Latest / History Harpies: Pop Culture, Past and Present / No, Don't Let That Dashingly Handsome Vampire Inside (Ft. Sinners, Dracula, and Interview With the Vampire)
Transcript
- 0:00They say we're loud, opinionated, afraid Telling
- 0:05us to hush, dim our historical light But darlings,
- 0:09we're the Harpies, sharp and keen Unveiling the
- 0:12truth behind the silver screen History Harpies
- 0:17hear us roar Hi, this is History Harpies. I'm
- 0:33Lauren. And I'm Christine. And welcome to what
- 0:36is episode... Fourteen! Fourteen, I think. Something
- 0:41like that. This week we are in the spirit of
- 0:45Halloween, Halloween which is on Friday, and
- 0:48if you are a... teenager or in college, you will
- 0:52have Halloween Weekend. I've never heard that before.
- 0:56Yeah, my daughter has Halloween Weekend, which is
- 0:58a series of parties and different costumes, and
- 1:01she probably has three or four different costumes.
- 1:03Are you serious? Yes. So it's like a wedding
- 1:05weekend. Yes. Yes. Extravaganza. Yes. I had no
- 1:08idea. It begins with some pre -gaming on Thursday,
- 1:11which of course, well, not of course, but for
- 1:13our listeners is homecoming, which will then
- 1:16segue into Halloween. Fantastic. And she has
- 1:18a Friday outfit, a Friday, like, afternoon outfit,
- 1:22and then a Saturday outfit. Unbelievable. Even
- 1:24though Saturday is not Halloween anymore, but
- 1:26you can still, you know, carry it on. Yes. Yes.
- 1:29It drags on. The whole weekend. Yes. And of course,
- 1:31if you're in college, Halloween is like the most
- 1:34debauchery, the most... fun the most everything
- 1:38and it goes on for many weekends yeah my son
- 1:42in college one of my sons in college told me
- 1:45that people actually rushed in fall, so they
- 1:49could do Halloween in the fraternity. Interesting.
- 1:52You know, this really is one of the most weird
- 1:54developments in American culture, that Halloween
- 1:57has become an adult holiday. It really is. I
- 1:59don't approve of that. I have to say, I don't.
- 2:02Oh, God. I don't approve of that. I do, because
- 2:03I have my Halloween tradition, which is getting
- 2:07in some ways more rigid every year, but in a
- 2:09good way, is I sit on my porch, I get really...
- 2:12really drunk, in a good way. In a good way. And
- 2:17I give out Halloween candy and I make all kinds
- 2:21of Halloween cocktails, themed cocktails. I have
- 2:24some friends over and I just enjoy the little
- 2:28kids and the costumes. Everyone swings by. Yeah,
- 2:31and just remember when my kids were little and
- 2:33they used to love it so much and do it. So yeah,
- 2:36I have my own Halloween tradition. And I also,
- 2:39because the alcohol, of course, permits me to
- 2:42eat more candy than I normally do. It's all good.
- 2:46Halloween is good. So I wanted to start, even
- 2:48though this themed episode is about vampires,
- 2:52we're going to talk a lot about vampire movies,
- 2:55to ask Christine what her favorite childhood
- 2:58Halloween costume was. This is a hard question
- 3:02because for two reasons. One, my memory of my
- 3:05childhood costumes is not great. I remember being
- 3:09a princess in one of those box costumes when
- 3:12I was really little. I tried to have my mother
- 3:15make me a punk costume when I was in sixth grade.
- 3:18That did not go well. But the other reason why
- 3:21it's a difficult question for me is that of course,
- 3:24growing up in the great state of Maine, it was
- 3:28always freezing on October 31st and so Maine
- 3:33kids had to wear coats over the costume. Such
- 3:37a problem. But even in Philadelphia, I remember
- 3:41that issue is that you wanted to wear this amazing
- 3:44outfit and then you had to wear some big coat
- 3:47over it and no one knew what you were and then
- 3:50you had to take it off when you get to every
- 3:52house. Good point. So this is such a strong component
- 3:56of my memory of how Halloween's as a child, putting
- 4:00the coat on. And of course, back when I was trick
- 4:03-or -treating, you were trick -or -treating,
- 4:04we still might get things like apples and cookies,
- 4:07right? Which is like so fun. Oh, with a razor
- 4:09blade. With a razor blade. The urban legend.
- 4:14Gen X Halloween was always about an apple with
- 4:18a razor blade in it, which I - With a drug -coated
- 4:21candy bar. Okay, I will tell you, my favorite
- 4:25Halloween costume, Now, just in tradition, Halloween
- 4:29traditions, when I was in elementary school,
- 4:31I went to Wyancotte Elementary School, which is
- 4:33the best elementary school on the planet. And
- 4:36our elementary school was located right next
- 4:38to an assisted living facility. And so one of
- 4:41the traditions that we had was to have a parade
- 4:44in front of the assisted living facility so that
- 4:47the seniors would come out and would enjoy seeing
- 4:51all these cute little kids in their outfits.
- 4:54Little costumes. I do not come from a family
- 4:58that sews or makes clothing. However, however,
- 5:04someone in my family, I can't remember if it
- 5:05was my mother or my father, helped me make a
- 5:08Crayola crown costume. And I was a red crown.
- 5:12And I wore the, you know, bottom was the kind
- 5:15of barrel part of it. And then I had the little
- 5:18pointy cap, which was the top of the crayon.
- 5:20And I paraded around in front of these seniors.
- 5:24And so the memory of wearing that crayon costume
- 5:26in some ways has much less to do with trick or
- 5:28treating on Halloween night proper, but more
- 5:31to do with the parade and the joy that it brought
- 5:33to the people. And I know that sounds sappy,
- 5:35but it really was this awesome tradition we had
- 5:38in our school and that everyone looked forward
- 5:40to it. Again, it was like brings me so much joy.
- 5:43I don't know if they do it anymore, but it was
- 5:46it was terrific Yeah, so my Halloween. It's funny
- 5:50my I was never anything scary and in part because
- 5:53I'm kind of scared of my own costume I like horror
- 6:00films, but I don't like dressing up myself like
- 6:03something scary. Interesting. Yeah, we can get
- 6:06into the psyche of that some more. But I never
- 6:09wanted to be anything scary. I never wanted to
- 6:12go trick or treating with people who are dressed
- 6:13as things that were scary. And I don't like being
- 6:16scared by actual humans on Halloween, which if
- 6:20you live in this neighborhood, you really can
- 6:22be. Our neighbors across the street do a phenomenal
- 6:24job, as you know, of scaring the shit out of
- 6:27the people who come to their house. So this is
- 6:31an incredible place to live for Halloween because
- 6:33I get like 500 trick -or -treaters. And the problem
- 6:38is I haven't even bought the candy yet. I have
- 6:40not either. I'm waiting for it to go on sale.
- 6:42Yeah, exactly. I went the other day to Publix
- 6:45and it was like... I could do not, like $16 for
- 6:48a bag of like seven Kit Kats. I'm like, no, no,
- 6:51I will wait for this shit to be a BOGO. And I
- 6:55also buy only the Halloween candy that I like
- 6:57to eat. So I gotta wait for the Kit Kats and
- 6:59the Twizzlers and I'm not buying - Twizzlers?
- 7:02Oh my - Oh my God, Twizzlers. Twizzlers are my
- 7:04favorite candy. Twizzlers are so awful. Come
- 7:05on now, girl. They're awful. They're awful. Again,
- 7:08we're gonna have to have a talk. Oh my goodness.
- 7:09We're gonna have to have another talk. How is
- 7:10this even possible? Do you know that I have like
- 7:12a king -size Twizzlers downstairs? I know they're
- 7:15plastic, but I love them. They're plastic! I
- 7:17know, and I eat them regularly. I eat them regularly.
- 7:20Yeah, I'll drink a Diet Coke, a Diet Dr. Pepper,
- 7:24and eat a Twizzler. And I might as well smoke
- 7:27a cigarette. Yeah. Yeah, I mean. It might be
- 7:29more healthy for you to smoke the cigarette than
- 7:31to eat the Twizzler. I eat so many, everyone
- 7:33who knows, I don't know how, how do you not know
- 7:35this about me? I don't know, it's amazing. Everyone
- 7:37who knows me knows I love my kids. You probably
- 7:40told me this like 10 years ago and I blocked
- 7:42it out of my brain on purpose. Yeah, because
- 7:44you obviously found it so disturbing. You found
- 7:46it disturbing. Yeah. I love Twizzlers. You and
- 7:48Carrie Bradshaw. Carrie Bradshaw loves Twizzlers.
- 7:50Oh, there, I know. Well, I love licorice. I don't
- 7:53like black licorice, but I love licorice. And
- 7:56in fact, there's a site called licorice .com.
- 7:59And I'm just hoping that somebody will love me
- 8:01enough one day to like order me a year long subscription
- 8:05to that place. Yeah, honestly. Yeah, small things.
- 8:09I love, love me some Twizzlers. Well, that is
- 8:12good to know. Gummies, Twizzlers, anything like
- 8:16that. But Twizzlers, and here's something now
- 8:18that they have, which it's a combination of the
- 8:21Diet Coke and the Twizzler. It's the sugar -free
- 8:23Twizzler. So even. So even. Yeah, so it's like
- 8:27you're just... It's like an abomination poison.
- 8:29Poison and abomination. It's like a Botox in
- 8:31a candy. And I just eat it up. Eat it up. I have
- 8:35it on my, you know, on the... Passengers seat
- 8:38in the car and I'm just driving along eating
- 8:41the twizzlers. I may take them to this class.
- 8:42I have to go to later The students know I love
- 8:46the twizzlers and they always have to twizzlers
- 8:49out in in the you know in the department office
- 8:52Interesting well, okay on that Early funeral
- 9:00you can like line my coffin with twizzlers. I
- 9:05love it This is so awful. We have to leave this
- 9:08topic immediately because it's so disturbing
- 9:10to me. So this week we decided that in honor
- 9:14of Halloween, we would talk about vampires. And
- 9:17of course, vampires have already come up in our
- 9:19pod when we talked about Salem's Lot, when we
- 9:22talked about Maine and Stephen King. We are not
- 9:25going to be talking about Salem's Lot today,
- 9:27but we did watch and think about a bunch of other
- 9:31things having to do with vampires. And spoiler
- 9:34alert. Sex workers will once again come back
- 9:38into this podcast. Where are the sex workers
- 9:40in our week? In Interview with a Vampire. How
- 9:43could I forget? So we watched Interview with
- 9:47a Vampire. The original Brad Pitt and Tom Cruise
- 9:51film, not the more recent series. And I didn't
- 9:53even know that that thing existed. It does, and
- 9:55I haven't seen it. And then we watched Francis
- 9:59Ford Coppola's Dracula. And we watched Sinners
- 10:04and we watched none of these films together,
- 10:07which is important because in past pods we have
- 10:10watched them together. We watched these separately.
- 10:13And so this will be a little bit of a schizophrenic
- 10:18podcast. And we have some disagreements. We do.
- 10:21About these. And in fact, it is the case that
- 10:24we have not talked at all together about Sinners.
- 10:27No. So we have no idea. No idea. We're like one
- 10:30of those game shows. Like a dating game where
- 10:32people are like behind pieces of glass or something.
- 10:35The reveal. The reveal. And one thing I will
- 10:37say that, and I don't know, you know, we can
- 10:40psychologize you with your Twizzlers. We can
- 10:43psychologize me with the vampires because...
- 10:45Being afraid of vampires is one of my earliest
- 10:48earliest childhood memories. I was and of course,
- 10:52you know, maybe it's a main creepy thing I was
- 10:54terrified of vampires, but also fascinated by
- 10:57them at the same time and I will say I still
- 10:59probably remain so And I give them no thought
- 11:02at all. No thought at all. Vampires, no. Not
- 11:06in my consciousness. Don't think about them.
- 11:08When there's a movie that comes out and it loves
- 11:10True Blood, I watch the whole series. I really
- 11:15appreciate some hot vampires. What about Twilight?
- 11:18Did you see Twilight? Yes. I also have not seen
- 11:20Twilight. Read the books. Even read the books.
- 11:23um but other than that other than cultural content
- 11:26i just never give them a second thought and in
- 11:28fact it's funny that even since these movies
- 11:31i almost haven't given them a second thought,
- 11:33even since the movies. How is this possible?
- 11:36I just don't think about it. It's so interesting.
- 11:37I don't think about them. But I think also, perhaps.
- 11:40I think it's your feel. No, that's exactly it.
- 11:42I was going to say, because I'm a European historian,
- 11:45and you're an American historian. Perhaps that
- 11:47I do think my field lends itself to whatever extent
- 11:51our vampire lore is indebted to European, Eastern
- 11:56European folklore. I think that probably is the
- 11:58case. And you're also very much a specialist.
- 12:01Obviously. religion, spirituality, supernatural,
- 12:06all of that, and I don't go near any of that.
- 12:08Except for just, like, the real, like, basic
- 12:11stuff. Stuff. The stuff. So let's see. Do you
- 12:16first want to talk about, we have Dracula and
- 12:19Interview with a Vampire. And Interview with
- 12:20a Vampire. Okay, let's start with those, which
- 12:22came out around the same time. Yeah, about 1994
- 12:26-ish. In the 90s. Yes. And as I told Christine,
- 12:30which goes into this. I was in college during
- 12:34those years, so I did not see a lot of movies
- 12:36in the theater. There just was no reason. I was
- 12:40having my own fun. And so my watch or even re
- 12:46-watch or maybe even first watch of these films
- 12:48was either on video or later, like I did the
- 12:52other night, watching these movies here streaming.
- 12:54So I never saw them in the theater or if I did
- 12:57see them in the theater, I was so drunk from
- 13:01being in college and I just didn't even register.
- 13:04Yeah, I don't believe I saw either of these movies
- 13:07in the theater. And I will start by saying, and
- 13:10Christine knows this, that I really, really detested
- 13:14Dracula. I think it is actually now, Jim and
- 13:18I went through the Francis Ford Coppola filmography
- 13:20and he really only has like three good films.
- 13:23So I would put this into the trash bin of his
- 13:26like bad films. And I actually really enjoyed
- 13:32Interview. vampire on all levels. I can't say
- 13:38that I enjoyed it in a, you know, kind of contemporary
- 13:41sense, but I appreciated it for what it was in
- 13:45the period. I think a lot of it holds up. Some
- 13:48of it kind of doesn't make some sense, but I
- 13:51also like, you give me some Brad Pitt and it's
- 13:54going to be tough for me not to like it. So there's
- 13:59that. Now, I know we have very different opinions
- 14:03on this. We do. So we are completely flipped
- 14:07in that I love Coppola's Dracula. It's not that
- 14:13I dislike Interview of the Vampire. I'm simply
- 14:15lukewarm about it. I have a lot of problems with
- 14:17it. And both of those films I did see in the
- 14:21theater as a sober person. I was sober. I saw
- 14:24both of them in the theater. Something else that
- 14:26probably bears bringing up is, so I have read
- 14:30the novel, Stoker's novel Dracula, multiple times,
- 14:34and I have read Anne Rice's Interview of the
- 14:36Vampire. As have I. Okay. As have I. So it has
- 14:38been a long time since I read that novel. A long
- 14:40time. And both of them, for me, I'll just say
- 14:42were required readings in multiple classes. Okay.
- 14:46Interesting. I didn't read either one of them
- 14:48as a quote on my own. Okay. And I did read both
- 14:50of them on my own. I read them for a gothic novel
- 14:52or I think I may have taken like Witches, Vampires,
- 14:57and Something Class at Wellesley and we read
- 14:59Anne Rice. Okay. So again, I was kind of taught
- 15:03these books more than I explored them on my own.
- 15:05And I certainly haven't read them in the past
- 15:08two decades. Okay. And did you read The Vampire
- 15:10Lestat, the sequel to Interview the Vampire?
- 15:14Again, in the class. Yes. Yes. Okay. And so,
- 15:17and I read these things in the wild. Okay. And
- 15:20as I said, have read Dracula multiple, multiple
- 15:22times. I've also read, I have to bring it up.
- 15:25I've also read several times the original vampire
- 15:28story, which is John Polidori's The Vampyre which
- 15:33came out of the same meeting at which Mary Shelley
- 15:36wrote Frankenstein, sort of the meeting with
- 15:39Lord Byron when they're all sitting around some
- 15:40beautiful house at Lake Geneva. I've read that
- 15:44which really is foundational and part of the
- 15:46reason why I want to bring up holiday right now
- 15:48is because when we talk about Sinners I will
- 15:50be bringing it up again but this is the foundational
- 15:53story it's a novella that says here's our noble
- 15:56aristocratic vampire figure which really sets
- 15:59the stage for Dracula and I think also for Interview
- 16:01the absolutely absolutely. So we have then an
- 16:05Interview the Vampire. As you say, Brad Pitt
- 16:08is our central character, the vampire who is
- 16:11being interviewed, Louis, who is a New Orleans
- 16:14nobleman, what in the late 18th century when
- 16:17we first meet. So it's the film starts in 1790.
- 16:22Okay, so this is right after the American Revolution.
- 16:26This is early national. uh history so before
- 16:30the civil war for our listeners and uh they are
- 16:35in New Orleans very much taking part of Creole
- 16:39culture, very much feeling, one of the things
- 16:42I like about this film is that it's very much
- 16:44pulling apart the different cultures that are
- 16:46existing at the time. And there isn't this sort
- 16:48of like Yankee, British post -revolutionary fervor
- 16:53as much as there is this interest in Creole culture.
- 16:56And we are told very explicitly and shown very
- 16:59explicitly that Louis is a master at a plantation
- 17:03with numerous enslaved people. who he in a lot
- 17:08of, well, one of them. kills but the rest of
- 17:12them protects and warns and says you're the you
- 17:15know your master is a devil and you need to you
- 17:18need to leave this site and they do but when
- 17:21the film starts he has lost his wife when he's
- 17:24the human he's lost his wife in childbirth he's
- 17:28devastated he's basically walking around looking
- 17:31for someone to kill him he's so devastated he
- 17:34wants to be reunited with his wife in in heaven
- 17:36or whatever and he comes upon the vampire Lestat
- 17:41who gets him to make the decision, or introduces
- 17:45the decision rather, for Louis to become a vampire.
- 17:49And this is very much a focus in interview, the
- 17:52question of choice, choosing whether to become
- 17:55one or not. We're told repeatedly that Lestat
- 17:57was not given a choice to become a vampire. I
- 18:01mean, the decision making process is not really
- 18:03clear with Louis, I think. I mean, we're told,
- 18:05of course, that he's making a choice. But we
- 18:07also have what was, of course, the very frankly
- 18:10erotic initial scene of Lestat, as Tom Cruise
- 18:14as Lestat, beginning to feed on Louis. You've
- 18:18got this scene that was so... And Louis does
- 18:21become a vampire, but it's not really clear because
- 18:23he's such a reluctant one. He doesn't want to
- 18:25kill humans. He is such a reluctant vampire.
- 18:27And it is very, very interesting to me this portrayal
- 18:31of, again, a vampire that doesn't want to kill
- 18:33humans. A vampire with very human feelings and
- 18:37a personality that is very similar to his human
- 18:40personality. And this is, of course, the problem.
- 18:43That Tom Cruise, Lestat, however we think about
- 18:45it, is consistently saying you're going to change,
- 18:50you'll see, you can only eat rats for so long
- 18:53and you're going to become like me, essentially.
- 18:56And he doesn't. But in the sense of feeding off
- 19:00humans regularly, being much, much more manipulative
- 19:04and much, much more having more evil in him.
- 19:09But when they come across, the Kirsten Dunst
- 19:12character, Claudia, which is so interesting to
- 19:15me because Brad Pitt kills her, feeds on her,
- 19:20sort of unwittingly, and then Tom Cruise with...
- 19:24turns her into a vampire and she doesn't have
- 19:26the choice and I mean again she's this little
- 19:29girl and she just wants to be alive and he says
- 19:32well do you want to be a vampire and she's like
- 19:33oh okay sure I just want to be alive I mean at
- 19:37that point she her her her mother has died from
- 19:40plague and you know she's she has nobody and
- 19:43she just basically just wants to be alive And
- 19:46the interesting thing with her is that for a
- 19:48while, and of course time in this movie is, you
- 19:50know, they go through hundreds of centuries,
- 19:53right? She is a very good vampire in the beginning,
- 19:56in the sense of Lestat's view. She's a willing
- 19:59killer. Yeah, she kills whoever, she kills whole
- 20:01families, she's his little kind of pupil, and
- 20:06grows very close to Brad Pitt, but then realizes
- 20:11that She will not age and that she will not become
- 20:15a woman and that she is trapped in this child's
- 20:18body and that is very, very devastating for her
- 20:23and that she will both need a supervisor. She's
- 20:27in this very weird liminal space of both needing
- 20:31a parent and needing help because she can't be
- 20:34independent because she is a child, but she's
- 20:36also a vampire and she is a killer and she can.
- 20:40You know, go out and murder a whole bunch of
- 20:42people, and that's how she survives. And of course,
- 20:45those are against vampire rules, we later learn,
- 20:48that you're not supposed to turn little kids
- 20:52into vampires. And it's done very explicitly,
- 20:55in the same way as a potentially divorcing couple
- 20:57saying, we need to have another baby, right,
- 20:59to hold this marriage together. Right. We're
- 21:01told that this is why Lestat does this. He fears
- 21:04that we will leave him. And there definitely
- 21:05is this question, both of family, but also companionship.
- 21:10And certainly one of the most disturbing ideas
- 21:14about Claudia is that it's in terms of saying
- 21:17what is the age of this thing, right, in terms
- 21:22of both the family dynamics, but also the erotics,
- 21:25right? Where we have these scenes, really disturbing
- 21:27scenes, where the fantastic Kirsten Dunst. I
- 21:30mean, she's incredible. She really is, her performance
- 21:35is stand out, stunning in this film. But we have
- 21:39these images of what is a child and not a child
- 21:42kissing Louis, saying, you're my love. And obviously
- 21:46it begins as this family dynamic that she is
- 21:49described as being their daughter, the daughter
- 21:51of these two men who are companions. But then
- 21:54as her mind ages, as she is more of a killer,
- 21:57even though her body has remained the same, there
- 21:59is, I think, again, really disturbing dynamics
- 22:02and this hint of... pedophilia, especially when,
- 22:06in order to kill Lestat, she brings home two
- 22:09boys, right? Two boys that she has drugged. He
- 22:13obviously doesn't know this. And this is the
- 22:16gift. This is the gift that she can think to
- 22:18bring to him. These two beautiful boys. And so
- 22:21I think that that, you know... Very famously,
- 22:24Anne Rice includes that character because she
- 22:26was trying to get over her own daughter's death.
- 22:29And the character in the book is much younger.
- 22:30She's five. And I think we're all grateful that
- 22:32it's not a five -year -old in the family. But
- 22:35that, to me, is so fascinating about the Claudia
- 22:38character. And as you say, this isn't supposed
- 22:41to happen in vampire world, but it is so monumentally
- 22:44disturbing in the context of the film. It is.
- 22:46And towards the end of the film, when, you know,
- 22:50Louis sort of saying, I have to leave you and
- 22:53she's like, well, I need another companion now.
- 22:55I need a mother figure. And she finds this woman
- 22:58and the woman is willing because she's lost her
- 23:00own daughter. And again, you really feel so much.
- 23:05empathy for Kirsten Dunst absolutely because
- 23:09she is trapped and she will always need someone
- 23:13to watch over her while at the same time she
- 23:15has this vampire maturity and she has these evolving
- 23:19adult feelings and she kind of, again, being
- 23:23sort of trapped in this body and that this issue
- 23:26of choice for her, which she didn't have, and
- 23:29you understand the vampire rules, right? When
- 23:31you sort of see why they're saying don't turn
- 23:34kids into vampires, right? And of course she
- 23:36very, very tragically dies in the end in a way
- 23:40that is very cruel. And also, I mean, in some
- 23:44ways, this is one of my questions, which is a
- 23:46practical matter. It's like, well, so Lestat's
- 23:48not dead. And don't vampires understand who's
- 23:52alive and who's dead? Apparently not. Because
- 23:55this is her punishment for, quote unquote, killing
- 23:57Lestat. That's right. Even though he comes back
- 23:59to life, or comes back to life, quote unquote,
- 24:01a couple of times. He comes back to life, but
- 24:03also what I didn't understand, and again, these
- 24:04are just practical matters, right? Is that, so
- 24:07when Brad Pitt sees him at the end of the movie,
- 24:09and he's like, you know, decrepit and old, and
- 24:13sitting there, and you assume he's been sitting
- 24:14in this chair for like hundreds of years. Feeding
- 24:16on rats. Feeding on rats. And then somehow he
- 24:20gets the energy. to fly into Christian Slater's
- 24:24car and feed on him, and he looks great again.
- 24:27And he looks incredible. Yeah. I don't understand
- 24:28that. I just really, the plot point, and maybe
- 24:31you can refresh me on the book or something,
- 24:33I don't understand why they don't, vampires who
- 24:36have all these senses, who know everything, right?
- 24:38They're supposed to be, right? Omniscient or
- 24:41something. Why don't they know that Lestat isn't
- 24:44dead? That is an excellent question. Or, I mean...
- 24:47It and I honestly don't remember from the book.
- 24:49Okay, but I I also wonder if it doesn't matter
- 24:53because certainly if Lestat isn't dead It's not
- 24:55for lack of trying She tries to she feeds him
- 25:00these two boys that she is killed on purpose
- 25:04right they then try to set him on Alligators
- 25:09right and then they set him on fire when he comes
- 25:12back the first time and so Yes, it's not for
- 25:15lock and try. But I wondered whether, and the
- 25:17film isn't explicit about this and this may be
- 25:19one of your concerns or criticisms, I don't know
- 25:23whether she's being punished for being a child
- 25:25or whether she's being punished for killing Lestat.
- 25:27Because they said two things, right? We don't
- 25:29kill our own, we don't make kids into vampires.
- 25:33Yes, but I don't think anyone's blaming her for
- 25:35that part. Okay. I think they're in part punishing
- 25:37Louis for that. But I think that it is because
- 25:40she has deigned to kill Lestat. Okay. But that
- 25:43is her attempt. All right. And but what I mean,
- 25:46one thing I think we look my concerns or I won't
- 25:49say concerns. What I don't find exciting or interesting
- 25:52about Interview the Vampire, I actually think
- 25:54that both of them are miscast. Even though it
- 25:57is very easy to think about it's 1993 and you're
- 26:00like, who's going to play Lestat? Whom Anne Rice
- 26:03envisioned basically as Sting, this kind of vampire
- 26:06as rock star. And I'm like, why wasn't it Sting?
- 26:09I would have been better. Sting's not a good
- 26:10actor. No, but I get the vibe. I get the vibe.
- 26:12Yes, you get the vibe. But it was that. He was
- 26:14the model. And you can imagine 1993, Tom Cruise,
- 26:18so hot, so sexy, so versatile. But to me, he
- 26:22doesn't work. The one thing he does in the film
- 26:24that is nice is that, of course, with Lestat,
- 26:26we have levity and humor. So Louis the dour
- 26:29one, but then Lestat is making the jokes. I also
- 26:32think, though, Don't think Brad Pitt is well
- 26:35cast as Louis and for whatever reason I mean
- 26:38the both of them of course have done so much
- 26:40incredible work and other things But I don't
- 26:43you really do need and in you as an expert someone
- 26:46who works in the history of sexuality, right?
- 26:48We need your opinion on that Okay, so he's your
- 26:50phrase because race of course comes up in this
- 26:52film To me it need they basically just need to
- 26:57be more I don't want to say more gay, but the
- 27:01erotics of their relationship needed to be radically
- 27:05amped. Well, and I think what you're saying, and
- 27:06this is why True Blood works so much, okay, is
- 27:10that the energy in true blood from, now I'm forgetting
- 27:15the name of the actor, but the actor who plays
- 27:16the main vampire who's married to Anna Paquin
- 27:20in real life, and then Alexander Skarsgård who
- 27:23is unbelievable as a vampire. That energy. Which
- 27:29isn't homoerotic between the two of them, but
- 27:32I mean, they're off the charts. They just exude
- 27:37sex. And you could, and again, if there was homoeroticism
- 27:41between them, you'd believe it. The difference
- 27:44between True Blood and... Interview with a vampire
- 27:48is night and day in terms of the this kind of
- 27:52sexuality that vampires are supposed to have
- 27:55I mean in terms of people just being drawn to
- 27:57them and yeah, and while there are sort of moments
- 28:01of that I I agree with you in this I just I don't
- 28:05attribute it to miscasting as much as the vision
- 28:09like I don't know if anyone had the conversation
- 28:12we need to get to They are smoking hot in the
- 28:16sense of being hot guys. But separately they're
- 28:19smoking hot guys. But we need to get two vampires
- 28:24together who exude sex. And I don't think that
- 28:30it's there. It didn't bother me as much. Again,
- 28:33part of it was like, well, this was early 90s,
- 28:36that sort of thing, and True Blood is later.
- 28:40But I understand what you're saying. I do understand
- 28:44what you're saying. It would have been a better
- 28:46movie because I think the storytelling is really
- 28:48good. I think the filming and all, you see all
- 28:53these amazing places and you see a real change
- 28:56in time. And then this point about Brad Pitt
- 28:59having witnessed so much time and the pain of
- 29:03his eras. All of this is very, very interesting.
- 29:06So anyway. I, but I think the casting in terms
- 29:10of sexuality and sexuality between them could
- 29:13have been more intense. Well, but I think one,
- 29:16and I hear what you're saying about it being
- 29:17the nineties, but I think that what I kind of
- 29:20stumble over is, so the director of the film
- 29:22is Neil Jordan. Right. And the immediate film
- 29:24that Neil Jordan had done before this is The
- 29:26Crying Game. Right. And so you do this film that
- 29:28is very bold in terms of sexual relationships,
- 29:32gender performance, right? All of this stuff
- 29:34where in effect, the whole point of The Crying
- 29:37Game is this man, this IRA fighter, Stephen Rea's
- 29:40character, who thinks that he's, again, straight,
- 29:44then sort of unwittingly is sexually attracted
- 29:46to and falls in love with this person who is,
- 29:49again, I mean, we would say now, right? I don't
- 29:51even know how we would describe the character
- 29:53now. And of course, so much about The Crying
- 29:55Game was this quote unquote big reveal, where
- 29:57you see Dil's penis. And so you can kind of
- 30:01also imagine, I think, someone saying, oh, well,
- 30:03Neil Jordan is so bold, right? That he basically
- 30:05will take Brad Pitt and Tom Cruise in this exciting,
- 30:08because of course, the book, the book is unabashedly
- 30:11homoerotic. I understand. It just absolutely
- 30:13is. But what I'm saying is, again, I am giving,
- 30:16I am... Even though I get what you're saying
- 30:17about The Crying Game, I never interpreted The
- 30:20Crying Game as an inherently erotic film. Fair
- 30:24point. It is definitely a sexually charged and
- 30:28interesting and layered film that explores these
- 30:30themes, but it isn't Body Heat. I agree. Almost
- 30:34nothing is. I want Body Heat. I want vampires.
- 30:37I agree. That's what I'm looking for, is Body
- 30:39Heat. Okay? And that is, I think, the issue that
- 30:44maybe it's the director, maybe it's the actors,
- 30:46but the vibe of eroticism that we see in a Body
- 30:50Heat or something adjacent to Body Heat, Nine
- 30:53and a Half Weeks or whatever, should be an interview
- 30:56with a vampire. I okay and I agree and the other
- 30:59thing and this is another part of the reason
- 31:00why I brought up Polidori Which also comes
- 31:03up in in Dracula and we can start talking about
- 31:06the Dracula Dracula a few minutes But from the
- 31:08very beginning of this European vampire model
- 31:12with John Polidori in the early 19th century
- 31:14You absolutely have the sense that the vampire
- 31:17is erotically compelling Part of the original
- 31:20DNA vampires are supposed to be irresistible
- 31:23irresistible and you also also have this very
- 31:27much this, this sort of, I don't want to say
- 31:29queer coded, but you completely have a tradition
- 31:32even before and absolutely right of basically,
- 31:34I mean, we talked very, very briefly about Dracula's
- 31:37Daughter, a film that comes out in the 1930s
- 31:40where the whole point is that the female vampire,
- 31:42right? She basically only wants women victims,
- 31:45right? Again, very sexually charged. And so it
- 31:47is so interesting that by the time we get to
- 31:49the 1990s, both of these things are tradition
- 31:52going back for, again, since the early 19th century.
- 31:55But interestingly, because I just showed this
- 31:57in my class, so we're looking at The Cellular
- 31:59Closet, and of course, there's all these vampire
- 32:01examples in The Cellular Closet. But one of them
- 32:04also is the Brad Pitt, Tom Cruise. I believe
- 32:09that's a clip in there. And you do think by the
- 32:11end of it, huh? After seeing the whole movie,
- 32:15you think, when you see just the clip, you buy
- 32:16it, right? But when you see the whole movie again,
- 32:20you're like, wait a minute. This really wasn't
- 32:23as... Faring sexy. No, it couldn't be. But I
- 32:28just think it was Jordan and the vibe of the
- 32:33whole thing, not wanting to go to the erotic
- 32:36place. And one thing I will say about both, well...
- 32:40I guess Eyes Wide Shut would create erotic for
- 32:43Tom Cruise. But Brad Pitt isn't traditionally
- 32:46in erotic movies. Yes. You're right. And Tom
- 32:50Cruise, until Eyes Wide Shut, I would argue,
- 32:52isn't either. Fair point. For the most part.
- 32:55Fair point. I mean, again, he's not like a Michael
- 33:00Douglas. Yes. Exactly. Give me another one. William
- 33:04Hurt for that matter. Right. He's not occupying
- 33:10those like highly charged, sexualized roles.
- 33:15And I just think that might be another reason.
- 33:18And again, for us, as gorgeous as Brad Pitt is,
- 33:21and I mean, the hottest role for Brad Pitt is
- 33:24Thelma and Louise. Yeah, you're right. It is. You're
- 33:27right. I mean, it's 10 minutes of incredible
- 33:29smolderingness, you know, but it is interesting.
- 33:31And then we can sort of abandon. But I just keep
- 33:34thinking, you know, the tagline for Interview
- 33:35of the Vampire, the tagline was, you know, it's
- 33:38this close up, of course, of Tom Cruise looking
- 33:40sexy. Right. Right. And, you know, "drink from
- 33:42me and live forever." And you're like, well, man,
- 33:44we're in for it. And then so I do. I mean, it
- 33:47is I have no interest in watching the TV show,
- 33:49but it would be interesting again to think if
- 33:52this film is made today with those two actors.
- 33:55And with also Brad Pitt and Tom Cruise. Not at
- 33:58their ages, right? At the ages they were. But
- 34:01this is, I will say, then to start talking about
- 34:04Coppola, which I love and you despise. And you
- 34:07can just talk about it because I really like...
- 34:09But this is also something where now we've layered
- 34:12onto this traditional eroticism, right? This
- 34:15love story of like reincarnation. And I will...
- 34:20we discuss this a little bit and has to come
- 34:23up. So in Coppola's Dracula the two main strikes
- 34:28against it. I hate to say the casting of Winona
- 34:32Ryder and even more so even more so even Keanu
- 34:36Reeves makes it unwatchable in these absolutely
- 34:38two crucial roles pivotal central roles. Yes
- 34:42central of Mia and Harker. So we mean Mina Mina
- 34:46Mina Mia is my niece. So that is the only reason
- 34:50why I know why Mina. So one of the as I told
- 34:54you One of the things I do really, really like
- 34:56about Coppola's Dracula is that it is super faithful
- 35:00to the novel. And Coppola, very famously, when
- 35:04he collects the actors, when he's first casting
- 35:06the film, he has them read through the entire
- 35:09novel. And some of them are terrible at it. Some
- 35:11of them are better. And you would think he would
- 35:13have replaced them at that point. You would think
- 35:14so. But again, he's like Keanu and Winona, right?
- 35:17These Gen X people. It's 1993 or 4, whatever.
- 35:20Right. For box office dollars, it makes sense.
- 35:23Yes, it makes sense. It was awful. Absolutely
- 35:25awful. In part because the two of them cannot
- 35:28do English accents. It's actively distracting.
- 35:32It is actively distracting to hear them speak.
- 35:35But one thing I again really, really like about
- 35:38it, and you can argue against me, is that it
- 35:41is so cinematic. And I told you that story about
- 35:45Richard E. Grant saying he had trouble putting
- 35:47together saying, okay, we went from reading this
- 35:49novel. We went from a script to what ends up
- 35:51on the screen, which is this utterly dazzling
- 35:55right over the top kind of rococo. We're throwing
- 35:58every possible image effect. And I mean, I really
- 36:03do find it to be incredibly intoxicating. The
- 36:07last thing I'll say, then I'll shut up and you
- 36:08can talk about it. No, I don't have to talk about
- 36:10it. I do actually like, as I told you, in, say,
- 36:131931 Universal version, we don't have that sense
- 36:16of like, oh, wait, there are Americans here.
- 36:17And so I like that because it seems so bizarre,
- 36:20right, that we have this kind of cowboy thing
- 36:22going on in Dracula, which is faithful to the
- 36:24novel. And Coppola restored that. And I think
- 36:26that was an interesting choice. Well, again,
- 36:30as I told you, when we talked about this the
- 36:32first time, just wherever we were, I think we're
- 36:34going to see that other movie, which maybe at
- 36:36some point point we'll talk about. All the things
- 36:39you're saying are well taken, and I respect them.
- 36:42However, I don't think they actually have to
- 36:44do with the movie that I saw. Like people at
- 36:47a table reading, sure. But the movie that I saw,
- 36:52which again, I honestly feel like I've forgotten
- 36:55it by now is how much I did not like it. It was
- 36:59just terrible acting. and the contract i think
- 37:05the acting was so distracts about acting was
- 37:07so distracting and that watching those horrible
- 37:10scenes in the beginning with Keanu and you know,
- 37:14Gary Oldman. And in a lot of ways, Gary Oldman's
- 37:18so over the top. I mean, he's just... Love it.
- 37:20Love it all. And it's really campy. But the problem
- 37:24is they're in two different genres. I mean, Gary
- 37:26Oldman is in, as you're seeing, right, he's visually
- 37:29dazzling, like we're just gonna throw it all
- 37:30out there. He's in that place. Keanu's playing
- 37:33it straight with this terrible accent. And it
- 37:36doesn't go together. So it's really hard to watch
- 37:40because it's like two people in two separate
- 37:42movies. One person who got the memo and then
- 37:46the other person who didn't. And again, as you
- 37:48said, it would be one thing if Keanu Reeves'
- 37:52character was in one scene. Or the Winona Ryder
- 37:54character. But both of them are in the whole.
- 37:58Movie and you don't buy for a second that they
- 38:02are in love with each other. They have no chemistry
- 38:04They I mean Winona Ryder has way more chemistry
- 38:08with Lucy And with that character, I certainly
- 38:12buy that friendship but the rest of it is to
- 38:16me a trainwreck and it's just The fact that it's
- 38:21over the top, it felt like it was over the top
- 38:24for the sake of it rather than for some sort
- 38:28of cinematic purpose. And again, films can be
- 38:32over the top. Like a Moulin Rouge or something
- 38:34like that where it feels over the top. All the
- 38:37Basler men, right? It feels over the top because
- 38:39it's just Basler men. This felt like, let's throw
- 38:44in this thing or just... just a lot of elements
- 38:50that either were to be confusing, but the acting
- 38:54was really at the core of it. So awful. And you
- 38:59just want to like look away and not for the reasons
- 39:02of like vampires killing people, but for the
- 39:06reasons of just like, what is he? doing. Like
- 39:10why is Keanu Reeves seeing this? Like what and
- 39:13then even the cutting back and forth between
- 39:16Winona and Keanu getting married and like the
- 39:21stuff going on with Dracula and I don't know.
- 39:28I just didn't buy it. And again, part of of why
- 39:33I'm maybe even incoherent about talking about
- 39:35it was like, I just lost interest. And I just
- 39:39wanted to fast forward, get it over with. And
- 39:43I was hoping something good would happen. And
- 39:46it didn't. And I didn't get I'm a huge Gary Oldman
- 39:50fan. And I didn't find when we're talking about
- 39:53eroticism or talking about like vampire lore,
- 39:56it didn't find him irresistible. I didn't find
- 39:59the chemistry between him and Winona Ryder believable
- 40:02and so again it feels like again another wasted
- 40:06opportunity you have like smoking Gary Oldman
- 40:09and then like nobody really convincingly responding
- 40:15to him so I think that Your reasons for liking
- 40:19it and, you know, true to the book and all of
- 40:21that, I appreciate that. But just coming at it
- 40:24from just a purely, I'm watching this movie and
- 40:27I'm not thinking about anything else and I can
- 40:30barely watch it. Okay. You know, I will argue
- 40:33one more point in its favor though. And this
- 40:35is actually a reason why I'm not as excited about
- 40:37Interview the Vampire. To me, Interview is totally
- 40:40inert. That is, there's nothing that we fear
- 40:43in that film. There's no threat in that film.
- 40:47The whole point of Interview of the Vampire is,
- 40:49well, Louis is just kind of moping. Telling his
- 40:51story. Telling his story, and his story is about
- 40:53being moping. That's true. And that's it. And
- 40:56we have basically no... Although, one thing,
- 40:59I'm sorry to interrupt. We do, from the very
- 41:03beginning, wonder... once we're introduced to
- 41:07Lestat and to Claudia, what will happen to them?
- 41:11But we know they're not going to die. Right.
- 41:15And Claudia, of course, does end up dying with
- 41:17sunlight, but it's not that I'm not that concerned
- 41:20about it. We're dealing with basically immortals,
- 41:22right? We're dealing with immortals. I guess
- 41:23I was concerned about that. And I think it's
- 41:25also because there are no humans in the film,
- 41:28other than Christian Slater, whom we see every
- 41:30once in a while as the interviewer. But there's
- 41:33no sense of an arc in that film at all. And one
- 41:37of the things that I was thought about, I'm like,
- 41:38I kind of always forget what happens after they
- 41:40kill Lestat the first time. And we have - That's
- 41:42where they go on their world travels. But to
- 41:44me, it's just kind of like, one thing I do like
- 41:48very much about Coppola's Dracula is, and of
- 41:51course it is because it's faithful to the book,
- 41:54we have a very clear narrative arc, right? The
- 41:57whole, there is a danger presented to us that,
- 42:01okay, Dracula is, is he going to kill Mina? And
- 42:05this of course is the case in the 1931 Dracula,
- 42:07right? Is he going to kill Mina? Is he going
- 42:09to turn her into a vampire? And of course in
- 42:11the book, and even in the Coppola film, the big
- 42:16threat is not that Mina is just going to die,
- 42:19but that she will be damned for eternity. That
- 42:21she becomes unclean by consuming his blood. And
- 42:25then there's the whole sensibility that all of
- 42:27the other men have to, quote -unquote, save her.
- 42:30And I think that that is interesting because
- 42:33even when we have sympathetic Gary Oldman, you
- 42:35know, I've crossed oceans of time to find you,
- 42:38he kills Lucy. It kills Lucy. Lucy turns into
- 42:42a vampire and starts feeding on children. And
- 42:45we have the feeding of children again. And so
- 42:48that actually is something. You have drama at
- 42:51the end. This is something, of course, Coppola
- 42:53does so well. The whole classic sun setting,
- 42:57and they're racing to get to the castle. This
- 43:00very heightened, very typical moment of suspense.
- 43:03but that it is the case that it is Lucy's, sorry,
- 43:07Amina's soul that sort of is in the bargain.
- 43:10And again, in the whole thing of Interview With the
- 43:11Vampire, I'm just kind of like, well, they're
- 43:12just kind of sitting around, as you know. They
- 43:15are. But I think maybe to me, what you're describing
- 43:18is Stoker and not Coppola. No, I think that's
- 43:22fair. But I do think the way that, again, he
- 43:23visualizes that, I think that's really, I like
- 43:26that a lot. But I totally agree. I want the recast
- 43:30version, right? I'll watch a recast version with
- 43:36the appropriate actors playing these roles because,
- 43:39again, the Stoker version is fascinating, but
- 43:43I don't want to see it ruined by these bad actors.
- 43:47Well, actually, one more thing before we talk
- 43:49about sinners. It is, of course, also the case
- 43:51that in Coppola's version, we do have the erotics
- 43:54of the vampire back. Right, very explicitly.
- 43:58And in a sort of weird way. Because he needs
- 44:01to maintain this kind of faithful love story,
- 44:03but also he basically needs to do it with Lucy
- 44:05in this kind of vampire weird way. So that's
- 44:08a little bit awkward, but he's not shying away
- 44:10from it. No, he's not shying away from it. And
- 44:13actually, Lucy is one of the better actors in
- 44:16the film. Sadie Frost, yeah. I'm good with Lucy.
- 44:20Um, and I feel bad that she had to be surrounded
- 44:23by that mess. Yeah. Yeah. All right. So Sinners.
- 44:29Okay. I saw Sinners this summer. Um, and you
- 44:34saw it, what, this week? A couple of nights ago.
- 44:35A couple of nights ago on HBO or whatever. I
- 44:37have not seen it. All right. So, um, I'm curious
- 44:40to hear what you think. Well, um, I thought...
- 44:45What I really liked about it, I thought the idea
- 44:49of having a vampire story set in 1930s Mississippi
- 44:54Delta was interesting. I actually thought that
- 44:58we were going to delve a little bit more into
- 45:01this kind of Robert Johnson, you know, selling
- 45:04the soul to the devil, blues man, crossroads
- 45:07thing. I thought that the film was going to lean
- 45:09a little bit more into that because of course
- 45:11that's such a fascinating story in terms of like,
- 45:13well, the devil is now here. I thought that Michael
- 45:17B Jordan was incredible. I thought he was terrific,
- 45:20absolutely terrific. The one, I thought that
- 45:24it started off very, very slowly. I thought it
- 45:27kind of probably could have been edited down
- 45:28in the first hour. I also think the clan bit
- 45:32at the end didn't really fit. I thought it was
- 45:35kind of unnecessary. Not every single film about
- 45:38the South in the 1930s needs to have a clan scene.
- 45:42But what I did think was really interesting about
- 45:44it, and this is where I'm going to go back to
- 45:45Polidori for a second. So bear with me and
- 45:47then I'm going to shut up. What we have with
- 45:51this John Polidori story this got a template
- 45:53that he creates is. The vampire is the thing
- 45:57that you fear will penetrate into your society
- 45:59right so Polidori frames the vampire for the
- 46:02first time as this kind of libertine nobleman right
- 46:05it had not been the case in European folklore
- 46:06before but now we have a handsome seductive man
- 46:09who is going to destroy virgins and do all of
- 46:12this. By the time we get to bram stoker the idea
- 46:16is that it's about immigration. And this is something
- 46:19dwelt upon in the novel, that these Eastern Europeans,
- 46:23Dracula's vampires, they're going to infiltrate
- 46:25London. Colonization, metaphor for imperialism
- 46:29and all of that. But also understood very literally,
- 46:33where it's not just a metaphor for imperialism,
- 46:34but the idea that Roman Catholics, even though
- 46:37obviously he himself is Irish, but Roman Catholics,
- 46:40Eastern Europeans, these people with these bizarre
- 46:43superstitions, are going to come to England.
- 46:46They are going to kind of infiltrate. that are
- 46:48going to water down, you know, English Protestantism
- 46:51that is so visible, right, in that film. I'm
- 46:54sorry, in the book. So what I think is interesting
- 46:56about Sinners is that, of course, our mid -triars...
- 47:00start out, they are white people, right? And
- 47:03they're Irish, but it is whites. And so the idea
- 47:07that you basically have in effect, this very
- 47:09happy, you know, kind of content family style
- 47:12almost, you know, we're all at the juke joint,
- 47:15sort of African American community. And so here
- 47:18now, again, the infiltrators, the evil people.
- 47:22Are white people and I think that that that whether
- 47:25Coogler intended that or no and I think that to
- 47:27me is one of the richest most interesting things
- 47:29it is those and and again, I think I think he
- 47:33did intend for it to be a commentary on racial
- 47:37appropriation racial interchange You know all
- 47:42that kind of stuff, but also the idea about whether
- 47:47or not racial cooperation can only occur in the
- 47:52land of the dead. Yeah. Right. Yeah. And so it's
- 47:55not so much a question, I mean, about traditional
- 47:59vampire stories about, right, like you live forever
- 48:02and you can be omnipresent, all that. But it's
- 48:06really about we can't get along in the real world.
- 48:09And so if we're all vampires, then Are our differences
- 48:14kind of we can we can mel together we can embrace
- 48:16tradition and we can all you know live more harmoniously
- 48:21but it's supposed to be a. Bad thing. It is.
- 48:26That's a bad thing. And certainly, I mean, the
- 48:27way that I read it, it's it's a satire of the
- 48:30white liberal, right? It's a satire of the white
- 48:32liberal who's like, Oh, no, no, basically, we
- 48:34can, we can all have equality and all this wonderful
- 48:37stuff. The only thing is you basically have to
- 48:39give up your, your identity, your personhood,
- 48:42right? You have to become a killer, a literal
- 48:44killer in order to embrace this, this sense of
- 48:47racial equality and happiness and the sort of
- 48:49peace and love. And so I absolutely read that
- 48:51as a satire on the a white liberal who's just
- 48:54like, oh, no, no, we're going to this kind of
- 48:56utopian place where all of this wonderful stuff
- 48:59will happen. And so to me, it really was kind
- 49:01of an affirmation of a particular kind of segregation,
- 49:05a reality that says, again, we are. And in some
- 49:09ways, I mean, it was interesting to me to compare
- 49:10it. I'm sure you thought this this way, too.
- 49:13It is interesting to compare it to his vision
- 49:16of Wakanda. Right. It's the exact same kind of
- 49:19thing. You have, in effect, a closed racial society.
- 49:22Right. Of course, in the case of Wakanda of Africans
- 49:25in this film of African Americans. And obviously,
- 49:29there's different ways in which. Non -africans
- 49:32and non -african -americans engage with that
- 49:34but the sense of like no this closed society.
- 49:37That's the good one And there's the temptation
- 49:40right that comes from these other directions
- 49:42Sure, and I I agree with that. I think to me
- 49:46again I agree with what you're saying about the
- 49:50you know sort of most of the film I mean until
- 49:53the vampire part. Yeah, right. Yeah, it's a storytelling
- 49:56about the lives of these characters, and then
- 50:00Mississippi Delta, they've come back, smoke and
- 50:04stack, they're kind of on the lam, they're gonna,
- 50:07one night of this, again, incredible night, and
- 50:09this juke joint, and it's, to me, what's most
- 50:13powerful scene is when, you know, all of the
- 50:17retelling of black history, black culture, and
- 50:20that, in the future, really, and the future,
- 50:22and right, and like, all of this. possibility,
- 50:25right? The possibility of cultural enlightenment,
- 50:29engagement, however you want to think about it.
- 50:32And all of that is ruined by the presence of
- 50:39these vampires but also by the what's interesting
- 50:43to me is it's also ruined by the reality of sharecropping
- 50:47which is that you know sharecropping people because
- 50:49they aren't paying with dollars and so there
- 50:52have to be you have to let these people in because
- 50:55they can pay and there's only so many favors
- 50:57that can go around to let the other people who
- 51:01have come who are so impoverished and who are
- 51:04in in this you know oppressive script in this
- 51:06oppressive economic system, that they're paying
- 51:11with fake money or whatever. And so it's... I
- 51:16think to me what Coogler's at as well is that
- 51:20there's this literal price you have to pay to
- 51:25keep your kind of quote culture alive, which
- 51:28ends up with these devastating consequences.
- 51:32And that by letting these white, of course they
- 51:36don't know that they're vampires, right? But
- 51:38that by letting these white... Folks come in
- 51:42and then end up literally sucking the blood out
- 51:44of of this night. You know, really, really shows
- 51:47you has I think his criticism. I agree with you.
- 51:51This is sort of criticism of white liberalism,
- 51:54but also the vulnerability of black culture.
- 51:57But and what's interesting about that, though,
- 51:59is that is that it's very specifically. the Hailee
- 52:05Steinfeld character who lets them in, right?
- 52:07They're not let in when they first come to the
- 52:09door, right? They're told like, you know, get
- 52:11the fuck out of here. And it's this very specific
- 52:14exchange, right? Where she and Stack are talking
- 52:17and it's like, okay, well, I will go out and
- 52:19talk to them, right? Maybe, you know, we can
- 52:21see if they're like decent people or whatever.
- 52:23And of course we're told what? That she is her...
- 52:28Grandfather is half black right that if I remember
- 52:31and she was part kind of part of the family Yeah,
- 52:34she's this kind of you know trusted figure She
- 52:37said her mother her mother had what been active
- 52:40in the family of Smoke and Stack she has a relationship
- 52:43Yeah, right with with Stack with stack so she's
- 52:47well so so her own whiteness plays these interesting
- 52:51roles and both being a liminal figure right
- 52:55and somebody who is part of she's the only white
- 52:57person who's part of the black community In an
- 53:01interesting way right back to her own hit her
- 53:04own history But then she's also this figure they
- 53:08can kind of like suss out whether these people
- 53:11Are like legit and whether or not they should
- 53:14be invited back in Well, and that's I mean to
- 53:17me. That's what was both. I don't know. I don't
- 53:20want to say disturbing That's not the right right
- 53:23word but but of course narratively right narratively
- 53:26she is necessary it is necessary that she is
- 53:29white narratively it is that she can go out and
- 53:31have this conversation that she is the first
- 53:33person to be turned and that that but then of
- 53:35course it's also Again i don't use the word disturbing
- 53:39but it is the fact then in terms of our greater
- 53:43sort of concept of the damaging aspect of her
- 53:47whiteness that since she can come back and she
- 53:50is trusted so in a sense i mean i think i mean
- 53:54that's why i keep coming back to this idea of.
- 53:57Fully closed community not close to people because
- 54:00of course we have the chinese couple right you
- 54:03are. invited in, right, who are part of also
- 54:05this kind of family. And so, but she, in her
- 54:09whiteness, she is absolutely the threat. Again,
- 54:12it is narratively required that she be white
- 54:14for exactly that purpose. But I find that also
- 54:17to be, in terms of the, I mean, the message to
- 54:19me is so screamingly clear, right, in terms of
- 54:23that desire for a closed community that does
- 54:26not. Open itself in any way to whiteness because
- 54:29even also right even coming back to Clarksdale
- 54:32having the kind of real estate transaction with
- 54:35the guy who ends up being in the plan it really
- 54:38I mean it's one of the most interesting things
- 54:39to me you can tell me what you think as an American
- 54:41historian so. someone asks, and it might be Preacher
- 54:45Boy, says to Smoke and Stack, like, why did you
- 54:48leave Chicago? Right. And of course, we then
- 54:50find out it's because they have pit the Irish
- 54:52and Italian mobs against each other. Sure, sure.
- 54:55Right, they're on the lam. Yes. But then, but
- 54:57what they say, right, I don't remember if it's
- 54:59Smoke or Stack, says, well, basically Chicago
- 55:01is just like Mississippi, but with taller buildings.
- 55:04Right. And so that was also really interesting
- 55:07to me, because of course, one of the biggest
- 55:08questions is, Why come back to Mississippi again
- 55:14Clarksdale this place is written with clan people
- 55:17and I don't know I thought that was it has to
- 55:20again it has to happen narratively But in terms
- 55:23of - And I guess I took that and I don't know
- 55:27whether they were, whether Coogler was trying
- 55:30to in some way insert the Emmett Till story.
- 55:33Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Kind of subconsciously
- 55:37into all of this. He's from Chicago. Of course.
- 55:40He's lynched in Mississippi. Yeah. There is always
- 55:43that, you know, that's the most frequent reference
- 55:46that would come to mind. and of course that happened
- 55:49that coming much later in 1955 but part of me
- 55:53read that you know again the the south there's
- 55:58there's always been this You know kind of tug
- 56:01between the south is a place of danger and the
- 56:03south is a place of refuge Yeah, and that within
- 56:07black communities the south is a place of refuge
- 56:09because There are all these you know from it.
- 56:12There's familiarity. There's family. There's
- 56:14food. There's church There's all the things that
- 56:16we see in the movie, right? There's also within
- 56:19these rural communities the opportunity for smoke
- 56:23and stuff, they're insiders. And they're not
- 56:26necessarily insiders for the Klansmen, right?
- 56:27But they carry a weight that in, say, Chicago,
- 56:31they have to build credibility. They are people
- 56:34from the South. There's suspicion of them. And
- 56:37so that they're able to come back to, you know,
- 56:39they have this money to invest in this juke joint
- 56:42with this man who they know is... probably, you
- 56:44know, up to no good and not looking to help them
- 56:50in a sort of social justice way anyway, but is
- 56:53gonna help them maybe in a financial way. And
- 56:56of course, they don't know that he's plotting
- 56:57later to like come kill everybody, right? But
- 57:00the idea that there's, again, I think Kugler's
- 57:04also trying to talk about the uneasiness of rural
- 57:09life and that... that really ambiguous line between
- 57:14familiarity and unfamiliarity. And that the vampires
- 57:17themselves, to me, are meant on a kind of meta
- 57:22level to represent the unfamiliar from the familiar.
- 57:26That you know people, that you grew up with people,
- 57:28that you have this history, that Southern history
- 57:31is... all about generations and generations and
- 57:34oral history and stories and storytelling and
- 57:36all of that. And that once people become vampires
- 57:40and become unfamiliar and you don't want to let
- 57:42them in, right? And the only reason, again, the
- 57:46Chinese woman who does eventually let them in
- 57:49to save her daughter. To kill them. To kill them,
- 57:53right? turning unfamiliar to you who you believe
- 57:59to be familiar and who you believe to be trusted
- 58:01is Something I mean, that's true of all history
- 58:04is true of all humanity, right? But in Southern
- 58:07history and the southern sort of lore it has
- 58:09a particular place and I feel like what I really
- 58:12like about sinners and I mean, there's a lot
- 58:15of There's unevenness of places, I agree with
- 58:18you on the editing, but what I loved about it
- 58:20was just how ambitious it is. In terms of the
- 58:24storytelling, in terms of the visuals of capturing
- 58:29Mississippi in the 30s and the fantastic Michael
- 58:33B. Jordan who carries the movie in two roles.
- 58:40The vampire of it, while it does feel kind of
- 58:44almost erratic, Right, but it is this hybrid
- 58:47genre and I think it's interesting and ambitious
- 58:49and when I saw the first time I left thinking
- 58:52You know, I'm I'm glad a movie like this exists
- 58:56and there's a lot to talk about There's a lot
- 58:58to show, you know with students and I don't think
- 59:02it's a perfect work and I don't think that and
- 59:05I think there's some of it that you know, you
- 59:07because I'm not sure about that, but It's very
- 59:11very provocative and I and I think that particularly
- 59:15in terms of capturing American history and racial
- 59:20complexity in a way that isn't particularly neat,
- 59:24particularly within the black community. I think
- 59:26he does a really good job. So, and I don't think
- 59:30it's, although it does come away with white people
- 59:33bad, black people good, it does come away with
- 59:37that. uh conclusion and but also then that some
- 59:41members of this community of this African -American
- 59:44community have been unwittingly seduced right
- 59:47into joining that kind of love and fellowship
- 59:49environment again not given a choice right we're
- 59:51talking about choice earlier with interview the
- 59:53vampire sure i mean it was one of the you know
- 59:55this will sound weird but what it reminded me
- 59:58in thinking about this in terms of their return
- 1:00:00what it really reminded me of somewhat oddly
- 1:00:03is in the heat of the night right where again
- 1:00:05you have Sidney Poitier right who goes from Philadelphia
- 1:00:08back down to Mississippi. That's a great, that's
- 1:00:11a great. And the same sense of like, okay, this
- 1:00:13is familiar, this is not familiar, and that he
- 1:00:16is used to his particular role in Philadelphia,
- 1:00:19right? The famous, you know, they call me Mr.
- 1:00:21Tibbs line, you know, when he smacks the guy
- 1:00:22across the face, which is, you know, so fantastic.
- 1:00:25And it really did remind me of that. But I will
- 1:00:27say something that I really liked about it, and
- 1:00:29we had just been talking about this in my grad
- 1:00:31class, is that, of course, what we also see is
- 1:00:34we see African -American Christianity, obviously
- 1:00:37in preacher boy's father, but then we also see
- 1:00:39kind of neo -African religion in Smoke's wife.
- 1:00:43I can't remember her name. Anyway, and so I really
- 1:00:47liked that, that that was also not necessarily
- 1:00:50ambiguous or ambivalent, but we do have the juxtaposition
- 1:00:54of these two particular religious paths without.
- 1:00:58but then also this kind of mixing because I loved
- 1:01:00it with the garlic right so we also have been
- 1:01:03this entrance of kind of again European folklore
- 1:01:05right how do you get rid of a vampire we have
- 1:01:07the garlic we have the stakes to the heart right
- 1:01:09all of this stuff and so I thought that that
- 1:01:11was really nice kind of a juxtaposition of these
- 1:01:14different religious traditions that to me didn't
- 1:01:16seem messy, right? It seemed like really natural
- 1:01:19and organic. And I liked that. So this kind of
- 1:01:22borrowing from vampire lore that was very traditional,
- 1:01:25but then also these other traditions entering
- 1:01:27in. And as I will repeat, I did want just two
- 1:01:32more little seconds. Reflecting on the whole
- 1:01:36Mississippi Delta blues, right? Satan's music
- 1:01:39and obviously there's some of that in the film
- 1:01:41Yeah, but I that's the one thing where I really
- 1:01:44wanted stronger connections between our kind
- 1:01:46of Irish vampires and The sense that this music
- 1:01:50music is the music that this music is the music
- 1:01:52of the devil And so I just thought that that
- 1:01:53was like kind of a lost opportunity and made
- 1:01:56again a film that I thought especially, I thought
- 1:01:58the second half was so exciting. I thought it
- 1:02:00was just really so well done and interesting.
- 1:02:02Well, it is. And I think, again, the ambition
- 1:02:05of the film to begin with, I agree with you.
- 1:02:07I mean, there's so much that this film says and
- 1:02:10can say. And that the second half of the film,
- 1:02:14especially, and that scene with them all dancing
- 1:02:17together and all that music, both dancing, the
- 1:02:20scenes, the montage of... Black culture past
- 1:02:24and present and Chinese culture and Chinese culture
- 1:02:27and but but then also once they're vampires outside
- 1:02:30Irish music and that's really really interesting
- 1:02:34and thoughtful And again to me just a level of
- 1:02:39smartness Yeah, that I just appreciate from an
- 1:02:43academic perspective like he clearly is is like
- 1:02:46reading things and yeah things and and to carry
- 1:02:52the film the way that Michael B. Jordan does
- 1:02:54is really amazing. And I probably need to watch
- 1:02:58it again because I saw in the theater and it
- 1:03:01is so beautiful in the theater. I mean, that's
- 1:03:03the other thing is that the filming of it and
- 1:03:07the Mississippi Delta, the way that they are
- 1:03:09capturing all of these different locales and
- 1:03:13the costumes, all of it is really amazing. And
- 1:03:17I'm just a Ryan Coogler fan in general, but I
- 1:03:20feel like this, which was really his first, you
- 1:03:22know, like non -creed, non -IP, non -IP, exactly.
- 1:03:29Really kind of original filmmaking was an encouraging.
- 1:03:36And again, it's interesting that you bring this
- 1:03:39in with the vampires because in some ways it's...
- 1:03:42It's leaning into vampire genre lore and in some
- 1:03:45ways it's really not it's about something else
- 1:03:48and because we don't know where the where the
- 1:03:51vampires came from right we have no conception
- 1:03:53we see this sort of. original vampire in the
- 1:03:56film, the one who goes up to the house of the
- 1:03:59married couple. But we don't know where he came
- 1:04:01from, we don't know how long he's been around,
- 1:04:02we don't know anything other than the reference
- 1:04:04at the very beginning of the film that we're
- 1:04:07told explicitly that the Irish also have this
- 1:04:10ability through music to kind of have this membrane
- 1:04:13between the living and the dead. cut split and
- 1:04:16so when it has this initial narrative that this
- 1:04:19is happening with african -american music we
- 1:04:21are told that the irish too and so that was pretty
- 1:04:23much the only thing i could figure out like okay
- 1:04:25is this a figure of the irish vampire Is this
- 1:04:29a reflection of that thing that was talked about
- 1:04:31with music again? I didn't find that to be super
- 1:04:33cohesive, but that's what sort of made sense
- 1:04:36to me in terms of where this figure is. But the
- 1:04:38other thing that I mean, we can go. I mean, this
- 1:04:40might be taking us to another level, but if we're
- 1:04:42thinking about vampires and we're thinking about
- 1:04:44sort of doubling among men, and we're thinking
- 1:04:47here about using twins, which is a really interesting
- 1:04:50trope for vampires, right? If we're going to
- 1:04:53think about. Lestat and Louis, if we're going
- 1:04:57to think about Dracula and his vampire friend.
- 1:05:02But the idea of the vampire as an erotic figure,
- 1:05:06which... We see a lot of eroticism in this film,
- 1:05:10pre -vampire and less to a degree. But also,
- 1:05:13but when during the turn. When Stack is killed.
- 1:05:15When Stack is killed. But the relationship between
- 1:05:19Smoke and Stack as who's going to be a vampire,
- 1:05:21who's not going to be a vampire, that to me is
- 1:05:25very interesting if we want to, for another time,
- 1:05:28think about the idea of actual male twins. What
- 1:05:34might what that what might that mean in terms
- 1:05:38of vampire lore? That's okay. I take that point,
- 1:05:42but I have to I just have to add in the context
- 1:05:45of the film It has to be stack Who is killed
- 1:05:49and who becomes a vampire? It has to be him right
- 1:05:52right because he is the one who basically has
- 1:05:53the relationship with the white woman and so
- 1:05:55in a sense it becomes almost punitive i think
- 1:05:58and what i mean i'm talking about their relationship
- 1:06:01i know i know i know i know i know that's what
- 1:06:03you're saying and but what i think is interesting
- 1:06:06is that you know i'm thinking about about black
- 1:06:09panther. You know all the brian kugler and i
- 1:06:12didn't see creed or any of the creed iterations
- 1:06:14but in black panther brian kugler clearly has
- 1:06:18he has sympathy with the villain. And we always
- 1:06:20kind of have these moments where it's like, oh,
- 1:06:22all of a sudden we're talking to the villain
- 1:06:23as if he's a nice guy. And of course we have
- 1:06:25that here, where we have the scene with Buddy
- 1:06:27Guy, real -life Buddy Guy at the end, where we
- 1:06:30learn that, in fact, this couple, they've just
- 1:06:33been, and I was like, well, wait a minute, now
- 1:06:34everyone's kind of hugging it out, which to me
- 1:06:37seems strange because presumably... stack and,
- 1:06:40what's her name, Hailee Steinfeld's character.
- 1:06:42Presumably they've just been murdering people
- 1:06:44for the past several decades. Just walking around.
- 1:06:46And now they're hugging it out with Buddy Guy.
- 1:06:48And so I was kind of, you know, as much as I
- 1:06:50liked the, you know, sort of stylings, right?
- 1:06:52But that to me I thought was again a very Ryan
- 1:06:55Coogler kind of moment. Oh, the villain's not
- 1:06:57so bad after all. You know, we're hugging it
- 1:06:59out. Well, also he let him live. He said he was
- 1:07:02gonna let him live and he let him live. And let
- 1:07:05him have a full career and let him go on to be
- 1:07:07a jazz musician. and then all that. So, yeah,
- 1:07:11I mean, it's - I thought that was, yeah. A nice
- 1:07:13little comment. Okay, well, I think this is all
- 1:07:16the time we have, but let's talk for a second
- 1:07:17about book recommendations. Okay, okay. And as
- 1:07:20maybe you can guess, my book recommendation is
- 1:07:23going to be John - Paula Dory's The Vampire.
- 1:07:26And that's Vampire with a Y, by the way. It is
- 1:07:29super, super short and it has a lot of problems.
- 1:07:32Paula Dory was a doctor by training. He was Lord
- 1:07:35Byron's kind of private physician when Byron
- 1:07:37was running around womanizing. And but it's so
- 1:07:41short, but it really is interesting in creating
- 1:07:43this template. As I said, the all of a sudden
- 1:07:46with Paula Dory, the vampire is the handsome,
- 1:07:49seductive nobleman who was a womanizer, much
- 1:07:52like Lord Byron, who was the model for that.
- 1:07:55And so it's a really interesting thing to read
- 1:07:57in terms of understanding all of the media that
- 1:07:59comes after it. Okay, well I'm gonna go back
- 1:08:03to one that was a hot book when it first came
- 1:08:06out was then turned into a movie which is Midnight
- 1:08:08in the Garden of Good and Evil, which I haven't
- 1:08:11read for a while, but certainly Lacked up when
- 1:08:15it first came out No pun intended. No pun intended
- 1:08:18John Berent and this is about sort of southern
- 1:08:23gothic culture and It's very much taking place
- 1:08:27in the world of Interview with a Vampire and
- 1:08:30Rice's world and really thinking about gender
- 1:08:33inversion and thinking about eroticism and thinking
- 1:08:37about the occult and all sorts of things like
- 1:08:41that. So while it isn't necessarily a vampire
- 1:08:43book, it does go along with actually both Sinners
- 1:08:47and Interview with a Vampire. Actually, it's
- 1:08:51funny, Jim asked me the other night, Are all
- 1:08:55vampire movies now about the South which of course
- 1:08:58True Blood is true And it's interesting the way
- 1:09:01that that has migrated No pun intended to from
- 1:09:05again the European folklore the Transylvania
- 1:09:09right all of that to then in an American context
- 1:09:13the South being the home for vampires, which
- 1:09:17I find to be just a really interesting idea because
- 1:09:22the most recent iterations of vampire movies
- 1:09:25that take place with vampires in the United States.
- 1:09:30Wait, where's Twilight? Is that the Pacific Northwest?
- 1:09:32That is the exception. Because of course you
- 1:09:34can't have California, right? Because there's
- 1:09:36too much sunlight. Twilight is the outlier. And
- 1:09:44yeah, it took place in the Pacific Northwest.
- 1:09:47But certainly True Blood and Midnight in the
- 1:09:50Garden of Good and Evil and some of these occult
- 1:09:54and voodoo. Look at New Orleans. New Orleans
- 1:09:59is tied to vampires. in lots of ways. So anyway,
- 1:10:05that's what I recommend. And the series True
- 1:10:08Blood, which I don't know if we'll talk about,
- 1:10:10but is really terrific. And it starts out so
- 1:10:14strong, particularly the first couple seasons.
- 1:10:16So, so, so good. And in a lot of ways is what
- 1:10:20I want in my vampires. I will amend my first
- 1:10:23statement. Okay. Vampires were on the mind when
- 1:10:26I was watching Truth. All the time. Because if
- 1:10:32you watch Alexander Skarsgard as a hot, mostly
- 1:10:36naked vampire for hours upon hours, there's nothing
- 1:10:40- You don't have to ask me twice. You don't have
- 1:10:42to think about much. Bill Moyer? Is that his
- 1:10:47name? Now I'm going to - Yeah, what's his name?
- 1:10:49Yeah. I can't remember. No, it's not Bill Moyers
- 1:10:51because that's like the interviewer. It might
- 1:10:52be Stephen Moyers. Stephen Moyers. But what is
- 1:10:55interesting about him, he was in a British TV
- 1:10:57show about vampires called Ultraviolet. Oh, I
- 1:11:00remember Ultraviolet. And Idris Elba is one of
- 1:11:03the stars of Ultraviolet. And you introduced
- 1:11:04me to that. I love it. I love Ultraviolet. It
- 1:11:07was a great, great show. It was so interesting.
- 1:11:09And again, Stephen, whose last name was... Why
- 1:11:11can't remember this? Stephen something. We should
- 1:11:14probably look this up. Married to Anna Paquin.
- 1:11:16Are they still married? I think so. But he's
- 1:11:19been in two vampire shows, which is really interesting.
- 1:11:20Well, he makes an amazing vampire. I just miss,
- 1:11:23and he has that sultry, smoldering, you know,
- 1:11:27sucky! And he's great looking in ultraviolet.
- 1:11:30He's like really, really sexy in ultraviolet.
- 1:11:32He's all that. He's all that. Well, on that note,
- 1:11:37I guess we will say what? Happy Halloween. Happy
- 1:11:39Halloween. Don't get too sick on all the candy
- 1:11:42you may consume or not consume. Stay safe. Don't
- 1:11:46get the razor blades. No razor blades in the
- 1:11:49apples. Check the apples. Those apples that people
- 1:11:51are giving out. Check the apples. And until next
- 1:11:55time, Harvey's out. His story