Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Avoiding Document of Resolutions: 10 Essential Strategies for Credit Unions
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:05I hope you enjoy.
- 0:07Just got off the beach, brought my notebook with me.
- 0:10I had my long career.
- 0:11I had different ways of keeping track of things, but when I started consulting.
- 0:16Gosh, three and a half years ago, I started using a college ruled composition
- 0:20notebooks, one for each month.
- 0:22And it allows me to go back and find things much easier.
- 0:26And instead of writing it on sticky notes or starting some electronic
- 0:30file, it's proven to be the best system that I've got anyway, in that
- 0:34I have a updated list that I update every month of potential podcasts.
- 0:38That I want to do.
- 0:39And I had a note that said three ways to avoid getting a document resolution
- 0:44and sitting on the beach, watching the waves, watching people walk by.
- 0:49I took out my pen and I actually came up with 10 ways to avoid a document
- 0:53resolution, and that's what I'm going to talk to here, just in case my
- 0:57throat gets a little scratchy, I'm going to open up a polar seltzer,
- 1:02which was on sale at Publix this week.
- 1:05Here we go.
- 1:06There's the seltzer.
- 1:07Take a sip before we get going.
- 1:09All right, 10 ways to avoid a documental resolution.
- 1:12First, so what is a document resolution?
- 1:15Obviously, most of the listeners know that, but it's part
- 1:18of the examination report.
- 1:20And short of getting something that is a formal action by NCUA,
- 1:24like a letter of understanding, it is a document resolution.
- 1:27The most aggressive required action by a credit union as part of an examination.
- 1:31Now, a code one can get a document resolution, a code five can get a document
- 1:36resolution, which means credit unions in the middle can get document resolutions.
- 1:40Of course, code ones and code twos oftentimes don't.
- 1:43Usually, if you're code three, you are going to get some document resolutions,
- 1:47although I've seen that not be the case.
- 1:50Also seen that recently.
- 1:52So anyway, so the reasons for a document resolution, a safety and
- 1:56soundness concern, a compliance concern, inadequate management or board
- 2:00oversight are three broad areas that will trigger a document resolution.
- 2:05However, let's dive into that.
- 2:07The first item I had written down was a violation of the Federal Credit Union Act.
- 2:11or a violation of an N.
- 2:13C.
- 2:13U.
- 2:13A.
- 2:14Regulation.
- 2:15File that under commit.
- 2:16No minor blunders.
- 2:18Obviously, you need to know what your policies are.
- 2:20We'll get to that.
- 2:20You need to know what the regulations are and you need to follow the Federal
- 2:23Credit Union Act situations like this put A lot of discretion into the hands
- 2:28of the examiner, because there are some instances where if you violate
- 2:32a regulation or a law, they have to give you a document of resolution.
- 2:37And that an example, the best example of that is Bank Secrecy Act, where they have
- 2:40agreements with FinCEN that they will do that type of take that type of action.
- 2:46In that situation, the examiner can't even.
- 2:49Negotiate with you.
- 2:50But other examples of violations of regulations would be a violation
- 2:54of the commercial loan rule.
- 2:56And that on occasion when someone gets into a new program and they don't
- 2:59understand the documentation requirements or the follow up requirements.
- 3:04Of commercial lending, the theory is, and the concept is commercial loans.
- 3:08You put more eggs in, in one basket, commercial loans can
- 3:11be more complicated to review.
- 3:13Commercial loans require a certain level of expertise.
- 3:15So if you don't follow the regulation, you can cause a loss to the credit
- 3:18union, some credit unions ultimately have caused loss to the insurance fund.
- 3:22So NCOA will act.
- 3:24fairly aggressively when it relates to a regulation violation
- 3:27of commercial loans, for example.
- 3:29Now, sometimes you might see NCUA negotiate that down to a different
- 3:33type of document in the examination, but I'll get to that shortly.
- 3:38Another no that you very rarely get any leeway on not being a
- 3:42document resolution if, is if you have issues tied to your audit.
- 3:46NCWA takes that very seriously and typically will have that in a
- 3:50document or resolution or higher if there were flaws in your audit, you
- 3:54didn't do your audit timely, etc.
- 3:56Or the verification of accounts, which falls into the responsibilities
- 3:59of the supervisory committee or the audit committee or state
- 4:02charters that might call it that.
- 4:05All right.
- 4:05So violation of the act, violation of regulation.
- 4:08Number two, a violation of your own policy is sometimes you might
- 4:11do a policy limit as squishy and might not document exceptions to it.
- 4:17If you do have exceptions to policies, NCOA is typically going to ask you
- 4:21to track those, monitor those, but I've seen situations where NCOA
- 4:25has criticized credit unions for not following their own policies,
- 4:29viewing their policies as a goal.
- 4:30For example, we'll have a loan to asset ratio of 80.
- 4:34You go to 81 the next month, you change it in your policy to 85, six months later,
- 4:39you go to 86 and then you change it to 90.
- 4:41Now, can you make changes like that?
- 4:42Yes.
- 4:42But NCOA is going to expect the board be involved, that there'd be good
- 4:47corporate governance around that.
- 4:48And that it's not just, oops, we went over and we want to keep making these.
- 4:51You need to have a logic behind that.
- 4:53And if you don't, NCOA will criticize you most likely in some way, shape
- 4:58or form, and it could rise to a level of a document of resolution.
- 5:03Now.
- 5:04Over the last few years, I've seen several instances in conversations with
- 5:07credit unions where credit unions had a strategic plan, their strategic plan said
- 5:13we're going to do A, B, and C, and then the results of the year were they did,
- 5:18instead of doing A, B, and C, they did A, D, and F, and maybe Z, and then went
- 5:24back and did B and C for good measure, and it wasn't exactly what the board
- 5:30approved at the credit union for their strategic plan, And then opportunities
- 5:34came about where, let's say, marijuana banking, let's say, opportunity to do a
- 5:39merger of a bank, acquisition of a bank, where that was not in the strategic plan.
- 5:44Are you worried about an NCUA exam in process or looming on the horizon?
- 5:49Don't face it alone.
- 5:50We're ex NCUA insiders with decades of experience, ready to guide you to success.
- 5:55Our team understands the intricacies of NCUA examinations from the inside out.
- 6:00Hire us and gain peace of mind during your exam process, insider knowledge of NCUA
- 6:05procedures and expectations, strategies to address potential issues before they
- 6:09become problems, continuous access to our extensive subject matter expertise
- 6:14with our Access Retainer, and more.
- 6:16You'll have on demand support from former NCUA experts.
- 6:20We're here to ensure your credit union passes your exam with flying colors.
- 6:24Contact credit union exam solutions today to learn more about our services and how
- 6:29we can help your credit union succeed.
- 6:32And as a result.
- 6:34Maybe some other things didn't get done that could have been
- 6:38done or should get gotten done.
- 6:39I've seen SUA be critical of a board and a credit union not
- 6:43following their strategic plan.
- 6:45Ironically, there's not a lot of references to the requirement of strategic
- 6:49plans, which by the way, they're not.
- 6:50They're just, of course, sound business practices.
- 6:52But that has popped up.
- 6:53So number one, comply with the Act of Regulation.
- 6:56Number two, comply with your own policies.
- 6:58And number three, comply with your strategic plan, or revise your
- 7:02strategic plan, or make your strategic plan a little bit more flexible.
- 7:06Number four, how do you avoid a document resolution?
- 7:09Communicate well.
- 7:11Communicate well with NCUA.
- 7:12If you're contemplating a new program, reach out to the examiner.
- 7:15Talk to the supervisory examiner.
- 7:17Make sure they're aware that you're contemplating these things.
- 7:20Sometimes they'll see best practices.
- 7:22And other institutions and share some ideas that will
- 7:26improve your implementation.
- 7:29Reminds me of a quote by a former NCUA board member who said when
- 7:33we were negotiating with NCUA's union, familiarity breeds consent.
- 7:37When you have a good relationship where you show that you are going to communicate
- 7:40well with them, you can get more leeway.
- 7:42That works with NCUA, that works with your teenage kids.
- 7:46Anyway.
- 7:47Communicate.
- 7:47Communicate.
- 7:48Communicate.
- 7:49Make sure that if you have a new program that you are in contact
- 7:52with NCOA relative to that.
- 7:54They're not going to bless policies and procedures and different things,
- 7:57but they will tell you what they've learned and they've seen a lot of things.
- 8:00Do that.
- 8:00Number five.
- 8:01Negotiate.
- 8:02Negotiate.
- 8:03Negotiate.
- 8:04Right?
- 8:04So, you get a document resolution.
- 8:06It's a draft.
- 8:07That is the first draft, right?
- 8:09You might have a better idea on how to deal with something.
- 8:12You also may be able to convince them that instead of a document resolution,
- 8:16here's fact A that you didn't consider fact B that you didn't consider.
- 8:21And maybe we can put it into an examiner finding instead of a document resolution.
- 8:25Now, why would you want to do that?
- 8:26It's a little less draconian.
- 8:28It's a little less likely to impact your camel code.
- 8:31And it's just a better place to have it in an examiner findings.
- 8:35Another thing you can do too is, okay, number one, maybe it
- 8:37shouldn't be a document resolution.
- 8:39It should be an examiner finding.
- 8:40And Oh, by the way, we fixed it before the exam was done.
- 8:43Sometimes they'll take that out of the exam in its entirety.
- 8:47Sometimes they'll just say, this was a problem.
- 8:49You dealt with it when.
- 8:51We're, we were here and now it's done.
- 8:53So negotiate number five, number six training, make sure your board is trained.
- 8:57Make sure your staff is trained, whether that's through the new America's credit
- 9:02unions, whether that's through NASCS, whether that's through leagues, whether
- 9:05that's through hiring consultants, there's a lot of good consultants
- 9:09and a lot of good areas out there.
- 9:11That can give you a deep dive on different things.
- 9:13So don't crimp your budget on training.
- 9:15Make sure your staff have the resources to do what they need to do.
- 9:19That's common sense, right?
- 9:21Numbers eight, subscribe to NCOA express.
- 9:26That alerts you when regulations are proposed, that alerts you when NCOA
- 9:31is going to do a webinar, that alerts you when a regulation is final, and
- 9:35it's a good way to keep track of what's out there and forward it on
- 9:40to your staff so they can develop a plan to resolve before NCOA comes in,
- 9:45because again, you're expected to stay up to date on those new regulations.
- 9:49Number seven.
- 9:50Subscribe to my podcasts.
- 9:52Of course, I've got two podcasts out there now.
- 9:54This one is with Flying Colors, where we assist our credit unions
- 9:58with NCUA exam type issues so that they can save time and money.
- 10:01Number two is an AI driven podcast, which is more audio book
- 10:06style hosted by Samantha Shares.
- 10:08And that podcast is called Credit Union Regulatory Guidance, which is
- 10:13again, audio books on NCUA related or financial institution related.
- 10:18Issuances that are still relevant or are new that you may
- 10:22want to study and understand.
- 10:25So again, subscribe to the podcast, just hit subscribe.
- 10:27I'd appreciate that.
- 10:28Hey, if you could give me a rating, if you like it too, that would be great.
- 10:31The more ratings you get, the more Apple and Spotify like to share your
- 10:36podcast when people do searches.
- 10:38All right.
- 10:38Founding problems.
- 10:39I mentioned people have issues with their audit and CUA is going
- 10:42to do a document resolution.
- 10:44So the best way to make sure you don't in this arena to make sure you don't get
- 10:49a document resolution is to make sure your main accounts are reconciled and
- 10:53that you have your audits done timely.
- 10:55If you go back and look at my podcast about CamelCode downgrades,
- 10:59Oftentimes when that happens, one of the into a board members will
- 11:02ask the chief financial officer.
- 11:04So what's driving this trend?
- 11:06And they will speak to operational issues, management issues, accounting issues,
- 11:10and oh, by the way, that's happening in some large credit unions over a billion.
- 11:14Again, commit no minor blunders.
- 11:16NCUA will not only react to accounting problems, they will overreact because
- 11:20that can lead to fraud, that can lead to losses at the insurance fund, and really,
- 11:25other than BSA, probably the least likely thing that they will negotiate on is
- 11:30accounting issues until they are done.
- 11:32All right.
- 11:33So that was number.
- 11:36Nine, number 10, give them access to you.
- 11:40If you're the CEO and they can't pick your brain, can't talk to you, you're
- 11:44not available during the day, or you're not even there during the examination.
- 11:48NCOA is not going to like that.
- 11:50Do they have access to your C suite?
- 11:51A lot of credit unions, particularly bigger credit unions, now have a chief
- 11:56risk officer who's responsible to, to liaison with government agencies.
- 12:00That's great.
- 12:01But they should understand what makes you tick as a CEO or a number two.
- 12:07Again, it goes back to communication, right?
- 12:09If you communicate well with NCUA at all levels, your examination will go better.
- 12:15Alright, so those are 10 ways to avoid a document resolution.
- 12:19I'll summarize them here for you.
- 12:21Number one, comply with the federal credit union act and regulation and regulations.
- 12:26Number two, apply with policy.
- 12:28Number three, live within what you approved in your strategic plan.
- 12:32Number four, communicate with NCOA.
- 12:34Number five, negotiate with NCOA.
- 12:37Number six, train yourself and.
- 12:40Your staff and your board.
- 12:41Number seven, subscribe to NCWA Express.
- 12:45Number eight, listen to my podcasts.
- 12:47Subscribe if you'd like.
- 12:49Number nine, avoid accounting problems.
- 12:51And number 10, provide them access to you so they understand what's going on at
- 12:56the highest levels of the credit union.
- 12:58That's a show of respect to the examiner.
- 13:01And it is appreciated.
- 13:02And I've seen that go awry over my 34 years at NCUA and my
- 13:06additional four years doing this.
- 13:07Wow.
- 13:07That adds up to 38, a couple more years, we'll be at 40 in the industry.
- 13:11All right, everybody.
- 13:12I enjoyed updating you on my brain dump on document resolutions.
- 13:16We're seeing more of them.
- 13:17We're seeing more code threes.
- 13:18I'm going to do a podcast on code threes coming up here soon.
- 13:22All right.
- 13:22I'm going to go back out to the beach.
- 13:24I hope you have a great week at your credit union.
- 13:26Normally, by the way.
- 13:28Okay, here we go.
- 13:28I digress.
- 13:29I hope you enjoyed listening.
- 13:31I.
- 13:31You'll listen again soon.
- 13:32This is Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.