Latest / Building Real / A New Parcel Every Week. Then She Found Out What It Cost. | Priyanka Shahra
Transcript
- Priyanka: Fashion is the second largest polluting industry globally. There are a hundred billion garments produced every single year. Think about the population we have, think about the number of people that actually have access to those garments. So the amount of waste is colossal. the way I had been consuming has really resulted in this problem. that's when I started thinking about how do we now solve this problem of the excess clothing that actually exists. One way to do it is to create brands that are more sustainable, that don't have the environmental degradation problems, But another way is just to preserve the resources we already have. Arjun Thomas: Priyanka, thank you again for taking the time to have this chat with me and good morning. Priyanka: Good morning and thank you for having me on this chat. Arjun Thomas: when I first started looking through what you did, the initial impression and and and pardon me here was that this was a fashion brand, when I kind of looked at your website and the stuff that you did. And the thing that came to my mind is that my knowledge of the fashion industry is limited to the, you know, three, four shirts that I have, that are right at the top of my pile and it keeps getting recycled because the twenty under that never see the light of day. I'm kind of a boring clothes wearer. but I'm curious as I dug in a little bit more, there's a lot more to the story than than just fashion. and I wanted to get your take on on what Swapaholic does and why it's different from other clothing brands or most clothing brands. Priyanka: I think to talk about swapping or swap a holic, we have to frame the problem. Fashion is the second largest polluting industry globally. There are a hundred billion garments produced every single year. Think about the population we have, think about the number of people that actually have access to those garments. So the amount of waste is colossal. And so that's really where we step in. Now, why me, why swapaholic? Because I think I was one of the perpetrators. When Arjun Thomas: Mm. Priyanka: I was in my early twenties, ASOS and I lived in India at the time. ASOS, this giant fashion brand, or it was a marketplace at the time and now it also has a brand, had just started shipping to India. So Arjun Thomas: Mm. Priyanka: I had a parcel at my doorstep every single week, wearing it as a badge of honor that I had new outfits to wear week on week. I really didn't stop to think for once how it could be so cheap that I, as a 20-something year old, could afford all of those clothes and so frequently. Sustainability was really not even a buzzword. No one was talking about it. No one understood what it meant. It was very esoteric at the time. And cut to a few years later, when I did my masters, I started thinking about this and I realized that the way I had been consuming has really resulted in this problem. And so that's when I started thinking about how do we now solve this problem of the excess clothing that actually exists. One way to do it is to create brands that are more sustainable, that don't have the environmental degradation problems, which is another conversation to have. But another way is just to preserve the resources we already have. Because looking at my closet week on week, having new parcels, having new items in my closet, just like you shared, I wasn't using 90% of what I had. I was just using the stuff that came in that was new and clothes, perhaps I wasn't disposing them, but I did have the disposal mindset where I wasn't really can being considerate of the ones that I already had in my closet. And so that's really where the concept of swapping really appealed to me. And that's how we began the journey because I thought if we use, if we reuse things that we already have, that will slow down the pace of the passion industry. And that was really the goal with which we began. Today, there are multiple things you can do at Swapaholic. You can swap with us, so you can swap your fashion. We have a proprietary point system that we developed 10 years ago, almost 10 years ago now. You swap in your clothes, you get system generated points because no two clothes are equal, ask any fashionist at. And you can use those points over a period of six months to swap out anything you like. You can also sell your closet with us. Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Priyanka: As a sustainable brand, you can also sell your products with us. As a brand that is closing down or has past season stocks, you can also circulate those clothes with us. So the idea is really to rescue everything that has found its way onto our planet, but no one really has used for. And of course, with the sustainable brands, it's also about giving them more platforms and avenues to show the alternatives. So it's sort of a one stop shop for sustainability. Now that's what we do, but the ethos behind it is really not about swapping fashion. It's about swapping one's mindset. It's Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Priyanka: about changing the way you consume. It's not about replacing one had bad habit of buying too much fashion or fast fashion or whatever you want to call it with buying secondhand or buying sustainable. The idea is to really swap the way you consume. Think about why you consume. And so increasingly that is really the conversations that we try to curate, the education that we try to spread within the community. Arjun Thomas: So there's a lot to unpack there. It it seems as you unpack what Swapaholic is. it's it's less a brand, it's more of a movement, it seems that there are a lot of kind of paths to that. and I'm curious about maybe taking a couple of steps back in your journey of discovery of this problem for yourself. What was that moment? Because you said you were a twenty something, that you were buying a lot of clothes on on ASOS and on and I think all of us went through that phase and some of us still in that are in that phase. But what caused that switch in your head to say, you know, what that said I'm doing too much or I'm being wasteful, or so so what was the what was that aha moment that got you to start considering something beyond just the clothes that you were buying? Priyanka: I don't so the first business I co founded was a brand consultancy in India. that was about 17 years ago. And a couple of years into it, I just started feeling like I wanted to be in the realm of sustainability. And I don't know why that came to me, or I Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Priyanka: didn't even know what it meant. And so I decided then to and to go into a master's program. And at that point I was in this space of just learning what is sustainability, what does it mean to us? What does it mean? within our lives. I thought it meant just, you know, recycling and you don't understand entirely what that means. at the time. So I did a before my masters actually I did there's Harvard has an extension school online. And I started doing courses there. And there were PhDs taking these courses who were really talking about what sustainability means. There were 101 classes, there were deeper classes, and that's really where my brain started switching and thinking about Understanding what sustainability truly meant. And one of the things I discovered along the way was just how polluting the fashion industry is. And that was very personal to me. And it was really funny because up until this point, I had said my entire life that I will never do anything related to fashion. I think a lot of people assumed it of me for whatever reason. I was in India, I loved clothes, I was constantly wearing new clothes, but I always said I'm never going to do anything to do with the fashion industry. But this was the first moment where I said, wait a minute, I do need to do something. but it just Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: has to not be in the way that I thought it would be. And yeah, so that's really how how it sort of unfolded at that point. Arjun Thomas: Right. So your journey was more down the rabbit hole, driven based on interest and every new stone you turned over. you found something of value to you and you continued down that path. So I get that completely. when you tried doing this for other people, so you obviously made a shift for yourself as a consumer first and then you kind of looked at swapaholic as an avenue to enable other Priyanka's as you were to kind of make the same transition. What did you find about that process and what did you what did you kind of discover about about human behavior through that process of trying to give people avenues to make better planet choices that you seem to have decided to take yourself. Priyanka: Yeah, I think that's a really interesting question because whenever you start off on an enterprise like this, I'm sure this will resonate with a lot of people. You know, you start off thinking, I'm going to change behaviors, I'm going to change the way people think, and it's going to, like you said, start a movement. but it doesn't quite do that. I think as consumers, and I I'm included in this, when any enterprise has an offering, you expect them to do the work. You get Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Priyanka: the convenience of It, you get good value for money, but you don't really want to do the work. And I think that's the first thing I've realized that people, no matter how much we marketed sustainability and how their small behavioral changes could impact the planet at large, they were quite apathetic to them. I think what really worked is when it was a great deal. Well, it it what worked is when it was a cool thing to do. or it was just really convenient. We had a pickup service, you could come and do it in a centrally located space. Those were the things that really work. So I think behavioral shift is really difficult across Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Priyanka: the board. Most people want convenience. So as an enterprise, if you can provide convenience, that's when you will have a sense of community come in and they will stay if that convenience is retained or enhanced. Arjun Thomas: Right. So s was that the the the the foundational barrier that you needed to remove, which is convenience first, everything else else second, and that's how you got people in the door to start making changes to their behavior because convenience was was on offer. Priyanka: I think it wasn't quite as linear, right? Because we started something, I had these very lofty goals about where it's going and what it can do and how people are going to change their mindsets around that very quickly. It didn't happen. So the learning was very heuristic and very nonlinear with every event, with every partnership, with every collaboration we learned and in a very sort of roundabout way tried to provide these things. But so initially we went with the fact that people will just learn this information and act differently, because that was what Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: propelled me to act differently. But that didn't quite work. So we said, okay, how do we now make it convenient? How do we now make it fair? How do we now make it cool? So we started sort of just trying to do everything that we could to get people attracted to it. And I have to say that almost 10 years next year will be our 10th year, nine years in nine and a half years into the business. It's the same. We're still trying to see why people will want to do this continuously. Because the other problem with fashion is that we are not loyal. Today we Arjun Thomas: Hm. Priyanka: with any brand, I'm not talking about swap holic per se. I'm saying with any brand. So anyone who loves fashion will walk into one brand, will love it, will go to another brand the next day, will go to a third brand. So you don't have a loyalty To a particular brand or a particular way of consuming, more importantly. When it comes to fashion, Arjun Thomas: Mm, right. Priyanka: you're going to consume in every way possible. So that's another challenge which we cannot mitigate because that's inherent to our human DNA, to be attracted and appeal to things and you know serve yourself in that way. So I think those are a few of the challenges that we're constantly observing, but also things that we're trying to do as a result. To see what people really truly value. Arjun Thomas: No, I I get that. I mean, as with a lot of consumer behaviour, especially around fashion, And possibly the close other example is go a step, you know, eating food. you want some variety and you you dabble in a different thing. So for example, if you want sports where you have a particular way of doing it, buying. If you want something close to going for going out, you go to another kind of brand. If you want to gift, there's another option. if it's something for homeware, there's something different. So we don't I completely agree with as I think through the way I shop as well. you you you actually have different personas depending on what your objective is. and is the finding and I'm just curious as I I'm thinking out loud as we're talking that swapahic or the need to be responsible about what we buy is just one of the personas of our many personas in the way we shop. And it's not something that will basically replace all the other personas. It just becomes another persona that maybe does a five percent or ten percent of our shopping. I'm just curious about you know, behavior. Priyanka: Yeah, yeah, you're right. It is that is really what I've observed, that it's one of the ways you consume. It is not the way you consume. You know, and that sort of lends itself to the point I was making earlier. You're not loyal to one way of consumption. And that's Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: why we keep going back to the swap your mindset. Because the idea is when you change the way you think about consumption, it's not just about passion. You should be making swaps across the board. And I'm not saying I'm perfect, no stretch under no stretch of imagination, am I? But I think that that effort has to be an ongoing one. There will be spots where you're just better at it. There will be spots that you're worse at it. But when your mindset is innately swapped, you will at least make an attempt at different spheres. And that's really where I felt like over the years, I felt that's really where the change is required. It's not just providing an outlet to say come and do this. Because you'll come and do it sometimes, but you'll also do the other things. Arjun Thomas: So I'm curious, you you mentioned the number right at the at the start of our conversation, which was a fairly staggeringly large number, which was hundred billion garments. is that yearly or every year, hundred billion garments? Priyanka: Yeah, annually. Arjun Thomas: annually, Jesus. what percentage of that do you think falls under the sustainable swapping behavior segment of that hundred billion that are produced every year? Priyanka: Those are all those are all newly produced. So those are not Arjun Thomas: Right, okay. Right. Priyanka: But but to answer that question another way, the statistics around garment wastage say that eighty percent of produced garments reach are disposed. So out of the hundred Arjun Thomas: Completely. So there's no recovery. Priyanka: there's no recovery and this the disposal channels now again, all of these numbers are really hard to gather because it's such a Arjun Thomas: Mm. Priyanka: opaque pr production cycle when it comes to the fashion industry. But it could be from different avenues, the fact the statistic. So for example, one is brands, they produce collections, and then those collections don't sell in its entirety, they have to dispose those. There's also Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: pre-production, I mean product waste during the production process. So the garment cutoffs, if you're cutting a t-shirt, then there are bits of the fabric that are wasted. So there's all of those Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: that are also included in this 80%. Arjun Thomas: So I'm curious about as a hypothesis, and the reason I asked the question is because the podcast I dropped a week ago, the one we were talking about, was again trying to shift the mindset around composting to a job to be done to resource recovery because there is inherent value in creating this beautiful kind of fertile nutrient that kind of goes back into the earth and kind of helps the next set of crops grow. and the reason why that and that seemed to really work well and resonate financially is because the moment there is the tag resource attributed to something it inherently has value. You're not doing this as a clean up activity, you know, because what you're collecting a actually has commercial value and therefore there's an incentive to do so. Do you believe there's some sort of a parallel that's possible in the in the garment segment where there's the ability to recover resources from the hundred or so billion garments that are produced annually every year? Priyanka: I think so. And I'm gonna start with why Swapaholic started our marketplace where individuals can also sell instead of just swapping. Through COVID, we realized that people just didn't want anything that they were hoarding anymore and they didn't want to replace it with another thing. They just wanted to get rid of things. And so that's where the selling happened. So we s opened up individuals to a platform for individuals to sell their closets, both physically and online. And that definitely had a lot of traction because there's a return involved. So I do definitely think that's a possibility. However, with the waste of the hundred billion garments produced, there's a lot of complexity because brands Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Priyanka: are already under a lot of fire for their production practices. So, like I Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: said, it's very opaque. We don't know which brand Arjun Thomas: Mm. Priyanka: is disposing what. So it does need a little more transparency. We don't know how many cutoffs are there from a particular garment that could be reused into something else. So it requires transparency in order for there to be industry around it. There is potential, but I think the transparency is severely lacking. Arjun Thomas: Right. So if I if would it be possible for you to kind of just articulate the the journey that a product goes through, from its its inception to I guess incineration into in today's world, to kind of get a sense of how these fabrics actually come together. So there's, you know, natural fabrics, artificial fabrics, there's dyes, and the process of essentially putting it together as to the best of your knowledge, I'm sure there's wide variations in how that's actually put together and how that contributes to potentially making the recovery process or the disposal process more complicated. Because I think for a lot of people, we put the clothes on our backs, but very few of us really understand what goes into actually making a garment. So maybe, you know, given the years that you spent kind of unpacking this in Rustry, that might be a good thing to talk about for a bit. Priyanka: Yeah, so essentially we can just, you know, for simplicity, we can put the garments that are produced into two categories. One is made from natural fibers, such as cotton and hemp and things like that. and the other is synthetic. So those are the two large types of fabrics that we are going to start with. So when you're looking at cotton, first it involves the cotton picking. It involves cotton production processes which are very intensive in they require a lot of water, they require a lot of chemicals. It's a very sensitive plant. It requires the industry sadly has a lot of child labor, Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Priyanka: a lot of forced labor because you need very delicate hands to actually pick the cotton Arjun Thomas: Small fingers, yeah. Priyanka: to pick the cotton. So those are a few of the issues when it comes to some natural fibers. Synthetic, of course, we know is lab generated. It's purely chemical, petrochemicals, and that's really where you're beginning. Once that main fabric is produced, the fabrics have to last the test of time. So now the cottons may be blended with polyester, which increasingly is happening. There are very few purely natural fiber brands. and the industry is trying, but it is more challenging because you have to take care of those clothes more. Sometimes they get spoiled in machines. So there was a reason that the industry went in that direction. So you have a lot of blended fabrics. You also then with the synthetics, you have a lot of fixing. A lot of chemical layers, things that are, you know, when people say wrinkle free and we get really excited, those are actually very strong chemicals. Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: so then these fabrics are they go into facilities where the designs they may go into a factory in we'll definitely go into a factory in certain countries such as India. you have I think Turkey was doing some, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Indonesia, there are certain regions that produce garments. So the orders and the designs may come from another country altogether and they will be produced most likely for fast fashion in some of these regions where the price points can be kept very low. So the garments are then produced in one factory, they are finished in another factory, which could be shipped somewhere else across the world. And then of course they're rolled out into different parts globally to actually be. Be sold along the way, over 8,000 chemicals can be used. And those chemicals, Arjun Thomas: A thousand. Priyanka: so a particular garment can have up to 8,000 chemicals, and Arjun Thomas: Jesus, okay. Priyanka: yeah, and these chemicals, most of them are unregulated. And so there are a lot of issues that you hear of. For example, there's a river in Indonesia called the Citarum River, and it essentially no longer exists. River has completely dried up, and this is because it's surrounded by factories producing garments, and all the chemicals are sort of pushed in are put into that water body afterwards, and it's a direct implication of what how much damage those chemicals can actually cause. The leather tanning industry is also known for using chemicals that are highly damaging. I forget the statistics, but I think eighty percent of leather tanning workers in a particular region in India actually have skin diseases. So the chemicals are extremely detrimental, but the workers really don't have a choice. So the the issues here are the environmental degradation, but also the lives of human beings that are being degraded and undervalued. Most of these workers who are doing this job are daily wage, daily breadwinners. They do not have access to contracts during COVID. A lot of them were just sitting around doing nothing. They've had to go into factories which have then subsequently crumpled and fallen. there's a factory in Bangladesh called Rana Plaza, which is the poster child for the conditions under which workers are actually work working. There was a movement that called Fashion Revolution that was born from this fac particular factory collapsing in twenty thirteen. Where you also think about who made your clothes and under what condition are you making your clothes. Because, like you said up earlier in the conversation, we don't really think about it, we just think about the clothes. So you walk into a beautiful boutique, your experience is very different from how that garment reached that beautiful boutique. So those are some of the so again, so you have the fabrics, the production of the actual fiber, then you have the fabric production, then you have the garment production in a couple of different stages. And then you have global distribution. So there's a huge shipping cost. And then after that, the items that don't sell are disposed of because Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Priyanka: they don't want to, so there they go on sale, all those things happen, but eventually they have to be disposed of. So it can be incinerated, which is just essentially burnt, or it can be thrown into a landfill, which brands do less often because they cannot be discovered to be throwing so many garments Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: out. and then of course the human consumption. So when we consume garments, there are microplastics in every machine wash that are going back into our ecology and into our systems. I've forgotten the number now, but thousands and thousands of microplastics, because even when you're looking at cotton as a fabric, like I said, or natural fiber, they have fixing that happens with chemical Arjun Thomas: Mm. Priyanka: coat coating, or they have synthetic parts of the garment. It's also Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: very difficult to recycle garments because they are typically made of more than one type of fiber. They have buttons, they have zips, they have all kinds of things that one machine cannot successfully break down. Arjun Thomas: So so given the fact that it's a massively complicated process to bring a garment to the retail market and therefore into the consumer, and it from what you're telling me, there doesn't seem to be a cost benefit incentive to recycle the garments given the complexity and the fact that it is a mass produced item. So the cost for purchases means that the cost the cost for purchases keeps keeps getting driven down, which means it's cheap to produce, and likely significantly more expensive to recycle than it was to produce. so given that disparity Given everything that you're seeing in the industry and that you've seen in the industry over the last decade and a half, do you see any signs of this kind of changing? Because for for this for their ha for this to have financial incentives, you know, obviously the recovery needs to be higher than the production value, I would assume. for it to make any financial sense for someone to kind of step in and say, you know, let's do something about this, right? beyond just the being charitable and goodwilled. Priyanka: Yeah, I'm gonna add one more point to that before I answer the question. so you're right, recycling is more expensive and even returning things to a company is more expensive for them because the return process requires them to think about opening the doing the quality check again, putting it back either in their warehouse. So even those garments end up in landfills most often. And I I mean I've known this for a long time, but recently I experienced it. So I wear my this is not a Not thing to be proud of. But I wear my shoes until they're torn and tattered. And the other day I was in the gym with my husband and he said, Enough is enough. Like this is where you need to, you know, I I draw the line. And he went and bought me shoes, and I'm not going to mention the brand's name. And he bought me some wonderful shoes after doing a lot of research. best technology and you know, great for me physically, and they were the wrong size because obviously I didn't help him in the process. He had to just figure it out. And then Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: he said, Okay, let's return it. So We started the return process. The new shoes arrived, but to pick up the return, the brand never came. Because it's more expensive Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Priyanka: for them. So I just ended up giving those shoes to my sister, who luckily is is a size smaller than me. And of course I wouldn't have thrown away a pair of brand new shoes. But the point is that they were the shoes were expensive shoes. They were not inexpensive. They were not $30, $40. They were a couple of hundred dollars because they were the latest technology and that's how they were sold to us. Even at that price point, it was not worth the brand's while to pick it up and to reinstate that in where whichever way they could. So again, so now the the problem, you're right, everything is produced so cheaply that it's so much cheaper to produce and so much more expensive to recycle in any way or form. and I don't want to, you know, sort of be a buzzkill and say that there is no viable option. I think a lot of very intelligent, competent people, businesses are really trying their level best and there has been some headway, but there's a long way to go because it is a very complicated process and I think it just constantly comes back to the fact that there is no transparency. If companies are mandated to be more transparent, it's also easier to find where the gaps are, to fulfill them, to plug them, to give brand, to bring to help the brands that want to help, to help them do a better job, you need to understand where the gaps are and what you have access to. So I think there are a few things that are very challenging in the process of recycling. So we aren't as far as we should be, which is why. It's important that everyone takes it seriously, including consumers. This is, you know, a place where everyone needs to come together. It's not just one particular stakeholder's job. Arjun Thomas: And that's something that I've always I've struggled with because you know, talking to a lot of founders and different businesses and just understanding human psychology, getting people to do something that is that is not important to them, it might be in their best interests, and very rarely those two things are not the same, right? So what's it what's good for you and what's in you know what's in your best interest and what you want to do are very rarely the same, most often. So so getting that behavior change is inordinately difficult and you've you've spent a decade trying to figure that out in in one specific space. So is the f question again, I'm just spitballing. Is the question less about figuring out driving responsible practices, though I I agree that's a big part of it. But finding new materials that don't have these problems and fixing the problem much, much earlier in the value chain. I know it it's it's a it's a very different way of looking at the problem because you know we are we live in the world that we live in and clothes are produced the way clothes are produced today. and the reason I'm kind of bringing this up is the conversations around energy consumption, which is all the Today and the greenhouse gases effects and people saying that for the longest time that we need to reduce our energy consumption. That's not gonna happen anytime soon, and people have realized they've given up on those. It's a pipe dream. the largest populations in the world, India, China, are only just getting a large percentage of their population out of poverty. And to keep tell those people to not burn energy isn't is never gonna happen. So the path forward for a cleaner planet is to find better, cleaner energy sources. That are abundant and most importantly cheap. People forgot that when they were talking about sustainable and renewable energy, right? Cheap is the most important thing. so so is that something that you're seeing in the industry where people are investing money in new fabric technologies that don't have the inherent problems that we the current fabric generations have. Priyanka: They are, but again, there there are lots of brands that are being more sustainable in their practices. They're being more ethical to workers. Yeah, so Arjun Thomas: What what does that mean? What does that mean? So So if you can unpack that, yeah. Priyanka: one is it means they're being more ethical to workers, right? They're working in smaller units, they know who's making the clothes, they're paying them fair wages. So that's on the sort of social side. On the environmental side, they are doing their best. They are using fabrics that are from natural sources. They are using and and now there are new fabrics. They're fabrics made of pineapple. That you know, you can have Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Priyanka: a pineapple leather or an apple leather. But these also inherently to keep a garment together, you they cannot be devoid of chemicals. That's just not how it's going Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Priyanka: to be. Now, what chemicals you're using, how you're using it, you need to think about. The other biggest challenge you have, even when you have the best of intention, best of resources to produce a sustainable brand, you are competing with price points. So as soon as you increase your costs by doing all of these things, your margins naturally decrease. And you, like we discussed, people don't have any loyalty. So your competition is giving them something similar for $10. there are some ultra-fast fashion brands as we now know. And again, this is not about naming and shaming, but anything I search for on Google, those are the ones that show up first. We've copied all the the higher end brands, and not to say the higher end brands may have produced it ethically. But I'm saying that now at every price point, everything is available. So when you are trying to produce ethically with the right fabrics, with the right processes, with the right chemicals, your price increases and you're dead before you started. How are you supposed to make money? The other thing is a lot of brands are reliant on you're not doing everything, right? You're not producing the fiber yourself. You're reliant on another stakeholder to provide the fiber, to buy the fabrics to you. Now, the fabric producers can also buy certificates, which is very Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: rampant in these areas because, again, it's being produced in markets which are more opaque and more disorganized in this sector. So the amount of fabrics that I've seen that have certifications but are not truly worthy of those certifications are astounding. Arjun Thomas: Hm. Priyanka: I've had people admit to me that they've bought certificates, certification to sell those fabrics. So you don't really know what's happening. The sector is yet too disorganized to solve this problem in this way. The other thing is that the fashion industry has become used to many cycles. There are 52 microseasons in fashion. What does that mean? It means that initially means to have spring, summer, autumn, winter, right? And those are the seasons people looked forward to, which was also four to three too many. But now there are 52 microseasons. So, which means every single week new clothes are being produced. That's how fast the turn is. And I'm guilty of that. I'm constantly attracted to what is in fashion because I'm seeing it everywhere. I may not now act on it at this stage considering the work that I do, but those things are exciting to me. And it's so cheap. So you just think, okay, just this once, I'll do it. I'm just one person, right? So, but I mean, then that's consumer mindset. Responding to the point you had is that. I don't think it's a bad idea. I mean it should be done. We have to change the way clothes are produced or fashion is produced. But that's not the only way to do it. The problem with with the fashion industry are so deeply entrenched that it's got to be everything all together. It's got to be government mandates, it's got to be industries changing, it's got to be consumers demanding that change because we really have the power. Every dollar, I think Livia Firth said this, every dollar we make is a vote towards the kind of world we want. So when we're buying fast fashion, we're giving a signal that that's really what we want. so consumers need to come together and also brands that are upcoming need to start thinking about things differently. Arjun Thomas: So given everything that we've talked about, and again, I don't want to paint a bleak bleak picture either, but we're dealing with a lot of things needing to come together. a l you know, globally, it's not even a local problem because the issue with with with with fashion is as you as you mentioned, the designs come from one place, it's produced in another place, it's shipped to another place. you know it's it's it's dumped in some other place, more often than not it's third world countries where you know out of sight, out of mind is a mantra that most people probably recognize. You know, if I don't see the garbage next to my house and I throw the garbage you know over the wall into my neighbor's house, it's perfectly fine, right? As long as I don't it's not in my compound, right? So that that mindset is kind of pretty prevalent globally. So given all these human frailties that we have as a species, and the fact that it's unlikely for global government participation on pretty much anything, you know, I think I've given up on on that being a reality. how does this you know how where do we where does this go? do we do we Are are we just destined to live in this in in this world that we've created for for ourselves where the incentive structures are driven based on consumers who want cheap products, who want convenience, which is, you know, one day delivery, ten minute delivery as we have in India, which I still find staggering. and is that going to change? Priyanka: Look, I mean I'm not one to feel eco anxiety or to be, you know, d to live in the gloom and doom for long. in effect, I think the idea is that you know, for me it's not about wallowing in this eco anxiety, it's really about saying that every small drop. methods. And that's why I'm really doing what I can because if essentially I think each of us need to come together and it's a chicken and egg. Everyone thinks the other stakeholder needs to get started Arjun Thomas: Mm. Priyanka: first, but that really isn't the case. And you know, when you talk about governments, France is doing a lot right now in terms of their laws related to fashion. And that's a great example. They aren't allowing certain types of ad advertisements. They have certain laws about what brands can come in when it comes to this ultra-fast fashion. And they really are setting the stage for what is possible. So that's going to be, you know, something that's going to unfold in the next couple of years for us to draw inspiration on. But at the same time, I still feel that consumers are the most powerful voice. Yes, we want convenience. Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Priyanka: and yes, it's harder for us to for us to drive behavioral change with so many people, but we still are the most powerful voice. And I think every single step that we can take, even if it's a little one, goes a long way. You know, and I think that is something that I Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: will never really get tired of of doing. And yes, the supply chain is convoluted and very opaque in the fashion industry. But I think our voices collectively can do a lot more than we can imagine. and it really isn't about a movement. It's really about voting with your dollar. So no one is saying get up and you know start rallying about this. But just do what you can, you know, make a better choice. If you can do that we're really getting somewhere. So I think that we've all got to start somewhere. Arjun Thomas: Which is a fair point and I think you're right. if we wait for someone else to take the first step, mm you'll be waiting a very long time. and we do have agency at the end of the day, so you know You've taken the leap 10 years ago to kind of start swapaholic based on you know your belief that this is the first step that you had to take. but what have you learned trying to do this over 10 years? I know we unpacked and talked about the industry at length. but when you kind of bubble this all distill this all down to how if it affects building a brand, building a business, what have you learned through the through the last 10 years of trying to sell into this space? I mean, maybe sell is too commercial a word. given everything we talked about, but but to make a change through swapaholic as a vehicle, what have you learnt about about about about from the business side? Priyanka: I think it's interesting. So, you know, we're we're now a certified B Corp as of a couple of years ago. And we've also from the get-go been a registered social enterprise under raise. So I think those have really made us very responsible towards the mission that we set out to achieve. Having said that, I think personally for me, in the early years, I I mean, for most part of the journey, I really undervalued. We spoke a lot about, you know, one of the first things I learned on that Harvard Extension School course I did was about the triple bottom line, that it's not just about the profit, but it's about people and planet as well. And I think I took the people and planet part a little more seriously than I did the Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: the profit part for a very long time. and because, like I said, the path hasn't been linear. It wasn't something that we Arjun Thomas: Mm. Priyanka: planned and said, this is our five-year plan and this is going to work out. It was it was very nascent, the industry at the time. It still is very nascent. And at that point, it just the landscape didn't exist. There was nothing to aspire to. There was nothing that worked that we learned from that we could do differently. We have to keep failing and learning along the way. So I think about the business, the key thing is that if you want to be sustainable while doing good, you do have to think about profit. And I think every time I say this, Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Priyanka: out loud I'm also saying it to myself. You know, and we've made some really silly mistakes. So I'll tell you a couple that have backfired. I'll tell you one that's backfired. So very early on I said for online or for offline, we just want to do away with plastic packaging. So any plastic that we have will be reused within because you need plastic to store garments, for example, for online, but we will reuse those for posterity. And there's just a finite number and we'll reuse those. And anything that goes out can't be plastic. So when we started the online six odd years ago, our online arm of the business, there was no option for biodegradable packaging. So we had it shipped in from Arjun Thomas: Hm. Priyanka: somewhere, spent too much money on it, and I knew that the customer wouldn't pay for it. So we had to absorb the cost. Then when Arjun Thomas: Hm. Priyanka: it reached, it was so biodegradable that it disintegrated on the clothes Arjun Thomas: god. Priyanka: or it tore on the way to reaching the the customer. Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: So then we had to invest in boxes. And then we got the boxes and we didn't want to invest in multiple sizes because this would be waste. So we invested in a size that now, even if the garment size is very small, the volumetric weight was much higher and we would have to absorb that cost. So we did silly things like this. Arjun Thomas: Hm. Priyanka: Another, so in the shop I said we're never going to buy bags. Customers have to bring their own bags. Arjun Thomas: Hm. Priyanka: And that seemed fair. then we had lots of complaints. So I found a cassava, a bag made of cassava starch. And because of the kind of material Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Priyanka: that it was, it's a smaller bag. It wasn't, they didn't have a larger option. So I said, okay, we'll make it work. And so two years ago, we had a customer that came into the store and bought this beautiful gown and it did not fit in this cassava starch bag. And she Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: and she was really, really upset about it. To a point Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: where the staff on the ground, who was a young girl that day, there was an altercation between them because this woman Charged at the staff as if she was going to hit her. The staff got triggered, after which she wrote rants about us on Google, reduced our rating, which made her husband write a rant, a relative write a rant, all because we didn't have a bag that fit the size of the garment that she had brought. And so Arjun Thomas: okay. Priyanka: it didn't just backfire in terms of cost, it also backfired in terms of reputation because we're so used to consuming Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: a particular way. And yeah, so so so I mean coming back to the to what I've learned is that it's great to have a noble cause, but you've got to break it down and you've got to really think about what the cost implications might be, whether there may be reputational implications, also realizing that behavioral change cannot happen overnight. How do you transition people into it bit by bit? You know, one of the things that I've said a couple of times is that. I hope there's not a need for swapaholic in this current form. I would be the most delighted if people were just consuming less and re recycling with each other. We exist because we want to solve a problem. We want to help people transition into changing or swapping their mindset. And until that happens, we're here, but otherwise we change the form to what is required. So I think that those are the key things I've I've really, you know, taken away that you've behavioural change needs to happen in a way that's palatable, that people understand. We're used to a one click checkout, we're used to having things at our fingertips, the convenience, the pickup services, which we've tried all of by the way, and lost a lot of money along the way, but also thinking about the commercial implications if we wanna last the test of time. Arjun Thomas: I mean, no surprise, I think every business takes its lumps in in in in large volumes in the early days. And part of the journey is to try something new and if it doesn't work you kind of roll back. So I'm curious on those two examples, what eventually happened. So with the box example, where did you finally land on? And in the plastic bag with the what the what's the what's the material, the cassava bag, where did you land on today? Priyanka: So the cassava bags, we finished that lot of bags and then I didn't order any more. I'm not gonna order anymore. Arjun Thomas: So what do people do now? Priyanka: Well, we now if what we do is we basically anyone who wants to donate a bag to us can. So we have a place in the store. If you want to donate a plastic bag or a paper bag or anything to us, it'll accept it. So we're reusing those bags now. We don't buy any more bags. I think that was something that we Arjun Thomas: Right. Okay. Priyanka: just wanted to do away with. and we have not had an episode like that again. Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Priyanka: when it came to the online, we have we've had to do two things. One is we use the boxes and and again, even with the boxes, you know, I thought it would be really important to write on the boxes in a very cute way that people should recycle these boxes. And and af as an afterthought, I realized that you people are gonna do whatever they want, no matter how much you whatever message you put on the box. So we just ended up wasting ink and Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: more money on creating boxes with this Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Priyanka: qubit message that said, recycle me. but then for the smaller packages now we just use the existing mailers in the market because the garments are more secure. So we don't have customer complaints that things have arrived disintegrated because there is no solution that does that. Arjun Thomas: Or deal with the returns, which again further compounds the problem of waste anyway. at least back and forth. so Maybe talking about behavior it it's a good segue over to the other business that you run, which I think might be slightly easier, which is catching them early, right? Priyanka: Yeah. Arjun Thomas: which is which is the kids' business. So you're a mum of two, five year old kids. so is that when the the journey to th this new business kind of started and a and why did you pivot not pivot, but why did you also decide to take on another challenge for for for for young ones? Priyanka: Actually, what was really interesting. So, this this business is called DinoStaury And it started off with stories of little dinosaurs. And the analogy was that our values are age-old, but we are essentially it needs to be packaged for the modern dinosaur, which is essentially us. So that was where the analogy brought us. Actually, I started the businesses at the same time. So while I was doing my masters, Arjun Thomas: Okay. Priyanka: I that year decided that anything that I feel passionate about I'm going to do. So that year I took on seven projects, including Arjun Thomas: Jesus, all right, okay. Priyanka: swapaholics, different scales. And at the time, of course, you know, it was everything was much smaller. I took on Dynostory and I took on swapaholic along with five other projects. And these are the two that sort of lasted the test of time. The rest sort of disintegrated over the la the next couple of years. So I started them ten years ago before I actually had children. Because at that time I've always loved books. And I was I grew up in a joint family and I was born to the oldest brother. So I had lots of cousins who were younger. And I was I'm very close to all of them, very blessed to be. But I noticed a value change over the generations because of the Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Priyanka: advent of social media and you know, globalization is is the the word of of that. at the the era was. And I thought, okay, what binds us? What are our roots? How do we really find ourselves in this world of so much noise? And that's really where DinoStaury was born. So our tagline is hold on to your roots. And we started off with values such as care and kindness, generosity, which today of course comes under the umbrella of mindfulness. When you are more mindful about who you are, you are going to be more mindful about the choices you make. For yourself, for the environment, for the people around you. So in a nutshell, that's what it is. We have 16 products that cover different values. But more than that, I always knew this wasn't about books. It was about content. So today we run experiences Arjun Thomas: Mm. Priyanka: for children's for children and for families that start with our content, our book, but we also have curriculums designed around it to help instill that value into day day-to-day lives. Now that's what we do. And coming back to your question. It is easier to have a child start small. You can normalize a lot of these habits. So, for example, I know all Arjun Thomas: Mm. Priyanka: of these things, but I still struggle myself with consumption just because it's become a really bad habit to consume. So I think with children now that I have the five year olds and I'm testing the product actively on them, I realize that their minds are can be shaped very easily. But it's not about what Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Priyanka: you tell children, it's what you show children at the end of the day. Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Priyanka: So even with children, it's the village that matters. We can do brilliant sessions where children are really receptive, but at the end of the day, if they go home and their families and their the institutions and their villages are exhibiting different behaviors, that's really what they're going to normalize. So again, it is a communal responsibility to come together and normalize this for children. Arjun Thomas: Right. a and and you're right, I think so much of it happens outside just the parents' control. the the time they spend with this with their friends, in school, with significant other peers and other playgroups really informs the way they see the world and in a way defines their consumer behavior. far more than we had when we were kids because again you know today everything is plentiful. We didn't thankfully have those challenges growing up. so I think the the the need to to push off instant gratification was a lot easier. We we we didn't have to deal with a lot of the things that kids today have to deal with. which I think we are lucky about lucky for doing so. but but w what what's the biggest difference between both the businesses for you? Priyanka: In terms of Arjun Thomas: Emotionally. Priyanka: You know, when I started off, I felt they were very different businesses. But today they've already really fused and merged because essentially we're trying to do the same thing with two different demographics. Even at Swapaholic, increasingly we are having community events that are about swapping your mindsets. Get to know yourself better and make better choices. And that's really what we're doing with children, just in another avatar. So they're very connected. Over the last couple of years, we've done Events that are collaborative. So in Swapaholic now we have a Toy Swap. Thanks to Dino Story's influence. We've had book readings there. at Dinostory, when we ran, we recently ran a large event at the National Library, and we had a clothing and book and toy swap for children, which was all you know sponsored by Swapaholic. so in effect, I mean that's the external manifestation, but I think the ethos behind the businesses is the same. How do you care more. How do you care more about yourself? How do you care more about the planet? How do you care more about the people around you? Because that's going to make the biggest Arjun Thomas: Right. And if you had to give advice to anyone toying with the idea of doing something in the sustainability of the circular economy space, what would that be? Priyanka: Hmm. So the practical me of me says do your homework, don't do what I did. but actually the the passionate me says the opposite. It says just get started. You know, the answers they come when you really care about what you're doing, when you're driven by a particular mission where it's innately connected to who you are, things will unfold. The answers will come. It's never going to be linear, no matter how much of a five year plan you lay out. The world is changing. Onston. Arjun Thomas: And are there avenues for maybe early stage founders looking to get into the space to kind of reach out to other business people like yourselves? is there an active community here in Singapore, back in India, I don't know where else you kind of work, that kind of brings people from different areas of business, but again with a common theme around sustainability or circular economy or stuff like that. Is is is is that such a thing? Priyanka: Yeah, there are WhatsApp groups now. Of course, government agencies such as raiSE are trying their level best to do it. You have the B Corp community that's also, you know, increasingly trying to become more active. And the other thing is also reaching out on LinkedIn. I think within the community, every almost everyone I know has just responded to cold messages when it is from someone genuine. In fact, I made a very dear friend who's doing wonderful work in sustainability. Just through that way. She'd heard about Swapaholic, Arjun Thomas: Hm. Priyanka: she messaged me on LinkedIn. We had a chat. She started her business that is doing wonderfully. many years later, she even got her B Corp certification before we did it and, reminded me to do it. So cold calls also are an amazing way to do it because I think everyone is very receptive to work together. Arjun Thomas: And maybe one last thought because well not thought question because I think it's on the top of most people's minds is do you see AI having any impact in the industry that you the that you're dabbling in? And if so what, if at all? Priyanka: I mean, yes, for for all businesses, in every single way. You know, of course, when you think about the back end, you think about so when I'm thinking about our online experience, for example, the inventory management process, which is a tedious process to have so many secondhand things over years, and we've had to build internal tools, but having AI help us identify what those garments are, what their shelf life might be, what we can put on sale. What is trending again? Because passion can also be circular. So you have a lot of things like that, obviously on the e-commerce side. We all know the implications of AI and how that can help us. and of course, with Dinostory as well, there are many now tools, apps generating content. The other day I gifted our set of books to someone and they said, this is amazing, but you know, I Every night I just get ChatGPT to tell me a story. If for my children, Arjun Thomas: Right. Priyanka: and it's great, So the the world is changing, the way we're illustrating what we're doing. so I think everything has a requirement for AI in some way, but in some way to be true to that human experience, I think it's now up to us, and that's really what I'm actively working on with both brands actually, to see where AI is helpful. And where AI is removing that human creativity which we should retain. So I think it's about striking that that balance. I also think AI is thrown around as if it's you know going to be an yeah, Arjun Thomas: Buzzword, yeah. Priyanka: and it's as if it's going to be an application that's just going to change your business forever. It's not. It needs to be used very judiciously in the right places to increase process efficiency, reduce, you know, inefficiencies. So on the operational side and on the creative side where do you want to use it without losing that human voice. Arjun Thomas: I agree. I mean we we're scaling intelligence at a rate that that's been that's unheard of. what's probably something that we shouldn't overlook is wisdom. and that's what you alluded to, which is how to apply it judiciously, depending on the use case. And that requires a fair bit of human judgment and experience, to decide what makes the most sense for my business, for my community, for my family. Priyanka: You know, when you yeah, and and and when you say community also, Arjun, sorry to cut you off, but I think when you just said community, it's the same thing. It's just community means human beings coming together. And I think that is where we need to realize that AI can't replace that experience for us. And shouldn't. Arjun Thomas: We're hoping. Social media unfortunately has taught us that it is a slippery slope, especially for people who grew up in that era. Kids I think are probably more vulnerable and more at risk for being take if for being taken down a completely virtual rabbit hole of of social experiences that unfortunately might have the you know, might end up replacing real human experiences, which is gonna be a terrible thing. but that's something that I guess governments and policy needs to come in and step in because for that you need a hammer. You can't do it in a very nuanced manner. especially when when when at least my perspective, when you have kids at that age, you have to step in. it it's it shouldn't be something that's subjective at that age. After a certain age it's fine. You should have developed enough mental faculties and experience in life to determine what's good for you and what's not. But below a certain age, yeah, you need to have someone step in on your behalf. Priyanka: Thank you. Arjun Thomas: one last thing before we go and thank you for for for taking the time and jumping through all the the technology hoops I made you do at the at the beginning Priyanka: Yeah, no, you shouldn't sorry. Arjun Thomas: of this call. what's the one thing that you would probably do differently th than you have in either one of the businesses, if you had to choose? Priyanka: I think with swapahodic, I would what I would do differently is just not take on the amount of infrastructural baggage I did very early on. I think I had pre-decided a destiny for a company that was that didn't have a benchmark. So I didn't know how it was going to go. I made a lot of assumptions on how people would behave and respond. so I think Trying an idea, testing it, doing it as an MVP, as opposed to doing it as a full-fledged business before a lot of the key assumptions have been proved. I think that's what I would definitely do differently. Having said that, I've gained a lot of knowledge capital from making those terrible, terrible mistakes. yeah, so there's always an upside, but that's what I would do differently. Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Scar tissue as we call it. Battle Hardden scar tissue. Priyanka: Yes. Arjun Thomas: Priyaka, thank you so much for your time. It was wonderful to spend this hour kind of unpacking both your philosophy and ethos and the way you look at the world. I will put in details to both Swapaholic Dinos Story as well as your LinkedIn profiles. So if anyone wants to reach out, understand a little bit more about the space, the businesses, is there anything else you wanna kinda chat about? Priyanka: No, thank you. This has been fun. It felt like we were just on having a coff cup of coffee together. So thank you. Arjun Thomas: Yeah, that was the only thing missing and I realised I didn't have my cupper. I'm gonna go grab it just after this. thank Priyanka: Yeah. Arjun Thomas: you again. Looking forward to catching up and and sharing a cup of coffee sometime in the near future. Priyanka: Yes, definitely. Thanks, Arjun, and thanks for putting up with my technologic technological ineptness. Arjun Thomas: No, that's it blame the machines. We always blame the machines. it's the one thing they're good for is is is taking the blame. So Priyanka: Thank you. have a good day, thank you. Bye.