Latest / This is Oregon / S2E2: Helping Kids Navigate Stress
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to This Is Oregon, a podcast where we take you inside research
- 0:04happening at the University of Oregon,
- 0:06and show you how it applies to your everyday life.
- 0:09I'm Ceara Wilson, your host for this episode.
- 0:12Our guest for this episode is Dr.
- 0:13Sunny Bai, Assistant Professor of Children's Behavioral Health
- 0:17and Psychology, whose research team is taking a look at children
- 0:21experiencing stressors and what that means for everyday parent-child interactions.
- 0:26Sunny, thank you so much for joining us.
- 0:28You describe yourself as a “family scientist”
- 0:30who's especially interested in the day-to-day realities of family life.
- 0:34Can you tell us more about what that looks like in your research
- 0:37and why studying the everyday is so important?
- 0:40Sure.
- 0:41So conceptually, what that means is that I study everyday interactions,
- 0:46like whether the youth thought that they had a fun day with their parent
- 0:49today, or whether they felt critiqued or criticized by their teachers.
- 0:53These everyday interactions seem relatively unimportant,
- 0:58but together they contribute to our general impressions
- 1:01about relationships that matter a lot to us,
- 1:04like how close we feel to the family or whether we feel safe at school.
- 1:10I also study everyday
- 1:11stressors that are unavoidable, like
- 1:15getting a bad grade on a test or feeling like someone's talking behind your back.
- 1:20Again, these on their own don't feel super harmful,
- 1:25but they give us a really important
- 1:28opportunity to practice different ways of coping
- 1:32and the way that respond to these stressors
- 1:35actually have implications for long-term mental health.
- 1:38I also use different types of approaches to really capture experiences
- 1:44as they are coming up and unfolding in everyday life.
- 1:48I conduct studies using ecological momentary assessments or brief surveys
- 1:53that participants can fill out sometimes several times a day over multiple days.
- 1:59And they help us get at questions like, “Right now, how do you feel?”
- 2:05Did you feel upset in the past two hours?” or “What happened at school today?”
- 2:10And then finally, I use
- 2:13naturalistic observational approaches or these are basically recordings,
- 2:18video recordings of everyday interactions
- 2:23that youth may be engaging in with family members or others.
- 2:27Sometimes that can be audio as well, or, others also record interactions
- 2:32that they might be having online on their smartphone.
- 2:35But all of these approaches really help us capture behaviors
- 2:41as they're, again, coming up, in daily life.
- 2:54Thinking about
- 2:56ways that you observe behavior
- 2:58such as recordings, what’s a method that you've used for that?
- 3:02Sure.
- 3:03I like to use what I call “naturalistic
- 3:07observational methods” or, “ecological behavioral methods.”
- 3:12And so let me just tell you what that looks like in the most recent study
- 3:15that I did. Yeah. Great.
- 3:16I really wanted to know
- 3:18how parents and kids are talking to each other after school,
- 3:22especially during, or on days when kids might have had
- 3:26some rough things happen to them during the during the school day.
- 3:30And so I had parents and kids install small cameras
- 3:34on the dashboard of their cars, and I asked them to turn it on or plug it in
- 3:39whenever they were in the car together, like going to soccer practice,
- 3:44maybe picking up takeout, going on a Target run— moments like that.
- 3:50Okay, so
- 3:50using dash cams in the car is a fascinating method.
- 3:53So why did you choose that approach
- 3:55and what kinds of things are you learning from those recordings
- 3:58that you might not get through, like a survey or an interview?
- 4:02Yeah, I chose that approach because what we're actually doing in daily
- 4:07life can look different from what we think we're doing, or what
- 4:11the other person thinks— maybe a mom is doing, or a dad is doing.
- 4:15So these behaviors or these observational methods
- 4:19that I use allow us to capture behaviors, as they're really unfolding.
- 4:25And we can capture those behaviors and measure them without
- 4:29the person's subjective
- 4:31sort of interpretation of the behaviors that are happening around them.
- 4:35So one particular type of interaction
- 4:39that we've really honed in on is support communication.
- 4:44And when I say support communication or supportive communication,
- 4:47what I'm referring to are conversations that convey, social support
- 4:52or conversations wherein the youth is seeking support.
- 4:56So we have recordings from 138 families,
- 5:00and so far we've done a deep dive into the first three.
- 5:05We've also looked at like an additional 50, but,
- 5:10the first
- 5:10deep dive with our first three families have shown
- 5:14that across a week or two,
- 5:18based on the recordings that we've collected,
- 5:21there are a total of about 52 episodes
- 5:24of supportive communication between the parent and the teen, where
- 5:28the teen was asking for help or signaling a need for support.
- 5:33And most of the time, parents responded to that
- 5:37need or picked up on that need, although not always.
- 5:40We found, for example, in this data that a type of support
- 5:45that we call informational support was the most common.
- 5:49We can think of informational support as advice giving or
- 5:53seeking clarification questions to get more information.
- 5:57And that's the kind of support we're seeing coming up the most
- 6:00in the day to day lives of, teens and their parents.
- 6:06To back it up, for our listeners briefly,
- 6:08can you walk us through the types of supportive communication definitions
- 6:12and how they showed up in this particular part of your research?
- 6:16Sure.
- 6:17So I was looking at five different types
- 6:20of support in my research.
- 6:23The first is emotional support,
- 6:25and that is where you make someone feel understood and cared for.
- 6:29The second type is informational support, which is providing advice or information.
- 6:35The third type is esteem support where you are trying
- 6:38to build someone else's self-confidence or self-concept.
- 6:42The fourth is social presence: just being there,
- 6:45which all of these parents were.
- 6:47And then the last one is tangible support or instrumental support.
- 6:51And this is where you're really trying to do practical things
- 6:55to help someone like take them to practice.
- 6:58We know that support of all types is really important for youth, mental
- 7:03health and teens who report that they are feeling supported
- 7:07and that they have people to turn to, tend to have fewer symptoms
- 7:11of mental health problems or mental distress.
- 7:15But there's a lot of nuance to this that remains
- 7:18somewhat underexplored, and that's what I'm really trying to do.
- 7:22Not everyone wants support in the same way,
- 7:25and not every situation calls for the same kind of support.
- 7:30We know that's true from adults, but we're not quite sure how this looks
- 7:34for teens who are really figuring out their preferences and their styles.
- 7:39Okay, so what you have found in your research
- 7:43is that the informational has so far been most common,
- 7:47and emotional is also something that the youth—our youth are seeking?
- 7:52Yeah.
- 7:53So as I mentioned earlier in the three families that we've done a deep dive
- 7:57on, we saw 52 episodes of supportive communication and informational support
- 8:03showed up in almost every single episode that we identified.
- 8:07And then emotional support came up,
- 8:09although a little less than half the time.
- 8:12Some things we just couldn't measure, like social presence we couldn't really
- 8:15measure because the parent and the teen were together all the time.
- 8:19And then tangible support was a little bit hard to measure using this approach,
- 8:24because the parent and the teen were stuck in cars, but that was okay.
- 8:27We wanted to know what transpired in everyday conversations
- 8:31and informational support actually make a lot of sense.
- 8:34If you think about your own relationship with your caregivers or your youth.
- 8:40Informational support, was considered to be present
- 8:44when the parent asked a lot of clarification questions to maybe
- 8:48convey their interest, get more information, get a better
- 8:52understanding of the child's situation, and/or provided advice and opinions.
- 8:58And we found that parents were doing a lot of clarification seeking
- 9:02when the child was bringing up a negative event or a negative experience,
- 9:06and so that came up really almost all the time.
- 9:10And we found
- 9:12that or in conversations with my colleagues in communication
- 9:15sciences, I actually found that that was not that surprising.
- 9:19Although as a psychologist, I did find it somewhat surprising.
- 9:23He said that advice giving is the most common form of support,
- 9:27even among adults, and so I guess that's what we're all really compelled to do.
- 9:32Wonderful.
- 9:33So pivoting slightly, what has data
- 9:36from surveys that are filled out shown so far?
- 9:39Yeah.
- 9:40So we had the parents and youth
- 9:41complete surveys about how they want to be supported
- 9:44and what they're doing to support their teen at the onset of the study.
- 9:50And we've analyzed that data, together with my students, Gauri Bharadwaj
- 9:55and Serena Wu, and they found that—they found a few things.
- 10:01Specifically, we were interested in how these,
- 10:05supportive communication preferences and perspectives
- 10:09were associated with youth mental health,
- 10:12and what youth wanted, and what the parents felt like they were giving.
- 10:16So youth wanted esteem support the least,
- 10:21and also they reported receiving it the least.
- 10:24Parents, as I mentioned, reported providing esteem support the least,
- 10:29and they also reported that they provided informational support
- 10:33at relatively lower levels, which is interesting because in our
- 10:38observational data, we actually saw quite a bit of informational support.
- 10:42We saw overall that when youth received a lot of
- 10:49emotional support from their parents,
- 10:51they were doing quite well, as in, they reported the lowest levels of depression,
- 10:57when youth sought out a lot of informational support
- 11:01from their parents, they were also doing quite well relative to other youth.
- 11:05Again, meaning that they reported lower levels of depression.
- 11:09Interestingly, youth who wanted more esteem support
- 11:14than the average peer
- 11:17were showing greater levels of depression.
- 11:21We also found some interesting patterns between like what
- 11:26the youth wanted and what the parents said that they were giving.
- 11:29So, for example, one really interesting finding we noticed
- 11:34was that regardless of how much they want, if there is like a mismatch
- 11:39between the amount of informational support that the youth wants
- 11:44and the amount of informational support that the parent is giving,
- 11:49that was very associated with youth depression,
- 11:53and specifically if the youth were
- 11:55receiving more than what they wanted.
- 11:58So if they were getting too much informational support,
- 12:02those kiddos were reporting higher levels of depression symptoms.
- 12:06Oh, interesting.
- 12:07And I think that's really interesting because I know the student
- 12:10probably—or I mentioned this really briefly
- 12:14just a little bit ago—but in general, kids wanted informational support.
- 12:19So like, informational support on its own is not a bad thing.
- 12:23And in fact, we think that it can reflect, problem solving and coping.
- 12:28The child wants to receive advice to figure out what to do
- 12:32when they're presented with a problem, and that's a good thing.
- 12:36But when the youth is wanting more
- 12:39than what they feel like they're needing, then that can,
- 12:43we're seeing that
- 12:44that being correlated with depression symptoms
- 12:47and what we think might be going on there is that perhaps,
- 12:52these youth are as I've already mentioned, maybe getting too much help.
- 12:58Yes, it definitely sounds like there can be a mismatch between
- 13:01the support that kids are looking for and the support that the parents
- 13:05tend to offer them—some interesting gaps and mismatches there.
- 13:10Seems like that can really make a difference.
- 13:13Yeah, and actually, we know from the couples literature,
- 13:17or research on couples, that looking at these matches or
- 13:23balance, I guess, of support seeking
- 13:25and support provision is really important.
- 13:29For example, in couples, there's this idea of invisible support,
- 13:34where support is most helpful and most effective
- 13:39when the receiver doesn't even know that they're getting that help.
- 13:43And I think what we're seeing with this “informational support
- 13:47mismatch” piece is perhaps that yes, it's helpful for youth.
- 13:52They want it, but if they feel like they're getting too much of it,
- 13:56it's going in the opposite direction of invisible support.
- 13:59It's very visible.
- 14:01And perhaps leading youth to feel,
- 14:04like they don't have autonomy
- 14:07or they don't have a lot of power to make their own decisions.
- 14:11That's just one possible explanation.
- 14:13Yeah, it sounds like that balance can be sometimes difficult to manage.
- 14:17Yeah, absolutely, and I don't want any parent to feel like
- 14:21providing advice or asking clarification questions is bad.
- 14:25It's actually very helpful, and most youth want some level of that.
- 14:31But also being attuned to what the youth is needing,
- 14:37and also being really cognizant of the youth’s
- 14:41developing autonomy, I think is really important during this period.
- 14:44Yeah, absolutely.
- 14:47Well, since it is back to school season,
- 14:49I would love to ask you a question about school stress
- 14:53and how that spills over into the home and what can parents do to better
- 14:57support their kids through those everyday stressors?
- 15:01Sure. I'm happy to talk about that.
- 15:03In some of my previous work, I looked that stress spill over
- 15:08and, that was actually one of the reasons I wanted to look at supportive
- 15:11communication spill over is how stress in one
- 15:15area affects, another.
- 15:18So how stress at school can affect the home life,
- 15:22or how it spills over into the home within the same day or even the next day?
- 15:27So in a prior study, I looked at
- 15:29whether parent-child conflict increased on days
- 15:34when youth experienced more stress at school.
- 15:37That is, did stress at school spill over into the home and create more stress?
- 15:42What we found was that following difficult days at school,
- 15:46the youth felt like they argued more with their parents, mothers and fathers,
- 15:52and they were less warm and fuzzy with their mothers and fathers.
- 15:56And this pattern was mediated by mood.
- 15:58And what that means is, when the youth had a rough day at school, they felt worse.
- 16:04And that worse sort of mood contributed to this feeling
- 16:08that they, got into more arguments with their or this, this perception
- 16:12that they got into more arguments with their parents—mothers and fathers—and
- 16:15that it was less satisfying the interactions at home.
- 16:19So I thought that kids who are coming from generally
- 16:23very close knit families would be somewhat protected from the spillover effect.
- 16:28No matter what happens at school,
- 16:29they feel really good about the time that they're spending with their parents.
- 16:33But what I found was kids who are close here to their parents
- 16:37and coming from more tight knit families, they were experiencing
- 16:41the greatest level of spillover, and that closeness
- 16:44really seemed to amplify the spillover effect.
- 16:48The other piece that was somewhat interesting
- 16:50was that parents actually didn't notice a change in their interaction quality.
- 16:55Parents were like, “Things are normal,”
- 16:57and it was really the youth who was perceiving that they are getting
- 17:01into more arguments with their parents and that they were less close.
- 17:04So it could be that things are okay
- 17:08on the whole and still, of course, youth perceptions matter.
- 17:13Yeah, yeah, it would seem to me that, you know,
- 17:17parents—coming from a parent myself—of thinking like, “Oh,
- 17:20they just had a bad day.” Yeah and I think that's a really reasonable response.
- 17:27And actually,
- 17:29it could also mean that even though the youth feels like there are more
- 17:32or the adolescent feels like they were more distant from their parent,
- 17:36maybe those negative feelings didn't like,
- 17:39manifest behaviorally.
- 17:42That's so great.
- 17:43So what can parents do in these sorts of instances?
- 17:47I think—so thinking about
- 17:51both research studies that I just had the opportunity to share,
- 17:55I think first, we definitely want parents to be offering emotional support
- 18:00and to be present, if possible, if their work schedules allow.
- 18:04And our survey data has shown that
- 18:08kids can never have too much emotional support.
- 18:13We also know from other work that emotional support or like providing
- 18:16comfort, showing understanding and care is very potent and very helpful.
- 18:22I think it’s also helpful for parents to be available
- 18:26if the child is seeking information or signaling
- 18:30a need to talk about their day more, or get advice, or get questions.
- 18:36It's a really—or get questions answered.
- 18:40Many kids
- 18:40do share about their day, although not everybody does.
- 18:44And if the child is seeking the parents perspective, it's a really great moment
- 18:48to reinforce problem solving and helpful advice seeking.
- 18:53Those are really good coping skills, very proactive.
- 18:57At the same time, we want to resist the urge
- 19:00to interrogate and sort of be that interviewer.
- 19:03I know parents want to ask a lot of questions,
- 19:06but we have to
- 19:09maybe, do that kind of question asking or asking for details,
- 19:14sort of at the level that the child is seeking.
- 19:18The kid also, or the youth will have bad days, and I think as humans,
- 19:22we all know that there are bad days and there are good days.
- 19:26So just remembering to balance the bad days with fun days, or a lighter
- 19:31sort of relaxing days, I think is important.
- 19:34And,
- 19:35my research at least seems to suggest that when you are close with your child,
- 19:39you may get the full range of emotions, both the irritability
- 19:44and the joy and that's not the worst thing.
- 19:50Yeah,
- 19:52“both
- 19:52the irritability and the joy,” I love that.
- 19:56So, Sunny, as you've been working on this research,
- 19:59what has been come as a surprise to you?
- 20:02Has any of your findings challenged your assumptions?
- 20:07Yeah.
- 20:08One thing that we hear from
- 20:12colleagues is like, “How authentic
- 20:15are families really when
- 20:19know that they're being video recorded,
- 20:21or observed on video, or observed
- 20:24either through direct recording or their phone?”
- 20:27One thing that really surprises me, aside from all the interesting findings
- 20:32that I had the opportunity to chat about today, is that people,
- 20:35surprisingly, are showing their authentic selves.
- 20:38And maybe it's not the most authentic.
- 20:40We would never know, right?
- 20:41Because we don't get to be true flies on the wall.
- 20:46But, we are seeing a good range of behaviors, interaction types.
- 20:51Every family is different,
- 20:54and there are just so many different ways
- 20:57that parents are connecting with their kids and caring for their kids.
- 21:02And it's just really inspiring
- 21:05and fun, and it gives me really good ideas.
- 21:08And so,
- 21:10yeah, I think that's like the one thing that I've been the most surprised by.
- 21:13There is so much diversity, so much individuality,
- 21:16and at the same time just care.
- 21:19That's great.
- 21:20Fascinating stuff.
- 21:21Well, Doctor
- 21:22Sunny Bai, thank you so much for your time and sharing your research with us today.
- 21:26Any final thoughts you'd like to share with us?
- 21:29No, thank you so much for having me.
- 21:32Thanks again for joining us today.
- 21:36If you're interested in learning more,
- 21:37check out the links in the episode description, and don't forget to follow
- 21:40This Is Oregon for more stories from the University of Oregon.
- 21:44We'll see you on the next episode.
- 21:47This Is Oregon
- 21:48is produced by the Division of University Communications.
- 21:51For more of the latest University of Oregon
- 21:53research and news, visit news.uoregon.edu
- 21:57or find us on your favorite social media platform using the handle @uoregon.
- 22:01Thanks for listening and Go Ducks!