Latest / The MaineHealth Podcast / Public Health Grand Rounds Hosted by Dr. Dora Ann Mills with guest Ross Greene, PhD
Transcript
- 0:00This is Dr. Dora Ann Mills, Senior Advisor for Public Health at MaineHealth.
- 0:06Welcome to our Public Health Grand Rounds, where about every month we explore
- 0:11a relevant public health topic with national and Maine experts.
- 0:15These Grand Rounds are posted to the MaineHealth podcast channel on Podbean
- 0:20and at MaineHealth.org, where you can hear current and past episodes.
- 0:26Please note that guests' opinions are their own. Well, good afternoon, everybody.
- 0:32So welcome to the beginning of the fall of 2026 Public Health Grand Rounds at MaineHealth.
- 0:40We are delighted today to welcome Dr. Ross Greene with us.
- 0:44You know, for those of us who work in public health or health care,
- 0:47I think we all know that youth mental health is really one of the defining challenges of this decade.
- 0:55We know that rates of anxiety, depression, chronic absenteeism,
- 0:59suicidality among youth and young people are higher than we've ever measured.
- 1:06And the adults who spend most of their time with kids, teachers,
- 1:09and school staff, for instance, are leading the profession in record numbers,
- 1:12in part because of a lot of the ripple effects.
- 1:16So the question is really not whether we need to respond, but how.
- 1:21And Dr. Green has spent more than three decades answering this question.
- 1:26He is a clinical psychologist and the originator of Collaborative and Proactive
- 1:31Solutions, or CPS, an evidence-based non-punitive approach to understanding
- 1:37and helping kids with concerning behaviors.
- 1:40His guiding premise is disarmingly kind of simple. You know, kids do well if they can.
- 1:46And when they don't, it's a signal of lagging skills and unsolved problems,
- 1:50not a lack of motivation or character.
- 1:53So it's a signal that calls for problem solving rather than punishment.
- 1:57He is the New York Times bestselling author of The Explosive Child,
- 2:02Lost at School, Lost and Found, and Raising Human Beings, and executive producer
- 2:07of the award-winning documentary The Kids We Lose.
- 2:11He served on the faculty of Harvard Medical School for more than 20 years,
- 2:15is an adjunct Professor of Psychology
- 2:16at Virginia Tech and is a founding director of Lives in the Balance,
- 2:21a nonprofit that provides free resources on the CPS model and advocates for
- 2:26kids and their caregivers.
- 2:29His newest book, published earlier this year, is The Kids Who Aren't Okay,
- 2:34The Urgent Case for Reimagining Support, Belonging, and Hope in Schools.
- 2:40It carries an endorsement from our own Commissioner, Pender Macon,
- 2:44Commissioner of Education, which is fitting because Dr. Green and Lives in the
- 2:49Balance are now based in Maine, right here in Maine.
- 2:53So welcome, Dr. Green, and Ross Green. We're so happy to have you with us today.
- 2:59And he's going to present and take questions afterwards, but also if you have
- 3:04a pressing question during his presentation, I think he's fine if you want to ask.
- 3:08And so if you have a question, feel free to put it in the chat or raise your electronic hand.
- 3:14And so we'll see it and we can call on you that way. And then he'll take questions
- 3:18at the end as well. So thank you very much and welcome, Ross,
- 3:22to MaineHealth Public Health Grand Rounds.
- 3:24Thank you for inviting me to do this.
- 3:27Yes, I have been working with very, very difficult kids for what seems like forever.
- 3:33I like to say that I work with the most difficult kids there are.
- 3:38I suppose that's a badge of honor, except that I don't find them to be all that
- 3:42different from other kids, believe it or not.
- 3:46And today you'll hear a little bit about the work that I've been doing for a very long time.
- 3:53So I thought I would start with a provocative title, but for me,
- 3:57this is not that provocative.
- 4:00Non-compliance is good.
- 4:03Oppositional behavior in kids is often among the first things people see,
- 4:12when a kid is beginning what could become the long road toward a very difficult life.
- 4:19It often starts with oppositionality.
- 4:23We might refer to it as a gateway behavior.
- 4:27So noncompliance is good is not a radical political statement. I promise.
- 4:33It's not sort of an ultra-progressive take on parenting It's saying that when
- 4:38a kid is not complying They're telling you something,
- 4:43And the something that they're telling you Is very important And you don't want to miss it And so often,
- 4:50we do miss it Which is why a lot of kids who start out as non-compliance end
- 4:58up being among the most expensive kids in our society.
- 5:03They can cost school systems a fortune.
- 5:07They tend to be the 10, 15 kids in every school who are accounting for 80 to
- 5:1590% of the discipline referrals.
- 5:18The vast majority of the punitive exclusionary interventions that occur after
- 5:24those discipline referrals, that are already identified, they already have IEPs
- 5:28most of the time, but whatever we've done so far hasn't worked.
- 5:33What that requires is a complete shift in our mentality, in our practices,
- 5:41and in our timing, starting with the recognition that noncompliance is good.
- 5:49So I want to start with a few key concepts that set the stage for everything
- 5:52I'm going to be talking about.
- 5:54This is a great place to start, because as I tell educators,
- 5:58this is what's walking in the door. This is the business you're in,
- 6:01but it's the business parents are in. It's the business any mental health professional
- 6:05is in, pediatricians, family physicians.
- 6:08We're all in the developmental variability business. If you're working with
- 6:11a kid, quite frankly, this applies to adults as well.
- 6:14You are in the developmental variability business.
- 6:18It's a very fancy way of saying every kid is different.
- 6:22Every kid has a different developmental trajectory,
- 6:27and it's critical that we are attuned and responsive to that developmental variability,
- 6:35because so often we aren't.
- 6:38I personally am not a very diagnostically oriented mental health professional.
- 6:45All ADHD really tells me is that a kid is developmentally variable and the ways
- 6:50in which whoever diagnosed the kid felt that the kid was developmentally variable.
- 6:56We're going to have to move beyond that diagnosis to really help the kid.
- 7:01The diagnosis that I'm supposedly a
- 7:04world expert on, oppositional defiant disorder, what does that say to me?
- 7:10Developmental variability. This is a kid who's developmentally variable in their
- 7:15capacity to respond to adult rules, requests, demands, requests.
- 7:26What have we been doing with oppositionality for a very long time?
- 7:32We've been trying to extinguish it. When a kid doesn't comply,
- 7:36we incentivize them to comply, or we
- 7:40ignore them in the belief that their noncompliance is attention-seeking,
- 7:47or we punish them.
- 7:49None of those are interventions that are going to do anything about the ways
- 7:55in which this kid is developmentally variable.
- 7:59Here's our definition of the talk. The definition of good teaching,
- 8:04good parenting, good treatment.
- 8:06Meeting every kid where they're at. There are so many initiatives,
- 8:11especially in our schools, that make it harder for educators to meet every kid where they're at.
- 8:20It is truly insufferable what we've done to the education profession.
- 8:27When you tell educators that their job performance and job security is going
- 8:31to be pegged to how their students do on high-stakes tests, you are no longer
- 8:36talking about developmental variability.
- 8:38You are talking about drawing a line at the end of the school year and saying
- 8:43every kid, irrespective of the developmental variability that's walking into
- 8:48the door has to get over that line by the end of the school year.
- 8:52That is an impossible dream.
- 8:56It's why a lot of educators have said to me, they've taken all the humanity
- 8:59out of my job. Time to put the humanity back in.
- 9:03I think we are seeing some of the signs in our society of having taken the humanity
- 9:09out of the job of the folks who have
- 9:13always been among the most important socialization agents in our society,
- 9:18our educators.
- 9:20By the way, meeting every kid where they're at is not unprecedented.
- 9:24Differentiated instruction is a way of meeting every kid where they're at.
- 9:28Personalized instruction is a way of meeting every kid where they're at.
- 9:32Special ed law is at least an attempt to meet every kid where they're at.
- 9:37Doesn't always work out that way. Given the developmental variability that's
- 9:42walking in the door in our schools, there is no choice but to meet every kid where they're at.
- 9:47That means that every kid is their own reference point for progress,
- 9:53not the line at the end of the school year, where the kid is at,
- 9:59at the beginning of the school year.
- 10:02You're going to get a kid a whole lot further when you're using them as their own reference point.
- 10:08You're going to help your students move a whole lot further if you're meeting
- 10:11them where they're at than if you're not.
- 10:13I say that to educators all the time.
- 10:17One more important concept, expectation management.
- 10:25Because of a lot of the initiatives that have occurred in our schools over the
- 10:30last two or three decades, we're placing expectations on a lot of kids that
- 10:35we already know they can't meet.
- 10:37What happens when you place an expectation on a kid that you already know they can't meet?
- 10:43You elicit concerning behavior, which, as you'll learn on the next slide,
- 10:50is simply the kid's frustration response.
- 10:54No, critical that we are managing our expectations well in an effort to meet
- 11:00every kid where they're at,
- 11:02and an effort to be responsive to developmental variability. Huge.
- 11:10Noncompliance is good. Let me explain.
- 11:13Not that you're wishing for it.
- 11:16But a kid's concerning behavior is best thought of. This is critical.
- 11:21We have a huge project going on right now in Ireland in its adult and child disability services.
- 11:29And my colleagues there were doing some planning for the future.
- 11:33And they said to me, Ross, what is your number one priority for Ireland in its
- 11:41treatment of kids who are struggling for the next five years?
- 11:46I said I want every adult in Ireland
- 11:49to know that concerning behavior is a frustration or distress response.
- 11:55That would be 10 giant steps forward because that is not what a lot of adults
- 12:01think concerning behavior is.
- 12:06Concerning behavior is not to be extinguished.
- 12:09It is to be attended to.
- 12:12In other words, it's the signal. We've all heard the cliche,
- 12:16all behavior is communication.
- 12:18What is concerning behavior communicating?
- 12:22That there's an expectation a kid is having difficulty reliably meeting. That's huge.
- 12:29Because if more adults saw it that way, they would be more responsive to the
- 12:34developmental variability that's walking in the door.
- 12:37In other words, noncompliance, in my view, is typically an indicator of developmental
- 12:44variability that is not being well understood or well attended to.
- 12:50It is a child who is struggling, and they're struggling over something.
- 12:56I like the term distress response because it brings us back to infancy.
- 13:02Infants have distress responses. Anybody who works with infants or has had a
- 13:08few or hung out with them knows that infants have distress responses. This is interesting.
- 13:14What do we do when an infant is exhibiting a distress response? We notice...
- 13:20One of the things we know is that some adults are better at noticing than others,
- 13:25but we can help them with that. They're not very good at noticing.
- 13:29Then we try to decipher what the infant is telling us with their distress response.
- 13:36We know that some adults are better at deciphering than others.
- 13:41We can help them with that if they're not too good at deciphering.
- 13:44Then we apply an intervention that addresses what we think is making them distressed.
- 13:52We know that some adults have better repertoires than others,
- 13:57but we can help adults who don't have great repertoires of what to do when an infant is distressed.
- 14:03And then we are paying very close attention to see how we did.
- 14:08And some of us, especially those of us in the collaboration business.
- 14:13Call that collaborating. Yeah, you're collaborating with an infant pretty much
- 14:19from the word go. Now, here's the question.
- 14:24Why do we stop doing that? Isn't that what you would do for not a distressed
- 14:31four-year-old, distressed eight-year-old, distressed 15-year-old?
- 14:35When do we stop? Right around the age of two, when two very interesting developments occur.
- 14:43Development number one, we adults, for whatever reason, become obsessed with compliance.
- 14:52At around the exact same age, that kids, now I would say that infants know what they want already.
- 14:59There's just some skills they don't have that permit them to go for it.
- 15:02But right around the age of two, those skills are starting to kick in,
- 15:06especially language and locomotion,
- 15:11which means that here at the age of two, you have a kid who's already knowing
- 15:16what they want, that they've had that for a long time, but now they have the
- 15:20skills, language and locomotion to go for it at the exact same point in development
- 15:26that adults have decided that they are obsessed with compliance.
- 15:30And as I always say, no wonder they call it the terrible twos.
- 15:35First of all, a lot of the kids I've worked with over the years,
- 15:38and that's now numbering in the thousands, quite frankly, never outgrew their
- 15:42difficult temperament.
- 15:43A lot of them, because of factors that occurred along the way in development,
- 15:50became compromised in the skills that are required for being compliant.
- 15:56Compliance requires skills. You bet it does.
- 16:01And not every kid, thanks to developmental variability, is blessed with those
- 16:06skills. We'll be talking about that soon.
- 16:09This is critical. Concerning behavior is a kid's frustration or distress response.
- 16:17It is not to be extinguished It is to be understood Because they're telling
- 16:21us something They're telling us that they're struggling To meet a particular
- 16:26expectation Most of the time Now,
- 16:30this last point is critical Us mental health professionals As with other professions
- 16:36We like to categorize things And one of the things we've been categorizing For
- 16:39a very long time Are kids' behaviors,
- 16:43An example of categories of kids concerning behaviors, if we were to turn to
- 16:48the trauma literature for our categories, we would have the categories of fight,
- 16:52flight, and freeze, which is great.
- 16:57I like the trauma literature, but if all we're saying is fight,
- 17:00flight, and freeze, we're still missing a lot of information.
- 17:04We're still talking about the kid's concerning behavior.
- 17:07We don't know anything about that kid yet. If we're to rely on the motherlode
- 17:14of categories of behaviors,
- 17:16the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, now in its fifth plus addition.
- 17:23By the way, the fact that it is in its fifth plus addition tells you that we're
- 17:29having difficulty getting those categories squared away.
- 17:33We keep inventing new ones and we keep changing the ones we already got.
- 17:38If you were to turn to the DSM-5, you would be greeted with dozens of categories of behavior.
- 17:46Wait a second. When you're talking about a kid's psychiatric diagnosis,
- 17:49you're still talking about their concerning behavior? Of course.
- 17:53Take a look at the diagnostic criteria for the vast majority of childhood psychiatric
- 17:57disorders, and what will you find?
- 17:59A long list of concerning behaviors.
- 18:03Now, this is important.
- 18:06I have categories of my own. They're fake. I'm one of the few people who's willing
- 18:11to acknowledge that his categories are fake. Mine are fake.
- 18:14But I use them for a very important reason, which will become very clear momentarily.
- 18:19My categories of concerning behavior are lucky and unlucky.
- 18:23What are lucky ways of communicating that you're having difficulty meeting certain expectations?
- 18:29I won't be exhaustive here, but whining, pouting, sulking, withdrawing. crying.
- 18:38Why do I refer to those frustration responses as lucky?
- 18:42Because those frustration responses aren't going to get you popped into timeout,
- 18:46aren't going to get you held in from recess, aren't going to get you held after
- 18:50school, aren't going to get you a detention, suspension, expulsion,
- 18:54aren't going to get you hit, hit at school. You betcha.
- 19:00In 17 of our 50 states, we are still hitting kids on the butt with a two-foot
- 19:07piece of plywood close to 100,000 times every school year hit.
- 19:14Of course, it's still very popular in American households as well.
- 19:18Those lucky frustration responses aren't going to get you pinned to the ground
- 19:23by two to four adults, what's known as a restraint, aren't going to get you
- 19:27thrown into a locked or blocked closet-sized room, what's known as a seclusion.
- 19:34But best of all, those lucky frustration responses are highly likely to elicit
- 19:40empathy, nurturance, support from your caregivers.
- 19:46That's a lucky kid.
- 19:49Not so for the unlucky variety. And once again, that's the variety of kid I've
- 19:53been working with for over four decades now in one way or another.
- 19:58What are unlucky ways of communicating that you're having difficulty meeting certain expectations?
- 20:03I won't be exhaustive here either, but screaming, swearing, hitting,
- 20:09spitting, kicking, biting, throwing, destroying, running.
- 20:14Why are those frustration responses unlucky? Because those frustration responses
- 20:20are highly likely to elicit the most punitive, exclusionary discipline our society has to offer,
- 20:27and far less likely to elicit empathy, nurturance, support from your caregivers.
- 20:36What's the difference between lucky and unlucky? How we treat them.
- 20:41Because as it relates to what those frustration responses are communicating,
- 20:47all frustration responses are created equal.
- 20:50There's an expectation. This kid is having difficulty meeting.
- 20:55And how we respond to that is going to make all the difference in the world for this kid.
- 21:03I may be wondering, what's driving kids who have maladaptive frustration responses?
- 21:11There's lots of theories about that.
- 21:13There's lots of societal ills that we could point to if we wanted to.
- 21:18But what the research tells me is that what's driving maladaptive frustration responses are skills.
- 21:28Skills these kids are struggling with. Skills most of us take for granted.
- 21:34Flexibility adaptability frustration tolerance problem solving emotion regulation
- 21:42now those are just the global skills there's actually hundreds of skills,
- 21:47that research has told us can be compromised in kids with unlucky frustration responses,
- 21:56why is that an issue because most people don't know that yet.
- 22:01Most people still think that concerning behavior is driven primarily by poor motivation.
- 22:09And that's why we have been trying to incentivize compliance for a very, very long time.
- 22:19Here are some things we can change.
- 22:22If we want to be more attuned and responsive to developmental variability,
- 22:29as far as as relates to my work, especially in the kids who are at greatest
- 22:34risk for adverse outcomes.
- 22:38Those who exhibit non-compliance at very early ages.
- 22:44First, we need to stop focusing on their concerning behavior.
- 22:48We need to focus instead on the expectations they're having difficulty meeting
- 22:53that are causing that behavior.
- 22:56That is huge. If Ireland ever asks me, Ross, what's your number two priority?
- 23:03Number two would be don't focus on a kid's concerning behavior and don't try to modify it.
- 23:09In this model, collaborative and proactive solutions, we improve behavior by
- 23:14solving the problems that are causing those behaviors. That's right.
- 23:18We call expectations, kids are having difficulty meeting.
- 23:22We call them unsolved problems. That doesn't mean the kid's the problem.
- 23:27That means that there's an expectation they're having difficulty meeting.
- 23:31And one of the biggest favors we do their parents, educators,
- 23:36Staff in treatment facilities, including here in Maine.
- 23:42Years ago, Long Creek and Mountain View, up northwest of Bangor,
- 23:49we helped them stop focusing on kids concerning behavior and helped them start
- 23:52focusing instead on the expectations kids were having difficulty meeting that
- 23:57were causing those behaviors. That is huge.
- 24:02Because once you identify the expectations a kid is having difficulty meeting.
- 24:07This becomes a very predictable kid.
- 24:10And if they're predictable, if we identify those unsolved problems proactively,
- 24:15they can be solved proactively.
- 24:18And we just got people out of the heat of the moment in dealing with these kids.
- 24:24And the heat of the moment is where they're so often finding themselves.
- 24:28So one of the first things we need to change is what we're looking at,
- 24:34not behavior, the problems that are causing that behavior.
- 24:38Examples of unsolved problems.
- 24:41At home, we might be talking about, these are benign things.
- 24:44These are mundane things, not benign.
- 24:47Difficulty brushing teeth before going to bed at night.
- 24:51Difficulty eating what mom or dad has made for dinner. Difficulty turning off
- 24:54the Xbox to come in for dinner.
- 24:57Difficulty turning off the Xbox to go to bed at night.
- 24:59Difficulty turning off the Xbox to engage in any other much more meaningful aspect of living.
- 25:05Difficulty completing XYZ homework assignment. Difficulty being in bed by 9
- 25:10p.m. with the lights and electronics off. I could go on forever.
- 25:15Those are what I'm talking about when I'm talking about unmet expectations,
- 25:18unsolved problems. Those are synonyms.
- 25:22Unsolved problems at school. Difficulty. There's hundreds. Why could there be hundreds?
- 25:29Because every day we place hundreds of expectations on kids at school.
- 25:33And thanks to developmental variability, it is guaranteed that some kids are
- 25:39going to have difficulty meeting some of those expectations.
- 25:44Difficulty coming back into the classroom after recess. Difficulty completing
- 25:48the double-digit division problems on the worksheet in math.
- 25:52Difficulty getting along with Trevor on the school bus in the morning.
- 25:55Difficulty agreeing with Billy on the rules of the four-square game during recess.
- 26:01Difficulty coming to school. Difficulty coming to school on time.
- 26:06Once again, I could go on forever, but now you've got the idea about what I'm
- 26:10talking about with unsolved problems.
- 26:14In the 5, 10, 15 kids in every school that are struggling the most,
- 26:19the vast majority of their unsolved problems are old.
- 26:24Expectations these kids have been having difficulty meeting for a very long
- 26:28time. And here's what's amazing.
- 26:31Often they've never even been identified, let alone solved. Why?
- 26:38Because we've been so over-focused on their frustration responses,
- 26:43their concerning behavior, which we have been busy counting and documenting and observing.
- 26:52We've been focused on the wrong thing. To help us focus on the right thing,
- 26:58there is the assessment of skills and unsolved problems.
- 27:01We call it the ACUP, and this is the 2024 rendition.
- 27:05It used to be called the Assessment of Lagging Skills and Unsolved Problems,
- 27:09but the neurodivergent community did not, justifiably so, did not like the word 'lagging'.
- 27:15They felt it had a neurotypical reference point, and they don't really feel
- 27:20like they're lagging anything.
- 27:22Proof that that's a neurotypical reference point. So we took out the word lagging
- 27:27And now it's the Assessment of Skills and Unsolved Problems This is assessment
- 27:30gold This should be the standard,
- 27:34Pre-referral triage instrument In every school, every clinic,
- 27:40Every treatment facility This is what gives us the information that's been missing,
- 27:45Top section What skills is this kid struggling with that are making it hard
- 27:51for this kid to respond adaptively to problems and frustrations.
- 27:55We've got to make sure that every adult knows that maladaptive frustration responses
- 28:01are due to skills, not motivation.
- 28:06Second section, what expectations is this kid having difficulty meeting?
- 28:13In the kids who've been struggling the most, and for a very long time,
- 28:17that list of unsolved problems is going to be very long.
- 28:20I want to repeat myself. Most of those unsolved problems are old.
- 28:25And here for the first time, they're finally being identified.
- 28:29This kid may have already had eight functional behavior assessments.
- 28:33We still haven't identified the expectations. They're having difficulty meeting.
- 28:37They may be on their 12th IEP.
- 28:40We still haven't identified the expectations they're having difficulty meeting.
- 28:47This might be their eighth behavior plan. Behavior plans are focused on frustration responses.
- 28:53The ACUP is focused on unsolved problems, problems we could have been busy solving
- 28:59if we hadn't have been so focused on frustration responses.
- 29:04The ACIP is a game changer. It is assessment gold.
- 29:08It also happens to be free on the Lives in the Balance website,
- 29:12the website that the nonprofit that Dora mentioned in the very beginning,
- 29:17based right here in Freeport, Maine, where I am sitting right now,
- 29:21because of how the ACUP changes people's lenses and timing and focal points.
- 29:29Here are things I commonly hear in ACUP meetings after we have identified a
- 29:35kid's skills and unsolved problems. Thank you, Libby. Wow.
- 29:40I didn't realize there were so many.
- 29:43Good that we now realize there are so many. You know, if I had this many unsolved
- 29:48problems and I knew I was going to get hit with them when I showed up at school,
- 29:51I don't think I'd get out of bed. Some don't.
- 29:56I don't think I'd show up. Some don't. This is an expectation management question.
- 30:05Can this kid actually meet all of these expectations? Probably not.
- 30:11If they can't, then why are we putting expectations on this kid that we already
- 30:16know they can't meet? That is a very good question.
- 30:21And finally, are all of these unsolved problems, and by the way,
- 30:25there could be 30, 40, 50 of them, are all of these unsolved problems of equal importance?
- 30:32That's a prioritizing question. No wonder what we've been doing hadn't been working.
- 30:38I'm kind of feeling bad about how I've been treating the kid What's that person now reflecting on?
- 30:45How they've been treating the kid And what they now know about the kid And coming
- 30:50to the recognition that the two do not square up,
- 30:54Finally So you're saying that this kid only gets upset When these unsolved problems pop up?
- 31:02That's right And you're saying these unsolved problems don't pop up We know
- 31:07they're coming That's right.
- 31:10There are any unsolved problems you write in on the assessment of skills and
- 31:14unsolved problems is by definition predictable or you wouldn't have been able to write it in.
- 31:19And you're saying that if we solve these problems with the kid,
- 31:23they won't get upset over them anymore, right?
- 31:27And you're saying we don't have to wait till the heat of the moment to solve
- 31:30these problems. We can solve them proactively.
- 31:36By the way, there's a ton of free resources on the Lives in the Balance website.
- 31:40And you've got it in the chat there, including a 30-minute video teaching you
- 31:44how to use the assessment of skills and unsolved problems, which I am breezing past.
- 31:50Here's another thing we can change. Our approach.
- 31:54Not only have we been busy rewarding and punishing kids so that they exhibit adaptive behavior.
- 32:04By the way, when you're doing that, you still don't know what the unsolved problem
- 32:07is that's causing it. You've blown past that. You don't want to blow past that.
- 32:12Noncompliance tells you there's something else going on. You're not focused
- 32:16only on the noncompliance.
- 32:18Plus, it's only unsolved problems that cause concerning behavior.
- 32:23Solved problems don't. So I'm going to repeat something I said earlier.
- 32:26In this model, you are improving behavior.
- 32:29In this evidence-based model, you are improving behavior by solving the problems
- 32:35that are causing those behaviors.
- 32:39But the problem solving is not unilateral it's not adult driven it's collaborative meaning,
- 32:50a process that both kid and adult engage in together this is something you're
- 32:56doing with a kid not to a kid this is something you're doing even if the kid
- 33:01is non or minimally speaking.
- 33:05And this is for those who worry that if we're not using consequences,
- 33:10you're not holding kids accountable.
- 33:13I've never thought that consequences were a particularly effective way of holding
- 33:17kids accountable. When you're consequencing
- 33:19a kid, the kid is the passive recipient of the adult solutions.
- 33:26No thinking, no engagement, no accountability.
- 33:31You want to hold a kid accountable? Engage them in the process of solving the
- 33:37problems that are causing their concerning behavior. That's accountability.
- 33:42This is my current obsession. Timing.
- 33:46It drives me nuts how much time and money is spent teaching,
- 33:53especially educators, what to do once a kid is already becoming escalated.
- 34:00It drives me nuts because I know that they are unlikely to need that training.
- 34:07That's crisis management training.
- 34:10When we identify problems proactively, when we solve them collaboratively and
- 34:16proactively, we almost never need our crisis management practices anymore.
- 34:26We have got to get out in front of unsolved problems if we're going to help these kids.
- 34:32So not only is the ASIP going to help us identify them proactively,
- 34:37not only are we going to try to solve them collaboratively, we've also set the
- 34:42stage for us to solve those problems proactively.
- 34:46These kids are very predictable.
- 34:48If we identify two pieces of information, why and when, the two questions it's
- 34:55most critical to answer about kids who are struggling.
- 34:59Why do some kids respond so poorly to problems and frustrations?
- 35:03When do kids exhibit concerning behavior?
- 35:05This is repetitious, by the way, because you've already heard about these things.
- 35:09The answer to the question why is skills, not motivation.
- 35:14And you've already heard what skills we're talking about here, the global skills.
- 35:19When do kids, the ASAP helps us identify the skills the kid is struggling with. Huge.
- 35:25That's lenses. That's huge.
- 35:28The ASAP also helps us identify when the kid is exhibiting concerning behavior,
- 35:33the expectations the kid is having difficulty meeting.
- 35:38Once those two pieces of information are identified, this is a very predictable kid.
- 35:44Intervention can be almost exclusively proactive.
- 35:49Isn't this interesting, though? Turns out that us human beings are wired to
- 35:55be reactive, not proactive.
- 35:58So to get out in front of it with these kids, we, believe it or not,
- 36:02have to go a bit against human nature.
- 36:06It has been to the advantage of the survival of the species that we've been
- 36:11reactive instead of proactive.
- 36:15You know, the species that stopped to think about whether there could be a tiger,
- 36:21is no longer with us at the watering hole.
- 36:24Apparently, and this is the one that I question, apparently it saves energy
- 36:30for our brains to be reactive instead of proactive.
- 36:35We think it saves time and energy. In some ways it does. In most ways, it doesn't.
- 36:43So though we are wired to be late, that doesn't mean we can't be intentional in our efforts not to be.
- 36:51And the assessment of skills and unsolved problems is one giant leap in that direction.
- 36:57Next slide, please. I find that part fascinating.
- 37:01Here's one more thing we can change and then we'll get into slight detail,
- 37:05our lenses for many years we've because we've been thinking that concerning
- 37:11behavior and non-compliance and kids not meeting our expectations was due to poor motivation,
- 37:18we've had the mentality that kids do well if they wanna long time ago i was
- 37:25trained in the kids do all if they want a tradition formally.
- 37:30And I left those territories a very long time ago. This is where I coined perhaps
- 37:36the most important phrase of my career and the one that probably embodies my entire body of work.
- 37:45Kids do well if they can.
- 37:48This is the belief that if this kid could do well, the kid would do well.
- 37:54If the kid isn't doing well, something's getting in the way.
- 37:58What's getting in the way?
- 38:00As it relates to their maladaptive frustration responses There are skills they
- 38:04are struggling with And as it relates to what's causing those frustration responses
- 38:10There are expectations These kids are having difficulty meeting,
- 38:15There is the mentality out there That all things are possible If you're just
- 38:22motivated enough That is not true First of all, I'm 68 years old Secondly, I'm five foot six.
- 38:30Thirdly, I'm not a very good basketball player.
- 38:34Motivation was all I needed. I'd be an NBA star at this point,
- 38:38but that ain't in the cards for me.
- 38:41No, no matter how motivated you are, some things are still beyond reach.
- 38:49When we have kids do all if they can lenses on, there are characterizations
- 38:56of kids with concerning behaviors that are no longer in our vocabulary.
- 39:00Attention-seeking, manipulative, coercive, unmotivated, limit testing, etc.
- 39:09Those characterizations flow from motivational conceptions about why kids are
- 39:16exhibiting concerning behavior.
- 39:18None of them are true. And if I had a few extra minutes, I'd explain why.
- 39:25I think I'll explain why on one of them.
- 39:27Let me pick my least favorite, unmotivated. I would never refer to any human being as unmotivated.
- 39:35Why not? Because here's what I know.
- 39:38The minute we take a closer look, what skills does this kid struggling with?
- 39:43What expectations does this kid have in difficulty meeting?
- 39:46We find that unmotivated doesn't even come close to capturing what's really going on with this kid.
- 39:52Plus, if we listen to the voices of the neurodivergent community, and we should,
- 39:58they are among the communities that has most often been inaccurately referred
- 40:03to as unmotivated and have been on the receiving end of a disproportionate share
- 40:09of punitive exclusionary discipline.
- 40:11We will hear adult members of the neurodivergent community telling us.
- 40:17That the sticker charts they endured as children were experienced by them as harmful, which adds up.
- 40:25They were the kid who was identified at a very early age as the kid who doesn't get the sticker.
- 40:33Now, not getting a sticker isn't going to solve any of the problems that are
- 40:38causing the kids concerning behavior in the first place.
- 40:41If there was another way to accomplish whatever we think we're accomplishing
- 40:46with stickers that didn't cause harm, we should do it.
- 40:52We have a few options for handling those unsolved problems. This will be the
- 40:56last thing we want to talk about.
- 40:58The other part of this model is that it articulates three different ways of
- 41:03handling those unsolved problems, and we call them Plan A, Plan B, and Plan C.
- 41:10What I've done here is I've taken three ways of handling unsolved problems.
- 41:15It provides a very nice shorthand for thinking about how we are currently handling
- 41:21unsolved problems and for how we might more productively handle them instead.
- 41:27Plan A is where a problem is being solved unilaterally.
- 41:31What I'm always telling adults is when you're implementing this model,
- 41:36you're almost never going to use plan A.
- 41:38Not because you're allergic to it you do need plan b that's where you're solving
- 41:44the problem collaboratively and you do need plan c,
- 41:48that's where you are putting some expectations on hold for now because especially
- 41:52in the case of the kids who have a lot of unsolved problems you're not going
- 41:56to be able to solve them all at once,
- 41:59i'm going to tell you how to do
- 42:00plan b momentarily but I want to tell you why plan C is such a big deal.
- 42:04You would put an expectation on hold for one of three reasons.
- 42:10Prioritizing, or what some of you might call triaging, because you can't solve everything at once.
- 42:18Expectation management, this is where you are giving very conscious,
- 42:24deliberate thought to whether an expectation is even in range developmentally
- 42:30for a kid at this point in their development.
- 42:33This is very different than saying every kid's got to get over the same line
- 42:37by the end of the school year.
- 42:38And finally, stabilizing. Any expectation that has been removed for now won't
- 42:45cause concerning behavior.
- 42:47And there are some kids who are so unstable, they're not meeting any expectations anytime soon.
- 42:54What we say to educators all the time is, stabilization comes before education.
- 42:59And what I have said to three teams of educators this week alone,
- 43:04where we're talking about kids who are struggling in a school,
- 43:08what's a successful day going to look like for this student?
- 43:11Because whatever you're doing right
- 43:12now explains why you are not having successful days with this student.
- 43:18You are still putting expectations on them that you're telling me they can't meet.
- 43:23That is the most important question I frequently ask schools to think about,
- 43:28when they're dealing with a kid who they are complaining is completely out of control.
- 43:32What is a successful day going to look like for this student do that instead.
- 43:39Let me tell you how you solve a problem collaboratively this is plan b there
- 43:43are three steps they are called the empathy step the define adult concern step and the invitation step.
- 43:52This is what I spend most of my waking moments helping people learn how to do.
- 43:56And something all of our trainers at Lives in the Balance spend a lot of their
- 44:01waking moments teaching people how to do.
- 44:04The empathy step. Remember, this is proactive.
- 44:08Is where we're gathering information from the kid about what's making it hard,
- 44:13for them to meet a particular expectation.
- 44:16Who's your number one source of information in this model?
- 44:20On what's making it hard for a kid to meet an expectation, the kid,
- 44:25even, believe it or not, if they're non or minimally speaking,
- 44:30even, believe it or not, if they can talk but aren't, we call them reluctant,
- 44:39talkers, you need info from the kid.
- 44:42And we're always telling people to be prepared for surprises in the empathy
- 44:46step when they discover that what they thought What was getting in the kid's
- 44:50way is not what's getting in the kid's way.
- 44:54This is a true story. I was working with this father a while ago,
- 44:58his three-year-old daughter. That's significant because a lot of people think
- 45:01you can't do these three steps with three-year-olds. They're wrong.
- 45:04His three-year-old daughter was having difficulty brushing her teeth before going to bed at night.
- 45:09But true to form for a lot of adults, he was telling me he thought he already
- 45:14knew what was making it hard for his daughter to brush her teeth before going to bed at night.
- 45:18He was sure it was the taste of the toothpaste. So he's telling me,
- 45:22five or six different flavors of toothpaste later, she's still having difficulty
- 45:27brushing her teeth before going to bed at night. So he says to me, so I finally did plan B.
- 45:33Thinking, you finally did plan B? And people think doing plan B takes a long time?
- 45:40Look how much time it took you to go through five or six different flavors of toothpaste.
- 45:44Here's what the empathy step sounded like.
- 45:47I've noticed you've been having difficulty brushing your teeth before going
- 45:50to bed at night. What's up?
- 45:53His daughter said, when you brush my teeth with the electric toothbrush,
- 45:56it gets water all over my face, and I hate getting water sprayed all over my face.
- 46:03I said to the father, now there's a concern that would never be addressed by
- 46:08five or six different flavors of toothpaste.
- 46:11The define adult concern step. That's where the adult is entering their concern
- 46:16into consideration. expectation the exact same concern that might previously
- 46:21have led them into plan a is now leading them into plan b,
- 46:27what are we adults concerned about well the answer to that question is the answer to the question,
- 46:33why is it important that this expectation be met so here's what it sounded like,
- 46:38my concern is that if we don't brush your teeth before you go to bed at night
- 46:41you can get cavities and it kind of hurts to get cavities filled and to tell
- 46:45you the truth i'd rather not spend the money if I don't have to.
- 46:49Two sets of concerns on the table. No turning back now.
- 46:54Time for the invitation. This is where kid and caregiver.
- 47:00Are collaborating on a solution, but a solution that must meet two criteria.
- 47:05Got to be realistic. Both parties got to be able to do what they're agreeing to do.
- 47:11And even more important than that, got to be mutually satisfactory.
- 47:16Meaning, the solution truly addresses the concerns of both parties.
- 47:22Here's what I've been saying a lot lately, and world history bears me out on it.
- 47:27Not just my work with kids and their caregivers, if a solution is not realistic
- 47:33and mutually satisfactory, I promise you this problem is still unsolved.
- 47:40Here's what the invitation sounds like. I wonder if there's a way for us to
- 47:44make sure that your face doesn't get wet when I'm brushing your teeth with the
- 47:49electric toothbrush. That was the kid's concern.
- 47:52And also make sure that you don't get cavities because it kind of hurts to get
- 47:57cavities filled. And to tell you the truth, I'd rather not spend the money if I don't have to.
- 48:02Believe it or not, you are then giving the kid the first crack at the solution.
- 48:07Not because it's the kid's job to come up with the solution.
- 48:09It's y'all's job to come up with the solution. If the kid doesn't have any ideas, I'm sure you will.
- 48:14But it's a very good strategy to give the kid the first crack. Here's what she said.
- 48:20Could we wrap a towel around my face when you're brushing my teeth with the electric toothbrush?
- 48:26And then my face wouldn't get wet. And also I wouldn't get cavities.
- 48:32Who won both lost nobody.
- 48:38How early should we start teaching kids how to do this as early as possible?
- 48:44The website is livesinthebalance.org.
- 48:48I am delighted to spend our last three minutes together answering questions,
- 48:52though I had hoped it would be 10 instead of three. But let's see what we got, if anything.
- 48:59Thank you so much. That was wonderful. I've heard you speak a number of times
- 49:03over the years, and I always learn something new.
- 49:07So I will start off a little bit, too.
- 49:10You wrote your first book like 20, 25 years ago or so?
- 49:16It's coming up to 30 years. It's about 28 years now, The Explosive Child.
- 49:22Oh, my gosh. Yeah, I remember that very much when the book came out.
- 49:25So you've written a book this year, and you've written a number of books in between.
- 49:30Are there things that keep changing in our society or about your understanding
- 49:35or both that causes you to, you know, the need to continue to write books? Is it...
- 49:43Well, Dora, as I know you have heard because you were at the talk I did for
- 49:47Freeport Speech, there are so many societal changes that have been to the disadvantage
- 49:53of kids over the last 30 years.
- 49:56That's an entire talk all by itself, which is what I did at Freeport Speech,
- 50:00although it wasn't, it was more Q&A with Nirav Shah.
- 50:04So yes, I think it's way harder to be a kid now than it ever has been.
- 50:10And for me, that cements the need to be collaborative instead of unilateral,
- 50:17and to take into account all of the factors, some of which we can't do anything
- 50:22about, but it's really important just to know what's walking in the door,
- 50:25even if we can't do anything about it.
- 50:28So a lot of it, so continued understanding, but particularly continued changes in society.
- 50:35So Megan's got a question there. We work with kids who cannot have expectations dropped or changed.
- 50:41Often the behavior is sexual perpetuation, substance use or physical aggression.
- 50:46How would you approach scenarios like this?
- 50:49You are not dropping your behavioral expectations, but what you are doing is
- 50:55you are looking at the unsolved problems that underlie the difficulties they
- 51:00are having meeting those behavioral expectations.
- 51:03And this is the work that we did at Long Creek and Mountain View because a lot
- 51:06of what was just described is what's walking in their door. Those are their behaviors.
- 51:12We're not saying we're going to
- 51:13drop the expectation that you not sexually assault people. Can't do that.
- 51:18But what we are going to do is take a look at the factors that are causing that
- 51:23behavior and try to solve those.
- 51:26In that respect, this is a very upstream model. Those behaviors are downstream.
- 51:33We're going to do an ACIP on that kid first, and then we're going to start solving
- 51:37whatever problems are related to the behaviors that you just described.
- 51:41But we are not dropping our behavioral expectations.
- 51:45We are solving the problems that are causing them to have difficulty meeting those expectations.
- 51:51And I just also would note that a number of people on this call are working
- 51:56with both individual children, youth, and their parents or caregivers or teachers.
- 52:04Some are also working with schools, like the Shaw Grant, for a public health approach.
- 52:11And I think they both overlap. I mean, just like anything, we work on public
- 52:16health issues, both with individuals as well as with across society.
- 52:20So I think, you know, those who are working on a public health approach,
- 52:24I think we're really asking what conditions should we create so that young people
- 52:28across a population are more likely to experience mental well-being.
- 52:33Whereas I think what you were talking about, you know, your approach is really
- 52:37around a particular young person or young people and how when they're struggling
- 52:42to meet expectations, how should we adults and others understand and respond to that struggle?
- 52:48So the two, I think, are complementary, but I just wanted to point that out,
- 52:51that we've got people on this call who are working in both and sometimes more
- 52:57one or the other, but they think they're very complementary.
- 53:00And a number of several who also commented that they really appreciate your approach.
- 53:06Carrie Burkett, who's our public health person up in the Memorial Hospital in
- 53:11New Hampshire, talks about that she loves this framework.
- 53:14And she's used it back when she was teaching, teaching after reading the Explosive Child.
- 53:18So if there's one thing that you think we could all just start doing differently,
- 53:24your framework, every time I hear it, I think, OK, this is so good. it makes so much sense.
- 53:29And then I feel like a daily, I feel like I have to have a, it's like having
- 53:32a bath or something. I need to keep hearing about it because it's so different
- 53:37than what society tells us.
- 53:39It's just like a step that you feel like we all could just take,
- 53:42you know, starting today or tomorrow to just move towards that framework.
- 53:48The phrase that comes to mind is question everything.
- 53:52Question training? I had to.
- 53:55Question your belief systems? I had to. I did not create this model to create book sales.
- 54:04I created this model because it reflected a new recognition about the kids that
- 54:10I was working with, a new awareness of why what we were doing wasn't helping
- 54:15them. We have an epidemic of these kids.
- 54:18It's not because what we're doing now is working really well.
- 54:20It's because what we're doing now isn't working very well at all.
- 54:24Question everything. But especially, I'll give the same answer as I gave in Ireland.
- 54:29Every adult needs to see concerning behavior as a frustration response.
- 54:32It starts there. That's a great way to end. Thank you so much.
- 54:37Jessica also has a question. Sorry, I missed it before.
- 54:41Could you speak to the relationship between your model on the idea of pathologic demand avoidance?
- 54:46I am about as enthusiastic about pathological demand avoidance as I am about
- 54:50any other psychiatric diagnosis, which is to say not that enthusiastic.
- 54:55Doesn't mean that I don't think these kids exist. I just think that the diagnosis
- 55:00does not necessarily tell us what we need to know about them.
- 55:03So it doesn't change anything about how I'm going to approach them.
- 55:07I was doing an interview with a New York Times reporter. they're going to come
- 55:11out with an article on pathological demand avoidance because it seems to be
- 55:14the diagnosis, the fashion diagnosis these days.
- 55:19I mean, she said to me, why do we need pathological demand avoidance?
- 55:23And I said, because we, we, we screwed it.
- 55:25We botched the job on oppositional defiant disorder.
- 55:28I said, you know, with oppositional defiant disorder, we have kids who are having
- 55:31difficulty doing what they're told. And with pathological demand avoidance,
- 55:35we're having, we have kids who are having difficulty meeting adult demands.
- 55:38Sounds pretty similar to me.
- 55:40The difference is on oppositional defiant disorder, we decided that it was due
- 55:44to passive, permissive, inconsistent, non-contingent, inept parenting.
- 55:49That's what we told parents for a very long time when they had a kid who wasn't
- 55:53doing what they're told.
- 55:54With pathological demand avoidance, we are saying that it's a strong driving
- 55:59for autonomy. That sounds a lot better.
- 56:02And anxiety, that sounds a lot better.
- 56:05But I'm not that enthusiastic about any diagnosis. You still in every kid.
- 56:10And that's why your comment that this is broadly applicable,
- 56:14it is broadly applicable.
- 56:16I haven't seen a diagnosis that I wouldn't apply this model to in one way or another.
- 56:21With a kid with pathological demand avoidance, you've got to figure out skills
- 56:24and unsolved problems. You've got to start solving problems collaboratively
- 56:27and proactively. It really doesn't change a thing.
- 56:30Thank you so much. I know you've changed thousands, if not millions of lives.
- 56:35Thank you. I really appreciate it. And I know my own two children who are both
- 56:41in their 20s, but their schools.
- 56:44I was very fortunate that they used your approach as well. So,
- 56:47and I know that at least one of them highly benefited from it.
- 56:50So I think they both benefited, but one particularly more so than the other.
- 56:55So I'm really extremely appreciative of your work.
- 56:58And it's been a great honor to host you here today. And you're getting a number
- 57:01of comments floating in. Very nice. Thank you.
- 57:04In the same way. So, and we're just proud to have you in Maine as well. Yes.
- 57:09And Caroline, the recording is going to be available, both the video as well
- 57:13as the audio and podcast.
- 57:15As you may know, Maine Health is, some of you may know that Maine Health is
- 57:17revamping their website.
- 57:18So our website for these public health grant rounds is a bit delayed,
- 57:22but we will, not updated, but we will do that soon, as soon as they let us do that.
- 57:27So thank you very much, everybody. And thank you again, Ross.
- 57:31It's great. Always wonderful to see you. And my deep appreciation for everything you're doing.
- 57:37My pleasure. Thanks for inviting me to do this. Looking forward to the next book.
- 57:41It's in the works. Good, good, good, good, good. Take care.
- 57:45Thank you for listening, and we look forward to connecting with you again at
- 57:50MaineHealth's Public Health Grand Rounds, where we explore a timely public health
- 57:55topic with national and Maine experts.
- 57:58These Grand Rounds are posted to the MaineHealth podcast channel on Podbean,
- 58:03and at MaineHealth.org, where you can hear current and past episodes. See you next time.