Latest / Chatter that Matters / The many lives of Aaron Bethune
Transcript
- 0:03You know, if you're just doing it for the award, then you know, you're missing out on the moments along the way that might be more important than just getting to the destination.
- 0:14We live in a time that rewards speed and certainty and scale, bigger platforms, louder voices, faster answers.
- 0:21And yet, behind closed doors, I keep hearing the same quiet questions from very accomplished people.
- 0:28Why does success feel so thin?
- 0:30Why does the momentum feel like a trap instead of a gift?
- 0:34And why do the tools designed to help us think seem to be thinking for us?
- 0:39My guest today is Aaron Bethune.
- 0:41He's lived in worlds that rarely speak to each other.
- 0:44It's a deep feeling that I just have to pursue with everything I do and that's that's led me to a lot of interesting experiences of my own and figuring sort of things out and
- 0:54seeing patterns and connecting dots.
- 0:58Been on stage with musicians where silence matters as much as sound, and boardrooms where narrative determines value, on a mountain where ego became a liability, monasteries where
- 1:09speech is silent, and now inside artificial intelligence systems where the quality of the questions determines the reality you receive.
- 1:20What fascinates me most about this young man is not what he does, but how he consistently refuses fragmentation.
- 1:27more the time goes by, the more I feel that we're here to have an experience.
- 1:30And so for me to, you know, embrace that and and pursue life as the experience that we have and see it in its moments of challenge and in in happy times is all part of success.
- 1:42He spent his life translating between art and business, intuition and structure, human wisdom and machine intelligence.
- 1:48He's like a cortex in our brain firing between the left and right.
- 1:53And if I was given only one word to describe him, I would say philosopher.
- 1:57at the rear view mirror, I see perfection.
- 1:59All the challenges, all the good times, all the things that have occurred have put me exactly where I am today.
- 2:06And without that I wouldn't be who I am.
- 2:07And I can I can have moments that I wish that'd been different, but I'm deeply appreciative of the experience that I'm having.
- 2:14I'm curious if you feel the same way after listening to the wonderful insights of Aaron Bethune.
- 2:38Aaron, welcome to Chat of the Matter.
- 2:41Tony, thank you.
- 2:42We've known each other quite a while and I guess my first question is you grew up moving between countries, cultures, languages.
- 2:50Give us the early stages of Erin that created this curious soul that's never satisfied if there's a door to open or a rug to look under.
- 2:59mean I I feel curious today even about this interview and I and it's it's always there and it's it's something that has led me down paths to really deeply understand things because
- 3:11I think that my brain wants to understand things and find the words that can help me share that with somebody else.
- 3:18And I you know, I can't pinpoint exactly where that began.
- 3:22Yeah, I grew up with my mother and grandparents until I was twelve in England and was born in Canada.
- 3:28From Canada, I went to England on a boat.
- 3:30My grandfather was a pianist, I used to lie under his piano while he'd play.
- 3:33Well, I met my stepdad when I was seven.
- 3:36I was very curious about that because essentially he helped us get out of a sand dune in Lantharotti, one of the Canary Islands.
- 3:45And I thought that was a curious lead in to uh a relationship with my mother and then my brothers after that.
- 3:51But I I I was I've always been passionate about
- 3:54music and and music is one of those things that I don't think you ever get to the point where you say, Okay, I f I figured that one out.
- 4:00Done, next thing.
- 4:02It's like you can sit down every day and improve and and find intricacies and different ways to look at the instrument, different ways to listen to the sounds.
- 4:08You know, I I I've just been curious about how the human mind works and what propels people to do what they do and experiences that lead them to make decisions in the future
- 4:18that have been shaped by those experiences.
- 4:20I'm just I'm just a curious kind of person.
- 4:22It's
- 4:23how you you talked about each time you can listen to music differently.
- 4:27You're never satisfied.
- 4:29And in some ways I look at your life that way.
- 4:32You never really found a lane you wanted to command.
- 4:37You were anything trying to find a way where where's the exit ramp and the entrance ramp onto the next one?
- 4:42Well, I think the lane that I put myself in is the one that gets to the corner.
- 4:46You know, when you get to the corner, you see what's around us, and then you can decide is it the right lane to be in.
- 4:51It's sort of a uncovering of information.
- 4:53It's like math equations.
- 4:54Do we create them or are they there to be uncovered?
- 4:57In my experience, the more I've uncovered, the more I've seen around the corner, which leads me to think, okay, I need to know that.
- 5:04I mean, even with the music industry, I I literally have done pretty well everything you can do from, you know, guitar tech, manager
- 5:12You know, being involved with record deals, publishing deals, music for TV, artist development.
- 5:18I mean, I've I've done a lot of different things.
- 5:20I I booked Sly and the Family Stones first tour of Japan from my dingy apartment um when I was in in university, and I didn't make any money.
- 5:29But it was this uncovering of like how does this work?
- 5:32Which, you know, becomes a question of success too.
- 5:34Is success the bank account, is success the accomplishment, is success, you know, finding out what you're looking for.
- 5:39Have you ever if you have a definition of that or is it is that something that you're always gonna be pulling at the different levers?
- 5:46When I talk about success with people I always say whatever it means to you.
- 5:49Hence my question.
- 5:50What does it mean to you?
- 5:51Well, I mean, freedom is a big part of success.
- 5:53Doing the things you love, waking up and being able to choose what you're going to do and feel purpose and meaning and, you know, sensing that your life is worth something.
- 6:02I mean, to me that that's success.
- 6:04Success is also the ability to understand myself and understand this experience.
- 6:10The more the time goes by, the more I feel that we're here to have an experience.
- 6:13And so for me to
- 6:15you know, embrace that and and pursue life as the experience that we have and see it in its moments of challenge and in in happy times is all part of success.
- 6:24You know, it's a it's also an element of value.
- 6:27You know, if your if your attachment to money is is that of a an emotional attachment, then, you know, you're likely telling yourself that you're really amazing if you've got
- 6:35lots of money.
- 6:36And if you don't, you probably think you're not.
- 6:38You know, financial is not the end all be all of of success, but
- 6:42you know, what is important and what does feel like success to me is is knowing that I'm doing what I'm here to do.
- 6:50And I think that that's something that requires actually putting aside some of those materialistic things that people consider as being success.
- 6:57I think sometimes those get in the way.
- 6:59It's like, you know, if you're just doing it for the award, then, you know, you're missing out on the moments along the way that might be more important than just getting to the
- 7:08destination.
- 7:08Do you
- 7:09Think that freedom is more available when you're young without having financial responsibilities, being a parent, maybe taking care of an elderly parent, that you have
- 7:21more opportunity to say, this isn't about material wealth, this is about intellectual stimulation, about emotional.
- 7:29Do I belong?
- 7:30Am I doing things with my capabilities that I feel have a higher purpose?
- 7:34Is that easier for us at young, or do we just make an excuse as we get older saying?
- 7:39I wish I had the freedom to pursue versus I'm forced to be on this path.
- 7:44I think that when you're younger there's a sense of immortality that, you know, you can do anything.
- 7:49I mean, I when I was younger, I was jumping off cliffs, I was climbing mountains, I was going white water, kayaking and rafting, I was, you know, canyoning down waterfalls.
- 7:58I was doing stuff that I can't even believe that was me.
- 8:01Because, you know, it was there's a sense of immortality and certainly no responsibility, no kids, nothing of that nature.
- 8:07And I think also because I had some experiences fairly young that enabled me to sort of see
- 8:14other elements of life that were beyond the materialistic goals of a lot of people, I think it came at the right time for me to be able to experience that in that moment in my
- 8:23life.
- 8:24That being said, I think that as we become older and as we, you know, have experiences that involve children, all sorts of responsibilities, of course, it becomes harder to feel
- 8:36that sense of freedom and at the same time easier to say, well, I'm too old, or it's, you know, my time has passed for that or
- 8:43you know, I've got too many responsibilities.
- 8:45But I I look at it too as being we're constantly creating this sort of sense of reality and and I look at music as an example.
- 8:54And when when you think of a song that you heard when you're twelve years old, every time you hear a band or an artist that sounds like that artist afterwards, it t tells you that
- 9:04sounds like such and such a band.
- 9:06It's not a brand new experience.
- 9:07It's one that builds off of that foundational experience.
- 9:10And I think that happens in our lives too with stories.
- 9:12We
- 9:13go through things, we we're almost like born into this field of opportunity.
- 9:18And that as we have experiences, we start building our fortress.
- 9:22And pretty soon we're living inside of a fortress that has no windows.
- 9:25We're very safe, but we've forgotten what's outside.
- 9:29Yes, life creates moments that require us to buckle down and be responsible.
- 9:35But we also have a decision and how we want to pursue what's around the next corner.
- 9:40You talked about stories and you talked about experiences and one that certainly defined you and made you realize that there was more to life than you thought was when you were
- 9:51two hundred meters from a summit.
- 9:54Share that story with us because I think a lot of people have been there in life and sometimes pursue things because they think that's gonna bring validation or bragging
- 10:05rights, as opposed to maybe what it brought you, which was some clarity.
- 10:09So I was, I was actively involved in, you know, mountain guide and all that sort of stuff I was mentioning.
- 10:15Somebody told me, hey, you should, you should try to climb one of these mountains, and we were gonna go do that together.
- 10:21And then they bailed, and I ended up doing it anyways.
- 10:23And I'm a week turned 19, and the youngest guy on the mountain.
- 10:27200 meters from the summit, I had this massive rather realization that I hadn't spent a single second training to get down.
- 10:35Not one minute of my entire training to be there.
- 10:38had been with the visualization of returning.
- 10:40It was just to get to the top and it and it hit me like I I didn't I didn't have a visual on what was going to happen next.
- 10:45And that combined with the night before, a guy had gone missing and just because of the time of night, there's little chance he was going to be found alive.
- 10:55And realizing I was quite possibly going to, you know, step over his body on the path to achieving what he'd also tried to achieve unsuccessfully, it was, you know, it was a lot
- 11:05going on in my head at the time.
- 11:07My grandmother died recently.
- 11:09I feel like I heard her voice in my mind saying, Look, Aaron, it's it's okay to turn back.
- 11:13That's that's the tougher decision and people are going to respect that.
- 11:16And I remember one of the guys in the expedition is like, Hey, look, we'll we'll we'll help you down.
- 11:21I said, I don't want you to help me down.
- 11:22I want I want this to be the experience that I came to have, which was one that doesn't involve you helping me down.
- 11:29It was amazing because you s you know, you start out at night with the uh headlamps on and you're
- 11:36You know, you're going for the sum, you really can't see anything around you.
- 11:39It's just void.
- 11:39It's just darkness.
- 11:41And I remember as the sun came up, it was so deeply and profoundly beautiful in recognizing just how insignificant I was in this vast universe.
- 11:55It just made me so deeply appreciative of oxygen, warmth, the ability to put one foot in front of the other.
- 12:02You know, no Mercedes was gonna change that.
- 12:04I mean, you know, at this point in time it was all about the basics of life and recognizing that, you know, I just I was at the dentist this morning and I I I give this
- 12:12metaphor at times to my kids.
- 12:14It's like if you if you feel your teeth with your tongue, they seem huge.
- 12:18You know what I mean?
- 12:18But they're tiny.
- 12:19And that's what we're doing all the time is we're looking at life as though we're this big deal, you know, we're this big wave bigger than the other wave.
- 12:26But at the end of the day, it's it's so it's so silly.
- 12:28It's it's not certainly not what I live for is is those sort of materialistic things.
- 12:33And probably because of that experience.
- 12:35And when I turned back, because of the time of day, no one was coming up and no one was returning yet, I came across Mike, who was the guy who'd been lost.
- 12:43And that was the beginning of a very long journey down the mountain.
- 12:47You know, one that of course also impacted me.
- 12:50And I couldn't help but think to myself, I was like, is it possible?
- 12:54My entire training was to be here for Mike.
- 12:56Is it is it possible?
- 12:59He'd he'd literally he was meters from falling off the south face of the Aconcagua, which is like the north face of Everest and in when you're in the southern uh hemisphere, it's
- 13:07the south face is the tough one.
- 13:09It's a ridiculous, ridiculous drop.
- 13:12And it's it was amazing that he was he'd been alive, but at that point, you know, I started giving him my supplies and I started, you know, basically carrying him down as
- 13:22best I could.
- 13:23until we got to high base camp and there was no one at the base camp.
- 13:27And that was crazy.
- 13:28And so I just sort of collapsed in my tent and and he we had to cut his boots off, he had frostbite.
- 13:34In the end, a guy showed up and I ended up carrying Mike down on ski poles down to the next base the next camp.
- 13:41Eventually, you know, help comes, but at that point I don't think I realized until later on how how dangerous that had become because
- 13:48I had been dehydrated myself at this point and w we're talking hours and hours and hours of and and at that level you're you know, your your body is consuming calories beyond the
- 13:58point of being able to put them back into your body.
- 14:00So as you're burning more as you're trying to, you know, put that level of effort.
- 14:04Do you think you were there for that reason?
- 14:06Do you think your grandmother that had died, the energy?
- 14:09I mean, people I've talked to that are absolutely convinced it's just it's all one energy force, do you think she guided you to do that to save
- 14:17I know that sometimes people can sort of feel, you know, sort of this new age woo-woo sort of thing and it can be off putting, but I like to look at things from the entertaining of
- 14:26an idea.
- 14:27And in my mind, when I look at the rear view mirror, I see perfection.
- 14:32All the challenges, all the good times, all the things that have occurred have put me exactly where I am today.
- 14:38And without that I wouldn't be who I am.
- 14:40And I can I can have moments that I wish they'd been different, but I'm deeply appreciative of the experience that I'm having.
- 14:46you know, to look at it through that lens in retrospect, you know, go, did I train?
- 14:51And I could think back of the training.
- 14:53Like, you know, when you're training for this kind of stuff, I I drink like 10 liters of water a day just to make it easy to drink one liter in a high altitude.
- 15:00So when you're putting yourself through training and you're just pushing and you're pushing and you're pushing, you're pushing, you think you're pushing to get to the summit,
- 15:06it's like in retrospect, you go, but what if I was pushing and pushing and pushing to find Mike?
- 15:11I mean, that guy was absolutely gonna die if that hadn't happened.
- 15:16So I do entertain that possibility because I think, you know, there's there's a friend of mine who talks about doneess.
- 15:21Everything is done.
- 15:22And he says it says in a positive way.
- 15:23It's like, what if everything was done?
- 15:25What if everything was absolutely perfect and as it should be?
- 15:28What if everything is unfolding in a way that is as it should be?
- 15:32And it doesn't matter if you look at it from a woo-woo kind of thing, or if you just go, okay, what if?
- 15:37Yes, to answer your question, I do believe that I was there to
- 15:41Find Mike and I've led my life that way and it's put me in some pretty interesting places because of it.
- 15:47Talk about your work in the music industry, where you're zigging where other people are zagging.
- 15:53Well, I think with music, I I started playing music myself at the age of four, started playing piano and at seven I found my stepdad's guitar and I went from Aaron you gotta
- 16:03practice when it was piano 'cause my grandfather played for eighty years to Aaron, maybe you might want to stop playing for a bit, 'cause I just played for hours and hours and
- 16:12hours and hours.
- 16:13I called myself for a long time an M, which was a musical mountaineer.
- 16:17Was it 'cause it was either one or the other or both if possible.
- 16:20And I actually went to go and do this sort of recreation administration program on Vancouver Island, which then turned into doing a jazz degree because I was set on this
- 16:29idea of building an adventure company and I was gonna do that.
- 16:32And as I did try to pursue a career in music and started getting down the path of playing in bands, I also came to see how it worked.
- 16:41And that's my curiosity because I'm like, how does this work?
- 16:43Like how are people going on tour?
- 16:45How are people getting record deals?
- 16:46How does music get on TV?
- 16:47How does how, how, how?
- 16:49The more I uncovered, the more I was like, okay, I got that.
- 16:51Now how about this?
- 16:52How about that?
- 16:52And I was I was looking at booking, you know, Macy Gray at a bullfighting rink in Madrid.
- 16:58You know, I was looking at bringing Madonna down to Benny Dorm.
- 17:02I mean, there's all kinds of artists that I was, you know, starting to get involved with and recognizing that just people looking for a paycheck.
- 17:09I mean, every it's a job, no matter how, you know, potentially glamorous, it's still just a job.
- 17:13And so once I kind of got to the point where I was like, yeah, this is really great.
- 17:17And and music is so creative and technology is such a key piece of that.
- 17:21And building, you know, connection and communities and you know, like music is at the forefront of branding, hands down, because it brings people together.
- 17:29It's not about just the singles, it's about how that music represents you.
- 17:33In fact, I remember later on having a conversation with the governor of Mississippi in which I was creating the role of music and culture ambassador with a client.
- 17:41using Bob Marley as an example, because we're looking for ways to help Mississippi have an ability to, through non-political methods, you know, make a an impact on the world.
- 17:50And their brand was Birthplace of America's music.
- 17:53And I was saying that think of Bob Marley.
- 17:55You can't think about Martin nothing of Jamaica.
- 17:57You can't think about Martin nothing of reggae.
- 17:58You can't think of reggae nothing about Marley.
- 18:00On and on it goes, right?
- 18:01And so it's like, how can you tap into that as a as a brand vehicle and which led to things with Grammys and stuff like that.
- 18:09But
- 18:10At the end of the day, you know, looking at how all this worked, I started to realize, well, music affects everyone everywhere.
- 18:16It's a vehicle of impact, of communication, of expression, of commonality, of of being able to find each other in in a place that other ways wouldn't wouldn't it be acceptable.
- 18:27And that led me, like the music and culture role for Ambassador Mississippi, the you know, working with the FIS World Ski Championship and Spotify and looking at how music impacts,
- 18:37you know, training.
- 18:39working with the Gwetin First Nation on strategy to stop Trump from d you know, selling oil leases in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge and all from a musical sort of
- 18:46perspective of how you connect with audience, how you connect with people, how you connect on a human level.
- 18:53Take me to the times you go to monasteries, take a vow of silence.
- 18:58I c I can't imagine lasting a minute in there.
- 19:02What do you discover about yourself when you go in there and how long do you actually spend living with this vow of silence?
- 19:09You know, the first time I went, I was there for a for a month.
- 19:12You know, it is like getting thrown the deep end, no question.
- 19:15But I was there and I and I think it was the first opportunity of just really deeply becoming the observer of of my life and of my thoughts and of what was happening.
- 19:26And and, you know, I think we we have this opportunity at all times to take advantage of the space b between things.
- 19:34What sitting in a monastery, I believe, does is
- 19:38expand that space.
- 19:40And so as you expand that space between the observer and the movie that's your life, it gives you a much better opportunity to find purpose in the actions that you do take.
- 19:52The idea of not speaking is everything's intentional.
- 19:55There's no unintentional thing.
- 19:57You don't, you know, listen to an audio book or music while you do the dishes, you know what I mean?
- 20:01Like you're everything you're doing, you're doing intentionally and being present and being there.
- 20:05It was funny because a couple of years ago I I was I was up at this monastery.
- 20:09Have a Trodrin as the as the abbess.
- 20:13I got an opportunity to to get acquainted with her and she actually gave me a Tibetan name and you know, I've really appreciated the time spent with her and so every time I can I go
- 20:21I go up to this particular monastery and I was up a couple of years ago.
- 20:24I was cutting down some trees from the hurricane that had happened, and I slipped while cutting
- 20:30spruce trees and and I skewered myself about the size of a drumstick right between the genitals and the leg, right in the crease.
- 20:36It created this sense of, first of all, I was distracted.
- 20:41That's why when you, you know, you have these movies where the monk is sitting there or whatever and the gunshot and they just see it go by.
- 20:47It's because they're so present that the in understanding would be that if you're in every single moment, you would have that ability to slow things down to be able to acknowledge
- 20:55them as they happen.
- 20:57And if if not, I mean you you are being distracted.
- 20:59And I think that that's w was my case.
- 21:01I was distracted.
- 21:02And if I hadn't been distracted, I wouldn't have slipped and skewered myself, which also gave me this epiphany of this idea of this idea of a blanket, of this kind of reality that
- 21:12we create for ourselves, of warmth and well-being, and I think I know what's gonna happen next and I'm gonna plan this thing out for the future.
- 21:20And just like I got my legs skewered, I also
- 21:23you know, felt like my reality being pierced and it was just an opening.
- 21:26It was like, wait a second, Aaron, don't fool yourself.
- 21:29You know, there's chaos here and you're making you're making sense of it, but you're not in control of it.
- 21:33You know, I look at a lot of these these spiritual practices, especially th those that are, you know, around meditation, everything just seems like a vehicle to pay attention.
- 21:44You know, whether it's, you know, sit in this meditation and visualize this thing, or whether it's do, you know,
- 21:49150,000 prostrations or walk around a a sacred mount, whatever it is, it's all about coming back to paying attention to the moment.
- 21:59It's all about bringing your awareness to the here and now.
- 22:06Roundtops to Music Studios.
- 22:08When we return, my conversation with Erin Bethune dies into the world of AI.
- 22:13And can our humanity survive in a world dominated by machines, patterns, and social media posts?
- 22:19That and of course my three takeaways.
- 22:28Life happens.
- 22:29When you think about it, those two words are really the story of all of our lives.
- 22:34And they're also why RBC insurance matters.
- 22:37Happiness, joy, sadness, surprise.
- 22:40The moment an ultrasound reveals the heartbeat.
- 22:44And suddenly your time arises and extends beyond your life to the child you're bringing in the world.
- 22:50Buying a home, starting a business, changing careers, finding the inner strength that comes from providing for others.
- 22:56Even taking care of a parent who once took care of you.
- 23:01Life happens through the moments we dream about, but life also happens when the road suddenly veers down a path you did not ask for and would never choose.
- 23:10When change arrives without warning, yet the people who count on you still need you.
- 23:14And that is why insurance matters.
- 23:16Because life is unpredictable.
- 23:19Critical illness, disability, and life insurance, they're there when you need them most.
- 23:24When certainty becomes uncertainty, when security becomes insecurity, no matter how life happens, RBC Insurance is there to help you prepare, protect, and face what comes next
- 23:35with greater confidence.
- 23:37Because insurance matters to you, to me, and to RBC.
- 23:45And the moment you're trying to emulate someone else's success, you're giving up your own.
- 23:50That takes a certain type of person, you know, like not to conform, not to necessarily f you know
- 23:57fit in when sometimes that might serve them temporarily.
- 24:01And we're in this amazing time where we've got tools where we don't really have to to conform.
- 24:06I mean, you know, we may fail, but it's always good to to fail doing something that you believe in rather than regretting that you didn't try.
- 24:15Today my special guest is Aaron Bethune and the best way to describe him is a Renaissance man.
- 24:20He's a writer, he's a creator, he's a mountain climber, and he's in a constant conversation with the role humans play in this beautiful place called Planet Earth.
- 24:35AI arise, does that not challenge everything you believe is important to us?
- 24:42I mean AI is gonna help nudge you into an echo chamber.
- 24:46AI is gonna take away the need to even focus on the present.
- 24:50Spoon feed you.
- 24:51I mean, is there a way that we can apply AI in our lives that can improve, that can put more human in humanity?
- 24:59AI, of course, has been around for a long time, but the LLMs and you know chat GPTs of the world that we think of, not so long.
- 25:06And I'm interested in in what it's trained on because it's all trained on output.
- 25:11And what I'm interested in is context.
- 25:13What was the human experience that led to that human providing that output that that that then the AI has trained on?
- 25:20And in my case, like everybody else that came into contact with the chat GPTs of the world, you know, I I was curious.
- 25:28I had what
- 25:29you a lot of people refer to as a oneness experience.
- 25:31And it happened during a meditation.
- 25:33It was about two hours into the meditation.
- 25:34And I just completely ceased to to being me.
- 25:37I became absolutely everything.
- 25:39And I had this sort of sense of clarity of being of Aaron being a vessel of awareness of veneer, of my re my reality being of veneer that, you know, made me feel like Aaron was a
- 25:51thing.
- 25:52But what this experience gave me was the understanding of I'm the ocean.
- 25:55And that we all have these, we're all waves, and we can look at the other wave and go, wow, look at that wave.
- 26:00He's so much bigger or smaller, whatever.
- 26:02But at the end of the day, the realization of being the ocean is what that experience kind of provided me.
- 26:08So I then went off on this sort of search to try and find the words that would really express that experience.
- 26:14So I could point to it and say, that that's that's what I felt, that's what I experienced.
- 26:17So I come across this quote by a living Zen master, and I end up actually reaching out to him.
- 26:24And we have this meeting set up, and I'm really quite excited about it.
- 26:28And the day of our our meeting, which was a Saturday, a touch base, hey, we're still on for our our our conversation.
- 26:36And he says, you know, we're gonna have to cancel because there's really nothing for us to talk about.
- 26:41He said, Here's what AI has to say about your question.
- 26:45And he sends me this deeply profound explanation that is being created by AI.
- 26:51And it just
- 26:52It made me really think about language.
- 26:55Here's the English language, which of which, you know, the the Chat GPTs of the world have every single word, so to speak.
- 27:02And then here's what we know and here's what we use, and that's our little window to express our human experience.
- 27:07And yet AI has all of the words and no experience.
- 27:12But it can still become something profound and it can still be something useful, but it it cannot be human.
- 27:18It cannot have that experience.
- 27:20If language is this
- 27:22tool of which we have meanings to the words.
- 27:26They're all just, you know, icons of a greater meaning.
- 27:28What what exactly is it to be human?
- 27:31Because words don't make us human.
- 27:33You know, that that is is a veneer of its own, right?
- 27:35It's an outer shell of of a personal internal experience is our communication is through language or through the arts, which is nonverbal at times, you know, dance, art, you know,
- 27:46music.
- 27:46It's it's it's those sorts of things that I think are are are human, of which I think the most
- 27:53moving of of those forms are the ones that are with imperfections.
- 27:59You know, it's the imperfection that resonates with us.
- 28:02If you listen to to that for some reason I'm thinking of the police right now, you know, you've got Stuart Copeland pushing that beat forward with a lot of intensity and you have
- 28:11Sting pulling back on the bass.
- 28:13That causes tension and release.
- 28:14And that's just like
- 28:15Something's going on, you know, or someone sings and their voice cracks, or the note doesn't bend to the quite, you goes a little too far or not quite enough.
- 28:23Mmm, that's real.
- 28:25But if you go and you fix it in the studio and you and you and you do all of that and you make it so that it's everything's on the beat, everything's in tune, everything's
- 28:32absolutely perfect, something's off.
- 28:35And now, you know, you move forward in technology.
- 28:38There's there's some technology.
- 28:39There was one technology in particular, they actually had a button that was called the humanizer.
- 28:43And it just scrambled stuff.
- 28:45And I was like, are you kidding me?
- 28:46Like, you need to now press a button to humanize, to scramble, so it's not perfect.
- 28:51And I think that's the thing too with with language.
- 28:53When you look at these LLMs, you know, we're we're seeing a lot of patterns in how how it expresses language.
- 29:01And we're starting to see those patterns as ways to go, yeah, that was written by AI.
- 29:05In reality, when you look at the people that have stood out, it's because they don't fit in, because they've broken the rules, they've broken the patterns.
- 29:11I mean
- 29:12Look at Elvis, right?
- 29:13I mean, I grew up wanting to listen to Elvis when I was five.
- 29:17Later on I got a chance to work with with some of his guys when I was producing B.B.
- 29:21King's band.
- 29:21And as a time when the way he was moving was just like, whoa, you can't do that.
- 29:27Same with Lady Gaga and the meat dresses.
- 29:29Like, whoa, wait a second, what is this, right?
- 29:31Data doesn't tell you that.
- 29:33You can't and and that's what all of this is working on is the past.
- 29:36The past.
- 29:37I'm I'm talking to people right now in the music industry about, well, how do we find
- 29:41What's going to happen next?
- 29:42What's gonna be the next big hit?
- 29:44And one of the things that I'm looking at is just a sort of a possibility is AI's ability to see patterns, yes, but also to process language.
- 29:53And is there ways for us to determine if something's going to become a hit because of how it makes people feel from day one?
- 29:59I mean
- 30:00Matt Damon talking about what it's like now to create for the Netflix audience, that they're told that they've got to restate the plot three times.
- 30:09They got to move the hook or the action scene into the first scene where a great movie builds towards the action scene.
- 30:16It's not that we're less intelligent, it's just we're that much more distracted.
- 30:22And if we continue to drive all our creativity off of what the data says.
- 30:28the recommendation economy, the Spotifies of the world that and the tells you what the playlist should be.
- 30:34I agree with you.
- 30:34I think we're in danger of completely erasing the mistakes that often turn into the magic.
- 30:41I think there's still hope for the human race that we realize that when everything sounds and looks and feels the same, what's going to make people interesting is not their ability
- 30:52to like where I grew up.
- 30:53Were you a Beatle fan or a Rolling Stones fan?
- 30:55Did you drink Budweiser?
- 30:57or Molson X to really finding those unique pieces, the Picasso in the attic that you might find day to day just being present.
- 31:06Well, I think there's agency too.
- 31:08I mean, it was interesting because years ago when we were looking at this when big data started really showing up in music.
- 31:14Is there a turning point in which there's been enough views on a video that people will get on the train and and support it?
- 31:22And the answer is yes.
- 31:23You know, there was a number in which you had to have at least X amount of views in order for people to share it.
- 31:28And that was partly because not everyone feels comfortable being the first person to say, no, this is really good.
- 31:34I know nobody else thinks it is.
- 31:36But I think it is and you should pay attention.
- 31:38But once it sort of hit that point, that tipping point, we could determine that that was going to spread further because it was validated.
- 31:45And I think that's part of this too, is it's like, yeah, you can come up with all sorts of patterns that, you know, you I mean, look at some of these amazing authors today that are
- 31:53basically using their name as the brand, but they have people writing it for them.
- 31:56It finna if they're following a formula.
- 31:58But, you know, is that enough?
- 32:01Should should should we be accepting of just the same old, same old that enables us to go, Yeah, that was that was good.
- 32:06Where I
- 32:07see AI as the most dangerous is not the conductor of the orchestra that's gonna use AI and really explore with the curiosity of the brain, not having to be interrupted just to get
- 32:18lost in it.
- 32:19But I think the vast majority are saying, no, I've I'm signed up to be a session musician and I'm just gonna get AI to do my work.
- 32:26I guess the the Hollywood line is AI won't take away your job, but if you don't use AI, it will.
- 32:32I think it's even different.
- 32:33I think there's some people are going to be airing on a mountain
- 32:37through AI and then next day Aaron and the jazz doing improv with other jazz musicians because of AI.
- 32:44And there'll be a lot of other people that'll go, I've lost any meaning for life because I'm I've surrendered it to something that is very convenient and expresses thoughts much
- 32:55better than I could.
- 32:56deeper sort of end of things for me personally, I'm looking at at as, okay, it's another tool in the tool belt.
- 33:03And we've got social media that at one point in time at least people thought was amazing.
- 33:08But I I don't know, is it amazing?
- 33:10I mean, f for example, you look at the indigenous communities and they have such depth of knowledge of the place that they're from that they can point to where mammoth bones are
- 33:18buried from who knows how many generations back.
- 33:20That's depth of knowledge from your community, from your generations in that location.
- 33:26Once upon a time, music had uh a similar thing.
- 33:28It was, you know, you had the Chicago sound.
- 33:31That sounds like this geographic location.
- 33:34Clear channel came along, bought up all these radio stations, started programming from headquarters, and suddenly you lose the the sound of the places.
- 33:42Well, social media shows up, and suddenly I can tell you what's going on in Israel, you know, better than I don't know, someone in Israel, based on my perception, of course.
- 33:52Yet I couldn't tell you what's going on in my local community.
- 33:55I mean, if you look at the current state of things, a lot of the tools that people are building are empty.
- 34:00They're void of of you.
- 34:01They're an empty tool for you to insert yourself into to make those have some kind of value.
- 34:06Well, those same tools are using AI to create content that sounds and looks very similar.
- 34:12So at what point do we lose our individuality as we start to use all the tools that are available to us?
- 34:17So my sort of feeling is is it's like, you know, people say, Well, I could never make a difference in the world.
- 34:21I could never change the world.
- 34:22I could
- 34:23But maybe you could.
- 34:24I mean, maybe you could actually start to look inside of yourself and really determine what what is your purpose to be here?
- 34:30What are things that you can make an impact on?
- 34:32I mean, sure, you could have liked a million people's posts today.
- 34:35I guarantee those people haven't really been affected.
- 34:38Momentary sort of dopamine things going off saying, Well, I got another like.
- 34:43But that interaction, those things that that machines and technology can't replace is the truly human parts of our experience and to to
- 34:52to find ourselves.
- 34:53Like there's an Alan Watts story where talks about God playing hide and seek in everybody and doing such a good job that we've forgotten that that's the case.
- 35:01And that when we find that, that we come to realization we're all God.
- 35:05I'm not coming at this from a religious standpoint, but I'm just saying that we have to go on these explorations and have these experiences to find those kind of things.
- 35:13And I I think we're distracted with technologies.
- 35:16What I do appreciate about AI and some of the stuff that I'm involved in.
- 35:20is this idea of context and looking into people's experiences and connecting those dots.
- 35:25And I find that the AI can sometimes see patterns that we're incapable of seeing because of our egos.
- 35:31And that's fascinating to me.
- 35:33But, you know, at the end of the day, I think that we have to really also question, you know, why why are we doing what we do?
- 35:39And I know that there's a lot of people that could sort of say, well, I'm doing this to pay the bills.
- 35:43And that's a very valid reason.
- 35:44But at the same time, it's we have more choice than we think.
- 35:48And, you know, they say, well, if there's guns to your head, you don't have a choice.
- 35:50Well, you still have a choice.
- 35:52You might not like it, but you still have a choice.
- 35:55And I think if we don't stop and, you know, pause and reflect and create space between our thoughts so that we can see these things more clearly, then we just get sucked into all of
- 36:04this technology that takes us down a path of a echo chambers and when AI is training on itself, it gets worse in synthetic learning.
- 36:12You know, when we start to sound like AI, we're not bringing anything new.
- 36:16If that's what we we deem to be the experience of what's going on in the world, then it's it can be quite depressive.
- 36:23Yeah.
- 36:23Aaron, here's what I'm taking away from our talk today.
- 36:28The first thing that you said that I want people to take away is how, how, how.
- 36:33This insatiable appetite to understand things, to not just look at a painting, but to wonder w what the canvas was made of and how they framed it and everything else that goes
- 36:45with it.
- 36:46Because I think scroll, scroll, scroll is as options you get from how how how.
- 36:51The second thing is
- 36:52I like to get to the corner to see what's next.
- 36:55I've never heard that before.
- 36:56And I just thought what a wonderful metaphor not to stay on the straightaway, even though it feels good and you feel like you're going fast, but to actually look for the hair pins
- 37:06and the and the corners because things might change.
- 37:09You might be heading off into a different direction and being open to that.
- 37:13And then the last one I guess is that what you just talked about, and it's probably the chord that's resonated the most is you have more choice than you think.
- 37:22Success is freedom.
- 37:24You know, if we get so caught up in our materialistic making sure we're getting validation of social media, making sure we're posting, describe our most interesting life, and we
- 37:34lose that, the moments that you've had on the mountain from your bedroom trying to produce light in Japan, the many stories you shared with me that we could do a whole series on, I
- 37:44just think you're you truly are a renaissance guy and it just reminds me sometimes that I should
- 37:50Slow down and smell the flowers, like my mother used to tell me.
- 37:53The combination of you doing that and at the same time frantically looking all around you for the how, how, how is what I think makes you one of the the most interesting people in
- 38:03my life.
- 38:03So I appreciate you joining me on Chatter the Matter.
- 38:05Thank you so much, Tony.
- 38:06And I I must say that, you know, you asked me, did I think I was training just to find Mike?
- 38:12And I said I think I was.
- 38:13And I think that that's something that I always keep with me all the time and understanding that, you know, yes, you might have signed up to do a specific thing, or you
- 38:21might have told yourself, I'm gonna do this for the next thirty days, or whatever that is, it's also perhaps the thing that put you on the path to find out what you're really meant
- 38:31to do.
- 38:32And I think if you're open to that, it's the difference between I'm putting my blinders on, I'm not letting myself distract get distracted by anything, to I'm gonna take the
- 38:40blinders off and still stay focused on the path I've set, but recognizing there's things around me that are in my periphery that if I can pay attention, maybe those are things I'm
- 38:49meant to be.
- 38:49And that's, you know, a big part of what I do today with people is is is help them to reflect on where they've come from and where they're headed and and maybe consider that
- 38:57there's there's a corner yet to be turned that they haven't even seen in front of them.
- 39:03Once again, a special thanks to RBC for supporting Chatter That Matters.
- 39:07It's Tony Chapman.
- 39:08Thanks for listening, and let's chat soon.