Latest / Interfaiths / Interfaiths: Unbiased- Combatting Antisemitism and Building Allies with Temple Beth Am
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to another episode of the Interfaiths
- 0:09programming here at FIU. We are very honored
- 0:14to have Joanne and Susan that are here from Temple
- 0:19Beth Am. They're very esteemed colleagues and
- 0:25they've been part of our Jewish Muslim small
- 0:29dialogue group and they are pillars in their
- 0:32own right of the Florida Jewish community and
- 0:35they have a strong interest in interfaith work.
- 0:38So what we'll do is we'll explore a little bit
- 0:41about their background and talk about the work
- 0:43that they're doing both with the community and
- 0:46their larger hopes and aspirations for the meaning
- 0:51of this interfaith work in this very challenging
- 0:54time that we're living through right now. So
- 0:56I'll start off with Joanne. Well, first of all,
- 0:59thank you for inviting us to participate in this.
- 1:05I'm currently the chair now of Unbiased, which
- 1:09is our anti -Semitism initiative at Temple Beth
- 1:11Am. Susan is on the board, the committee with
- 1:16the rest of us, and we've been working for the
- 1:20last three years on this initiative. We'll tell
- 1:25you a little bit about my background, what brought
- 1:27me to this kind of work within our synagogue.
- 1:31I was born in Miami, raised in Miami, so it's
- 1:37unusual to be a native and still here. I left
- 1:40for a few years and came back, but I grew up
- 1:43in a Miami that's very different from the Miami
- 1:46of today. It was a small town. Everybody got
- 1:50along. Our neighborhood was multicultural, different
- 1:57religions. My elementary school and middle school
- 2:01and high school, there were people of every faith,
- 2:04every ethnicity. There were immigrant students
- 2:09who started coming in the 60s. And I grew up
- 2:13feeling like, yes, I am a Jewish girl, but I'm
- 2:20also a human being. And that was sort of how
- 2:23it was. We didn't feel different necessarily
- 2:25except at Christmas time when our classrooms
- 2:29had a Christmas tree and we all had to bring
- 2:31an ornament. My mom wasn't quite sure where you
- 2:34buy an ornament. So we got one and brought it.
- 2:36And I always wanted one in my house, but I always
- 2:39helped my friends down the street decorate their
- 2:41Christmas trees. They came to my house and lit
- 2:43the menorah. It was fine. I went to school in
- 2:48high school. It was the first time that I was
- 2:51in integrated high school. The schools in Miami
- 2:55were forced integration, but in my area, it didn't
- 2:59have to be forced. It was natural. People lived
- 3:00there and lived and worked and studied together.
- 3:04So I grew up feeling like interfaith work, it's
- 3:08a word I didn't know what it really involved.
- 3:10We all got along. We didn't talk about it. As
- 3:13a matter of fact, reflecting... my three closest
- 3:18lifelong friends who are still among my very
- 3:21best friends that I met in elementary school
- 3:23are not Jewish. And I didn't have close, close
- 3:26friends who were Jewish until probably middle
- 3:28school and high school when I got more involved
- 3:31in the greater Miami Jewish clubs and social
- 3:35things. I wound up becoming... nursery school
- 3:41teacher and then a high school art teacher here
- 3:43in Miami during the Marielle boat lift. So I
- 3:47had students coming into Hialeah High School
- 3:49every day, new students, and then I decided to
- 3:53go to law school. And I went to the University
- 3:56of Miami and upon graduation I was offered a
- 3:59teaching position. So then I was a professor
- 4:02at the law school for 30 years. Again, working
- 4:05with all kinds of people. kept my faith very
- 4:11close and personal. I didn't get involved in
- 4:15the Jewish community and in Jewish outreach.
- 4:17Instead, I brought my Jewish faith and my Jewish
- 4:20values outward and became very involved in boards
- 4:24in Miami and the Community Relations Board and
- 4:27some other volunteer boards. And that work taught
- 4:31me there was a lot I didn't know about different
- 4:34people in different areas. I got quite ill, and
- 4:41I had to stop working, and I had to stop doing
- 4:43everything. And it gave me a number of years
- 4:47to reflect on what did I really enjoy in my life,
- 4:50if I ever felt well enough. And it was community
- 4:54outreach and social justice work. And when Rabbi
- 4:57Barris came up with the idea for this anti -Semitism
- 5:01initiative, I said, that's it, I'm in. So that's
- 5:05how I got involved. That's amazing. Yeah, I mean,
- 5:08it's a wonderful. So do you feel that that has
- 5:12also helped you in terms of what helped change
- 5:15your private faith into something that you pursued
- 5:22a bit more? Hmm. Probably getting sick. I wasn't
- 5:34sure. In fact, I was pretty sure it was not going
- 5:37to be okay. And I was. And it was a miracle.
- 5:42And my rabbis were very comforting and very involved.
- 5:47And I learned, I'm going to quote something I
- 5:50heard the other night. One of our confirmands
- 5:52at Temple Beth Am had written something. And
- 5:55I'm going to take it for a moment, apply it.
- 5:59She said, being Jewish means being part of a
- 6:03strong, compassionate, kind, and caring community.
- 6:10And that was when I felt it. I felt it because
- 6:14people I didn't even know knew me reached out
- 6:17and were very comforting and I began to feel
- 6:23the personal faith along with the community faith.
- 6:28That's amazing. Wonderful. So, Susan? Well...
- 6:34I grew up for the first four years of my life
- 6:36in upstate New York in a little town called Boston
- 6:39Spa. And I grew up Jewishly. There was apparently
- 6:47a large synagogue in Saratoga Springs right next
- 6:51door. I was too young to really participate.
- 6:56My family then moved to Miami. after that. And
- 7:03it was a very challenging time. My father needed
- 7:09to take his oral surgery boards again, and there
- 7:13were quotas. And in fact, I found out that we
- 7:19had changed our name so that he would be more
- 7:23accepted in the community. And it came as a great
- 7:26shock. It was very confusing to me. I thought,
- 7:29wait a minute. Am I adopted? Am I part of this
- 7:31family? How do I fit in? And I, unfortunately,
- 7:36I had looked into some papers and that's how
- 7:38I found it. What kids do when there are little
- 7:42straw baskets. And then I didn't know how to
- 7:44bring it up to my parents. I was kind of in a
- 7:48deep, dark space for a bit and finally brought
- 7:51it up. And they explained to me that when they
- 7:55moved to this very tiny town at the time in upstate
- 7:59New York, there were just four Jewish families.
- 8:02And then when we moved here, that was the name
- 8:05that they chose a name. And that was, it was
- 8:08a family name. And so I then understood that.
- 8:13When I came to Miami in the late 50s, early 60s,
- 8:18there was a lot of racial tension and tension
- 8:22for any minority group, which I didn't really
- 8:27understand. And kind of just... went along with
- 8:34my life in a public school. And then eventually
- 8:38our schools went on strike and I had to go to
- 8:41a private school. And fortunately, my parents
- 8:43were able to send me. By then my father was settled
- 8:46in his new profession that he had started over.
- 8:50He had been a dentist and then went back to become
- 8:52an oral surgeon. And there was tremendous racial
- 8:56tension because he practiced in Hialeah. And
- 8:59people there, couldn't afford the healthcare
- 9:04they needed. And he would just take them as patients
- 9:08and they would return it in services. It was
- 9:10kind of like a barter system that I grew up around.
- 9:14And that was my experience in high school. There
- 9:21were private clubs and parties that I wasn't
- 9:24invited to because I was, I identified proudly
- 9:28as a Jewish woman. And went through college and
- 9:34graduate school away from Miami. Got graduate
- 9:38degrees in counseling education and then in social
- 9:42work. And really worked in a social action area,
- 9:45working with mostly in a medical setting, but
- 9:49with minorities, for which I was the minority.
- 9:56And that was all fine. Prior to that, I married
- 10:02someone who was not Jewish, which really was
- 10:05uncomfortable for my mother. My father passed
- 10:12away when I was 17. He caught hepatitis from
- 10:16a patient. Didn't know he had it. They didn't
- 10:19glove in those days. And he didn't know he had
- 10:23it or thought he had something else like the
- 10:25flu. I met my husband in college and we got married
- 10:35a week after college. Actually, yesterday was
- 10:38our 50th anniversary, our 50th wedding anniversary.
- 10:42Who did that then? I mean, and I think my mother
- 10:46was just happy to get rid of me. And my husband's
- 10:50family were Episcopalian and our rabbi here.
- 10:56My husband thought he would convert, and then
- 10:58at the 11th hour, chose not to. He just didn't
- 11:01feel that that was where he wanted to be. And
- 11:05a very prominent rabbi in Miami said, you know
- 11:10what, I'm going to... put my bets with these
- 11:15two and that they're going to, you know, raise
- 11:19a Jewish family. And we did. And at 50, he chose
- 11:23Judaism, which came as a complete surprise to
- 11:28the entire family. You know, my younger daughter
- 11:32at the time said, you know, put her hand on her
- 11:34hip and went to school and said, just because
- 11:36he chose Judaism doesn't mean that we have to
- 11:39give up the tree. It was all very interesting
- 11:44while we were at Temple Beth Am. And I slowly
- 11:47got involved with interfaith families, young
- 11:51couples, and with parents and grandparents whose
- 11:56children had interfaith marriages. And I got
- 11:59involved in, I actually went for training up
- 12:03into Cincinnati to Hebrew Union College and would
- 12:07help run the... classes, introduction to Judaism,
- 12:12and I would do the psychoeducational parts with
- 12:15another colleague who had gone for training.
- 12:18And then we started working with parents and
- 12:21grandparents. And I was quite surprised when
- 12:25my husband chose Judaism. I just thought, we're
- 12:28an interfaith family. That was my identity. But
- 12:31the truth is, is that from a very early age,
- 12:34and I think I shared this with you, there was
- 12:36a life book. called The World's Great Religions.
- 12:39And I was in love with this book, so much so
- 12:43that my parents had to find it because the library
- 12:46copy was getting checked out too much. And that
- 12:50really stimulated my interest in learning about
- 12:53people. And I saw it as layering when people
- 12:56either chose to stay in their religion and just
- 12:59learn more about another, or they chose Judaism,
- 13:05that they didn't have to give up who they were
- 13:07and what they thought. It was an opportunity
- 13:10to grow and to layer. And that has basically
- 13:12been my motivation. for this kind of work. I'm
- 13:20very interested in learning about people. My
- 13:23background is in counseling, and I learned so
- 13:26much in having these relationships and listening.
- 13:31And that was the real motivator for me, and particularly
- 13:36in a world now that seems to thrive, unfortunately,
- 13:41on hate, and in particular, anti -Semitism. I
- 13:47feel the need to contribute in whatever way I
- 13:50can to learn more about others and have others
- 13:52learn more about me and about what I'm all about
- 13:58and what I value. And my guess is, and what I
- 14:01found out, it's not even a guess, is that we
- 14:04share so much in common. So let me go back to
- 14:08Joanne. I think talking about this idea, this
- 14:10is a really important idea of antisemitism. That
- 14:14is something that has become much more apparent,
- 14:17I think, in the last few years, this rise in
- 14:22anti -Semitism. I know that MBIAS is specifically
- 14:24focused on anti -Semitism. Can you talk to us
- 14:26a little bit about what you see in terms of that
- 14:31experience and what has that been like to see
- 14:39an increase in anti -Semitism and what do you
- 14:40think is driving it? What has it been like? It's
- 14:49been very heartbreaking, first of all, because
- 14:52there was a time when hatred and anti -anybody
- 14:59was under the radar, under the rug a bit. And
- 15:04in the last eight years, well, no, more, people
- 15:11have become comfortable expressing hatred. and
- 15:15that's led to more hatred and that has led to
- 15:18violence. There's been a history of anti -Semitism
- 15:25for thousands and thousands of years and the
- 15:28Jews have typically been the ones that are identified
- 15:33when somebody has to say it's because of the
- 15:36other. That's why things are the way they are.
- 15:38And so that's not new. What's new is... The feeling
- 15:45that it's okay to be like that. That it used
- 15:48to be embarrassing to share that you hated other
- 15:51people because of who they are or what they believed
- 15:53or what they look like. You kept it quiet. Now
- 15:56it's just out there and it's all over the social
- 15:59media and it's being fomented into action and
- 16:05violence. There used to be a theory that one...
- 16:13teaches in law school and learns in law school
- 16:15about free speech. You can have the freest of
- 16:20speech in the whole wide world, but you cannot
- 16:23scream fire in a crowded movie theater because
- 16:28people will trample each other and that leads
- 16:31to violence and that leads to action. So free
- 16:37speech is fine until it begins to hurt people.
- 16:42So the speech that we're hearing, the hate -filled
- 16:45speech and the anti -Jewish, anti -Israel, anti
- 16:53-Zionism, is not just a feeling. It's actually
- 16:58a call to people coming to action, and that's
- 17:01terrifying. People have been dying, yeah. People
- 17:03have been dying. Relationships have been hurt.
- 17:07People have begun to hate their neighbors and
- 17:10their friends. cohorts and political divisions
- 17:14because of that and it's also islamophobia and
- 17:19lgbtq plus hatred and bigotry and racism anytime
- 17:28somebody seems other yeah and i'm not going to
- 17:32get into politics but i will say the leaders
- 17:35in the world and in the community have an obligation
- 17:40to tamp it down instead of fan the flames and
- 17:43I'm afraid that it's going to get worse before
- 17:47we figure out ways to make it better. So what
- 17:52is, I know you don't represent the entire Jewish
- 17:57community of Miami, but what is Temple Bet Sam's
- 17:59role in trying to to challenge sort of this hatred?
- 18:08We decided when Unbiased got started, this was
- 18:13before October 7th. Things changed a lot since
- 18:20then. So I'm going to go back to our initial
- 18:22charge. We came up with the name, and our marketing
- 18:26department was fabulous in coming up with the
- 18:28name. You'll notice the U -N is small letters.
- 18:31B -I -A -S, Bias, Caps, and E -D. It's Understanding.
- 18:38and educating about bias. That's how that came
- 18:41about. And so we remain committed to that goal.
- 18:47Our mission is to educate and bring awareness
- 18:51to hatred and anti -Semitism through programming,
- 18:57through conversations, through education, but
- 19:03also a big, big part of that with unbiased is
- 19:08we want to be allies to others and consequently
- 19:14gain allies in our struggle for fairness and
- 19:20for peaceful resolution of difference and And
- 19:25I just put a plug in for our small group dialogues,
- 19:28which I was co -chair with Joe Jacoby. And I
- 19:32said, I feel very, very strongly the way you.
- 19:36get allies and get to know people as you look
- 19:39them in the eye and you have a conversation and
- 19:42you get to know one another. So I'm going to
- 19:44take this opportunity to thank you, Iqbal, for
- 19:47you and I met a couple of years ago. We both
- 19:51expressed interest in the other's work and it's
- 19:54developed into not just a working academic. relationship,
- 19:59but we've all become friends in our group. We
- 20:02trust one another, and we feel comfortable having
- 20:06difficult conversations about differences, and
- 20:10that is a true gift. Absolutely. Susan, I'll
- 20:16maybe let you have the last word, but what has
- 20:20your experience been like with the small group
- 20:24dialogue, and what are your hopes for the future?
- 20:28I have truly enjoyed the small group dialogues.
- 20:32Thank you very much. Really, it's been interesting.
- 20:37It's been thought -provoking. It's been emotional.
- 20:42There are certainly triggers that have come out.
- 20:48Mostly what I hope for is an ongoing relationship
- 20:51and getting to know You and getting to know the
- 20:56other members of the group more intimately. I
- 21:02think there's a lot to be gained by that. We
- 21:05have the trust where we are starting to talk.
- 21:10I certainly don't have expectations that our
- 21:13experiences are going to have been the same or
- 21:16that we'll necessarily see eye to eye. But I
- 21:20do hope for deeper understanding and compassion
- 21:25and caring for one another. And I hope that that
- 21:31can also allow us to feel really confident in
- 21:37ourselves as a group to be able to go out and
- 21:40continue that process and just allow it to grow
- 21:44and to flourish and to not... to be okay with
- 21:52being uncomfortable. Because that's how we all
- 21:56grow. The wobble is what's so important. And
- 21:59for me, I am looking for opportunities to learn
- 22:04more and to grow and to further my valuable relationships
- 22:10with people. Thank you so much. Can I add one
- 22:13last thing? Sure. Thank you. I watched some of
- 22:17your other podcasts, and I just want to add this.
- 22:21If others are thinking about doing this interfaith
- 22:24work or interfaith dialogue, I would encourage
- 22:28you to always start with food. Agreed. We like
- 22:34it. It's an icebreaker. You eat together. You
- 22:37talk together about what foods you like. really
- 22:41listen to one another. We all have stories we
- 22:45want to share but it's really important to really
- 22:47listen and understand where the other person
- 22:50is coming from and what their life experience
- 22:53up until this moment has been that brought them
- 22:58to this point in feeling the way they feel. Absolutely,
- 23:01yeah. No, I mean I think for me especially it's
- 23:03been very illuminating to be able to understand
- 23:08like a Jewish perspective. And especially understanding
- 23:11sort of anti -Semitism and sort of the challenges
- 23:14of October 7th, I think, from a Jewish perspective.
- 23:19And on a personal level, it's been really wonderful
- 23:22to see how you've embraced me and my family as
- 23:25well. So especially, you know, my young son.
- 23:27And sometimes I have caregiving duties, so I
- 23:30have to take him everywhere. And you guys have
- 23:33been so hospitable and so kind. And that's just
- 23:35been, that means a lot to me. So I really appreciate
- 23:37that. That's been a pleasure. Yes. So I think
- 23:40what we can do is in the fall, then we continue
- 23:42with, I think, going through our experiences,
- 23:46kind of our Muslim background and Muslim perspectives.
- 23:49And I think even having Zafreen talk, I think,
- 23:52would be very interesting because her experience
- 23:54living and growing up in Pakistan and coming
- 23:56to the United States. And I think that there's
- 24:01just so much there in terms of thinking about.
- 24:04What does it mean to encounter diversity? And
- 24:08the way that Jews are seen in Pakistan is completely
- 24:10different. And kind of what work can be done
- 24:15in terms of anti -Semitism globally, I think
- 24:17that's a whole other discussion as well. Oh,
- 24:19wow. Yes. Absolutely. Yes. Look forward to that.
- 24:23Well, thank you guys so much for coming and for
- 24:26allowing yourselves to be interviewed. I learned
- 24:28a lot, and we'll continue the conversation for
- 24:31sure. Thank you. Thank you so much. Thank you.
- 24:34Thank you.