Latest / Braver New Worlds / Reimagining Capitalism, Business Ownership, and the Next Economy - Abraham Chen of B Local San Diego
Transcript
- Nathan: Hello and welcome back to Braver New Worlds, a podcast about the stories we need to tell for the future we want to see. My name is Nathan Young. I am your host. And today we're talking about something that touches almost every part of our lives, but that we don't always think of something that we can change or redesign. And that's that's the big macroeconomy of our world. My guest is Abraham Chen. He is the executive director of B Local San Diego, an organization working to rethink the role of business and help build the economy that benefits more than just. individual shareholders of different companies, but actually benefits communities and workers and people and planet and the larger field of stakeholders with relationship to the company. this is an interesting discussion for me because frankly I guess I've always been a little bit skeptical of the B Corp movement. I lumped it in the with the whole idea of like conscious capitalism and still like sort of struggle with the idea that it really is, you know, beholding on individual people with some power and authority to make a decision to to operate this way. there's some validity to the critiques I have here, there's also a lot that I didn't realize about The way the B Corp movement actually is like laying a foundation for this reimagining of the way economies are run and the way businesses are run. And one of the things I didn't realize is just like how fucked up our current system of capitalism really is. Like, yeah, there's the greed and the corruption and the disregard for people and planet, but I also learned, you know, from this conversation, and Abraham was going to tell us a little more about it, is that that behavior has essentially been codified into law. Like private equity firms are essentially required by legal bylaws under which they were created to behave this way. And we discussed that in the conversation. That's pretty profound effect on how we live and how businesses operate. And this is really part of like the big shift that B Corps can help help make happen. And we also get into some of these big questions about community and meaningful work and AI and what we're supposed to do with the limited time we have on this planet. and yeah, if we really want to spend that time working for the sake of working, or if there is a higher level cause and way we can be operating that we can devote ourselves to and how to make all that happen. So you're looking for purpose, you're feeling like the current economic system is a sham, wondering what if business doesn't have to work the way we've simply assumed it has to work, this episode is for you. So let's get into it. Nathan Young: Abraham Chen, welcome to the podcast. Abraham Chen: Hey, pleasure to be here. Nathan Young: So As I like to start all these off, just introduce yourself to the audience who they know who you are. Abraham Chen: Yeah, absolutely. So my name's Abraham, as Nathan has so kindly introduced, and I'm the executive director of BLocal San Diego. We're a 501c3 here in San Diego focused on economic systems change. And we do that through the B Corp certification which the B Corp certification, for those who don't know, is the most rigorous standard out there that's third party verified for for-profits measurement on their social impact and how they treat people and the planet. It's extremely wide ranging, it's global in nature. And so there's ten thousand certified B Corps in the world and the movement's about twenty years old. Actually, they're celebrating twenty years old this year. Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: Okay, cool. yeah, tell us about this because I think a lot of people have might be like heard of B Corpse and people listening to this podcast are probably like sort of vaguely aware of it, but they haven't looked into it further yet. So I mean, for somebody that might be interested in it, maybe the question I ask is like why B Corps? Why is this B Corp certification? I'll say the current gold standard because I know it's got some imperfections too. But like what's so good about it for the situation in the world we're in right now? Abraham Chen: Yeah, totally. So B Corp certification, I mean B Corp is some folks may have seen it. It's the B with a circle around it and you'll see that on products when you're in the grocery stores. But actually it applies to any type of for profit company. And essentially why does it matter? Well, if you think about the form of capitalism that we're in today, it's really heavily focused on extraction and returning value to its shareholders only. what we call shareholder capitalism. May for folks who've been to business school or been around business, they may have heard about Milton Friedman in the nineteen fifties, really famous, right, for declaring that the sole purpose of business was to return value to shareholders. And, you know, as we survey the landscape of the society we're in, we we start to see the effects of that, right? Really dramatic Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: extraction of natural resources and all these subtle and not so subtle ways in which we have become kind of lulled to sleep in a way, of this business as usual type of perspective on how things work. We're like, company laying off thousands of workers on a whim. That's just business as usual. You know, like yes. Yeah. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Right? Yeah. Well, I think that's an interesting point. And I think a lot of times we we sort of have accepted that business we don't like it and we've sort of accepted 'cause it doesn't feel like there's an alternative. And so Abraham Chen: Yeah. Nathan Young: it's part of the case that like B Corps are the alternative. Abraham Chen: Yeah, I think but part of it is that we've lied been lied to there is no alternative and that this is how it's always been. The form of capitalism we're in really came around like forty years ago in the nineteen eighties, in terms of dramatic financialization, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: right? Everything was about ROI and about the balance sheet. And the way that everything is structured really started to take off in about 40 years ago. So to your point, if you Look at the history of business. It's been far longer that companies have existed to benefit the community. In fact, if you look in the eighteen hundreds, you actually weren't allowed to form a business unless you could prove that it would be of a benefit to society. you literally wouldn't be allowed to form that business. And there were all these powerful antitrust and laws as well to make sure that businesses didn't grow too big to the point where they could just extract as as they wanted to. Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: So to your point, yeah, what are the alternatives? And today B Corp is really what's leading the way. And so B Corp certification, kind of to dive into it, may I talk a little bit about the history of the B Corp certification? So do you remember, Nathan, in the 1990s? Nathan Young: Yeah yeah of course. Yeah, do it. Yeah. Abraham Chen: there was Nike, who was kind of like the big basketball apparel company, Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: and then there was this one company called And One. They had like that nameless Nathan Young: Mm. Abraham Chen: face. is this like a deep cut for you? Nathan Young: Yeah, I don't remember and one. I I thought you were gonna say rebox, so Abraham Chen: No, no, and one, the big like oversized basketball shorts and like they had all these street ball mixtapes. There's a whole thing. Yeah. Nathan Young: okay, okay. I prop I feel like I recognize the look you're describing, but I wouldn't have known that was the name of the brand per se. Abraham Chen: Well, so they were challenging at the time, challenging Nike for the number two spot in basketball apparel across the whole globe. and essentially the founders had created this company. They didn't even like s necessarily set out to do this, but they were treating the workers really well. They had really strong practices in terms of employee gives back programs, kind of trying to model a company that could be really good. Well, they decided at some point that they were gonna exit the business. And what they learned was that they have This thing called fiduciary duty. I don't know. it's very lawyery term. Have you heard of this fiduciary duty? Ha ha ha yeah, that's true. So Nathan Young: I mean I heard it from Sam the other week, so yeah. Abraham Chen: essentially, in our economic system, you must sell to the highest bidder or risk being ousted by your board or being sued by your shareholders for not maximizing Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: their profit. That is actually codified into law. And so Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: What they found out when they were selling And One was that they had to sell it to the highest bidder. They are forced to do so. And after they did, that company tore out all of their commitments and fired a bunch of workers within the first year. And lo and behold, less than three years later, And One was being sold for parts, and we don't even know about the company anymore today. So that's a backdrop. Well, Nathan Young: Wow. Yeah. Abraham Chen: the founders of that company looked in, they're like, how is this the reality of how business Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: works today? And they decided to try to do something about it. And that was 2006, and that was how B Lab was formed. So that's a nonprofit Nathan Young: wow. Abraham Chen: that actually creates the B Corp certification and manages it. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Abraham Chen: their thesis is that can we codify the performance of a business into how they operate, into their governance system, into real hard paper paperwork that shows that they're actually treating their workers right. Have that all embedded into a stamp that creates more trust with the consumers, with their suppliers, with anybody who touches the business, and carries that into the long term. So they also came Nathan Young: Yeah, okay. Abraham Chen: up with this legal structure called benefit corporations, which help you change. I mean, talk about governance as a word that makes people fall asleep, right? But but when Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: you connect it to how this whole system works, you're like, my gosh, this actually really matters. The benefit corporation law. allows you to protect your company by putting into its bylaws that the company serves a higher purpose and mission than just its shareholders. And so that way you can actually protect yourself from that fiduci fiduciary duty that we're talking. Nathan Young: Yeah. Okay, it's so interesting because okay, just that example you give there, what's it the company called? And one? Is that what it's called? An one okay. Like spell that out. And one like what Abraham Chen: Yeah, that's what it was called. A and D and then the number one. Yeah. And people really enjoy seeing Nathan Young: okay, and one. Okay, got it. Okay, I think it Abraham Chen: like the mixtapes and the there's a documentary about it too, the rise and fall of N1. Yeah. Nathan Young: Okay. Sounds a little bit more familiar. So 'cause that's an interesting example because yeah, it is like, okay, there's this company that existed and yeah, it was creating this product that people liked, it was employing all these people, everything was going good. And then Abraham Chen: Yeah. Yeah. Nathan Young: yeah, the people that were the shareholders, quote unquote the shareholders, realized like, well, it might be benefiting all these people, but our benefit would be like if we just you know, sold it for parts. And and so rather than hundreds or thousands of people or however many people it might have employed at like presumably a wage that was like they're making a living off and paying their bills, it just sort of put some money in a couple of people's pockets, basically. Yeah. Abraham Chen: That's right. Yes. And what is really creepy about all of this is that this is actually the rule, not the exception. If you start to study our business system closer and closer, you Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Abraham Chen: start to realize this pattern just keeps happening over and over again. If you first see a brand you like Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: and it sells off to private equity, you see the Reddit threads about a company or a brand, immediately like, it's over. Everyone just like Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, totally. Abraham Chen: is we just know and we just assume that's just how it works. I mean Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: Think about a good example close to home is the brewery industry in San Diego, right? Ballast Point. I used to love Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Yeah. Abraham Chen: going there in college, like you know, after I turned 21. And so right, Nathan Young: Ha ha ha. Abraham Chen: they would have these cool things that would release new beers, it'd be like victory at sea days, you remember like with the stouts Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: and porters. And when they sold off to Constellation, everyone's like, my gosh. And it doesn't happen immediately either. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: It's like all these shareholders they just come in and they're like, okay, let's like how do we take all this trust that this company banked with the community Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: and its customers and figure out where the value is and extract that. And now, that goes fireworks. That I am not a fan of extraction for the record. yeah, you'll clip that for the blooper reel. but essentially, Nathan Young: Mm. Mm-hmm. Toilet, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that's hilarious. Abraham Chen: yeah, take all of that and now when we look at ballast point, I mean They just sold off their main brewing facilities. I think Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: they're about to get sold by Constellation for parts. And the brand is a shell of itself. by the way, if we were even entertaining this idea of shareholder value, that's actually awful shareholder value, if you think about it. I mean the company's gone now. Like, Nathan Young: okay. What yeah. Abraham Chen: that's terrible long-term shareholder value. Right? Nathan Young: I would that's what I would think, but it sounds like, you know, for whatever reason, like they're they're able to make the case that like just the money in our pockets right now is more valuable, like yeah, then yeah, Abraham Chen: Right now. Yeah. Short term greed. Nathan Young: yeah. And I mean, are they partly like making the case of like, this company's kind of on the decline, so we might as well cash out now? Is that part of the case they're making or or is it even who knows? Abraham Chen: Typically they are buying these companies at the height of their success and cashing those things in. you'll even see really awful cases, very common, for larger private equity firms to saddle really successful companies that they require with huge amounts of debt that they've collected as an organization and then drag Nathan Young: yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Abraham Chen: that whole company down. That happens over and over. I'm telling you, it's Nathan Young: Yeah, I've seen that case. Abraham Chen: a it's like a really weird horror movie once you start to see it play out. And somehow Nathan Young: totally. What Abraham Chen: we're like, yeah, that's a plot we've accepted. Nathan Young: Yeah. Well I think another one like that comes to mind is like National Geographic, right? Like that was bought by Fox or Murdoch or something like that, I think. And Abraham Chen: Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: the Wall Street Journal, similar thing. I we're seeing a lot like as somebody that watches media a lot, that's like very cognitive media, that it's it's a big thing that's happening in the media world. All the T V channels, all the news, like the different newspapers, the Union Tribune, Abraham Chen: Yeah. Nathan Young: the Washington Post, all that stuff. So it's it's yeah, Abraham Chen: Yeah. Totally. Nathan Young: it's definitely and like local news stations all across the country, right? And so now all the local news stations are basically just sort of like shells of them for themselves and just repeat whatever corporate lines they want to our parents and grandparents. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And so Abraham Chen: Yeah. It's a zombie horror movie. Yeah. Yeah. And well and here's the thing. A lot of times when I start getting on this so box of sorts, people are like, Well, so are you like anti-capitalism? You know? And I'm like, Well, hold on a second. Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: The core thesis of capitalism is that it's a system for generating immense innovation and wealth, right? And growth, economic growth. And those things are great. When you look at the version that's kind of metastasized, it doesn't do those things. Once you innovate and accumulate wealth, it gets snapped up and sold for parts and accumulated to the very, very tippy top in the hands of a few. I mean there's 10 individuals, billionaires in this country that own more than 31% of the wealth, Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: like just significant chunks of the wealth that's been distributed, if you will. Nathan Young: Yeah. Well so it sounds like fiduciary responsibility concept is yeah, that has sort of taken away a lot of like I guess the word would be commoditized, these sort of smaller, medium sized businesses have been commoditized and bought up by Aggregates. I'm not sure like with the actual these bigger companies though that do sort of buy the brand and stuff. And yeah, I think we could all have kind of seen the same evil that they just buy the brand and you're like, all right, you bought a brand, you know? But Abraham Chen: Yeah. Nathan Young: part of what you said earlier though, this only happened the last forty years, and I don't know like how deep your history knowledge goes, but how did this was this line that like you have to work towards shareholder value, was that in the laws the whole time and only people decided in the eighties to really like, we better do this now? Or was that a new law stuck in there somehow? Abraham Chen: Yeah, it's a good question. I don't know the precise timing when fiduciary duty came into play, but Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: I know that really in the nineteen eighties, Jack Welch and GE really like made this concept really, really popular. Like this is the way to run a large Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Abraham Chen: enterprise. they shifted labor from a company's greatest asset literally into a liability. If you look at any company's balance sheet, labor Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: costs are One of the highest liability costs. it's why it's relevant to today because we're seeing these companies lay off thousands and thousands of workers in the age of AI, and Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Abraham Chen: it's because of that conceptual framework. And so, Nathan Young: Mm. It Abraham Chen: go ahead. Nathan Young: Well it's funny because when you say that too, and it's sort of like all these things they're tied to so much more than we could probably answer here. I'm sure you're not very smart about economics, but we might need like a real, legit economist. I don't know, or are you economist or are you just smart about it? He just knows things. Okay. All right. Well Abraham Chen: Just somebody who stares at it and tries to figure out the patterns. Nathan Young: 'cause yeah, 'cause like was that shift to making labor an asset or a liability instead of an asset? what was the trick there? Or did something technologically changed where like it really became more of a liability than an asset? Or was somebody's like, what if I just move labor over here and and we just do it that way and yeah, I don't know if you have Abraham Chen: Yeah. Nathan Young: any insight on that at all, or that's just Abraham Chen: I mean the truth of the matter is it's probably a whole bunch of things happening at the same time in that era. Nathan Young: Yeah, Abraham Chen: and there are people much smarter than I who spoke on the subject. Like Nathan Young: Okay. Abraham Chen: I would cite wealth supremacy is a great book. I think Sam talked about it in his talk as well. that Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: really goes through the history and the minutiae of like how we end up in a system like this. But I think the key thing, and and hopefully folks listening to this too, like that Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: hopefully this triggers people's curiosities and right, starts to unravel like, Nathan Young: Yeah, totally. Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: wait, business wasn't always like that. Because Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: we have to figure out how we got here and how it works in order to start to hack into it and co opt it for the version that we do want. Right. So even when Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah to it. W Abraham Chen: I was talking about like when people would say, are you anti-capitalist? I'm like, actually I think I'm trying to save capitalism in some ways. Nathan Young: Yeah, right. Like mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: Right? Like put the soul back in it because if it could create this much innovation, this much this much wealth, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Abraham Chen: And this much growth for our economy, how do we ensure it does that, but in a way that's actually balanced for everybody's thriving? Because when you do it in a way that's unequal, like like those K-shaped curves that they talked about post-COVID, Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: the problems are gonna come back to us as a society as a whole. They don't just magically go away when they're swept under the rug. And when Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: people feel disenfranchised or they feel like the system doesn't work for them, well, they start to opt out of the system in some really dramatic ways. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah, it's no wonder why people are so upset. Yeah. And Nathan Young: Yeah, that's when the Yeah, it's when the pitchforks come out and stuff too, right? So yeah. Yeah. Abraham Chen: really, if we all wanted this to work, we would be investing into being that interdependence, that equity. DI's gotten a bad name in today's world. It's actually a way for us to figure out how to make the system work for all of us, in a balanced Nathan Young: totally, totally. Abraham Chen: way. Nathan Young: Yeah. Well and let's talk about what that alternative could be. 'Cause one of the things you mentioned was shareholder capitalism, which I think is interesting 'cause it is like, yeah, when you think about a business that opens up, even if it's a big corporation, they're benefiting from all right, whatever community they set up shop in, that community has a sort of like or I'm stakeholder capitalism is one that you that we talked about. So like yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: That's the shift. Yeah, from shareholder capitalism to stakeholder capitalism. Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: to stakeholder capitalism. So yeah, so if a business opens up, like everybody lives in a town or that city or that community has like a stake in what's going on with that business on some level, right? And the school that educated the workers that are gonna work there have a stake in that business on some level, right? And so like I don't know, but tell us about what you know, when people the more official definition or how it's like I'm just sort of giving you my colloquial ideas, but what how is it talked about more officially, the idea of stakeholder capitalism? Abraham Chen: Yeah. Yeah. The idea is how do you find balance in benefiting all of your stakeholders? Right. Which isn't that foreign of a business concept. It's just that the gravity of finance has pulled us so far into only focusing on shareholders that we've lost sight of why businesses were created in the first place. First of all, you have a duty to your customers to generate value for them. And then you have a duty for your workers, like to actually create good, purpose-filled jobs for them. And then to your community, right? By by proxy. There's a duty to the planet, too. A lot of companies, I mean all companies really, depend on natural resources to exist. If we just keep taking natural resources and we don't put anything back, well, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: you're gonna end up with a problem. And that's kind of the path we're on right now. We're seeing this extreme version of extractive capitalism. And so B Corp certification codifies that by asking you very direct questions about your impact on your workers, right? Things all the way down to how performance reviews are done, to fair wages, to Nathan Young: Mm. Mm. Abraham Chen: whether you have human rights in your supply chain, right? Human rights stances, to justice, equity, diversity, inclusion, right? Do you actually have a workplace that's creates belonging? All of these things are measured out. They're not just kind of nice tabs or things that you say you have, you have to produce documentation to show you have it. And then a third party verifies that you do it. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Abraham Chen: And you can't just say you have it either. You have to have it at a high level. And all of that becomes Nathan Young: Mm, mm. Toll. Abraham Chen: the form of this certification, this B with a circle in it, that Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: you can then put out to the market to show, hey, we're walking the walk and we're talking the talk. And that's why you should have trust in us. Now beyond that, what we were talking Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. It Abraham Chen: about earlier, like companies being sold for scraps, right? On top of that, B Lab really, really deeply encourages companies to become benefit corporations. So they can also enshrine that for the long term and not fall under the pressures to just sell be sold for parts. Nathan Young: Okay. And so the benefit there is for the company that decides to become B Corp certified is like, like I'm sure they believe in what they're doing, right? That's like the number one benefit. But it also is a marketing benefit too, theoretically, right? people see Abraham Chen: Yeah. Yeah. Nathan Young: it and it's funny too. We'll come back to that. But then the other piece is that So by becoming a B Corp certified organization, they can no longer be sold off for parts. if they sell, whoever they sell to has to maintain that B Corp certification. they have to stay that B Corp or couldn't sold to somebody when they couldn't they just be like, Well, we're not a B Corp anymore, so we're still gonna scrap it or is there what are there guardrails there, or is there any kind of like how's that work? Abraham Chen: Yeah, it's such a good question. and even when I started my own B Corp journey, that was a key question for me. I was like, man, how does this thing work? And it does sound a little bit too good to be true. Also, if it succeeds, I'm sure the system will push back, right? So Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, for sure. Yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: here's the dirty laundry, here's the dirty truth. what I've noticed about B Corp certified companies is yes, they're more resilient, but there are still ways in which the current financial system can try to overcome or circumvent Invent that. Famous Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: example was Alberts. They got listed on public markets and started to succumb to quarterly pressures of investor earnings and shareholders wanting to see strong Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: returns. And lo and behold, this company that at its beginning was like this darling of an innovative company that was creating shoes made out of sustainable. Do you know the stories of Alberts? So, yeah. Nathan Young: Like vaguely. I mean I yeah from their yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: They had made this innovation of the sole of the shoe being made out of sugar cane byproduct. Nathan Young: wow, okay. Abraham Chen: And this was a way to introduce sustainability into an industry that's not known for sustainability, footwear. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: And then they went the extraordinary step of making that design completely open to the public so that all other shoe companies could copy them. Because they Nathan Young: well. Abraham Chen: so believed in the mission of sustainability Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: in this industry. That they actually didn't protect their IP, they allowed anybody else to copy the sugar cane model. Well, again, once they got so successful for doing this and building Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: this much trust with their consumers, well, again, financial pressures start to get to them. They got listed Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: in public markets and then start to break that down to the point where now they're not even really a footwear company anymore. They sold off all those assets and they've pivoted to AI. It was it's very strange. So Nathan Young: Yeah, okay. I was worried about that. Abraham Chen: That's the dirty laundry, is that it's not perfect. That there are still great, great B Corps out there, right? Companies like Ben and Jerry's who are carrying out their fight quite public right now. Patagonia, which many people know, Warby Parker, right? there are companies that are able to uphold this. I think B Corp really helps you encode this identity Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: in. But the truth is it's not quite enough. This movement is 20 years old. Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: Right. And what a lofty crazy idea. How Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: do we certify any company of any type, any size? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: It's a hundred and sixty-one different industries that B Corp is in across a hundred countries. So it's like Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Abraham Chen: global. The scale is staggering. And yet Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: we are finding that there are still ways in which it's not quite enough to protect from what the original founders of B Lab found out. So Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: That's where benefit corporation law comes into play, but also alternative ownership models like the perpetual purpose trust. which is what and I won't, yeah, I won't dive too far into that. Go for it. Nathan Young: Wait, before we get I w I just wanna Okay, yeah. All right, go go for it. okay. Abraham Chen: so essentially Patagonia has all of its voting shares put into a trust, that essentially protects its mission in a trust. Nathan Young: Okay, well I'm sorry. start your thought at being the perpetual purpose trust and just go with your thought there. Abraham Chen: So it's all about ownership. who owns the company and who has a say in what that company does, right? Nathan Young: Mm. Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: And that's what folks across the B Corp movement are finding out. Oftentimes what happened is the founders or some very passionate board members, passionate shareholders would say, Okay, we need this B Corp certification, which is a start. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Abraham Chen: And then they realize, my goodness, okay, we gotta figure out how to take and protect the governance structure of the company so that the voting shares can actually live in a place where it can't be touched. that way it can keep its mission. And that's what Patagonia realized. So Nathan Young: Yeah. Okay. Abraham Chen: they set up a perpetual purpose trust, which is a separate entity that houses the decision-making process for the company. Another really famous B Corp Tony's Chocalonely. Has an even more robust version of this. I don't know if you've heard of this. it's a phenomenal company. They basically Nathan Young: Never heard of this one. No, Tony Cioccolone? Okay. Abraham Chen: formed to eliminate this. a couple journalists dug into how the slave trade is deeply embedded into the cocoa supply chain across the globe. And they're trying to figure out how to reverse this, and they could find no chocolate company that had this removed from their supply chain. So these Dutch journalists just Created their own chocolate company called Tony's Nathan Young: Wow. Abraham Chen: Chocolate Only. And their entire purpose is to eliminate the slave trade from chocolate supply. Yeah. Nathan Young: okay. Abraham Chen: And the chocolate's phenomenal, but then they realize, my God, if we achieve any modicum of success, essentially what's gonna happen is the financial structures that exist will come and do Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: what we were talking about earlier. So they formed a really, really deep and unsexy governance structure that has all of its stakeholders on the board of that decision making structure so that no one can ever touch the mission. It Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: will remain that mission, it's not a chocolate company. It's a eliminate slaves trade from the chocolate supply chain. Nathan Young: Wow, okay. what I'm hearing, these are amazing and it's interesting to know, it's funny because my brain that's been trained too much on like shareholder capitalism, little things are going off for me, and I think that might be part of the tension that a lot of us have is like yeah, it's so I think it could be very easy and sort of satisfying to be like dismissive, like what there's a couple of companies, what's that gonna do? Or it's all very idealistic or it's just like a marketing scheme or whatever. I mean, I don't know, does this come up in like conversations around like that? what are your thoughts on that? Abraham Chen: All the time. All the time. I'll start with what sounds like a tangent, I'll tie it in. The B Corp movement as a whole, the reason it's actually magic is not necessarily because of the certification. It's because it actually brings values aligned individuals into community with each other. And we start to talk about ideas of how we can make this better. Just like you Nathan Young: Mm-mm. Yeah. Abraham Chen: just said, right? Like, wow, I hadn't heard about all these companies. Well what's really powerful is when these companies talk to each other, we know we have shared values. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Abraham Chen: Because nobody fakes their way into B Corp certification. And we're like, my God, okay, I trust you. You're also trying to do this thing. What Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: can we do about this? And what I find in the B Corp circles that I talk about is there's a lot of impatience, right? We're doers. And so we're like, why can't we just get this figured out and fix this thing right now? Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: And so there's a lot of debate about economic systems change and the people debate, hey, is this a marathon or a sprint? Right? Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: Like, is it like do we just run for a real long time and try to move the needle a tiny bit? Or do we like push hard and just like go after this thing? And Nathan Young: Mm, mm, mm. Abraham Chen: the best model that I've found for this is a relay race. It's Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: a bunch of people running as hard as they can, trying to do the best that they can, and then handing it off to the next person to try to do it. Right? Where Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. Abraham Chen: and one failed, right? B Corp Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: is now picking up the mantle. Where we're seeing B Corp fail in certain ways, we need something else to take the mantle. And For me, this is very controversial for me to say as the executive director of B Local San Diego, but I Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: actually believe B Corp isn't the end all be all. This isn't the silver bullet of fixing all this. I Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Abraham Chen: actually think B Corp is the doula for the next economy. I think we're ushering in this system and these sets Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: of companies that are challenging the status quo and saying, Hold on, we could do so much better than this. And doing the best that we can in this moment to figure out how we can hand this off to another structure that's ultimately going to generate the type of economy we all want, which is one where everybody flourishes, where the planet flourishes, and we can Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: have something that regenerates for generation after generation. That's what we all want. Nathan Young: You may have noticed that one of the recurring themes of this podcast is that the world as it is isn't the only world that's possible. And the people I talk with on here are often exploring different ways of leading, working, building community and creating change in the world here too. you also may have noticed that we have a few problems in our world. Things, you know, aren't aren't the way that a lot of us would like them. And many of the guests I've had on here have had on specifically for the ideas they have to share about what could make our world a better place. and this all gets back to the kind of work that I do too. This connection of leadership and social change. Very much part of the work I do. I work with leaders to help them own and share their own bold vision for a better world. Sometimes this means helping someone find the message in the heart of a talk they're giving or an overall message they're sharing about, who they are and the kind of work they're doing. Sometimes it means helping an organization tell a clearer and more compelling story about the work they're doing and the change they're trying to make. And sometimes this even means helping my clients understand what it means to be courageous applying that courage to the message they wanna share. Right now I do this primarily through coaching and consulting with leaders specifically, but also with some organizations. I'm also developing a set of tools and training models an idea I call narrative leadership, which is a framework for understanding how the stories we tell shape what we believe is possible and our ability to make these stories real. And I'll be sharing much more about this work here soon. So if any of this sounds interesting, it sounds like something that you could use help with for your either for yourself or for your organization, I'd love to hear from you. I'd love to see if we could work together. you can start by visiting my website which is storyculture consulting dot com or finding me on social media and all the channels. It's Nathan Cody Young on all of There are ways you can message me either through social media, through the website. And of course keep listening here. I plan to roll out some pieces of this here very soon. So as more and more of that comes together, you're all gonna be the first to hear about it. So thanks so much for listening to my little commercial here, And now let's get back to the episode. Yeah, yeah, okay. I mean, how cogent of a vision do you have of what that next economy might look like? Even if it's just like Abraham's vision? Abraham Chen: Yeah, I can give you two versions that are actually very visceral. One was when I was in London two years ago. And I don't know if you know this, but London's the fastest growing B Corp region in the world. they have a thousand B Corps. Compare that to fifty in San Diego and maybe like one to two hundred in places like New York and the Bay Area. London has a thousand plus. They've they've 10x. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: I remember being there and just being able to see like the B Corp logo in shop windows and in Nathan Young: yeah. Abraham Chen: products that I bought and I was like, now as a consumer, I get to choose any product Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: I can think of or service I can think of, I can choose a better version of that. I can choose a company that's doing it better. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: that power was remarkable to me. Like I had the power of choice and I that to me was like, wow, that's really cool that they've embedded social impact and everything we've just discussed. Into an actual marketplace competitive advantage. So that Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: was one. Okay. The other is a place, a little place called Mondragon. It's hidden in the hills of northern Spain in Arrasate. This is a place that has the world's largest worker-owned cooperative. There's 90 plus companies and 70,000 workers, and Nathan Young: Mm. Abraham Chen: every worker owns a share of the company. And they have one vote and they're all in one giant cooperative with each other. Okay. Nathan Young: Okay. Abraham Chen: but what's really powerful of this company is that it flexes when the economy does well and different. During COVID, they were able to flex. So certain companies weren't doing well. And they could flex workers from that company as it shrank into other companies within the structure. Nathan Young: Hmm. Okay. Abraham Chen: And it's not just like when you talk about cooperatives, by the way, in the US. You know what I'm curious like what comes to mind for you in terms of what types of companies? Nathan Young: like I think of that certain kind of like grocery store that seems to be near colleges and Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Well I wouldn't go that far. Yeah, I yeah, like well I Abraham Chen: Grocery stores. Yeah. People with no yeah, and no shoes, right? Like very hippy dippy. Nathan Young: will say that Loki this came up the other day. co op deli counter might be like my second favorite kind of food. just like you know I don't know. But but yeah, but like no, these are like l yeah, yeah. But like l Abraham Chen: Yeah, yeah. But that's what we think of. Yeah, grocery stores and maybe farmers in in agriculture. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. But like I mean I don't know I think these are like legit things and yeah. But go I'm sorry, go ahead, keep going. Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: So in Mondergone, there's a bank that's a cooperative. Their second largest grocery store chain is a cooperative across the entire country. There is a high tech biotech company that does biotech research. There is Nathan Young: Wow. Okay. Abraham Chen: a manufacturing, high manufacturing industry that supplies custom machinery to companies. They have ninety plus companies within this whole system. And the key thing is just that it's just owned by the workers. Let me tell you, when I got the chance to visit there with the University of San Diego's Global Executive Seminar last year. And what's so remarkable about this place is that you got this sense of community and peace there. when they're describing how the thrive they're all about the thriving of the community, I was like, cool, Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: these guys don't need B Corp at all. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, they're just doing Abraham Chen: Because the workers, Nathan Young: it. Abraham Chen: they were already voting for their own rights. They were already voting for the decision of the companies to benefit their community, to benefit the actual sustainability of the company for the long term. They all collectively wanted to see this thing succeed and do Nathan Young: Mm. Abraham Chen: right by all the people involved in building it on a day-to-day basis. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: when you're talking about the vision for what could be, that's Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: what I see. Like that's what we need. And Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: It was really remarkable. So we took a bus there and we kind of stepped off. And what's so weird about talking about all these business systems is that when I stepped off the bus, it was actually a visceral feeling. it's very hard for me to describe this. I'm not a spiritual person by nature, Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: but there was something really like it makes my the hair on the back of my arm stand up even just thinking about it. Like you could feel a sense of wellness in this place that is like immediate. And I was like, this is This is very strange. Like Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: there were children running around in the playground. It was like two o'clock in the afternoon, and parents were around looking after them, and you could just sense there's like wellness in the community. And it was so weird to me that the business system could actually feed into that in a deep, deep way. By Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: the way, it wasn't always this way for this region in Mondragón. They were actually a manufacturing built area. That was seeing a massive decline at the end of the Industrial Revolution Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: and a huge worry that all of them were gonna have to move away from this region because Nathan Young: Do Abraham Chen: the good paying jobs were leaving. they Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: had a phrase like, where your wallet goes, your people will go also. and so they had to come up with a way, an innovation, to actually Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: help keep really well-paying jobs local so that people could keep living there. Nathan Young: Yeah. Okay. Abraham Chen: And this is where it ties to San Diego. Because if you think about like what we love about San Diego, we've been going through a recent exercise at Be Local San Diego. We have this Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: giant nine-foot flag and we have people draw on it and draw Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: what they love about San Diego. And let me tell you, there's like 10 pictures of sunsets over the beach. Right? Yes. Great beers, like, Nathan Young: Like a California burrito and like yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah. Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: man, all of it. But like we love living here. Are you kidding me? It's so beautiful here. The weather's perfect year-round. And everyone has this desire to figure out how to stay here and how to have keep their friends here, right? Which is Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: not that different from that area where Mondragón is. And for me, that's why we're kind of positioned for this. Like, how do we create an economic system and business system here in San Diego that helps people stay here and that keeps good, well paying jobs, good companies, wealth. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: Here in San Diego so that we keep living in this really amazing place. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. How how how do we do it? How do we do it? What we do? Abraham Chen: And that exists today. Yeah. Yeah. So it starts by challenging the existing notion of companies, by pushing our companies to dive into the certification process. Be local San Diego is here to help with that. We've got programs coming this Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: fall to help BIPOC and women owned companies to go through the certification. And we've got education workshop series with people like Sam who are helping to teach people how to embed these practices in their business. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: We're also going to be embarking and helping people change their governance structures so Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: they can be like companies like Patagonia and Chautoni's Chocolate Lonely to actually embed that into their governance. And we Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: want to start moving. I think to be fair, I don't know that our system is quite ready for the shock of what I talk about with cooperatives and ownership, but it's gonna get there. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Abraham Chen: And we are positioning ourselves to be able to help companies do that. It Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: does exist today. I don't know if you heard of an eSOP. Or an EAT, employee stock ownership programs. Uh-huh. Yeah, we're true believers in this. We're believers in this. Nathan Young: I mean, I heard about all this stuff from Sam like two weeks ago. So Yeah, yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: And we really believe in its ability to actually turn the tide and get us to that next economy Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: where actually workers benefit and the community benefits and the planet benefits. Yeah. Nathan Young: Okay. Well I want like that turning tide thing. I wanna come back to that. So remind me before we 'cause I have thoughts. Abraham Chen: Yes. I will. Yes. Let's I wanna hear them. Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: so I have like three things competing for which one's gonna I'm gonna say first here right now. Abraham Chen: Ha ha ha. Nathan Young: actually let's start here. So Mondragón when did that happen? Did that happen in the eighteen hundreds? when did that transition happen that you're describing? Do you know? Okay. Abraham Chen: Yeah. Nineteen fifties. So this town has been around for over a thousand years. The reason I know Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: this is 'cause when I was there they were celebrating all these like thousand year histories, which is wild. in San Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: Diego most of the houses were built in like nineteen seventies. But a priest named Father Ariz Mendiereta, which you know say that three times fast with a Spanish accent, but he I just practiced in the mirror, like, yeah, three times three times a day. No, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. That was good. Like you you got much better like you even like kinda rolled the R's a little bit there. Okay. Abraham Chen: I kid. And so he came in and said, this exact concept that we were just talking about, my gosh, all these community members are gonna leave. How do we ensure good paying jobs remain here? And he had this concept of workers owning their stake in the company. And he trained Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: four young men to set up industries where the companies they set up had this structure embedded. And then over time they perfected it. so nineteen fifties is not that long. It's really not that long ago. Nathan Young: Mm. Mm. Yeah. yeah. Yeah, toy. Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: but they become an example into the world. Nathan Young: Okay. That's interesting. So that Abraham Chen: Does that give you hope or does that scare you? You're like, is that really possible? Nathan Young: Well no, so so here's how the historian and the sort of my narrative mind goes in that. It's like Abraham Chen: Please. Nathan Young: so nineteen fifty Spain, that's like, you know, right after World War Two. Abraham Chen: Yeah. Immediately post and immediately post civil war, yeah. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. So like there's civil war and I I don't know exactly what hap when the like Franco regime fell, but I think it was like right around then, right? So Abraham Chen: Mm. Right around that period, yeah. Nathan Young: so what I hear is like this emerged out of this like moment of massive transition for the country. And there was people with the idea that came here. And so here's where I would say like this is sort of like both a hope and a frustration because when we're talking about being ready and taking the small steps and stuff. One of the things I've just been observing in my own life and the years I've been alive is that a lot of times new ideas will be kind of like there and there, percolating, percolating, percolating, percolating, then all of a sudden, boom, it just this this wave takes over. And it usually Abraham Chen: Yes. Nathan Young: comes from some massive transition happening. And the big one that we all just experienced was COVID. so much stuff that our whole culture changed around that. working from home, the George Floyd's Black Lives Matter protest went up. And so just like a Abraham Chen: Mm-hmm, mm hmm, mm-hmm. Nathan Young: lot of ideas changed during that moment. And then there's always a sort of back and forth and a recoil and a pushback and but there's just things that like have been done that aren't getting undone and a lot of just social norms have changed. Abraham Chen: Yes. Nathan Young: And I mean I think another one is the end of the I don't know how old if you're old enough to remember this, but like just the sort of end of the Bush era and the Iraq war and the social the financial collapse that happened there. And just like, you Abraham Chen: Yes. Nathan Young: know, that that was the sort of big shift where a lot of things just sort of changed there too. And so I Abraham Chen: Absolutely. Nathan Young: guess what I'm getting at is like, yo, some shit's gonna happen here soon, man. Like like Abraham Chen: Yes, yes, yes, Nathan Young: and more I get the the value of the be local thing, but my mind always goes to how do we set up the narrative to where this idea that we all accept shareholder capitalism as this normal thing, well business that's just how business goes, it's how they do that. And be like, no no no no no no no we're gonna do stakeholder capitalism. We're gonna talk about business in a way like they have an obligation to their communities. the community contributed to that business existing. They need to give back. Because the tension I have here, and I'll stop here in a minute, is that like so much of what you've described also depends on the magnanimity. Magnim magnimity? Magn magnanimicity. Magn magn Yeah. No well like well like mag Abraham Chen: Arismendi Reta Magnanim magnanimity. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, magnanimity of of the owners at of yeah, of the owners of those companies at the time, right? Like like Allbirds, Patagonia, like those all could have gone either which way, right? Yeah. Abraham Chen: Yeah. It's magnanimous. Sure. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. They required their top shareholders to choose into stakeholder capitalism. That's right, that's right. Yes. Nathan Young: Yeah, at probably at like a pretty big expense to them, right? Like 'cause I know like getting B Corp certified, Abraham Chen: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. yeah. Nathan Young: it's not easy. And like everybody that we're talking to in our Abraham Chen: yeah. Nathan Young: circles are we're we're small. We're like, two, three person businesses and we're taking on Abraham Chen: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Nathan Young: this thing. And so there's sort of like that narrative change that exists because like how do we get I always think of like the here in San Diego, the big industries, the pharmaceutical and science research that happens up on on yeah, up on the Mesa. You know, it's like Abraham Chen: Yeah, biotech, mm-hmm. Yes. Nathan Young: is any of them becoming like a B corp Is that even like in the cards, you know? That just seems like I don't know. Now I'm just okay, now I'm just ranting. You take whatever you want from that and like say s okay. Abraham Chen: Yes, I'm following. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. So talk about social upheaval. We have Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: gone forty-five minutes in and we haven't even uttered AI. So big props to us, right? Like you know, applause for both of us, all right? Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: Artificial intelligence is introducing that social upheaval as we speak, right? Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: What's really interesting is that people are asking about how AI is gonna impact blah blah blah. There's all these existing structures around AI that we should be questioning, like business structures. Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: Did you know that Anthropic is a public benefit corporation? Nathan Young: Or are they? Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: Mm-hmm. So before Anthropic was ever anthropic and and Claude and all that, right, Dario and team split off from open AI because they did not like ha the direction of things where things were going. And they Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: set up this little their own little AI shop. And then they're like, shoot, we don't want to go down that path. We see we're very like cognizant of the power of AI to transform society. We're also very aware of the temptations that this financial Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: system will will have. So they went to guy named Eric Reese, who actually author of The Lean Startup, but then has recently wrote a book called Incorruptible. and they're like, Eric, a lot people are telling us you're the guy who collects all these weird governance structures that help protect companies. Like, what can we do? And it's like Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: you've got to put in this public benefit corporation law into your company so that when you grow and inevitably have this insane success. They they are the fastest growing company in the history of mankind. They understood and again I'm no AI apologist, okay? I'm not under any Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: kind of notion that my god, and so anthropic is some kind of angel company. No, no, they'll they'll be pitfalls down the road. But they figured out a way to build this governance in, right? So it's happening Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah. There's problems. Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: before our eyes right now. And again, like there's an impatience for us to see these big changes in our lifetime. It's a relay race. We're running as hard as we can with what we have right now. B Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Abraham Chen: Corp movement is twenty years old. It's only twenty years old. It's just Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. Abraham Chen: in its infancy. And we're doing the darndest that we can. We've run into a certain number of issues. We're like, my gosh, okay, that that works and that doesn't work. Right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: But we gotta run as hard as we can towards it. And to me like that almost go dives into a philosophy of why we're even like on earth in the first place. You Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: know, our existence is so finite. Right like and I I I hate to take this Nathan Young: Mm mm mm. Tot, yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: in such a deeply philosophical place, but that's maybe that's the core of who I am. Yeah. I mean, Nathan Young: No, this is what we do on this podcast. Go for it. Abraham Chen: okay, on average, you and I are projected to live around four thousand weeks. Which is a sobering thought. Two thousand Nathan Young: yeah. Abraham Chen: of those spent working. this is at the DNA of why I'm doing this work, by the way. for me there was like first an existential panic that set in, we're like, my god, I gotta figure out my purpose. And then a lofty like, okay, what is the big problem that's worth my time, talent, and treasure to solve? And for me, this was this was it. Like the economy to me, again, talk about a word that puts people asleep sometimes, right? And I'm like, wait, no, this touches every facet of our lives and touches the lives of not just the seven generations after us, but the livelihood that the one planet that we have. And by the way, we're destroying at a record pace right now. So I was like, I gotta sprint as hard as I can with these few two thousand to four thousand weeks that I have to try to figure out what's the best that I can do right now. Will I live to enjoy the shade of the trees I planted? Probably not. But you bet I gotta try. All right. what's that famous quote and the best time to plant a tree was forty years ago and next best time is right now. Nathan Young: Yeah, toll. Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: And like it, we gotta do it. We gotta do it. Because alternative is to spiral into this sense of, my gosh, nothing works and everything's broken. What's Nathan Young: Yeah, totally. Abraham Chen: the point of it all? Right? And and devolve into a puddle. And I think it's okay to do that from time to time. We need that. We need that release. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm, mm hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Abraham Chen: But then to pick ourselves up and say, okay, but what can I do today? What can I do right now to make this better? And then say, Ooh. Who else is doing stuff like that? Who are the Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: ones who, in the face of all of this insanity, trying to build something that actually is meaningfully moving us towards the type of world we want to see? Can I join forces with them? For me, that's been Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: the B Corp movement, that's been B Local San Diego. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, that's cool. Well and I gotta say, like, yeah, like it has been great to see the way you've been sort of building the community around the B Corps and stuff and like yeah, it's just you're right, like just to have the happy hours of people, you know, having these conversations and stuff too is like so valuable. It Abraham Chen: Yeah. It's like the trust that people are gonna build community themselves. Yeah. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. totally, totally. And what and like I mean, just the grandiosity thing that you're getting at too, like the big philosophical thing, it is it is so interesting because a lot of what I've heard you describe, like when you describe like Mondragon and some of these other companies, 'cause like what really like rewards us as humans is working cooperatively with each other on different things. And I think so Abraham Chen: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Nathan Young: much about like different places I've worked and different companies I worked and like how much more engaged and rewarding and happy and hopeful the whole experience would have been like a little bit more of a stake to where I mean I've done so much shit for free that 'cause I liked, I agree with it versus things I've gotten paid for. But it is like, yeah, to have a little bit more of a cooperative spirit within a company to be like, we're doing this together. We're working on this together. Like we've found this need in our society that we're gonna fulfill whether, it's some good altruistic need or I'm thinking of different companies I've worked for. Is it commercial property research, you know? Like whatever. we're working together on this. it would be just a very sort of a shift that would be very validating and I'm trying to think of it would just feel a lot better, you know? And I think of just Abraham Chen: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Nathan Young: our neighborhoods here and like yeah, if we'll go support restaurants and stuff for the neighborhood here, but if we had a little bit more of a steak and we're all sort of invested in this restaurant that comes here and making sure that no corporate restaurant can show up here or this owner can't sell and it becomes something shitty or you know a gross cunt. Yeah. Abraham Chen: Yeah. Yeah, a hundred percent. That was the story of Whole Foods, you know. They like when they first started their the store was nearly destroyed by a flood and they were gonna shut down completely. And the Nathan Young: Mm. wow. Abraham Chen: neighbors loved the store so much they all came and showed up and helped clean it up for free, as you said. Right. Nathan Young: Yeah, wow. Abraham Chen: Yeah. And took care of it. And that experience was so moving to the founders that they decided and bed that into the concept of conscious capitalism. Nathan Young: Wow, okay. Didn't even know that. Abraham Chen: Yeah, and yeah, I mean everything you're saying, Nathan, I hundred percent agree. I mean, if you think about like the age old question, can money buy happiness, right? the answer is actually yes, to a certain degree. There there's a famous study, right? Yeah. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Well, it looked by unhappy it could buy avoiding unhappiness by just having your needs met. Abraham Chen: Yeah, up to about seventy thousand median, which is probably like, you know, with inflation closer to eight, ninety thousand now. But Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: what I mean, I I experienced all this time working in corporate America. I would grow these teams and I'm like, I look, yes, we need to negotiate your salary and make sure you're thriving based on your wages. That's no doubt. After that point, the money starts to mean a whole bunch of other things. What people really are looking for are just two components meaningful work and meaningful relationships. That's it. That's it. Right? And Nathan Young: Yes. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. That's it. Yep. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: so if we can build systems and can actually create that environment more and more and more, we're gonna have a much more thriving society that can actually pour back into its thriving than the other way around, which is what we've seen. This extraction, extraction, extraction. So yeah. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And yeah, in a company that can like, you know, or just some sort of business operation that can do Abraham Chen: Yeah. Nathan Young: that for both the people and like feel like all right, you're contributing to something meaningful, you're working with people that you like and you're working towards something meaningful altogether, like yeah, it's gonna feel Abraham Chen: Yes. Yeah. Nathan Young: so different and so valuable and like and you're paying getting paid enough to like, you know, you're making your needs are met. You're doing good. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Abraham Chen: That's right. That's right. Yeah. And that's what I see from our B Corps. not a single one of them is doing it perfectly. FY Right? It's not Nathan Young: No, of course not. No, no, no. Yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: possible. None of us are living life perfectly, Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: but all of them are striving that in that direction. Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: And all of them have proof that they're performing at very high levels of it and they're constantly trying to improve. The B Corp Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Abraham Chen: certification, by the way, has improvement plans. Year zero, year three, year five. to actually like reflect what real life looks like, which is this constant Nathan Young: Yeah, totally. Abraham Chen: journey of improvement. Yeah. Nathan Young: Well, I think that's a good spot to wrap it up. We're we're at the s I mean we could, but like, you know yeah, yeah, totally. I don't Abraham Chen: You don't wanna talk for another full hour? No, just kidding. Turning into a long form podcast, yeah. Nathan Young: know. Well this is like the thing. Like it's so funny 'cause yeah, there's so many I would love to just have like a podcast which is sort of running conversations every week with people, but no we'll just we're stopping it now. This is it, we're calling it. So Abraham Chen: Yeah. Yeah, we could talk for Nathan Young: I gotta edit it. I gotta edit it too. That's that's the part. That's the part that like, you know. Yeah, yeah. yes. Yeah, yeah, yeah. people that help, but it's still yes. all right, anyways, Abraham Chen: that's true. That's true. The longer we talk, the more you have to edit. Yes. Yeah. Nathan Young: Abraham, people that like what you're talking about, how can they find out more about you? How can they get involved with you know, be local San Diego, B Corp, all this good stuff. Abraham Chen: Yeah. So be localsandiego.org. That's where you can find us. feel free to email me if any of this inspires you. Find me on LinkedIn or Instagram as well. we've got events, monthly events that happen. so give us a follow. Come join us in person. And vote with your time, talents, and treasure. Not just your vo your votes are important too. Go vote. But Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Abraham Chen: every vote you make with your time, your time and your treasure is so critical to creating Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Abraham Chen: the economy we want. Go work for a B Corp. Go shop from a B Corp. Go put your donate. Donate to BlocalSandiego.org. We need your donations. Like we need y everybody voting on a daily basis with what they Nathan Young: Yeah. Abraham Chen: have to actually make a shift here. Nathan Young: Yeah, totally, totally. Yeah, yeah. And all all this stuff we'll put in the show notes too. So people can look at it there too. all right, Abraham Chen: Sure. That's perfect. Nathan Young: well, Abraham, thank you so much for coming on and really excited to have you. And yeah, Abraham Chen: Yeah. Nathan Young: this is great. I'm very inspired. I'm gonna be thinking about this one for a while. So yeah, thanks again. Yeah. All right, take care. Bye. Abraham Chen: Yeah. Thank you for doing what you do. Appreciate you, Nathan. Mm-hmm. Bye bye. Nathan: All right, that's it today for my conversation with Abraham Chen. Thank you so much to him for coming on the show. One of the ideas I'm really taking away is Abraham's idea that maybe we don't have to believe that any one organization or generation is going to solve the whole problem. Maybe our job is to run as hard as we can with what we have, learn what we can, and hand the baton to the people who come next. I'm personally impatient and want to fix the world like right now, but maybe he has a point there. I'm going to sit with that. I'm also thinking a lot about that part that we talked about at the end, and I can't help but fantasize about what it might look like or feel like to work for a company with a bigger purpose. And maybe that purpose isn't necessarily related to the product per se, but more related to the life and happiness and security and community it could grant to its workers. I'm thinking even of the most boring corporate jobs I've had and how the vibe might have changed if there was a more actively vested interest in the success of the company. and of the people I worked with we feel like we're all working together for our own sort of wealth, security and well being, as opposed to just sort of going there, getting a paycheck, getting yours and leaving. Since most of my work has been in like media and marketing, I definitely like think about how that would be a really interesting model for those types of businesses. But I'm also fascinated by just like the prospect of what if we all had a stake in every business in our city or town or neighborhood. How would that change us? What would be different? And what would that change of the way businesses operate too? if you want to learn more about Abraham's work, you can find BeLocalSandiego at belocalsandiego.org. We'll have all the links down in the show notes too. And if you enjoyed this conversation, subscribe to Braver New Worlds. Share it with someone who might be thinking about these questions too. And consider what you're voting for with your time, talent, and treasure going forward in the future. thank you so much for listening and we'll see you at the next one.