Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / How Will The House Vs The NCAA Settlement Impact Ohio State?
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:04here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going, Tony? You
- 0:11know when sometimes you're like, you know, how do you feel about how
- 0:16you're doing your job? How do you feel like you've done you? Have
- 0:18you been successful in life? Today's one of those days where I think everyone
- 0:23should be feeling great because you look at what the leadership of college athletics has
- 0:29led college athletics into over the last oh couple decades, and it's like,
- 0:34boy, I don't know how good I am at whatever I'm doing right now,
- 0:37but I'm better than those guys, that's for sure. Yeah. I
- 0:41just have like a tunes this meme the driving cat and you just have like
- 0:46the NCAA over Tunsus's face and then like the next the next image is the
- 0:51car going over the cliff, and turns out don't let the NCAA drive.
- 0:57Basically, don't let whatever you do, don't let the nca drive your car.
- 1:00So we are going to going to talk about Tom's favorite thing, court
- 1:06stuff, and but the the House versus the NCAA settlement is coming down.
- 1:12Plaintiffs are agreeing the the defendants are agreeing, the NCAA, the conferences,
- 1:19everybody has come to an agreement, and we want to talk about how that's
- 1:23going to impact the game more and more more more importantly, how it's going
- 1:25to impact Ohio State. And yet with all of these agreements, Tom,
- 1:29there's still this one of the things that has been written, not enough is
- 1:33Matt Brown extra points or Ross Ellinger, Pete dam or whomever is saying,
- 1:37you know, the judge could still say no. And it's like boy,
- 1:42like all rise, the Honorable Teddy Valentine is presiding like somebody if the judge
- 1:49wants to make it about themselves, like oh no, no, no,
- 1:51no, please, we're all in agreement. Let's just let's just move on.
- 1:55But Tom, this this thing, this judge thing, or any other
- 2:00kind of aspect like you said, it could go out the window. There's
- 2:04all of this momentum right now. Nothing is settled. Nothing, even the
- 2:08settlement isn't settled. Correct, Even the settlement isn't settled. And even once
- 2:13the settlement is settled, there's still a whole bunch of other stuff that isn't
- 2:16necessarily resolved. By this College Athletics has gotten itself into a point where a
- 2:24multi billion dollar settlement that's going to involve schools paying twenty million dollars a year
- 2:30for the foreseeable future, moving forward to future athletes and paying out multi billions
- 2:36of dollars to solve just an issue with athletes over a four year span prior
- 2:40to the institution of NIL. That doesn't actually solve all the problems. And
- 2:46there's a bunch of well, I don't know, we'll have to figure out
- 2:47how we'll apply Title nine, for example, And all of this goes back
- 2:53to you know, this is all stuff that if you had asked college administrators
- 2:59ten years ago, they would have said, never, couldn't that's that's not
- 3:02what we do. Because I think there's an important distinction here we talk about
- 3:07the NC double A and the utter fecklessness of the NCAA. The NC double
- 3:10A is you know, when I say the NC DOUBLEA, you probably are
- 3:15thinking of previous NCAA president Mark Emmert, who you know, was basically getting
- 3:20paid a couple million dollars a year to stand up and getting punched in the
- 3:23face repeatedly by every person writing or talking about the NCAA. The NCAA is
- 3:29actually made up of schools, administrators, president, university presidents, all of
- 3:34those people have screwed this up so unbelievably badly that we are at this point
- 3:40because there was no plan. There was no plan at all five ten years
- 3:45ago for dealing with any of this stuff. And the plan was just,
- 3:49well, this is all impossible. There's no possible way to handle this.
- 3:53When they built the Berlin Wall, Tony, the United States diplomats in Berlin,
- 4:00you know, they started the Soviets started building the Berlin Wall like overnight,
- 4:03like you know, one am or something like that, and they woke
- 4:05up the Soviet or woke up the American ambassador, whoever it was, and
- 4:12he goes to the file cabinet where you know, they have plans for all
- 4:15of these different you know, possibilities, and he opens the one that says
- 4:18border closure and there's there's a faulder there. He opens it and there's nothing
- 4:21in there. That's the NC double A and the university presidents like five ten
- 4:26years ago, just you know, what's the plan for Well, you know,
- 4:30we have to start paying the players. And you open the folder and
- 4:31there's nothing there. And that's how you get into this mess where you've got
- 4:36state legislatures, you've got judges in different places, You've got you know,
- 4:41you're you're going to Congress and begging Congress to please, please, mister Congress,
- 4:45save our lives, please save our please save our college sports. There's
- 4:48just there was no plan and now so now everything's just happening, like everything's
- 4:53just sort of happening to the n c double A and the member schools.
- 4:56And that's how you get into a spot where, Okay, now you're facing
- 4:59a lawsuit that could be the end of your organization, so you have to
- 5:01settle. But we haven't even talked Tony about the smaller schools. Yes,
- 5:05this is a settlement between the the big conferences, the big schools, the
- 5:12NCAA itself, and you know these these different, these different class action lawsuits.
- 5:16There are a whole bunch of people who are getting volunteered to get paid
- 5:20to pay a whole bunch of money in this and those those conferences, in
- 5:24those schools are not real happy about it. Yeah, And that's where I
- 5:27want to go right now. And if you want to follow along in the
- 5:30the table of contents of this show, I'm just using Ross Dollinger's tweet from
- 5:36from Thursday night as just a guideline in terms of all of the bullet points
- 5:43of what the settlement means. And you're talking about the small schools, and
- 5:47so basically, of that two point nearly eight billion dollars of back pay of
- 5:54ten years that it needs to be paid, the NCAA is going to take
- 5:59care of forty percent of it. Schools are going to take care of that
- 6:00sixty percent. So that's like one point six billion dollars or something like that
- 6:05that the schools are going to be responsible for. Now, the Power five
- 6:11schools are going to be responsible for forty percent of that. The other twenty
- 6:16seven conferences like will be responsible for sixty percent of that. And according to
- 6:23one of the articles that I read, ninety percent of the back pay is
- 6:27going to Power five football players and basketball players. So basically, weaber State
- 6:31for the next ten years is going to have to write a check because Joe
- 6:35Burrow couldn't get nil. That's ridiculous. That is that is the very top
- 6:40making the very bottom pay because they don't want to have to, you know,
- 6:44like, ah, we'll just just pass it on, I'll just raise
- 6:46prices or whatever, you know, like they're just they're it's being passed on
- 6:51to people had nothing to do with this, Like you're going to have these
- 6:56small schools and conferences that will have to pay out more than the last and
- 7:01over the previous ten years. Then they anybody would have made from nil.
- 7:09Like again, if I just use Weaver State or somebody at Bowling Green,
- 7:14like the idea that they could have this huge windfall is fine, but like
- 7:24the big schools that have caused this should have to pay more than they're getting
- 7:29away with. And a lot of the small schools are the small conferences are
- 7:32furious, but it's like we have to go along with it because they don't
- 7:36have the power and if they if they if they try to drag their feet
- 7:41or say no, then everything collapses. So you just got to go along
- 7:44with it and get washed away and hope you can keep your head off a
- 7:46head float. I think Tony t used your example there of Weber State and
- 7:50Joe Burrow. This would be the first time Weber State is responsible for a
- 7:54former Ohio State athlete since choebe Ohsokolic. I believe would have been the last
- 7:58time we'll name from the name from the past. Is this is this is
- 8:05the you know, the big boys saying to the to the little little guys,
- 8:09you know, you know, what are you going to do about it?
- 8:11This is a settlement that they the Big Conferences were the parties to the
- 8:15settlement that you know, the Big Sky Conference was not a party to the
- 8:18house case. It was just the Five Power Conferences, which are really now
- 8:22the four Power Conferences. But the PAC twelve is a party to this in
- 8:26one of the many This is how screwed up this is right now, the
- 8:31it's the really the five Power Conferences, and they're just going to go,
- 8:33well, yeah, they'll just send the bill down to that end of the
- 8:37table and they'll they'll take care of it. And yeah, it is.
- 8:41It is rather unfair. This is you know, it's it's cut like the
- 8:45Power Conferences are trying to fund a new baseball stadium or something like that,
- 8:48like yeah, I don't know, yes, we make all the money,
- 8:50but what if you know, what if what if you guys paid it just
- 8:54you know, jack up a hotel tax or something south a Big Sky Conference,
- 8:58it'll be fine. It's it's I think the thing that people are probably
- 9:05wondering is, well, why why would they possibly go along with it the
- 9:07smaller conferences, and I think that if they don't, I think there's a
- 9:13possibility of the big conferences just you know, pull away and separate, and
- 9:16then you you're you know, maybe that's at the end of the current TV
- 9:20deals or whatever. But then you really have Okay, now there's no more
- 9:22D one. Now you know, now Weber States no longer invited the NCAA
- 9:26basketball tournament. So how do you like that. There's just there's a lot
- 9:30of leverage that the big guys have over the little guys. But yeah,
- 9:33it that struck me as deeply unfair that, well, Ohio State's making all
- 9:39of this money, and or Michigan's making all of this money, or Texas
- 9:45is making all of this money, all of these big schools and you know,
- 9:48they're they weren't paying their players, so they have fancy facilities, and
- 9:52their athletic directors are making X amount of money and their football coaches are making
- 9:54X amount of money. And now that it's now that the bill has come
- 9:58due, it's well, listen, we're all in this together. We've all
- 10:01got it. We've all got to solve this problem together, because you know,
- 10:05listen, whose fault is this. Look, we're not here to point
- 10:09fingers. We're not here. That's not what this is all about. You
- 10:11know, I, personally, Tony would love to see Jim Delaney, Larry
- 10:16Scott, all of these guys who are making ten million dollar bonuses, twenty
- 10:20million dollar bonuses off of this system. I would love to see a lot
- 10:24of that recouped as part of the settlement. I suspect, Tony, that
- 10:28is probably not how it's going to happen. Jim Delaney made like trying to
- 10:35find it real quick, because I think it was like seven million dollars last
- 10:39year from the Big Ten. Still, he sure did, Tony, he
- 10:43sure did that. He was I believe the highest paid person in the Big
- 10:48Ten's financial statements, even though he doesn't work for the conference anymore. And
- 10:52that includes or whether it doesn't does not include I think like a four hundred
- 10:56thousand dollars cent annual salary just as consultant. Maybe maybe you could give that
- 11:03back for like laundry, the cost of laundry for the players that he has
- 11:07always been so concerned about over the years. Maybe this would be a way
- 11:11to give back the Jim Delaney laundry fund. And you know, at this
- 11:16point though, he could probably just instead of laundry, just buy everybody washers
- 11:22and dryers. You can get a really good discount by the pair. Buy
- 11:26in ball, you'd probably get two good ones total for like eight hundred bucks
- 11:30total in if you buy in ball, that's a drop in the bucket for
- 11:33him. Or you know what, how about just dropping the bucket? Can
- 11:39do laundry that way? Do it do it in the old ways like he
- 11:41used to at North Carolina, Tony. Do you remember when Jim Delaney said
- 11:46that when if the Big ten schools had to start paying players, the Big
- 11:48Ten would have to seriously think about going to Division three. I haven't heard
- 11:52anything about the Big Ten going D three, but I assume that has to
- 11:54be imminent right now since brave leader Jim Delaney is just sitting there as a
- 12:01consultant then getting paid a lot of money. I'm sure he's advising them to
- 12:03go D three right now. So we may have another breaking news podcast any
- 12:07day now covering that he's probably like an a lounge chair, like being fed
- 12:11grapes, saying I can't believe they caved, can't believe the Big Ten caved.
- 12:16Please more grapes. And so now with this, this settlement is will
- 12:22eventually should eventually allow schools to pay players directly around twenty two million dollars a
- 12:28year, twenty two percent of the annual ticket revenue TV revenue of the Power
- 12:35five schools. Now, the thing is like it's on average twenty two percent,
- 12:39but it's going to be like ten percent of Ohio State's budget, and
- 12:43it'll be like, you know, twenty percent of say Georgia Tech's budget something
- 12:46like that. So there's still gonna be some fluctuations and things there, and
- 12:50you don't have to go that high, but if you want to compete,
- 12:54you're going to have to. So that that will kick in if all goes
- 12:58well next summer now fall. And in terms of how this impacts Ohio State,
- 13:05they're going to keep up. That's the one thing that we can always
- 13:09we've always said here is that whatever changes take place, and there's a bunch
- 13:13of fear mongering about how Ohio State's going to fall behind, how Ohio State's
- 13:16going to be left behind, Ohio State is always going to be well equipped
- 13:20to keep up and excel. And this is going to be another one of
- 13:24those things where yes, they'll have the twenty million to do it. And
- 13:28then on top of that, collectives aren't going anywhere. Now they may come
- 13:31in house, but the collectives are there as They're going to be bonuses as
- 13:37well, so like you're the nil stuff, rather there's going to be added
- 13:41bonuses to this. So Ohio State's going to be just fine in this aspect.
- 13:45They'll have the money, they'll have more money. And tom should Buckeye
- 13:50fans be concerned that Ohio State is going to be left behind because of the
- 13:54revenue share model, No, as an Ohio State fan, you are probably
- 14:01in just about the single best position that any person can be with their college
- 14:07athletics program right now. You know, this is a everything about college sports
- 14:13right now. The separation of the power too from the rest of the power
- 14:18conferences. Well, guess what Ohio State is part of the Big Ten?
- 14:22If there is some kind of a future split of the haves versus the have
- 14:26nots in college football where you know what, Yeah, we've been playing football
- 14:30with Indiana for a long time, but what does Indiana really bring to the
- 14:33conference? Not that much we can live without you. Well guess what.
- 14:35Guess what set of the vide Ohio State's on they are on the positive side
- 14:39of that, and they are going to move up to whatever the highest level
- 14:41is. Financially, Ohio State is one of the biggest in the nation athletic
- 14:46departments. It's you know, like Ohio State and Texas are usually kind of
- 14:50right there one and two. Ohio State as this as this is a flat
- 14:56percentage based on the average. Guess what, this is going to be the
- 15:00smallest that Ohi You know, Ohio State's percentage of their total athletic budget is
- 15:03going to be some of the smallest among which all the teams that are doing
- 15:07this, and yet there will be you know, pissing and moaning about how
- 15:11this is. You know, this is going to be a lot of money,
- 15:13and oh boy, they've really got to make make the numbers work.
- 15:18It is everyone's problem more than it is Ohio State's problem. So you know,
- 15:22for you know, as an Ohio State fan, you know, however,
- 15:26this is bad. If this ends up being bad, you know,
- 15:30in some way financially or whatever for the Ohio State Athletic Department, it is
- 15:33going to be so much worse for everyone else and in ways that it's going
- 15:39to be better for Ohio State. It's going to be so much better for
- 15:41Ohio State than it is for just about anyone else. So, you know,
- 15:45this is you know, is this a good day or a bad day
- 15:48for college athletics? I think the answer is, well, that's a very
- 15:52complicated question and a very complicated answer, and it depends a lot on some
- 15:56things that haven't been decided yet. Is this a good thing or a bad
- 15:58thing for the future of Ohio State sports as an ongoing enterprise. It's probably
- 16:04much better for Ohio State than it is for virtually anyone else in the nation.
- 16:10Yeah, they're going to be in a position to survive and thrive.
- 16:17I was listening to an interview with Tim Albin this week, Ohio University head
- 16:22coach, who was asked about the possibility of like a group of five for
- 16:29you know, chief group of five is that if there's still five conferences there
- 16:33by the time this whole thing settles, you know, would you be in
- 16:37favor of a playoff for the group of five? S? Absolutely, because
- 16:40it's it's a completely different situation for Ohio and Ohio State or Clemson or Georgia.
- 16:48Because you're you're not You're not living in the same world, and so
- 16:51it would be nice to be able to play for a championship and have your
- 16:53players be able to play for a championship. I don't know whether you would
- 17:00rather have that one shot of being the one team that makes the CFP versus
- 17:06being the one who wins the group of five, because I don't think you
- 17:11can have both, do you If it's like winning the NIT If you win
- 17:18the group of five, it's like, well you were the sixty fifth past
- 17:21sixty ninth best. Like if you win the group of five playoffs and the
- 17:23group of five champion was like the other the top ranked team was in the
- 17:27CFP, it's like, well you're the congratulations on being the second best group
- 17:32of five team. But this continues to separate those things. I do expect
- 17:37eventually a group of five championship, And as Albert said, just wherever the
- 17:41money leads, that's where we're going to go. And so far, it's
- 17:45kind of like if you're you know, you're stranded in the mountain, just
- 17:48go downhill and find the water source and then take the water source to civilization.
- 17:53And following the money is following downhill to the water and and hasn't let
- 18:00anybody, well, has it. It hasn't. You're always no one gets
- 18:07stranded out in the wilderness and dies of exposure, Tony. That's not a
- 18:11thing that happens. So I'm sure it's going to be fine. I think
- 18:12that was the end of your story, right, Yeah, no, correct,
- 18:15Just find find the water and you'll be fine. Don't drink it,
- 18:18Boil it if you can, if you have no fire, I don't know,
- 18:22strain it through your sock, depending on the condition of your feet.
- 18:26So yeah, go ahead, Tom. I do like the idea that the
- 18:30group of five is drinking water through a sock. That's a pretty good analogy
- 18:33for the situation they're in right now. They're stranded alone in drinking water through
- 18:37a sock and water. If they're like wall wall, things are good for
- 18:42Ohio State, and Ohio State's going to be fine no matter what. Ohio
- 18:45University. Let's take them. What what is the future for them? Now?
- 18:51They now all of a sudden, they have to pay twenty percent,
- 18:53you know, they have to pay whatever this chunk of you know, this
- 18:57this chunk of money is to you know, for back pay for as part
- 19:03of this settlement, and their athletic budget is probably ten percent of what Ohio
- 19:07States is maybe a little more than that fifteen percent something like that. Guess
- 19:12what, That money has to come from somewhere. And they do not have
- 19:15a big fat TV deal with Fox that's going to pay them, you know,
- 19:18sixty million dollars a year or whatever it is, so that money has
- 19:22to come from somewhere. The you know, if you can feel fine about
- 19:26this, if you're an Ohio State football fan, if you're an Ohio University
- 19:30baseball fan or swimming fan or softball fan, what does this mean for the
- 19:36future of your program? Will Ohio University still be able to support those programs
- 19:40to pay for those programs if they have to have all this money going back
- 19:44to pay you know, because JT. Barrett couldn't get nil back way back
- 19:48when, and that money has to go to pay for that. That's a
- 19:52little bit more of a murky area. And that doesn't even get into the
- 19:55Title nine piece of this, where you know, there's all these write ups
- 20:00about Title nine and it's like, what is you know, in terms of
- 20:02paying the players, just do the you know, do the non rev sports
- 20:07women's sports have to get half? You know, an equal amount of the
- 20:08money. We don't know. That's not part of a settlement. So yeah,
- 20:12this is this is going to be you know again, this is if
- 20:17you were an Ohio State fan, this is fine. Everything is fine,
- 20:19nothing's going to change. This could potentially have real serious ramifications for a huge
- 20:26number of programs that are not Ohio state size, Ohio state scale. And
- 20:30we'll get to the title nine aspect in a sect here the next series of
- 20:37ballplayers from ross Ellinger talking about cap enforcement, the cap of that twenty two
- 20:42million dollars or whatever, and then also having the a more legitimate reporting of
- 20:52the nile stuff. I do wonder once players are paid through the university,
- 20:57like, all of that is foiable, so you'll be able to find out
- 21:02what a player is making through university. And that's going to be something that
- 21:07we probably do every year now when we you know, we also do like
- 21:10the coaches salaries, the coaches performance reviews, and also please send along the
- 21:15players salaries and the the oversight and the enforcement also talks about this has to
- 21:26be true nil and it has to be based on developed fair market value data,
- 21:33and the NCAA would enforce that. Now, the idea of the NCAA
- 21:34enforcing anything. Part of the settlement is that, hey, the NCAAA can
- 21:40enforce stuff again, but that doesn't mean states aren't going to sue you for
- 21:44doing it. So like this whole thing is still contentious in that way.
- 21:48But the idea of nil and fair market value is interesting to me because I
- 21:55enough as Pete and Eco set On three wrote about talking with some some collective
- 22:00people and how the asks from the players are way out of bounds, like
- 22:04they've got to stop asking for all this money, and it's like maybe the
- 22:08collective should stop paying all of the money, Like I'm not asking, I'm
- 22:12not talking about collusion. But you have the power to say no, we're
- 22:17not going to We're not doing this. Your ask is too much. Do
- 22:21you have the power to negotiate you? And and if somebody else out negotiates
- 22:25you, congratulations. I'm sure you've been a fan of capitalism your entire life
- 22:29up until that point, so I don't want to hear you complain when it
- 22:32impacts you finally negatively. But the idea of the nil being fair market value,
- 22:37I think is a fantastic idea. But I'll believe the enforcement of all
- 22:44of this when I see it, and every single loophole is going to be
- 22:47taken advantage of, as it always is. Every boundary is always pushed.
- 22:52So godspeed well the idea of fair market value and what the NCAA is going
- 22:59to determine what firm market value is and then they're going to enforce it and
- 23:02you're not allowed to earn more than that. I mean, phrases like restraint
- 23:06of trade come to mind. You know, there's a reason the like Major
- 23:11League Baseball or the NFL can put a salary cap on things, and that's
- 23:15because they have an anti trust exemption through Congress. Guess who does not have
- 23:18an anti trust exemption through Congress. Why it's the nc DOUBLEA. So why
- 23:22would the NCUBA be able to put a cap on the amount of money that
- 23:26you earn any more than you know, the state of Ohio could say,
- 23:30sorry, you're no one in the state of Ohio who does sports media is
- 23:34allowed to earn more than this amount of money per year. That couldn't do
- 23:38that. Why Why would the nc DOUABLEA be able to put that kind of
- 23:42cap on this if they don't have an anti trust exemption, because that would
- 23:47be you know, that that would you're opening yourself up. I would certainly
- 23:49assume to lawsuits alleging collusion, which is what you just said. That's you
- 23:56know, there was a back in the eighties, major League Baseball had an
- 24:00off season where all of a sudden, like none of the good players got
- 24:04signed this one off season, and it was really weird. And then later
- 24:08it turned out that the Major League Baseball owners have just sort of made a
- 24:11private agreement among themselves not to give people any more money than you know,
- 24:15a million dollars a year or whatever it was back then. And guess what
- 24:19they got in a bunch of trouble because you can't do that, even with
- 24:22an anti drust exemption, you can't just privately agree to not pay guys.
- 24:26So, yeah, this is this is all like, it all looks great,
- 24:30it all sounds wonderful. I'm sure everything no pay for play or booster
- 24:36pay. Okay, sure that's been going on forever. But now you're going
- 24:38to have a system where the nil is allowed. But you know, these
- 24:45payments that have been going for probably one hundred years now under the table,
- 24:49that's all going to go away somehow. I just I you know, this
- 24:53all looks great. This all sounds wonderful. I have so many questions about
- 24:59how it's actually going to be you put into place and enforced that I feel
- 25:03like, this is great. This is like your rough drafts. What's the
- 25:07final version of this going to look like? I have no idea. The
- 25:11fair market value thing I think will come into play with the Title nine stuff,
- 25:17because as Charlie Baker, the NCAA president, says, you know,
- 25:21he doesn't think it's necessarily about dollars for Title nine. It's about access,
- 25:26and so you need that fair market value basically to show that we don't need
- 25:32to pay the women's sports as much as we need to pay men's football,
- 25:37football and men's basketball, because that's that's where all of the revenue is generated.
- 25:41That those are the recognizable faces, so on and so forth, that's
- 25:45where the market is for nil. You'll have exceptions. You know, you
- 25:49can't use Caitlin Clark as proof of hey, look look how much I deserve
- 25:53because she is the outlier of all outliers. But there will be those,
- 25:57and those players will be able to capes. I just think you'll use that
- 26:03fair market value to prove that everybody has access. But we don't like,
- 26:11you're not paying a baseball player as much as you're playing a football player,
- 26:15so you've got to be able to use that. Now, some of the
- 26:18other loopholes that they're talking about with Title nine is to make all of the
- 26:22payments come through the collective, because the collective is not the university. So
- 26:26then you've basically done an end around around Title nine completely. And there are
- 26:32other people who believe that Title nine basically does not apply here. As you
- 26:36said, Tom, the courts will decide whether Title nine applies there. But
- 26:41I think the fair market value is one way to it, because I am
- 26:44a lawyer. The fair market value is one way to maybe keep everything above
- 26:49board while also actually keeping everything above board basically and not having to do an
- 26:55end around and saying, look, this is what everybody's worth in this realm.
- 27:00And then of course you'll have somebody to be like, how is how
- 27:03is a freshman? How is an eighteen year old quarterback worth two point two
- 27:07million dollars when they haven't done anything? It's like, well, because other
- 27:11people are offering them. If anybody else is offering you know, you're swimmer
- 27:15this much by all means take it. But I if you're trying to make
- 27:21everybody earn the same that's that's not going to happen. There's I just don't
- 27:26see how that happens. Well, And what are you basing it on?
- 27:30Are you basing it on if you're a freshman, it's based on your recruiting
- 27:34ranking? Or is it based on your social media following? Or you know,
- 27:40Jeremiah Smith, for example, number one player in the class at twenty
- 27:42twenty four. Okay, he came in and number one player in the class,
- 27:47and obviously I had quite a following on social media and a lot of
- 27:51you know, a lot of name recognition. So okay, he's worth this
- 27:52much. Okay, then we start going to spring practices and then everyone's talking
- 27:56about Jeremiah Smith all the time. Okay, So does that mean he's worth
- 28:00more? Does that mean his fair market value has gone up more? Or
- 28:03does that mean that he's still under the same deal as the you know,
- 28:08as when he came in and then when he goes out and you know,
- 28:11if he scored three touchdowns in week one against Akron, does that make his
- 28:15I mean it does does his nil value his fair market value go up?
- 28:18What? How is this all being evaluated. This is all what you know,
- 28:22this is all a wonderful idea. It's a it sounds like a great
- 28:26plan, and you know, this is a lot of this I think.
- 28:30I look at it and I go, you know, this is they are
- 28:33building the tracks. The train is running down the tracks, and they are
- 28:37like building the tracks in front of the train and just hoping the train doesn't
- 28:41pass the end of the tracks. That's kind of where we are right now.
- 28:45And this is you know, this is all supposed to go into effect
- 28:48next year, which that's good that it's not going into effect this year because
- 28:52I don't think he would be ready to go into effect this year. Next
- 28:55year's next year's coming pretty fast. So will this all be ready? Will
- 28:59all the battles be settled before next year? I'm going to guess probably not.
- 29:03This is you know, this is getting pitched as here's this solution that
- 29:08solves everything. And then the more you look at it, the more it's
- 29:11like, well, it feels like maybe the can has been kicked a little
- 29:18bit down the road and you know, you've you've deflected this meteor that was
- 29:22coming directly per earth. But you know, there are potentially a lot more
- 29:26metiaors coming from a lot of different directions here, and you know, maybe
- 29:30they'll be able to deflect them all. But right now they're kind of going,
- 29:33well, I think we think we got that one. That's good.
- 29:36Yeah, you've deflected it, but it's just skipped a little, and then
- 29:38it's going to come back around, or if it's going to bring it back
- 29:41around right right for a direct hit. So roster changes coming in terms of
- 29:52the scholarship cap, you'll be able to get make everybody, put everybody on
- 29:55scholarship. However, they continue to talk about limiting a roster to like eighty
- 29:59five, which there's been a huge pushback from schools I'm sure, like Ohio
- 30:03State sort of like, okay, we'll make it like ninety or ninety five,
- 30:07which is still crazy small can when you consider I heard Matt Ruhle on
- 30:15the radio and I think he said in Nebraska right now is like one hundred
- 30:18and forty players, like one hundred and forty five players on the roster.
- 30:21And of course they've always had this huge walk on program that has been a
- 30:25huge part of them forever, and so you'd essentially be getting rid of the
- 30:30walk ons now you can't just stack rosters like you can't do it like back
- 30:37in Woody's day, when you could have one hundred and thirty players and guys
- 30:41would wait four years for their turn. You can have ninety five scholarships and
- 30:45try to have classes of thirty five every year, you're going to be losing
- 30:48fifteen guys every year to the portal. Because you know of the situation in
- 30:55terms of well, I don't want to sit any longer. I do think
- 30:59you'll you'll see three year contracts signed. You know that that's going to be
- 31:03something that is now in play for this which then what what's the buyout on
- 31:11it? And do schools even care about a buyout, Like if they want
- 31:14to cut somebody, I don't think they. The investment is probably pretty small
- 31:18and the buyout would just be the length of the rest of the contract.
- 31:21Basically, because no, no high school agent is going to allow their their
- 31:26client to throw in a small buyout out there in a you know, Ohio
- 31:30state wanting to get rid of a thirty year lineman for another spot. Oh
- 31:33yeah, fine, we'll just we'll pay the rest of the four hundred and
- 31:36fifty thousand that is required or whatever it would be, but that would limit
- 31:42movements and then of course there would be buyouts. It's like if you want
- 31:45to hit the portal. You know what, Tom, what's a good number
- 31:49is it? You know? Is it fifty percent of the contract? Like
- 31:53that's all going to be part of this as well. Coaches can coaches talk
- 31:57about, well, if I leave, I've got to pay out. There's
- 32:00no way that with these three year deals like that, you'll see some of
- 32:05the buiouts. But then will it become a recruiting pitch or recruiting lore like
- 32:09we won't give you, we won't force you to have a buyout. Does
- 32:13that give you the upper hand even though it takes away your upper hand?
- 32:16Well, I think you're going to see teams not enforcing that a lot,
- 32:21probably because you know, it's like if you get someone to come to your
- 32:24school and you promise them something and then you don't deliver it, and you
- 32:29know, word gets around that you you know, or you offer a guy
- 32:34you know this is this is always a concern with in state prospects. For
- 32:37example, you offer a guy from this high school and then like he doesn't
- 32:40develop the way he thought, and so the offer gets pulled and then you
- 32:44are persona non grata at that high school forever. If you are limiting people's
- 32:49ability to transfer out, that's the kind of thing that will probably eventually hurt
- 32:52you in recruiting. So eventually people probably are not going to do it.
- 32:57I think my bigger issue with all of this is going back to the limiting
- 33:01the roster size at a time when you're asking players to play more games.
- 33:07It was not that long ago. Well it was that long ago because it
- 33:09was when I was in college and you were in college. But there used
- 33:12to be an eleven game regular season and no conference championship game and one bowl
- 33:15game, and it was twelve games was the season. And now twelve games
- 33:19is the regular season, and maybe there's a conference championship game, and if
- 33:22you lose that, you could potentially have to play four more games on top
- 33:24of that. So now you've gone from a twelve game regular season to a
- 33:27seventeen game regular season. There's a bunch of, you know, studies and
- 33:31data about the impact of football on one's health long term, whether that's CTE
- 33:37or just you know, the ability to get out of bed in the morning
- 33:39without sounding like you're making popcorn, whatever it is there's a bunch of data
- 33:45on that that you know, colleges and programs and leagues and the folks in
- 33:50charge of DNC DOBLA are concerned about limiting the number of exposures and number of
- 33:53hits the guys are going to take. And you know, this is a
- 33:55big concern and we really care about the health of the players. But also
- 34:00so we need you to play a bunch of extra games, and we need
- 34:01to do it with fewer people. Seems a little incongrus to me, Tony.
- 34:06It doesn't feel like that necessarily aligns with the idea of limiting the number
- 34:09of exposures. But TV wants more games, and schools have to you know,
- 34:15schools don't want to have to pay, so you know, hey,
- 34:17we're gonna have to just do it with fewer people and we'll just have to
- 34:20figure it out. I just have to figure it out. And as I'm
- 34:22reading all of these, like the schools are gonna have to you know,
- 34:27all baseball players can be on scholarship. Not that Wisconsin has a baseball program,
- 34:30but thinking back to Barry Alvarez when they had the opportunity Wisconsin, when
- 34:36all the schools are giving the opportunity to bring all of the COVID people back.
- 34:39He's like, no, we're not We're not doing that. That's going
- 34:42to be too expensive. So you know when you talk about, hey,
- 34:45why can't you just have one hundred and fifteen if you're gonna eliminate put everybody
- 34:52on scholarship, I don't know why they needed to make this change. I
- 34:54don't know why they needed to do this. I don't know why you can't
- 34:58just keep We've been talking for a while how they're gonna raised the scholarship limit
- 35:02because of the added games. We sat and talked with Bill Corrello what we
- 35:07do every year for like an hour talking to Big ten head of officials,
- 35:10talking about last year, the number of exposures like you said, and the
- 35:15running clock after first downs to limit you know, to limit seven take seven
- 35:21plays off the game and over the course of the season. That's like taking
- 35:24a game of exposures away from a player because they're concerned about safety. We've
- 35:30talked about the field ter if the different kinds of field, the safety there.
- 35:34The NFL is allowing safety helmets now and that's going to be coming to
- 35:37college football I assume next year as well. And yet yeah, but it's
- 35:43just, you know, another fifteen scholarships with all of these other scholarships,
- 35:46that's just that's a bridge too far. And plus, I you know,
- 35:50I don't want to have to give back any of my buildings, or you
- 35:53know, I don't. I don't want to take a hit. I will,
- 35:57I will gladly cut staff, but I don't want. I don't want
- 36:00to be personally impacted by this. And yet they're they're going to have to
- 36:07figure something out in terms of the scholarship stuff. And I think one of
- 36:08the ways it takes us to our final bullet set of bullet points here is
- 36:13that potential new D one subdivision for increased power conference rule making flexibility for leagues
- 36:22to set some of their own rules, which we've talked about in the past,
- 36:24which has kind of been ongoing and building up. So Toledo Bowling Green
- 36:32they can have their eighty five scholarship limit. The teams are going to buy
- 36:37in that, you know, the SEC and the Big Ten have talked about
- 36:40if you're going to buy in, then this is going to be the limit.
- 36:44You can have this many. You don't necessarily have to because through all
- 36:46of this you don't have to do the twenty two percent. That's the cap.
- 36:50But if you're not going to do it, expect to be left behind
- 36:52by those who will. It's going to be a recruiting draw for those schools.
- 36:58And so I you know, this is going to necessitate a split if
- 37:05schools, the major schools are going to want more than eighty five or even
- 37:09more than ninety five. And I just think or and I even saw somewhere
- 37:15and maybe the most most recent article by Ross Ellinger Pete Tambill about the idea
- 37:21of a practice squad, which is really what the need for the walk ons
- 37:25would be. So if you if you allow for a practice squad, that
- 37:30kind of alleviates the issues there because I guarantee you talk to any coach or
- 37:35like, I know, we don't want to lose our walk ons, and
- 37:37you know, we may be talking to Ryan Day here in the next couple
- 37:42of weeks, and it's one of my first questions is going to be,
- 37:45Hey, how do you feel about only having eighty five guys on your team?
- 37:47How would that? How would you fare? How would how you know?
- 37:50What kind of response would you have to that? Well? How are
- 37:53you going to practice? If you only have eighty five guys on your team,
- 37:57how are you going to practice? You know, the the scout team
- 38:00is a really important part of just the daily operation of a football program because
- 38:06you need someone who's running the other team's offense so your defense can get a
- 38:08chance to see, you know, go up against what they're going up against
- 38:13on the field, and same thing for the other teams. You know,
- 38:15the other team's defense. You've got to have those. Those are generally like
- 38:19walk ons, those are generally true freshmen guys. If you only have eighty
- 38:22five scholarship guys and you have no walk ons, there's gonna be a lot
- 38:25more pressure on those true freshmen to be playing or at least be ready to
- 38:30play, so they're not necessarily going to be able to go get beat up
- 38:32on the scout team or to dedicate all their practice reps to being on the
- 38:37scout team and letting the offense and defense get their you know, their ones
- 38:40get their work in. So that's going to create a pretty significant logistical challenge.
- 38:45Sure you can, you can have a practice squad. The whole reason,
- 38:50I'm sure people are wondering, well, if you can have a practice
- 38:52squad, why couldn't you just have scholarship? Couldn't you have walk ons?
- 38:57And the answer to that is, you know, there are programs right now,
- 39:00like Nebraska is one of them where they're kind of doing a little bit
- 39:02of a workaround where yeah, guys aren't on scholarship, but they have nil
- 39:06that makes up for the scholarship. And Ohio State has done that in a
- 39:07couple isolated cases as well in the past. And so this is the NCAABLIE
- 39:13trying to just legislate that out of existence and we're going to We're going to
- 39:16solve that problem. It's like, well, you're probably creating multiple other problems
- 39:21by solving that problem and help big of a problem exactly is that because you
- 39:24know, sure you can have teams at you know, with a bunch of
- 39:29extra guys, that's fine. I think the long term health impacts here would
- 39:37be my biggest concern if I was a if I was an athletic administrator,
- 39:40because you're probably looking at some of these articles and saying, why are they
- 39:45you know, why is there concern that these guys are not employees? Will
- 39:49will players be employees in these major sports? And the schools are saying no,
- 39:52no, no, no, no, no, no. Why Well,
- 39:54employees have all sorts of you know, there there are health benefits that
- 39:59come a along with being an employee, and you may be liable for long
- 40:04term health issues. And are there long term health issues associated with playing football?
- 40:07I don't know, Tony, who's to say so, you know,
- 40:10I think you've got to be mindful of that and you've got to be able
- 40:14to sort of say, look, we're doing what we can do to limit
- 40:17limit some of the long term health impact because whether they're whether they're employees or
- 40:23not, they might eventually be employees even if they're not employees now, and
- 40:29that might come by a lawsuit. Lots of stuff during this whole process has
- 40:31come from the NCAA saying no, no, no, no no, and
- 40:35then the court saying, yuhuh, that's something that might come at some point
- 40:38in the future in terms of employment, and then some of the long term
- 40:44you know, the the NFLPA has had a bunch of injury settlements and long
- 40:49term injury kind of expenses. I don't know why college would be exempt from
- 40:54that, because you know, you can you can look at this and go,
- 40:57well, no, they're not employees. This is totally different from the
- 41:00NFL, and now you know, now you've got your roster caps and you've
- 41:02got a practice squad now, and okay, well we're paying them, but
- 41:06they're not employees. And it's like, you know, this is this is
- 41:08one of these like how stupid do you think I am? Kind of situations,
- 41:12because that was you know, the NCAA went to the Supreme Court a
- 41:15couple of years ago for the Austin case and basically got swatted into the third
- 41:20row and they got the kemba with tumbo finger wag and a nine to o
- 41:23decision that was basically so they're not you know, they're not employees. They're
- 41:29student athletes, which is totally different, and it's important that they're amateurs because
- 41:32it's important that they're amateurs, Like how stupid do you think we are?
- 41:37It feels like the nc DOUBLE is potentially setting itself up for another how stupid
- 41:40do you think we are? With employment at some point in the next decade
- 41:45or two. Well, and right now, the mood for employment by the
- 41:50student athletes, from what I've read and what other people have said, is
- 41:52that it's not really there. They don't want to be employees. They like
- 41:55the way things are because now they'll be getting paid, so that's fine.
- 42:00And also they're not around long enough to fight this battle. They're you know,
- 42:04you're not asking like a freshman to come in and you know, battle
- 42:07for five years, which is you know, this thing has been going on
- 42:10for not not not just house, but the obannon has been going on for
- 42:15ten years, and the NCAA football one has been going on for however long
- 42:20as well. So it's like, I'm I'm here to play football, I'm
- 42:24here to to joust whatever varsity sport you've got. I'm not here to battle
- 42:30and and coret because I'm here for like three, four or five years.
- 42:32I'm trying to get an education, or I'm trying to go to the NFL.
- 42:35I'm trying to go to the NBA. I don't have time for this.
- 42:37I need to focus on what I'm here for. I'm not here to
- 42:42be a plaintiff. And so it's it's gonna be difficult too, I think
- 42:46get that aspect going in terms of the the employment and part of the agreement
- 42:52on this the settlement is the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs agree to lobby on behalf
- 42:58of the NCAA's effort seeking congressional protections, which would be like the anti trust
- 43:02things like that. We've talked in the past about how Congress I don't know,
- 43:07I can't remember who it was telling the NCAA, we're not going to
- 43:09save you. We will help you, but first you've got to get this
- 43:14ball rolling. And the ball is rolling, and so maybe now Congress will
- 43:17step in, especially with all sides agreeing. Yet there is still another class
- 43:23action lawsuit out there font No, which probably gets negated with this, or
- 43:30at least the attorneys from that won the House think that that will be pushed
- 43:35aside or rolled under however, just done away with at some point because the
- 43:42players from House, the players in the class action of House, would have
- 43:45to leave House and go to that one. And right now they know they've
- 43:50won, so why would they lose this to go maybe wait another two or
- 43:53three years to see if they win. When it's like like I said,
- 43:55it's as we say, it's a transient nature of college sports. I'm here
- 43:59now my money. J. G. Wentworth said it best is my money.
- 44:02I want to now so and forth and I forget the jingle. I
- 44:07apologize. Please don't write but that's that well. And I think the question
- 44:14is this settlement doesn't necessarily have to apply to everyone who's in college right now,
- 44:20and it doesn't have to necessarily apply to anyone moving forward. That's that
- 44:22was another sort of thing where this is. Players don't have to agree to
- 44:28opt into this this settlement. They could choose not to. And you know,
- 44:34just because guys right now are you know, this doesn't have to be
- 44:37someone who's a plaintive from this. This could be someone else, you know,
- 44:39because a lot of these cases are from people who have already completed their
- 44:43eligibility. So you know this this is not you know, the the employment
- 44:46piece, and this is a whole separate conversation with the Dartmouth men, the
- 44:50basketball team and all that kind of stuff. There are a million different issues
- 44:54around that, and I'm not going to even pretend to understand all of them.
- 44:59But just because it settled out does not mean it's settled five years from
- 45:01now or ten years from now. And you know, someone who is currently
- 45:05an athlete or was previously an athlete could potentially file a lawsuit. So there's
- 45:08all sorts of stuff that you know that this does not necessarily settle so I
- 45:14just want to make sure people understand that that that's not you know this,
- 45:17this is the final answer to all of these questions. This is, well,
- 45:22we think we've maybe kicked the can down the road a little bit,
- 45:24but I guess we'll see how far down the road the can goes. Yeah,
- 45:28but suffice it to say, to wrap up, Ohio State should be
- 45:30fine. As long as the sport is fine, Ohio State will be fine.
- 45:34And the sports are fine, Ohio State will be fine. So before
- 45:38we go to the tom, I do want to tell you the story so
- 45:43has nothing to do with anything except for the show sort of. So my
- 45:46mother in law asked me to return something that she got from Amazon. And
- 45:50really it's really easy to return stuff from Amazon. You just go on to
- 45:52your account say I'm returning this, I'll send you a QR code. But
- 45:55it was like this oil of ol anti aging cre you know, wrinkle anti
- 46:00wrinkle stuff, and so it's like, tell my wife, you know,
- 46:04I got to go take this anti aging cream to the UPS store and tell
- 46:07them, hey, I need to return my anti aging cream. Ha ha
- 46:10ha. And you know it's like, you know, this is kind of
- 46:14embarrassing, right, It's like, who cares, nobody knows me. And
- 46:16then I get to the store, to get to the UPS store, and
- 46:19I'm walking up with my oil of LA and behind the counter, somebody's like,
- 46:24what are you taller in person? Always when you don't want Yes,
- 46:36yes, so taller and more youthful looking in person. Honestly, it wasn't
- 46:43mine. It may look no it's not mine, but yes. I always
- 46:47do appreciate the viewers and a listener feedback out there, and please keep my
- 46:53private life private, all right. I only put this out there like be
- 46:55rabbit in eight mile. You know, I'm just gonna I'm de escalating situation.
- 47:00I am taking away the weapons that would be used against me. Tony
- 47:04went to UPS. That's a private school. We call it the you anyway
- 47:10that well do. I want to thank you all for tuning in. As
- 47:13always, if you're watching this video on YouTube aid and give us a thumbs
- 47:15up, we would appreciate that. You can always find us at YouTube dot
- 47:19com, slash buck, I Huddle of course, Buckeye Huddle dot com as
- 47:21well Tom Buckeyes Tomorrow morning every weekday morning. Right now. Tons of stuff
- 47:25there, just I have not listened to the Matt Sars yet was that one
- 47:29a good one? Yeah. Matt Sars, who runs matsarsports dot com,
- 47:32which is kind of the pre eminent expert in college football TV, had him
- 47:38on to talk about all the new TV deals and how everything's a little different
- 47:43this year, as well as can I the process and in terms of figuring
- 47:46out, Okay, the Ohio State Oregon game, when is that going to
- 47:50air? What network is that going to air on? Is the Ohio State
- 47:52Penn State game going to be a primetime white out game? Is that going
- 47:57to be a big new and kickoff? Talk to him about all that kind
- 47:59of stuff, as well as TNT sub licensing, the College Football Playoff and
- 48:04a lot more. Yeah, and we did not know this at the time,
- 48:07but that Penn State Ohio State game could still be a big neon kickoff
- 48:10because Fox does own that week, as we found out recently, So Mark
- 48:15and Kevin or should we do home any any day now from the Southern Swing.
- 48:20So there's ongoing coverage there at bucke Huddle dot com as well. So
- 48:24thank you all for tuning in and we'll talk to you guys later.