Latest / Friend Forward / 4 things I no longer believe about friendship (because learning THIS research changed my mind)
Transcript
- 0:00So surely there are ideas that you have about friendship today that you did not have 10 years
- 0:06ago. Maybe they're ideas around how friends ought to show up for one another or how forgiveness
- 0:12should or should not work, or even ideas around ghosting or connection. And it makes sense because
- 0:19as you engage with new friends, they show you new sides of yourself. They expose you to new ideas.
- 0:26And then you have negative experiences that make you start to question what's even possible
- 0:31in friendship.
- 0:32As we continue to live, our ideas around relationships evolve.
- 0:37And I am no exception.
- 0:40In this week's episode of the Friend Forward podcast, I want to share with you some of the
- 0:45friendship research that I have learned over the past nine years that has completely changed
- 0:51my mind.
- 0:52Let's get into it.
- 1:05Welcome back to the Friend Forward podcast, a show where we're dedicated to unpacking the
- 1:10complexities of women's friendships. I'm your host, Danielle Byard Jackson, a woman's relational
- 1:15health educator and author of the book, Fighting for Our Friendships. And it's my job to study
- 1:21what the latest research has to say about women's cooperation, communication, and conflict.
- 1:27But you know that already. You know, when I first started doing this work specifically about
- 1:32eight years ago now, it would always catch me by surprise whenever I'm wrapping up a keynote and
- 1:37they've given time for a Q&A or if I'm doing a podcast interview and the person who's speaking
- 1:42to me asks me about my personal friendships. It always catches me off guard because I'm showing up
- 1:48polished, you know, I'm here just to share the research. I got my blazer on, so you know I'm
- 1:52serious. And I'm prepared to just share data with you and my interpretations and applications from
- 2:00that data. I am not prepared to share about my personal life. Now I've gotten a little more
- 2:04comfortable, especially here on the show as the years have gone on, but I've always seen those
- 2:07things as separate. The reality is you can't do this work up close in a deep way for so long and
- 2:14not have your personal relationships be transformed by what you're learning. So I want to share with
- 2:20you beliefs that I have previously held that have evolved for me personally since doing this work.
- 2:27These are the most top of mind, I suppose, and they come up the most frequently. Remember,
- 2:33if you are a member of Office Hours, which is our private digital community, you're always going to
- 2:38get a little more there. So you're going to get this month's gathering kit, which is a way that
- 2:44I have walked you through an activity so you can be a host in a low cost, low key way.
- 2:49I want us to commit to our goal of gathering our people more.
- 2:54Okay.
- 2:54Being a connector.
- 2:55So I've hooked you up there.
- 2:56You'll also have supplementary material that goes with this particular episode, specifically
- 3:01bonus content from this conversation.
- 3:03So I'm sharing three additional beliefs in that bonus content.
- 3:07So be sure to go over to that space.
- 3:09If you are currently a member of office hours, and if you're thinking about joining, remember
- 3:13you can join us anytime by visiting betterfemalefriendships.com slash podcast. We look forward
- 3:19to seeing you over there. Okay, let's jump in. So the very first friendship belief that has
- 3:24personally evolved for me is this, all I need is my two besties and I'm good. It turns out that
- 3:32according to the data, that is just not true. Now, I know that this is a message that I see pretty
- 3:38often floating around on social media, you know, I'm an introvert or I don't trust people like that.
- 3:44So I just need my two besties. The reason why we focus on just one or two people is because of
- 3:50cynicism and a lack of trusting that others have good intentions. It's due to our introversion.
- 3:55We'll say, you know, I'm not extroverted like that, talking to all those people or because of
- 3:59our age. Oh, you know, I used to have a lot of people, but as you get older, you know, I'm not
- 4:03worried about that. There's some truth here. The research does tell us that we have the cognitive
- 4:08to maintain three to five ultra close relationships at one time. So the idea of having your inner
- 4:15circle reserved for a low number of people is true. There's truth to that. Why? Because the
- 4:22most socially fit people are maintaining on average about three close relationships at any
- 4:27given time, because we need to be known intimately and it's not possible to be known intimately by
- 4:32everyone. So we do need a handful of people who we elect to bring in in that way and they're getting
- 4:39a more connected experience of us. This is true. But the idea that that's the extent of your social
- 4:46network and that's all you need is a lie. Hear me clearly, is a lie. And it has nothing to do with
- 4:51your level of extroversion, whether you're talkative, whether you're super, super social
- 4:55and going to parties every week. Irrelevant. Okay? Now we did learn in a previous episode of the
- 5:01podcast that one predictor of your well-being in your 50s is the quantity of your friendships in
- 5:08your 20s and the quality of your friendships in your 30s. So we do need to focus on quality.
- 5:13But the research also tells us that people who have more friendships are happier than people
- 5:18with fewer. It is what it is. I'm just telling it to you like it is. Now, the degree of closeness
- 5:24that we experience with all these people is going to vary. So if you think about a small,
- 5:29tiny little circle, and we think of concentric circles circling around that, that get bigger and
- 5:33bigger and bigger, the number of people we can fit in each of those rings is larger, but the degree
- 5:39of closeness is smaller, right? But we need those quote unquote weak ties. Sociologists refer to
- 5:45those connections you have with like acquaintances, like y'all are cool, but it's not that deep.
- 5:49We need those too. So you need a certain texture in your friendship landscape. So if there's any
- 5:56part of you that's convinced yourself that you don't really need people. You just need two besties.
- 6:01I'm telling you, according to research, that is not true. And it's something that I have had to
- 6:06interrogate since doing this work. And I am so happy to report that I am so blessed to enjoy
- 6:14so many different kinds of connections. I do think it's largely because I love people. I think people
- 6:21are interesting just generally. I like talking to people. I like exchanging ideas. People are always
- 6:26putting me on to things. It doesn't even have to be that deep and it was an enjoyable experience.
- 6:31So as an extension of me enjoying people, a lot of times relationships form, which is nice.
- 6:37And I hope the same for you. But here we're focusing mostly on mindset. I need you to open
- 6:42your mind to the fact that you need lots of different connections, but the degree of closeness
- 6:48can vary and it should. Okay. The second friendship belief that has evolved since doing this work
- 6:54is the idea that men's friendships are just easier.
- 6:58Now, you already know from following along for a while
- 7:01the degree to which that would put me
- 7:03in an absolute spiral today if someone said that.
- 7:06But I think when we're talking about ease,
- 7:07we're talking about a lack of friction.
- 7:10What we have to realize and what I've come to realize
- 7:12during the beginning stages of my work
- 7:15is that a lack of friction is not an indicator
- 7:18of closeness or maturity
- 7:20or having relationships figured out
- 7:23or doing relationships better. Unfortunately, unfortunately, we know from the research that
- 7:28while men's friendships might tend to have less friction, tension, or conflict, I'm doing air
- 7:33quotes because every relationship comes with some amount of conflict, okay, internal or external,
- 7:38that this often happens because men tend to keep each other at arm's length when it comes to
- 7:44platonic intimacy and emotions, right? So if I have you at arm's length, then I could call myself
- 7:49your best friend easily for 30 years because there isn't really any risk here. So if I'm
- 7:54talking to you infrequently or when I do talk to you, I'm only talking about surface level things
- 8:00and it doesn't really go that deep. I'm not really making these social or emotional risks with you.
- 8:06Then I can maintain, quote unquote, the relationship with ease, right? But the quality
- 8:12or dynamics of the friendship are definitely affected by that. Now with women, the research
- 8:16tells us, we tend to integrate our friends into our lives to the degree of a sibling, men to the
- 8:23degree of a cousin. So when I'm bringing you into my life, into the fold, and women's friendships
- 8:28have a lot of multiplexity, which means we are relating to each other in a lot of different
- 8:34contexts. And this one friendship's meeting a lot of different social needs, okay? Then bringing you
- 8:40up close means you can see my flaws. You can see my imperfections. There is an increased chance
- 8:45that we're having friction because we're all up in each other's space, right? We are helping raise
- 8:50kids together, right? You're helping give insights to my parenting. You are praying with me or for me.
- 8:56We're sharing career advice. You know, we might be on a dating journey together and we're swapping
- 9:01stories and encouraging one another. You're all up in my business. Don't we think that the closer
- 9:06we get, the more inevitable it is that we're going to have these tensions. So I have come to understand
- 9:12that men having easier friendships, I don't know that we're using the word easy correctly. Maybe
- 9:18we're just saying like frictionless, but I certainly don't think we need to be in a position
- 9:22where we're like, let's take a note from men on how to do friendship. Okay. Now I do think there
- 9:27are things we can learn from each other, but you know, okay. Now I have two other friendship
- 9:33beliefs that I want to share with you because I'm excited about the way that they have evolved.
- 9:39But before I do, I just want to make note of if you are leading some kind of organization
- 9:44and you are really enjoying these kinds of conversations, you enjoy down-to-earth yet
- 9:51data-driven discussion on complex topics like the way that women engage one another platonically,
- 9:58right?
- 9:59How we find connections, how we argue and engage in conflict, and how we reconcile and
- 10:05find harmony once more.
- 10:07I'd love to be your keynote speaker.
- 10:10Truly, this is what I do.
- 10:11And I love being in my educator era, okay,
- 10:15and bringing this to life in a way
- 10:17that is humorous and warm,
- 10:19but also it has those technical components
- 10:21where people walk away not only feeling inspired,
- 10:25but equipped with data.
- 10:26So you can reach out to my team anytime
- 10:28to get that on the books.
- 10:30You can contact us at samanthaatellpublicrelations.com.
- 10:35I'll be sure to put the email address in the show notes as well.
- 10:38But we'd love to bring this experience to your workplace or women's organization.
- 10:43The third friendship belief that has evolved for me since doing this work is that if a friend
- 10:50and I have a very tense conversation or we're starting to have hard talks, it's the beginning
- 10:59of the end.
- 11:00Now, I think many of us know intellectually, like, no, no, hard talks are good.
- 11:03I think many of us know that.
- 11:05And I know if you've been listening for a while, you have a healthy mindset on conflict.
- 11:08We know it's not inherently bad, but it is inherently uncomfortable and vulnerable.
- 11:15And for me at one point, I would think that we're close because there is an absence of
- 11:21conflict.
- 11:21Like we're in a flow.
- 11:22She just gets me.
- 11:24We have this unspoken chemistry and we have fun socially and I can cry to her.
- 11:29And that is an indicator of our closeness.
- 11:33So when friction would arise, you're naturally thinking, oh, this is evidence that we're not as
- 11:40compatible as I thought. And once you start going down that route, I think you become less motivated
- 11:45to actually try to collaborate, to work, to figure out how do we get around this thing.
- 11:52And when I learned that the research finds that we tend to report feeling closer on the other side
- 11:58of healthy conflict, it completely changed how I engage. So whenever people inevitably kind of ask
- 12:04me the question around, you know, have your friendships changed or what are your friendships
- 12:08like? I always, always say that doing this work has made me braver in my friendships. I feel less
- 12:17timid about letting her know that, you know, what she said kind of hurt my feelings. Girl, what did
- 12:21you mean by that? What you said last night at the party, you know, or saying that I have a certain
- 12:26need and expressing that and not feeling clingy about it or leaning into some of my more avoidant
- 12:33tendencies and seeing conflict as a sign that this is just like, this is too much. We're getting too
- 12:38close. It ain't that deep, right? Whatever it is that's triggered seeing that, oh, us having the
- 12:43issue has a certain purpose. Like this problem that we're trying to figure out has an adaptive
- 12:50function. It is a moment that is an opportunity for me to show you your feelings matter,
- 12:59for you to see that I'm invested because I'm trying to work through it. So I'm showing you,
- 13:03I care. It's a moment for us to articulate certain grievances, needs, ideas, boundaries
- 13:12that maybe we hadn't before. And now this tense moment or circumstance or situation has helped to
- 13:18bring those things to the surface. So now it makes sense that we're having this conversation,
- 13:23right? And then even us working through it together, forges us together because we're kind of like,
- 13:27man, look at us. We did that, right? Now I better understand you. I hear your heart. I also see how
- 13:33you treated me with respect during this exchange. It's a chance to practice how I can regulate myself
- 13:39in my body when I disagree. I mean, so many things come from conflict and now I definitely don't look
- 13:46forward to it. Do not get me wrong. But I don't run from it. And I feel like I lean into those
- 13:51moments with more curiosity. And it's been really powerful. So I hope that you can embrace that too,
- 13:58because it's a game changer. It really is. The next friendship belief that has evolved for me
- 14:04over time is something relevant to social events. When it comes to socializing with friends,
- 14:11I used to think the more the merrier. I no longer believe that. Now this might ruffle some feathers,
- 14:18but I'm just going to tell you like it is. Now, perhaps this comes from being raised by a mother
- 14:24who would always say to me, it's just nice to be nice because her mother used to say that to her.
- 14:29That was my grandma's like mantra. Well, it's just nice to be nice. And by that, she meant invite
- 14:33everybody. Just let everybody come. All the girls can come to your birthday. And on its face, it seems
- 14:40like a noble intention and it honors a certain egalitarianism that we tend to really value in
- 14:48female dominant spaces. So I get it. Okay. I get it. Just invite everybody. Now I do believe in
- 14:55be welcoming to everyone, be warm with everyone, be civil with everyone. I don't believe everybody
- 15:02should come to all the things. Let me explain. Now two books have been transformative for me
- 15:09in rethinking this. The first is the wildly popular book, The Art of Gathering. The second
- 15:15is a book titled The Art of Community, Seven Principles for Belonging. When I tell you these
- 15:22made me rethink everything about the whole, it's just nice to be nice, invite everybody to all the
- 15:27things. Now for some events, yes, absolutely all are welcome, but that decision to invite everyone
- 15:35or to have a more curated guest list
- 15:37should be driven by one question.
- 15:39What is the point of this gathering?
- 15:42And what do I want the experience to be like?
- 15:45Because if the point of a gathering,
- 15:47and I could even be referring to like
- 15:49when you bring three people to your house
- 15:50or you go to coffee with like two other women, okay?
- 15:53The art of gathering, the objective of it
- 15:56is different every time.
- 15:58So if you're having a large event
- 16:00and your goal is to just put butts in seats
- 16:02and you want lots of people,
- 16:03then yes, invite everyone.
- 16:04If you're hosting a gathering with three women and the purpose of it is to talk about the volunteer work you do while you also spill a little tea, then it might not make sense to invite the girlies who are not in that volunteer group with you.
- 16:20And not to intentionally exclude them, but to better serve the purpose for the people who are there and to create more safety for the women there.
- 16:28Because they want to speak on certain things.
- 16:30They want to speak to certain topics.
- 16:31They want to do so with depth and nuance.
- 16:33and whenever there's an outsider around, you tend to be very aware of it. So in order to be polite,
- 16:39do you find yourself not talking about the things you wanted to talk about, not going deep in certain
- 16:44ways because you want to honor the guests who would feel like an outsider if you didn't go there.
- 16:48And one of the examples that was given in the book about the principles of belonging was,
- 16:53you know, if you have a bunch of jazz musicians and they're coming together to just jam and we
- 16:57know that jazz is highly improvisational and all this stuff, right? And then you're like, yeah,
- 17:02Anybody can come jam.
- 17:03I mean, maybe, but if you're trying to have a specific jam session that is rooted in jazz,
- 17:09it might not make sense to invite everyone.
- 17:11He gives the example of having invited people who did other genres just because you're like,
- 17:15yeah, you want to be nice.
- 17:16And so you invite your musician friends from like a different world.
- 17:19But the groove was not the same when they got together because he could feel that his musicians,
- 17:23his friends who normally get together, they were trying to accommodate the outsider.
- 17:28So the outsider wasn't totally satisfied because they feel like, you know,
- 17:31I'm trying to get in, but what's going on? And then the people who were regulars there couldn't
- 17:36totally enjoy themselves because they're trying to not lean in too heavily so that the other person
- 17:40can join in. And again, there's a time and a place, but what is the purpose? Let's get more specific
- 17:45to women's friendship. Maybe it was a year ago now, I was talking to two of my closest girlfriends
- 17:51and I was telling them that I was having a dinner party coming up. And I host dinner parties pretty
- 17:56often where it's like six women, but I like hosting in a very specific way. And I don't mean with
- 18:02regard to like the napkins and florals and stationary. Okay. I mean, I'm big on intentionality
- 18:09and purpose. We're either here cause we're talking about our faith. We're here cause we're talking
- 18:13mom stuff. We're here because I want to have a certain experience. So maybe we're talking book
- 18:18club and people know that I'm pretty intense about book club. So we don't talk about this book.
- 18:22Okay. You're not going to not read the book and come for vibes. Maybe another, maybe another book
- 18:27clubs, but if that's the case, you're a social club. You're not a book club specifically, but not
- 18:32too much on that. You can judge me later. Okay. So I have to give careful thought to the experience.
- 18:38I want those women to have. What's the point? What's the point? If I know we're going to dig
- 18:43in in a certain way for something that's like highly niche, then should I be thoughtful around
- 18:48who I'm inviting? Because it takes away from the experience. If you're having a dinner
- 18:52and you want women to be able to speak to certain things
- 18:56without having to dance around
- 18:58or being fearful that we're going to be judged,
- 19:00that really requires you to be thoughtful
- 19:05about who you invite into that room.
- 19:07And it does not make you mean
- 19:09to not invite someone into a space.
- 19:11And if you're the person not invited,
- 19:13you're not entitled to be in the space.
- 19:15Now, if we're talking about friends that you have
- 19:17who never invite you,
- 19:19they're intentionally leaving you out,
- 19:20they're trying to hide things and conspire,
- 19:22that's a whole other issue. I'm not speaking to that. That's something totally different in my
- 19:27mind. Okay. Mistreatment and exclusion that's persistent and all these signs that are signaling
- 19:33to you, we don't enjoy your company. We talking about something else. Okay. Right now I'm talking
- 19:38about the idea of social gatherings and tailoring them according to the objective and the experience
- 19:44that you desire. And that means not everyone's invited to all the things. And when I was talking
- 19:48to my friends about a particular dinner party that I had coming up. I was like, by the way,
- 19:53I love you guys, but you're not invited. And it was a whole, it was a whole thing. And I kind of
- 19:57laughed and they kind of laughed, but they were also like, that's messed up. But I had to explain
- 20:01the women I had invited was for a very specific thing, like these five, six women. And so these
- 20:06two girls, they're my best friends. They're my best friends. And I'm like, these girls, I don't
- 20:11really know too well. And it's kind of a get to know you for a particular thing to me. It wouldn't
- 20:16be appropriate to also have my besties there that didn't share the same context and also didn't fit
- 20:21the whole, we're all trying to get to know each other vibe. And I'm trying to facilitate connections
- 20:26among the ladies. And then I turn around and my besties are down there and they don't fit
- 20:29this programming at all. Okay. But it was their first time hearing somebody, I think, speak very
- 20:34explicitly about the whole idea of like, if I host anything, you're invited. I'm like, most of the
- 20:38times. Yeah. But if it's like a very specific gathering, no. And I already know someone might
- 20:44be listening right now and be like, that's crazy, but I'm a highly social person. And a part of my
- 20:48enjoyment comes from having really good gatherings and social experiences where people feel seen,
- 20:55but sometimes for it to be inclusive and to have people feel like, wow, I really belong here.
- 21:01By extension, it means that some people don't belong there. So that when you say this is a safe
- 21:06space, you can actually mean that because they know that everybody who's here in this room has
- 21:11been curated and invited for such a time as this. And we have these shared experiences or goals.
- 21:17And so I feel like, man, I'm with my people. That can only happen if not everybody's invited to the
- 21:23party. Quote me. If you disagree, come tell me about it. Come tell me about it. Anytime.
- 21:30Betterfemalefriendships.com or on Instagram at friendforward. Okay. Now listen, if you are a
- 21:36member of Office Hours, we're going to keep this going. I have three additional friendship mindsets
- 21:41that I want to share with you that have changed for me in a very personal way. So please be sure
- 21:46to go to that space as soon as you can to enjoy bonus material from this conversation. But for now,
- 21:52I encourage you to identify certain friendship beliefs that have evolved. And if you haven't had
- 21:58any evolve, I want you to look at why. Because as we grow, as we age, and as we engage in different
- 22:04relationships, it should change and challenge what we know to be true about ourselves, about others,
- 22:12and about all that is possible in female friendship. If this is something you're working
- 22:17through and this episode is particularly resonant for you, I want to hear about it.
- 22:22You can come and visit us on Instagram at friendford, or you can visit us anytime
- 22:27at betterfemalefriendships.com. In the meantime, I'll be right here rooting for you always
- 22:32on your ongoing journey toward better female friendships. Until next time.