Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Man or Bear
Transcript
- 0:00Paters Er listeners, we have a very special guest with us today. Kate
- 0:03Stu. Were an old friend of mine and someone who's been on the podcast
- 0:09since the very beginning. You came on early, maybe in twenty eleven or
- 0:14something to talk about flirting. You're a therapist, and we've also supervised supervise
- 0:22these therapists who are in training. Both. You have an agency in Seattle
- 0:28Modern Therapy, and you came on the podcast a long time ago to talk
- 0:35about flirting. You had flirting classes back then. You also came on the
- 0:39podcast talk about open relationships, and you had a manual for open relationships how
- 0:44to. And you emailed me recently and said you wanted to come on to
- 0:50talk about the man versus Bear debate. Welcome to the podcast, Kate.
- 0:55Thank you. Any other things I should be plugging before we forge ahead.
- 0:59Not at the moment. I will probably remember many things at the minute I'm
- 1:03in my car driving away, but not at the moment. Thank you.
- 1:04Well, so I thought we would watch the viral video in question, a
- 1:11TikTok video that had millions and millions of views in it. It sparked this
- 1:15whole debate, and then I'll throw to you and you can give me your
- 1:19thoughts on this. Okay, Would you rather be stuck in a forest with
- 1:23a man or a bear? Man is scary? With a bear? Well,
- 1:30I've heard about bears. They don't always attack you, right unless you
- 1:33like fuck with them? So maybe a bear probably depends what man? But
- 1:38probably a bear hundred percent of bear, which is like terrifying to say,
- 1:42but definitely a bear. Some men are very scary out there. A bear,
- 1:48I would say, I would say a man. So I don't know
- 1:52what your take is on this video. All you said to me over email
- 1:56was that you wanted to come on the podcast and talk about it. So
- 1:59I don't know if you're pro this or anti or nuanced. So what is
- 2:04your take? Wow? I would say thoughtful and curious more so because this
- 2:09could mean so many things going forward for culture as a whole. For one
- 2:15of the things I've been most concerned about is dating between men and women because
- 2:21I feel that it could really cause it could cause, you know, a
- 2:25population decline in a lot of ways, like we're already seeing what about you.
- 2:30Would you rather see a bear or a strange man in the woods?
- 2:36I can't. I don't even know. I mean, I think my first
- 2:39response as someone who lived through the Me Too movement and is has witnessed I
- 2:46don't even know how to describe it, but how culture has evolved since the
- 2:51Me Too movement, I would say probably a bear. But then again,
- 2:54I just as a person who is historically not willing to commit to an answer
- 3:00on any things as far as like I see the world in shades of gray,
- 3:04it's hard for me to say for certain, but I generally would say
- 3:06a bear. Yeah. So I didn't really know much about this event on
- 3:13TikTok. In fact, when you emailed me about this, you said,
- 3:15you know, are you talking about the man versus bear thing? And I
- 3:22responded to you over email and I said, oh, yeah, I've seen
- 3:25that because I recently on Reddit they asked a bunch of men do you think
- 3:30you can take on a bear if you were in a fight, And a
- 3:36strange amount of men said that they thought they could take a bear in a
- 3:39fight. They said that interesting. They thought they could beat the bear in
- 3:45a fight, and I thought that's ridiculous. One Two, It also kind
- 3:51of depends on the bear, because there's a lot of it. You got
- 3:53panda bears, you got grizzlies, you got black bears, You've got bears
- 4:02exactly, so you got water bears. Just joking. Those are like microscopic
- 4:08things. But yeah, it being in Seattle and growing up in the woods
- 4:15outside of Seattle, you know, we would see bears and certainly we would
- 4:19have to be on our toes. And in the seventies, that's all we
- 4:21did was spend time in the woods, and so like I remember one time
- 4:26me and my friends were just one friend. We were riding our bikes through
- 4:30the woods, and we came around this corner and there was bushes on either
- 4:33psyche, so you couldn't really see far, and all of a sudden,
- 4:38boom, there's a brown bear just right in front of us. And it
- 4:43was utterly terrifying. I can only imagine, you know. I turned around
- 4:47and I, you know, my friend was behind me, and I'm just
- 4:49like bear, and we just booked it. And I don't know if the
- 4:54bear chased us or ran the other direction or laughed at us. But but
- 4:58I wasn't going to stay around to find out because I knew that, you
- 5:01know, things skill badly. I didn't assume I was going to die in
- 5:04that moment. But you know, if you're told if the cubs are nearby,
- 5:10the bear might attack to defend the cubs, or if it just is
- 5:15startled, you know, and you're on a bike and you're covering around the
- 5:17corner and it thinks you're threats. Just in general, it'll attack. You
- 5:21know, Bears don't generally seek out humans to kill, unlike the movie Cocaine
- 5:28Bear. If you've seen that. Have you seen that movie? If not,
- 5:30but I can only imagine it. I don't know why I dragged my
- 5:33wife to that movie. I saw good reviews. It's not the sort of
- 5:36movie I would want to see, but it had good reviews, and I
- 5:40thought it would be different. But it is exactly what you think it would
- 5:43be. And you actually went to see it in the theater. I did.
- 5:46Yeah. Wow, it must have been one of those slow movie times
- 5:50when there's not a lot of good movies in the theater. But anyway,
- 5:55so to me, when I see I think it, you know, it
- 6:00this phenomenon of we just saw what was it like? And it's you know,
- 6:03it's anecdotal, but something like six or seven women and most of them,
- 6:09all except one, said they would rather run into a bear in the
- 6:11woods than a man, and it just brings so many things. And then
- 6:18I don't know if people don't know, this created a whole viral sensation and
- 6:21there were lots of response videos, and it had what you would imagine to
- 6:27be their responses. A lot of men saying that this is ridiculous and you're
- 6:30all misandristic, you all hate men, and you're just assuming all men,
- 6:36not all men, hashtag not all men, that kind of stuff. And
- 6:40then you have women saying you don't understand, you know what we go through,
- 6:46right, And that's like the real divide, like it's making. There
- 6:48was a somewhat of a divide, and now there's even more of a divide,
- 6:51right, So what sort of divide did you see? You know,
- 6:57it really seemed I have heard the threats I've heard in talking to people who
- 7:02are interested in dating, flirting classes, et cetera. I hear a lot
- 7:05about and we've all heard it like on apps on you know, internet dating
- 7:11women are getting so many of these unsolicited pictures and messages that say DTF and
- 7:18all of these things, and they're kind of becoming kind of turned off of
- 7:24that of that venue for meeting people right and and some and to some extent
- 7:30in person is not that much better. And then this comes out, and
- 7:33this so clearly highlights how women feel about men in general and about their degree
- 7:41of safety around men they don't know. And it is really, as I
- 7:46think, it, united women behind something very clearly like would you rather run
- 7:50into a bear in the woods. It's very it's not we're saying, oh,
- 7:56I'm second wave feminist, your first wave feminist, I'm you know this,
- 7:59or that. It really united women around this common, very simple question.
- 8:03And then I think what has even caused even more unification is the real
- 8:09strength or intensity of the responses that we're seeing from men, which are mostly
- 8:16that bearwoo Terry de Shred's what are you talking about? You hate all men?
- 8:20And I also think it is a case that we're not seeing the more
- 8:24reasonable responses from men, because that's not how the internet works. We see
- 8:28the worst. But given that it's causing women to really unite even more and
- 8:33double down, which is causing the more vocal men who are saying these things
- 8:37to kind of double down on that too. And as I think about this,
- 8:41I think, what does this mean for I hesitate to say heterosexual men
- 8:46and women, because it's more about women who date men and men who date
- 8:48women, right, because we don't know who all is dating who? What
- 8:52does this mean for dating in the future, Like, are we going to
- 8:54have people who are just decided to be celibate or not go into relationships because
- 9:00they are only interested in the opposite sex and just cannot relate to them.
- 9:05That's my concern as a person who thinks about relationships and what does that mean
- 9:09going forward? Yeah, that people would because of the way our society is
- 9:16and their experiences or maybe even the systems in place, like the way online
- 9:22dating can be, that people wouldn't get their needs met. They want a
- 9:26relationship or they want to have semi casual dating, but because of the landscape,
- 9:35they don't feel safe for viable reasons and will avoid that. That's what
- 9:39you're saying, right, And so I think it is there is a degree
- 9:45of this being about safety, but a lot of it is just feeling like
- 9:48they can trust I think on women's part, feeling like they can trust it
- 9:52if they interact with a man on an app or in person, that they
- 9:56will be like a kind person or just like a decent human there's that,
- 10:01right. I think there's a lot of that kind of just doubt, right.
- 10:05And I think the other thing that's problematic about this is it only takes
- 10:09one or two bad actors to really like poison the well in a way and
- 10:15make it so that, like I know, I had friends who were doing
- 10:18app dating and they would get three unsolicited pictures and a bunch of dtfs and
- 10:24then they're like, I don't want to do this anymore. And if you
- 10:26look at the statistics or the research, women have a lower degree of motivation
- 10:33to do to date in general, but also to use apps, whereas men
- 10:37have more. And you could say that's either because higher degree of interest in
- 10:41sex, or it could be because we haven't taught men to connect emotionally to
- 10:46each other as much. But I think it's kind of driving a wedge and
- 10:52it's going to be a lot more like we know about the in cell community,
- 10:58and we're going to wind up with women who are not exactly equivalent,
- 11:03but who are just saying it's too much trouble. I don't want to date
- 11:07if I'm only interested in men. So this brings a couple of things to
- 11:11mind. One is it reminds me of a similar so we say viral event
- 11:16that happened ten or fifteen years ago with Rebecca Watson. She is a podcaster
- 11:20and she is popular and was popular back then, and there was a convention
- 11:26in Vegas in which she was known to be there. It was a science
- 11:31convention and she's known as a science podcaster, and she was in the convention
- 11:35in the hotel and it was in the evening and she's going back up to
- 11:39her hotel room. She's getting in the elevator and there's a bunch of people
- 11:43in the elevator and people are getting off and there's left two people in the
- 11:50elevator, her and this guy. And the guy turns to her as they're
- 11:54going up in the elevator and says, you're Rebecca Watson and she's like oh
- 11:56yeah, and he's like, oh, I'm a big fan. She's like,
- 12:00oh, okay, thanks, and she'd been experiencing this, you know,
- 12:03all day long. And then he says, oh, you know,
- 12:07we're having a party in my hotel room. You should come. It'd be
- 12:13great if you could come. And she's like no, thanks or whatever,
- 12:18and then he gets off at his floor and then she continues up and then
- 12:22she gets off at her floor. She tweets her posts or something something to
- 12:26the effect of, Hey, guys, if you're in an elevator with a
- 12:31woman, don't interact with her in that or don't propose that she come back
- 12:35to your hotel room because it's scary. And the followers of her were a
- 12:43lot of guys, so it was not taken well, and a lot of
- 12:48people were like hashtag not all men, how dare you know? Because and
- 12:52she didn't claim there was any threats or any indication of creepiness or anything.
- 12:58The way she framed it, she's like, it could have been totally innocent.
- 13:03In fact, you know, she would follow up and say it likely
- 13:05was innocent, It likely was a real party, and he likely wasn't trying
- 13:11to rape me, but there's a percentage chance that he was. And if
- 13:16he had asked me downstairs before we got in the elevator, then that's different
- 13:22because I can run or scream, but I'm alone in an elevator with him,
- 13:26and it just is scary and ninety nine. In fact, even some
- 13:31famous men like I think Richard Dawkins, if you're familiar, you know,
- 13:35the scientist he even was refuting what she was saying, or what some people
- 13:41would say was attacking her for saying that that she's ridiculous and she's one of
- 13:48those misanderstick women that assume all men are rapists and all these guys are like,
- 13:56I'm not a rapist, and stop thinking of us as that. You
- 13:58know, it's threatening to a lot of men. So it's this is very
- 14:03similar in terms of the reaction. The thing that I mostly knew, but
- 14:11this really solidified it for me is that and I can kind of relate as
- 14:16a as a half Asian person. I'll just speak to that is like,
- 14:20I assume that most white people don't look at me and think racist thoughts or
- 14:28treat me in a racist way, you know, ninety nine. Especially in
- 14:31Seattle, it's a lot of half Asians and so in a lot of Asians.
- 14:35So I just figure, yeah, you know, chances are if I'm
- 14:37being treated poorly or if I'm around a white person, it's because someone just
- 14:43doesn't like you, not because of right, It's because I'm generally unlikable or
- 14:48something. Now, but or if I'm just in an elevator with a white
- 14:52person, you know, I'm just going to assume everything's fine. But the
- 14:56problem is is that if I am mistreue. If you know, I'm waiting
- 15:01for a table and a white couple walks in and they get the table first,
- 15:05and I don't have an explanation about it, there's you know, let's
- 15:09say a two percent chance that yeah, some racist thing just happened to me.
- 15:13Well, that two percent question mark is a lot of distress. And
- 15:20if you're a woman and you're in an elevator and you think, well,
- 15:26ninety eight percent chance this guy is not going to rate me. But let's
- 15:28says, say there's a two percent chance, and maybe the percent is even
- 15:33higher, I don't know, but let's say there's a two percent chance that
- 15:35he's going that he's about to kill me and rate me. Do you want
- 15:37to roll those dice? You don't want to roll those dice? And if
- 15:41you can ask men, please don't put me in a position to think about
- 15:45rolling those dice. You know, yes, I'm pretty sure you're not going
- 15:48to rate me. But on the off chance that you are, the consequences
- 15:54are so high that I'd rather not have that as a question in my head
- 15:58all day long. The way that it is, the way that it is
- 16:03for women. You know. Another venue where this happens is I'll be walking
- 16:07downtown, you know, maybe at night, and I just happen to come
- 16:11out of a place by myself, and I'm walking behind a woman that's walking
- 16:15by herself, you know, right, and I'm behind her, and because
- 16:19I have this awareness of what her experience might be, I don't know,
- 16:23maybe she cares about it, maybe she doesn't. But I'll hang back so
- 16:27I'm not like walking directly behind her, or I'll figure out a way to
- 16:32get in front of her, you know, so that she's behind it,
- 16:36you know, because I don't know the percentage chance, but there's a percentage
- 16:40chance that she is thinking about the percentage chance that I'm about to rape her.
- 16:44The question is where did you learn that? How did you learn that
- 16:45I listened to women? Okay, Okay, that's what I did. I
- 16:51as a man, can only relate sort of as a as an Asian.
- 16:56But it's not the same thing, right, But I can't. It doesn't
- 17:00it's not your life on the line, right, It's a different kind of
- 17:03a thing. Like I would get pulled over a lot in my youth and
- 17:10was pretty sure, particularly when I was outside Seattle. It was happening a
- 17:12lot more that it was because I looked brown or something and they just figured
- 17:18out or a guy. Maybe because I'm a guy. I don't know,
- 17:22but i'd be pulled over for the silliest of reasons. And so I can.
- 17:27But that's you know, that's not being raped and killed, right,
- 17:30it's But even if I hadn't had that experience, if I listened to women
- 17:37and believe what they're telling me, you know, then I think, oh
- 17:42that I have, I can't relate to that because I haven't been like that.
- 17:45But yeah, that would be tough. And so when you're asked man
- 17:49versus bear and someone's like, bear, I'd rather meet a bear in the
- 17:53middle of the woods, you know, people should listen to that, right
- 18:00I did. You. There's another video that was, if not necessarily this
- 18:04one, that was kind of what kicked off this whole debate, which was
- 18:10when someone asked a man, would you rather your daughter encounter a bear or
- 18:18a man in the woods, and he was not sure, he didn't not
- 18:19to answer that, and then they said a bear or a woman, and
- 18:22he said woman without So that's the other kind of aspect to that is in
- 18:27some setting. There was a man who who understood it and actually thought the
- 18:32same way because he was thinking about a woman who was in his family.
- 18:37Right, Yeah, you send me a number of articles and some other quotes.
- 18:42This is the article from Forbes that you sent me, an article by
- 18:45Connor Murray. And these are some quotes from women after they were elaborating upon
- 18:52saying they'd rather meet a bear. They say, quote, the worst thing
- 18:56the bear can do to me is kill me, you know, meaning the
- 19:02bear isn't going to traumatize me. Another quote, the bear doesn't get enjoyment
- 19:07out of it. I thought that was interesting, right, Like, the
- 19:11bear is just trying to protect If it does kill me, it's just a
- 19:17good reason. Yeah, it's like a reasonable reason from the bear's perspective.
- 19:22But there are men out there who are psychopathically, sadistically trying to target me
- 19:27or they've been told by society that it's okay to do this to me.
- 19:32And there's been a lot of TV shows about that recently, like what like
- 19:37about serial killers, like that, all of the true crime stuff that people
- 19:40were getting so obsessed with. Right, I think a lot of that backlash
- 19:44has to do of like the crisis of masculinity. I don't know if you've
- 19:47been following that, but there have definitely been some books about this. As
- 19:51equality feminism has progressed, the roles that men have are less defined, and
- 19:57a lot of men have struggled with that. And I think this is the
- 20:03more insecure men are not coping, and this is those what we're seeing are
- 20:10the men who are insecure responding. I think that's what I would say is
- 20:14a lot of the really strong kind of negative responses are from insecure men.
- 20:22Yeah, and it's understandable, but not a reason to go too far with
- 20:27it. But it's understandable that a lot of men are worried about being falsely
- 20:33accused of sexual harassment or rape or something, because the consequences can be so
- 20:38great, you know. And there are examples of people being falsely accused and
- 20:42their lives just completely fall apart because of that, you know. So it's
- 20:48an anxiety that some men have. I can tell you as a man,
- 20:52I don't have that anxiety because I guess I just trust My experience in the
- 20:56world tells me that I can trust people generally. For a lot of men
- 21:02when they start seeing me too, they are thinking, Oh, I've done
- 21:07stuff like that. What do I do? I don't know what to do.
- 21:11How about I just attack me too and attack women, which just you
- 21:14know, doubles down, you know. And there was a woman that did
- 21:18a TikTok about this, and she was saying that, look, I spoke
- 21:23out just in the comments about how I understand why women would rather see a
- 21:30bear than a man, and I had men who went after me in the
- 21:33comments section. Then I went to another platform. This isn't exactly I remember
- 21:38that one. Yeah, I went to another platform, and these same men
- 21:42followed me to this other platform and were continuing to attack me. Case and
- 21:48point, I know. But it's also I think it kind of highlights the
- 21:53need for a sense of like meaning or purpose. And I think that in
- 22:00the absence of other senses of meaning or purpose, that looks like a sense
- 22:04of meaning to those men who are following that woman, like, how dare
- 22:08you attack us? I will avenge our people kind of thing. Huh yeah,
- 22:12So what kind of meaning or purpose have been lost or could gain that
- 22:18would not result in this? So I think if I always think about like
- 22:23my grandparents, I don't know if what your relationship with either of your sense
- 22:27of grandparents was but my maternal grandparents I don't know my paternal paternal grandparents as
- 22:33well, but my maternal grandparents got married at like nineteen grandfather went to war,
- 22:38like started having kids at like twenty one, twenty two. Like there
- 22:41was no time for any of them to be thinking is this life meaningful to
- 22:47me? Is this am I fulfilled? Like it was just you're the dad,
- 22:51You go to work and make money, right, Like it was very
- 22:52It was so cut and dried. There was not a lot of variation.
- 22:56There was a lot of like roles were differ. Of course, power was
- 23:00more imbalanced, and so a lot of those men wouldn't have had time to
- 23:10chase this women down across all of these domains and say like how do you
- 23:12do this? But as as it has become that there are you know,
- 23:18two parents in working in homes, there are women can have all these jobs
- 23:22that men had, and there's more equality, women can afford to live on
- 23:29their own. There is less inherent meaning to just being a man and less
- 23:34inherent power, and so you have all these guys that are lacking meaning and
- 23:41purpose and feel insecure and also, yeah, perfect storm looking for some thing
- 23:47to do to give them purpose, and you have. Andrew Tate comes along
- 23:51and says, I'll give you purpose, and people want answers like you.
- 23:55Often hear people saying the reason why folks are drawn to religion is because it
- 24:00gives them answers to questions that can't answer. And I think this is the
- 24:03other thing. When people find Andrew Tate, they may be thinking, why
- 24:07can't I find why are women not approaching me? Why can't I find a
- 24:10partner? And Andrew Tate gives them an answer. It's not when we all
- 24:14agree with, but it's an answer, right. But I think that the
- 24:22man versus Baar thing highlights a lot of things independent of gender. I think.
- 24:27I think it also I don't know, but I think it highlights just
- 24:30how few people actually go into the woods and actually encounter encounter animals. You
- 24:37know what I mean? Because at Yellowstone and I'll see videos like this on
- 24:44Reddit of people will just walk right up to a buffalo, a bison and
- 24:51will take a selfie and try to pet it. Yeah, Or they'll see
- 24:56a moose and want to pet it, and then the moose will attack,
- 25:00you know. And it's just evidence that people just don't have a lot of
- 25:06experience. They're not stupid, they just haven't been told. They don't know.
- 25:11And you know, the vast majority of animal depictions that someone would see
- 25:15would be in cartoons or in loving depictions, you know, documentaries about oh,
- 25:21look at nature, everything's so nice. Yeah, right, you know,
- 25:26and you know, maybe for good reason, it's like, let's not
- 25:29be terrified of every single animal and kill them. Da da da. But
- 25:33at the same time, you know, they're animals, are wild animals,
- 25:37and you know they're capable of taking you out of this world. You know,
- 25:41we were not the top of the food pyramid fifty thousand years ago.
- 25:45You know, there were animals that would eat us, you know, cats
- 25:49and jaguars and stuff. I mean, I'm not saying that the women who
- 25:55are saying that they would rather run into a man, or they'd rather run
- 25:59into a bear than a man. I'm not saying that they don't understand the
- 26:03danger of a bear. I don't know that. But to me, if
- 26:07I was asked this question which would be weird, I would say it's not
- 26:11weird. Well, depends on the bear. There's a lot of different kinds
- 26:15of bears, you know, like one time I was in Jasper near bamf
- 26:19in Canada, and I was completely in the wilderness and there wasn't any civilization
- 26:26nearby, and I had to go to the bathroom, so I peed along
- 26:32the trail. I'm loving this. I'm loving this story so far. I
- 26:34mean, I don't know if that's bad, but I did. And I
- 26:40walked further down the trail, and I turned around at some point and I
- 26:45saw a black bear sniffing my peace spot. Whoa, but it was pretty
- 26:52far away. I didn't feel threatened by that black bear. If it wanted
- 26:56to kill me, it could have, but those kinds of bears typically aren't
- 27:02that ferocious. I had a pretty good distance between me and the bear,
- 27:07Whereas if it was a grizzly or a polar bear like, I would be
- 27:11running for my life, even though I knew the chance of it like running
- 27:15me down wouldn't be very high. If they were to ask me that question,
- 27:18I would have a very long answer in terms of like, depends on
- 27:22the bear. Sounds like a therapist, right, That's how therapists respond to
- 27:25things. Also depends on the dude. Depends on the context. If I'm
- 27:29solo and again, I'm not a woman, so I can't answer the question
- 27:32at all. But if I'm solo hiking and I see another solo hiker guy
- 27:38and we're passing each other in the woods, that's one context. Another one
- 27:44is I'm walking down a dark alley and there's a guy hiding in the shadows.
- 27:48You know, these are very different circumstances, right, if you're on
- 27:52the Pacific Coast Trail, I think that's what it's called, like in you're
- 27:55hiking by yourself, you were going to run into some men that are by
- 27:56themselves, right, It's like it is it is definitely a pretty like flat
- 28:03question and that there's not a lot of context or like real like detail to
- 28:08it. And you're right, like it does it does depend on where you're
- 28:11at or like. But I think that's the idea is like, if someone's
- 28:15just saying, we're not going to give you any detail, would you rather
- 28:18do this or do this? And I do think it's not I particularly it
- 28:22is useful in some context as far as just showing how many women will answer
- 28:26that question, but I don't think it actually is useful in that I don't
- 28:32think all of these women have ingen countered bears in the woods. But I
- 28:34don't know. I mean, I think it's it really does depend on like
- 28:38where you're at and what's happening, But yeah, exactly. I think it's
- 28:42also a litmus test for trauma, right if you have been harmed by men,
- 28:51and most women have, and that's that comes to mind, you know,
- 28:56if you ask people the question, man or most people have not had
- 29:02negative interactions with bears, whereas they have had negative reactions. Right then,
- 29:04right right. I think another thing that's illuminated by this question is that people
- 29:10are terrified of strangers in general. I think more and more, right,
- 29:12you know what I mean, Yes, that's not what the question is getting
- 29:15at, but I think that it does kind of illuminate that, don't you
- 29:19think it does? And as someone who has taught classes on flirting for a
- 29:23very long time, I talk to everybody and it's really interesting to see the
- 29:26reactions I get because some people are kind of like, what why I hear
- 29:30you talking to me? And some people just we'll talk. But it's not
- 29:33it's not as common, and I think that's as technology has advanced, we
- 29:38spend more time engaging in technology than we do with other people, which I
- 29:41mean, who who uses their phone and you want to actually call people.
- 29:45That's the thing I always say, because like, so it is it Also
- 29:48it does show like how comfortable feel with someone they don't know, and like
- 29:52how I don't know it really how people. It almost it says a lot
- 29:57more about like people experiences, Like I think a lot of people of color,
- 30:02like you said, might have a different kind of reaction to this versus
- 30:06like I think about myself. I was raised in an environment where there were
- 30:11not a lot of threats, So I have a different reaction to a lot
- 30:15of you know, people I don't know than other folks might because I have
- 30:18not been the victim of like hate crimes necessarily or things like that because of
- 30:23the color of my skin and where I grew up. Yeah. Right,
- 30:27It'd be a similar question to ask would you rather run into a bear or
- 30:33a police officer? Right? Yeah, that's actually a really good question.
- 30:36You ask anybody that, and I think you get some pretty interesting responses,
- 30:41you know what I mean. For some people that'd be like, well,
- 30:42a police officer, and some people are like, oh my god, that's
- 30:47really that would be a really interesting question to try to get out there as
- 30:49far as like what would people's responses to that be? So switching topics?
- 31:00Do you still teach your flirting classes? I do? Indeed, I just
- 31:03wrapped up the first in person class I've had in probably eight years. I
- 31:07think it's been because I did some online and then I just didn't do it
- 31:11for a while because I had a small child at home and then the pandemic
- 31:14and stuff. So if people wanted to sign up for that, where would
- 31:18they go? Flirting classes dot com? And so I've got another in person
- 31:23class happening in July and Seattle, and then I think in August we're going
- 31:29to do a online only version. And it is like sometimes you should come.
- 31:36You should definitely come sometime because it is like really heartwarming to see people
- 31:41like learn to become a little bit more confident, and even people who were
- 31:45really in their shells and then just come a little bit out of their shells.
- 31:48You know that that was a big deal for them, and it's just
- 31:52been It's like, it's always such an incredible thing to watch people grow over
- 31:56the course of what's essentially like three because we meet them and then there's three
- 32:00more meetings and it's just really it is really incredible. It's not even about
- 32:05like I'm teaching people how to floor. It's like a it's like this group
- 32:08therapy where people encourage each other to kind of like be more social and try
- 32:13new things and engage with people. Is often what it ends up really looking
- 32:16like, maybe telling them that they're not as repulsive as they think they are.
- 32:22Yeah, yes, definitely, and that someone would enjoy engaging with them
- 32:29and spending time with them. There are people out there who would. It
- 32:30reminds me of Swingers, the movie with Vince Vaughan going, You're so money,
- 32:37You're so money and you don't even know it. Do you remember that?
- 32:40Yes? So what do you do in this class? It really it's
- 32:45interesting because it sometimes changes a little bit from class to class. And historically
- 32:52I've had all of this curriculum that I have created, and we talk about
- 32:55specifics like where to go to meet people, like we talk about confidence,
- 32:59and there's all of us stuff. But what happens often is people will come
- 33:01in and they'll ask questions and they'll say, I don't know what to do.
- 33:06I saw this person I was interested in a bar, and I didn't
- 33:09know how to approach them. And then we'll all kind of come together and
- 33:12kind of say, okay, well where is the bathroom? Like could you
- 33:15try to talk to them after you go come back from the bathroom or things
- 33:17like that, and so we do. There's what usually is I always think
- 33:22of it's going to be like meaning that they could go to the bathroom and
- 33:24have kind of a pep talk to themselves or something. No, not necessarily,
- 33:28because what you'll notice in Seattle bars like kind of just in this area
- 33:32of Seattle is or anywhere people are trying to meet someone, they're all like
- 33:37these little tables that are all kind of separate. Whereas if you go to
- 33:42other places like La I guess New York places like that, people are mingling
- 33:47right or they're playing the hanging out. Catch them as they're coming back from
- 33:52the bathroom or like they're in a booth, or they're at a table,
- 33:55or they're standing somewhere. So you go somewhere and then you caress them.
- 34:00Do you think of what what I say to this person? Would I say
- 34:01like, oh, who's winning this game of pool? Or something like that?
- 34:07And then we go over a lot of kind of we talk about what
- 34:09flirting is. And then after coming back from that. So at the end
- 34:14of the class we do we practice, which is really fun because it's a
- 34:16lot like improv. Like we have people get up in front of class and
- 34:20we'll say, Okay. The thing I always say is I'm going to give
- 34:22you two minutes to start a conversation and close it. And what that entails
- 34:29is someone has to start a conversation and then when they close it, they
- 34:32have to get some sort of contact information or something in order to kind of
- 34:36continue it. And I want to preface this by saying I don't necessarily view
- 34:39flirting as being like an ends based, like goal based kind of activity.
- 34:45I think it's more of like a way of life and interacting with people.
- 34:49But knowing that most people are trying to flirt in order to meet someone to
- 34:52date, we kind of look at it from that perspective. But we'll pick
- 34:55two people out and we'll say, okay, everybody where, what's happening?
- 35:00Where are they flirting? And people will say they're at a show, and
- 35:02I'll say what kind of show? Country music? They're seeing? A country
- 35:07show? And two people will be up here, And it's interesting because it's
- 35:09often not the two not two genders of people who would be sexually attracted to
- 35:15each other. So it'll be like two straight men or you know, straight
- 35:19women or things like this, and we'll say like, okay, you're in
- 35:23you're at this you're at this country show. And I'll say okay, Joe,
- 35:28you start, and Joe walks up to Jeff you know, and says,
- 35:31oh this do you like this band? And they're like, oh yeah,
- 35:34they've seen it before. And then they'll say like, yeah, some
- 35:37something you know when they were playing at this place. And then I'll say
- 35:40like, okay, wrap up, because because I'm trying to get people to
- 35:44be able to do this in two minutes so that when they have more time,
- 35:47they can still do it. But if they have to do it quickly,
- 35:50like in an elevator, they'll find a way to kind of make it
- 35:52work if they're trained to do it quickly, if we're you know, doing
- 35:57drills. And then they'll say like, oh, well, I heard they're
- 35:59playing again next week at blah blah blah. Do you want to come?
- 36:01And then we wrap it up like that. And we've had people in museums,
- 36:06we've had we've had settings where it's someone's in a grocery store, they're
- 36:08looking at cereal and to see people go through the whole process and people will
- 36:13surprise you too, which is really fascinating that people who don't talk at all
- 36:16will get up and they'll have a whole conversation and they'll look kind of comfortable,
- 36:20and it's like everyone's just like clapping afterwards, like wow, I didn't
- 36:23think that was going to happen. And it's like TV. It's like reality
- 36:28TV but better. It's really it's pretty incredible. Yeah, so what do
- 36:34you hear from them after the class? Do you hear from them after?
- 36:37I do? And we also this last class was really fun because we had
- 36:42a couple. We had an entire family that met in twenty eleven flirting one
- 36:45on one class. They met as a man and a woman met in class,
- 36:51and they have a son. They got married. The whole relationship happened,
- 36:54and it's no weel framed. She's a senator and I always like to
- 36:59yeah, she is senator, she's a friend of mine. You don't know,
- 37:02well, I did not know that they met in your class. I'm
- 37:07surprised you didn't know that. How do you know know? Well, we
- 37:12go way back. I feel like I'm made on her for fifteen years this
- 37:16or something. But and you never asked her where she met. She must
- 37:22have told me at some point she In fact, she just emailed me the
- 37:25other day. That is really funny. But yeah, did she email you
- 37:29about like I was a fundraiser for her friend. I got that emailed right.
- 37:34But she came to class and like, and she guest helped with like
- 37:38we had people practicing, and she was I wonder if she found out about
- 37:40your class through the podcast. Maybe because she listened to the podcast back then.
- 37:45She I mean, she knew about the podcast back then. So I
- 37:49like to give her such a hard time. I'm like, when she came
- 37:52to class, I was like, this child should have been named after me,
- 37:53but wasn't. And I would like to know the next child is going
- 37:58to be named after me? Uh huh. Okay, well, so success
- 38:02story there. You also emailed me initially about another topic, Yes, about
- 38:09the Washington laws, State of Washington laws about sexual harassment, sexual misconduct,
- 38:16sexual okay, sexual misconduct okay. So there's a sexual misconduct WHACK and there's
- 38:23a general professional misconduct RCW. So WHACK stands for Washington Administrative Codes. Was
- 38:30our laws and then the Revised Code of Washington RCWS that these are all statutes
- 38:35and laws, they're the laws of our land. For you, you were
- 38:38saying you were trying to revise it somehow update it. Yes, I have
- 38:45worked for many years with the sex positive community. So these are people who
- 38:49are kinky identified, polye non monogamous. It's an interesting kind of umbrella term
- 38:55that could cover a kind of small group activities or interest behaviors, whatever you
- 39:01want to call it, or a much bigger kind of range of interests.
- 39:07But the sex positive population is kinky identified people and people who often have different
- 39:12types of relationship orientations than just monogamous and in i'm one of my kind of
- 39:22areas of interest is erotic counter transference and erotic transference as well, and I
- 39:27think it's not and for anyone who doesn't know, erotic transference is when clients
- 39:31have sexual feelings toward their therapists or romantic and then erotic counter transference is when
- 39:37therapists have those feelings toward their clients. And the what I was so,
- 39:46the thing about erotic counter transference, it's really interesting is nobody talks about it,
- 39:52but there's tons of misconduct where people are having sex with their clients.
- 39:55Yeah, I have, not only as a supervisor and professor or bad and
- 40:00as a therapist, but as a podcaster. I've been talking about it for
- 40:02good for you years and years and years. And that's always what I'm saying,
- 40:07is that even though done research and we've been talking about it for over
- 40:12one hundred years, it goes back to Freud and young and all those people.
- 40:15We barely talk about it. Now. You can go through graduate school
- 40:19and have it never come up in class or anything, and it's ridiculous.
- 40:24And then you have all these therapists that will experience erotic countertransference and have absolutely
- 40:30no idea what they're doing, or they get very simplistic advice from or just
- 40:35really bad advice right from colleagues, and it results in harm to clients and
- 40:39like very easily fixable situations that just have no guidance, or they'll stuff their
- 40:47feelings and then bad things happen from there, and then bad things that happen
- 40:52to clients. I think it's important to note is not always a therapist has
- 40:54sex with our client. It is a therapist feels this and then is terrified
- 40:59and just immediately says I can't work with you anymore. Doesn't do the effective
- 41:02work of saying, you know, I let's you know, finalize this and
- 41:07I'll transition you to someone else because of a conflict or whatever. Someone would
- 41:10say, yeah, I mean you go on read it, for example,
- 41:14and you'll see good advice and bad advice. And some people will say,
- 41:17you know, if someone said I have erotic counter transference, they wouldn't word
- 41:22it that way because I don't even they don't even know that the terminology.
- 41:25And a lot of people will say, oh, you have to terminate,
- 41:28you have to refer out. You know, it's everyone's answered everything. It's
- 41:31sort of analogous to whenever you might complain about your job or your marriage,
- 41:37bad bad friends will say like we'll get a divorce or quit or something.
- 41:42It's like, oh, thanks, Sherlock, I didn't know that was a
- 41:44post. I don't think that's bad advice or bad friends. I think that
- 41:46as people who can't deal with the discomfort of seeing their friend being happy.
- 41:50Right, it's an easy answer for their for their anxiety as a listener,
- 41:53Right, it's like, if you just end that, then I don't have
- 41:55to deal with this speaking right, right, So, uh, you are
- 42:00wanting to revise the laws of watches because I think what's really interesting about this
- 42:06is obviously the sexual misconduct code is there and has been there for a while
- 42:12because it is very damaging to have sex with your clients. This is no
- 42:15one's doubting this. But what I think is more recent is the kind of
- 42:21visibility of kinky activities, behaviors, relationships, and also, like polyamory is
- 42:28is still pretty new, but polyamory doesn't exactly it's not as important in this
- 42:32particular issue, But there have been cases of therapists entering into kink related relationships
- 42:39with clients, right. And what's interesting is some of these kink related relationships
- 42:45don't involve sex or any kind of contact, but they can still be in
- 42:51incredibly impactful because of the emotional impact, right, that happens and could potentially
- 42:55be more impactful than having sex with a client, although that a lot I
- 43:00could. There's that's up for debate depending on who you ask. But what
- 43:04I had had really been thinking about is there are some of these relationships that
- 43:08would really show up as misconduct, but they would not show up a sexual
- 43:13misconduct. So Kate let me get this straight. Let me get this straight,
- 43:16Kate. You're saying that you would like the laws of Washington State to
- 43:24be changed and or clarified to allow for therapeutic erotic activities within therapy. No,
- 43:35the thing that what I wanted was for. So there's there's sexual misconduct,
- 43:40which is because that is such a big issue, it's its own kind
- 43:45of branch of misconduct. And then there's like more's general misconduct. But what
- 43:49I wanted to see happen in the sexual misconduct rules is more language specifically calling
- 43:55out any like kink related behaviors, kink activities, roles, relationships. If
- 44:02you want those to be legalized or you want them to be illegal, I
- 44:07want them to be illegal, and I want them to be illegal to the
- 44:10level that sexual misconduct is illegal, which is really the most I think,
- 44:16highest profile. It's hard to say the most illegal versus the least illegal,
- 44:21but is taken the most seriously because like, if you enter into a BDSM
- 44:28relationship with your therapists, that could have impacts that are as negative as life
- 44:35altering as having sex with your therapist. Right right, There's so many of
- 44:38these roles in these activities and these kink related behaviors that I think have such
- 44:47a dramatic impact and can have Like we think about oxytocin and how what's happening
- 44:53in people's brains, like what emotionally is happening in these relationships, and it
- 45:00is very it is akin to what can happen in sexual relationships and beyond.
- 45:07That's interesting. Yeah, I hadn't thought about that, but that makes a
- 45:09lot of sense that it would at very least need to be discussed and decided
- 45:14upon ethically and legally in our field, because up until recently, it wouldn't
- 45:20have been something that would be likely to happen in therapy. But with the
- 45:25increase in sex positivity in our culture and in our field, and I think
- 45:31particularly in Seattle, since we're known as a sort of a mecha for that
- 45:36kind of thing, then you're going to see therapist therapists who will say,
- 45:42well, I'm not having sex with my client, and I want to be
- 45:45sex positive and I'm involved in these kink related things in my personal life and
- 45:52i want to use them. You know, Like I'm thinking someone would,
- 45:55well, what would be a kink that you'd be concerned about being used in
- 46:00therapy that is a really and it's not necessarily the one hundred percent that is
- 46:06happening in therapy, but more that people recognize therapists recognize that they can't just
- 46:14say, Okay, we're going to stop therapy and we are going to start
- 46:16a daddy daughter little girl relationship where I interact with you as this parent figure,
- 46:23right or like dominant submissive relationships, there's a lot of those that I
- 46:31think could cause a lot of harm because therapists are in roles that are so
- 46:37trusted that I mean, I think there's a whole range. I mean,
- 46:40there's a lot of things in them. Submissive, like financial domination obviously,
- 46:47which is involving money, which has kind of a different level. And then
- 46:52I do think like there, I mean, there are some acts that involve
- 46:58blood being spilled, and I think about like there's all I mean, who
- 47:01even you can go through a whole list of other risks associated with that,
- 47:06and there's just so much of Sometimes these kinks interact with trauma in a way
- 47:14that can be so reparative, it can also kind of re enact trauma.
- 47:19It really depends on who's doing it. And I think we need to make
- 47:22this as far off limits as possible so that it doesn't so and I think,
- 47:29like you had said at one point, like for people to think,
- 47:31oh, this is okay because I'm not having sex with them, is we
- 47:35need to make sure that's not what people are thinking. And also when people
- 47:39are kind of sliding into misconduct of like violating boundaries or like even sexual misconduct,
- 47:47a lot of times that happens is because people are slipping down this very
- 47:52slippery slope, one tiny increment at a time. And I think in kind
- 47:55of the kink world, it could be the case that someone is like,
- 48:00well, this is at least it's not sex, it's not sex, or
- 48:02this could be really helpful for them, and not really taking into account like
- 48:07the harm that could be possible, right, because it's not P and V.
- 48:12Right. But you're perfect to spearhead this because your agency, Modern Therapist
- 48:20sattle Is, has been from the beginning and still is sex positive and advertises
- 48:24itself that way, not only for sex positivity and kink, but also for
- 48:30polyamory. And you're perfect for this job because you know it and are familiar
- 48:37with the concepts, and what you're saying is that it's post therapeutic relationship where
- 48:45there will be conversations and then the therapist is thinking, Okay, well,
- 48:50if we're going to start doing this, we have to end the relationship.
- 48:52And there can be some dubiousness to that, right, because the therapists and
- 48:58client could be officially on paper ending the therapeutic relationship, but they're not really
- 49:02ending. They're just doing it to jump through what they believe to be an
- 49:07ethical and legal hoop that they have to jump through. But the therapeutic relationship
- 49:09is essentially still continuing, and that could be a problem, of course.
- 49:13But when people officially terminate and you know, five years later they meet in
- 49:21a kink activity that isn't illegal, it's not even necessarily unethical, there's a
- 49:27lot of it happens, and it happens, and there's a lot you know,
- 49:30the king community can be pretty small at times, and if you're a
- 49:34kink friendly therapist, there's a chance that you're into kink yourself, right,
- 49:37Like, think about the Seattle Erotic Arts Festival. There's a lot of therapists,
- 49:44There are plenty of therapists who go to that, and also so many
- 49:46like kinky people wind up there too, So like, even just thinking about
- 49:51that, yeah, if people follow us on Instagram or Facebook, you might
- 49:55have seen last year me and my wife sitting on a penis that was at
- 50:02the Erotic Art Festival. There you go. My favorite part of the last
- 50:07year's Erotic Art Festival was there was a bunch of sculptures that were erotic in
- 50:15nature, you know, stone granite would sculptures and yeah, like you know,
- 50:22penis is a vagina's bodies. And the activity was that you were given
- 50:29the opportunity to be blindfolded and then a guide would walk you from sculpture to
- 50:36sculpture and all the sculptures were locked down and you could encounter the sculpture from
- 50:43just by feeling it, you know. And the Erotic Arts Festival there's a
- 50:45lot of like music and drinks and that, you know, there's a lot
- 50:49of loudness, so it's not like you're on stage, you know, you're
- 50:52it's darker. It's sort of like a club feel at night. Anyway,
- 50:55And so Stacy and I did this and it was a trip. You know,
- 51:00it was so interesting. I mean, one just to try to imagine
- 51:04a physical object in your head as you're just touching it, but also the
- 51:08guide would have to touch us, you know, because she didn't want us
- 51:14to run into anything, you know, so she's guiding us around. She's
- 51:19sort of like a mother figure, and that she would guide our hands,
- 51:22you know, by holding our hands, and it was it was a really
- 51:29magical experience. Highly recommend But anyway, so you're saying that you want the
- 51:35laws to because currently it's not necessarily illegal to have sex after you terminate a
- 51:40relationship with a client. They make it very complicated though, because if the
- 51:45client can say they were harmed at any point in time after I mean basically
- 51:52after you meet them for even a consult, if you have sex with that
- 51:54person, even if they only have a consult and then they and then twenty
- 51:59year later you have sex with them, even at that you can still be
- 52:02on the hook for that. So it's one of those things I think they've
- 52:06left. I am surprised the State of Washington has left some wiggle room there
- 52:09because I would assume they would just say, like you, you can't do
- 52:13this at all. But I actually know two or three people who married their
- 52:16therapists, not therapists who married their clients, but people who married their therapist.
- 52:21Yeah, it's common. They don't usually advertise it. Imagine that the
- 52:25therapists don't usually advertise it. Yeah, I mean, the more I learned
- 52:31from attorneys, the more I learned that the law is necessarily vague because every
- 52:38case is different, and they don't want to be draconian and just draw a
- 52:45line around things because you know, it depends, you know. Like,
- 52:50let's say that they did draw a line and say that once a client,
- 52:53always a client, so you can never have sex with them. You have
- 52:58one session with a client, twenty years later, you meet them, Neither
- 53:02one of you remembers the fact that you had that one session years ago,
- 53:07and you have sex, and then another person finds out about the sex and
- 53:12is jealous and upset and decides to alert the police that the therapist, you
- 53:19know what I mean, And then that therapist goes to jail because it's against
- 53:22the law. You know. That's an extreme case, of course, and
- 53:24I'm not advocating for therapists to have you know, to me, once a
- 53:29client, always a client, I would never encourage, and I certainly would
- 53:32never do this. If I did meet a client, I would never engage
- 53:37in anything along those lines. I always look incredibly startled and run away,
- 53:42which is like the hilarious thing because if I don't, if I don't immediately
- 53:45leave, I will hug people and forget that I'm not supposed to be excited
- 53:49to see them. So that's a yeah. So it's interesting that you're working
- 53:53on that. Where are you in that process? So you will? You
- 53:59can take one guess and imagine who it is. Who is who offered to
- 54:02help me with this? And yeah. I emailed Senator Frame and I said,
- 54:08can you help me with this? I don't know. I can't get
- 54:09anyone else to respond. I can't get any of my personal representatives or senators
- 54:15to respond to me. And she said, oh, yeah, send it
- 54:17to me. I'll, I'll, she said, her legislative assistant really likes
- 54:21that kind of stuff. So I'm what I'm assuming will happen is that we
- 54:28look at this for the next session, which would be next year. And
- 54:32I don't know that I actually told you this when earlier this year in January,
- 54:37some lawyer out of Norware sent me a link to a bill that would
- 54:45make consensual choking illegal, make it a crime consensual choking, And I was
- 54:52like, why did someone send this to me in the first place? But
- 54:54I think it was someone who worked with it was like a criminal like work
- 55:00criminal defense, and I would imagine he found it and was like, well,
- 55:02someone needs to do something about this. It's funny because I think the
- 55:06reason that this wound up in my inbox is because I set up sex Positive
- 55:10Washington, which is a sex positive group for healthcare providers just to have listings
- 55:16on it and things like that, and seeing that patients and clients could find
- 55:22clinicians right right right, And so that's how this wound up with me.
- 55:27And then I was like, I have to I have to testify this hearing
- 55:31when this goes into hearing, when this bill goes into hearing, because like
- 55:35I just I don't agree with this, and someone needs to be advocating for
- 55:37this the other side of it, right, And you're not going to find
- 55:39a lot of politicians or lobbyists that are going to stick their neck out on
- 55:45this, right, So yeah, someone's got to do it. So I
- 55:50think what happened is they saw Kate Suwart Sex Positive Washington and we're like,
- 55:53oh God, we don't want a TVW He's going to turn into a circus
- 55:57if we like let this person who obviously you know, going to talk about
- 56:01people consensual sex and things like that in like this you know, hearing room
- 56:06in the legislative building. They were probably like, oh, we don't want
- 56:09it, that's we just don't and so they just immediately yanked it and then
- 56:13it just didn't go through open. I didn't even get to go to the
- 56:15hearing, which I was like, really wow. I mean like you're like
- 56:20in Godfather when the brother arrived, just his presence in the hearing just shut
- 56:28the whole thing down. You know, that's a weird reference, but that's
- 56:30what I thought of, was like, just just your just your present.
- 56:34You didn't even have to say anything. It was just like, oh,
- 56:36god, Keith's on the case, pull the bill, pull a weird kind
- 56:40of superhero. Yeah. But man, if anything happens along these lines,
- 56:45you got to come back on the podcast. I would happy maybe you could
- 56:50get me and know well yeah yeah, yeah, yeah, Well thanks for
- 56:54coming on the podcast, Kate. As always, it's it's great to see
- 56:59you. And if people want to find you, they can go to Modern
- 57:04Therapy Seattle, which is a sex positive group practice. A lot of my
- 57:10supervises and friends and colleagues have worked for you and have loved it there and
- 57:16have stayed on and it's been a wonderful group practice to recommend to people.
- 57:24And you've helped so many people because you know, therapists and l are generally
- 57:30sex positive whether they know it or not. But it's another thing to be
- 57:34trained and supervised and equipped and competent in that area. It's not just for
- 57:40kink and BDSM, it's just for all of us. We all need sex
- 57:45positivity in our lives. And also people can find you where else Flirtingclasses dot
- 57:52com and that is basically it for now. Okay, and everyone out there,
- 57:58please take care of yourself. Why should be will take care of themselves?
- 58:00Uh? For their mental health