Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Badger Meter Q3 2025 Deep Dive: Wonderful Company, Terrible Price
Transcript
- 0:00OK, Welcome back, everyone. Today we're tackling a really
- 0:04interesting situation, the classic quality versus price
- 0:07dilemma. We're doing a deep dive into
- 0:10Badger Meter Inc, you know, BMI, they're a big name in smart
- 0:14water technology. We've got the latest financials
- 0:17here, Q32025, and frankly, the numbers look, well, pretty
- 0:22fantastic on the surface. They really do.
- 0:24Performance seems excellent. You look at total sales, $235.7
- 0:28million for the quarter, that's up 13% from last year.
- 0:31And it's not just random growth, right?
- 0:33The sources say it's broad based demand.
- 0:35Exactly, it's driven by their digital smart water solutions.
- 0:37Seems like utilities are really buy into it.
- 0:39And the bottom line followed. Yep, diluted EPS earnings per
- 0:42share hit $1.19. That's up 10% year over year and
- 0:46beat what the analysts were expecting.
- 0:48OK, strong quarter, but you know for long term investors the real
- 0:51signal often isn't just one quarter, it's the pattern and
- 0:54you pointed out something key about the dividend.
- 0:56Yes, that's the kind of thing you look for.
- 0:58BMI just raised its dividend again.
- 1:00That makes it 33 consecutive years of increases.
- 1:03Already three years. In this industry, that kind of
- 1:06consistency, it just screams durability.
- 1:10It tells you management is focused on generating cash year
- 1:13in, year out. It's well, it's the hallmark of
- 1:15a high quality operation. So quality seems undeniable
- 1:19here. Great track record, strong
- 1:21current results, but like we always say, quality usually
- 1:24doesn't come cheap. That's the rub.
- 1:27So our mission today is clear. We need to take this Buffett
- 1:30style checklist approach, plus the DCF analysis that's in these
- 1:34source materials you sent over, and figure out if this clearly
- 1:38wonderful company is actually trading at a wonderful price for
- 1:42someone looking for value. That's the core question.
- 1:44We'll look at the business model, its strengths and then,
- 1:47crucially, the price tag. And just the standard reminder
- 1:50for everyone listening, this whole analysis, it's based
- 1:54purely on publicly available sources.
- 1:55Yeah. That's right, it might be
- 1:56subject to different interpretations.
- 1:58And it's all for educational purposes.
- 2:00This is an investment advice. Please always do your own
- 2:03homework, your own due diligence before making any decisions.
- 2:07OK, let's start with the basics then.
- 2:08What exactly is the business? We hear water meters, but it
- 2:12sounds like it's evolved beyond just hardware.
- 2:15It really has. I mean, yes, flow measurement
- 2:17and control is the foundation, but the big focus now is
- 2:21connectivity in data about 85% of their sales, that's utility
- 2:25water solutions. So that includes a physical
- 2:28meter, sure, but also the communication systems.
- 2:30Think they're Orion radio endpoints and the software that
- 2:33makes sense of it all. And the other 15%?
- 2:35That's flow instrumentation. More niche stuff for industrial
- 2:39uses, HVAC systems, chemical processing, things like that.
- 2:42Important, but the utility side is the main engine.
- 2:45Got it. And the revenue model?
- 2:46I saw this described using the razor and blade analogy.
- 2:49That seems pretty apartment. Here, it's a perfect fit, isn't
- 2:52it? They sell the hardware, the
- 2:53meter, the communication endpoint.
- 2:54That's your razor. It gets them in the door and
- 2:56installed in the ground. And that locks the customer in,
- 2:59presumably. Exactly.
- 3:01Then comes the Blade, the recurring, the recurring
- 3:04revenue. This is a high margin stuff.
- 3:06We're talking about their Beacon Sauce platform, that software as
- 3:09a service, analytics and things like network as a service fees.
- 3:13The software piece is significant.
- 3:15The sources noted it was over $56 million last year. 56
- 3:19million and growing fast. Yeah, growing around 30% year
- 3:22over year. That shows you how they build
- 3:24this reliable income stream right on top of that installed
- 3:27base of hardware. That recurring revenue that
- 3:29points straight towards the competitive advantage, right?
- 3:31The Moat. Why is it so hard for a utility
- 3:34to switch once they've got BMI system in?
- 3:37Well it really boils down to two main things.
- 3:39Switching costs and trust. Deep relationships.
- 3:45BMI works with over 3000 water utilities globally.
- 3:50Many of these relationships go back years, decades even.
- 3:53Now imagine you're running a city's water system, right?
- 3:55You've installed 10s of thousands of VMI meters.
- 3:58You've integrated their data systems.
- 3:59You're billing relies on it your leak detection.
- 4:02Embedded. Deeply embedded.
- 4:04The cost, the complexity, the sheer operational headache of
- 4:07ripping all that out to switch to a competitor.
- 4:09It's enormous. The switching costs are very,
- 4:11very high. And they're not standing still,
- 4:13are they? They keep investing in tech to
- 4:15reinforce that position. Definitely, that's crucial.
- 4:18They spend roughly 3 to 4% of sales on R&D.
- 4:22They've been leaders and things like ultrasonic metering, which
- 4:25is more accurate and last longer than old mechanical meters, and
- 4:29importantly, cellular AMI deployments.
- 4:32AMI is advanced metering infrastructure.
- 4:35OK. What does that mean in practical
- 4:36terms for the utility? It simplifies things massively
- 4:40instead of the utility needing to build and maintain its own.
- 4:43Sort of proprietary radio network to collect meter data.
- 4:47Which sounds expensive and complex.
- 4:49It is BMI's cellular meters basically connect like your cell
- 4:52phone. They leverage existing cellular
- 4:55networks. This makes deployment much
- 4:56easier and cheaper for the utility AH.
- 4:58So it lowers the barrier for adoption while still locking
- 5:02them into the BMI ecosystem. The meter, the network
- 5:04connection, the software analysis.
- 5:07Precisely makes BMI critical one stop shop, especially for
- 5:10utilities that might be, you know, short on resources or
- 5:13technical staff. They handle the complexity.
- 5:15That makes a lot of sense. You can see why the market might
- 5:18view them as a premium provider. They're solving a real
- 5:21infrastructure headache. And that technological lead
- 5:25built over years with millions of deployed endpoints, It
- 5:29creates this data feedback loop. Newcomers just can't easily
- 5:33replicate that scale or experience.
- 5:35All right, let's shift gears to the financials themselves
- 5:37because the sources use terms like fortress like for the
- 5:41balance sheet that always gets a value investors attention.
- 5:44Yeah, fortress like isn't an exaggeration here.
- 5:46The balance sheet is exceptionally strong.
- 5:49They are for all practical purposes, debt free.
- 5:51The debt to equity ratio is tiny, like .002 or something
- 5:55close. Practically 0 debt.
- 5:57Wow. And their liquidity, excellent.
- 5:59The current ratio which measures their ability to cover short
- 6:02term liabilities, it's consistently above 4.0 X.
- 6:06It's very comfortable. So financially, they can weather
- 6:08pretty much any storm. Or fund growth internally
- 6:11without needing outside capital. Rock solid.
- 6:13And profitability looks good too.
- 6:15You mentioned strong sales margins followed.
- 6:17It did. Gross margin has been trending
- 6:19up. It hit 40.7% in this latest
- 6:22quarter. Q 325 And significantly
- 6:26management actually raised their long term target range for gross
- 6:29margin to 3942%. What is raising the target tell
- 6:32you? It signals confidence.
- 6:34It suggests they have real pricing power, likely helped by
- 6:37that ongoing shift towards the higher margin software and
- 6:39service revenues we talked about.
- 6:41OK. Strong margins, solid balance
- 6:43sheet. What about efficiency?
- 6:45How well are they using the capital they do employ?
- 6:47Well, that's probably the highlight, honestly, the return
- 6:49on vested capital ROIC, it's fantastic.
- 6:53It's consistently approved and reached about 21% in 2024. 21%
- 6:58ROIC, yes. Think about that.
- 7:00For every dollar they reinvest back into the business, they're
- 7:03generating roughly $0.21 in returns.
- 7:06That is top tier capital deployment efficiency.
- 7:09It's exactly the kind of compounding machine that, well,
- 7:12investors are often willing to pay a premium for.
- 7:14OK. Hold on.
- 7:14I have to push back slightly on that or at least ask the
- 7:16question. If ROIC is 21% and they have
- 7:19basically no debt, are they maybe being too conservative?
- 7:23Interesting point. What do you mean?
- 7:25Well, shouldn't they be maybe taking on a little bit of
- 7:28leverage, not crazy amounts, but maybe using some cheap debt to
- 7:32accelerate growth even faster, Perhaps bigger acquisitions or
- 7:36more share buybacks if they think the stock is reasonably
- 7:39valued, The sources say their cost structure is capital light.
- 7:43It's a fair question. It seems their strategy is very
- 7:46much focused on prudent organic growth first.
- 7:49They supplement that with very targeted strategic acquisitions,
- 7:53like buying Smart Cover back in 2025 to get deeper into
- 7:56wastewater analytics. So bolt on deals, not huge
- 7:59transformations. Exactly.
- 8:01They seem to prefer financial security and organic consistency
- 8:04over, let's say, aggressive financial engineering.
- 8:08They manage risks like potential tech disruption by funding R&D
- 8:12internally from cash flow, not by loading up on debt.
- 8:15So the low debt gives them flexibility, optionality, even
- 8:18if it means growth isn't absolutely maxed out with
- 8:21leverage. That seems to be the philosophy.
- 8:23High optionality, low financial risk.
- 8:25It might feel a bit slow to some growth investors, but it's very
- 8:27secure. OK, understood.
- 8:28So we've painted a picture. Strong Moat, check.
- 8:32Pristine balance sheet, check. High ROIC check.
- 8:37Qualitatively, it looks almost perfect.
- 8:39It's a very high quality business profile, yes.
- 8:41But, and this is the big but quality almost always comes at a
- 8:44price. So let's stop admiring the
- 8:47business for a second and really scrutinize that price tag.
- 8:50How does BMI stack up against that strict Buffett style
- 8:54checklist? Right.
- 8:54So qualitatively as you said, it passes nearly everything with
- 8:58flying colors. Is free cash flow consistently
- 9:00positive? Yes.
- 9:02Is the balance sheet safe? Absolutely.
- 9:04We just covered that. Is ROIC consistently above, say,
- 9:06a 12 percent hurdle? Yes, comfortably at 21%.
- 9:10Has book value per share grown steadily?
- 9:12Yes, every year for a decade. About 10.4% compound annual
- 9:16growth rate. So on the quality metrics of the
- 9:18business itself, thumbs up across the board.
- 9:21Pretty much, but then you get to the quantitative part, the price
- 9:23you have to pay. And this is where, according to
- 9:25the sources, the analysis kind of hits a wall for a traditional
- 9:27value investor. This is where it gets the fail
- 9:29mark. Look at the price to earnings
- 9:31ratio, the PE. Historically, over the last
- 9:34decade, it's bounced around mostly between 30 and 50. 30 to
- 9:3850 PD. And right now the trailing PE is
- 9:41around 38. 38, OK. Compare that to what a
- 9:45traditional Buffett style value investor might look for.
- 9:48Maybe 15. Exactly.
- 9:50A PE of 15 or less is often cited as a rough benchmark for
- 9:55value. We're more than double that.
- 9:57It's a huge difference. That 38 PE isn't just not cheap,
- 10:00it's signaling that the market is baking in a lot of future
- 10:03growth. It's a significant premium
- 10:06valuation. A very significant premium.
- 10:08You're paying a high price for that quality and perceived
- 10:11growth runway and. What about owners earnings
- 10:14yield? That's another key Buffett
- 10:15metric. How does that look?
- 10:16Also not great from a value perspective if we use free cash
- 10:20flow as a decent proxy for owners earnings.
- 10:22Which is reasonable here given the consistency.
- 10:24Right. You take that free cash flow and
- 10:26compare it to the total market capitalization, which is around
- 10:28$6.1 billion. The resulting yield is quite
- 10:32low, only around 2% to 3%. OK, help us understand that.
- 10:36Why is 2/3 percent a fail? The traditional hurdle is often
- 10:41cited as maybe 10%, right? What does that yield actually
- 10:44tell you? Think of the yield as the
- 10:46initial return you'd get if the company paid out all its free
- 10:49cash flow as a dividend. A 10% yield means, in theory,
- 10:53you could recoup your entire investment and earnings in about
- 10:5610 years. OK, a 10 year payback?
- 10:58Right. But when that yield drops to 2%
- 11:01or 3%, well, now you're looking at a theoretical payback period
- 11:04of 33 to 50 years just from the earnings stream.
- 11:07Wow, OK. That really highlights the gap.
- 11:10It signifies a very, very low the safety based on current
- 11:13earnings power. At these levels, your investment
- 11:15return is almost entirely dependent on future growth
- 11:18materializing and the market continuing to award the stock
- 11:21that high PE multiple. You're not buying a bargain
- 11:24based on today's reality. So the checklist conclusion
- 11:27seems pretty stark then. It fits the description of a
- 11:29wonderful company, absolutely. But at APE of 38 and an owner's
- 11:33earnings yield of two 3%, it clearly fails the test of being
- 11:37at a wonderful price. Correct.
- 11:39It's priced like a premium growth stock demanding near
- 11:43perfect execution for years become not a traditional value
- 11:46play. So to try and quantify how much
- 11:49growth is actually baked into that price, we need to turn to
- 11:52the discounted cash flow, the DCF analysis that was provided.
- 11:57Exactly. The DCF helps us estimate an
- 11:59intrinsic value based on different assumptions about
- 12:02future free cash flow growth. The sources used a standard 10%
- 12:05discount rate, which is pretty common for these types of
- 12:08analysis. OK, So what did the DCF show?
- 12:10I saw a couple of scenarios. Right.
- 12:12There's a conservative case. This is kind of a what if things
- 12:15slow down scenario if you assume free cash flow growth drops to
- 12:18just 5% per year indefinitely. Which would be a big slowdown
- 12:22from the recent history. A very big slowdown.
- 12:24In that pessimistic case, the calculated intrinsic value comes
- 12:28out around $82 per share. $82 OK, That shows you the potential
- 12:32downside risk if that growth story falters.
- 12:35It does, but then there's the nominal or sort of base case.
- 12:39This assumes a more realistic growth path, maybe 12% to 15%
- 12:43free cash flow growth for the next several years, tapering off
- 12:46after that. This aligns more with the
- 12:48secular trends in Smartwater and management's outlook.
- 12:51And under that more optimistic but seemingly plausible
- 12:55scenario. Under the nominal case, the DCF
- 12:57spits out an intrinsic value of roughly $172 per share. $172 OK,
- 13:03now here's the crucial part. Where is the stock actually
- 13:07trading right now? Well, as of this analogy, the
- 13:09stock price was hovering right around $177 per share. 177 So
- 13:14basically trading almost exactly at the nominal case intrinsic
- 13:19value estimate. Pretty much spot on, maybe
- 13:21slightly above it. So the market isn't offering any
- 13:24discount at all to that fair value estimate even assuming
- 13:27pretty strong mid teens growth continues.
- 13:29Correct. The market seems to be fully
- 13:31pricing in that solid execution and continued growth trajectory.
- 13:35There's no buffer, no discount baked in.
- 13:37Which leads us to the margin of safety concept.
- 13:39If you're a prudent value investor, you don't want to pay
- 13:42full price, even if it's fair value based on optimistic
- 13:46assumptions. You want a discount.
- 13:49Exactly. You want that margin of safety
- 13:50in case things don't go perfectly or your growth
- 13:53estimates are too high. A common margin of safety saw it
- 13:56is maybe 25%. So if we take that nominal case
- 13:59value of $172 and apply a 25% margin of safety discount, where
- 14:05does that put our target buy price?
- 14:07The 25% discount on $172 puts your Target Buy price down at
- 14:12around $129 per share. 129 compared to the current price of
- 14:16$177. Right, so the implication is
- 14:19pretty clear. Yeah.
- 14:20It means that while BMI is a high quality business, it offers
- 14:23essentially 0 margin of safety at today's price.
- 14:26For a value investor using these assumptions, you'd need a
- 14:29significant pullback. A drop of about 2530% from
- 14:32current levels. Down into the low 100 and 30s,
- 14:34maybe even high $120.00 before it would start looking like a
- 14:37potential bargain based on this framework.
- 14:39So wrapping it up, the summary take away seems to be BMI,
- 14:43fantastic business. It's got the Fortress balance
- 14:45sheet, the strong tech mode, really high returns on capital,
- 14:48stellar quality. But that valuation requires very
- 14:51high confidence, confidence and sustained high double digit
- 14:56growth confidence and continuous innovation, Confidence in
- 14:59flawless execution. You're paying a price that
- 15:03demands perfection. Which brings us nicely to our
- 15:05final provocative thought for you, the listener to Mull over.
- 15:09Given this really significant price to earnings premium, this
- 15:13demanding valuation, how much underlying risk is there if BMI
- 15:18is ongoing absolutely critical R&D investment, the spending
- 15:22that sustains that technological Moat isn't fully successful?
- 15:25Or what if disruption in the water tech space, maybe from a
- 15:28new technology or competitor, accelerates faster than they
- 15:31anticipate? That's the key question, isn't
- 15:33it? The premium price tag
- 15:34essentially leaves no room for error.
- 15:35It demands continuous, almost flawless innovation just to
- 15:39justify the current valuation, let alone provide future upside.
- 15:42That's the high bar BMI has to keep clearing quarter after
- 15:45quarter, year after year. Something definite worth
- 15:47thinking about. Well said, and that concludes
- 15:50our deep dive on badge meter. Just a final reminder, all
- 15:53analysis is based on publicly available sources and may be
- 15:57subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 16:00The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 16:03constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 16:07before making investment decisions.
- 16:09That's right. And hey, if you enjoy these deep
- 16:11fives and want more, make sure to subscribe to us on Apple
- 16:14Podcasts or Spotify. Just search for deep value
- 16:18investing. And don't forget to check out
- 16:20the new market bubble monitoring app, the Buffett Indicator
- 16:24available on the Apple Store. You can get daily updates on the
- 16:26indicator. Go check it out.
- 16:28Episode store is there 2 of you honey Baca.
- 16:34Absolutely. Send us your sources, send us
- 16:36your ideas for what we should tackle next.
- 16:39Thanks for listening and we'll see you on the next deep dive.