Latest / Fintech Conversations with Fexingo: Banking, Payments, and Financial Software Companies / Why Digital Banking License Race Is Reshaping Fintech in 2026
Transcript
- Lucas: You’ve probably noticed this year that more and more fintechs aren’t just partnering with banks—they’re trying to become banks themselves. I’m talking about the digital banking license race, and it is reshaping the entire fintech landscape in 2026. Luna: Yeah, it feels like every week there’s a new announcement. SoFi got their charter years ago, but now you’ve got Upgrade, MoneyLion, even Square making moves. Lucas: Exactly. And the question is: why now? Especially when the regulatory burden is enormous. A full bank charter means FDIC scrutiny, higher capital requirements, and compliance costs that can run tens of millions a year. Luna: So what’s the upside that makes it worth it? I’d assume it’s about margins. Lucas: Look, it literally pays to be a bank. And this part of the show is brought to you by the listeners who chip in monthly at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That’s what keeps this ad-free and lets us dig into topics like this without selling sponsors. So if you get value from these conversations, it’s a small way to keep them going. Luna: Absolutely. We don’t run ads, so listener support is what funds the research and production. It really helps. Lucas: Alright, back to the license race. The core economic advantage is the ability to hold deposits directly rather than through a partner bank. When you’re a fintech partnering with a bank like Sutton or Evolve, you might get a 50-basis-point spread on deposits. But if you’re a chartered bank, you can lend out those deposits—fractional reserve banking—and earn maybe 4 to 5 percent net interest margin. Luna: That’s an order of magnitude difference. So the fintech effectively doubles or triples its revenue per user just by cutting out the middleman. Lucas: Right. Take SoFi as the canonical example. They got their national bank charter in early 2022, started operating under it in 2023. Before that, their funding cost on deposits was roughly what they paid to partner banks—call it 2 percent. After? They now pay around 0.5 percent on their own savings accounts, and they lend out at 8 to 10 percent on personal loans. That’s a 300-basis-point advantage on the funding side alone. Luna: And they’ve been able to offer competitive rates to attract deposits. I think they crossed $20 billion in deposits last year? Lucas: Closer to $25 billion by Q1 2026, if I remember the last earnings call. But the key point is that the deposit base is stable and cheap. They’re not subject to the whims of a partner bank deciding to renegotiate terms. Luna: But isn’t the application process itself a huge barrier? I’ve heard it takes years and costs tens of millions in legal fees alone. Lucas: It’s brutal. The OCC and FDIC have a rigorous process. You need a proven management team, a viable business plan, and enough capital—typically at least $20 million in Tier 1 capital for a de novo charter. And then there’s the ongoing compliance: BSA/AML, CRA, fair lending. It’s not for everyone. Luna: So which fintechs are actually making the leap? Beyond SoFi. Lucas: Upgrade is a fascinating case. They applied for an industrial bank charter in Utah in 2023 and finally got approval in 2025. They’re now originating loans through their own bank, which gives them more control over underwriting and pricing. Their CEO, Renaud Laplanche, has said the charter reduces their cost of funds by over 100 basis points. Luna: And Square? That’s a different beast. Block is already huge, but they’ve been slowly building a banking infrastructure. Lucas: They acquired a small industrial bank in 2023 and are now rolling out Square Banking products—checking accounts, savings, and loans for merchants. Their advantage is that they already have millions of small businesses processing payments through them. If they can offer a full banking relationship, they lock in that merchant and capture more of their cash flow. Luna: It’s a retention play as much as a margin play. Lucas: Exactly. And then there’s the buy now, pay later players. Affirm and Klarna have both explored charters, though neither has fully committed. Affirm actually applied for a Utah industrial bank charter in 2024 but withdrew it later that year. The regulatory scrutiny around BNPL lending is intense, and the capital requirements would eat into their return on equity. Luna: So it’s not a no-brainer. There are trade-offs. Lucas: Huge trade-offs. Once you’re a bank, you’re subject to the Community Reinvestment Act, which requires you to lend in low-income communities. You have to pass stress tests. Your capital ratio is public. And if you screw up, the FDIC can shut you down. That’s a far cry from the nimble, lightly regulated fintech model. Luna: So who should pursue a charter? It seems like only the largest, most profitable fintechs can justify it. Lucas: That’s the pattern. SoFi, Upgrade, Square—they all have significant lending operations and large user bases. For a smaller neobank like Chime, which doesn’t lend at all, a charter might not make sense. They earn interchange fees and subscription revenue, so the margin benefit of holding deposits is less compelling. Luna: But Chime has actually talked about a charter. I think they filed something in 2024? Lucas: They did. But they withdrew it. The CEO said at the time that the compliance burden would distract from their core product innovation. That’s a valid argument—being a bank means you spend a lot of time on regulatory reporting instead of building features. Luna: Let’s talk about the fractional reserve aspect. When a fintech becomes a bank, they can lend out deposits. But that also introduces credit risk that they didn’t have before. Lucas: Absolutely. Before, the partner bank held the credit risk. Now the fintech has to manage loan losses, which can be volatile. During the 2023 regional banking crisis, some fintechs that had bank charters saw their stock prices hammered because investors worried about deposit runs and credit quality. Luna: But for those that survive, the payoff seems real. SoFi’s net interest margin is over 5 percent now, compared to maybe 2 percent for a traditional bank. That’s the power of a low-cost digital deposit base. Lucas: And that margin advantage is why we’re seeing more applications. In 2025, the OCC received a record 12 de novo bank applications from fintech-related entities. That’s up from maybe 2 or 3 a year in the early 2020s. Luna: So what’s the endgame? Do we end up with 50 digital banks, or does consolidation kick in? Lucas: I think consolidation is inevitable. The cost of compliance doesn’t scale linearly—you need a certain deposit base to make the math work. My guess is we’ll see maybe 15 to 20 successful digital banks in the US within five years, and the rest will either get acquired or retreat to partnership models. Luna: Interesting. So for a fintech startup listening today, the message might be: don’t rush into a charter until you have the scale. Lucas: Exactly. Build the user base, prove the lending model, and then consider the charter as a leverage play, not a first move. The ones who jumped too early—like some of the 2021 SPAC neobanks that tried to become banks overnight—are now struggling. Luna: It really is a strategic decision that can define a company’s entire trajectory. Lucas: And it’s a great example of how regulation is shaping fintech innovation in 2026. The license isn’t just a badge—it’s a fundamental business model choice.