Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / 5G4D News Flash-Black Beard w Volko Ruhnke
Transcript
- 0:00Freshly Doug from the cold face of the board game world. We bring you
- 0:06five games for Doomsday. So I'm delighted to have on this news Flash the
- 0:15designer inventor of the Coin series and many other games, and also the designer
- 0:21of the current game on Kickstarter, the Hunt for black Beard, Folko Runka
- 0:25Falco. Welcome to the new Flash, Well to news Thank you for having
- 0:30me back on your show. So I interviewed you probably a couple of years
- 0:35ago now, and you were talking about this game at that time. Even
- 0:40then and so, and as far as I know, it was with another
- 0:44publisher at this time. So can you give us kind of the history of
- 0:47the development of Hunt for black Beard and it's sort of its journey to ending
- 0:51up with Ford Circle. Yeah, I mean, and I will give you
- 0:54that. I guess the news Flash shortened version because there's a long and winding
- 0:59journey. I had done in my day job training intelligence aunts. I had
- 1:04done a game about hunting fugitives for the classroom, and I thought I could
- 1:08apply some of the lessons learned from that design to some famous historical case and
- 1:17pirate hunting certainly appealed, and the story of Blackbeard's Last Days in North Carolina
- 1:22in seventeen eighteen had all these elements of man hunting methodology that I wanted to
- 1:30show on the tabletop. So my original idea was I could maybe get the
- 1:34game at least to the printers by the three hundredth anniversary of Blackbeard's Demise,
- 1:40which was near the end of seventeen eighteen, So twenty eighteen. Thats how
- 1:44long this game has been in development. In the end, it did not
- 1:49fare well with GMT games pre order system for a variety of reasons, but
- 1:53it was a good thing because the market was telling us something. Because I
- 1:57ended up revising the game quite substantially, including the components that would be necessary
- 2:06to a much I think, smoother and less awkward system. And we worked
- 2:13for a while to see whether we could come up with a solitaire game that
- 2:15was good enough, and I had designs for solitaire, but I was not
- 2:21satisfied with the experience, nor were the playtesters. So it sat for a
- 2:27while while we thought about what to do, until finally I offered Kevin Bertram
- 2:34of Fort Circle whether he might be interested in the design, even if it
- 2:38does not have a solitary system. It's a it is right now in design
- 2:42a purely two player game, and Kevin was willing to go forward with that
- 2:46and it fit his line he thought of games. He already had one pirate
- 2:52game, you know, about the Barbary Pirates. So now we are on
- 2:58Kickstarter with Fort Circle. So tell us before we get into the game itself,
- 3:04because I remember listening to a podcast telling the story of black Beard and
- 3:08it is incredible. So can you give us a pracie of his last days
- 3:13in the States and why you found this particular story so interesting? Yes.
- 3:19So he had a short but very successful career. He actually commanded a small
- 3:29flotilla of pirate ships at several hundred crewmen and several ships, and they went
- 3:36on quite the I don't know, escapade across the Caribbean. Turned came up
- 3:44to Florida because it was a popular thing to do in the day to prospect
- 3:47a sunk Spanish galleon off the coast of Florida, but didn't find much and
- 3:53kept heading north until he arrived at North Carolina. And then it gets controversial.
- 4:00What happens is on his way into North Carolina, at a place called
- 4:03Old Topsail Inlet, most of his ships. Two of the ships ran aground
- 4:13and were wrecked, and he sent off one of his pirate captain comrades to
- 4:19go see the Governor of North Carolina. And meanwhile he himself absconded with just
- 4:25his most picked men on a small sloop called Adventure and most of the loot
- 4:31and money that they had, and maroon the rest of his flotilla's crew.
- 4:38And then his friend Steve Bonnet returned. He was gone, Blackbird was gone.
- 4:44And Blackbird himself sailed further north to the colonial capital at Bathtown, and
- 4:49there pursued and accepted a pardon because there were royal pardons on offer in that
- 4:57time as part of the war on the piate Ritz to kind of turn them
- 5:00away from that UH, and Governor even of North Carolina provided that, and
- 5:06then Blackbeard camped on okra Coke Island and frequented bath Town. And the problem
- 5:13was, there are a number of problems with this, this pardon UH,
- 5:16and with North Carolina UH basically harboring black Beard. Well, one problem was
- 5:21black Beard kept up his piracy and UH took a prize from the from the
- 5:29French and some and some other depredations. And at this time, so it
- 5:35starts to get really complicated. So I need to kind of cut to the
- 5:38chase. Here in Virginia, the Lieutenant Governor Spotswood is a rival of North
- 5:43Carolina and that governor and there's a Royal Navy uh station there to frigate sized
- 5:48ships, and Spotswood decides we're not going to have Blackbeard hanging out next door
- 5:54in North Carolina. Uh. He bankrolled uh the Royal Navy uh uh uh
- 6:00putting an expedition together to go down and capture the pirate. And at this
- 6:04time what's happening is spots Would in Virginia is gathering all kinds of information about
- 6:12what's going on in North Carolina because it's not his purview, and so he
- 6:16really has to use spies and informants and that kind of thing to figure out
- 6:19what's going on there. Since Governor Eden and other apparent friends of BlackBerry in
- 6:24North Carolina are in effect protecting the pirate or former pirate, depending on your
- 6:29point of view, and so there's a lot of intelligence work going on.
- 6:34This is a reason why among many that the story was interesting to me from
- 6:40a manhunting perspective, and that expedition by the Navy from Virginia heads down,
- 6:46but actually there's also an overland component. Navy Captain brand goes overland into North
- 6:53Carolina, considered, I think by most Assorians to be an illegal expedition because
- 6:59the Royal Navy and the Royal Colony of Virginia don't really have the writ to
- 7:04go enforcing the law in a proprietary colony of North Carolina. So the colonial
- 7:10politics are very juicy in all of this story. Regardless, their information was
- 7:15quite good about what Blackbeard was up to and where he would be, and
- 7:19they do indeed encounter him, and they fight a battle on the water off
- 7:24of okra Coke Island, the Battle of Ocracoke in November seventeen, eighteen November
- 7:30by the calendar of the day it would now be in early December, in
- 7:32which Blackbeard is killed as quite a close run and sharp and bloody little battle
- 7:45between blackbeard sloop and two Royal Navy commandeered sloops. And the rest of Blackbeard's
- 7:50crew is arrested and brought up to Williamsburg in Virginia for trial. And so
- 7:59how did you try unslated this story of Blackbeard then into a game, so
- 8:05an aspect of h figuring out how to get at a well prepared, clever,
- 8:15and protected target, like let's say, an effective pirate. Uh.
- 8:20An aspect of that is where where you know? Where do you think the
- 8:26target is going to be? Where do you think the pirate is headed?
- 8:28Where you know, where can you go to intercept or disrupt them? And
- 8:33a lot of that has to do with what do you what does that person
- 8:37want? And so in the game, the black Beard player has a lot
- 8:43of decisions to make, but a kind of central and secret decision is do
- 8:48you want to continue being a pirate or do you want to rejoin decent society
- 8:52and live a good life in North Carolina? Because Blackbeards seem to equivocate between
- 8:58these two few objectives, and where you go to achieve those objectives geographically is
- 9:05different, and how much money those objectives cost you or how much you can
- 9:09earn is different. And so that is sort of a great I mean,
- 9:16it's a great kind of a player strategy fork in the road that in this
- 9:22case happens secretly behind the screen, but the other player, the hunters,
- 9:26are trying to discern that to and if they get that information to kind of
- 9:33forecast, where to look, where Blackbeard might show up, and how well
- 9:37prepared he will be for battle, and so all that I think translates into
- 9:43a two player game very well. And so Full Circle are interesting as a
- 9:48publisher because they do historical games, but they don't have as much rules overhead
- 9:58as a game that you would assume would be published by someone like GMT for
- 10:01instance. And I recently played pen Dragon. Yes, the coin game wonderful
- 10:09game, but for someone who's primary a Eurogamer, there's a lot of rules
- 10:13there. When we look at the Hunt for black Beard, how does it
- 10:18fit in with thought circles ethos of sort of accessible entry level wargames in terms
- 10:26of its weight Yes, so to some degree. Time will tell in terms
- 10:31of how difficult or weighty h players will find Hunt for black Beard to handle.
- 10:37I suspect it somewhere in the middle of those two points. It is
- 10:43certainly the fastest playing game that I have have ever designed, and I hope
- 10:50it is also at the same time the most the most accessible. That said,
- 10:56I suspect that players will find Hunt for black Beer somewhat more intricate than
- 11:03say, Shores of Tripoli, and an aspect of it that I've worked hard
- 11:09to try to support with materials in the box to help you learn to play.
- 11:16An aspect of it that may be more challenging than the other Fort Circle
- 11:20games is that quite a lot of the action, at least initially, is
- 11:26happening in secret. You know, Blackbeard is planning piracy with tiles and ponds
- 11:35and cubes behind a screen. The pirate moves around the map by means of
- 11:41hidden blocks that the Hunter's player then is inspecting, and often inspecting secretly.
- 11:48That is, when the Hunter's player looks somewhere by virtue of an informant,
- 11:52the black Beard player doesn't get to see where that is either, and the
- 11:56Hunter's player, behind another screen is preparing their expedition into North Carolina. So
- 12:01so that makes it a little harder to learn, because if you have so
- 12:05much happening that that that you are responsible for as an individual player, it's
- 12:09hard to help another player do that right until you've kind of seen everything work.
- 12:13So I have. So there's a quite uh uh. I wouldn't say
- 12:20elaborate, but but uh, you know, more elaborate than typical for me.
- 12:24Perhaps learn to Play. There's separate learn to Play booklet that takes you
- 12:28through a whole game and even a teaching guide so that if you you know,
- 12:31are you know, you feel like you've learned the game. But how
- 12:35do you you get your friend you know, to learn how to play?
- 12:37Then there's a there's even ideas for how to do that in a structured way.
- 12:43And so why then, because I've as I say, I've I've played
- 12:46coin games and they are for a year a game that the reason be heavy?
- 12:50Why did this game turn out to be as far as you're considered relatively
- 12:56light? For you? Uh, it was really an an aim point,
- 13:01So I have my I mean, it's a matter of taste, how much
- 13:07intricacy and how much fidelity you attempt to put into a historical game, right,
- 13:13they have the range that you've just described, and that's really a design
- 13:16aim point. No matter what, it doesn't matter. It could be a
- 13:20game that takes one hundred hours to play and a you know, uh you
- 13:24know, fills a full dining room table and then some and has several thousand
- 13:28pieces. It's still a simplification of history, of course, so you're always
- 13:33simplifying to make something into a tabletop game. That's inevitable and the question really
- 13:39is not whether to simplify. The question is how much am I simplifying what?
- 13:45And some of that has to do should have to do with what is
- 13:48the focus the hunt for Blackbeard? The focus is on the hunt. There
- 13:52are combat rules in it, but the combat rules are for me extremely simplified,
- 13:58because it's not the main point of the game. The main point is
- 14:03preparing, you know, for that combat and making it happen or avoiding it,
- 14:05depending on which player you are. So so I set out to make
- 14:13a game that would typically be completed in forty five minutes of play, that
- 14:18the the the and how much history and how much how many difficult decisions and
- 14:24dilemmas can I pack into that? And for me, that's on the shorter,
- 14:31smaller, simpler side of my usual kind of design zone, if you
- 14:35will, and I think still ends up perhaps on the higher side of the
- 14:41scale for for fort circles lineup. And so you said that you won't need
- 14:46to sort of model techniques that you used in your in your day job.
- 14:52So without breaking the Official Secrets Act, what what elements of sort of in
- 15:00telligens and man hunting are in the game that you took from you know,
- 15:03working in the Secret Service. So yeah, so I'll give you a couple
- 15:09a couple examples. So one I had already mentioned was this idea of gathering
- 15:15information and considering what does your target want to be able to forecast, you
- 15:20know, where they might be in in what situation. I had done,
- 15:24as I mentioned, a game for the for the Service, as you put
- 15:31it as a training game, as a co design actually with a specialist in
- 15:35this and it was about the modern day Mexican hunt for Al Chapo, the
- 15:41drug lord. And if you read about that man hunt, a really important
- 15:48part of it was to what degree did this drug lord want to run his
- 15:54drug empire? And to what degree was he worried about his family, his
- 15:58daughters, his ex wives and this sort of thing. And the fact was
- 16:03he was very focused on that second aspect family and that that was an important
- 16:08way that the Mexican authorities were able to keep tabs on him and ultimately figure
- 16:14out where he was going to be when. So it's it's actually a very
- 16:18similar story with Blackbeard and what he was, you know, what he was
- 16:22actually after in North North Carolina and trying to discern that through information gathering,
- 16:30through informants through spies. So that's one aspect. Another aspect is distinguishing between
- 16:37what we might call strategic intelligence and tactical intelligence. And in the game,
- 16:42the Hunter's player, the Royal Navy Spotswood in Virginia essentially will have a variety
- 16:49of informants, enemies of black Beard or enemies of Blackbeard's friends in North Carolina
- 16:55that they can use to in effect spy, to secretly collect information on Blackbeard's
- 17:00whereabouts. That's great because now the Hunter's player, by that means can know
- 17:07something about black Beard that the black Beard player doesn't know the Hunter's player knows.
- 17:12So that's really important that that you're not tipping your hand as the hunter,
- 17:19and that you can set set a trap or that you can act on
- 17:22information but leave the fugitive the target at ease. Okay. On the other
- 17:30hand, that would be called strate tag intelligence. But the downside of that
- 17:33is it's typically older information, at least typically in pastimes like in the eighteenth
- 17:40century. So in the game, when you as a Hunter's player, when
- 17:45you when you secretly spot where black Beard is using informant, that's actually not
- 17:49where black Beard is. It's actually where black Beard was a turn before.
- 17:55Very helpful, but not as helpful as if you have your forces right on
- 17:59the scene, you're your sloops or your navy captain on land, and they
- 18:06scout or they investigate a location in North Carolina, They're going to get really
- 18:11up to the information. Either they're going to see that black Beard is there
- 18:12or they're going to see that black Beard is not there, and they'll be
- 18:15able to act on that right away if they find it. So that's tactical
- 18:18information, but it's very much in the open. If the Royal Navy is
- 18:23sailing around North Carolina, you know people are going to see that and they're
- 18:26going to let their friend black Beard know. So that the way that strategic
- 18:30and tactical intelligence inter relate is a very big part of gameplay and hunt for
- 18:37Blackbeard. So just to get towards wrapping up, then I'm already sold on
- 18:42this love I love pirates, I love the story of Blackbeards. So I'm
- 18:49not someone who needs convincing. But there may be people listening to this who
- 18:55might think this sounds incredibly interesting, but a sort of still on the fence.
- 18:59What would you say to them to convince them that this might be a
- 19:02game they'd like to try. So I would say that, you know,
- 19:07if you're interested in Pirates, this is as you mentioned from Fort Circle,
- 19:15it is a historical game. This isn't about treasure island adventure stereotypes. This
- 19:22is researched and the best that I could do putting together the general view of
- 19:29historians. And there's a lot of controversy, but I'm trying to take them
- 19:32all into account of how things really went down in North Carolina in seventeen eighteen
- 19:37and what you know, pirate hunting, how it worked and what it was
- 19:41about. So there are a lot of games that are kind of fictionalized fantasy,
- 19:47and there are a lot of fun This is history, and Fort Circle
- 19:51allows us to put a lot of historical supplementary material in the box, so
- 19:56you get quite a bit in there to explore and back up the history.
- 20:03If you're into historical games and the concern is, well, you know,
- 20:07Blackbeard is that sort of a you know, Walt Disney movie kind of a
- 20:11thing. Again, rest assured. I've done my very best to reflect the
- 20:18history as accurately as historians have been able to discern it. So just to
- 20:25wrap up, then, what are the vital statistics, how much does it
- 20:27cost, how long does it take to play, and when can we expect
- 20:32to have it in our hands. So I understand that the Kickstarter contribution asked
- 20:37is seventy dollars and the Kickstarter will run for the next month or so.
- 20:42There is some final artwork left to be done. You're seeing prototype art.
- 20:48You know, you'll see a very good, getting very good idea of what
- 20:51it's going to look like, but there are still some things that need to
- 20:53be let's say, tuned and completed in terms of the art. And my
- 20:57understanding is that Kevin bertram A fort Circle is aiming to have it available before
- 21:03the end of the year. It's two players and it will play once you
- 21:08know how to play the game forty five minutes or less, I would say,
- 21:12and if things go very badly for black Beard, it might be even
- 21:15a lot shorter than that. So quite quite doable in a sitting to you
- 21:23know, play either side once, or play and see if you're you can
- 21:26do better the next time, play again, and so forth. Excellent.
- 21:30Well for Kurunka, thank you very much, Thanks Ben Pleasure. You can
- 21:33support the show by going to Patreon dot com. Forward Slash five. Thank
- 21:40you for listening.