Latest / Film And Whiskey / Stalag 17 / Benchmark Full Proof Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone. Before we get into today's
- 0:02episode, I just wanted to remind you that we have a ton of extra
- 0:05content over on our patreon. We do movie watch parties
- 0:08special page here on the bonus episodes and all other sorts of
- 0:11wacky stuff that you can access easily.
- 0:14If you head on over to patreon.com slash film, Whiskey
- 0:19In 1953, director, Billy Wilder, and star William Holden, gave
- 0:24the world a slapstick drama about one man's redemption in
- 0:27the heart of a World War Two. Prisoner camp in 2023.
- 0:33We bid a fond farewell to a flight of five.
- 0:35Bourbons, the film is Stalag 17, the whiskey is Benchmark
- 0:42foolproof and more view them both.
- 0:44This is the film and whiskey podcast.
- 1:06Welcome to the film and whiskey podcast, where each week, we
- 1:09review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 1:12I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G. And this week, we are looking at
- 1:16Billy Wilder's 1953 film, Stalag 17, Stalag strogg.
- 1:23Now, Brad, I will say right up front, I fully expect that if we
- 1:28were to list out the most seen to least seen films of season 7
- 1:33by the general population. This has got to be close to the
- 1:36bottom. It's not that it's necessarily
- 1:38an unpopular movie, but it is. Let's Be Frank here. 70 years
- 1:41old, and it is not one of Billy Wilder's, top four, or five most
- 1:46remembered movies. Yeah, I'm going to describe to
- 1:49you how old this movie is. You can watch it for free on
- 1:53Pluto TV. You sure can and onto and on to
- 1:57be. So if that tells you how popular
- 1:59the It's I don't understand, like I actually did watch this
- 2:03partially on to be and the prints that they are using is so
- 2:07crappy and so old. And like it was, it was both
- 2:11pixelated and a bad print of the movie to the point where I
- 2:16pulled off my shelf, the Stalag 17 DVD that I have.
- 2:20If you know anything about DVDs, DVDs are they're encoded at 480p
- 2:26and I put it in my DVD player and I was like, wow, this is a A
- 2:30major Improvement in picture of her.
- 2:32Yeah. Over what was on to be.
- 2:34So I went back and forth. There's actually a free
- 2:37recording. I don't know if like I think
- 2:40Paramount produce this picture. I don't know if they just
- 2:42haven't felt like copyright striking it but the entire movie
- 2:46is just on YouTube. Oh, there you go.
- 2:49Just end it and it's not like somebody like some company, did
- 2:52it? It's just some dude uploaded it
- 2:54like eight years ago and it's also in like 480p.
- 2:58So, there you go, folks. Our highest recommendation for
- 3:02the ideal conditions, watch Stalag 17, as God, intended on
- 3:07to be, or on some guys YouTube stream.
- 3:11Yeah. Where's where's Scorsese?
- 3:12Or the Criterion Collection, right?
- 3:15Aren't they? The funny thing is, this movie
- 3:17is available on Blu-ray and it has like Stellar reviews.
- 3:20So I'm imagining that looks really good if you get it there
- 3:22but you know or you could go the free route and you can watch the
- 3:25year olds worst version of this on to be All right, you're new
- 3:31to the field, whiskey podcast. This is exactly what you can.
- 3:34This mix is what we talked about, folks.
- 3:36These are the jokes. So I'm thinking about Stalag 17,
- 3:41and I think, to be fair and to be Frank, this is the one that I
- 3:46needed a third movie by Billy Wilder to put in here.
- 3:50And like, most directors, Billy Wilder has five six, seven
- 3:54movies that are like, most people would recognize them by
- 3:58name and then you get into Okay. There's probably like the next
- 4:01tear down and when people like Spielberg, you probably don't
- 4:05hit that. Quite as early Hitchcock, you
- 4:07probably don't hit that quite as early, but with Billy Wilder, I
- 4:10was really torn because he has a few other movies.
- 4:13There is a movie that came out in 51 called Ace in the Hole
- 4:16which was a huge flop. I believe upon release but has
- 4:19been reclaimed and is not like really popular with Criterion
- 4:23Bros. He has a movie in the late 50s,
- 4:26witness for the prosecution, which gets nominated for Best
- 4:28Picture. Here's movie in.
- 4:29The mid-40s called The Lost weekend is Weekend.
- 4:33At Bernie's the sequel. It is suika.
- 4:35Is you actually made that joke like earlier in the season?
- 4:38I think you forgot that you made that joke already.
- 4:39No, it didn't work the first time and it didn't work.
- 4:42Now, Brad all that to say. I went with Stalag 17 because
- 4:47after Sunset Boulevard, I was like, you know what, we need a
- 4:50palate cleanser here and this movie for being very tense and
- 4:54very dramatic at Parts. It's also a lot of fun.
- 4:59Yeah, 100%. I was saying to you before.
- 5:01We got on that, there's, there's two characters in this film
- 5:05named animal and Shapiro and they, they feel like they are
- 5:10straight out of a Three Stooges like silent era slapstick
- 5:16comedy. And they're just hanging out in
- 5:20the middle of this prisoner of war camp where they're trying to
- 5:23find, you know, this informant and it's it just doesn't fit.
- 5:29Get it fits perfectly and I loved it.
- 5:32So if we can go back through the annals of film and whiskey here,
- 5:36I think this is our third prisoner of war movie after the
- 5:41Great Escape and Bridge on the River Kwai.
- 5:43I don't think we've done anymore besides that.
- 5:46And this will be really wants to toe the line between the two in.
- 5:51A lot of ways. I think it's it's got, well, I
- 5:53think it's closest to the Great Escape, and it's kind of, not
- 5:56fair to this movie, to compare it to the Great Escape, because
- 5:58the Great Escape Happens 10 years after this movie.
- 6:01And I think as we discussed this movie today Brad, it's really
- 6:04important that we keep in mind that this is one of the first
- 6:07prisoner of war films to come out after WWII and they kind of
- 6:12tip you off to that in the opening narration where the
- 6:14narrator basically says, hey I'm sick of watching movies that
- 6:18didn't look like my experience of the war at all.
- 6:20We were in a prisoner of war camp and then it shows you what
- 6:23the prisoner of war camp looks like.
- 6:25And so even though I don't necessarily think it's as
- 6:27effective as the Escape or as Bridge on the River Kwai it is
- 6:33really important to note that this is one of the first times
- 6:35somebody dared to show something like this on screen.
- 6:39Yeah. And it's a good choice because I
- 6:42feel like, you know, now like I looked up you know WWII
- 6:47prisoners of war movies. There's like over 80 of them Bob
- 6:50yeah it's like a massive amount and I think that like prisoner
- 6:55of war movies It's just a it's a feasting ground for interesting
- 7:01character development under high pressure situations paired with
- 7:06lots of deception and like everybody knows the stakes,
- 7:10everybody. It honestly kind of reminds me
- 7:13of when Patrick H Willems talked about baseball movies and how
- 7:19everybody knows the geography and rules of a baseball game.
- 7:24Like, it's almost the same thing, like, as Soon, as you
- 7:27know, it's a prisoner of war movie, you know, the rules, you
- 7:30know that the prisoners are going to try to deceive the
- 7:33guards. They're going to try to escape
- 7:34in some way or, or ruin the guards lives in some way and the
- 7:39drama that plays out from there has an established set of rules
- 7:43and I think that's what makes prisoner of war movies, so
- 7:46attractive. Yeah, I totally agree man and I
- 7:49think that it's time for us to get into talking about this
- 7:52movie in particular again we'll put it in the context of, you
- 7:55know all the other prisoner of war.
- 7:57Movies. But when it comes to Stalag 17,
- 8:00I know for a darn fact that this was your first time seeing it.
- 8:03Brad. Don't try to my first time first
- 8:06I'm hearing of it. Yeah, there you go.
- 8:08I mean, it is, it doesn't really have a title that rolls off the
- 8:11tongue, even though I have to say.
- 8:13Like once you understand from the first two minutes of the
- 8:15movie, what the word Stalag means?
- 8:17Stalag 17 is a pretty badass name for a movie, like it just
- 8:20sounds cool 100%. Yeah, it's a, it's a cool title
- 8:24and it's I think it's an interesting.
- 8:27Addition into the world of Billy Wilder.
- 8:30It feels so much different than his traditional movies that
- 8:34we've watched from him. Yep, that I'm really glad that
- 8:38you picked it as the third movie here.
- 8:40Yeah, I am too. And I was really leaning towards
- 8:42Ace in the Hole for this movie, but it has that that same really
- 8:48mean-spirited cynicism that Sunset Boulevard did.
- 8:52And I think Wilder kind of pressed the reset button on
- 8:54himself a little bit before he made Stalag 17.
- 8:57And we'll see this happen again next week.
- 8:59When we make the turn from this movie into the film that he
- 9:01makes a year later Sabrina. So I'm excited to get kind of
- 9:05the full picture of Wilders versatility as a director and as
- 9:08a writer throughout these three movies, but that means that it
- 9:12is time for America's favorite segments.
- 9:15Brad explains rats gonna give us the movie plots with only 60
- 9:19seconds ticking on the clock. So let's go ahead and do you
- 9:22take with this little segment that we call Brad explains?
- 9:26Yeah. Yes, Brad explains the part of
- 9:28the podcast, where Brad breaks down the movie that he has just
- 9:31seen often for the first time. As we know this was Brad's first
- 9:35time seeing Stalag 17 Brad. You have one minute on the clock
- 9:40to explain the plot of this movie, to our listeners.
- 9:43In the most spoiler, filled fashion possible.
- 9:45And I have to say, we don't always give spoiler warnings
- 9:49beyond what I just said. But this movie hinges on finding
- 9:54out the identity of someone who is under And so if you have even
- 9:58the smallest bit of interest in seeing this movie, I would
- 10:02recommend watching the movie coming back after you finish it
- 10:05to hear our take on it because we're going to spoil the twist
- 10:09right now. Yeah.
- 10:10And I was going to say like this movie is two hours on the dot.
- 10:14It's not too long. Nope.
- 10:15And it's honestly a lot of fun. So I if you likes Bob said, you
- 10:20have any inclination to go, watch it, go watch it, it's free
- 10:23on to be high-definition doopy. So go check it out.
- 10:30All right man you have a minute on the clock and go Stalag 17 is
- 10:35a prisoner of war movie about some American are prisoners in a
- 10:41German prisoner of war camp at the start of the movie.
- 10:44Two Americans are killed while trying to escape from the camp
- 10:48and it helps establish. The fact that in this one
- 10:52Barracks, there is an informant telling the Germans what's going
- 10:55on in the barracks. The first person suspected and
- 11:00the person suspected throughout most of the movie is William.
- 11:02Holden's character Sefton, who is kind of a black market Savant
- 11:08and he's able to wheel and deal his way into being the king of
- 11:13the market. If you will, there are different
- 11:16slapstick. Things that happen with too kind
- 11:19of Side characters animal and capiro thing takes seconds.
- 11:25And it turns out Out. I'm not even going to spoil it.
- 11:28Bob just watch the daggone movie.
- 11:30Yeah, baby. It's not Sefton.
- 11:33There you go. 17. How you figure out, who the
- 11:36informant in the barracks? He is?
- 11:38Yeah. Will he succeed question mark
- 11:41who's to say, who who is to say? All right, so that's the setup
- 11:45for Stalag 17. Brad.
- 11:48We're going to be comparing this movie a lot to The Great Escape.
- 11:50I just know that it's going to happen but it's probably the
- 11:53only other movie that I can really think of.
- 11:55And I say movie because when it comes, To TV.
- 11:58I think something like Hogan's Heroes.
- 12:00Is pretty, pretty much like directly copied from Stalag 17.
- 12:05The, the German prisoner, yes, like the counter bigard.
- 12:10What? Yeah, it's like the same guy.
- 12:12No, nothing. It's the same guy, it's the same
- 12:15character. But in terms of movies, I think
- 12:18that this is obviously most closely related to The Great
- 12:21Escape, especially since in the Great Escape you have these
- 12:25really taught, really The dramatic Escape sequences but
- 12:30you also have them balanced out with like sequences of guys
- 12:33getting really drunk and doing silly things and toying with the
- 12:37Germans, but not getting shot for it.
- 12:39Because the Germans are just like, oh, you.
- 12:41So and so's. And you have that in this movie
- 12:44too, and it's not necessarily believable, but it makes for a
- 12:47really fun movie and even if you don't get it, I don't know how
- 12:51many fun poww movies there are and those are really the only
- 12:54two I can think of as a you don't get Stephen.
- 12:57In riding away on a motorcycle either, you sure don't.
- 13:00And that's the that's that's a point in points in the greatest
- 13:03games. Favor also, anytime we talk
- 13:06about the Great Escape, I will never not mention.
- 13:09It's just got the most catchy theme of any movie of all time.
- 13:16I feel like we are already kind of tipping our hand.
- 13:19A little bit in that, I don't think this movie is quite as
- 13:21good as the Great Escape, but I do think it lays the blueprint
- 13:23and the Prototype. Yeah. 100% does I I think for
- 13:27me, the thing that that captured me very quickly was with this
- 13:32movie was that the opening escape sequence.
- 13:35Oh gosh, is incredible. Really, one of the best parts of
- 13:38the whole movie, honestly? Yes, yeah.
- 13:40The tension is extraordinarily high.
- 13:43Like I said, we already know the stakes that are at hand.
- 13:46We know the geography of the movie.
- 13:49So when Wilder just plops you right into the middle of this
- 13:52escape sequence, you're on the edge of your seat from the very
- 13:56start. Then you never come back down
- 13:58because you keep wondering, like, who is the informant?
- 14:02And I feel like a lot of modern movies are little more
- 14:05predictable about who it might be.
- 14:08This one. Genuinely keeps you guessing?
- 14:10I like I did not guess who it was until it was revealed.
- 14:14Yeah, I think that opening sequence is like a perfect
- 14:17microcosm for the whole movie because the narrator of this
- 14:20movie, is just a guy in the barracks, it's not William
- 14:23Holden. And honestly, his voice kind of
- 14:27Reminds me of in 12, Angry Men, like the little puny squirrel
- 14:32you guy. He reminds me exactly of that
- 14:34guy. I think the the narrator is
- 14:37Cookie, right? His kind of assistant, I think
- 14:40so I'm not entirely sure like and I think he says who he is
- 14:43right at the start but I can't remember for the life of me
- 14:46right now but all that to say he does not have the most like you
- 14:50know, seductive audio voice. Yeah, just sounds.
- 14:54And then we went to the prisoner of war camp.
- 14:57It seemed like the whole movies. It's like your seven-year-old,
- 15:00trying to tell a story. Yeah, pretty much actually.
- 15:05But I guess what I'm trying to say is, I think it's a great
- 15:07microcosm for the movie because you get plopped into this guy is
- 15:11setting up the world of the p.o.w. camp and so it feels kind
- 15:15of like it's going to be a comedy and a little bit slap
- 15:18sticky. And oh you know it's not it's
- 15:20not so easy for us but we get by and then all of a sudden you get
- 15:24plopped into the barracks and it's like we are mid.
- 15:27Escape plan right now and it is very tense and very taut.
- 15:32And those two guys make it out of the perimeter, of the camp,
- 15:37but the Germans are there waiting for them.
- 15:40And I think the brutality of their murder and and how quick
- 15:45and how cold and how clinical it is is like I wasn't expecting
- 15:50that for movie that came out in 53 and you know the you see
- 15:54these guys pop up out of their hole and I'm like okay cool.
- 15:56We made it in Camera pans over and you see the Germans there
- 15:59and you register like oh man, they're going to get caught and
- 16:01then boom, like they're getting machine gun to death and it is
- 16:05like also the fact that the Germans didn't just wait outside
- 16:09the hole with like you know, a rifle or something guns, they
- 16:14set up an entire machine gun nests and there's like a guy
- 16:17feeding the bullets in it. Like, it looks like it looks
- 16:19like the D-Day set up from Saving Private Ryan.
- 16:23Exactly. Like, for these two, dudes
- 16:25popping out of a hole with real-world No weapons there
- 16:28gunshot with like any aircraft ammunition.
- 16:32All right, so anyway, I guess what I'm saying here is, I love
- 16:35the way the movie starts because it also achieves the balance
- 16:39that I think this movie achieves of, finding the the comedy and
- 16:43the lighter moments. But then knowing when to like,
- 16:45cut it out and just get really serious about things.
- 16:48Mmm. Yeah, I think that Wilder
- 16:51strikes a perfect balance throughout the film and I kind
- 16:55of want to talk about some of the Vince's, because the only
- 16:59place I think the balance is lacking is in the fact that
- 17:03certain characters are always serious and certain characters
- 17:07are always fun. Yep, yep.
- 17:10And I don't know if that's something you struggled with.
- 17:13It's something that. Like, I didn't mind a ton but it
- 17:15definitely felt a little bit dissonant like, you know, like
- 17:19two keys playing off tone from each other.
- 17:21Yes. And it felt like in the world of
- 17:24the movie, even when things get very serious Yes those comedic
- 17:28performers are still stuck in whatever World they've created
- 17:31for themselves where they're still being comedic.
- 17:34Yeah for like you know I just don't buy them as serious now
- 17:38because you've had them be comedic in 90% of every other
- 17:40scenario in this movie. So yeah, I totally agree, man.
- 17:44But if we're talking performances, we have to start
- 17:46at the top with William Holden. This is the movie that wins.
- 17:49William Holden the best actor, Oscar, he thinks when he wins
- 17:53it, that it almost a was undeserved, but Thought that
- 17:57somebody from the movie, From Here, to Eternity, should have
- 17:59won it instead of him and he thought it was a makeup from him
- 18:03not winning in 1950 from Sunset Boulevard.
- 18:06And I think the place to start when it comes to talking about
- 18:09Holden, is to compare this character and the roll directly
- 18:14to Sunset Boulevard. Last week, I said that one of
- 18:18the things I didn't like about the character of Joe Gillis is
- 18:20that he is a piece of shit, but also that he doesn't have the
- 18:24sort of self-deprecating, you know.
- 18:27No, I'm an ask but I'm kind of charming about it that I think a
- 18:30character, you know, somebody like a Clooney could have
- 18:32brought to that role. He has that here and it's
- 18:35hilarious because even in the first ten minutes of the movie,
- 18:38he's doing that kind of Rye little grin and he's saying like
- 18:42these horrible things and everyone hates him and he's just
- 18:44like I don't care like I'm gonna let it roll off my back and I'm
- 18:47like man if only Wilder had let Holden bring this energy into
- 18:52Sunset Boulevard, I think it would have been proved that
- 18:54character and it works perfectly here.
- 18:57Yeah, I think what makes it work here.
- 18:59Bob is the fact that in our subconscious we know that
- 19:05Holden's character in Sunset Boulevard has a choice about
- 19:10being at that Mansion like they can play it up all they want
- 19:13that he's stuck there but he could leave at any time.
- 19:17He could pick up and go back to Dayton which he tries to do at
- 19:20the end of the film and he could leave whenever he wanted to.
- 19:25Whereas in a prisoner ER of War Camp you know that he doesn't
- 19:30have a choice like he is stuck there.
- 19:32And yeah he could try to help escape and all that.
- 19:35But you know, it's more understandable of him trying to
- 19:38make the best of a really crappy situation than it is in Sunset
- 19:42Boulevard and I think that just makes him a little more
- 19:44sympathetic as a figure. The funny thing ultimately I
- 19:48guess the irony is as much as I hate the character of Joe
- 19:52Gillis. I think that he is a complex
- 19:54enough figure that I See William Holden winning an Oscar for that
- 19:59movie and it being justified, whereas this character Sefton
- 20:03he's barely in the movie until the last 15 minutes.
- 20:07Like he's in and out a little bit but it's not until you hit.
- 20:10Like I don't know the one hour mark that the narrator's like oh
- 20:14yeah I should tell you a little bit more about this guy Sefton
- 20:18and you forget that he's supposed to be the star of the
- 20:21movie and he really does take over in the last 20 minutes of
- 20:25the movie, and it has this great kind of Monologue towards the
- 20:28end. But even as I found out that he
- 20:31wins the Oscar, for this movie, I'm like, is this a leading man
- 20:34performance? Like, I guess it's, the lead
- 20:37performance of the movie, but this feels so much more like an
- 20:40ensemble picture than one that has even a central figure in it.
- 20:45Yeah, I'm with you 100% knowing that he won the Oscar and this
- 20:51It almost felt like watching Last of the Mohicans for me,
- 20:54where I thought that Daniel Day Lewis won the Oscar for that
- 20:57performance. And so, I was like waiting for
- 21:00him to be awesome and I never felt like he was, whereas in
- 21:04this one I was like, oh, I know that he want to perform one it
- 21:07for this performance and so I kind of was just like once again
- 21:12waiting for him to be awesome and was like, oh, like he's
- 21:15good, it's a solid, B b-plus character and performance.
- 21:20I just don't know if it's anything that deserves an Oscar.
- 21:23Yeah. Like honestly, if anything,
- 21:26Richard Erdman of the television show Community Fame.
- 21:32He, I thought he was incredible as hafidh sergeant Hoffman.
- 21:37Hmm, I really liked his performance.
- 21:40He had a a sincerity and earnestness about him.
- 21:44That felt just really Charming. Yeah.
- 21:46There's a couple people in this Ensemble that I thought really
- 21:49stood out to there's a guy named Neville brand.
- 21:51His character's name is Duke. He's the guy with the beard that
- 21:54is like, mama always suspicious of William Holden, aye.
- 21:57Yeah. It was excellent in that role
- 21:59because he doesn't really do much except for beat suspicious
- 22:02the whole movie, but he plays it really, really well.
- 22:06There is one other person from this movie, that gets nominated
- 22:08for an Oscar for best supporting actor.
- 22:10And that is Robert Strauss, who plays animal.
- 22:13Now, we've talked about him a little bit to this point, but
- 22:15animal is for the most part, the comic relief of the movie and I
- 22:20want to pinpoint One Moment In the movie that I wish Wilder had
- 22:24milked just a little more and it's toward the end of the
- 22:27movie. And they're having this kind of,
- 22:30I don't know. Dance party in their barracks
- 22:32and half. The guys are dressed up as women
- 22:35or are playing the women in, you know, their dance Pairs and
- 22:39animal has been in love with Betty, Grable the whole movie
- 22:42and he sees one of his one of his fellow soldiers, dressed up
- 22:46like a woman and is convinced in his kind of delirium that it is
- 22:50Betty Grable Able and he starts dancing with her and then it
- 22:53turns out to be by delirium, you mean drunken stupor?
- 22:56You know? Yeah, it turns out to be Shapiro
- 23:00who reveals himself and says hey man I'm it's me your buddy and
- 23:04there's this really kind of sad and touching moment where you
- 23:06realize like he's heartbroken it's not it's not played for
- 23:10Laughs, he's like legitimately crushed and you feel for him.
- 23:16And the problem that I have with that moment is that I think
- 23:18Wilder in some of his later It's like the apartment, he can find
- 23:23the tragedy in the comedy a little bit better and I think in
- 23:26this movie, it's still trying to be played for a laugh when it is
- 23:31actually kind of crushing. And I wish that he had just
- 23:34leaned into that the tragedy of that moment just a little bit
- 23:37more. I think that's kind of again for
- 23:39me, that's like emblematic of the whole movie where it works,
- 23:44but I think it could have worked just a little bit better.
- 23:47Yeah, and maybe a slightly more mature way.
- 23:50Wilder could pull that off. I do think that Shapiro and the
- 23:55animal are a really fun Duo that that kind of keep the movie
- 24:01driving forward, as I was watching.
- 24:04You said his name was Richard Strauss, Robert stress, Robert
- 24:07Strauss playing playing the animal.
- 24:10He reminded me of a mixture of, like, Brad Garrett from
- 24:15Everybody, Loves Raymond, and John Belushi.
- 24:19Oh nice. Yeah.
- 24:20Just have like the sort of what's the the kind waves?
- 24:23I get the slaven leanness of. Yes, but Belushi, but he has the
- 24:29voice and the gate and the sort of like, hunched over.
- 24:33I don't know awkwardness of Brad, got ya?
- 24:35Yes! 100% And I so for me like the
- 24:39mixture of those two actors for me, just 100% worked.
- 24:44I thought he was incredibly funny and his his relationship
- 24:49with Harry. His friend that he mistakes to
- 24:51be Betty Grable at one point is honestly, like really sweet and
- 24:55touching. And, and the, the few moments
- 24:58where I believe in that the most is when things are looking dark
- 25:04for the barracks and for the troops and they're still kind of
- 25:07doing their slapstick thing, I think there are moments where
- 25:10I'm like, you know, I don't know if I would do any different if I
- 25:13was in a prison of War Camp. Yeah, it brings a level of
- 25:17humanity to the situation that I think is helpful.
- 25:21A few more people to mention before we go to break, Peter
- 25:23Graves who becomes a really, I was a super popular character
- 25:27actor, but if you've ever seen the movie Airplane, he plays the
- 25:30pilot in Airplane, super funny role.
- 25:32He has perhaps the most interesting role in the movie
- 25:35playing price and I think Brad is probably time to spoil
- 25:40everything here at this point. Yeah, it is price, is the
- 25:43informants and he is a German who apparently lived in
- 25:47Cleveland for a while, dude. I was so, So, pumped, they talk
- 25:51about something that's not see, what are you talking about?
- 25:55I mean, we lived in my town, her Ray, I do.
- 26:00I do, remember when I was in high school they found not just
- 26:05in like Cleveland, but in Seven Hills, my tiny little itsy-bitsy
- 26:11suburb right off of Cleveland. Was this the the John demjanjuk
- 26:15guy? Yeah, they found this Nazi
- 26:18prisoner prisoner of war. A while.
- 26:21Yeah. Concentration camp guard.
- 26:23Yeah, just like 90 years old. Living in Seven Hills Ohio.
- 26:27Yeah, I'm telling you they did a Netflix documentary about him a
- 26:30couple years ago was like a four part series of how they finally
- 26:34figured it out about him and how they finally got things to stick
- 26:37in his trial. Super interesting, that is a
- 26:40complete aside. Peter Graves really good in this
- 26:43movie, I was just excited that they talked about Cleveland,
- 26:47Ohio, and Cincinnati, a specific.
- 26:49I come on, come on. On baby.
- 26:51Let's go. Hi.
- 26:52Oh, I just even when it's not even like a badge of honor,
- 26:54you're excited about hearing Ohio pop up in a movie.
- 26:59How often do you hear Ohio? Pop up in the movie but just
- 27:01last week, Joe Gillis Dayton Ohio.
- 27:04Dad's that's true. Dayton Ohio, has maybe, maybe
- 27:06Billy has like some some connection.
- 27:09He's got a soft spot. Yeah, yeah.
- 27:11The last person I want to talk about is Otto preminger.
- 27:14Now, if you know your film history, Otto preminger is
- 27:18primarily known as a director and I Almost brought him up last
- 27:22week Brad, but we were running a little bit long.
- 27:24Otto. Preminger is a director who was
- 27:27known for really pushing the boundaries within the confines
- 27:31of Studio movies. So he, some of his most famous
- 27:35movies would be like Anatomy of a Murder with James Stewart, so
- 27:39fantastically. Yeah.
- 27:41But his movies were always pretty long and they were always
- 27:44like, really, I don't want to say salacious, they were well
- 27:47made and they weren't smutty, but they were always pushing.
- 27:50The envelope in terms of like violence on screen or subject
- 27:53matter on screen. 1940s smutty, I guess so.
- 27:59Yeah, 50s and 60s to, but your toddy in 2023.
- 28:03I guess what I'm saying is it wasn't like he was pushing the
- 28:05boundaries by making like you know erotic Thrillers or like
- 28:09and he was just trying to get subject matter on screen that
- 28:12wasn't discussed really taboo topics on screen.
- 28:15And last you saying that? He's like the German Hitchcock
- 28:17then I may be in some capacities.
- 28:20So, I mean, he makes a movie adaptation of the the Opera
- 28:23Porgy and Bess, which is an all-black cast that at a time,
- 28:26that that wasn't being done. He made a movie in the mid-50s
- 28:29with Frank Sinatra called The Man, with the Golden Arm, which
- 28:32is about heroin addiction. Like, it's just stuff that
- 28:34wasn't wasn't on screen at the time and lasted.
- 28:38That's a title for a movie, man. Writes, holy cow last week, you
- 28:42kept mentioning Billy Wilder as someone who kind of pushed the
- 28:45envelope or really wanted to push back against cultural norms
- 28:49and I almost brought It up Otto. Preminger.
- 28:52Not realizing that he was going to pop up in this movie as an
- 28:54actor. So once again, Wilder is working
- 28:57with collaborators that he really respects.
- 29:00You know, last week, it's Erich von stroheim playing a character
- 29:04in his movie and Cecil B Demille this week.
- 29:06It's Otto preminger. Yeah, and preminger was as a
- 29:12director. He said that the only thing he
- 29:14would yell at his actors for was showing up late or forgetting a
- 29:18line and apparently he told Billy Wilder.
- 29:21Hey, if I forget any lines in this, I'll send you a bottle of
- 29:25cough of caviar and apparently Billy had quite a few potholes
- 29:31and Kathy are by the end of the film.
- 29:35That's funny. I think caviar comes in tins
- 29:37instead of bottles but that's good.
- 29:39Probably yeah. I just thought about drinkable
- 29:41caviar and I was like, oh gosh, that's that's horrible.
- 29:45Have you ever had caviar Bob? I never have.
- 29:48I never heard nor have I It's not something I'm interested in.
- 29:53I would be interested in it, if it was like really high quality,
- 29:55like I've seen it like fresh caviar.
- 29:57I'm like, I would eat that but it's like, yeah, this is baby in
- 30:00my pantry for six years. Let's try this hill and of
- 30:04caviar. Oh, thank you.
- 30:05It's right next to the sun kiss. Well, speaking of super fancy
- 30:09things that we keep in our pantries.
- 30:11Brad. It's time for us to get into
- 30:13drinking the whiskey of the day. It is the last in the line up of
- 30:18five benchmarks that we have done and it's called Benchmark
- 30:21foolproof. What do you say?
- 30:23We try it. Let's get to a bob to our are
- 30:25very fancy with sweet. All right, everybody.
- 30:35Today we are drinking the final in our Benchmark series
- 30:40Benchmark, foolproof. You haven't even seen my final
- 30:43form yet brand? Yeah.
- 30:45Bob, I didn't think he knew Anna Mae.
- 30:47There you go. Then, I'm full of surprises.
- 30:50Good job. I'm proud of you.
- 30:52Just like this. Whiskey is full of proof.
- 30:54Am I right? It's all the proofs.
- 30:57So, yeah, if you've been paying attention to our podcast, we
- 30:59have tried five consecutive Benchmark branded products to
- 31:04start this season, Buffalo Trace wanted to expand its most
- 31:08valuable not valuable that lets the word for like value wish
- 31:14line as well. Yeah, there is a little box, its
- 31:18cheapest line of whiskey Benchmark and it did so, by
- 31:22adding a whole bunch of fancy words after the word Benchmark,
- 31:25we started with the 86 proof, top floor, and then we switch to
- 31:29the 90 Proof small batch there. Was a 95 proof, I think single
- 31:35barrel and then Benchmark bonded last week at 100 proof.
- 31:39And after that, they said screw it, like, we're not going to
- 31:41keep going up. So incrementally, we're going to
- 31:43take this all the way up to 125 proof, turned it up to 11 if you
- 31:49will, Brad, I don't know the exact price point on this.
- 31:52That's usually something that you bring to the table research
- 31:55wise, but I don't Saul the research getting out of even.
- 32:00I don't know if there is a whiskey.
- 32:02E on the market. That is so high.
- 32:05In proof for what I assume to be, so little in price as I say,
- 32:10it costs over $100 less than its proof point there.
- 32:15There you go. I was going to say, like old
- 32:17Granddad 114 is a, you know, 11 proof points lower than this.
- 32:22And also, I think retails for at least thirty dollars now.
- 32:25So I mean, you know, unless you're buying Everclear, I don't
- 32:28know if you can get anything. This High proof for like 25
- 32:31bucks. Yeah, yeah.
- 32:33I was going to say this is a, I'll spoil the value right now.
- 32:38It's a really solid value. Bob, this is the second most
- 32:42expensive of The Benchmark lineup at $23 in the state of
- 32:46Ohio. Okay.
- 32:47But I like how this is still cheaper than the Single Barrel.
- 32:52Yes, that's crazy to me. Hmm.
- 32:54I mean, you know, Bob it takes a lot of time and effort to pick
- 32:57out one crappy barrel with someone barrel and then water it
- 33:01down to 90 bucks. Oof.
- 33:02Yeah, about 25 dollars worth of effort.
- 33:07Okay, so on The Benchmark foolproof front, we are looking
- 33:10at, like I said, a 125 proof bourbon whiskey that has been
- 33:14aged for at least four years. It does not have an age
- 33:17statement on the bottle, which means it's a blend of a whole
- 33:19bunch of different ages of whiskey.
- 33:21But that also means that the minimum, the youngest whiskey in
- 33:24this blend is at least 4 years old.
- 33:26Buffalo Trace, does not disclose the mash bill, but some some
- 33:30pretty smart people online. Have pretty much figured out.
- 33:32What the mash bill of this is, if you'd like, to go look it up
- 33:34for yourself. I'm excited to dive into this,
- 33:37man. I think, overall, this has been
- 33:38a pretty great experience going through these cheap whiskeys.
- 33:42Yeah, I will say, I think if I had to guess I think that
- 33:47Buffalo Trace, new of my hatred for its high-end lineups and
- 33:52they were like, well, we got to appease Brad somehow.
- 33:55Yeah. So we're going to put out this
- 33:57fought line up of five cheap Whiskey's and I'll be honest
- 34:01with you. Bob for Out of five are really
- 34:04solid great values. Ones that I think that indicates
- 34:08that you've already tried this before.
- 34:09I'm sipping it live as we discuss it.
- 34:12So why don't you go ahead and give your nosing notes Brad?
- 34:14So I can write mine down as well.
- 34:18Yeah. So I'm getting like everything
- 34:21classic that you want out of a bourbon.
- 34:24There is caramel there's brown sugar.
- 34:26There's vanilla for me, it gets into a little bit of spiciness,
- 34:30some cinnamon, maybe a little Like nutmeg almost kind of good
- 34:34takes a Christmassy turn at the end.
- 34:36Yep but I there is nothing to complain about here.
- 34:40It's not an overly complex knows, but it's the the proof
- 34:44points. Give it a little bit of depth
- 34:46that the other ones were missing out on.
- 34:48So I give it a 7 & a half. I really love how crisp this one
- 34:52is. Like, it just reminds me of,
- 34:54like, apple peels, but also kind of like, you know, we just had a
- 34:57nice little rain storm blow through here as I'm recording
- 35:00this. And I went outside and I smelled
- 35:01that like, After the rain smell it has that really great like
- 35:04almost rainwater kind of smell to it.
- 35:06It's really, really beautiful. I think this might be just go
- 35:09ahead. Is it just me or did like, do
- 35:13you no longer enjoy things, just to enjoy them, but you
- 35:16immediately are like, hmm. This is going in the old whiskey
- 35:20palette log every time I smell a smell, you know?
- 35:25Yes yeah, toddler diaper. I'm like all right I'm going to
- 35:28log that one in the back of my head.
- 35:30Exactly. So yeah, I think this might be
- 35:33my favorite nose out of all five of them and it's not surprising
- 35:36because this hasn't been diluted at all.
- 35:38And so we're really getting, you know, exactly or close to what's
- 35:41coming out of the barrel here. I like it a lot.
- 35:43I'm gonna give it an eight and a half on the nose.
- 35:45Yeah, a baba. And I'm with you, this is
- 35:48probably the best smelling of the five, and when you get into
- 35:52the palette, you can tell that there is some flavor going on
- 35:55here. Once again, this is not a
- 35:57complex whiskey. Like it's all of the nice,
- 36:01beautiful. Awful things.
- 36:02You love about bourbon. It's brown sugar caramel like I
- 36:06said some spiciness there, I don't know if I've ever had a
- 36:09pallet that so perfectly mimics the nose, but all the notes I
- 36:15gave before are still here but their enhanced a little bit
- 36:18because I'm actually drinking the whiskey.
- 36:20I give it an 8 and a half out of ten on The Taste.
- 36:22Yeah, this I think this really will appeal to fans of Buffalo
- 36:26Trace because it has that So bitter.
- 36:29It's almost sour. Oh keynote to it but I think
- 36:32here it's almost like it doesn't come across as a flaw and it
- 36:36doesn't come across as something.
- 36:37That's from a lesser brand? Do you know what I mean?
- 36:40Like I think before we've been like okay maybe they're just
- 36:43putting that in the Benchmark line because it's lower quality
- 36:46here. I think it's just like hey this
- 36:47is what Oak tastes like you know.
- 36:49Yeah but what I really love about it is on the pallet for me
- 36:53it was like two very quick rapid-fire waves of heat coming
- 36:57from the front of my To the back.
- 36:59And then it just like repeated that process again really,
- 37:02really spicy. Like the ethanol notes really
- 37:05come out in. Her, are prickly on the palate,
- 37:07like you said, man, not super complex.
- 37:10It's for me, it's brown sugar and it's vanilla, and it's
- 37:14really, really tasty. It's kind of thin on the
- 37:17mouthfeel. I think because it is so high
- 37:19proof, so it kind of manifest as a little bit thin, but not as
- 37:23stringent, and I really, really like that.
- 37:25I'm going to give it. See, here's the hard thing.
- 37:28I'm scoring it knowing that it's $23.
- 37:30Like, is this an actual 88 and a half out of ten?
- 37:34Well, Dallas, give it. Give it an actual score.
- 37:37I think I'll give it a seven and a half palette.
- 37:40If I'm talking like every whiskey ever considered this is
- 37:44like a three out of four star. I'll give it a seven and a half.
- 37:47Yeah I think that's fair for me. The finishes were all ding it a
- 37:52little bit because it does take on that, traditional Buffalo
- 37:56Trace okita, Guinness and adjusts hours a little bit for
- 38:01me, I'll give it a six and a half out of ten on the Finish.
- 38:03It's not bad but you can tell that it is a cheaper Whiskey on
- 38:08the Finish. Yeah I think I'm just gonna pair
- 38:11it. You here man six and a half for
- 38:12all the reasons you just said yeah and that takes us to
- 38:16balance. This is where we consider knows
- 38:18taste and finish kind of as one cohesive whole.
- 38:22Was there, a part of this drinking experience that stood
- 38:25out from the others for good, or for bad or did it?
- 38:28Kind of make sense, all throughout.
- 38:31I think, for the most part Brad, this is exactly what I expected
- 38:34a 125 proof. Benchmark product tastes like,
- 38:38it's just significantly better than most Benchmark products,
- 38:41but it still carries all those same flavors throughout.
- 38:44So I think, I guess I'll give it a seven and a half like it's
- 38:48above average. It's not a perfect, obviously
- 38:50whiskey, but it's pretty darn consistent, and it's what I
- 38:53expected. It's me.
- 38:55Yeah, I'm in literally the exact same spot Bob.
- 38:58You parotid me earlier, I will pair it.
- 39:00You here seven and a half on the balance and I'm just going to
- 39:04say this, let's keep this short and sweet today, man.
- 39:06This is a 10/10 value. I don't really know that there's
- 39:09like any debating this even though it's not our favorite
- 39:11whiskey. Even though I probably
- 39:14shockingly, might still go for the top floor before I would go
- 39:18for this one, if we're talking like ranking, 1 through 5 in
- 39:21these. Yeah, there is no better value
- 39:24out there for a high-proof whiskey, and it's a palatable
- 39:27high-proof whiskey. It's not Just like hey my rum
- 39:30and coke needs extra alcohol in it.
- 39:32It tastes good. Yeah.
- 39:34No 100%. This is a 10 out of 10 on value
- 39:37out of all the things I could say nice about Buffalo Trace.
- 39:40They are knocking it out of the park on these cheap Benchmark,
- 39:44Whiskey's that genuinely, I think almost every single one of
- 39:48them could retail for ten dollars higher and I would still
- 39:52be like, oh yeah, so, you know, seven out of ten value.
- 39:55Like that's like it could be a little cheaper, but it's a good
- 39:57price too. The agree, man.
- 39:59Real quick. Before we get final scores on
- 40:01this one. Let's kind of power rank the
- 40:04five that we did. Mmm, for me, I think, you know,
- 40:08I don't even know if I need to go one and two, but like, the
- 40:09upper tier for me, is top floor and this and then the small
- 40:15batch and then in the bottom, tier would be the single barrel
- 40:20and the bond it. Yeah, I think for me I would go
- 40:25small batch and foolproof I'm kind of tied at the top, I
- 40:30really like those and then right behind that the bonded and the
- 40:35top floor and kind of their second category.
- 40:38And then the Single Barrel kind of Fallen pretty far behind.
- 40:42Yeah, for sure. I think, like you said, four out
- 40:44of the five everything except the Single Barrel was a
- 40:47no-brainer recommendation from us in terms of like, you know, I
- 40:51think last week I even said with the bonded, like I wouldn't
- 40:53recommend trying this at the bar, but they're all worth a
- 40:57pickup except for that sing. Carol.
- 40:58So yeah. And especially like, if you have
- 41:01a buddy who enjoys drinking whiskey like go put ten to
- 41:04twelve dollars each in and and buy a bottle of it and then you
- 41:08each have, you know, 350, 375 to drink.
- 41:12Exactly. Like, it's the easiest purchase
- 41:14you'll make. Okay, man, I'm coming out to a
- 41:1740 out of 50 on this whiskey. What are you coming out to Bob?
- 41:20I'm at a 40 out of 50. Hey, so we have our first 40 of
- 41:25the Season which is usually pretty I dare this one,
- 41:29obviously was helped out by its value score, but even if you
- 41:33don't consider that, it's such an incredible value and just
- 41:36take that part of the equation out.
- 41:38We came out to essentially a 30 out of 40 on the tasting notes,
- 41:43which is like a well, above average experience, this is not
- 41:46just a budget bourbon, it's a budget bourbon.
- 41:49That takes pretty good. Yeah, 100% Bob and it, I think
- 41:54we paired it with just about the right movie.
- 41:56I think so too. Have a Gidget yet really solid
- 42:00movie. So let's get back into it.
- 42:02Let's do it. All right, everybody, that was
- 42:07Benchmark foolproof. A 125 proof, whiskey that only
- 42:12cost $23. And that alone should get you to
- 42:16go try it. I mean, you might as well but
- 42:19leaving that to the side. We are going to jump back into
- 42:22the episode and go to Canada's. Absolute favorite segments to
- 42:28fax at a falsehood? Is gonna try to stop you by.
- 42:34All right? And what is wrong to facts in a
- 42:39foster, to facts in a falsehood is the part of the podcast where
- 42:42Brad presents three items to me, as fact about the making of this
- 42:46movie, one of which he has completely made up and it's my
- 42:50job to establish, which one is the falsehood Brad.
- 42:54I am a whopping 2 and 2 on the season, so far sitting pretty at
- 42:59500. If this was baseball, I'd be in
- 43:01good position. Yeah.
- 43:02You'd probably be like, s in your division.
- 43:05Doing pretty solid. So we'll see if I can keep the
- 43:08streak alive here. I won last week to bring myself
- 43:11back up to 500. I'm gonna be real with you man.
- 43:14I did a lot of research on Sunset Boulevard to prepare for
- 43:17that episode because it's such a major movie.
- 43:20I do did 08 Messer, nothing about this movie.
- 43:24The funny thing is, you know, before you give me your two
- 43:26facts in a falsehood. Let me just say, for being a
- 43:28movie that I feel like a lot of dads will have seen at some
- 43:33point. There's not a It online about
- 43:36this movie. And I have this stack of Billy
- 43:38Wilder books behind me. Like they talk about Stalag 17
- 43:40but it just doesn't seem like anyone is super interested in
- 43:44learning that much about the production of this movie.
- 43:47Even the Wikipedia page doesn't even go in depth to the extent
- 43:50that I thought that it would. So, yeah, man, I'm coming into
- 43:53this one, pretty cold. You are in Prime position here
- 43:57to get a victory this week, hit me with your two facts and a
- 44:01falsehood. Alright fact, number one, the
- 44:04dog tags that. Can see around the necks of some
- 44:07of the prisoners are authentic. They are not actually pair of
- 44:11us, dog tags. But instead are a single dog tag
- 44:15with two slots that lets them be broken in.
- 44:17Half in the event, the soldier is killed and this is actually a
- 44:21German set of dog tags. Hmm, fact.
- 44:25Number two, William, Holden's line.
- 44:27This ain't the Salvation Army. This is everybody for himself.
- 44:30Dog-eat-dog was originally written as this.
- 44:34Ain't the YMCA. We're not all bunk buddies here.
- 44:39Nice. I didn't expect that.
- 44:41I hope you didn't make that one up because you're going to legit
- 44:43get us canceled with that one. All right.
- 44:49All right, fact, what were three warrants or Tome an extra in the
- 44:52film was an actual prisoner of war in Germany.
- 44:56He relates that they're around, nine other pows that served as
- 44:59extras in the film, he himself was flying in a B-24.
- 45:03That was shot down over Northeastern Germany during the
- 45:06war. Hmm.
- 45:07All right, Brad, I'm gonna assume that you didn't make up
- 45:10number two because if you did we have some problematic things to
- 45:13discuss after that one. Number one is, Really
- 45:19interesting and I think just because I hope it's true, I'm
- 45:24going to say number three is the falsehood number two.
- 45:30It's Brad did you can't do that, okay, I've 100% did not think of
- 45:37it as a gauge show, how to do this, I mean, one of the most
- 45:42iconic gay songs of all time is about going to the YMCA.
- 45:47Wait, that's a socket. Okay, people are you ever heard
- 45:51of the Village People? Yeah.
- 45:53They're all gay. It's didn't know that.
- 45:57You didn't know that the village.
- 45:59I've never seen a picture of the Village People.
- 46:01Yes. I see the yakked in history,
- 46:03dude. Well, filming whiskey Nation,
- 46:11let it be known, Brad made up a number two without knowing his
- 46:16LGBT history and intended intended, no offense with that
- 46:20one you know what that her purse.
- 46:22My gosh. How do we steer out of that one
- 46:29man? I think that's it dude this was
- 46:33our final final scores and I'm gonna go hide in a bunker Right.
- 46:39Okay, let's talk about Stalag 17.
- 46:43Brad. What do you want to talk about?
- 46:47Let's talk about some of the slapstick.
- 46:49Comedy. What what was your funniest gag
- 46:52from from animal and Shapiro? Hmm.
- 46:57I mean, I think it's got to be the painting, a line on the
- 47:00ground gag to get over to the women's showers to try to see in
- 47:03there. That was hilarious.
- 47:04Like not just slapstick that felt like a, a cartoon like an
- 47:09actual like Wiley Coyote Roadrunner cartoon, like Thing
- 47:15about it was this could be a Three Stooges skit.
- 47:19Yes, it's perfect. It was yeah, it was hilarious.
- 47:23Also, why are there Russian women just hanging out at a
- 47:28prisoner of war camp in their own little compound?
- 47:31I mean, they're also prisoners, it's not like they're just
- 47:34shacking up there. Yeah.
- 47:36But it just seemed weird to me. I was like, maybe I just don't
- 47:39know my World War Two history enough, but when they conquered,
- 47:44you know, Territories. I thought they just kind of let
- 47:47the women and children keep living in the area.
- 47:50They didn't put him in the prisoner camps, I don't know, I
- 47:53don't know. I can I also think that maybe
- 47:56I'm being a little bit swayed by The Great Escape and The Bridge
- 48:00on the River Kwai. But I was thinking in the
- 48:02opening narration, they say that everybody in that p.o.w. camp is
- 48:06at least a sergeant, right? So like they may not all be
- 48:09officers, but it's essentially an officer's camp and yeah, so I
- 48:13don't know why that they weave they would Even have a women's
- 48:16section of that camp, but you know, who knows?
- 48:19Maybe the Nazis were just trying to be efficient and save space.
- 48:21Yeah, that's if there's anything.
- 48:25The Nazis are known for the efficiency.
- 48:30Yeah, it's just Bob, did you know that this is the episode?
- 48:34That's just going to end the podcast?
- 48:36Yeah, it's just destroy whiskey, but why?
- 48:43I will say, I really enjoyed this movie.
- 48:45The, I think we kind of have talked about the slapstick side
- 48:49of it. How did the tension work for
- 48:52you? Like what did you think about
- 48:54his the the way he used shots to establish tension and drama and
- 49:02the gimmick of the light being pulled to show, you know, when
- 49:06things are going on? How did that half of the movie
- 49:09work for you? It works great for me.
- 49:11I think the thing that didn't work about it is that it's not
- 49:14half the movie. And the slapstick stuff.
- 49:17Not only goes on too long as a percentage of the movie.
- 49:21But I think each and every slapstick gag goes on for about
- 49:24like a minute too long. Just in general, I really wish
- 49:28that he had trimmed those up and I when I look at the runtime of
- 49:32this movie, like you said, it's not super long but I did find
- 49:34myself getting pretty bored in stretches.
- 49:36I think because it wasn't like slapstick, tension, slapstick
- 49:42tension. It was like, yeah, slapstick.
- 49:45Filler slapstick filler tension, filler slapstick slapstick and
- 49:50then he didn't get to the tension Parts until way late in
- 49:53the movie. And between the combo of like it
- 49:56just has too much fat on it. And also they try to Milk The
- 50:00Comedy past the point where it's funny in some places, it really
- 50:05left. Me wanting more.
- 50:06And I think the final reveal of who the mole is, is done really
- 50:10well, but I almost wish that it had been like a It almost like a
- 50:16like a courtroom type set piece where it's June monologue, after
- 50:19monologue of, you know, accusing and finding evidence.
- 50:23And it's not it's like a 3-minute like, hey, he did this
- 50:27thing. Here's this light and everyone's
- 50:28like aah. He's the Nazi.
- 50:30And that's the end of the movie and I was like, man, you really
- 50:33built it up well, and it feels like an anticlimax now.
- 50:36Yeah, that was my biggest complaint of the movie is that
- 50:41they build up. Not not just the climax but they
- 50:44built. it up as like Sefton has this impenetrable wall that he
- 50:50has to, you know, blow his way through to convince everyone
- 50:54that he's not the mole and then he just does it in two minutes
- 50:59like and that for me was the biggest Miss of the movie
- 51:04because of like you said, they set it up so incredibly, well
- 51:08that you don't know who the Spy is, and it genuinely could be
- 51:13anyone but Seth Didn't, you know, he has that great line
- 51:16where he says the only people who know, it's not me Army and
- 51:21the guy who did it right? And that line like is the
- 51:25epitome of the problem facing him.
- 51:28And it just feels like too easy of an out to just be like yep,
- 51:32here's the explanation. Alright now let's figure it all
- 51:35out and we'll be done with it. One thing that I wish I had paid
- 51:38more attention to is. Does the audience definitively
- 51:43know that it's not him? Like because I feel like right
- 51:46up until the point where Wilder reveals to the audience who it
- 51:50is. And then you find out that
- 51:52Sefton is also kind of he has a good idea because he's like in
- 51:56the room when it's happening, I don't know that we ever actually
- 52:00see any evidence that would exonerate him.
- 52:03It's not like yeah, we saw him outside the barracks then when
- 52:06we come back in we can tell that something had happened in there.
- 52:09I think. Oh you know what?
- 52:11In you know, what would have made this a new our movie?
- 52:14Hmm. If he was the Spy, well that's
- 52:17what I'm saying. Like yeah, that would have taken
- 52:19it right back in the classic, Billy Wilder territory, right?
- 52:23And I feel like for such a long time, Wilder is toying with the
- 52:26audience of like, is he the mole, is he not the mole and
- 52:29then he reveals who the mole is, and it becomes a completely
- 52:31different thing where you're on Sefton side now and you're
- 52:34wanting him to find the evidence to exonerate himself and I wish
- 52:39that it had just built into a to be frank like an Aaron Sorkin,
- 52:43e, Few, Good, Men type ending and it doesn't do that.
- 52:48And for, they're all of the Fantastic dialogue and
- 52:51one-liners in this movie. I really wanted some sort of
- 52:54verbal fireworks at the end of this film that I just didn't
- 52:57get. Yeah man, disappointing Movie 2
- 53:02out of 10 worthless. Well before we jump into final
- 53:06scores, Brad it is time for our final segment of the day that we
- 53:09call. Let's make it a People who
- 53:12nearly end of the episode. So thanks for listening to the
- 53:15film and whiskey show. Let's pair another film with
- 53:18this one. Even if it's a struggle, it's a
- 53:19final segment of the day. Now let's make it a double.
- 53:22Let's make it. A double is the part of the
- 53:24show, where we pair this movie up with another film to make the
- 53:28perfect double feature Brad. I think we've pretty much
- 53:31already said, explicitly many times.
- 53:34What the perfect pairing for this movie?
- 53:36Is I have a better one. Oh, okay.
- 53:39Well then, let me say this way. I'm In the Great Escape because
- 53:42that's the correct answer. I think Bridge on the River Kwai
- 53:44could be, you know, at almost as good because it is a William
- 53:48Holden starring prisoner of war movie, like it's just go back to
- 53:52back on those, but then you'd be watching movies for like five
- 53:55and a half hours. So you would same thing with
- 53:59Great Escape. That's a three-hour movie too.
- 54:00So Brad. What's your pick?
- 54:03Remember that. My pick is a another prisoner of
- 54:07war movie and B is made with the goal of getting In this podcast,
- 54:12cancelled I am going to pick Tropic Thunder.
- 54:15Oh, now, is it because they let me take a guess as to why you're
- 54:20picking it is it because it's so perfectly balances, the themes
- 54:25of war and actual danger with slapstick comedy.
- 54:32Yeah, yeah, yeah. I'll be honest with you.
- 54:35I actually think that they would be a pretty funny pairing
- 54:38together. Yeah.
- 54:39To go from such an old film that.
- 54:41It has slapstick elements to a very modern film that has those
- 54:45slapstick elements. I'm like, actually, as I'm
- 54:48talking convincing myself that this is actually a great idea,
- 54:53but all I'm going to say is Tropic, Thunder is a hilarious
- 54:56movie and should be watched in addition to Stalag 17, which is
- 55:01a great movie as well. Totally agree.
- 55:03I think you just wanted to get another Tom Cruise reference in
- 55:06here. I I gave us a Few Good Men and
- 55:08you were like not good enough. My friend We need more crews.
- 55:13References fat fat, dancing. Cruz is what we needed.
- 55:17Is there any other all right, dude, I think it's time to give
- 55:21final scores on this movie. I am coming out weirdly to the
- 55:25same score that I came out to with Sunset Boulevard and it's a
- 55:29massive caveat. I'm giving this movie an 8 out
- 55:31of 10 because I think it works about as well as a movie with
- 55:35this. Premise can work like on paper.
- 55:38If you try to pitch me this movie I'd be like That's really
- 55:42risky. And I think the ceiling for that
- 55:44movie is 8 out of 10. And I really think this movie's
- 55:46pretty much achieves it ceiling. Sunset Boulevard is a movie that
- 55:50I think has much higher Ambitions and works fairly well,
- 55:55but has never worked perfectly for me.
- 55:57And so I guess my caveat is I think Sunset Boulevard is
- 55:59probably for talking like Capital C Cinema.
- 56:04Sunset Boulevard is the better made movie, but they work to
- 56:07pretty much equivalent extent to me.
- 56:10Yeah, I'm I'm kind of with you, I mean except for the part where
- 56:15I like Sunset Boulevard said, didn't I I'm going to give this
- 56:19a name. Then I think it's an incredibly
- 56:21funny movie, the drama and the pacing worked pretty well for
- 56:26me. You know, I know you said you
- 56:28had issues with the level of slapstick and filler stuff.
- 56:32I that didn't bother me quite as much.
- 56:34I definitely think this could be like a hour and 42 H 50 minute
- 56:39movie instead of two hours. But overall, I think the
- 56:42performance is a really great. I don't think holding deserves
- 56:44an Oscar for it, but I do think it's a really good performance.
- 56:48So, So yeah, I think this is in a pretty easy, 8 out of 10 for
- 56:52me. All right, well, we want to know
- 56:54what you think whoever's out there that's seen Stalag. 17, if
- 56:58you've seen this movie before, reach out to us, and I will give
- 57:01you a sticker because I don't expect that many of you have.
- 57:04And yet it's a really good movie.
- 57:06So if you've seen it, let us know at one of our social media
- 57:09accounts, Facebook Twitter, Instagram or Tick-Tock at film
- 57:14whiskey or jump onto our Discord.
- 57:16You can find a link to the Discord at the end of every one
- 57:18of our Notes and we are on there every single day talking to you
- 57:22guys, the fans of the film and whiskey podcast.
- 57:25Next week, we will be back with Wilders follow-up to Stalag 17.
- 57:291954 is romantic comedy Sabrina which I'm like super pumped for.
- 57:36Yeah, I'm really excited man. Anytime we do.
- 57:37Audrey Hepburn, I get very excited and she's incredible.
- 57:41All right, we'll see you for that one next week, but until
- 57:43then, I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G and we'll see you next time.