Latest / Politics with Paul / Most Common Mistakes and Misunderstandings about Campaigns w/ Alex Patton | Politics with Paul #74
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul Podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:08And what better way to start off the new year than with a guest?
- 0:11And for such episodes, I always add a disclaimer that I do not take a stance for or
- 0:15against a guest's political views or groups they support.
- 0:19But regardless of your political views, every political campaign makes mistakes along the
- 0:24way.
- 0:24They're only human after all.
- 0:26Yet some are much more prone to mistakes and errors than others.
- 0:30These slip ups can cost you a lot of time, money, and energy, and they can make difference
- 0:35between winning and losing a campaign.
- 0:38So what are these common mistakes made by political campaigns or by others regarding how
- 0:43to evaluate political campaigns and how do you fix them?
- 0:47Well, that's what today's guest Alex Patton is here to talk about today.
- 0:50Actually, Alex because he came and taught classes a couple times while I was in grad
- 0:55school at the University of Florida.
- 0:57But credentials wise, he has been the principal and senior government affairs strategist with
- 1:03OZN Media for just over twenty years, and he's also an adjunct professor with the University
- 1:09of Florida and the nearby Santa Fe College.
- 1:11And before then, he was the founder and senior researcher for a couple of survey research
- 1:16firms.
- 1:17So he knows a little bit about campaigns.
- 1:19So let's dive into the world of political campaigns, particularly the mistakes made by
- 1:23campaigns and by those who examine campaigns.
- 1:26Please welcome Alex Patton to the show.
- 1:28Alex, good to see you again, man.
- 1:30How are you?
- 1:30I'm doing well.
- 1:31Thank you for having me.
- 1:32Happy New Year.
- 1:34Yeah.
- 1:34Happy New Year to you too.
- 1:36And thank you for being the first guest of the New Year.
- 1:39So with
- 1:39all my guests, fantastic.
- 1:42With all my guests, I like to get into the why and how about what they do and their
- 1:47involvement with the topic of the episode.
- 1:50So what got you into political campaigning?
- 1:53Then that is a very long story.
- 1:55How long do you have, Paul?
- 1:57You know, ever since high school, you know, I was one of the student government nerds.
- 2:03I've always enjoyed the political process.
- 2:06I actually grew up overseas, so I was exposed to the European systems of politics as well as
- 2:13the American part.
- 2:14And so it's always just fascinating.
- 2:17And when I went to college, my degree eventually ended up being political science.
- 2:23I had the great pleasure of taking a semester off of school and actually working my first
- 2:29congressional campaign when I was a junior in college.
- 2:32And then I had the even greater honor of being elected student body president of the
- 2:38University of Florida.
- 2:40And so politics has kind of always been in my blood.
- 2:43Now, having said that, when I finished being student body president of the University of
- 2:48Florida, I swore off politics.
- 2:50I was done with it.
- 2:52And so I went into actually corporate insurance.
- 2:58Still a little bit of a political connection, but it's like a drug, Paul, as you know.
- 3:03It just sucks you right back in.
- 3:06And so I found myself volunteering for campaigns.
- 3:10I found myself helping, found myself in the political process and still denying it.
- 3:20And then finally I started my own ad agency.
- 3:25And when we started, we were an ad agency.
- 3:27We were having large commercial clients and then occasionally picking up political
- 3:34business.
- 3:35And it just is a drug and I couldn't put it down.
- 3:40And it got to the point to where in the ad agency, the political stuff was causing a
- 3:46conflict.
- 3:47It was causing a conflict between me and my partner.
- 3:50We had different political views at the time and different candidates that we wanted to work
- 3:54on and clients we wanted to take on.
- 3:56And staff wise, right?
- 3:58We had hired for an ad agency and then I would come in and ask people to do political work and
- 4:08they weren't aligned with me politically.
- 4:10So this is a very, very long story of saying, I never ever intended on being here, but here we
- 4:17are.
- 4:17So the ad agency promoted to doing nothing but politics so that we could align the staff and
- 4:23get everybody together and just started admitting who I was, which is a political nerd
- 4:30and a political junkie.
- 4:31And that's the path.
- 4:33You know?
- 4:33You know, that's such an interesting question because I think if you ask a lot of people of
- 4:37how they ended up in politics, you're going to get these trajectories that are just wild.
- 4:42And I I think our trajectory, my trajectory is is probably the same.
- 4:46Yeah.
- 4:47I didn't have the the hiatus from politics that that you have, but I definitely have a love
- 4:55hate relationship still do with with with politics.
- 4:59It's it can be very frustrating, but it's just there's just knowing about how it works and and
- 5:04describing how it works to other people is just that's what really gets me.
- 5:07It's not the actual campaigning.
- 5:09I like knowing about campaigning and how it works, but just the actual nitty gritty.
- 5:14That that's that's just not for me.
- 5:16But that's okay.
- 5:17I try to take the the education route there.
- 5:19But I I still think that's a it's a fascinating way that you came came back to.
- 5:24And like you said, it it does just have a way of pulling you back in even when there's been
- 5:29times where I think, ugh, do I really wanna do this?
- 5:32It's it's it's very hard to get away.
- 5:36I mean But My my entire life, all I wanted to be was a professional baseball player, but I
- 5:42couldn't hit a curveball.
- 5:43I wasn't fast enough.
- 5:44I you know?
- 5:45And there was no so politics became my competition and my you know, that's the drug
- 5:53that we go with.
- 5:53And so, anyway, long story to a to a very short question.
- 5:58I apologize.
- 5:59Oh, no.
- 6:00That's fine.
- 6:00I didn't know you were I didn't know you were a baseball guy.
- 6:03I I I never I never really tried baseball, but I bat and ball sports are not my forte.
- 6:10I do football and basketball.
- 6:11That that's that's my bread and butter.
- 6:13I played basketball all the time, and I played football in high school.
- 6:17But in any case, back to you getting back into politics.
- 6:21Like I said at the beginning, we all make mistakes, especially when we are starting off
- 6:25in a career.
- 6:27So for you, what were two to three of the big mistakes you made early on in your political
- 6:32consulting career?
- 6:33And how did you learn from and correct those missteps?
- 6:37That's a that's a really interesting question, and I appreciate you asking.
- 6:40I mean, I I think one of them was probably youthful arrogance, shall we say.
- 6:48You know?
- 6:48And and there wasn't a voter that I didn't consider unpersuadable.
- 6:55And if I just had creative enough media, if I just communicated enough with frequency, there
- 7:02was no voter in the universe that I couldn't convince to come over to my side.
- 7:09Now, again, now when I started, we weren't as polarized, we weren't as partisan as we are
- 7:14now, but still that's just an astronomically arrogant thing to think.
- 7:20So that's one mistake.
- 7:21Right?
- 7:22The second one, I think, is just more related to the ins and outs of politics in the sense
- 7:27that, you know, I felt in this business that if I took on very hard cases, people that I
- 7:35believed in, but were running in districts that maybe they weren't competitive in.
- 7:42And if we won some of those, that we would be lauded by the party and we would be lauded by
- 7:48the political establishment.
- 7:50That's not the case at all.
- 7:51In this business, in political business, especially on the consulting side, you are
- 7:56judged by your wins and losses, period.
- 8:00You are not judged by how many awards you win.
- 8:03You are not judged by how great your creative is, how great your strategy is, how many
- 8:09campaigns you win that you shouldn't win, how many times you perform 10 points above the
- 8:14baseline margin.
- 8:16It is a wins and loss game.
- 8:19And nobody gives you credit for the value and effort.
- 8:22So that may be a little cynical in the sense that, but if you're going to be in the
- 8:28consulting business in this day and age, then if you want to be successful, then you load up
- 8:37on incumbents, you load up on easy races and work in highly, highly gerrymandered races to
- 8:41where everything is in your favor.
- 8:43You get 10X your competition's resources and you win.
- 8:49Right?
- 8:50And so that was one mistake, was thinking that you were gonna get the attaboys and earn your
- 8:55way in.
- 8:56That's just not how this business works on on on the partisan side.
- 9:01So I think those are probably two of my big ones.
- 9:04The other third one is just taking so long to admit that I'm a political creature.
- 9:11And it's a funny story because here we are, and this is kind of one of those moments, right,
- 9:16Paul?
- 9:16So we're running this ad agency, and I have a a contractor who's a client, and he's been a
- 9:22client for a while.
- 9:24And he calls me into his office, and this was kind of the the the precipice point.
- 9:29And he fires me.
- 9:31And he says, I'm letting you go because every two years you go get involved in this political
- 9:37stuff and you ignore me.
- 9:40And I was ready to fight him and argue with him.
- 9:42And I'm like, nah, he's right.
- 9:44You know?
- 9:45And so that was the point to where we actually converted away from an ad agency into more of a
- 9:50general consulting and political only firm.
- 9:54So, you know, that's kind of one of those mistakes too.
- 9:57It took me a long path to admit who I truly am, which is this political monster.
- 10:06Maybe monster's a little bit over the top, but the the point about the persuasion, I actually
- 10:12just did my last episode just this this past week on persuasion versus mobilization and
- 10:18whether campaigns are about one or the other or both.
- 10:21And that was one of the points I made is no matter no matter how persuasive you think you
- 10:26are, there are some people that are just never gonna budge.
- 10:29But at the same time, there's also people that no matter what you do, they're always gonna
- 10:33stick with you just because they gotta, you know, stick with the team.
- 10:36But
- 10:36Absolutely.
- 10:37It it it is sorry.
- 10:39Go ahead.
- 10:40No, absolutely.
- 10:41You're correct.
- 10:42Oh, yeah.
- 10:43Yeah.
- 10:44So it'll try to and also when I was younger, when we're all younger when we're first getting
- 10:51politically acclimated when we're kids, It's usually the idea is that we all come together
- 10:59and debate all these things properly and we determine for ourselves who the best candidate
- 11:04is.
- 11:04Maybe there's a few people that do that, but for a lot of people, their decision has already
- 11:11been made.
- 11:12Yeah.
- 11:13I think if you work more than one campaign cycle, that gets beat out of it pretty quickly.
- 11:19Yeah.
- 11:19Yeah.
- 11:20Unfortunately.
- 11:20I mean, it's it's great to have core beliefs since it not just be easily swayed, but at the
- 11:24same time, it's good to be able to at least listen to other viewpoints.
- 11:29But that was talking about you.
- 11:31Now let's talk about maybe what you see in other political consultants or anybody else
- 11:37involved in politics, and I'm sure a lot of them have the same issues that you talk about.
- 11:41Like, I think most of us who have been in politics, we all have youthful arrogance at
- 11:47some point.
- 11:47But in general, whether you made these mistakes or not, what are two to three common errors
- 11:52that you see from political consultants, and what should they do instead?
- 11:57On the political consulting side or on the Or or just
- 12:01or or well, we'll we'll we'll talk a little bit more about some of the other facets of
- 12:05politics.
- 12:06But, yeah, let's focus on the political consulting side.
- 12:09On the consulting side, I think there's almost too much of a reliance on rules of thumb.
- 12:14Right?
- 12:14I mean, you know, you and I both share in the sense that we've got master's degrees from the
- 12:20University of Florida political campaign.
- 12:23So that's a very specific kind of extra education on the political process and things
- 12:28involved in it.
- 12:29Most political consultants don't.
- 12:32They come into it through and there's no continuing education for any type of clinical
- 12:38consultants.
- 12:39It's done by mentors, it's done by rules of thumb that are passed down, and it's done
- 12:46through experience.
- 12:48Most political consultants are rewarded for confidence as opposed to competence.
- 12:55So I think part of it is you rely a lot of political consultants rely too much on rules of
- 13:03thumb, and they rerun the campaign that was successful for them last, as opposed to, you
- 13:10know, researching and doing the data work to see if the groundwork has shifted.
- 13:17You know, we're all guilty of that.
- 13:19You know, I missed the first Trump election pretty badly because I refused and did not see
- 13:28a lot of voters that were activated because of Trump, you know, that were outside the normal
- 13:34universe of people that vote.
- 13:36So I think that's the biggest, I would say, bucket of mistakes that a lot of local
- 13:41consultants made because they're rerunning their last successive campaign as opposed to
- 13:46and relying on these rules of thumb as opposed to doing the work, you know, and and and
- 13:52looking at the data, doing the research, and making sure that the ground hasn't shifted.
- 13:58Yeah.
- 13:58It it to some extent, these rules of thumb, it it does make sense that use them as a baseline
- 14:03because there's they're rules of thumb for a reason.
- 14:05But like you said, every election's different.
- 14:09Everything's or every election's got their own unique circumstances.
- 14:13You might be able to use those rules of thumb as a baseline, but at the same time, you need
- 14:17to make sure that is this really holding up?
- 14:20Because as time marches on, things change.
- 14:23Now, obviously, there may be some very basic core things like most Democrats gonna vote
- 14:28Democrat, most Republicans gonna vote Republican, but how many of those people are
- 14:32gonna be like that, for example, you won't necessarily know until you actually do the
- 14:36research.
- 14:37And the thing with, you know, with Donald Trump, I think a lot of people forget.
- 14:41In the case of Donald Trump, was also easy to dismiss him because he had run-in 2008 and
- 14:462012, and I wanna say he ran in another campaign before then, and he really made very
- 14:53basically little noise at all.
- 14:55I remember it's just like a like a throwaway punchline by late night talk show host like a
- 15:00Jay Leno or Craig Ferguson about Donald Trump running for president.
- 15:05And then you fast forward to 2016, and all of a sudden he's or 2015, really, and he's already
- 15:10gaining steam, and he becomes the Republican presidential candidate.
- 15:14It's just like, wow.
- 15:16Times changed.
- 15:17I mean, yeah, the the rules of thumb of thinking somebody like that couldn't win for a
- 15:23while, that was a good rule of thumb, but then times change.
- 15:27So I I I I could definitely see a lot of people missing that part.
- 15:30Go ahead.
- 15:31Yeah.
- 15:31And I was gonna and I think the other mistake is, you know, so much of the press and and so
- 15:38much of the research is driven by presidential elections and congressional elections.
- 15:44Right?
- 15:44Maybe some senate elections.
- 15:46And a lot of times what you learn from those races cannot scale down.
- 15:52You know?
- 15:53And what I mean by that is, you know, local campaigns or state legislative campaigns are
- 16:00not going to have the resources to do the things that a presidential campaign can do.
- 16:06And so trying to do, I mean, like, I remember this came to a head, and this is, you know,
- 16:14many cycles ago, but the big fad at that time was modeling, right?
- 16:18We gotta create a model.
- 16:20Well, at that time, creating a model was 15 to $20,000, you know, and they weren't as
- 16:26prevalent as they are now and data wasn't as cheap, you know?
- 16:29So you would get down to a state ledge race and people like, we gotta have a model.
- 16:32And it's like, okay, give me $15,000.20.
- 16:36Oh, no.
- 16:37You know?
- 16:37And so a lot of that doesn't scale down.
- 16:41And so trying to replicate it doesn't work.
- 16:44I'll give you another example.
- 16:46For a long time, Twitter was the rage, right?
- 16:49You gotta be on Twitter to form the narrative.
- 16:52Well, I mean, come on.
- 16:53If you're in a legislative district, in a state house seat in the state of Florida, and you're
- 16:57working in a Republican primary, right, there may be nine, ten, 11,000 voters that you care
- 17:02about.
- 17:02How many of them are actually on Twitter?
- 17:05Right?
- 17:05Especially in a Republican primary where your voters are you know, so some of that stuff just
- 17:10doesn't scale down.
- 17:13And a lot of times, candidates get distracted by it, and I think consultants get distracted
- 17:18by it because everybody loves the new fad and the new toy, but it's just not possible.
- 17:24You know?
- 17:25So I think that's another big mistake that sometimes we make.
- 17:28Yeah.
- 17:28I I think I wanna say it was actually you that taught taught me this when you taught one of
- 17:33our mutual friend, Roger Austin's classes.
- 17:36For those who don't know, Roger Austin, he's another professor at the University of Florida,
- 17:41and he's a shall we say, he's a very unique character.
- 17:45All libertarians are.
- 17:46Think it
- 17:46was you.
- 17:48Yeah.
- 17:48I I think it was you, though, who who taught us that that the about the organic reach of of
- 17:56social media being I don't remember what the exact number was, but it was something
- 18:00incredibly low.
- 18:01Like, there far fewer people see social media posts than you think they do.
- 18:06And then, of course, now social media posts or social media companies have ways for you to
- 18:10boost your posts so you can get, you know, however many more people to look at.
- 18:15And then I think it was also you that said, like, over 50% of advertisements are fraud or
- 18:21something along those lines.
- 18:22Am I remembering that correctly?
- 18:23Yeah.
- 18:24I mean, there's considerable amount of research that, you know, almost half of Internet traffic
- 18:27is bot traffic.
- 18:29You know?
- 18:29Yeah.
- 18:30And now it's even more, you know, I mean, just personally on our personal website, you know, I
- 18:37mean, we're not a huge website for a company.
- 18:40Right?
- 18:40But we write a blog and we do get some traction.
- 18:43In the last sixty days, China and Singapore are the biggest viewers of my website by a factor
- 18:51of five.
- 18:52Know?
- 18:53And so some of that is AI bots training themselves.
- 18:57I mean, you could tell by how they're crawling the site if that's what's going You know?
- 19:02So, you know, even when I teach media to my students, it's it's hard for them to understand
- 19:10how much of this traffic they see on social media, whether it's TikTok or whatever, is fake
- 19:17generated AI bot content.
- 19:21You know?
- 19:22And that's, you know, that's for another podcast, Paul, but that's something that's
- 19:25very, very concerning as we move forward in this process.
- 19:29Yeah.
- 19:31Absolutely.
- 19:32Especially as social media becomes more and more important for for campaigning.
- 19:39And I just reminded me of another funny thing.
- 19:41I when when I was still at the political campaigning program at UF, I I I as I knew that
- 19:48Roger was gonna get a kick out of it where I found a a an article of this she she was some
- 19:56consultant for somewhere, and she said that the amount of advertising that campaigns do on
- 20:04social media was shockingly low, that it was like lower than 20%.
- 20:08And this was back, what, like 2018.
- 20:10So some campaigns may wanna rely more on social media, but if you just rely on the rule of
- 20:14thumb that, oh, you need to have a whole bunch of social media, not necessarily gonna help out
- 20:19your campaign.
- 20:20And it it so I just I just remembered that now, and and I I knew Roger would would get a a kick
- 20:27out of that one.
- 20:29Yeah.
- 20:29But yeah.
- 20:30So I mean, another example of that is, like, you gotta you have a 55 year old candidate
- 20:35that's running for office, right, for state senate, state house, and they've never created
- 20:42a social media presence before they decide to run for office.
- 20:45Right?
- 20:45So they fire up a Twitter account and they think, okay, you got a couple 100 followers,
- 20:51you know, and they don't know how the social media space works.
- 20:57Organic reach on these platforms, you know, is now less than 5%.
- 21:02They want you to buy it because they want the revenue.
- 21:06You know?
- 21:06So if you've got 200 followers at 5%, how many people are you talking to?
- 21:12You know?
- 21:12And so they end up farming it off to an intern who's operating.
- 21:17It's just, it could be a time suck.
- 21:20You know?
- 21:20Now, if you're running for the United States Senate, that's a whole different ballgame.
- 21:26You better have a pretty good social media data.
- 21:28So anyway, it's just that's where I go for these things sometimes just don't scale down
- 21:34and consultants are trying to do them because they're the latest fad in the press.
- 21:41And so I think that's a pretty big mistake that a lot of consultants make.
- 21:45Right.
- 21:46So this next question, we kind of answered it already, so I'm trying to think of how to
- 21:50rephrase it.
- 21:51But I I was talking about how I just did an episode about persuasion versus mobilization of
- 21:57voters.
- 21:57For people who haven't seen it, basically, persuasion means it's a voter that's up for
- 22:01grabs that you can possibly convince to come to your side, and mobilize means they're already
- 22:05on your side or more likely be on your side, and so you just gotta turn them out to vote.
- 22:09For you, Alex, do you think that some of it is we we we already talked about how they they
- 22:15falter on the fact that they think they're more persuasive than they actually are.
- 22:18But do you think some of the issue is maybe not necessarily that these voters some voters can't
- 22:26be persuaded, but more just that the actual persuasion tactics are faulty, whereas if they
- 22:33came up with something else that there could be more persuadable voters, or do you really think
- 22:37that's just that's not that much the case?
- 22:40Well, I I think it's a it's a pretty nuanced conversation.
- 22:43Right?
- 22:43And this goes back to even our last thing.
- 22:45It really depends on what type of race you're talking about.
- 22:49Because if you are in an open Republican primary, when I say open, I mean a non
- 22:55incumbent, you've got four candidates that are Republicans that are running in a primary or
- 23:00four Democrats that are running in a Democratic primary, And it's a closed system.
- 23:04So no one knows any of the candidates for the most part.
- 23:08Right?
- 23:08No.
- 23:08I think voters are persuadable then, depending upon who gets there first, what the frequency
- 23:14is, and how to communicate.
- 23:17But once you get into general elections and once you get into districts, and then when
- 23:23partisanship takes over, and when the heuristic and the shortcut is party ID, then that sliver
- 23:30of people who are persuadable is extremely small.
- 23:34And then when you start looking, well, okay, why about the independents?
- 23:37Well, the independents, as you know, mostly act as closeted partisans, right?
- 23:42Nothing binds independents together other than they don't like other party.
- 23:47And so then they become somewhat persuadable, but the persuasion tactic may be, are they
- 23:54gonna vote or not?
- 23:56And so again, I think it's a nuanced conversation, but if we're gonna blow it up to
- 24:01a general election kind of thing, no, I don't think in this day of hyper, hyper partisanship
- 24:08that many voters are left up to grab at the presidential level, at the state senate level,
- 24:15even at the county commission level.
- 24:20There's a case study that I really like in Alachua County, which is the county that I'm
- 24:24in.
- 24:24And if people don't know Alachua County, it's a fairly liberal county and has been for a long
- 24:29time.
- 24:30For the most part, Republicans in this county average 42%, right?
- 24:37And that's over a twenty year period over any type of countywide election.
- 24:43Republicans average 42.
- 24:46And that is at the presidential level, at the governorial level, at the county level.
- 24:52So the case study in this was really interesting.
- 24:54We had a Republican candidate that ran for one of the county constitutional officer, and he
- 25:01spent like $10,000 on his campaign.
- 25:05And then there was a Republican who was running in a fairly hot, at that time, county
- 25:12commission race and spent $800,000 on that candidate.
- 25:16Right?
- 25:17So a 10 to one difference.
- 25:19The election happened, and it was about a half a point difference in the eventual outcome.
- 25:24Right?
- 25:25And so that's when you start to see, okay, is this persuadable?
- 25:28Right?
- 25:29And I've had this intellectual debate with a lot of people.
- 25:32You know, you attended the University of Florida for your grad school.
- 25:36I'm a double gator.
- 25:37Right?
- 25:38Tim Tebow is the man.
- 25:41Right?
- 25:41Tim Tebow walks on water.
- 25:43If Tim Tebow wanted to take my daughter out, I would let Tim Tebow take my daughter out.
- 25:48I know Tim is married, but I mean, for all indications, Tim Tebow is an accomplished human
- 25:54being and a very, very nice person.
- 25:59Right?
- 26:00The minute he steps into politics and puts his name, whether he's a Democrat or Republican,
- 26:06half the people are gonna find reasons not to no longer like Tim Tebow, or they may like him,
- 26:10but they're never gonna vote for him.
- 26:13Right?
- 26:13So the thought experiment is in Alachua County, where the University of Florida is housed, if
- 26:19Tim Tebow ran as a Republican in Alachua County, would he be a viable electable
- 26:26candidate?
- 26:28And I think, you know, the answer is no.
- 26:32You know, you know, and again, this goes back to the research that I've looked at in the
- 26:36Locksworth County, every single countywide race for the last twenty six years, there have only
- 26:45been three times where a Republican has won the vote.
- 26:49One time it was Marco Rubio won with 42% of the vote when Charlie Crist was an independent
- 26:55split off.
- 26:56Right?
- 26:57The other two times were county commission races where the Democrat had a fatal flaw.
- 27:04So but if you put up a well resourced Democratic candidate, you put up a well
- 27:08resourced Republican candidate in this partisan environment, it's going to be sixty forty.
- 27:13Right?
- 27:14And so, again, the thought experiment.
- 27:16If Tim Tebow ran in Alachua County with all of his accolades at football, Heisman winner,
- 27:22great guy, Would he break 45% of the vote in Owachua County?
- 27:26I don't know if he would.
- 27:28I I feel like Tim Tebow would be one of the, like, handful of exceptions.
- 27:32Now whether he could win a reelection campaign when he has a whole term of policies of whether
- 27:39they agree or disagree, then maybe there's a difference or I feel like Tim Tebow, but
- 27:44generally speaking, I agree with you.
- 27:46Yeah.
- 27:46I I just When
- 27:47I With his Go ahead.
- 27:48With his with his strong, strong identity as a pro life candidate, I'm not sure he would get
- 27:57that well in Electoral County.
- 27:59Knowing the Democrats in Electoral County, even though that, you know, let's say you ran for
- 28:04county commission, right?
- 28:06And the life issue has almost nothing to do with being a county commissioner.
- 28:11The campaign would be about that.
- 28:14Okay.
- 28:14That, you know what, that's fair.
- 28:16In any case though, I do generally agree that it is it's like when people say, like, oh,
- 28:24well, you know, we should have somebody like The Rock run for president.
- 28:27And it's just like, yeah, a lot of people like him now.
- 28:30I mean, there seems to be a little bit less people seem to like him a little bit less, but
- 28:36whenever you use somebody who's, like, otherwise generally pretty well regarded some
- 28:40sort of celebrity and people like, oh, well, we just need to run them as a democrat or
- 28:44republican independent, whatever.
- 28:46I mean, a lot of times they use independence.
- 28:47Like, you think that's gonna persuade a lot more people than it actually is.
- 28:51Or or a lot of the people, you know, that we talk about that are persuadable.
- 28:56A lot of times they just don't show up to vote.
- 28:58So even if they can be convinced that you're the right candidate, are you gonna convince
- 29:02them to go vote?
- 29:04Even if they are persuadable, you still have to get them to go out to vote.
- 29:07And a lot of times, they just don't go to vote for whatever reason it may be.
- 29:15So you have a lot of experience in polling because you've done survey research, and you've
- 29:20you've just read read and done however many polls that you've done now.
- 29:24And that's another area I think a lot of mistakes are made, especially when it comes to
- 29:28people misunderstanding polls, but also how polls are made and even political professionals
- 29:35reading polls.
- 29:37Something you had written on LinkedIn had really piqued my interest there as talking
- 29:42about, like, how much are these these poll respondents not not how not so much how
- 29:49trustworthy they are, but how much are they willing to admit their real feelings.
- 29:52So I wanna ask you about a couple of things.
- 29:54What do you think are two to three of the big things that pollsters get wrong when they make
- 30:00polls, which can then adversely impact a campaign?
- 30:04Well, you know, I think it's obviously one of the things that people I don't think understand
- 30:12about colon, right, is when you do a poll and you pull a sample and when you we are trying to
- 30:20predict what an outcome is going to look like.
- 30:24Right?
- 30:25And that's not what I'm that's not the way to say that.
- 30:28We are trying to predict the composition of the electorate.
- 30:31Right?
- 30:32And so all of our polls are weighted towards that prediction.
- 30:36So if you are wrong in your prediction, then your polls are going to get skewed.
- 30:42You know?
- 30:43And that's what we saw, again, with with the Trump first election.
- 30:46Right?
- 30:46There was a block of voters that were activated because of Trump that did not have a history of
- 30:54prior voting.
- 30:57And so they were missed.
- 30:58And when they showed up, you saw the polls kind of all missed in the same direction.
- 31:03So that's an error on the pollsters in the sense that, okay, we our screens were too
- 31:08tight.
- 31:10We weren't going in.
- 31:11And so, you know, when Trump ran for reelection, one of the things that I did is I
- 31:16opened my screen up in the sense that I wasn't just relying on prior voting history.
- 31:22I was relying on prior voting history and their intent and what they told me they were gonna
- 31:26do.
- 31:26So the polls kind of adjusted and, you know, obviously, they're a little bit more accurate.
- 31:31I think the other thing, because again, polling is a business too.
- 31:36Right?
- 31:37There's a lot of junk polls out there.
- 31:39A lot of people are putting out a lot of, junk is the polite word, and they're trying to form
- 31:47the political environment, and they are not meant for research.
- 31:50Right?
- 31:50They are an exercise of public relations.
- 31:53You're trying to create the bandwidth effect for a candidate that you're working with or
- 31:57some other purpose.
- 31:58And again, that goes to the press being naive about why pollsters releasing stuff and or the
- 32:05public being naive on why pollsters are releasing stuff.
- 32:08You know, the good stuff never gets released ever.
- 32:10Right?
- 32:10That's all internal.
- 32:13And then I think the third one is because the polling industry is so competitive, is
- 32:19pollsters communicate with a certainty that mathematically does not exist in a poll.
- 32:25Right?
- 32:26Any pollster is going to tell you, yeah, we have a margin of error.
- 32:29It's plus or three, plus or minus three, plus or minus five.
- 32:32And they glance right over that.
- 32:34Right?
- 32:34And they will report that, you know, candidate A is at 40 or at 51, candidate B is at 49, and
- 32:42candidate A is definitely going to weigh.
- 32:45No.
- 32:46You know, that's within the margin of error.
- 32:48That is statistically a deadbeat.
- 32:51You know, so if we wake up on election day and the results are flipped, if you're a good
- 32:57pollster, that's not a surprise to you because you know that that's a mathematical possibility
- 33:02of a poll that you released.
- 33:05But you're not communicating uncertainty with your polls because the public and the press and
- 33:11nobody rewards that.
- 33:12Everybody wants certainty.
- 33:14Everybody wants confidence.
- 33:16No one wants nuance.
- 33:17Right?
- 33:18But as somebody that polls and somebody that consumes a lot of polls, you have to be able to
- 33:26sit with the uncertainty that is inherent in polling.
- 33:31Know, polling still remains the best instrument that we have for gauging public sentiment,
- 33:38public opinion, but you have to be able to sit with the uncertainty, and you have to be able
- 33:44to sit with the uncertainty of the math.
- 33:48I think that's probably the biggest mistake.
- 33:52Yeah.
- 33:53It's such a great point about the whole, you know, polls are they're they're more trying to
- 33:59gauge things, but, like, you can't be a 100% certain.
- 34:01If you deal the way you're a 100% certain is if you poll every single person, which is not
- 34:06feasible.
- 34:07This you have a sample for a reason.
- 34:09And, you know, without getting too technical for the people at home, basically, there's a
- 34:14mathematical equation where you basically get to a level of what we call 9599% confidence.
- 34:21So you you're you're not entirely certain, but you're very confident that this is the
- 34:27representation of how the electorate thinks, but it could be and it might be within a
- 34:33certain range, but it could be just outside that range.
- 34:35There's still a slight chance it could be.
- 34:37So without getting too into the weeds of that.
- 34:40You know, when I when I teach polling to my students, right, I'm like, okay.
- 34:45There are two things that we we have to communicate about a poll.
- 34:48One's the margin of error.
- 34:49Right?
- 34:49That's the inherent plus or minus.
- 34:51So that means in every if I give you a poll, in most polls, because of cost constraints, a good
- 34:58margin of error is plus or minus 5%.
- 35:00Right?
- 35:01So that means any number I report is in a band 5% higher and 5% lower.
- 35:07Right?
- 35:07That's a 10 swing that you have to put in there.
- 35:10But the second part of that is the 95% confidence level, which everybody glosses over,
- 35:15right?
- 35:16And how I explain that is, if we did this poll again, right, we are 95% confident that the
- 35:24result would fall within that 10 margin, right?
- 35:28So what that also means is there's a 5% chance that if we redid that poll again, it's outside
- 35:35that 10 band.
- 35:37You know?
- 35:37And if you've done enough polling, which I have, you're going to get a poll that's going
- 35:42to be an outlier that you just look at it and be like, what the hell just happened?
- 35:47You know?
- 35:48And, again, that's the math.
- 35:50If you poll enough, you're going to get an outlier poll.
- 35:53The question is is do you report it?
- 35:56Most pollsters will never report the outlier.
- 35:58You know, if they get something that's outside the conventional wisdom, they're not going to
- 36:02report it because, again, you know but you know mathematically there are outlier polls that are
- 36:10out there.
- 36:10So, anyway, the math allows for uncertainty.
- 36:14We as pollsters have no incentive to communicate the uncertainty.
- 36:19The press hates nuance and hates uncertainty.
- 36:23They'll kinda report it but gloss right over it.
- 36:26And my god, do candidates hate nuance and uncertainty.
- 36:29Right?
- 36:30I mean, their egos on the line, their elections on the line, they wanna know for certain, am I
- 36:36gonna win, you know, or where this is?
- 36:38And they they do not want nuance
- 36:42Yeah.
- 36:43Yeah.
- 36:43But there is, you you do hear people say like, oh, polls lied.
- 36:48They're like, no, it's they're trying to gauge things.
- 36:51They're not telling you this is exactly how it is.
- 36:55Might be exactly the divide in in public opinion at that particular time, but we're not
- 37:02saying that that is what it is.
- 37:03We're trying to gauge it as as as well as we can.
- 37:07But summary, like you said, some people assume nuance means you're you're lying, I guess.
- 37:12But that kind of gets more into this question now.
- 37:15So what are two or three of the big things that campaigns, candidates, and even pollsters get
- 37:23wrong when it comes to interpreting these poll results.
- 37:27So not necessarily that these polls are faulty, but even if the polls are sound, what do you
- 37:34think are some of the misinterpretations that happen a lot of the time?
- 37:37Again, I think it goes back to just not understanding the inherent uncertainty of any
- 37:44pair.
- 37:44Right?
- 37:45They're not as precise as all of us would like.
- 37:51Right?
- 37:53Any poll, even the best conducted poll, even the most expensive academically robust poll has
- 38:01uncertainty in it.
- 38:04And we just do a really poor job as an industry, as a business of communicating that
- 38:14uncertainty.
- 38:15And then the other one is, I think, when a pollster or a campaign or an interest group, if
- 38:25they're releasing a poll to the public, there's a PR component behind it.
- 38:31Right?
- 38:32And so you have to kind of look at that.
- 38:37I would be I think one of the most interesting research projects would be to go back and look
- 38:42at the last election and look at all the polling aggregates that were out there and see
- 38:49if there were some pollsters that were trying to gain, the aggregate pollsters.
- 38:54You know?
- 38:55Because I do think there's a large PR component to a lot of these polls that are released that
- 39:01the press gobbles up and they run with, like they love.
- 39:04The public, I don't think is unaware of that.
- 39:08So are some of these pollsters lines of strong worry?
- 39:13Are they shading?
- 39:14Are they skewing?
- 39:17Are they purposely choosing a weighting method that will skew something one or two points that
- 39:26way for PR purpose?
- 39:27I think there's a lot of that that goes on in the industry, You know?
- 39:31Because, you know, internally with my clients, the incentives are for me to be as accurate as
- 39:36possible.
- 39:38The incentives with the press and the public is and with clients when we go public is trying to
- 39:45create a narrative, you know, whether that is trying to create a horse race effect, trying to
- 39:50create a a bandwagon effect, inevitability, whatever you wanna call it.
- 39:56Any poll that gets released to the public has a PR function behind it.
- 40:01And I think that a lot of voters would be better to be, you know, just a little more
- 40:06skeptical of things that get released.
- 40:09Because, again, I will tell you the good stuff never gets released.
- 40:12Yeah.
- 40:13That that's another that's another one of my pet peeves is just how media covers polls.
- 40:17Now to be fair, it's always a two way street.
- 40:21You know, we can complain about the media and how they cover things, but at the same time, we
- 40:26as the consumers are responding to these media stories and how they cover things.
- 40:33So it behooves them to cover
- 40:37If I could
- 40:39way that we're responding to.
- 40:40If I could change anything about how the media respond reports polls is I would require them
- 40:46to have margin of error bars on other on all of the graphs so that they can show the margin of
- 40:52error on the results of the poll.
- 40:56I think that would actually go a long way to being helpful.
- 40:59Yeah.
- 41:00At the same time, though, I think some people, they they say, oh, this is a margin of error,
- 41:05but they don't really know what it is, and they still kind of gloss over that.
- 41:09Now at the same time, I think if the media tried to explain margin of error more clearly,
- 41:14I think still a lot of people would tune out because they don't wanna, like, get that much
- 41:19into the weeds.
- 41:19So I think it's a little bit on us as consumers, but it's also a little bit on the
- 41:24media as well.
- 41:24So I don't wanna absolve one or the other too much.
- 41:27But something that you had brought up before is, you know, those fake polls.
- 41:31I remember back in it must have been 2016, and and when May was still a thing, they they had a
- 41:38story about it.
- 41:39But it was that fake poll that said that Kid Rock would beat Debbie Stabenow as they had
- 41:44gone head to head in the election.
- 41:46It's just like, okay.
- 41:47Come on now.
- 41:48He never said anything about running for office, and people just ran with it because it
- 41:52sounded like a juicy story.
- 41:54That's pretty good.
- 41:55I mean, we should put out a poll of t Tim Tebow land in Alachua County.
- 41:58Right?
- 41:59Yeah.
- 42:00That that yeah.
- 42:01That that would be I mean, that would be all over the news in in Alachua County, I'm sure.
- 42:08But another pet peeve of mine, if you will, is when people also make is moving more from
- 42:15polling and more of the of the interpretation of actual election results.
- 42:20Something that really also bothers me is when people make declaration about declarations
- 42:25about how one year's elections or this one individual election at the state or local level
- 42:31is a bellwether of how all the next year's elections are going to go.
- 42:36Oh, this this one state senate race that's not even happening at a normal time of the year or
- 42:43even if it is happening at a normal time of the year, it's still in an odd numbered year, so
- 42:47you're having a lot of different voters.
- 42:49But in this case, I'm talking about 2025 elections being super predictive of twenty
- 42:54twenty six elections.
- 42:55So I'm gonna ask you about that.
- 42:57So what are some misconceptions and mistakes that are being made about takeaways from the
- 43:03twenty twenty five election?
- 43:04I would like you to give one to two takeaways each for Democrats, Republicans, and
- 43:10independents that they're getting wrong about the twenty twenty five elections.
- 43:14I I agree with you.
- 43:15That's a big pet peeve of mine.
- 43:17Right?
- 43:18A special election is special, you know, by definition.
- 43:22You know?
- 43:23And there are different dynamics.
- 43:24There are different money dynamics that go on.
- 43:26And so putting a pin in one election that happens in 2025 and trying to predict what's
- 43:31gonna happen in August and November 2026 is a fool's errand.
- 43:36Right?
- 43:37Now you can look at all of the data points, right, of all of the special elections and
- 43:43combine that with other polling and kind of say, okay.
- 43:47Do we see massive trends heading into 2025?
- 43:51Yes.
- 43:52The Democrats in any special election and most elections in 2025 are overperforming any type
- 43:57of baseline you wanna put in.
- 43:58Right?
- 43:59So that is a trend.
- 44:01The generic ballot question that we as pollsters track all over the place, that's a
- 44:07massive gap that's opening up.
- 44:09Right?
- 44:10I mean, I saw one the other day and there was a plus 14 in favor of the Democrats.
- 44:14Plus eight at the national level is a blowout territory.
- 44:18Plus 14 is ridiculous.
- 44:20Right?
- 44:21Now will that calm down?
- 44:22Probably.
- 44:23Right?
- 44:24But the mistake is, as we have seen in in this recent political cycle, oh my god, a week is a
- 44:34lifetime now in politics, Paul.
- 44:36You know?
- 44:36And if you're trying to take a trend in December in 2025 and extrapolate that out for
- 44:42eight months from now, oh my god.
- 44:45What's gonna happen in these eight months is ridiculous.
- 44:47Right?
- 44:48And then you also have fundamentals that are at fault.
- 44:50What's the economy going to do?
- 44:52What's the inflation going to do?
- 44:54You know, and right now, everybody right now is feeling the pinch.
- 44:58There's eight months, nine months, things can turn around in the economy.
- 45:03You know, do we anticipate that?
- 45:05I'll leave that up to economists.
- 45:07Right?
- 45:09So yes, in the sense that I agree with you 100%, seeing a single isolated result in 2025
- 45:16and trying to predict what's gonna happen in 2026 is a fool's errand in probably the
- 45:21borderline, one of the dumbest things that you do in politics.
- 45:25But if you look at all of the trays, right?
- 45:28I mean, are some significant headwinds coming into the election for the GOP right now.
- 45:34But the mistake is, you know, again, take a look at the senate map.
- 45:39Right?
- 45:40The United States senate map of those who are up for elections, the fundamentals are really
- 45:45guarded by the composition of those states.
- 45:51You know?
- 45:51I don't care if Republicans are overperforming I'm sorry.
- 45:56Democrats are overperforming by 16 points.
- 45:59A Democrat candidate is probably still not gonna win in Alabama.
- 46:02Right?
- 46:04And unless there's a fatal flaw like Roy Moore, then you saw a Democrat win.
- 46:09We can't get over enthusiastic about these things, but they can inform what we're looking
- 46:15at and how we're looking at 2026.
- 46:18You know?
- 46:19So, again, I think the biggest thing I have is, you know, eight, nine months from now, if you
- 46:24and I try to predict what the political environment's gonna be from nine months from
- 46:28now, oh my god.
- 46:29We're gonna miss 22,000,000 things that are gonna happen in that time frame.
- 46:34You know, if we try to predict what's gonna happen next week, Paul, we're gonna miss
- 46:3725,000,000 things that are gonna happen.
- 46:41Yeah.
- 46:41That that's that's another thing too is when people just get really early on about
- 46:46predicting things or, like, even when one presidential election finishes and people are
- 46:50like, okay.
- 46:51What's gonna happen four years from now?
- 46:52Like, can we settle down and and focus on what's gonna happen, like, in the next few
- 46:58months?
- 46:59Yeah.
- 46:59Like
- 47:00You know?
- 47:00It's And, again, even as a pollster, right, that's one of the things that I don't like in
- 47:07the sense that and one of the things that I'm privy to is people will look at a poll, a
- 47:13snapshot in time and try to extrapolate that out.
- 47:16I have the ability because I'm pulling so much.
- 47:19I'm seeing trends over time.
- 47:22And so that is much more helpful than looking at a single data point.
- 47:28It's the same thing with the, you know, special elections and elections happening in 2025.
- 47:32You know, as a whole, Democrats are significantly overperforming.
- 47:39Will that trend hold out for the next nine to ten months?
- 47:42It's the Democrats, you know, and who knows what they're gonna do.
- 47:45Yeah.
- 47:46But and and then also it's we're coming up on a election too.
- 47:49So is it really the 2025 elections being predictive of what's gonna happen in the
- 47:53midterms, or is it just we look back in midterm history and say, well, usually the party that's
- 47:58or the president's party just gets waxed.
- 48:02Especially, I mean, if you look at the first time that Donald Trump was in office, they
- 48:06Republicans lost, what was it, 40 seats, I think it was.
- 48:08So and then when Joe Biden was out in office, Democrats lost a bunch of seats too.
- 48:13So, you know, how much of it is just, you know, just the historical trend and how much of it is
- 48:192025, especially when very few states are having statewide or even state legislative
- 48:26elections happening in twenty twenty twenty twenty five a normal year.
- 48:30But like you said, though,
- 48:31it's it's
- 48:31you take everything into account.
- 48:33Go ahead.
- 48:34And we still we still don't know at the congressional level how all of these midterm
- 48:39redistrictings are going to turn out.
- 48:41Right?
- 48:41I mean, that's a major, major factor on the map.
- 48:44You know?
- 48:44And if Florida redistricts, you know, on the maps that I've seen, I mean, the Democrats
- 48:49could lose five seats coming out of Florida.
- 48:51Right?
- 48:51I mean, like that.
- 48:53So you know?
- 48:53But we still don't know what Florida's going to do.
- 48:56That's just a small example on the redistricting midterm.
- 49:00So there's still a lot of x factors to predict and try to figure out where they're going.
- 49:06And so, like you said, the polling in politics, we have to be able to sit with some
- 49:14uncertainty.
- 49:15And we are we as a public and as professionals and as political nerds, we are extremely
- 49:21uncomfortable sitting in that uncertainty.
- 49:25Yeah.
- 49:27Admittedly, I'm more from a personal standpoint, I don't like uncertainty either.
- 49:33I want things to be clear like, okay, this is going to happen.
- 49:36I don't like, it's the anxiety in me that's like, I can't have too much.
- 49:42That's unpredictable.
- 49:43Although although funny enough, it doesn't bother me as much when it comes to actually
- 49:47analyzing politics, so I don't know what that's about.
- 49:50But I I think another that I wonder if that's also tied to I remember reading not too long
- 49:56ago about I think it was a study that was put out this year, but basically people who are
- 50:01more polarized have this complete trying to think of the word, but just complete disgust
- 50:10with the idea that they could be that there's uncertainty.
- 50:14There's there's a very things are very certain in their mind.
- 50:16They they they almost can't even comprehend uncertainty, and you see that in a lot of
- 50:21polarized people.
- 50:22So I wonder if that might also be something to do with that.
- 50:25Obviously, that's that's kind of extrapolating a little bit, but I wonder if that's because
- 50:29you see a lot of candidates act in a polarized manner.
- 50:33Maybe that also leads into the they need certainty in their election state.
- 50:37Or is it or might just be because they're trying to win and they wanna be certain that
- 50:40they can win.
- 50:41I don't know.
- 50:41Might be Well,
- 50:42I I think that's probably a function.
- 50:44Like you said, polarized voters are very certain.
- 50:49Right?
- 50:49There's not a lot of uncertainty there.
- 50:52So if you're competing in a closed primary and it is a sixty forty gerrymander district, well,
- 51:00you better project certainty.
- 51:01You better reflect that back.
- 51:04Right?
- 51:04And so that's why we get a lot of people that get elected that don't sit with uncertainty and
- 51:10don't acknowledge nuance because it's not the incentives aren't lined up because when they
- 51:15campaign, they campaign in these highly polarized environments that are certain.
- 51:20So I think that's a very interesting point to make.
- 51:24Yeah.
- 51:25And so we're just about coming up on towards the end.
- 51:28But before then, it's not just the campaigns and the pollsters and and the candidates and
- 51:36and everybody that are making mistakes or have misunderstandings.
- 51:39But I think media and academics make mistakes a lot when it comes to analyzing campaigns too.
- 51:46We talked a little bit about the media earlier, but maybe we can focus a little bit more on the
- 51:51academic side because we were actually just talking earlier about, you know, the political
- 51:55campaigning program is a very unique blend of both the practical and the academic, and the
- 52:00practitioners have their blind spots and their strengths and then the academics have their
- 52:04blind spots and their strengths.
- 52:05But what do you think are two to three of the big issues that maybe not as much media unless
- 52:10you have something else to add there, but missed academics also make when it comes to
- 52:15analyzing campaigns?
- 52:17I think a lot of times they've missed what I would call the gist or the zeitgeist.
- 52:22Right?
- 52:23Let me rephrase that.
- 52:24So one, I think academics look backwards a lot of the time.
- 52:29Right?
- 52:30They're exploring things, you know, and so academics are still trying to unravel what
- 52:36happened in the first Trump election and the reelection.
- 52:42That's science is slow, right?
- 52:45And political science, especially when you deal with human behavior is extremely messy.
- 52:51And so I don't think it's a criticism of academia.
- 52:53I think it's just how academia is.
- 52:56They look backwards, Right?
- 52:58And so I think sometimes we all are gonna miss kind of the trends that are happening right
- 53:04now.
- 53:05I mean, trends that are happening as they go.
- 53:08I think the only other bias would be, or the only other mistake is just in what they choose
- 53:13to study.
- 53:14Right?
- 53:16And and sometimes they just are are missing the gist.
- 53:19You know?
- 53:20One of my one of the books that I hate in academia is the book of What's Wrong with
- 53:26Kansas.
- 53:27Do you remember that book?
- 53:29Where I
- 53:29I read they were looking that now.
- 53:31So they looked at Kansas voters in a sense, and they said, okay, Kansas voters, the thesis of
- 53:39the book is they're voting against their economic interest, right?
- 53:43Here's a bunch of people in Kansas that are relatively poor, they blah, blah, blah, blah,
- 53:49they keep voting Republican, right?
- 53:51They're voting against their own interest.
- 53:55And liberals couldn't figure out why Kansas voters were voting for conservatives.
- 54:03Right?
- 54:03But they're missing the gist of this because in that book, there's a set of values that are
- 54:11inherent of what defines what's in their interest.
- 54:14Right?
- 54:15And so I think a lot of times people just don't understand the voters in the sense that it's
- 54:21not a 10 plan.
- 54:23It's a gist, it's an attitude.
- 54:26It's not necessarily an opinion about a specific policy.
- 54:32And those things get all kind of wrapped up and untying those sometimes gets a little bit
- 54:36almost too nuanced.
- 54:38I'd have no idea if that made any sense at all, Paul.
- 54:41We could revisit that if you want to.
- 54:43No.
- 54:43No.
- 54:43No.
- 54:44I think I think it does.
- 54:45Although in the case of academics, I think sometimes they still let their their own
- 54:50political biases in a way like what you just talked about or how liberals couldn't
- 54:53understand why Kansas was a little conservative.
- 54:56It's like, I think conservatives and liberals often don't really understand why the other
- 55:01side votes the way they do, and they think their side, everybody should have the same
- 55:07interest as them.
- 55:08Why why don't so I I think a lot of times Republicans are gonna think that Democrats in
- 55:14Maryland, for example, are always voting against their their interests, and Democrats
- 55:19think that Republicans in Kansas are always gonna vote against their interests.
- 55:22I think that's just partially just their their political beliefs talking.
- 55:27I don't know if you necessarily agree with that.
- 55:29I I I but I do think that there's a little bit of that as well.
- 55:32So I I I think I I got, what you were, trying to say there.
- 55:36But there is that whole academics, political practitioners, media, they all have tunnel
- 55:44vision about their specific thing where academics, they can sit back and analyze all
- 55:49the races and and look back in time.
- 55:51They have all the time in the world to do that, but they're not the ones who are actually
- 55:56trying to win elections.
- 55:57Whereas the people who are winning elections, they don't necessarily really care that much
- 56:01about, you know, why things happened before.
- 56:03They just wanna know what's gonna win them the election now.
- 56:06And media, of course, is trying to generate clicks and views, but they're also the ones
- 56:12that are the sort of gateway for people to see both what academics and political political
- 56:20practitioners are doing.
- 56:22So it's it is one of those things even though it can it can be very easy to criticize all of
- 56:26them.
- 56:27They do have all their strengths and and weaknesses.
- 56:31At least
- 56:32You know?
- 56:32I I would say so.
- 56:33I don't know if you necessarily agree with it.
- 56:35No.
- 56:35And I love academic studies.
- 56:38I you know, I'm I'm such a nerd.
- 56:40I read them for fun, you know, because I do think they're very informative, and and and I
- 56:44think some academics are doing incredible work.
- 56:47Right?
- 56:49But I wish I could take many of them and put them behind the focus group glass, right?
- 56:55So they could actually see voters and how they are and it's a story I tell.
- 57:02We've done significant amount of research on clean energy throughout The United States.
- 57:08For whatever reason, that's kind of a niche that we've developed.
- 57:12And I'll never forget this focus group that we were in.
- 57:15And we were talking to a group of Republicans about energy and clean energy and that type of
- 57:21thing.
- 57:21Now this was, I don't know, but this was well after Al Gore's election.
- 57:27And I remember a voter who said something to the effect of something about a clean energy
- 57:34project.
- 57:35And he kinda raises his hand and he goes, is that that Al Gore?
- 57:40Because if it is, I'm against it.
- 57:41And that was it.
- 57:43You know, there was no argument on the clean energy side, on gigawatts, on megawatts, on
- 57:49however you wanted to make it.
- 57:51You know, clean energy was associated with Al Gore and his neurons, and that was it.
- 57:57That was the end of discussion.
- 57:58And I wish just those little moments, you know, if I weren't covered so tightly by NDAs, that I
- 58:04could just pump into academia every once in a while so they can kind of see how voters are
- 58:08making these connections.
- 58:10And sometimes it's not as logical as a lot of academics would like it to be.
- 58:16It's not as structured as a lot of academics would like it to be.
- 58:20Yeah.
- 58:21I think another thing with academics, because I find the studies fascinating too, they are
- 58:26incredibly informative.
- 58:27I use a lot of their data for my episodes, whether I have a a guest interview or not.
- 58:33I think, though, a lot of times they they really need to I wish they were made their
- 58:39content more accessible to regular people.
- 58:43Now to an extent, I get why to they can't like, when they when they give their articles to
- 58:51journals and the journals own a lot of the studies that they do at that point, they can't
- 58:55really necessarily share as freely the content they do because they technically don't own it
- 59:00anymore.
- 59:01So I I know there's that kind of a thing as well, but I think sometimes they just generally
- 59:07don't make their content as accessible as it could be.
- 59:12And I I think that another thing that they get tunnel vision about I was one of my classmates
- 59:18that from UF and I were talking about this one day is basically just this tunnel vision that
- 59:27they have about statistical significance.
- 59:32I forget the exact study he was talking about, but basically he found some sort of factor like
- 59:39race and income.
- 59:41Whatever it was he he he was looking at, they were not statistically significant when you
- 59:46would have expected race and income to have a very strong influence on whatever it was that
- 59:52the study was about.
- 59:53And he thought that was interesting, but somebody he was talking to who was who was an
- 59:57academic was saying, no.
- 59:59We don't we don't care about that.
- 1:00:00It's just like but if it's something that is not that is completely different than what you
- 1:00:06would expect, like if you expect race and income or whatever to have a strong impact for
- 1:00:13for for those at home, statistical significance, easiest way to describe it is
- 1:00:17that this that a factor has a likely has a significant impact on whatever it is that
- 1:00:25they're studying.
- 1:00:25That's probably the easiest way I could describe it.
- 1:00:27But just the fact that the only thing that matters is if something is statistically
- 1:00:33significant.
- 1:00:34It's like, well, no.
- 1:00:36If something isn't statistically significant and you expect it to be, I would think that
- 1:00:40that's pretty important stuff.
- 1:00:42So that that's that's another thing too as I think academics can get very stuffy and set in
- 1:00:47their ways too, kinda like what you were talking about with rules of thumb for political
- 1:00:52practitioners.
- 1:00:52I don't know if you've kind of encountered that yourself.
- 1:00:56Yeah.
- 1:00:56I will tell you that I 100% agree with you that, you know, this business model of these
- 1:01:02academic articles being put behind paywalls, if I had a magic wand, I would smash that business
- 1:01:08model.
- 1:01:09I would absolutely destroy it in the sense that most of these studies are done somewhat with
- 1:01:16federal research dollars and or state dollars.
- 1:01:19These are public taxpayer dollars that are paying for this research.
- 1:01:22This private business model putting them behind a paywall, I think is just silly.
- 1:01:28And the people performing a research don't get profit from a model.
- 1:01:33Just isn't it's insane.
- 1:01:35And I would smash that business model.
- 1:01:37Just give me the power, Paul.
- 1:01:39Do it in a heartbeat.
- 1:01:41If if I had the power, I I would I would do the same thing, man.
- 1:01:44But, yeah, it's that's that could be a whole other conversation too.
- 1:01:48Just, you know, the kinds of things that are wrong with that model.
- 1:01:52Unfortunately, don't have enough time to cover that today.
- 1:01:55But any before we get to the random question of the day, any final thoughts you'd like to leave
- 1:02:00us with in regards to mistakes made by political campaigns or anybody analyzing
- 1:02:06campaigns and how to correct those mistakes?
- 1:02:10You know, I think the biggest mistake that people make is thinking that this is easy.
- 1:02:17Right?
- 1:02:17I mean, I think candidates, especially we we've worked with a lot of first time candidates.
- 1:02:22And, you know, they've had some success in business or they've had some success in the
- 1:02:27civic, they're on chamber committees, they're on governmental committees.
- 1:02:33And they think that the transition to being an elected official and campaigning is easy.
- 1:02:37It's not, it's a very stressful process.
- 1:02:41You know?
- 1:02:42And I think a lot of people come into it naive.
- 1:02:46You know?
- 1:02:46And it's, I I guess, you know, Monday morning quarterback.
- 1:02:50Right?
- 1:02:50Everybody's a quarterback with the team loses on Monday.
- 1:02:54But this is hard.
- 1:02:55You know, human behavior is really messy.
- 1:02:58Trying to predict human behavior and why people vote the way they do.
- 1:03:02And it's hard, and there's a lot of uncertainty there.
- 1:03:06And so I think that's probably the biggest mistake is just candidates walking into it and
- 1:03:12or the press walking into it and thinking that this is an easy process.
- 1:03:16It's not.
- 1:03:18You know, I've had many candidates crying in my office.
- 1:03:22You know, it's a process and it takes a lot out of you.
- 1:03:28And, you know, so I I just think we should recognize that.
- 1:03:32So anybody that's thinking about getting into the politics into the political arena, they
- 1:03:37need to have that gut check moment of, okay, am I being naive about this?
- 1:03:41Do I think this is gonna be an easy walk?
- 1:03:44And you know, maybe I should talk to a couple of people that have been through this process
- 1:03:48before and have a couple of battle scars and maybe heed their advice.
- 1:03:55And and I think, you know, the system would benefit from that.
- 1:03:58Yeah.
- 1:04:00The point about unpredictability about human behavior is such a good point to make.
- 1:04:05Now, some people may look at, Well, you guys just said that people who are typically
- 1:04:09Democrat vote Democrat and Republicans vote Republican.
- 1:04:11That's true.
- 1:04:12There are some things about human behavior that are fairly predictable, but some things that
- 1:04:18when they when they when it's not predictable, it is very unpredictable, especially if you're
- 1:04:22looking at individuals.
- 1:04:23Yeah.
- 1:04:24Groups you can look at and say, well, generally speaking, they're gonna go this way.
- 1:04:28But when you talk about individual people and and really close elections, sometimes you just
- 1:04:34you have no idea what's gonna happen.
- 1:04:36And That's exact the aggregates the aggregate predictions are really easy.
- 1:04:40Right?
- 1:04:41Yeah.
- 1:04:41But the campaigns can be won on the micro ones that are not.
- 1:04:46Right?
- 1:04:46Yeah.
- 1:04:47Who are the Democrats that are not going to vote Democrat and why?
- 1:04:51You know?
- 1:04:52That's a much more difficult question than who the Democrats are gonna vote for the Democrats.
- 1:04:57Yeah.
- 1:04:58Yeah.
- 1:04:58Some people, like yeah.
- 1:04:59You they they always vote Democrat or they always vote Republican.
- 1:05:02You can always count on them, and they come out every election, but those ones are a little bit
- 1:05:07back and forth or even those very few that, like, I voted democrat my whole life.
- 1:05:12I voted republican my whole life.
- 1:05:13This time, I'm voting the other way.
- 1:05:16Every once in while, you get one of those.
- 1:05:17It's not common, but then sometimes they they change an election.
- 1:05:22So
- 1:05:23Yeah.
- 1:05:23And those are the voters that I really wanna talk to and just go, why?
- 1:05:26Tell me why.
- 1:05:28Because those are fascinating stories on how people make that turn.
- 1:05:32Yeah.
- 1:05:32That's something I wanted to do something with.
- 1:05:35I I don't know what to do, like, if I had a podcast episode or if I made a report or if I
- 1:05:40did a book about basically people you fully expect to do one thing and they don't.
- 1:05:47Why would the why would you do that?
- 1:05:49I I I don't I it's it's something I don't know how exactly I would delve into that if I even
- 1:05:54have the ability to, but that is it's it's the the people that are the most interesting are
- 1:05:59the ones that do what you least expect, I I I in in most cases.
- 1:06:02Cases.
- 1:06:03But great great points there.
- 1:06:06Well, that is gonna cover the the majority, the the main part of this interview, the the
- 1:06:12mistakes made by political campaigns.
- 1:06:14So we're gonna end off with a random question of the day for those of you who are new to the
- 1:06:19podcast.
- 1:06:20I always, with guests, come up with a random question of the day that is fun, nonpolitical,
- 1:06:25get a little bit of a different side of the guest I have on today.
- 1:06:31So, Alex, for you, I know you're a sports guy.
- 1:06:34So today's random question of the day is, what's one of the one of the most fun sporting
- 1:06:40events you've been to in person?
- 1:06:42And just doesn't have to be the most fun, just one that immediately comes to mind for you.
- 1:06:46It has to probably any of the University of Florida national championships.
- 1:06:51So those have always been exciting.
- 1:06:55The probably the most memorable one would be I went to the very first SEC football
- 1:07:01championship football team.
- 1:07:04That was in Birmingham, Alabama at the time.
- 1:07:07So that was the University of Alabama versus the Florida Gators.
- 1:07:11The Florida Gators were driving down to win in the fourth quarter, and Antonio Legum made an
- 1:07:16interception in Gators boots.
- 1:07:18Certainly, it was a heartbreaking loss heartbreaking loss, but one of the more
- 1:07:24memorable times I've had at a sporting event.
- 1:07:28So I would probably say, yeah.
- 1:07:30I'm not a much of a pro guy.
- 1:07:32I like baseball games, especially in the old historic stadiums, you know, Fenway, those
- 1:07:38types of things, I'll go any and all.
- 1:07:41But college football games with the pageantry and the history, nothing beats them.
- 1:07:49And so especially when any of our University of Florida teams are playing for national
- 1:07:55championship, that would be great.
- 1:07:57I'm not going to talk to you, Paul, about USS win over the University of Florida.
- 1:08:01I'm not going
- 1:08:02to do not I gonna bring that one up.
- 1:08:04I was not gonna right
- 1:08:05It on the on the top of your forehead.
- 1:08:08I saw it.
- 1:08:09It was coming.
- 1:08:10No.
- 1:08:10I I I made sure I was not gonna bring that one up specifically.
- 1:08:13I I will say when I was at the USF UF game, I was sitting almost completely up at at the top,
- 1:08:21and I I was I was hanging around nice people, but one of the one of the the mom, she had her
- 1:08:26kid who's probably, like, seven or eight year old, he looked at me and goes, why don't you
- 1:08:29like the Gators?
- 1:08:30Like, no.
- 1:08:31I don't just like the Gators.
- 1:08:32It's just USF comes first for me.
- 1:08:34Nothing against the Gators.
- 1:08:37But and he's a little kid, but that that was a that was a fun time, but that was not what I
- 1:08:42was gonna bring up.
- 1:08:42Although, real quick, before I bring up the one I was gonna say, did you go to the the the
- 1:08:48basketball national championship for the men's side?
- 1:08:50I've been
- 1:08:50This past one of them.
- 1:08:51I I didn't go to the most recent one.
- 1:08:53No.
- 1:08:53Okay.
- 1:08:54Gotcha.
- 1:08:54Man, that so that's it would have been o seven, o eight.
- 1:08:57Yeah.
- 1:08:58Right?
- 1:08:59Yeah.
- 1:08:59When Billy was here.
- 1:09:01Yeah.
- 1:09:01Okay.
- 1:09:01Yeah.
- 1:09:02That's that's sick, man.
- 1:09:03I would love to go to obvious obviously, you'd love to go to, like, a national championship,
- 1:09:07and then other ones like an army navy game.
- 1:09:10That would be sick too.
- 1:09:11Now the the game I was actually gonna bring up, which was not USF UF, I was not gonna do that
- 1:09:16to you.
- 1:09:16But the one I was gonna bring up was two years ago in basketball when USF played Florida
- 1:09:25Atlantic, and this was when we had coach Amir Abdul Rahim, rest in peace, for the one year.
- 1:09:33And as a USF fan, particularly with men's basketball, we do not exactly have a successful
- 1:09:40history to speak of.
- 1:09:41And this coach Amir just completely turned that around and showed us what was possible.
- 1:09:48That was just an incredible season, but that was the year after FAU had gone to the final
- 1:09:54four.
- 1:09:54And so they came to the Yingling Center.
- 1:09:57And I did not ever think I was gonna see the Yingling Center, which is USF's home basketball
- 1:10:04arena for those who don't know.
- 1:10:06I never thought I was gonna see that place sold out, and that place was sold out and an
- 1:10:12unbelievable atmosphere.
- 1:10:14We we were we were destroying them initially, and then the student section, I hope they
- 1:10:19learned their lesson.
- 1:10:20They started chanting overrated to FAU, and they almost came back and won, but we did hold
- 1:10:25them off.
- 1:10:25But that that was that was definitely one of the most amazing sporting events I've been to
- 1:10:32as well, especially because USF men's basketball does not have a whole lot of
- 1:10:37success.
- 1:10:37Now the the women's side has a good amount of success.
- 1:10:40The men's side doesn't quite have it, but, yeah, that there's just a lot of fun times I've
- 1:10:45I had there.
- 1:10:47I have a friend of mine in Orlando, and we have for years been talking about our dream trip is
- 1:10:55going to go to England and spend a week, ten days and do nothing but go to premier league
- 1:11:02games.
- 1:11:02Oh, yeah.
- 1:11:03So that's that's what we're working for.
- 1:11:05I would love, and I would probably allow you to amputate half of my arm if I was able to go to
- 1:11:12a world cup final.
- 1:11:13I would absolutely love a world cup final.
- 1:11:17I think that that would be just incredible.
- 1:11:20So, anyway, my my level of football goes both ways, football and soccer.
- 1:11:25Yeah.
- 1:11:26I I'm not the biggest soccer guy.
- 1:11:27I mean, I I will watch USF soccer, but I coached at the YMCA on this on the side too, so
- 1:11:33I do coach the kids in in in soccer too.
- 1:11:36So I I I don't I don't dislike, but I would def I would absolutely love to go to a World Cup
- 1:11:42game too.
- 1:11:42I mean, that that would be that would be awesome.
- 1:11:45And even as psychotic as some of the the fans can be, especially in the English Premier
- 1:11:50League, that that would be that would be cool to go to a a few of those games too.
- 1:11:55But, you know, I don't know if the the fan enthusiasm of the Premier League is any
- 1:12:01different than the fan enthusiasm of the SEC.
- 1:12:04I I really don't.
- 1:12:06Yeah.
- 1:12:07That that's that's that's a good point.
- 1:12:09It's yeah.
- 1:12:10It it it gets intense.
- 1:12:12It does.
- 1:12:13But as as much as I'd love to go on about this, obviously, we gotta wrap things up.
- 1:12:18So, Alex, thank you so much for coming on.
- 1:12:21But real quick, do you have any links that you want to share?
- 1:12:28I I just think the only thing if you wanna get in touch with me, ozeanmedia.com,
- 1:12:32ozean,media.com.
- 1:12:35We'd love to hear from you.
- 1:12:36Love feedback.
- 1:12:37We've got a blog that is, where I publish some of our research, some of our things that we're
- 1:12:42thinking about.
- 1:12:43So any comments there would be welcome.
- 1:12:46And, yeah, I I appreciate you having me on.
- 1:12:50I've had a very good time talking about the ins and outs of politics.
- 1:12:55And, again, thank you.
- 1:12:56It's been fun.
- 1:12:57Yeah.
- 1:12:58Absolutely.
- 1:12:58And and thank you again for for coming on to chat.
- 1:13:02It's good to see you again.
- 1:13:03Even you know, besides the coming coming up to Gainesville a couple months ago, I I don't
- 1:13:09think I'd well, I've talked to you before then, but I hadn't actually seen you since since you
- 1:13:13taught a couple of those classes when I was at UF.
- 1:13:16So thank you again for coming on here.
- 1:13:17But I'll I'll make sure to put the Osean Media link in the show notes.
- 1:13:23And for myself, my Facebook, Paul Raider author and speaker, my LinkedIn profile, which I write
- 1:13:28on pretty frequently, medium.com, which I also write on political science on from time to
- 1:13:33time, my book, Why Independents Rarely Win Elections, which you could buy on an ebook and
- 1:13:38paperback format on Amazon, my five day educational email course, which is free, you
- 1:13:43can sign up for, is also in the show notes on how we can more effectively mitigate
- 1:13:49polarization, and my email, PaulRayderWrightsgmail dot com.
- 1:13:55So that's gonna wrap things up.
- 1:13:57So thank you again, Alex, and thank you so much for those of you who are tuning in at home, and
- 1:14:02we'll see you next time.