Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Use a Competing Job Offer Without Burning Bridges
Transcript
- Lucas: So Alex writes in, and his situation is what a lot of people would call a 'good problem to have.' He's been at his company for two years, solid performer, likes his team and his manager — but a recruiter reached out, the interview process moved fast, and now he has a written offer from a competitor for twenty percent more than his current base. Luna: Which is flattering, and tempting. But Alex says he doesn't actually want to leave — he just wants his current employer to step up. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a tricky conversation to navigate. If you handle it poorly, you come across as threatening, or worse, you take a counteroffer and then six months later you're out the door anyway because the trust is broken. Luna: Right, I've read that something like eighty percent of people who accept a counteroffer end up leaving within a year, anyway. But that doesn't mean you can't have the conversation. Lucas: No, it means you have to be thoughtful. The first rule is: do not bluff. If you don't actually have a written offer, you're not negotiating from leverage — you're making an empty threat. Alex has the offer, so he's in a genuine position to have the conversation. Luna: And he needs to book a private meeting with his manager. Not an email, not a hallway conversation. A scheduled, one-on-one conversation. Lucas: Exactly. And the framing matters so much. You want to say something like, 'I value being here and I see a future on this team. I've received an offer that's hard to ignore, but before I make any decision, I wanted to talk to you about whether we can find a path for me to stay.' Luna: That puts it on the manager to respond constructively, not defensively. It says, 'I'm on your side.' Lucas: Right. The worst thing you can do is walk in and say, 'Match this or I'm gone.' That triggers a fight or flight response, and even if they match, they'll start looking for your replacement as soon as you leave the room. Luna: So then the manager asks, 'What's the offer?' Do you show them the written offer? Or just tell them the number? Lucas: I'd share the number and the role — but I wouldn't show them the document unless they ask. That keeps it professional. You want to be transparent without making it feel like a hostage negotiation. Luna: And what if the manager says, 'We can't match that right now, budget is frozen.' Lucas: Then you have a decision to make. If they genuinely can't, but they offer a path to get there in six months with a clear timeline, you might consider it. But if the answer is just 'no' with no plan, then the new offer is basically telling you your market value is higher than your current employer is willing to pay. Luna: And then you have to be ready to leave. Because if you stay after they say no, you've lost all leverage for the next conversation. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the advice I'd give Alex: go into the conversation prepared to accept the new job. If your current employer steps up — great. If not, you already know what your next move is. Luna: One more thing: if they do match, get it in writing. A verbal promise is not a raise. Lucas: Absolutely. You want an updated offer letter or at least an email from HR confirming the new salary effective immediately. And then you go back to the other company and politely decline — professionally, because you never know when paths cross again. Luna: That's a good reminder. Decline the offer graciously. You don't burn the bridge you just built. Lucas: Right. And honestly, that's part of why we do these episodes — to help people have these conversations with confidence. We keep the show completely ad-free because we think this kind of advice should be accessible to anyone. If you've found it useful, the best way to support that is at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it's a small thing but it keeps the episodes coming without any sponsored interruptions. We really appreciate that. Lucas: So for Alex, and for anyone else facing a similar decision: don't lead with an ultimatum, but don't undervalue yourself either. You have data — use it respectfully. Luna: And remember, the goal is not to win a negotiation. The goal is to get to a fair outcome that works for both sides. Lucas: Exactly. Okay, next episode we'll tackle a listener question about asking for flexible hours when your boss is a stickler for the nine-to-five. See you then.