Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Mediation: Why the Other Side Won’t Settle (and What You Can Do About It) with Robert Jacobs
Transcript
- 0:07I'm Robert Cohen and I'm the emcee for a few
- 0:11minutes tonight. And it's my pleasure to introduce
- 0:14to you Bob Jacobs and his topic. At this moment,
- 0:20whether this is being seen now at 6 p .m. West
- 0:24Coast time or whether it's being seen a year
- 0:26from now at a different time zone is a most important
- 0:29topic for mediators and mediation advocates.
- 0:34Welcome to mediation. why the other side won't
- 0:38settle and what you can do about it. I've had
- 0:41the pleasure of talking with Bob for about the
- 0:43last 15 minutes and he is a lawyer's lawyer.
- 0:47He had decades of experience as a litigator,
- 0:50a trial lawyer, worked the defense, worked plaintiff's
- 0:54cases, did trials, I'm sure many, many arbitrations
- 0:58and many, many mediations. He's a very thoughtful,
- 1:04nuanced person, and he's brought that to his
- 1:07mediation practice. He started off on his own,
- 1:10and then ultimately he, after coming back from
- 1:13Africa, and there's a bunch of interesting stories
- 1:15which we won't get into, I'm sure about him,
- 1:18he went full -time with Judicate West. And I
- 1:21think that you and I will have a lot to learn
- 1:24today, and I would like to throw. the microphone
- 1:28over to Bob now and ask him to start his program.
- 1:30And I thank you very much for your participation
- 1:33today, Bob. Thank you. Thank you, Robert, having
- 1:36to be here. The nice thing about this program
- 1:40is that it has an opportunity or people who attend
- 1:43will have an opportunity to to ask questions
- 1:46of someone who spends their days dealing with
- 1:51very difficult situations and seeing things from
- 1:53both sides. The way this program is set up is
- 1:56to ask questions at the end. So please keep track
- 1:59of your questions. The program will go about
- 2:01an hour, and then we have time afterwards. I'm
- 2:04happy to stay late and answer as many questions
- 2:06as there are. And with that, we will get started.
- 2:11Here is the program. I need to share my screen,
- 2:15so I don't know who the person that I talked
- 2:18to about this. That's where the program is. I
- 2:25don't see a There's not there's not a An icon
- 2:34here for sharing screen It should be the green
- 2:39button share got it right here. Thank you. Okay.
- 2:42Thank you Okay, this program why the other side
- 2:48Won't settle in what you can do about it And
- 2:52I'll take this to the next slide This is an interactive
- 2:56program. So what you want to do is take your
- 2:59cell phone and scan this QR code, and then what
- 3:04happens is you can watch the program on your
- 3:06screen, on your computer screen, and then the
- 3:11phone gets turned into a polling device. It's
- 3:14interactive, and so the voting takes place on
- 3:17your phone. So if you wanted, you could watch
- 3:19the whole thing on your phone, but it's probably
- 3:21a little bit bigger and easier to watch on the
- 3:23computer screen. So if you don't get this scanned
- 3:29or you have any trouble with it, you can go to
- 3:31the URL that's on the left -hand side, www .menti
- 3:36.com and enter this code that's down there. And
- 3:39that is on the top of every slide. So if you
- 3:41get disconnected, you can join by going to that
- 3:46URL and then entering the code at any time during
- 3:48the program. Today we're going to talk about
- 3:53four reasons why the other side won't settle
- 3:55mediation and what you can do about it So number
- 4:03one Why won't the other side settle? Here is
- 4:07the first reason that we'll talk about because
- 4:09they don't see the case like you do So This is
- 4:21our first interactive part of this presentation.
- 4:25Your phone will give you an opportunity to tap
- 4:28in answers as limited number of characters, but
- 4:31let's get some collective thoughts here about
- 4:34how do you best help the other side see liability
- 4:38and damages like you do. You can enter it into
- 4:42your phone and then hit submit. We'll start seeing
- 4:44them show up on the screen here. How can you
- 4:49best help the other side see liability and damages
- 4:53like you do? Yes. Explain using case law and
- 5:03facts evidence presented in case in an email.
- 5:05Absolutely. What else do we have? This is a comment
- 5:12from a mediator, caucusing each party separately
- 5:15to find out what they need. Absolutely. We will
- 5:17talk about that during this program indirectly.
- 5:21Explain a point they haven't considered. Yes.
- 5:23Share brief. Share evidence. Double yes. Meaning
- 5:28confer. Don't hold anything back. Give all records,
- 5:31evidence, etc. Absolutely. Just a comment on
- 5:35this. I occasionally get mediations. I'm a little
- 5:38bit of an outlier when I do my mediations. I
- 5:42ask for briefs two full weeks in advance. And
- 5:45that's so that I have plenty of time to digest
- 5:48them. And then I hold mediation conferences a
- 5:52week in advance. And then that gives us some
- 5:54runway in case there's things that needs to happen
- 5:57so the other side can have enough time to evaluate
- 6:01the case. I occasionally have situations where
- 6:04parties want to submit a brief to me and do not
- 6:07want to give it to the other side. This comment
- 6:09here about don't hold anything back. I mean,
- 6:12there may be reasons for not exchanging a brief.
- 6:14But the key thing is, if you don't share your
- 6:16brief, then they're not going to include that
- 6:18in their case evaluation. So anything that the
- 6:21other side needs in order to evaluate the strength
- 6:23of your position absolutely has to be sent to
- 6:26the other side. It starts with the billing rapport
- 6:30and cooperative and collaborative report. Yes.
- 6:33Needed to explain? Yes. Find the part explained
- 6:36background. Thank you. All good comments, every
- 6:39one of them. Here's some distillation or some
- 6:43crystallization. If you represent a plaintiff,
- 6:47make sure the other side has all the facts and
- 6:50all the law that established liability. So what
- 6:53I say in my mediations is, please exchange briefs
- 6:5714 days ahead and submit them to me. If you have
- 7:00something that is for my eyes only, send me a
- 7:02separate brief or a separate letter that explains
- 7:04that, but give the other side the background
- 7:06on your case so they can see the case the same
- 7:08way that you do. if you represent a defendant.
- 7:14Make sure the other side has all the facts and
- 7:17the law that establish a defense. And then this
- 7:21is a big one. I have this again and again and
- 7:24again, as recently as last week. I get a case
- 7:27in, they're coming in for maybe it's pre -litigation
- 7:30mediation. I just had another one set for next
- 7:32week. So no complaint has even been filed yet.
- 7:35But all the defense has is a bare number and
- 7:38an allegation with no documents, no kind of documentary
- 7:43support as far as the quantification or the nature
- 7:46of the damages. And there may be a case somewhere
- 7:50in another universe where somebody just makes
- 7:52an allegation. And if the other side knows that
- 7:55there's something that maybe the plaintiff doesn't
- 7:57know and they're really anxious to settle, then
- 7:59they might settle on that basis. But barring
- 8:01a case like that, Every defendant is going to
- 8:05want to see how your damages are calculated.
- 8:07It's essential. And it's a surprising occurrence
- 8:11how often it happens that that won't be worked
- 8:15out before the mediation. And so that's one of
- 8:18the reasons why I say, let's have the pre -mediation
- 8:20conference a week ahead. And if we don't have
- 8:22that information, it's like making homework assignments.
- 8:25Are you willing to provide this? Are you willing
- 8:27to provide this? Please get it to the other side
- 8:28as soon as possible. All of this may seem self
- 8:32-evident. I promise you it is not. So let's talk
- 8:38about this. Now this gives you an opportunity
- 8:40on your phone to vote on this. And let's see
- 8:43what our collective thought is. Why don't counsel
- 8:46disclose key facts or law and mediation, especially
- 8:51when that kind of information, those facts or
- 8:55law are essential for the other side to make
- 8:57a steady decision on the strength and the value
- 9:00of your case. How come that doesn't happen? So
- 9:05you can look at the options on your phone, choose
- 9:08one or two, and then submit. What we kind of
- 9:32generally have at this point, the runaway winner
- 9:36is, they are concerned the other side may influence
- 9:39taint or modify the evidence. A valid consideration,
- 9:43especially if depositions have not been taken
- 9:45or there's information you think the other side
- 9:47doesn't know or that they may come and try and
- 9:51change things, a valid concern. So that can be
- 9:53a legitimate and a real factor in why key facts
- 9:57are law or not, disclosure of mediation. And
- 9:59there can be situations. where it makes sense
- 10:02to do that. You may think the case is perhaps
- 10:04poised for settlement without some of your strongest
- 10:07points because they're not necessarily set in
- 10:10concrete and they might be able to be changed
- 10:12by the other side. If so, then it's a studied
- 10:14decision about whether or not you share that.
- 10:18My experience is, number two, they have not worked
- 10:22out their own case. So many times, I'm going
- 10:26to share with you I'm sure we have a number of
- 10:29mediators who have joined us today. They'll understand
- 10:31perfectly what I'm talking about. But I'm going
- 10:33to share with you some of my own thought processes
- 10:36when these cases come in. When a case comes in,
- 10:40I get a case and I get a brief that has facts
- 10:44and law inside of plaintiffs or defense. And
- 10:47then I get the mirror image from the other side.
- 10:50And one of the great things about the case is
- 10:52I come to it fresh, like a judge would, and I'm
- 10:54not invested with a client. So my vision is just
- 10:57about as clear as it's going to get for anybody.
- 11:00It's a neutral third person. When I get the case
- 11:04in, I look at it through the eyes of how would
- 11:07I be working up this case? I absolutely do that.
- 11:11And what would I need and what would I want to
- 11:13see in order to evaluate this case? And if that's
- 11:17not present in the briefs. then I'm talking with
- 11:20counsel about it. I never move in front of them.
- 11:23You can't do that because that's going to kill
- 11:26your if you if you move out ahead of counsel,
- 11:28it's going to kill your rapport and your trust
- 11:30and that that goes nowhere. So you can't move
- 11:32ahead of counsel. But I will absolutely be talking
- 11:35with counsel and saying, have you considered
- 11:37giving this to the other side? Or what about
- 11:39this? There's some holes here either in liability
- 11:41or in law that don't add up on what you need
- 11:44in order to put together your prime efficient
- 11:45case. What about this? Sometimes they need to
- 11:47go out and see if there's some additional background
- 11:49that they can put together. But if they don't
- 11:52have a case. It can be very, very tough to get
- 11:55the other side to see it like you see it. This
- 11:58number three, they plan to ambush the other side
- 12:01of trial. I promise you, I promise you, I promise
- 12:05you that when you're involved in those caucuses
- 12:08and the other side is refusing to budge and it
- 12:11feels like they're giving you a stonewall, sometimes
- 12:14it is, but a surprising number of times it is
- 12:18not. And the reason I know that is because I
- 12:22sit with the other side, and I hear what they
- 12:23have to say. And I know I can be snowed. I know
- 12:29that. But I don't think that most of the time
- 12:31I can be snowed. And I hear what the other side
- 12:34says, both client and counsel, and many times.
- 12:40council are willing to let their clients talk
- 12:42freely at these mediations. And that can be,
- 12:44that can absolutely work magic when that happens
- 12:47for a lot of reasons. It allows me to find out
- 12:50what the values of the client are. And once I
- 12:52understand the values and I can try to work to
- 12:55see if we can achieve those. But as I hear what
- 12:57they're saying and I hear what's important, sometimes
- 13:00they can't come down to the range or come up
- 13:02to the range that the other side is talking about.
- 13:03And that feels like it's complete stonewall,
- 13:05but it's not. It's just a different in need.
- 13:08or a difference in perspective. So it feels like
- 13:10they've come to mediation not even planning to
- 13:13settle, like they're looking for a fishing expedition
- 13:15or a free discovery opportunity. There might
- 13:18be the occasional blue moon case like that, but
- 13:21I do not see them often at all. So they don't
- 13:24plan to settle mediation, I don't see that. They
- 13:26plan to ambush the other side of trial, I don't
- 13:28see that very infrequently. The other side just
- 13:32has legitimate needs or problems or issues that
- 13:35impede settlement, but it's not typically because
- 13:37of those two. If the key facts or the law are
- 13:44not provided to the other side, they will not
- 13:47include them in their case evaluation, which
- 13:49means they're not going to have them in their
- 13:51settlement negotiations. It's plain as day, simple
- 13:54math. So the first one was. Why the first point
- 13:59is why doesn't the other case the other side
- 14:01see the case like you do? It may be because they
- 14:04don't see the same facts or the same law that
- 14:06you do. So the first thing you can do to help
- 14:09the other side see the case like you do is make
- 14:12sure they see all of the facts that you know
- 14:15that are favorable to your case and the law.
- 14:18That's the first point. Here's the second point.
- 14:21Why won't the other side settle? Sometimes, even
- 14:24if they have the facts in law, they don't value
- 14:26the case like you do. Genuine differences of
- 14:33opinion and likely trial outcome account for
- 14:36many differences in case valuation. And of course,
- 14:40the trial outcomes, the difference of opinion
- 14:42is literally comes down to what's the judge going
- 14:44to do, what's the jury going to do, and there
- 14:47is no exact science on that. So that accounts
- 14:51for many times the difference in case valuation.
- 14:55Money is always important, but it isn't always
- 14:59the only answer. Settlements are driven by decisions,
- 15:07and decisions are based on values a huge majority
- 15:12of times. Settlement decisions are based on values.
- 15:17So that's why, as a mediator, It is essential
- 15:21to the extent that I can that I find out what
- 15:24the values of counsel are, which many times are
- 15:26what you'd expect them to be, and especially
- 15:29the clients. Some non -monetary considerations
- 15:35can significantly affect negotiations and settlements.
- 15:42The other side won't always tell you when their
- 15:45non -monetary values are driving their negotiations,
- 15:49but it doesn't mean that they aren't. And I see
- 15:53this. I see this again and again and again. Money
- 15:57is always important, but sometimes there are
- 16:00other things truly that drive the settlement
- 16:02decisions that are not just money. Sometimes
- 16:05it is, sometimes it's not. So what kind of non
- 16:09-monetary considerations are we talking about?
- 16:12It's the principle of the thing. Sometimes it's
- 16:16death of a case when a client walks in, especially
- 16:18an unsophisticated client says it's the principle
- 16:20of the thing and you're going, well, principle
- 16:22has value. But, you know, I saw a great cartoon
- 16:26years ago from The New Yorker and it showed a
- 16:29lawyer sitting at his desk and there's a client
- 16:30sitting across and the lawyer's looking at some
- 16:32papers going, you have a pretty good case, Mr.
- 16:35Pinkin, how much justice can you afford? The
- 16:39principle of the thing that's sometimes for insufficient
- 16:42clients, but It's also a reality for very well
- 16:47-heeled clients where sometimes Their sense of
- 16:50what's right and wrong is so offended that they
- 16:53are not gonna they're not gonna take it lying
- 16:55down They're not gonna give someone else a satisfaction
- 16:58and they have the money to back it up and they're
- 17:00willing to spend it That this is a reality Sometimes
- 17:04it's I can't let them get away with that again
- 17:05a principle -based reason for not settling or
- 17:08for picking a particular settlement value or
- 17:12negotiating range. Sometimes it's a sense of
- 17:16trying to make the world a better place, you
- 17:17know, and part of that is I'm not going to give
- 17:19them a license to do this. I don't want them
- 17:21to do this to someone else. I'm not going to
- 17:23give them the satisfaction. Sometimes it's a
- 17:26sense of equalizing or sometimes revenge. I've
- 17:29been through a lot of pain of whatever kind it
- 17:32is and I want them to feel like I do. Sometimes,
- 17:35you know, I mediate in courthouses. Sometimes
- 17:38when I do that, if the clients need it, I might
- 17:42just say, look, these courthouses are filled
- 17:44with people who have been wronged. That's why
- 17:47they're here. So everyone, almost everyone who
- 17:50comes here feels like they've been wronged. That's
- 17:53what these places are for. Sometimes that helps.
- 17:56You have to use your discretion when you bring
- 17:58up those kinds of things. This is a big one.
- 18:01They disrespected me. or they can't treat me
- 18:04like that people get angry and they get offended
- 18:09and they get upset and they lose what they think
- 18:12is respect or they feel is respect and so sometimes
- 18:16what they're saying is money or other settlement
- 18:19demands but what's really driving it is this
- 18:21and you know this because when you're in the
- 18:23room and the clients are talking about it this
- 18:26is what they're talking about you just know it
- 18:28doesn't happen in every case but a surprisingly
- 18:31large number of cases this is it significant
- 18:33reality. And in certain kinds of case, a strong
- 18:39interest in exerting and demonstrating control.
- 18:42I see this most frequently in something like
- 18:45employment cases, you know, where there's maybe
- 18:47a history or a relationship, sometimes a long
- 18:50-term relationship between the parties, and someone
- 18:52just has known these people and they're just
- 18:54not going to take this line down. Maybe an employee
- 18:56feels that way or an employer. I also see this
- 18:59dynamic a lot in trust litigation cases, strong
- 19:03interest in exerting and demonstrating control,
- 19:06long -term relationship, or it can happen in
- 19:08business relationships, where partners have long
- 19:11-term shareholders, people who've known each
- 19:13other for a long time, something goes south,
- 19:16something goes sour, sometimes the whole history
- 19:19comes back up and it's who's going to be in control.
- 19:22In those kinds of cases, these last two are absolutely
- 19:26critical in order to be able to bring that kind
- 19:29of a case to resolution. Let's talk about mediation
- 19:34briefs. What are the key benefits to sharing
- 19:40your brief with the other side? And I've talked
- 19:42about this a little bit about not sharing briefs,
- 19:44but let's talk about it for a minute. Opportunity
- 19:46to vote by your phone. There is a runaway winner
- 20:25here with projecting a good faith negotiating
- 20:27style thereby promoting trust in the negotiations.
- 20:30If you come into a mediation and the other side
- 20:33is not going to share their brief, what's the
- 20:36natural response to that? What are they afraid
- 20:41of? More likely is what are they hiding? Or are
- 20:43they even serious about this? Why are we spending
- 20:45our time? Why are we wasting our time? Where
- 20:47are we going through this? Are they going to
- 20:49tell us what their claim is? Everyone has been
- 20:52through lots of mediations where briefs were
- 20:54shared. What is it about this case? Why they
- 20:56cannot share their brief? A real valid negotiation
- 20:59or consideration here. This one on the bottom
- 21:02about the good faith negotiating style. This
- 21:07one here, this has got the lowest votes. You
- 21:10save considerable time with the mediator. I truly
- 21:15believe most mediators make a studied effort
- 21:18to honor confidence. confidentiality If you have
- 21:23a brief and it goes to the mediator only Then
- 21:29the mediator may not know how much of that brief
- 21:31they can share with the other side and When they
- 21:34get into the room, how do they effectively press
- 21:38your case? Explore your case the strength of
- 21:42your arguments with the other side if they cannot
- 21:44even discuss them So if you have that, you know
- 21:48We all learn this by experience as far as litigation
- 21:52goes, that your litigation practice takes on
- 21:55your own personal style and your own personality.
- 21:58Same is true with mediation. And there's a lot
- 22:01of different styles of mediation. And if there's
- 22:03not a real pressing of your case and a vetting
- 22:06of your case with the other side, then this is
- 22:09less important. But if you're going to mediate
- 22:12with a mediator who wants to take your arguments
- 22:14to their side and start saying, what about this?
- 22:16What about this? How are you going to get around
- 22:18this? How are you going to counter this? What
- 22:19evidence do you have on this? And literally start
- 22:21arguing your case in the other room. If the mediator
- 22:24doesn't have a situation where your brief has
- 22:26been shared with the other side, their hands
- 22:28are tied. They can't explore that. And then they
- 22:30have to come back to you on every point and say,
- 22:33can I share this? Can I share that? It's unworkable.
- 22:35It's just impossible. It just slows everything
- 22:38down and time Even though we go for a full day,
- 22:41time is so precious. It looks at the beginning
- 22:44of the day, we've got lots of time, but how many
- 22:46mediations do we all get through where we start
- 22:48getting it towards the end of the day and there's
- 22:49still a distance to go. So you have to keep the
- 22:52clip up all day long or you're going to run out
- 22:54in difficult cases at the end of the day. Then
- 22:57people get tired. Then they say, let's put it
- 22:59down. And then things sometimes go sideways.
- 23:02Whereas if you could wrap it up that day, a lot
- 23:04of times you get a better result if you can.
- 23:06So this is a significant one. For me you save
- 23:09considerable time with the mediator You pave
- 23:12the way another one for opposing counsel to share
- 23:15your brief with their client You know the first
- 23:21the very first decision I have to make as a mediator
- 23:25right off the bat is Who's driving the bus? In
- 23:29in the other room is it the client or is it the
- 23:32attorney? If it's the attorney and the client
- 23:35is just taking whatever they're attorney has
- 23:37to recommend and really very passive or very
- 23:40malleable for what the client attorney is going
- 23:43to recommend, then this consideration, the second
- 23:48one, is less important. But if you have a client
- 23:51who is headstrong or independent minded or running
- 23:55the show, driving the bus, you know, when I used
- 24:01to litigate, I would prepare my brief. Sometimes
- 24:04it was for the opposing client attorney. it often
- 24:07was for the opposing client. Because I wanted
- 24:09that opposing client to see the strength of my
- 24:12case, and I didn't know how their own attorney
- 24:15had presented it to them. I didn't know if they'd
- 24:17really given them the full scoop. If maybe thing
- 24:20was a little bit, had a positive shine on it,
- 24:22I wanted them to see my case. So I wrote my brief
- 24:26for the opposing client many, many times, especially
- 24:28if I had any sense that the client was the one
- 24:30driving the bus. So if you have a situation where
- 24:33you think the client is maybe in control, And
- 24:36maybe the client doesn't fully appreciate the
- 24:38risks or the problems that they have with their
- 24:40own case. This can be very valuable. And then,
- 24:43of course, this one. By sharing your brief with
- 24:45them, you invite them to share their brief with
- 24:47you. And that way, you're just so much further
- 24:50down the road when you get to mediation. If you
- 24:51have a common understanding of what the disputes
- 24:53are, the commonalities are to read upon, the
- 24:57issues that are not, then you can be in a much
- 24:59better position to make effective use of your
- 25:01time and see how you can hammer those things
- 25:02that need to be hammered so you can see the coming
- 25:04resolution by the end of the day. Who's your
- 25:09primary intended audience for a mediation brief?
- 25:11And I talked about this a little bit in the previous
- 25:13slide, but we can take just a moment here. Let's
- 25:15take some thoughts, our collective thoughts.
- 25:18When you're doing your briefs, who's your primary
- 25:20intended audience? Run away in favor of the mediator
- 25:49Certainly the mediator if the mediator lacks
- 25:52the facts and law that are underlying your case
- 25:56or your defense your clients They cannot explore
- 25:58them in the other room. So the mediator of course
- 26:00is essential. This is an interesting one your
- 26:03own client This this is a reality too We've all
- 26:11had cases with difficult clients who maybe don't
- 26:14want the things that would be in their own best
- 26:16interest, but they just don't really see it.
- 26:18They lack the sophistication. When that kind
- 26:21of a case gets to mediation, most of the time
- 26:25the attorneys try to put on a good face, especially
- 26:29to the other side. Because you can't you can't
- 26:32broadcast or telegraph that you've got issues
- 26:34with client controller your own client You just
- 26:36can't do that Especially with when you're dealing
- 26:38with a client because they see you as their champion
- 26:40and they should and that's how that's how it
- 26:42is but in separate caucuses between just the
- 26:47mediator and council when when situations warranted
- 26:50It's possible to get a sense of this, you know
- 26:53that sometimes these briefs are maybe for people's
- 26:56own clients maybe if they refuse to hear reason
- 27:01or they have their own ideas about how things
- 27:02work and they see it in black and white. Sometimes
- 27:04it can be a valuable education tool for your
- 27:07own client or that's one side of the coin. The
- 27:11other side, of course, is client development
- 27:14or client marketing, client understanding. They
- 27:18see you as the champion and they see what a great
- 27:21job you've done on the brief and then they have...
- 27:23greater confidence in you and hopefully they'll
- 27:25take your recommendations as far as settlement
- 27:27goes to get the case settled. That's an interesting
- 27:29one. Opposing counsel, obviously yes. Opposing
- 27:32client, obviously yes. We've talked about that.
- 27:36Why submit your brief on time or early? I regularly
- 28:15deal with insurance adjusters. And the theme
- 28:19is always the same, which is, as the case progresses
- 28:25on mediation day, and you're talking about money,
- 28:29you always get this, well, that's all the authority
- 28:31I have, or we don't have that today, or we can't
- 28:34get that. And then when you probe, even just
- 28:37a little bit, what you get is, you know, We reviewed
- 28:40this beforehand, thoroughly. We took it up to
- 28:42three different layers or levels, different people.
- 28:45This is how we evaluate the case. It's how we
- 28:47see it. OK, well, as a mediator, if it's clear
- 28:52to the other side it's never going to be in that
- 28:53range, then that precipitates questions for me
- 28:57like, well, do you think it might ever change?
- 28:58Well, I don't know. Good. What do you think?
- 29:00You know these people. Do you think it'll ever
- 29:01change? Well, it might. The problem is the insurance
- 29:06professionals. require time to evaluate the case.
- 29:11If you think about it, and we all know this,
- 29:13all the insurance company has is money. They
- 29:15have liability and policies, and all they have
- 29:17is money. And they cannot open the tap too fast,
- 29:21too far, or too hard to let it go too fast. And
- 29:23insurance counsel live and die by this. So you
- 29:26just can't do that. And the way they control
- 29:30it, the way they keep the tap turned down the
- 29:32right amount, is by settlement authority. before
- 29:36the mediation starts, they have evaluated this
- 29:38case, they've reviewed it. And if they don't
- 29:40review it and they don't see the risk or the
- 29:42likelihood, they will tell you, we just don't
- 29:44see it. We're just not there. I recognize there's
- 29:46a cost that fans were prepared to pay. We just
- 29:48don't see it. If you don't do your mediation
- 29:51brief on time, or you don't get it early to the
- 29:54other side, you forgo the opportunity. for the
- 29:58insurance company to make a studied determination
- 30:01as to what your case is worth. So even if you
- 30:02have a great case on mediation day, they may
- 30:06not come with authority. You can't settle that
- 30:07day. That doesn't mean you can't maybe get it
- 30:10on a later day, but you've chewed up a day. Sometimes
- 30:13things change. So if you're going to try and
- 30:17make the most of mediation day, give the insurance
- 30:20company enough time so they can evaluate it.
- 30:22Sometimes it takes them a couple of weeks. So
- 30:24if you can actually get your brief in. a couple
- 30:27of weeks in advance to the other side. That so
- 30:32well lays the groundwork for the insurance company
- 30:34to have the time they need to carefully evaluate
- 30:37the case. Now I've had, we've all had cases where
- 30:40insurance adjusters come in at the last minute
- 30:42and they make a couple of magic calls and they
- 30:43can do it sometimes on the fly. Sometimes that
- 30:46works. Other times it does not. So the way you
- 30:49remove that as an issue, get your brief to the
- 30:51other side early or on time. Mediators are real
- 30:55people. They are busy, they have schedules, and
- 31:00sometimes, you know, if you don't get a brief
- 31:02until seven o 'clock the night before mediation
- 31:04day, you do your level best to review it and
- 31:07to digest it, but it may not get the same type
- 31:10of study consideration that it would get if you
- 31:13had it in several days before that. So if the
- 31:17mediator understands your case better, let's
- 31:19just be blunt, let's be clear. Mediators are
- 31:23people too, and they are. And the thing is, so
- 31:28many of us take our jobs so seriously and want
- 31:31to give good service, whether we're the attorney
- 31:34or the mediator or the judge. It's just true,
- 31:36not in every case, but in so many cases. And
- 31:39if you can really digest it, and if it's persuasive,
- 31:44the first person you want to convince, of course,
- 31:47the mediation, is the mediator. I mean, you want
- 31:49to get the other client and the other counsel.
- 31:51But if the mediator feels of the validity, and
- 31:56the strength and the empathy and the sympathy
- 31:58of your side of the case. If they really kind
- 32:01of feel that, sure, they need to argue both sides.
- 32:04They need to do the best they can. But we know
- 32:07that as people, we can detect sincerity and we
- 32:10can detect vibes and emotions. And if you can
- 32:13sell the mediator on your case so that they think
- 32:16it's a really great case, it's just easier when
- 32:19they go into the other room and they're presenting
- 32:21it to the other side for them to make a compelling
- 32:23presentation. Here's what the other side says.
- 32:26Here's my concern for you. If you don't settle
- 32:28this down, it goes before a judge and a jury,
- 32:30how are they going to feel with A, B, C, X, Y,
- 32:33Z? And they just reiterate the points in your
- 32:35brief. How is that going to play to a judge and
- 32:38a jury? And of course, the response to that is,
- 32:40well, we think a judge and a jury would never
- 32:42go with that. But in reality, what they're thinking
- 32:43is, yeah, it's a concern. So that's why we're
- 32:46here to talk settlement. You give the mediator
- 32:49the best opportunity by giving the facts, the
- 32:51law, and time. Invective is defined as insulting,
- 33:01as a dictionary definition, insulting, abusive,
- 33:04or highly critical language. So this is a scale,
- 33:08a sliding scale, and you can vote on your phone.
- 33:11Invective in a mediation degree is a useful aid
- 33:14or can be a useful aid in the mediation process.
- 33:18Zero is strongly disagree. Ten is strongly agree.
- 33:24Let's see what our collective thinking is on
- 33:25this. We're way down to the left end, and I kind
- 33:42of already talked about this on the purpose of
- 33:44going to the client. But the reality is, if your
- 33:48brief is aimed at the opposing client, and there's
- 33:52an effective in there castigating the opposing
- 33:54client, disparaging them, calling into question
- 33:58their motives, making them look poor, then in
- 34:01addition, the difference is realistically, when
- 34:04you get to trial, the person you're trying to
- 34:07convince is the judge. or the person you're trying
- 34:09to convince are the jurors. When you're at mediation,
- 34:14the person you really have to convince is the
- 34:15opposing client and counsel. And so if you can,
- 34:21you know, if you attack the opposing client too
- 34:24strongly at trial, you run the very real risk
- 34:27that the jurors may rise to their defense because
- 34:30they don't know who wears the white hats and
- 34:32who wears the black hats or who the good people
- 34:34are and who the not good people are. They don't
- 34:35know that. At the mediation the person you have
- 34:42to convince is the person that you're actually
- 34:44opposed against So if you put an effective in
- 34:46your brief and you make it really spun up Then
- 34:51their back goes up then it's emotional now you
- 34:53have to deal with all the emotional issues On
- 34:56top of everything else that you're dealing with
- 34:58and it slows things down and sometimes they just
- 35:02dig in and I had a mediation last week, you know
- 35:05where someone just they The pigs get fat, the
- 35:09hogs get slaughtered, someone was just too intransigent
- 35:13about their position, demanding too much, and
- 35:15the other side just said, I'm out of here, and
- 35:16they walked out and left. There was nothing I
- 35:18could say. You couldn't save it. You said, I'm
- 35:20cutting this off right now. You consulted me,
- 35:22and off they go. Doesn't happen often, but it
- 35:25doesn't get us any closer to sudden, at least
- 35:27on that day, unless there is a particular strategic
- 35:31reason for spinning the other side up, and that
- 35:34might happen. And if that's so, then that's a
- 35:36calculated decision. If there's a reason why
- 35:39you want the other side to be spun up, then go
- 35:42for it. But unless there's a reason, if it's
- 35:45just because it's been a frustrating case and
- 35:47you want to lay it out for the record because
- 35:48that's the way the other side has conducted themselves
- 35:50or the way the other client has been and you're
- 35:53getting that from your own client that they've
- 35:54been difficult to work with, take a step back,
- 35:57take a deep breath and say, is this sentence
- 36:00or is this effective? Is it going to help these
- 36:03people want to settle with me? or is it going
- 36:05to push him further away? And what's my goal
- 36:07at the mediation? If a trial is as much effective
- 36:11as you think you can get away with with the judge
- 36:13and the jury, whatever you think is going to
- 36:15be effective. Number three, why won't the other
- 36:21side settle? Because they don't see the case
- 36:23like you do. Because they don't value the case
- 36:26like you do. Here's the third part. Because they
- 36:30genuinely expect to prevail at trial. This is
- 36:34also a reality sometimes they really think they've
- 36:38got these great odds of trial Sometimes settlement
- 36:43seems impossible because the parties literally
- 36:48are in different universes So when that happens
- 36:55when the parties are really light years apart
- 37:00Why don't they just keep chiseling away with
- 37:02the offers and counter offers until they reach
- 37:04a settlement somewhere in the middle? Why do
- 37:07they do that? Sometimes that works So I sometimes
- 37:13refer to these as ping -pong or two -step cases
- 37:16back and forth back and forth plaintiff taking
- 37:18incrementally smaller steps or incrementally
- 37:22incremental small steps defense making incremental
- 37:25small increases until you come to agreement or
- 37:29a meeting of the settlement number somewhere
- 37:31in the middle. In my world, sometimes, oftentimes,
- 37:36those are the easiest cases to mediate and to
- 37:38settle. Because what's happening is the parties
- 37:41are making roughly equal moves. Sometimes it's
- 37:44not equal, but they're doing the work of the
- 37:47mediation. They're taking the temperature of
- 37:49the other side through the offers and the counter
- 37:51offers until they meet somewhere in the middle.
- 37:53Those are the easiest ones. Because the party's
- 37:56doing the work and everyone knows how it works.
- 37:58It's very ordered. You feel very much in control
- 38:01of the process And um, and you just go until
- 38:04you know, if parties are willing to keep moving
- 38:05until it's settled. Those are the easiest The
- 38:09more challenging cases are those where a party
- 38:12won't even respond to a move Unless the other
- 38:16side makes a major move The one party won't even
- 38:21respond so it goes like this demand offer Demand,
- 38:26offer, freeze. Freeze. Not even going to respond.
- 38:34Okay? We're here at mediation. They say, I'm
- 38:35not going to respond. Why do parties do this?
- 38:40Let's take an open -ended question here. These
- 39:09are all good points. I'm going to talk about
- 39:11this first one. I'll take more if there are people
- 39:13are willing to share more insulted by the offer.
- 39:17Yes Ran out of authority. Yes Different different
- 39:22realms of universe. Yes To force the other side
- 39:25to bet against itself Sometimes you can get that
- 39:28to work and when you can it's great You know
- 39:30if the other side is motivated enough to settle
- 39:32and you can if you can get them to move without
- 39:35moving at all great But I recently was in meeting
- 39:39of mediators. We talked about a mediation where
- 39:42one side without disclosing any of the facts
- 39:44said I settled a case recently This is one of
- 39:47the mediators after 63 moves 63 moves 63 he said
- 39:56what happened is the plaintiffs Would make a
- 40:00demand the defendants would come up by a dollar
- 40:03Plaintiffs would make a different demand plaintiffs
- 40:05would come up by A dollar. A dollar. So why would
- 40:11somebody do that? Why would the defense come
- 40:13up by a dollar? Isn't that like a slap in the
- 40:15face? But you look at the alternative, which
- 40:18is nothing at all. So when you get to a mediation
- 40:22and the other side refuses to move at all, how
- 40:27does that feel? It feels like a complete hardball
- 40:37or a complete stonewall. And then you get responses
- 40:40like, the other side isn't negotiating in good
- 40:42faith. They're not serious. We're wasting our
- 40:43time. I've got a lot of work to do back at the
- 40:45office. They're not even going to negotiate.
- 40:47Why are we even here? You get those kinds of
- 40:49responses, which are legitimate. That's how it
- 40:52feels. By making a dollar, what the defense does
- 40:56is they say, we're interested in settlement.
- 41:00We're willing to move. But you're in the wrong
- 41:04range for what we're willing to do. So they're
- 41:07trying to telegraph that. If there's too much
- 41:09confidence on the other side, on the plaintiff's
- 41:11side about what's going to happen in trial, that
- 41:13goes nowhere. The defense has to come up materially
- 41:16or the negotiations end. But in that case, it
- 41:20worked. So we know this. We know this. That at
- 41:25mediation, the parties frequently will telegraph
- 41:29a message to the other side about what that party
- 41:33is willing to do or where they're willing to
- 41:35go. That's common. When we're doing it with offers
- 41:38and counter offers, the way we telegraph those
- 41:40messages are by the timing and by the amount
- 41:43of the jumps. We do that. But when you get a
- 41:48mediation where the one side just says, I'm not
- 41:49gonna move, and then the other side says, well,
- 41:51if they're not gonna move, I'm not gonna move.
- 41:53Then you're just completely stuck. Then what
- 41:56is the message that really happens? Really, what
- 42:00the side who first says that, I'm not going to
- 42:02move, what they're really telegraphing is we
- 42:05need to be in a different negotiating range.
- 42:07But they don't say that. They just say, I'm not
- 42:09going to make an offer. And so the other side
- 42:11is left to take it as they will, which sometimes
- 42:13isn't good. But really, the message is you're
- 42:17in the wrong range. We're here. We're willing
- 42:19to talk. We just have to be in a different range.
- 42:22We all know that sometimes parties telegraph
- 42:26where they're really willing to go. by the ranges,
- 42:29like by the midpoints. And that's a lot of the
- 42:33background and a lot of the philosophy on doing
- 42:35brackets. Sometimes you can communicate or telegraph
- 42:38where you're at without making a firm offer or
- 42:40specifically explicitly saying so. Two key reasons.
- 42:48And this is what we were just talking about.
- 42:50Either that the midpoint is wrong. So in other
- 42:53words, if we've got two different universes,
- 42:56and we got the planets sky high, you know, out
- 42:59of the stratosphere high, and the defense in
- 43:02the basement low, and the midpoint is wrong,
- 43:06and one of the sides is using the midpoint as
- 43:09kind of the indicator where the case is likely
- 43:11to go, then they feel like, I can't even move.
- 43:15I can't even move because the midpoint's wrong.
- 43:18Or sometimes, and this is actually, this is very
- 43:22common, The other side that stops says, I'm not
- 43:27going to make an offer because I have no confidence
- 43:30that the other side is going to get into the
- 43:32right negotiation range where I want to do it.
- 43:33They don't say these words. What they say is,
- 43:36no response. We're not going to make an offer.
- 43:39Rarely do you get this kind of analysis or this
- 43:41kind of detail, but that's really frequently
- 43:43what's going on. They just don't have any confidence.
- 43:45The other side is going to do it. They're just
- 43:47way up, way high. No, we're not going to get
- 43:49anywhere, so we're just going to stop. When the
- 43:56parties stop exchanging offers, the path forward
- 44:00may not be entirely clear. What should you do
- 44:07if the other side won't even respond to your
- 44:11good faith move? I'll invite responses here by
- 44:18the voting on the phones. As a very young litigator,
- 44:52I'm going to talk about this fifth one. I was
- 44:55very straight up, very straightforward about
- 44:57what I was willing to do and what my client was
- 44:59willing to do. And when the mediation didn't
- 45:00happen, then I just assumed we're going to trap.
- 45:02And sometimes that happens. In a settlement context
- 45:07and as a more senior lawyer, what I realized
- 45:09is a lot of times people rethink this, they come
- 45:12back, it might be a month, might be two months,
- 45:14might be six months down the road, maybe right
- 45:15before trial. Even if a mediation fails, it doesn't
- 45:19mean that it's... terminal just means it's not
- 45:21going to happen that day. Other times I've had
- 45:24cases, though, where it didn't happen mediation,
- 45:27I really did go to trial. No further mediations.
- 45:30I mean, parties had to change a heart, change
- 45:32a position, something happened, and that was
- 45:33it. That was the day. So you have to make that
- 45:36evaluation before you walk away from the day,
- 45:37of course. If there are available dispositive
- 45:41motions, like there's a pending summary judgment
- 45:44motion, well, you know, both sides. can say well
- 45:48we think we're going to win this and so we'll
- 45:49settle on that basis but frequently my experience
- 45:51is the party that spent the time and the money
- 45:53energy and effort to put together the summary
- 45:54judgment motion thinks there's a reasonably good
- 45:56chance of it being granted or most of the time
- 45:58they wouldn't have done it not in every case
- 46:00for most cases that can be very challenging to
- 46:02mediate while you've got a pending despondent
- 46:03emotion doesn't mean it can't be done it's an
- 46:06added challenge so spend the mediation length
- 46:08and think it over That can be effective in some
- 46:11cases. You have to make your evaluation. Are
- 46:13they likely to dig in? Are they likely to change?
- 46:15Is there a chemistry here today that might not
- 46:18be present later on down the road? And sometimes
- 46:20that happens. Proposed brackets can be very effective
- 46:24as a way of telegraphing where you're willing
- 46:26to go. But I'd like to focus on this one. Empower
- 46:31the mediator. Empower the mediator. Yeah. Empower
- 46:37the mediator. Empowering the mediator depends
- 46:44on your mediator skill set, disposition, and
- 46:46approach to mediation. I'm going to be point
- 46:47blank here. What happens when you choose your
- 46:51mediator, if you're choosing a whole skill set,
- 46:55a whole approach to mediation, a whole approach
- 46:57to life. And the way to be most efficient is
- 47:00to figure out as best you can, whether you talk
- 47:02with colleagues who have used that mediator or
- 47:04you've mediated with that mediator before, to
- 47:07look at that mediator's strengths and skills
- 47:10and play to that. Shape your mediation according
- 47:13to what your mediator is most comfortable and
- 47:16most skilled at doing. And that's the way you
- 47:19can make the most of their skills to try and
- 47:21get this case to settlement. Now, some mediators.
- 47:28Our most comfortable contain demands and offers
- 47:32between the parties without pressing the parties
- 47:34too much and We've all been through mediations
- 47:37like that. I as a litigator I went through many
- 47:39many of those where the mediator never came in
- 47:42and pressed me They did not explore my case with
- 47:45me. They did not explore the other side's case
- 47:47with me. It was literally what I've heard described
- 47:49as carrying waters, demands back and forth, where
- 47:51the parties lay the groundwork and do the, they
- 47:54take the labor in order to test the other side's
- 47:57resolve and interest in settlement by the offers
- 47:59and counteroffers is the tried and true method,
- 48:02the time -tested method, the classic way of handling
- 48:04mediation, and it can be very effective, especially
- 48:07when it works. In difficult cases where people
- 48:10are not willing to make offers for the reasons
- 48:13we've talked about or others, that may not be
- 48:16enough. So in these mediations where you have
- 48:19back and forth the parties do much or most of
- 48:21the work in determining the other side's appetite
- 48:23for settlement, other mediators will press your
- 48:27case with the other side. They will take your
- 48:30facts and your law and your arguments in your
- 48:33brief and vigorously discuss them with the other
- 48:36side. So one of the one of the calculations is
- 48:39if you want a mediator that's going to do this
- 48:42then make your evaluation when you're selecting
- 48:44your mediator is are they going to explore my
- 48:48case with either side and are they going to explore
- 48:50the other side's case with them having read the
- 48:54briefs digested the law maybe even read a case
- 48:57or two if it's something they're not up to speed
- 48:59with so they can really explore this with either
- 49:01side saying what about this you get the trial
- 49:03has this going to play to a judge jury your trial
- 49:06has this witness going to go from the other side
- 49:08How is that really going to play, do you think?
- 49:11Those kind of questions. You would think that
- 49:15this happens with every mediation about pushing,
- 49:18pressing this with the other side and exploring
- 49:20the case, but I promise you it does not. Because
- 49:25the mediator is neutral. The parties are often
- 49:27willing to share information with the mediator
- 49:30that they would never share with opposing counsel.
- 49:33This is as true as the day is on. There is good
- 49:38reason for this. Parties intuitively and instinctively
- 49:42know that if they communicate their weakness
- 49:45or their concern or their bottom line to opposing
- 49:48counsel, it will be used against them as a next
- 49:51round of settlement moves, and they are right.
- 49:56If the parties have confidence in the mediator,
- 49:59that the mediator will not disabuse them or take
- 50:01advantage of them or make a misstep of some kind,
- 50:05then oftentimes the parties are willing to kind
- 50:08of give some pretty good indications to the mediator
- 50:10what they might be willing to do if the mediator
- 50:14asks for it, if they request it. Many times they'll
- 50:19do that and it's not a formal offer, but it's
- 50:21kind of like a could you, would you, how about
- 50:23this, if we could get it to this, would you do
- 50:25that? And a lot of times people will give you
- 50:28a sense of where they are at. And I refer to
- 50:37it as telegraphing a settlement range or a number.
- 50:39Like maybe, oh, we want to do something in this
- 50:41range. So even though the actual numbers being
- 50:44exchanged are much higher, a plaintiff might
- 50:47say, yeah, we might be willing to do something
- 50:48in this range. That type of information is absolute
- 50:53gold. because it gives you an insight as a mediator
- 50:57into what the other side is willing to do. Or
- 50:59the defense says, you know what, we don't think
- 51:00it's worth it, but I mean, if the plaintiff would
- 51:02take this, maybe we'd do this. It's absolute
- 51:05gold. Because if you're in a stuck position where
- 51:09the parties have stopped making offers and you
- 51:12can't go back and get the one side to move because
- 51:14they don't have any confidence the other side
- 51:15is ever going to come into the right range, this
- 51:18is just about the last thing you're left with
- 51:20other than brackets. And brackets narrows the
- 51:23gap. You know, so one really great way to do
- 51:27it is you start with a typical classic back and
- 51:30forth ping pong approach. You hit a block, you
- 51:34hit a snag. Brackets. Parties don't want to communicate
- 51:38a midpoint that's not right. You hit a snag.
- 51:41You get to this. Empower the mediator. What would
- 51:44it take? What if I could get this? That kind
- 51:47of thing. If both sides will participate in this
- 51:50approach, the mediator is able to explore settlement
- 51:54possibilities at specific ranges or numbers that
- 51:58look very different from the formal offers being
- 52:01exchanged between the parties. And what you can
- 52:04end up with literally is two concurrent parallel
- 52:09sets of negotiations going on at the same time.
- 52:13One with the formal back and forth numbers, and
- 52:16then the one where the rubber really hits the
- 52:18road, which is What if we can get to this? Would
- 52:20this work? What about that? Going on at the same
- 52:23time so that nobody is looking weak. No one's
- 52:27giving away too much information. You still have
- 52:29the back and forth going between the parties.
- 52:31But then in the background, you've got the real
- 52:33dialogue that's going on about what's it going
- 52:35to take. Super effective. This approach to mediation
- 52:40requires a high degree of mediator skill and
- 52:45a high degree of trust between CASEL and the
- 52:48mediator. And the trust has to go both ways.
- 52:51The mediator has to be skilled, because if you're
- 52:54getting involved in this kind of discussion with
- 52:57each side, as a mediator, not only do they have
- 53:01to trust you so they'll disclose it to you, but
- 53:02as a mediator, you have to decide, are these
- 53:06the kind of people that if they give me this
- 53:08kind of indication and we can get the other side
- 53:10to that, are they really gonna do that? or are
- 53:13these the kind of people that they say will do
- 53:14this and they seem sincere but if it looks like
- 53:16we can get there then they're going well on second
- 53:18thought you know we actually wanted something
- 53:20more and back up start negotiating backwards
- 53:23and that happens as a mediator it's absolutely
- 53:26miserable because you you put yourself on the
- 53:29line to try and get to something that they reassured
- 53:31you is going to work and then they start sensing
- 53:33that it might actually happen and it's like well
- 53:34you know we actually need more it's absolutely
- 53:37miserable and it actually destroys your trust
- 53:40with your mediator. After that point, it's like,
- 53:43you know, okay, well, I can't trust anything
- 53:44you're going to tell me. So how are we going
- 53:46to do this now? Yeah. In that mediation and in
- 53:49subsequent ones, mediators like dogs and people,
- 53:52which I just have long memories, you know, they
- 53:54remember this. However, if you have the trust
- 53:58between parties and the mediator and the mediator
- 54:02is willing to ask and explore what would it take
- 54:05if you can't get there through the back and forth
- 54:07ping pong or through the brackets. The results
- 54:09can be dramatic. You end up selling cases, and
- 54:14the comments you get after are something like
- 54:16this. I never thought this case would settle.
- 54:19I never thought it would. Parties were so far
- 54:22apart, bitter litigation back and forth between
- 54:26the parties, and they end up with a settlement.
- 54:29It absolutely looks and feels like magic, and
- 54:31it can be dramatic. What it comes down to is
- 54:37the parties. were never willing to telegraph
- 54:41to the other side what they were actually willing
- 54:44to do before the mediation even started. They
- 54:47wouldn't telegraph it for fear that that would
- 54:49be used against them in the next round of negotiations,
- 54:51but they were willing to communicate it to the
- 54:53mediator. And once this third party, you get
- 54:55this trial going, once the mediator has that
- 54:58and can broker it between both sides, you have
- 55:01a case that actually could have settled before,
- 55:02but nobody trusted the other side enough to make
- 55:06it happen. And so even though theoretically,
- 55:09our clients pay us to represent them and their
- 55:12interest and to settle cases and speak for them
- 55:14because of the lack of trust and sometimes communication
- 55:17between counsel. They bring in an additional
- 55:20layer of cost that is oftentimes worth its weight
- 55:23in sheer gold. So back to this question. Why
- 55:28is trust between the mediator and the party so
- 55:30important? And I've kind of talked a bit, a little
- 55:32bit, but we'll just spend a moment here. Actually
- 55:35note, we're still close to the end. I've talked
- 55:36about this. I'll skip the... the comments on
- 55:39this one. Here's the last point. Why won't the
- 55:44other side settle? Because they don't see the
- 55:46case like you do, because they don't value the
- 55:48case like you do, because they genuinely expect
- 55:51to prevail at trial, and because they want to
- 55:54get the best deal possible. When the other side
- 55:59doesn't settle, if they understand both The facts
- 56:04and the law, they value the case, they understand
- 56:06what it is, they're not missing some fact, but
- 56:08if they won't settle because they want the best
- 56:10deal possible, they are not negotiating the case.
- 56:15They are negotiating you. The price they're willing
- 56:20to pay or the price they're willing to settle
- 56:23for is what they think they can get from you.
- 56:25They're negotiating you. If that's their approach
- 56:27in settlement, the best deal possible. Sometimes
- 56:32parties employ hardball negotiation tactics in
- 56:37trying to get the best deal possible. But most
- 56:41parties, and this is based on years of experience,
- 56:44most parties are focused primarily on their own
- 56:47settlement needs, values, and goals, just statistically
- 56:51in the mediation that I've handled, which has
- 56:53been a lot by now. It's been since 2016. My runaway
- 56:58experience. is that most people are focused on
- 57:01their own settlement needs, values, and goals.
- 57:03There are some who are making their valuations,
- 57:07not their valuations, their demands based on
- 57:09what they think they can get from you. And that's
- 57:12the key thing. And there's an element of that
- 57:14in many mediations, granted, but kind of just
- 57:20generally. Most parties are focused on their
- 57:21own needs, values, and goals. That's not to say,
- 57:24however, that even if you're not having somebody
- 57:28who is basing their own numbers based on what
- 57:31they think they get from you primarily, that
- 57:32there isn't room for some good old -fashioned
- 57:34horse trading, you know? Of course there's some
- 57:37of that. Of course when you negotiate, nobody
- 57:39wants to leave money on the table if you're plaintiff.
- 57:41Nobody wants to give away the store if you're
- 57:43the defense. Nobody wants to do that. And a big
- 57:46part of what we do is based on what the other
- 57:47side has to say or what they're willing to do.
- 57:50Perfectly understandable, reasonable, legitimate.
- 57:53But if that becomes the whole basis, and you're
- 57:56willing to negotiate backwards to get there,
- 57:58It can be very, very frustrating. So let's talk
- 58:02about this. We got a couple minutes left. Why
- 58:04do planus sometimes come in with a sky -high
- 58:06opening demand? Most plaintiffs don't want to
- 58:38leave money on the table, but my experience is
- 58:44that when the plaintiffs come in with just a
- 58:47huge settlement demand, that's not because they're
- 58:50really planning to leave money on the table at
- 58:52that level. They know it's high. They know it's
- 58:55high. So yeah, they don't want to leave money
- 58:57on the table, but they want to set the range.
- 59:03They want to set the range. So this first one
- 59:04is... They want to get the range at the right
- 59:07level. And coupled with the second one, they're
- 59:09expecting a low defense offer. So they've got
- 59:11to have some room to negotiate. There can be
- 59:16situations, I think, where maybe some plaintiffs
- 59:19hope the defense will accept such a demand, but
- 59:22that's not my experience generally. Generally,
- 59:24it's these first two. They want to have some
- 59:27room to negotiate. They're trying to set up the
- 59:29range. And that's why we get sometimes these
- 59:31offers where people refuse to give an offer on
- 59:34the defense side, because they're not going to
- 59:35negotiate in that range. And then it's up to
- 59:38the mediator to see what you can do to find a
- 59:41range that's going to work for both sides to
- 59:43negotiate with them. Or you end up just trying
- 59:45to do this, trying to broker a deal with both
- 59:48sides to tell you what would it take. I know
- 59:50plaintiffs use their bottom line number for an
- 59:52opening demand. Because we're at time, I'm not
- 59:54going to take comments on this. I'll just review
- 59:56them briefly. Defense will think the plaintiff's
- 59:58true bottom line is something less, negotiate
- 1:00:00accordingly. Makes sense. Plaintiff doesn't want
- 1:00:03to leave money on the table. Makes sense. The
- 1:00:05plaintiff hopes to conduct negations that range
- 1:00:07higher than their bottom line. Yes, you can't
- 1:00:09use their bottom line because if you do your
- 1:00:12bottom line and then you're not going to move
- 1:00:14downward, the defense is going to think you're
- 1:00:15stonewalling. You know, it's a process of compromise.
- 1:00:19You're not going to compromise and they won't
- 1:00:21take you seriously. So the mediation fails. So
- 1:00:23the plaintiffs cannot come in. They cannot realistically
- 1:00:25come in with their bottom line number unless
- 1:00:27the defense is highly motivated at that number.
- 1:00:32I send out a monthly newsletter on mediation
- 1:00:35-related topics. If you'd like to be included,
- 1:00:39send me an email. Just say, add me to your newsletter,
- 1:00:41and I'll do that. We've come to the end of our
- 1:00:45program. And we have just a minute for takeaways
- 1:00:49and closing comments that I'll take here. And
- 1:00:52then I'm available to stay and answer any questions.
- 1:00:57This has been a webinar, so we haven't been able
- 1:00:59to take questions during the course of the program.
- 1:01:03But I'm available to stay for as long as people
- 1:01:05have questions and comments or anything you'd
- 1:01:07like to share here. It's been great being with
- 1:01:09you. Good luck to every one of you with your
- 1:01:13future negotiations and cases and may they all
- 1:01:15be successful All right, Robert. So it looks
- 1:01:19like we actually have a couple questions here
- 1:01:21our first question from Dana Green She asked
- 1:01:23if a mediator asked to meet with attorneys only
- 1:01:26because both sides are so far apart and an other
- 1:01:30side The other side refuses to meet. Is there
- 1:01:33anything you would recommend them doing? I can't
- 1:01:39tell from that question if it's a request to
- 1:01:42meet with both attorneys together or each attorney
- 1:01:46separately. And surely, if you have one side
- 1:01:49that will meet and one side that won't meet,
- 1:01:51it's going to be possible to meet separately
- 1:01:53with one side. I have had situations where I
- 1:01:59have met with both attorneys together. Those
- 1:02:02are the exception. Typically, people know what
- 1:02:06the other side's position is and so there's not
- 1:02:09a lot of need for that. When I've done that,
- 1:02:11typically it's been because there was a lot of
- 1:02:14material to cover or a lot of very technical
- 1:02:16information in that case and it's going to be
- 1:02:18a lot more efficient to have the attorney explain
- 1:02:21it if there was a question about that information
- 1:02:23or the technical pieces. So I'll bring the attorneys
- 1:02:25together so that they can get over that hump.
- 1:02:27It's usually a very discreet purpose or amount
- 1:02:30of information that I'm looking for when I bring
- 1:02:32them together. So I doubt this is the way with
- 1:02:35every mediator. I think it depends on the mediator's
- 1:02:38perspective on whether they have attorneys meet
- 1:02:40together separately outside the clients or together
- 1:02:44or separately, but mine is typically separately.
- 1:02:47And when I'm meeting separately with the attorneys,
- 1:02:51you know, if the client is in Never Never Land,
- 1:02:55The attorney may not ever tell you that and may
- 1:02:58have what might look like very unreasonable demands
- 1:03:00the other side that you can't figure out as a
- 1:03:01mediator. And if I sense that's happening or
- 1:03:04there's a problem between attorney and client,
- 1:03:07sometimes I'll ask the attorney if I can, and
- 1:03:09the client. I'll say, can I talk with your attorney
- 1:03:11separately? Of course, of course. And I'll say,
- 1:03:13the attorney can talk with you about everything
- 1:03:14we talked about when we come back in. I'll meet
- 1:03:16separately with the attorney and sometimes you
- 1:03:18learn about those things. That's not to take
- 1:03:21advantage of the client or to take advantage
- 1:03:23of one side. It's very based on need. And if
- 1:03:26you understand what the client needs, then you
- 1:03:28do your level best to see if you can accommodate
- 1:03:30that within the parameters of the case can yield,
- 1:03:33recognizing that not every case is based only
- 1:03:36on money. There's other things. So it can be
- 1:03:40very, very successful meeting with attorneys
- 1:03:42separately in caucus. I can't remember having
- 1:03:46very many situations where I've asked. or invited
- 1:03:49an attorney to meet with me separately where
- 1:03:51they refused. I'm sure it happens. It just hasn't
- 1:03:53happened very often to me. Okay, and then Jack
- 1:03:58Russo asks, when and how do you use quote unquote
- 1:04:02bracketing and when and how do you avoid it even
- 1:04:05if one side wants it and wants to get a mediator
- 1:04:08compromise? This really varies by mediator. A
- 1:04:14lot of mediators use mediators compromises a
- 1:04:16lot or mediators proposals a lot. I typically
- 1:04:20don't. I extended one recently, you know, because
- 1:04:24it seemed like the best thing to do. But what
- 1:04:27I do is I use a mediator's proposal device in
- 1:04:30almost every mediation. Instead of saying, okay,
- 1:04:35I'm going to give the mediator's proposal and
- 1:04:36then if both sides accept it, fine. If they don't,
- 1:04:38nobody knows. I will use that dynamic but without
- 1:04:42that kind of finality and I'll do it in the case
- 1:04:45in the situation of what if we could and I'll
- 1:04:47say I'll go to the one side and I'll say do you
- 1:04:50think if I could get this and what I'm trying
- 1:04:52to do is get a sense maybe on what might be possible
- 1:04:54the other side say if I could get up this would
- 1:04:56it do it and so I'm exploring kind of the same
- 1:04:59dynamic as a mediator's proposal without actually
- 1:05:02making the formal mediator's proposal now I'm
- 1:05:04not sure I addressed all the pieces of that question
- 1:05:06was there something more Let's see Bracketing
- 1:05:15how to win to avoid it and open side wants at
- 1:05:18once a mediator compromise. Hmm Oh Bracketing
- 1:05:24I didn't address the bracketing on the bracketing.
- 1:05:26Um, it's really a touchy feely situation I don't
- 1:05:29use them in every mediation. It really depends
- 1:05:32so You know, in one sense, bracketing is just
- 1:05:39accelerating the back and forth process. And
- 1:05:43if you can't get the parties to move, then you
- 1:05:48can start proposing brackets like this, or you
- 1:05:51can invite the parties to propose a bracket.
- 1:05:54And then you can talk about that with them. Say,
- 1:05:55well, I'm not sure you'd be able to do that if
- 1:05:57you don't think it's going to be well received.
- 1:05:58And maybe you can shape a bracket and present
- 1:06:01that. And people are sophisticated and experienced
- 1:06:03enough to know, well, you know, I'm looking at
- 1:06:05the midpoint of the bracket. Does that mean this
- 1:06:07is really what we're talking about? And if the
- 1:06:09other side says, you know, I'll do a bracket,
- 1:06:10but the midpoint is not going to be there, then
- 1:06:12you can communicate that. So sometimes it can
- 1:06:14be a good way to keep some momentum going. A
- 1:06:17lot of times I've had mediations where people
- 1:06:20just, it's just the wrong range and they just
- 1:06:22say, I'm just, I'm just not going to do it. But
- 1:06:23they don't give anything specific on what the
- 1:06:25other side would need to offer in order for them
- 1:06:28to come back and continue to mediate. So I've
- 1:06:31settled, I would say probably maybe 80 % of my
- 1:06:36cases go like this, demand offer, demand offer,
- 1:06:39settle, which seems almost impossible, but that's
- 1:06:43because I'm doing this exploration thing, which
- 1:06:44is lack of media's proposal without being in
- 1:06:46media's proposal in the background. It can be
- 1:06:49super, super effective. Is there another question?
- 1:06:53And I see we've got one on the screen here. Let's
- 1:06:56see. We actually have quite a few more as well
- 1:06:59in the Q &A box. Michael Schwimmer asked two
- 1:07:02questions. The first one, how can you determine
- 1:07:05who is driving the bus, council or client? And
- 1:07:08then his second question, what did you mean when
- 1:07:10you said don't get ahead of council? OK, I'm
- 1:07:15going to take the second piece on that first.
- 1:07:16Don't get ahead of council. You know, I would.
- 1:07:22What I meant by that is. I was talking in the
- 1:07:25context of things that you might be offering
- 1:07:27or suggesting, and you can't do that. You can't
- 1:07:33make promises on behalf of council. You can't
- 1:07:36give indications on behalf of council if the
- 1:07:38council isn't involved with that. That doesn't
- 1:07:40mean you can't say, well, what if I could get
- 1:07:43this? But you can't start saying the other side
- 1:07:46is going to do this or the other side. You have
- 1:07:48to get that kind of authorization from council
- 1:07:50before you can do that. You have to respect the
- 1:07:52council. You always have to. That was the second
- 1:07:54piece of this question. Remind me of the first
- 1:07:56part, please. The first one being, how can you
- 1:08:00determine who's driving the bus, counsel or client?
- 1:08:04You know, when I litigated, that was much harder
- 1:08:08to determine than since I started mediating.
- 1:08:11Because when you litigate, the only place you
- 1:08:13see the client is in deposition, and then you
- 1:08:16see them at trial. And so it's very, very hard.
- 1:08:18Deposition is such a highly structured and highly
- 1:08:21combative, you know, it's a tense situation.
- 1:08:23it's not easy to get a sense of who's driving
- 1:08:26the bus. So since becoming a mediator, when I'm
- 1:08:29a mediator and I'm involved in going to each
- 1:08:32room, some attorneys are very, very protective
- 1:08:36of their clients and they're just not gonna let
- 1:08:38their client talk. In those cases, the attorney's
- 1:08:40driving the bus. He's driving the bus, or at
- 1:08:43least I have to assume that because I don't have
- 1:08:44any indication of the client is. So what happens
- 1:08:46is, when I am, interacting with a room. I'm trying
- 1:08:55to direct my energy and my focus and my comments
- 1:08:59and my purpose to the person who's driving the
- 1:09:01bus. So you know there are some situations where
- 1:09:05the attorney has some significant client control
- 1:09:07issues. And sometimes the attorney feels a little
- 1:09:11bit at a loss or a little out of control, a little
- 1:09:14bit helpless sometimes. And they will never communicate
- 1:09:16that to the outside. But when you go in and you
- 1:09:19start talking with them, it's just the body language
- 1:09:22and the comments and you feel, or maybe if you
- 1:09:25sense something, you might talk separate with
- 1:09:27the counsel and you get a sense of this. And
- 1:09:29if that's the case. then I'm directing a lot
- 1:09:32of what I have to say to the client. Never, it's
- 1:09:34just not my style. Not in an oppressive way or
- 1:09:38an aggressive way with the client. I always respect
- 1:09:41the clients. But if the need is on behalf of
- 1:09:44the client and the attorney has maybe got some...
- 1:09:47some difficulty with client control, but sometimes
- 1:09:49the attorneys are very appreciative that you
- 1:09:50can sort of help them with their own client.
- 1:09:52And so I'm talking direct with the client, well,
- 1:09:54there's this and there's this, I'm sure you've
- 1:09:55talked with the attorney about this, but have
- 1:09:57you considered this? What about this? And this
- 1:09:58could go, and I have some concern about this
- 1:10:00and it might go this way. What about this? And
- 1:10:02you're really trying to either talk with the
- 1:10:05client about what the possibilities might be
- 1:10:06that it doesn't go right or that it goes wrong
- 1:10:08or that it can go right. I mean, all those things.
- 1:10:11And the interesting thing about mediation is,
- 1:10:14You know, you show up to a trial and it's structured.
- 1:10:17There's opening statement, you know, and then
- 1:10:19there's examine of the witnesses and then there's
- 1:10:20cross -examination and surrey -buttling. It's
- 1:10:22all very structured. You show up in a mediation.
- 1:10:24There's none of that. You just show up and it's
- 1:10:27literally, you just have to go. You just have
- 1:10:30to go and you have to start talking. And you
- 1:10:32have to figure out how you're gonna get to this
- 1:10:33where there's this well -developed dispute and
- 1:10:37understand what the dynamics are. And so even
- 1:10:39though in a mediation, I'm doing a ton of talking.
- 1:10:42I'm also just a huge sponge for information that's
- 1:10:46coming in. And you can get a sense. If the client's
- 1:10:50driving the bus, the way that they interact in
- 1:10:53the room, if they'll let you be in the room with
- 1:10:55them when they have some talks before they separate
- 1:10:57out and start talking about numbers, you can
- 1:10:58get a sense on who it is. And so literally what
- 1:11:01I'm doing at that point is I'm trying to understand
- 1:11:04what the client needs to see if I can get that.
- 1:11:07Because if I can't get what they need, then that's
- 1:11:09a roadblock. Okay, so it looks like we have another
- 1:11:20question Here Seth is asking how often do you
- 1:11:24find that the parties come back later in a case
- 1:11:26for a second mediation? And or are able to continue
- 1:11:30negotiations for weeks after mediation that doesn't
- 1:11:33immediately result in a settlement and eventually
- 1:11:36resolve the case That's a common experience and
- 1:11:40it depends, you know, I did I I've had several
- 1:11:44cases just recently Where where the follow -up
- 1:11:48was far more time intensive than the day of mediation?
- 1:11:51You know, so you do what you can at the mediation
- 1:11:54and at the parties are interested and it doesn't
- 1:11:56settle for whatever You know, frankly sometimes
- 1:12:00sometimes you'll do a mediation and everyone
- 1:12:02says well, you know It's not gonna work with
- 1:12:03we'll go to trial and so you think well, you
- 1:12:05know There doesn't seem to be a whole lot and
- 1:12:07maybe I'll follow up with those or sometimes
- 1:12:10Sometimes some time will go by and then you'll
- 1:12:13get a call from one of clients or I'm sorry,
- 1:12:15one of the council, and they'll say, you know,
- 1:12:17do you think if we did thus and such, we might
- 1:12:18get it? So what that says is people go back to
- 1:12:22their respective corners, they think about it.
- 1:12:25Maybe they weren't willing to do it day of mediation
- 1:12:27for whatever reason. They might not have had
- 1:12:28the settlement authority. If it's an insurance
- 1:12:30company, they might be rethinking it. Personality
- 1:12:32-wise, if it's a personal case, maybe they've
- 1:12:34gone back and talked with their friends, their
- 1:12:36spouse, with their family, whatever. Maybe they're
- 1:12:38rethinking this. So sometimes, There's subsequent
- 1:12:40contact by the one side. You really can't ever
- 1:12:44disclose that. I don't think, because I think
- 1:12:47it would be unfair to that party to make them
- 1:12:48look unduly weak. So you can't disclose that.
- 1:12:51But what that means is you just have to say,
- 1:12:52you know, some further communications with the
- 1:12:55party without signing to who initiated it, some
- 1:12:57further discussions. And what do you think about
- 1:13:00this? Or maybe you don't even take that. Say,
- 1:13:02you know what? I've been thinking about this
- 1:13:04case. I'd like to know, would you be willing
- 1:13:05to do this? So sometimes they can be very, very
- 1:13:08extensive. And I had one, I had an employment
- 1:13:11case a couple of months ago, hard fought, big
- 1:13:14money. And we got to, we did mediation and everyone
- 1:13:19was dug in. And I basically, you know, my wife
- 1:13:22likes to tease me that I'm like the pit bullterrier.
- 1:13:25I got ahold of it and I just didn't let go. And
- 1:13:28I just kept coming back. And most of the time,
- 1:13:32it's the way that I see mediation. I see tenacity
- 1:13:35is just about the hallmark quality. And And so
- 1:13:39I usually don't stop unless people say, we don't
- 1:13:41want to talk to you anymore. And now if we're
- 1:13:43not going to sell, we're going to go to trial.
- 1:13:44They tell me that, I stop. But if they don't,
- 1:13:47I'm back at them. And a lot of times, you can
- 1:13:50make it happen. But it depends. It depends on
- 1:13:52the case. Really, there's no future prospect.
- 1:13:54They don't want to have you talk further. And
- 1:13:56maybe they come back. Maybe they don't. OK. We
- 1:14:01still have two questions. What is the best way
- 1:14:05for a plaintiff's lawyer to get the mediator
- 1:14:07to treat policy limits as the floor rather than
- 1:14:10the ceiling of the settlement? You know, I've
- 1:14:24had mediations where the insurance company has
- 1:14:27paid over policy limits. And my experience is
- 1:14:32those are not easy. The insurance company hates
- 1:14:35to do it. They haven't typically come in and
- 1:14:38evaluated the case that way. There has to be
- 1:14:43really a very decent, legitimate risk of a bad
- 1:14:47faith claim by the insured in order to make that
- 1:14:51colorable. And so it's not easily done, but I
- 1:14:54have seen it done. So as the outset, as a general
- 1:14:58proposition, I don't see the... in most cases,
- 1:15:04the policy limits coming in just out of the blocks,
- 1:15:07the insurance adjuster showing up and saying,
- 1:15:08you know, we got this coverage limit, that's
- 1:15:10our starting point. It doesn't matter what the
- 1:15:13mediator says, that's just not going to happen
- 1:15:15in most cases. You know, they're going to come
- 1:15:16in, they're going to have their limits and they're
- 1:15:19going to be viewing that as the ceiling. And
- 1:15:22before that ceiling, they're going to be having
- 1:15:24whatever number the ground table has said of
- 1:15:27that, or whoever's been reviewing this case has
- 1:15:29said of that, and sometimes you can get past
- 1:15:31that. A lot of times you can, but that's what
- 1:15:33they're going to be doing to that. So if you're
- 1:15:34going to be looking past policy limits, it's
- 1:15:38going to be a fight, and there's got to be some
- 1:15:40pretty good backup to get there. That's my experience.
- 1:15:44All right, perfect. And I have one last question
- 1:15:46from our Q &A here. If because of historical
- 1:15:50experience of parties, at least if one party
- 1:15:52shows trust deficiency in other party in honoring
- 1:15:56a settlement. How, as a mediator, would you deal
- 1:16:00with that situation, I guess? If I can, I don't
- 1:16:05want to miss this one that's on the screen, and
- 1:16:07we haven't addressed that, so if I can, I'd like
- 1:16:09to address the ones on the screen, if I may,
- 1:16:10then come back. That's absolutely fine. This
- 1:16:13was helpful, and I'd like to know more about
- 1:16:16why is a brief more important if we should be
- 1:16:19relying on empathy and skills. to help move the
- 1:16:23mediation along isn't a brief, more dominarian.
- 1:16:32This is a really interesting question. You know,
- 1:16:42if you analyze the vibe and the flow of most
- 1:16:47mediations, at nine o 'clock or 10 o 'clock in
- 1:16:53the morning. We're still talking about cases
- 1:16:56or we're still talking about facts. And that
- 1:17:00might go for an hour or two or three or four,
- 1:17:02depending on how complex the case is. But by
- 1:17:06three o 'clock in the afternoon, you know, when
- 1:17:09the facts and the law are pretty well settled,
- 1:17:13Everybody knows what they are. You've worked
- 1:17:16through the differences. You've made your evaluations
- 1:17:18as to what they are. And so you're talking more
- 1:17:24on the emotional side and on the numbers side
- 1:17:26at that point of the day. And finally just comes
- 1:17:29down to a discussion of numbers pretty much or
- 1:17:31other non -monitor considerations. That's almost
- 1:17:33every mediation. So this is a great question
- 1:17:35when it's saying, why is a brief important if
- 1:17:38we're relying on empathy and skills? I'm gonna
- 1:17:42give answers in kind of several pieces on this.
- 1:17:46I think in the first piece, and I do not discount
- 1:17:49this, I think the party's expected, and I think
- 1:17:53the council expects it. And if it's a mediator,
- 1:17:56I came right in, and I completely dispensed with
- 1:17:59the brief, and the facts in the law, and I just
- 1:18:02started saying, you know, give me an on offer
- 1:18:03number, what's it gonna take? And I had mediations
- 1:18:06like that, where there was a real simple case,
- 1:18:09and within five minutes I was talking. numbers
- 1:18:11and demands and offers those are the big exception
- 1:18:14very simple case no issue about facts or law
- 1:18:17almost admitted liability very simple it's just
- 1:18:19all about the numbers very unusual but um i think
- 1:18:25the party's expected to talk about the substance
- 1:18:28i think the council expect it um i'm reading
- 1:18:33a book right now called never split the difference
- 1:18:36by a guy named chris loss it's he's a former
- 1:18:40FBI hostage negotiator. And it's absolutely fascinating.
- 1:18:45And his point in there is that these, he says,
- 1:18:48well, you know, split the difference. He says,
- 1:18:50so you come into a hostage situation, you've
- 1:18:51got four hostages, you have the lead negotiator
- 1:18:53for the FBI. What are you saying? Give us two
- 1:18:55hostages and we'll let you go to have a good
- 1:18:57day. He says, no. He says the hostage negotiator
- 1:19:01to be successful has to get everything of substance
- 1:19:05from the other side without giving really anything
- 1:19:08of substance in return. And that's the hallmark
- 1:19:11of these FBI negotiators. These empathy and skills,
- 1:19:19the way the mediation comes in, to be just brutally
- 1:19:23honest, is it's a real -time organic procedure.
- 1:19:29And you're evaluating what's coming in right
- 1:19:31now in real time from each side and evaluating
- 1:19:36What those emotions are and you have to be able
- 1:19:38to repeat it to mediate on this level It's not
- 1:19:42where you're just doing back and forth offers
- 1:19:44and the parties are doing all the work figuring
- 1:19:45out where the other side's at taking the temperature
- 1:19:47through offers counter offers If you're going
- 1:19:49to do this more difficult grade or type of mediation
- 1:19:53You have to be evaluating the parties and their
- 1:19:56council and evaluating the media and the skills
- 1:19:58and the emotions but the brief the brief is like
- 1:20:02it's the it sets the stage for all of that and
- 1:20:05If you've got one side that thinks, you know
- 1:20:07what, I've got this slam dunk piece of law, or
- 1:20:10this slam dunk facts, and that shapes my view
- 1:20:14of the case, and the other side doesn't know
- 1:20:16about it, then what you're shaping the rest of
- 1:20:17the day doesn't take that into account. So you've
- 1:20:19got a disparity there between how these two sides
- 1:20:21are valuing the case. So you have to spend the
- 1:20:24first part of the day in a case with any complexity,
- 1:20:27looking at the facts and the law, so you can
- 1:20:29come to some kind of understanding as to what
- 1:20:30it is, and both sides understands the other side's
- 1:20:32case. And then you start talking about what does
- 1:20:36this do at trial with a judge or jury? How do
- 1:20:39they do it? And this, of course, is the only
- 1:20:42opportunity that the clients get a chance to
- 1:20:44kind of tell their story. And we try not to spend
- 1:20:46too much time on that because it can show up
- 1:20:48a lot. But sometimes, excuse me, sometimes that's
- 1:20:51important. They want to be heard or sometimes
- 1:20:53you have even if they don't want to be heard.
- 1:20:55They need to be validated, especially with non
- 1:20:58-monetary considerations. But the briefs are
- 1:21:00the precursor. They're the foundation for all
- 1:21:02of it. So they're essential. I don't find the
- 1:21:05briefs domineering. It's just literally the starting
- 1:21:08point to try and get to a common set of facts
- 1:21:11and law so that we can argue it and discuss it
- 1:21:14from there. Back to you on the question. Next
- 1:21:16question. I'm sorry. You have to read it back
- 1:21:17to me again. Of course. All right. So this is
- 1:21:22a Question about context. How would you deal
- 1:21:25or a mediator deal with a situation? Where I'm
- 1:21:28looking at the historical context of the parties
- 1:21:31with one party Showing deficiency and trust of
- 1:21:36the other party for honoring a settlement Did
- 1:21:43you read that last part again, yes So One party
- 1:21:49shows a deficiency in trust of the other party
- 1:21:52in honoring a settlement. I'm assuming it's One
- 1:21:58party Doesn't have trust in the other regarding
- 1:22:01honoring of the settlement. I think is what the
- 1:22:03question is asking. Okay. Well, um, I This this
- 1:22:08is actually a not infrequent occurrence if I
- 1:22:11understand the question correctly the way I understand
- 1:22:13it. So what I'll address is How do you deal with
- 1:22:16it when there's a distrust between the two sides
- 1:22:18maybe in the way they're negotiating or maybe
- 1:22:21if you even get to a settlement about the other
- 1:22:24side is going to honor the settlement? I'll tell
- 1:22:27you what I do is when I was first at a law school
- 1:22:34and took one of my very first cases, we had a
- 1:22:39room full of attorneys and I had the smallest
- 1:22:41bit player in the whole room. And we negotiated
- 1:22:44all day, mediated all day, got to a settlement,
- 1:22:47the lead attorneys, you know, way my senior by
- 1:22:50many years, said, okay, we'll circulate an agreement
- 1:22:52next week. It'll be done. And I thought, that
- 1:22:53sounds great. It took a full year. And I said,
- 1:22:56I will never do that again. I said, it's just,
- 1:22:58it was miserable. I couldn't get it done. I'm
- 1:23:00just not gonna do it. And so what I did is for
- 1:23:0430 years, every time I did a settlement, I absolutely
- 1:23:09required the final form of settlement agreement
- 1:23:11be signed that day. And I litigated a lot of
- 1:23:14cases, and I never made an exception in 30 years.
- 1:23:18So I would take a settlement agreement with me,
- 1:23:20prepared, soft copy. Back in the old days, it'd
- 1:23:22be hard copy. But I never made an exception on
- 1:23:24that. And I could do that because I wasn't in
- 1:23:26these roomfuls of tons of attorneys. You can't
- 1:23:28do that. You can't control that. But my cases
- 1:23:30are typically ones where I could get it done.
- 1:23:32And so I would do that. I'd say, we're going
- 1:23:34to have a settlement agreement today. And we
- 1:23:35would do it. So I didn't have to rely on. And
- 1:23:38sometimes, you would have people come back after
- 1:23:41the fact and have buyer's remorse or talk to
- 1:23:43somebody and say, no, we want to rethink this.
- 1:23:45No, sorry, too late. We've got a settlement agreement.
- 1:23:47So you're not going to be able to do this in
- 1:23:49every case. But if it's a case where the decision
- 1:23:53makers are going to be present and there any
- 1:23:55reasonable possibility of getting a settlement
- 1:23:57agreement signed that day, I think it's great
- 1:23:59practice. They could take a settlement agreement
- 1:24:02that day so you can enlist the mediator, get
- 1:24:05their help in hammering out any remaining terms
- 1:24:07and get the ink on the deal before people start
- 1:24:09thinking about it or thinking I left money on
- 1:24:12the table or I gave away the store or my wife
- 1:24:14says I had to do this or my cousin says I had
- 1:24:16to do that. Just get the deal done that day.
- 1:24:18So that's, I think, one thing you can do really
- 1:24:20proactively is take a settlement agreement with
- 1:24:22you. It's hard to do because life is busy and
- 1:24:26litigation practice is busy. Sometimes there's
- 1:24:28not time, but If you can, it's great practice.
- 1:24:31And statistically, you're going to settle the
- 1:24:32case anyway. So you need a settlement agreement
- 1:24:34anyway. So it shouldn't be a waste of time. But
- 1:24:37that's one thing I think that you can do to try
- 1:24:39and deal with that. If you have a case where,
- 1:24:42for whatever reason, you can't ink a deal that
- 1:24:45day, you're at risk. You're at risk. And so,
- 1:24:49I mean, you don't want to not come to an agreement
- 1:24:51because you think they're not going to do it.
- 1:24:55I don't have a ready answer for that. I mean,
- 1:24:58you do the best you can. If you want to sign
- 1:25:01a term sheet, because that's all you can get,
- 1:25:03that's probably the fallback and the next best
- 1:25:06answer. But we all see from the advance sheets
- 1:25:08how many cases, reported cases, there are where
- 1:25:11people sign term sheets and then it blows up.
- 1:25:14So you do what you can. I don't have a silver
- 1:25:18bullet for that one. All right. Well, this concludes
- 1:25:24our questions today. Thank you so much for your
- 1:25:26time, Robert, and thank you to our audience for
- 1:25:29staying with us tonight. Everybody, I guess have
- 1:25:32a lovely rest of your evening. Thanks. Thanks
- 1:25:35very much for being here. You may be eligible
- 1:25:37for CLE credit in your state. Visit bhba .org
- 1:25:41slash podcasts for more information.