to choke.
- 12:34Yeah, it's the myth of...
- 12:37Is the myth of that,
- 12:38the support structure, actually legit?
- 12:40I have found it not.
- 12:41No, it's not.
- 12:43But they will perpetuate it as such.
- 12:45It's just safer to buy it all from
- 12:47one place because we know it'll all work
- 12:49from one place.
- 12:50It's all been tested in theory on paper.
- 12:52I just find that that's a myth.
- 12:54Yeah.
- 12:55I think when you chunk your system into
- 12:57the layers that it exists in,
- 12:58there isn't one manufacturer that's
- 12:59addressing all those layers cleanly
- 13:01anyway.
- 13:03There's two big ones who try their best,
- 13:05and their salespeople will tell you
- 13:06otherwise.
- 13:07So I don't think that one of those
- 13:10layers is required to be one of the
- 13:13other ones.
- 13:14You, my friend,
- 13:15in that time period between now and July,
- 13:18must have not have talked to the right
- 13:20boots at Infocomm.
- 13:23Well,
- 13:24I'm sure somebody will show me on it.com
- 13:25and yes,
- 13:26Justin did actually
- 13:30Declare his independence from us today.
- 13:33He said he was too cool to be
- 13:34on this show with us.
- 13:36Come on, Larry.
- 13:37This is your chance.
- 13:38Let it go.
- 13:39Come on.
- 13:41We call this a Justin Free Friday.
- 13:42It's like every other Friday, isn't it?
- 13:46It is a Justin Free Friday.
- 13:50Justin.
- 13:51The rivalry between Larry and Justin over
- 13:53who may or may not miss a show.
- 13:55continues you know what whoever has an
- 13:58account out there they can spend some
- 13:59tokens on us can you give us an
- 14:00audit on how many shows each of us
- 14:02have been on i don't i want to
- 14:05know the numbers i already know that i'm
- 14:10justin's problem
- 14:12speaking of justin the thing that i'm
- 14:16declaring independence from will sound
- 14:19just like justin so i'm sticking up for
- 14:21justin at this point i am all right
- 14:26yeah so historically on our campus
- 14:30The architects bring in the AV consultant
- 14:34on large capital projects,
- 14:36and I'm the creep standing outside the
- 14:39window like Justin, staring inside,
- 14:42trying to like...
- 14:43Face pressed against the glass?
- 14:44Yeah.
- 14:44Like smearing things?
- 14:46I send them our designs and...
- 14:49try to play nice and hopefully they use
- 14:51some of them watching them laughing
- 14:55exactly doing that doesn't cost enough
- 14:57money we're not going to make any margin
- 14:58that's not all from the same company no
- 15:02preferably one you don't use however this
- 15:05past year i've actually got a capital
- 15:09project that we're designing from the
- 15:11start and then we have another one that
- 15:15i'm actually working in
- 15:18close proximity with the AV consultant to
- 15:21get everything in the same county or
- 15:23they're actually talking to me like this
- 15:25is like usually they talk with the client
- 15:29and then I follow up and like okay
- 15:34in eight years how do you want this
- 15:35room to actually work like oh that kind
- 15:38of thing but I feel like this year
- 15:41we're actually making progress you know
- 15:42we're starting to
- 15:44dump tea over the side of the ship,
- 15:46we might be making headway in us handling
- 15:49all of the capital projects on campus.
- 15:54So I'm feeling pretty excited.
- 15:57I am declaring independence from
- 15:59consultants coming in and directing the
- 16:02future of buildings.
- 16:05The British are coming.
- 16:07I can see Larry running down the hall.
- 16:11Oh, man.
- 16:12Kicking tea out of their hands one cup
- 16:14at a time.
- 16:15No, we won't have it.
- 16:16Not here.
- 16:18Fight the fight.
- 16:20We're not consultants.
- 16:24We're adjusted.
- 16:27Jamie,
- 16:27you want one or you want me to
- 16:28jump in?
- 16:31I think I'm going to declare my
- 16:32independence, and I have been.
- 16:34I'm continuing my fight for independence
- 16:38from...
- 16:41specified independent networks.
- 16:46There will be no new islands on this
- 16:47country.
- 16:49When have you ever had an island?
- 16:51He's building up a wall.
- 16:54There will not be an island coming in
- 16:55here.
- 16:55There will be no islands.
- 16:58I got the bridge manufacturers happening.
- 17:01You got some sort of dredging ship and
- 17:03you're going out there connecting all the
- 17:04islands.
- 17:05All the islands.
- 17:06You're not part of the mainland.
- 17:08You build an island,
- 17:09I'm dropping in a new bridge.
- 17:11Or at least a ferry service.
- 17:14Um...
- 17:16Once they get all the packets.
- 17:17Yeah,
- 17:20at least it's going to run through there.
- 17:21It's not fast, but it'll get you there.
- 17:24Just put them all on this boat.
- 17:25It'll get there sooner or later.
- 17:27I use all my network ferry services for
- 17:29Dante.
- 17:29It works great next week.
- 17:32Oh, yeah.
- 17:33Don't worry about it.
- 17:33You can hear today's class in three days.
- 17:36But I had, to Larry's point,
- 17:40we did have a capital project where the
- 17:42original bid spec was for a company called
- 17:45who does have a healthy ecosystem,
- 17:49but it only kind of lives in its
- 17:50own little world.
- 17:52And I said, well,
- 17:53I need it on the big world.
- 17:55Like, well,
- 17:57it doesn't really work that way.
- 17:59Then I guess I really don't need to
- 18:01have you here.
- 18:03in which they responded with well that
- 18:05doesn't seem right very nice sir look quit
- 18:11quit selling me the goods of it's av
- 18:14over ip we can just go anywhere as
- 18:16long as it's on our own little network
- 18:18switch that's on our little network island
- 18:20that's on our little can it interconnect
- 18:21well yes but it won't work the way
- 18:25you think it should
- 18:27I'm just over it.
- 18:27So I know it's been an ongoing battle,
- 18:30but it seems like I lost ground in
- 18:32the last year or so.
- 18:34Wait,
- 18:34you're telling me somebody installed some
- 18:35islands over there?
- 18:38They're not installing them as much as
- 18:39they're attempting to.
- 18:40They're trying to.
- 18:41Oh, they're trying to.
- 18:43Hardcore.
- 18:44It's like eroding away.
- 18:45They have shovels out there.
- 18:47Every time he's not looking,
- 18:48they're just digging.
- 18:49It's kind of like those new islands that
- 18:53Abu Dhabi's putting outside.
- 18:55We're going to make a palm tree island.
- 18:58I thought you were thinking more like Bugs
- 19:00Bunny cutting Florida away.
- 19:02Whatever works.
- 19:04I just,
- 19:06but I'm also finding that even as an
- 19:08industry, we're kind of, it was like,
- 19:10everybody's trying to do that.
- 19:11Now they're kind of going back to what
- 19:12Chris was saying.
- 19:13Like,
- 19:13let's get away from that single vendor
- 19:14thing.
- 19:14And we're seeing vendors come out and say
- 19:16like, well, in our network,
- 19:18all this stuff plays nice together.
- 19:20But if you want to put it on
- 19:22a different network,
- 19:23it only three quarters of the way plays
- 19:25nice together.
- 19:26i'm just kind of tired of that bs
- 19:28three quarters of the way it plays nice
- 19:29together i want that to be somebody's
- 19:31slogan listen i'm full ass half ass of
- 19:34the time it's quarter ass well so to
- 19:39your point jim you are even seeing that
- 19:40with the the threatened and it comes up
- 19:42every couple years the threatened in this
- 19:44case av over ip interoperability yes but
- 19:47what we're seeing is kind of like hd
- 19:48based a number of years ago or still
- 19:50depending on you're using that or not um
- 19:53certain things will make that transition,
- 19:55but not all the features and not all
- 19:56the monitoring and not all the support and
- 19:58maintenance.
- 19:58It's just like...
- 20:00But if you buy only our stuff,
- 20:02it works fine.
- 20:05Come on.
- 20:06Just stop trying to close us in again.
- 20:09There's two main companies, like large...
- 20:12ish companies that over the years i chose
- 20:15them because they were more open and they
- 20:17were let's try and now they're starting to
- 20:19close themselves off they're building
- 20:21their own walls to fill the moat to
- 20:23become an our own island and i'm just
- 20:25kind of over it like come on let's
- 20:28open that crap up let's go let's use
- 20:30the full power islands are nice man you
- 20:33should give it a try
- 20:35The weather's great.
- 20:36Larry, feet up on an island, hanging out.
- 20:40Well, that's because Larry has, like,
- 20:41seventeen boats that he drives around to
- 20:43each one of these islands.
- 20:44Yeah.
- 20:45It's nice.
- 20:46I want to get the little umbrellas with
- 20:47just, like, one-nine-two, one-six-eight.
- 20:48And the weather's nice here, too.
- 20:49Put them in the drinks.
- 20:51Is it?
- 20:53In fact,
- 20:53I was just setting up a few encoders
- 20:54and decoders today,
- 20:55and they're all one-nine-two,
- 20:57and those suckers work all day long.
- 21:01It doesn't matter that it pulled a
- 21:02one-six-nine.
- 21:03It's fine!
- 21:04It still works.
- 21:05Those are a little more difficult when it
- 21:07does pull an APIPA.
- 21:07Yeah, I just, like I said,
- 21:10I'm declaring my independence from the
- 21:14islandification of our systems.
- 21:18You'll be back.
- 21:20All right.
- 21:23Okay.
- 21:23I believe in world peace.
- 21:24I'm looking at my list here of other
- 21:25things.
- 21:25We didn't get to mine.
- 21:26The first one was free.
- 21:27That was Pam.
- 21:28I'm just trying to see,
- 21:28did we do any ones on here that
- 21:30we already taken?
- 21:31Yeah, I guess we did.
- 21:32Okay.
- 21:33Mark,
- 21:33what are you declaring independence from?
- 21:35I have a list of things.
- 21:36The first one.
- 21:37There's no list.
- 21:39Get after it.
- 21:39I'm going to put it out here anyway.
- 21:41Freedom from the tyranny of the control
- 21:43panel.
- 21:45Ooh.
- 21:45Wait, wait.
- 21:46Expand.
- 21:47Do you mean the control interface,
- 21:49or what do you mean by that?
- 21:50One of the things I keep asking myself
- 21:52is why are we still expecting users to
- 21:54be temporary AV technicians every time
- 21:58they walk into a room?
- 22:00We're all guilty.
- 22:01We've spent decades perfecting the
- 22:03buttons, the panels, the menus,
- 22:04the source selection.
- 22:06Start here, buddy.
- 22:08Yeah, exactly.
- 22:11We shouldn't be making a better interface.
- 22:13We should be actually just eliminating an
- 22:14interface altogether.
- 22:16I know that sounds blasphemous to many,
- 22:18especially people who pride themselves.
- 22:20I'm a programmer.
- 22:21This is how it all starts.
- 22:22I get it.
- 22:23I get it.
- 22:24Look how terrible these graphics are.
- 22:26Right.
- 22:27I've seen people who think this is good.
- 22:28And I'm like,
- 22:29the fact that if it has any more
- 22:30than three selections on it, it's bad.
- 22:34What happens if there's four sources?
- 22:35No.
- 22:36Get rid of one of them.
- 22:37You don't need that.
- 22:38What's the fourth source, Larry?
- 22:39Get rid of it.
- 22:40I don't know, but I'm just saying.
- 22:41Justifies existence.
- 22:43Wireless share.
- 22:44Duh.
- 22:46It doesn't work on this island,
- 22:47but it could be it.
- 22:48You want to throw into Boston Harbor as
- 22:49far as you can.
- 22:50So, to me, it is, are we,
- 22:53for a chunk of the industry that claims
- 22:56automation and out there and doing the
- 22:58things,
- 22:58and we deal with sensors and all these
- 23:00things,
- 23:00we can automate a lot of things we
- 23:02ask people to have to do via those
- 23:04touch panels,
- 23:05and people still think they have to put
- 23:07those things on there.
- 23:08We've got to put an advanced page on
- 23:09here so they can route everything to the
- 23:10moon.
- 23:11Nobody cares.
- 23:13Nobody cares about that stuff.
- 23:14Because you think it's neat from a
- 23:16programmatic standpoint.
- 23:17I need blank and freeze.
- 23:18Yeah, like,
- 23:19do you need to have all this stuff?
- 23:21The more I see touch panels,
- 23:22the more I'm like,
- 23:23I just don't want to need those things.
- 23:25Mark,
- 23:25the module I got from my lock-in single
- 23:28manufacturer ecosystem,
- 23:29it has all these options.
- 23:31I'm putting all of them on there.
- 23:34No, they're not directors.
- 23:37I need to see my notes on the
- 23:39screen here in PowerPoint.
- 23:41You can't do that.
- 23:41No, that's...
- 23:42Using the same thing everywhere, sir.
- 23:44Right.
- 23:46Unless you bring a laptop or a paper.
- 23:49Let's break away from the shackles of
- 23:51over-buttoning touch panels and actually
- 23:52question the need to have them in the
- 23:54first place.
- 23:55What can we automate?
- 23:56The rooms do what?
- 23:58What are they supposed to do?
- 23:59Can we just automate that when people walk
- 24:00in, please?
- 24:01I want to hear who's going to turn
- 24:02it off.
- 24:03When they leave their room, it turns off.
- 24:05It doesn't matter.
- 24:07That happens if they fall asleep and the
- 24:09room turns off in the middle of the
- 24:10movie.
- 24:10That's not good.
- 24:11Well, you're not just doing motion.
- 24:14There's other ways we can do these
- 24:15different arguments.
- 24:17That might say more about the movie than
- 24:20the actual system.
- 24:22Freedom from the tyranny of the control
- 24:23panel.
- 24:23I think it's time to rethink where you
- 24:25actually need them.
- 24:26And it's not the first thing you need
- 24:27to have in every system is a control
- 24:29panel.
- 24:30I want to agree with you,
- 24:32but I have tried the automation route.
- 24:36I want to, but you're dumb.
- 24:37Sometimes people plug in things they don't
- 24:40actually want to see,
- 24:42and they need the panel there.
- 24:44They'll plug in their laptop,
- 24:46but not actually want to switch to the
- 24:48laptop.
- 24:48I have no idea why they do it,
- 24:50but I have seen that.
- 24:51I'm completely on board with the
- 24:53simplification of control.
- 24:55Yes.
- 24:56That's not what he said.
- 24:57He said remove the touch panel.
- 24:58I want to get rid of the touch
- 24:59panels if possible.
- 25:00I don't think that you really do.
- 25:01I don't think you can.
- 25:03During this call,
- 25:04I've been sending messages to my team that
- 25:05said go to every room in the college
- 25:06business room and get rid of them.
- 25:08Get rid of them.
- 25:09I'm thinking about the new car we just
- 25:11bought and the fact that it had... No.
- 25:14I mean, but...
- 25:16We'll have a long,
- 25:17deep-dive conversation at some point,
- 25:18like,
- 25:18what is it that you need that to
- 25:19do?
- 25:20Today's not the venue to do it,
- 25:21but I think we over-engineer by way of
- 25:22touchdowns, because we can.
- 25:24We don't need to be doing all that
- 25:26stuff.
- 25:26So, Mark, this is intriguing,
- 25:27and we've talked about this in the past
- 25:28many, many times,
- 25:29but this is an interesting concept of,
- 25:30like, the next time you have a,
- 25:32call it a simple room, a basic room,
- 25:36something without any frills...
- 25:38Can it be designed and engineered in such
- 25:40a way to not require a user interface
- 25:42and what would that look like?
- 25:43I think that's a personal challenge for
- 25:44everybody because there is definitely
- 25:46something to that.
- 25:47And I think we do those pretty
- 25:50consistently.
- 25:51It's once you get past that very simple
- 25:53room that I don't think it works.
- 25:55Well, that's my next thing.
- 25:56If there's time,
- 25:57freedom from the one-size-fits-all.
- 25:59It sounds like we have a future
- 26:01off-the-rails yelling contest on our
- 26:03hands.
- 26:04It doesn't need to be the same thing
- 26:05everywhere all the time.
- 26:06We can have variances.
- 26:08Anyway, that's my stuff.
- 26:09Standards hit apart.
- 26:12Kits that don't need to all be exactly
- 26:13the same.
- 26:15But how are we going to support that?
- 26:17You'll be fine.
- 26:19So somewhere in here,
- 26:20and I'm looking for my notes on it.
- 26:22Oh, no.
- 26:25There's notes?
- 26:25Well, sorry.
- 26:25I'm phrasing the wrong way.
- 26:27See,
- 26:27I don't have these all labeled correctly.
- 26:30What?
- 26:32One of my quiet contemplations is about
- 26:36touch panel interfaces.
- 26:37Oh, no.
- 26:38I think that that is inappropriate.
- 26:39But I don't know which one it is
- 26:40because I have them labeled by number.
- 26:42One, two, three, four.
- 26:43Are you sure it's not Contemplation F?
- 26:47I literally saw somebody on Facebook
- 26:48posting like, hey, look at this.
- 26:50We're doing a UI conversation.
- 26:52I couldn't tell if the post was
- 26:54Making fun of it or saying it was
- 26:56good?
- 26:57I think I remember that one.
- 26:59There's like...
- 27:00...twenty-seven buttons on this touch
- 27:02panel.
- 27:03And it's like, as a user...
- 27:04I found it.
- 27:06If your touch panel has more options than
- 27:08a standard keyboard on a computer...
- 27:11you are doing it wrong but you're correct
- 27:15we'd like you but we would like you
- 27:17to share that with some sort of yes
- 27:19quarterly manufacturer call and make
- 27:20everyone else look at it too so are
- 27:22we taking an impromptu quiet contemplation
- 27:25yes here we go okay here we go
- 27:26break it up ready here it goes and
- 27:30now quiet contemplations by miles dante
- 27:35If a touch panel has more than three
- 27:37or four buttons,
- 27:39it should also have a small slot where
- 27:41users can insert their hopes and watch
- 27:43them disappear.
- 27:47And hundred dollar bills.
- 27:49See that?
- 27:51We're getting there.
- 27:52By hope, we meant a hundred dollar bill.
- 27:55I built that automated room,
- 27:57which I've teased you guys having.
- 27:59It's a Zoom room, so there's a controller,
- 28:00but it's a meeting controller.
- 28:02All the stuff.
- 28:03Oh, my God.
- 28:04Okay, I declare we separate from Mark.
- 28:07That's a different thing.
- 28:10The on-off, all that stuff,
- 28:11do you need to press a button for
- 28:13on-off?
- 28:14Not if it's a Zoom room, no.
- 28:16Take that out.
- 28:17If I walk into a room,
- 28:18if I plug my thing in,
- 28:19do I need to have an on-off?
- 28:21Yes.
- 28:21Because apparently there are people who
- 28:25come in and plug in their laptops just
- 28:27to charge them.
- 28:28I have had to answer those support calls,
- 28:30yes.
- 28:31I think it sounds like we are going
- 28:33to have a show on this in the
- 28:34near future.
- 28:35What can be automated versus what can't.
- 28:36We're going to score it and we're going
- 28:38to weight it.
- 28:38And if any of you out there are
- 28:40listening to this and you think that Mark
- 28:42is an absolute moron.
- 28:44Which is everybody.
- 28:44Or agree with him.
- 28:45Or a genius.
- 28:47One of the two, that's it.
- 28:48No middle ground.
- 28:49No middle ground.
- 28:49There's nothing in between.
- 28:50You're the pro Mark or con Mark.
- 28:54Nothing in between.
- 28:55There's no in between.
- 28:56And come on and let's yell at him.
- 28:58So let's do that.
- 28:59You know, Mark,
- 28:59you could build a highly automated system
- 29:01to do all of this without any user
- 29:03interface if you stay within one
- 29:05manufacturer's ecosystem.
- 29:06Yes.
- 29:07That we've declared independence from.
- 29:08You might be right.
- 29:11Mark's declaring independence.
- 29:12I don't need to have any of those
- 29:13ecosystems to begin with.
- 29:16None of them.
- 29:19VGA cable strung directly to that
- 29:21projector,
- 29:22SignalSense gets a job done all day.
- 29:24There's something to be said for that.
- 29:25And then I use the twelve-volt tap off
- 29:27of the side of it to go over
- 29:29and hit the lights.
- 29:30Exactly.
- 29:34Anyway.
- 29:34All right.
- 29:36It is an intriguing, like, you know,
- 29:38design exercise.
- 29:39Like,
- 29:39how much of your typical space could you,
- 29:41like,
- 29:41fully automate and how would you do that?
- 29:43Yep.
- 29:45Nothing else, though.
- 29:45Everything else is fine.
- 29:49Chris,
- 29:49you have independence from mystery DSP
- 29:51files in here.
- 29:52Explain.
- 29:52I have independence from everything.
- 29:53You don't like just random ass DSPs that
- 29:55are done differently by somebody else?
- 29:58But if the outcome's the same,
- 29:59does it matter?
- 30:01Yeah, when you go to troubleshoot, like,
- 30:02why is that mic over there weird?
- 30:03Holy crap, what is this?
- 30:05My favorite is,
- 30:06I'm going to declare independence from the
- 30:07DSP.
- 30:07I need everything to line up in the
- 30:09DSP.
- 30:09I can't stand, like, the weird, like,
- 30:10spider web stuff.
- 30:11I want everything to be very linear.
- 30:14Or the simplified DSP files where there's
- 30:15one giant mixer block,
- 30:17and it all runs to that.
- 30:18Oh, the mystery blocks.
- 30:19Oh, this is the,
- 30:21what do they call it?
- 30:21The, um...
- 30:23the terms like oh you just be whatever
- 30:25you want it to be don't do that
- 30:26flex block yeah don't do that shit like
- 30:28you're hiding like you're hiding like
- 30:30you're hiding like you're hiding like my
- 30:31proprietary seasoning is my proprietary
- 30:32seasoning is my proprietary seasoning is
- 30:34special spices i put into my psp special
- 30:35spices i put into my psp special spices
- 30:36i put into my psp program i cop
- 30:36i've been using this same program i cop
- 30:37i've been using this same program i cop
- 30:38i've been using this same one for ten
- 30:39years one for ten years one for ten
- 30:39years great does it though it's a great
- 30:40does it though it's a great does it
- 30:41though it's a channel strip i mean let's
- 30:42be channel strip i mean let's be
- 30:46Let's see.
- 30:46Do we have anything else we want?
- 30:47We've talked about architects.
- 30:48We have that in there.
- 30:50Proprietary cables would be a good one.
- 30:52I'm glad we're seeing companies move away
- 30:53from that.
- 30:54They're going to come back.
- 30:57By the way, I found this one.
- 30:59I had a very old room, something called,
- 31:01say, the camera stopped working,
- 31:02et cetera, et cetera.
- 31:02When everyone looked at it, yeah, hey,
- 31:03that camera seems to be dead.
- 31:04It receives its power over this
- 31:05proprietary cable from a unit over there,
- 31:07which is also using a proprietary
- 31:09extender.
- 31:11Which is also discontinued.
- 31:12So the cable and extender are both
- 31:14discontinued.
- 31:14You're up a creek.
- 31:16So enjoy.
- 31:17Just call your ecosystem of choice and get
- 31:21your new one.
- 31:23uh also noted displays with terrible input
- 31:25switching that's a that's a good one like
- 31:27i'm going to show you the home screen
- 31:28because here's many android icons you
- 31:30might want to look at that there i
- 31:33declare independence from home screens on
- 31:36professional displays like we need to be
- 31:38able to turn that shit off i'm so
- 31:40tired of
- 31:42Getting a, quote, professional display,
- 31:44and then it's got the Android front end
- 31:47or something similar, the web OS,
- 31:49and you can't do anything with it.
- 31:52That's absolutely ridiculous.
- 31:53Can you be called professional commercial
- 31:55and have Android on it at the same
- 31:56time?
- 31:57Apparently so,
- 31:58because that's all they're shipping now,
- 32:00and it's awful.
- 32:04Many of them also are Teams appliances.
- 32:06It's fantastic.
- 32:07It's an Android-based Teams appliance.
- 32:08Enjoy.
- 32:10It costs nine thousand dollars.
- 32:11What could go wrong?
- 32:11Look how many of those I never buy.
- 32:16We put Google and Microsoft in the same
- 32:18box.
- 32:18Good luck.
- 32:19Do you have a final finale with the
- 32:20fireworks here?
- 32:21Oh, that's right.
- 32:22I forgot I paused all my fireworks.
- 32:26Why is it not unpausing?
- 32:27We need something very controversial.
- 32:29Uh-oh.
- 32:31The most controversial of all of them.
- 32:32Why is it... You broke everything.
- 32:35Everything seems to be broken now.
- 32:37Yeah, that's...
- 32:38What is happening?
- 32:39Freedom from network.
- 32:40This is what happens when you get that
- 32:41fancy new fiber you updated to.
- 32:42It should have been a private island.
- 32:44There it is.
- 32:45Well, but the fireworks are happening.
- 32:49There's a button labeled pause and unpause
- 32:52all,
- 32:53and the unpause ain't unpauseing nothing.
- 32:55Whoever did the touchpad design sucks.
- 32:57Well, yeah,
- 32:58this one has just as many keys as
- 32:59a laptop, which oddly enough,
- 33:00because it's running on a laptop.
- 33:01I love it.
- 33:03I love it.
- 33:05All right, well, enough of that.
- 33:06I would say then, yes,
- 33:07we simply declare independence from bad AV
- 33:10stuff.
- 33:10Across the board...
- 33:11Overpriced little widgets are also...
- 33:14What's overpriced if it's a little widget?
- 33:17I have this fundamental belief.
- 33:20Smaller the widget,
- 33:21the less it should cost.
- 33:23Soundbars.
- 33:25Soundbars are not a premium.
- 33:27Mark,
- 33:28could I interest you one that has an
- 33:30internal appliance for an ecosystem you
- 33:32don't use?
- 33:33This now costs seven thousand dollars.
- 33:35When I've made that cognitive choice that
- 33:37I'm going with the soundbar,
- 33:38I've already decided I'm not going with
- 33:40the most premium option.
- 33:40You've already made enough compromises in
- 33:45that space.
- 33:45Mediocre audio is good enough.
- 33:46I don't need nine thousand dollars in your
- 33:47soundbar.
- 33:48Thousands of dollars is not going to make
- 33:49up that difference.
- 33:51What if it cost even more?
- 33:52Now it's more premium.
- 33:54But what?
- 33:56if I put a service contract on that.
- 33:57Would that mean I'm in business?
- 34:01What if it tied to our also proprietary
- 34:04cloud monitoring service that could show
- 34:05you if it's red or green?
- 34:07You have to go through my proprietary
- 34:10service to even get it online, sir?
- 34:12Yeah.
- 34:13Oh, you wanted to configure it?
- 34:16Yeah, I need an account.
- 34:17Let's go set up an account with our
- 34:18cloud monitoring thing.
- 34:19Yeah,
- 34:21I just used one of those the other
- 34:22day.
- 34:22Granted,
- 34:23performance on it was pretty good.
- 34:26for the cost I paid, which was,
- 34:27here's a trial, it's free, sort of thing.
- 34:29Step one is sign up for your cloud
- 34:30monitoring service.
- 34:31I'm not really pleased with that.
- 34:32I put it right back in the box.
- 34:35You know who you are.
- 34:36Bring it to Infocom, drop it off.
- 34:37I'm not, no.
- 34:41It's sitting in the box here on my
- 34:42desk.
- 34:42Give me a shipping label.
- 34:43Your desk has no room on it, then.
- 34:45That thing's on your desk.
- 34:47I do like this option of taking stuff
- 34:49to Infocom and returning it to the booth.
- 34:52Yeah.
- 34:52We've shipped things to corporate
- 34:53headquarters before and just no return.
- 34:55Just pick, here you go.
- 34:56We have a mixer we might do that
- 34:58with.
- 34:58yes maybe if you're listening i don't
- 35:01think i don't think that zoom is going
- 35:02to be there we can leave it at
- 35:04the other we can take it to the
- 35:05other zoom and here's your mixer back this
- 35:08did not work very well i don't i
- 35:11don't even think the stupid ipad app that
- 35:13runs that mixer is even works anymore i
- 35:17don't know it's so bad i have the
- 35:19ipad app but the mixer is over at
- 35:20your place the connection doesn't
- 35:22bluetooth does not go twelve hundred miles
- 35:27And it didn't work well to begin with.
- 35:29Things you learn on the road.
- 35:32We done declaring independence from
- 35:33things?
- 35:33We're declaring it.
- 35:34Lessons from the road.
- 35:36Hey, Mark, this is July.
- 35:40We've already been there.
- 35:41Thank God we went to Infocom.
- 35:42We just got back from Infocom.
- 35:46We're all a little hungover, but smarter.
- 35:47I can close out with this.
- 35:50I forgot I had this loaded in here.
- 35:55We really miss Justin, apparently.
- 35:57Yeah,
- 35:57Justin holds this whole thing together.
- 35:58You guys don't know Hulk Hogan's...
- 36:00I was going to say, is this wrestling?
- 36:07Then light up the fireworks.
- 36:08Let's make this grand entry.
- 36:10Let's go.
- 36:11This is entrance music for the longest
- 36:12time.
- 36:12All right, take us out of here,
- 36:17big guy.
- 36:17Hold on, I'm going upstairs.
- 36:20This one says grand finale.
- 36:21I have to run.
- 36:26Well, everybody, thanks for listening.
- 36:27We got there.
- 36:28All right, I'll get out of here.
- 36:31Welcome to the summer.
- 36:32I'm going to leave the hook of this.
- 36:34Keep it rolling.
- 36:41Thanks for putting up with yet another
- 36:42episode of AV Super Friends On Topic.
- 36:45You can contact us with questions,
- 36:46topic ideas,
- 36:47or general complaints at
- 36:48avsuperfriends.com.
- 36:59Nice work, everyone.
- 36:59Sharp broadcast.
- 37:00Really good.
- 37:01Everyone on the floor as well.
- 37:02Really a lot of hustle.
- 37:03I liked it.
- 37:05The opinions expressed by the AV
- 37:06Superfriends are solely those of the
- 37:07individuals and do not represent their
- 37:09respective institutions, organizations,
- 37:11companies, or clients.