Latest / Backfire Guns Podcast / The Truth About 6.5 Creed Plus Peak...
Transcript
- speaker-0: Welcome back to the Guns Podcast. It is a beautiful day. We got some interesting stuff happening in the firearm. speaker-1: ⁓ man, it's getting spicy out there because Federal announced the 6.5 Creedmoor Plus peak. Now, this isn't like breaking news. I think you guys have seen this. We didn't want to do too much of like a reaction video to this, like right at launch, because we kind of want to take a couple days and wrap our heads around this one. And my my thoughts have evolved quite a bit over the last few days as I've looked at it. What was your initial so well? Okay. Those who don't know, this is for bolt action rifles. This is, you know, center fire ammo. They've taken the ever popular six point five Creedmoor load and they've released a high pressure version of it. So while, you know, your standard cartridges might go at whatever, 72,000 PSI, this thing's going to 80,000 or, you know, sometimes lower 65,000, 60,000 PSI for standard. ⁓ this thing's going up to 80,000 PSI. And so we're using, you know, hotter powders in the exact same brass case to just create more pressure and shoot that bullet out faster. Now, the reason that you would not do this before is because the gun explodes when you do this. So the brass needs to be able to hold the pressure in there. The brass is just barely smaller than the chamber, and then as the the bullet goes off as the cartridge explodes, as ignition happens, the the brass or the the the case anyway, is expanding just slightly and then is constrained by the chamber around it so that it doesn't just keep extr keep expanding and bust. And then if the if the brass or the case ex busts get a s gets a seam in it, then the pressure comes out and the action isn't airtight, so we're Sending gases out in a dangerous way, but then also the pressure just keeps building on that action, and the action may not be strong enough, and then you blow out the side, and that's where we get into real problems. So that's why we haven't done this in the past, just super high pressure, because you know that's kind of what the actions were made to. So what Federal has done is they took a cartridge that was made recently, the 6.5 Creedmore, relatively recently, 20 years. And they said, well, if this is using a modern twist rate and more modern actions, you know, it doesn't have a eighteen hundreds action, you know, on or, you know, you couldn't do this with 3006, right? Because it's been made for too long. Who knows? But with all modern actions doing this, they say, Huh, we s maybe we can just bump up the pressures in this. So that's that's the genesis of this. What it promises is it takes your old school six five Creedmore and it turns it into a fire breathing dragon. Now instead of going 2,800 feet per second, you go over 3,000 feet per second with the exact same rifle you currently have. Okay, so that's we set the set the story for those of you who missed it. speaker-0: I I'll be honest, my first thoughts, I was slightly skeptical just because of what we saw with the seven backcountry, because similar idea, ⁓ was nobody really showed accuracy when they shot it. And so that was my first thought was like, okay, I'm curious to see how, you know, this high pressure stuff is affecting accuracy. So that was my first thought. ⁓ and I still don't know. So I don't really have a fully formed thought about that part of the cartridge because we haven't seen it yet, but I think there's a a reason we're not seeing it. But I think, I mean, I was really high on the seven back country when it first came out. I still really like the seven back country. ⁓ and I f I think I kind of have to like the six five Creedmore plus peak too, because it's the same thing in a six five basically. Mm-hmm. ⁓ and I I think probably the craziest the craziest part about this is and we did see this with the seven back country too in a quite a bit shorter barrel, you can get the same velocities as a six five PRC, ⁓ with, you know, less recoil. And that is super intriguing to me. Yeah. I mean, we're we're shooting their exact claim is you can shoot a a ⁓ a six five Krimo plus peak in a twenty-inch barrel at the same speed as a six five PRC in a twenty-four-inch barrel. And that's that's pretty crazy if that's true. ⁓ I've yet to like shoot the gun myself. We we haven't been able to get our hands on it yet, but man, that's pretty sweet. speaker-1: Okay. You just okay, you just launched a lot of things we have done. speaker-0: Did but I didn't go into detail about them. I just those were my first thoughts. That's what I thought about. Now we can kind of uncover. speaker-1: It's good. ⁓ I yeah, and I I had some of the same original thoughts. the one that I might add to that is just I it it's easy for the average consumer to get to get sucked into v more velocity is always better. And so I'm seeing it seems like the average person when they see this, they're like, Whoa, I have an outgun now. And and Because you know, I got a 6.5 Creedmore and now it's so much better. Just got the 2.0 upgrade. And the water that I always want to put on that is we we've always been able to do that. We it's the issue has never been, I just don't know how to get a six point five millimeter bullet to go any faster than a six five Creedmore. ⁓ we can't do it. There there's been the twenty-six nozzler that'll absolutely send that bullet. speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-1: Flying downrange. There's been the six five PRC. Like people have cre made insane wildcats with a 50 BMG case launching out a 6.5 millimeter bullet, right? Like the issue has never been we can't make a 6.5 millimeter bullet go faster. And yet I think that's what most consumers are latched onto is now. Ooh, better. And there's a reason that 6.5 millimeter Creedmore became so famous. speaker-0: Speed. Right. speaker-1: Launching bullets at very mild 2750 feet per second kind of velocities, even though other cartridges could go much faster. And so that was my initial reaction is you guys, that wasn't the goal. Like we've turning we're turning into the s the 6.5 Creedmoor into the 6.5 PRC. Well, then why not just use the 6.5 PRC? Right. That was my initial thought. speaker-0: Right. Yeah, I I was slightly skeptical. Like I say, I'm I'm very curious to see accuracy because I the seven back country have yet to see really accurate. and you know, maybe that's just a caliber thing, maybe that's just a seven millimeter, it's going hot. We've seen that with seven PRC and other things. ⁓ and so I'm curious to see if this is going to affect the accuracy of the six five Cream because I mean As much as people like to hate on the six five Creedmore, it's one of the most inherently accurate cartridges out there. It's why it's why everyone and their dog has one, you know? And so I'm curious to see how it affects the accuracy in people's current six five Creedmore guns. speaker-1: Yeah. Okay, so I I that's that's my number one question here. If we could do this and do it accurately, okay, we don't need just raw speed, but there could be some advancements here that we'll get to. I so I I'm with ya. Now the seven backcountry, I have seen endless problems with accuracy on. Would you agree just as we've read comments from people? speaker-0: Everywhere, whether it's y our own YouTube comments, other people's YouTube comments, forums, you know, it's just everywhere. You see it all the time. Anytime you're looking at seven backcountry anything, that's gonna be one of the first things that comes up is people having accuracy issues with it. speaker-1: Right. Now I did see I I can't remember who it was. ⁓ Somebody I follow online, somebody I know that built a a seven back country and and got it to be very accurate, ⁓ like you know, th three quarter MOA kind of accuracy. Good. ⁓ totally happy with that in a hunting rifle. And so it it can be done for sure, but in the ones that we've shot, in what we hear from you guys, it's a problem. Now What I would say though is seven backcountry is a lot of cartridge for a lightweight hunting rifle. It kind of like a 300 PRC. The 300 PRC is by no means an inaccurate cartridge, but it's so much cartridge that in a lightweight hunting rifle, you're I I might even go so far as to say you're you're probably not going to have good accuracy results. Even the top notch, you know, we're going to the expensive rifles. When it's a three hundred PRC and a lightweight rifle, I'm probably you're probably about maxed out or ab around one point two MOA. Probably. Yeah. Is that fair enough? speaker-0: Yeah. Kind of what we've seen with through our accuracy testing on the accuracy database. Yeah. You know, anything three hundred wind mag and up, it just kind of seems we can't really get under that one inch zone. Right. It's like everything ⁓ it even in you know, we've shot some we have some expensive guns on that list, you know, the Seekins, the Socco, and they've none of them have been able to really get under under that area. Right. And so yeah, yeah, I would agree with that. speaker-1: And ⁓ the important caveat that that we know, but just to make sure the listeners are on the same page as us, what you're talking about is we can't get that good accuracy if we're talking about just cramming a big cartridge into the exact same lightweight rifle. If you set up that rifle to shoot those bigger cartridges at drive tacks with them. Absolutely. But if you just take your regular old whatever TKT three X super, you know, super light. And you shoot it in a ⁓ 22 ⁓ whatever a 243 and then a whatever a seven PRC in the exact same thing. I promise you the two forty-three is more accurate. It just it will be yeah in that same rifle platform. But you can build it. You just you just have to. And most people, you know, it's it's backcountry, right? Seven back country is the whole idea. So this is going in lightweight rifles a lot of times. And a lot of times, similar to the seven PRC. It's tough. speaker-0: And one of the big selling points for them is shorter barrels. Mm-hmm. And where are you gonna find shorter barrels? In the lighter weight hunting guns. And so it it's a selling point, it's cool, it's it's cool to think about, but like you do have to take into account and now here we do have, you know, less cartridge. So that is appealing. Yeah. speaker-1: That makes sense, right? Yeah, it's like if we said ⁓ seven backcountry or seven PRC can be a lot for a lightweight rifle. Well here you go. speaker-0: Now we got a s now we got a little six five. Yeah. speaker-1: So one thing I did notice though is in the videos that did come out, it's pretty obvious that federal their marketing guys must be pretty locked in the magazine world. 'Cause like the only people that got early access to this thing were the magazines. Yeah. Like they don't YouTube, nah. speaker-0: Yeah. There was a couple of YouTubers but like they were magazine people that have a YouTube channel. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. They like like I thought it was interesting. They they emailed us but they didn't give us the early ammo to the actual ammo. It was just like here's the info about the cartridge. Yeah. But speaker-1: Not all like magazine They gave us seven backcountry early. speaker-0: They did do that. Yeah, with the help of Horizon. But yes. Yeah. speaker-1: Anyway, so ⁓ so the six point five plus peak accuracy, I initially say I'm not so sure because just a lot of pressure, just more vibrations happening in that rifle during the accuracy, but it is less than the seven back country. And I did notice as the the influencers that that did show it, all of them said, now Federal told us we can show this ammo, but not to talk about the accuracy. Because it hadn't been tuned in yet. And I'm like, ⁓ you know what I mean? Yeah. Like that's it's like saying, you can review this Lamborghini, but don't drive it. Yeah. You know, like accuracy is the one thing that I care about. I care how it's gonna shoot. And so, you know, not to take a cynical view at it, because I understand there can be things, but I kind of feel like, is this even ready to show? speaker-0: Yeah, my If Yeah, it's one of those it's one of those things where it's like i i you probably shouldn't have shown it, but I wonder if the reason they did was because they don't want somebody else to come up with this before then. Yeah. And so they're trying to get out in front of the in front of the horses here. Yeah. And but at the same time, like, y do you want to release a bad product at at the cost of that? You know, like is that worth it? Uhhuh. ⁓ speaker-1: ⁓ I've speaker-0: I would say probably not, but maybe they see it differently. Mm-hmm. Yeah. speaker-1: And with the seven backcountry, they were tweaking that load until like right when it came out. ⁓ and that's something I'm not super comfortable with. Like you know, wait till very last for accuracy. you know, th that that does have me nervous. But I mean, hey, I mean it's not like we or anybody else can be dogging on it because we just we haven't seen it. We don't know. Yeah. The one Area four nineteen did a video on it that I liked. ⁓ and they did show some of the groups. I think it was at two hundred yards or something like that. And it was like okay-ish. There was a lot of a lot of, well, look at these three. They're really close together. That one could have been me. You know, where it's just like the classic thing everybody always says, it's like speaker-0: Yeah. ⁓ Right. speaker-1: And I'm like, Yeah, you know sometimes that's absolutely the case. Yeah. But a lot of times it's like, no, that's just the natural dispersion of this ammo. Like sometimes it's it they're not all in one hole and it's not anything you're doing wrong necessarily. It's like you shoot enough, you shoot a twenty thirty shot group and you start to see, ⁓ yeah, a lot of them get in the center, but a lot of them aren't, you know. Right. And so I don't give you I never give anything a pass and just say like, ⁓ that would you know. Maybe that was me. I'm like, no, if I'm shooting this for accuracy testing, I need to show up, do my job, and say, no, I put together a good group there. What's on the page is on the page. That's that's that's the gun, that's the ammo. Right. Anyway. So what do you think then? What is your bet when we get to actually shoot the production of this stuff? Do you think accuracy is going to be a problem? speaker-0: I I don't think it's gonna be as big of a problem as the seven back country, just because it's not as much. Mm-hmm. ⁓ but I it's I can't imagine accuracy, you know, if we put it in one of our current six five Creed Morris, I can't imagine it would be the same accuracy. I would imagine it's increasing by a quarter to and half an i to a half an inch on average. Okay. That's my that's my guess. speaker-1: Yes. I wouldn't be surprised if that's the case, but I also am like open open to the case that but y maybe that's not the case at all. speaker-0: Maybe it's just accurate. Yeah, it could be. It could be. But I I just until I see it, it's hard for me to believe 'cause when you look at all the numbers it's like that's it's a lot. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. speaker-1: Okay, interesting. Well, all right. So accuracy, we just gotta see. One thing that I will say that they're doing a good job of is they're launching five different bullets in this six five Creed more plus peak. That's really cool because ⁓ another thing that I was thinking is like if you s there are a lot of people that would say six five Creed, nah, not for elk. Six five six point five PRC, yeah, that you know, might might just be enough. And so if you are in that case. Or or if if you do subscribe to that theory, then ⁓ my problem with saying just buy the six five creed and use plus peak would be, yeah, but what if your gun doesn't like that one load? Mm-hmm. But here where they're giving you five different loads that you're able to test, probably one of them will speaker-0: And I think it's what work. And I think it'll be two on release and then the three they just have listed as coming soon. ⁓ I see that. Yeah. So they've got they've got the two, the Terminal Ascent and the Fusion Tipped, are both gonna be on release. And then they've got ⁓ three others, the Burger Elite Hunter, the Barnes LRX and the Sierra Match King. Those three are listed as coming soon. So I'm not sure wh speaker-1: I didn't see Good catch. I didn't see that. speaker-0: It's all technically coming soon, right? Because none of it's out right now for the public. It's I think their release time is like mid July to August, is what they've been saying. And so ⁓ how far in the future is that is kind of my question. ⁓ because yeah, the five loads is great, but how long is it before we have the five loads? Because when Backcountry came out, it was the same thing. They didn't have the promise of the three other loads. It was just the fusion tipped and the terminal ascent. Yeah. And ⁓ that was kind of one of our particular speaker-1: Yeah, go to speaker-0: problems with it was like, yeah, if there were more loads, there's a better chance we could find something that works and there just wasn't. So yeah, I'm I'm just curious to know how long that's gonna take, if they have if at any point they're gonna ha have a set timeline when that's gonna be released. But yeah. speaker-1: And there's another point with accuracy is if we're shooting the terminal ascent, man, I have struggled so much to get that bullet to shoot accurately. speaker-0: I don't know if we've ever got a gun to shoot like sub like consistently sub MOA five shot groups. Yeah. speaker-1: Yeah, we're we're especially like if we're if we you know, we're testing rifles all the time, you know, we're got tons of different rifles we're testing and we'll try like five different loads with a gun when we're doing a review and it just never ends up being that the terminal ascent is the most accurate bullet in that speaker-0: And this is I find this so funny because one of the things we always talk about whenever we talk about reloading, ⁓ is like don't like go into reloading with an expectation of which bullet you want to use. Let the cartridge and the gun tell you what bullet is going to work. And it seems like every like Federal is always pushing the terminal scent because it goes faster, it's got better terminal ballistics, but it's just not the y we just can't find the accuracy. And so it's like try and like Find the bullet that's gonna give you the accuracy. Yeah. Because that ⁓ if you're gonna lose a hundred, hundred and fifty feet per second and we're already shooting thirty one hundred. So if we're gonna go from thirty one hundred to three thousand feet per second, it's really not that big of a deal. Yeah. If you're gonna be able to shrink your group size. Right. I mean, I'll take that trade-off any day of the week. Yep. Any day of the week. But it does seem like they have that that fixation with this bullet. They're just trying to force it. down our thirds. It's a cool bullet and I want it to work because it's really cool. But speaker-1: Design is smart. Yeah. speaker-0: We have yet to to see the accuracy. Yeah. speaker-1: Okay, but you brought up another point then about accuracy. Okay, they they said the their current load that they're sending out to everybody, you can't you know, it's not accurate yet. But then they're shipping in July? That makes me uncomfortable. That makes me very uncomfortable. speaker-0: Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that's just not smart. Yeah. Okay. I maybe they have something dialed up and they've got something like in the works and it's like, you know what? We're we're this close. We think we can make it by then. Those things. But it is slightly concerning. speaker-1: Not enough time then. Yeah. Interesting. Yeah, I I think I understand that. I mean we like sometimes we I have ⁓ overly ambitious timelines that I later later e end up eating my words. So I get it, but that does make me uncomfortable. Okay. All right, enough about accuracy. So the claims that I'm seeing from people that have trying it, I I wrote down three. speaker-0: Well, yeah. speaker-1: And I want you to kind of respond to these and tell me what you think. Okay. So we we talked about, you know, we threw a little cold water on this, but also the promise, like we're excited about this thing too. The most significant advance in cartridges in the last fifty years. True or not true? speaker-0: See, this is one of those things where it's like it it's tough because how do you quantify what's the most significant advance? To you. To me. speaker-1: So what else has even happened in fifty years? That's what I started thinking. speaker-0: We we've got like, you know, they've gone, you know, sharper shoulder angles and higher B C bullets and stuff. ⁓ maybe it is. Maybe it is. I I it's hard to quantify what that means though for me. Yeah. Like I'm not sure what that truly means. Like is it, you know, advancing on what exactly? What are you trying to advance in? speaker-1: Well, you hit you hit on exactly what I was thinking. This is not as big of an advance as high B C bullets. Right. But the bullets from fifty years ago compared to today, th that's the biggest thing in my mind is higher BCEs. Mm-hmm. less wind deflection and less drop. That's a that's a huge change. The BC of the older bullets is nothing compared to what we can do today. ⁓ now we s we're saying cartridge was the was the exact phrase. You know Part of a full cartridge is a bullet, right? So I don't know. Okay, but in terms of like So then w what else though? I mean tighter tolerances in general. Yeah. Like the six five Creed gave us, ⁓ that really all the new cartridges have have had less slop in there. And that one I say, yeah, it makes a difference, but also you can have a really accurate three hundred win mag and the tolerances are mega sloppy on it. speaker-0: Right. Yeah. If we're including higher B C bullets, then I would say that's the biggest one. But this might be close number two. speaker-1: I be too. Okay. All right. I at first when I heard that I was like, ⁓ come on and then I started thinking about it like not much has changed and so yeah, maybe fair actually. speaker-0: It's like what's really happening. Yeah. So yeah, I'm gonna say it's a close second. If and you obviously there's gonna be some people out there were like the bullet's not the cartridge, you know? And if you're not gonna count that then I would say yes, this probably is. Okay. But yeah. speaker-1: Alright, so alright, it's kind of a big deal then. Okay, the next one was makes the six point five obsolete. So this is the six point five Creedmore plus peak. Does it make a six point five PRC obsolete? Six point five PRC is your favorite cartridge? speaker-0: Okay. This makes my skin crawl. This makes my skin crawl. Like if we if we match up both loads, the the federal terminal ascent 130 grain bullet in both loads, I mean it's barely better. speaker-1: It's a hundred feet per second faster than a six point five PRC. But again, faster is not necessarily better. speaker-0: Faster doesn't always mean better because, you know, even if you can get faster and you can get, you know, slightly better ballistics, you know, it could cost you accuracy. And so it yeah, it goes back to that whole thing. But anyways, ⁓ we're talking, you know, yards increased max range. We're talking at six hundred yards, you're only dropping five inches less. There's the there's it is a difference. But it's ⁓ that's just it's just minimal to me. speaker-1: Forty? Five inches. The big one for me is the wind deflection. So at 400 yards, it we're using the same terminal ascent bullet, 130 grain, in the 6.5 Creedmoir Plus peak versus the PRC. And the wind deflection is 0.6 inches. That's pretty small. That 100 feet per second isn't buying you a whole lot. speaker-0: It's nothing. It's not. ⁓ It's nothing. Now here's what people are gonna come back with, and it is a very valid, you know, rebuttal to this is that, you know, you can do this in a four inch shorter barrel. Which that is cool. That is a big deal. speaker-1: And that's like the the if you were to hit the six point five PRC on one thing, no question. It's you gotta have a longer barrel. If you have a twenty inch barrel on a six point five PRC, you essentially turned it into a six five Creed. ⁓ speaker-0: You gotta have Right. Yeah. And for me, you know this. Barrel length doesn't matter to me. I like the longer barrels personally. You're not It's just I I don't know what it is about the longer barrels, but I just like the longer barrels. I'm definitely in the minority there. I am definitely in the minority. But yeah, I don't mind that. So for me that's not an issue. but and then speaker-1: You don't like the idea of the short little speaker-0: I mean it's rifle. Cool, but like it's just I don't know. That's just not one of my my crazes in with guns is the lightweight short thing. I I know that's most people's, but it's just not mine. Yeah. So for me that's not an issue. So for me, absolutely not. I mean, for some people, you know, if you're really about that short, then yeah, six five PRC is not speaker-1: Okay, hey, everybody can have their opinion. speaker-0: Is not gonna be the move if this is an option and it shoots well. Yeah. Because there's that's the little that's the asterisk there. ⁓ but the other thing that people could come back with is the recoil. Okay. A lot. Yeah. speaker-1: Okay, this is where I want to dive in. Okay. I was going nut. You know, we've done a tremendous amount of engineering work on recoil in the last whatever four years. Like a lot. Like we've shot thousands of rounds on high-end pressure pressure sensors to just see what different, you know, rifle weights and stock lines and recoil pads, obviously with the backstop recoil pad. Just s we've done so much work on that just to figure out what makes a rifle feel like it has more recoil. ⁓ a lot of this is physics. And so, you know, if you are shooting you there are really four numbers that go into a general recoil calculation five that go into a general recoil calculation. You got the muzzle velocity of the bullet. How heavy is that bullet? Then we want to look at the powder charge in the in the cartridge. The reason we need to look at the powder charge is because of the ejecta. The the powder is actually gonna fly out of the barrel too. And you'd think that, you know, what does that matter? A little bit of powder. ⁓ but you know, every action there's an equal and opposite reaction. It's like if I'm standing on your chest, there's gonna be a certain weight. And then if I jump, if I push myself up, you know, there's a reaction on your chest too, right? So it's the same thing with the powder. If the powder is flying out, it means there's also force backward, right? And so ⁓ you wouldn't think it's that much, but it's, you know, say you got fifty-five grains of powder. Well, if the bullet is 140 and we have 55 grains of powder, the the amount of powder is actually pretty significant, adding to the recoil, right? So there's ⁓ that, and then of course the rifle weight. So those are all the general numbers that are going to go into a recoil calculation. And so what was driving me crazy as I was watching this is I heard so many people kind of repeating the the marketing line just saying, you know, it's shooting faster than the 6.5 PRC with less recoil. And I was it was breaking my brain because I was like, not possible. Right? That's not it's physics, right? If the bullet is going faster and it's the same bullet the same bullet and everything else is the same, that's not possible. It's physics, right? But I was wrong. And it's because of what we talked about the powder. So the six point five Creedmore case, the actual case, if you're you know, have a typical amount, the b you know, bullet setback in in there, you know, y you're gonna get forty five grains of powder in there. It's like that's the max you could fit in into there. The six point five PRC can have fifty-six grains if you were to max it out. So about ten grains, eleven grains, more powder in the six five PRC. And so it's a different powder, obviously, ⁓ in order to get the increased velocity from the smaller space. But that is what ends up making the difference in the recoil. So I was wrong. ⁓ as speaker-0: Tim was wrong. speaker-1: Ha it doesn't happen up. Just kidding. Happens ⁓ about twenty times a day. ⁓ okay, so here here are the actual numbers. ⁓ and this is looking at a hundred thirty grain bullet and the advertised velocities for each. Okay, here it is. The standard six five Creedmore, thirteen foot pounds, six five Creedmore plus peak, fifteen foot pounds, and the six point five PRC almost eighteen foot pounds. And so you're jumping up About two foot pounds of energy between each of them. Two foot foot pounds more to go from six five creed to six five peak, and then two foot pounds from six five creed plus peak to the six five PRC. That's pretty fascinating. Yeah. So it is actually two foot pounds less recoil energy to achieve the same performance as the PRC. That's a big deal in my mind. speaker-0: Yeah. Even if it was the same recoil, would you feel the same? If it was the same recoil as a six five PRC, would you feel the same? Or does it need to be lower for you to really be interested in that? speaker-1: ⁓ okay, so if it had the same amount of recoil, I would say cool, this makes your rifle a little bit more versatile if your rifle happens to like this load, and if you want to get the that velocity. You know, a lot of times I don't want my six five Creedmark going faster. I want it to keep a mild little accuracy load. But if I did want to take it on an elk hunt, then hey. makes my 6-5 Creed maybe an option for this hunt if I thought it was borderline before. So that's kind of that that's what I would say as the that would be my take on 6-5 Creedmoor plus peak. But now seeing this with the recoil, that's actually the thing that I'm most excited about. speaker-0: Cool. Yeah. Two foot footbounds it doesn't sound like a lot. Mm-hmm. But that can be the difference between seeing your impact and not seeing your impact. speaker-1: A hundred percent. That's exactly what I would say. I don't care about my shoulder. I it's not like ⁓ my my poor shoulder can't take this six five PRC. I don't care about that at all. I want to spot the speaker-0: Yeah. It's about how much it's moving your gun in any direction it's moving. Like if you like spotting your impact is so valuable. Like it's hard to like really get people to understand how valuable it is because a lot of times when people talk about recoil, that's not even what they talk about. Right. It's like, ⁓ how's it gonna feel? You know? And y six five PRCs it's like nothing, but sometimes at the closer distances you're not gonna be able to see your your impacts. Now you you drop that down two foot pounds. That changes the equation. Yeah. So it that that is very intriguing. Yeah. speaker-1: Yeah, and you know, w we make recoil pads, the backstop recoil pad, and so, you know, we hear a lot of people wanting to get a recoil pad because of their shoulder, right? And, you know, that's fine. Sometimes they make sense. There are some rifles that I have that are like I that's actually physically painful to shoot. ⁓ I hope he doesn't mind me sharing this. I talked to ⁓ Lee from Oregon Mountain Rifles. They're we're hopefully gonna work with them for them to manufacture a recoil lug anyway for Artika chassis. and he said he actually had I I this is the first time I had met him. I just called him up this week 'cause I saw they made a recoil lug for Tika and I was like, ⁓ you know, we're not set up to manufacture tungsten. Or not tungsten, ⁓ titanium. And so I thought, ⁓ maybe we just work with them and have them make make this part. Anyway, I was talking with him and he ⁓ it's funny you called because I actually just bought five of your recoil pads. And I was like, ⁓ really? And he said, Yeah, I have a had a I can't remember what it was, but he said he had a rifle that was just it was hurting to shoot. And he said it made such a big difference he's went out he bought five more. I was like, ⁓ that's pretty cool. Nice. ⁓ so it I like I get that. And there are some rifles where that's the case. But for me, the number one reason that we like even work on all this recoil stuff is about spotting your impact. My shoulders fine. Yeah. I wanna I wanna be able to track that shot better. speaker-0: I can only think of one time where my shoulder like genuinely hurt shooting guns. Like I've shot a lot of the bigger guns. The only time was when ⁓ we had what's his name? Fritz with that device. ⁓ yeah. He brought like an old seven mag Winchester. Yeah. And I had to take like thirty, thirty five shots of that gun just sitting there taking it and it hadn't it the recoil pad was basically a steel recoil pad. That was I I the next morning, like I looked at my shoulder, it's just completely bruised. Yeah. Other than that, I've never really had a problem with it. speaker-1: Mosa Nagant with the steel recoil pad. They were like ready to kill commies with that. It wasn't about our grandpa's didn't worry about their glass shoulder. Yeah. speaker-0: ⁓ huh. But so what do you think? Does it make it for you, does it make the six five PRC obsolete? What does that mean though? What does it mean, obsolete? Like I to me that word is just thrown around speaker-1: Round. Okay, obsolete in my mind would mean if I'm going to to the pew vending established. No, this is a podcast. That's so nice. Gives me such a break from YouTube. Yeah. If I go to the gun store, would I just say, No, I don't want the six five PRC anymore? Like there would just be no purpose for that anymore. Okay. Would that be the case a year from now? speaker-0: We get to say what we Yeah. speaker-1: We once we got six five because six five plus peak now, like nah, we'll get two loads. I don't trust it because who knows if those two are gonna be accurate in my rifle. I'd I need to try a few bullets and stuff, see what's gonna work the best. And so, yeah, we're g put ourselves into that future. I might actually say yes. If if this is accurate, all all of this rests on that question. I have not seen it, and so I cannot say. speaker-0: Really? Okay. Yeah. speaker-1: But just based on on the release year and all the other information, and we're assuming they can get the accuracy dialed in, I would say probably yeah. speaker-0: Okay. For me, obsolete, like like I I don't really know what in my mind I I believe to be obsolete when it comes to this question, because like pretty much every cartridge is gonna work for what you wanna do. Like obviously you don't wanna take a two hundred forty three on an out cunt. Like I ⁓ it's probably been done, but ⁓ nobody advises for that. speaker-1: Okay, but put yourself in that future. Let's say this stuff is accurate. You can get this accurate, just like you get a 6'5 PRC accurate. Why would you pick the 6'5 PRC at that point? speaker-0: Uh-huh. speaker-1: What advantage would it have? speaker-0: Advantage. None, I guess, but I mean Barrel Life? Okay. speaker-1: Okay, let's get to that. That's a good question. I don't trust the claims on barrel life. speaker-0: I don't think I do either. I mean, they're saying it's gonna be similar, right? Yes to claim. speaker-1: I the the claim was I think the word they used was comparable. speaker-0: Yeah, I how comparable. speaker-1: Right. Like does five thousand comp ⁓ compare with one thousand? Sure, kinda. They both use the word thousand. speaker-0: Yeah. I yeah, I don't trust it either. It that's gonna that's the one thing with with these the comparison between these two cards. speaker-1: Yeah, I mean w when you look at at barrelware, you know, so this is right at the end of the of the of the chamber where, you know, at the start of the barrel you put your cartridge in there and where the you know the brass mates up with the shoulders, where it stops, then we have the bullet that has just a little jump into where the rifling starts. There's just a little space between where the bullet is sitting and where it's going to engage in the rifling. In the throat area of the cartridge, as as you shoot more and more rounds, it's that's the hottest part, it's the highest pressure part, and that's where it's gonna start to wear at the r at the metal the most. You see kind of cracking in there that kind of looks like you know, like mud in a desert after it, you know, dries after a while and just kinda gets those cracks in there, get that kind of alligator skin kinda look on there. It starts to to get some of that cracking and it's just gonna start eroding at the beginning of those lands there and just eroding the throat of your rifle and of the barrel. And so when you have this cartridge that has dramatically hotter, higher pressure, you ⁓ like we've got a physics problem here. Yeah. How is it gonna be the same? Yeah. I like I know the six five Creed more to the six five PRC, they have dramatically different barrel ⁓ barrel lives. And so how is this one that's even a tiny bit hotter and way more pressure, how is that somehow supposed to be comparable then? speaker-0: I don't think it is. I don't buy that. Yeah. I don't buy it. Is that something do you think they've actually tested that? Or do you think they're just expecting something? speaker-1: That's the part that I'm I think they've done I'm sure they have done some testing. I would think so. But I just tell me how hotter and higher pressure is gonna cause less barrel wear than the six five PRC compared to the six five Creed. Yeah. Somebody explain that to me. I don't think so. speaker-0: Love Yeah, I don't think so either. speaker-1: Now th it is incredible timing though, because proof ⁓ had came out with the proof exponential twist barrels. Now to be clear, this they did a great job on the on the marketing of this, this PXT barrels, because this is another one that got everybody super excited. We like proof research barrels a lot. ⁓ some of the marketing I had to kind of yawn at a little bit because they It maybe seemed a little bit like for the first time ever, we've decided to tr to do gain twist. And it's like Gain Twist has existed like since the dawn of time. We've been doing Gain Twist forever. Like a lot of different brands have done gain twist, have you know, but this comes at the perfect timing to when finally we can use gain twist. So I I should step back. Gain twist, you have the the rifling in your barrel, and Generally it's a consistent twist rate. It might be one full three hundred and sixty degree rotation every seven and a half or eight inches, depending on what cartridge we're talking about, and that's your twist rate. Gain twist is where it starts out slower and then it it gets faster ⁓ gain. And there are, you know, twenty different variations on what the rate of that of the increase is and how long it stays slow and all that kind of thing. Testing has been done on this forever. Bunch of different brands make ⁓ game twist barrels already. And the problem has been it seems cool, but never nobody's ever really been sure why we need that. ⁓ and the the results have just been the same, ⁓ different but the same, except now. Because if we don't twist the bullet ⁓ quite as early, we're not building up pressure. speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-1: nearly as fast. And by not ⁓ building up the pressure as fast, da da da da barrel live. And so that announcement comes perfectly timed for this. And so I actually am quite excited about the proof exponential twist barrels because of this. We can use it now. Now it's going to make a difference. And so you saw on the proof research YouTube channel, speaker-0: ⁓ speaker-1: ⁓ they, you know, did a testing, I think they five thousand rounds. What what what was the cartridge they used? Did you see that one? Anyway, I don't they they sh crazy number of rounds ⁓ with the proof exponential twist and and it was still taken, still shooting great. And so I'm very excited about gain twist in this world of the plus peak ammo. Just high pressure ammo in general. speaker-0: For that one. My question is cost 'cause those barrels are gonna be a little more expensive. Are they? I think they're somewhere around like thirteen hundred dollars for one the the PXT. speaker-1: Barrels. I wonder if that's kind of an initial thing because I don't know that it's necessarily harder to manufacture once they get the line set up. I wonder if they're selling ⁓ at a premium while that's new. speaker-0: Just 'cause it snow and hot right now. speaker-1: Yeah. Now now the manufacturing is interesting though about this. So there are three basic ways you can make the rifling. There is hammer forged, which is, you know, what you might see on a Ruger American or a Tika for that matter. And then there's button rifling that Savage does a lot of button rifling, where something is actually pulled. So hammer forged I should go back to. You're getting a mandrel. with that rifling and then you're taking the barrel blank over that and beating the crap of it onto the shape of that mandrel and that's how you're getting the the rifling into it. The those machines, by the way, when you tour the factories are so they are loud and they have to like make special concrete pads and stuff to put ⁓ on separated from the rest 'cause it'll just shake the crap out of the building. Anyway, the then you have button rifling where s ⁓ a button is pulled through the bore of the barrel to to make that that rifling. That one is the interesting one here. Because as far as I'm aware, you couldn't do gain twist with button rifling. Because the button itself has a certain, you know, certain pitch to those to the rifling twist and that it can be in the as it's pulled through. So I don't think you could do that. I don't think you could do gain twist with button rifling. Open to being wrong on that, but I think that's the case. So it could put some barrel makers behind here if they if a different manufacturing method was needed. But then the other one is the single point cut ⁓ rifling. That's what you're gonna see on every top top notch barrel is gonna be single point cut. You know, your Bart lines and stuff, CRB. ⁓ they're single point cut and they're you know making this little cutter going through may do, may do 200 passes on your finest match barrels. They just cut out little bits of material every tail every time, and they can do gain twist there. And so we we could leave if we do embrace this high pressure ammo, and it seems like the industry really wants to go that way, then it could leave some barrel makers behind. speaker-0: Yeah. You said you had three claims. What was the third claim? Claims. speaker-1: Three claims. Three types of barrel manufacturer. speaker-0: No, three claims. We he we said most significant advance and makes the six five PRC obviously. There was a third one. Yeah. speaker-1: Yes, okay. ⁓ I don't think I'll ever go back to standard pressure ammo was the third point. speaker-0: I don't know. I mean, if we can solve the problems with the like like with the Seven Back Country, for example, we saw the brass was cracking. Mm-hmm. Or the it what the the peak alloy casing was cracking in some cases. Not that. Yeah, we saw on several occasions. We saw we had somebody showed us a a picture of speaker-1: Yeah, you're right. I forgot about speaker-0: His or his friend's rifle. I don't remember who it was. Maybe somebody that came out and shot a challenge. Yeah. Saw it on a forum one time. We've seen it in several places. speaker-1: I had totally forgot about that. Yeah, you're right. We did see several broken cases. Fire. speaker-0: That's yeah, and that's concerning. Yeah because that's gonna start releasing the pressure and now the case isn't holding the pressure like it's supposed to. That's the s that's that's the problem right there. So if we can solve the problems with the accuracy, barrel life, and that, then I I could understand why somebody would have that point of view, but I don't know. I personally I don't think ⁓ it would keep me from having Using brass cartridges. speaker-1: Yeah. Okay, I'll add one to the list of problems that that may make that statement not correct. The this claim that we're both talking about. will we ever go back to standard pressure ammo? ⁓ is extraction. We definitely experience on seven back country sticky extraction. And that's just the nature of of how this works, is the the cartridge itself, the case itself is stronger. speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-1: And so it is keeping the pressure in there. But also it less spring back ⁓ coming. And so it's when you have to actually take that shot case out of there, that that extraction is rough on there. And we ⁓ it's not fun. On seven backcountry, the ones that we've shot, like you shoot and then you kinda have to pull up the the bolt and rip it back. Yeah. It's not speaker-0: It's not a smooth experience. speaker-1: Not at all. It's not like a you know, on a fine match rifle where you can just run the bolt with just your forefinger. Just Yeah. Not on a seven back hunter. speaker-0: Now. And I'll add another one even. Reloading. Because we they haven't figured out a way to reload the seven backcountry now. There's there's they're claiming that soon after launch, again, soon, when does that what does that mean? ⁓ unprimed cases for reloading coming soon. So if if that's true, that's a st step in the right direction of for for people that make that claim. But Yeah, unless they can figure out reloading, then in no world does that make sense. speaker-1: Yeah, and I mean here we are like the seven back countries been out for a minute now. Where the unprimed cases. Like it exists. speaker-0: Yeah. We're coming up on two years here in a few months. speaker-1: Right. ⁓ like they do exist. There's a twenty count for twenty five dollars, but there's not one in stock anywhere ever. Right. And only a couple stores that seem to have ever sold it. ⁓ the reloading, not it's ⁓ like if you're a heavy duty reloader, this just is not the cartridge for you. speaker-0: No. At all. And it kinda seems like even if they figure out figure it out, there's gonna be some problems along the way. Yeah. It's not gonna be it's not gonna be like reloading brass ammo. Yeah. So yeah. So I guess there's there's like five issues that kind of Yeah that claim out of them. speaker-1: And it and just ⁓ the accuracy thing, like will I ever wanna say, ⁓ no, I want six dasher plus peak. No, no, no, I I'm shooting that cartridge. It's mild because I want max accuracy out of this thing. Yeah. And whenever you look at like the most inherently accurate cartridges, they're always the mild one in that in that caliber, like three ⁓ eight Winchester. speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-1: Why is it why is it known for accuracy? It's like the most mild dirty cow a popular one anyway. Why six five Creedmore? It's like the most mild six five you just go through every caliber and inherently accurate, in my mind, mostly means mild. Some other things do. Tight chamber tolerance is good, whatever, but speaker-0: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Big mild is ⁓ how mild it is. Yeah. Yep. speaker-1: Okay, so that one, nah, I'm not on board for that. I'm I don't think I'll ever go back to standard pressure ammo. Nah. Not on board with that at all. Maybe after a long time. Maybe ten years from now we really work out all these bugs. Extraction isn't an issue. The accuracy isn't an issue. None of these other things. At that point I could say, hey, same velocity, less powder, less powder. Less recoil and it does everything else just as well. Okay. I could be on board with it. Yeah. So at some point will we just go to all high pressure ammo? Maybe. But I haven't seen it yet. speaker-0: Yeah. And my other thing with is just like functionally, yes. For all the people that are just like performance, performance, performance. ⁓ yes. But like there's some other cool cartridges out there, you know, like Seven Psalm is awesome. You know, like I that whole the whole idea of I could never go back is just like there's so many cool things that you're like right. speaker-1: Watch me go back In a minute. speaker-0: There's too many cool things to go back to to make this we're starting. speaker-1: Still going back to thirty acht six. We think we're never going back to any brass baseline. speaker-0: That's right. Yeah. speaker-1: Okay, so overall, as I look at the whole plus peak debacle, I would say the things that I saw most people excited about, I'm not excited about. Just for velocity, nah. Doesn't do anything for me. We've always been able to get faster than a six five Creedmore. The versatility, that's exciting to me. But there are a lot of problems still. The cool thing though speaker-0: Wait, more? speaker-1: Is all your only investment is grab the six five Creed you already have and go out, grab one box of ammo, and this is fun. That is what blew me away with this announcement is I was so surprised that they just made it the standard six five creed with a new load. I thought for sure this was going to be a new cartridge. I knew I mean everybody in the industry knew there was a six five high pressure coming from Federal this year. I just the whole time I it was never even registering for me that it it was just a load they were doing and not a new cartridge. speaker-0: I wonder, 'cause you know, with the seven back country, we talked to so many manufacturers who said, yeah, the seven back country is by far the least accurate of all our options. ⁓ huh. And people have just stopped buying it. You know, now it's just the least popular rifle. Part of me wonders if they caught on to that and they were like, you know, if I think people could be more excited, they're gonna want to buy the ammo more, and the ammo it the the load itself is gonna be more popular if they can just take their old gun and And see if it works. And s which it genius, I think. Yeah. Just genius. speaker-1: Yeah, I I think this is absolutely genius and I think they're gonna sell a pop speaker-0: I love it. Yeah, they are. I mean, this is I mean, in our last video ⁓ or one of our last couple videos, ⁓ when we talked about the most versatile cartridges with the influencers. Yeah. ⁓ that was like the number one comment from everyone was, What about the six five Creamer plus Peak? Mm-hmm. And we had filmed that video before they, you know, the the soft launch of this. Yeah. When people started talking about it. And so it wasn't on there, but I don't know if it Do you think it would have even been on there, even if it wasn't, if it was after this? I I just don't I don't think so. It's not proven. Yeah. That's the thing. That's. speaker-1: No, I don't. I you know, it's a wait and see right now. Yeah. But I am excited about this. Like will I be buying it? Yes. Will I be buying a lot of it? Yes. But for testing. And we'll see see what happens at that point. I I'm glad to see things advancing and changing ⁓ and seeing this innovation. I think, you know, with any innovation there's gonna be some speaker-0: It's cool. There's cool stuff. Ha ha. speaker-1: hiccups and things and hopefully we'll be able to get past ⁓ and they'll just make everybody's you know, keep pushing things forward. speaker-0: And I mean we can't knock ⁓ too hard because we're always on the gun industry, like, you guys are taking too long to update things. Let's let's get things rolling and now they're doing it. So you know what? Props to you for that. That's right. But speaker-1: Right. And I bet there is a lot of hand wringing in Nebraska right now. I don't think Horny's happy about that. speaker-0: about this at all. At all. Yeah. They got beat to the punch? speaker-1: Now, what do you think is next? Because Federal made it pretty obvious in the the marketing packet stuff that they sent to us that there are more cartridges coming, more of this plus peak stuff. So I started to think, where do you apply it next? And I'm a little bit lost because the most ob the the most dominant would be if you could do 308 Winchester plus peak. The problem is it doesn't have the twist rate. Mm-hmm. speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-1: Because it's a slow twist on that, and if we want to use modern high B C bullets and push ⁓ fast, it's not gonna twist that bullet fast enough. It wouldn't work. That's why the six five Creedmoor is the obvious step here, because it's modern, it does have the fast the fast twist. So speaker-0: Mm. Do they just make a new thirty caliber cartridge? speaker-1: Maybe, maybe it's the thirty back country. speaker-0: Could I could I could very well see that. I could also see six millimeter. speaker-1: Yeah. It would be interesting to take a essentially a three ⁓ eight case, make it the plus peak and just mimic thirty aught six velocity in a three ⁓ eight short action kind of form factor. That'd be that's a new cartridge. I don't think they could do that when so many actions for three ⁓ eight are old and may not have been made to this pressure and we again we don't have the twist. And so I so what do you think is next then? There's nothing quite like the six five creed that I'm seeing where you just, ⁓ yeah, just launch that sucker. speaker-0: I think I think it's gonna be a whole new cartridge they're gonna come up with. speaker-1: Yeah, I think I couldn't think of any that it would just be an obvious one to just add it to because I can't think of any like mild modern cards, maybe a 25. Ooh, a 25 Creed. 25 Creed plus ⁓ okay, that would be sick. Because I do because the 25 PRC, the Wildcat, sick. Like that is amazing. speaker-0: I could see that. See that. ⁓ ⁓ huh. speaker-1: So if you could go twenty five Creed plus peak. speaker-0: ⁓ that could be cool. speaker-1: And they've already, you know, made the manufacturing lines and stuff for the six five. Now we just neck it down. That's it. speaker-0: That's that's that could be cool. Do you think that is what they'll do? It does it does seem it does seem like the firearms industry is trying to push the twenty five caliber recently. Right. So I could see that. speaker-1: It all the actions are brand new. It has the twist rate. speaker-0: Yep. Okay. That's gotta be it. speaker-1: I think if I were if I were federal, I think that's what I'd 'cause twenty five Creed plus P could be amazing. speaker-0: I think that's it. And people just love the twenty five caliber. I could just see see that being so popular. speaker-1: Yeah, and the reason I say that is so we have our reference loads sheet that we kind of have a you know, all the different cartridges and stuff. If you look at the the twenty-five PRC that that's a wildcat, it just looks like a misprint next to like everything. Like ⁓ you know, we have whatever sixty-five cartridges in here, sixty-five different loads that we're tracking, all different cartridges just to see. What has the best wind deflection, everything? Like, it looks like a misprint. It's such a laser beam while still having mega light recoil, just 15 ⁓ foot pounds of of recoil energy. And you're getting, you know, significantly two inches less wind drift ⁓ compared to the 6.5 PRC that's amazing. Like it's just that's that is a sweet spot for like Western deer hunting. 25 PRC would be it. But Hornady has said they're not gonna do a 25 PRC. Yeah, they have. They said you they have tested it quite a bit and they were having problems on like second and third firings, little donuts forming. that it it just was a little bit much for that creed more form factor. But I don't understand that problem because Hughes a speaker-0: Yeah. Why? Have they said why? speaker-1: little bit calmer of a powder. Like just chill it down a little bit then. Yeah. If if we're if we're stressing the brass a little bit too much and we can't reload this enough, like just just chill it down a little bit. And so I don't I don't see why we couldn't just do a twenty five Creed more a little faster. Yeah. Just just don't load it up to its max capacity. And then it seems like we could solve that issue. But I don't know. They're a lot smarter than I am and I'm sure they've considered that. ⁓ so they're just speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-1: First the engineers say no. speaker-0: My bet is it will happen in the next five or seven years. speaker-1: Maybe so. They've pretty publicly said no on that one. speaker-0: I think I think they'll go back on that. I just I it just to me it kinda feels like the atmosphere is we're trying to push the twenty five caliber. It just kinda seems like they they want people to to be excited about the twenty five. speaker-1: Yeah, I could or they're working on their own high pressure and they're they know, ⁓ no, no, no, no. We don't make twenty five Creed and twenty-five PRC. We just make twenty five Creed and twenty-five plus Hornady, you know? That would make sense. That would make sense. speaker-0: Whatever. That could be it. Yeah, instead of going with th the just skip a s skip a step on the ladder. speaker-1: Yeah, you don't have to have a Creedmoor line and a PRC line. You have a ⁓ Creedmoorish, you know, the mild velocity and then the higher pressure of ho ho ho ho ho we f speaker-0: ⁓ that could be it. Figured it out. We figured it out we figured out the industry industry. ⁓ speaker-1: That one would actually be pretty speaker-0: That would be cool. That would be cool. Yeah. speaker-1: All right. Thanks everybody for joining us on the Backfire Guns podcast. Tell somebody about it. We'd love it. This is a brand new we're we're, you know, trying to get a get our podcast. So tell some b tell some people about it. We'd love to have ⁓ your friends see what we're talking about. Thanks everybody. See ya on the third, thirteenth, and twenty third of every month. speaker-0: Free audio postproduction biophonic.com