Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Manager Is New
Transcript
- Lucas: So you just got a new manager, and you've been doing great work for two years. You want a raise, but the person who's supposed to approve it has been in the seat for three weeks. What do you do? Luna: This is such a common situation. New managers inherit teams, and suddenly your performance history isn't obvious to the person who controls your salary. Lucas: Right. And the advice you hear online is often 'wait six months, let them see your work.' But that can cost you real money. So today we're going to talk about how to approach this deliberately, without sitting on your hands. Luna: And we have a concrete example. I read about a software engineer at a mid-size fintech who got a twelve percent raise six weeks after a new manager started. How did they pull that off? Lucas: They didn't ask right away. They spent the first two weeks building a relationship and understanding what the new manager cared about. Then they made a targeted ask. The key was timing and preparation. Luna: So the first step is really about the relationship, not the money. Lucas: Exactly. Your new manager doesn't know your reputation yet. They don't know the project you rescued last year. So your first job is to help them see you as a reliable, high-performing contributor. That starts with a one-on-one where you ask about their priorities, not pitch your raise. Luna: But how do you transition from 'I want to understand your priorities' to 'I deserve a raise' without feeling awkward? Lucas: You don't pivot in the same meeting. You plant a seed. Early on, you can mention that you're excited to keep growing in your role, and that you'd love to discuss your contributions and compensation once they've had a chance to see your work. That sets up a future conversation without pressuring anyone. Luna: So you're basically scheduling a future ask. I like that. Lucas: Yeah. And then you have to deliver. In the following weeks, you make your work visible. Not in a showy way, but concretely. You share wins in team channels, you volunteer for visible projects, you document your impact. You're giving your manager evidence to use when they go to bat for you. Luna: And what about the actual conversation? What do you say when it's time to ask? Lucas: You frame it as a partnership. Something like: 'I've been in this role for two years, and in the last year I've driven these outcomes. I'd like to align my compensation with that contribution. Can you help me understand what that would take?' You're asking for their help, not making a demand. Luna: But some managers might say, 'I don't have enough data yet to justify a raise.' How do you handle that? Lucas: That's where your preparation comes in. You bring the data. You bring your achievements, numbers, any positive feedback from clients or colleagues. You make it easy for them to say yes. And you can offer to help them craft the justification to their own manager. Luna: So you're almost doing their work for them. That's smart. Lucas: It's collaborative. You're saying, 'I know you're new here, and I know you don't want to look out of your depth. So I'll give you the ammunition to make a strong case for me.' Luna: That actually addresses a big concern: the new manager's own reputation. They don't want to be seen as overpaying someone they just met. Lucas: Right. So you have to make them feel safe. That means not just listing accomplishments, but tying them to the team's goals. Show how your raise is really about retaining a valuable asset who can help the new manager succeed. Luna: What if the new manager is younger or less experienced than you? Does that change the approach? Lucas: It can, but the core is the same. You want to be a partner, not a threat. You might soften the pitch: 'I'd love your guidance on how to position this with leadership.' That flips the dynamic — they're the expert, you're the one asking for help. Luna: So you're using their ego a little, but in a healthy way. Lucas: Exactly. And one more thing: timing. Don't ask in the first week, but also don't wait too long. If you wait six months, you've lost half a year of higher pay. The sweet spot is usually between three and six weeks, once you've had a few interactions and they've seen some of your work. Luna: But what if your new manager is just a middleman? The real decision-maker is above them. How do you handle that? Lucas: You still go through your manager, but you can hint at the bigger picture. 'I understand you need to discuss this with your leadership. Is there anything I can provide to help you make that case?' You're giving them a tool to use in their own negotiation. Luna: That makes sense. So you're almost coaching your manager on how to advocate for you. Lucas: Yeah, but gently. You don't want to sound like you're telling them their job. You're just making it easier for them to say yes. Luna: I think one of the biggest fears is rejection. If your new manager says no, does that hurt your relationship going forward? Lucas: It doesn't have to. You can frame it as a conversation, not a final answer. 'Is this something we can revisit in a few months? What would need to be true for that to happen?' That keeps the door open and shows you're long-term oriented. Luna: So you're turning a possible no into a roadmap for later. Lucas: Exactly. And if they're still reluctant, you can ask for alternative forms of compensation: a bonus, extra vacation days, a title change that positions you better for the future. There's often more flexibility than people assume. Luna: One thing we haven't touched on: what if you have a new manager because of a reorg, and your old manager left on bad terms? Does that change anything? Lucas: It can, but it also can be an opportunity. The new manager might be eager to build a positive culture, so they might be more open to rewarding high performers quickly. But you need to be careful not to trash your old manager. Focus on your contributions, not the drama. Luna: So keep it professional, keep it about your work. Lucas: Always. And here's a stat that might reassure you: a survey from the Society for Human Resource Management found that employees who ask for a raise get one about seventy percent of the time. And that number doesn't drop dramatically when the manager is new. It's all about how you make the case. Luna: That's a strong number. So it's worth the ask. Lucas: Absolutely. And look, this topic — building a case with a new manager — it's exactly the kind of situation where we hope we've helped you think more clearly. If you've ever gotten value from this show, and you want to keep it going ad-free, you can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, that link really does keep us going. We don't have ads, and it's because of listeners like you. Lucas: Thanks for that. Now, back to you. One more scenario: you've asked, you've made your case, and your new manager says 'I'll look into it.' What do you do next? Luna: That's the moment where you don't just let it drop. Lucas: Right. You follow up in a week or two. A simple 'I just wanted to check in on that conversation we had. Is there anything else you need from me?' That shows you're engaged, not pushy. Luna: And if it goes quiet for longer? Lucas: Then you set a specific time to revisit, maybe in thirty days. You put it on the calendar so it doesn't get lost. And if they still don't move, you might have your answer — at which point you can decide what that means for your next steps. Luna: So the ball stays in your court, even though they're the one deciding. Lucas: Exactly. The worst thing you can do is ask once and then never mention it again. You have to be a little bit persistent — politely, but consistently. Luna: I think the big takeaway is to treat your new manager as an ally, not a judge. You're bringing them into your corner. Lucas: That's the whole game. Build the relationship, give them the tools, and make it easy for them to say yes. Do that, and you've got a real shot at that raise.