Latest / Politics with Paul / How Federal and State Laws and Legislation are Interpreted: A Crash Course | Politics with Paul #72
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09Today, we're going to talk about how to interpret laws and legislation.
- 0:15Do your eyes glaze over whenever you are trying to make sense of legal text and information?
- 0:21Or do you really want to know how to understand legislation but you don't know where to begin
- 0:26or you're just overwhelmed by all the jargon?
- 0:29Well, you're in luck today because today I'm going to give you a crash course that
- 0:34introduces you to the world of interpreting laws and legislation.
- 0:38A lot of this actually comes from a webinar I do for civics and public affairs and
- 0:43nonpartisan organizations about helping themselves and their clients better understand
- 0:49legislation, particularly ones that they have a vested interest in or against.
- 0:55And that webinar goes much deeper into the weeds, so I'll plug that as well.
- 0:59And I had an episode early on in this podcast history that talked about how people interpret
- 1:06The US constitution.
- 1:07And we will, of course, go into that, but some of that content, while it is in today's
- 1:11episode, will improve upon that information that was over a year ago now and go into some
- 1:19more info that is relevant.
- 1:20And we're also going to talk about how to interpret federal statutes and state statutes
- 1:26as well, along with why this stuff is important to know.
- 1:29But as you'll see today, there was a sort of through line between old debates about how to
- 1:34interpret the US constitution and how to interpret federal and state statutes today.
- 1:40I'm going to start with those early constitutional debates and then work the way
- 1:45down.
- 1:46It'll make sense at the end.
- 1:47And then at the end, I will talk about why this information is practically useful even if you
- 1:53might not realize it.
- 1:54So let's go.
- 1:57First of all, the origins of constitutional interpretations, particularly when it comes to
- 2:03implied versus enumerated powers.
- 2:05So after the US constitution was ratified, the debate over its interpretation, well, was by no
- 2:12means over.
- 2:13It had in some ways only just begun, particularly over how stringently we should
- 2:19adhere to the words of the constitution.
- 2:22And so this is where this debate between particularly implied versus enumerated powers
- 2:27enters.
- 2:29So implied powers are, they're implied, powers that are not explicitly stated to belong to the
- 2:35federal government but considered necessary for its function.
- 2:40And the chief source of justification for people who advocated for implied powers came
- 2:45from what is called the necessary and proper clause, which is that Congress shall have power
- 2:50to make all laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into execution the
- 2:55foregoing powers and all other powers vested by this constitution in the government of the
- 3:00United States or in any department or officer thereof.
- 3:04And then on the flip side, you've got enumerated powers.
- 3:07They are enumerated.
- 3:08They are explicitly laid out to be legal and belonging to a particular government official
- 3:14or body.
- 3:15So I might say that X power goes to president, Y power goes to congress, Z power goes to the
- 3:22supreme court or federal courts in general.
- 3:25And the chief source of justification for this comes from the ninth and tenth amendments to
- 3:30the US constitution.
- 3:31The ninth amendment says basically that all rights that are not expressly denied by the US
- 3:37constitution are given to the people.
- 3:39And then the tenth amendment says powers not given to the federal government belong to state
- 3:44governments.
- 3:45So who supported which kinds of powers back then?
- 3:51This was before we had the Republican versus Democratic schism, if you will, that we see
- 3:57today.
- 3:58Technically, actually, the Democratic Party existed then in a different form, but we'll get
- 4:02to them in just a moment.
- 4:04Implied powers were predominantly supported by the long since defunct Federalist Party.
- 4:11The or the Federalist Party was born from early supporters of the US constitution replacing the
- 4:16Articles of Confederation.
- 4:17When the US constitution was being debated, not everybody agreed that the Articles of
- 4:23Confederation needed to be completely thrown out.
- 4:26Some people argue that it should simply be revised, and that's initially what the
- 4:31Constitutional Convention was under the guise of and then a lot of people got very upset
- 4:35because these articles of Federation were getting thrown out wholesale.
- 4:40But for people who supported implied powers, particularly federalists, they felt these
- 4:45powers were necessary to invigorate the federal government following the very weak central
- 4:51government from the Articles of Confederation.
- 4:54So that whole necessary and proper to help the federal government execute its powers.
- 5:01And then on the flip side, enumerated powers were predominantly supported by the Democratic
- 5:06Republican Party, who is the Democratic Party of today.
- 5:09They were born out of the anti federalists who opposed replacing the Articles of
- 5:14Confederation, but they slowly started to become accepting of the constitution.
- 5:19And they felt that these enumerated powers were necessary to keep the federal government in
- 5:24check and keep states' rights the states' rights intact given the states' time as
- 5:31colonies under the British crown's strong central government.
- 5:35And so they were very concerned that the Necessary and Proper Clause in particular would
- 5:40lead to federal government overstepping its bounds.
- 5:45Perhaps ironically though, the Federalist Party would cease to exist by the 1820s and the
- 5:50Democratic Republican Party was the earliest iteration of today's Democratic Party.
- 5:55And actually, some cases, Democratic Republican presidents would use implied powers to do
- 6:03various things like, for example, Thomas Jefferson and the Louisiana Purchase, which
- 6:07basically doubled the size of The United States at that point.
- 6:11He was actually not sure that the constitution gave him any power to make that decision, but
- 6:17the implied powers doctrine, if you will, was used to say, okay.
- 6:22You know what?
- 6:22This needs to be done.
- 6:24We're going to buy this giant tract of land for a really good price then.
- 6:29So you're you're about doubled the size of The United States at that point.
- 6:34It was for, I think, $25,000,000 in, which was pretty good deal.
- 6:38But in any case, that just has demonstrated how there was that debate between enumerated and
- 6:44implied powers.
- 6:46So like I said at the beginning of this episode, there's a sort of through line from
- 6:53the debate between these old constitutional arguments about enumerated and implied powers
- 6:58to today's debates about how to interpret the constitution.
- 7:03It doesn't quite use the same terminology as enumerated and implied, but you can see some
- 7:08certain parallels.
- 7:10And the easiest way to think about this is that there are two, technically three, but we're
- 7:14gonna I'll I'll talk about that in a moment, but there are technically two basic schools of
- 7:19thought about interpreting the US constitution.
- 7:23On one side is originalism, and then the other side is living constitutionalism.
- 7:28And originalism has an offshoot that sometimes conflicts and sometimes coincides with it
- 7:33called textualism, but that will appear in the next section that we talk about.
- 7:39So we're gonna look at this dichotomy between originalism and living constitutionalism and
- 7:45showcase several of the key arguments for and against both.
- 7:49So originalism basically says that the words of The US constitution should be interpreted in
- 7:55the way that they would have been interpreted in the time of the framers of the constitution.
- 7:59And you sometimes hear this called original intent.
- 8:02So whatever the founding fathers meant, that's what we got to go with.
- 8:06It does not change throughout history, the meaning of these words.
- 8:11Doesn't that sound quite a bit like enumerated powers?
- 8:15Not entirely like enumerated powers, but it's looking to what the framers meant by the text,
- 8:20want to look at things that they explicitly said in text, which is a lot like enumerated
- 8:25powers, which talks about what is explicitly said in the text.
- 8:29If it's not outright stated, then it's not constitutional, basically.
- 8:35And then on the other side is living constitutionalism, which basically says that
- 8:38the meaning of the constitution evolves over time to adapt to new challenges and changing
- 8:43values, and sometimes that refers to the constitution as a quote unquote living,
- 8:50breathing document.
- 8:52Doesn't that sound a lot like implied powers?
- 8:55Because for the constitution to evolve, there has to be some level of implication to find in
- 9:00text to say, well, this is what the constitution would have said about, insert,
- 9:05current challenge or changed societal value if it was being written today or if the founding
- 9:12or the framers of the constitution were writing it today, this is what they would say.
- 9:16But like any other ideologies or theories, there's going to be some flaws in them.
- 9:21So let's talk about arguments for and against both originalism and living constitutionalism.
- 9:29So key strengths or arguments that are made in favor of originalism is that the framers were
- 9:36the original source for the meaning of these words.
- 9:39Obviously, we're trying to figure out what the framers meant at the time that they wrote these
- 9:45things.
- 9:45That has to be accounted for in some way.
- 9:48Number two is that the framers were very prescient about issues with governance that
- 9:53could crop up after a time.
- 9:54I mean, The US constitution still stands a good two hundred thirty six years on.
- 10:021789 was when it was completely ratified, so there had to be some level of foresight from
- 10:09the framers of the constitution.
- 10:11And then number three, it's important to look to the past for some guidance on the present
- 10:14and future.
- 10:16One of my guests that I had recently on the podcast here, Crom Carmichael, we kind of
- 10:21talked about that idea a little bit about how to look to the past for guidance for the
- 10:26present and the future.
- 10:28But on the flip side, some of the weaknesses that some people will point out in originalism
- 10:34is that for all their prescience, framers couldn't account for everything that could
- 10:39possibly crop up after their time.
- 10:42They were only human and no matter how prescient people are, your foresight is only
- 10:50gonna be able to go so far.
- 10:52There's all sorts of issues that the framers could not even dream would come up, although
- 10:58they knew that some things would come up.
- 10:59They just didn't really know what they were.
- 11:01Number two, some people argue against originalism.
- 11:05Even the framers and the early statesmen of The United States disagreed on the meaning of the
- 11:10constitution, and they didn't get everything they wanted.
- 11:14These constitutional debates, the constitutional convention, which actually went
- 11:17on for several months and over several meetings, there was a lot of sharp disagreement
- 11:23about what to put in the US constitution.
- 11:26So some framers can have different intent behind different words.
- 11:32And then number three, the constitution is somewhat vague in many respects and thus can
- 11:37make it more difficult to establish framers' intent.
- 11:41And to some extent, that was necessary to actually get constitutional passages
- 11:49implemented is they only could be so specific because some of the framers said, no.
- 11:55No.
- 11:56No.
- 11:56I we don't like that.
- 11:57It should be said like this.
- 11:59So sometimes they had to make things a little bit more ambiguous, especially if you compare
- 12:03it to federal statutes and state constitutions and and state statutes.
- 12:09The US constitution is not very specific about a lot of things.
- 12:13This is actually not a very long document at all.
- 12:15So I wanna say it's something like 7,300 words for a defining document of what US law is
- 12:23supposed to be based on, it's there's really not a whole lot to it.
- 12:28So that also throws a bit of a monkey wrench in it, if you will.
- 12:35And then arguments for and against living constitutionalism.
- 12:39So some of the key strengths or arguments that people will point to for living
- 12:43constitutionalism, and to some extent, are the inverse of the arguments against, for and
- 12:49against originalism.
- 12:50So some of the key arguments that people make for living constitutionalism is that the
- 12:54framers could not predict everything, so you need this document to be adaptable.
- 12:59If you can't possibly know everything that's going to come up, you can't necessarily write
- 13:04rules for every single situation, so you need to be able to adapt as time goes on, as new
- 13:11challenges crop up, as societal norms and values change.
- 13:15Number two is that the constitution was meant to not be too strict in meaning so that it
- 13:20could adapt and enough of the framers could agree on the document, otherwise the
- 13:25constitution would not exist.
- 13:27And then number three, the constitution had some notable flaws in its past that had to be
- 13:34corrected.
- 13:35We particularly look to race, for example.
- 13:38Even though the Transatlantic slave trade was eventually outlawed in 1818, I believe it was,
- 13:46it wasn't outlawed immediately.
- 13:48You still had the three fifths compromise, which counted every slave as three fifths of a
- 13:55person for the purposes of the census instead of what slave owners would have wanted is for
- 14:02one whole person or for people who were not slave owners who opposed slavery was for them
- 14:09to not count for the purposes of a census and a lot, of course, in a lot of cases, to abolish
- 14:15slavery outright, but slave owners wouldn't be going for that.
- 14:20So unfortunate flaws that were not rectified until the civil war happened.
- 14:30But so you had a lot of these issues in The US constitution, and just like any other document
- 14:37or thing created by humanity, there were flaws into it.
- 14:41So we can't treat the original meaning of the constitution as perfect.
- 14:45Now, on the flip side, some of the key weaknesses and arguments against living
- 14:50constitutionalism is that if you take it too far, it could easily go too far by becoming an
- 14:56excuse to interpret the constitution the way that one sees fit, which would make the
- 15:01document ultimately meaningless and can threaten people's rights if we can just make
- 15:05the constitution say whatever we want and change it according to our whims, then why do
- 15:10we even have the document in the first place?
- 15:14So, that also accounts for or doesn't account for, but it also brings up the problem of
- 15:25people.
- 15:26We all have our biases, and a lot of times we say the constitution means what we want it to
- 15:31say.
- 15:31Don't necessarily actually try to look at it through an unbiased lens.
- 15:37Another argument against living constitutionalism is that it can ignore the
- 15:41valuable perspective that the framers had and continue to have for today's problems.
- 15:46After all, this document has been going on for two hundred and thirty six years and still
- 15:51around and has been amended 27 times, but considering how long it's been around, that's
- 15:58not really many amendments in general, and we haven't had an amendment since 1992, I believe
- 16:05was the last was when the twenty seventh amendment was ratified.
- 16:11So obviously still not a perfect document, but still incredibly valuable and a lot of it is
- 16:18still intact today.
- 16:20And then number three, the constitution isn't as vague as some political observers would
- 16:24argue.
- 16:26There are, as the enumerated powers would suggest, there are a lot of things that are
- 16:32specifically stated in The US constitution.
- 16:34There has to be some sort of baseline that we can agree on and say, okay, this is definitely
- 16:39what the constitution says about these things.
- 16:42So originalism, living constitutionalism, have their pros and cons.
- 16:48Which one's the quote unquote best one?
- 16:51That's for you to decide, but this is just really to lay out the arguments that people
- 16:57make for and against because I try to make these debates as even as possible for people to
- 17:03decide, give you the arguments that people make for their side and for against the other side.
- 17:11But you can still see these arguments about originalism and living constitutionalism, are
- 17:17still things today, but you can see them in other legal theories and interpretive tools
- 17:28that we are gonna talk about right now.
- 17:30So now we're gonna be talking more about specifically reading statutes.
- 17:35Reading federal statutes and state constitutions and state statutes, but
- 17:40especially statutes at the federal and state levels, it's not quite the same as reading The
- 17:45US constitution or even the state constitution, but there are a lot of similar tools and
- 17:51arguments that you see, similar tools that are used, similar arguments that are made.
- 17:56And you can also see how debates about how to interpret the constitution influence these
- 18:03legislative interpretive tools both directly and indirectly.
- 18:07And there's a lot of history of legal theory that we're gonna be glossing over because it's
- 18:13not really necessary for the purposes of this episode, and I don't wanna bug this this whole
- 18:18thing down.
- 18:19This is more of a crash course into how to read legislation so that you can do it for yourself
- 18:25to some extent.
- 18:27But I'm going to draw some comparisons to these early debates that we just talked about with
- 18:32enumerated versus implied powers and originalism versus living constitutionalism.
- 18:38So there are two major overarching theories in how to read statues.
- 18:44Not necessarily the only ones, but they most can be incorporated into one of these two
- 18:50schools.
- 18:50So one is we call purposivism and one that we call textualism.
- 18:54You might remember textualism because I mentioned it earlier.
- 18:58Purposivism is the idea that interpretation should advance the statute's purpose.
- 19:04Basically, what was the statute made for?
- 19:08And this name comes from this idea that's, quote, Legislation is a purposive act and
- 19:17judges should construe statutes to execute that legislative purpose.
- 19:23And so this focuses more on the legislative process, accounting for the problem that
- 19:28Congress or a state legislature was trying to solve and how this statute in question was
- 19:35meant to solve it.
- 19:37So you can see how purposivism reflects limbing constitutionalism and implied powers to some
- 19:43extent.
- 19:44In the case of implied powers, you're talking about interpretations that advance the
- 19:47statute's purpose.
- 19:48You're using interpretations that are basically what is implied to be the statute's purpose.
- 19:56What is the statute implied to be trying to do?
- 20:00And in the case of living constitutionalism, one could say that advancing a statute to
- 20:05purpose can change and adapt over time.
- 20:09And then on the flip side, you have textualism, which focuses simply on what the text says.
- 20:14And I mentioned earlier that it's an offshoot of the originalist interpretive theory of The
- 20:19US constitution.
- 20:20It can actually butt heads with regular originalism because textualism doesn't care
- 20:26about the intent of the framers of The US constitution or legislative body who wrote a
- 20:33statute.
- 20:34The two still generally align because it's still talking about, like, what was the
- 20:38original foundation of the text, but whereas originalism talks a little bit more about the
- 20:46intended original meaning from legislators.
- 20:51Textualism just says, We don't care about that.
- 20:54What does the text say, basically?
- 20:57And so it simply says to interpret the laws by the words original meaning, and that's
- 21:01regardless of what the intent was.
- 21:04And some would say that it's what a quote unquote reasonable legislator or irregular
- 21:11English speaker would think a statute's text means.
- 21:14So it's not nearly as concerned with context as purposivists are.
- 21:19So you can see how textualism reflects originalism to some extent, but also the
- 21:23enumerated powers to some extent because they're talking about what the text explicitly
- 21:28says.
- 21:29Enumerated powers are talking about what the text explicitly says.
- 21:35But now if we go a little bit further into the field of purposivism and textualism, There are
- 21:43five main tools of legislative interpretation and both purposivists and textualists may use
- 21:53any or all of these tools, how much weight they put on each one of them and which ones they use
- 22:01first can differ, but they can and sometimes do use all five of these main tools of legislative
- 22:09interpretation.
- 22:11For better or for worse, laws are not always straightforward and obvious in their meaning.
- 22:18A lot of times we'd like that to be the case, but the ambiguity can be intentional or
- 22:23unintentional.
- 22:24And also certain lawyers get paid lots of money to find ways to interpret or even bend laws to
- 22:31what they want it to mean and what their clients want it to mean too, so there is that.
- 22:38But why beyond that, why wouldn't laws be clear about what they mean?
- 22:43Well, a lot of it comes down to the realities of the legislative process with all the
- 22:49wheeling and dealing that goes on there.
- 22:53Legislators meticulously craft legislation and have to debate its provisions in committees and
- 23:01on House or Senate floors.
- 23:05Now, this gonna be oversimplifying it a little bit, but more vague bills can be attacked for
- 23:11being too broad, not strong enough.
- 23:14What do these words mean?
- 23:16What are the unintended consequences that can happen?
- 23:19So you can just look at that and say, well, why are there sometimes so many vague laws and
- 23:26legislative bills?
- 23:28But more specific bills can be attacked for being too narrow, not accounting for enough
- 23:34situations.
- 23:35The meaning of the words on there can also still be debated, and there still can be
- 23:40unintended consequences.
- 23:41So you make things more vague, they could be attacked.
- 23:45You make things more specific, they could still be attacked.
- 23:48And, of course, the different situations can lead to different kinds of attacks and
- 23:55arguments.
- 23:57But even beyond that, laws can still get passed despite being sloppy and not well worded,
- 24:04whether legislators bring up possible issues or not, or if you have a legislature or state
- 24:10government in general that leans heavily towards one party and there's a lot of group
- 24:15thinking and hive minded behavior, they probably will think, Oh no, we got this figured
- 24:22out.
- 24:22We don't need to really actually account for anything else and so they won't actually listen
- 24:28to arguments that are made, whether they are reasonable arguments against a bill or not.
- 24:35So you can still find plenty of sloppy bills or bills that are archaic but have never been
- 24:42actually addressed and updated and modernized.
- 24:47But also administrative agencies, are in the executive branch, may also interpret laws in
- 24:53ways that a legislature did not intend and how much leeway they have to do that depends.
- 24:59Now at the federal level, we did see the Chevron deference doctrine take a hit, which
- 25:06the courts will, to some extent, defer to what administrative agencies interpret the law as as
- 25:14long as there's some level of reasonableness to it.
- 25:19Now, at the federal level, that has taken a hit with some recent US Supreme Court rulings, but
- 25:25at the state level, you might still see that kind of thing where a court may a state level
- 25:31court might defer to a state executive agency's interpretation of a state law.
- 25:38But despite often being at odds with each other, like we said earlier, purposivism and
- 25:43textualism might use any of these five tools that we're gonna talk about, but with varying
- 25:49order and weight put on each of them.
- 25:52So here are the five basic tools of interpretation that we can use for legislation.
- 25:59Number one is ordinary meaning.
- 26:02This is concerned with how words are understood in common speech and dictionaries or if they
- 26:06have specialized meaning in certain fields.
- 26:09Number two, statutory context, which looks at surrounding phrases in statutes and the overall
- 26:15structure of the law.
- 26:17Number three, canons of construction, presumptions about how courts ordinarily read
- 26:23and interpret legislation.
- 26:25Number four, legislative history, which is the record of a legislative body's discussion when
- 26:31enacting a law.
- 26:32There's a lot of meanings that you can refer to and other documents that talk about what
- 26:37legislators meant with a law.
- 26:39And then number five, statutory implementation, which talks about how a law has been applied in
- 26:44the past and how it might be applied in the future.
- 26:48And all of them have their own strengths and weaknesses.
- 26:51Legal interpretation tool number one, ordinary meaning.
- 26:55This is concerned with how a word is understood in common speech, dictionaries, books,
- 27:01databases.
- 27:02So if I opened Webster's dictionary or another dictionary right now and looked at a specific
- 27:08word in a statue, what does the dictionary say about that?
- 27:11Or what does a relevant database say about that?
- 27:15Or how do people just use a word in general?
- 27:19Or could the word have a specialized meaning in a particular field?
- 27:23So, for example, if you looked at state statutes or federal statutes, you might see the
- 27:30word corporation, which tends to you tend to think about a big business, but it could also
- 27:37refer to a city which can be called a municipal corporation or it might just be talking about
- 27:43maybe even a nonprofit is called a corporation.
- 27:47You sometimes might have to look specifically at what the state statutes say a word means if
- 27:53that state statute even says what that word means.
- 27:58But speaking of which, in many cases, certain words in statutes will have a section in those
- 28:05statutes that define what the words in other sections mean.
- 28:08Not always, but it might have an entire section blocked off of, these are definitions for
- 28:15various words that you'll find here.
- 28:17And if you go to a statute that deals with that thing, it might tell you, go to section 100 to
- 28:25see what this word means, for example.
- 28:28And even if the word may mean something else in another context or in another state's laws, one
- 28:35state might have different stipulations for what that word means.
- 28:40If I were to use examples like artificial intelligence, we generally know what we mean
- 28:51when we say artificial intelligence, but in legal settings, it's not enough to generally
- 28:57know what you're talking about.
- 28:58So with the rise of artificial intelligence getting better and better and scarier and
- 29:04scarier, Different states are talking about addressing artificial intelligence in different
- 29:12ways.
- 29:12Now how that's going to butt up against the Donald Trump administration who is trying to
- 29:18take a preemptive approach to artificial intelligence, that's beside the point.
- 29:23States might have different definitions for all the things that constitute artificial
- 29:29intelligence.
- 29:30Like, you play a video game and you're one in particular where you you kill things, which I
- 29:37like to do a lot of times.
- 29:38I like to play a lot of RPGs and first person shooters, but that's technically artificial
- 29:43intelligence.
- 29:44But that's not the kind of artificial intelligence that people are typically talking
- 29:47about.
- 29:48You're typically talking about things like chat GPT or anything else like that or Grok for for
- 29:55Twitter or X.
- 29:57Those are usually the kinds of things that people are talking about when it comes to
- 30:00artificial intelligence.
- 30:01So you might need to be very specific about the kinds of artificial intelligence that you are
- 30:05talking about because AI is not a new thing.
- 30:08It is a it's something that's been around for a while, but the kind of AI that we're talking
- 30:14about is a lot more recent.
- 30:15It's come up in the last few years.
- 30:20Another one is a monopoly.
- 30:22So you're talking about a monopoly, you're talking about a market where there's only one
- 30:28seller of goods That generally you generally understand what people are talking about, but a
- 30:35state might write laws so that there's something that's akin to a monopoly.
- 30:40So they might say a seller that controls 70% of the market where it's effectively a monopoly,
- 30:47even though technically monopoly has to have a 100 of the market and be considered the sole
- 30:52seller of whatever the good is.
- 30:55Or you talk about a monopsony was the the opposite end of the spectrum.
- 31:00Well, I don't know if it's opposite end of the spectrum, but it's where there's only one buyer
- 31:04in a market.
- 31:06So you might say where a buyer has 70% of the market or 60% of the market, it might be
- 31:13considered he might he or she or it might be considered if it's a business might be
- 31:18considered a monopsony.
- 31:21Or what is a political symbol?
- 31:23Here in Florida, that has been a bit controversial because of a law regarding what
- 31:31political symbols can be displayed in public settings.
- 31:36And some people have argued that the pride flag constitutes a political symbol, whereas other
- 31:43people argue that it doesn't constitute a political symbol.
- 31:47So how do you define a political symbol in law?
- 31:54That is another major example of how you have to be specific about what you mean with a word
- 32:03or a term.
- 32:07But not everything in statutory law will be expressly defined, which is predominantly where
- 32:12this ordinary meaning interpretive tool comes in.
- 32:15So if there's no specific definition that comes into play, we say, okay.
- 32:20Well, what does a dictionary say?
- 32:22What does an outside database say or books or common speech?
- 32:27Now one of the big issues with the ordinary meaning interpretive tool is that a judge might
- 32:34invoke ordinary meaning, quote unquote, as a smokescreen to really just justify their own
- 32:40policy preferences, even if they don't intend to.
- 32:42Maybe they really think that this particular meaning of a word is ordinary meaning, but they
- 32:49either don't admit or they don't realize it's just their bias speaking.
- 32:54So, ordinary meaning is not even necessarily agreed upon.
- 32:59Legal interpretive tool number two, statutory context.
- 33:05So what do the surrounding phrases and the overall structure of the law say or do they
- 33:12give any clues as to what a statute's meaning is?
- 33:16So you can talk about that if if there is a section that talks about the definition of a
- 33:22word or you can look at the surrounding clauses and other parts of a section and see what they
- 33:30might indicate about what a word's meaning is.
- 33:33Or is the term in the statute used elsewhere to indicate what that word means?
- 33:39A legislative body might have used different language elsewhere in a meaningful way or use
- 33:45those same exact words in a different way in another passage in the statutes.
- 33:53Many statutes will be part of a much larger relevant passage.
- 33:59Not every state structures their statutes the same way, but a lot of them will follow a
- 34:03format that's similar to articles, sections, paragraphs.
- 34:09They'll say article one is executive branch, for example.
- 34:13Then section one, two, three, four, etcetera, etcetera, will say different aspects that
- 34:18relate to the executive branch, like which agencies are part of the executive branch,
- 34:24which executive offices are part of the executive branch in that state.
- 34:30And then paragraphs might talk about more specific things like this specific office is
- 34:37part of the executive branch.
- 34:39This specific agency is part of the executive branch.
- 34:43Or they might call the article a title or something like that.
- 34:47Verbiage might be a little bit different, but the basic idea is that's how state statutes
- 34:53typically structure themselves.
- 34:56There's other states that use things called state codes that are more divided by particular
- 35:04subjects instead of just simple one, two, three, four, five, six.
- 35:08It might be alphabetical, but that's a little bit beside the point.
- 35:13So if disputed language is used in another statutory provision, courts generally will try
- 35:18to give it the same meaning throughout statutes just for the sake of consistency.
- 35:22And that other provision might illuminate the meaning of what the word means in another's
- 35:29provision.
- 35:31But an issue here is that if you find multiple instances of a term in other provisions of the
- 35:36statute, that can make the definition of a term rather murky.
- 35:39So if you have let's use political symbol again.
- 35:43If you have political symbol in statutes, let's just say random number, 20 and you see that
- 35:53word political symbol used in section 103, but they're used in two different ways to mean two
- 36:07different things, well, which of those meanings do you go with?
- 36:12That's not necessarily an obvious answer to that kind of thing.
- 36:19So you might have even more ambiguity about what a law means.
- 36:25And then that opens up a whole other can of worms, maybe even a dispute with another
- 36:29statute that uses that same word.
- 36:32Legal and interpretive tool number three, canons of construction.
- 36:37So what is the general understanding of how a relevant court reads statutes?
- 36:42So if we talk about Michigan, how does the Michigan State Supreme Court or the appellate
- 36:50courts, how do they typically read statutes?
- 36:53And these can serve as a these canons of construction can serve as a guiding principle
- 36:58for interpreting statutes across legal disputes, though they might not always be
- 37:02applicable.
- 37:03So canons are more so presumptions rather than explicit rules.
- 37:07There's no rule book that's that Michigan justice has to look at and say, oh, okay.
- 37:13This is how we typically construct laws.
- 37:15No, there's presumptions that are made.
- 37:19So there are two main types of canons of construction.
- 37:24There are semantic canons and there are substantive canons.
- 37:27So semantic canons focus on text, grammar, and presumptions about legislative drafting, and
- 37:34these are especially favored by textualists because it simply focuses on the wording of the
- 37:38text.
- 37:40State legislatures often have a legislative drafting manual that legislators follow when
- 37:48crafting laws, and those are examples of something that could be looked to by the courts
- 37:53in the case of semantic canons.
- 37:55They can use that to help their understanding of, okay, this is how statues in this state are
- 38:01typically crafted and interpreted.
- 38:04So one type of semantic canon is called a surplussage canon, which requires courts to
- 38:10give each wording clause of a statute operative effect when possible.
- 38:16So in other words, interpretation should not define a statutory provision in a way that
- 38:21renders it or another part of the statute inoperative, at least whenever possible.
- 38:27But an issue here with these kinds of canons is that some judges question whether a surplusage
- 38:33canon is even true or if it is more likely more or less likely that a legislative body even
- 38:41uses superfluous language.
- 38:44Once again, it's a presumption rather than an actual explicit rule, these semantic canons.
- 38:50And then you have substantive canons, which focus on the presumptions about particular
- 38:55outcomes that the legislative body would or wouldn't want.
- 38:58So it's especially favored by purposivists because it focuses on the statute's purpose and
- 39:03what the legislative body, whether it's Congress or state legislature, was trying to do
- 39:09with a statute.
- 39:11And one type of substantive canon is the canon of constitutional avoidance, which says that if
- 39:18one reading of a statute raises, quote unquote, serious doubts about its constitutionality, a
- 39:25court should look for another, quote, fairly possible, unquote, reading that avoids
- 39:30constitutional issues.
- 39:32So if one reading suggests there's no way that this is constitutional, then you see if there
- 39:37is another reading that doesn't challenge constitutionality.
- 39:42So if we talked about political symbols again, is there a way to interpret it where it is
- 39:48infringing upon free speech in a way that violates the First Amendment of the US
- 39:52constitution, or is there a way that you can read it where it doesn't violate the First
- 39:56Amendment of the US constitution?
- 39:59But an issue here is that judges disagree on how much constitutional doubt should be present
- 40:05or whether an alternative reading is quote unquote fairly possible.
- 40:10Legal interpretive tool number four, legislative history.
- 40:14So what is the record of a legislative body's discussion and deliberation when it comes to
- 40:20enacting a specific law?
- 40:22How can you discover evidence about the legislature's intent or support textual
- 40:29interpretation or understand a law scope or some combination thereof?
- 40:34Well, there's several major tools that you can use to do that, which include recordings of
- 40:42committee meetings when they're trying to hammer out the issues with the bill so that
- 40:46they can ship it off to the full chamber floor, whether it's a house or senate.
- 40:51You can look to written minutes of the committee meetings, which sort of like a text
- 40:56transcription of the committee meetings that you would otherwise get through video or other
- 41:04reports by legislative staff depending on the state.
- 41:06Some reports on legislation and what the legislation is trying to do and what are what
- 41:11are its predicted effects.
- 41:14Now how many of these tools are readily available for state statutes depends on the
- 41:18state in question because some states make it much harder to find recordings of the meetings,
- 41:23some might livestream the meetings but others don't, and some might have fewer reports on
- 41:30legislation and predicted effects than others.
- 41:33So using legislative history as an interpretive tool can be easier in other states than or in
- 41:41some states than in other states.
- 41:44But an issue here is that legislative history can be conflicting.
- 41:48It makes it difficult to determine which parts of the record should be heated, like if like if
- 41:53you talk about committee meetings and you're looking at a couple of legislators who disagree
- 41:59on a bill, but the bill gets passed through.
- 42:02So which of those intentions do we do we look at when we're talking about the ultimate
- 42:10intention behind legislation and the ultimate interpretation of legislation.
- 42:15Do we talk about that legislator who succeeded in getting that bill passed or the one who was
- 42:19unsuccessful in stopping that bill?
- 42:22That is not exactly a straightforward answer.
- 42:27Legal interpretive tool number five, statutory implementation.
- 42:32So how has a law been applied in the past and how might it be applied in the future?
- 42:37So courts would investigate how a statute actually works, asking what problem a
- 42:43legislative body sought to address with the disputed provision and how that body went about
- 42:48addressing it.
- 42:49So you can also look to statutory context to consider a law's operation.
- 42:55And courts might look at practical consequences to see if an asserted interpretation aligns
- 43:01with the statutory scheme and they might also rely on their own understandings of how a
- 43:08statute is supposed to be implemented in order to interpret the statute's meaning.
- 43:14But you also if you're a court, you might also look at administrative agencies'
- 43:20interpretations because these administrative agencies are typically the first official
- 43:26interpreters of statutes as they must resolve interpretive questions to carry out the
- 43:31statute.
- 43:32Even though Congress or state legislature might have meant one thing by a passage, an
- 43:39administrative agency may look in and say, Oh no, did they mean this?
- 43:43And sometimes, of course, they might have their own motives for interpreting a law the way that
- 43:49they want to interpret a law, or if a governor is at odds with that state legislature, they
- 43:54might coax that administrative agency to interpret a law in a way that that legislature
- 44:00did not intend for it to mean.
- 44:02So you can see a little bit of that schism between executive and legislative there.
- 44:08So that's not necessarily a foolproof way of looking at things because how the statute might
- 44:20be implemented in a state, it might depend on who exactly is in office.
- 44:25So that is one of the big issues there with using statutory implementation.
- 44:30So you see how each of these tools has its own positive things going for it, if you will.
- 44:38Some of these reasonable ways that it might be used to say, okay, this is a good tool to use
- 44:44in this situation.
- 44:45But just like anything else that involves human beings, they also have their own weaknesses and
- 44:49arguments that you could make against using them.
- 44:52And what interpretive tool is going to be used or which ones are going to be used and how
- 44:59much.
- 45:00A lot of it's gonna depend on the judge in question or the panel of judges or the full
- 45:06court.
- 45:08Yeah.
- 45:08Like, if it's going in front of the supreme court, if it's going through an appellate
- 45:12court, appellate courts might have panels of judges that look at it before it goes in from
- 45:18that whole court.
- 45:20So you need to know which one of those interpretive tools is most likely gonna be used
- 45:27by that judge.
- 45:29Speaking of which, why is it important to know how to read laws and legislation?
- 45:34Now you've got this far.
- 45:36Maybe you already understand some level of the importance of how to read laws and legislation,
- 45:44but I think it still bears fully diving in in case you start to think, well, is it really
- 45:50worth it to know these things?
- 45:51Or if you're trying to teach other people how to read laws and legislation, These are some of
- 45:56the reasons that you you can use and should use to show people why these things are important.
- 46:03Because anybody can benefit from knowing how to interpret and read laws and legislation, not
- 46:08just people who are regularly involved in politics.
- 46:11Even if you're not, it's still very useful.
- 46:14So I'm gonna talk about four main reasons why you should care about how to interpret
- 46:21legislation and why you should learn how to do it.
- 46:27Number one is that it enhances civic education.
- 46:31That might sound kind of obvious, but you gain a better understanding of how the government
- 46:35works, which inevitably impacts your life because, especially when it gets to state and
- 46:41especially local government, they have more and more direct impact on your day to day life,
- 46:46especially if it is a policy that you care about.
- 46:48Whatever policy it is that you can think of that you say, this is the thing I want to get
- 46:53involved in.
- 46:54This is the one I want to make a difference in.
- 46:55Well, what?
- 46:57Knowing how to read this legislation is important for you.
- 47:00If you want to change a law or if there's a law that you really like or a legislative bill that
- 47:05you really like, but you're trying to get it through to the finish line, you should know how
- 47:10these interpretive tools are used.
- 47:13And just you're just better able to understand debates about laws, and we can have a better
- 47:19civic life in general for this country, A civic life that is very much, shall we say, not doing
- 47:29so hot right now.
- 47:31And but, of course, civic education is vitally important to upholding and promoting our
- 47:37democracy and our political way of life in general.
- 47:42Another reason why you should know how to interpret legislation is that it helps to
- 47:46incorporate as much info as possible to come up with the best solutions for a policy or
- 47:52governance issue.
- 47:54Nobody has all the answers.
- 47:55Some people certainly like to think they have all the answers, but when you get all these
- 47:59different perspectives, it helps find the shortcomings in a policy that can negatively
- 48:04affect citizens whether directly or indirectly.
- 48:08Bad laws don't help out the general citizenry.
- 48:11There might be some special interests that benefit from a poorly written law, but overall
- 48:17it doesn't really help people.
- 48:18So you should have some understanding of these different arguments so that you can look at
- 48:25legislation from various angles, even if it's one you support and say, Oh, okay, I see why
- 48:31somebody would think this is an issue and you can fix those shortcomings accordingly.
- 48:37Number three reason that you should know how to interpret legislation.
- 48:41If you have any interest in getting involved in politics or you're already involved in politics
- 48:46but you wanna sharpen your skills, it always helps you to know how other people think, not
- 48:52just because you're coming up with the best solutions for a policy, but if you are involved
- 48:56in a legal battle or you have a vested interest in a legal battle, you need to know not only
- 49:00your own arguments, but the arguments of the opposition so that you can more effectively
- 49:05counter what they argue.
- 49:08So if a piece of legislation or a bill is being sued in court, you need to know why people see
- 49:19that bill the way they do.
- 49:20Even if they have a misconception of the bill, you still need to know why exactly they think
- 49:26what they think and what interpretive tools they are using so that you can counter those
- 49:31arguments, especially if you're working for a client that is trying to get legislation passed
- 49:37or trying to save a law from being struck down by courts.
- 49:42And similar to what we call a SWOT analysis in a campaign, SWOT stands for strengths,
- 49:48weaknesses, opportunities, and threats.
- 49:52So in those kinds of campaigns, you look at, well, what are the things you're about your
- 49:57candidate or whatever it is you're campaigning for that are positives that you can build upon
- 50:03and that you can really harness to help to push your campaign in the best position.
- 50:08But what are also some of the arguments against your candidate or whatever it is you're
- 50:13campaigning for so that you can watch out for, okay, this is a point of attack they're gonna
- 50:19use against whatever it is you're campaigning for and say, this is why you shouldn't vote for
- 50:27this person or for this issue.
- 50:30Opportunities are more looking at the opposition saying, okay.
- 50:36We can attack them on this.
- 50:38And then threats are more like what are their strengths that they can use to their advantage
- 50:43and how do you mitigate those.
- 50:45So it's a similar case with legislative interpretive tools.
- 50:50You look at the strengths and weaknesses of the bill or law that you support, and you look at
- 50:56the opportunities or and threats from the opposition, what arguments they have on their
- 51:02side, for their side, and against your side.
- 51:07And then the fourth reason that I'm going to cover that you should know how to interpret
- 51:12legislation is that you're less likely to be hoodwinked by partisan, ideological, or other
- 51:18biased interests who try to bend laws to suit their interests and convince you of their
- 51:24beliefs.
- 51:25So there are several things that they use against you or try to use against you.
- 51:31One is that information related to laws and legislation is usually not readily accessible
- 51:37or easily understandable.
- 51:38That's partly why I even made this episode in the first place so that this stuff can be more
- 51:43accessible and understandable so that you kind of know how these disputes about how to
- 51:50interpret laws happen.
- 51:53Another thing that these biased interests try to use against you is that even if people know
- 51:59how to read and research, they don't often have that much time to devote to it, so they can't
- 52:04really spend the time to go look for this information, so sometimes they have to rely on
- 52:09somebody to tell them what what to think, especially if it's somebody they trust.
- 52:16And then number three, a lot of information is competing for your time.
- 52:20There's a lot of stimuli.
- 52:21Not all of it is political.
- 52:22Some things are just maybe it's sports.
- 52:25I love sports.
- 52:26I love video games.
- 52:27I have a whole bunch of things that are competing for my time too.
- 52:29All of us have a whole bunch of things that are trying to compete for our attention, or some of
- 52:34us are raising kids or have a spouse or whatever other interests there are out there.
- 52:41A lot of this stuff is competing for your time, which can overwhelm you and make you just
- 52:45simply rely on sources you trust, sort of like what we talked about before, but it's not with
- 52:50the knowing even if you know how to read a research.
- 52:53But it might not even be because you just don't have the time to do it.
- 52:56You might just feel like I can't handle all the stimuli being thrown at me.
- 53:01Somebody just tell me what to think about piece of legislation.
- 53:06And even if it's not necessarily like a specific source that they're going to to tell
- 53:09them what to think, they might just hear arguments and say, okay, this one sounds like
- 53:14it makes the most sense.
- 53:15I'm gonna go with that.
- 53:16But they don't necessarily look at the information themselves.
- 53:20Now it is true that some of these special interests really do believe what they are
- 53:25telling you.
- 53:26It's not all nefarious trying to pull the wool over your eyes, but for others, it is purely
- 53:34for their political gain that they try to convince you of their side.
- 53:39So they try to say, Well, no, this is what this law actually means and this is why you should
- 53:45believe it.
- 53:48And they might have an argument on their side, they might not.
- 53:53But these are people that are trying to win policy battles in legislatures, elections and
- 54:00public opinion polling.
- 54:02Whenever So people are that heavily involved in politics and trying to tell you this is what
- 54:06this legislation means, you should take it with a grain of salt because they're trying to tell
- 54:14you something so that they win.
- 54:15Doesn't mean that you shouldn't listen to them at all, but it does mean that you should be
- 54:19careful how much you trust other opinions.
- 54:23When you have the time and when you have the capability, it is always best to research the
- 54:28information yourself and come to your own conclusion, which doesn't necessarily mean that
- 54:34you won't be subject to bias that way also, but it's generally a good policy to try to look at
- 54:43laws and legislation for yourself.
- 54:47But it's it's hard.
- 54:49It takes a lot of time and effort to do that.
- 54:51And that's a big reason why I even made this podcast in the first place, to try to help make
- 54:56that a lot easier to deal with.
- 54:59Try to put this information in one place so that you're better able to inform yourself, not
- 55:06just me inform you, but for you to inform yourself.
- 55:09So I hope that I succeed in that endeavor, not just with this episode, but with all that I do.
- 55:15But I was gonna wrap things up for today's episode.
- 55:19As always, thank you so much for listening and tuning in.
- 55:22Please like, comment, subscribe, and share the podcast on YouTube, on Spotify, on Apple
- 55:27Podcasts.
- 55:28And for this episode in particular, will plug that webinar that I do again that is about
- 55:33helping or being able to read legislation to best serve your clients or yourself if you have
- 55:40legislation that you particularly care about or even if you're trying to craft legislation
- 55:44yourself.
- 55:44Knowing these interpretive tools can really help you in those endeavors to try to A, make
- 55:51the best policy but B, also succeed in making it reality.
- 55:56But other than that, my five day educational email course about how to more effectively
- 56:01mitigate political polarization, particularly the mistakes that we make that unintentionally
- 56:06inflame polarization and how to fix those mistakes.
- 56:09My Facebook, Paul Raider author and speaker, my LinkedIn profile, which is simply Paul Raider,
- 56:15medium dot com where I write on from time to time, my email, PaulRaiderwrites@Gmail.com, my
- 56:21website, Paul Raider dot org, and my book on Amazon, why independents rarely win elections
- 56:28and how they could become more competitive.
- 56:30You could buy that in ebook and paperback format.
- 56:33But that is going to wrap things up for today.
- 56:37So thank you so much again for listening, and we'll see you next time.