Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / China's Dominance in Renewable Energy
Transcript
- 0:09OK, let's dive in. We have to start with something
- 0:12that sounds, well, almost unbelievable.
- 0:14An incredible achievement, really.
- 0:16It is astonishing, Yeah, we're talking about China's clean
- 0:19energy target. Exactly.
- 0:20But, and this is the huge but, there's a massive catch, isn't
- 0:23there? Oh, absolutely.
- 0:24A giant asterisk. Because while we talk about this
- 0:27green surge, China is still by far the world's biggest
- 0:31polluter. Right.
- 0:31So let's set the scene first. Back in 2020, President Xi
- 0:35Jinping lays out this goal. 1200 gigawatts of renewable energy
- 0:39capacity by 2030, a huge target for a decade away.
- 0:43Huge target and well, they didn't just meet it, they
- 0:45smashed it. How quickly?
- 0:47Get this July 2024, they hit 12106 gigawatts.
- 0:52Wow. Six years ahead of schedule.
- 0:54Six years. That's incredible.
- 0:56Just to give people a sense of that scale, 1200 gigawatts is
- 0:59like. What?
- 1:00It's roughly the entire generating capacity of Japan and
- 1:03Germany put together. All of it.
- 1:05OK. And the pace they're adding this
- 1:07stuff. It's just off the charts
- 1:08unparalleled, really. This year alone, they're
- 1:10expected to had something like 70 gigawatts of wind and maybe
- 1:13190 gigawatts of solar. So no question they are leading
- 1:17the world in building the green future infrastructure.
- 1:20Yielding it, yes. But here's where that paradox
- 1:22just slaps you in the face, right?
- 1:24Despite all this capacity, all this world leading green tech,
- 1:29China is still the number one polluter.
- 1:31And I mean, it's not even close. Give us those numbers again.
- 1:34They're crucial for understanding this whole thing.
- 1:36OK, so the latest figures, this is from the Energy Institute's
- 1:392024 review. China released a record 11.2
- 1:43billion tons of CO2 in 2023 billion.
- 1:47With AB. With AB and that was up
- 1:49642,000,000 tons from the year before that jump.
- 1:54It's the biggest annual increase they've had since 2011.
- 1:56OK. And how does that stack up
- 1:58against, say, the US? Well, the US number for 2023 was
- 2:01about 4.64 billion tons, which interestingly was actually one
- 2:05of our lower figures recently. So China's emitting more than
- 2:08double the US. More than double, yeah.
- 2:09So you have the situation, global champion of green
- 2:13capacity and at the same time global champion of pollution.
- 2:17It's. Genuinely mind bending.
- 2:20OK, so that's our mission today, right?
- 2:22To unpack this massive conflict. How can the country winning the
- 2:26renewable build out race also be driving global emissions up?
- 2:30It really boils down to this clash between, let's say,
- 2:34central ambition and the messy reality of their internal energy
- 2:39system. Let's just underline that scale
- 2:40again for a second. The construction numbers are
- 2:42wild. You mentioned 2022.
- 2:44Right. In 2022, China installed almost
- 2:47as much solar power as the rest of the entire world combined.
- 2:50Just. Staggering.
- 2:51And then in 2023, they doubled down.
- 2:53They literally doubled their new solar installations compared to
- 2:57the year before. And not just solar, right?
- 2:58Energy storage too. Yeah, energy storage capacity
- 3:01additions nearly quadrupled in that same year.
- 3:03I mean, the shift is real. Fossil fuels are now less than
- 3:06half of China's total installed generating capacity.
- 3:09Less than half? What was it before?
- 3:11Just a decade ago it was something like 2/3 fossils.
- 3:14So that's a fundamental infrastructure change.
- 3:16And you have to remember, this wasn't just market forces, this
- 3:18was deliberate policy. Absolutely strategic decisions
- 3:21going back to the mid 2000's. The goal was clear.
- 3:24Position China as the world's go to supplier for green
- 3:28technology. Corner of the market,
- 3:29essentially. Pretty much, yeah.
- 3:31And they've largely succeeded. They now control over 80% of the
- 3:35global solar manufacturing capacity.
- 3:37The whole supply chain, really. From mining the rare earths and
- 3:40minerals. All the way to assembling the
- 3:42final panels, they dominate it. And look, there's been a side
- 3:46effect, a +1 globally, this massive scale, it's pushed down
- 3:51the price of renewables for everyone.
- 3:52Definitely. Cheap solar panels worldwide are
- 3:55in part thanks to this Chinese industrial push.
- 3:58Everyone kind of benefits from that aspect.
- 4:00OK, so they're building the tools for the global transition,
- 4:03but let's swing back to the pollution inside China because
- 4:06the spending is huge, but the actual generation, that's
- 4:09different. That's the critical point, All
- 4:11that solar and wind capacity. In 2024, it generated only about
- 4:1414% of China's actual electricity use.
- 4:17Only 14%, yeah, with all that capacity.
- 4:19Yep, 14%. That's the gap.
- 4:22That's the core of the paradox right there.
- 4:24They can make the clean power. They have the machines, but
- 4:27they're not using them to their full potential.
- 4:29Why? Well, it's that crucial
- 4:31difference between installed capacity, what you could
- 4:34generate, and actual generation, what the grid takes.
- 4:38And you know, China, the US and India, together we're
- 4:41responsible for over half, about 53% of all global energy
- 4:46pollution last year. Why just demand?
- 4:49Immense energy demand growth in China mostly, And that demand is
- 4:53still overwhelmingly being met by the old guard by coal.
- 4:56Which leads us straight into this concept researchers are
- 4:58talking about. It's not an energy transition,
- 5:00it's energy addition. Exactly.
- 5:02That's the heart of the problem. The idea, the principle was
- 5:04supposed to be established before breaking.
- 5:07You build up the renewables, get them solid, then you phase down
- 5:09the fossil fuels. Makes sense.
- 5:11But what's actually happening is, well, they're just adding
- 5:13the clean energy on top. It's being layered over an
- 5:15existing and actually growing reliance on coal.
- 5:19So wait, instead of replacing old coal plants, the new solar
- 5:24and wind is competing against new coal plants.
- 5:26You got it. Every GW of new solar is
- 5:29fighting for grid space, not just with old coal, but with
- 5:32brand new, freshly built coal capacity.
- 5:35That sounds counterproductive. It's deeply problematic, and the
- 5:39numbers on new coal construction are frankly pretty alarming,
- 5:43despite all the pledges about controlling coal.
- 5:45What are the numbers? In 2024, construction started on
- 5:4894.5 gigawatts of new coal-fired power capacity. 94.5 gigawatts
- 5:55of new coal starting construction now.
- 5:58Yep. That's the highest level of new
- 6:00coal starts since 2015. So they're setting records for
- 6:03solar installations and simultaneously starting the most
- 6:06new coal plants in almost a decade.
- 6:08That feels like a deliberate contradiction.
- 6:10It certainly looks that way, and here's the statistic that really
- 6:13puts it in perspective. China now accounts for 93% of
- 6:16all global construction starts for coal power this year. 93% So
- 6:21the rest of the world's new coal is basically insignificant
- 6:24compared to China. 'S it's almost a rounding error.
- 6:26China is continuing this massive investment in coal, while the
- 6:29rest of the world is generally moving away from it.
- 6:32That single statistic tells you so much about the climate
- 6:35challenge right now. OK, so why?
- 6:38Why does coal still have this iron grip, especially when
- 6:41renewables are getting cheaper? It sounds like the system is
- 6:43somehow rigged it. Is the sources point to
- 6:48basically 4 big systemic reasons why coal keeps winning even when
- 6:52cheap solar is sitting right there?
- 6:54All right, let's break them down.
- 6:55What's #1. First up, grid preference.
- 6:59China's enormous power grid? Well, it prefers the steady,
- 7:04predictable power you get from a coal plant.
- 7:06Like it's easier to manage. Exactly.
- 7:08Think of the grid operator like, I don't know, a nervous air
- 7:10traffic controller. They trust the big, reliable,
- 7:14maybe dirty Boeing 747. That's the coal plant.
- 7:17It always lands when scheduled. The renewables, the solar and
- 7:20wind. They're like the flashy high
- 7:21tech fighter jets. Super capable.
- 7:24But their flight plan depends entirely on the weather.
- 7:27So when the grid is stressed, the operator plays it safe.
- 7:29They give priority more operating hours to the
- 7:32predictable coal plants. Stability over cleanliness,
- 7:34especially with massive industrial demand.
- 7:36Got it. What's the second reason?
- 7:38Second, energy security. This is a big one in Beijing.
- 7:42You've got geopolitical tensions always simmering.
- 7:45Plus, they had those severe droughts recently, right?
- 7:48That hammered their hydropower output in 2022-2023.
- 7:52Right, I remember that. So events like that just
- 7:54reinforce this deep seated view that real energy security, the
- 7:58ultimate backup, still means coal.
- 8:01It's seen as the insurance policy they'll compromise on
- 8:04climate goals to keep the lights on and the factories running.
- 8:07So they keep building coal, not just for everyday use, but as a
- 8:10backup for those times when the sun isn't shining or the rivers
- 8:14are low. That's a big part of it, yeah,
- 8:16that's insurance. Third reason is more economic
- 8:18long term contracts. These power purchase agreements
- 8:21or PP as. Of the Ppas, how do they lock
- 8:24things in? Well, the big electricity
- 8:25buyers, the utility companies, they're often locked into these
- 8:28long multi year contracts to buy power from specific coal plants.
- 8:33So imagine your local utility has a 20 year contract for like
- 8:37an old expensive cell phone plan.
- 8:40Even if someone offers them a brand new free smartphone that's
- 8:43the cheap solar power, they still have to pay huge penalties
- 8:47if they don't fulfill their contract for the old expensive
- 8:50plan. So they're basically forced to
- 8:52buy The Dirty power even if clean power is available and
- 8:55cheaper, just to avoid breaking an old contract.
- 8:58Pretty much. It actively crowds out the
- 9:00renewables. It's a major market inefficiency
- 9:03directly undermining all that investment in green tech.
- 9:07That's kind of shocking. What's the fourth reason?
- 9:094th is financing influence. This tells you who's pushing for
- 9:12all this new coal construction. OK, over 3/4, more than 70, 5%
- 9:16of the new coal capacity approved in 2024.
- 9:19It was backed financially by coal mining companies or groups
- 9:22that are already have big mining operations.
- 9:25So the companies digging the coal out of the ground are also
- 9:28financing the new plants to burn it.
- 9:30Exactly, it's a self perpetuating cycle.
- 9:32They're essentially investing to guarantee future demand for
- 9:36their own product. For their minds.
- 9:38It doesn't matter if market forces or even central
- 9:41government climate targets point the other.
- 9:43Way it really paints a picture of internal conflict, doesn't
- 9:46it? Central government pushing
- 9:47green, but local finance and old infrastructure pushing back hard
- 9:52with coal. That's a very good way to put
- 9:53it, Intense internal conflict. OK, before we get to the
- 9:57potential fix for all this, we need to talk about 1 area where
- 10:00China has made huge progress because it's not all bad news on
- 10:03pollution. That's right.
- 10:04It's crucial to distinguish between climate emissions, the
- 10:07CO2 and local air quality. Remember that war against
- 10:11pollution China declared back in 2014?
- 10:14Yeah, targeting that smog, the particulate matter, PM 2.5.
- 10:18Exactly. The stuff you can actually see
- 10:20and breathe, the stuff that was causing major public health
- 10:22crises in cities. And that war, it's actually been
- 10:25a measurable success. How?
- 10:27Much success. The data shows PM 2.5 levels
- 10:29nationally dropped by a really significant 42 percent compared
- 10:33to 2013 levels. Wow, 42%?
- 10:36That's huge. What does that mean for people's
- 10:38health It. Translates, according to
- 10:39estimates, to the average Chinese citizen gaining about
- 10:422.2 years of life expectancy. 2.2 years longer life just from
- 10:47cleaning up the particulates. Yeah, and interestingly, sources
- 10:50say that a noticeable drop in global average particulate
- 10:53pollution levels is directly linked to China's success here.
- 10:57OK. So they tackle the particulates
- 10:59because it was an immediate, visible local health threat,
- 11:03people choking on smog in Beijing.
- 11:06But the CO2 emissions keep rising because, well, climate
- 11:09change feels more distant, less immediate.
- 11:12Maybe it doesn't choke you today in the same way.
- 11:15That seems to be the key distinction.
- 11:16Yes, the political will was there forcefully to fix the
- 11:19visible air quality crisis. But we should add, even with
- 11:22that progress, China is still I think the 13th most polluted
- 11:25country for a particulars still still.
- 11:28And something like 99.9% of its population lives in areas where
- 11:31air quality still exceeds WHO guidelines.
- 11:34So the challenge remains huge. But they did show they can act
- 11:37decisively when the threat is perceived as direct and urgent.
- 11:40OK, so let's tie this all together.
- 11:41You have, on one hand, the world world leader in building green
- 11:44infrastructure, on the other, a system locking in fossil fuels
- 11:49through these economic and grid mechanisms we talked about.
- 11:52How does this potentially change?
- 11:54What's the proposed way out of this paradox?
- 11:57Well, a lot of hope is being pinned on fixing the
- 12:00infrastructure itself. Remember how we said the grid
- 12:03favors coal? Part of that is because China's
- 12:05power grid isn't really one National Grid.
- 12:08It operates more like 6 separate regional grids.
- 12:11Balkanized, you called? It yeah, basically.
- 12:13So the massive solar power generated way out in the western
- 12:16deserts often struggles to get efficiently transmitted to the
- 12:19big cities and industrial hubs in the east where the demand is.
- 12:22Coal plants near the cities fill the gap.
- 12:24So the fix is basically to connect everything up properly.
- 12:28That's the idea. There's a major push to create a
- 12:31truly unified national power market by 20-30.
- 12:34Merge those six regional grids into one integrated system.
- 12:38And the goal is? Better management of supply and
- 12:40demand across the whole country make it easier to move that
- 12:43clean power from where it's generated to where it's needed.
- 12:46Which, in theory, should undermine the need for all those
- 12:49local coal plants, right? If the grid operator in Shanghai
- 12:52can easily and reliably pull cheap solar power from Xinjiang
- 12:56province, why keep the expensive, dirty local coal
- 12:59plant running as much? That's the theory, that's the
- 13:01hope. It should force coal into more
- 13:03of a backup role rather than the primary role it often plays now.
- 13:07So. Will market reform this grid
- 13:09unification finally be enough to overcome those four big forces
- 13:14propping up coal? The grid preference, the
- 13:17security concerns, the PPA is the financing.
- 13:20That is the multi trillion dollar question, isn't it?
- 13:22It's going to be a huge test. Central Market logic versus
- 13:25entrenched regional interests in the power of the coal industry.
- 13:29So wrapping this up, what does it all mean for you listening?
- 13:31Well, China has clearly won the race to dominate global
- 13:34renewable technology manufacturing scale price that
- 13:38they're number one. But the internal fight, the
- 13:41political and infrastructural battle to actually use that
- 13:44technology effectively at home, that's the next massive.
- 13:47Hurdle, and maybe the hardest one.
- 13:49And the provocative thought we want to leave you with is this
- 13:52How can 1 country simultaneously be the world's green energy
- 13:57manufacturing powerhouse and its biggest climate polluter?
- 14:01It's a paradox that defines the entire global climate struggle
- 14:04right now. Yeah.
- 14:05So next time you read about another giant solar farm opening
- 14:08in China, just remember that somewhere else they might be
- 14:11starting construction on 94 gigawatts of new coal.
- 14:15That contradiction is the reality we're dealing with.
- 14:18A complex and frankly conflicted picture.
- 14:21Thank you for joining us for this deep dive into Chinas
- 14:23energy paradox. Thanks for having me if.
- 14:25You found this useful or interesting, please do follow
- 14:27the channel. That way you won't miss our next
- 14:29exploration in the complex issues shaping our world.