Latest / Crypto Coin Show / RWA on Blockchain about to explode? With BlockApps | Blockchain Interviews
Transcript
- 0:00I'm Ashon Addison from the Crypto Coin Show and today on Blockchain interviews with Victor
- 0:05Wong, founder and Chief product officer of block Apps. Victor, thanks for
- 0:09taking the time and great to see you here today. Oh, thank you,
- 0:12Ashtin, thanks for having me. You're very welcome. Excited to dive
- 0:15into the real world asset space in blockchain and what you and the team at
- 0:20block apps have been building. I know you've been in the space for a
- 0:22long time. I would love to hear a little bit more first of all
- 0:25about your background in business and blockchain and how that led up to block apps,
- 0:30and then we can dive into all the latest information. Okay, great,
- 0:34Well, I guess I've been a long time participant in the space.
- 0:38I helped with the launch of the Ethereum public blockchain, and then from there
- 0:43we really focused on real world adoption of blockchain by primarily focusing on private blockchains
- 0:51and enterprise adoption. So we built many of the first, you know,
- 0:56blockchain applications used by enterprises using theorem technology, and over time we created a
- 1:04fairly large business growing and working with those enterprises. But you know, in
- 1:11sort of the more recent times, we realized that we think the real adoption,
- 1:15mainstream adoption of blockchain is not going to come primarily through private blockchains,
- 1:22but really through public blockchains, and because enterprises are now getting comfortable with,
- 1:30you know, putting some of their workloads on public blockchain. The example is
- 1:34the announcement by block rock this week. So we saw that trend over a
- 1:38year ago and we made that kind of pivot toward the rw A space.
- 1:42Yeah, it's very interesting and it's amazing to be at the inception of ethereum
- 1:49and see and be actually helping build out that mainstream adoption. It's interesting to
- 1:56see that transition from major companies. They want to get involved with this,
- 2:00but in the way that they do it. You know, private ethereum blockchains
- 2:04are are not the ethereum that we see on in coin market cap. They're
- 2:08using the technology, but it was just a matter of time before they get
- 2:13comfortable with something that you know, eventually will likely be a multi trillion dollar
- 2:19or more market alone. And the real world asset space is one of the
- 2:24major use cases for ethereum. Of course, there's so many, but I
- 2:29know that I feel like it's one that is yet it's it's on the cusp
- 2:35of that hockey stick effect. You know, we've we've heard of obviously the
- 2:39finance industry, which will also be tokenized into into real world assets. But
- 2:45other things that you wouldn't normally think of of being tokenized are now like people
- 2:50are getting comfortable with ethereum technology to be like, hey, we should tokenize
- 2:53all this other stuff because there's incredible benefits there as well. Yeah, and
- 2:58that's so what we we saw as like really, you know, at block
- 3:01apps, and this kind of transitions into what we're doing at block apps when
- 3:06we made the tradition, when we made the transition away from the enterprise private
- 3:09blockchain market. You know, what we were doing in that market for Fortune
- 3:15five hundred companies, governments, you know, all of these big clients was
- 3:19really we were taking real world assets and tokenizing them, mostly for like supply
- 3:23chain use cases. So we started off with basic EP THEEREM, but how
- 3:29to add all these features in order to make it work for these kind of
- 3:32use cases. And you know, some of those things include identity changes to
- 3:37the consensus algorithm, how to model them in smart contracts. So that's some
- 3:42of the work that we had kind of previously did and What we saw is
- 3:46that as kind of these companies and kind of started to move toward the public
- 3:52blockchain space, but also as the kind of mainstream adoption kind of petered off
- 3:58a bit, and we see, you know, at block apps, we
- 4:00sayah, machion is to onboard the next one billion blockchain users by offering the
- 4:05rare and valuable things. What we mean by that is, you know,
- 4:10like it has to be something that someone would buy, whether or not blockchain
- 4:15was involved or not, and you use the blockchain aspects to make it more
- 4:19enticing to them by either giving them lower cost by fractionalizing, or you know,
- 4:25making it more available for like secondary market trading. So that that's really
- 4:29what we're focused and to do that, we've kind of launched our own a
- 4:33theorem derived blockchain with these extra features that we call Strato Marcata. Oh,
- 4:39very interesting. I'd love to dive into that a little bit later as well.
- 4:42And great insights into the RWA space. I know that eventually, you
- 4:48know, the entire stock market and hopefully every car and every building will be
- 4:54tokenized. It's just a matter of which are the assets that are ready and
- 4:59the people that are ready to understand and buy those assets first. As all
- 5:02the entire world of assets gets transitioned into blockchain, what do you think are
- 5:09some of the ripe areas in what types of assets are most fit to become
- 5:13the early adopters of tokenization for people to buy and trade? Right? So,
- 5:18I mean you have where things started, you know, the earliest our
- 5:21WA's or stable coins, right, And you know, really, what we
- 5:26think about it is that it's things that people can understand and also want access
- 5:31to. So part of our thesis is that we want to kind of there
- 5:35are whole classes of assets that we want to democratize that currently normal people don't
- 5:43have access to, like you know, for example, just as an example,
- 5:47most of these are like high value assets. Let's say you have the
- 5:50money and you want to buy, you know, a high end piece of
- 5:55art or commercial real estate. Now you probably winningness and know exactly where to
- 6:00go to do this, and that's assuming you have the money. Most people
- 6:03don't have the money. So how can we bring it down to make it
- 6:08available to most people? And you know, that's where we're using the blockchain
- 6:12ability to fractionalize and de risk it by allowing people to you know, sell
- 6:16it when they want to as kind of like the benefit. So we sort
- 6:20of lead with the assets and classes of assets that we've seen already. Are
- 6:26are like, think of anything that the wealthy have access to to their portfolios
- 6:30that most normal people don't have. So I mentioned a couple there. You
- 6:33know, art we've looked at, but you know that's not our main focus.
- 6:38Medals is another. You know, commercial real estate for example. There
- 6:45are so many collectibles we've started with, Like, there are so many of
- 6:48these sort of areas that we're kind of looking into now, and you know,
- 6:53pretty much from everyone we talk to, they're really interested in kind of
- 6:56moving in this direction. It's very cool and I love that as more people
- 7:02are interested in investing in different types of assets. For the example that you
- 7:08gave about art or real estate, you know, ninety nine percent of the
- 7:11world can't go buy a skyscraper all out, you know, they want to
- 7:15get one percent or zero point one percent of it. And I think that's
- 7:18where tokenization really comes into play, lowering the barriers for entry. But I
- 7:24think even middle, medium priced or lower priced assets, there still are a
- 7:29lot of benefits for tokenization or just the liquidity, the transparency and being able
- 7:33to move something or own it digitally and buy it from somebody across the world
- 7:38without having to go through all the logistics of figuring out how you're going to
- 7:43move this precious piece of art. You know, most people that are investing
- 7:46in something, they don't necessarily have to have it in their possession to own
- 7:51it if they own it on the blockchain. Yeah, I think that's the
- 7:56core piece of the blockchain that most people don't talk about. I think the
- 8:00core function in terms of real world assets of blockchains is really to separate ownership
- 8:05from possession, right, so you don't necessarily need to own something in order
- 8:11to read the benefits of trading or you know, reselling it. And we've
- 8:16seen this kind of happen on an industry level already. Like you know,
- 8:20you can think of commodities, future markets, they already do this. You
- 8:24can think of you know, in the sneaker market, they already do this
- 8:28where there are consignment vendors that owe the actual item and then you can retrade
- 8:33those items without having the friction of having to ship it every time. So,
- 8:37you know, we're taking that and kind of generalizing it. Our ultimate
- 8:41vision is to be able to kind of take any tradeable real world asset,
- 8:46put it on the blockchain, and be able to kind of reap these benefits
- 8:48of like the whole having a tradable digital entity because it can move very fast,
- 8:56can be more reliable, and like we said, it can kind of
- 9:00allow you to lower the costs of having a partial ownership without having to buy
- 9:05the whole thing. M h and I was looking into the block apps marketplace
- 9:11some of the different types of real world assets that the team is starting with
- 9:13saw carbon in their metal, metals, and collectibles. I'm curious on the
- 9:20metal side. I feel like personally it's a great diversification to have some kind
- 9:24of metals in your portfolio as well. Can you talk about the difference of
- 9:28people that have been traditionally buying metals or even digitally buying them from somebody,
- 9:33versus on the tokenization marketplace. Yeah, so really it's about you know,
- 9:39kind of like when you buy any kind of token, we basically allow you
- 9:48to kind of resell it right away, right so, which makes it much
- 9:52more easy. Like part of the part of the issue with things like metals
- 9:56is they can be very heavy in bulki to ship in volumes, you know,
- 9:58you don't want to move around even a thousand ounces of silver is you
- 10:05know, close to eighty pounds, Like it's a big bar. And the
- 10:07shipping costs alone are enormous. I mean people complain about das costs, Like
- 10:11if you just think about the ship and costs of something like that, it's
- 10:13crazy, right, So, but how can you kind of adopt to a
- 10:18world where you can trade in something without having to have the physical thing?
- 10:24First of all, you have to have trust that the physical thing is being
- 10:28held and is real. Right, So in our world and the way we
- 10:33kind of design show Mercada is we have this idea of issuers. Like issuers
- 10:37are people that have been verified and are holding that physical thing. So for
- 10:43example, the meatos we sell in Mercada today, we work with a partner
- 10:48TOKENY, and for every ounce of silver you are buying effectively shares in one
- 10:54hundred ounce bars which are kept in evolved So you know, it's we've taken
- 10:58that idea from the stable coin world, where like asset backed stable coins,
- 11:03you know, and Blackrock is doing this with financial instruments and applying it to
- 11:07real things, and we think that is where you know, as these kind
- 11:11of individual items move people will be able to leverage the profits off it without
- 11:18having to buy the whole thing. And that's what work I'm really really interested
- 11:22in. You know, it's very interesting and I'm curious for traditional investors that
- 11:28they invest in the stock market, they maybe not are familiar with the intricacies
- 11:33of blockchain or the tokenization part. What is the major difference between you know,
- 11:37going to the commodities exchange or on the stock market and purchasing something that
- 11:41they think is as close as they can get to silver versus buying it on
- 11:46the tokenization market. Yeah, I mean the big answer to that question is,
- 11:52you know, when you're is control, right, And what we mean
- 11:56by this is that when you buy, you can definitely buy, you know,
- 12:03ETFs of various items like this, Like it could be real estate,
- 12:05could be art, it could be any of these categories, right, but
- 12:09you're still missing the underlying control of what you're buying, right, Like you
- 12:13don't make the decisions I want to buy this building and not this building,
- 12:18right, I want to buy this kind of metal or this art piece and
- 12:20not this our piece, right. And you know, what we're offering is
- 12:26the ability to buy effectively asset tokens, So you buy, you know,
- 12:33a component of that asset itself, and it's up to you if you want
- 12:35to group them into a fund, that's fine with you. That's fine with
- 12:39us if you want to, you know, but like you know, kind
- 12:41of more clearly what you're buying versus sort of that fund kind of portfolio thing.
- 12:46And you know, we see that people will eventually build portfolios themselves once
- 12:50they're kind of given that aspect of it, but they want more choice over
- 12:56the things to buy. Like you know, where you buy real estate,
- 13:00even in one city or one district can be very different. So you know,
- 13:03why should experts take that money? And then the next part is management
- 13:07feeds, Right, those experts charge a lot of money to do that,
- 13:11whereas you know, our fees are like effectively they're transparent, right, we
- 13:16don't charge those kind of ongoing feeds generally for sure. Yeah, that's definitely
- 13:22one part of the traditional markets is it's you know, blockchain, you're lowering
- 13:26the fees not just on the transaction costs, but just like holding your own
- 13:28assets and being able to understand how much something costs. There's a lot of
- 13:35benefit that I think traditional investors have yet to realize or see those benefits because
- 13:39they need to get into it deeper. I feel like maybe twenty twenty four
- 13:43is the year that we see an explosion in real world assets moving into the
- 13:48portfolios of not just crypto lovers, but traditional investors as well. And we
- 13:54saw the huge news this week with black Rock and other entities moving into real
- 13:58world asset space. Can you talk about that news, maybe elaborate and what
- 14:03that could mean for tokenization being adopted. Yeah, so I think what you
- 14:11know, like that to us is sort of like the icing on the cake
- 14:15of a trend that we've been seeing over a long time. So you know,
- 14:18when we saw, as I said, with private blockchains and this kind
- 14:20of thing, what we saw that companies wanted to tokenize was like real items,
- 14:26whether to track it and move it, and you know that's something that's
- 14:30really important for them, right. So a lot of the things we did,
- 14:33like we trucked agricultural products, we tracked you know, oil and energy
- 14:37products, we tracked all these kind of like mining kind of not like crypto
- 14:43mining, but like physical mining, you know, resources kind of thing.
- 14:46And we saw that there's a huge amount of value when you digitize something and
- 14:52understand the kind of ownership, understand where it came from, right, And
- 14:56now I think people are kind of catching on to the thing is that that
- 15:03doesn't have to only be used by large companies. That can be used by
- 15:07individuals to make their buying decisions. And I think this is you know why
- 15:11black Rock is moving into that, right, Like they're seeing that for financial
- 15:15instruments, this is something that's important. Right, We've already seen, like
- 15:20I said, this happen in the commodity spaces and other eras. But this
- 15:24is giving us an opportunity to move sort of i liquid assets into this.
- 15:28And there are so many ill liquid assets in the world, Like the majority
- 15:31of assets are illiquid, right if you think about things like the stock market,
- 15:35that's just a small part of what is available in the entire world that
- 15:41we could potentially tokenize. And I think Blackrock is waking up to that too.
- 15:46Yeah, No, it's incredible. The opportunities are sort of endless,
- 15:50you know, even just personal items, everything you own could be tokenized and
- 15:56then there'll be a stock market tokenization market for that, so to say,
- 16:00which will be crazy, and I think people will look back at the stock
- 16:03market and see they'll realize that it was crazy to see how inefficient and slow
- 16:10and higher cost it was than when blockchains, you know, adoptions becomes mainstream.
- 16:15Maybe it takes a few years or five or a decade or a few
- 16:18decades to get everything on, but I feel like it starts slow and then
- 16:23it moves up a lot quicker. And you know, discussion around tokenization,
- 16:30especially of real estate and metals and commodities, has been around, but it's
- 16:33just lowering the other barriers to entry, whether it's understanding blockchain technology or the
- 16:40user experience, or actually getting the old world transition to the new world.
- 16:45There's all these barriers. So do you think that that is you know,
- 16:51is there It's hard to put a time frame on it, but is there
- 16:53a time frame in when we start seeing capital more capital than before moving into
- 16:59the space. Yeah, so I really think. I mean, being around
- 17:03as long as I have, you can see these waves. Right. So
- 17:07you saw the launch of the theorem, and then you know it he would
- 17:11study for a really long time, and then you had the ICO group,
- 17:15and then you know, another crypto winter. Then you saw the NFT group,
- 17:19right, and then another crypto winter and then, So what I think
- 17:23is driving the kind of activity now is really the kind of realization that blockchain
- 17:32can be used for things that are effectively asset back tokens, right, people,
- 17:38you know, the one question when I talk to non crypto natives about
- 17:44tokens, they always say, well, what am I actually buying? Like,
- 17:45what's behind this thing? Right? And unfortunately, you know, like
- 17:51I definitely understand blockchain as well as anyone, but like you know, at
- 17:55the end of the day, I have to say, well, it's network,
- 17:56computational power or math or some answer like that. That's not a satisfying
- 18:02answer to most people. So I think ultimately what needs to happen, and
- 18:07what companies like ourselves and what companies like Blackrock are really saying, is that
- 18:11what we need to do is find things that people want to buy, regardless
- 18:17of whether they're on the blockchain or not. Right, And if we can
- 18:19do that, if we can make that, then you know, we don't
- 18:23have to lead with blockchain. We can kind of go for it. And
- 18:26I really think we're moving into the next era of what I would call the
- 18:32RWA, right, Like, all of these things are kind of moving in
- 18:34this direction, and they're going to be acid back stable coins of all kinds
- 18:38of structs and varieties. It's a great explanation, Victor. And yeah,
- 18:44when I also try to explain blockchain, because it's a new asset class and
- 18:48it can't really be defined from traditional economic explanations. It's hard to explain because
- 18:56you can't just go back to an old textbook and read that's that's completely new.
- 19:00And I like what you said there about buying an asset that's on the
- 19:07blockchain. As long as they don't have to understand the blockchain and they don't
- 19:11know, they don't need to know the underlying technology. I feel like,
- 19:15because it's more novel people, they get interested, but then it gets confusing
- 19:19and then they're like, ah, whatever. But traditional applications or even on
- 19:22your banking application, people don't care what's the underlying technology. They don't need
- 19:26to know, you know, what was the coding language that made their banking
- 19:30app safe. They just they just trust it. They just use it because
- 19:33it's been around, and I feel like, yeah, it's going to take
- 19:37some time, you know, Like that's why the irony is of the blockchain
- 19:40space. I mean, I'm a technologist that you know, I've started multiple
- 19:44at tech companies, and like, I think one of the things is that
- 19:48one of the things that attracted to us to this industry is that it's about
- 19:55you know, that blockchain could provide better security and trust than other techno ology
- 20:00is available. But you know, to the most of the regular world,
- 20:03blockchains have been synonymous with fraud and scams, so there's there's kind of disconnect
- 20:08and use the banking example that I think that banking example is perfectly right.
- 20:12You'll think about the database that the bank uses. You know, you don't
- 20:17think about, for example, the transaction fees of Amazon charges, right,
- 20:22like you don't think about these things. What you think about is can I
- 20:26like, are they offering me something that I can get access to and and
- 20:32can I trust that they actually have that thing? And you know, like
- 20:36I think that's something that we haven't been focused on in the blockchain space enough,
- 20:41and that's really why we kind of took it upon ourselves to kind of
- 20:45focus really on that problem. Mm hmm. Yeah, it's a great focus.
- 20:49And Victor, if I went to the marketplace for block apps and maybe
- 20:56you can just explain, you know, as we've sort of danced around it,
- 21:00I want to go there, and I don't want to have to learn
- 21:02about blockchain. I'm personally curious on how it works, but understanding the user
- 21:06experience in making it as easy as possible or similar to what they've known in
- 21:11the past to be able to buy metals and understand the benefits of tokenization without
- 21:15having to go through a blockchain one on one course, Yeah, how would
- 21:18I go to the marketplace and get that done fast and easy? Yeah?
- 21:23So, and to be clear, like you know, for example, tomorrow
- 21:27we're launching you know, carbon nutrols silver that's both going to be on the
- 21:32public etherem blockchain and our marketplace, so you know, we provide interfaces for
- 21:36both, right, but on you know, like we think that the experience
- 21:41on ethererem and level two s for djms have improved dramatically, so people know
- 21:47how to use metamasks buy something, and you can do that with the assets
- 21:51we're offering too. You know, it's starting tomorrow our first of that kind
- 21:53of acid classes. You know, we're selling a carbon neutral silver token and
- 22:00that's going to be available you can buy it directly on the public etherem.
- 22:03Now what the marketplace was meant to do was really provide that what I would
- 22:07call web two point five experience for non blockchain users. Right, So,
- 22:12like think about, okay, how do I create an identity, how do
- 22:15I pay? Can I pay in a credit card? How do I you
- 22:18know, under the hood or you know, everything you buy is effectively we're
- 22:23tokenizing it. That's all there and all the technology is there, but we
- 22:27kind of wanted to hide that on the marketplace. So that's we want to
- 22:32make it very very easy for that kind of normal user to kind of be
- 22:36able to buy and look at what they own and that kind of stuff,
- 22:38and that entire process is evolving too, but you know that that's really what
- 22:44we focus on. Creating identity, buy with a credit card, be able
- 22:48to see what I own with that identity, you know. And in many
- 22:52ways it looks almost like a normal website, but under the hood, it's
- 22:56all you know, blockchain derived technology. Yeah, it's really cool. It's
- 23:00a normal website, but it's actually powered by the technology of the future of
- 23:03that, right exactly. And as people get more comfortable, we're moving more
- 23:07and you know, we kind of want to move them more and more in
- 23:11a blockchainy direction, right, So we're going to make it feel you know,
- 23:15even in our next release coming up, it's going to feel more like
- 23:18an NFT marketplace, like. But you know that the average user we're going
- 23:22after, which is sort of the more late, more like early mainstream kind
- 23:27of vieuwser really you know, like it's still too overwhelming for a lot of
- 23:33people. And if we're going to reach our goal of getting more people on
- 23:37the blockchain and bringing more of the mainstream, we have to kind of meet
- 23:40them where they are today. No, I know that there are millions of
- 23:45new people that are getting crypto wallets and getting familiar with it, but it's
- 23:49also great to have that web two point five experience and sometimes you just want
- 23:53to use your credit card or just you know, build a web throughout yea,
- 23:56so exactly, you know, like and like we want to be able
- 24:00to kind of use all the benefit of crypto, but you know, make
- 24:03it easier. And it's funny because when I started, all the problems that
- 24:08we were talking about, well really technology problems, right, like we had
- 24:14to solve scalability, we had to you know solve start to create standards like
- 24:19and a lot of those poor technical problems are resolved now or you know,
- 24:26there are huge amounts of people working on them, which is great, but
- 24:30you know, getting that normal person interested in you know, I love all
- 24:36the developed technical developments, you know, the works that are being done on
- 24:40zero knowledge proofs, the works being done on you know, scaling and layer
- 24:44twos and now layer three's. All of that is super exciting to me personally.
- 24:48But you know, for my non crypto friends, I have to have
- 24:52something for them that will get them interested. And what really gets some interested
- 24:56is like, hey, have you ever thought about buying this really interesting thing
- 25:00like silver or you know some metal you never thought of and would you like
- 25:04to And a lot of that's so we're like yes, And so blockchain to
- 25:08them is just a means to an end, well said Victor. And if
- 25:15people want to learn more about where wild assets or how block apps is tokenizing
- 25:19them, or try out the marketplace and buy the carbon neutral silver that's that's
- 25:23coming out and follow along for as more types of assets get tokenized. Is
- 25:30there a best place to go to to learn that or to get started.
- 25:33Yeah, you know, they can come to our website block apps dot that,
- 25:38they can follow us on Twitter at block apps. And if you're particularly
- 25:42interested in buying, you know, the public if theorem carbon neutral silver,
- 25:48you can go to CNS dot block apps dot very cool. I can leave
- 25:52those links in the show notes below as well. I appreciate your insights,
- 25:55Victor into where old assets with this news this week with Blackrock, I feel
- 26:00like we're on the cost of something huge and more people are going to be
- 26:03looking for different RWA alternatives, and I feel like this is something that's coming
- 26:08at the perfect time. So thank you so much for coming on today and
- 26:11all the best with block caps moving forward. Thank you, Ashton, it's
- 26:15been great talking to you.